Chicago Atlantic Real Estate Finance, Inc. (REFI) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 8, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Harry Sullivan
executiveThanks, and good morning, everyone. It's a pleasure to have you join us for Chicago Atlantic Real Estate Finance's conference call, where we'll go over what the company achieved in the third quarter of 2023. Joining us on today's call are John Mazarakis, our Executive Chairman; Tony Cappell, Chief Executive Officer; Andreas Bodmeier, Co-President and Chief Investment Officer; Peter Sack, Co-President; and Phil Silverman, Interim Chief Financial Officer. We put out our results this morning in the earnings press release, and you can find it in the Investor Relations portion of our website, together with the supplemental we filed with the SEC. A live audio webcast of today's call is available. If you're listening to a replay of this webcast, please keep in mind that everything we say is only accurate as of today, November 8, 2023, and no updates will be made after this call concludes. Some of the comments and statements we make during this call could be considered forward-looking statements under the meaning set forth in the securities laws, and that includes statements about how our portfolio will perform in the future, our pipeline of possible loans and other investments, dividends going forward, and financing activities. Every forward-looking statement reflects Chicago Atlantic's judgment as of the date of this conference call, and such statements carry risks and uncertainties that may cause actual results to differ materially from what we currently expect. We encourage investors to review carefully the various disclosures the company has made, including the risk and other information in the company's SEC filings. In addition, we'll be discussing certain non-GAAP measures, such as, though not limited to, distributable earnings and adjusted distributable earnings. You can find definitions of these non-GAAP measures, along with reconciliations to the most comparable GAAP measures, in our SEC filings. At this point, I'll hand the call over to John Mazarakis. Please go ahead.
John Mazarakis
executiveThanks, Tripp, and good morning to all of you. During the previous quarter, I mentioned that perhaps the moment had arrived to embrace a stance of cautious optimism, and that view remains unchanged on our end. Beyond the encouraging strides made across a number of states over the past 90 days, HHS has issued a recommendation that cannabis be moved from Schedule I down to Schedule III — a welcome step toward removing the punitive tax weight that operators carry because of 280E, along with SAFE Banking appearing in a revised form as SAFER. Though we stay doubtful regarding how soon SAFER might make it through Congress and the crucial rule implementation taking even longer than that, the fresh perception is that federal-level changes have become more achievable. That shift in perception is having a favorable effect on the actual situation for equity capital among investors and operators; this reality has clearly influenced our borrowers' credit in absolute dollars. Given that some movement has now occurred at the federal level, people have asked whether we anticipate a new influx of capital coming into the industry, especially from the bigger banks; our belief persists that cannabis will stay capital-constrained for a while, with demand speeding up and overall credit quality getting better. If bigger banks decide to move into this space once federal rules are finalized, our view remains that the leading and most attractive path will involve providing capital to established lenders such as Chicago Atlantic. For larger, more heavily regulated financial institutions, the learning curve plus the work of implementing rules will create a tough early hurdle. Since day 1, we've remained completely dedicated to this industry, and we hold strong conviction about this space. No operator we've partnered with and/or extended credit to, and no investor involved in the industry, has ever doubted our dedication or our capacity to meet their capital requirements. When you put together the biggest platform, an in-house originations group, direct lending know-how, a balance sheet that's both well-capitalized and conservative, and a loan book that's diversified, that's the strongest argument you can make for being a top capital provider in this industry. We're also seeing further evidence that conditions have gotten better: our pipeline of actionable deals has climbed past $600 million, compared with $400 million in the prior quarter. The originations team has stayed busy in places like Maryland, Missouri and Ohio, where deal activity has accelerated thanks to adult-use transitions. And the maturities that we and other capital providers have been talking about for a while now continue to represent a real and meaningful opportunity. A number of sizable operators have bond and/or debt facilities that will still require refinancing within the coming 12 to 18 months. Combine that with expansion into new states, and what you get is our pipeline being pushed higher. Our approach in assessing the cannabis sector has consistently been one of caution and pragmatism. I'll close with a principle that guides everything we do here at Chicago Atlantic: any time we put capital to work, it must produce a robust return for our investors while also protecting the principal they've entrusted to us; we've demonstrated that we can be trusted stewards of that money, and you can expect the same level of care from us as we evaluate the opportunities ahead. At this point I'll hand things over to Peter.
Peter Sack
executiveThanks, John. To start, I want to give a brief update on the partnership we have with New York, along with that state's Cannabis Social Equity Investment Fund. In the quarter, roughly $19 million was funded by us, part of the REIT's $50 million pledge to the Social Equity Investment Fund. Litigation in New York regarding licensing is still going on, and it has held back how quickly the fund gets deployed, but our dedication to this effort and to CAURD license holders throughout the state hasn't changed, and when it comes to the credit quality of what we've funded so far, our confidence is very high; we're also looking into social equity programs in additional states, though it's premature to share any details there. The scale we bring to this industry has no equal, and we offer know-how spanning real estate, operations, finance, legal matters, and credit underwriting that turns these efforts into something workable. Our originations stay concentrated in the core markets we care about, as we've said previously, and we keep very strict discipline in underwriting. You should expect us to keep leading in markets that have durable advantages and where operators are strong on the basics. Tony, over to you.
Anthony Cappell
executiveMorning, everyone. Looking at things through a credit lens, over the past 60 to 90 days our portfolio has seen substantial strengthening. Equity prices have been reacting well to news about possible rescheduling, and that is plainly a good thing when it comes to risk premium, while also bettering our standing now that equity values are higher. Should 280E be eliminated, operator profitability along with free cash flow ought to strengthen considerably and multiples should widen — exactly the sort of development that tends to draw in additional equity capital. As of September 30th, total loan commitments in our loan portfolio stood at $356 million spanning 27 portfolio companies, carrying a weighted average yield to maturity of 19.3%, versus 19.2% on June 30th and 18.3% one year earlier. Our weighted average loan-to-enterprise value stayed appealing at 42.5%, against 41% on June 30th. Given the robust beginning to the quarter that we shared on the previous call, total gross originations rose $35 million, with roughly $33 million of that funded to new borrowers. That gain was partly offset by $11 million in principal repayments, $9 million of which came from unscheduled early repayments. Our portfolio was 81% floating rate tied to the prime rate, a decline from 88% last quarter yet an increase from roughly 60% in September of 2022. This modest drop in floating rate loans stemmed from three new loans made during the quarter that carry a fixed coupon, the biggest being the loan to New York Social Equity Cannabis Investment Fund. Despite these fresh originations, we still see a favorable effect on portfolio yield whenever the Federal Reserve lifts its target rate and the prime rate goes up. I'll now hand things over to Andreas.
Andreas Bodmeier
executiveLike we said in the prior quarter, loan number 9 — roughly $16.3 million of principal still owed — got shifted into nonaccrual. At that point, we mentioned that we were working through enforcing our rights and remedies in order to chase full repayment of the amounts owed, and that this approach was specific to that borrower. As of September 30th, that loan is still sitting in nonaccrual. That said, the administrative agent has completed a foreclosure on the borrower's membership interest and is currently collecting bids with the goal of selling the assets to satisfy the loan. Our expectation is that those bids will come in above the carrying value we hold on the balance sheet. Turning to the capital structure, we had $63 million drawn on the revolving credit facility as of September 30. After the quarter closed, we pulled an additional $11 million on that line. That leaves us with $25 million of total liquidity, net of estimated liabilities. As we mentioned in the press release, we're restarting conversations with our lending group about extending the line so we can fund more investment opportunities; through the existing accordion feature, we can extend the facility up to $125 million, and we think this will be a more efficient way to finance portfolio growth. At quarter end, our balance sheet still carries low leverage of 23% of book equity, versus 22% at year-end. On a consolidated basis, our debt service coverage ratio came in at 7.2 to 1 at quarter-end, against a requirement of 1.35 to 1. Down the road, we'd like to move toward leverage equal to 100% of our book equity. The realistic near-term goal is nearer to 50% of book equity. Both of those targets would still be well under what other mortgage REITs run, and they imply considerable portfolio growth over the coming few years. We plan to reach that point in a highly measured way, while at the same time offering our investors an attractive yield. I'll hand things over now to Phil, who will walk through our financial results.
Phil Silverman
executiveThanks. Net interest income came in at roughly $13.7 million for the three months that closed on September 30th, which was in line with the prior quarter. Gross interest income rose by about $0.5 million, and that was helped by the favorable effect of the 25 basis point bump in the prime rate during July, along with the yield earned on close to $35 million of new fundings in Q3. As of September 30th, the portfolio stays nicely diversified, with loans spread across 27 borrowers. During the third quarter, we booked about $0.7 million of non-recurring interest income tied to early principal repayments, versus $0.6 million in the second quarter. Those gains were partly offset by added interest expense from the $20 million of net borrowings on our revolving credit facility made during the quarter. Total operating expenses, before the provision for credit losses, matched what we saw in the second quarter. Management and incentive fees declined by $0.2 million, but that was offset by an equivalent rise in stock-based compensation expense. For Q3, adjusted distributable earnings reached $0.57 per weighted average diluted share, up from $0.55 in Q2. We paid out a dividend of $0.47 for the third quarter, giving us a dividend payout ratio of about 83%. So far this year, we have distributed roughly 80% of taxable income. Earnings per weighted average diluted common share in Q3 were $0.54, versus $0.47 in Q2. Our quarterly CECL reserve stayed steady compared with the prior quarter, at approximately $5.2 million as of both September 30th and June 30th. When setting the reserve for the quarter, we took into account reversals tied to principal payments received in Q3, including the complete repayment of loan number 15, which were offset by new reserves on originations made during the third quarter. Portfolio credit quality held steady, with 88% of the portfolio risk rated three or better as of September 30th, up from 87% as of June 30th. Measured relative to size, our reserve for expected credit losses equals 1.5% of outstanding principal as of September 30th, compared with 1.6% as of June 30th. Roughly 74% of the portfolio, based on outstanding principal, is fully secured by real estate collateral. Another 23% is partially secured, while the remaining 3% carries no real estate collateral. On a weighted average basis, our portfolio had real estate coverage of 1.5x as of September 30th, 2023. Book value as of September 30th climbed to $15.17 per common share, up from $15.06 as of June 30th. Finally, given our results through the first nine months of the year, I want to note that we are reaffirming the 2023 outlook we issued previously. Operator, we are ready to take questions now.
Crispin Love
analystThank you, and good morning to all. I appreciate your taking the time for my questions. To begin with, you mentioned that the credit quality of your operations is getting better because of possible scheduling adjustments as well as regulatory easing. Yet given that credit improvement, do you believe that rates charged to new borrowers might come down even without much of an increase in competitive pressure in the near future?
John Mazarakis
executiveCrispin, thank you for asking. This is John speaking. We have not seen any indication of interest rate, essentially yield, compression; therefore, we anticipate that actual yields will stay at their current levels.
Crispin Love
analystAll right. That's useful. Now regarding Loan number 9, the one that's a non-accrual — from what you said, it seems you anticipate that loan being taken care of through a sale. Could you share anything further on that, or a timeline when a sale might happen?
John Mazarakis
executiveThis relates to a workout or the foreclosure process. Given that declaring bankruptcy isn't an option here, I'd say it's moved along fairly quickly; we believe the bids will end up above our carrying value. That's everything I can offer at this point. We're hoping to get it resolved very soon.
Crispin Love
analystExcellent. That's encouraging to hear. Then, only one more question from my side. Regarding the dividend, it looks like you are set to make a special dividend payment during the fourth quarter. I would just like to know whether that remains the case along with the goal of paying out 90% to 100% of net income as dividends.
John Mazarakis
executiveYes, we anticipate distributing more than 90%.
Crispin Love
analystThat's everything I wanted to ask.
John Mazarakis
executiveI appreciate it, Crispin.
Mark Smith
analystHey, everyone. I'm just wondering whether you've got any fresh perspective regarding Ohio or additional states? And perhaps you could highlight markets that are progressing at a good clip? Or, alternatively, any other new states that might be requiring somewhat more time before they're fully operational?
John Mazarakis
executiveYeah, I'd say yesterday was a really significant occasion, since Ohio tends to lean conservative as a market. So witnessing that 56%, 57% has felt quite motivating. We kind of saw it coming. Still, anticipating something is different from actually getting it onto the ballot, and then having it pass. Florida, I believe, appears promising. We'll find out, we'll find out how it plays out. I'm not able to predict the future. So, we simply need to be patient.
Mark Smith
analystHave there been any notable changes when it comes to build-out or capital requirements in certain states where revenue recognition or medical rules have shifted more recently?
John Mazarakis
executiveFor sure. Those are the states where we're seeing the most activity. As I said, Maryland, Ohio, which was somewhat anticipated. So there was some activity in those places, and then Missouri.
Mark Smith
analystAll right. And in a similar vein, when you take a wide view of the sector, especially across the states where you currently operate, are there any markets or pockets that look like they've gotten worse? Or does it seem to you that things have sort of hit bottom everywhere?
John Mazarakis
executiveMy sense is that we've largely hit bottom, and interestingly, you're actually seeing some favorable momentum out in the Western states. A few of those figures, looked at through a price lens — or at least a wholesale price lens — are turning positive on a year-over-year basis. So yes, absolutely, when you remove all capital from an industry, and that industry happens to be extremely CapEx-intensive, it shouldn't come as a surprise that wholesale prices have flattened out. So that's a good sign.
Mark Smith
analystAlright, and here's my final question. If you could go into a bit more detail about the somewhat greater move toward fixed rate loans we saw this quarter, that would be helpful. Do you anticipate that continuing going forward? Any extra perspective would be appreciated.
John Mazarakis
executiveNo, I'd call it purely random. Yes, we noticed it too. It simply occurred, in my view; a shift toward a fixed rate structure isn't something we're anticipating. That said, floors are in place for us. So when rates could begin declining, holding a fixed rate isn't the worst situation to find yourself in.
Mark Smith
analystOkay. Great. Thank you.
John Mazarakis
executiveThank you.
John Mazarakis
executiveAppreciate everyone being here today. Our team is open to take any additional questions you may have. Once more, many thanks. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Chicago Atlantic Real Estate Finance, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Chicago Atlantic Real Estate Finance, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Chicago Atlantic Real Estate Finance, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.