Caledonia Investments Plc (CLDN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 21, 2024

London Stock Exchange GB Financials Capital Markets earnings 47 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Mat Masters

executive
#1

Okay, good morning everyone, and welcome to our presentation of results for March 2024. It's my privilege to take you through all of this. And it means we're entering the company's 96th year, so we're making our way along. Our CFO, Rob Memmott, along with Alan Murran, who co-runs our Public Companies Team, will present the results, and a question and answer session will come after the results finish. Before we begin the results, I want to mention a project we carried out over the year whose purpose was to explain the reasons behind what we do, since, as we come to learn in life, grasping why people do things is frequently more important, or at least just as important, as grasping what they do and how they do it. We received assistance with the project from many people, and the feedback we got really quite moved us. And it was extremely, extremely useful in helping us sort of reflect on ourselves and on the way we communicate. And the same fundamental theme emerged from the feedback, which concerned how we spend time. I'd like to point out a few pieces of the feedback for you. First, there's a pronounced family dimension to Caledonia, and that extends past our supportive family shareholder.

Mat Masters

executive
#2

This comes down to how we run things. We aim to establish lasting, trust-based connections with our employees, with our coworkers, and with those we collaborate with. And the folks we deal with genuinely value that a great deal. Second, the way we go about investing—or the investing business itself—differs greatly from how others do it. And that genuinely matters a lot when it comes to drawing investment talent into the firm. We received some feedback from a person—likely from an investment team, I'd imagine—who remarked: "What I like is that we don't invest just for the sake of investing." What underlies that is that since we aren't raising funds and we're long-term investors, nobody faces any pressure either to invest or to divest. As a result, every investment decision gets made at the proper moment, based purely on its own merits. So the project team recognized that the time spent investing sits at the core of what we do—whether that's in colleagues or in the people we partner with, or even, in fact, our approach to investing. And to help people grasp that more completely, today we're posting a short film on our website that explains it, and we're also publishing our manifesto—a brief statement that sets out our values and culture—and we hope people find it useful for understanding why we do what we do.

Mat Masters

executive
#3

We've also put the phrase "Time Well Invested" into our logo — you can see it on the screen — and into our materials, so as to bring this to the fore and remind people what Caledonia is about. So before we get into the results, a few slides to remind you about Caledonia and how what I've been talking about works in practice. So I'd like to say that we are very self-managed. All of the direct investing and fund selections is carried out by our 25-strong investment team, who only work for our shareholders. They specialize in our chosen strategies, which are designed to benefit from our long-term approach, and they don't do any marketing, and so they're not distracted from investing your money. We target long-term, real compounding returns, aiming to grow your investment ahead of inflation by 3%-6%, and achieving this should deliver performance ahead of the FTSE All-Share over the longer term. We've been operating like this for a long time and have a successful track record of demonstrating success against these metrics. The Cayzer family established the company in 1928, and their ongoing long-term support provides a benefit to everyone by underpinning our culture of investing time.

Mat Masters

executive
#4

What we've learned is that putting money into businesses and letting them create value—instead of trading for the short term—produces really strong returns. The strength of compounding across long horizons is something we're all familiar with. We give things time to develop our people, so they can build enduring partnerships, knowledge, and capability, along with the patience to put us in a strong position to make excellent investments. Each of our selected investment strategies intentionally targets big markets, and we anticipate those markets will keep presenting appealing opportunities for a very long time. That gives our investment team room to build a high-quality set of investments to choose from, and we are completely aligned with shareholders. They aren't investing merely for the sake of it—put another way, gathering assets—they're picking the finest investments to make at the right moment. In a moment you'll hear directly from Alan Murran about how this plays out in practice. Through our approach we get a well-balanced portfolio run via three core investment strategies, all of which are essentially doing the same thing in different areas of the market, namely investing in high-quality companies... We'll go into more detail on these later, but I want to note that we're delighted that across the last 10 years, these strategies have produced very strong returns relative to their targets.

Mat Masters

executive
#5

What we do is combine these elements to create a portfolio that's very well diversified across both geography and sector. The investment team constructs the portfolio from the bottom up, so sector exposure comes out of the investment team's activity and their judgment about which individual companies are good ones to invest from, or to invest in, rather. This quality-first approach tends to keep us away from sectors where macro factors or leverage are significant, because we invest in companies and not cycles, and do not like the risk that excessive leverage brings. So we tend to avoid sectors influenced by commodity prices or are highly capital-intensive, and so rely on leverage to make returns. And the result of our approach has delivered returns at the top end of our inflation + 3%-6% targets, and kept us well ahead of the FTSE All-Share over the medium to longer term, which is good to see. Now, there's a significant difference between the NAV total return chart and the TSR chart over 5 years, which is those middle set of bands. And what is causing that is the discount opening up over that period. Rob will talk more about what we're doing to address that later on in the presentation.

Mat Masters

executive
#6

Now turning to the year's key points. Per-share NAV rose to GBP 53.69, and for the first time our assets hit GBP 3 billion. Total NAV return came in at 7.4% for the year, and every pool contributed positively. Private capital enjoyed a strong year, climbing 12.3%, mainly on the back of the 7IM sale, and AIR-serv, which we bought at the beginning of the year, has beaten expectations. Both public company strategies did well, finishing at or above the upper end of their target range. Growth from our funds pool was softer than in recent years at 2%, as continued solid results from our North American mid-market buyout funds — sorry, lower mid-market buyout funds — were partly offset by weaker performance in our Asian PE growth and venture capital funds, mirroring tougher market conditions in that region. As a reminder, the funds pool has produced excellent long-term returns, with a ten-year figure of 17.3%. We have declared a final dividend of 51.47p per share, bringing the total for the year to 17.4 pence, a 4.5% increase over last year. Then, near the year end, we bought in just over 290,000 shares for roughly GBP 10 million, at an average discount of 36%.

Mat Masters

executive
#7

We think the shares right now are priced well below what the business's assets are worth, and Rob will go into more detail later on about the steps we're taking in response. Caledonia has a lengthy history of giving money back to shareholders and carrying out buybacks. In fact, looking back at the 1980s and comparing the share count with today, we've cut it by nearly 50%. Share buybacks have been something we've done for many years, and across the last 10 years, we've returned slightly less than GBP 500 million to shareholders via ordinary and special dividends. I want to add a few remarks on private capital. Through private capital, we get the chance to invest directly in a modest number of established businesses based in the U.K., and it also takes in our stake in Cobepa. Our typical investment range is GBP 50 million to GBP 150 million, and since we aren't raising and returning funds the way private equity does, we're able to manage and realize value with a genuinely long-term perspective. That matters for our partners too, who appreciate the value that this time affords them. A total return of 12.3% for the year came from the sale of 7IM, which produced a GBP 59 million, or 32%, uplift over the 31 March 2023 carrying value.

Mat Masters

executive
#8

Strong operational results throughout the majority of the investment portfolio's holdings additionally contributed to performance. So that you can grasp the risk being taken with your equity, this portfolio generally employs modest leverage, with net debt usually at 2 to 2.5 times EBITDA. As is evident, longer-term returns have proven quite strong, and across over 10 years, the pool has delivered 13.9%. I'd like to discuss AIR-serv, acquired at the start of the year for GBP 200 million, of which GBP 143 million came from Caledonia. AIR-serv designs, manufactures, and delivers services supporting an extremely large installed base of air, vacuum, and jet wash machines throughout Europe. Several aspects of the business appealed to us, among them that over the last 40 years, starting from an established U.K. position, it has built a number one or two position across its six other core markets. It features robust earnings growth, a well-invested estate exceeding 21,000 machines, underpinning roughly 100 million transactions annually. It mainly offers a non-discretionary product, supported by an industry-leading service and support team, which maintains machine uptime at a very high level.

Mat Masters

executive
#9

We believe this is a genuinely attractive business to put money into. After meeting Clive Steel and his team, we took to them right away, and they laid out for us how they could keep expanding the company by installing additional machines across the U.K. and, in particular, in the newer European markets. Now, we very much enjoy putting further capital behind the teams we are already supporting. Across our whole business, this ranks among the highest-returning and lowest-risk investments we can make, so learning that Clive had more investment opportunities for us to fund behind him was a real pleasure. Luckily for us, Clive appreciated our truly long-term style of investing and partnering, which made him very glad to work alongside us. Progress so far has been solid: we have finished the corporate carve-out of the business and brought in key hires for the team, and we have put GBP 12 million of CapEx in to support the company's growth, so everyone is highly pleased with that. Trading at the business has been strong, and that shows up in the valuation rising by around 19% across the year. Alongside AIR-serv, the portfolio is mainly made up of the other three operational businesses based in the U.K., plus Cobepa, the private capital investment company headquartered in Belgium.

Mat Masters

executive
#10

Let me give a quick comment on each of the companies. Stonehage Fleming had a strong trading year, and that shows up in both their growth and their valuation. Our pubs business, Liberation, did feel inflation's effects over the year, though revenue and profitability are now improving. Cooke, which is the leading maker of cinematography lenses, was affected by the Hollywood strikes — those are resolved now — and that held back its trading and, as a result, its valuation during the year. That business is recovering and keeps making operational progress, with the launch of a new prosumer lens range that is proving very popular. Last, and certainly not least, Cobepa's portfolio, for the most part, traded well over what was a quiet year for them in terms of investment activity. Now, this year, Cobepa reaches its twentieth year. We backed Jean-Marie and his team when it was created, and we've had a really good relationship and partnership with them and Cobepa's other shareholders over that period, and it has delivered brilliant returns for all of us. It's multiplied our original investment by 5.5 times, and we had a co-investment with Cobepa in BioAgilytix, which delivered 4.5 times — just under 4.5 times cash on cash returns to us — and we continue to look at investment opportunities together.

Mat Masters

executive
#11

That's really the heart of it—forming connections across the years, and here we are, 20 years in with Cobepa, and our excitement about continuing to work together is just as strong as ever. So at this point I'll pass things to Alan, who'll cover our public companies.

Alan Murran

executive
#12

Thanks, Mat. Good morning, everyone. It's a pleasure to be here with you today. I'm Alan Murran, and I co-head Caledonia's Public Companies business, where I'm responsible for the capital portfolio. Mat has done a great job covering Caledonia's culture and the private capital business. I'll be speaking about public companies and about how we performed over the year. I'll also give a case study on Watsco, one of our amazing portfolio companies. It's North America's largest distributor of air conditioning equipment. Unfortunately, that's something we don't really require in the U.K., but thankfully for our investment, it's a necessity in the Sun Belt of America. I'll also give you a flavor of the team and talk you through what we like and what we think we look for in our investments. To start off, I'll describe the two portfolios. So firstly, the capital portfolio is about GBP 700 million, and the income portfolio is about GBP 250 million. So that's GBP 950 million in total, and that's about one-third of Caledonia's NAV. So we look for quality compounders across both portfolios. As Mat mentioned, we look for, on the capital side, we have a higher return target with no yield requirement, and this really gives us the ability to focus and look for the really special companies that we want in our portfolio.

Alan Murran

executive
#13

On the income side too, the return target is lower, though it includes a solid dividend, and that means quality is a focus there as well, just like on capital. Now, I've got a terrific team working across both portfolios. There are 6 of us, and we become 7 next month, and over the long term, the returns we've had are really good. To dig into these a bit more deeply — take the capital side, for instance: across 3 and 10 years, we've delivered roughly 10%, and on the 5-year figure we've done even better, at just under 13%. That works out to a cumulative return of more than 80% over that brief span. On the income side, the strategy shifted about 5 years ago, and we've produced a solid 6% across 3 and 5 years, dividend included. Let me also spend a little more time on the team. It's an experienced group, with every member bringing at least 6 years of experience — something really important given our thorough investment process, which I'll cover in more detail later. On top of that, this is a team that's passionate about investing. In fact, during our recent recruitment, that was one of the key traits we sought in our candidate.

Alan Murran

executive
#14

We also have a culture that’s very collaborative and meritocratic, where we encourage open debate, and I think that’s a major reason most of us have worked together for many years now. This year’s performance is a 12% return for the combined portfolios, with a 14% return for the capital portfolio and a 7% return for the income portfolio, just under 7%. On top of that, this performance has mainly been driven by the operating performance of the underlying companies, which has been good. In addition, some opportunistic trading has supplemented it. For example, in October of last year, we topped up a number of holdings across both portfolios. In addition, there was a well-timed purchase in RELX last summer, which was actually a position that the team started work on in 2020, but were very patient on when to buy it. Net, over the course of the year, we have spent about GBP 33 million, net of all sales. So turning to Watsco, I’m gonna give you an overview of the business. I’m gonna talk about the quality characteristics. Give you an insight into our investment thesis, and talk about the returns that this company has generated. But before doing all that, I’d like to tell a story.

Alan Murran

executive
#15

Watsco is a company I first became aware of back in 2016. I was at a sell-side conference. Usually at these events you pick up a bit of information about companies. They run through a quick summary of who they are, and finding a genuine idea there is pretty uncommon. But that particular day, we got lucky. Right from the start it was obvious that Watsco displayed every one of the quality traits we seek in an investment. So, after carrying out additional research on the business and meeting with management, we opened a position in 2017. Now, moving to an overview. Sorry, let's spend a moment on returns. We also added to the. We also opened a position amid the COVID sell-off within the income portfolio as yields reached target levels. And turning to returns, the returns from Watsco have been remarkable. That works out to an annualized return of 22% since inception, so a genuinely strong investment that we still hold today. Spending a little time on a summary of the business. Watsco has a wonderful history. The current CEO, Albert Nahmad, transformed the company from a manufacturing operation into a distributor in 1989, and starting from that position, he has built the business up to a $19 billion market cap, an incredible accomplishment for an exceptional entrepreneur.

Alan Murran

executive
#16

Think about it this way at a high level: if you're a homeowner and your air conditioning equipment fails on a hot day, what happens? You've got to call your local contractor, and that contractor will either sell you new equipment or repair what you already have — and to do that, they go to their distributor. Now, Watsco operates more than 690 locations across 42 states and serves over 125,000 of those contractors. So Watsco has the quality characteristics that we look for in our investments. I'll touch on three of these. First, it has a resilient business model. There are 120 million HVAC units in the U.S., and every year, these break. So this means that Watsco has an installed base of demand that it can continuously tap, and a product, when it's roasting outside, that's necessary. Number two, they, like Caledonia, like us, have significant family ownership. This means that they have a long-term thinking, and they have a unique culture, and it means that they are great owners for other smaller distributors to sell to. And then thirdly, this long-term thinking that Watsco has enables them to invest heavily and digitalize their business, giving them a significant long-term advantage over the competition.

Alan Murran

executive
#17

Now, back to the thesis we started with. That initial thesis capitalized on something genuinely appealing about Caledonia—something Mat mentioned when he discussed culture—namely, our capacity to take a long-term view. With Watsco, what unfolded was this: as I explained, once they began putting money into digitizing operations, it meant bringing on board a substantial number of tech staff and directing capital toward system upgrades. Near term, that weighed on profitability, yet we could see past it and formed the judgment that margins would widen and market share would be gained. That is the reason we first established the position in 2017. Now, considering the returns from that point and our activity since. We added to the holding in 2019, and later, amid the COVID sell-off, we made a sizeable purchase and also started a holding in the income portfolio. After that, for several years, we simply held and waited, and then, as the portfolio—as the company kept delivering, we trimmed our position more recently following a big rally in the share price.

Alan Murran

executive
#18

During this stretch, as you can see, the share price has more than tripled, and it paid a healthy dividend along the way. What's nice is that this result isn't speculative. The company's own performance has driven it. Across that stretch, revenue has risen by almost 70%, going from GBP 4.3 billion to GBP 7.3 billion. EBIT margins have also widened substantially, by 270 basis points, reaching 10.9% — so genuinely, genuinely strong results. Now I'll pause here to also discuss how we invest and monitor in general, since it's extensive and certainly doesn't stop once an investment is made. For instance, with Watsco, across the years, we've met management many times in Florida, at our offices here, and at conferences. We've visited their stores and those of their competitors. We've met their suppliers. We've read plenty of HVAC trade magazines. It's an interesting thing. Beyond that, this is something we do across all our investments, or indeed, things we're considering investing in, so it keeps the team very busy. So to wrap up, we've gone through the portfolio's returns, which is 12% for the team over the year. We've covered Watsco and what we look for in investments, so I hope it's been informative.

Alan Murran

executive
#19

I'd add that working at Caledonia is a privilege, since its structure of permanent capital, no fund flows, and a supportive shareholder base gives us the best possible conditions as investors in public markets. Truly, that is a setup you seldom come across. So I think it's a wonderful place to work, and I know my team shares that view. Thank you. With that, I'll hand over to Rob.

Rob Memmott

executive
#20

Thanks, Alan. Morning, everyone. To start, let's walk through the funds pool. That pool of ours has now been operating for over 10 years, and the opportunity here is significant. These funds typically don't do marketing in Europe, which means we're frequently the sole European investor in the fund — a genuine differentiator for Caledonia. The pool is spread across some 74 funds, run by 42 different managers, and invested in more than 600 underlying companies. 59% of the pool focuses on North America, in the lower mid-market buyout space, while 41% focuses on Asian buyout, growth, and venture. Strong returns have come out of this pool. On the graph at the top right-hand side, you can see 17% over three years, 17% over 10 years, 16% over the five. Current year performance stands at 2%, or 4% in local currency. At the half year, we gave you an update on the significant drop in divestment activity, and we'll examine the cash numbers more closely on the next slide. But this was a theme common to both markets, as investors adjusted to higher interest rates in North America and in Asia, where the general reduction in capital market flows weighed on in-year performance.

Rob Memmott

executive
#21

The year's overall positive result came mainly from our North American funds, which returned 9.8% in local currency. That was supported by the trading performance of the companies — the underlying company trading performance — which offset part of the multiple compression we experienced from higher interest rates. NAV also rose thanks to Q4 exits, and the profile of those exits is what we'll examine on the next slide. As a reminder, North American companies employ fairly modest leverage, in the 2 to 4 times range. Our Asian portfolio saw a 3.1% decline in local currency, reflecting those difficult market conditions, with few exits or fundraising activity occurring during the year. On this slide, we'll take a somewhat closer look at cash flow. In the lower left-hand corner, you can see realizations from North America and Asia across recent years. At the bottom, spanning the last 5 years, you'll see the cash generation — the net cash flow for each year. Viewed cumulatively, you'll see that it is positive. At the half year, in the current year, we reported an outflow of GBP 50 million, but for the full year we now show an outflow of GBP 37 million, which clearly shows the second half was cash positive.

Rob Memmott

executive
#22

Specifically, we're happy about the better trajectory we're seeing in North American distributions. There's a small callout on this slide that breaks out, quarter by quarter, what realizations looked like in North America, and you can see how strong Q4 was for us. During Q4, 8 divestments helped us, producing roughly GBP 30 million of cash and coming in at a 10% premium to net asset value. On the upper left-hand side, we've put a pie chart that lays out the weighted average life of our primary portfolio. In North America, that weighted average comes to 4 years, versus the typical fund hold period of 4 to 6 years. When it comes to Asia, the weighted average life sits at 5.1 years. We anticipate a longer hold period there, since the assets lean toward venture and growth in that market. Measured in U.S. dollars, our capital commitments fell from $524 million to $476 million. At current exchange rates, that equals GBP 377 million. We invested or called $116 million, including $60 million of new commitments split between primary and the acquisition of a secondary position in an existing holding. There's a case study on New Heritage Capital. New Heritage, which is headquartered in Boston, is a typical example of one of our North American funds, with a focus on the North American lower mid-market.

Rob Memmott

executive
#23

The strategy is to purchase small businesses — in U.S. terms — that are frequently owner-managed, and this is often the first institutional capital put into the company. The plan is to transform these companies via operational efficiency and, where appropriate, bolt-on acquisitions. These improved companies with greater scale provide feedstock for the next level of mid-market private equity. In 2015, and before investing in the fund, the funds team built a very close relationship with the fund's principals, diligencing their performance track record and understanding their investment culture. Caledonia are members of the Fund Advisory Board, as we are for 80% of the North American funds where we invest, providing a level of oversight and influence over the GP. The first commitment was in 2019, GBP 20 million of a fund size of GBP 260 million, and then we recently followed on with a GBP 30 million commitment into Fund Four. You'll see from the table that we are expecting a return of 2x from Fund Three, and with Fund Four being at the beginning of its investment period. Caledonia is the only European investor, which, as I mentioned earlier, is a real differentiator for us. On the next slide, we'll see four of the underlying portfolio companies within New Heritage, and these are really reassuringly traditional businesses, a food manufacturer, a provider of mental health services, enrollment solutions for higher education, a SaaS BPO for independent grocers, all with good margins, cash generative, and are scalable.

Rob Memmott

executive
#24

In Q4, we sold two of the businesses, and both went at a premium to NAV as well as a solid money multiple. Now on to the figures — the part everyone's been waiting for. Let me give you a few of the headline points. Over the past 12 months, our NAV has risen to GBP 3 billion, producing a total return of 7.4%. After the 7IM sale, we hold GBP 2.7 billion invested across a diversified portfolio of listed and privately held companies and funds with global reach. That portfolio has returned 8.7%, with each of the pools contributing positively. That compares in line with the FTSE All-Share's 8.4% return over the last 12 months. From the 7IM sale proceeds we received GBP 256 million, which left us with year-end cash balances of GBP 227 million, and the balance sheet carries zero structural leverage — though we do have an undrawn revolving credit facility, giving us liquidity of GBP 477 million, which will let us act and invest in assets we find attractive. On the dividend, our proposed dividend raises the full year by 4.5% to 70.4p. That comes to GBP 38.3 million, fully covered by net revenue of GBP 40.5 million.

Rob Memmott

executive
#25

The final dividend of 51.47p is going to be paid to shareholders on the 1st of August. As I said at the half year, I really do love a waterfall chart, and this presentation won't let you down. The first one is on slide 25, and it shows our portfolio of investments and how it moved through the year. These grew from GBP 2.5 billion on the left-hand side of the chart at the start of the year to GBP 2.7 billion on the right, including GBP 346 million of investments made, GBP 142.5 million relating to AIR-serv within our private capital pool, GBP 109 million into the funds pool, and GBP 77 million into the quoted pool. And as Alan mentioned, you know, part of that is a new position in RELX. Part of that is seeing opportunity around our core position to trade. Our realization is GBP 371 million, included GBP 256 million from 7IM, GBP 72 million from funds, and GBP 44 million from the quoted pool. We received investment income or cash yield of GBP 46 million, and recorded gains, total gains on investment of GBP 232 million, being a return of 8.7%. This was driven by strong performance in both the quoted and private capital pools, offset by foreign exchange of GBP 39 million.

Rob Memmott

executive
#26

On the valuation side, our quoted assets get marked to market every day. For private capital, we apply the IPEV guidelines and carry those holdings at fair value. These businesses generate cash and carry conservative leverage of 2 to 2.5 times. Multiples fall in a 9 to 14 times range, which is in fact in line with the prior period — so it's the trading performance of the underlying businesses that's driving the returns. When it comes to the funds, we depend on the management NAV statements. Those are audited by reputable firms under IFRS or U.S. GAAP, both of which are fair value bases. The team goes through the valuations to make sure trends or company-specific issues are properly reflected and understood. 75% of NAV was valued using the 31st of December NAV statements, the most recent information reported. In the table on the right, you can see returns and yield by pool. For the overall portfolio, 8.7%, with a cash yield of 2.5%, and every pool contributed positively. Our NAV has grown from GBP 2.8 billion to GBP 3.232 billion, driven by investment gains. Investment gains, net of management costs, produce the 7.4% return for the year, and out of that we've paid last year's final dividend and this year's interim dividend of GBP 37 billion, closing at GBP 3 billion — 37 million, closing at GBP 3 billion.

Rob Memmott

executive
#27

The currency breakdown of where our assets are domiciled is shown in the pie chart. U.S. dollars account for 52%, and sterling makes up 39%. So shifts in the dollar and sterling exchange rates are going to have an effect on results within the period. During the 12 months, foreign exchange cost us GBP 39 million, which brought our NAV total return down by slightly more than 1%. Turning to the net debt bridge, the main movements going from left to right, we began at GBP 222 million. Net investment flows came to 27 million, cash yield was GBP 44 million, and cash cost was GBP 29 million in management expenses. There's a small amount of working capital in the period, and after that we paid out the dividend of GBP 37 million, ending the year at GBP 227 million. As I mentioned, GBP 227 million, and we have an undrawn RCF of GBP 250 million, giving combined liquidity of GBP 477 million, and that gives us the capacity. What that means is we're able to act when we spot attractive opportunities that fit our criteria. Now, as long-term investors, it matters that shareholders gain from the rise in NAV. TSR over 10 years is 8.6% per annum, but we're aware that over 5 years a gap exists between NAV and TSR, caused by the discount widening.

Rob Memmott

executive
#28

In the past year, that figure has gone from a bit below 33% to a bit below 39%. And thinking about how solid the balance sheet is, our listed investments, marked to cash each day, come to GBP 950 million. Cash held on the balance sheet stands at GBP 277 million. Those two together have a combined NAV of GBP 1.2 billion, so with a market cap today of GBP 1.9 billion, that effectively means the private company assets trade at a 60% discount — which strikes us as too much and fails to reflect the quality of the investments we hold and our long-term performance record. This is a live matter the board is discussing, and we're pushing ahead on everything within our control. First, and probably most significantly, is continuing to build on our track record of delivering long-term real returns. Second is share buybacks, and we gain from the ongoing support, stability, and cultural foundation that the Cayzer family gives our investment philosophy. Their stake currently sits at just under 49%, which limits how much we can do in share buybacks. We can't take them through 50%. In March and April, we bought 290,000 shares at an average discount of 36%, which is accretion to NAV per share of 10.1p.

Rob Memmott

executive
#29

And we'll keep buying back stock, though only inside the limits we have in place. Third, we're continuing to develop how we handle investor relations and communications so that the Caledonia investment case gets properly understood and rated — the aim there being to broaden the shareholder base and bring in more marginal buyers. In the presentation we've included additional case studies. At the half year there were three, and there are three now, and we've expanded the disclosure, which I hope you find helpful, especially in showing in a tangible way how we think, how we operate, and how we invest. That will carry on at future interim and full year results, and in March we launched a new fact sheet. From here on, we'll put out the monthly fact sheet, and the full commentary will come when we report our interim and full year results. So to sum up, Caledonia has assembled a diverse portfolio that is well positioned to deliver long-term returns. We put money into quality businesses centred on free cash flow, which means the portfolio can respond to the challenges the macro environment creates. We have a robust balance sheet, with assets marked at the conservative end of a valuation range, and liquidity of GBP 477 million, which gives us the firepower to act when we spot an attractive investment.

Rob Memmott

executive
#30

The seasoned team is 100% dedicated to carrying on with investing in and managing the portfolio of high quality companies and funds. So at this point we're going to open things up for questions, starting with the room, and after that we'll take some from those joining remotely. If you're remote and would like to send a question in writing, we will gather those together, read them out and address them. Also, during the Q&A, we'll have something on screen. We've put the manifesto up. Please take a moment to read it, if not right now, then later. And we've also included a link to the short video. It runs for two minutes. Please watch it after the meeting.

Mat Masters

executive
#31

I'll hand it over to the room now. Anyone have questions? Alan.

Analyst

analyst
#32

Actually, this one's for Alan. Thanks. I've got a question for Alan. The message on quality is coming through loud and clear, but I'm just curious how that kind of works alongside valuations — using Watsco as an example — and whether you can sort of top slice in there. I'm just wondering how that squares with the long-term approach?

Alan Murran

executive
#33

All right. So the way we approach risk management is shaped by valuations. What I mean is that, in general, whenever we purchase businesses, we hold off until a point in the market arrives that lets us buy while enjoying a margin of safety. After that, we let those businesses expand their free cash flow as time passes. And broadly speaking, if you remain invested in a company and it delivers, and it is doing what it needs to do when it comes to compounding its free cash flow, that is the primary source of returns. That said, valuations also factor in interest rates, so when valuations get out of line or our concentration risk grows too large, we do manage that risk. But across the long term, as Watsco has shown us, it keeps compounding even while valuations fluctuate.

Analyst

analyst
#34

Thanks.

Analyst

analyst
#35

Thanks. Regarding the private equity positions, your approach to valuations has been pretty cautious. AIR-serv is a relatively new holding, yet it got written up in these results. Could you walk us through what drove that increase in the value of that position?

Mat Masters

executive
#36

Yeah. Perhaps Alan.

Rob Memmott

executive
#37

To start with, AIR-serv was recorded at cost when we bought it. So at the half-year mark, the figure reflected what we paid for that business. Since then, trading has performed very strongly — ahead of what we expected, you know, and growing at a double-digit rate year on year. So now that we've had the business for 12 months, we'd look to value it on an EBITDA multiple, the same way we do across the rest of the portfolio, and by looking at market comps. The multiple applied is very much in line with the acquisition, so we aren't raising it — it's really the business performance that's driving the returns.

Analyst

analyst
#38

Stepping back for a moment, I was just wondering — when you look at the fund exposure, there's clearly a pretty significant tilt toward Asia. What's behind that? And am I correct in thinking that you essentially look to play the U.K. and Europe through the directs?

Mat Masters

executive
#39

Neil, Asian funds have been a component of our program for a good while now, so that piece is well established. You know, our funds program deliberately centers on the American mid-market, since that gives us, if you will, the best of American capitalism minus excessive leverage levels, and returns there are truly driven by fundamentals. So we view that as a terrific area. And then through Asia, we gain exposure to, you know, markets that are growing. And when you go visit, you know, the companies in that region, they're managed fantastically, and they're doing genuinely good things. So the companies still excite us, and we've been putting money to work over there across a long stretch of time. So it remains an ongoing piece of the strategy. What I think has occurred over the last few years is that the geopolitical dimensions, sort of, and also certain aspects of capital markets in parts of Asia have simply become a bit tricky, and we're clearly attuned to that and monitoring what goes on.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Caledonia Investments Plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Caledonia Investments Plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Caledonia Investments Plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.