Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 14, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 63 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you all being with us. I want to remind everybody that the presentation today, which you can download from our site citigroup.com, might include forward-looking statements. Those are based on what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. Actual results, capital, and other financial conditions could differ materially from those statements because of a variety of factors, including the precautionary statements mentioned in our discussion today and those in our SEC filings, including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 20 Form 10-K. Before we begin, I also want to welcome Jennifer Landis, our incoming Head of IR, who joins Citi next month and will host this call starting in October as I step away from the seat to take on a new role within Citi. I want to thank all of you for your partnership and support over the past few years. Having said that, let me hand it over to Jane.

Jane Fraser

executive
#2

Thank you, Liz, and a good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to be with you once more today. To begin, I'll go over how we performed in the first complete quarter during which I've held the CEO role, and after that I'll bring you up to speed on where we stand with our strategic priorities. During this quarter, net income came in at $6.2 billion, which works out to $2.85 per share; an improving macro backdrop keeps working in our favor, as shown by yet another sizable release of our allowances for credit losses. The truth is, the speed of the macro rebound is running ahead of what we previously anticipated around the world, and accompanying it is rising confidence among consumers and corporations. That message also came through unmistakably in the discussions I had with clients during the week I recently passed in London. Of course, we must stay alert to how uneven this global recovery is, given ongoing contagion and difficulties with vaccine distribution in a number of regions, yet we feel positive about the momentum that lies ahead, and because of that, we chose to speed up certain investments on purpose. Within our institutional businesses, fixed income trading normalized as we had anticipated, in contrast with the remarkable volatility seen in Q2 of last year, while our equities franchise enjoyed an especially robust quarter. Going forward, we do anticipate that volatile markets will remain above where they stood before COVID. Our Investment Banking franchise kept performing well, with solid momentum in M&A and a very strong pipeline for the remainder of the year. Our efforts to grow fee revenues showed very encouraging progress, with double-digit growth in ICG fee revenues and, more specifically, fee growth of over 20% year-over-year in Treasury and Trade Solutions and Securities Services, as well as in the private bank; TTS, of course, serves as the backbone of the distinctive global network we provide to our clients. And although lower rates keep weighing on that business, we especially like our positioning from a market share standpoint as the post-pandemic recovery takes hold; in Consumer Banking, even though elevated payment rates in cards weighed on our loan book and revenues, spending now sits well above pre-COVID levels, with global purchase sales up 38% year-over-year. We expect that to turn into loan growth during the second half of the year. And we keep enjoying good momentum in deposit growth as well as AUMs throughout our consumer franchises. Here in the U.S., as we've talked about, we're putting money into our home market, as the warmly received June launch of our innovative Custom Cash Card shows. Abroad, the budget is what defines the picture for our consumer business. So although the Mexican economy remains soft, loan growth came back in Asia, and that happened even with new COVID outbreaks. Now to capital. Across the first two quarters of 2021, we gave back close to $7 billion to our shareholders, the highest amount the Federal Reserve's rules allowed. Looking ahead, we're dedicated to giving back whatever capital exceeds what's required to put into our franchise. So even though the Fed's latest stress test pushed our stress capital buffer up to 3%, that won't change the common equity Tier 1 target we'd manage toward, which is roughly 11.5%. On a standardized basis, we closed the quarter at 11.9%, leaving us with surplus capital to hand back to shareholders via a solid dividend and a continuing buyback program. Finally, tangible book value per share rose to $77.87, which is up more than 9% versus a year earlier. Let's now shift to three strategic priorities of ours: Strategy, Transformation, and Talent. I'm quite happy with how far we've come on refreshing our strategy. We acted quickly to kick off the sale process for the 13 consumer markets in Asia and EMEA that we intend to leave. The initial round of bids proved highly encouraging and competitive, which comes as no shock since these are excellent businesses for the right owners. Across those regions, we've hit the ground running with our wealth strategy. We're directing meaningful strategic investments toward product capabilities, technology, and talent, and that's already showing up in stronger client acquisition. We keep doing rigorous, energetic work to refresh our strategy throughout our consumer and institutional businesses, guided by the four principles I laid out for you earlier this year: being clinical, being focused, and ensuring both connectivity and simplification. Our ultimate aim is to lift the returns we produce and narrow the distance to our peers by putting money into the franchises that will generate the greatest growth, the three most prominent being TTS, wealth, and commercial banking. And I have strong confidence in the growth and return potential these connected franchises will bring us. Just as we've done up to now, we'll tell you about our strategy decisions as we reach them, and we're eager to lay out our plans for you in fuller detail at an Investor Day, which we plan to host during the first quarter of next year. We're going to place our whole vision for the company before you. That way, you can hold us accountable for delivering on it. As we talked about on last quarter's call, we're also laboring very hard and diligently on our transformation. This is a major undertaking, and an exciting one too, and we're collaborating closely with our regulators to satisfy their expectations, with plans to submit our proposals to them this quarter; now, while tackling the consent orders is an intense focus of the transformation, the work we're doing extends far past the orders themselves. We've resolved to modernize our bank. We aim for nothing short of excellence, and that means putting money into our risk and control environment, as well as into the infrastructure required to serve our clients in a world that's increasingly digital. Alright, here's an illustration using TTS. The money we're putting in will make our platform more scalable, automation is going to boost efficiency along with the client experience, and spending on data is going to lift revenues, plus what we're investing will help put us in a position to keep our standing as the top corporate bank worldwide. That brings me at last to talent, and there we've achieved meaningful strides during the last few months. The quality of people we've been drawing into the company to expand our businesses and back our transformation makes me very pleased. We've strengthened the teams already in place by bringing aboard best-in-market hires across data, risk, strategy and controls, and also on the front lines of wealth, the commercial bank, and BCMA, especially. We keep putting money into a culture of excellence and into our own employees, giving them fresh leadership and growth chances. It's this mix of a new viewpoint together with our current pool of high-caliber talent that is going to let us move the firm ahead with excellence, urgency, and accountability. Now, before handing things to Mark, I want to express my thanks to Liz Lynn for the excellent work she has done heading our Investor Relation efforts across the past several years. And as you're aware, and as she said, she will become our Finance Lead for BCMA, where all of us know she'll do a terrific job. With that, Mark is going to walk through our presentation; and after that, the two of us will gladly take your questions.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Thanks, Jane, and good morning to all of you. Turning to slide 3, Citigroup posted net income of $6.2 billion for the second quarter, along with EPS of $2.85 and a RoTCE of 15.2%. Revenue came in 12% lower than a year ago, which mirrors a normalization in fixed income markets, together with reduced card loans in consumer and the effect of lower interest rates. On expenses, we saw a 7% increase year-over-year, and in constant dollars the rise was 4%, reflecting a normalization against last year's low figure, plus ongoing investments in our transformation and other strategic investments, partly offset by productivity savings. Our credit results remained solid. We saw $1.3 billion in net credit losses, but that was more than covered by a $2.4 billion ACL release. That release speaks to improvements in the portfolio as well as our macroeconomic outlook continuing to get better. Looking at constant dollars, end-of-period loans were down 3% compared to a year earlier, and the reason is that both institutional and consumer customers are paying back at higher rates. That being said, I want to note that we're starting to see some areas where loan growth is emerging, and for the first time in more than a year, loans were up on a sequential basis. On deposits, we had a modest increase, rising 4% from a year ago, which shows our consumer and corporate clients remain engaged. During the first six months of 2021, overall revenue declined 9% compared with the same period a year earlier, or 10% when measured in constant dollars. That drop was driven largely by more typical conditions in fixed income markets and reduced card balances on the consumer side, even though we recorded robust growth in fee revenue for consumer and for ICG once fixed income markets were excluded. By the midpoint of the year, total expenses had increased 6% as reported and 3% in constant dollars. I'll share additional detail on what we expect for the rest of the year in a moment. Credit costs produced a gain of about $3 billion, reflecting the release of more than $6 billion from reserves, and we generated approximately $14 billion in net income alongside a RoTCE of 17.6%. To wrap up, as Jane noted before, we've given back about $7 billion of capital during this year. We're still dedicated to putting money into our franchise while also distributing whatever capital is left over to shareholders, thanks to the room the SCB framework gives us. Now let's look at each business. On Slide 4, you'll see how the Institutional Clients Group performed; ICG produced EBIT of $4.9 billion for the quarter, a big jump versus a year ago. Revenue fell 14%, largely because fixed income markets were weaker, while expenses rose 4% and climbed 2% in constant dollars, since spending on transformation and other strategic investments was largely balanced out by reduced incentive compensation and cost savings. Our credit expenses fell sharply, helped by an allowance for credit losses release of about $900 million along with reduced net credit losses. In addition, ICG produced a 16.4% return on allocated capital. On Slide 5, you can see a more detailed breakdown of revenues for the Institutional Clients Group. Second-quarter product revenues declined 17%, largely because the prior-year period was a tough comparison, especially in fixed income markets. Despite that, we continue to see strong client engagement and sound underlying growth across our fee-based businesses companywide, including TTS, Investment Banking, Securities Services, Commercial Banking, and the Private Bank. Excluding the markets-related component, non-interest revenues climbed 24% this quarter, and we remain confident in our forecast of continued strong fee growth over the back half of the year. Looking deeper into the figures, revenues in Banking declined 1%. Within Treasury and Trade Solutions, a roughly 25% jump in fee revenues — driven by solid client engagement and trade growth — was more than offset by lower interest rates, resulting in a 1% revenue decrease. Across our Payments Business, we continue to see favorable trends: cross-border flows up 13% and clearing volumes up 10% over the past 12 months, together with the early stage of a recovery in commercial cards. And by the close of the quarter, TTS loans had expanded by approximately 5%, which mirrors rising client demand and better macroeconomic conditions. Investment banking revenues rose 1%, since greater M&A and equity underwriting revenues were mostly canceled out by a drop in debt underwriting. Although the overall DCM wallet increased during the second quarter, every bit of that growth came from non-investment grade, which gave us no advantage because of our SKU toward investment grade. Still, when compared with a more typical year, revenues climbed 38% against the second quarter of 2019, with robust growth across every product. In our Private Bank, revenue was up 4%, driven by higher fees and increased lending activity. That performance showed good momentum with both new and existing clients, though lower interest rates worked against us to some degree. Corporate Lending saw a 15% decline in revenue, largely attributable to reduced volumes. Overall markets and securities services revenue came in 30% lower than the same period a year ago. Within that, Fixed Income was down 43%, a result that reflects the tough comparison to a strong prior-year stretch across both rates and spread products. Despite that, we kept working closely with our clients, and revenues from corporate and investor clients alike grew steadily when measured against the historical average. Turning to the numbers, equities brought in 37% more than the prior year. The main drivers there were derivatives and prime finance, both of which turned in strong performances amid healthy client engagement and supportive market conditions. Over in securities services, revenue was up 9% as reported, or 5% when you strip out currency effects. What we saw there was healthy fee revenue growth, coming from both new and existing clients, helped by higher assets under custody and more settlement volume, though narrower spreads worked partly against that. And if you look at ICG's first-half results, Investment Banking made a strong contribution, with the Private Bank and Securities Services also delivering solid results, which together helped offset the normalization in fixed income markets that we had expected. I'd like to note as well that revenues in equity markets are up over 30%. Turning now to Slide 6 and what Global Consumer Banking delivered in constant dollars. This quarter, GCB's EBIT reached $2.4 billion, which is a big jump from a year earlier. Revenues declined 10%, because even though deposit growth stayed strong, spreads compressed, and Investment Management carried solid momentum, all of that was more than offset by lower card balances across all three regions. As for cards, we're encouraged by consumer spending, which continues to improve — purchase sales climbed almost 40% versus last year and roughly 20% from the previous quarter — but revenue is still being held back by high payment rates. Expenses rose 7%, which mirrors ongoing transformation investments plus other strategic spending, a pickup in marketing, and greater volume-related costs relative to the low mark set 12 months earlier, all partly offset by savings from efficiency efforts. Credit quality is still solid, and credit costs fell substantially, helped by the $1.4 billion ACL reserve release together with reduced net credit losses. In addition, GCB posted a 20.8% return on allocated capital. Last, when we examine the first-half results, our drivers have improved steadily, and that bolsters our confidence in the outlook as we head into the back half of the year. Slide 7 provides a closer look at North America Consumer results. Second-quarter revenue dropped 11% versus a year ago, largely because of weaker cards revenue, though that was still better than the 15% year-over-year decrease recorded in the prior quarter.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

Both our branded cards and retail services saw revenue drops — 12% for the former and 14% for the latter. The reason is that the headwinds persist from elevated payment rates, since customers keep tapping stimulus funds and other relief programs to reduce what they owe, which means fewer loans and a mix that leans more toward transactor balances. That puts pressure on our net interest revenues, though it helps our delinquency and loss trends at the same time. Even so, sales activity keeps recovering, with purchase sales now exceeding where they stood before the pandemic, led by discretionary spending such as travel and dining. Within Branded Cards, total purchase sales climbed 40% compared with a year ago and, importantly, rose 11% against the second quarter of 2019. In Retail Services, purchase sales likewise increased against both the second quarter of 2019 and 2020. The encouraging part, then, is that spend recovery keeps progressing and our acquisition levels are getting back to where they were before COVID. Going forward, we anticipate that purchase sales growth will turn into loan growth by the time the year ends, once stimulus eases and customers go back to more typical payment habits. Now for Retail Banking, revenues fell 7% versus the prior year, hit by lower deposit spreads and weaker mortgage revenues. Even so, momentum remains solid as we expand and strengthen our retail bank relationships, while also raising their quality and stickiness. Average deposits rose 18%, which includes 24% growth in checking, and Citigold households grew 16% in number, helping push AUMs up 23%. Slide 8 shows International Consumer Banking results in constant dollars. Second-quarter revenues dropped 6% from a year earlier, with Latin America down 11% and Asia down 3%. Across International Consumer as a whole, Investment Management has good momentum, with assets under management up 15%, mostly from Asia, and those figures are considerably larger if you look only at the four international wealth hubs. Average deposit growth stayed robust at 8%, though deposit spreads were lower; and as in the U.S., purchase sales rose 26% year-over-year, while cards loan growth remained difficult this quarter, with average card loans falling 8% because of elevated payment rates. Slide 9 gives more detail on global consumer credit trends. In the U.S., NCL and delinquency rates both stayed favorable, thanks to the substantial customer liquidity coming from stimulus and other relief programs. Based on the delinquency trends we see now, we don't anticipate credit deterioration in the U.S. portfolio during 2021, and how losses ultimately play out in terms of timing and level as we look toward next year will hinge on whether the stimulus produces a lasting benefit. So as we had anticipated, both Mexico and Asia saw credit losses and delinquency rates move lower after hitting a high point during 2021's first quarter. Taken as a whole, then, activity is bouncing back, and the consumer is in quite sound financial shape, which points to solid momentum going into the second half of the year. On Slide 10, you can see how Corporate/Other performed: revenues slipped a bit in dollar terms, since one-time items we'd already disclosed from the earlier year outweighed the episodic gains booked this quarter. On the expense side, there was a modest dollar increase, largely from FX effects, and just like the previous quarter, we've shifted additional cost into the businesses tied to infrastructure risk and controls investments. That shift, as noted before, left EBIT at the Citi level untouched, but we've recast earlier periods so the numbers compare more cleanly. Credit costs came down versus a year ago, helped by a release this quarter against a build in the comparable prior-year stretch. All told, EBIT broke even for the quarter. Going forward, we'd anticipate a pretax loss each quarter somewhere between $200 million and $300 million through the rest of 2021. Slide 11 lays out our net interest revenue and margin trends, plus non-interest revenues on a reported basis. For comparison against earlier periods, constant-dollar net interest revenues appear on Slide 19 of the appendix; during the second quarter, net interest revenue reached $10.2 billion, a year-over-year drop of $880 million, as loan balances fell and rates came down. Sequentially, net interest revenue kept steadying, with the quarter's extra day canceled out by weaker cards revenues. Net interest margin fell three basis points, largely from lower cards NIR and modest balance sheet growth tied to deposits, partly countered by higher markets NIR during the quarter. Now to non-interest revenues at the bottom of that slide: in the second quarter, non-NIR dropped $1.4 billion, mostly from normalization in fixed income markets. Beyond markets, though, we enjoyed strong, broad-based fee growth exceeding $600 million spanning GCB and ICG. Across the last two quarters, those fee revenues have come back to pre-pandemic levels of about $4.4 billion each quarter, which signals a recovery running somewhat ahead of expectations. With half the year behind us, these results leave us at ease with our earlier outlook, and we still see total Citi revenues falling within the mid-single-digit range for the full year, though the mix will probably look somewhat different, something I'll cover shortly. Slide 12 presents our key capital metrics, which once again stayed strong and stable this quarter, letting us back clients and give capital back to shareholders. Our CET1 capital ratio rose to 11.9%, as buybacks and dividends mostly absorbed net income. In the course of this quarter, we gave back $4.1 billion altogether to holders of common stock — $1.1 billion through dividends plus $3 billion via buybacks. Our supplementary leverage ratio came in at 5.9%, lower than the previous quarter, mostly because the temporary SLR relief came to an end; and tangible book value per share rose 9%, reaching $77.87, thanks to net income. Before turning to Q&A, allow me a few minutes to discuss how we see 2021; regarding the topline for Citigroup overall, we continue to anticipate that revenues will fall in the mid-single digits as reported. Yet, as I noted, the mix will probably differ somewhat from what we had initially expected. So far this year, growth in non-interest revenues has come in stronger than anticipated, and we do anticipate that momentum in fee growth will persist through the second half, chiefly because of ICG. As for net interest revenues, we look for continued stabilization during the back half and expect some loan growth to emerge by year-end; thus, even though net interest revenues have fallen about $2.2 billion so far this year, just beyond what we initially projected for the entire year, if this base case pans out, we don't foresee a meaningful additional drop in net interest revenues going forward on a full year basis. So, once more in total for Citigroup, we continue to anticipate that revenues will fall in the mid-single digits.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

Regarding costs, after our recent strategic refresh efforts, we've decided to push even harder on some strategic investments, partly because the recovery appears to be happening faster than we anticipated. Consequently, our projection now is that Citigroup's overall expenses will rise by a mid-single-digit percentage. These investments are strategic ones aimed at bolstering our franchise and fueling growth over the long term; for instance, we've sped up spending where we see major growth potential, such as comprehensively throughout Wealth and the Commercial Bank. We've also intensified our focus on established strengths and units like TTS, Securities Services, and the Investment Banking business. Lastly, because of the quicker rebound we're witnessing now, we're ramping up investments in things such as cards marketing to seize this opportunity. All these investments will yield considerable advantages eventually. In the meantime, costs tied specifically to the transformation—which we'd anticipated would fuel the 2% to 3% rise in total Citi expenses for this year—are arriving pretty much as forecast. Such investments encompass efforts on the consent order plus the wider initiative to modernize the bank, which will enhance our risk and control framework and enable us to serve our customers and clients better via a better operating environment, resulting in quicker decisions, greater efficiency, and an enhanced client experience. And I'd note that the composition of this spending is 30% technology and 70% non-tech related investments. Lastly, this guidance factors in achieving productivity savings that come as a side effect of the investments we've made over the past few years. And to be clear, we'll keep doing as we have before and seek ways to run as efficiently as possible throughout this investment phase. And one more thing, we might also encounter some occasional effects this year stemming from the market exits we're undertaking; and as I've said before, we'll be very open regarding how these moves affect our financials. So, to wrap up, we're pleased with the investments we're making and strongly believe they'll set us up well to eventually narrow our return gap to peers. Before we begin taking questions, I also want to pause and express gratitude to Liz Lynn for her tenure as the Head of Citi Investor Relations. Liz has been part of the Citi IR team since 2013 and has headed the Group since 2019. I'm aware she's forged solid connections with all of you and has been essential to my team since I became CFO, just over two years back. She's going to take on the role of Chief Financial Officer for our Investment Banking business. And as Liz said, Jen Landis will be with us in August as our new Head of Investor Relations. On our upcoming earnings call, I hope everyone will congratulate Liz on stepping into her new position and give Jen a warm welcome to Citi. With that said, Jane and I are glad to take your questions.

John McDonald

analyst
#6

Hello, and good morning. Mark, I really valued your comments at the end about where expenses are headed and the revised projection you gave for this year. Would you mind going into a little more detail on that? You're hardly the only one — other banks have been raising their own expense targets too. So what I'd like to understand is how much of this is driven by inflation pushing up the cost of operating a large bank in this environment, versus how much is something particular to Citi? And one more thing: does the expense run rate you expect for the second half of this year look like the level you'd sustain going into next year, or are there items that are running high just this year? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#7

Yes. Good morning, John. Appreciate that. So to start, I want to repeat part of what I already said earlier — we're being very intentional about the way this franchise is operated, okay? What I mentioned was that Jane, myself, and the rest of the leadership group are in the middle of a careful effort to rethink our strategy. While doing that, and particularly because the rebound arrived so fast, we're identifying real strategic chances to invest in the franchise. And we refuse to — we're not going to miss this opening while it's here. I've mentioned this point to you previously, and it concerns parts of the franchise that are bound to grow and deliver strong returns. So, whenever we talk about TTS, the Commercial Banking business, or Wealth, those are operations with significant expansion potential and, under ordinary conditions, returns exceeding 20%. Therefore, as I've stated, we're taking hold of that opportunity. Regarding the transformation work, I've consistently made it plain that we anticipated it would produce the 3% — 2% to 3% year-over-year gain, and that is materializing pretty much as we projected, and once more it's the right course of action, a crucial step toward bringing this bank up to date. Rising prices will certainly play a role, especially when it comes to staffing and the fight to attract skilled people. Still, that's something we handle all the time, and we keep hunting for gains in output and cost savings that mostly cancel it out. As for 2022, I won't offer any forecast, but I do think this stretch, as we emerge from all this, matters a great deal — it's our chance to make sure capital is being deployed wisely so the company is ready for what lies ahead.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#8

My apologies — the mute button caught me briefly. Good morning, everyone.

Mark Mason

executive
#9

Morning to you.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#10

For a start, hello and good morning. My opening query concerns branded cards over in North America. The typical balances came in almost unchanged, yet the spread is showing some strain. Could you shed some light on this — is it merely a case of more teaser rate promotions, or will it recover? What's your take on where revenue is headed and the narrowing spread we witnessed during this quarter?

Mark Mason

executive
#11

Right. Once more, the forces at play regarding cards revenue, and branded cards specifically within North America, which fell 12%, stem mostly from what we are observing when it comes to — when it comes to loan balances. And should you examine average interest-earning balances, those balances for our branded cards have declined roughly 11%. The positive side, as we've mentioned, is that purchase sale activity has risen substantially compared with a year ago and versus the quarter before, yet those payment rates truly are staying rather high, rather elevated. The favorable aspect is this shows up as an advantage when it comes to cost of credit, with losses coming in beneath expectations, and now reduced reserves given the releases we're seeing, but the real issue is that combination of elevated payment rates, diminished loan volumes, and average interest-earning especially, which is weighing on the top line.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#12

All right; that clears up the transactor balances question. Maybe thinking more broadly about the Wealth business, you issued a press release noting that you’d made sizable investments and new hires in Asia Wealth, with a fairly ambitious and aggressive plan to expand headcount. What’s the current status of that build out? And are you putting similar investments into other markets?

Jane Fraser

executive
#13

Yes, look, I think as we said, we’re quite enthusiastic about the wealth opportunity for us because we hold all the different pieces needed to succeed here — the brand, the client relationships, the platform, the commercial banking franchise — and we are already a sizable player. For instance, we’re number three in Asia, where a lot of the growth is coming from. The opportunity for us is pulling all of the pieces together into a single integrated offering across the full spectrum of clients. And so we’ve been investing in that platform, the technology; you’ll have seen the announcement yesterday in the U.S. about a self-directed digital offering there. We’ve been expanding and growing talent in the front line as well, and we’re very pleased also with the investment product revenue growth, which is — where from a mix point of view, we see the greatest upside for us. So, early days in the execution of this, but I think pleasing progress as we pull this together into this single integrated offering, invest behind it, and you’ll see the benefits in terms of growth as well as obviously return and revenue mix going forward for the bank.

Mark Mason

executive
#14

Yeah. Jane, the one thing I would put on top of that is that within the quarter we're already delivering solid results, correct? Private Bank revenues rose 4%; client assets kept climbing strongly, up 26%, with AUMs rising 29%, plus momentum in deposits, and so on. And like Jane said, while we put money into making the platform stronger, just yesterday we announced the launch of the self-directed investment digital offering, which is aimed again at U.S. consumer and wealth management clients, so it's encouraging movement as we spend and get ourselves ready to seize more opportunity in this space.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#15

Thanks. Good morning, Jane and Mark.

Mark Mason

executive
#16

Good morning.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#17

I just wanted to touch briefly on capital. When the SCB results came out, you'd mentioned a dividend of at least 51% and suggested buybacks would happen. Could you help us flesh that out a bit more — how should we think about the kind of capital return, or any dividend increases you might weigh from here, and how does that fit with potential changes in the SCB and your minimums?

Mark Mason

executive
#18

Sure. First, though, what I'd point out is that, as the second quarter shows, we repurchased the maximum the regulatory rules permit, based on the average of four quarters of net income. So continued capital return is something we remain very enthusiastic about. On the SCB and the latest results: as you're aware, our CET1 ratio target sits at roughly 11.5%. Built into that target is an estimate for the stress capital buffer of between 2.5% and 3%. Until this most recent set of results, the previous couple had come in at 2.5%. That 3% takes effect at the close of the third quarter. More significantly, the drivers affecting that Stress Capital Buffer — namely PPNR, plus balance sheet risk-weighted assets — will be actively managed by us, and our intent in doing so is to bring that Stress Capital Buffer back down. Turning to capital actions: with the SCB now in place, as you know, we have flexibility to make those calls in any given quarter, consistent with our — with the regulatory minimums, and that's what we intend to do. Given where the stock trades, buying back shares makes a lot of sense for us, so we'll keep skewing toward that. And right now, our dividend stays at 51%, but as I said, the flexibility from the SCB means we'll keep revisiting that quarter-to-quarter.

Jane Fraser

executive
#19

One more thing I’d mention is that, while we carry out this effort around strategy and the plans ahead, Mark and I both feel very confident about how much capital this franchise can generate, and we’re eager to give back surplus capital to you beyond what we’ll already be doing to invest and narrow that return gap versus our peer set.

Mike O'Connor

analyst
#20

I simply wanted to expand on what was said regarding the dividend. I get that there's a leaning toward repurchasing shares, and you've been quite clear about wanting to do so when the price sits under tangible book — that logic holds up. That said, I suppose it's a signal to the market that the dividend is being held steady. Does that hint at something regarding the earnings power underneath, or a restricted capacity to raise the dividend? My thinking is you'd presumably want to bump it up by 2 cents at minimum, purely to indicate a favorable trajectory, provided it doesn't require much capital; so perhaps you could say a bit more about the dividend. To repeat, specifically, ought we to infer anything about implied earnings power underneath, and are there any caps tied to interest when it comes to the dividend? Thank you.

Mark Mason

executive
#21

Yes. Allow me to state this plainly. There's no hidden signal in that whatsoever, correct; it's, as I said regarding the level the stock is trading at and it making sense to repurchase shares. Our dividend yield sits pretty much in line with what peers offer, at approximately 3%. And so, and nothing is stopping us from taking capital actions, plus we hold no worries regarding the earning power of the franchise; and actually, lots of the areas — as I noted before and as Jane noted — we know will add to ongoing strength in our earnings power. So, well capitalized, we feel good about our earnings power and no concerns or no hidden signal regarding the capital actions and their direction that we discussed and once more, we possess the flexibility thanks to the stress capital buffer, as we move quarter to quarter, to tweak things as we judge appropriate in the best interest of our investors.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#22

My apologies — I had also been muted. Mark, I wanted to dig into a portion of the NII guidance. There seemed to be a bit of uncertainty regarding how it ought to be read. From what I gather, we're looking at a $2.2 billion decline so far this year, and for the entire year, no additional drops beyond that point should occur; that suggests roughly a $10.5 billion NII run rate across the latter six months. I simply wanted confirmation that this is the correct reading of those comments.

Mark Mason

executive
#23

Yeah. So, once more, taking a look; what we observe is the NIR essentially leveling out, and part of that shows up notably outside markets, yet in the aggregate on that page too, the outlook for overall revenues remains the same at a 5% drop, or mid — a decline in the mid-single digits, pardon me. You've got it right, at the halfway mark, we find it lower by $2.2 billion when it comes to net interest revenues. The market-related piece of that is frequently difficult to forecast, but my point is that whatever offsets or added strain appears there will probably be counterbalanced by fee momentum we anticipate, considering the strength emerging during this quarter.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#24

I've got something to ask Jane and you as well, Mark. It concerns the way you view the significance of scale within the business refresh — that's how I suppose I'd describe what you're undertaking. Jane, perhaps you can give us some insight into just how crucial scale is for what you're trying to carry out. My reason for asking is that investors frequently come to me with questions about the efforts you're making regarding those parts of the business lacking the same scale as, say, the standout segments such as Global Search, Treasury services, or Mexico.

Jane Fraser

executive
#25

Right. To begin with, scale is plainly extremely important in this context, especially as the world becomes more digital. As you note, Betsy, take TTS — each day we move $4 trillion of volume across the globe, and we hold a number of franchises possessing material scale, and we anticipate growth from them. That's precisely where the transformation program proves highly beneficial, making sure our platforms can scale. When it came to Asia-Pac and EMEA, we chose to exit the 13 markets where we judged it impossible to reach the scale required to compete in those highly local portions of the business; this allows us to concentrate our firepower either on areas where we're maintaining a leading market position or on other areas where we intend to invest so as to attain the scale we believe will be necessary down the road. U.S. consumer stands out as an obvious illustration. So, I expect you'll hear more and more from us about our strategies for those businesses — whether keeping the leading positions here, with help from the transformation program, or in areas where we'll put money to work to gain greater scale. As I mentioned, U.S. consumer is the clear example, and there are pockets within Commercial Bank we're enthusiastic about, plus Securities Services, one where we consider it extremely attainable, particularly in light of our pre and post-trade capabilities; and finally, some of that scale will emerge from the connections among our businesses as we build greater connectivity, which will likewise give us scale. Taken together, our various franchises will hold competitive advantage collectively, rather than merely being strong one by one.

Ebrahim Poonawala

analyst
#26

Just a brief follow-up — I get that you're taking a measured approach to strategy as you head toward, I believe, the Investor Day you brought up, which is in the first quarter of next year. But when we consider the investment spend and how to frame the expense outlook, Mark, could you address the possibility that we might see some expense creep as you go further and deeper into this — both regarding your guidance of mid-single-digit expense growth for this year and when we think about how long that investment cycle lasts over the coming years?

Mark Mason

executive
#27

Yes. Look, once more, this is something within our control, correct? So, once more, I want to emphasize that the decisions we're making are very deliberate, centered on the opportunities we see throughout the franchise, and doing so is the right thing, correct; so, we will keep doing that. Regarding the risk to it, I don't believe there's anything unexpected here, correct. So, should revenues arrive meaningfully different, a certain portion of our expense base is linked to revenues, and so that would clearly fluctuate, but apart from those volume-related expenses — transaction, compensation, and so on — what I've guided toward is what you should expect, in terms of the very deliberate decisions to deploy the money in this manner, and we will keep doing that. Should we find more investment opportunities in '21 or 2022, we will pursue them. Because once more, we know we can deliver on the benefits and the returns tied to deploying that money.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#28

Mark, you made an interesting point regarding revenues from the investment banking business. My notes suggest you mentioned they came in at 39% or 38% above 2019, or perhaps below — I'm double-checking here. Either way, your business remains comfortably higher than where it stood in 2019, and we went through a stretch, until the pandemic that you know well, when growth in investment banking and trading was rather tough. Looking ahead, when you speak with your teams in Investment Banking and Global Markets, why do they hold this view, since an increased volume of activity seems tied to what we all just experienced over the last 18 months? Do they believe it can last, or will we revert to 2019? What are those folks telling you regarding the coming 12 to 24 months in those businesses?

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Yes. Let me begin by noting that our dialogue with clients remains very, very strong throughout the franchise, particularly within Investment Banking; and consider this — numerous businesses, numerous companies spanning industries, are genuinely being forced to examine their business model. They're also thinking through how they wish to reshape their operations as they emerge from this pandemic. That covers everything from approaching digitization, to considering going direct to consumers, to what the pandemic signifies for supply chains, to how staff work remotely, to how they oversee their liquidity levels, to what should be done with that surplus liquidity, whether they ought to be acquiring or something else — so we sit within that conversation, which is hugely indicative, I believe, and strongly reflects the franchise we possess. Our clients' overall outlook is positive concerning the environment ahead. Sure, there are certain matters to handle as well, yet optimism is broadly present. Therefore, what I conveyed regarding '19 is this: although normalization is occurring, we are normalizing at a level above where we finished 2019, and we would anticipate ongoing momentum along with continuing to gain share as time goes on. Jane, is there anything you'd like to add?

Jane Fraser

executive
#30

Absolutely. Mark, I believe you captured that quite thoroughly. Right now, we're seeing a significant amount of engagement from clients, truly on a global scale, and there's considerable demand beyond what's happening on the investment banking front — the move toward e-commerce, where clients require our TTS offerings or cross-border flows, which we're watching translate into trade demand that's beginning to pick up nicely. Commercial banking is another segment where a great deal of fresh demand is emerging from clients, stemming both from strategic initiatives with our investment bank and from their own global growth that we're facilitating via our Treasury Services and similar offerings. So overall, I'd say there's a broad feeling of optimism. Our pipeline is fabulous — you never want to tempt fate with these things — but heading into the year's second half, we truly do have a fabulous pipeline worldwide, and that gives you solid confidence in sustained momentum.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#31

Let me pose my question at this point, and afterward I'll get back in line. What I really want to focus on is capital. Look, it can't have escaped you that tangible book value stands at $78 while the share price sits at $68. Given that, my thinking is we ought to be liquidating the chairs at your desks along with the silverware, doing whatever it takes to repurchase shares. With that in mind, my first question: regarding the divestitures across 13 consumer markets, relative to current marks, are you anticipating a gain or a loss on those?

Mark Mason

executive
#32

Right, so here's how I'd put it. Mike, as Jane said, interest from purchasers on those assets has been strong; that shouldn't come as a shock, since in our view these are solid businesses that simply lack the scale we need, which Jane pointed out. We need to work that process to completion and observe the outcome, and I'll keep being transparent with you regarding gains and losses or how it moves through our financials; however, I won't stand here and state whether it's a gain or a loss or what it specifically means for those 13 markets. What I can say is that when capital gets released through those transactions, we'll keep making highly deliberate choices about deploying that capital. Our first focus is growth opportunities delivering returns exceeding our cost of capital, and after that, figuring out how to give as much back to shareholders as is sensible through buybacks, dividends and so forth. We've stayed disciplined on this up to now, and that discipline will carry forward.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#33

Just to make sure I've understood correctly — your CET1 ratio stood at 11.9, and the return on capital came in above 11.5. If you were to put a dollar figure on that, what would it translate to in possible buybacks right now? And I'm assuming that wouldn't factor in any capital released from any sales. So there could be a potential repurchase of a substantial amount of stock if you were both willing and able — is that right?

Mark Mason

executive
#34

A bit more than $4 billion in excess capital, the difference between 11.5 and 11.9 — that's what it comes out to.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#35

Mark, do you have anything to share regarding promotional trends you're observing, and about card pricing, since everyone has returned to concentrating on the business? You brought up marketing spend, but could you discuss a bit what you're noticing when it comes to promotional pricing there?

Mark Mason

executive
#36

Sure. What I'd put it as is just this: like the expense figures would imply, and like we've said, we're behind in getting new card customers onboarded. So — and what we observe is that our acquisitions sit mostly at levels from before COVID, before the crisis, or before the pandemic, and honestly, what we see is typical behavior as those card customers join, and just as it has always been, the acquisition strategy is going to involve a mix, but so far, typical behavior is what we're seeing, so to speak. And look, new account acquisitions lean toward branded cards, and they're in products that depend less on the 0% offers, plus products such as Flex Pay and Flex Loan, which will produce interest right away as those balances increase.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#37

A separate item. Jane, when you consider the tech strategy of building things in-house at Citigroup versus teaming with outside companies, where do things stand with Google and Google Plex, and with your interest in leveraging third parties to bring in new customers more cheaply up front, even if their lifetime value might be smaller? Given that trade-off, what do you think right now, since aside from a few early headlines we've barely heard anything about the Google tie-up. Thanks.

Jane Fraser

executive
#38

Sure. Hi, Mike. Great question. That piece — working with big tech — matters a great deal to our disruptive strategy here in the U.S., since we're examining two things: how to strengthen value propositions for customers, for the customer base itself, and then these emerging new ecosystems. And undoubtedly COVID has sped up the embedded finance model in the U.S. — just consider the travel ecosystem, consider home improvement ecosystems — and the advantage for us is that this isn't unfamiliar territory. We've long worked with partners across Asia — Grab, Paytm and We Bank — along with our more traditional partners. What these partnerships show us is that we gain a great deal of knowledge, since these new ecosystems are still in their early stages. We gain a great deal of knowledge regarding marketing, regarding user experiences, regarding the tech stacks. It definitely lets us reach next generation customer bases, and just as importantly it extends past consumer, so looking at the corporate side, our Stripe partnership, the work underway in TTS with Project Spring to enable payments, is a core element, especially as wholesale and retail sort of merge some of these payment chains into one. So with Google Plex and a number of other tech partnerships we have in the States and around the world, we are quite deliberately building a broad suite of APIs and partner integration capabilities; so that we can bring other partners into our offerings, create more innovative solutions without having to build or buy everything on our own, and Citi plex with Google is one such case; right now we are actively testing features with our own employees. We'll finalize dates, we'll share with that — we'll share that with you once available. But it's one of many different partnerships we have and an important partner for us, yet far from the only one here in the States helping us disrupt and grow going forward.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#39

Alright, let me ask a second thing, this one about capital. Since you're moving toward a bigger GSIB bucket, Mark, Jane — what's the thinking there, not only regarding capital targets but anything you can actually do about it? I realize it's a year, maybe slightly more, before that takes effect, yet clearly you're weighing target capital and must factor in what's headed your way.

Mark Mason

executive
#40

Yes. And look, as you're aware, given all the liquidity sitting in the market, a lot of us have felt strain on our GSIB score; that's definitely been true in our case, and the elevated GSIB score of 3.5% wouldn't kick in until the start of 2023. We view the whole capital stack in an integrated way — the 11.5% target for us, which sits comfortably above regulatory minimums, but it does take that into account — take that into account, and there are pieces of it, as I said before, that we're able to shape and control; the stress capital buffer forms one part, and I mentioned earlier that we can affect those levers even without fully grasping the Fed's models — we know PPNR is something we can affect, we know the balance sheet and its allocation are things we can affect, and in the end what stress losses emerge from it; so we'll keep managing that. Obviously we'll still hold a buffer even with an elevated GSIB score. And as you're aware, the regulators keep saying capital across the system is roughly at the right levels; they'll keep watching the drivers that shape the stack too, GSIB and balance sheet size and so forth, and we'll see how things develop. But again, we feel good about our position. We're well-capitalized, we have a solid read on the drivers ahead that will generate capital capacity for us, and we plan to once more put that to work where it makes sense and otherwise give it back to our shareholders.

Elizabeth Lynn

executive
#41

We appreciate everyone being on the line for today's session. If any additional questions come up, don't hesitate to get in touch with our IR team, and thanks once more — enjoy the rest of your day.

Operator

operator
#42

That brings an end to our review of Citi's results for the second quarter of 2021. We appreciate everyone joining. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.