Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 15, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Elizabeth Lynn
executiveThanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being with us. Joining us on the call is our CEO, Mike Corbat, who will go first. After that, Mark Mason, our CFO, will walk you through the earnings presentation, which you can download from our site, citigroup.com. Once that's done, we'll be glad to take your questions. Before we begin, please note that this presentation today might include forward-looking statements. Those are based on what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty as well as shifts in circumstances. Actual results, capital, and other financial conditions could differ materially from what's in these statements because of many factors, such as the precautionary statements mentioned in our discussion today and those in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 2019 Form 10-K. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Mike.
Mike Corbat
executiveThanks, Liz, and good morning to all of you. We released our results today for 2020's first quarter, posting net income of $2.5 billion along with earnings per share of $1.05. COVID-19 had a major effect on what we earned. Revenue held up well, since the economic shocks from the pandemic did not hit until the quarter was almost over, and we kept up our discipline on expenses. Even so, as you might anticipate, credit costs pulled our net income down. The sizable loan loss reserves we established also captured the Day-2 impact from the new CECL accounting standard. Within our Institutional Clients Group, our markets business delivered a strong showing as we assisted clients in navigating extreme volatility, which pushed trading revenues above both last year's level and what is ordinarily a robust quarter for that business. Treasury and trade solutions took a hit from interest rate reductions, yet client engagement remained very robust for the entire quarter. Investment Banking equaled last year's solid results while we kept picking up share among the clients we target. Global Consumer Banking likewise did well on the revenue side given the conditions. In the US, we saw strong revenue growth in cards, with branded and retail services at 7% and 4%, respectively. Average deposits grew 8%, with yet another solid portion coming in digitally; in Asia, revenues dipped slightly as COVID-19's economic effects showed up there first; in Mexico, revenues climbed modestly, setting aside a one-time gain from 2019, since the virus's effect on that nation's economy was limited during the quarter. Our tangible book value per share rose to $71.52 by quarter's end, which is 9% higher than a year ago. We closed the quarter with a common equity tier 1 ratio of 11.2%, as risk weighted assets rose considerably from greater client demand. As I mentioned, what we face is not a financial crisis but a public health crisis, and it carries harsh economic consequences. Even though revenue performed well this quarter, the environment we exited into looks dramatically different. We have built substantial loan loss reserves, but nobody can say how severe the virus's impact on the world economy will be or how long it will last. Still, we came into this crisis from a very strong position when it comes to capital, liquidity and balance sheet. The resources at our disposal let us serve our clients without putting our safety and soundness at risk. Now I want to spend a moment highlighting a few of the steps we are taking to support our people, clients and communities, which you can find on Slide 3. I must say I take great pride in how our people have handled this rapidly changing situation. We have moved aggressively to shift toward remote working so our people are less likely to become infected, and wherever the virus's spread requires it, we send people to our sites only when there is absolutely no way for them to do their jobs remotely. To give you an example, seven days ago, within North America Markets and Securities Services, 98% of our staff were working from home, and around the world our employees adjusted nicely to this fresh mode of operating, with more than 80% of our colleagues doing their jobs remotely. The money we've put into our technology has enabled us to run things very smoothly under a set of conditions that would have been difficult to envision with such a big portion of our workforce all working off-site at once; those same investments are likewise assisting us in serving our customers via digital and mobile channels, whether that's a consumer putting a check in for deposit or a corporate treasurer handling liquidity. Our spending on risk management and controls, which will never be finished, is also standing us in good stead as we confront the serious economic slump and wide fluctuations throughout markets, whether in equities, fixed income or commodities. We've attempted to assist in keeping our employees financially sound as well and to lessen the stress they are experiencing. Last month we made the decision to give a one-time payment of $1,000 to workers earning $60,000 or less per year in the US, with equivalent payments being made in our international markets. And we have stopped any new reductions in our workforce for now. From a consumer and institutional standpoint, we're in a strong position to serve the clients and the customer segments we've been concentrating on. We recognize that lots of consumers are dealing with genuine hardships, and we're trying our hardest to assist them. We moved quickly to put in place ways to lessen the burden on our consumer appliance and announced further accommodations last week in the US. Although we haven't been a major participant in small business lending, we're stepping up our efforts so we can assist clients who take part in the Payroll Protection Plan, and we have extra consumer relief programs available in our international consumer franchise. We're working diligently to assist our corporate clients, many of whom are confronting financial strain; we've managed to help them, while staying inside our risk and liquidity limits. We've also been assisting the communities we served throughout this incredibly challenging period, teaming up with organizations such as the World Health Organizations, Citi's foundations have already committed $30 million today to help those affected and we'll be making further announcements in the coming days; we've given personal protective equipment to hospital workers and last week we began utilizing our cafeteria at our headquarters to prepare meals for food banks. Our employees keep devising fresh methods to assist and I couldn't be more proud; and as a Bank, we'll do all we can to aid the broader economy. We act as the transmission mechanism for policymakers for both fiscal and monetary, which they can use as a bridge to the real economy. Looking ahead, there are too many unknowns to count. The path that virus will chart, whether there will be successful interventions, the action government leaders will take either reopen the economy or put in place measures that will further restrict it. Another thing to keep in mind is that COVID-19 is a disease we haven't seen before, and as you'd anticipate, the medical advice keeps changing. Even so, we're confident we can handle any situation that arises, and with that, Mark will walk us through the presentations, and then we'd be glad to take your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks, Mike, and good morning to all of you. Beginning on Slide 4, Citigroup's net income for the first quarter came in at $2.5 billion. The results encompassed a $4.9 billion build in credit reserves during the quarter. That reserve increase captures how changes to our economic outlook stemming from COVID-19 have affected us. These builds are bigger because that shift in our economic outlook carries a significant effect on the lifetime losses we estimate under the new CECL standard. Revenues reached $20.7 billion, up 12% versus the prior year, largely driven by stronger markets revenues along with the benefit of mark-to-market gains on loan hedges within our corporate lending portfolio. Expenses came in roughly flat compared with a year ago, and we managed to produce positive operating leverage as well as a 27% gain in operating margin. Credit costs totaled $7 billion for the quarter. Our effective tax rate for the first quarter stood at 19%, under our full year outlook, which reflects a modest benefit tied to stock-based incentive compensation. How this health crisis ultimately affects the economy, and how we perform, will keep evolving across the quarters ahead. What we're already observing differs throughout our franchise; the earliest shift in consumer behavior appeared in Asia, where spending decelerated in reaction to travel restrictions and other limits on commercial activity. That same pattern is showing up now in the US and is just starting in Mexico, which will likely weigh on loan balances. Even so, deposit growth stays robust across regions, and we're using digital channels to connect with our clients. The rate environment has shifted considerably. Our accrual businesses carry the effect of the three US rate cuts from last year, plus some effect from the further cuts made this quarter in reaction to the crisis, and we expect the impact to become more pronounced ahead. That said, I'd note it has been partly offset in areas such as TTS, where clients are directing volumes our way because they see us as a stable partner of choice. A comparable dynamic is unfolding in markets, where we're likewise viewed as a counterparty of choice. On top of that, we're seeing larger corporate loan volumes, which reflect drawdowns and new facilities as our clients respond to the crisis. And last, our investment banking performance captures the market volatility we've witnessed, along with the uncertainty that persists on the corporate side. Right from the start, we've concentrated on our employees and our clients, and on making sure we preserve balance sheet strength to serve them through this uncertainty. As of March 31st, our CET 1 capital ratio stood at 11.2%, under the 11.5% target we've stated, even with our efforts to support clients through this period. We also had more than $800 billion of available liquidity to help support our clients, and when you include the $4.1 billion transition impact from adopting CECL at the start of the year, together with the additional reserves taken this quarter, credit reserves now sit at approximately $23 billion, with a reserve ratio of 2.9% on funded loans. Given the amount of capital, liquidity, and reserves on our books right now, along with considerable earnings power before provisions, we're functioning from a strong position. We pair that financial strength with operational resilience, thanks to investments made in our workforce, our operations, and our technology, as well as digital tools that let us partner with and assist our clients while everyone navigates this crisis. Now let's look at each business. Slide 5 presents Global Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. Revenues rose 2%, since growth in North America was partly offset by weaker revenues in Asia, reflecting the early effect of COVID-19 on how customers behave. Expenses came in roughly flat, which let us produce positive operating leverage and a 5% gain in operating margin. Total credit costs reached $4.8 billion, climbing substantially versus last year, and included a reserve build of about $2.8 billion, tied mainly to how changes in our economic outlook have hit us. Slide 6 gives more detail on North America Consumer results. First quarter revenues hit $5.2 billion, a 4% increase over last year. Even though COVID-19's impact has reached North America only during recent weeks, we've drawn on what we learned in Asia to shape our response strategy. We were among the first banks in the US to offer help for affected customers, beginning in early March; since then we've broadened that support and keep assessing whether more is required. Beyond that, the upgrades we've rolled out to our digital tools have positioned us to respond better and keep serving our customers while they work through this pricing. Digital deposit sales stayed robust this quarter, hitting $1.6 billion. We keep pushing mobile adoption, which is up 13% year-over-year. We adjusted things so customers can handle more transactions through self service channels, such as higher limits for ATM withdrawals, mobile check deposits and Zelle transaction. We've also kept rolling out new digitally driven value propositions, like Citi Wealth Builder, a fresh digital investment platform aimed at clients in the emerging affluent segments; these tools let us stay connected with our clients, even though about 40% of our US branches are now temporarily closed, caused by reduced customer traffic, especially in urban areas. Now on to the businesses. Branded cards revenue came to $2.3 billion, up 7% year-over-year, fueled by 5% loan growth and ongoing spread expansion, with net interest revenue as a percentage of loans improving to 933 basis points this quarter. Client engagement stayed solid through February, with purchase sales growth of about 10% across the first two months of the quarter. Yet, as happened industry-wide, purchase sales fell sharply in late March once more extensive lockdowns took hold in many states. Categories such as travel and entertainment absorbed the heaviest blow, though there was some offset from greater spending on essentials and stronger online sales. All told, branded card purchase sales increased 3% during Q1. Yet if you look at how things trended during the last month, that points to a substantial drop-off in purchase activity for Q2, and that's anticipated to hit loan growth. Retail Banking revenue came in at $1.1 billion, essentially flat versus a year ago — gains from higher deposit volumes and better mortgage revenue got canceled out by thinner deposit spreads. Deposit momentum kept building, with average deposits at 8%. As mentioned before, digital deposit sales stayed robust this quarter even while we kept tweaking pricing in light of where rates stand now; on top of that, engagement from existing customers was strong, which supported balanced expansion across deposit <<inaudible>>, checking included. Although AUMs fell 6% from market movements, we achieved ongoing growth in Citigold households plus investment fees over the quarter, and mortgage revenues rose thanks to more refinancing activity. Lastly, retail services revenues reached $1.7 billion, a 4% increase versus a year ago, on the back of reduced partner payments and a larger average loan. Purchase sales declined 3% compared with a year earlier in Q1 — once again, with notable strain late in March, caused by weaker client activity and closures of stores at certain partners. We expect this to affect new account acquisitions as well as loan balances throughout the year.
Mark Mason
executiveNorth America Consumer's overall costs came in 1% lower compared with a year earlier, since savings from efficiency efforts outweighed what we spent on investments along with costs tied to volume. Now on credit: our total credit costs reached $3.9 billion, a significant jump from the prior year. This quarter we added about $2.4 billion to reserves, which mirrors how our economic outlook has shifted. Meanwhile, net credit losses rose 8% versus a year ago, driven by loan growth and seasoning in both cards portfolios. In US branded cards and retail services, our NCL rates stood at 346 and 553 basis points, respectively. That matches the pickup we normally observe during the first quarter. In the past, NCL rates have tended to run higher in the first half than in the second half of the year. That said, with the economic environment shifting so quickly because of COVID-19, we'll probably face more pressure on NCL rates during the back half of 2020, which lines up with the reserve actions taken this quarter. Slide 7 shows our International Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. Over in Asia, revenues were down 1% from a year earlier in the first quarter. Even though COVID-19 showed up early in that region, we recorded strong investment in FX revenues through most of the quarter. That was offset by weaker purchase sales activity and lower loan balances in our card business, caused by movement restrictions and shifts in how customers behave. We likewise felt an effect on customer acquisitions for products such as insurance, which depend more heavily on face-to-face engagement. Still, average deposit growth stayed strong at 8% this quarter, and we keep pushing digital engagement throughout the franchise. Right now, we're seeing some early signals that activity in China will pick up, since movement restrictions have loosened over the past week or so. That said, it's a small consumer business for us, and naturally, many other markets remain at an earlier stage of working through the crisis. Moving to Latin America, total consumer revenues were largely flat versus a year earlier and rose 3% once you exclude a residual gain from last year's sale of our asset management business. As in other regions, deposits in Mexico grew nicely this quarter, with average balances climbing 4%. We're also getting a lift from better spreads in card. Even so, pressure on overall loan growth persists. And although we haven't yet felt the full brunt of COVID-19 in Mexico, we did notice purchase sales slowing in March, which should keep going as customer behavior probably tracks what we've observed in other regions; all told, operating expenses for our international business rose 3% in the first quarter, led by Mexico, reflecting investments plus episodic items that were partly offset by efficiency savings, while cost of credit climbed to $939 million, mostly because of how our economic outlook has changed. Slide 8 offers more detail on global consumer credit trends, showing the seasonality we usually witness in the first quarter. On the whole, COVID-19 hasn't had a dramatic effect on our credit numbers so far, though it's still early days. We do expect unemployment to climb, which means loss rates for this year will be higher than we first anticipated. That said, it's hard to say how much help the unprecedented $2 trillion relief package, along with the relief programs we've launched for our own customers, will provide in softening some of the possible strain on consumers. I'd add that we're taking the right steps to manage both new and existing credit exposures, and that includes spending on our operations. And as I've mentioned on earlier calls, we're pleased with how our consumer credit portfolios are positioned, both against the industry and against Citi's own risk history. Take our US card portfolios: the FICO distributions for our outstanding loans and open to buy exposures lean far more toward the upper end than they did before the 2008 crisis. Consequently, if we stress today's card portfolios to the same degree as 2008, our pro forma loss rates come in 25% to 30% below what we saw in the last crisis. In Asia, as our credit metrics show, we keep a very low risk portfolio aimed at high quality consumers in both our unsecured and mortgage portfolio, where our average LTV is under 50%; in Mexico, we obviously serve a broader range of clients than in our other region, because of our national footprint; even so, we generally aim at a higher quality segment than our local peers do. Our clients' credit profile has gotten better over time, since we've stayed disciplined and made lending criteria tighter since the crisis, which shows up in our more stable NCL rates over the past few years; we also produce strong margins in Mexico, with a net credit margin of cards, for instance, of about 20%. With that said, the full impact of COVID-19 clearly isn't known yet, and we stay vigilant in how we manage the portfolio. Now turning to the Institutional Clients Group on Slide 9. Revenues of $12.5 billion rose 25% in the first quarter, as strong performance in fixed income and equity markets as well as the private bank was partly offset by lower revenues in TTS and corporate lending. The quarter also got a boost from $816 million of mark-to-market gains on loan hedges, as credit spreads widened during the quarter. Total banking revenues of $5.2 billion fell 6%. Treasury and Trade Solution revenues of $2.4 billion were down 5% as reported and 2% in constant dollars, as strong client engagement and solid growth in deposits were more than offset by the impact of lower interest rates. Our global footprint lets us have a unique relationship with our clients. Even the breadth of that relationship, we're playing a pivotal role in helping our clients navigate through these unprecedented times. We keep observing strong fundamental business drivers in TTS, among them a 24% rise in end-of-period deposits measured in constant dollars, plus 6% growth in cross-border flows. We also keep witnessing the payoff from what we've put into technology, thanks to faster uptake of digital tools. During March, even as we and the bulk of our clients were operating remotely, we brought on roughly 1,000 accounts through digital channels — triple the count we opened that way in March a year earlier. On top of that, CitiDirect users have surged, climbing 25% versus a year ago during the quarter to surpass 580,000 users. Inside that figure, active mobile users multiplied by ten this year. Yet as the quarter came to a close, the complete weight of the lower rate setting did start to be felt, with revenues falling 9% compared with a year earlier for the month of March on a reported basis. Investment Banking revenues reached $1.4 billion, essentially flat versus last year, beating the market wallet as gains in M&A and equity underwriting got offset by a drop in debt underwriting; still, I'd point out that investment grade debt underwriting climbed double-digits versus a year ago, since we assisted clients in sourcing liquidity amid this shifting environment. Private bank revenues came to $949 million, an 8% increase, powered by heightened capital markets activity as we stood by our clients through choppy market conditions.
Mark Mason
executiveWith greater volumes in lending and deposits, partly counterbalanced by reduced deposit spreads, which mirrors how lower interest rates have affected us. Corporate lending revenues came to $448 million, a drop of 40%, largely due to an adjustment in the residual value of the lease financing, plus other marks on the portfolio; and although average loans stayed about level, we recorded a substantial rise in end-of-period loans during this quarter, which mirrors the drawdowns and new facilities I referenced earlier, as we keep supporting our clients. Total markets and Security Services revenues reached $6.5 billion, an increase of 37% compared with last year. Fixed income revenues were $4.8 billion, up 39% year-over-year, with gains across rates and currencies and commodities. With volatility, volumes and spreads hitting record levels, we actively made markets throughout this turbulent period for both corporate and investor clients. Equities revenues totaled $1.2 billion, rising 39% versus last year, which reflects strong performance in derivatives, including more client activity stemming from higher volatility. And lastly in security services, revenues rose 1% on a reported basis and 5% in constant dollars, pushed by greater client activity and deposit volume, partly offset by reduced spread. Total operating expenses were $5.8 billion, up 3% year-over-year, since efficiency savings were more than outweighed by higher compensation costs, continued investments and volume-driven growth. Total credit costs of $2 billion rose significantly from last year, and we built roughly $1.9 billion in reserves this quarter. The rise in reserves mainly mirrored the impact of changes in the economic outlook, along with some downgrades and volume growth in the portfolio. At quarter end, our funded reserve ratio stood at 81 basis points, including a funded reserve ratio of roughly 2% on the non-investment grade portion. We give more details on the corporate portfolio in the appendix to our earnings presentation. Total non-accrual loans rose sequentially this quarter, yet the ratio of non-accrual to total corporate loans stayed low at 57 basis points. On the whole, we feel good about our corporate credit quality and, like consumer, we remain vigilant in managing the portfolio and reserve levels relative to the stresses we see out there today. Slide 10 shows the results for corporate/other. Revenues of $73 million fell significantly from last year, which reflects the wind down of legacy asset, the impact of lower rates, plus marks on legacy securities as spreads widened during the quarter. Expenses dropped 24% as the wind down of legacy assets was partly offset by higher infrastructure costs, along with incremental costs tied to COVID-19, including a special compensation award granted to roughly 75,000 employees who are being most directly impacted by COVID-19. And the pretax loss was $535 million this quarter, higher than our previous outlook, which reflects loan loss reserves on our legacy portfolio, locks on security, the impact of lower rates plus the special compensation award. Slide 11 shows our net interest revenue and margin trends. When you strip out inflation, our total net interest revenue came to $11.5 billion for the quarter, which was down a bit compared with the same period a year ago. Lower rates weighed on us, but that was largely made up for by growth in loans, an additional day, and stronger trading-related NIR. Looking at it versus the prior quarter, net interest revenue fell by about $330 million, which mirrors the lower rate setting, one less day during the period, and the corporate lending adjustment I brought up before. Net interest margin also came down 15 basis points from the prior quarter, and weaker net interest revenues account for about half of that drop, while the rest comes from expansion of the balance sheet. Moving on to non-interest revenue, during the first quarter solid business results across most of the period, plus a notable surge in trading during March, produced a sizable gain in non-interest revenue. When we think about the second quarter, we anticipate declines in both net interest revenues and non-interest revenues, since we'll feel the whole quarter's worth of lower rates and a far sharper hit from COVID-19. Slide 12 lays out our key capital metrics. Over the quarter, our CET 1 capital ratio fell to 11.2%, largely because risk weighted assets went up. That rise in RWA came from the support we extended to our customers, together with greater market volatility and wider credit spreads. Our supplementary leverage ratio stood at 6%. Tangible book value per share rose 9% to $71.52, helped by net income and a smaller share count. To sum up, conditions shifted dramatically during this quarter, yet we kept performing well despite the difficult backdrop. We closed the period with a solid capital and liquidity position. We definitely felt slower global growth and macro uncertainty hit our top line results as the quarter came to an end; even so, we're confident in how we manage risk across the cycle; we stay disciplined around our target client strategy and firmly believe that concentrating on these higher quality, more resilient segments is the correct approach no matter what the economy does. As we look ahead to the second quarter and the remainder of 2020, keep in mind that all of us are dealing with tremendous uncertainty right now. And how we perform will keep shifting in the quarters ahead. That being the case, because of the negative effects of COVID-19, we no longer anticipate achieving a RoTCE of 12% to 13% for the entire year. Judging by what we see at present, on the top line, we think the revenue pattern from late March and early April — marked by reduced activity tied to COVID, especially in banking, and in our consumer franchise — will persist across much of the second quarter. And within our markets business, revenue ought to track the wider industry. Normally the first quarter is the best one, and this year it was obviously especially strong, so we'd anticipate some return to more normal activity levels there. And then last, the top line will feel the effects of lower rates more strongly; when it comes to expenses, a few points matter as we run the franchise and keep costs in check — among them the unknown fallout from COVID-19, the question of how we keep protecting our frontline staff, and the question of how we make sure we can help customers get through this. With that in mind, we are carefully weighing where resources must go so we can still deliver for customers, at a moment when about 80% of our workforce is remote. On this front, we feel good about the technology investments made over the past few years. Thanks to those investments, we can navigate this stretch and serve our customers and clients through digital channels. That said, I want to add that in these unprecedented times, we are likewise looking at every chance to run as efficiently as we can and possibly pull back on certain investments we would otherwise have funded, so as to counter some of the headwinds COVID-19 has produced; we would also anticipate a natural decline in certain volume related expenses, such as T&E, meetings and event calls.
Mark Mason
executiveOnce more, there’s plenty of uncertainty right now, but we’ll share more regarding the effect on the top line and those efficiency initiatives during the next month, once the consequences of COVID-19 are clearer. Still, that ought to give you an idea of how we view the landscape and the earnings power we have before provisions. Moving on to credit. As we look toward the second quarter and the rest of 2020, we do anticipate a greater amount of losses based on the outlook we hold at present. And since that outlook keeps shifting, it’s likewise sensible to anticipate further buildups in credit reserves should conditions worsen. That said, because of the credit quality within our portfolio, we stay confident about preserving our overall strength and stability, and about carrying on supporting our customers and bringing in new business. Without a doubt, every company across the globe will experience an economic hit from this unprecedented situation; yet we’re confident that Citi will come out of it in a position of strength, having shown that we met our stated objective of being an indisputably strong and stay institution and having demonstrated that we stood by our clients and backed our customers and employees throughout this very difficult time; with that, Mike and I are glad to take any questions.
Glenn Schorr
analystHello, and thank you so much. I'd like to know whether you could share a bit more regarding what's driving the reserve build — since card is somewhat larger for your firm. Could you discuss the reserve and your approach to it when looking at it through the lens of branded cards compared with retail services partner cards? Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveOf course. Good morning, Glenn. As you're aware, if you go to page 20, we've laid out some extra details there, and you'll notice that we began — or rather finished, I should say — the year with roughly $14 billion of reserves. You're correct that the majority sits in cards, divided between branded and retail, and our emphasis clearly leans toward clients with higher FICO scores, which is definitely true in cards and tends to be higher in retail services, though not as elevated as on the cards side. That will therefore have some effect on how the two are split. Regarding the day one impact, you can see it came to approximately $4.1 billion. We discussed that during the previous call, and we added another $4.9 billion, bringing us to a total reserve balance of nearly $23 billion. What's worth noting is that the cards portion is obviously around $9.5 billion — but again, I mean 9.5%, pardon me, of LLR to loans; yet again, we generally view this as a book of higher quality. As for the factors that matter, there's a whole set of variables we push through our model, alongside the severity of a recession and the probability of a recession. I'd say the two most essential when it comes to cards — and again, all of them matter, and grasping how they interact matters too — but two extremely important ones are clearly GDP and unemployment, plus how those shape consumer behavior in either scenario. Clearly, on the retail services side, our partners are the ones more directly hit by the COVID-19 situation, yet we also have the $2 trillion relief stimulus that's been rolled out, and it remains somewhat unclear how that will ultimately unfold and affect behavior. So there are many puts and takes running through the model, and those economic assumptions shifted right up until the quarter's end, but in short, given our outlook as it has been, this extra build of $2.4 billion per cards was the right amount for us to take.
Glenn Schorr
analystAll right, that side is really useful. Thanks. Perhaps just a single follow-up — I'm interested in your perspective, since you're right in the middle of everything, about how much better the financial plumbing has gotten thanks to certain government moves, and then where you — most crucially — believe the greatest need for further improvement lies on the plumbing side, things such as money markets, CP; I mean reserve banks?
Mike Corbat
executiveYes, Glenn, what I'd say is that what we've witnessed coming from the Fed alongside the Treasury working together is genuinely remarkable, not only when it comes to the sheer scale of dollars and programs, but also, I believe, the breadth involved and how quickly they got those things up and running. I mean, take the CP facility, the money market liquidity facility, the repo facilities, the wider corporate pieces, the SBA loans, and now something not getting that much attention, but this main street program that exists; and from a plumbing standpoint, yours is a good question, since clearly the real economy has no direct line into the Fed or into the Treasury. And I believe if the banks — and specifically the big banks' role, one among many roles we filled, being that transmission mechanism linking fiscal, monetary and the real economy. And I think you only have to look at how markets were trading in those early days, so many of the fears and concerns present then, whether those were the initial worries about draws, whether those were the initial worries about money funds being able to secure liquidity right across the board, and I believe the programs have come a long way. I think a handful of things still remain out there that likely require further work; and certainly, as an institution, as an industry, we're continually talking with the Fed and the Treasury about those. And once more, as I expect, when those things generate challenges, it's probable we'll see a response emerge from those bodies capable of tackling it. So I think the plumbing is in fact functioning rather well, that despite operating remotely and the figures Mark and I mentioned, and we saw during late March record volumes of trading when it came to settlement, clearing, margin — margining within the system. And once more, the bulk of that accomplished remotely, and you know, every one of us would have told one another 6, 9, 12 months back, you know, we're going to model for this kind of stress, we probably all would have doubted how the system performs; so I take pride in how we've performed and I'm quite happy so far, with how the system has performed.
Glenn Schorr
analystThat's great, thanks to you both.
Erika Najarian
analystHello there, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveHey, Erika. Morning to you.
Erika Najarian
analystI just wanted to —
Mike Corbat
executiveGood morning, Erika.
Erika Najarian
analystThanks, Mark. Hello — I'd like to get some clarity around what you said regarding losses on cards. I just want to confirm that my understanding is right. Your comment was that present-day losses, meaning the cumulative figure as of now, might come in 20% below what occurred during the global financial crisis. And looking back at the regulatory data, 2009 plus 2010 together equal a 20% loss rate. So I simply wanted to verify that we had this right — that in a cumulative loss scenario, card losses of 15% to 16% could be seen, roughly consistent with the company run DFAST as well as the Fed stress test?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, absolutely — what I stated was that, you know, assuming you look at the card portfolio that exists now, which carries better quality than the one in '08, and then applied stress for the '08 financial crisis, then indeed, our pro forma loss rates would land 25% to 30% below the level we saw during the prior crisis. That is — that's my view.
Mike Corbat
executiveAnd I want to be clear here, Erika — that isn't a forecast. It's simply establishing a baseline grounded in what we've seen historically.
Erika Najarian
analystUnderstood. And on a call yesterday, one of your competitors mentioned they had no issue dipping under their 10.5% regulatory minimum in order to help their clients. So I'd like to know where Citi stands on continuing beneath that 10% bright line, particularly given that's the point at which automatic distributions on dividend and other payouts are triggered?
Mark Mason
executiveSure, let me kick things off, Mike, or?
Mike Corbat
executiveSure, go ahead.
Mark Mason
executiveYou know, look, I think our perspective is that we're obviously in a time of uncertainty right now. The crisis we're up against has no precedent. And you know, when I consider what we're trying to accomplish, you know, the top priority being making sure our employees stay safe and well, and then alongside or in addition to that, making sure we're in a position to serve our clients, our customers, and to play a meaningful part in steadying the economy; so when I think about all of those things together, we want to show up for our clients; and I think in a moment like this, our clients expect us to show up for them. And you've seen our CET1 ratio fall to 11.2% this quarter, and as what our clients need keeps shifting, we're going to show up for them, and that means our ratio comes under more pressure than we'll work through. If we were to fall, you know, under the 10% that you mentioned, there's still a lot of space between that level and drawing on the buffer that the — you know, that the regulators have given approval for. And so we're handling it carefully, with diligence, but within the framework of those priorities I just listed.
Erika Najarian
analystThank you.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Betsy Graseck
analystHello there, and good morning. How's it going?
Mark Mason
executiveMorning to you, Betsy.
Mike Corbat
executiveBetsy.
Betsy Graseck
analystMy question concerns how that capital is being used — a portion of it is arriving through drawdowns — and I'd like to get your view on how clients will end up deploying those drawdowns. Should we expect them to stick around for many quarters, many years, or do you believe that within the next 12 months we'll witness some of it being paid down by terming out in the capital markets? It would also help if you could tell us about the deposits tied to this — what share of the drawdowns flowed back to you through deposits, and how sticky those have been. Thanks.
Mike Corbat
executiveSure, Betsy. Looking at the figures, I'd put the draws in the first quarter at approximately $30 billion to $32 billion, which represents somewhere around 10%, 11%, or 12% of what we have outstanding but unfunded. So that isn't what I'd describe as an especially significant figure. Returning to what I told Glenn earlier, the extraordinary measures surrounding the CP facilities — including certain corporate facilities, some of the SBA, and probably more likely the main street lending facilities — take away a great deal of that strain. Two things stood out to me there: there were plainly industries experiencing stress, and those were fairly simple to spot among the list Mark had described; and then there were those who simply felt it was a favorable moment to pull in liquidity. Once the Fed programs and the Treasury programs were put in place, the bond markets reopened, and you witnessed record debt issuance late in the first quarter. Again, our portfolio is mostly investment grade, and with those programs in place, an investment grade portfolio like that can reach the capital markets. So we observed people moving in that direction. Naturally, this is something we were watching. We speak with our clients all the time; but once more, certainly as we entered the second quarter, draws on the facilities have actually been really de minimis, and from our conversations, we neither see nor sense that pressure at present.
Betsy Graseck
analystUnderstood. Then regarding deposits, could you help us understand what share of the draws ended up as deposits, and how do you view whether those deposits will stick around?
Mark Mason
executiveSure, I'll speak a bit more generally about deposits. The ICG deposits that came in during March totaled roughly $92 billion, and our deposits increased quite a bit in March alone. Breaking that down, roughly one-third came from corporate clients who had built up liquidity via draws or issuance. And it isn't necessarily only liquidity, only draws from us, but around one-third we'd tie to that rise in liquidity draws or issuances they've completed. Roughly one-third came from brokered dealers and clearing houses and financial institutions as they shored up their liquidity buffers. And one-third came from investor clients reducing risk and shifting to cash. So that provides some sense of the mix. Naturally, we examine how persistent the deposits are, and some of those are definitely operating deposits. And I believe part of what shapes the outlook somewhat is, as Mike described, the extra channels now open for clients to obtain additional liquidity when needed. But also how long this lasts, and there's considerable uncertainty, as you've heard us mention, about how long this crisis we're working through lasts. So hopefully that gives you a sense.
Betsy Graseck
analystUnderstood. And look, since those drawdowns have decelerated sharply — you described them as de minimis, Mike — my expectation is that the strain on CET1 going forward will ease up too. So perhaps you could share how you're viewing that? And with that in mind, how are you viewing the dividend? Thanks.
Mike Corbat
executiveSure; so, as Mark laid out, the way we approached it — you watched us put a balance sheet to work, and you watched CET1 go from 11.8% down to 11.2%, which plainly leaves us plenty of room, plenty of buffer. And once more, it's early days here, we don't know, and who knows where this heads, but our instinct, or the way we're framing it, is this — the recovery is going to be uneven. As a team, I'd say we've more or less ruled out a uniform V-shaped recovery. The question becomes, is it U-shaped? Is it W-shaped, or are parts of it L-shaped? And I think we want to hold onto a great deal of flexibility and capacity so we can step into the situations that matter. And once more, as we've said, if there are two roles, one is, how do we deploy our own balance sheet? And then how do we truly deploy and bring to life many of these programs, and keep going with programs that the Fed and the Treasury have rolled out; so in the right situations, we're ready to let that ratio decline. We're talking with our board. We're talking with our regulator, and I think Mark said, you know, we believe we have a great deal of capacity when it comes to capital and the things we can do before we come anywhere close to triggering any discussions about the dividend, but once more, we're going to handle that as a moment that arrives when it arrives; but you know, to be clear, given our capacity here and how we're looking at things, we stayed committed to paying our dividend.
Betsy Graseck
analystUnderstood. Thank you.
Ken Usdin
analystThanks, and good morning. If you wouldn't mind, a few additional questions regarding the card segment. If you break out the branded cards versus retail services, could you walk us through what you're observing — relatively speaking, we can detect it in the pace of change from the first quarter, but would you anticipate divergence in spending patterns, volume balances, and credit as this develops, or any detail you could provide there? Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely, let me begin with spending. During the quarter, looking at the final week of March, card spending activity broadly for us declined roughly 30% in US spend, by category down a total of 30%. The major categories affected won't shock you: travel declined 75%, dining and entertainment fell about 60%, discretionary retail — which covers apparel, department stores, and so on — dropped 50%, while essentials rose 10%. As you would anticipate, and once more, that brought us to a total decline of about 30% in that final week; we've all witnessed what has kept unfolding over the last couple of weeks. Therefore, I would anticipate, we would anticipate ongoing pressure on purchase sales volumes throughout most of the second quarter, given how this is persisting, and that should also ultimately affect loan volumes, where we expect some top-line pressure. Likewise, as you mentioned, we possess a sizable retail services business with partner clients whom we counsel in that area, and we've been collaborating with them to help drive digital sales. But clearly, the shutdown across most of the economy, stay-at-home orders, and temporary store closures throughout most of the country will undoubtedly affect our partners and our results, including a deceleration in new customer acquisitions and, again, reduced purchase sales volumes through that portion of our business. Having said that, we have several partners — or rather, one large partner — who function as essential resources for the economy, and although they'll experience lower store traffic, they can keep serving. So in the end, you know, like I mentioned, we'd anticipate that a portion of that revenue strain shows up in Q2, and then as the year goes on, we'd look for NCLs to improve — that is, assuming things such as the $2 trillion relief package and a few of the additional customer relief programs we rolled out actually gain traction.
Ken Usdin
analystYeah, and thanks — just one more question. If balances were to decline, since cards make up a much larger share of your balance sheet, is there a favorable offset that shows up in terms of reserving requirements? I'm just curious how, specifically for you folks, the flow of card spending and outstandings shapes the way card reserves get built. That is, if that's a reasonable question.
Mike Corbat
executiveYeah, so when you consider CECL and the notion of accumulating expected lifetime losses during any particular quarter, several factors are involved. These include your recession probability, how severe a recession might be, our outlook on the key economic variables and how they will unfold, plus balances. Consequently, when balances move and when the composition and mix of those balances move, that will affect what we would anticipate regarding those lifetime losses, and thus what we would anticipate regarding how that reserve balance would change.
Ken Usdin
analystGot it. Okay, thanks a lot.
Mike Corbat
executiveThank you.
Matt O'Connor
analystMorning. In the US, plenty of measures are clearly in motion that ease pressure on borrowers when we consider credit losses — fiscal support, deferrals on payments. Could you perhaps describe what is happening in Mexico and Asia, plus some of your larger markets in those regions, regarding actions that could reduce the strain on consumers? And is that impact comparable to what we observe domestically? Or in what way do you incorporate it when estimating possible losses?
Mike Corbat
executiveYes, Matt, that is an excellent question. When we consider every location where we operate, several perspectives must be applied to truly assess the situation of these nations and their economies. First, you must examine the public health reaction. Has the government treated it seriously? Have they introduced policies? Have they implemented social distancing? Have they enforced shelter-in-place style rules, and what does the path of that appear to be? The second element concerns what you observe regarding both monetary and fiscal measures. And not merely what has occurred so far, but also the ability of those economies to carry out those and additional actions, possibly going forward. The third key element we examine involves the fundamental demographics of the economy — for instance, whether they hold large exposures or rely on oil exports or other commodities or similar items where concentrations exist. Therefore, I would say it is not divided by region; rather, we truly adopt a nation-by-nation method for this. And I believe you have witnessed it vary widely, with very robust reactions from the US, from Japan. You have seen certain reactions from Europe, and I think you have seen some that are slower. Specifically, regarding your question about Mexico, we know the President has described himself as a fiscal hawk, and I think he has been unwilling to employ any kind of extraordinary expenditure to address this crisis so far. And clearly we are monitoring that closely. We have attempted to remain fairly cautious concerning our credit standards there and the actions we are taking, and we are clearly tracking it intently.
Matt O'Connor
analystAll right, and I’d like to ask a bit more about that. If I remember correctly, the customers you’re aiming for in Mexico are, you know, at a much higher level than what I’d call the general customer group; so could you perhaps go over again a few of the credit measurements for the card portfolio in Mexico in particular? Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveI —
Mike Corbat
executiveMark, would you like to take that one?
Mark Mason
executiveI can’t pull up the credit metrics right now. What I’d say is this — even though we serve a wider swath of the population in that market, our emphasis tends to land on the upper tier, and that’s definitely true when you stack us against the other competitors in Mexico. So our credit profile leans toward the higher end. Their setup is different, including how FICO works there specifically. And as you’ve watched across the last several quarters, we’ve actually kept a very close eye on things — our loan volumes have indeed moved downward compared with the wider industry, because we’ve stayed, you know, really watchful and committed to remaining within our risk limits, which once again sit higher than what most rivals in that country have.
Matt O'Connor
analystYeah. All right. That helps. Thanks.
Mike Mayo
analystApologies if I caught only some of that. Regarding further reserves set aside going forward, another $5 billion during quarter two or quarter three. Yes, no, possibly.
Mark Mason
executiveHi, Mike. Allow me to offer a few remarks on that. First, once more, there’s considerable uncertainty here as we contend with a major crisis, as you’re aware. Even though we’ve wrapped up this quarter, the factors we monitor, as you know, keep moving around substantially. Given that setting, and again, depending on numerous considerations, among them the way customers react to the relief programs available, and so forth, my expectation is that we’d record further builds in quarter two. That’s roughly where things stand. I mean, I’m not going to — you know, we still have the remainder of the quarter left to unfold. We have analysis and models still to work through; we have consumers who need to react to a great deal of the stimulus out there. We need to grasp how it keeps affecting the various businesses we operate in; it’s far too soon to give you any sense of what that figure is.
Mike Mayo
analystAll right, and what takeaways do you have from Asia? The virus hit that region initially, after all. You ought to be somewhat further ahead compared with other banks lacking that kind of experience, so what are you observing regarding, you know, volumes along with credit losses and your capacity to collaborate with clients?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Mike Corbat
executiveYeah, so I think that —
Mark Mason
executiveSorry, Mike, you go ahead.
Mike Corbat
executiveIn a sense, Mike, you could say we've been lucky enough to live through that. We picked up quite a few lessons, I'd argue, and I think our actions showed that — the steps we took to bring employees back from remote locations, the kinds of client engagement we pursued. One thing we're monitoring really carefully is cases ticking back up as people begin returning. So we need to stay very conscious of the method and timing — or the timing and method — by which we actually do that. You saw us in early March, I believe as the first US bank, step forward and reach out, especially to our consumer customers, opening channels and discussing certain forbearances plus fee forgiveness and similar measures to draw them in. And to Mark's point, the credit figures show it's been comparatively mild so far, and we've rolled out programs across most, if not all, of our Asian countries offering comparable forbearance arrangements, genuinely attempting to engage on that front. So it's early days, yet once more you could — the data suggests that roughly 60 days in or thereabouts, we'd likely had a fairly full February and March regarding COVID in Asia, but as I say, we continue tracking the figures intently; it comes down to the engagement and the programs, and some of this involved pulling the playbooks from '08 off the shelf, along with certain items from the years in between.
Mike Mayo
analystAnd if I could ask one more thing. You mentioned the virus flaring up again and folks returning to the office throughout Asia. So, are your staff members actually heading back at this point? Is that something you're witnessing directly, or is it merely guidance from outside medical professionals that you're getting? Do you see it with your own eyes? Also, at what point do you intend to reopen operations in that region? Specifically at Citi Asia? To put it another way, what's the count of employees on remote work, and what's the count in the office?
Mike Corbat
executiveRight, perhaps you didn't catch it. But we touched on this briefly before, Mike, regarding how inconsistent the situation is — when you consider this virus, it isn't simply inconsistent in how it progresses relative to our position across the globe; here in the United States alone we have a gap of no less than 2 to 3 in terms of the virus's status. And, you know, across Asia, China has likely shown the most coordinated push to get staff returning, and I'd say we're mostly back to normal there. Based on the most recent figures I reviewed yesterday, roughly 2/3 had returned in Hong Kong, and I'd say the majority of other areas in that region are at figures below that. Consequently, we're adopting a highly tailored, or rather location-by-location, approach regarding the way we return our people. So, you know, the initial factor is: what stage is the virus at in its path? The next factor is: which activities at a given location prove extremely hard to duplicate when working remotely? And after that, in tackling those, what's the most secure method through which we can start getting staff back? So I believe that —
Mike Mayo
analystStill, that's quite impressive — two-thirds back in Hong Kong. So, you know, would you say that leaves you cautiously optimistic about what lies ahead, or should we not read too much into it?
Mike Corbat
executiveOnce again, I'd say it varies by location, so we're approaching this on a site-by-site basis — but even so, you know, recognizing again, you probably didn't catch this part, you know, our doors are fully open for business. We're simply operating in a different way, correct. If you consider what we've managed to get done just during the month of March, it isn't as though we're sitting idle. You know, for instance, yesterday, you know, more than 180,000 people were logged into our systems remotely at the same time, and our peak figure was 132,000 of those individuals on at once. Consider what Mark and his finance team have pulled off, you know, finishing the quarter with a $2 trillion balance sheet. Look at the CCAR submission, look at everything around the remediation efforts, the small business programs, all of it being delivered remotely. So again, how we proceed will be bespoke, as Mark said, with an eye toward ensuring our people stay safe. And at the same time, doing whatever we can to serve our customers and clients through this extraordinary period; and it's going to be case-by-case.
Mike Mayo
analystAll right, thank you.
Mike Corbat
executiveThank you.
Mark Mason
executiveThank you.
Saul Martinez
analystHello there. Hey, good morning everyone.
Mark Mason
executiveHey, Saul. Good morning.
Saul Martinez
analystI have a few questions about CECL, so I appreciate your patience. First, I'd like to hear how you view the DFAST stress losses — do you consider that a solid benchmark for assessing reserve adequacy under CECL? We field plenty of inquiries about why allowance levels sit so far beneath the nine-quarter stress losses seen in the severely adverse scenario of the adversary. I believe that applies to your firm as well. In my own opinion, DFAST offers a helpful data point, yet there are basic distinctions, clearly going past variations in the economic scenarios applied. DFAST aims to gauge loss-absorbing capacity during a severe downturn. Its estimates might lean toward the conservative side for losses, whereas with CECL, these are point-in-time estimates — your best projections of losses across the loans' lifespan given an economic scenario. That's before even considering the many methodological divergences in calculating such figures, like weighted average remaining life or similar factors. Still, I'm eager to know if you have a view on whether these stress losses ought to act as a benchmark, or how valuable they are for assessing if a particular bank or yours holds sufficient reserves?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, you covered quite a bit there. I'd say it functions as a benchmark, and you've pointed out some significant distinctions in methods and viewpoints — everything from the modeling to the assumptions, and so on. Thus, it does work as a benchmark. However, what we're going through right now, even when we filed a plan from a CCAR standpoint, is that this is a scenario. It's definitely a stress scenario, but at present we're enduring an actual real-life stress event. Those scenarios are designed to guide a company's capacity to handle stress, yet here we face a genuine trial that has placed us — and I believe the whole industry — in a spot where we continually model and show our capacity to endure real-time strains and the possibility of actual losses. Having said that, CECL is a fresh method, and I find the timing intriguing because we witness a notable change from transition to day one, which in a typical setting, you wouldn't expect such a striking change. Yet once more, as you're aware, that comes from a perspective — one that looks ahead at what has become a crisis within a pressured situation; therefore the size of that shift we observe on day two stems directly from it. Also, I believe we'll find that this keeps going, as you know, and whatever we undertake regarding reserves set aside for the future will keep drawing from that same perspective. What we end up actually facing in terms of losses, though, will depend on the degree to which the ambiguity I mentioned comes to pass; so once more, no stress scenario crafted, as you know, up to this point, as you know, would have taken into account the scale of fiscal and monetary measures that have appeared so quickly. As you know, that isn't captured in any modeling, and the way customers or consumers respond to it isn't included in any CCAR DFAST model we might have used. Just how that counterbalances the effect of, as you know, joblessness or eventually losses is entirely uncertain. Consequently, there's quite a bit, as you know, yes, it's one data point, as you know, but quite a bit of ambiguity and, I'd anticipate, discrepancies given that we're now navigating an actual, real-world situation.
Saul Martinez
analystThat helps. Let me ask a follow-up, if I may. Your team relies on a single scenario, while most big banks run several scenarios when they figure out their reserves. Apologies if I already missed it, but could you lay out the broad strokes — the main broad-stroke assumptions you're working with, whether that's worldwide growth, growth in the US, or joblessness, that sit beneath that scenario. And I suppose this ties into it: does relying on a single scenario introduce greater volatility? Because with scenario analysis, you're able to sort of fine-tune between varying results, whereas things shift a lot more when your outlook changes — in your situation it's one scenario replacing another, rather than perhaps a spectrum of results under something like a weighted-average scenario analysis, which is what most banks do. So does it — do you believe it leads to more volatility, plus more jumps and releases, than would otherwise be the case?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, we do rely on a model approach, using a scenario, but I'd say this: that scenario got shaped by what you could call an additional management adjustment, and the factors we take into account aren't just thousands of variables such as GDP, unemployment, and a great many other statistics, given the kind of business we run — they also include the likelihood of a recession and how severe that recession would be. Through our management adjustment, we're able to toggle the levels of severity we'd anticipate in a recession — be it 25%, 50%, 75%, or a 100%, measured against how severe an '08 recession was, or whatever the situation may be. So even though we rely on a model and a single scenario, there's flexibility there, so to speak, when it comes to making sure we capture what we believe most accurately reflects the forward view of the economic outlook in our analysis. And regarding — as I might have said — I believe I said earlier at some point that you have to put a stake in the ground when the quarter ends and examine the assumptions available to us — those thousands of variables, and certainly the key ones I named. This quarter especially, we've watched things keep shifting, so even the view we'd have adopted when the quarter closed on a number of those metrics — the outlook for them has kept changing. So we're testing out a number of different scenarios to see how they'd hit our ratios and our projected losses — things like unemployment landing somewhere between 10% and 15%, and GDP dropping anywhere from 20% to 40%. We keep doing that kind of scenario work to get a handle on what it means for our CET1 ratio and the other key measures we need in order to run, manage, and plan properly at the firm.
Saul Martinez
analystUnderstood. All right, that's genuinely useful. Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveAll right.
Brian Kleinhanzl
analystGreat, thank you. Mark, I've got a quick question first about ICG and the reserve coverage in that area. I hear you saying you feel comfortable with it. If you look at the reserves you're holding relative to total exposures, that works out to roughly 80 basis points against all exposures, but then again, non-investment grade makes up 21% of the portfolio. So which metrics are you focusing on to feel comfortable there? It seems like it wouldn't take many delinquencies to produce a big jump in losses, right?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, look, there are a number of metrics we rely on when it comes to ICG. GDP matters a lot, obviously a view on downgrades matters a lot, a view on energy prices, oil prices matters a lot, and as you mentioned — we don't have the whole portfolio broken out here; but that 81 basis points will be a blend of places where we believe we need more — more reserves, so for instance, when we added reserves, and you can see roughly what our reserve ratio looks like for the energy sector, for example, that's nearer to 2%, 2.1% when it comes to the funded reserve ratio. So I point to that as simply one illustration of how clearly some will be higher, some lower, and when it comes to the broader non-investment grade, similar to the illustration I just gave you, the broader non-investment grade bucket runs closer to 2% when it comes to the reserve ratio; so, again, I get the question, given the 81 basis points, but we are — clearly applying sound judgment as we work through the various risk profiles within the portfolio.
Brian Kleinhanzl
analystRegarding the outlook you provided for how March and April might shape the remainder of the quarter — apologies if this was already addressed, but is there any fresh detail on how purchase sales were performing in April, and how TTS revenues were performing in April? You mentioned TTS was down 9% in March — has that deteriorated in April? Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveSure. I don't have the spend figures in front of me — let me check for April. I'm not certain whether you caught this, but as I mentioned before, card spend activity during the latter part of March, that final week, ran at roughly 30%, down 30%, with a varied mix reflecting the distinctions among the various categories. On TTS, once more, I lack the April data; we did experience pressure during March, and what I was alluding to was rate pressure flowing through in commercial card activity, which serves as another proxy for spend, comparable to retail card or consumer card spend levels, and that was down quite significantly, which is telling about our corporate client base regarding T&E — commercial card spend declined by nearly 60% — while B2B, business-to-business, commercial card activity fell roughly 19% during March. So those trends will likely persist. That said, I'd simply point out that we keep seeing very strong engagement with our TTS client base, evident in the higher volumes recorded in Q1, and we anticipate that will carry on; we also see it in the new accounts being opened with them, and we'd expect that to carry on as well, including through use of many of our digital capabilities. And honestly, as this situation keeps evolving alongside all the uncertainty it brings, we'd expect to serve as a vital partner to these large multinational clients as they consider what the new norm will look like. So the metrics will shift, the top line will shift given the rate environment, but I believe those underlying drivers, so to speak, reveal a great deal about what the future prospects hold for the firm here. Mike, do you want to weigh in on —
Mike Corbat
executiveJust quickly, Mark, before we wrap up here. I want to return to what Mike asked and say sorry for having inverted my figures. Worldwide, more than 80% of our employees are working remotely, and as for Hong Kong, roughly one-third are back while two-thirds continue working remotely. So, Mike, I apologize for getting that reversed. Operator, with that, I believe that brings the call to a close.
Elizabeth Lynn
executiveWe appreciate everyone being here with us right now. Should any additional questions come up, don't hesitate to get in touch with our Investor Relations team. Thanks so much, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today’s conference call. Thank you for your calling. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.