Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 14, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 100 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello everyone, and I appreciate all of you being with us. Our chief executive, Mike Corbat, is going to kick things off on today's call. After that, Mark Mason, who serves as our CFO, will walk you through the earnings presentation, and you can download it from our site, citigroup.com. Once that's done, we'll gladly answer your questions. Before we begin, please keep in mind that this presentation today might include forward-looking statements, and those rest on management's present expectations while being subject to uncertainty and shifting circumstances. A range of factors could cause actual results, capital, and other financial conditions to differ materially from what's stated, among them the precautionary statements cited in our discussion today as well as those contained in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 2019 Form 10-K. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Mike.

Mike Corbat

executive
#2

Thanks, Liz, and good morning to all of you. We came out today with our results for the second quarter of 2020; net income came to $1.3 billion, and earnings per share stood at $0.50. Just like in the first quarter, credit costs pulled our net income down; even so, the business performed strongly overall, which demonstrates that we've managed to steer through the COVID-19 pandemic fairly well up to this point. With revenue growing a solid 5% and expenses well managed, falling 1%, both measured against a year earlier, our margin rose 13%. Loans grew and deposits rose considerably. Regulatory capital went up, we keep building on our considerable liquidity, and there is more than sufficient room on our balance sheet to keep serving our clients. The Institutional Clients Group delivered an outstanding quarter. Fixed Income climbed 68%. We posted our strongest investment banking quarter in recent memory, and private bank revenues came close to $1 billion. And although Treasury and Trade Solutions kept feeling the pressure of the lower rate environment, we did observe solid client engagement along with robust deposit growth in that business. Global Consumer Banking revenues fell and spending decelerated sharply because of the pandemic. In North America, even with the drop in purchase sale activity, branded card revenue edged up thanks to a mix shift toward interest-earning balances. Meanwhile, retail services experienced a sizable decrease in consumer spending among our partners. Retail banking recorded higher mortgage revenue driven by refinancing activity amid the low rate environment; over in Asia, reduced travel and consumer activity once more brought revenues down. And in Mexico, revenues dropped as the country contends with the fallout of the health pandemic. Our capital position grew stronger over the quarter, with our Common Equity Tier 1 ratio rising to 11.5% on an advanced basis. I felt good about how we did on the Federal Reserve's most recent stress test, which put our stress capital buffer at 2.5%. That keeps us well above our new regulatory minimum of 10%. Our tangible book value per share came in at $71.15, down just a bit from the first quarter yet still 5% higher than a year ago. Our plan is to continue paying the quarterly dividend for as long as macroeconomic and financial conditions allow. Throughout the quarter, we kept standing behind our clients, colleagues and communities during this pandemic. While I'd like to have more of our people back in the office, we've made it clear that we won't do anything that puts their health and safety at risk. Most recently, we halted plans to bring a limited number of colleagues back to sites in areas where the health data was trending the wrong way. We've also stayed dedicated to helping communities through a range of initiatives. All told, that adds up to more than $100 million given by our company along with its foundation. Still, what makes me proudest is the $2 million that my colleagues gave from their own pockets to groups delivering COVID relief under our matching program. Not long ago, we made an initial distribution to the Citi Foundation, which came to $25 million in net profits from the Payroll Protection Program, in order to back community development financial institutions. Through a $50 million facility, we're buying loans so that minority-owned depository institutions can extend credit to businesses via PPP — another partnership of ours. Given the economic gaps that run along racial lines in our society, this work matters even more. Naturally, we keep serving our clients too, whether that means offering consumer relief or assisting companies in reaching the capital markets to shore up their balance sheets. We began the second half in a strong spot to deal with whatever arrives. The environment we're in is entirely unpredictable, and the models offer no cycles to reference. COVID-19 has the economy in its grasp, and that hold probably won't ease before vaccines become widely available. Our approach will remain one of managing through it all with a keen focus on risk management. We keep putting money into our infrastructure to improve safety, soundness and controls, so that we are unquestionably a strong and stable institution. With that, Mark will walk us through the presentation, and afterward we'll gladly take your questions.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Thanks, Mike, and good morning to all of you. Let's begin on Slide 4. At Citigroup, net income for the second quarter came in at $1.3 billion, and that figure included a $5.6 billion addition to credit reserves during the quarter. That build mostly mirrored the worsening economic outlook since Q1 ended, as measured under CECL, along with downgrades within the corporate loan portfolio. The reserve build also captures a further qualitative management adjustment, which addresses the possibility of more severe stress and/or a recovery that arrives somewhat more slowly. Revenues reached $19.8 billion, up 5% versus the prior year, largely driven by stronger Fixed Income and Investment Banking revenues. Expenses declined modestly compared with a year earlier, producing positive operating leverage and a 13% gain in operating margin. Credit costs for the quarter totaled $7.9 billion. Our effective tax rate came to 9% in the second quarter, reflecting a larger relative benefit from tax advantage investments and other tax benefit items, given the reduced level of EBIT. Now let's look at how we did in the first half of 2020. Net income delivered was $3.8 billion, even while we raised credit reserves by $10.5 billion under the CECL framework in light of the current environment. Revenues rose 8%, primarily reflecting sustained strength in our Markets and Investment Banking businesses, while expenses stayed flat versus a year ago, which let us generate positive operating leverage and a 20% rise in operating margin. Measured in constant dollars, end-of-period loans were up 1% year-over-year, reaching $685 billion, driven by growth in our institutional businesses, which was mostly offset by reduced spending activity in our consumer business. Deposits climbed 20%, reflecting client engagement in what you might call a flight to quality, spanning both the institutional and consumer franchises, and that has helped reinforce our available liquidity; we also kept a strong capital and liquidity position, which has proven essential to our capacity to support clients as they navigate this crisis. At June 30, our CET1 capital ratio stood at 11.5%, which is 150 basis points higher than our regulatory minimum requirement. We held close to $900 billion in available liquidity. And counting the extra reserves taken this quarter, credit reserves now total roughly $28 billion, with a reserve ratio of 3.89% of funded loans. Given the capital, liquidity and reserves we hold today, plus the substantial pre-provision earnings power demonstrated through the first half of the year, we keep operating from a position of strength. And as we said last quarter, we pair this financial strength with operational resiliency, enabling us to partner with and support our clients as everyone manages through this crisis. Let's move to each business now. Slide 5 presents Global Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. Revenues fell 7%, since strong deposit growth was more than offset by lower loan volumes and lower interest rates across every region. Expenses dropped 8%, as lower volume-related expenses, cuts in marketing and other discretionary spending and efficiency savings were partly offset by higher COVID-19-related expenses. The overall credit cost came to $3.9 billion, a substantial increase versus a year ago, and that figure includes roughly $2 billion of reserve build, which reflected the worsening economic outlook. On Slide 6, you can see a more detailed picture of North America consumer results. Revenue in the second quarter was $4.7 billion, a decline of 5% compared with last year. Throughout the quarter, our emphasis stayed on delivering assistance to customers hurt by COVID-19. Since this crisis started, relief has reached over 2 million accounts — that's about 6% of our total balances in cards and mortgages. Encouragingly, a large number of those same customers kept making their normal payments through the second quarter, though we recognized this — and as of today, more than half of the enrollees in our cards program have exited it, with over 80% of those customers still current, while reenrollment rates are running below what we expected, in the mid-teens. Now let's move to the businesses, beginning with cards. Branded Cards revenue reached $2.2 billion, up 1% from a year earlier, since weaker purchase sales and lower average loans were offset by a favorable shift in mix toward interest-earning balances, which lifted net interest revenue. As the whole industry saw, purchase sales fell sharply — down 21% in the second quarter. Still, in recent weeks we've observed signs of improvement, with purchase sales in June running down in the low double digits versus a year ago, compared with a 30% drop in April. Average loans were 7% lower, which mirrors reduced sales activity. We also implemented credit actions in the quarter, such as pausing proactive marketing and cutting back on credit line increases and balance consolidation activity. Given today's conditions, we consider these risk actions sensible, but they'll probably put additional pressure on interest-earning balances during the back half of the year. Retail services revenue was $1.4 billion, down 13% from a year ago, which mirrors lower average loans along with larger partner payments. Net interest revenue fell 7% as average loans dropped 6% on reduced purchase sale activity. Purchase sales in the second quarter were down 25% versus last year. Yet, much like Branded Cards, June brought improvement, with the decline in sales pace easing to the mid-teens. Larger partner payments accounted for the rest of the revenue drop relative to last year. As we've noted before, retail services revenue is reported net of payments tied to income-sharing arrangements with our retail partners, and those can shift from quarter to quarter depending on the overall mix and profit outlook for our portfolios. Retail Banking revenue was $1.1 billion, down 3% from a year earlier, as the gains from stronger deposit volumes and better mortgage revenue were more than erased by lower deposit spreads. Deposit momentum kept building, with average deposits up 14%, driven by a mix of environmental factors — the delay of tax payments, stimulus payments and reduced overall spending — plus our ongoing strategic push to generate organic growth. Purchases made through digital channels picked up speed even while we kept tweaking our pricing in response to today's rate conditions, with digital deposits up $3 billion during the quarter, reaching a total of almost $12 billion. We likewise witnessed robust involvement from current customers, which fueled even growth throughout our deposit offerings, such as checking, which was up 13% year-over-year. For North America consumer, overall expenses fell 10% year-over-year, since cuts to marketing and other discretionary spending, plus efficiency gains and reduced volume-related costs, outweighed added expenses tied to COVID-19. Moving to credit. Total credit costs reached $3 billion, a large jump from a year ago, after we set aside approximately $1.5 billion in reserves during the quarter, which mirrors how our economic outlook shifted, partly offset by a modification in how we account for third-party collection fees; Slide 7 presents our International Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. Within Asia, second-quarter revenues dropped 15% year-over-year. Cards revenues were down 22%, which mirrors reduced activity, with purchase sales falling 29% year-over-year. Asia card revenues are being hit disproportionately by reduced travel spending in the region, because of our wealthy customer base and a bigger share of fee revenues originating from travel-related interchange and foreign transaction fees.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

In the same way, we saw a negative effect on acquiring customers for products like insurance, since those rely far more heavily on face-to-face engagement. Even so, deposit growth on average remained strong, reaching 10% during the quarter, even though spreads on deposits came in tighter, reflecting both a shift toward quality and continued client involvement across the entire franchise. Even with investment revenues declining in the quarter, we kept witnessing fundamental momentum in our wealth management drivers, as Citigold customers increased 6% and net new money rose 10% versus the prior year. We're seeing some initial signs of a pickup as of today, with purchase sales declining less sharply and both net new money and investment sales improving significantly in June compared with earlier months, though how the recovery takes shape is still uncertain. Turning to Latin America: overall consumer revenues fell 7% from a year earlier. Similar to other regions, Mexico delivered strong deposit growth this quarter, with average balances up 9%; even so, revenues were hurt by reduced purchase sales and loan volumes, along with tighter deposit spreads amid current conditions. For our overseas operations, total operating costs dropped 4% during Q2, driven by savings from efficiency measures and reduced expenses tied to volume, while credit costs climbed to $883 million. More specifics about worldwide consumer credit patterns can be found on Slide 8. Due to the economic downturn, credit loss rates generally increased this quarter, but this stemmed much more from smaller loan balances, as it remains too early for COVID-19 to have a clear effect on our net credit losses. In the U.S., rates of delinquency at 90-plus days showed improvement. Despite those smaller balances, less spending plus substantial government aid and the relief we provided customers have created cash that's gone toward reducing what they owe, reaching even the oldest past-due categories. Because of that extra cash and the help programs, early-stage late payments are improving too, but we're still in the early days, and there's a lot we don't know about when the economy will bounce back and how people will behave after these aid and relief measures end. In Asia, late payments ticked up a bit, but they remain fairly low in absolute terms. Mexico took a harder hit — COVID-19 hasn't reached its peak there yet, and customers aren't getting the same government stimulus support. Moving on to Slide 9, the Institutional Clients Group. Second-quarter revenues came in at $12.1 billion, a 21% increase, or 25% higher once you exclude the roughly $350 million pretax gain from last year on our Tradeweb investment. Gains in Fixed Income, Investment Banking and the Private Bank were partly offset by weaker revenues in TTS, Corporate Lending and Securities Services. Loan hedges also dragged on the quarter, with $431 million of mark-to-market losses as credit spreads tightened. Throughout the quarter, we kept witnessing robust engagement from clients right across our institutional franchises, and we've been busy assisting them in steering through these uncertain times; within TTS, we kept collaborating with clients to keep their operations running, handle their supply chains and fine-tune their working capital along with liquidity. Momentum in our digital initiatives remains evident, shown by impressive gains in CitiDirect users and in digital account openings, which deepen our ties with clients even further. Over in Markets, volumes hit records as we stood by our clients, drawing on our Citi Velocity platform and electronic execution capabilities; much like in the first quarter, we actively made markets for corporate as well as investor clients while assisting them in navigating volatile macroeconomic conditions. Within Investment Banking, clients are still concentrating on where short-term and long-term liquidity comes from and goes. We kept extending new loans and arranging extra draws for clients aiming to strengthen liquidity; even so, we witnessed sizable repayments, resulting in the sequential drop in end-of-period loans within Corporate Lending; and we keep assisting clients in reaching capital markets, which produced additional share gains. I want to highlight that our underwriting of investment-grade debt jumped 131% compared with the same period last year, since we continued helping customers obtain liquidity through this changing landscape. Turning now to results by business, starting with banking. Banking revenue overall was $5.7 billion, up 4%. Treasury and Trade Solutions brought in $2.3 billion, which represents an 11% decline as reported and a 7% drop in constant dollars, because strong client activity and consistent deposit growth were outweighed by weaker interest rates and lower commercial cards revenue. In constant dollars, our average deposits rose 30%. We saw healthy growth in instant payments and API volumes, and cross-border flows performed well even with the significant macroeconomic downturn, and all of this gives us confidence in the fundamental strength of the franchise. Investment Banking revenues hit $1.8 billion, up 37% from last year, beating the market wallet and marking the best revenue quarter since the financial crisis. Results mirrored robust growth in debt and equity underwriting, partly offset by M&A. Private Bank revenues totaled $956 million, up 10%, fueled by greater capital markets activity plus higher lending and deposit volumes, partly offset by reduced deposit spreads. Corporate lending revenues were $646 million, a decline of 11%, since higher volumes were more than offset by narrower spreads. Total Markets and Securities Services revenues reached $6.9 billion, an increase of 48% year-over-year. Fixed Income revenues amounted to $5.6 billion, growing 68%, driven by strong performance in rates and currencies, spread products and commodities. Equities revenues of $770 million dropped 3% versus last year, as solid cash equities performance was more than offset by weaker revenues in derivatives and Prime Finance, mirroring a tougher environment. And then last, in Securities Services, revenue declined 9% as reported, and 5% when measured in constant dollars, since greater deposit volumes got more than outweighed by narrower spreads. Total operating expenses came to $5.9 billion, rising 7% from a year earlier, because efficiency savings got more than outweighed by greater compensation costs, ongoing investment, and growth driven by volume. Total credit costs reached $3.9 billion, climbing substantially versus last year. We added roughly $3.5 billion to reserves during this quarter. That reserve build stemmed from shifts in the economic outlook, along with downgrades within the corporate loan portfolio over the quarter. At the close of the quarter, our overall funded reserve ratio stood at 1.71%, which includes 4.9% on the noninvestment-grade portion. Further detail on the corporate portfolio appears in the appendix of our earnings presentation. Total nonaccrual loans rose $1.5 billion quarter over quarter, which mirrors the present environment, with approximately half of that rise originating from smaller-sized exposure. On the whole, we stay vigilant in how we manage the portfolio and reserve levels against the stresses visible today. Slide 10 presents results for Corporate/Other. We brought in $290 million in revenue, a big drop from the prior year. That decline reflects legacy assets winding down and rates sitting lower, though it was partly cushioned by an AFS gain along with favorable marks on legacy security as spreads narrowed during the quarter.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

Costs came down a bit, since the runoff of older assets was partly balanced out by greater infrastructure spending, plus extra expenses tied to COVID-19, along with a pretax loss of $343 million for the quarter, which mirrored loan loss reserves on our legacy portfolio and reduced revenues, partly offset by reduced expenses. Slide 11 illustrates how our net interest revenue and margin have been trending; measured in constant dollars, total net interest revenue reached $11.1 billion this quarter, a drop of $580 million compared with a year earlier, mirroring the effect of reduced rates and smaller loan balances, partly offset by greater trading-related NIR and the better mix in Branded Cards that I referenced earlier. Looking sequentially, net interest revenue fell by about $250 million, largely mirroring the reduced rate environment, partly offset by greater trading-related NIR and the lack of an episodic onetime item. Net interest margin fell 31 basis points from the prior quarter, with reduced net interest revenues accounting for approximately 1/3 of that decrease and the rest coming from balance sheet growth, mirroring a rise in liquid assets, driven by greater deposits as we served our clients' needs while also reinforcing our own liquidity amid the current environment. Moving to noninterest revenue. During the second quarter, robust trading and investment banking results produced a substantial year-over-year gain. As we turn to the third quarter, we anticipate that both net interest revenues and noninterest revenues will fall year-over-year, mirroring the effect of reduced rates and diminished activity tied to COVID-19, along with a normalization in investment banking activity. Slide 12 presents our key capital metrics. Our CET1 capital ratio rose to 11.5%, chiefly mirroring the reduction in risk-weighted assets. Our supplementary leverage ratio rose to 6.7%, chiefly mirroring the advantage of the temporary relief provided by the FRB. And our tangible book value per share dipped slightly to $71.15, mirroring the debt valuation adjustment, DVA impact to OCI as Citi's credit spreads tightened during the quarter. During the quarter, we also got our stress test results, including our preliminary stress capital buffer, SCB, requirement of 2.5%. Combining this SCB with a GSIB surcharge of 3% produces a minimum regulatory requirement of 10%. To sum up, the environment stayed challenging this quarter, yet we kept performing well. We finished the period with a robust capital and liquidity position. Underlying business performance during the quarter stayed solid, and we managed to absorb the sizable reserve build with robust results in our Markets and Investment Banking businesses. Overall client engagement stays robust, aided by greater digital acquisition and engagement. And although our consumer business has been affected by COVID-19-related diminished activity, we have observed a pickup through the quarter. Having said that, we did encounter a sizable headwind from the full quarter impact of the reduced rate environment. As we look ahead to Q3 and the remainder of 2020, our expectation is that conditions will stay difficult and unpredictable. On the revenue line, we anticipate ongoing strain in consumer, which mirrors how rates and reduced activity tied to COVID-19 are affecting things. We'd also anticipate that the persistent low-rate backdrop will keep dragging on our accrual businesses within ICG. For Markets and Investment Banking, results ought to track wider industry patterns; even so, we'd anticipate some normalization compared with the first half. According to our best assessment, we'd anticipate that these headwinds across the back half of the year will leave full year revenues flat to down slightly, as a decline in net interest revenues is more or less offset by noninterest revenues on a full year basis. When it comes to expenses, our focus stays on safeguarding our employees and backing our customers. And we still feel positive about the investments we're making, especially in digital capabilities and infrastructure and control. Even so, we keep looking at every opportunity to run things more efficiently so we can fund those investments and counter the headwinds COVID-19 has created; and on the whole, we continue to expect expenses to be flattish to down slightly for the full year. Now on to credit. Given our present outlook, we do anticipate a greater level of losses ahead. That said, the release of existing reserves ought to offset this. Naturally, how reserves end up in the back half of the year still hinges on the environment versus our present outlook; so in closing, we're getting ready for a variety of outcomes and stay confident in our capacity to preserve our overall strength and stability while continuing to back our customers; with that, Mike and I are glad to take any questions.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#6

Just a fast one about cards. During your remarks, you said you're doing fewer balance transfers and running a tighter credit box, and that this is hitting revenues. Could you size up what share of the book, or remind us what share of the book, is promotional, where that might land, and how much strain we're really discussing on the card side? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#7

Yeah. Mark here. Well, I'd mention a few developments we're observing. Clearly we're steering through a crisis right now; and what we've observed is reduced purchase sale activity, reduced loan volume, and honestly, fewer new card acquisitions, on both the branded side and the retail side; and given that, given the conditions we face, we've pulled back marketing spend, pulled back bal con and similar things. And as you're aware, what occurs is that when you pull back that spending, going forward you don't receive the growth in average interest-earning balances, loan balances, that in the end generate future revenues; and so that remark was only intended to say that while we carefully steer through this crisis, we've had to pull back. We've chosen to pull back that spend. And I believe what matters most is that we switch it back on once this crisis reverses. And that's how we're roughly planning, so we begin to see those promotional balances recover as the economy improves, as GDP improves, as unemployment declines, and we can begin growing those balances once more; so that mix, as you're aware, matters greatly; it will come under pressure while we steer through this, but afterward we want to respond quickly to the economy as it shifts, which honestly differs from how it was done previously.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#8

That's reasonable. Everything sounds cautious, I understand, and I'm sorry if I overlooked this during the prepared remarks. Regarding the reserve build, I realize there are various scenarios and many moving pieces. Still, could you describe where things stood at the close of the first quarter compared with where they stand now, at the close of the second quarter, along with the economic conditions you based the reserves on, so we can make that comparison?

Mark Mason

executive
#9

Sure. Let me attempt to put some dimensions around that, since I believe it matters, first, to sort of grasp our method for CECL modeling. After that, I'll walk you through the variables — the main variables — we applied here in the second quarter in particular. So keep in mind, when we tackle CECL, we must adopt a perspective on what the economy will look like going forward. Our method has been to set up models for the purpose of projecting those reserve levels; and for that we rely on a single scenario. For the modeling, we rely on a base scenario. Beyond that base scenario, which produces the quantitative result in terms of the reserve level, we also apply a quantitative method that produces a management adjustment. That management adjustment exists to reflect economic uncertainty together with the chance of a deeper stress event or a recovery that takes longer. Those 2 pieces therefore matter to the way we set the reserve in both the first quarter and the second quarter. In the first quarter, more — just a few remarks on the second quarter to — to address your question more directly, the underlying economic forecast projected U.S. unemployment reaching a peak of approximately 15% or so during the second quarter, with GDP dropping 35%-plus from one quarter to the next. What matters now is the shape and speed of the recovery, including whether a substantial second wave of the virus appears or how prices affect broader employment, et cetera, and our base scenario has GDP recovering sequentially in the third quarter and beyond and bring, call it, under 10% by the end of the fourth quarter of '20 and then trending down from that through the fourth quarter of '21. Such assumptions essentially presume a possible second wave, though one that remains controlled. It presumes a suitable fiscal response, should one be required, to sustain that pace of recovery, yet substantial uncertainty remains. And that essentially shapes the quantitative method. We then weigh the likelihood of a different downside scenario, and we add reserves accordingly; and so if you consider our total reserves, which appear on Page 20, I believe, which total roughly $28.5 billion in terms of the ACL reserves, that figure includes approximately $2.2 billion or so, $2.3 billion or so in extra management adjustment reflecting the chance of a worse outcome. Alright, so I hope that clears things up. We start with one very specific baseline case, and then we examine a case under more pressure, plus one under significantly greater pressure, and we assign a likelihood to each so we can determine the appropriate management adjustments. That is exactly what makes up the $28.5 billion on the books right now.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#10

Can you discuss a little the timing of when you expect charge-offs to genuinely begin rising? And clearly, you've referenced those sizable reserves, and that might or might not affect earnings in full; but as we consider loss recognition, perhaps you could address when you believe we might begin observing that, along with what peak levels and when; and clearly, it could differ depending on region. So any perspective on those subjects would be useful.

Mark Mason

executive
#11

. Sure. So we are — if you sort of examine what we've disclosed, we still aren't witnessing meaningful NCLs at this point. We still aren't witnessing — there are certain upticks, but we still aren't witnessing meaningful NCLs. We still aren't witnessing substantial rises even within the 30 to 89 buckets; actually, those are falling; so if you examine sort of North America, the 30 to 89 delinquencies dropped quarter over quarter in Branded Cards. Within retail services, those remained fairly flat. In Asia, in Mexico, those fell too, all within our supplement. And part of that stems from, as you're aware, there being government payroll protection programs. There are stimulus checks. There are unemployment benefits. There are all these items that exist in numerous ways to sort of support the economy. And so we still aren't witnessing the stress, so to speak, sort of working through those early buckets. What I'd say is that as we move through the latter half of the year and toward the latter half of the year, we're probably going to see NCLs begin to climb. And we're probably going to see some of that, at least on the consumer side, begin to peak around the middle of next year; but I think what you need to remember is that we're accumulating reserves now around lifetime expected losses. And so to the degree that the forecast unfolds as the scenario would indicate, you'll see those losses climb. And all else being equal, when it comes to balances, you'll also see the reserves drawn upon to cover those losses.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#12

For my second question, I want to stay on that topic. None of us has been through a CECL cycle before—this is our first one. My thinking always goes like this: you accumulate these reserves, and the idea is that when charge-offs come, you pull from them. But built into that logic is an assumption—that losses won't climb beyond whatever amount you've set aside, correct? Take this scenario: losses are rising, yet the broader economy continues to weaken. In that situation, it's genuinely unclear whether pulling from reserves is the right move. What I'm getting at is that reserve draws should line up more closely with increases in charge-offs than they apparently did in the pre-CECL era. Still, my assumption would be that in the second half of this year, say, as charge-offs rise, you won't be tapping reserves just yet — not until you feel sure the macro picture won't turn out worse than the assumptions behind your reserves. Does that sound right?

Mark Mason

executive
#13

To reiterate, every three months, we'll form an opinion about what lies ahead for the economy. So, picking up on what you're saying, should we reach Q3 and find that our projections match those we held when Q2 closed, then we'll assess loan balances — assuming nothing else shifts on that front — and we'll judge whether conditions in the economy will unfold as our scenarios suggest, improve, or deteriorate, and adjust reserves to match. To add to what you asked about, keep in mind that when I walked through how the reserves got set, there's also a management adjustment we put in place — a qualitative method designed to capture part of that uncertainty along with the possibility of an even more severe outcome.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#14

I really don't want to pose one more question about the reserve, but I just want to confirm that we took away the correct points from all of that, Mark. When we consider your present view of the economy, have you finished with meaningful reserve increases? If so, regarding what you're hinting at, ought we to believe that when charge-offs finally begin to appear, they get drawn against your reserves, and you possess a longer reasonable and supportable period than your peers? Also I'm curious, as investors begin assessing banks on normalized earnings, how ought we to think about the end-state ratio of reserves to loans compared with that longer R&S period?

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Yes. Here's how I tend to think about it: obviously — you've heard us mention the uncertainty, an unprecedented crisis. We've adopted a stance on our forward look of the economy and how it unfolds. And that is, in fact, a stance that shapes what we've set up in the way of reserves; right now we're at reserve levels of 28.5%, 3.9% or so of funded, 7% against the global consumer bank in terms of against balances. The ICG at 1.7%, even inside the ICG, noninvestment-grade is nearly 5%, 4.9% in terms of the reserves against the loan balances. We're at reserves where we feel the level — we feel at ease with the level of reserves we hold; but that is, for all the reasons I laid out, connected to the scenario I've laid out for you, a scenario in which we see the meaningful drop in GDP this quarter, yet we also see a recovery sequentially in the third quarter and unemployment begin to fall by the fourth quarter. And so if those things play <<inaudible>> a little bit of room there, I would say, since I do have a management adjustment, then I would expect that the first half would reflect by and large the majority of the reserves we would need to take. And so — and as losses started to play out that we'd be utilizing that reserve in order to cover them. So hopefully, that helps.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#16

Yep, that's useful; and I'll circle back offline regarding normalized reserves. But I wanted to squeeze in my second question. One of your competitors said earlier today that, essentially, trading revenues ought to be halved for the back half of the year when it comes to normalization. And should the same be done for Citi in that same period? And my hunch is this probably applies more to the fixed side than it does to equities.

Mark Mason

executive
#17

Yes. Look, performance in our Markets business has been really strong, and FICC especially came in up 68%. If you take away last year's gain, then that number climbs to almost 90%, slightly under that mark. So the results there were genuinely strong. During my prepared remarks, I mentioned that we expect our Markets revenue and our Investment Banking revenue to normalize in the second half of the year. I think that still holds true for what we're expecting. I also gave some guidance on how to think about our full year performance, and I hope that's useful for modeling how we'll do. I also went over how overall or annual revenue should come in roughly level, perhaps a touch lower, as net interest income falls by an amount that noninterest income mostly makes up for across the year. If you sort of build that into your models, I believe it will capture the normalization I mentioned when it comes to markets, and that will appear in both lines, though a sizable chunk of that normalization will land in the noninterest side.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#18

I've got several things I want to cover, so I'll put a couple out there, and then I'll jump back in line later if that works. But Mike, the statement that really stuck with me was the idea that we're going to be struggling right up until a vaccine arrives, and that could be accurate. Nobody truly understands how this will unfold, but that comes across as somewhat more downbeat than what some other folks have offered in their guidance. And of course, when a vaccine might come is anyone's guess as well. So I'm just attempting to square that remark with — and the reserves look solid. It appears the reserve build in the second quarter is the peak; so it's capturing all of that. On the other side, if we truly must wait for a vaccine — plus you brought up Mexico lacking the stimulus, and we've seen some data after the quarter closed that appears somewhat worse. So I suppose what I'm asking, Mike, is how sure are you that sufficient reserves were set aside by the end of the second quarter, given what you said regarding Mexico, the vaccine, and what has happened since the quarter ended?

Mike Corbat

executive
#19

Absolutely. Thanks, Mike. Let me address what I said about the vaccine. When we consider — when I consider this health crisis, not in terms of particular dates but rather a wide-ranging timeline, in effect, I see it moving through 4 phases: containment, stabilization, normalization and in the end, a return to growth. I'd say that at present, the economy, as we've observed, the global economy, the worldwide health crisis isn't at the same point everywhere. We didn't arrive at it simultaneously. We also didn't get the same reaction from a health standpoint or from a fiscal or monetary standpoint; and because of that, we're going to witness exit and exit rates that differ, and we're actually going to witness the figures when it comes to COVID resurging in certain places in varying ways. I'd say that at this moment, generally across the globe, we sit somewhere between containment and stabilization. Containment means we're able to flatten the curve when it comes to how cases spread. Stabilization means that as we pull back or begin removing some of the obstacles or measures that were implemented, working from home, social distancing, all of those sorts of things that were put there; and as those begin to be lifted, you wouldn't actually see cases return. And once you reach the third phase, which is normalization — and to put it plainly, normalization for me means, am I prepared to board the airliner, am I prepared to ride a subway, am I prepared to enter a crowded venue to watch a sporting event or a concert or whatever it might be. And realistically, I believe, when we reach that third bucket, I simply can't picture it happening; plus, I'd add that plenty of people can't picture it happening either until it feels like there's a vaccine against the virus that's out there for the general public at that point; and therefore, one issue folks wrestle with nowadays is a certain mismatch between the market's position in certain respects and the actual place we're at regarding this health crisis along with all the unanswered questions floating around. So I'm not trying to sound gloomy here. My aim is to be realistic, and my honest view is that genuine normalization requires exactly that. On the latter portion of what you asked, responses have differed in various forms. Health-related responses have differed. Economic-related responses have differed. And regarding your question about Mexico specifically, my sense is that in each instance, those responses came across as rather plain, correct? The dramatic measures from the U.S., the U.K., or certain other governments globally really haven't shown up. It's resembled a business-as-usual reaction far more; and consequently, we're observing that economy getting struck quite severely. Plus it remains, comparatively, at a somewhat early point; and incidentally, that applies not only to Mexico but to much of Latin America and elsewhere on the globe. And when we project growth rates ahead, I believe our current projection calls for roughly an 8% GDP contraction in Mexico going forward. So the economy has taken a blow and will keep taking one. With that said, the steps we've implemented regarding — the risk-based method we've adopted concerning how we've examined and stayed conscious of risk heading into this, I believe, ought to work in our favor; though once more, I suspect the consequences here will probably linger longer in Mexico.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#20

To finish my question, after the quarter closed, coronavirus infections have risen in Florida and Texas, plus we're observing the situation in California. Have your assumptions shifted at all over the past two weeks?

Mike Corbat

executive
#21

Mike, when you mention functions, what do you mean by that?

Mike Mayo

analyst
#22

Sorry, your assumptions.

Mike Corbat

executive
#23

Ah, assumptions. My apologies. Of course, yes. Well, from my perspective, if we're trying to describe what's taking place here, in certain instances, as a revival or a second wave of this, first, I'd say we've witnessed societal shifts as well as changes in behavior, and what we've observed in the States where there's been a revival is, in certain respects, a split within the population. There are those, I believe, who have gone back to the initial protocols from the earliest phase of COVID and what ought to be done, and then there are those who are, I suppose, being far more — for want of a better word — free spirited, or sort of pressing ahead with their lives. You can observe that in spending patterns: although these cases have seen a revival, we've watched spending decline again in certain of those locations, yet it hasn't necessarily dropped back to the reduced levels of the bleakest period of early COVID. The second element there, and it appears in every one of the national health reports, is that demographics have shifted; we were in fact seeing — and some of this might be due perhaps to testing or expanded mass testing — but we are in fact seeing the typical age of the infected group declining. In round one, it averaged within the 50 to 50-year plus bracket. The most recent figures I observed coming out showed the newest cases in the States actually averaging in the mid-30s. So we are in fact seeing a distinct demographic there. And once more, I believe that carries some effect regarding how people react and what spending and what other matters look like. And regarding Mark's earlier comment, Mike, just to wrap up on this, I believe what we're witnessing is that the remarkable measures by the Fed and the Treasury leave not only our models but those of the industry sort of craving additional insight. We've never witnessed this kind of action, whether it's the checks individuals receive, whether it's Payroll Protection, $500-plus billion, whether it's the holiday regarding income tax payments, but we are in fact seeing a consumer in the U.S; that actually sort of enters into this and it isn't entirely even but in fairly good shape. Savings rates have risen. Clearly, spending levels have fallen. Mark discussed a few of the delinquencies and a few of the favorable developments we're observing there regarding the buckets and the roll rates; it's early. But once more, I think as we consider a possible spike back up in certain regions, clearly, over the weekend, stimulus round 2 came on the table. It appears to be bipartisan, and so in all likelihood we're going to get more from that. So once more, I'd say those factors provide us — I wouldn't call it reassurance, exactly, but they do provide us, I believe, a solid perspective, given everything we've experienced regarding the consumer specifically, allowing us to hold up against certain of these shifts in infection rates down the road.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#24

So, in just 10 seconds: the $28.5 billion in reserves you're holding, from where we sit on July 14, accounts for everything — Mexico's 8% contraction, some spending tapering off, a jump in cases, and all the rest that's currently in play. This isn't like the first quarter, when so much was brand new. Is that $28.5 billion your best current projection of future losses under CECL?

Mike Corbat

executive
#25

Yes; and one thing I'd adjust there, Mike — once more, it isn't — we closed in — our stance is as of the quarter's end; it's as of June 30; yet once more, unemployment heavily influences the models. GDP matters to them too; and while we moved through last quarter, running various flashes, those figures shifted; so once more, those inputs drive the models. And I'd guess that as those inputs keep shifting, there will be movement. Still, as of quarter end, we feel good about how we set them and the reserving tied to that.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#26

Mark, you provided solid specifics in those slides, as you mentioned, regarding both the commercial and wholesale portfolios. You also displayed certain migration patterns, like AAA moving to BBB and so forth. Could you tell us what share of the corporate portfolio underwent review and received a downgrade? Also, how frequently must you now examine the portfolio for possible upcoming upgrades or downgrades within it?

Mark Mason

executive
#27

Right. Well, we review the portfolio nonstop, and we've accelerated that pace considerably while steering through this crisis. Clearly — I'd begin by noting that essentially every company, every sector has taken a hit from this. Naturally, certain ones are hit harder than others. Regarding sectors responsible for a sizable chunk of the reserve build we've recorded, I'm thinking of aviation, energy, autos, commercial real estate somewhat, plus retail and retailing, and together those likely accounted for 1/3 of the build we witnessed. We did observe notable downgrades during the quarter, and you heard me mention noninvestment-grade reserves standing at 4.9% of loan balances. Thus we're vigorously examining the portfolio, as you'd expect. We're reviewing both the 80% investment grade and the 20% noninvestment-grade portions of our balances, and we're making adjustments appropriately, and we'll keep doing so throughout the quarter and keep working through the whole book. For context, roughly a couple of thousand names played a part in generating those downgrades. So there are substantial names and substantial review and assessment that we undertake during the quarter.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#28

Great. Moving on, as a second question, turning back to the consumer slides, you shared the assistance programs being provided to certain clients — you might label it forbearance — across credit cards, mortgages, and so forth; this has two parts. Is there a method for you, Citigroup, to determine the share of those clients who lack jobs yet collect boosted jobless payments, given that delinquency levels throughout your portfolios and those of competitors remain quite low, and one possible factor is that these jobless benefits are so advantageous for those without work? Can you somehow isolate the greater-risk segments within these forbearance categories that might ultimately become charge-offs later this year or in the next?

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Yeah. Well, we're always, once more, examining the portfolio. When it comes to particular jobless data, that is something we can access while dealing with our clients and going over their individual credit metrics; so that we don't possess; we do possess, as you're aware, the initial signals of both clients who — who utilized forbearance worldwide and the — and them continuing to pay. Thus we have — considering it worldwide, 40% to 60% of clients who were — who are signed up for the consumer relief initiatives keep making payments, and they are contractually required to do so, nearly 50% in Branded Cards and 40% in retail and once more, elevated figures across the globe. That's a favorable signal that individuals are gaining from the initiative and taking those advantages and directing them toward their obligations. And the other key figure that I believe is a solid sign and likely moves somewhat nearer to what you're attempting to grasp is that initial enrollment numbers have dropped considerably. Although we provide reenrollment, the rates are coming in under what we expected. They're roughly in the mid-teens, if you will, or approximately that level, and beyond half of all enrollments that have fallen away so far, and more than 80% of those stay current. Consequently, we're observing encouraging signals of those exiting enrollment continuing to stay current, which we consider a favorable sign. Having said that, we've mentioned it a few times during this call, there remains some unpredictability, a fair degree of unpredictability out there regarding how this situation keeps changing, yet solid forward-looking signals among purchase sales, among reenrollment figures, among ongoing payment, both within and outside the programs.

John McDonald

analyst
#30

Mark, I was hoping you might go into a bit more detail regarding what we can expect from consumer revenues. You brought up the prospect of ongoing top line strain there. I'm just curious — it sounded like perhaps things are getting somewhat better in Asia. Your revenues fell 15% for the quarter, yet it sounded like there might be a slight uptick there. With Latin America, I couldn't tell. So perhaps you could just flesh out a bit what you're anticipating when it comes to consumer revenues, both internationally and here at home?

Mark Mason

executive
#31

Yes, absolutely. So here's the thing — I believe we will keep encountering strain when it comes to that consumer revenue line. And I believe that, as you're aware, if we consider — if you simply break it apart really fast, within the U.S., for our Branded Cards and our Retail Services, those unemployment figures matter enormously as signals for those operations. You already know what those figures are. We've witnessed — although purchase sales have gotten better, they remain down within the 20s compared to a year ago; therefore we anticipate that loan activity there will stay under strain and so — consequently, the top line for the domestic consumer business will remain under strain too. In the same way, when I consider Asia, for instance, over there we have a sizable card business. Our focus there is on the wealth segment. Once again, purchase sales remain strained over there. The character of that card activity leans toward travel, and Mike spoke about the possibility of travel bouncing back and how that might appear going forward. Therefore we would anticipate ongoing strain across Asia. Likewise, the insurance operation there is strained given the face-to-face interaction it requires, and the same goes for Mexico, simply because of the slowdown in GDP. So I believe consumer will keep facing some top line strain. I believe the fundamental signals there remain solid for us when it comes to deposit growth, when it comes to client engagement, when it comes to digital access and usage of what we offer. And so we have solid signals, among them investment AUMs in Asia, that indicate encouraging developments as we emerge from this period. But while we navigate through it, top line strain is going to be there.

John McDonald

analyst
#32

Regarding Latin America, can we wrap this part up?

Mark Mason

executive
#33

Sure. So specifically in Mexico and Latin America, like Mike mentioned, we continue to face GDP-related strain occurring later in the cycle when it comes to handling or navigating the COVID-19 pandemic. Employment in that region will probably remain under some strain; therefore, my expectation is that there will be revenue challenges for consumer operations in Latin America, especially Mexico, while we move through this period. Having said that, I'm encouraged by our current standing. During certain earlier quarters, we began to modestly reduce our lending operations. From a reserves perspective, I believe our position is strong. Additionally, thanks to investments made in previous years, I think we're set up to keep building momentum there once Mexico bounces back from this.

Brian Kleinhanzl

analyst
#34

Great. Perhaps a fast one for Mike. I realize Hong Kong has seen plenty of shifts, still a major portion of your portfolio; and regarding the operations there, has anything changed in the way you consider that business and how you view it going forward, to begin?

Mike Corbat

executive
#35

Yes. Brian, I'd say, first, when we consider the region, Hong Kong alone isn't enough to focus on. I believe a somewhat wider perspective is necessary; and the term I'd choose is that it's complicated, correct? We have the mix of a sideline trade deal with China. There's the interplay between China and Hong Kong. There's the recent announcement or creation of this new national security law, which is, I think, rather specific when it comes to calling out financial support regarding China against its sovereignty with significant penalties around that. So I think we must keep all those in mind. From where we stand, we've been in Hong Kong quite a while; it's a key location. It serves as our Asian hub as we operate in a number of countries there; and I'd mention a couple of key points about that. First, we follow local laws. Second, our aim truly is to be there supporting our clients and that we're quite accustomed to operating in charge for complicated environments. And as part of that, I think we have found both the Hong Kong government and the HKMA and others very supportive of our business and our approach. And at the same time, we have, I think, gotten the same support from China and haven't, in any way, kind of gotten restrictions or other things from them; so clearly, it's something we watch very carefully. It matters to us. But clearly, we're dedicated to being there and clearly are tracking things closely.

Brian Kleinhanzl

analyst
#36

All right. Let me ask something else. Mark, you said there was some pressure in retail services coming from partner payments. So have those elevated partner payments now been fully reflected in the run rate? Or should we anticipate that they will rise going forward? And what exactly were they?

Mark Mason

executive
#37

Sure. As you're aware, our retail services partner business is made up of a number of partners, and under many of these arrangements, profitability is shared — meaning there is a contractual split of profits between the partners and us. We determine that based on our outlook in any given quarter for the rest of the year. So we estimate what we believe profitability will be, and then, clearly, we reflect the portion that goes to the partner in the revenue line. That profitability estimate leaves out ACLs, so the reserves we have been building. It does include any NCLs that we realize. So it's important to note, again, that when we calculate the lifetime reserves we are building, even though we will share them once they become losses, that is excluded from the profitability estimate. So basically, what has occurred, and what has driven part of the drag in retail services, is that we have seen the losses we expect from retail services move beyond roughly 2020. As I said earlier, we see good signs in some of the early buckets; and because of that, our view of when those losses will actually come through as NCLs has been pushed into 2020. As a result — '21 — sorry, 2021. Consequently, the 2020 profitability view for some of these partners has increased; and therefore, the amount shared has gone up, which puts pressure on the top line. To address the other part of your question, we believe at this point, based on our view for the rest of the year, that we have accounted for the level of profit sharing we would expect. But as things change, we would need to adjust accordingly.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#38

So Mark, I'd like to revisit CECL and hear how you see the stickiness of those reserves once charge-offs begin to occur, and also, I suppose, the readiness to let reserves go, since I believe all of us have been zeroed in on builds, when does the peak arrive and there's been less attention paid to the rhythm and speed of releasing reserves and reductions in reserves as actual losses begin to show up. And, well, as you're aware, CECL sort of operates in reverse. Each quarter, you have to ask — you project what lifetime losses will be across your portfolio, your charge-offs, and then sort of derive a plug through the loan loss provision. So I'm wondering, with all the uncertainty that we are — that still surrounds us and that we'll probably keep experiencing, whether once charge-offs begin to appear in, say, the fourth quarter or early next year on a more material basis, whether there's a kind of bias toward keeping reserve levels quite elevated and not really releasing reserves, because even if we're not — even if releases aren't occurring or we aren't building reserves while charge-offs occur, that might suggest provision and credit costs stayed rather high for some time. So I'm wondering what you — do you believe there will be a kind of reluctance or a natural tendency to sort of wait it out and see a bit more stickiness in reserve levels until we gain greater clarity on everything happening in the world.

Mark Mason

executive
#39

I believe it mostly hinges on what our outlook is at that moment during that particular quarter. I mean, there simply — there's no alternative way for me to sort of put it. When we reach the — we're now in the third quarter. As we move through the third quarter and the fourth quarter, we'll possess a view, one that looks ahead. And should that forward-looking view remain significantly uncertain or deteriorate relative to the second quarter, then we'll probably have to keep adjusting reserves in line with that. Should that forward-looking view improve, we can — or stay the same, for that matter, it will back the release activity you're referring to. And that's how I think about it. And I think that's probably how it will play out.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#40

All right, understood. And perhaps, since we're drilling down on that point — if your economic baseline, which I realize you're only relying on for a single instance near-term, hasn't shifted, or has even improved somewhat, yet you're still facing substantial uncertainty and a wide spectrum of possible results, several of which are considerably more negative, my assumption would be that your qualitative adjustments will account for that in one manner or another — is that the case, and is that already captured?

Mark Mason

executive
#41

Correct. Correct. So here's how we currently approach the qualitative component: we'd set aside roughly a 15% probability that the recovery turns out weaker or more delayed, correct? That carries consequences, or an implied elevated jobless rate, and so forth; therefore, should we see conditions improving, we would essentially assemble that probability, if you will, in order to modify how we view the management adjustment that ought to be applied.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#42

Starting off with costs. Mark, throughout this year you've managed to keep things impressively steady, staying within that range of $10.4 billion to $10.5 billion. During the first half, revenue came in $3 billion higher while costs stayed level. I also caught your earlier remark that from this point you anticipate maintaining a fairly flat trajectory. But since we're probably going to see revenues drop in the second half, could you discuss what flexibility exists for bringing the cost base down, considering what you said about taking care of staff, putting money into technology, and all the ups and downs around pay and headcount?

Mark Mason

executive
#43

Absolutely. Thanks; a few points come to mind. First, like I said during my prepared remarks, my expectation is that for the whole year our expenses will stay approximately flat, and that's essentially the target we're working toward, even as revenues come in flat to somewhat lower. When you consider everything we're handling amid this crisis, there are numerous moving pieces. We're facing certain headwinds across several areas, such as the steps taken to take care of our staff, expanding what we can do around collections, and strengthening how we detect fraud—all of which I believe matter for getting through this crisis thoughtfully and responsibly—plus sanitizing buildings and making sure employees can work remotely with the necessary equipment. Every one of those items carries a cost, and those were costs we hadn't budgeted for this year. Naturally, certain tailwinds exist too. For instance, marketing spending has been reduced, as you heard from me. Travel and entertainment costs are down since folks are using Zoom far more instead of flying out to see clients. So those tailwinds provide some offset. Yet on balance, looking at those expenses, we do face headwinds. On top of that, there are investments we'll keep making: spending on technology; spending to strengthen our digital offerings, which have shown real value while navigating this crisis; and spending on infrastructure and controls so that we safeguard the franchise while also boosting operational efficiency and enhancing data quality, and so on. Beyond that, we have productivity programs and other levers that naturally move along with revenues. That means compensation costs will shift as needed. Transaction costs will shift based on the volumes we observe, and we'll keep achieving our productivity savings through right placement and cutting the number of centers and similar actions; so yes, levers exist, but substantial headwinds exist as well, and that's roughly how I arrive at that outlook of approximately flat as we get through this particular year.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#44

Understood. For my follow-up, regarding capital: during this year, the advanced approaches have constrained you somewhat more on CET1, since advanced RWAs have run slightly above standardized. That gap is roughly 20 basis points. Yet once we move into the SCB framework, is there anything you can do to improve advanced RWAs relative to the standardized method? And how significant a priority would that be?

Mark Mason

executive
#45

Yeah. Well, we are involved in — a major driver of what's pushing the advanced — the downgrades tied to the crisis we're working through; that element will probably remain in place for some time, and we are actively managing and optimizing the balance sheet to find ways to affect or lower those risk-weighted assets and help in the calculation here of CET1 and — yet that's the headwind we must deal with; what I would note now is that the regulatory minimum for CET1 under both standardized and advanced is approximately 10%; therefore on an advanced basis we stand at a ratio, as Mike and I have mentioned, of 11.5%. That leaves us still 150 basis points above that regulatory floor, which we believe provides room to navigate this stretch of uncertainty and a variety of possible outcomes. It also leaves us room when you consider some of the further stress analysis the industry is facing. So yes, advanced. Yes, a side effect of the crisis we're in. Yes, we're always seeking to manage it effectively where that's sensible and where we can keep serving our clients in a manner that's excellent for the franchise.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#46

Mark, could you perhaps help us break down a bit how we should think about where NII is headed? How do you — deposits moving toward safety have proven stickier than I'd have expected, and we're still watching deposit growth. What assumptions are you making, I suppose, regarding growth on the balance sheet and NIM? Where do you think NIM will hit its floor? That sort of detail would, I believe, be useful for grasping your assumptions next to ours.

Mark Mason

executive
#47

Yes. So look, we sort of noted during my opening remarks that we clearly had a NIM drop of roughly 31 basis points from one quarter to the next. That reflects, once more, a mix of reduced rates, the shift in loan mix we've observed — meaning fewer NAM cards and more ICG within that mix — plus the balance sheet growing, which truly mirrors the robust deposit growth and the strong liquidity standing we hold. So as I consider that pattern, we will probably keep seeing, as I said, strain on our cards, lending activity worldwide. We'll probably keep seeing rates affect certain banking operations of ours, operations such as TTS and similar ones; consequently, I believe we'll keep facing some strain on the NIM line in the quarters ahead. Yet again, I'd direct you back to the overall revenue projection I provided, since clearly other elements are at play there in returning to flattish to somewhat lower.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#48

Understood, that all makes sense. I was simply wondering whether you're working from an assumption that the balance sheet stays roughly flat or that it expands further. Of course, I've caught what you've said regarding certain of the pressures, and I'm merely attempting to determine what your base case assumption for the balance sheet happens to be.

Mark Mason

executive
#49

Right. As for the balance sheet, we'll observe that there will probably be a certain amount of growth in it, yet client demand that we observe out there will be what drives that, along with our capacity to satisfy it, though from a GAAP asset standpoint we will probably witness some ongoing expansion in the balance sheet.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#50

All right. And to piggyback on that regarding capital. Mike, do you believe — circling back to what you said before — that a vaccine has to be visible before banks can feel confident enough to go back to repurchasing shares? Or is it simply a matter of needing slightly more macro data that's steady? How are you weighing a return to buybacks, considering where your capital stands? Clearly, it's not possible during Q3, but past that point.

Mike Corbat

executive
#51

Yeah. My view is that it comes down to what we observe and anticipate ahead from an economic standpoint, and clearly, what's happening across the economy — consumer as well as institutional — and the way we're forecasting losses and loss rates down the road. And whether we're at ease with how the pandemic is progressing. And applying my time line, do we sense that we're at some point within that stabilization shifting toward normalization, correct? So here, I believe there's a concern that when the weather turns colder — though maybe Florida and Texas and others have now put that to rest. But come autumn, perhaps a resurgence emerges and certain of these metrics jump. I think we would want to witness this subside and feel some reassurance that we have the capacity to hold it down and that, once more, we gain a clearer picture. I don't know exactly what the new normal looks like, but we gain a clearer picture of normalcy, whatever form that takes, coming back to the worldwide economy.

Charles Peabody

analyst
#52

A few things about your capital — specifically your tax situation and what it means for your capital. To start, with the stress test, my understanding is that the CARES Act gave some capital relief tied to your tax position. Is that accurate, and could you quantify it? Then, second, down the road, if tax rates go up, like Biden has proposed, what would the boost to your CET1 ratio be? And last, Jamie Dimon seemed this morning to suggest he'd be eager to get buybacks going again at some point in Q4, once the election is over. I'm wondering whether you view buybacks as something regulators control or something political.

Mark Mason

executive
#53

All right. On the CARES Act, yes, there's a benefit there. For us, I wouldn't call it material to the CET1 ratio, though I can't give you that precise figure right now; as for the tax rate and the possibility that taxes get rolled back, there will be a lot of pluses and minuses involved, among them the effect on the DTA and other items throughout the company. So I'm sorry, I don't have the exact calculation for that, but we can definitely follow up with you on it.

Charles Peabody

analyst
#54

Even so, wouldn't you need to record billions of dollars of write-ups on your NOLs? Am I right about that?

Mark Mason

executive
#55

Such adjustments as that one would be necessary — I'd have to, we'd have to make several of them, and they would increase capital. Yet there are additional...

Mike Corbat

executive
#56

But Mark, I was going to...

Mark Mason

executive
#57

Please, Mike, you first. No, you go.

Mike Corbat

executive
#58

What I'd add, Charles, is that another factor you've noticed affecting our tax rate comes from how wide-ranging our operations are — we haven't really gotten the same advantage that institutions focused mostly on the U.S. have enjoyed. So once more, what applies to us is a mix between domestic and foreign. And with that rate climbing once more, my view is that returning to a worldwide taxation approach isn't likely. A territorial approach is what we'd keep, and relative to certain American peers, that would in all likelihood work in our favor on a comparative basis. Turning to the last thing you raised, my read is that when the American sector chose to move forward and halt buybacks, politics played no part. We did it, in our judgment, out of caution — it seemed like the correct course, with no idea what lay ahead as we entered this period. My read today isn't that politics is involved. My read is — and as the Fed has put it, the decision will in the end rest with us to return and bring buybacks back when the moment is appropriate. And once more, as we mentioned when answering earlier questions, we'll keep watching that; and once conditions are right, we'll be in there again filing so that buybacks restart, or rather get underway.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#59

A couple of things, and I'll be quick. First, Mexico. A few years ago, as I recall, you put roughly $1 billion into infrastructure down there. So has that spending wrapped up, is it done? And is it baked into the run rate at this point? Or is that a pool of money that could be freed up and used for other purposes? Basically, I'm asking whether it's an efficiency opportunity.

Mark Mason

executive
#60

Yes, so we did announce an investment some years back. For the most part, we've moved past it. I believe we're at around — maybe 80% or so of the way through deploying those funds. Whatever remains functions as a lever for us that we weigh when making these kinds of decisions; and bear in mind, that money went toward building out and improving our technology, branches, digital capabilities, and similar areas. So I'd say those investments have clearly paid off, but we're mostly past that stage, and the remainder is there for us to toggle as needed.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#61

Okay. Then, turning to the U.S., can you update us on how things stand with the push to increase deposits there? Obviously, I can see that deposits rose during the quarter both domestically and abroad. But my focus is really on the consumer segment; you'd announced partnerships with American Airlines and Google, so I'd like to get a sense of where that strategy stands; and do you believe there's anything more you can do to lift consumer deposit growth in the second half of this year and into the next?

Mark Mason

executive
#62

Yes. We've seen extremely strong consumer deposit growth, pardon me, throughout the quarter. I believe we gained from the investments made in our digital capabilities. As you've observed, digital deposit sales expanded significantly, reaching as much as $12 billion by the time the quarter closed. And we keep seeing those gains materialize both within our market and beyond it, which, as you're aware, has been central to our approach of making sure we draw on the reach of our cards customer base, which has a wider U.S. presence than our retail banking footprint does; and so we continue to watch the strategy's benefits unfold. Part of that is driven by some of what I referenced earlier regarding the stimulus that's out there and the delay in terms of tax payments. Even so, we've managed to capture upside from both new and existing clients, and we anticipate continuing to do so through the rest of the year. I'd also point out — I know your question concerned consumer specifically, but I would also point out that we're likewise seeing very good continued traction on the institutional side within our TTS franchise. And that growth is in many ways a result of what we've seen and done in working very closely with our corporate clients to bolster their liquidity positions, whether it was early on when they drew down their own lines or during the quarter when we partnered with those same clients to access the capital markets, we've been sort of that partner of choice, that flight to quality on both the consumer side in the U.S. and internationally as well as the institutional side.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#63

Yeah, I understood institutional performed exceptionally well. I simply wanted to know whether, within that, the consumer side has additional space to pick up speed and push things ahead going forward.

Mark Mason

executive
#64

Sure. Regarding the consumer, that's visible in the U.S., in Mexico, and in Asia. Consumer growth has been robust everywhere across those regions, and we're happy with what we're seeing here. Mike, anything you'd like to add?

Mike Corbat

executive
#65

Right. The other thing I'd add, Betsy, is that this lines up really well with what we've discussed before — out of that $12 billion Mark brought up, two-thirds, and that's a fairly steady figure for us, originates from beyond our branch footprint, something we clearly focus on because of how our branch model works.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#66

about 2/3 of the increase in consumers originating beyond the branch footprint?

Mike Corbat

executive
#67

roughly 2/3 of the digital expansion originates beyond the branch footprint.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#68

Let me make sure I've got this right — you're not steering us toward positive operating leverage for this year, Mark? Since before, you mentioned expenses would be flat to down, and after that you described them as flat. And it seems as though you're — I realize COVID costs are substantial and make this a hard year, but — so there's no positive operating leverage in this year?

Mark Mason

executive
#69

I'd say again what I mentioned before: revenues are somewhat lower and expenses are pretty level, correct?

Mike Mayo

analyst
#70

All right. So I suppose — regarding the stock side of things, your firm wasn't involved to the same degree as some rivals; walk me through the reasoning here. I mean, during March you saw those corporate drawdowns. Then the fixed income markets took their place. And at this point, perhaps we're seeing a shift back toward equities with more equity-related activity, and one of your competitors posted a significant increase in equities. You mentioned a normalization in capital markets. Are you anticipating that equities will get better? Do you acknowledge that underperformance? Is it simply a matter of timing? What's your thinking there?

Mike Corbat

executive
#71

Right. What I'd say is, first, let's sort of divide this business into a handful of separate buckets. So first, I'd say our performance in cash trading was solid. It was robust. And I'd add that, once again, it's still early to tell, but we underperformed in both Prime and Delta One — Prime Finance, Delta One derivatives. Looking at it from an equification standpoint, if you dig into the figures for our capital markets, you'll find a really strong result in ECM, where our ECM business rose 56% compared with the prior year. So when it comes to the capital raising side, we were pretty active in most of the prominent deals that got done; and so, once again, cash trading, fine. We'll see how things shake out, but weaker performance in derivatives, Delta One, Prime Finance, alongside a robust result when it comes to ECM.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#72

So, just a wrap-up question. During this call, the value of your shares declined. You're lagging the BKX. That's only a single day. I realize equities fluctuate — don't overanalyze it. But I believe there's a sense I'm picking up that perhaps you're being more realistic, pragmatic regarding what's actually happening out in the world, and that connects to what you said about the vaccine. You're observing something particular to your business that makes you warier. Or perhaps I and others are simply taking your remarks too pessimistically. And I bring that up since, when you discuss the revenues, the NIM fell 31 basis points. It continues to drop further. You brought up that customers are under strain, there are reduced partner payments within retail services, ICG is moving back toward its typical level, and TTS is taking a blow from decreased rates. You're not going to see favorable operating leverage, and there's also the matter of expenses and loan losses. On top of that, Mexico is coping with COVID. We're sitting at a point that's only partway between containment and stabilization, and there won't be any buybacks for a while yet. So taking all of that together — that sums up several of the downside items you laid out on this call. Maybe that came out by accident, or maybe it was deliberate. Either way, this is kind of a last chance—either to balance things out with something encouraging, such as digital banking or deposit growth or along those lines, or to come out and say, "Honestly, I'm among those who think this will be a lengthy journey," and perhaps you're not aligned with everyone else.

Mike Corbat

executive
#73

Mike, let me start by making clear that being negative isn't what we're aiming for. My sense is that we're all facing this together. And I'd definitely say the things we don't know are greater than the things we do. If anyone happens to own a crystal ball, I'd be glad to take a look at it. That said, based on what we're observing and what we've already shared about getting through 4 extremely difficult months—the first half of 2020—with revenue climbing 8% while expenses held steady, plus our capacity to take on substantial reserve builds under CECL's new framework and the wide-ranging involvement we're seeing from our clients, I believe the numbers will keep showing, as they come into focus, that we're still gaining market share. We've kept adding to our capital. We've kept adding to our liquidity, and we feel really good about our position and about how we're heading into the back half of the year. There are things we simply can't predict, and we have no way of knowing them. Within that uncertainty, we're observing flare-ups in areas that had previously seen declines, only for numbers to rise again. Approaches differ across the U.S., and they've varied internationally as well. So once more, I'd say we enter this feeling quite confident about our position. Still, we don't want anyone hanging up from this call with the impression that everything globally is wonderful and that we're experiencing a V-shaped rebound. From where we sit, a V is on its way. A U will arrive. A W will arrive. Whatever shape it takes, our organization needs to be prepared to manage all of them. And I believe you've observed throughout our businesses that although revenues have faced pressure in some areas, we've navigated this quite effectively up to now. I'm genuinely proud of the team for what they've accomplished. But once more, nobody, in my view, should walk away from any bank's earnings call this quarter thinking the worst is completely over and a rosy road lies ahead; so feel good about where we stand. The environment remains uncertain. The steps we've taken thus far have been exactly right, and I believe we're well positioned for whatever comes next.

Operator

operator
#74

That wraps up our review of earnings for the second quarter of 2020 today. We appreciate everyone for joining in. You're free to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.