Champion Iron Limited (CIA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 30, 2025

Australian Securities Exchange AU Materials Metals and Mining earnings 33 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining Champion's conference call on the Q3 results for the 2025 financial year. <<operator_script>> Today is Thursday, January 30, 2025, and this call is being recorded. I'll now hand things over to Michael Marcotte, Senior Vice President, Corporate Development. Please go ahead.

Michael Marcotte

executive
#2

Thanks, operator, and thanks to everyone for being with us on today's call. Before we get started, I'd like to point people to our website, championiron.com, where the presentation for this webcast is available under the Events & Presentation tab. I'd also like to remind everyone that during this webcast we will be making forward-looking statements. For more detail on those forward-looking statements, along with the risks and assumptions, you can look at our MD&A, which is also posted on our website. With me today are a number of our executives, among them our CEO, David Cataford, who will handle the formal presentation, our CEO, Alexandre Belleau; and our CFO, Donald Tremblay. With that, I'll hand things over to David, and we'll wrap up with a Q&A portion. David?

David Cataford

executive
#3

Thanks, Michael. And thanks to all of you for joining the call. So, walking through the quarter's highlights — as I'm sure you've seen, it was a tougher quarter for us. Even so, in spite of those difficulties, we still produced a little more than 3.6 million tonnes in the quarter and sold slightly under 3.3 million tonnes. That's a bit disappointing, because when you look at the quarter, we were on a run rate that would have delivered record sales as well as record rail material. You likely saw that we railed roughly 1.4 million tonnes in November. So we do know the work done on the logistics side itself is beginning to pay off, and we look forward to the coming months so that we can start drawing down our stockpile. We had no significant environmental issues during the quarter. Sadly, there was 1 accident at the construction site involving 1 worker, who is now stabilized, and we are working with the site and all the contractors to make sure we can carry on with the project while keeping everyone safe, and we've offered support to this worker and to others who were nearby as well. On community and sustainability, we kept working with our First Nations partners and also began consultations with the Kami Project.

David Cataford

executive
#4

So we began holding meetings with the different communities, the First Nation communities, and really working on making our partnership with the Newfoundland and Labrador communities stronger. If we look at our operations, as we said, we had an incident at our load out. I would just like to point out that, looking at our operations going back to 2018, this is the first occasion we have had an event like this that was unplanned and that had our site — at minimum our loading capacity — halted for roughly 14 days. It was also the first time an event occurred on the silo at the load out, and one of the difficulties was figuring out the right approach to get people in there safely to carry out the modification. We came up with a plan and were able to get in to do the repair, and we have made modifications at the load-out. So should an event ever happen again, we would then be in a position to complete the work much faster. So that was unfortunate, since we lost approximately 14 days of shipping. And once more, without those 14 days, we would have been able to sell more tonnes than what we actually produced.

David Cataford

executive
#5

On the operations side, one standout is that we posted a record month — actually a record quarter, apologies — for waste mined, hauling, ore mined, and hold. The money we've put into mining equipment is delivering returns, since we can now keep the mine stable and healthy while still supplying all the tonnes the plants need so we can ultimately raise output. Through the quarter, the P65 index moved around a bit. Looking at the quarterly price, it was up slightly, roughly 3.3%. A key item this quarter has been the C3 freight index, which fell by a touch under 20%. Sadly, those gains don't show up in this quarter's results, as most of that decline came late in the period, but we'll capture the benefit from those lower costs over the next months and quarters as we send vessels to our customers. On provisional price adjustments, there was 1 negative item for the quarter — about USD 4 per tonne negative across the 3.3 million tonnes sold in the period.

David Cataford

executive
#6

As the quarter closed, roughly 1.7 million tonnes remained in transit, with an anticipated settlement price near USD 110 per tonne. Regarding the realized selling price, that was one factor where we took a bit of a hit during the quarter, largely because, since beginning Phase 2, we haven't entered into long-term agreements for material from Phase 2, given that we're finishing a flotation plant that will let us make one of the highest grade materials worldwide. Our real focus is on signing contracts for this DR quality type of material. However, since this project will be delivered before this calendar year ends, and we'll begin selling tonnes of this material a few months afterward, we found ourselves not wanting to sign longer-term contracts for the current concentrate. As a result, we're more exposed to spot pricing and the spot scenario. Looking at spot purchases of concentrate, particularly Canadian conc, whether from us or our neighbors, we observe that discounts have been offered to sell into the Chinese market.

David Cataford

executive
#7

The change in quality isn’t the reason here. What we’re really seeing is demand for P65 material that contains somewhat more silica, and once the flotation plant is operational, we expect to be able not only to eliminate those drawbacks but also to lift the premiums on what we sell. On operating costs, they remain elevated relative to where we’d like them to be. As we noted for the quarter, conditions were tougher—additional maintenance was carried out during the outage on the logistics side, the volume effect also weighed on us in that period, and there was a little extra rehandling of material at the stockpile. Taking everything together, we came in just under CAD 79 per tonne delivered in the vessel. Revenue was approximately $363 million, with EBITDA of $88 million; one area where we fell short of consensus on forecasted EPS was largely because, given our existing debt facility—our debt facilities in the U.S.—and the Canadian dollar to U.S. dollar exchange rate.

David Cataford

executive
#8

The situation shifted significantly over the quarter, particularly toward its end. As a result, we needed to revalue the debt denominated in Canadian dollars, which produced a roughly $21 million hit — approximately $0.04 per share. That stands as one of the primary factors behind the EPS shortfall, though it was a noncash item for the period. Regarding our cash movement, as you observed, cash declined from $180 million to roughly $90 million during the quarter. First, we paid a dividend of $52 million. We also put substantial investment into our flotation plant over the quarter — about $70 million. And as you're aware, the fiscal third quarter is normally when we incur the heaviest other CapEx costs, largely because of the dike work we perform in the summer months and also on the waste dumps. So, looking at our feasibility study for the Phase 2 project, during the first year certain investments were underway at the waste dump — the new one we're constructing — along with upgrades to the tailings facility. That remains on schedule for delivery across the coming years and does carry a CapEx impact in the near term.

David Cataford

executive
#9

But taking a longer view, after that work is finished, well, it will be constructed to last for the project's entire mine life. On the balance sheet side, our net debt did go up. A key driver is roughly $100 million tied to the mobile equipment portion, part of that for the 400 railcars we bought, plus some mining equipment under lease financing with Caterpillar and with Komatsu. So that explains about $100 million of the change in debt, and a decrease in our cash really drove the shift in the net debt position. Still, looking at our balance sheet, it remains very healthy, which lets us complete our flotation plant, deliver on it, and fully capture those premiums down the road. Looking at our cash position too, as we said, the last quarter would have set a record for railing capacity and for sales had we not had the load out event. So we know the investments made on the logistics front — whether the new locos that arrived from the rail provider or the railcars that arrived on our side, the logistics gains we've achieved working in coordination with IOC and ourselves.

David Cataford

executive
#10

So all of those things are beginning to bear fruit, since we'd have been able to ship and sell a greater tonnage than what was produced and begin drawing down the material. In January and February, logistics tend to be somewhat more difficult because of the weather and occasionally certain elements freezing. At times we implement some mitigation measures to slightly reduce the tonnage per railcar so the freezing risk can be minimized. But after we get past those 2 months — and we're nearly through them at this point — we'll be able to genuinely begin destocking our stockpile. As for our growth projects, the 2 main ones we're working on at present are really the flotation plant and the Kami Project. Turning to the DRPF project, we remain on track to deliver it within the $471 million budget. Over the coming months, work is underway to finalize this, with just over $180 million left to invest so the project can be completed. On the time line, we're still on track to deliver the project in the second half of 2025, targeting December.

David Cataford

executive
#11

There were some delays tied to the accident that occurred in December — construction had to be halted for a period so we could ensure everyone's safety and also fix the various components that got damaged that month. That said, we remain on track to deliver the project this December. Turning to Kami, which was one of the quarter's major highlights: in December we signed an agreement with Nippon Steel and Sojitz to keep assessing the Kami Project and to bring them in as partners, selling down 30% to Nippon Steel and 19% to Sojitz at a valuation of roughly CAD 500 million. We were also very pleased to see Nippon Steel's communication noting that they searched worldwide to find the right kind of material for their green steel transition, and as they stated, Kami was the finest project they identified globally to invest in. So looking at the present transaction, it lets us keep advancing the Kami project — whether that's the feasibility study or permitting — and ensures Champion shareholders don't need to put in capital, since the partners will mainly handle this over the coming years.

David Cataford

executive
#12

If we turn to the timeline for Kami, at present we are completing the permitting, and that ought to take roughly 2 years, along with the feasibility study. After those are finished, we will then be able to determine the next steps. So do we head toward an FID, or do we instead keep enhancing the project? But once more, it is a great source of pride to have partners as credible as Nippon Steel and Sojitz, and it is genuinely telling regarding the growth profile for DRI worldwide. The fact that Nippon Steel and Sojitz have come in and secured this at this moment really demonstrates that they hold the view that a shortage of this kind of material will emerge over the coming years, and they want to make certain they secure 1 of the best materials in the world. At Kami, as we said, the next steps at present are that we keep meeting with local communities and with government officials at the provincial level and the federal level to identify the areas where we can keep improving the project and make sure that we can, as we said, permit the project and be in a position to evaluate the next steps.

David Cataford

executive
#13

To give you some context on Kami, as we've mentioned before, the key point is that Kami sits roughly in the middle of the range when it comes to investment or CapEx intensity among high-grade assets, based on what we've observed in recent years. That really puts Bloom Lake in an interesting position, because we have serious companies—steel manufacturers—that came in at a valuation that effectively valued Bloom Lake at approximately USD 5 billion, or CAD 12 per share. So this really underscores the earning power Bloom Lake will have over the coming years. Looking at Bloom Lake, calendar year 2025 is when we complete the flotation plant, with a substantial amount of investment being made. But as we move into calendar year 2026, our earning power rises significantly and our CapEx spending drops considerably. So we do see the potential in the years ahead to generate a substantial amount of cash with Bloom Lake. And as we noted regarding the broader macro environment for steel growth—when we read about or observe what's happening with steel, there isn't much growth forecast—where we do see growth is in the DRI space, and that's precisely where we're investing to reach.

David Cataford

executive
#14

So if we look at DRI globally, particularly in the Middle East and Europe, there are quite a few new projects coming through that will be capable of producing electric arc furnace steel. That is definitely the market we're aiming to address. Maybe one last point before I hand things over to the Q&A portion: there's a great deal of noise in the market at the moment related to possible U.S. and Canadian tariffs. As you know, we don't sell any tonnes into the U.S. Our potential exposure is somewhat around maintenance, owing to parts we may purchase within the U.S., but it's very limited relative to other companies when it comes to tariff impact. With that said, thanks, everyone, for joining the call, and I'll turn it over to you for the Q&A portion.

Operator

operator
#15

<<operator_script>> We'll take our first question from Orest Wowkodaw at Scotiabank.

Orest Wowkodaw

analyst
#16

I’d like to ask about your CapEx. Over the past 2 quarters, sustaining capital has looked quite high compared with earlier quarters and definitely compared with the technical report. If we leave out the DPRF growth capital, I’m wondering whether we should expect the run rate from the last 2 quarters—roughly $110 million a quarter, excluding DPRF—or whether that should come back down toward the $60 million per quarter level going forward. Clearly, you’re putting in a lot of investment here. I’m just wondering how much remains to be done.

David Cataford

executive
#17

Yes. Thanks for the question, Orest. If you look at the most recent quarter, it was really somewhat unusual, particularly regarding the spending on mining equipment and also the railcars. So that was one of the factors. But the figure you brought up — roughly $60 million per quarter — aligns more closely with the investments to be made in terms of CapEx and is more consistent with our feasibility study, as you correctly point out. I think the railcars and the mining equipment really represent an unusual portion that we saw in the last quarter.

Orest Wowkodaw

analyst
#18

All right, and to follow up on that, the DPRF product you're launching — was any portion of it meant for customers in the U.S.?

David Cataford

executive
#19

At this moment, serving U.S. customers wasn't the plan. That possibility always exists for us. However, should it head to the U.S., we'd have to address the pelletizing part. So generally, those buyers purchase a greater amount of pellets rather than actual pellet feed. As we consider prospective buyers across the Middle East, North Africa, and Europe, they do possess pelletizing capacity and require the pellet feed. Thus, that represented more of the market we aimed for, at minimum, when launching the project.

Orest Wowkodaw

analyst
#20

All right. So the plant should be starting up in roughly 10 or 11 months. Could you update us on how things stand with contract signings? Are those negotiations already happening, or does production need to be nearer before that can occur?

David Cataford

executive
#21

Yeah. So negotiations actually kicked off over 12 months back. That means a good deal of travel to Europe, the Middle East and North Africa, sitting down with the different steel mills — plenty of encouraging conversations. Our expectation is that we'll likely sign the initial contracts around October or November 2025, which ensures everything is locked in ahead of when we begin selling the cargoes in calendar 2026.

Operator

operator
#22

The following question is from Alexander Pearce with BMO Capital Markets.

Alexander Pearce

analyst
#23

David, in your remarks you noted that the shipping run rate appeared to get better before the low doubt issues. I'm just curious whether you might give us a bit of an update on how fast you believe you can move those extra stockpile tonnes down the rail, on top of your production rate?

David Cataford

executive
#24

Yes, and thanks for asking. If we consider the rail operator as it stands now and what's being produced along that line, you've likely seen IOC's guidance on tonnage. Should they land at the bottom of that guidance range, that leaves us with considerable room to move additional tons downward over this calendar year, and we'd capture that share. Yet even in the event they reach the top of their guidance, we're still positioned to begin drawing tonnes out of our stockpile. Looking back at last quarter, absent a disruption, we'd likely have brought down roughly 3.8 million tonnes. That's a gain of approximately 200,000 tonnes for the quarter. Still, we expect that to keep getting better, since we'll be moving past the winter period, which is generally the time we can raise tonnes per railcar while also raising the tonnage we ship down. So in terms of destocking the stockpile, I believe 2025 will prove a solid year.

Alexander Pearce

analyst
#25

Okay, so perhaps I can move on to my second question, which concerns maintenance. You noted that because of the problems last quarter, you did additional maintenance, as I recall. And normally, Q4 is somewhat of a maintenance quarter. So I was just wondering whether you anticipate a quarter with more maintenance this time around in Q4.

David Cataford

executive
#26

Yes, I appreciate the question. The tasks we completed involve more complex components, and those aren't really going to affect how long our major shutdowns last. As you can imagine, when we have those large shutdowns, they're scheduled several months in advance. We require the parts in hand to carry out all the work, along with the different contractors and the specialized skills. What helped us was the time we had, I would say, at our disposal to perform some minor maintenance in certain areas, which may reduce the maintenance cost somewhat, but it certainly won't alter the time line. Looking at our shutdowns, the schedule is usually set by the maintenance work performed inside the mills, and we truly can't accomplish or modify any of that work during short-notice situations such as the one we're facing now, since we had no opportunity to prepare, and swapping out the liners in our mill at this moment would have been somewhat pointless. So there are modest gains, but I don't believe the timing of our Q4 shutdowns will shift much.

Operator

operator
#27

The following question is from Nick Giles at B. Riley.

Nicholas Giles

analyst
#28

Alright. Turning to Kami — congrats on the Nippon deal. It's genuinely good to see. Could you remind us what the feasibility study is expected to cost overall, and then what Champion's net share comes to?

David Cataford

executive
#29

Looking at the work that has to be completed, the feasibility study cost involves geotechnical drilling that needs doing. We also need to — and although we call it a feasibility study, I include permitting in that as well, since there are certain expenses tied to the permitting efforts we're undertaking. On top of that, some upgrades identified in our prefeasibility study must be made to the port infrastructure and to the infrastructure required for getting the electrical line installed, which makes us very happy. You likely saw the announcement too that Quebec and Newfoundland appear to have reached an agreement regarding power between the 2 provinces. That is a real help as well for what we're examining when it comes to bringing power into the Labrador City area. At a high level, the cost of finalizing all of this lands in the order of magnitude of roughly $60 million. And given how we structured the deal, well, that amount will be invested mostly by the partners. So Champion should not need to contribute any of its own cash over the next 2 years in order to keep advancing the project.

Nicholas Giles

analyst
#30

David, that's genuinely useful, and I appreciate the level of detail. My follow-up is probably more about operating costs, which remain a bit above where you'd want them. You've carried out some additional maintenance. Volumes appear as though they may be stronger over the coming quarters. So how should we frame the effect of better fixed cost absorption? And can the cost impact of rehandling volumes be quantified in any way?

David Cataford

executive
#31

Yes. So the cost effect of rehandling those volumes is a few dollars per tonne to get it there, and a few dollars per tonne to bring it back. So there is an impact tied to those tonnes that we've had to stockpile at site. If you look at the volume improvement, there's definitely a few dollars associated with the volume increase as well. The real game changer for us too is once we begin debottlenecking the project, because at that point we can really absorb even more of some of the fixed costs. But the one thing we need to have in place properly is the logistics, to make sure that when we do invest to debottleneck the plant, we're actually able to bring down those tonnes, and we're not stuck in a stockpiling scenario again. One thing I just want to keep emphasizing on the logistics is that, if you go back a few years before Phase 2 came on, logistics issues were never talked about. So as soon as that is settled, we do feel that we'll be able to bring down the tonnes being produced in an uninterrupted way and in a very stable way. It's taken longer than it should have.

David Cataford

executive
#32

And as you're aware, things have been difficult for us. But once that's done, we ought to be able to take out all those tonnes, remove the bottleneck at the site, and get our costs to a level nearer to what we disclosed previously.

Operator

operator
#33

<<operator_script>> Craig Hutchison of TD Cowen has the next question.

Craig Hutchison

analyst
#34

Turning to DRPF commissioning — how long do you expect that process to take? Then, once it's commissioned, do you plan to blend your product across Phase 1 and Phase 2 at first, until a price is set for the DR material? And maybe a follow-up: if you were selling DR product today, could you give us a sense of the market price for that product above the 65% index, if there's any clarity on that?

David Cataford

executive
#35

Yes. Thank you for that question, Craig. I realize 12 months sounds brief, yet a great deal can unfold around the globe within that span. As things stand, looking at how we're currently approaching commissioning and the ramp-up of the flotation plant, the plan is to produce 2 distinct products. Our intended method for the ramp-up is to prioritize volume over quality, which runs somewhat counter to what we did during Phase 1 and Phase 2. As you'll recall, when we launched Phase 1 and Phase 2, the goal was to guarantee that each individual car meets the 66% specification, giving us market credibility as a high-grade producer. Once the flotation plant is integrated, our aim is to keep the volume disrupted by this ramp-up as small as possible and ensure we ultimately reach that 69%. Now, should the market remain at today's levels, I'm fairly confident the approach will involve blending 100% of the material, creating a new product at entry-level DR grade, and selling 100% of our tonnes on that basis.

David Cataford

executive
#36

Suppose a shortage does emerge in scrap, and the metallics buyers are ready to pay a higher price for the 69% product than for the entry-level DR. In that case, we'll simply keep the products separate. What's interesting is that our infrastructure will give us the ability to adapt very quickly. And with our clients, the approach we'll take to structuring contracts will be one that preserves that same flexibility for us, and there's potential added value if we reach 69% instead of 67.5%. But as you can imagine, looking at today's market, with DR pellet premiums sitting at roughly $45, the premium we'd receive for our material is below what we built into the forecast in our feasibility study. Where we do have advantages, though, is on the shipping side, and that's an added benefit relative to that feasibility study. So our target markets are really the Middle East, North Africa and Europe. By selling there, we'd currently save USD 4 to USD 5 per tonne on shipping costs, on top of the Fe units and on top of the premium.

David Cataford

executive
#37

So this remains a project that delivers a lot of accretion for our shareholders. That extra flexibility, though, will let us see where the market stands in 12 months and really ensure we get the greatest value out of that material.

Craig Hutchison

analyst
#38

Thanks for that. And just to follow up, is there a real — a price you could actually quote today for a product at the entry-level DR grade? Do you have any idea what that price would be now compared with the 65% index, if that information is available out there?

David Cataford

executive
#39

Yes. Sadly, that data isn’t publicly available. The sole figure we’re able to share in any way is USD 45 per tonne for an entry-level DR-grade pellet. That’s the official number, so to speak, but when it comes to concentrate, nothing is publicly available.

Operator

operator
#40

That seems to be all the questions for now. We do have one more question coming in. The next question is from Orest Wowkodaw at Scotiabank.

Orest Wowkodaw

analyst
#41

David, in your preamble did I hear you mention that under present market conditions, the 65% product was selling at a discount in China compared with what you'd call the spot price? And I'm just wondering whether that is still going on as we move through the calendar first quarter?

David Cataford

executive
#42

Yes. Thanks for the question, Orest. So yes, that is precisely what I stated. At present, first spot cargoes are being sold in China with Canadian count, and there is a discount of a few dollars per tonne, and we do forecast that it will still be there next quarter. Then again, things can change very quickly with China. As you have seen, we have had premiums in the past to the P65; now we are more in a slight discount portion. But again, it really depends on the appetite that China has for this type of material. And when you look also at their steel margins, they seem to be favoring a little bit more low grade right now, and that is what we have seen. So that is why we have seen the slight discount come in.

Operator

operator
#43

That appears to be all the questions we have at this point. Go ahead with any closing remarks you'd like to make.

David Cataford

executive
#44

Yes. And once more, many thanks to all of you for joining the call. As you're aware, the past 6 months have been difficult. If you consider the forest fires, the effects on production that we experienced, and also the accident at site while we were constructing. I take a lot of pride in the way our teams have collaborated to ensure we could keep those impacts to a minimum, but once more, what I sense is that we're now beginning to move into a position to head back toward the operational excellence you've watched us achieve between 2018 and 2022. And truly putting that ramp-up period behind us, along with internal logistics, so we can fully capture 100% of the benefit from the tonnes sold or produced at Bloom Lake. I look forward to calendar 2025, when we'll complete our various projects, and to being in a position in 2026 to genuinely lift our earning power and make certain we can deliver proper results to our shareholders, and this is the year when we'll keep assessing the best approach for returning capital to shareholders, since most of the large CapEx items will be behind us by the end of this calendar year.

David Cataford

executive
#45

Once more, many thanks to all of you for the backing. I look forward to talking with you in the coming quarter, and I hope your day is a wonderful one.

Operator

operator
#46

Everyone, that brings us to the end of today's call. You're welcome to hang up at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Champion Iron Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Champion Iron Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Champion Iron Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.