Ceconomy AG (CEC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

December 15, 2022

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 71 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for being on the line. We appreciate you joining us, and welcome to the CECONOMY AG Investor and Analyst conference call. During the recorded presentation today, everyone will be in listen-only mode. After the presentation, there will be a question and answer session. Should you wish to pose a question, press 9 and then the star key on your touchtone telephone. For operator assistance, please press 0 and then the pound key. At this time, I would like to hand the conference over to Hendrik Finger from the investor relations team. Please go ahead.

Hendrik Finger

executive
#2

Thank you, and good morning to all of you, and welcome to this morning's call covering our Q4 12M results. Joining me today are Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, and Florian Wieser, our CFO. They'll walk you through today's presentation. Before we begin, let me take care of the usual formalities. First, this call is being recorded. A replay will be made available on our website later today. Second, please keep in mind that today's presentation and possibly some answers to your questions may include forward-looking statements. For additional information on this, please refer to the disclaimer. Now I'll hand things over to our CEO, Karsten Wildberger.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#3

Thanks, Hendrik, and good morning, everyone. I'd like to extend a warm welcome to all of you on our analyst and investor call. Let me begin by saying that the 2021 to 2022 business year proved hard on all of us — there's no doubt about that. Yet at the same time, it was a year in which we kept moving our company forward. First, we completed the Convergenta transaction successfully, which allowed us to simplify the complex structures we had before. We likewise cut our costs, brought our stores up to date, and made the brick-and-mortar business stronger. It gives me real pleasure that our service and solutions business has grown. Our online capabilities have been brought to the next level, and we have made sustainability a cornerstone of how we do business. With a new and bold brand campaign, we have considerably reinforced our presence in the market. Put differently, we have bolstered our foundation while at the same time tackling head-on the challenges that were necessary amid extraordinary market conditions. I want to use this moment to thank our 50,000 colleagues across Europe for all we accomplished over the past year. It also gives me great confidence to know we have such a dedicated and excellent team. My thanks go as well to our customers, our partners, and our suppliers.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#4

Moving to page 4, if we may. The world and the whole economy were fundamentally altered by Russia's invasion of Ukraine. That has produced an energy crisis, inflation has climbed sharply, and consumer sentiment has dropped steeply over the course of the year. The environment is not ours to choose. What we can do is accept the challenges and find the right answers. We take action and concentrate on what we are able to influence, and we are doing that successfully. We reached our updated outlook and delivered at the upper end of our EBIT guidance. Turnover rose versus the prior year by 3.2 percentage points to EUR 21.8 billion, so we did better than so many had expected. Let me also make clear that our growth was primarily in real terms and not driven by inflation. Above all, we sold more products, we sold more services and solutions, and we achieved a record year in this fast-growing business. Our over-the-counter business recovered. Customer frequency in our stores increased by about a quarter compared to previous year. We are also resolutely developing online, where we perform at a different level than before the pandemic. Last year, the share of turnover of our online business was around 25%. This is almost twice as high as in the 2018 to 2019 financial year, so pre-COVID.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#5

On the earnings side, we delivered an EBIT of EUR 197 million, landing at the top end of the guidance we had revised. Every region except DACH showed improvement in our results. Our strategy execution also advanced significantly, and that leaves us in a good position to come out of the crisis stronger. Let me highlight a few key accomplishments on that front. Please go to slide 5. Our Net Promoter Score, NPS — the measure we rely on for customer satisfaction — rose 5 points, reaching 50 points. In service and solutions, a business that is critical to our success, we keep expanding at more than 20%. Service and solutions adds strongly to margin. At a sales share of 6.2%, it contributes approximately 30% of our gross profit. We have bolstered our online capabilities and updated our strategy, with Experience Electronics as a new category and as the guiding principle. A complete strategy update will be presented at our next Capital Markets Day, and more specifics will come out at the start of the next calendar year. Our governance structures have also been streamlined. MediaMarktSaturn now has CECONOMY as its sole shareholder, while Convergenta is the biggest shareholder of CECONOMY. Decision-making has become much quicker for us now.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#6

Starting on page 6, I'll lay out the steps we're taking on margin and liquidity protection so as to offset the economy's negative impacts. We're acting decisively when it comes to costs, profitability, and liquidity. On costs, let me begin by noting that we wrapped up successfully our new operating model program during the last financial year — a program that had been launched in 2020. As a result, we took out EUR 125 million in annual costs. Given the market situation, we're now cutting costs even further. We're putting in place an efficiency program built around three main elements. First, we're flattening structures within our central and administrative functions. That means, for instance, fewer departments at our central and local headquarters, and a reduction in the number of interfaces. Second, we're taking further steps to automate and digitalize manual processes in our stores. Our Pick and Pack app is a good example — it lets us process online orders in our stores far more quickly. That, for instance, produces an overall effort reduction of more than 50%. Third, we'll strengthen further our two successful brands, MediaMarkt and Saturn in Germany, for the benefit of our customers, and in doing so, at the same time, bring down material costs.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#7

Starting in January, every one of our customers is going to have unified product ranges and will get the benefit of the best offering we have. We're also going to run joint campaigns so that our marketing activities become more efficient and more effective. The cost optimization measures I described above will mean one-off expenses of EUR 60 million-EUR 80 million this year, and that is going to produce substantial savings each year. For 2022, 2023, we already expect savings of EUR 15 million-EUR 30 million, and after those years, we're in the mid double-digit million EUR amount saving territory. Now let me move to profitability. Our margins need to get stronger. There's no question about that. One important lever here is our profitable service and solutions business, and we'll keep growing it. We're also going to improve our product mix and reinforce growth in new categories such as e-mobility or health and fitness. And last but not least, we see plenty of potential to optimize our marketing activities even further. With our current Let's Go campaign, which has been successfully launched across Europe, we have a stable foundation that we will keep building on. On liquidity, we are going to strengthen it, and toward that end we are continuously optimizing our inventories and our goods rotation.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#8

Beyond that, we’re in a trusting, constructive conversation with our partners aimed at improving conditions. We’ll align our assortment range better and streamline it further, in line with what customers prefer. Florian will soon provide more detail on our prudent financial policy, which matters greatly to us. Before that, allow me to share further insight into how our strategy is being implemented. Please turn to page 7. Over recent months, we’ve achieved substantial operational progress. Customers come first for us, and we concentrate on ways to further enhance the shopping experience for them. We are improving. NPS rose by 5 points to 50 points across the full year and to 52 points during the fourth quarter. A growing number of customers highlight the strong personal advice they get in our stores and the better functionality and usability online. Our repair capabilities at our Smartbars in our stores, along with our delivery and installation services at customers’ homes, are expanding. Service and solutions accounted for 7.4% of total sales in Q4, the highest level ever. Our online business is likewise growing more important. In Germany, we’ve now succeeded in moving up to third place among the largest online shops with mediamarkt.de, while Saturn.de holds a strong sixth place.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#9

Our customers are seeing much better performance and functionality from our web shops overall. Following a successful launch in Germany and Spain, we've now also brought our marketplace to Austria. The Netherlands will be the next marketplace we launch. We're strengthening our brick-and-mortar business. We're modernizing existing stores and raising selling space productivity, and we're also opening new formats, frequently at a much smaller size. By the end of last year, we had remodeled slightly more than the targeted 25% of our stores. Our investments are paying off. In the modernized stores, productivity has risen by around 15%, and sales grew by around 8%. We've also taken a leap forward in sustainability, a cornerstone of our strategy. Take the circular economy. We have significantly expanded our repair services. Over the last year, we repaired more than half a million devices at our Smartbars, and across the company in total, we repaired 3.2 million appliances throughout the year. Through our extended trade-in services, we exchanged around 80,000 old products for vouchers, which is almost 250% more than in the previous year. We now offer such trade-in services to customers in 6 countries. To put it clearly, with what we offer in terms of service and sustainability, we have a unique selling point in our industry.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#10

Let me walk through page 8. Back in October, we rolled out a brand and marketing campaign that's new, with a single campaign serving every European market. It gets across the direction we're taking in a catchy way. Under the slogan "Let's Go," it reaches our customers at different levels through a range of advertising formats. It communicates very clearly and impressively just what we stand for. An appealing customer experience across all channels, personal advice and service, and tight integration of online and offline. Delivered by our colleagues who are passionate about technology and about people — that's what each and every person at our company represents. The people taking part in the campaign are our own. Let's Go works both externally and internally. It also served as the communication platform for our Black Friday season. I'll return to that later on. Now let me move to page nine and our retail media activities. In the retail media business, we see considerable additional growth potential over the medium term. Retail media means, for instance, advertisements that brand manufacturers place in retailers' web stores or apps, reaching customers directly at the point of sale. So retailers gain an appealing new advertising opportunity for their business.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#11

Given that we connect with roughly 2 billion customers each year through online channels and our mobile apps, we possess every prerequisite needed to grow relevant new business in this market. So over the next few months, we'll be establishing a retail media platform of our own across our web stores, which will give our industry partners appealing advertising opportunities along with analytics. We're strengthening these offerings in partnership with Criteo, a top specialist in this area, and in September we signed a partnership agreement. Having said that, I'll now turn things over to Florian Wieser, who will walk you through how our business developed over the past year and go into greater detail on our most important key figures. Florian.

Florian Wieser

executive
#12

Thanks, Karsten, and good morning, everyone joining us on the line today. I'll walk you through our Q4 and full year numbers in more detail, beginning on slide 11. I want to restate what Karsten mentioned earlier. It's been yet another turbulent year, one heavily shaken by external developments. Those developments fundamentally altered the macroeconomic and sector-specific environment. After COVID eased and related supply shortages subsided, the Russian war against Ukraine created elevated uncertainty. Ceconomy and MediaMarktSaturn clearly felt those effects as well. Rising inflation and a strong deterioration in consumer sentiment weighed considerably and negatively on our business performance. To give you a bit more color, let's review the past financial year. Ceconomy got off to a very promising start in the first month of the financial year, despite challenging market conditions, supply shortages, and a cyberattack in November 2021. Our business picked up additional momentum in the second quarter after COVID restrictions eased. During the first six months of the year, CECONOMY succeeded in lifting both sales and profitability and was well on track toward its full-year targets. From June onwards, and despite a series of proactive measures to drive demand, sales fell noticeably amid cloudy macroeconomics and a deteriorating consumer sentiment.

Florian Wieser

executive
#13

So because of that, CECONOMY revised its outlook during July to reflect the altered situation. Demand recovered pleasantly over the closing weeks of the last fiscal year. Multiple campaigns throughout our country portfolio turned out to be successful. Consequently, trading performed well, with Q4 sales up 3.6% and full-year sales higher than the prior year. That sales momentum beat what we had expected in our updated outlook, particularly in the West and Southern and Eastern Europe segments. We therefore managed market share gains across both channels during the fourth quarter. Put simply, market momentum was extremely volatile throughout the past fiscal year, which clearly limited visibility. Even with our successful measures, adjusted EBIT fell year-on-year, landing at EUR 95 million in Q4, which meant we reached the full year guidance range at its upper end. Let's now go deeper into the operational drivers, beginning with our online business on slide 12. During the first three quarters, online sales fell year-on-year as expected, after COVID restrictions were gradually lifted the year before. In Q4, we reversed that trend, and our online sales rose by 6% against a comparable undistorted prior year. So our investments into omnichannel processes that deliver an effortless online shopping experience are paying off.

Florian Wieser

executive
#14

April saw the successful launch of our Omnichannel Spine initiative in the Netherlands, and rolling out our new powerful webshop to a growing number of countries represented significant operational milestones. Those steps contributed to a Q4 online sales ratio that rose 1 percentage point year-on-year, reaching levels well above pre-COVID. For the full financial year the ratio came in at 24.6%, so there is still room for growth, and we will continue working toward a ratio of 30%. Key contributors will be boosting our app traffic and further improving our user experience. The pickup ratio — a crucial proof point of our omnichannel proposition and one of our competitive edges versus online pure players — stood at 40% in Q4. That means 4 out of 10 customers conveniently collected their online orders in our nearby stores. Let's move to slide 13, to our service and solutions business, a key success factor for our resilient business performance. In line with the previous quarters, demand for our service offerings was high. We increased services sales by more than 20% in both Q4 and full year, fueled by the operational progress we have made. We recorded increased demand across all service categories. Sale of GSM contracts and financing solutions performed particularly well.

Florian Wieser

executive
#15

We clearly made our online service offerings better so that picking service options feels more attractive throughout the customer journey. Starting in Q2, the improved online visibility and our smarter recommendation engine began delivering growing results, and we strengthened the advice on accessories and services at our in-store pickup stations. Those enhancements produced higher attachment rates, both online and offline, which fed through into a steadily rising sales share, as you can see on slide 14. In 2018, CECONOMY kicked off a comprehensive initiative aimed at shifting the business from its former transactional focus to an offering that is convenient for customers. In Q4, we have now hit an all-time high services share of 7.4% of sales. Even with substantial external headwinds, we managed to show steady growth. That not only propped up our gross margin but also boosted customer satisfaction and our net promoter score. Looking back, this business focus has worked very well and laid the groundwork for further profitable growth in this area. To put it briefly, our thriving service and solutions business was and will be a decisive positive contributor to gross margin development, which we show on the next slide for Q4. Our gross margin came in flat by roughly 1 percentage point and stood at 19.1% in Q4.

Florian Wieser

executive
#16

For the entire year, that figure came in at 17.7%. That latter number amounts to an increase of 60 basis points compared with the prior year. As we typically do, allow me to walk you through the operational factors behind what happened in Q4. To start with, our goods margin and goods valuation were hit by product mix effects, including a high share of GSM, intense competition in the market, inflationary pressure within goods cost of goods sold, and inventory levels that were elevated. On the plus side, our thriving service and solutions business gave our gross margin a lift. We certainly welcome the margin improvement for the full year against a prior year that was burdened by COVID. That said, the goods margin we currently have is still well under pre-COVID levels. It also falls short of our internal ambition, and it does not mirror the relevance we have with customers and suppliers. Going forward, we will convert the benefits of our efforts into goods margin accretion even more strongly. These initiatives will be essential: streamlining our assortment, growing within attractive categories, investing into supplier partnerships, and further scaling our own logistics operations. Let us now turn to our OpEx development on slide 16. During Q4, our absolute operating expenditures were roughly at the same level as the prior year. The OpEx ratio fell somewhat, which was driven by the higher sales level. Across the full year, we recorded an OpEx increase of around EUR 210 million.

Florian Wieser

executive
#17

Out of that, around EUR 170 million came from last year’s missing COVID-related subsidies and from savings. With inflation rising sharply, we consider this a satisfactory outcome. Naturally, we are feeling cost pressure in a number of areas, including personnel, energy, and warehousing. At the same time, our ongoing, active efforts to optimize costs are delivering results, and we are achieving savings on location costs and advertising. Looking ahead, location costs, marketing expenses, and headquarter costs will stay in focus. First, we are modernizing our stores with cost awareness so that we get the greatest possible results from the capital we use. We keep working successfully and continuously on our location costs. Since COVID, demand in commercial real estate has generally shifted in our favor. Second, we will reduce our advertising spend substantially by combining the strength of our two brands in Germany through joint promotions and campaigns, as Karsten explained earlier. Finally, we continue to examine the cost structures at our headquarters in order to build a leaner, more agile organization. Through these ongoing measures, we expect to restrain inflationary pressures in the post-COVID era, thereby paving the way for sustainable margins and earnings growth. Later, Carsten will give you some color on how inflation is set to affect our profit and loss for fiscal year 2022, 2023.

Florian Wieser

executive
#18

Now let's take a look at how our segments performed, on slide 17. Once again, the picture shows fairly mixed trends across the regions. In Q4, sales in the DACH region shrank by 3.6%. Hungary kept growing, while sales in Germany and Austria fell. This year, sales in Germany were shaped by inflation and the lower purchasing power that came with it. The prior year had been marked by strong pent-up demand after lengthy store closures. Measures we successfully launched to stimulate demand, along with cost savings, could not fully offset the declines in sales and margin. Earnings in Austria, Switzerland and Hungary matched the prior year level. Western and Southern Europe had less gloomy macroeconomics than DACH. There we saw continued good momentum in Spain and the Netherlands. Sales in the remaining countries came in just slightly below the elevated prior year levels. Earnings for the entire year, or earnings for the entire region, moved in line with the sales uplift, mostly supported by rising profits in the Netherlands. High sales growth was achieved once again in Eastern Europe, driven by strong demand in Turkey. Let's now move to reported financials down to EPS on slide 18. Overall, we saw a drop to EUR 0.31 in earnings per share for the full year 2021/2022.

Florian Wieser

executive
#19

Beyond the drop in reported EBIT, three other factors were at play. First, EPS took a hit from how we valued our strategic stake in Fnac Darty. A partial impairment reversal of EUR 150 million had boosted reported EBIT in Q2 of last year, whereas this year in Q3 we booked an impairment of EUR 56 million. Second, on a brighter note, Q4 marked the first time we captured tax benefits stemming from the Convergenta transaction. Deferred tax assets taken through profit and loss cut our income tax expense by EUR 195 million. That does not yet represent the entire scope of tax benefits arising from the transaction. We recognized only the share we will realize across the next five years, in line with a conservative plan for our Germany business. With the new corporate structure in place, we anticipate the underlying tax rate — excluding non-tax effects and one-off items — heading in the direction of 30%. Third, last year's financial result had support from dividends paid by Metro Properties and M.Video, and those did not recur this year. Before I move on, let me say a few words about our dividend proposal for fiscal year 2021, 2022, since the situation is rather specific this year. Under German GAAP, the available balance sheet profit is blocked from distribution because of the capitalization of deferred tax assets.

Florian Wieser

executive
#20

Both our Management Board and our Supervisory Board have reached the decision to put a proposal before the Annual General Meeting: the net profit for fiscal year 2021, 2022 is to be carried forward into fiscal year 2022, 2023, and no dividend payment will be made for the past fiscal year 2021, 2022. Moving on, let's look at free cash flow on slide 19. One big factor behind our cash flow was a negative movement of roughly EUR 360 million in our net working capital position. Back in the prior year, we already posted a cash outflow from working capital, driven partly by elevated stock levels. This year, stock levels rose slightly further still. I'll return to that subject shortly. On top of that, our net working capital position fell because receivables from suppliers peaked. That stems from increased back conditions following the heightened campaign intensity seen in the fourth quarter. In addition, shorter payment terms brought about by new legal regulations in Belgium, along with our deliberate move toward direct sourcing from chosen suppliers, likewise put pressure on our net working capital position. For the current fiscal year 2022, 2023, we anticipate a reversal in the operational net working capital development.

Florian Wieser

executive
#21

On income tax, higher advance payments plus scheduled repayments for prior years resulted in a larger cash outflow. The anticipated reversal of last year's COVID-related VAT deferrals in Germany keeps weighing on this year's free cash flow. Cash flow came in at minus EUR 533 million, which was EUR 263 million below the prior year. Let me give you a stock taking of our liquidity and financial position on slide 20. That negative free cash flow debited our cash levels. We booked several scheduled one-time payments, which also weighed on our liquidity. These include the EUR 130 million Convergenta cash component, a net amount of around EUR 120 million of repaid promissory notes, the EUR 63 million dividend payment, and repurchases of minority interests from store managers in Germany. Altogether, non-recurring cash outflows reached a mid triple-digit million EUR amount. Our cash position stood at around EUR 800 million as of September 30th. This development, paired with a gloomy opinion on macroeconomics, has clouded the view of certain external parties on our business. Given the one-time nature of many of last year's cash outflows, the encouraging start into the Christmas quarter and our prudent financial policy, we believe that we are not properly characterized in this isolated view.

Florian Wieser

executive
#22

I'll provide a bit more context here. We anticipate that our liquidity will once again be approximately EUR 2 billion by the close of December. At minimum through 2026, there are no significant debt maturities scheduled to come due. A EUR 1.1 billion revolving credit facility remains available to us, and as of today it is still undrawn — in fact, it always has been. All of our bank partners have agreed to the first one-year extension option on the RCF facility A. More recently, the rating agency Fitch has launched a BB rating with a stable outlook covering both Ceconomy as a company and our bond. Even with this financial cash sitting in our bank, we are still pursuing coordinated steps aimed at improving our cash flow from operations. Allow me to share a few specific examples. Above all, we intend to increase the rotation of our stocks and are working through our old inventory levels. Our plan for this involves more balanced order management, dedicated campaigns, and a streamlining of our assortment. Second, we are accelerating the cash coming in from back margin conditions, made possible by rolling out digital tools in Germany. Third, following the successful ramp-up of our own inbound logistics, we have moved to direct supply in a number of cases, which supports both availability and rotation of stocks.

Florian Wieser

executive
#23

The steps we've put in motion are already starting to help our net working capital position, and we expect it to head toward a more sustainable level over the course of financial year 2022, 2023. That wraps up the financial section. I'll now hand things back to Karsten for the outlook and his closing remarks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#24

Thank you so much, Florian. So what should you expect from us as we work toward our objectives? What you should expect is a two-track approach from us. That means we'll keep consistently carrying out the steps we've taken to counter the economic crisis. At the same time, we'll keep executing our customer-centric omnichannel strategy. I'm convinced that the progress we're making will show up even more clearly once conditions grow more predictable and sentiment improves. Right now, we'll do everything we can to raise our profitability and boost our efficiency. Our aim is to offset, as far as possible, the inflation-driven cost increases you can see on page 22. We're seeing pressure in purchasing, logistics, staff, energy, and location costs. To cushion that cost pressure, we're relying on a bundle of effective measures that will deliver very significant savings. We keep working on further optimizing the terms we have with our suppliers. We'll also streamline our product range and align it even more closely with what our customers expect. We'll consistently carry out our efficiency program, which I've already explained to you. That will also take effect in the current year. On top of that, we're counterbalancing the drastic rise in energy costs.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#25

Through a set of actions, we have already cut energy use considerably across our stores and administrative offices. As an illustration, we rely on lighting concepts that are highly energy-efficient. We brought the indoor temperature down by 2 degrees. On the sales floor, far fewer TV sets are now left switched on. Altogether, this is a program worth a high double-digit million EUR amount in the current business year and substantially more in the years after that. Ladies and gentlemen, allow me now to move to the outlook for fiscal year 2022, 2023 on page 23. The steps we have set in motion to hold our own in this environment are taking effect more and more. Our strategic transformation has been carried on successfully, and we are becoming a more efficient organization. We are making progress, and we have entered the new fiscal year with good customer demand. Still, we are operating in times of high economic uncertainty, and so we offer two scenarios together with a set of assumptions. Drawing on our most recent trading experience, we regard scenario 1 as the more likely one. Under scenario 1, for the full year 2022, 2023, we anticipate a slight rise in sales and a clear improvement in adjusted EBIT. We assume that overall economic conditions will not worsen further and that the consumer electronics market will contract only moderately, at most.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#26

If the broader economy were to worsen beyond what we can currently predict, and if demand for consumer electronics were to drop sharply, that would clearly hurt our business. Under that second scenario, we would need to anticipate a significant drop in sales and adjusted EBIT for the 2022 and 2023 business year. Once more, from where we stand today, we see the first scenario as the more probable one. I'd now like to offer an early read on consumer demand during October and November of this year. Put briefly, it came in stronger than many people would have anticipated, myself included. Our campaigns rolled out very effectively across Europe, and Black Friday proved quite promising for us. All in all, in a competitive market, we saw encouraging consumer demand in October and November. Sales across those two months, October and November, came in above the prior year. Please go with me to page 25. Ladies and gentlemen, we are well-positioned to grow profitably over the mid and long term. We will come out of the current economic crisis stronger. What should you expect from us over the coming months? We will grow sales by leveraging our leading market positions and focusing on further improvements in customer experience.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#27

We’re going to connect our online operations and our brick-and-mortar operations even more closely. We’ll expand and enhance what we offer customers by growing our marketplaces and our circular economy proposition in additional countries. Our growth emphasis will stay on our profitable service solutions business, and in that area, sustainability services will be front and center and will set us apart from competitors. We’ll capture our opportunities in new product categories such as fitness, health, and mobility. We’ll grow retail media, which is a major business opportunity for us. Finally, we’ll put liquidity measures in place and will make sure our cost structure becomes more efficient following the targeted restructuring measures as I’ve outlined in detail. In short, we are mastering the challenging economic environment, and our measures are working. Everything we do is being aligned with our customers’ expectations. We’re continuing to consistently implement our omnichannel strategy and strengthen our competitive position. We are vigorously driving forward the strategically important service and solutions business, and we will improve our profitability and liquidity. Before I look forward to answering your questions, let me just make one personal remark because today is Florian Wieser’s last analyst call for CECONOMY. Let me thank Florian Wieser wholeheartedly for his contributions to our business.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#28

Speaking for myself, Florian, collaborating with you was genuinely a pleasure. I appreciate the backing you gave me, and I wish you nothing but the best, both personally and in your career, going forward. Many thanks for listening, and at this point I'm happy to take your questions.

Operator

operator
#29

Ladies and gentlemen, we'll now start the question-and-answer portion. To ask a question, you can press 9 and then the star key on your touchtone phone. Should you want to drop out of the question queue, press 9 followed by the star key once more. If speaker equipment is what you're using today, kindly lift the handset before you make your selections. Anyone with a question can press 9 and then the star key right now. Please hold for the 1st question. Our 1st question is from Clément Genelot, Bryan, Garnier. Please go ahead.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#30

Good morning. There are three questions I have. First, regarding Q1 sales: could you give a little more detail on how sales performed? Specifically, was the main driver discount events like Black Friday and the soccer World Cup? My second question concerns back margins. Coming back to slide six, I'd like to revisit the earlier question about back margin conditions. What exactly does that mean? Does it mean back margin payments will be spread more evenly across Q1, Q2, and Q3? Does it mean we should anticipate a bigger boost from back margins in those quarters, with Q4 then softer purely for that reason? Lastly, what should we expect from the CMD next year? Is it simply a restatement of prior targets, or should we look for more detail on the marketplace, retail media, and so on? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#31

Yes. Thank you so much, Clément, for those questions. I'll begin with question 1, the back margin, and Florian will take that one, then I'll wrap up with a few responses regarding the question about the Capital Markets Day. On Black Friday performance and how the soccer world championship affected Q1 — maybe on the whole, beyond Black Friday, we also saw very strong demand in the GSM sector during Q4 of last year. Obviously our service and solutions business contributed to that as well, since we sell contracts on behalf of certain operators too. We performed well in NDA, especially SDA and floor cleaning, for example. That was a focus area as well, because product mix — clearly getting the right product mix — mattered for improving profitability. As for the Black Friday period, looking at the top products we sold, gaming is clearly there. NDA and IT hardware are there. We're actually also quite strong at selling TVs, often very specific brands, so to speak. That also demonstrates that we can make the market. We were also able, for example, to sell more than 100,000 of earphones, wireless earphones. There was decent demand on the cleaning side too. This is something that carried on through, say, the end of last year.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#32

That’s carried on. Clearly mobile phones and notepads too, plus wearables. A pretty wide spread. Top 20 products. I’ve shown you a quick look here. To be honest, the Soccer World Cup hasn’t really given anything a lift. Demand for TV in general isn’t especially strong. Italy — which actually did very well previously, also since the government provided some subsidies for IPTVs — has in fact fallen very, very sharply, by more than 60%. This market actually isn’t hard right now. The World Cup here hasn’t helped. Let me recap once more. If somebody had told me 10 weeks ago how October and November and Black Friday would turn out for us, I’d have said I wouldn’t have believed it. In that sense, overall we’re very pleased. Clearly, for example, certain markets such as Italy — there we’re also seeing some difficulties.

Florian Wieser

executive
#33

On the second question about the earlier topic of back margin conditions: first, I want to stress that the P&L is not affected. The positive effect of back margins is properly accrued in our P&L, so no changes in the P&L should be expected going forward. What we mean is an earlier cash-in of these conditions, and I touched on this briefly in my remarks when I said we have implemented a digital tool. Let me explain briefly what that means. In our business, particularly around campaigns, there are article-related conditions. When we sell an article, or when we buy an article, during a campaign, we receive an extra contribution from a supplier. These conditions that we get for these articles during a campaign can include qualitative conditions. The article must be sold within a certain period of time, and certain marketing criteria must be fulfilled. Over the last month and years, it took some time for the supplier and us to prove to each other that these qualitative conditions had been met. There was a lot of manual work, and at times it took us a couple of months to actively collect the cash for the conditions, which had already been properly accrued in the P&L.

Florian Wieser

executive
#34

Because we've rolled out a digital tool, we're now able to collect these outstanding accruals from suppliers far more quickly, and that's going to give a meaningful boost to our net working capital. As you saw in Q4, some of the worsening in net working capital came from a rise in receivables owed by suppliers, driven by higher campaign activity. This push to cash in back margins sooner specifically targets that issue — it lifts liquidity and improves net working capital, with no effect on P&L. With that, I'll hand things back to Karsten for the Capital Markets Day question.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#35

Right. Regarding the Capital Markets Day, let's start with timing. We intend, during the first half of the coming calendar year, to bring you up to date on strategy — on what you should expect from us — and to offer greater transparency. Most likely that happens once Kai-Ulrich Deissner has come on board as the new CFO, which should be around April or May, roughly that window. As for what we'll cover, what should you expect from us? Naturally, given the many conversations I have with you, with investors and with partners, we get plenty of questions about wanting more transparency and a clearer grasp of our business at times. The primary aim is plainly to help you understand our business better — what it is we do. That's the first point. Personally, what matters a great deal to me is that you also gain a clearer picture, since this is something we keep discussing. It's evident that profitability has to improve. So what exactly are we doing about it? Because we already know what has to be done. We don't suffer from any lack of insight, and we are executing on it. Of course, that becomes tougher during an economic crisis. It isn't so simple, given that we also face a high density of competition.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#36

I want to give you a fuller update on what this means for mix, how we are actually expanding services and solutions, and what the relevant scalable growth businesses are that we're pursuing in a tangible way. This is going to be part of a strategy refresh, so that it also feels more real. Naturally, I'd also like to make some pledges — what you can expect from us, by when, and what we will deliver. Hopefully this will be a good, tangible exchange, and I personally am very much looking forward to it.

Clément Genelot

analyst
#37

Okay, yes, thanks.

Operator

operator
#38

Volker Bosse from Baader Bank has the next question.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#39

Hello. Good morning, gentlemen. Thanks for taking my question. This is Volker Bosse from Baader Bank. I'd like to begin with how business is trading right now. It's good to see and good to hear that you remained safely above last year's level. But what are you seeing when it comes to consumers' shopping behavior? Do you sense that consumers are trading down because of recession fears, or are you seeing fewer big-ticket items? Are there any trends you've noticed during Q1? My second question concerns store openings and store closures. What should we expect in 2022? Just briefly, where do you want to end up, and in which regions do you want to open stores, and in which regions do you want to close stores? Last but not least, the question is about one-offs in 2022 and 2023. I mean, in the past, you already announced the one-offs for the new operating model as well as for introducing the efficiency program. Just for clarity, is all of that done, these investments for these initiatives? Or are there any one-offs that we can already factor into our financial model as of today? Thank you.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#40

Yes, thanks. Thanks, Volker. Questions 1 and 2 I'll handle, while number 3 goes to Florian. Regarding what you asked about current trading and shopping trends, let me offer a few comments. Obviously, what I'm describing reflects our experience through the end of November. The reason I frame it that way is that, clearly, we're also in volatile times. Once more, it has been a very good stretch — surprisingly so, for me personally. Broadly speaking, our stores are performing strongly. That means traffic is better than what we obviously saw during COVID times. Things are strengthening, and we've also seen good conversion rates alongside good average volume values, which is good. As for shopping trends, interestingly, right now we remain strong at the entry level and very strong at the more premium end as well. You could say we're seeing a kind of bifurcation, with strong demand on the entry side but also on the premium side. One thing we consistently hear is that MediaMarktSaturn is also getting better at selling and presenting products more at the premium range, as well as at the mid and entry points. These are — this is something that is very visible.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#41

Of course, at Christmas time, I'd expect SDA to remain a really strong category.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#42

SDA — what is that? Sorry.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#43

Could you say that again?

Volker Bosse

analyst
#44

Could you explain what SDA stands for?

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#45

Sorry. Small Domestic Appliances — you know, items, little machines for the kitchen, or a toothbrush, and so on. That kind of thing. So that's, that would be my view on the first point. On store openings and closures, let me say this. Clearly, we have plenty of work ahead to boost the productivity of our store space and floor space in general. That matters. That's why it isn't only about closing — it's about cutting space where we're making progress. It's launching new formats, particularly smaller ones besides the lighthouses, and also refreshing stores. You see, when we put investment into the stores, we see a productivity gain as well as a sales gain. For example, over the last year, we shut 10 stores, 7 of them in Germany, and we also opened — as in Turkey, which is a big growth market for us — we also opened stores. I think what we'll see going forward is that stores where we don't believe, given shifts in consumer behavior, that you can't run them profitably, obviously we'll close them. Wherever we can, we are reducing the floor space, and we are also getting much better at opening and running smaller locations profitably.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#46

That combination is what matters, and I could picture a point down the road—say, over the medium term—when we'd actually be operating a larger number of sites, though each one would clearly be smaller in scale. So, on to the third question now, and Florian, go ahead.

Florian Wieser

executive
#47

On the one-off program, let me offer two comments right at the start. If we look back over the past six years, we have structurally adjusted our cost base. Overall, comparing those six years, we have grown the top line. At the same time, we cut the absolute cost level by roughly EUR 400 million, and that is before even factoring in inflation. Once you factor in inflation, our cost reduction is actually even stronger. The key driver here has been our structural one-off programs. You remember Project One — today we just reported that we successfully completed the new operating model one-off program, and the savings came in at EUR 125 million above our initial expectations. From where I sit, CECONOMY has proven that we can successfully implement these programs, and that we don't just implement them — over the long run, we are able to substantially reduce our cost base. These programs, Project One and the new operating model, were dedicated to bringing the cost structure to a level that is sustainable in normal times. If you look at the current times, they are anything but normal. Now, as we do our budget and our plan for the upcoming months, we decided that we have to do something again — that we have to structurally reduce our costs, unfortunately, one more time.

Florian Wieser

executive
#48

That's the reason we announced today a further one-off initiative, with a one-off range of EUR 60 million to EUR 80 million, which is expected to land in this fiscal year — EUR 60 million to EUR 80 million in one-offs. Those funds will go into three buckets. The first is our — well — our marketing, strengthening our sales brands. Karsten said in his remarks that we want to bring Saturn and MediaMarkt closer together in Germany, using our strength and bundling it, rather than positioning both brands against each other as we did previously. That's bucket one. Bucket two is that we want more digitization in our stores. A first step has already been taken by centralizing our structure. We purchased the minority stakes held by our store managers, and over the last 3 years we established a global business service center with 1 branch in Germany and a 2nd branch in Barcelona. We want to raise the level of digitization across all store processes. Third point, bucket three, as Karsten mentioned, we want fewer interfaces, we want to streamline the departments, and to centralize value creation further across the various steps in our value chain. Those are the 3 buckets, and we expect savings from this program already this year, particularly in the 2nd half, with the majority of it then in the fiscal year 2023/2024.

Florian Wieser

executive
#49

That's perhaps a quick recap of the one-off programs and the effects you can expect for your models.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#50

Yes. Thanks. I just have one quick follow-up. You mentioned the buyout of store managers’ minority stakes — has that program wrapped up, and what was the end result? What % of your store managers accepted your offers, and how many still hold on to their minority equity stake in the store? Thanks.

Florian Wieser

executive
#51

We put effort into these programs over the past 12 months.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#52

Yeah, that's right.

Florian Wieser

executive
#53

Almost every country is centralized at this point. What I was referring to was that, taking Germany as an example, over 90% of store managers there agreed. I believe only 10, 20 store managers still hold stakes now — no more than that. More than 90% said yes, and things are nearly all settled. If you look across our country portfolio as a whole, only 2 countries, 2, 3 countries remain where a handful of store managers still have them. All in all, we're a centralized company today, and you can regard this as finished.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#54

Great. Thanks so much for the update. Thank you, and best wishes for the rest of the year during these busy days, particularly for retailers. All the best. Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#55

Thanks a lot, Volker.

Volker Bosse

analyst
#56

Appreciate it.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#57

And the same to you.

Operator

operator
#58

Jean Teurquetil from Allianz Global Investors has the next question. Go ahead, please.

Jean-Sébastien Teurquetil

analyst
#59

Hello, and good morning. Thanks for taking my question. To begin with, I have 1 question about working capital. I realize you expect a faster receivable position. Yet when we examine the financial metrics, it appears things have actually worsened by 10 days, moving from 6 last year at then September to 7. So, are your actions forward-looking? Even more importantly, on payables, I've noticed a deterioration of 4 days year-on-year as well. What's your perspective there? I understand you plan to improve your inventory position, but how do you see payables for next year? That's my first question. My second question is broader: you've burned EUR 500 million of cash this year. I know several one-offs were mentioned. Could you quantify, under your two scenarios, what the level of cash burn of cash inflows would be according to the scenario? Thank you.

Florian Wieser

executive
#60

Alright, thank you very much for that question. I'll begin with net working capital. The first point concerned the receivables position and what actions we're taking going forward. Let me give you a bit more detail. When you look at fiscal year 21 versus fiscal year 22, net working capital declined because receivables owed by suppliers rose by EUR 150 million. That EUR 150 million is entirely tied to the heavy campaign activity we had in Q4. As I explained earlier in response to Clément Genelot's first question, when you run that kind of campaigning, it takes a while for us to actually collect those contributions from suppliers. That's what drove the deterioration in net working capital. So what we've done is bring in digital tools that match these accruals, or back margins, far faster. That's why we expect, first, to do this much more quickly and to see an improvement and a reversal of this receivables situation. Second, as I just mentioned, there's also an element of phasing. In last year's Q4, campaign planning was less intense. We were seeing pent-up demand. This year, as Karsten explained, we put proactive measures in place to stimulate demand.

Florian Wieser

executive
#61

Macroeconomics looked more uncertain to us, consumer sentiment was falling, and that is why we attempted to boost demand and ran somewhat higher campaign intensity, which led to the elevated receivables. Neither of those things will happen again in 2022/2023. So we clearly anticipate an improvement in these receivable positions that will benefit our net working capital. The second topic concerned payables and what is being done about them. One point is clear. There will be pressure on payables because of a few elements. One was regulatory changes, which we observed in Belgium. I brought this up in my remarks. Second, we are seeing rising interest rates. Euribor is going up. Extending payment terms through factoring or other financial supply chain instruments becomes less appealing. We also see some mix, goods margin mix, as Karsten mentioned, we saw strong growth in telecom. Telecom typically is a category with lower payment days. These are factors weighing on payment days. However, we of course are working on this too, and the key measure is stock rotation. As also mentioned in the remarks, we originally planned to reduce stock levels in fiscal year 2021, 2022. Because of consumer sentiment and all the, yeah, all the headwinds we are facing, we postponed this initiative, so we even saw somewhat higher inventory levels.

Florian Wieser

executive
#62

We've already observed over recent weeks of this new fiscal year that inventory levels are coming down. As those inventories decline, our own logistics operations—which give us significantly better stock rotation by lessening the bullet effect in central inbound—will plainly enhance stock rotation, and as stock rotation improves, the payable structure will improve as well. So we think that through operational measures we can offset the adverse external effect on payables. That's why, overall, to reinforce this measure, we clearly anticipate a reversal of the trend in net working capital and, similarly, a benefit to free cash flow in 2022, 2023. Your third question concerned the negative free cash flow we are currently facing. I explained that free cash flow this year took a significant hit from scheduled one-time payments related to the Magenta transaction, dividend payments, and the buyout of minorities, which we just discussed with Volker, and that affected our free cash flow. Our clear ambition and target is to improve free cash flow and to achieve positive free cash flow in 2022, 2023. Looking at the two scenarios, the major contributors in both, as Karsten explained, are the non-recurrence of the scheduled one-time payments in 2021, 2022.

Florian Wieser

executive
#63

Looking at scenario 1, which seems more probable given where we stand today, EBITDA will go up, and as I mentioned, net working capital should reverse its trend. Under the second scenario, EBITDA might come in below prior years, meaning we could see a deterioration. Even in that scenario, we still want net working capital's trend to reverse, but under that more negative scenario, free cash flow might turn negative. I hope that covers everything you asked.

Jean-Sébastien Teurquetil

analyst
#64

Just one more question. In a scenario like this, how are your conversations going with the financing partner — around financing, bringing in new financing, and liquidity? Thanks.

Florian Wieser

executive
#65

Right. Like we said, being very prudent with finances is kind of our signature. I think the past 12 months have brought the toughest business conditions we've seen, and at no stage were we even pushed into drawing on that EUR 1.1 billion revolving credit facility. That, I think, makes it plain how responsibly we behave and how proactively we line up our countermeasures. Going ahead, we foresee no problems with covenants or with getting at our financing sources. We're confident.

Jean-Sébastien Teurquetil

analyst
#66

All right, thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#67

Right now, we don't have any additional questions. If you'd still like to ask something at this point, press nine and then the star key. Our next question is from Andreas Riemann at ODDO BHF. Please go ahead.

Andreas Riemann

analyst
#68

Yes, good morning. I have two quick questions. First, about price increases. I believe you said growth last full year was driven by price. Which categories currently allow for higher prices? Second, you've mentioned before that improving the goods margin is important, since you lost a lot during the last years of lockdowns. I think you even said some products would be unlisted. Where do you stand in that process? That's my second question. Thanks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#69

Thank you, Andreas, for those questions. Regarding your first one about higher prices, I believe I mentioned — or at least I hope I did — that the sales growth we saw was not driven by inflationary price increases, but was in fact real: we sold more products, more services, and so on. What we are watching right now, and have been for a while, is of course our capacity to pass along the price rises we encounter from, for example, suppliers when purchase prices for products go up. We are actually performing well on that front. We feel confident we can manage it. We are also noticing that the markets do respond to pricing initiatives and similar moves, since naturally we cannot simply absorb the cost. That is the reason we take these steps, and it is working. As for the unlisting of products — the point of what we are doing is this: we are getting better at identifying what the customer truly wants and what is more effective from a capital usage standpoint. That is why we are streamlining the portfolio. In that sense, we are cutting down the number of SKUs we hold in our books quite substantially, because doing so is the right call, and we actually serve customers better, with improved availability as well.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#70

The big task we still need to tackle — and it's a bit of homework we had to do and still do — is Germany, where we're currently streamlining a very large portfolio at a fast pace, going from 30,000, 40,000 SKUs down to, say, below the 20,000 mark. It's also worth noting that this represents roughly a EUR 300 million inefficiency ticket in networking capital that we're working through and getting out of the system. Our logistics, together with our national distribution center, will go a long way toward speeding this up. We're doing a good job here right now, and obviously we will accelerate this. I think we're now much faster and even somewhat ahead of the plan that we thought a few months ago would be possible. We're on track here.

Andreas Riemann

analyst
#71

Let me go back to that first question about whether you're passing along higher costs. Does that really mean you're shifting the mix, or attempting to shift it—or actually raising prices?

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#72

So the first thing is, whenever we're compelled to raise prices, we pass that along. And look, with certain phones, they get more expensive — naturally, we pass that on. If a washing machine costs more, we pass that on too. I mean, it's working. We're seeing this across many markets, and I believe we can keep doing it. Your other question, I think, is a really important one: how do we improve the mix, since that's a key lever for profitability? What we did last year worked well — we saw we could gain share, and that we should gain share, in SDA, small domestic appliances. We launched a program, and if you look at how we performed there, it has paid off and it has worked out. Right now we're also working on the white goods section, where we're already strong, but I think there's so much more we can do. Why? Because in all these difficult times, selling energy efficient devices — a washing machine, et cetera, a dryer — is a super big opportunity. Today we're selling 40% more energy efficient devices than we were a few months ago.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#73

Customers also want to save money. What I'm saying is that we're actively working on the mix — how we steer it, how we execute on it, how we position and present products, and actually on the assortment as well, because on one hand it's helping our business and helping our margin, and it's also good for the customer. Yes, you can see — will see more of us when it comes to mix.

Andreas Riemann

analyst
#74

All right, I appreciate the responses.

Operator

operator
#75

Since nobody else has a question right now, I'll return the floor to Karsten Wildberger, our CEO, for a few closing remarks.

Karsten Wildberger

executive
#76

Yes. Thanks. Many thanks. Ladies and gentlemen, I appreciate the time you've given us and the questions you've raised. So with that, I'll bring today's results call to a close. I'd like to wish each of you a joyful and happy holiday season, and to all of our say French participants, best of luck in the final, and take care, stay healthy — and should you still be in need of Christmas presents, we would be glad to assist, whether that means white goods or brown goods or good telephones. Thank you so much. Goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ceconomy AG transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Ceconomy AG earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ceconomy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.