Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 15, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 88 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#1

Thank you, operator. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Before we begin, I want to point out that the presentation we're giving now — which you can download from our website, citigroup.com — might include forward-looking statements. Those statements rest on management's present expectations and carry uncertainty as well as changes in circumstances. Actual results, capital and other financial conditions could differ materially from what those statements suggest, owing to a range of factors, among them the precautionary statements cited in today's discussion and the ones in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 2019 Form 10-K. Having said that, I'll hand things over to Mike.

Michael Corbat

executive
#2

Thanks, Liz, and good morning, everyone. Since this is the final earnings call I'll be on with you, we're doing things a bit differently today. Once I finish my remarks, I'll hand things over to Mark. And before we move to Q&A, Jane is going to share some thoughts about the transformation she has been leading and how she views our strategy developing. So let's go ahead and begin; we closed out a turbulent year on a strong note, with net income of $4.6 billion and earnings per share of $2.08 in the fourth quarter. We finished 2020 with more than $11 billion in net income even though credit reserves doubled because of the pandemic and the impact of CECL. All told, we raised our ACL by $10 billion across the year. As evidence of how strong and durable our diversified franchise is, revenues came in flat versus 2019 despite COVID-19's enormous economic effects around the world. Deposits rose almost 20% as we stood by our clients all year long, and we see considerable franchise value in the deposit base growth we're witnessing. Now to the fourth quarter. Our Institutional Clients Group did well, as it has all year, led by our markets businesses, where revenues climbed 14% compared with the fourth quarter of 2019. Banking posted a 7% revenue decline as Investment Banking activity decelerated and low rates kept weighing on Treasury and Trade Solutions, though the Private Bank stood out with a 6% increase. The pandemic continued to weigh on our Consumer Banking revenues, even though deposits grew in every region. In the U.S., our retail business gained from unusually heavy mortgage refinancing as homeowners found opportunities in this ultra-low rate environment. And digital deposits kept up their momentum. In Mexico, smaller loan volumes put pressure on our revenues. In Asia, card spending fell once more, but wealth management kept performing strongly; we remain very well capitalized with robust liquidity to serve our clients. Our common equity Tier 1 ratio rose to 11.8%, comfortably above our regulatory minimum of 10%. Tangible book value per share climbed to $73.83, a 5% rise from a year ago. And we welcome the Federal Reserve's decision on share repurchases, since we have excess capital available to return to shareholders, and we intend to restart buybacks during the current quarter. With my retirement from Citi coming at the end of February, I recently reviewed some of the challenges we confronted when I took over as CEO; and while there is always more work to do, I take great pride in what the firm has achieved. We are in a fundamentally different place than we were in October of 2012. We've streamlined our consumer business and embraced the shift to digital, so we can serve our clients the way they want to be served; we've reestablished Citi as a go-to bank for our institutional clients throughout our global network. Wherever you are around the globe, our bankers are present at the table when the biggest deals happen; we have fine-tuned our capital foundation, dealt with our legacy assets and cut our DTA by over 50%, creating $7 billion of regulatory capital along the way; we sharply raised how much capital we give back to shareholders. We moved from a $0.01 dividend to handing back more than $85 billion of capital since 2013, and our share count is down 30%. Prior to the pandemic, we had substantially enhanced how good and how steady our earnings were, along with our return on assets and our return on equity. Because of the pandemic, although this year's financial results are not what I would have hoped for in my final year as CEO, in many respects, I could not feel more pride. Everything we did to make our firm stronger helped us make it through this remarkable year. And I take pride in the fact that we have demonstrated our ability to endure a crisis and come out of it stronger still, in contrast with what happened more than a decade ago. For context, let's put 2012 side by side with 2020; in 2020, a pandemic year, our net income was nearly $4 billion greater, our return on assets was 12 basis points higher and our return on tangible common equity was 180 basis points higher than in 2012. That demonstrates just how far Citi has traveled. And we further demonstrated what our firm stands for by serving our customers, our clients and our communities. When the pandemic struck, we became the first bank to roll out an accommodation program for consumers. We set up a small business lending program in only a few weeks' time. We gave these profits to COVID relief efforts, part of $100 million in such grants that we made across the year. And after the murder of George Floyd, we unveiled $1 billion in strategic actions aimed at helping to close the racial wealth gap and boost economic mobility in the United States. As I mentioned, there is always more work to be done. But I feel truly good about the firm as Jane gets ready to take over. She has devoted herself to the transformation we have started in order to strengthen our risk and control environment and make sure the firm runs with excellence in every area. I know she would do all she can to maximize returns and drive Citi forward for the good of all our stakeholders. With that, Mark will walk through the presentation.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Thanks, Mike, and good morning, everyone. I'll begin on Slide 3. Citigroup posted net income of $4.6 billion for the fourth quarter. Revenues fell 10% versus the prior year. Trading stayed strong, but that was more than offset by the combined effect of lower interest rates and reduced consumer activity. Expenses rose 2% year-over-year, which reflects continued investment in our transformation, including infrastructure that supports our risk and control environment, plus higher repositioning costs as we adjust capacity in targeted areas. Credit performance was still strong, with credit losses of $1.5 billion, down both sequentially and year-over-year. For the quarter, credit costs were approximately neutral, as an ACL release of $1.5 billion—largely from improvement in our base macro scenario—offset those losses. EPS was $2.08, and ROTCE stood at 11.4%. End-of-period loans declined 4% year-over-year in constant dollars, driven by softer consumer spending activity and greater repayments in both institutional and consumer. Deposits increased 19%, reflecting steady client engagement as corporate clients built liquidity, plus higher savings rates and lower consumer spending. Turning to full year results, in 2020 we achieved solid performance despite the pricing, with net income exceeding $11 billion, even as we raised reserves by approximately $10 billion. We closed out the year with robust capital and liquidity, and tangible book value expanded over the course of the year. On the top line, although the pandemic hit us significantly, we kept full-year revenues level with 2019, as higher noninterest revenues completely offset the drop in net interest revenues. Expenses rose 2%, matching guidance, reflecting our investment in transformation. The results also reflected COVID-19-related costs and the third-quarter civil money penalty, which were offset by reduced discretionary spending and ongoing efficiency savings. The full-year EPS figure reflects a $0.16 effect from changing how we account for third-party collection fees that were determined earlier — this reverses the net income benefit and raises opening retained earnings by the same amount, leaving capital neutral at year-end. Slide 4 offers more specifics about the reserving steps. Keep in mind that these reserves combine our projected lifetime credit losses under a particular base scenario with a management adjustment for economic uncertainty, which accounts for the chance that results turn out worse. This quarter's reserve release mainly comes from our brighter macroeconomic view. That said, I'd point out that we increased our management adjustment tied to economic uncertainty, since how fast and in what form the recovery takes is still changing. When we look at the reserves we're holding now, we feel we're in a solid position, with close to $28 billion in reserves, equal to an allowance for credit losses of about 4% against funded loans. Now on to the businesses individually. Slide 5 presents the Institutional Clients Group results; during the quarter, ICG posted EBIT of $4.8 billion, which is 30% higher than a year ago. Operating margin was down 5%, as revenues came in lower and expenses rose 2%, driven largely by spending on infrastructure and controls, while credit costs fell sharply owing to a $1.3 billion ACL release. The release this quarter stemmed mostly from a better outlook for global GDP and fewer downgrades across the portfolio. Our overall funded reserve ratio at quarter end was 1.4%, which includes 4.4% on the noninvestment-grade portion. Total net credit losses were $210 million. Turning to the full year, ICG had a strong year, delivering 13% revenue growth, positive operating leverage and a 24% increase in operating margin; however, because of the ACL build this year, ICG EBIT was down 6%. For the entire year, ICG generated a 13.8% return on allocated capital. On Slide 6, we provide a more detailed breakdown of revenues for the Institutional Clients Group. Fourth-quarter revenues fell 1%, since robust trading results were outweighed by weaker revenues in TTS, Investment Banking and Corporate Lending; within banking, revenues were 7% lower. Treasury and Trade Solutions revenues dropped 8% as reported and 6% in constant dollars, because strong client engagement and solid deposit growth were more than outweighed by lower interest rates and reduced commercial cards revenue. In constant dollars, average deposits rose 22%, and despite the considerable macro slowdown we saw solid growth across our underlying drivers—digital adoption increased, cross-border transaction volumes grew more than 10%, and clearing had a record quarter. Investment Banking revenues fell 5% versus last year, since lower M&A and debt underwriting revenues more than outweighed solid equity underwriting growth. Private Bank revenues were up 6%, powered by capital market strength along with better managed investment revenues and higher lending. Corporate Lending revenues dropped 25% on lower spreads, higher hedging costs and lower average volume. Markets and Securities Services revenues overall climbed 13% from a year earlier. Fixed Income brought in 7% more revenue, with gains in spread products and commodities partly canceled out by declines in rates and currency — though I'd point out that FX and global rates both delivered solid results, and client engagement was strong throughout the business. Stock trading revenue climbed 57% compared with a year earlier, powered by solid results in cash equities, derivatives and prime finance, which mirrored bigger client trading volumes and better market conditions; and lastly, Securities Services posted flat revenue as reported, though it gained 2% in constant dollars, since increased activity from new and current clients, together with higher deposits, settlement volumes and assets under custody, was partly canceled out by thinner spreads; across all of 2020, revenue rose 13%, lifted by this year's considerable markets strength plus a healthy contribution from Investment Banking and the Private Bank. All year long, we kept witnessing robust involvement from clients throughout every one of our institutional businesses, since we actively assisted them in steering through this tricky climate — thanks to our worldwide platform, the advances we've made in building new digital offerings, and our full-service approach, which lets us seize the organic connections that run across the franchise. And with the momentum observed this year in key drivers — digital adoption, deposit growth and client engagement among them — we're positioned even better to secure further share gains in 2021, as those clients come to appreciate more completely the advantages of picking Citi as their platform of choice. Turning now to Slide 7 and Global Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. GCB generated EBIT of $1.7 billion. Revenue declined 13%, as continued strong deposit growth and Wealth Management momentum were outweighed by softer card volume and lower interest rates in each region; despite that, we saw signs of sequential stabilization during the quarter. Expenses increased 4% in both North America and international consumer businesses, driven mainly by higher repositioning. Excluding repositioning costs, total GCB expenses were unchanged, since efficiency savings largely offset COVID-related costs. Credit cost fell 45%, with lower volumes and improved delinquencies driving lower net credit loss, along with an ACL reserve release in all 3 regions. And turning to full year results, GCB posted EBIT of $1.1 billion, sharply below last year, mirroring the pandemic's impact and larger reserve builds under CECL.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

On Slide 8, you can see more detail on North America consumer results. Overall fourth-quarter revenues fell 11% versus a year ago, though drivers did show positive momentum during the quarter. Sequentially, revenues rose 3%. Branded cards revenues dropped 13%, driven by lower purchase sales and lower average loans. Purchase sales rose 9% quarter over quarter on seasonal activity and the ongoing recovery in consumer spending, yet they were still lower than a year earlier. Meanwhile, payment rates are climbing as consumers stay liquid, and we have not yet observed stress in their overall capacity to pay. So even though purchase activity has picked up, clients are also paying down faster, which keeps pressure on our loan balance. Retail services top line was down 16% from the prior year, reflecting smaller average loan balances and increased payments to partners. Net interest revenue dropped 12%, with average loans off 11% due to reduced purchase sales activity and elevated payment rates. Similar to branded cards, purchase sales climbed 18% quarter over quarter yet remained under the prior-year figure. The remaining portion of the revenue shortfall versus a year ago came from larger partner payments, which mirrors the effect of fewer losses in 2020 and, as a result, a bigger income share. Retail Banking revenue dipped 1% compared with last year, as solid deposit growth and improved mortgage revenue were outweighed by a narrower deposit spread. Average deposits grew 21%, helped by a 29% increase in checking. Digital deposit sales kept their momentum, rising $2 billion from one quarter to the next. Our wealth management drivers also showed sustained underlying growth, with Citigold clients up 18% year over year and assets under management up 11%. As we close out the year, we're pleased with client engagement: spend activity is still recovering, the fundamentals of wealth management remain strong, and substantial deposit growth gives us room to expand and deepen those relationships ahead as we keep investing in our products and digital capabilities. Slide 9 presents International Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. In Asia, fourth-quarter revenues were down 16% from the prior year. Wealth management keeps showing solid momentum, with investment revenues up 16%, Citigold clients rising 7%, and net new money growing 13%. Average deposit growth also stayed robust at 14%, though deposit spreads were lower. Card revenues continued to face year-over-year pressure, with purchase sales falling 13% because travel in the region is still significantly affected; even so, purchase sales improved sequentially this quarter, as we had expected. Now to Latin America: total revenues fell 16% year over year. Mexico followed the pattern seen elsewhere, posting solid deposit growth this quarter as average balances rose 13%, while purchase sales picked up from the prior period. Even so, deposit spreads stayed under pressure, and lending volumes kept shrinking amid the macroeconomic backdrop. More detail on worldwide consumer credit trends appears on Slide 10. Credit loss rates were mostly down during the quarter, supported by abundant U.S. liquidity, lower spending, and benefits from relief programs. In Asia, by contrast, those rates climbed, mainly since accounts exited relief programs as expected. Delinquencies outside the U.S. compared with a year earlier is concentrated in accounts coming off relief programs and mirrors stimulus that has been more limited in these regions than in the U.S. With those trends in mind, our expectation remains that peak losses will land in Asia and Mexico in the first half of 2021 and ought to start recovering after that. At the same time, in the U.S., although we do anticipate losses starting to climb in 2021, based on the current delinquency trend and the anticipated effect of recent stimulus, we now see peak loss rates being delayed until the first half of 2022. Whether deferring these losses simply shifts their timing or ultimately results in smaller total losses remains an open question, and we're watching it carefully. Corporate/Other results appear on Slide 11. Revenue dropped significantly from a year earlier, reflecting lower rates, the runoff of legacy assets and the absence of one-off gains. Costs were essentially flat, as the legacy asset wind-down was offset by infrastructure, risk management and control spending. The pretax loss for the quarter was $690 million, roughly in line with our earlier outlook. Slide 12 shows how net interest revenue and margin have been trending. Measured in constant dollars, net interest revenue totaled $10.5 billion for the quarter, a decline of $1.3 billion compared with the prior year, which reflects the impact of lower rates and reduced loan balances, partially offset by stronger trading-related NIR. Looking sequentially, net interest revenue continued to stabilize and, excluding market, came in roughly flat against the third quarter. Net interest margin declined 3 basis points, reflecting both the lower net interest revenue and balance sheet growth driven by strong deposit growth. Moving to noninterest revenues for the fourth quarter, non-NIR declined 6% to just over $6 billion, reflecting weaker consumer activity relative to a year earlier. Now to full year results. Top-line revenue came in unchanged: a drop in net interest revenue was fully made up for by noninterest revenue that was higher, thanks to markets staying strong throughout the year and solid investment banking results. Slide 13 shows our main capital measures. Our CET1 capital ratio climbed to 11.8%, which puts us 180 basis points above the regulatory minimum. The supplementary leverage ratio was 7%, and tangible book value per share increased 5% to $73.83 on the back of net income. Before handing things back to Mike, I'll spend a few minutes on how we see 2021. As for the top line, market performance in 2020 was extraordinary, and we'd anticipate some normalization in the year ahead. Based on how things develop, we could see revenues decline by a mid to high single-digit percentage this year, mostly because of market conditions. This outlook assumes that industry wallets will be closer to 2019 levels. As for net interest revenue specifically, it assumes continued stabilization in the first half of the year, with improvement in the back half compared with our base case—and that base case assumes loan growth by this point in the recovery. For the full year, net interest revenues fall by roughly $1 billion to $2 billion versus 2020. On the expense front, we expect full-year costs to increase somewhere between 2% and 3%, primarily because of spending related to our transformation. Our credit cost should come in substantially below the 2020 level. We also expect a tax rate of about 21% for the year. Putting that all together, we foresee pressure on operating margin this year; still, with credit costs lower, we ought to deliver meaningful profitability gains versus 2020. And last, as Mike said earlier, we anticipate buying back shares across the rest of 2021, pending Board approval, starting this quarter. In closing, reviewing our 2020 results shows the substantial earnings capacity and durability of the franchise. As we stand here now, our capital and liquidity positions are solid. Client engagement overall continues to be robust.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

Each quarter, our book value increased, and our attention stays on backing our colleagues, customers, clients and community — all of which leave me feeling very confident as we head into 2021. So with that, I'll turn things back over to Mike.

Michael Corbat

executive
#6

Thanks, Mark. At this point I want to hand things over to Jane, and she'll speak with you for a few minutes.

Jane Fraser

executive
#7

Thank you, Mike, and good morning, everyone. I'd like to express my appreciation to Mike for his backing and for collaborating so closely with me throughout this transition. Ensuring a smooth CEO handover at Citi mattered to him, and he has clearly been enormously helpful to me as I get ready to take on the role at the end of February. My excitement about what lies ahead for this company is enormous, and I'm equally determined to address the weaknesses in risk and controls that regulators have pointed out; a transformation effort is now underway that will clearly benefit both our clients and our investors, while at the same time meeting what regulators expect from an institution of such global importance. And of course, we continue to deal with the pandemic. Even though we'd like to believe the end is near, the virus has surprised us and demonstrated how unwise it is to think plans will unfold exactly as intended, so we will remain watchful and flexible. As I move into this role alongside Mike, two things matter most to me: our transformation work and rethinking our strategy, with the end goal of accomplishing three outcomes — putting Citi in the strongest spot to succeed, substantially lifting our returns, and resolving the concerns our regulators have flagged. Although it's still early, we're already making solid progress on these priorities. Regarding the transformation, we're deliberately taking a step back—addressing the underlying problems, establishing what our desired end state looks like, and building the detailed roadmaps to reach it. We've set up dedicated work streams focused on risk and controls, data, and compliance, along with others aimed at fostering a culture of excellence and accountability and at reinforcing our key business processes. A member of the executive management team leads each of these streams. Collectively, we're responsible for making the bank simpler and more modern. Our gap analysis against the target state will be delivered in February, followed by the detailed implementation plan in May. Getting there will take time, and we'll need to put substantial resources into both technology and people. I promise you that your capital will be invested wisely, and that you — along with our clients and our regulators — will see the results and benefit from them. Ultimately, our goal is excellence in risk and controls, in how we operate, and in how we serve clients. Turning back to strategy: over my 16 years at Citi, I've been fortunate to work across a range of businesses and regions. Even so, this transition is affording me useful time to step back and examine our strategy and businesses with a dispassionate eye. At this pretty early point, you wouldn't expect me to give specifics, but I can describe how we're thinking about it. We possess an excellent franchise, top-tier capabilities, and a great brand. No other institution matches our worldwide network, making us the most global bank — which gives us a unique edge in helping clients expand and thrive internationally. Our capital position and balance sheet are solid. We have a deep bench of talent around the globe. So although there is work ahead, that is a strong hand to play. Several principles will shape how we renew our strategy. With a clear-eyed perspective, we are reviewing our strategic position and determining which of our businesses can secure leading positions in a marketplace that has become far more digitized. Along the same lines, I see real worth in concentrating our efforts and in steering our investment dollars and resources toward those operations that will produce stronger growth and better returns over time. I also hold that it matters to ensure the businesses we own are a good fit with one another. That way, taken together, they carry a competitive edge and create synergies. And last, as any genuine Scot would, I hold that simplifying the company offers value waiting to be unlocked. As you're aware, on Wednesday we disclosed that Consumer Wealth Management and our Private Bank will be merged into a single business line. There's a growth opportunity in Asia and the U.S. that I'm especially enthusiastic about. Earlier this week, we announced a new head of our TTS franchise as well as new leadership for U.S. consumer. Looking ahead, I'm eager to share further opportunities and moves with all of you. Let me end as I began—by thanking Mike. All 38 years of his career have been spent at Citi. No one could be more committed. Citi always came first for him. When he stepped into the role, it was an extremely challenging time. He had to make hard decisions as he guided the company through the post-crisis restructuring. During his tenure, Citi turned into a more streamlined, compact, secure and vastly more robust organization — it resumed expanding, closed the distance to competitors, and gave back a substantial quantity of capital to investors, precisely as he had pledged. His consistent guidance throughout this year carried us through an extremely challenging stretch for everyone, yet the past twelve months demonstrated how the efforts he directed have made our company more resilient as we stood behind our employees, customers and communities amid this pandemic. The platform he’s handed over is exceptionally strong, and I’m fully dedicated to carrying forward what he achieved. We feel deep appreciation and pride toward him, and everyone here at Citi sends our warmest wishes as he moves into what comes next. Mike, would you care to say a few words before we close things out?

Michael Corbat

executive
#8

Thanks, Jane. I value what you said, and I'm confident the firm will be in excellent hands. Jane, Mark and I would now be glad to take your questions.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#9

Jane, I think it's wonderful that you joined us, so I really have to ask you this one; so I'm with you, concentrating on a robust business, positioning it on its own and then ensuring businesses mesh nicely together. During part of your time here, you came from the Latin American consumer side and global consumer. I would really like to hear your perspective and your thoughts on the question that has surfaced over the years of just how much global consumer does "fit well together." Are they separate businesses standing alone? How much can they leverage going forward to become a genuine global consumer platform?

Jane Fraser

executive
#10

Thank you, Glenn, for that question. So we are only just starting the work on the strategy. And as I mentioned, we're stepping back, and Mark and I are working on a dispassionate view of all of the businesses and looking at which are the leading franchises we want to invest behind, which are the others that we want to grow to win; and as we do that work, we will let you know what direction we're going to be taking, as we have already done in this week's announcement on wealth and on the new leadership in TTS. But I would say, let us do the work and then we'll let you know how everything fits together; and if there are pieces that end up not being part of the call, we'll let you know, but let us do the work first.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#11

All right. That's fine. Perhaps I'll come back with a more detailed question. On the card side, I believe part of the strategy over the past couple of years has involved turning card customers into digital banking clients. In the appendix I noticed there's been customer growth, but not a huge amount of expansion recently in active digital and mobile customers, I'd say, over the last 5 quarters. So I'm wondering whether that's — what are you doing to pursue that opportunity, and does it fit into the plan going forward?

Jane Fraser

executive
#12

Yeah. So regarding digital customers, the picture differs across different regions of the world. Mexico delivered massive expansion for us, starting from a far smaller digital foundation; when COVID arrived, the whole industry sped up rapidly, and we hold a leading position there. Turning to the U.S., our card customers are already highly engaged on digital channels, so we did not anticipate comparable gains. Another factor I would mention is that customer acquisition has fallen everywhere owing to COVID, and it is generally the case that newcomers joining any platform show greater digital uptake. We feel fairly confident that when the recovery arrives, we will also see an increase in digital adoption in the U.S. from here on.

Mark Mason

executive
#13

Jane, the one thing I would tack on there is that we've observed increased e-statement penetration — or e-statement usage, rather, along with e-payment usage. Usage of our e-statements and payments has risen by roughly 15%. So, as you can imagine, throughout this crisis people have been actively engaging with our digital capabilities, and that's partly a byproduct of the investments we've been making in digital technology. So we feel good about that.

John McDonald

analyst
#14

Mark, could you break down a bit of what's behind the 2021 expense outlook — the investment spend, perhaps the transformation spend, and where the savings are coming from?

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Sure. Well, as I mentioned in the outlook, we're seeing expenses rise roughly 2% to 3%. The transformation spend will probably account for most of that, as we get a handle on what that cost will actually be. As you know, we've already spent $1 billion this year. That's already baked into our run rate. But we're working toward a broader investment strategy, and we're doing that in the context of — obviously we'll do it in the context of how the strategy Jane talked about develops. So continued investment in digital capabilities, both on the consumer side, as you heard me mention, and also on the ICG side, especially in our TTS platform, where the investments already made there have delivered good benefits; but as you know, that's an area where innovation and technology are what's needed to keep a competitive advantage there. We just announced the wealth management business, if you will, bringing together wealth from the consumer side and in the private bank. And that, I would imagine, will be — not I would imagine, that will be an area of investment for us as we grow fee revenues, which Jane has pointed to as an important objective of ours. We'll also see growth in advertising and marketing. So in that outlook, I talked about net interest revenue stabilizing but picking up in the back half of the year with growth in loans. And that loan growth is going to be a byproduct of us starting to put money to work again back in advertising and marketing, which was down materially this year as we managed through this crisis. So those are a couple of areas we would look to invest in, in the context of that 2% to 3%. But again, a lot of it is going to be towards this transformation; and it is an investment, which I continue to remind folks of, and that is to say that we expect to and we'll focus on ensuring that we get a payback on that in the coming years. And so hopefully, that gives you a good sense, John.

John McDonald

analyst
#16

No, that helps. And to pick up on the net interest income outlook you raised — I believe you mentioned it might decline by $1 billion to $2 billion compared with a year earlier. Which factors would push you toward the low end of that range rather than the high end?

Mark Mason

executive
#17

Yes. So once more, net interest revenue may decline, and that reflects in part the speed of the recovery we are projecting. So how loan volumes move is going to matter a great deal. Clearly, the GDP forecast we hold plays into that; and clearly, the rate curve and its path will be another key element in the mix. With that said, I would note that we have observed — on the card side, you heard me bring this up in my prepared remarks; we saw solid sequential momentum in purchase sale activity. Part of that is seasonal, but part of it is simply strong activity with our customers, and we expect that to keep going. We — obviously, stimulus has already been announced. There is some talk of substantial stimulus or further stimulus ahead; and ideally, that carries us to a point where it supports some of the GDP growth reflected in our forecast.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#18

My first question goes to Jane. Like Glenn, I just can't help myself. I believe investors are quite eager to hear about your strategic plans, since the constructive criticism I receive regarding Citi is that investors broadly support your existing plan along with the remediation and recovery. Yet I think they keep wondering if you have plenty of breadth but insufficient depth when it comes to market share and businesses. That's a long-winded way of posing this question, so I apologize. Your peers appear to be converging on a mid-teens ROTCE, or slightly above that, at a normalized level. And when you consider the wonderful franchise you already possess and the opportunities available to improve it, do you believe Citi can reach that level eventually, whenever that normalized period comes?

Jane Fraser

executive
#19

Yes, that's an excellent question. It's one Mark and I have devoted considerable time to working on and discussing, as we examine what the right configuration of businesses should be and how we — as I mentioned, in the principles we're setting out for how we're viewing the Citi of the future, particularly in a digital environment, given that the world is shifting rather quickly on that front; so once we've completed the work, we'll be setting out the various metrics and milestones for measuring us, both regarding progress and regarding the desired outcomes. Over the last few weeks I've been speaking with a number of our key investors — great, very helpful conversations — and gathering their input on which sorts of outcomes are desirable; and they're very much part of the mix as we undertake this work on the strategy and on the transformation. As Mark said, the 2 go hand-in-hand going forward. So we look forward to coming back to you with that picture once we're ready. And Mark, I know, has been key throughout all of this; so let me hand the mic to him.

Mark Mason

executive
#20

Yes. Thank you, Jane. So, in the remarks you prepared, you rightly concentrated on approaches aimed at spotting chances for growth, enhancing our returns, and closing the distance to peers. That kind of strategic emphasis, I believe, together with the investments we have made — and are making, both transformation-related and growth-focused — will definitely set us on that course. I also think that the normalization of GDP within the credit environment is going to help. And then, as a lot of people are aware, we have a deferred tax asset plus some legacy assets that we will keep reducing over time. And I believe those — combining those elements, beginning with the strategy and a plan to keep returning capital and return on capital, places us on the right path toward reaching those better return levels, not to mention the possibility of rates rising over time or during the normal portion of the cycle.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#21

Then for my second question, I'd like to direct it to Mark. It looks like the stimulus package we've seen so far — and possibly more to come — might create a bridge both sturdy and lengthy enough to, if not postpone losses, at least reduce the actual cycle losses in card. How should we frame the stimulus in terms of its effect on spending and loan volume patterns, and how does that feed back into the NII guidance?

Mark Mason

executive
#22

Yeah. Well, when we consider where our reserves sit and what's happening there, we definitely took stimulus effects into account. What I'd emphasize is that stimulus up to now has produced elevated payment rates and a steady sort of capacity for the consumer to pay, which has been a positive. It appeared not just in payment rates but also in the reduced delinquencies we've observed and, clearly, the reduced losses we've observed. Additional stimulus is certainly needed. The favorable aspect of that, I believe, is that it ought to keep supporting the payment rates we've been seeing. And should it be large enough, it can eventually spur more consumption and help lift GDP and bring unemployment down. As I mentioned earlier, our present forecast presumes that loan momentum strengthens toward the end of — or the middle — pardon me, the back half of 2021. Should that materialize sooner, we might see greater volume in loan growth. And clearly, that would help our NIR forecast. So in that sense stimulus is positive. It will also bring — as it kicks in, there will probably be some near-term pressure on lending volumes, since people tend to use it for liquidity and to pay down balances. But eventually, I believe it will be a benefit.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#23

I've got one easy question and one tough one for you. Mark, the easy one is yours. What's the earliest Citigroup could begin buying back stock? And what amount do you figure you might repurchase during the first quarter? Also, I don't believe you were permitted to buy any this quarter, but did you anyway?

Mark Mason

executive
#24

Right; so, as you're aware, the Fed's guidance gave us the go-ahead to bring back buybacks. A cap applied in the first quarter, calculated from our trailing 4-quarter average of income. That works out to roughly $1.8 billion of buybacks in the first quarter; and so, pending Board approval, we'll authorize some level of buybacks in Q1; we haven't begun those buybacks so far.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#25

Alright, here's the hard one for Jane — if we look out 5 or 10 years and try to imagine Citi, who is it that Citi wants to be by 2030? I'm asking since you mentioned that Citi is global. But even with that global standing, Citi has fallen short of what was expected in every one of the past 5 decades. You can follow the thread back to Walter Wriston, to the 1980s, to Sandy Weill and John Reed and the financial supermarket idea, to the financial crisis — and even after all the retrenching and derisking, and I agree the odds of bankruptcy are much lower, return on capital has lagged the cost of capital over the past decade; so when you take over you'll be the seventh CEO at Citigroup. Why is this time going to be different? What can you do differently, whether in business mix, customer mix, or geographic mix? Because from where I sit and I — it's great. You could examine this clinically or without emotion, but the underperformance of Citi over virtually any period across the past 50 years stirs something extremely passionate in me. So I'm simply attempting to work out what you're able to do — with your 16 years at Citi and your McKinsey background — to genuinely at last transform Citi so that it produces sustainable returns above the cost of capital. So once more, where — what is Citi's endgame?

Jane Fraser

executive
#26

Well, thank you, Mike. So I believe the end game — and you asked how we look in 2030 — is really quite simple. As you mentioned, we're a global bank; we aim to be the leading global bank. Our businesses leave us strongly placed for that. In other words, we hold leading franchises within each of the competitive arenas they operate in, along with an approach the market has grasped clearly throughout that period. Our aim is to rank among the finest in how we serve clients and customers, above all when it comes to safety and soundness; and I would also mention that we wish to be viewed as contributing positively to society, since I believe that element matters greatly in the current environment. Yet everything we do serves the goal of producing the returns our investors are looking for. So to be fair, while we have made demonstrable progress over the last 10 years since the crisis, equally know that there is a gap to close with our peers. You can hold me accountable for doing so along with the management team; we're a team on a mission to get this done, and we will get this done.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#27

I don't want to keep harping on the same point, but perhaps just one brief follow-up, if you can offer us any assistance. I believe a major worry among investors is that they cannot discern the route to returns at the level of peers. When you consider it — without revealing details about strategy and such — do you see it as genuinely a matter of efficiency? Or is it a matter of capital, given the DTAs? How do you view where you stand at present and what is causing that gap?

Jane Fraser

executive
#28

Well, these are precisely the questions Mark and I are sitting down with, examining our various businesses and asking how we ensure — as I mentioned during the opening remarks, we are considering how to steer our resource allocation and how to steer our investments toward businesses that will serve as significant growth drivers for the franchise and high-returning areas for the firm going forward. We have already introduced one that we consider important on that front in wealth, where we have numerous separate components of the puzzle that we believe will let us be highly successful in this domain, uniting the different pieces of the firm to push this forward, and it will clearly be one among several areas that we see helping us enhance our returns. And as Mike said, that is not the sole component. There are other elements, as I mentioned, within the different principles. We perceive value from simplification. And that is in terms of, obviously, the operating efficiencies and similar benefits that we would gain from it, as well as potentially business mix. And we want to push the businesses to ensure that they truly fit well together, so that they achieve the synergies as well as the competitive and collective comparative advantage. So it will be a combination of components. But as I say, we are undertaking this work. We will inform you as we proceed about the decisions we make along the way and look forward to sharing them with you, frankly, with the intention that we have both a leading global firm as well as an organization that delivers the desired results to our investors. Mark, anything to add, my friend?

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Yes, I think you put that nicely, though I want to echo one point you made, which is that we will get this finished, correct? And it's a blend of things. We'll keep honing the strategy here. We have some very strong businesses possessing competitive advantages that we intend to keep reinforcing; we're going to put investments into the franchise, since that's what will be required in order to keep driving better returns. Yes, there are a few drags. I brought that up earlier. They definitely do weigh on returns, between the DTA and legacy assets. But we also hold excess capital as we sit here, with a CET1 ratio of 11.80% against our 11.50% target. And so we're going to keep working all of those things together; and I believe those are the things — we believe those are the things that will get us back to the continued improved levels of returns that we saw coming into this crisis.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#30

All right, that's fair enough. And perhaps just speak — talking about one of those companies where you're seeing growth that you've been putting money into. Could you address the underlying — clearly, with interest rate pressure, it's difficult to discern it, the underlying growth in TTS. What's your view on these businesses? We've witnessed competition, whether in treasury services or payments, wholesale payments, it appears to be a competitive landscape. How do you think about that business and its growth going forward?

Mark Mason

executive
#31

Yes, absolutely. I'll handle that one. So to begin with, we feel quite positive about the TTS business we operate. We regard it as part of our services business within the ICG services, which would encompass TTS and security services. As you're aware, we hold a very distinctive position in this area of our franchise; and you're correct, the headline figures are impacted by interest rates; but we feel quite positive about the underlying momentum in the business, and we believe that's demonstrated by a few key drivers. You know we operate in 95 countries. That provides our clients with the capacity to transact in over 140 currencies. And we deliver that on a global platform. We have 600,000 users on that platform, which is up roughly 9% versus last year. And within that figure, mobile users have risen about 95%. We keep expanding accounts with our clients; and we now have the capability to open accounts digitally in 50 countries; during 2020, we opened over 14,000 accounts digitally, representing an increase of more than 200%; and growing accounts strengthens our relationship with clients and lets us penetrate new activity centers, which lets us capture more flows across our platform. And in the end, that generates more revenue. So this digital activity drives revenue for us down the road, and it also is more — it's a more efficient way for us to conduct business with clients. We're also observing solid transaction volumes across various payment types with these clients. We've had very strong clearing performance and cross-border flows throughout the year. And so those factors give us considerable insight into what the momentum will look like as we emerge from this crisis. And that's before mentioning further opportunities with new clients. As you know, we've shifted our commercial business squarely into the ICG. There's additional upside for our TTS platform with a commercial — with the commercial client base; and so we feel quite positive about where we stand. We're not taking our position for granted. We will keep investing in this platform, and we're eager to capture the growth and support our clients as they emerge from this crisis.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#32

I'd like to ask a follow-up about expenses. So the guidance suggests roughly $44 billion for this year, and as you hinted, there's a lot of investment baked into that. When we think ahead — it's somewhat hypothetical, since strategy changes and simplification efforts could affect the expense base — but looking past this year, should we see that as somewhat of an inflated expense base, where certain investments are running above typical levels and you can scale them back? Or is it closer to a normal run rate, with efficiency really coming from revenue growth?

Mark Mason

executive
#33

Yes. Let me offer a couple of brief points. First, as I said and as you just echoed, expense growth is coming. Jane noted that we're in the middle of making headway on our transformation. And we'll need to submit a plan in May, get it approved, and keep investing to execute against it. That will shape how we think about some of the later years. But on your question about an inflated expense base, my answer would be no. It isn't an inflated expense base at all; these are investments, as you've heard me say many times, and there will be a return on them. That return will show up both in revenue and in a more efficient operating platform; we have a track record now. We've built some credibility now by demonstrating productivity across our platform, whether through automating processes, reducing data centers, or low-cost location strategies. Since our Investor Day, we've kept improving our productivity. And that's what you should expect. That's what we expect of ourselves, and we'll deliver as we come out of these investments we need to make. So no, not an inflated expense base. That said, setting that aside, we will keep investing in the business. And so if opportunities arise, whether as a byproduct of the strategy refresh Jane mentioned or otherwise, we intend to seize them and make those investments, because that is the only path to those improved returns we're targeting and focused on. So hopefully, that answers your question.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#34

That's helpful. Moving to another topic, regarding the strategic review, I think plenty of speculation has circulated concerning which businesses, if any, you might exit. I won't identify them, but a handful of those, looked at on a stand-alone basis, generate quite high returns, while others do not. Conceptually, though, how are you thinking about this — if you do exit or sell a given business, a gap could open up, because you'd be forgoing some earnings before you can put them to work in areas such as digital and TTS and wealth, in terms of the payback, correct? There's a possibility that early on you give up some earnings, and your capital might get bloated, and again, certain investments need time before they pay off — so does that concern you at all, or...

Jane Fraser

executive
#35

Yeah. What we're looking at currently has far more to do with what we want to be going forward. And where we stand in that work is examining how — what the individual businesses are, and how they fit together best. Digitization is altering a fair number of things, as Mark mentioned. It's opening up plenty of new opportunities, but also bringing some significant investments, both for growth and for returns. Should certain operations emerge that strike us as poor fits for the overall portfolio, I believe we possess solid capabilities for figuring out a sensible way to divest them. That said, truthfully, that isn't our current position. Our attention is on the company we intend to become. So, as I mentioned, give us time to complete the work, and afterward we can return to you with our plans—what we're examining and how that journey will unfold. Speculating at this point feels premature to me.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#36

Two things I want to ask. First, about the profitability improvement we've discussed here. I realize we've spent a lot of time on the expense side and on revenue growth, but the funding cost side also crosses my mind. Given that you've got a strong brand here in the U.S., a genuinely solid mobile app, and we're in a fairly low interest rate setting, why not launch a high-cost savings product and lower your wholesale cost of funds by shifting away from wholesale funding toward such a savings offering? At this rate, you really should be able to gain some ROA from that.

Mark Mason

executive
#37

Yes. Look, deposit growth has been quite good, and part of that comes from our high-yield savings accounts. That said, we also saw strong checking account growth this quarter, along with growth in our digital deposits. So you're right — there is a funding cost benefit there. We've watched that unfold, along with the liquidity present in the market. Our plan is to keep growing when it comes to building those deposits. And we've been smart in how we manage our liquidity, holding some back, obviously, for lending needs as they may arise for our customers and clients, while also paying down wholesale debt. We did that throughout the year, and we've also been investing; we made some investments during the year. I believe we've put in as much as another $78 billion or so, up 21% for the year. So we've been thoughtfully managing the liquidity we've seen over the course of this year. We'll keep doing that, and we'll keep growing deposits on the consumer side, because you're right, it is a lower-cost funding alternative. And we'll do so if it — if it makes a lot of sense.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#38

My next question for you, Mark, concerns how you're approaching credit. You noted that credit costs should come in lower in '21 compared with '20, and I think we can all agree on that. What I'm trying to get at is how much flexibility exists there. Perhaps one question on that is about the reserve analysis and what unemployment level you're assuming in your reserving as of year-end '21; and is there potential for that reserve release to be bigger as the year unfolds? And then maybe — I know you discussed how stimulus might affect net charge-off peaks. Putting a number on that is difficult. But perhaps give us a sense of how you're viewing the path of credit costs year over year.

Mark Mason

executive
#39

Sure. I guess there are a few elements there. First, as you're aware, Betsy, when we model this, we consider the macroeconomic variables available to us at any given moment. So if you look at Page 4, we set out the variables used this quarter; and you can see that for both U.S. unemployment and U.S. real GDP, we've observed improvement relative to the third quarter forecast we ran. And I'd say, even looking at this, there's been additional improvement beyond the fourth quarter '20 forecast shown here. So those matter greatly in the assumptions and in what we can model regarding reserve levels. And as we see that get better or get better still, we'd expect that to be — that to show up as even lower reserves. I think another key factor is the stimulus and how that — and the extra stimulus out there and how that eventually plays out and what it means and whether it spurs consumer consumption and whether it spurs even greater improvement in unemployment will be important elements at work here. And then I guess the last piece I'd note is that we keep holding a management adjustment for economic uncertainty. And as we see these variables keep improving, that will affect how we think about severity and probability tied to that downside scenario. So all of those elements matter in how we think about the reserve levels we hold. While we still feel good about the roughly $28 billion we have in balances, we feel very good about the direction these economic variables seem to be heading; on losses, again, it's been interesting how this has unfolded. And so really, what all of us are trying to determine is whether the lower delinquencies and lower losses observed so far represent a delay or a deflation of losses, right? And whether that holds up is something only time will reveal, as we sit here today. And as I mentioned during my prepared remarks, we view this as something of a delay, since we now expect losses to peak in 2022, especially for U.S. consumer; but again, with another stimulus package right around the corner, that could in fact be pushed out even further, and ultimately we would hope it simply disappears and gets deflated and comes down. So...

Ken Usdin

analyst
#40

Mark, here's a follow-up on the fee side. We get it — this will be a tough year-over-year comparison. I'm just curious whether you can break out when you expect some of those areas to get back to around 19-ish. I realize that's a moving target given the environment, but if you separate Trading from Investment Banking, could you walk us through the visibility you have that's a bit easier to see, and how you expect that to trend — particularly Investment Banking, TTS, and so on?

Mark Mason

executive
#41

Sure. So once again, on the Investment Banking side we keep having productive conversations with our clients. Clearly, performance tied to the SPAC space and equity capital markets has been very strong, and given the character of those deals, that will keep unfolding. So that carries on into 2021. The dialogue has been really good — not only in investment banking but across our corporate clients generally, since they're working out what emerging from this crisis means for their business models, how they view their digital capabilities and needs, and how they view their supply chains and the way those might be shifting. They're having those conversations internally and with us, and we're part of that discussion. Being part of it opens up opportunities on the TTS side, on the Investment Banking side, and possibly even in corporate lending activity, which we're hoping picks up in the back half of the year as well. So the corporate dialogue is very, very strong and ongoing, and I believe that ultimately helps drive some of that fee revenue you mentioned. On the markets piece — again, it's been an extraordinary year for us. The industry has seen a lot of wallet growth in markets, and obviously that has to normalize at some point, and our forecast is that it does. But I'll tell you, in the early days of January we've kept seeing robust activity. It is early in the quarter. Still, we have seen that, so we'll have to watch how it unfolds over the rest of the quarter and into the balance of '21.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#42

Got it. And one more question about rates — it's always a bit trickier to figure out how much of a boost you folks get from rates, just because of how global all the yield curves you face are; but can you help us out, or at least remind us, exactly how sensitive the company is, or isn't, to — say the long end moved here in the U.S., how much contribution could that add?

Mark Mason

executive
#43

Yeah. Look, our sensitivity tends to be greater on the short end of the curve, though we did disclose some IRE information in our Qs. And to be fair, that's somewhat difficult to compare against peers. So we show what a 100 basis point increase on the long end would look like. And — but the reality is we would see — as the curve steepens, we would see some upside as we think about investing further out on the curve, and as it would also affect the pressure we've been experiencing from MBS repayments and similar items; and so we're more sensitive on the short end. But as it steepens, we believe we'd see some benefit.

Christoph Kotowski

analyst
#44

On Page 10 of your handout, I'm reviewing the global consumer trends, and I'm trying to get my head around that. I guess I have 2 questions — one specific, one wider. The narrow one: just looking at Latin America, losses have gone down while delinquencies have risen considerably. Is that a matter of accounting, of forbearance? Or is it something genuinely economic underneath? And is COVID the driver, or is it other economic variables?

Mark Mason

executive
#45

Yes. Look, what we're seeing there is that as people exit the relief programs that have been in place, delinquencies are picking up, just as was expected. So that's what's behind the increase we see in the fourth quarter. And ultimately, that will show up in the NCLs; but again, that is in line with what we were expecting in Latin America.

Christoph Kotowski

analyst
#46

All right—so that drop is probably just the other side of the same coin, the forbearance, correct?

Mark Mason

executive
#47

Exactly. That's correct.

Christoph Kotowski

analyst
#48

Right, okay. So I suppose, just taking a broader look at the situation. I mean, if you consider COVID infection rates, North America's are high, Asia's are low, and Latin America falls somewhere between the two. Normally, I think all of us about 9 or 10 months ago would have assumed that economic disruption and loss rates would more or less track that pattern. And from what I can tell, that doesn't appear to be happening in any way, shape or form. So I'm wondering whether you can explain that. And how should we assess the disruption COVID is causing, particularly, I guess, in your global businesses?

Mark Mason

executive
#49

Look — go ahead. Sorry.

Michael Corbat

executive
#50

No, Mark — actually, Chris, what I was about to say is that we need to focus on what I'd call the unevenness, correct? That unevenness — how we entered this whole situation, whether you look at timing, at position, at the health response, at the economic response. When you examine the demographics, it's clear that across the various layers, the various strata, you observe different patterns. There was a headline this morning in the paper: 1 out of every 5 people in New York City receiving a rent subsidy are behind on their payments — at least 2 payments. Yet at the same time, we keep seeing paydowns when it comes to credit cards. Businesses are on differing trajectories. So again, I believe that as vaccines are distributed state by state, that is going to produce differing outcomes. And then there's the second round — what President-elect Biden announced last night — and ultimately what gets passed and how it flows into the sector. So from where we sit, not only in the U.S. but across the world, we're genuinely adopting a highly granular approach — geography by geography, client segment by client segment — and striving to stay very attuned to each one of those. And so I don't believe there's any single formula that lets you examine this and arrive at the answer. It has to be tackled at a fairly granular level.

Charles Peabody

analyst
#51

Yes. I had a follow-up question about the markets commentary or the trading businesses; and in particular, I wanted to focus on your FICC trading businesses. Could you give us a bit more color regarding the fourth quarter — where the strength in FICC was and where the weakness was in terms of rates, credit, commodities, currencies? And then as part of that, my understanding is that you were caught wrong-footed in the rand. And I was wondering — and I'm assuming that losses there were not material because it's not a deep market. But is something changing about the environment that's going to make it more difficult in 2021 for positioning or market making or trading? Because you do talk about normalizing. Was there anything in that rand experience that you can extrapolate?

Mark Mason

executive
#52

Sure, this is Mark. Sorry, Mike, go ahead.

Michael Corbat

executive
#53

To start, Charles, on the rand matter, I’d frame that as a research call rather than a firm positioning decision. Our analysts published what they saw as a recommendation on it, so it shouldn’t be interpreted as the firm holding that stance. That came from independent research. On your second point, when it comes to FICC trading for us, if you examine the fourth quarter and the figures we’ve reported, you should note relative strength in credit and credit spread products—measured against our rates and currencies business, that’s smaller; it remains a meaningful business for us, just not as large. Some others have described outsized, very significant returns in leverage lending; we’re not as big in that area. And when we look at trading revenues, we tend to view them across longer cycles, not merely a quarter; The Street research today suggests the trading wallet for 2020 rose roughly in the mid-20s. Looking at our trading revenues for 2020, we’re likely up around the mid-30s. So quarter-to-quarter matters less. Still, for us, continuing to gain share there—and the underlying mix tends to move that around somewhat. That said, we feel quite good about our position and the conversations we’re having. Looking ahead, it seems unlikely that wallets will rise to the same degree, certainly in trading, as they did this year. We expect seasonality to return. But as Mark said, early in the new year we’ve seen activity stay high. And if more potential stimulus or government programs emerge, with the Fed and others continuing to take stances on rates, trajectory, and where things go, that could keep trading volumes relatively elevated. So we think we’re well positioned and are in dialogue on those fronts, though we clearly can’t escape all the market dynamics around where wallets go.

Mark Mason

executive
#54

And Mike, the one thing I would tack on is this: when you look at the figures, FICC has climbed 34% for the year. Raise in currency is higher by 32%. Spread products, up 40%. Performance has been very strong in this year. It's tough to feel disappointed with those figures. So everything you said is exactly right, Mike; and I believe the business has been completely engaged with clients, and we will keep doing that.

Charles Peabody

analyst
#55

Just to follow up on that, I realize this was an exceptionally strong year, especially in FICC, which was good to see. But when you look ahead to 2021, does that mean you expect FICC to be less robust and equity to sort of offset that? Or is there some mix between FICC and equity in how you're thinking about it?

Mark Mason

executive
#56

Look, our equities business is up. We're up 25% this year as well, right? So the usual — and the wallets were up for equities too. So will we see a normalization happen across the board next year, or at some point?

Michael Corbat

executive
#57

Also, Charles, I’d mention that we should examine the newly issued calendar. Obviously, the calendar was robust on both the debt and equity sides. We observed the seasonality, and we clearly saw debt issuance decelerate during the fourth quarter. There was a recommendation, and client uptake was to move ahead, build substantial liquidity, and strengthen the balance sheet. So there are probably fewer debt financing needs for 2021. Yet at the same time, I have to note—and I reviewed this last evening—that the equity calendar is still very strong; and again, we’ll see what the markets provide, but we need a market that welcomes new issues, especially in the SPAC space, where we have excelled and which has been strong; and so again, I believe that will also shape some of the secondary activity as we move through the year.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#58

Mark, going back to share repurchases — clearly, there are constraints tied to income, and you laid that out very clearly, both for you and for your peers. If those constraints get removed, perhaps following this year's stress test, and we return to the more traditional rules, or the regulations that took effect October 1 with the stress capital buffer, where as long as you meet your CET1 requirement you're free to do whatever you'd like — with that as the backdrop, would you guys think about an accelerated share repurchase program if you got the green light, instead of doing it each quarter the way it was done in the past, because that's what the regulations required before?

Mark Mason

executive
#59

Yes; we'll need to look at — first of all, the stress capital buffer, obviously, is a key piece of how this all comes together; and coming out of the recent resubmission, you saw the prospective stress capital will have to rise by 10 basis points. They haven't applied that. We're still subject to the 2.5% stress capital buffer, but that will be a factor we have to consider in the outer-quarters from 2021. And then after that, there'll be another CCAR submission, and we'll get results that inform the go-forward there. Each quarter, we'll look at what our projected performance would suggest, including that stress capital buffer juxtaposed against our target. And that view will allow for us to take the capital actions that we think are appropriate inside of what those results would suggest; and so we will take this in quarterly decisions, so to speak, ensuring that our outlook supports the capital action that we want to take. And so that's how we intend to approach it.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#60

That's great. And Jane, you mentioned that significant effort will be devoted to examining ways to generate growth for Citigroup, so that the profitability gap versus your peers can be closed. Obviously, I don't expect answers from you on this call. But one thing that separates Citigroup from 2 of its largest and more profitable peers is your U.S. consumer banking franchise. Those 2 peers, which reported their numbers today, have ROEs above 25% in that business, while looking at your global consumer business using your fourth quarter figures, the ROE came in at roughly 15%. Could there be an opportunity for depositories acquisitions in the United States? Could there be an opportunity to expand the Consumer Banking business in the U.S.?

Jane Fraser

executive
#61

We definitely think a strong opportunity exists. And our strategy, having combined all of the U.S. consumer business over the past year or so, has been to ensure we capture that by expanding and deepening customer relationships in the U.S. And we've pursued several important initiatives in digital and digital acquisition, as Mark mentioned. So yes, we do see meaningful growth opportunities, and our home market matters greatly to us. As for the specifics, as we've said, more to come.

Andrew Lim

analyst
#62

So regarding the system — sorry, for the overall system, we have observed that excess deposits increased substantially at banks. I believe one of your rivals has pointed out how this is creating strain on certain ratios, and one of those would be your supplementary leverage ratio. And I think if you removed the temporary exclusion of cash and treasuries from that ratio's numerator, then things would appear rather tight. I just wanted to see how that plays out for Citi, whether you're seeing that same sort of pressure and what your thinking is on that. And then if I could ask 2 brief technical questions. I didn't quite catch what you said regarding LatAm NCLs declining. What was the cause of that? It just seems to me a bit surprising that, that would be the case; and then finally, on your risk-weighted assets, they rose quite a bit this quarter. It doesn't appear that it could be entirely credit driven. Just if you could provide a bit more color on that.

Mark Mason

executive
#63

Sure. Let me begin with your first question, which was about, I think, the effect of deposits; and so yes, we have witnessed a significant rise in deposits; that does affect a number of the important metrics. From an SLR standpoint, if not for the relief, which kind of disappears at the end of the first quarter, we'd have an SLR lower by 109 basis points; so the reg relief provided 109 basis points of relief there; it also has had an effect on — and by the way, we are managing to that SLR relief going away at the end of the first quarter; so we're aware of that. We're managing accordingly to that. It's also had an effect on our GCIB score, which is — has kind of tripped into the next bucket, the 3.5% bucket; and the large percentage of that increase that we've seen in the GCIB score was also driven by deposits; and so we'll have to manage that as well. Obviously, there — we hold a view that some consideration needs to be given to both of these metrics as the Fed has been clear in terms of their view that there's enough capital in the system; and so we're hopeful that as kind of things evolve, that some consideration is given to that. But in the meantime, we're managing the balance sheet and deposits and capital accordingly and with full knowledge of how the relief might evolve in the case of the SLR. On your Latin America credit risk question, what I was getting at is this: since we had customers enrolled in a relief program, the NCLs we've recorded came in below where they'd have landed had those customers not been going through relief. So you observe the lower NCL this quarter, yet at the same time delinquencies begin rising. Those delinquencies climb as people exit that relief program and begin to — or cease paying, rather — and as a result, delinquencies move up. So before long, you'll see the NCL begin rising as people move past the 90 days past due delinquent stage and into losses. I hope that was clear. Your final question concerned advanced RWA growth. I mean, we did see RWA rise quarter-over-quarter. The drivers behind that were a mix of credit risk, market risk and operational risk. Within that, FX contributed to some of the increase, along with derivatives and mainly derivative and FX exposure increases, CVA included. So those are the primary drivers behind the advanced-basis RWA tick-up that we saw.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#64

I'd like a quick clarification, if I may. You've said wealth management is a focus, and we can see the stats you give for Asia — for instance, investment sales up 58% linked quarter — but fee revenue in Asia consumer actually dropped 10% linked quarter. So in revenue terms, is this really a small business? With no disclosure, it's hard for us to work that out. Or what other offsets are there? Because I hear you call it a material part of Asia, yet there's no way for us to put any context around this.

Mark Mason

executive
#65

Yes. And look, we're going to — we just announced, obviously, that we're creating this wealth management business, bringing the private bank together with our global consumer wealth management operation. So we'll share more detailed metrics on that front. But our Asia wealth management is a sizable business, and we are going to continue or expect us to continue to see growth there. So stay tuned for more disclosure and more details around the strategy for how we pursue that.

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#66

Thanks, everyone, for being with us. Should anything come to mind afterward, don't hesitate to contact our IR team. Thanks once more — enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#67

This concludes today's earnings call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.