Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 15, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Elizabeth Lynn
executiveThanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate your attendance. Prior to starting, I want to note that the presentation today — downloadable from our site, citigroup.com — could include forward-looking statements grounded in management’s present expectations and subject to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. Actual results, capital, and other financial conditions might differ materially from those statements because of various factors, among them the cautionary statements cited in today’s discussions and in our SEC filings, such as, without limitation, the Risk Factor section of our 2020 Form 10-K; having said that, I’ll pass it to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Liz. Morning, everybody. It's a pleasure to be with all of you on my debut earnings call since becoming Citi's CEO. Mark and I have plenty to discuss today, so let's dive right in. This morning, we released our results for the first quarter, along with the first set of strategic moves we're making in our Global Consumer Bank aimed at concentrating on where we hold competitive advantages and boosting what we deliver back to shareholders. So I'll begin with a few observations about the first quarter. I'll bring you up to speed on the strategy work that continues. The year has started off considerably stronger than anticipated. We feel good about the rebound in front of us, and we're getting the bank ready for a stretch of durable growth. For the quarter, we posted earnings of $3.62 per share, with net income of $7.9 billion. Net income hit a record for any quarter, powered by solid results in our Institutional Business and a $3.9 billion release from our Allowance for Credit Losses thanks to the brightening economic picture. Within the Institutional Clients Group, our markets businesses once again gained from an active environment; fixed income delivered a solid showing following a very strong first quarter a year ago, and equities had a record quarter. Investment banking also turned in a record quarter, mirroring elevated activity in equity underwriting. Treasury and Trade Solutions, the backbone of our global network, saw deposits grow even as revenues kept feeling the effects of low interest rates. Global Consumer Banking revenues declined versus the prior quarter because of the pandemic. Even so, we plainly see a recovery taking hold in Asia and in the U.S., and our ACL release reflected that. I'd point out that this is the healthiest consumer exit from a crisis we've witnessed in recent history, largely propelled by the U.S. government's stimulus package. Now, although loan demand fell, we did see robust growth in wealth management and in digital engagement, and both sit at the heart of the consumer franchise we're building. Our capital levels stay strong and stable, which lets us meet our clients' needs and give capital back to our shareholders. At 11.7%, our common equity Tier 1 ratio is the same as it was in the fourth quarter, and we restarted buying back common stock, which we had voluntarily halted when the pandemic began. Our tangible book value rose to $75.50, a 5% increase from a year earlier. Moving to our strategy. Back in January, I laid out four principles guiding how we're refreshing that strategy. First, we said we'll be clinical in judging which businesses we can keep or secure leading market positions in. Next, we intend to be focused by steering resources toward higher returning businesses and away from the rest. Third, we intend to be connected, making sure our businesses mesh well and produce synergies. Finally, we'll be easier to deal with, which helps us serve customers better, meet what regulators require of us, and create value for those who own our stock. We also made a promise to make the strategic calls required to put Citi in the strongest position to succeed and to narrow the returns gap versus our rivals. We promised to tell you about those calls as we reached them, and that's exactly what we're doing once more today. Back in January, I talked about our renewed emphasis on wealth; we think our position is very strong for capturing robust expansion and appealing returns in that business, especially across Asia and the U.S. As of now, wealth at Citi accounts for about $6.5 billion of revenues, alongside three-quarters of a trillion dollars in client assets. There are numerous synergies with our markets, BCMA, and commercial banking franchises throughout our worldwide network. Yesterday, we revealed the leadership group for Citi Global Wealth, and effort and spending are already progressing well on the business strategy and growth plans. Today, we revealed our choice to concentrate our consumer banking franchise across Asia and EMEA purely on four wealth centers, specifically Singapore, Hong Kong, UAE, and London; this puts us in position to seize the entire range of the wealth opportunity via these key hubs, where we can serve clients both onshore and offshore. Across Asia, this lets us keep running our top-tier consumer businesses in Singapore and Hong Kong, both of which have scale and deliver very strong returns; so we will seek exits from our consumer operations in the other 13 markets across Asia and EMEA. Now, even though these are great franchises, we lack the scale required to compete, and we've concluded that over the long run we simply are not the best owners for them. In line with the principles we set out for the strategy refresh, we think our capital, our investment dollars, and our other resources are better redeployed toward higher-returning opportunities in other places. What's the upshot? Global Consumer Banking will be made up of two scaled franchises, in the U.S. and Mexico, plus these four hubs, serving 100 million customers altogether. Let me be crystal clear about one crucial point. Citi will keep investing in and serving our institutional clients across these 13 markets; we possess a leading institutional franchise in Asia that generates high returns. It is a completely essential element of our future success. We see significant chances to invest and win share with our institutional clients throughout the region. In fact, my own experience in Latin America showed me how much the institutional businesses in every market gained from sharper focus after we exited our sub-scale consumer franchises and streamlined the operating model there. I completely anticipate the same outcome in Asia. Meanwhile, the thorough effort on our strategy refresh goes on. We'll keep telling you about the decisions we reach as we strive to narrow the returns gap with our peers. At the same time, we are, naturally, working hard on our Transformation. This quarter, we're preparing our next submission to the OCC. That represents an enormous amount of work, and we remain engaged closely with our regulators so that we satisfy what they expect, and we anticipate delivering our full plan to both of them by no later than Q3. We've established what the end states look like, completed the gap analyses, and right now we're moving through the detailed program plans, resourcing, and interdependencies, and execution has already begun in a number of areas. The necessary investments align directly with our strategy efforts. Take simplification, for instance — we're going after it by changing our operating model, and also by eliminating manual processes and controls. Let there be no misunderstanding: what we intend to accomplish is nothing short of a fundamental transformation, achieved by delivering excellence in our risk and control environment, in how we operate, and in the service we give our clients. The road ahead excites me, and I'm certain that these investments — along with others we'll make in talent and technology — will help us modernize the bank and put Citi in a position to win. Last, let me update you on certain ESG commitments we are making. Over the years, we've taken pride in leading across many dimensions of ESG. In my view, it's embedded in everything we provide to our clients and to the communities we serve worldwide. As you probably know, on my first day as CEO at the start of March, I made a commitment that Citi would hit net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, and within the next 12 months we will deliver our plans for how we'll get there. The support we give clients through our environmental finance activities is critical to helping them transition to a low-carbon economy. To that end, we're extending our current environmental finance target from $250 billion by 2025 to $500 billion by 2030. Beyond environmental finance, we also finance other activities that support the UN Sustainable Development Goals. Those include our important investments in affordable housing, healthcare, and workforce development. By 2030, we're committing an additional $500 billion to these activities, which brings our total Sustainable Development Goal commitment to $1 trillion by 2030. With that, I'll hand things over to Mark, and then the two of us will be glad to take your questions. Mark?
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, Jane, and good morning to all of you. I'll give a quick rundown of this quarter's results, then walk through the strategic refresh and the specific steps we unveiled earlier today in greater depth. On the whole, the year got off to a better start than we had anticipated, helped by a favorable capital markets environment and a boost from the cost of credit during the quarter. Citigroup posted net income of $7.9 billion for the quarter. Revenues came in 7% lower than a year ago. On the investment banking side, results kept coming in strong, and the markets business turned in a good showing. Even so, those positives were surpassed by the impact of interest rates coming down, a decline in consumer card lending, and the absence of the loan-hedge mark-to-market gains we booked a year ago. On the expense side, we saw a 4% increase from the prior-year period, driven by continued spending on our transformation, such as the infrastructure underpinning risk and controls, along with other strategic outlays, with efficiency savings providing a partial offset. Turning to credit, net credit losses came to $1.7 billion, and that figure was exceeded by a $3.9 billion ACL release, which stemmed mostly from a better macroeconomic picture and smaller loan balances. EPS came to $3.62, and ROTCE was just over 20%; in constant dollars, end of period loans fell 10% year-over-year, driven by weaker spending activity in consumer and higher repayments in both institutional and consumer. Deposits rose 7%, reflecting steady client engagement, as corporate and consumer clients alike continued to hold more liquidity. Before I turn to each business in greater detail, on slide four I want to go over the strategic refresh Jane talked about earlier. During our previous earnings call, we talked about how big an opportunity wealth is for Citi moving forward, and we shared that we were forming Citi Global Wealth — the goal being to link up assets and capabilities between the consumer and institutional sides of the house, and to change the way we deliver for clients at every point on the wealth spectrum. In the quarter just ended, we continued to develop Citi Global Wealth, and the slide lays out certain specifics regarding the size of this business, while the appendix holds further material on the main drivers. Allocated annual revenues for Citi Global Wealth came to about $6.6 billion, and investment revenues grew 15% in the past year, fueled by clients doing more and by an increase in client investment assets. We're continuing to bring the component businesses together into one wealth platform, and over the next few quarters we'll settle on the best organizational approach for carrying out that strategy, then share an update with you. Now I'll move on to the steps we made public today. Because our strategy centers on Global Wealth Management, we've decided to concentrate our Global Consumer Banking footprint in Asia and EMEA around four wealth centers. As Jane noted, this strategic move lets us streamline how we operate, while channeling investments and resources into areas where we hold competitive advantages and have the scale required to generate stronger returns over the long term. I'll walk through the 13 markets we intend to exit, which you can see on the slide, and the appendix holds additional detail. During the prior year, those operations brought in about $4 billion of revenues. They've traditionally been profitable, but as with other consumer businesses, CECL's effect dragged down full-year results because of the pandemic, and the cost of credit in these markets almost doubled compared with the year before. At the close of 2020, total assets stood at $82 billion. Roughly $7 billion of allocated TCE backs these businesses. When we've faced comparable situations, we've shown we can cut expenses effectively. That said, as the slide points out, the expenses we're assigning to these markets are fully allocated, and the eventual expense reductions might vary somewhat from that figure. These markets will keep being run within the GCB franchise; relevant actions are already well underway. As we move forward on these and other actions within our ongoing strategy refresh, we plan to tell you more. One last thing I'd like to underline, echoing something Jane said before: across all of these markets, we'll keep serving ICG clients, our commercial banking clients included. Taken more broadly, this strategic shift frees us to direct more investment toward ICG in Asia. Now, business by business. On slide five, you'll see how the Institutional Clients Group performed. We delivered a strong quarter, driven by solid execution and a favorable operating backdrop. ICG's EBIT for the quarter came to $7.7 billion, up 65% from a year earlier. Revenues declined 2%, reflecting the fact that last year included mark-to-market gains on loan hedges that aren't present this time. Excluding that, revenues were up 5%, as banking gained 9% while markets and Securities Services added 2%. Expenses were 8% higher, driven by investments in infrastructure and controls along with other strategic investments, increased compensation costs, and growth tied to volume. Credit costs came down significantly, helped by a $1.9 billion ACL release. This quarter's release mostly reflected a better outlook for global GDP along with modest gains in portfolio credit quality. At quarter end, our overall funded reserve ratio came to 1.1%, with 3.6% on the non-investment grade portion. Net credit losses totaled $186 million, and ICG posted a 25.7% return on allocated capital. Slide six gives a closer look at Institutional Clients Group revenues. Product revenues rose 5%, fueled by record revenues in equity underwriting and equity trading alike. Given these strong results across our overarching equities franchise, we're pleased with the strategic investments we've made, which let us use our full-service model to better monetize today's market. On the banking side, revenues grew 9%. Treasury and Trade Solutions revenues declined 10% in constant dollars, since strong client engagement and solid deposit growth were more than offset by lower interest rates and reduced Commercial Cards revenues. Even with those challenges, our core business drivers kept showing momentum. Average deposits rose 14% in constant dollars during the quarter. Across the last year, digital adoption and penetration climbed substantially, and we also recorded 7% growth in cross-border flows plus 6% growth in clearing volumes. Investment Banking had its strongest quarter on record, with revenues climbing 46%, powered by equity underwriting thanks to our leading position in the SPAC market. Private Bank revenues rose 8%, another record quarter, helped by higher lending volumes and managed investments revenues. In Corporate Lending, revenue increased 8%, driven by the lack of marks from the prior year, though this was partially counterbalanced by reduced volumes. Overall, Total Markets and Security Services revenue grew 2% compared with a year ago. Fixed income revenue declined 5%, a result of last year's robust results in rates and currencies. Spread products revenue improved year over year as clients pursued yield amid the current low-rate setting, with consistent demand in both flow and structured products. Equities revenue climbed 26% relative to the previous year, powered by cash equities, derivatives, and prime finance, which reflected healthy client engagement and supportive market conditions. Last, Security Services revenue was up 1% as reported and approximately unchanged in constant dollars. On this front, fee revenue expanded nicely thanks to clients both new and existing, with the lift coming from higher deposits, assets under custody, and settlement volumes, partly canceled out by narrower spreads.
Mark Mason
executiveLet's move on now to how Global Consumer Banking performed in constant dollars, which you can see on Slide seven. The pandemic is still holding back revenues, and so are elevated payment rates, but consumer spending keeps improving and credit remains healthy — signs that a recovery should take shape as the year progresses. GCB posted EBIT of $2.8 billion for the quarter, a big jump over last year, mostly because credit costs got better. Revenues fell 15%, since weaker card balances and lower interest rates in all three regions were partly balanced out by ongoing strong deposit growth and wealth management momentum. Expenses were down 1%, with efficiency savings and reduced volume-related costs partly offset by investments. We saw a meaningful drop in credit costs, which came from releasing ACL reserves across all three regions along with fewer net credit losses. This quarter's release was mainly a reflection of reduced volumes and an improved macroeconomic picture. GCB posted a 25% return on allocated capital. On slide eight, you can see more detail on North American Consumer results. Revenues for the first quarter fell 15% versus a year ago, largely because of weaker cards revenues. Branded Cards revenues declined 11%, which reflects a 15% drop in average loans, since customers are tapping liquidity from stimulus and other relief programs to reduce their debt. Retail Services revenues decreased 26%, driven by larger partner payments and lower average loans. Net interest revenues fell 18% as average loans decreased by 13% in rates. The rest of the revenue decline versus last year came from higher partner payments, which reflects lower forecasted losses and therefore higher income sharing. Turning to a broader view of our cards businesses, we continue to see sales activity recovering. At Branded Cards, total purchase sales held flat year-over-year, while essential spend rose 12%, and recovery is beginning to appear in categories such as travel and dining. At Retail Services, purchase sales increased 4%. Purchase sales are rebounding a bit more quickly than we had previously expected, and with the vaccine rollout, that should help discretionary spend recover further. Higher payment rates are the main thing affecting loans. Revenue is under strain because of that, yet our loss and delinquency patterns are improving as a result. On the positive side, spend is bouncing back and ought to keep doing so, plus our credit portfolio is showing real durability. At this point our attention is on rebuilding loans and revenue by boosting spend activity, coming back into the market to acquire new accounts, and putting money into lending capabilities along with fresh value propositions. Now, on the Retail Banking side, revenue declined 8% compared to a year earlier, which reflects the squeeze from narrower deposit spreads. Even so, we're still seeing solid momentum as we build and strengthen relationships with retail banking customers, while also making those relationships higher quality and more sticky. Average deposits rose 22%, with checking up 30%, and AUM climbed 32%. Beyond that, we keep expanding our digital offerings so they stretch from deposits into wealth management and mortgage lending. As Jane mentioned, we're still committed to the franchise, and all of this strengthens our belief that we can expand our U.S. retail bank using a digitally driven, client-focused approach, supported by measured brick-and-mortar expansion into new markets over time. On slide nine, we show International Consumer Banking results using constant dollars. In Asia, first-quarter revenues were down 12% year over year. Momentum in wealth management remains solid: investment revenues climbed 22%, Citigold clients increased 14%, and net new money rose 13%. If you look only at the four global wealth hubs, those numbers appear much stronger. Average deposit growth remained healthy at 13%, even though deposit spreads came in lower. Card revenues continued to face pressure relative to last year, with purchase sales declining 5% and average loans down 13%, which reflects the significant ongoing impact on travel in that region. Even so, some signs of recovery are emerging, such as higher new card acquisitions and year-over-year growth in purchase sales in March. Shifting to Latin America, total consumer revenues were down 16% from a year ago. As in other regions, deposits and assets under management in Mexico grew nicely this quarter, with average balances climbing 9% and AUMs rising 17%. Deposit spreads stayed pressured, and lending volumes keep shrinking because of the macro backdrop. Slide 10 offers more detail on global consumer credit trends; within the U.S., NCL and delinquency rates both stayed favorable, thanks to a substantial amount of customer liquidity from stimulus and other relief programs. Based on the delinquency trends visible now, we don't anticipate credit deterioration in the U.S. portfolio during 2021. Peak losses might not arrive until late 2022, contingent on whether the stimulus produces a lasting benefit. Conversely, in Mexico and Asia alike, credit losses peaked in the first quarter of 2021. That was anticipated, reflecting customer accounts coming off relief programs. The effect was especially sharp in Mexico, where the peak NCL rate exceeded 10%, since most customers exited relief programs at the close of last year's third quarter. Setting aside the accounts enrolled in relief programs, our credit trends in Mexico and Asia are both stable. Delinquency rates improved this quarter, as you can see. Slide 11 reports Corporate other results. Revenues were approximately flat in dollar terms, since lower rates were offset by the absence of marks relative to last year plus a few episodic gains this quarter. Expenses fell 1%, as infrastructure, risk, and controls investments were largely offset by allocating certain costs to the businesses. That shift had no effect on EBIT at the Citi level, and because it was immaterial, we haven't restated it retrospectively. Credit costs dropped versus last year, due to a release this quarter against a build a year earlier. To wrap up, our pre-tax loss came to $231 million for the quarter. As we look forward, a quarterly pre-tax loss around $500 million is what we'd anticipate for the rest of 2021, though it will fluctuate somewhat from one quarter to the next. Our net interest revenue and margin trends appear on slide 12. Measured in constant dollars, total net interest revenue reached $10.2 billion this quarter, down $1.4 billion compared with a year earlier, which mirrors the effect of reduced rates and smaller loan balances, plus the effect of one less day than the prior year, partly offset by somewhat greater trading-related NIR. Looking at the quarter compared with the one before it, net interest revenue continued to steady, and if you set aside the impact of there being two fewer days in the period, it was about level with the fourth quarter. Net interest margin dropped five basis points, which tracks the lower net interest revenues, with treasury actions and balance sheet optimization providing a partial offset. Turning to non-interest revenues: in the first quarter, non-NIR slipped to slightly more than $9 billion, largely driven by the mark-to-market on loan hedges, which counterbalanced strong investment banking revenues. Our key capital metrics appear on Slide 13, and as Jane pointed out, they remained strong and stable yet again this quarter, which let us support clients and return capital to shareholders.
Mark Mason
executiveOur CET1 capital ratio stayed at 11.7%, since net income was about matched by buybacks and dividends, plus the effect of OCI and a rise in risk-weighted assets. In the quarter, Citi returned $2.7 billion in total to common shareholders, consisting of $1.1 billion in dividends and $1.6 billion of share repurchases. Our supplementary leverage ratio came in at 7%, and tangible book value per share rose 5% to $75.50, powered by net income. Before we go to Q&A, let me take a few minutes to discuss what we expect for 2021. To start, our top-line outlook for the full year has gotten better since last quarter. Back then, following how 2020 performed, we had anticipated that industry wallets would come back nearer to 2019 levels during this year. With the strong beginning to the year, and the recovery signals ahead growing more positive, we now think wallets will be a bit above 2019. At the same time, our view on net interest revenues hasn't changed, and we still anticipate a drop in net interest revenues of between $1 billion-$2 billion, with stabilization carrying on into the second quarter and an improvement in the back half. Put together, that points to revenues declining in the mid-single-digit range, which is better than our earlier guidance of a mid to high single-digit range decline; when it comes to expenses, we still expect full-year expenses to rise in the range of 2%-3%, largely from investments tied to our transformation agenda. We might also encounter some episodic impacts this year stemming from the market exits we are pursuing. As I said earlier, we will be very transparent regarding how these actions affect our financials. On cost of credit, we still hold a generally favorable view when it comes to credit performance. Depending on the macroeconomic outlook, additional reserve releases could occur. Because of how large the reserve release was this quarter, we would not anticipate the same magnitude of ACL release in the future. With that, Jane and I are glad to take any questions.
John McDonald
analystThanks. Jane, I'd like to pose something strategic — just hoping for additional detail regarding this notion that the money you're putting into risk and controls will likewise support your objective of bringing Citi's technology up to date for customers' benefit. Might you expand on that somewhat and perhaps share a few instances where technology shortcomings became apparent during your listening tour throughout the company?
Jane Fraser
executiveHi, many thanks, John. What's happening right now is captivating. I get opportunities to speak with bank CEOs — they're our clients worldwide — and every one of us discusses the identical subject: a significant transformation is underway, a digital transformation across the industry. When we consider the consent order and the transformation, the transformation we're undertaking extends well beyond merely the consent orders, even though those are clearly an extremely vital piece of it. When we consider the investments being made, I view those going into our infrastructure and our data as strongly tied to a strategic requirement, along with what the consent orders demand and require from us. I offered one illustration a moment ago. Data would be an evident illustration of this, since investment directed at our data's quality will deliver a substantial effect for our shareholders by generating revenues and enhancing our client experience, enabling quicker decisions on risk or business matters, and also ensuring the data we possess is correctly governed from a safety and soundness standpoint. A great many of the investments we currently have represent the strategy and transformation efforts converging, just as happens at numerous banks.
John McDonald
analystAlright, a brief follow-up for Mark on this. Mark, in what way ought investors frame the several-year expense tied to this transformation? Clearly, you've provided us a certain amount of insight into what's baked in to arrive at your guidance for expenses this year of an increase of 2%-3%, does this sort of thing actually get stretched across several years? It doesn't seem like a simple or a fast undertaking.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Thank you, John. Just as Jane has mentioned it is, and I've mentioned before, it is an effort spanning multiple years. We've been laboring very hard to pinpoint the gaps we possess and to pinpoint the underlying drivers. Like Jane said, we're proceeding very forcefully to build the plans that shift us toward more thorough execution. Those plans need to be finalized. We're still grinding through that. As you said, I've been quite explicit, as we generate the details regarding what we can anticipate when it comes to headwinds, that 2%-3% this year, the $1 billion in the prior year. As we finalize those plans, I'll keep sharing transparently what our finest projections are for the way expenses keep developing. What I'd add, John, is that, I say this frequently, I suppose, these are investments. As Jane noted, there are advantages we anticipate from them. The data was an excellent illustration of how we capitalize on that with our clients, but additionally how securing that quality data, and avoiding the need to redo it and reconcile it, and so on, and so on, spares us on the operating cost too. I point that out since as we undertake additional investments, we will without a doubt keep hunting for productivity chances that serve to counterbalance those.
Glenn Schorr
analystHello, and thank you so much. I suppose there's an easy question that likely isn't so easy to respond to, which is: if selling off the 13 markets doesn't move revenue or earnings much, yet plenty of staff and attention get released, then my question becomes — what happens with that money? Speaking conceptually, since everybody has expected a big capital return narrative from you, and you're delivering one. Setting the consent order to one side, how are you thinking about deploying that capital aggressively to strengthen the businesses you're leaning into further?
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely. Look, I believe this is among the reasons the refresh Jane outlined matters so greatly. It lets us zero in very clearly on those pieces of the franchise where we believe our competitive edge is meaningful. As Jane said, those will be the pieces of the franchise receiving more resources — via expense dollars and investments, and also via capital allocation — so we can seize the growth we see in client opportunities there. Following that, once we've made sure we're seizing those opportunities that produce returns aligned with our aim of closing the gap to peers, we then clearly wish to give excess capital back to shareholders, which is what we've been doing. That's how we view it. First, let's start with what the strategy is. Second, let's confirm that strategy rests on growth opportunities and suitable returns that work for us. Let's put capital there to capitalize on that, and then whatever remains, let's hand it back to shareholders.
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me also weigh in on that point. I've spent a lot of time hearing from our investors during a very productive listening tour, gathering what they think, and I have a sharp sense of what matters most to us: narrowing the performance shortfall relative to our competitors and ensuring we build a plan that brings both the right investment shape and the specific steps needed to get there. Like Mark mentioned, nothing ranks above this for us.
Glenn Schorr
analystThanks for that. I want to dig into just a single item. When it comes to wealth, it clearly matches a high-return profile. You said you're increasing your commitment. As a merged company, I'm curious what measurements you believe we should watch to judge whether this works. Which connections to the other operations matter most, and how can those be leveraged more effectively? What kinds of systems and product platforms would you need to bring in to reach those bigger ambitions? Thanks.
Jane Fraser
executiveYou should watch what you wish for, since this topic could keep me talking for hours. In wealth, I believe our position is extremely strong. Mark shared some insight into how large and how broad the business stands today. From my vantage point, we possess a remarkable brand, one that people aspire to in wealth, especially across Asia, though also globally; we have our commercial bank, active in 30 geographies worldwide, and that's where a great deal of wealth gets created. Through our relationships, we assist with generating wealth and identifying its source for numerous clients, and naturally within ICG as well; we hold a top-tier institutional platform along with the associated capability. Our footprint is firmly established across the key wealth centers globally. I genuinely believe our position is exceptionally strong once we can unite these varied assets and capabilities onto one platform. Investments are already underway to establish a unified wealth platform organization. Yesterday brought the leadership announcement. You would have noticed it; we've begun putting money into expanding our relationship managers and FAs worldwide and truly assembling the firm's finest. As we develop the technology roadmap, I anticipate we'll also have a distinct tech stack aligned to support it. Jim O'Donnell is currently assembling those plans, yet we view this as an enormous opportunity, and you can gauge us and hold us responsible through the returns we deliver, the expansion of fee income, and our ability to keep steadily gaining share in the coming years.
Erika Najarian
analystHi, good morning.
Jane Fraser
executiveGood morning.
Erika Najarian
analystYes, I just want to build on what Glenn asked. Jane, during your prepared remarks you said the company is now putting its attention back on Consumer operations where it has scale, namely the U.S. and Mexico. So we're curious — I'm certain your strategic review is still underway. How do you envision the Citi Consumer franchise here in the United States? Once we're beyond a period where, ideally, your multiple better captures your ROE potential, and once the consent order is behind you, would you be open to inorganic chances to grow market share in the United States?
Jane Fraser
executiveErika, that's a wonderful question, and it's definitely one I've been hearing very clearly from a lot of our investors while we've been speaking with them. The U.S. is where we're based. We must nail it; it's a wonderful franchise when it comes to brand and the customer base we serve across the nation. We definitely see room to grow in wealth, which we've discussed; our cards business is sizable, and during the pandemic the cross-sell of our wider banking offering sped up. On the larger digitization theme, our clients are extremely high quality both inside and outside our footprint, and their digital engagement has been strong, and it has only grown. In the retail bank this quarter, 50% of new accounts came in through digital channels. For instance, roughly 75% of our customers are already engaging with us digitally. Our partnerships are outstanding. I believe we hold excellent assets and building blocks. As you noted, the strategy refresh work is happening as we speak. We look forward to returning to you fairly soon, once the work is finished and we have the plan for the actions we'll take; our horizon is longer term, and in the meantime, partnerships will matter a great deal. We would be delighted to pursue inorganic moves if, further out, they make sense for our shareholders and for us. Right now, our emphasis will be on partnerships.
Erika Najarian
analystThanks for that. My next question goes to Mark. The way you presented guidance likely addresses part of what I'm asking. The investor community appears convinced there's room for banks to bring in more revenue, whether through wallets continuing to grow within your ICG segment or via other, more conventional NIR channels. This comes in two parts. First, assuming revenue improves from where we stand, would the 2%-3% expense target still be reachable? And second, regarding costs tied to those divestitures, a competitor of yours mentioned that once you strip out overhead, or costs assigned to exited operations, the net savings would land somewhere around 75%-80% of the expenses you'd identified. I'd like to know whether that same proportion applies to the 13 markets you're leaving.
Mark Mason
executiveCertainly. To start, on the revenue side, I addressed this within the guidance, and what I pointed to was something I brought up during the prior quarter, namely the market wallets returning to normal. Based on what we've observed right at the beginning of this year and the robust opening Jane mentioned, although I anticipate a degree of normalization, my current expectation is that market wallets will sit above where they were in 2019. We believe that creates some upside; it partly drives the down mid-single-digit guidance I provided for overall revenues. You're correct about the curve steepening. That opens up certain possibilities. We hold dry powder that can be deployed toward liquidity; some has already been used, though additional dry powder remains available. As I noted before, we're observing elevated payment rates coming from the consumer side, which counterbalances part of that possible upside. I framed NII as a range, down $1 billion-$2 billion, and that range should give you a feel for what we could achieve or capture should more of that upside materialize. On expenses, two points. First, regarding what you raised about revenues. The response is that should wallets keep performing at an even higher level, or should the rebound prove even larger on the lending side, the consumer side, or ICG for that matter, greater expenses would follow, including transaction and compensation costs. I believe everyone would view that as good cholesterol. Should that unfold, then obviously, as I noted, there are exotic costs linked to the exits. On that subject, and regarding your point about allocations, both Jane and I bring deep expertise here. My own background includes Citi Holdings, where I was on the team and eventually led it. Jane, meanwhile, has headed Latin America. Those two segments of the business have, in the past, pulled out of various nations, and the two of us have concentrated hard on making sure we removed as much of the leftover expense tied to those withdrawals from the company as possible. Rest assured, we would apply that same kind of attention to these withdrawals; that's roughly how we see it. At this moment I don't have a ratio I'm ready to provide, but do understand that this will be something we zero in on so we can capture the greatest value from this choice.
Matt O'Connor
analystMorning. This is a hard one to respond to, I realize. But when we consider when the consent orders might be resolved, we look at those issued in October of last year and treat them as basically resetting the clock — or, given that a number of them have been in place for multiple years, and both the Fed and the OCC recognize the progress you've made, perhaps it's better not to view it as a clock reset. My reason for bringing this up: looking at other consent orders across the industry, resolution typically takes multiple years — 3, 4, or 5 years. With you folks it's somewhat more complicated, because, again, it isn't as though you're beginning from zero. I wanted to know whether you could say anything regarding the timing and how I should think about framing it.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, sure. How about I kick things off, and then Jane, you might have some input too.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah.
Mark Mason
executiveI'd put it this way — the consent order left no ambiguity regarding the directives and the areas requiring our attention. As Jane explained, what we're dealing with here is honestly a somewhat wide-ranging transformation; completing it will demand a multi-year push, and that push is already in motion. Sure, certain items you've heard us mention had actually gotten started prior to the order. Quite a few remediation projects were already progressing in a few of the domains the order calls out. We're building on that earlier work. To be honest, what sets this transformation apart from a remediation is the end-to-end lens we're applying, rather than addressing an identified issue through a very narrow, siloed, or tactical method. To accomplish that, you genuinely must stop briefly, step back, and examine the front end of a process — the point where things enter our systems — and grasp how those processes can be improved, along with the technology behind them and the governance surrounding that. I mention this because yours is a difficult question. Certain pieces we'll continue to speed up, yet we want to ensure we're doing so within the larger context so we get it right, and that's what truly matters to us. Jane, is there anything you'd like to add?
Jane Fraser
executiveMark, I believe you put that really well. Fixing issues is tactical. Changing things at the core is more strategic, and far more fundamental. That's the work we're engaged in. We're covering everything from beginning to end. We're examining the end states we aim to reach, ensuring we achieve genuine excellence, in our operations. That's where our attention is. We're oriented toward what's ahead instead of dwelling on what's behind.
Matt O'Connor
analystTo build on that point, the truth is you've got to resolve those regulatory problems before you can pull off certain parts of this transformation, isn't that so? Correct? Your capacity to complete deals, your capacity to launch new branches — there are simply numerous limitations. Hearing about the long-term vision is nice, I suppose, but doesn't the house need to be put in order first? Prior to being able to pull off some of those items? Is doing both simultaneously possible?
Jane Fraser
executiveOh, doing both simultaneously is completely possible, and that is precisely where our attention is. Like I said, the transformation and the effort behind it, along with the strategy, largely move together and bring us toward a shared objective, which is ensuring we're outstanding for our investors, for our clients, and equally for our regulators and the safety and soundness agenda. Those two things move together very much. Risk and controls matter obviously, especially in a digital world. To function as one of the world's most significant financial institutions, we require them to meet a very high standard. That's the intention, as is the intention to make sure our operations are the same. One in the same goal here.
Mark Mason
executiveRegarding what you mentioned, Jane, pulling out of those 13 nations does make the company structure less complicated. Correct? Establishing Citi Global Wealth and merging the former private bank, our wealth business, and consumer into one lets us build an investment platform — a single, unified investment platform — which streamlines the organization and makes it simpler to keep controls around those processes. Jane has it precisely right. In many respects, this strategy fits with the transformation already in progress.
Matt O'Connor
analystAll right, thanks a lot.
Saul Martinez
analystHi there, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Saul Martinez
analystMy questions are a mixed bag, all tied to the strategic refresh. To start, you provided plenty of detail on the financial metrics for the 13 exit markets. Do you also have the reserves sitting on the balance sheet in those countries that might be released over time? Next, the time horizon. Mark, you said you'd share more detail as it emerges. Any kind of guidance on timing would help. Is this a matter of quarters, or will it unfold across a number of years? Even just some guideposts. Third, and I'll wrap up here. Perhaps more significantly, Banamex. How are you viewing Banamex within the strategic refresh? It clearly isn't a subscale business, Mexico does face some macro challenges, as you've pointed out, and the government holds very heterodox policy views on a whole host of matters. Any thoughts on how you're approaching Banamex at this point?
Mark Mason
executiveJane, would you like to begin, and then I can add to that?
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah. Why don't we go start off with timing.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. Yeah, I'll take the reserve
Jane Fraser
executiveMexico.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely.
Jane Fraser
executiveJane Fraser here — I can hand off the reserve question to you, Mark. On timing: we've already started moving, and we aren't wasting any time. What we're doing is this — the work has begun. In a number of markets, actions are already in motion. Our aim is to finish those exits promptly, and in certain markets we expect to be out during this quarter. At the same time, we'll be careful about the identity of the buyers and our approach, plus the value we generate for shareholders along the way. Even though there's urgency behind the action, we'll ensure these are sound moves for our shareholders and act suitably. Regulatory approvals across different geographies will determine the timing. As Mark mentioned, once we know more, we'll bring you an update on the process. We've been extremely open regarding our intentions. Now, on Mexico — Mexico is a franchise with scale. If I set Mexico against our Asian consumer franchises, scale is a real advantage for them. Returns there are solid. Considerable upside potential exists. Our digitization investments have truly delivered. Right now, there's plenty to appreciate in that franchise over the longer term, and I know we'll provide a clearer picture of the strategy there as the strategy refresh work continues. Plenty to appreciate. Mark, would you like to take the reserve?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah.
Mark Mason
executiveI suppose I'll offer a few remarks. I won't be providing a particular reserve figure, and I apologize for that. What I can tell you is that, based on what we put on the page, things were approximately at breakeven during 2020. We're all aware that in 2020, sizable reserves got set up because of the pandemic. If we instead looked at 2019, a year that was more normal, then EBIT tied to those 13 markets would have come in slightly below $1 billion, give or take. That should give you a feel for how the reserve build has, at least in part, affected the present financials we've presented here. And once more, as we work through these transactions, we'll be suitably transparent about the impact we observe from them.
Mike Mayo
analystHi, Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveHey, Mike.
Mike Mayo
analystSo you've been in this role for roughly 45 days, and you're already announcing an asset disposition. I take it you're not sitting around. When you evaluate these asset dispositions, or ones that might come later, what criteria guide you? Returns could be a factor, growth could be a factor, synergies with the broader firm could be a factor, or perhaps regulatory advantages tied to the consent order could be a factor. Does simplifying and reducing the number of systems to resolve earn you any credit, or are there other yardsticks you rely on? From what I can see, exiting those 13 consumer markets — those seemed to consume a lot of capital. It's hard for me to believe the returns were strong there. There are so many variables to weigh. What criteria guide you?
Jane Fraser
executiveThat's a compelling question, Mike. Honestly, my approach is to focus on what we aspire to become rather than what we don't, since what you don't want to be tends to drop out of that pretty naturally. Our primary focus is on how we narrow the return gap versus our peers and ensure the businesses we operate in are capable of winning; we hold ourselves very strictly to those principles I set out right at the start, which we discussed back in January; we've applied this consistently throughout the strategy refresh effort. The initial item we examine is whether this sector, this client segment, or this business has appealing dynamics when we project over the medium and long term. Crucially, within those dynamics, are we capable of winning? Can we hold a strong position here? I believe it's clear in today's financial services landscape that scale is plainly a crucial factor. The flip side of that is lacking scale typically puts you at a disadvantage. We examine connectivity. I think it matters greatly that we achieve synergies spanning our major platforms and our client segments. You'll be hearing us discuss that considerably more in the future, along with what metrics we'll use to show that we're genuinely realizing those synergies. We examine fees and returns. So if it's capital, is it producing returns? Are we achieving the growth? We fall short on fee revenues compared to what Mark and I would prefer. That enters into the equation. Then, does it genuinely align with the strategic identity we hold for Citi and are developing through the refresh? If the answer is yes, then it becomes a candidate for investment, with the strategy spelled out. If the answer is no, the reverse applies. On dispositions, timing will always be something we factor in. As I mentioned on the previous question, there are no fire sales here, and we'll be careful about how we make sure we deliver value for shareholders on the exit, considering the potential value of partnerships with possible buyers, and so on. What’s the best way for us to turn this into revenue and create value while we’re doing it? In a lot of respects, it’s somewhat a mix of every item you just listed, though our starting point is the reverse, if that makes sense. What is it that we’re going to be? Put our attention on guaranteeing we produce the most value from that. Pretty soon afterward, the remaining choices basically follow from it. I believe that’s visible in what we chose regarding Citi Global Wealth as well as the hubs into which we’re putting money across Asia and EMEA. In the same way, the other calls about the 13 markets that are left on consumer amount to the exit.
Mike Mayo
analystAlright, a second question from me. It's still early days, yet might you have an idea regarding the type of return that you would eventually want to deliver? And in the end, what identity would you wish Citigroup to hold? What does Citigroup stand for?
Jane Fraser
executiveRight.
Mike Mayo
analystHow would you sum it up in an elevator? Give us the pitch.
Jane Fraser
executiveMike, Citigroup is fantastic. Once more, if I think back to what investors have been telling me while we've been traveling around and hearing from them — what is it they're asking for? They'd like us to narrow the returns gap versus our competitors. Mark has offered a few hints, I believe. We're looking at a normalized rate environment, and we've got the strategy in place for it. Something in the mid-tier range strikes me as sensible, though I'd definitely add: allow us to do the work. I want to be certain we hold a truly thoughtful strategy, and that we have clarity surrounding it. When you ask what Citi will become, we'll come back to you with far greater precision and clarity on that, once again. From a few of the steps we've taken, I believe you can tell we genuinely aim to be excellent. That applies not only to how we serve our clients — plenty of whom have needs spanning the globe — and there's considerable consistency on that front. Beyond that, regarding what Citi is, my wish is for the term excellent to describe us in how we operate, in our culture, in our accountability, and in everything we do. You'll be hearing that word from me often, and it's the standard to which I hold myself and the firm.
Steven Chubak
analystHi, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveMorning.
Steven Chubak
analystLet me kick things off with a question. If I look back to 2014 and consider the strategic moves you made, Jane, what was laid out back then was quite comparable when it came to the profitability characteristics of the businesses being exited and the capital gains that would eventually be realized. Yet it was hard, at minimum, to detect some of those gains when I examine how the profitability picture has shifted. From where you sit, having been with the company when that effort was launched, what did you take away from that experience? Is there anything different in how you'd proceed this time that could produce perhaps more noticeable or clearer improvements to the bottom line?
Jane Fraser
executivePardon me. I simply want to confirm I've got the question right. You're asking about it in terms of what digitization delivers?
Steven Chubak
analystSetting aside digitization entirely — when I recall those departures, there were strategic moves you'd carried out back in 2014, pulling out. Uh-huh. Yeah. A small set of markets, in an effort to fine-tune that worldwide consumer presence; the way it was disclosed was quite comparable, in that the markets being left behind were only marginally profitable. There were capital advantages that stood to be gained.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah.
Steven Chubak
analystAt a minimum, those gains show up in the bottom line. I'm wondering whether you could just talk about a few of the lessons that came out of that?
Jane Fraser
executiveAll right. Understood.
Steven Chubak
analystYou may see it somewhat differently.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Looking at LATAM, the gains we achieved were really quite extraordinary. First off, I believe we could concentrate heavily on what we do best within our institutional franchise; we made certain we had genuinely top-tier talent. We put money into our technology and platforms; we stayed sharply focused on that client base of multinationals we serve in the region, especially the investor base involved in Latin America. We pushed the returns from teenagers up to mid-20s within a fairly brief span. We climbed the rankings on the banking side, and truly cemented our leadership in the institutional space. I would add that we also streamlined the management structure in that region and reaped considerable advantages from that simplification, which flowed through to the bottom line too. My own experience has shown there is genuine upside from focus. You improve in the businesses you operate in, you attract strong talent, and you can bring in more dedicated talent; that is the distinction. You can genuinely establish the connections among the various businesses, and zero in on them. Mark, I'm not sure whether you have anything further to contribute, since you and I.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Jane Fraser
executiveAre both in these journeys together.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Jane, I believe you summarized that nicely. What I would stress regarding how things differ today as we proceed is really those final two points you raised — specifically that intense concentration on ensuring the correct people are in the correct roles while we work through this strategy refresh. Making certain the organizational structure backs that up. Once more, I return to the wealth illustration and how that organizational structure was reset. You could reference the notion of shifting commercial into ICG so that you have that concentration behind that strategy, and you can genuinely see the connections throughout the company. The final element is the targeted investment; we are shifting away from scattering the investments and truly wanting to concentrate them where we believe the largest growth possibilities exist and where the greatest returns are. I think you covered everything, Jane.
Steven Chubak
analystThat's really helpful information, and I appreciate both of you walking us through what you've seen. Turning to my next question, I want to dig into the TTS segment. It's a strong business, and historically the expansion in the balances beneath it has been both quite healthy and pretty steady; over the past few quarters, though, it has come under some pressure. A lot of that appears to be connected to net interest income or rates. I was hoping you might share your thoughts on the trends you're seeing underneath that business. Given where we are now — with most of the rate headwinds presumably having been fully taken in or baked into the run rate — how do you see things?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, sure. Let me start us off, and Jane, feel free to jump in whenever you want to add something from the client side. So on the revenue point, you're correct that on an ex-FX basis we're looking at a decline of about 10% compared to last year. You've got it exactly right. The low rate environment we've been dealing with has played a really big role in what's showing up in our total TTS revenues. That said, deposit volumes have come in higher, and that naturally carries through with an effect. On your wider question, what we pay attention to is, first, how engaged we are with clients — and our engagement with clients has been very substantial and meaningful all the way through this crisis that we've been working through. That involvement shows up in the larger count of accounts — digital accounts we've opened for those clients — and it really underscores the money we've put into onboarding and into strengthening what we can do digitally. You can see that involvement in the clearing volume and the cross-border deals we've handled, with each rising 6% and 7% across the last 12 months, so the fundamental engines are solid. Even though commercial card activity and fee revenues are under pressure, once you set commercial card aside, things have looked strong. Honestly, if the economy keeps bouncing back and those GDP projections begin to materialize, our expectation is that business activity will shift and that will begin showing up in revenue. Once again, we're seeing really solid, ongoing involvement from our customers, and in the way they're changing their own approaches. One final illustration: a lot of our customers, with digital transformation speeding up, are zeroing in on B2C efforts, which is a key growth space. We're in on that conversation. When it comes to their business model or models, we're in on building that answer. Jane, is there anything you’d like to add on top of that?
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. There's a lot more coming your way regarding our TTS business, along with the services platform it stands for on behalf of so many clients we serve globally.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Jane Fraser
executiveOver these past several months, when I speak with customers, they're extremely enthusiastic about our TTS platform. Beyond enthusiasm, their reliance on it runs deep. For them, it's a strategic asset. The range of services, the information it carries, the additional aspects involved. The expansion we expect from this, in my view, will be quite substantial come next year. You'll also hear us discuss the commercial bank more in the future, since mid-market and born digital clients are the ones who leverage our TTS platform along with the related capabilities and services so that they too can begin expanding globally. It turns into something essential for them; there's additional room to grow alongside our current customers. A great many new customers are joining us on this, and this will be a thrilling piece of the narrative ahead. The fundamental possibilities in this area stand apart from what happens with rates.
Ken Usdin
analystThank you. Hello there, and good morning. Jane and Mark, I wanted to ask the two of you about the global recovery and how it's pacing. When you go through the supplement, you can observe varying growth rates depending on whether you're looking at loans, cards, or deposits, since those move at different speeds, and naturally there are also currency translation effects. How would you assist us in grasping, as you anticipate revenue stabilizing over time, the way you expect the global customer base to recover when it comes to pacing between the U.S. and non-U.S.? It would be excellent if you could compare that, to whatever degree possible, with the wholesale side as well. Thanks.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. Let me begin with a bit more on the macro front. Mark will chime in regarding some of the other significant dimensions for us. Look, what we're observing is asynchronous growth. I believe you're seeing the U.S. and China clearly leading the recovery along with Asia. Europe has been delayed, though it certainly hasn't been derailed. Certain emerging markets are struggling. You do witness a differing picture across various regions of the world. As I think you heard me say at the start of this call, we're fairly optimistic about the U.S. specifically over the coming few years. Consumers out there hold a great deal of unspent savings. There are enormous amounts of liquidity in the market. Corporate balance sheets are largely healthy. You've also got considerable dynamism from digitization, which is altering consumer behaviors and fueling investment. On the whole, the outlook around the world is certainly much improved, but it is an asynchronous one. As Mark discussed, we're seeing strong pipelines, a great deal of client engagement, and a great deal of client activity. Mark, why don't I hand things over to you on.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah.
Jane Fraser
executiveHow you're seeing some of this translate?
Mark Mason
executiveOkay, so I’ll offer a few observations here. First, on the consumer side, the pressure hasn’t let up, and we’ve already mentioned that loan volumes have fallen — in Branded Cards specifically, average loans were down almost 15%, or 15%, while Retail Services average loans declined 13%. That said, I’d point out that recovery signals are appearing. Even with those loan declines, payment rates are still elevated, and from a cost of credit standpoint, that’s helpful. On purchase sales, some encouraging movement is emerging. Branded Cards purchase sales came in flat compared with a year earlier. Retail Services purchase sales rose 4% versus the prior year. The broader outlook looks favorable when it comes to GDP and unemployment. In North America, the stimulus still needs time to work through. We feel good that consumer spending patterns appear set to turn more favorable, and that should without question support the forecast I referenced — namely, improvement in NIR and some lending activity in the latter half of the year. Over on the corporate ICG side, likewise, we’re definitely seeing encouraging indicators around markets activity; we’ve discussed this, and it has carried on since last year. Even when I consider ICG loans, there’s been lending activity in the private bank. There’s been lending activity in certain areas of markets. Lending activity tied to trade — all of these are solid signals of the recovery we’re all working toward.
Ken Usdin
analystYes. Another question regarding cards, Mark. During your prepared comments, you noted that an increase in card losses was anticipated. You said in a general way that losses on cards would stay fairly low. Could you help us grasp how you anticipate card losses will move over time?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. I'll bring up a few points about that. First, let's break it down. On the chart from slide 10, Latin America saw a significant rise this quarter, nearly 11% of NCLs. That again results from customers exiting the relief program during the third quarter. When we examine the delinquency buckets, no meaningful indications of growth are appearing within them. That reassures us that for Latin America, a peak has been reached. In other regions too, nothing in the delinquency bucket points toward substantial rises in our NCLs. Actually, in North America, as I told you, we probably wouldn't witness that before late in 2022. It comes down to the payment rates we observe. It's the low activity tied to the delinquency buckets; clearly the effect of stimulus flowing through all of it reassures us at this point that a surge in NCLs is unlikely, at least in 2021.
Brian Kleinhanzl
analystHey, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveMorning.
Brian Kleinhanzl
analystYes, a couple of things I wanted to ask. Those balances declined 30% compared with the same period a year earlier. What I'm attempting to figure out is how much of that reflects what clients are asking for as opposed to how much risk you're willing to take on overall. Perhaps I'm simply trying to determine whether, if you were willing to take on more risk, those loan balances might return faster.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Well, look, as you're aware, we're navigating this crisis. If you think back to the beginning of last year, and to the second quarter of last year, the focus was on making sure clients had the right amount of liquidity; that's kept occurring, as reflected in our deposit growth, as you've heard other people say, as you can see in the monetary action there. By and large, our corporate clients hold plenty of liquidity, and a lot of the clients we work with can choose how they'd like to reach the market for that liquidity. You observed that in certain ECM and DCM activity for the remainder of last year and even some of it still going on. That's a long-winded way of saying this business is driven by clients. It comes down to client demand, so it isn't a matter of risk appetite. Risk appetite always matters. We always function within our risk appetite framework. What you're witnessing here relates to client demand.
Brian Kleinhanzl
analystAll right. Then a follow-up about cards. You mentioned wanting to expand the number of new card accounts. Could you elaborate a bit further on what the approach behind that looks like? Does it lean more toward returning to promotional balances and reopening that pool once more? What will you do to bring in those new card accounts? Thank you.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Once more, what matters with the card situation here is making sure our timing is correct when it comes to reentering the market, correct? Clearly, arriving at this point, our intention was to be quite deliberate regarding the way we handled our risk. We made risk standards stricter so that we could be sure we would handle things responsibly throughout this pandemic. Now, as we sit here and observe every indication of recovery that you have heard us refer to, what it comes down to is a responsible reopening, correct? Making certain we aim at the customers we seek over the longer term, the current customers to whom we are extending line availability where doing so is sensible. When it comes to our Retail Services, we are going after new account acquisitions in that area and in Branded Cards too. It comes down to that reentry approach, and in line with the target market customer you have heard us talk about previously, who tends to be of a higher quality.
Chris Kotowski
analystMorning, and thanks. I want to ask about the exit markets, especially those in the Pacific Rim. Do operational connections exist among the businesses in each of those nations that would make those firms more attractive when sold together to a pan-national buyer? Or is the structure quite modular, such that it could be broken up and every country sold off to whoever bids the most? Also, I was curious whether the Cards carrying the Citi brand are included in these dispositions, or whether you keep that business separate and keep working to attract and expand the cardholder base?
Jane Fraser
executiveHi, Chris. Regarding the exit markets, I'd say it's a bit soon to be guessing about who the buyers might be. These franchises are wonderful. In the individual markets, we have truly exceptional talent and truly exceptional capabilities. We anticipate a great deal of interest. As for who and what, I will definitely not be speculating at this point. On your question about operational connections, this is something that Mark and I, as he mentioned, have been through a fair number of divestitures in various geographies; we have strong expertise in ensuring we can carve out the consumer franchises and then put money into the capabilities for the ICG businesses; that has never been an issue in any of the divestitures we've completed, and there were many. I believe it was roughly 11 or 12 throughout Latin America and elsewhere previously. Our teams are skilled at this. It won't be a problem. Actually, it will let us, as we've stated, direct our investments more toward the institutional platforms and wealth in the hubs, as we discussed. And on the subject of Branded Cards, are Branded Cards part of the sale? Yes, that's a very straightforward response to that.
Chris Kotowski
analystAll right.
Jane Fraser
executiveNaturally, transaction services continues to be a key component of what we offer across those 13 markets. On the TTS side, our strengths in commercial cards, our strengths in payments, and so forth, stay whole, and we will keep putting money into them.
Gerard Cassidy
analystGood morning, Jane. Good morning, Mark.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Jane Fraser
executiveMorning.
Gerard Cassidy
analystMark, could you tell us something. A lot of us are attempting to see how your institution and rival banks might appear once conditions return to something closer to usual and the pandemic is behind us. Loan loss reserves stand out as one key topic, because as you and others in the industry noted, they were increased substantially. At present, naturally, you are reducing them. Could you let us know — if my memory serves, on the very first day, January 20, when the fresh CECL guidelines took effect, the ratio of your loan loss reserve to loans stood at roughly 2.6%, and I believe right now it sits near 3.3%. Could you provide some sense, directionally speaking, of whether you believe you might reach that level? I realize numerous variables are in motion, along with shifts in the loan composition and varying economic forecasts, yet the economy appears far stronger over the coming 12 months than it did before the pandemic, back when all of you established those day one reserves. Naturally, at that time, we had no idea the pandemic was on its way.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. This is genuinely difficult to respond to, given how many dynamic elements are involved. Even though we are at 3.3%, as you mentioned, the broader conditions keep getting better. As those economic measures shift, be it U.S. unemployment or GDP, and likewise as our balances shift. As we keep coming back into the market, as I more or less indicated in my earlier answer, we will begin to expand balances, and that is going to affect the composition of the balances we hold. Every one of those elements, plus, in our situation, the way the likelihood and intensity of a downside scenario keeps transforming, turn into key considerations not just for replying to what you asked, but also for how we approach potential future reserve releases. I am not attempting to sidestep what you asked in any way, yet this is something that will end up being a sort of side effect of how we arrive at some feeling of normality and how the portfolio keeps developing.
Gerard Cassidy
analystUnderstood. Yes, that makes complete sense. Jane, I might have overlooked this, yet I could clearly pick up on the enthusiasm in your tone regarding the fresh update to the strategy. If you had to step back, how long is this — a 3-year, 5-year undertaking? Do you have any sense of the timeframe required for Citi to reach the position you're aiming for?
Jane Fraser
executiveThat's a good question. When we undertake the strategy refresh work, what we're doing is examining things from a long-term standpoint for the company. I don't believe completing the strategy refresh work will take us a great deal of time, and as we've mentioned, we'll be eager to share it with everyone along the way. We proceed with execution the moment it's appropriate. As someone who used to be a consultant, I genuinely don't know whether strategy is something you ever finish. The world moves fast; it's a captivating world. I believe some of that enthusiasm comes from my excitement about the franchise. The prospects for the company excite me. I'm also pragmatic. There's a substantial amount of work ahead of us. Mark and I have absolute clarity on our priorities. I don't expect it will take us long at all to return to everyone with a clearer picture of our direction. I'm eager to do that, and above all, eager to move forward with it. I don't think you ever finish.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely, Gerard — I can promise you that Jane has all of us operating with real urgency, and that is exactly the right place for our attention to be during this strategy refresh. Jane, you hit the nail on the head. Strategy isn't something that simply comes to a halt. Nicely put.
Vivek Juneja
analystHello, Jane. Hello, Mark. I appreciate you letting me ask something.
Jane Fraser
executiveHello, Vivek.
Vivek Juneja
analystJane, I'd like to hear your perspective. You've completed those exits—the ones you discussed in Latin America—and at present you're carrying out something similar within the consumer bank, plus you've now made an announcement regarding Asia. How would you characterize the distinctions between your consumer franchise in Asia and the one in Latin America? Specifically on investment sales, what proportion of revenue does that represent, say, in your Asia consumer bank compared with Latin America? That's one smaller follow-up on the matter. Will those revenues disappear as well? So two separate questions—one somewhat bigger picture—but connected to it is this entire investment sales topic and how you view it, along with what it means for your private banking revenues, which I assume differ from this investment sales revenue appearing in the.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah.
Vivek Juneja
analystConsumer bank.
Jane Fraser
executiveYeah. I believe there are notable distinctions between our consumer operations in Asia and those in Latin America. To be clear, in Latin America our franchise today consists solely of Citibanamex. That's one country, holding roughly a 20% market share, and it provides a complete suite of services to consumers, unlike our Asian operations, which were somewhat smaller. Those are strong operations. They have a solid brand, as you're aware. They possess excellent card businesses and a wealthy customer base, yet their scale hasn't matched what we possess in Mexico. To me, they're quite distinct. I suppose what you're really asking is how the divestitures affect our wealth operation in Asia. When you examine each Asian market individually, the local capital markets aren't especially advanced. The offshore markets in Hong Kong and Singapore, plus those in the Middle East, the United States, London, and similar locations, turn into crucial markets. Typically, the onshore wealth chance is enormously overshadowed by the offshore wealth chance, and that's where we believe we're positioned best to direct our focus and resources. What I'd add, though, is that one benefit for Citi is that we aren't merely an investment sales operation — we also hold the deposit business, the card business; we certainly have the capital market platform. We can provide our clients with outstanding managed investments. The content we can deliver, because of our ICG franchise, is genuinely top-tier. I know it's rather remarkable when it comes to asset allocation advice. These are truly the capabilities we can bring. The client is extremely well-diversified across lending, banking, along with the investment and managed investment capital market revenues that you observe. I don't view this purely as investment sales. This is something we can offer that's far broader within those wealth center hubs. In those 13 markets, the offshore opportunity greatly exceeds the onshore one. You'll receive further guidance on this down the road, as Mark mentioned, and as Jim elaborates on the strategy and the plan we have. You should anticipate getting additional details.
Jane Fraser
executiveWe appreciate everyone being here today. Should you have any additional questions afterward, don't hesitate to get in touch with investor relations. Thanks once more, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the first quarter of 2021. We appreciate everyone joining us. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.