Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 13, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 99 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello everyone, and we appreciate your presence on this call. Joining us today is our CEO, Mike Corbat, who will kick things off. After that, Mark Mason, our CFO, will walk you through the earnings presentation, which you can download from our website, citigroup.com. Once that's done, we'll gladly answer your questions. Before we begin, please note that this presentation might include forward-looking statements. These are grounded in management's present expectations and are vulnerable to uncertainty and shifting circumstances. Actual results, capital, and other financial conditions could differ significantly from what's stated here because of numerous factors, such as the precautionary statements mentioned in our discussion today and those in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 2019 Form 10-K. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Mike.

Mike Corbat

executive
#2

Liz, thank you, and greetings to everyone joining us. Our Q3 2020 numbers were released earlier today. We recorded $3.2 billion in net income, which works out to $1.40 per share. Our navigation of the COVID-19 pandemic continues to be remarkably strong. Credit costs have stopped rising, deposit balances continue to increase, and revenue is up 3% year-to-date. As all of you know, consent orders with the Federal Reserve and the OCC were signed by us last week, and after I take you through how our business and financials performed, I'll address what we're doing about them. The institutional clients group continues to produce exceptional results. Investment Banking had yet another powerful quarter connecting clients with the capital markets, and private bank revenues are now up 9% year-to-date. Even though interest rates were much lower, Treasury and Trade Solutions — the foundation of our worldwide network — declined only 4% in the quarter and 5% for the year on a constant-dollar basis. Trading also performed well, as fixed income climbed 42% and equities gained 18% year-to-date. Revenues in global consumer banking remained strained by the economic consequences of the pandemic, largely driven by a drop in credit card spending. At the same time, deposits continued to rise significantly, credit costs declined, and we observed more investment activity from our wealth management clients. Taking everything into account, our global consumer banking franchise has shown resilience in the face of the obstacles we confront. Our capital position got stronger during the quarter, with the common equity tier one ratio rising to 11.8%, comfortably above the 10% regulatory minimum. Tangible book value per share rose to $71.95, a 4% increase from a year earlier, and we stay dedicated to giving capital back to shareholders as time goes on. Now to the consent orders, which center on four areas affecting our risk and control environment: risk management, data governance, controls, and compliance. What connects these areas is the necessity of modernizing our infrastructure, governance, and processes. We've had remediation programs running, and although we've made headway in these areas, we're simply not where we need to be. While that outcome isn't what we hoped for, we remain committed to addressing every problem identified in those orders and to transforming our bank. Many of you are aware that we've already begun reorganizing our structure and accelerating our spending. Program management now sits in one central function, and we've taken lessons from the rigorous root cause reviews that independent consultants carried out. Our team is laser-focused on eliminating steps that require human handling, bringing automation into our workflows, and ensuring that reliable information is available without delay whenever management or regulatory reports are generated. Even more critical, we are elevating the reinforcement of risk and control practices and the pursuit of operational excellence to the level of a strategic firmwide priority moving forward. Fixing this is going to take real time and real effort. We have to dig deep into where the gaps are, so that what we build actually fits the problems in front of us and carries us to where we need to land. The total price tag isn't something we can pin down yet, given that this work will stretch across several years, but I can tell you plainly that we're committing whatever people and tools it takes, all while continuing to deliver for our customers. Equally important: on the question of how long this takes, we and our regulators see it the same way, which means we won't cut corners on doing this properly or doing it fully just to get there sooner. All told, putting this money to work will do more than just reinforce the strength and stability we already have — it will lay the groundwork for digital systems that sharpen our operating efficiency, boost our ability to compete, and substantially upgrade the quality of service we deliver to our clients and customers. That means these outlays aren't optional; in hindsight, we should have acted sooner and prevented the situation from getting to where it is now. Even so, this company has made tremendous strides over the past several years — shedding balance sheet risk, improving how efficiently we run, and lifting business results — all aimed at narrowing the performance and return gap between us and our rivals. What we're built on is solid, steady, and safe. The way we performed through this pandemic demonstrates that the strides we've taken toward excellence in risk, controls, and operations are what Citi needs to move forward to its next chapter. Committed, capable individuals form our franchise, and they make us proud daily. Whatever has been requested of them, they have delivered, and I'm confident they will keep doing so going forward. Change is what fuels this transformation as we approach the February transition, and every member of the management team is dedicated to bringing Citi where it must be and accomplishing that properly. Having said that, Mark will walk us through the presentation, and afterward we'll gladly take your questions.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Thanks, Mike, and hello everybody. If we begin on slide three, Citigroup's net income for the third quarter came in at $3.2 billion, and that figure factors in a slight build in credit reserves of about $300 million during the quarter. The reported numbers also reflect the $400 million civil money penalty tied to the consent orders Mike referred to earlier, and that reduced EPS by $0.19. Revenue for the quarter totaled $17.3 billion, down 7% versus the same period a year ago. Trading and investment banking are still performing well, but that strength was more than outweighed by the combined effect of lower interest rates and reduced activity levels in consumer. Expenses rose 5% compared with a year earlier, since we keep putting money into infrastructure that supports our risk and control environment. Credit cost came to $2.3 billion, which is considerably lower than what we saw in the first half of the year. Our effective tax rate for the third quarter stood at 20%. Turning to results for the year to date, we generated net income exceeding $7 billion, even while adding roughly $11 billion to credit reserves. Revenue rose 3%, mainly reflecting ongoing strength in our markets and investment banking businesses, while expenses were up 1% versus a year ago, which let us produce positive operating leverage along with a 6% gain in operating margin. Measured in constant dollars, end of period loans fell 4% from a year earlier to $667 billion, which reflects a greater volume of repayments across institutional and consumer, plus a deceleration in draws within our institutional businesses, and reduced spending activity in consumer. Deposits increased 16% amid steady client engagement, reflecting what our global platform delivers across both the institutional and consumer franchises, which also helps reinforce our available liquidity; and with three quarters of the year behind us, we keep managing effectively through this crisis, with substantial capital and liquidity, along with a sizable cushion in the form of credit reserves. At September 30, our CET1 Capital ratio stood at 11.8%, nearly 200 basis points above the regulatory minimum requirement. We hold more than $950 billion in available liquidity; we have over doubled credit reserves since the close of last year. As of today, they total almost $29 billion, and counting the slight build taken this quarter, our reserve ratio held roughly steady at 4% on funded loans; and as we noted last quarter, we feel good about our capacity to keep supporting our clients as we all navigate this crisis. On slide four, we give further detail on reserving action taken thus far this year. As a reminder, these reserves incorporate our estimate of lifetime credit losses linked to a specific base scenario, along with a management adjustment for economic uncertainty, which leaves some room should a more adverse outcome occur. During the first quarter, our base scenario assumed a short lived downturn followed by recovery in the back half of 2020, with unemployment dropping to 7% by year end, and full year GDP near prior year levels. As we reached the end of Q2, our base case envisioned a downturn that would be both more severe and longer-lasting in the current year, followed by a steeper rebound in the next one. What you can observe now is that we anticipate a recovery that is somewhat softer and more gradual for both unemployment and GDP all the way through 2022. That said, I'd point out that when we look ahead on a rolling 13 quarter basis at unemployment, just to give one illustration, the picture keeps getting better as we put more distance between ourselves and the worst point of the crisis. The outlook for additional variables such as VIX and oil prices matters too, and on the whole those improved during this quarter. Consequently, taking everything together, the shift in our base macro outlook this quarter did not produce a meaningful effect on reserves. That said, we increased our management adjustment for economic uncertainty, which went from $2.3 billion up to $3.1 billion over the quarter, partly offset by reduced loan volumes along with several other minor items. As of today, we are building in a downside scenario that is worse than what our base case assumes. To illustrate, we are now including a considerably larger decline in U.S. GDP growth rates, which for 2021 sits almost 9% below our base case, whereas in our Q2 outlook it had been merely 1% below the base case; so holding everything else constant, had the management adjustment stayed the same, we would have recorded a reserve release of approximately $500 million during the quarter. When we look at how much in reserves we're carrying right now, we feel we are thoroughly positioned for anticipated credit losses, since what we've reserved for is worse than our base case. What's more, because of the lifetime character of the CECL methodology and the cautious character of our management adjustment, it is now more probable than not that reserve releases will occur and our ACL will decline in 2021, offsetting losses down the road as we keep working our way through the crisis, provided our base case proves correct. That said, this could be partly offset, since we would probably have to set aside extra reserves to cover loan growth later on as the economy mends and we meet our clients' requirements. Now let's move to each business. Slide five presents the constant dollar results for global consumer banking. GCB posted EBIT of $1.4 billion. Although revenues are still strained, credit costs fell substantially this quarter, which mirrors a modest ACL release, along with reduced net credit losses, especially in the U.S., where the benefits of government stimulus and other relief continue to show up. Revenues dropped 12%, since ongoing robust deposit growth and momentum in Asia, wealth management were outweighed by diminished card volumes and reduced interest rates throughout every region, while expenses fell 2%, as decreases in volume related expenses, cuts to marketing and other discretionary spending, and efficiency savings were partly offset by higher COVID-19 related expenses. Slide six provides more detail on the results for North American consumer. Total Q3 revenues of $4.5 billion came in 13% lower than a year ago. Revenue for Branded Cards came in at $2.1 billion, a decline of 12%, driven by reduced purchase sales and a lower average loan balance. Industry-wide, purchase sales kept recovering through Q3, rising 16% from the prior quarter, though they remain 9% below where they stood a year ago. Meanwhile, payment rates are climbing as consumers stay liquid, and we haven't yet observed strain on their overall capacity to pay. So even though purchasing activity has picked up, our clients are paying balances down faster, which puts pressure on loan balances. That creates a revenue headwind, yet it also helps cost of credit, since delinquencies and losses came in better than what we initially projected for 2020. Retail services posted $1.4 billion in revenues, down 21% compared with a year earlier, driven by lower average loans and larger partner payments. Net interest revenues fell 16%, as average loans dropped 10% amid reduced purchase sales activity and higher payment rates. Much like Branded Card, purchase sales bounced back sequentially in the quarter, up 18%, but were still 8% lower year-over-year. Increased partner payments accounted for the rest of the revenue decline versus a year ago, reflecting the effect of lower loss expectations in 2020 and, as a result, greater income sharing. In the quarter, we rolled out a new digital credit card program with Wayfair.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

Through this collaboration, our portfolio has become more diversified thanks to a top e-commerce retailer, and in 2020 we now serve consumer credit card programs for 5 of the 10 biggest U.S. e-commerce firms. Retail banking revenue came to $1.1 billion, a 2% decline versus a year earlier, since robust deposit growth and stronger mortgage income were outweighed by narrower deposit spreads. Deposits averaged a 19% increase, which included 26% growth and checking; digital deposit sales kept gaining traction, with over two thirds originating from customers beyond our branch network. And we'll keep seeking ways to strengthen ties with those customers, among them via our digital wealth investments. North American consumer total expenses fell 3% compared with a year ago, as we controlled marketing and other discretionary costs while capturing efficiency savings and lower volume-driven costs, which outweighed added COVID-19 related expenses. Credit cost overall was $1.2 billion, a 23% drop from the prior year, driven by reduced net credit losses plus a modest reserve release. Slide seven shows international consumer banking results in constant dollars. In Asia, revenue fell 13% versus a year earlier in the third quarter. Cards revenue dropped by 23% because of reduced activity, with purchase sales down 17% year-over-year. Asia card revenue keeps feeling an outsized hit from reduced travel spending, among them lower travel-related interchange and foreign transaction fees. That said, the strength in our wealth business continued. This quarter, investment revenue reached an all-time high, rising 16%, driven by consistently high levels of client engagement, and we saw a 7% increase in Citi gold clients along with 13% growth in net new money compared with last year. Average deposits also grew at a healthy 13% pace this quarter. Turning to Latin America, consumer revenue overall declined 10% from a year earlier. Just like in our other regions, Mexico posted good deposit growth this quarter, with average balances up 13%. However, deposit spreads remained under pressure, and lending revenue took a hit from branch closures as well as the continued deterioration in the macro environment. For our International consumer segment, total operating costs were down 1% during Q3. That came from greater efficiency, cost savings, and reduced expenses tied to lower volumes. Meanwhile, cost of credit decreased to $392 million. The improvement reflected fewer net credit losses along with a small reserve release in the quarter, which stemmed from a change in how we account for third party collection fees. You can find additional information about worldwide consumer credit patterns on slide eight. As we noted before, credit patterns were largely stable or somewhat better this quarter, supported by abundant liquidity within the U.S., lower spending, and advantages from relief programs. That said, we still expect losses to begin rising in the coming year and likely reach their highest point around late 2021, as government stimulus and similar programs come to an end while unemployment remains elevated. Now to the Institutional Clients Group on slide nine, ICG posted EBIT of $3.7 billion this quarter and $10.8 billion year-to-date. Third quarter revenues came in at $10.4 billion, up 5%, driven by robust results in fixed income and equity markets, investment banking, and the private bank, though that strength was partly offset by weaker revenues in TTS, corporate lending, and security services. During the third quarter, we kept witnessing robust client engagement throughout all of our institutional businesses, thanks to our highly differentiated global platform, the strides we've made in building new digital solutions for clients, and our full service model, which lets us capture the natural linkages that exist across the franchise. Turning to how the businesses performed, and I'll start with banking. We brought in $5.3 billion in total banking revenues, which works out to a 2% decrease. Treasury and trade solutions posted $2.4 billion, falling 6% as reported and 4% in constant dollars — strong client engagement and healthy deposit growth simply couldn't make up for lower interest rates and weaker commercial cards revenues. On average, our deposits grew 26% in constant dollars, and we recorded solid growth along with positive underlying drivers even with the major macro downturn. Instant payments offer one good example of the client engagement we keep seeing: we're now live in 26 countries, and client demand for these capabilities has been considerable. On the investment banking side, we brought in $1.4 billion in revenues, which is a 13% increase compared with last year. That reflects solid growth in capital markets along with continued share gains. Capital Markets is still extremely strong — equity underwriting especially — and that let us keep supporting our clients as they raised liquidity through IPOs, convertibles and follow on offerings. At the Private Bank, revenues came to $938 million, up 8%, driven by robust client engagement, particularly in capital markets, as well as improved managed investments, revenues, and higher lending. On the corporate lending side, we brought in $538 million, which is a 25% decline. The reason is that although we did more volume, that was outweighed by tighter spreads. We're still originating new loans and helping clients with additional draws, but we also had a lot of repayments come through because we assisted our investment grade clients in tapping the capital markets, and that's what drove the drop in loans at period end. For total markets and security services, revenue came to $5.2 billion, up 16% compared to the same period last year. Just like we did in the two previous quarters, we're staying active in making markets for our corporate and investor clients, guiding them through what remains an uncertain landscape. In Fixed Income, we saw $3.8 billion in revenue, an 18% increase, powered by solid results in spread products and commodities. In equities, we brought in $875 million in revenues. That's a 15% increase compared with the prior year. Cash equities and derivatives delivered solid results, driven by strong client volumes and market conditions that were more favorable, though lower prime finance revenues offset some of that. And then in security services, revenues declined 5% as reported, or 4% in constant dollars, since higher deposit volumes were outweighed by lower spreads. Operating expenses overall came to $5.8 billion, up 3% from a year earlier, which reflects our ongoing investments in infrastructure, risk management and controls, plus higher compensation costs. Credit costs came in at $838 million in total, a meaningful increase versus the prior year, though they dropped considerably compared with the previous quarter; reserves added during this quarter amounted to $529 million. The main driver behind the rise is the ongoing lack of clarity around where the economy is headed. At the close of the quarter, our funded reserve ratio overall stood at 1.8%, which includes 5.7% on the non-investment grade piece. Net credit losses totaled $326 million. Last, non-accrual loans on a total basis fell by about $400 million from one quarter to the next, landing at $3.6 billion, which mirrors write-offs and repayments throughout the portfolio. Results for Corporate/Other appear on Slide 10. Compared with the same period last year, revenues dropped sharply. That decline came from winding down legacy assets, the impact of reduced interest rates, and valuation marks on securities. On the expense side, the decrease from legacy asset wind down was outweighed by outlays for infrastructure, risk management and controls, plus additional COVID-19-related costs and the $400 million civil money penalty we mentioned earlier. Excluding that one-time penalty, corporate/other recorded a pre-tax loss of $657 million this quarter. As for the fourth quarter outlook, we expect a pre-tax loss roughly in line with that figure. Slide 11 lays out the trends in net interest revenue and margin. Measured in constant dollars, net interest revenue totaled $10.5 billion this quarter, a $930 million decline from a year earlier, driven by lower rates and smaller loan balances, partly offset by greater trading related NIR.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

Looking at things quarter over quarter, net interest revenue fell about $670 million, and that came from smaller loan balances plus reduced trading-related NIR, while net interest margin dropped 14 basis points, which mirrors those lower net interest revenues. Now moving to non-interest revenues. During the third quarter, non-NIR was down 2%, landing at $6.8 billion, because of softer consumer activity, though that was partly offset by robust trading and investment banking revenues compared with a year earlier. When we think about the fourth quarter, we anticipate these same dynamics continuing, with net interest revenues and non-interest revenues both falling versus a year ago, which reflects lower rates, reduced activity tied to COVID-19, and the normalization in trading and investment banking activity; on slide 12, we lay out our key capital metrics. Our CET1 Capital ratio rose to 11.8%, helped by net income, our supplementary leverage ratio came in at 6.8%. And tangible book value per share increased 4%, reaching $71.95, also driven by net income. Before wrapping up, let me take a few minutes to discuss what we expect in the fourth quarter. On the top line, we anticipate continued pressure in consumer, reflecting the impact of rates and reduced activity tied to COVID-19. And we would also expect the low rate environment to keep weighing on our cool businesses within ICG. Our markets and investment banking businesses should track broader industry trends. Altogether, we expect this to produce full year revenues that are approximately flat, with the drop in net interest revenues more or less offset by non-interest revenues across the full year, in line with prior guidance. When it comes to expenses, we stay focused on protecting our employees and supporting our customers. We are making targeted investments in the franchise where we see the best opportunities ahead. And we are speeding up investments to achieve excellence in our risk and control environment and to enhance our operations for a fully digital world. Consequently, we could see expenses rise a couple percent or so across the full year. Now on credit. As I said earlier, if our macro outlook holds, we wouldn't anticipate further reserve builds. But with the uncertainty that remains, we are also unlikely to record any material releases this quarter; and in the fourth quarter, we would expect losses at a level comparable to what we saw this quarter. To sum up, conditions stayed difficult this quarter, yet we keep performing well. Year-to-date, we have shown the considerable earnings power of the franchise, we finished the quarter with a strong capital and liquidity position. Overall client engagement remains strong. We grew book value this quarter, and we have stayed focused on supporting employees, customers, clients and communities; with that, Mike and I are happy to take any questions.

John McDonald

analyst
#6

Hello, and good morning. Mike, I simply wanted to pose your question regarding what we've taken away from the consent order and the requirement to put money into this area. I suppose what I'm asking is, what kept these problems from being handled sooner? Did we, did we misunderstand what the regulators were looking for? Or was it simply that the focus and manpower of management were required somewhere else? And you hadn't gotten around to it yet? Am I coming through?

Mark Mason

executive
#7

John, Mark here, am I coming through?

John McDonald

analyst
#8

Yeah, my apologies. Is this coming through for you?

Mark Mason

executive
#9

Yeah, we got it. I believe Mike's microphone might be on mute — you've muted it.

Mike Corbat

executive
#10

Oh, is this coming through?

Mark Mason

executive
#11

Yep, yep, you're coming through now.

Mike Corbat

executive
#12

Okay, apologies for that. Sorry about it. So, John, what I was getting at is that throughout roughly the last 10 years, I believe we've put in substantial effort toward getting this company ready, from a money standpoint as well as a strategic one. We've also made quite a few bets in spaces we considered essential. And that won't stop — we'll keep making those focused investments. Mark discussed the coming stage of our transformation at the Barclays Conference. And when we consider that, operating the way we do has always been our emphasis. Still, I'd admit our pace hasn't been sufficient. Once more, if you reflect on COVID and how we got through it, I take real pride in what we accomplished and managed to pull off — and clearly it isn't finished. Along the way, we launched several major remediation efforts to shore up our controls, our infrastructure, and our governance. Having said that, we moved too slowly, and we need to pick up the pace. That's absolutely where our attention will go. Regarding what people ought to expect and how we'll tackle this, there are essentially 4 pillars we'll concentrate on. The first is the organizational piece. You've already witnessed movement there with the creation of the Chief Administrative Officer role and the recruitment of Karen Peetz. I believe we're building and establishing a structure for how we'll proceed. Then there's the strategic piece, which really means settling on the ultimate vision for our processes, and — crucially, as I mentioned at the start — we've engaged outside parties to assess what must change and where we came up short. It also means ensuring our efforts align throughout the whole company. So rather than just fixing one particular problem, we solve things comprehensively. Behind that, I'd point to an operational piece — ensuring that with areas such as data and technology, we push the right automation, remove manual touch points, and handle the other matters we've mentioned. And significantly, the fourth piece is culture — ensuring every business, every region, every function grasps that getting this right falls on all of us. So John, I'd say the issue was never a shortage of hard work or dedication, though I would say we definitely could have found smarter ways to reach that finish line.

John McDonald

analyst
#13

Alright, that answers my question. Now I have something else for Mark. Mark, clearly the consent orders mean more costs and investment over the next few years. Do you believe you can still close that profitability gap with peers? Is that still something you're aiming for? And if big M&A or portfolio acquisitions aren't possible, could there be chances to trim down and streamline the company as time goes on, which might boost profitability? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#14

Thank you, John. The response — yes, it is. What we aim to do is keep reducing that gap, keep boosting profitability, and enhance returns as time passes, so nothing there has shifted. Each — each crisis brings, in certain respects, a special chance; and that special chance is to really examine your business model, and you notice companies everywhere needing to work through that while they navigate this crisis, and in the same way, we'll do so, helped by a new CEO coming in, and while steering through this crisis, we'll keep reviewing our business model, keep reviewing our strategy, and determine what's appropriate once we emerge from this, and how we can most effectively seize chances to serve our clients.

John McDonald

analyst
#15

All right, thank you. Just one brief additional question. Do you have clarity on which purchases or portfolio increases would count as significant, as opposed to what happens in the normal run of business? Or does that remain something yet to be pinned down?

Mike Corbat

executive
#16

That remains to be pinned down. Still, certain items are plainly business-as-usual — securitizations, for instance, along with other sorts of things we carry out in various sections of the franchise. Even so, we've yet to settle on what counts as significant and to secure the regulators' blessing on it.

John McDonald

analyst
#17

All right. Thanks.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#18

Hello there. Perhaps just one brief follow-up. Good morning. A short follow-up regarding the Consent Order. Will those expenses sit within Corporate/Other rather than inside the businesses? And tied to that, is it your understanding that once the group exits the capital return suspension, you'll be free to act on the capital return front just as any other bank would?

Mark Mason

executive
#19

Yes, of course. On your first question, as I said earlier, incremental spend of more than $1 billion is what we're putting out in 2020. Depending on what the spend is for, that gets divided between Corporate and certain other businesses. My expectation is that moving ahead the dynamic stays similar, and again, based on what the spend is for, it would land in Corporate/Other or within one of the respective businesses. A quick illustration: some consulting spend we undertake, which is intended to help define a vision or scope out a key process, for instance, would probably be booked in Corporate/Other, since it benefits the whole franchise. That's just one illustration. As for capital actions moving ahead, nothing in the Consent Order stops us from making decisions on capital actions, or from taking those decisions going forward. So as we emerge from this crisis, we'd anticipate being able to act the same way our peers do.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#20

Thanks for that. If I may, a fast question about cards. In Asia and Mexico, you're down by double digits — actually, considerably more than double digits — but taking the business overall, could you break down how much of that you attribute to the macroeconomic climate and to some of the factors you've already mentioned? The reason I ask is that what we're trying to figure out is what gets us to the point where things stop falling and then start climbing from that floor. That also covers your marketing approach — specifically, what you're doing with promotions and teasers generally, given the macro picture, and how you're marketing to the banking customer base. Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#21

Sure. Well, there are several distinct forces at play here that I'd flag as significant. The main one, which you identified, is that we remain in the middle of a crisis. As a result, we continue to observe considerable strain on purchase sales. Conditions have improved relative to earlier quarters, yet strain clearly persists. We're noticing this throughout the franchise. A major negative factor this quarter, as you can see, is retail services; part of that relates to the partner and revenue-sharing arrangements we have, because when the forecast for loss expectations improves, the result is that we end up giving a larger share of revenues to our partners. Still, the force worth monitoring as all this unfolds is the path of unemployment and GDP, and what that translates into when it comes to purchase activity beginning to rise. That will matter a great deal. We're tracking it carefully; we've reduced advertising and marketing spending, along with various other items, and we intend to be deliberate about the moment we step back in once we detect indications of a turnaround. So we're watching it closely. Being late is not something we want. We'll act aggressively to pursue opportunities where it's sensible and run tests where we believe encouraging signals justify boosting some of that spending to generate the future volume activity we anticipate. But at this moment, volume pressure remains. It's genuinely a direct consequence of the crisis we're working through.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#22

Thanks, Mark.

Mark Mason

executive
#23

Yep.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#24

Hey, good morning.

Mike Corbat

executive
#25

Good morning.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#26

Morning. Perhaps one thing — a quick follow-up regarding costs. Over the past several years, you folks have managed quite well in terms of putting money into investments while balancing that out through efficiency gains. Clearly, that might not work out flawlessly in the current year, given the added outlay. How should we view this moving ahead? Does this increase begin to level off in the coming year? And can you roughly return to that earlier trajectory? Or what's our framework looking past the fourth quarter?

Mark Mason

executive
#27

Right. So here's the thing — like I said, we have roughly an extra $1 billion in spending during this year, directed at infrastructure, risk and controls. That additional spending course, if you will, began back in 2019. So in some measure, our run rate reflects more money going toward those kinds of efforts. We'll have a chance to examine that outlay, the billion dollars, and readjust it or steer it elsewhere or reorder priorities for it. A portion of it represents spending for a single year that we'll get the chance to allocate once more, so to speak, when we reach 2021, and we'll seize that chance. The order demands, I believe, a highly crucial phase, namely that we pause and establish a goal and a stated vision for certain of these core processes, along with the risk management and controls and compliance surrounding them. I call out that phase, since we must accomplish it to properly size the reordering of priorities for the spending already within our cost structure, and determine what additional spending is required; therefore, we'll carry that out across the timeframe granted to us under the order. This is an investment; I stress that, because a lot of what Mike outlined regarding automation, regarding fewer manual touch points, regarding straight through processing. A great deal of that will produce gains in how we operate our organization, in how we not only enhance our operations, but in how we can reach the market and compete and serve our clients. Thus, I do anticipate gains building up from these investments later on; and we'll set that apart, since I won't sacrifice the funds required to achieve those enhancements and those investments. Setting that apart, we'll keep acting as prudent stewards of the company. Which means making certain we review the entire franchise and confirm — and confirm that our spending is done wisely.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#28

All right, that's useful. And perhaps if we shift over to NII for a moment. I do value the guidance on a year-over-year basis. But considering the current rate environment, at what point and in what place do you expect it to level off?

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Yeah. Well, clearly, a great number of elements were at work during the quarter and across 2020 — not just rates, but also the volumes that came through matter greatly here, not to mention how much liquidity exists in the market and what that does to the balance sheet. Assuming today's patterns roughly continue, my expectation is that for the near term it will settle and remain fairly even as we move through the rest of the year. We're forecasting a bit of near growth in the accrual businesses, with any luck as COVID fades somewhat. That said, as I've mentioned previously, the markets near could be rather volatile. So, as you're well aware, it's somewhat difficult to forecast. But I am watching — we are watching for it to stabilize as we get through the close of this year.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#30

Okay. Thank you.

Mark Mason

executive
#31

Yep.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#32

Hi. My question is for Mike.

Mike Corbat

executive
#33

Good morning.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#34

Mike, you and I have seen eye to eye on plenty regarding how much more resilient Citi has become. From the moment you took the top job, this company has been less complicated, more solid, and better protected, and just look at where the CDS spreads sit. Back when you became CEO, they were 4 times wider, and that counts as real headway. Where we part ways, though, is on how quickly additional restructuring needs to happen. That brings me to my question: where's the urgency? When I talk to investors, to the people I speak with, there's a common sense of deep disappointment about technology, about the new regulatory landscape and tech. The way problems were handled wasn't clear to investors, but it comes down to execution — moving too slowly. You've said this new technology fix will require time when it comes to the business mix. People continue to ask why you keep this global consumer footprint, which has awful efficiency and returns — the worst ROTC in the class this quarter at 8%. Even if we credit you with the 12% from last year, that's still under the 19% JPMorgan posted this quarter by itself; so where's the urgency? Given the better position your balance sheet is in now, yet the strategy still has far to go — wouldn't it make sense to hand things over immediately to incoming CEO Jane Fraser, showing everyone how urgent this really is? Thanks.

Mike Corbat

executive
#35

Absolutely. To begin, Mike, I'd say the board and the company both value having a genuine handover. If you remember, mine took roughly five minutes. Within this process, I promised the board I would remain for the full year and finish the three-year plan we laid out back in 2017. The shift is beginning at this point. In my view, that gives Jane a real chance to be deeply engaged with our financial plan. You may remember that when I came on board, I felt it mattered that the CEO take ownership as we moved into budgeting and planning. My arrival timing worked out well in that respect, I'd say. With Jane joining us, I expect that same ownership to hold true, since she'll be responsible for what gets delivered next year and beyond. I also want to note how significant it is that Jane has picked up the transformation efforts, is handling the gap analysis, and is dealing with other matters tied to the Consent Order. By the way, even with that added responsibility, Jane still keeps a day job running consumers. On top of that, she's supervising how our North American business goes back to working in the office. To me, making this change in an orderly way is the correct move. When it comes to what has been achieved, I value the recognition you mentioned. Still, to keep in mind where things stood when we began, net income climbed from $7.5 billion to more than $19 billion by the close of last year. Return on assets moved from 39 basis points up to roughly 100 basis points. Return on tangible common equity, true, remains below where our competitors are, but it climbed from 5% to 12%. Even so, that helped considerably in narrowing the distance. Back in 2012 we handed back almost no capital at all, while across the most recent six years we've returned close to $80 billion and shrunk our share count by roughly 30%. Personally, I doubt you get those results absent commitment and urgency; the team now in place and how dedicated they are makes me feel terrific. So I believe the progress we've achieved is meaningful. Jane, in my view, has a foundation from which to build. She and the team, I expect, will stay focused on those priorities. Once more, as we exit COVID, as Mark discussed here, or when we emerge from COVID and the conditions around us, there are opportunities they can seize, I believe. They will, I believe, and they'll surely move with that urgency. Shareholders truly count, Mike; you must examine the entire firm, be it pay structure, employees, especially those earning more who receive a large portion through stock or instruments tied to stock, plus the various programs and scorecards closely connected to our performance and to what ideally drives share performance over time. Once again, no single item stands out on its own. I'd argue that nailing those numbers really matters, and I'm confident the board shares that view. The compensation committee, as I understand it, works diligently to create that kind of alignment. And when it comes to disclosure, we've been pretty forthcoming about both the metrics and the scorecard system used to evaluate leadership along with the broader management team here at the company.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#36

All right. Let me try to fit in one final question, and this one's for Mark. Clearly, there's disappointment when it comes to execution, strategy, controls, and transparency, but let's turn our attention to the financial side going forward. On the expense front, Mark, this has already come up, and you're already putting a billion dollars to work. Some portion of that, you view as a one-year outlay. My guess is a review has to happen, so the precise amount needed to resolve these issues isn't something you truly know yet. Still, should we be thinking in terms of billions? We wonder whether $2 billion is bigger than a breadbox. Again, when word comes that this isn't a quick fix or an easy one, and that it's going to take a while, imaginations start running wild. Is the figure $10 billion? Is it $5 billion? Please frame it as best you can, again, keeping in mind that you're only in the early stages of a fuller review.

Mark Mason

executive
#37

Yes. Mike, here's what I'd tell you — look, going back over the years, I believe we've been quite responsible when it comes to managing our investments, and folks ought to expect that we'll stay responsible on that front. My second point is that, as I noted before, these are investments, and in my view they're necessary ones for bettering how we operate and how well we can compete. And we're going to make these investments, right; pinning down an exact figure, as you've pointed out, is difficult. As I said in response to a question earlier, my expectation is that we would — we will keep raising our profitability. We will keep bettering our returns; yet I cannot size the number for you for next year or for the year after, other than to say that we're still running the company; through this crisis, I think we've performed quite well. There's still a crisis we have to manage our way through, and we'll keep doing so while focusing on our clients and responsibly managing our overall financials. Once we have greater clarity on what the actual spend looks like, and once we get through the budget that's in front of us, along with the response to the order, I'm certain I can provide you with more color on that.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#38

Morning, and thanks for taking my questions. So it doesn't seem like Jane is with us on this call, and that's okay. That's not a surprise. But when can we expect to hear from her regarding the transition, and also her thinking on the regulatory matters and how the process moves ahead?

Mike Corbat

executive
#39

Right. I believe we ought to give her time to settle in, work through some of these processes, get up to speed, and begin forming the views I mentioned. So we'll likely bring her onto the January call, perhaps with more of an eye toward what's ahead. Then, clearly, once that following quarter arrives, she'll have the range.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#40

That's logical. And recognizing there may be additional perspectives to consider here; however, right now, when it comes to tackling the regulatory matters, is it simply about allocating capital and repairing the procedures, which you seemed to hint at? There might be certain strategic adjustments. So, do you believe this is the operating model Citigroup will maintain moving forward? Or could there be deeper organizational shifts on the horizon to resolve the regulatory concerns and strengthen the company's standing?

Mark Mason

executive
#41

Yeah. Perhaps I should attempt to shed more light on what was said previously. To put it plainly, as Mike explained, there's a Consent Order we must deal with. And crucially, I believe, when examining that consent order, it gives us a chance to pause and review those essential processes along with the infrastructure controls, compliance work that underpin them. So that represents one key action that we, as diligent stewards of the franchise, plan to carry out, and portions of it are already underway, as noted in the consent orders. Aside from that, what I was hinting at was merely the notion that we find ourselves in a crisis. And while navigating a crisis, you discover things regarding your business; and like I said, we engage with clients constantly. They're discovering things about their own operations as they steer through this crisis; we're discovering things and spotting possibilities within our business, such as the investments we've made in digital have proven to be quite prudent investments as we steer through this crisis. What possibilities exist to speed up that kind of spending moving forward, since the embrace of digitization has likely been pushed ahead by a couple of years now. The significance of revenue mix and expanding our fee base revenue or the momentum that our wealth management businesses are gaining in this kind of setting, opens up possibilities for us to examine ways to grow that part of our business and operating model. So the crisis will generate and has generated a chance for us to reassess. Beyond that, with any incoming CEO, I think one would anticipate a chance for that individual to pause and examine the business we possess, examine the landscape we're operating within, and to evaluate what the correct way forward is considering where we believe the growth trajectory lies, and where we believe the return possibilities are. And so, that's the other component that would Jane arriving in February. I'm certain, she will want to seize that chance and see what results from it. So ideally that makes the point clearer.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#42

Yes. It does. Thanks for the color.

Mark Mason

executive
#43

Yep.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#44

Hi, good morning.

Mark Mason

executive
#45

Good morning.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#46

Mark, I'm sorry, but I'll need to ask you again something you've already fielded a number of times. Maybe this attempt will work out. When we consider savings from productivity against what gets spent on risk management for 2021, is $11.9 billion, or actually $10.9 billion, a reasonable place to start for thinking about quarterly expenses over the coming several quarters?

Mark Mason

executive
#47

Sure. The costs we had during the quarter you mentioned, of course, include a $400 million civil money penalty — that sits within operating expenses as part of it. As for 2021, our plan is still being built at this moment. That makes it difficult for me to hand you a precise figure, or a run rate figure, for you to use in forecasting 2021. So I'm sorry to let you down. Beyond what I've already said in response to that, there isn't much more I can offer.

Erika Najarian

analyst
#48

Thank you. My follow-up is for Mike. Calling out rivals by name is never simple, I realize. Still, picking up on what Mike Mayo asked, analysts like us have been fielding one question repeatedly since that journal article was published: why doesn't Citigroup count as the next Wells Fargo when it comes to regulatory trouble? A lot of investors noticed that your consent order arrived last week, while Wells' asset cap and limits on business activity only landed a couple of years following its own consent order. Setting aside everything you've already fixed, and maybe just peering ahead, what can you tell your existing and would-be investors so they feel confident you won't travel the same grinding path of regulatory remediation as one of your competitors? That path, obviously, could hit business activity restrictions hard.

Mike Corbat

executive
#49

Sure. One really key element there, Erika, is what we mentioned regarding the absence of broad customer harm. Our firm gained nothing from these activities, and that point carries forward. Then there's the second element, which concerns customer harm and related matters — not only Wells Fargo, but the whole industry faced deep examinations of sales practices and similar issues. In this situation, you've observed, and we've discussed, the 4 areas of focus. That's where our time will go. We've been instructed to perform the gap analysis. We've clearly been dealing with this for some time, and we will clearly conduct a thorough gap analysis, yet I believe we need to form a sensible picture. Once more, we welcome whatever findings emerge regarding what must be done. Just as crucially, I think, comes an appreciation of the process failures that brought us to this point. To repeat: no fraud, no customer harm, no gain from any of it. Let me also return briefly to what you asked Mark. A useful frame here: in the past, you've heard us describe how we tackled the expense side — essentially striving to counterbalance the costs we've incurred for some of this transformation effort. What you'll hear from us going forward, and how you ought to view it, is that these are distinct tracks. The remediation effort will cost whatever it costs. Even so, don't conclude from that there isn't still meaningful work we acknowledge we can pursue through business improvement processes. So we aren't tying the two together as though they must offset each other, yet we'll keep pushing on those items to sharpen the company's efficiencies apart from this. The second thing, I'd say—and we haven't given specifics on this, though we have mentioned it—is my belief that this effort, this transformation, is going to deliver an ROI through what it enables us to do and to do in a different manner. We've discussed it from the standpoint of the client and customer: how we bring data together, how we push risk and controls across the organization in a way that's more automated. Our view is that this positions us not only to make the process better, but we genuinely believe that as time goes on, we'll see a return when it comes to the benefits and the costs tied to those, both directly and indirectly.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#50

Hi, good morning.

Mike Corbat

executive
#51

Good morning.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#52

Alright, so perhaps this one is directed at Mark, and it concerns capital. Something that occurred not long ago is that the advanced CET1 has turned into your binding constraint. And a central thing we keep hearing, plus an expectation, was that we'd witness a meaningful rise in RWAs tied to operational risks. It appears that, broadly, there hasn't been a lot of shift when it comes to RWA divergence, and I was hoping you might address whether the effect of recent events is completely captured in that figure? Or might we anticipate additional upward strain during the fourth quarter?

Mark Mason

executive
#53

Absolutely, yes, the — what you're referring to is the civil money penalty. Yes is the answer; our estimates of the impact have been incorporated into the RWA for operational risk connected to that. And simply because of where it lands regarding the level, the size of the effect compared with other operational risks, no material change to the RWA came about because of it.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#54

Understood. Alright, and I have one more question, Mark, tied to what we discussed regarding profitability goals and the wish to narrow the distance versus competitors — that remains your aim. You intend to host an Investor Day this year. It got pushed back because of COVID, and afterward because of the consent order and a CEO change. So does the management team plan to offer updated targets within the next few months? Also, is there any intention to actually hold an Investor Day, which would allow for a fuller update? I realize answering is difficult with Jane absent from this call, but we'd like some sense of how to view the timing for when we might at least receive refreshed targets that let us hold the management team accountable?

Mark Mason

executive
#55

Yeah. Once more, as you noted, that question is a hard one to address. Clearly, I'd want to give Jane the chance to settle into the role and to sort through a few of the items Mike mentioned, which I mentioned before. Clearly, during the fourth quarter — at least, looking back, in the fourth quarter — we've attempted to offer some context regarding not just full year results, but also what we observe in the market ahead. We'll find out how this fourth quarter unfolds. After that, clearly, on the fourth quarter earnings call, we'll provide a revised view of what we believe performance could be in 2021, plus when we can offer a broader picture of how we view matters, how we view matters moving forward.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#56

Hey guys, good morning.

Mark Mason

executive
#57

Hey, Saul.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#58

My apologies — I realize I'm flogging a dead horse once more regarding the consent order and the possible costs tied to applications. Still, I understand it's tough to pin down whether the timeline revolves around this. In terms of getting additional detail, it's obvious you're treating — you intend to treat this seriously and you won't cut corners; yet these sorts of processes can run up costs, and you're required to enhance results over the near term, and afterward comes expense, but also to establish more methodical fixes for operational risk efficiencies, which call for investments over a longer horizon and so forth. So, given all that, how — I mean, at what point do you figure you'll understand what you're dealing with. And by what you're dealing with, I mean, not just the added costs, and I'm not merely referring to items — which in absolute dollars, how much will you need to lay out to resolve these problems and the timeframe needed to resolve these problems? At what point do you expect to have a stronger grasp on the many various facets of this?

Mark Mason

executive
#59

Yes. So allow me to attempt to address this once more. So look, we lay out, roughly $42 billion to $43 billion annually when it comes to total expenses. You've heard me mention, roughly $9 billion of that relates to technology. And perhaps half of whatever relates to sort of compensation. But I bring that up to say that clearly we have a sizable expense base, one that we've handled extremely, extremely carefully across the last several years. And given that expense base, there are a few separate areas that I believe are worth calling out as we consider the added need; so one is the billion plus and added outlay that we've undertaken; and as I said before, the chance to re-spend those dollars, to reorder priorities for, those dollars. There's also outlay that we incur on current operations and infrastructure, that we incur annually. And that as well, I think, will present us a chance to take another look at that outlay, that base, and reorder priorities for that outlay, correct? So there are several categories where we can redirect, so to speak, toward a superior method, so to speak, of tackling what's been called out in the order. And only after we sort of work through the added amount already sitting there, the base that falls away and hands us a chance to re-spend, do we then confront, alright, what additional is needed regarding the investment. Now, a couple of percentage points of an uptick is quite substantial when it comes to absolute dollars that could be directed at these sorts of initiatives. As for the timing — well, let me have one of them. The next point I want to bring up is that, like Mike mentioned, beyond the necessary outlay to tackle the opportunity or the investment and infrastructure risk and controls, we still have chances to examine our data centers, to examine where we need — to make sure people are placed correctly throughout the organization. So our footprint, to examine some of the roll off from certain COVID spending we've had to undertake this year. So there are additional opportunities to examine dollars we have, not to mention capacity adjustments that might be justified as a result of this COVID-19. And so my — what I'm attempting to emphasize is that many puts and takes exist throughout the budget process we're building right now. And the process we'll employ to dimension the spend tied to this order. Regarding timing, the order actually indicates that we have roughly 120 days to pinpoint the gap, a gap between our current state and an end state target. And then roughly 90 days to develop and get a plan approved, after which we can move toward executing or continuing to execute against. And so, that gives you a sense of how we're thinking about the timing and the dimensioning of this; but again, I believe we've got a track record now, as has been noted, of being very thoughtful and responsible regarding investment dollars and our total expense base, and you and others and shareholders should expect that we will stay disciplined and responsible when it comes to that. And again, as I said earlier, we're aiming to improve profitability and returns as we do this, right?

Saul Martinez

analyst
#60

All right, that's useful. And ideally, they'll manage to deliver on that second item. Just one brief follow-up, and it's somewhat more of a routine one. I believe it's really more of a fix or a clarification. Mark, I think during the fourth quarter you said that corporate and other pre-tax losses ought to be comparable to what we saw this quarter, and I <<inaudible>> with no civil fee booked this quarter?

Mark Mason

executive
#61

Sure. So leaving aside that $400 million. What I said was approximately the 657 we're looking at, once you take out the $400 million civil money penalty, is probably going to be the level we see in Q4.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#62

Thank you. Morning. Mark, could we switch to another subject? You said you don't actually anticipate NCOs beginning to tick up until late next year, so I wanted to ask whether that's simply a matter of timing shifting? And could you take us through what you figure the loss curve will look like in general across roughly the coming year? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#63

Yeah, absolutely. So once more, it's — as you review the whole portfolio, payment rates are arriving at levels above what we had projected. And when you consider the stimulus as well as the forbearance programs that have been running, consumers are demonstrating a fair amount of resilience; thus, when we examine loss curves and delinquency buckets, plus what those are indicating, across the coming several quarters, it appears that at the aggregate level, we're likely to see — we're likely to see losses near the fourth quarter or the back end of 2021. Naturally, assumptions regarding GDP, assumptions regarding unemployment, every one of those factors enters the picture. But that is genuinely what we are observing. That will differ across regions. And so in Asia. in LatAm, it's possible we see that sooner, but the back end I was referring to was essentially, when you look at the portfolio in aggregate.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#64

Understood. All right. And could I ask a second question regarding taxes specifically? Clearly, whenever the tax rate decreased, you had to take a writedown on the DTA. And regarding the forward view, based on what is currently known, concerning a possible increase to 28%, contingent on how the election turns out, plus the eventual strategies. Do you have any sense of how a shift in direction could affect the others favorably, whether through the tax rate, and the ability to write the DTA back up?

Mark Mason

executive
#65

Certainly. So it's difficult to predict precisely what will occur, but should we have witnessed, or if we do witness, the tax rate climbing to 28% or thereabouts, and it became effective during the latter portion of 2021. That would probably cause our DTA to grow by roughly $4 billion; meaning a one-time boost to our detail of about $4 billion. And clearly that would mean our rate sitting near that level, our tax rate sitting near that level. Consequently, reduced income because of the elevated tax rate, and reduced income feeding into the CET1 ratio. After that, regarding the disallowed DTA, given a greater corporate tax rate, we would anticipate going back to our utilization levels of approximately a billion dollars annually; so that provides a bit of insight into a few of the shifting components if that were to take place.

Mike Corbat

executive
#66

Mark, one key distinction here, I think, is what emerges regarding whether things stay territorial or shift back toward worldwide taxation. What folks seem to be discussing at present, I believe, is that it would probably stay territorial, and given an average worldwide tax rate around 25%, that would definitely work in our favor in certain places where we do business.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#67

That’s a valid observation. Yep.

Brian Kleinhanzl

analyst
#68

All right. Thank you. First, a quick question about the NII. I heard you mention that it will be stabilizing following the fourth quarter when looking ahead to 2021. But you just described several of the elements that are producing that stability? Then why are you confident that it is truly stable at that level? Did you consider the possibility of stimulus and perhaps additional consumer deleveraging should we receive stimulus in that statement? Thanks.

Mike Corbat

executive
#69

Yes; and so, look, once again, that is that is tied to the sorts of current trends we are observing, which broadly involve better unemployment and better GDP. Clearly, there is discussion of another stimulus regarding its effect; we have assumed that somewhat later, in the first quarter of 2021. It does assume that we keep seeing purchase sales activity improve quarter over quarter. We have seen some of that certainly in Q3. We keep seeing that even in the early days of October. And so that unfolding would be another key element. And then clearly, what occurs regarding the overall liquidity that is in the market is an element that affects mix and the NIM too.

Brian Kleinhanzl

analyst
#70

Alright, perhaps for my follow-up I'll ask about the net interest margin. If we look at what you're earning on assets, would you say you're approaching the peak yields, given where we are in the repricing cycle? And with rates having settled at a low point, are you also anticipating that yields on earning assets are nearing their floor? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#71

Sure. So regarding the NIM, we've clearly felt some of the rate-related pressure. That pressure has shown up in the market, in the composition of our assets, and also from deposit levels that have remained rather elevated paired with, honestly, insufficient loan demand to deploy those funds. Consequently, it depends on how that liquidity sitting in the market develops. What ultimately happens with asset pricing will be a significant determinant there. The NIM essentially results from how those near <<inaudible>> revenues unfold and how the balance sheet changes over time. So there's still a degree of uncertainty regarding how a few of those market dynamics will shake out, though we do expect that to stabilize as we get to the latter part of the year.

Jeff Harte

analyst
#72

Good afternoon, everyone. Sadly, there's another question from me about a consent order. Do you have any sense of where regulators stand on whether the remediation projects already running are sufficient, or whether they simply haven't progressed quickly enough?

Mike Corbat

executive
#73

Sure. What I'd say, Jeff, using my own phrasing, is that they haven't progressed quickly enough and haven't been comprehensive enough. So once more, I believe this gap analysis will help us understand that better. But as I mentioned, we've engaged outside parties to assist us in examining and considering these matters. So once more, we'll find out what the final analysis produces. Still, I think we have a grasp of the proper strategy and course.

Jeff Harte

analyst
#74

So we're not necessarily beginning from scratch?

Mike Corbat

executive
#75

In the broad sense, no. Certain more finely tuned spots might justify doing so, though not on a wide basis. And once more, I believe if you consider, say, the way we've steered through this crisis — which strikes me as a solid, real-world, live trial — again, I think we could obtain the data. We could reach the correct conclusions; we could move promptly. Yet once more, I think this pandemic has revealed to us the quickened shift toward digital, plus the capacity to keep working remotely, or more remotely, as time goes on, and the capacity to reach quicker and superior choices as essential, and especially, as I think rightly our regulators keep elevating the standard for the bigger institutions, when it comes to what they expect.

Jeff Harte

analyst
#76

All right, and here's a more basic question. Citigroup has a fairly big footprint in Mexico, and that's a market where people worry about the macro picture. Could you share what you're observing specifically on the credit side within the Mexican business? And what do you expect right now? To what extent have things such as deferrals provided relief there?

Mike Corbat

executive
#77

Yeah, absolutely. So here's how I'd put it: Mexico, like other regions globally, offered forbearance under the program, but in a difference from the U.S., Mexican customers had to be under 30 days delinquent at the close of February to qualify. And what we observed is this — looking at loss rates across the quarter, there's a modest increase in Latin America, mostly attributable to Mexico, plus the effect of those borrowers moving through the delinquency stages and ultimately into losses. Having said that, Mexico also delivers a higher NIM when it comes to — when it comes to how it performs overall. And for losses in that market, we'd anticipate a peak arriving earlier than the close of 2021. On our exposure more generally, total country exposure to Mexico stands at roughly $57 billion, which is slightly lower than it was in the second quarter. As of the third quarter's end, loans there totaled around $30 billion across GCB and ICG. Within Mexico, 13 or consumer loans are roughly 16 are corporate loans; and of that 13, slightly over half sits in credit card and personal loans. And keep in mind, we aim for a higher-quality customer segment compared with most competitors in that market, and we set pricing for the risk accordingly; so we'd anticipate that working out fairly well. Beyond that, 81% of the payroll loans in our portfolio sit in industries with reduced layoff risk, such as government, employers, and pensioners. That as well ought to help when we consider how solid our book is. Then there's the mortgage piece, and it leans toward LTVs of 50%, under 50%. That also speaks to how sound our books are. So on balance, we believe our reserves are appropriate, and we're handling sensible performance levels there.

Charles Peabody

analyst
#78

Yeah, I had a few follow-ups regarding net interest and the revenue guidance. As we moved into 2021, you repeatedly used the term stabilization. So my first question would be, does that mean we'll see additional softness during the fourth quarter prior to it stabilizing? And then the associated question on page 11, where you display the breakdown of net interest revenue between the core bank and the markets-related piece? There was a significant decline in markets-related net interest revenue. And I was curious whether you could discuss what caused that, and which of those components should be expected to stabilize first?

Mike Corbat

executive
#79

Yes, and just so we're clear, the stabilization I was talking about is essentially as we head into the fourth quarter, and therefore I would anticipate net interest revenue to stabilize during the fourth quarter for Citi overall. And that's due to many of the factors I already listed. Look, markets revenue, as you've heard me say previously, it's truly essential to examine total revenue. Total revenue there matters partly because the way transactions get structured with clients affects whether that revenue arrives as near and non-near. And so, I believe it's extremely important to, as I said, examine total revenue there. And our total revenue this quarter, as you noted, as I noted earlier, is higher when it comes to total markets revenue, given the strong fixed income and the strong equities performance we witnessed there. And so, that portion is below the prior quarter as we observe some of that normalization in markets occurring, yet still quite strong given the environment we're navigating and frankly, as we head into a fourth quarter featuring an election and, in Europe's case, Brexit along with speculation regarding stimulus and uncertainty regarding vaccines, it's difficult to predict precisely how customers and clients will choose to reposition their books as some of those things become clearer. And so total revenue in terms of markets revenue is how we think about it, and a fourth quarter that I believe will show near revenue stabilizing, but bear in mind, markets performance will likely have puts and takes.

Charles Peabody

analyst
#80

For my second question, I'd like to pose essentially the identical thing regarding the split between markets-related NII and core bank. Should we anticipate that core bank NII will genuinely rise from the third quarter to the fourth?

Mike Corbat

executive
#81

Would I anticipate that? Well, once more, my anticipation is that during the fourth quarter, net interest revenues along with non-net interest revenues will each be lower compared with the same period a year earlier. Yet taken together, the two should stay fairly flat.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#82

Thanks for taking my questions.

Mike Corbat

executive
#83

Good morning.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#84

Good morning, Mike. Regarding this entire regulatory matter, reading the consent orders is rather disheartening — the incentive compensation failed to take risk management into account, along with the remarks concerning the practices the regulator has identified. With that in mind, what modifications ought we to anticipate when it comes to senior management incentive comp? Also, could you address why risk management wasn't made a priority, given that it's such a foundation since the previous crisis? And what alterations should we anticipate at the board level, plus among other senior executives, because of this?

Mike Corbat

executive
#85

So the idea of accountability. And I believe what they're referring to extends beyond merely the executive management team. Yet clearly, there are numerous work streams in play here, and a considerable number of individuals are engaged in those processes; and it's essentially drilling down and essentially ensuring that those who bear responsibility for each of those processes receive the suitable weighting. And I believe the difficulty arises because in many of the cases, or across many of the work streams, you in fact have individuals for whom it isn't, it isn't their only role; they are a practicing expert, or an active practitioner when it comes to the markets business, or in consumer, or across various functions. And we have seconded <<inaudible>> them as one element of their duties into performing this regulatory work, since they, they are the expert. They represent the channel through which a number of these matters would move. And the issue is, how do you establish the correct equilibrium and correct accountability surrounding that? So I don't view it and claim that it's executives, only the executive team. I think it's about achieving the correct equilibrium. And so, for instance, ought someone in risk to be accountable for delivering on the financials of the company's profitability expenses, or are there components contained within that? And so I think it's essentially establishing the correct equilibrium to encourage the correct behaviors, produce the correct results and — in people in both directions appropriately. So once more, I think that the manner in which it's drafted, my interpretation is in fact wider than the manner you've characterized it.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#86

So when you look ahead, does that suggest you'll bring in additional staff, in your view, so that certain individuals can be held entirely accountable for this? How are you approaching that going forward?

Mike Corbat

executive
#87

In risk and controls, we've brought on thousands of staff since the year started, and throughout last year we kept adding personnel to these projects. So there's no question we've been supplying those resources, acquiring that know-how, and we've attempted to recruit subject matter experts from other companies and other sectors to assist us in thinking through these matters. I believe we've completed a number of truly crucial, robust external hires. I believe we've executed some quite effective internal personnel shifts, and I also believe we've advanced decisively regarding what I'd describe as individually adding staff, meaning turning this remediation into not merely their top priority but, in numerous instances, their exclusive duty when it comes to execution. So once more, yes, we are fully dedicated to securing the proper resources, the proper expertise, the proper talent, and consequently the proper accountability for performance on this.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#88

And Mike, you might have brought this up already, but Karen Peetz clearly was hired as our CAO, and to assist in a way, to assist in a way with steering this transformation throughout the company. So like you're saying, we're adding the personnel we require and tackling it.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#89

Hi, good morning. Good morning. Yes, so as you just said, Karen came aboard in June. And Mike, I understand you turned into CEO of Citibank USA, pretty much around that June period; so I suppose I'm sort of examining all of this and thinking, you had to have anticipated, you've been dealing with this for some time, and I was, I was figuring you most likely anticipated some form of demand from the regulators, that you were already partly carrying out — is that accurate? Like, could this consent order be a shock to the street, yet is it truly a shock to you?

Mike Corbat

executive
#90

Well, regarding these, regarding these work streams, as we've admitted, we have been addressing them for some time. So it isn't as though, suddenly, we got up one morning and thought, gee, we're going to, we're going to tackle a few of these items as de novo or a fresh project. So we have been addressing them for some time. And I would say that, once more, what we have been centered on is truly uniting these projects. I would say a historic method that we've adopted as we've approached these, in certain respects sequentially or separately, and I don't believe that has produced the results that either I or Citi or regulators would necessarily desire; and so as we proceeded along this route, it grew clear to me and I believe the board and others that we truly needed to merge these processes and establish a body capable of tackling it; and I believe we're quite lucky to have Karen among us who has experienced some of this and possesses this know-how to be able to, I think unite these work streams. Because when you consider data as an illustration, data flows through risk, data flows through compliance, data flows through many of your controls, and ensuring we're adopting a comprehensive method to how we approach and update our data strategy is essential. So that we do it one time, we do it correctly, we do it, we do it comprehensively. And so once more, I don't believe the term for certain work streams is new. I believe the wider, more inclusive, comprehensive method, in certain areas is more recent.

Mark Mason

executive
#91

So Mike, regarding that point about how we've already kicked this off — once again, that extra billion dollars in spending, we didn't just begin that recently; it started at the start of the year, correct. And we also laid out additional dollars back in 2019. And incidentally, that billion wasn't money I held onto — rather, it was our assessment of what's needed to gain as much momentum as possible during the year, and we're putting that additional billion to work while still keeping our overall costs in check. All right.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#92

Yeah, that's a fascinating observation, because when I examine the stock, what I see is a share price that effectively reflects a 5% ROE. Right? And should someone argue that's justified since costs will climb enough to produce that 5% ROE, well, that implies roughly a 5 billion rise in expenses. And Mark, going back to what you said before, you noted that you intend — or at least hope — to carry out this profitability improvement, which clearly sits above 5% right now. So can you walk us through the types of profit gains you believe you can pursue across the coming couple of years? What I'm curious about is, what are the major themes? Is it improved deposit gathering — core deposits that lower your cost of funds? Is it stronger execution among the customers you already have? Is it adding new customers? Give us a sense of how you're approaching this.

Mike Corbat

executive
#93

Yeah, so when you look at it, several pieces make up that picture. We aim to seize extra connections throughout our franchises — for instance, expanding what we do with TTS clients. As I said before, we're experiencing considerable momentum around instant payment capabilities, and likewise doing more linking our capital markets operation with spread products and trade lending for corporate law clients, creating distinctive structuring chances. So throughout the franchise there are linkage possibilities we'll keep seizing, and I believe those will support top line results. We also have room to expand in wealth management, an area where this quarter we recorded 16% growth along with investments in Asia; we believe additional gains remain, we see further upside, and we see more wealth growth potential in the U.S. too. Beyond that come operational gains — again, when we talk about manual activity, substituting improved technology, automation, or straight through processing for that manual work eliminates the manual steps, and doing so raises output quality while making it more timely. Over time it's also cheaper once those manual steps are gone. So as we move into 2021 and 2022 and past that, I'd describe it as better profitability stemming partly from top line gains and eventually expense advantages drawn from many activities, among them capacity adjustments we might choose to make once this crisis ends. Then the remaining items also come into play, such as cost of credit, and so forth.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#94

Thanks. Morning, Mark. Morning, Mike.

Mark Mason

executive
#95

Morning.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#96

Mark, you provided solid specifics regarding the consumer portfolios. Could you also tell us about the commercial side? Looking at those ratings you disclose to us, from investment grade down through BB, B, and CCC, they basically have not shifted much at all since Q4 2019. So could you tell us what you are observing across these portfolios, and whether the energy books along with the leisure, hospitality, and travel books remain the areas where you face the greatest risk exposure—where you anticipate the largest credit losses across roughly the coming 12 months?

Mark Mason

executive
#97

Yeah, yes, absolutely Gerard. Let me begin by noting that, as you are aware, since emerging from the prior crisis, we truly revamped our risk framework and our risk appetite, and we reconsidered our client focus so that we concentrate on clients able to make the most of how broad our offering is, while also concentrating on multinational investment grade style clients. As a result, we have kept a tilt in ratings such that roughly 80% of our portfolio sits among those investment grade names. We possess a lengthy track record of functioning across every sector you can see on page 23. Plus we bring deep cycle-tested experience along with expertise in every one of these industries, and that encompasses client selection. And quite often, we serve as bankers to numerous leaders within their respective industries. And it matters to recognize that, since I believe it reflects not just the quality of the name, but also what we can anticipate while moving through downturns, and it reflects why we remain so dedicated to standing beside our clients and assisting them in navigating the uncertainty. When I consider a few of the sectors we highlight amid this crisis, we have been deliberate regarding how we have handled these clients over time. So if you examine aviation, our exposures in that space are typically secured. They typically—we hold broad experience in structuring to reduce risk in that area, whether secured or backed by guarantees from export credit agencies. We hold broad experience valuing collateral in that area. If you examine autos, in numerous instances the lending occurs through securitization vehicles. Therefore, bankruptcy risk is quite low, with underlying consumer obligors in that scenario. If you examine energy, much of it involves reserve-based lending with borrowing bases subject to periodic redetermination. That assists in lowering exposure whenever oil prices decline. So if you examine these—if you examine our dealings with these clients across these sectors, our deep experience, we believe it places us well to navigate this alongside them. And we certainly feel confident about the reserves we hold. And we have acted proactively. Before the crisis hit, we trimmed our exposures, simply because of the point we'd reached in the cycle. Then, once the crisis began, we moved quickly to downgrade borrowers in affected industries, and we set up tighter oversight. Even so, as I said earlier, we have confidence in the book we hold, confidence in the reserves we've built, and confidence in our capacity to steer these clients through this period.

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#98

Appreciate everyone being here today. Should anything else come up, don't hesitate to get in touch with Investor Relations. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#99

That wraps up this call about our earnings for the third quarter of 2020. We appreciate everyone for joining in. You are now free to

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.