Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 14, 2020

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 66 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for remaining on the line. We appreciate your presence and are glad to have you with us on this CECONOMY AG conference call. <<operator_script>>. At this point, I'll hand the conference over to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations. Please proceed.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#2

Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us on the call for our Q2 results. Joining me are CEO Bernhard Düttmann, our CFO Karin Sonnenmoser, and Ferran Reverter, who serves as CEO of MediaMarktSaturn Retail Group. They'll be walking you through the presentation we have for today. Before we begin, a couple of quick formalities. First, please note this call is being recorded, and a replay will be posted on our website later today. Second, bear in mind that the presentation today, and possibly some of the answers we give to your questions in the Q&A session, may include forward-looking statements. For more details on that, please see the disclaimer. With that, I'll turn things over to our CEO. Please go ahead.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#3

Good morning, everyone, and thank you for being on today's call during these difficult times. I can tell you, these are difficult times. I'm sitting here in this room, and everyone who isn't speaking has a mask on. That's something I've never witnessed before. I'll begin the presentation by reviewing the second quarter. After that, I'll hand things over to Karin, who will take you through the financials and the updated guidance for the whole year. Ferran will then bring you up to date on our operations, particularly as they relate to the corona crisis. As we've done before, we'll finish today's call with a Q&A session. Ladies and gentlemen, there's no need for me to inform anyone on this call that recent weeks have been extraordinary. The present corona crisis has a drastic impact on each of us — personally, professionally and socially. Numerous parts of the industry around the world are struggling. The economy has been experiencing difficult times. In March, the coronavirus brought a temporary halt to nearly all of our stationary business. For a retailer, that's the worst scenario imaginable. All of this came after CECONOMY had gotten off to a very solid start in this new financial year. Just a brief recap.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#4

The Black Friday season in 2019 turned out well. Beyond that, during the first quarter we achieved meaningful operational advances on our strategic initiatives, which set the groundwork for a strong full year. Through January and February, the positive momentum from the first quarter carried on, and we are entirely aligned with expectations. Indeed, on the whole, both sales and earnings moved favorably, with momentum building. That situation shifted entirely in March. COVID-19 began spreading rapidly throughout Europe. Following local government directives, we had to progressively close the majority of our stores. By mid-March, the adverse impact of the corona crisis on our business was being felt across the entire group. Given this situation, we were required to pull our guidance for the current business year. In a crisis, swift action is essential. We responded right away. So what actions did we take? Above all, we promptly rolled out extensive health, safety and protection measures for our customers and employees. On the operational front, I take great pride in our colleagues, who showed remarkable dedication in rapidly, rapidly redirecting commercial activities and resources toward the online channel, thereby scaling up our online business. To lessen the effect of store closures on earnings and liquidity, we have additionally put in place a number of short-term measures.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#5

Ferran will provide further detail on this a bit later. I'm happy to report that the teams at CECONOMY and MediaMarktSaturn carried out proactive crisis management successfully to lessen the COVID-19 impact. Beyond that, we moved decisively to strengthen our financial resilience. We drew down our bank lines right away, and we managed to secure a revolving loan facility worth EUR 1.7 billion, provided by KfW with an 80% participation, along with our partner banks contributing another 20% participation. We're glad about the strong backing from the German government, KfW and our partner banks. A condition attached to the loan agreement requires CECONOMY to suspend dividend payments while the credit facility remains in place. The term runs until December '21, with a 1-year extension option at KfW's discretion. In addition, Karin, myself and the management Board of MediaMarktSaturn decided to waive our short-term performance-based remuneration for the current financial year. In the same way, the short-term incentive for the company's second management level will be cut for this year. This new credit line adds to our existing facilities of EUR 980 million. I strongly believe that short-term financial flexibility matters greatly in times like these.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#6

The purpose of this syndicated loan is to act as a backup facility that addresses a worst-case COVID-19 pandemic situation. Should the economy keep reopening and we avoid a second shutdown scenario, then any draw on the new syndicated loan would, we expect, be very limited, if we draw at all. If, however, a second COVID-19 wave were to occur — something all of us hope will not happen — we would be well positioned to withstand that additional storm. Drawing on what we learned during the March and April lockdown, our revised worst-case assessment has reached the conclusion that EUR 1.7 billion will deliver enough flexibility and safety. Now let's move on to a quick look at how we performed in the second quarter. As noted earlier, January and February saw a very good performance from us. March, though, brought a serious challenge in the form of the corona crisis. Even though pure online sales remarkably doubled in March, that was not enough to offset the sales lost in the brick-and-mortar business. On top of this came a negative margin development. As I already said, we implemented short-term countermeasures successfully, yet all of us knew that ours is a business with high operational leverage.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#7

When a business that normally sees higher volumes runs into this kind of sales shortfall, a significant hit to the bottom line can't be avoided. Beyond that, we also had to record an impairment on our Fnac Darty stake of roughly EUR 268 million during the second quarter, and that further weighed on our reported EBIT. To finish up, let's briefly review the 2 headline figures for the second quarter. As you're already aware, the pandemic's negative effects are already showing up in our overall financial performance. Sales, adjusted for currency effects and portfolio changes, came in 6.6% lower. As a result, adjusted EBIT fell by EUR 157 million versus last year. More recently, the gradual reopening of our stores marked an important step back toward normality in our business. Over 90% of our stores group-wide are open once more. Still, given how widely locations were closed through April, we expect COVID-19 to affect Q3 again. That said, in April our mitigating cost measures worked well to soften the negative effects. We keep confronting the crisis with determination, and we'll apply what we learned from it to speed up CECONOMY's transformation. Let's now turn to the financials, and I'll hand things over to Karin.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#8

Thanks, Bernhard, and good morning, everyone joining the call. I'll walk you through the quarter's figures in detail. Group sales reached roughly EUR 4.6 billion in Q2. One factor drove the drop we experienced this quarter: the store closures in March. So for context, combined sales across January and February — also adjusted for currency effects and portfolio changes — rose 3.7%. At that point, momentum was fully intact. Countries with high sales volumes, including Germany, Italy, Spain and Poland, suffered the most in March. Yet markets untouched by closures, like Hungary, the Netherlands and Sweden, performed well during March. Let me illustrate how COVID-19 affected sales through the second-quarter curve using the waterfall chart on the following page. That should give you a clear picture of the dynamics at play here. Sales last year totaled roughly EUR 5 billion in Q2. During January and February of this fiscal year, performance was robust, particularly in the key German market, Austria and Turkey. The online business and the Services & Solutions segment likewise posted solid growth rates. All told, sales were up 3.7% across the first 2 months.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#9

March looked completely different. Closed stores caused brick-and-mortar sales to fall sharply. Thanks to a focused set of measures — I'll come back to this in a minute — we strongly boosted online sales in March. That said, it couldn't fully offset the drastic decline in brick-and-mortar. Consequently, group sales fell by around 28% in March. And again, taking currency and portfolio effects into account, this ultimately resulted in minus 6.6% in group sales versus last year. In the second quarter, online sales, adjusted for the Greek MediaMarkt business, rose by around 23.7% versus last year. Adjusting for iBOOD as well, online sales climbed by 26.9%. Since COVID-19 trials began, we have increasingly concentrated our sales activities and our resources on the online channel. This also includes shipping from stores to support online sales. Our efforts have paid off. The figures speak for themselves. Online trading has been particularly strong in the last weeks, with pure online sales up almost 100% in March, which gained further momentum in April. Ferran will shed some more light on the current online performance later on. Unlike the online business, our Services & Solutions offering was affected by the COVID-19-related store closures.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#10

Following double-digit growth in January and February, Services & Solutions sales for the quarter ended up at the same level as the prior year. To give a bit more color on the various categories, during the second quarter extended warranties and insurances showed positive development, while the other categories within the Services & Solutions segment declined. Clearly, more store-related services felt the impact of store closures. Let's now turn to Slide 14 for a look at gross margin, OpEx and EBIT. During the first 2 months of the quarter, we observed a positive gross margin trend. In fact, gross margin was nearly stable versus prior year. In March, though, gross margin fell, largely because of COVID-19-related effects, among them product and channel mix effects and higher delivery costs resulting from the strong growth in the online business, and let's not forget the lower income from Services & Solutions in March. Altogether, this produced a 230 basis point decline in gross margin in the second quarter. Initial savings tied to the COVID-19 cost measures recently introduced benefited earnings, especially in personnel and marketing. We expect the full impact of those savings to materialize in April.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#11

On top of that, the benefits of the cost and efficiency program are still coming through and helped earnings in the quarter. Overall, adjusted EBIT fell sharply in Q2, landing at minus EUR 131 million versus plus EUR 26 million a year earlier. Essentially, every region played a part in that negative movement. Within DACH, Germany posted a substantial drop in earnings. The main driver was unfavorable sales and margin trends in March stemming from COVID-19-related store closures. On top of that, a provision for legal risks tied to contractual penalties weighed on earnings. On the positive side in Q2, we saw lower material and personnel costs along with initial COVID-19-related savings, especially in marketing. Short-time work introduced in Germany and Austria had not yet affected earnings and will only start to from April onward. Earnings in Western and Southern Europe were likewise hit by COVID-19-related pressure on sales and margin in Italy and Spain. Even though our stores in the Netherlands reopened in March with reduced opening hours, earnings there also fell in Q2. In Eastern Europe, earnings were down too, entirely because of persistent earnings weakness in Poland, which deteriorated in March due to the corona pandemic.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#12

When it comes to Others, Sweden's earnings came in under the prior year, and that was due to an impairment of right-of-use assets at the Swedish country organization. Let's turn now to Slide 15. As you may remember, on our Q1 call I had already flagged the risk of an impairment tied to our Fnac Darty investment. Well, given the sharp drop in stock markets, our Fnac Darty investment took an impairment hit at quarter end. That led to an impairment of roughly EUR 268 million in the second quarter, which was partly offset by our share of Fnac Darty's result of about EUR 34 million. So the total earnings effect linked to associates came to approximately minus EUR 234 million. Lastly, we need to factor in EUR 3 million of trailing restructuring expenses tied to the reorganization and efficiency program. As a result, reported EBIT was minus EUR 368 million in the second quarter. Let's now examine the bridge from EBIT to EPS on Slide 16. Please bear in mind that we now see the report figures also including the effects from IFRS 16 in the current period. Earnings before taxes fell by EUR 424 million to minus EUR 391 million in the second quarter.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#13

Moving past the lower operational earnings, this drop stems from a reduced net financial result, which is attributable to increased interest expenses, primarily because of recognizing the interest component for operating leases under IFRS 16. In addition, during the prior year, the financial result gained from a larger METRO dividend and a valuation gain tied to the 5.4% stake that was still held at that point. Turning to taxes. Over a 6-month period, the tax rate came in at minus 36.6%. This is essentially just a technical figure. The negative tax rate largely reflects the Fnac Darty impairment. For this financial year, in light of the current circumstances and the Fnac Darty impairment, we anticipate distortion in the tax rate. For upcoming financial years, though, we still expect the underlying tax rate to move toward 35%. Overall, given the corona-induced reduction in operational earnings and the Fnac Darty impairment, in which the minorities did not take part, earnings per share fell by EUR 0.89 to minus EUR 0.82. Now let's move to the cash flow statement. Free cash flow during the first 6 months totaled EUR 286 million, which represents an increase of EUR 362 million versus the prior year period.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#14

But this rise is basically tied to IFRS 16 adoption. When we look at lease-adjusted free cash flow, which deducts repayment of lease liabilities so that free cash flow is more comparable under IFRS 16, we see a year-on-year increase of EUR 86 million. The main explanation for that is a lower net working capital outflow during the first 6 months. That came from a bigger rise in trade payables, driven by a higher starting point as of September 30, 2018, and also from the temporary extension of payment terms with some suppliers in the context of COVID-19. This effect more than offset the larger increase in inventories. On cash taxes, initial suspension measures were still being implemented in March, which accounts for the EUR 15 million reduction. The main effects on lowering the cash tax burden, though, are expected in Q3 and Q4. A higher outflow of other operating cash flow worked in the opposite direction. That is mainly explained by restructuring-related cash outflows and the reversal of noncash effects tied to the Greek transaction. We have also seen cash investments go up. Just to make that clear here. This increase is related to the cash effective investment into the joint venture in Greece in the first quarter.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#15

As we anticipated, spending on modernization and expansion came in well under the same stretch a year earlier. Across the whole year, we now foresee CapEx landing beneath our earlier guidance of 1.5% of sales. Turning to the outlook: folks, much has already been said today regarding the COVID-19 crisis. Attention is understandably drawn in large measure to this exceptional event. One facet of the crisis is how limited visibility remains. That sits alongside plenty we do know, yet equally alongside plenty of open questions. Let me start with what we know. Through the first 5 months of the year, our performance was very solid. We remained fully on course toward our targets for the present business year. Then March arrived, and it was hit hard by corona-induced store closures. Those closures weighed on sales and margin in April as well. Still, we put cost mitigation measures in place successfully, and they helped slow the earnings shortfall. Because of that, the year-on-year drop in adjusted EBIT for April was materially smaller than the one in March. Let me also be clear on another point. No cost reduction tied to the reorganization and efficiency program is being put at risk by the current crisis. That program is implemented, and the savings are arriving as expected.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#16

Cost optimization, as you’re aware, is going to stay highly relevant for us going forward as well. Then there are the unknowns. How the COVID-19 virus will develop is something nobody can say. Has the worst passed? Might a second wave arrive? When will life get back to normal—or to the new normal? What is that new normal going to look like? Right now we also lack knowledge about whether recovery will differ by region or geography. Clearly, any timing is uncertain. And we still don’t know whether consumer sentiment could be impacted, or in what way, and how consumer behavior might change as a result of the shutdown and the recession. Given these uncertainties, on March 18 we withdrew the original outlook we had for financial year 2019/'20. We keep assessing the situation and are taking every measure required to protect our business. Because of how dynamically things are developing, though, a detailed forecast of business performance over the coming months isn’t possible at present. And as of now, the effects of COVID-19 on our business for the full year 2019/'20 can’t be predicted with sufficient reliability. Even so, we’d like to at least give you a rough sense of how we see financial year 2019/'20.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#17

On the sales side, for the full year we now anticipate a drop in ForEx adjusted sales. As for adjusted EBIT, a significant decline is what we expect for this financial year. This year's EBIT will take in a positive effect of presumably EUR 5 million to EUR 50 million stemming from the transition to IFRS 16. With that, ladies and gentlemen, I'd now like to pass things over to Ferran for a business update in the context of COVID-19.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#18

Thanks, Karin, and good morning from me as well. Ladies and gentlemen, during difficult times, we at MediaMarktSaturn succeeded in getting ourselves ready for the crisis at a very early stage. The choices we made rested on early signals from our business partners in Asia, and also from within our country organization in Italy. An internal task force had already been assembled in January. And we effectively apply the knowledge that we obtain throughout all of our markets. Once we had reached a solid grasp of the situation, we put in place decisive and swift actions. Bernhard already mentioned some of this earlier today. To safeguard our employees, our customers and our business, extensive health and safety measures stood right at the top of the list. In addition, we cut our costs sharply and set up liquidity outflow by taking a range of steps. First of all, we had to bring in short-time work across most of our countries. Throughout Europe, over 30,000 employees in stores and administrative units were affected, and in part still are today. Second, we held negotiations with our landlords to pause or delay rental payments for the time being. On top of that, we lowered investments in store expansion and modernization. And we have likewise negotiated significant agreements with our key suppliers, including a temporary payment shift.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#19

The third area is our effort to prevent extra cash from going out the door. That covered, for instance, moving or pausing marketing spending tied to physical stores, along with postponing tax payments. There's no doubt we needed to act fast and take fairly tough steps. Overall, we believe we made the correct moves at the correct moment to soften the crisis's near-term impact. A number of these urgent actions will produce a structural gain. We anticipate a durable and enduring beneficial impact on our operations from them. Allow me to point to 4 particular areas of action. The first is costs. Not only will our costs be brought down in a lasting way, we will also work to make our fixed cost more flexible so we have greater room to maneuver. As an example, we aim to tie a store's rent amount to that store's turnover. Here we have seized the crisis's momentum to begin talks with our landlords about structural changes. The second is supply chain. We will keep adapting and refining our supply chain so as to capture the strong growth potential of our omnichannel business model. Already during the crisis, we demonstrated how quickly and consistently we could move our supply chain over to online.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#20

Third, marketing. We're going to aim for a big move into digital marketing and targeted below-the-line communication. Fourth, IT. We'll also keep enhancing our IT systems by speeding up the rollout of one inventory along with new capabilities, like ship from store. And that service has already been performing really well in recent weeks. One key factor for us during the past weeks has been how resilient our omnichannel business model is. Store closures, naturally, had to be carried out in line with governmental regulation. We're talking about 87% of our store group-wide that we had to shut in March. We did a great job refocusing our commercial activities and resources away from brick-and-mortar toward online, thanks to the commitment, dedication and also the creativity of our teams in the individual countries across all functions. The result: pre-online sales more than doubled in March. In April, the number is even more impressive. Pure online sales grow by roughly 300% on a year-on-year basis. This was supported by shipment from store, which was only possible thanks to our recently introduced employee app. With this app, our productivity increased massively. Existing customers keep relying on us. But we also welcome a high number of first-time buyers.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#21

Actually, new customer sign-ups over the recent weeks came in at three times the level of the prior year. That's quite encouraging. At this point, we're reasonably far along in reopening. As of this week, every one of our stores in Europe has reopened, with Turkey the exception. In Germany, our home market, all locations are back operating with full floor space. Over the first days since reopening, we've observed some promising sales catch-up, particularly in Germany and Italy. Still, it's plainly too soon to gauge the full extent of the rebound. Early on in this crisis, we had already agreed that notwithstanding the difficulties in front of us, we wouldn't allow it to pull our attention away from transforming our business model. As I noted, I think certain changes already put in place will assist us along this path. To keep moving forward, we're pushing ahead with 3 sets of measures. First, we'll broaden our omnichannel model further. On that front, we've upgraded our online business through our new webshop and consumer app. Both are live in Germany and will be introduced across every one of our countries by the middle of next year. The new webshop and the app feature a wide array of new functionalities and have been received very favorably by our customers.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#22

This also lets us push our online attachment rate higher, since we see considerable potential there. Meanwhile, we'll bring our omnichannel edge into play with even greater force. That covers our ship-from-store capabilities, which improve availability and delivery times for customers while also optimizing our working capital. Our omnichannel strengths further include our service portfolio, which we'll keep expanding. On top of that, we're refining operations through advanced data analytics and speeding up our competencies so we become a true smart retailer. What that means is we'll keep rolling out new tools that optimize our operations automatically and in real time, drawing on big data. Our SMI pressing tool is one concrete example we've already introduced. Second, we'll maintain a tight focus on cost. We'll further improve our sales and services productivity. We'll also keep optimizing our store network and speed up the rightsizing of spaces, and we'll keep making our cost more flexible. A higher share of performance-based online marketing is one concrete lever here. Third, we're tapping into new income sources. Launching our marketplace in the fourth quarter of the current fiscal year will let us significantly expand our assortment from 2021 onwards.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#23

Beyond that, we're going to roll out a wide array of new services. Take the new advertising offering for our suppliers as one instance — it draws on the digital ad inventory across our webshop and app. And last, we'll monetize our supply chain capabilities in both directions, toward our customers and toward suppliers. Every crisis brings challenges along with opportunities. At MediaMarktSaturn, we choose to concentrate on the opportunities. Though the challenges come first, naturally. Even though we've managed to reopen over 3/4 of our stores quickly, sales are anticipated to catch up against the timeline. A second COVID-19 wave, together with all the associated effects on our business, can't be ruled out. And with the dire economic outlook, we anticipate consumer spend will be below pre-crisis levels, including for consumer electronic products. That could persist for a significant stretch of time, with differences across individual countries. Conversely, we see substantial opportunities that, as the market leader in our segment, we ought to be able to capture. As market consolidation speeds up, we'll watch the markets closely and size up opportunities that arise to grow our market share. With the impact of COVID-19 on the retail sector, we'll be even more relevant to our suppliers and landlords.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#24

Web-based sales are going to stay at higher levels, driven by shifts in what customers do, and that will be supported by store sales that are recovering. And last, we ought to be able to take advantage of the digitization trends emerging from the COVID-19 crisis. Take home office equipment — that's among the areas where we expect demand to rise strongly. There are further cases too, such as home entertainment or products for home schooling. Ladies and gentlemen, in summary, we handled the crisis quite well. We showed our ability to respond quickly when conditions change fundamentally. It was the right things that we addressed last year in order to get ready for harder periods such as this one. Yes, these are very challenging times for us, yet we can state with conviction that we are today a better and more efficient company than we were 1 year ago. Our omnichannel business model has proved very robust and successful. We are on the right path to becoming the customer's first choice, to becoming a genuinely smart consumer electronics retailer with a unique product and service offering. That's all from me — over to you, Bernhard. Thank you.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#25

Thank you, Ferran. Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to close out today's call briefly. I'd like you to take 4 key points away from this discussion. First, it's clear the mandatory store closures hit our performance hard in the second quarter. Government measures aimed at fighting the virus brought most of our stationary business to a standstill. That's especially disappointing given how solid our start to this year had been. Second, it's evident that business year '19/'20 will be anything but normal. It will stay exceptional and challenging. That's particularly true given the limited visibility we're operating with right now. We can't predict yet what the long-term implications of the COVID-19 crisis will be, whether from the expected recession or from a structural change affecting our business. Third, the reopenings matter enormously for how we perform going forward. Each store that's up and running is a help to us. Having more than 90% back in business so quickly now is a great result. We remain alert when it comes to the health and safety of our employees and our customers. Fourth, the COVID-19 crisis gives us the chance to speed up the successful transformation for CECONOMY. We've already done this in online, and we will generally embrace this opportunity.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#26

To us, the takeaway is pretty straightforward. Even with the present circumstances, we feel confident about the appealing long-term prospects for this company. With that, I'd like to wrap up today's presentation. Thanks for listening, and at this point I'll hand the call over to the operator so you can ask your questions.

Operator

operator
#27

<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Nicolas Langlet at Exane BNP Paribas.

Nicolas Langlet

analyst
#28

I have 3 questions, if I may. First, it could be a little early for this, but do you have anything to say about how consumers are behaving in stores that have reopened recently? And how do you see in-store traffic developing over the next few months? Second, when we factor in the efficiency program, the COVID-19 cost optimization and the support from states, what reduction do you expect in your OpEx base for full year '20 versus full year '19? I realize a precise figure is hard to give, but even a broad range would help a lot. And lastly, on gross margin. Can you break down the 230 basis point decline among the mix effect, delivery costs and the lower sales of the services solution? And for Q3, how do you expect those 3 elements to play out?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#29

Okay, on consumer behavior, what we're seeing right now is that people are coming back to our stores gradually. And we're catching up on sales gradually as well. So essentially, what we observe is that conversion is going up. The average basket size is going up too. But we're still not at the pre-level when it comes to traffic. At the same time, we're maintaining momentum in online sales.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#30

Nicolas, okay, to revisit what you asked about gross margin: both the COVID-19-driven channel shift and the stock valuation effects made contributions of roughly the same size to the weaker gross margin in Q2. Combined, those two account for roughly 1.3% — percentage points — of margin decline. On your question about how much OpEx reduction we anticipate, what we're seeing is that COVID-related cost savings added a bit more than EUR 100 million in April, and most of that came from tax savings. That said, it's a very broad-brush figure. And bear in mind this figure hinges on lots of moving parts that swing around considerably. For instance, we keep reopening additional stores, and in doing so we cut the count of employees on short-time working schemes and kick off new marketing campaigns tied to the reopening. Also, bear in mind that a big chunk of the savings from short-time working in March turned into earnings-effective savings in April. We've observed what amounts to a period shift here. With stores progressively reopening, our expectation is that April will be the single month carrying the largest portion of mitigation countermeasures. I hope that covers your question.

Nicolas Langlet

analyst
#31

Yeah, absolutely. And regarding gross margin—when we look at Q3, should we anticipate a further decline in gross margin, given that you'll have been under lockdown for a longer stretch? Or are there any initiatives in place to offset that effect?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#32

No, at this point we aren't anticipating any bigger drop in our margins.

Operator

operator
#33

Volker Bosse from Baader Bank has the next question.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#34

Volker Bosse from Baader Bank. I have three questions. The first one concerns your guidance, and I'd like a little more granularity there. Obviously, no one can say how COVID-19 will unfold over the remainder of the year. Still, I'm certain you're running various scenarios. So what sales decline ranges are in your model? What's the upper bound? What's the lower bound of your scenario? And yes, some indication of the range would help, including on earnings as an outcome of those sales scenarios. Second question. Yes, I'd like to probe productivity and frequency as well. I know it's early days, but some kind of indication — are we at 10% of pre-crisis level? Or is it 30%? So what does that mean for people coming back? Where do we stand? I realize it's ramping up step by step, but any indication would be helpful. And my third question is on the supply chain. Do you anticipate any supply chain disruptions during the year because of, yes, limited production capacities in China, in Asia, generally? Any forthcoming information on that?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#35

Volker, I'll take your questions. First, on the guidance. Of course we have scenarios, but sharing them isn't sensible since they're extremely wide-ranging and so many factors come into play, and honestly we don't know if a second wave will hit or anything like that. Right now, we're quite pleased with how business is going in our stores. We've watched people line up outside the stores waiting to get in, which made it very clear that customers see real value in our store network. We could also see that at the start — in each store's first days — we posted a high sales figure. So evidently there's substantial pent-up demand that the crisis had held back, and now consumers are returning and are in fact purchasing. That's why it's also very hard to forecast what the longer-term trends will look like, once this sort of pent-up demand settles down to a normal level of sales behavior or buying behavior. But I think that answers it: at the beginning, once we opened a store, we saw a strong ramp-up at every one.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#36

On the third question, supply chain — I believe Ferran needs to add to what I'm saying here. But the key point is what Ferran already emphasized: back in January, when we saw the crisis approaching, we placed larger orders for certain products so that we wouldn't run short on supply. On this, though, Ferran, I'd like to ask you to shed a bit more light on it.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#37

Okay, on the supply chain side — as you're aware, we've got a well-defined plan there, the one we announced about transitioning to a single inventory and a single platform, built around NDCs, local hubs, and our stores. So at the onset of the crisis, what we saw was that we attempted to scale up our online warehouses quickly, and inbounds turned out to be one of the bottlenecks. That's exactly what we discussed on the call — we moved very fast to set up ship from store using our employee app, which helped us scale our supply chain considerably. Obviously, for the time being this is an interim fix, but it fits within the project we'll roll out over the next couple of years, as we announced. So overall, what we've demonstrated is that our supply chain has stronger resilience, and we can genuinely adapt to the momentum.

Operator

operator
#38

Juergen Elfers from Commerzbank AG has the next question.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#39

Yes. I have a handful. Perhaps we could take them one at a time. First off, let me ask Karin. Regarding the cost savings of more than EUR 100 million, Karin, you mentioned that most of it came from tax savings. Could you give us some background on those tax savings? And when will those postponed taxes and postponed rents need to be paid out?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#40

Juergen, my apologies, but I believe you've got me wrong there. What I referred to was tax personnel expenses — not tax.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#41

Apologies — that was personnel expense.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#42

Right. Right. Right.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#43

Yes, I get it. So when will those rents that were deferred start showing up in the P&L?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#44

On the tax deferral or…

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#45

Rent.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#46

Rent?

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#47

Yes, about that — could you give us a bit of background on the tax components you announced in the — I think it was on 17th of April, when you announced some of those cost-cutting measures.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#48

You kind of lost me there. Alright, let me begin. Actually, our goal for this fiscal year is to realize effective savings in a double-digit million amount. We pushed back tax and — however, we anticipate the bulk of the tax postponements landing in Q3 and Q4. On savings more broadly, you can — we're confident the high point of cost savings will arrive in April. And after that, as stores reopen, those cost savings will decline, since most of the savings stem from short time work along with the reduction of the personnel expenses.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#49

Alright, I’m referring back to that note I mentioned. You said that as of 17th of April, CECONOMY had reached agreement with the relevant government bodies to defer taxes including VAT, corporate income tax, and trade tax. My question was really about that context. Could you shed a bit more light on it?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#50

Juergen, may I take this one? This is the liquidity measure. It was a liquidity measure as an initial reaction to the crisis, because when you have no sales — and that was the sentiment at the very start — that we lose a lot of sales, since we didn't know we could ramp up online sales as quickly as we did. So then we had to — we immediately worked on deferring payments. And these deferrals were, number one, tax payments of VAT, where we obtained government approval to postpone those payments. And number two, we went the same route on rent. So we talked with our landlords about postponing rental payments, so those were deferred as well. And with some of them, we could also negotiate reductions or various other things. And the last thing we also did then was that we had — what? no, no, no. That's already — suspending rent, yes. And the — that still is the liquidity part, sorry.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#51

<<inaudible>>

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#52

So that was taxed, and that was rent. After that, we focused on cutting costs — partly marketing expenses and other expenses we could halt right away and where we could essentially terminate contracts. That happened immediately — an operational step to also shrink our cost base. As the business comes back — with the business coming back, we definitely have to — we have to repay the deferred rent payments. We have to pay out, and we also have to pay the taxes to the government. So what we had is simply a temporary liquidity measure. As for the rental payments themselves, as a cost-saving step, we are renegotiating rental contracts, as Ferran has stated, to also make them more based on sales-related rental payment. So we're trying to renegotiate our contract in that direction. And second, some landlords also waived part of the rental obligations, so that we have a reduced burden from rental payments themselves.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#53

I'm only raising this tax matter and the postponement of other payments because I wasn't certain I actually wanted to examine the quarter's cash flow and see how much the free cash flow bridge slide has been helped by those deferrals, or by the other majority portions that will come in only starting from Q3.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#54

My sense is that the largest effect on the cash flow statement came from our major suppliers. We’ve also renegotiated some payment delays, and that has a substantial effect on net working capital — which you could see in the tax payments. We had a deferral of roughly — sorry, let me get the figure right — even the figures for payment terms, and that produced a deferral of close to about EUR 400 million. On the tax payments, it’s much lower; the effect there is much smaller.

Executive

executive
#55

EUR 15 million.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#56

So I'm seeing EUR 15 million there for tax payments.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#57

All right, all right. So then, if I might, could I just pose one question to Ferran? On Slide 22, I think, you pointed to several initiatives, immediate measures by the Board, and the count of employees on short-time work leaves me somewhat taken aback. Perhaps, Ferran, you could shed some light on that? In the annual report at the close of last year, you disclosed 50,000 employees -- headcounts, that is. And out of the 55,000, slightly more than 30,000 were in short-time work. Is that right? And why is the figure not considerably higher?

Ferran Reverter

executive
#58

Is that right? Well, the thing is, we also had to bring in some staff to handle ship-from-store in our locations. That's the reason. That's why.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#59

Still, those 30,000 represent merely 55% of all the people on our headcount. My expectation would have been — I'd have expected that figure to be considerably larger.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#60

Yes. As a baseline, we were aiming for 80% to 85%, right? But that fluctuated during the corona pandemic, because once we launched ship from store, order volumes in the stores ran very high, and that's why we required additional staff in the stores.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#61

That leads me to my second question. We are now seeing a sharp rise in pure online sales. Clearly, that is a strong signal—or perhaps let me ask whether it is a clear indication that processes are functioning when handling a 300% increase in such orders? Or to phrase it another way, is your back-end system that underpins the sharp online uplift being supported by a cloud so it can cope with a significant surge in demand? Has that already been proven successful during last year's black week? And when it comes to handling such online uplift, is CECONOMY well prepared with regard to the processes working in the background?

Ferran Reverter

executive
#62

Yes. 100%. You can’t carry out this ramp-up unless the right cloud processes are in place. 100%. You’re completely right. Yes. That’s exactly why we tried to make clear today that this is a major success.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#63

Honestly, Juergen, that turned out to be a useful chance to observe that — during Black Friday, we get heavy online traffic for a day or a week. This time around, it lasted over a longer stretch, and the system held up. So we are — these days the systems handle this far better and get it done effectively. We also picked up lessons on ways to further refine our processes within our online business.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#64

If we're talking about those clouds—my view is that handling a big volume of customer orders all at once probably requires a cloud behind it. So is the cloud already the key backbone across every country?

Ferran Reverter

executive
#65

Yes. Well, naturally, every one of those systems is being moved into the cloud. If you didn't do that, there'd be no way to manage it. 100%.

Juergen Elfers

analyst
#66

Alright, that's helpful. So one last question, and this is for Ferran as well. You mentioned a plan to introduce a marketplace during Q4 '19/'20, which would create an additional revenue stream. Would you mind telling us how far along you are in building out the marketplace platform and its framework?

Ferran Reverter

executive
#67

So, as we mentioned during the presentation, we're going to launch the marketplace in Germany in the last quarter of this fiscal year, and that's where we'll test things out, because as you can imagine, yes, there are a lot of new elements involved with new suppliers. And what we're saying is that this can create new revenue streams, and I've already said that this could come from marketing, from supply chain, and obviously from commissions.

Operator

operator
#68

We’ll take our next question from Fabienne Caron at Kepler Cheuvreux.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#69

I have three brief questions. The first is for Karin. Could you walk us through the key factors driving the smaller gross margin decline you're expecting in Q3? I can perhaps see services in there, but I was also wondering what's going on with discounts and promotions to bring customers back into your stores? The second question is for Ferran. What share of online do you think the group will reach by year-end? How do you see that growth unfolding? And you mentioned stores fulfillment. From an economic standpoint, does stores fulfillment make sense, because I believe it wasn't really profitable from a cost perspective? And last, Ferran again, on the marketplace. How will that operate? Will you stop vendors from selling products that MediaMarkt sells directly?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#70

Fabienne, I'll begin with what you asked about the gross margin drop. On April, I mean, the year-on-year adjusted EBIT decrease was significantly smaller than in March, where we see. The explanation is that our gross margin fell substantially in April versus the prior year, driven largely by the continuing channel shift, a reduced share of Services & Solutions online, and higher delivery costs stemming from pure e-commerce sales in most countries. So, I mean, to sum that up, I mean, we anticipate a considerable year-on-year gross margin decline in April. That reflects more days of store closures in April. We're also seeing a pronounced channel and product shift effect, plus the headwinds to income from Services & Solutions, as I mentioned earlier. I hope that answers your question.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#71

Right. I wasn't thinking just about April — I had the entire quarter in mind.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#72

So the way gross margin shakes out across the full quarter really hinges on how consumers are feeling and on everything that happens in the stores. Please understand that at this moment, we simply can't forecast that. What I mean is, we've had the first weeks open, and we'll just have to watch how things develop from here.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#73

All right, that clears it up — my mistake, since I took one of the earlier questions to mean you aren't anticipating a bigger drop in gross margin for Q3 than what we saw in Q2.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#74

Yes. We’re expecting pretty much the same drop. To phrase it another way, we don’t anticipate a bigger fall in gross margin for Q3.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#75

Alright. On the online and in-house sales side, our expectation was a range of 15% to 20%. And over the mid-term, 20% to 25%. Now to your second question about ship from store. For me personally, ship from store represents a distinctive capability. What I mean is that it has enhanced availability, delivery time and working capital. And it is genuinely very valuable that during this crisis momentum, or equally in the Christmas campaign or in large campaigns, it truly lowered the risk of the indices. It also helps to build a new customer proposition, which is same-day delivery or 2 hours delivery, and that will make us even more competitive against our competitors. And ultimately, if you build the right process with digitizing the tools, we are drawing on our existing employees already from the stores. So we are trying — it is true that, obviously, NDC for parcel products will in principle always be more efficient. But all in all, we are closing the gap. And we have clear rules for when we need ship from the store and when we need our NDC.

Fabienne Caron

executive
#76

So this isn't just a stopgap — it's permanent, is that right?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#77

May I just...

Ferran Reverter

executive
#78

Apologies — I’m not able to help with that.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#79

Is it here to stay?

Fabienne Caron

executive
#80

What I was saying is that this isn't just a temporary step — it's here for good. This is something you'll keep developing, shipping from store?

Ferran Reverter

executive
#81

Yeah, definitely.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#82

Fabienne, one more point on that. Ship-from-store gives us a really great capability, since it lets services be layered onto the products. Pre-installations, for instance. Doing that in the stores and then shipping from store out to customers is ideal. That is precisely what matters for the omnichannel model, where you essentially blend your capabilities across the online channel and the brick-and-mortar business.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#83

Now about the marketplace side of things. With marketplace, we're going to expand the assortment we currently have, clearly. So our partners are quite enthusiastic about it, since they'll be able to carry even more — yes — SKUs within our offering; it's fair to say we have to manage the pricing here really well. And it will be a huge help for launching new categories. That's going to bring a lot, a lot more speed — a lot more speed.

Operator

operator
#84

Our next question is from Clement Genelot at Bryan Garnier.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#85

I have two questions, if I may. First, are you concerned that the fresh social distancing rules now in place at stores could limit the range of services and extended warranties down the road in a post-COVID-19 world? And the second one concerns possible bonus payments. At food retailing companies and also at Fnac Darty, we observed that the groups will pay bonuses to at least warehouse staff or even store employees who keep working through the outbreak. Are you planning to do the same? Or are unions pressing you to do so?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#86

Clement, the first item — what exactly were the measures regarding bonus payments, or — sorry.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#87

That was the second one.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#88

The second one?

Clément Genelot

analyst
#89

The next question concerned bonus payments. Are you planning to give employees some bonuses since they continue working?

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#90

Ferran, that would answer — Ferran?

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#91

We’ll take a look.

Ferran Reverter

executive
#92

No. We’ll take a look at that. No.

Karin Sonnenmoser

executive
#93

And the first one was about measures, if I got that right. Measures to save what, exactly?

Clément Genelot

analyst
#94

Since your plan depends on services tied to in-store extended warranties, do you see the new social distancing rules potentially getting in the way of those ambitions? My guess is that employees won't be keen on spending too long in the store or staying too near salespeople.

Bernhard Düttmann

executive
#95

I believe I understand what you're asking. First thing: we're really glad that our stores are open again, which means we can restore services and bring that service back to customers. It's true that we need to maintain distance from customers. Yet even with that distance, services can be delivered and brought back up to the previous level. In fact, during January and February we did quite well at selling services, and that represented a very positive trend at the time, and we aim to get back to that level again with services. We also feel that we've arranged our stores in such a way that this is achievable, that we can put it into practice.

Operator

operator
#96

That brings us to the end of the questions for today, and I’ll now turn things back to Stephanie Ritschel, Vice President, Investor Relations, for her closing remarks.

Stephanie Ritschel

executive
#97

That wraps up our results call for today, everyone. We appreciate your time and the questions you've raised. Should anything else come up afterward, you're always welcome to reach out to us through Investor Relations. We're looking forward to speaking with you again. Take care, stay well, and goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.