Caledonia Investments Plc (CLDN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 26, 2024

London Stock Exchange GB Financials Capital Markets earnings 52 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Matthew Masters

executive
#1

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the results presentation for Caledonia covering the six months to 30 September 2024. My name is Mat Masters, Chief Executive of Caledonia Investments, and I'm delighted to take you through these results today. With me are my colleagues Jamie Cayzer-Colvin, who runs our funds pool, and Rob Memmott, our CFO, here to walk you through the results. Now, we'll aim to strike a balance between covering what is quite a short stretch of time for us — the last six months — and reminding you about the strategy and the long-term returns of the business. So, moving through the cautionary statement and giving you some building blocks, so to speak, to lay foundations for our investment approach. Now, our goal is to deliver long-term NAV per share and dividend per share growth to our shareholders. Our track record, shown in the graph at the top there, demonstrates that our approach — making long-term investments in the equity of good quality companies — has proved a sound way of achieving this. As a reminder, we are self-managed — or, as I put it, very self-managed — through the in-house investment team, whose focus is on making Caledonia better and better at executing against our long-term strategy.

Matthew Masters

executive
#2

In what I call our ecosystem, we’re extremely fortunate to have the backing of a supportive shareholder—the Cayzer family, the people who founded the company in the first place. Our culture, purpose, and values are captured and articulated really effectively by the tagline we recently added to our logo, “Time Well Invested,” and that tagline does a great job of explaining how we go about things. Put simply, our goal is to put money into solid businesses capable of producing outstanding returns while avoiding excessive risk. We carry out that strategy by investing largely on a direct basis in listed and unlisted companies of high quality, and additionally in funds that our own in-house team chooses. Since there is no fundraising or other assets under management for us to worry about, this in-house team concentrates entirely on the existing portfolio—looking after it—and then giving careful thought to what the opportunity set ought to be for future investments. There is enormous alignment between this investment team—meaning everyone from me all the way to those picking each of the things we invest in—and our shareholders, since we get paid only on performance measured against gains in NAV per share, and a substantial portion of our performance is paid in Caledonia shares.

Matthew Masters

executive
#3

Our performance is judged by whether shareholders' assets grow on a per-share basis, and the performance component of our pay comes in Caledonia shares. That, I think, keeps us very closely aligned with shareholders. The entire investment approach is built so that time works in our favor, and I hope it's clear that putting time to good use is a great way to tie all of this together. What follows is an overview of the portfolio, which we characterize as nicely balanced across the three different areas. Each of those areas accounts for roughly a third of the portfolio, or a third of the NAV. First is our public companies piece, a concentrated portfolio of the best long-term confounders — excuse me, compounders, I should say — that we are able to understand and follow, and we are highly selective. What we seek are well-managed businesses with underlying growth, good returns on capital, and good margins that we believe will persist into the future. Private capital is where we own companies directly, generally U.K.-based, and we work alongside management teams to help them grow and improve in quality over time. Then comes our funds area, where we back proven management in the North American lower-mid market area, and also more growth-oriented managers in Asia.

Matthew Masters

executive
#4

So that gives you a picture of the portfolio overall. Their long-term return records are visible in the bottom right corner of each segment, and it's good to see those either near the top or in fact past the upper end of what we target. We're quite happy with the areas chosen for investment and with the way they're performing. Putting it all together for a look at our long-term results, it's encouraging that over the longer term the gold bar — that's the vertical one, the NAV per share returns — sits at the top end of our target range, and our target is staying ahead of inflation plus 3%-6%, which is what that horizontal gold bar illustrates. Over the shorter term, share price performance hasn't kept pace, because the discount widened by just under 17% across the last five years. In fact, during the half year, so March through September, the discount did narrow somewhat, which was good, but Rob will say more later about what we're doing on investor relations generally, since addressing that matters. Turning to the short term and the results for the six months to the end of September, here are the highlights.

Matthew Masters

executive
#5

NAV total return rose 0.5%, though foreign exchange weighed heavily on this result — chiefly the U.S. dollar softening versus the pound between March and September — and we estimate that cost us GBP 104 million, sorry, and cut our NAV total return by 3.6%. In the breakdown, public companies did well, in either currency, posting 7% in pounds and 11% in dollars, with solid operating results across the portfolio feeding through into share prices. Naturally, we're delighted with that outcome. Private capital posted a weak -2.8% return, yet that really obscures strong results across the bulk of the portfolio, which, excluding Cooke, came in at +5.2%. Cooke, though, has kept trading weakly. That reflects the fallout from the movie industry strikes, so it was written down again during the period, and that is how the 5.2% became a minus 2.8% portfolio return. Over the six months, we bought DTM, a very interesting business that Rob will discuss in more detail later, and we're delighted to welcome Leigh and his management team to Caledonia, and we look forward to working with them going forward.

Matthew Masters

executive
#6

We put GBP 55 million into that business. Inside the private equity funds, the North American portfolio produced a positive return of 5.3% in dollars, while the Asian portfolio grew 1% in dollars during the period. Both portfolios ended the period in positive territory, but when you combine them and factor in the pound's strengthening, the portfolio came in at minus 2.4%. Foreign exchange plays a role in these results, and I'd note that the dollar-pound rate has actually returned to its end-of-March level, so this may all prove transitory. To recap, foreign exchange cut our performance by 3.6% over the period. Cook took a further 2.1% off. Looking through all of this, we're very pleased with how the underlying portfolio is doing. Today we're announcing an interim dividend of GBP 0.1969, which represents a 4% increase over last year's interim and extends our 57-year streak of dividend increases. During the half year, we bought just under 750,000 shares, and at an average discount of 34.8% that's the easiest investment decision we have to make, and it immediately added GBP 0.256 to NAV per share. Now, to preserve our ability to keep doing buybacks, we've issued a circular today seeking permission from non-Concert Party shareholders to do so, on the understanding that this would push the Concert Party, or family holding, as I call them, above 50%.

Matthew Masters

executive
#7

Before putting this into effect, we conducted a substantial consultation process with shareholders, and our view is that it serves the best interests of every shareholder; Rob will give us some further detail on that a bit later. Turning to the portfolio, I'll start with public companies, where we have just over GBP 1 billion invested, which is approximately 35% of the portfolio. It's a concentrated collection of long-term compounders, very selective, seeking well-run businesses that have sustainable underlying growth, pricing power, and appealing returns on capital. Given those ingredients, we believe long-term ownership will be rewarded. Well, this period really validated that approach, since the largest contributor to the portfolio came from Oracle, which we profiled during last year's interim presentation. As you may remember from that, our Oracle investment was made in 2014, which means we're 10 years into holding it — so it's really just getting going. We put in GBP 34 million. All of that money has come back to us through sales and dividend income, and today it's worth GBP 96 million in our portfolio. It's early days so far, but so far it appears to be going okay. Oracle began as a database company, so it shouldn't come as much of a surprise that, with growth spurred by advances in AI, they are really starting to benefit from this.

Matthew Masters

executive
#8

Demand is rising for them. They are adding capacity to serve that demand, so bookings can be turned into revenue and profit. In fact, they lifted their guidance for the coming five years recently, from 10% annual growth to 14% annual growth, and that's a substantial shift in Oracle's growth profile, and it produced a 20% gain in their share price. It was a large holding in the portfolio since we like it, and we believed it looked like a nicely balanced risk-reward opportunity for us, and over the half year we've been rewarded for that. That's excellent work by the team. We opened a new position in the period with Pool Corporation, a top supplier of swimming pool equipment in America. Now, as I said, we prefer to build these opportunities over time, and getting to know these businesses takes a while, and Pool Corporation is a genuinely good case study. In fact, Watsco, one of our other holdings, referred it to us as an idea, and while we were visiting with them, we asked them for other ideas, and they said, "Well, you might want to go and look at Pool Corporation." In fact, a former Watsco employee had run it for a while, and so we figured the DNA of the business would be pretty good.

Matthew Masters

executive
#9

We took our time getting familiar with it. We kept an eye on its pricing. During COVID, it actually saw an enormous surge in earnings and share price, since everybody was at home and redoing their pools, so we simply stayed away while that was happening. The situation, we believe, has settled down, and it has entered attractive pricing and rating territory, so we have increased our position during the period, and I think it would be a solid long-term investment for us. Turning to our top holdings, people mention the Magnificent Seven. One of them, Microsoft, is in our portfolio. Our first investment in Microsoft was in 2014, so we have held it for quite some time. Technology is a key driver of operational performance, and as I consider those holdings visible there, a technology story, and certainly innovation, sits behind most of them. We may not own all of the Mag Seven, but we are certainly watching the impact of technology. In this results presentation, we will profile Fastenal, an American supplier. It does have international operations, but it is mainly an American supplier, a North American supplier of construction and industrial products, and it is another cracking long-term compounder.

Matthew Masters

executive
#10

At this point it's classified as a distribution business, yet it produces a 20% operating profit margin, really strong returns on capital, and over a 20-year span has delivered a 15% total shareholder return. That signals something distinctive is happening inside this company. Fastenal works alongside its customers, frequently supplying its own personnel and equipment and running operations full-time at customer locations, and it makes sure those customers enjoy a dependable supply of what you could call non-manufacturing inventory — picture personal protective equipment, cutting tools, and the bits and pieces industrial firms require to keep operating. Fastenal vending machines sit within the Amazon estate, inside the Amazon warehouse estate, dispensing consumables, which amounts to a solid endorsement of the company's quality and logistics. Still, the bulk of its business comes from ordinary industrial companies throughout North America, and it offers them a highly compelling value-based proposition. This is a genuinely well-run company. Among the hallmarks we observe in such well-run companies is decentralization, and decentralized companies tend to feature long-tenured, highly experienced, trusted staff, who are given the autonomy to respond to market opportunities ahead of them however they judge best. That theme runs through a great deal of the portfolio.

Matthew Masters

executive
#11

We actually favor this decentralized style of running businesses. Fastenal’s business usually has no debt and a solid track record of increasing its dividend. It’s unusual for America: it pays a special dividend from time to time, and it approaches share buybacks with a value mindset. That sounds like other places we know. We’d model our policy along similar lines. As I said, I think it’s very well run. The company puts most of its investment into IT, and the heart of the operation is its inventory management system, which it develops in-house, and that’s the central piece that makes this business quite special. We added the holding in March 2020, having actually tracked it for only three years, but the COVID sell-off gave us a good entry valuation, and that, along with solid operational progress, has produced an annualized return of 22% since we invested, or two times our money. We’re very pleased with it. It’s early days, even though we’ve held it for four years. I still regard it as really early days in the portfolio, and we expect it will keep being a good contributor for us. With that, I’ll hand over to Jamie to talk about funds.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#12

Thank you, Matt, and good morning to all of you. I'm Jamie Cayzer-Colvin, and it's a pleasure to be here presenting the funds pool to you today. During this short presentation, I'll refresh your memory on the funds pool strategy. I'll go over how it has performed lately, and I'll finish with a case study. As you've probably picked up from earlier presentations, the Caledonia partnership model calls for considerable rigor and time when making these investments, as Matt just showed through how long you tracked some of these investments. Inside the private markets, that approach gets difficult, especially when you're searching in markets situated far from the U.K. So we launched a program to partner with top-tier managers in regions where we lacked a presence. But since Caledonia's resources are finite, we've focused our efforts on the world's largest economies, which obviously means North America and Asia. In North America, our investment strategy is centered on the very foundational elements of American capitalism. That's specifically targeting small founder-owned businesses. Here, value is created through simple things: revenue growth, margin growth, and multiple expansion, without relying on complex financial structuring or substantial debt. We refer to this opportunity as the lower mid-market, which encompasses companies typically with operating revenues of below 50 million.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#13

This is a huge market. It contains close to 6 million companies, and we track more than 600 managers who are open to investment, staying in touch with them via routine gatherings across an extended timeframe. Across many of the Caledonia funds where we hold positions, we are the sole European investor, and in most of them, we do serve on their advisory boards. What we appreciate about this sector is that competition is lower because company sizes are small. A lot of sellers are also not always driven simply by getting the highest valuation, and quite frequently, the buyer's culture shapes the seller's decision. Plenty of firms in this sector have strategic plans that are not fully developed, and quite often, the management team lacks the experience depth you would typically see at a bigger company. So when a manager with an operational focus steps in, these businesses can be professionalized. They can get themselves ready for growth and become more appealing as acquisition targets, and by that route raise the odds of securing higher valuation multiples when they exit. Our Asian program has moved from a Pan-Asian multi-style approach to one more centered on regional growth, with particular weight on China growth and venture. The program is mainly divided between fund of funds and growth and venture funds.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#14

Roughly 40% sits in fund of funds, with 60% allocated to growth and venture. Diversification makes the fund of funds piece vital, since it gives broad reach across different Asian geographic regions, a range of fund styles, and multiple sectors. The growth and venture program takes advantage of the substantial growth Asia has seen over the past 20 years. This segment's first investment was made in 2026, and from that point our managers have managed to multiply invested capital by two and a half times, net of all costs and fees. At present, the whole fund program holds investments in 76 funds spanning 42 managers — 25 of them in North America and 17 in Asia. Looking further out, the funds portfolio keeps producing double-digit growth. Results for the half took a hit from the weakening of the U.S. dollar. Even so, both the North American and Asian portfolios posted positive returns in local currency across the six months, as Matt said a little earlier. The North American program in particular is doing well, as noted, yet unfortunately Asia has not fully realized its potential, largely because of macro uncertainty in the region. Still, we think the portfolio is well positioned to deliver good returns in spite of these geopolitical challenges.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#15

On the investment side, GBP 67 million was put to work during the period, and most of it went into North America; on top of that, we committed 130 million to new funds — $130 million. Following a quieter year last year, realizations have picked up speed now that exit markets have improved, and North America has been the standout case. As I mentioned earlier, overall the portfolio produced positive cash flow of GBP 27 million, with GBP 67 million drawn down and GBP 70 million in distributions offsetting it, plus a secondary sale of one of our fund positions worth GBP 19 million. We're hopeful that this trend keeps going, and early indications definitely back up that optimism. The portfolio is very well balanced. In the graph over there, you can see a third sits in new and emerging investments, a third are nice and maturing, and a third are in that exit mode. Now I'd like to turn my focus to Decheng, a global life science and healthcare fund with a presence both in China and in the USA. Notably, 48% of our Asian primary fund program is invested in the healthcare sector through investments in over 120 companies.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#16

Now, I'm sure a lot of you are familiar with what's called the Patent Cliff. Across the world, $300 billion in pharmaceutical sales face risk from now through 2030 as patents run out. Well, big pharma hasn't been sitting still, and they're holding $500 billion in firepower, which they'll probably deploy to tackle this challenge. As an investor in early stage biopharma opportunities, Decheng is well positioned to capitalize on this opportunity. So far this year, we've seen 23 transactions above $1 billion, with Alpine Immune Sciences the biggest at $4.9 billion, a company from a Decheng portfolio, which I'll come back to shortly. Now, we first connected with Decheng just after its founding in 2012. The founder, Min Cui, has impressed us with his clinical expertise across life science and pharma, combined with a truly remarkable drive and ambition, providing a strong platform with which to drive commercial success, but also with the added benefit of that the investments that they make really do make a positive impact and save people's lives. The Decheng team actively seeks early stage life sciences companies with transformational technologies. They focus on firms with excellent clinical data, but recognizing the fact that robust data alone is insufficient. Proven and capable management teams are essential to realizing the value creation opportunities, along with a very clear strategy for monetization from day one.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#17

So, China has traditionally been viewed as a me-too market—a place where you can pick up cheap knockoffs. I'm not claiming cheap knockoffs are no longer available there, but you find them in London too. Still, it's clear that over the last 20 years, China is no longer regarded as me-too; in fact, in lots and lots of areas it has turned world-class and leading, and that holds true in life sciences as well. Disease doesn't respect national borders, and cures shouldn't either. Decheng has managed to locate and pinpoint compelling Chinese opportunities and assist in structuring their overseas expansion, especially into North America. Earlier I brought up Alpine Immune Sciences. That's a textbook illustration of a Decheng investment that got sold earlier this year for $4.9 billion to Vertex. Back in 2018, the Decheng team spotted outstanding clinical data from a proven team in the immune oncology field. They saw an unmet medical need tied to kidney disease, which makes it difficult for the kidneys to filter waste out of the blood. Decheng then led the initial PIPE financing and afterward co-led and took part in two additional investments, putting in $52 million altogether and becoming the company's biggest shareholder. Two members of the Decheng team, Min among them, sat on the Alpine board and played a pivotal role in steering the company through to its successful exit, producing an impressive 8.2 gross returns and therefore a distribution to us of GBP 11 million in the half.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#18

When it came to Alpine, the Decheng team played a key role in pinpointing appropriate co-investors, in shaping the monetization strategy, and in the talks with Vertex as well. To sum up, our funds program has strong resources behind it and is backed by a truly outstanding, highly skilled team. Across the long run, it has produced solid double-digit growth for our shareholders. This team has a wide-reaching network, holds a strong portfolio, and has an impressive pipeline of investment opportunities, and we are firmly convinced it will deliver excellent long-term performance as we move ahead. With that, I will pass it over.

Rob Memmott

executive
#19

Thanks, Jamie, and good morning, everyone. Our private capital pool invests directly in businesses that are mainly UK-focused. That pool now stands at GBP 848 million, and five companies account for 90% of the value. Most of the valuations sit between 9 and 14 and a half times LTM EBITDA, and we usually employ fairly modest leverage — 2 to 2.5 net debt to EBITDA within the capital structure. The reason is that we want business performance to drive returns and dividends as well. Strong returns have come from the pool — 13%-15% across three, five, and 10-year periods. During the six-month period, positive performance across the majority of the portfolio produced 5.2% net growth. As Matt mentioned, this was offset by Cooke Optics, leading to an overall pool reduction of 2.8%. One notable highlight in the first half was the acquisition of DTM, Direct Tire Management, and I'll give a bit more detail on DTM shortly. Just to go through the main companies, first of all, Cook. As we reported previously, the Hollywood Actors and Writers' Strike in 2023 hit the business heavily. That led to lower demand for the core cinema lenses, as content production in the U.S. and worldwide experienced a severe slowdown.

Rob Memmott

executive
#20

Content creators are adjusting their business models with caution, and although production volumes are recovering gradually, shoot days in LA remain below the levels seen historically on average. We're collaborating with the management team to steer through this difficult stretch, which has led to restructuring of the cost base and to building out our digital capability. The Cook brand and product portfolio are still held in high regard, as shown by the successful launch of the new prosumer lens, the SP3. That said, we anticipate a delay in demand picking up for the new Cook cinema lenses once the sector bounces back, and this has led to a GBP 50 million reduction in our valuation. Cobepa, our investment in a Belgian-headquartered investment company, holds a diversified pool of 20 private investments. We have invested for more than 20 years, and over that stretch Cobepa has delivered annualized returns of 12%. Returns for the current year are somewhat depressed, with an average cash balance of roughly 17% of NAV, which simply drags the return down for the period, 1.6% in sterling, 4.4% in constant currency. Stonehage Fleming keeps building its LTM, fueled by growth in assets under management, revenue in its family office, and its financial services business, a 7.6% return in the period.

Rob Memmott

executive
#21

For AIR-serv, the return was 6.1%. That shows the momentum has kept building since we acquired it last year. It continues to trade well, with more machines in place and solid progress on lifting revenue per machine. Early in the year, we got our first dividend of GBP 6.2 million, which shows how strongly the business generates cash and the advantage of our prudent capital structure. Last, Liberation, our pubs and brewing business. Happily, all three revenue categories — food, drink, and accommodation — have grown year on year. Cost inflation and cost pressure have eased, and that has delivered both revenue growth and margin expansion during the period. We keep moving forward on optimizing the Cirrus Inns, with a capital program of refurbishment making good progress. Overall, a 9.1% return in the period. Now, since the 30th of September, we've had the budget. The rise in national insurance and minimum wage will hit Liberation hardest within the portfolio. The management teams are right now working through various ways to mitigate this increase, such as reviewing rosters and recruitment plans, as well as driving a number of profit improvement initiatives. So, to Direct Tire Management — DTM is a leading provider of outsourced tire management services to specialist fleet operators.

Rob Memmott

executive
#22

If you picture niche fleet operators, what comes to mind is probably a local authority or a builder running a mixed set of vehicles to provide time-sensitive services across scattered sites. DTM joined us in August, and we're very pleased to back Leigh Goodland and his team as they build and expand the company. The deal was contested. Among the reasons we came out on top: the leadership recognised what kind of capital Caledonia provides — ordinary equity, not the high-coupon loan-picking instrument that most of the PE industry typically uses; our offer was deliverable, especially our capacity to underwrite the debt, which we have since refinanced; the ties we formed with management during the process; and strong references that colleagues at other portfolio companies gave to the management team. DTM appeals to us because it is a growing, high-quality business that generates cash. Its entrenched position as an intermediary and in the independent market helps it earn margin from, and deliver value to, every part of the supply chain. The customer proposition stands out as a key differentiator, given how essential the service is and how costly failure would be for DTM's customers. That competitive edge is durable, as shown by its long-term track record, net new customer wins, very little churn, and growth in financial metrics.

Rob Memmott

executive
#23

Tech is the foundation for what it delivers, and there's more room to boost operational efficiency. The market's expanding, and we believe there's room to grow our share of it. We're also giving particular thought to, you know, services nearby and geographies too. The management team's strength showed throughout the process, and how broad that team is — that's something we're, sort of, especially happy about from the acquisition. Trading has matched expectations, and on the 100-day plan the team is progressing very well, which includes bringing in a high-caliber chair in David Brennan. So, on to the figures. In the first half, our NAV of just under GBP 3 billion produced a return of 0.5%, as mentioned already, 4.1% at constant exchange rate. We have GBP 2.7 billion invested across a quality, diversified portfolio of listed and privately held companies and funds with global reach. In the period, we finished a new revolving credit facility, upsizing it to GBP 325 million on better terms. Three banks provide the facility. GBP 175 million carries a three-year tenor, GBP 150 million a five-year tenor. Right now the facility is undrawn, so that GBP 325 million plus GBP 135 million of cash on balance sheet leaves us with GBP 460 million of firepower.

Rob Memmott

executive
#24

So that means we’re able to move fast and put money into assets we see as attractive, and the DTM acquisition is an example of that. Our interim dividend is GBP 0.1969, which is up 4% year on year and works out to GBP 10.6 million, and shareholders will receive that interim dividend on the 9th of January, 2025. A presentation from me wouldn’t be complete without a few waterfall charts, so we won’t let you down. The first one is the portfolio of investments. These have risen from just under GBP 2.7 billion on the right-hand side to just over GBP 2.7 billion on the right-hand side, left-hand side, right-hand side. What drove that growth: GBP 227 million of investments made during the period, GBP 55 million into DTM within the private capital pool, GBP 66 million into funds, GBP 81 million into our public companies, including new positions of Pool Corp, Sage, Croda. Our realizations were GBP 177 million, including GBP 94 million from the funds. That included that secondary sale that Jamie referred to, GBP 19 million. GBP 68 million from public companies as we took advantage of market pricing, trading around our core position. In addition, disposing position of BAT within the capital pool and DS Smith and Pennon in the income pool.

Rob Memmott

executive
#25

We got investment income, or cash yield, of GBP 29 million, and we recorded returns on investment of GBP 21 million. That works out to a return of 0.7 on the assets. The drivers were strong performance — excuse me — in the public pool, with the majority of private capital doing well, and North American funds, offset by that FX and the adjustment made to the Cook valuation. On valuation, our quoted assets get marked to market daily. Within private capital — excuse me — we follow the IPEV guidelines and account at fair value. For the funds pool, we rely on the fund manager NAV statements. Every one of these funds is audited by reputable firms and is accounted for on an IFRS or US GAAP basis, at fair value. The team reviews the valuations to make sure trends and company-specific issues are appropriately reflected. As of the 30th of September, 98% of the funds pool NAV was based on 30th of June NAV statements. In the table at the bottom right, you can see performance by pool, sort of, and the cash yield by pool. Our NAV now stands at GBP 2.9 billion, and you can see the sort of impact FX had on returns during the period.

Rob Memmott

executive
#26

On top of that, there are two key bars: shareholder returns, GBP 28 million for payment of the prior year dividend, and GBP 26 million put toward share buybacks. Those buybacks have added 25.6p to NAV per share. The pie chart on the right-hand side breaks down assets by domicile currency: 52% U.S., 38% sterling. So movements in the sterling to dollar exchange rate will have an impact on impaired returns. Matt touched on the FX point, and it is moving around a little. Anyone who has gone through the October factsheet will see that GBP 71 million of the 104 has now been reversed. Net debt bridge, moving from the left-hand side to the right. We began with GBP 227 million of cash and net GBP 48 million invested in quality assets. Cash yield of GBP 27 million and cash costs of GBP 17 million. There is a bit of working capital in each of those two numbers. Then we have the payment of the prior year dividend and the share buyback. Undrawn facility plus cash on balance sheet, GBP 460 million of firepower. We fundamentally believe that long-term shareholders should benefit from the increase in NAV.

Rob Memmott

executive
#27

The total shareholder return across a decade comes to slightly below 8% each year. When you look at three to five years, the difference between net asset value per share and TSR has grown, and that's because the discount has widened. In our view, the present discount of 38 to 39% means the market is placing far too little value on how good our investments are and on our long-term record. As we said at the year-end and again at the AGM, the board treats this as a live issue, and we're pushing ahead on what sits within our control. The first thing is to keep extending our record of putting money into quality assets and producing long-term real returns. The second is to keep developing our IR and communications so that people understand and properly rate the Caledonia investment proposition. The aim there is to broaden the shareholder base and bring in more marginal buyers. One date for your diary: on the 22nd of January, we'll run the first of three capital market spotlight sessions. That opening session covers private capital, and two further events are planned across the coming year, each focused on one of the other two pools. The third area we've been working on is share buybacks. We gain from the continued support, stability, and cultural foundation that the Cayzer family gives to our investment philosophy.

Rob Memmott

executive
#28

Over the past six months, we've kept buying back stock within the limits we presently operate under, namely holding the Concert Party beneath 49.9%. In that stretch, we picked up slightly fewer than 750,000 shares, which produced GBP 0.256 of NAV per share accretion. The Concert Party's stake now stands at 49.5%, and once you allow for a modest amount of headroom, that puts us at the maximum level of shares we're able to purchase. After hearing consistent feedback from shareholders, this morning we announced that a circular has been issued seeking approval from non-Concert Party shareholders to lift that cap. Doing so will let us buy shares, and should the Concert Party go past 50%, no mandatory offer will be triggered under the takeover code. In our view, purchasing shares at a meaningful discount represents sound investment and capital allocation for the company. It adds to NAV per share, benefits every ordinary shareholder, and will leave the company free to act as an acquirer in the markets. We've consulted with nearly half of the non-Concert Party shareholders, and that group makes up a substantial share of those who voted at the most recent AGM. The non-Concert Party directors are unanimously recommending that shareholders cast their votes in support of this resolution.

Rob Memmott

executive
#29

The circular is going up on the website later today, and it will include a Q&A that we hope shareholders find helpful. Also, should shareholders like a call with Matt and me, please reach out the usual way. So to sum up, Caledonia has assembled a diverse portfolio that's well positioned to deliver returns over the long term. We put money into quality businesses centered on free cash flow, which means the portfolio can respond to the challenges the macro environment creates. Our balance sheet is robust, with liquidity of GBP 460 million, which gives us the firepower to invest when we find attractive opportunities. The experienced team are 100% focused on continuing to invest in and manage a portfolio of high-quality companies and private equity funds. And as a management team and board, we're committed to doing what we can control to drive shareholder value. We're going to take questions now. At first, we'll take them from the room, and after that we can go remotely to those who are online.

Ash Nandi

analyst
#30

Ash Nandi here from Deutsche Numis. One question regarding Liberation Group. It’s clear that this is among the bigger returners in private capital. Would you mind discussing how the operational business splits, what percentage of Liberation Group comes from Cirrus, and giving a little more background on what’s going on at Cirrus along with the improvements being made?

Matthew Masters

executive
#31

Yeah. Apologies in advance if any of these figures aren't exactly right. So Liberation owns approximately 150 pubs. Most of them they also manage, though they do have a tenant estate as well. Cirrus came with 24 pubs, and those were very well invested, but Liberation has an operational approach that we believe in, and have witnessed, that does enhance return on investment. So the manner in which they put money into their pubs — they have a consistent and more predictable method of achieving solid returns from pub investment. And likewise the operational practices inside the business, including the way they handle menus and train staff and everything else. So the integration task is converting or adapting the Cirrus estate and its people so that it fits in. So it's properly consolidated inside the Liberation Group. And that has taken some time to accomplish because you need to secure planning permission, and you need to make changes. And then, while you're doing that, you have to go and find — as you're upgrading certain premises, you're seeking out different things. So that process is ongoing. And a recent example, which is handy for all of us to see, would be the Punch Bowl Pub, which I suggest everyone drop into.

Matthew Masters

executive
#32

If you recall what it was like in there before, you can compare that with how it looks today, and you'll notice things have gotten better. What I believe we're observing is that the gains we anticipated are indeed materializing, though it simply requires some time before they show up in the figures, and those figures are starting to reflect that now. So, I hope that answers your question.

Ash Nandi

analyst
#33

Thanks — and sure.

Alan Brierley

analyst
#34

Alan Brierley here, from Investec. It's good to hear you describe buybacks as the simplest investment call. The waiver is clearly uncapped, but if we're being realistic and looking into a crystal ball, how do you expect the family's ownership to develop, and at what point would you begin to feel uneasy?

Matthew Masters

executive
#35

I really can’t represent the family’s view, and I won’t put a family member in that position either. So this is really a wide-ranging capital management exercise, and there are several ways we can deploy capital, which I could walk through. We want to continue putting money into the portfolio. We do intend to keep paying dividends, including the occasional special dividend, and then we’ll also want to carry out some buybacks, though the word I’d use for them is judicious. Over the past six months we have been buying back stock, and we repurchased roughly GBP 20 million to GBP 30 million, just so you have a sense of the pace. During the consultation, we heard what people had to say regarding buybacks, and they wanted to understand where shareholdings might shift and perhaps how that could affect the liquidity of the float. And we clearly want to avoid materially eroding the free float, so I wouldn’t expect those numbers to move around much very quickly, Alan, in answer to your question — hence a judicious approach. Thank you.

Chris Brown

analyst
#36

Chris Brown from J.P. Morgan Cazenove here. I have a quick question about the Asian funds portfolio, specifically the secondary sale. I'd like to hear the reasoning behind that realization or secondary sale, and also how it affected NAV — what kind of discount you sold it at.

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#37

This was a fund position we held at the tail end. The amount involved was quite considerable. One investment accounted for 90% of it. We believed that company's prospects over the next couple of years were fairly marginal, and an opportunity the manager presented to us—to create some liquidity, since quite a number of their investors were seeking liquidity—looked attractive. It was executed at a small discount, but we felt that having the cash in hand justified that discount.

Matthew Masters

executive
#38

Does anyone have a question online?

Moderator

operator
#39

Okay, so the first question from the online queue. If the family’s stake goes above 50%, would that have any effect on investment trust status?

Matthew Masters

executive
#40

Rob, would you like to handle that one?

Rob Memmott

executive
#41

Yes. That answer is no. I mean, the family has kind of stated in the circular and the release that the Concert Party strongly backs the business continuing to operate. As Matt kind of announced, the level we're attempting to give people a view of is sort of the pacing and the amount of buybacks we're going to do — continuing the sort of program we're currently operating on, and the pace of that program we're currently on means that really there won't be sort of huge swings in the percentage ownership of the company.

Moderator

operator
#42

Michael Pollett has another question submitted online. He's asking whether splitting the shares would make the company's stock more marketable?

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#43

That's a pretty good question, honestly, and we're doing some modeling on it right now. We're keeping an eye on making sure our shares are understood and appealing to the retail market, so that might be something that helps a bit in that area.

Moderator

operator
#44

Mark Westwood has another question along those same lines. He's asking why we're only requesting authorization to repurchase as much as 5% of our shares, rather than a larger amount.

Matthew Masters

executive
#45

Should we take this one?

Jamie Cayzer-Colvin

executive
#46

That's right.

Matthew Masters

executive
#47

So we're requesting 5%, spread across 18 months, and typically people do request larger amounts over shorter timeframes. And I think that reflects how we're signaling the pace at which we anticipate the buyback being executed. Okay. Does anyone else in the room have questions, or not? Well, with that, thanks so much, everyone. Thank you.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Caledonia Investments Plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Caledonia Investments Plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Caledonia Investments Plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.