Card Factory plc (CARD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 3, 2022

London Stock Exchange GB Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 35 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#1

Hello and welcome to our preliminary results update for FY 2022. Darcy Willson-Rymer here, CEO of Card Factory, and with me today is Kristian Lee, our CFO. In a moment, Kristian and I will take you through the financial performance update for FY 2022, after which I'll give an update on delivery progress for our Opening Our New Future growth strategy, followed by the outlook for the year ahead. To start, I'd say that having just finished my first full year as chief executive of Card Factory, I've been struck by the potential that comes from the design, print, manufacturing, and retail capability, along with the culture of the business, and I feel optimistic about our opportunities for growth. Card Factory is a company that customers and colleagues alike love, and there's an energy among our colleagues to do the right thing, which our FY 2022 performance reflected. Looking back on FY 2022, we tackled a number of operational priorities. When lockdown ended, we made sure the stores reopened and traded as strongly as possible. We responded actively to supply chain pressures so as to mitigate trading disruption, and the fact that we hold our own in-house design, print, and manufacturing capability proved its worth through FY 2022.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#2

We went back over our Opening Our New Future growth plan and refreshed it. Phase one of the ERP rollout is now complete, we've brought in new talent to make the leadership team stronger, and we moved faster on evolving the culture at Card Factory. And as the results show, we made sure the right financial structure was in place. You can see all of that in how FY 2022 turned out, with sales coming back steadily once lockdown ended. That gave us a top line that kept improving, reaching GBP 364.4 million across the 12 months to January 31st, 2022 — that is, our financial year FY 2022 — up 28% year-on-year, with store sales growth doing the driving. Store performance recovered steadily at +33% year-on-year, which mirrored a 20% rise in trading days versus the prior year along with a rebound in our market share. Online sales stood above pre-pandemic levels at +23%, which mirrored the wider range of products we now offer online, a better customer experience, and a faster shift in how consumers behave. Profit came in ahead of what management expected, even with meaningful inflationary and supply chain headwinds, at a PBT of GBP 11.1 million against guidance of GBP 7 million-GBP 10 million.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#3

The company continues to produce a lot of cash, and leverage came down considerably over the year. Our push to strengthen the business financially showed up in robust operating cash flow, which rose 42% against the previous year to GBP 114 million, excluding lease liabilities. We finished the year with a stronger balance sheet: closing net debt, excluding lease liabilities, stood at GBP 74.2 million, versus GBP 107.7 million in FY 2021. Last, we're glad to have completed a successful refinancing with our banking partners, as announced on April 21st, 2022, and under the revised agreement the group is no longer obliged to use best efforts to raise additional equity in order to make prepayments on the debt facilities. To go through the refinancing and all the details of our financial performance, I'll now pass things over to Kristian.

Kristian Lee

executive
#4

Thanks, Darcy. Now I'll walk you through the FY 2022 financial update for Card Factory. Revenue rose by GBP 80 million overall in the period, reflecting a gradual rebound in store performance after lockdown restrictions were relaxed. Stores LFL came in at -5.7% versus FY 2020, and online like-for-like revenue for Card Factory was -1.5%, giving a combined Card Factory position of -3.9%. Profit before tax for the period reached GBP 11.1 million. That beats the GBP 7 million to GBP 10 million guidance we provided in January. Net debt, excluding lease liabilities, has fallen significantly to GBP 74.2 million. That's almost half the level we saw in January 2020, before the pandemic. Net debt including lease liabilities stands at GBP 193.7 million. Turning to like-for-like sales performance. Footfall on the high street remains subdued, as we've continued to see. Transactions in the period reflected that at -23%, while average basket values stayed strong at +22% during the period since reopening in April 2021. Card Factory online at -1.5% came against a tough comparative of 135%, remembering that FY 2021 included five months of lockdown when people shopped online.

Kristian Lee

executive
#5

Turning to the divisional breakdown, total store revenue came in 33% higher than FY 2021. Our store portfolio has been going through a consolidation evolution, matching shifts in how people shop. On a net basis, we added four stores, bringing the portfolio to 1,020. Even after the pandemic, we currently see just circa 2% of stores that are marginally loss-making. Through our monthly review and the property reviews, we tackle these with an action plan and relocations. Trading recovered with particular strength across the year, above all into December, when like-for-like on December 21 versus 2019 reached -1.4%. We also launched the first new model store in Coventry, which features better customer flow, improved store navigation and operational efficiencies. During the financial year, we intend to open a number of additional stores of this kind as trials. That said, I believe store performance reflects the strength of the Card Factory brand and underlines how important stores are within the wider omni-channel strategy. Turning to online, I've already touched on the -1.5%. The main areas where Card Factory has performed strongly are non-personalized cards along with gifting, parties and balloons, as people have shopped online and brought parties back.

Kristian Lee

executive
#6

Getting Personal, on the other hand, came in somewhat softer at -21%. That really mirrors a couple of factors. First, it ties to what we laid out earlier regarding prioritising profitable sales and pay-per-click transactions, which deliver a solid return on investment. Beyond that, there's a piece where we're moving Getting Personal across to the new platform, and that's slated for late H1 of FY 2023. On partnerships specifically, GBP 4.6 million was lower than a year ago, though it matched our expectations. The decline stems largely from The Reject Shop, reflecting the lockdown stretches we're observing in Australia. Aldi has held sales flat year on year, keeping in mind the five months of lockdown during FY 2021, when shoppers gravitated toward essential retailers while non-essential ones stayed shut. Partnerships have performed robustly, and we've brought in a new business development director to steer that strategy. Turning to margins across the period, product margins were strong, up 4.4 percentage points. Currency gains on our blended FX position accounted for 0.4 of that, while 4% came from realigning stock provisions together with better stock management.

Kristian Lee

executive
#7

Wage increases in our stores came in line with what we had expected, thanks to the National Living Wage and some offsetting productivity gains. Meanwhile, the rise in property costs really reflects the fact that government rates relief was lower in FY 2022. Direct expenses went up in step with higher sales, and operating expenses reflect the investment we've put into IT infrastructure, plus an element in the prior year that benefited from CJRS government support during the lockdown periods. Taken together, that gives us EBITDA of GBP 85.6 million for the period, versus GBP 45.8 million. That's nearly double the profit we posted last year. On top of that, looking now at the depreciation line, you have the right-of-use assets, with the rent charge running through that line. That too has come down, to GBP 37.3 million against GBP 39.6 million in the previous period. Net financing expenses came in higher than the prior year. That reflects the refinancing we carried out in May 2021, and it also reflects the refinancing options we looked at before the refinancings we announced on April 21st this year. All told, profit before tax was GBP 11.1 million, compared with a GBP 16.4 million loss in the prior year.

Kristian Lee

executive
#8

Now, an important point is cash flow. The upside from higher profit matters, but one thing I really want to flag is net working capital. Across 2 years, we've improved net working capital by GBP 62 million, and that clearly helps when it comes to lowering the business's net debt position. On other lines, you'll notice CapEx at GBP 6.6 million, versus 7 million last year. That shows the cash and CapEx discipline we applied through the COVID-impacted periods in order to preserve cash. On lease liabilities, you'll see GBP 54.8 million compared with GBP 22.1 million. That reflects GBP 19 million of rents deferred from FY 2021 into 2022. Turning to free cash flow, it came in stronger than FY 2021, at GBP 42.5 million versus 36.1. At the underlying level, we absorbed a further GBP 90 million hit from rents during the year, so the underlying figure would be closer to GBP 61.5 million. That explains why net debt fell sharply by the year end. On the liquidity update, really 4 key points. We've completed the refinancing. That puts the liquidity concerns behind us and leaves us with adequate headroom. We've also eliminated any obligation for an equity raise, and we now have a new financing facility running through to September 2025 to underpin the five-year strategy.

Kristian Lee

executive
#9

Naturally, inflation and headwinds have drawn plenty of discussion. For FY 2023, we anticipate that revenues will return toward the FY 2020 levels seen before the pandemic. As we guided earlier, the expectation is that meaningful inflationary headwinds will persist throughout FY 2023. At Card Factory, the main pressure points are freight costs, fuel, the National Living Wage, and energy. We acted preemptively in these areas and offset a substantial share of them through a mix of efficient cost and working capital management, along with targeted price increases. Our expectation for FY 2023 on revenue and profit is unchanged. On FY 2023, one more point regarding CapEx. We do expect to spend circa GBP 23 million during this financial year. That reflects the areas for delivering the strategy and the areas where we preserve cash, as I mentioned, in the cash flow across the last couple of years. The principal areas are the ERP phase two implementation, developing online — which includes raising our fulfillment capacity and efficiency — plus the broader omni-channel offering and investment in stores. We will still invest in existing stores and new stores, circa GBP 7 million, with a gross store number of around 50 and a net store number of around 38, as we do look to carry out more relocations within the existing portfolio.

Kristian Lee

executive
#10

Now, moving on to a quick update on how trading is going right now. In the opening few months of this financial year, what we've observed is performance matching what we had anticipated, and our market share position has kept on recovering, which clearly matters a great deal. That said, within our spring seasons — Valentine's Day and Mother's Day — we're noticing a mix shift toward everyday ranges, which normally account for 70% of annual sales. We think that shift could move closer to 73%. Still, keep in mind that Valentine's Day and Mother's Day together make up considerably less than 10% of total sales across the year. Looking at how things should go over the remainder of the year, we expect to gain more and more from the strategic improvements we have planned, among them growing our market share in complementary categories, rolling out trial stores, and targeted price increases. There are three key initiative areas: price increases; authority in complementary categories — these take in soft toys, and we've brought in books as well as confectionery and chocolates; and the third is leadership and card choice, with key areas being refreshed ranges and new price points. Specifically for wedding, female, and open, we'll be aiming to refresh those ranges. That wraps up the financial update, and I'd like to hand back to Darcy for the strategy update.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#11

Thank you, Kristian. Since we announced our revised Opening Our New Future growth strategy back in September, this marks the first strategy update. I realize that some of you weren't able to join that update, so I'd like to open with a quick recap. After that, I'll walk you through more detail on the key milestones we've delivered and what our priorities are for the months ahead. To sum up, the right path forward is unmistakably to move Card Factory away from being a store-led card retailer and toward becoming a market-leading omni-channel retailer of cards and gifts. With this strategy in place, Card Factory is well positioned to become the U.K.'s number one destination for every customer looking for unrivaled quality, value, choice, convenience, and experience. Our work is to transform Card Factory into a leading omni-channel brand in our space, helping customers celebrate each and every special occasion, and we aim to become a global competitor that puts cards and gifts in the hands of more customers. As we set out at the time of our interim results in September, we'll build on the quality and value heritage we already have, taking Card Factory on a journey that gives our customers more convenience through greater access to products wherever and whenever they want them.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#12

This is going to be delivered via a better digital experience and by moving to a fully omni-channel operation. We'll grow our store footprint across the U.K. and the Republic of Ireland, and we'll also build our international presence in countries that are ready for disruption, because we've identified gaps in those markets for the value and quality that Card Factory offers. We'll give customers more choice by taking our leading card offer and extending it into complementary ranges. We'll stay a card-led value retailer in a stable market, one where 73% of U.K. adults buy cards. That said, we'll serve customer demand by offering greater choice through complementary gifting and party ranges, which opens access to a large market worth GBP 44 billion per annum in the U.K.; within that, we'll be targeting GBP 5 billion, which is between four and five times larger than the card-only market Card Factory has focused on before. And finally, we'll deliver an exceptional customer experience through better data capabilities that help us understand the customer, through brand investment, and through ESG investment. We'll build a culture of accountability, with colleagues empowered to make the right decisions for the business and a shared understanding of its identity, strategy, vision, and values, within a diverse, inclusive, and socially responsible business.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#13

Our strategy is now being executed, and we have already hit some notable milestones. We have reinforced the leadership team by filling the key positions of Chief Information Officer and Digital Director, acknowledging how essential digital is to growing our business, along with a new Business Development Director to head up our partnership strategy. Beyond that, we have appointed Card Factory's first Customer Marketing Director to lead our new customer marketing function. Those appointments add substantial experience to our leadership team and will make sure we possess the right capabilities to propel the next phase of our growth. As for milestones in delivering the strategy, they include launching our first new-format model store in February 2022. The Coventry store makes better use of store space, improves how customers flow and navigate through the store, and also boosts operational efficiencies. The results at that store have been very encouraging, and we are confident similar results can be delivered as additional trial star stores open. We are also moving both online platforms, cardfactory.co.uk and gettingpersonal.co.uk, onto one unified platform, which unlocks cost benefits and the chance to substantially expand the gifting range on cardfactory.co.uk. Going forward, our focus for the next financial year is generating growth opportunities around the store estate and building out our broader capability.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#14

Key milestones involve leveraging the leadership position we already hold in party and balloon categories so we can grow our share in our stores across adjacent categories like stationery and confectionery. Cards in store won't be sacrificed for this. The point is to make smarter, more agile decisions regarding the space given over to complementary categories. We'll finish rolling out trial model stores so we're ready for a broader rollout from FY 2024, while feeding valuable learnings into the existing store estate as they come. On new store openings, we've found a profitable path for launching our first stores in central London. Beyond that, after profitable success with our first 14 stores in the Republic of Ireland, we'll keep pursuing our expansion plans, with a further five stores already identified and additional openings planned. More broadly, regarding the wider capabilities required to deliver our strategy, we will trial letting shoppers click and collect any product from our online or app platforms for pickup in store. That's the first step toward rolling out our omni-channel capability, which we believe gives us the opportunity to leverage our brand, our store estate, our vertical integration, and our quality and value proposition, along with our investment in our online channels, to materially increase our share of the online market.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#15

We’re going to roll out phase two of our ERP. The new ERP system is already live across finance, and it will support the growth strategy throughout the whole business, helping us understand and react quickly as shopper habits and preferences change. It will give us the ability to see stock across every area of the business, which is essential for omni-channel operations. It will also let us integrate with future partners, both in the U.K. and internationally. And finally, to help maintain margins, we’ve started a highly targeted set of price increases on some of our products, building on the success we had last year. We’re carefully analyzing how that affects sales, and we are actively considering further price rises on other SKUs. We’re gonna do all of this while maintaining our value proposition. On our ESG focus, we are committed to growing the business in a socially and environmentally responsible way. We’re making considerable headway toward these objectives. Highlights include being on track to reduce waste, with 90% of our products free of single-use plastic, and all of our products being glitter-free by the end of FY 2024. We’re progressing well on reducing our carbon footprint, and we have an ambition to become a carbon-neutral business.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#16

On the social side, we rolled out our diversity, equality, and inclusion strategy, and it's delivering a positive difference for colleagues, for the communities in which we operate, for the products we sell, and for the suppliers we partner with. When it comes to career progression and talent management, our approach is progressive for every colleague, and we keep making a positive impact in the communities where we work and for the charities we back through our Card Factory Foundation — and all of that rests on a rigorous approach to good governance. To sum up, looking forward, our focus is on building out our digital proposition and using our store estate and brand heritage to turn Card Factory into an omni-channel business, so customers can reach our product wherever and whenever they choose. We'll keep building on our success in complementary categories to serve a GBP 5 billion gifting market. Alongside that, we're also growing our successful partnership model, both in the U.K. and internationally, and all of it will keep resting on the strength of our vertically integrated model — a unique point of difference for Card Factory that lets us own every aspect of design, manufacture, distribution, and sales channels, both in store and online.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#17

We'll keep strengthening the company's finances—it's very profitable, generates plenty of cash, and the refinancing we completed successfully now supports that. So for FY 2023, Card Factory anticipates that revenues will move toward where they were before the pandemic, and what we expect for FY 2023 revenue and profit has not changed. We've acted preemptively to help soften the inflationary pressures we're encountering throughout the business, and we'll keep watching and reacting to evolving macro environmental pressures. Card Factory is now in a strong position for longer-term growth, with a target of more than GBP 600 million in sales by FY 2026. That growth ambition is already being delivered, and we'll make significant headway this year in delivering our Opening Our New Future strategy. So we're excited about the growth opportunity that lies ahead. We remain focused on making changes that let us deliver on our transition from a store-led card retailer into a market-leading omni-channel retailer of cards and gifts. Thank you for your engagement and for your time today. Kristian and I are now happy to take any questions you may have.

Operator

operator
#18

For anyone on the line who wants to pose a question, just hit star one on your phone. Our first caller is Kate Calvert from Investec. The line is yours.

Kate Calvert

analyst
#19

Good morning, everybody. I've got just a couple of questions. The first one concerns the supply chain. Considering how much exposure you have in China, and clearly the ongoing COVID restrictions and the disruptions happening there, what changes are you making this year so that supply stays consistent, especially as we head toward Christmas? My second question relates to your product margin percentage — it remains fairly well under the peak levels seen before COVID. Where do you expect it to recover to across the coming three years?

Kristian Lee

executive
#20

Thanks, Kate. Yeah, so I mean, regarding China, as you mentioned, there is some exposure there, and we've been watching it pretty closely. The main thing we've generally focused on, you know, when it comes to evaluating risk to the business, is where else we can source products from, so within Europe and other regions. I think right now, in terms of how much product we've already sourced for the seasons and Christmas especially, we remain fairly comfortable with that. On product margin, we made an obvious note in the statement about, we did provide for stock at the back end of last year. Because of some freight issues, which would have been widely noted in the press, we ended up substituting some products. There was a bit of a tailwind on that provision. I think if we're looking at the 4% we guided to in the note, 4 percentage points difference, probably about two of that relates to a tailwind in the period. I think product margins will stay, like I say, 2% different, but there or thereabouts. I don't think that the pre-tax product margins we'd seen would get back to those levels on the basis we've introduced a lot of other categories.

Kristian Lee

executive
#21

We've talked about confectionery, chocolates and other items within the non-card space. Those are the kinds of things that, you know, are really driving solid cash sales. As I said, the margin — I'd expect it to land around 2% different from where we sit now by the time we reach year end.

Kate Calvert

analyst
#22

Okay, thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#23

At this point, the phone queue has no additional questions waiting.

Speaker

unknown
#24

Thanks, Sergey. A few questions have come in through the webcast. For anyone who wants to ask something on the webcast, just a quick reminder to click the Submit Question button in the control panel at the bottom of your screen. Our first one comes from Adam Tomlinson at Liberum. Could you discuss where stock currently stands and what availability levels look like? How comfortable are you, and where does inventory need to be?

Kristian Lee

executive
#25

When it comes to where stock levels stand right now, we've clearly put some money into handheld terminals and essentially into getting stock details at the line level and SKU level within stores. We now have far more — a much stronger grip on inventory and availability. Building on that, we've successfully managed to reduce stock levels. I think we stay comfortable with the lower stock levels we saw at the close of FY 2022.

Speaker

unknown
#26

Could you provide some specifics about how CapEx is structured for FY 2023?

Kristian Lee

executive
#27

We haven't provided a clear breakdown of that GBP 23 million guidance, obviously, but the main area is essentially ERP phase two — the core stock system — which delivers the full stock loop and gives us better visibility on stock. Then there's online investment, around online fulfillment, meaning the capacity and ability to fulfill orders better, plus investment in omni-channel and online. And then, as I said, we're still looking at circa GBP 7 million going into stores across about 50 growth stores, 38 net, along with relocations in there. Other areas where we'll keep investing include vertical integration and Newport, and obviously the competitive difference we have there. There'll be an element in that. Some of this really reflects where we held back cash on CapEx over the previous two years — some of that investment was always part of the five-year plan.

Speaker

unknown
#28

Could you share a little more detail about where that major investment is headed?

Kristian Lee

executive
#29

Like I said, those categories really get divided between the two of them. As I mentioned, we haven't provided anything beyond that.

Speaker

unknown
#30

Thanks. The next question he has is this: regarding the price increases you mentioned, could you help us put a number on what you're planning, and tell us what you've observed competitors doing up to now?

Kristian Lee

executive
#31

Regarding price increases, we obviously ran several market tests before implementing these changes, in order to gauge the effect on volumes. What we examined were particular key price points. Take GBP 0.59 to 0.69 as an example, and we shifted GBP 0.89 to 0.99. Certain GBP 1.49 cards went to GBP 1.99. The crucial thing, though, is that this isn't simply a matter of changing the tab on the card that already exists. Our aim is to re-engineer those cards and add greater value to them. Then, obviously, there are the non-card areas, where we've brought in other categories — books, confectionery, chocolates — at various price points too.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#32

Kristian, let me just jump in on the pricing piece. I think that's an important one. To start with, in September I said we'd aim to offset inflation by combining productivity gains with price, and that's our strategy — and we're executing it. The other thing worth noting about price is keeping the architecture intact. As Kristian mentioned, we've pushed some prices up to GBP 0.89-GBP 0.99, for instance, but what we've tried to do is keep a logical price architecture. Our entry price point at GBP 0.29 hasn't changed, though we've introduced higher price cards, so in some categories our exit price point sits higher. Take wedding, for instance: we've now added a card with more in it, so as Kristian set out, it delivers more value, but with an exit price point of GBP 2.99, for example. Beyond that, it's about keeping the architecture appropriate and also examining how we can drive spend.

Speaker

unknown
#33

Thanks. Adam’s final question is this: you mention that you’ve already offset a meaningful share of inflationary pressures up to now. Could you provide a bit more detail on that?

Kristian Lee

executive
#34

Naturally, freight has been one of the key areas. I'd say the primary inflationary pressures we're seeing are freight, obviously, the National Living Wage continuing, and what we've observed with fuel prices. On freight specifically, something we examined in great detail is container fill. Clearly, getting the most out of containers and the timing of shipments affects pricing. Obviously, on the in-store side, we've looked at greater efficiencies and more places where investment in IT and technology can remove tasks from stores to offset the National Living Wage. We've hedged, you know, roughly 3 years ahead on price regarding what's happened with energy prices in that area. On fuel, you know, we've been negotiating with a number of carriers for DC-to-store routes, and through those negotiations those contracts, you know, avoid absorbing the full impact of fuel inflation. A lot of other measures have been taken as well, but those are probably some of the major items.

Speaker

unknown
#35

Thank you. Several questions have come in from James Gilbert at Argan Capital. First, could you take us through how your projected medium-term revenue growth breaks down across each initiative? What portion comes from store openings, range, market expansion, online, and so on? In that context, can you also give us guidance on medium-term operating margin targets, please?

Kristian Lee

executive
#36

Regarding how the projected revenue builds up over the medium term, we obviously haven't provided that breakdown to the market. As for the overall split we're aiming for over the next five years through FY 2026, it's for 20% of sales to come via online and partnerships. On margins, we previously gave guidance on where we were targeting future margins to reach — you know, circa 17% from PBT. Those guidances remain essentially intact, though clearly, with inflation where it is, those things will stay under review.

Speaker

unknown
#37

Thanks. One quick reminder before we wrap: if you want to pose a question through the webcast, just hit the Submit Question button located at the bottom of your screen. Since there are no more questions, I'll return things to our speakers for any extra or closing comments.

Darcy Willson-Rymer

executive
#38

That’s great. I’d like to use this moment to express appreciation to everyone for spending their time and giving attention today, and we look forward to connecting with our shareholders in due course. Thank you so much, everyone.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Card Factory plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Card Factory plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Card Factory plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.