Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 14, 2021

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 61 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jenn Landis

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate all of you being here. Let me note that the deck we're using today — you can find it on our site, citigroup.com — might include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects, and they're subject to uncertainty as well as shifts in circumstances. A range of factors, among them the ones we lay out in our SEC filings, could cause actual results to come in materially different from what those statements suggest. Before diving in, I want to express my gratitude to Liz Lynn, who has been an amazing partner over these past few months. Getting to know the whole Citi team has truly been a pleasure, I feel privileged to step in as the next head of investor relations, and I'm eager to collaborate with all of you; with that, I'll hand things over to Jane.

Jane Fraser

executive
#2

Thank you, Jenn, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to be here with you today. Before I update you on our results and priorities, let's begin the call by discussing the macro picture as we see it and the incredible engagement we keep having with clients. Without a doubt, the ongoing rebound from the pandemic is fueling confidence among both corporations and consumers. I'm especially encouraged by the strong pipelines we're seeing for the remainder of this year and stretching further out. Sentiment among our corporate clients is still quite favorable, with solid cash flows and liquidity propelling M&A activity as well as deleveraging. Household balance sheets are still remarkably sturdy, supported by the rise in consumer net worth that occurred during the pandemic. Having said all that, growth has cooled off somewhat. Three areas are getting our close attention. First, the deceleration in China and how it affects worldwide growth; second, inflation along with supply limitations in labor, materials, and energy; and finally, how the U.S. debt ceiling talks will play out. These same topics keep coming up again and again when we talk with clients. Now, for the quarter: we posted net income of $4.6 billion and EPS of $2.15. These results include a pre-tax loss tied to the divestiture of our Australia consumer business, and Mark will walk you through the specifics. If you set that transaction aside, our third quarter revenues would have risen 3% compared with last year, and EPS would have come in at $2.44. Within the Institutional Clients Group, revenues climbed 4% year-over-year, since we keep experiencing robust client engagement, with momentum in Investment Banking, Equity Markets, and Securities Services, which more than compensated for the 16% drop in Fixed Income Markets. I'm extremely proud to share that this was Citi's strongest M&A quarter and the second-best Investment Banking quarter in a decade. Lending in the ICG expanded once more this quarter, though only modestly. Equity Markets also delivered a very strong quarter, with revenues climbing 40% year-over-year. Even with Fixed Income Markets normalizing relative to 2020's rather extraordinary performance, overall markets revenues dipped just 5%, and they rose 11% compared with the third quarter of 2019. We keep successfully carrying out our strategy of growing fee revenue throughout the ICG businesses; for instance, although TTS is still dealing with interest rate headwinds, our fees this quarter reached their highest level in a decade. You can also see how our global network gives us a unique position to assist clients in navigating the supply chain difficulties so many of them face, something we anticipate will continue for the near future. In the same way, we generated double-digit fee revenue growth in Securities Services in the Private Bank as client assets under custody and assets under management maintained their vigorous growth trajectory; in Global Consumer Banking, strong consumer balance sheets and persistently elevated payment rates did mean that loan growth stayed under pressure. The other key drivers, though, are somewhat more encouraging. U.S. Sales from purchases on Branded Cards sit nicely above where they were in 2019, and new accounts in Branded Cards, Mexico, and the Asia hubs have all reached or surpassed pre-COVID marks. In the same way, deposit and asset-under-management gains in the double digits keep favoring us throughout the franchise. Let me take a moment on what we're doing in U.S. retail. The money we've put into digital and our digital playbook is beginning to return value. We hold $19 billion in digital deposits, which rose 26% over the past year. Over two-thirds of those digital deposit balances, we find, originate with customers who live beyond our branch network, and roughly half of that money comes from cardholders who previously had no retail relationship with us. Naturally, Google's choice to shut down Google Plex let us down, yet that effort taught us plenty, and the bulk of what we invested will be put to work in our own initiatives and partnerships down the road. Taking everything together, we closed the quarter at a Common Equity Tier 1 capital ratio of 11.7% on a standardized basis, and tangible book value per share climbed to $79.07, a gain of more than 10% versus a year earlier. So far this year, we've handed back nearly $11 billion to shareholders via a solid dividend plus buybacks. Our commitment stands: we will return capital beyond what's needed to fund the franchise and preserve our safety and soundness. On the whole, I feel very good about these results considering the conditions we face. There's plenty of work still in front of us, but the payoff from investments made earlier is becoming visible. Now I want to bring you up to speed on our strategic priorities. If you look at slide three, we've added a page spelling out our leading priorities along with several steps already taken toward them. Every quarter we'll give you this page so you stay current on our position, the milestones, and how progress is unfolding. As it shows, we've been putting in serious effort on the priorities I've described. The transformation, the strategy refresh, and our culture and talent. Without question, transformation ranks first among our priorities at this moment, and central to it are safety and soundness and answering the consent orders by modernizing how we manage risk and control. This quarter, we handed our plans to the regulators and kept up a productive conversation with them as we now shift decisively into execution. Investment in our risk and control environment is already moving well along, we're genuinely instilling a culture of excellence into this work, and we're proceeding with urgency. We're also still making headway on renewing our strategy. Besides revealing the sale of our consumer business in Australia, we're far into the second round of bids for the markets we're still exiting; we've started examining how those exits will let us streamline operations in Asia and remove stranded costs. We can't wait to lay out the full strategic picture for everyone at Investor Day and share where we intend to take this company. As Mark will get into, we've already started putting a number of the choices we've made into action, and that covers TTS, Wealth and Commercial Banking, where we're putting money into front office hires and into better digital products and services. The effect of that spending is beginning to show up already in the key drivers across those businesses. Then there's culture and talent. We keep drawing in highly capable people from outside while making progress on our diversity targets, making sure accountability is clear and tearing down the silos that have held us back as a company for a long time. This is a new Citi, and every bit of this effort serves a single overarching aim: to responsibly narrow the returns gap with our peers. We'll come back to you with the metrics and milestones we'll use to hold ourselves accountable, and you can hold us to them too. So with that, I'll hand things to Mark to walk through how we performed in greater detail, and after that the two of us will be happy to answer your questions.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Thanks, Jane, and good morning to all of you. Let's begin on slide four. As Jane said, Citigroup posted net income for the third quarter of $4.6 billion, earnings per share of $2.15, and an ROTCE of 11%, on revenues of $17.2 billion. Included in those results is a pre-tax loss of $680 million tied to the sale of our Australia consumer business. If you set that item aside, EPS would have come in at $2.44, with an ROTCE of 12.5%. Just to remind you, although we got a premium to book on that sale, we did take a pre-tax loss, mostly from the currency translation adjustment that accumulated over time and is already reflected in our capital. When the deal closes, the capital effect of that loss will be mostly offset, and roughly $800 million of capital allocated to the business will be released. Revenues fell 1% versus the prior year. Setting aside the loss on sale, revenues would have risen 3%, mainly from Investment Banking fees, along with robust growth in Equity Markets and Securities Services. Expenses rose 5% compared with a year earlier, and in constant dollars expenses were up 4% for the quarter. Year to date, our expenses are higher by 5%, with two primary drivers. Investments in the transformation, including the six programs addressing the consent orders, which accounted for about 3% of the growth so far this year. Business-led investments, which center on expanding our front office in the Investment Banking, wealth, and Securities Services areas, and on improving our client experience and digitizing our network. So far this year, we brought on more than 500 bankers, advisors, and other front office support in Wealth, including the Private Bank and the Consumer Wealth businesses, plus 200 Corporate and Investment Bankers globally in high-growth areas, including senior hires covering Tech, Healthcare, FinTech, and Private Equity. In our services businesses, TTS and Securities Services, we keep enhancing client experience and digital capabilities, which lets us capture significant new mandates; in Consumer, these investments cover development and marketing for new offerings such as the Citi Custom Cash Card and installment lending, as well as spending on our mobile and digital user experience. There were also higher volume and revenue-related expenses, plus business as usual expenses, which were mostly offset by efficiency savings. As a reminder, we will keep examining our expenses for chances to self-fund investments. Now on to credit. Credit performance is still strong, with net credit losses of just under $1 billion, more than offset by an ACL release of $1.2 billion, largely reflecting continued improvement in portfolio quality. In constant dollars, end-of-period loans dropped 1% from a year earlier, reflecting the impact of the Australia exit. Excluding that impact, loans would have been up 1% year-over-year, driven by active client engagement in TTS, Private Bank, and markets. End-of-period deposits rose 6% year-over-year, reflecting continued engagement with our consumer and corporate clients, as well as continued momentum in client acquisition and deepening across both corporate clients and consumers. To wrap up, as Jane mentioned before, we've given back about $11 billion in capital thus far this year. Although we're still dedicated to putting money into our franchise, we'll keep handing back surplus capital to shareholders. Now let's look at each business. Slide five presents the results for the Institutional Clients Group. Revenues rose 4% compared with both the prior year and the previous quarter, primarily fueled by Investment Banking, Equity Markets, and Securities Services. Expenses climbed 9%, with roughly half of that rise coming from transformation and the remaining half from business-led investments and higher revenue-related costs, partly offset by efficiency savings. Credit costs were mostly benign during the quarter, since minimal net credit losses were more than offset by an ACL reserve release. That produced net income of $3.4 billion, up 21% for the quarter and 60% year-to-date. ICG posted an ROTCE of 14.5% for the quarter and 18.8% year-to-date. Slide six provides a more detailed look at revenues for the Institutional Clients Group. On the banking side, revenues rose 11%. In Treasury and Trade Solutions, ongoing growth in fee revenues of 20% versus a year ago — the strongest quarter for fees in a decade — mirrored solid client engagement and client acquisition, plus a recovery in commercial card revenues. Yet all of that was more than offset by the effect of lower deposit spreads, pushing total revenues down 4%; we continue to see momentum throughout our payment business, with 15% growth in cross-border flows and 10% growth in clearing transactions over the last year. At quarter end, TTS loans were up 15%, mainly in trade loans, where our technology investments in supply chain and deep local knowledge let us serve our clients' needs around the world. Investment Banking revenues rose 39% versus a year ago, largely fueled by M&A, as we keep seeing the advantages of our front office investments, which left us well positioned to capitalize on greater deal activity. As Jane said, this was the second-best quarter for Investment Banking revenues and the best quarter for M&A in a decade. Private Bank revenues rose 4%, driven by growth in assets under management, loans, and deposits, reflecting momentum with new and existing clients. This quarter, we brought on almost 200 bankers, investment counselors, and other front office support and onboarded more than 200 new clients. Our investments in talent keep fueling growth, which is a good sign for our overall strategy and wealth. Corporate Lending revenues rose 17%, primarily driven by a lower cost of funds and a modest gain on sale, partly offset by lower loan volumes. Total markets and Securities Services revenues fell 4% from last year. Fixed Income revenues fell 16%, reflecting continued normalization in market activity across rates and spread products. We saw strong activity with our corporate clients, working with them on foreign exchange products to support their global operations and hedging solutions to help with their risk mitigation efforts. In Equity Markets, we saw a 40% increase in revenues, marking our second-strongest quarter over a 10-year span. This was fueled by cash equities, derivatives, and prime finance, thanks to robust client engagement and supportive market conditions. This is yet another area where our spending on talent and technology is delivering returns. Over in Securities Services, revenues rose 10%. There, we experienced robust fee revenue growth, since the ongoing investments in our platform and product capabilities allowed us to expand revenue among both new and current clients, though this was partly countered by reduced deposit spreads. Now, examining ICG's year-to-date performance, we've had a robust input from Investment Banking and Equity Markets, plus stable outcomes in the Private Bank and Securities Services, which assisted in counterbalancing the anticipated normalization in Fixed Income Markets. Moving on to Global Consumer Banking results in constant dollars on slide seven. Revenues fell 14% and 5% when excluding a loss on sale, as steady deposit expansion and investment management momentum were outweighed by decreased card balances and reduced deposit spreads. Expenses climbed 5%, with roughly half coming from transformation and the rest from business-led investments and volume-related costs, partly offset by efficiency savings.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

In terms of credit cost, this quarter saw a slight upside, since an ACL reserve release of about $1 billion exceeded net credit losses; net income came to $1.3 billion, a rise of 44%. GCB posted a ROTCE of 15%, or 21.5% once the loss on sale is excluded. Turning lastly to results for the year to date, our drivers have improved steadily throughout the year, with purchase sales rising 5% against 2019, while acquisitions approach pre-pandemic levels worldwide. Excluding the loss on sale, the business produced a 22.4% ROTCE. Slide eight gives a closer look at North America Consumer results. Third quarter revenues overall fell 4% versus a year ago, since headwinds persist from elevated payment rates and deposit spreads. Even so, trends in cards and retail banking give us encouragement. At Branded Cards and Retail Services, purchase sales rose 24% and 14% respectively versus the same period last year, and each exceeded 2019 levels; in retail banking, average deposits and, within that figure, checking deposits, each climbed 14%. AUMs rose 16%, while Citigold households increased 13% in the quarter. Progress also continues on our U.S. digital strategy. U.S. digital deposits rose 26% against the prior year, and installment loan balances, which include our Citi Flex Loan and Citi Flex Pay products, likewise expanded considerably, climbing 22% versus a year earlier, with more than 80% of such loans originated digitally; slide nine presents results for international consumer banking in constant dollars. Revenues fell 30% year-over-year during the third quarter. Once the loss on sale is excluded, revenues dropped 5%, comprising a 7% decrease in Latin America and a 4% decrease in Asia. Across international consumer as a whole, investment management shows solid momentum, with assets under management growing 10%, mostly from Asia, and growth is considerably larger when you isolate the four international wealth hubs. Purchase sales increased 8% versus the prior year, and average deposits rose 3%, though deposit spreads were lower. Slide 10 offers further detail on global consumer credit trends. Credit stayed favorable once more this quarter in every region. Based on the delinquency trends visible now, we don't anticipate credit deterioration within the U.S. portfolio during 2021. Slide 11 presents Corporate / Other results. Revenues rose by more than $300 million, helped by greater net revenue from the investment portfolio. Expenses fell by $300 million owing to the absence of the civil money penalty, which we incurred in the 3rd quarter of last year, partly offset by higher transformation-related expenses. Credit costs remained a benefit in the quarter, though they reflect a smaller ACL release in the legacy portfolio than a year ago. EBIT was a loss of $330 million. On slide 12, you can see how our net interest revenue and margin are trending, along with non-interest revenues on a reported basis. Net interest revenue came in at $10.4 billion for the third quarter, which was down roughly $100 million compared with a year earlier, as lower loan balances and the effect of lower rates weighed on results. Looking at the year-to-date picture, net interest revenue fell by roughly $2.3 billion. Now turning to non-interest revenues, which appear at the bottom of that slide: in the third quarter, non-NIR was down approximately $50 million versus a year ago, and the driver there was the hit from the loss on the sale of the Australia consumer business. If you strip out that loss, non-interest revenues would actually have risen by more than $600 million, or 9%, on the back of strong fee growth in ICG. Slide 13 lays out our key capital metrics. Our CET1 capital ratio moved down slightly to 11.7%. Over the quarter, Citi gave back a total of $4 billion to common shareholders, split between $1 billion of dividends and $3 billion of share repurchases. Our supplementary leverage ratio was essentially flat at 5.8%, while tangible book value per share rose 10% from a year earlier to $79.07, helped by net income. Before we get to Q&A, let me briefly cover what we expect for 2021. On the top line, for Citigroup overall, we still anticipate revenues will be down in the mid-single-digit range on a reported basis, leaving aside any divestiture-related impacts. On expenses, we continue to expect full-year expenses will be up in the mid-single-digit range, again excluding any divestiture-related impacts, since we're still transforming our risk and control environment and putting money into our businesses. Over time, we'll keep looking for ways to partially self-fund those investments. With that, Jane and I are ready to take your questions.

John McDonald

analyst
#5

Morning, and thanks for taking the question. Mark, on net interest income — overall it appears to have landed somewhat above what you'd signaled back in September at the Barclays conference. Can you share more detail on what lifted core ex markets NII during this quarter, and what that tells you about the outlook for NII expansion going forward?

Mark Mason

executive
#6

Absolutely. Morning, John. If you turn to page 12, the figure was roughly $10.4 billion. A few items, I'd say, drove that. First, the Treasury investments we've been making added to it, since we're putting a portion of our excess liquidity to work. Second, as I noted earlier, we experienced sequential loan growth in cards, especially Branded Cards, which rose 3%. On top of that, certain late fees and balance transfer fees in cards flowed through. There's also an additional day in the quarter, and together those elements produced the uptick we recorded. Regarding the remainder of the year, all of this factors into the total revenues guidance I provided, and that guidance remains unchanged. We keep aiming to invest in the cards portfolio via new acquisitions, with a long-term view of how we grow loans over time there.

John McDonald

analyst
#7

All right. As a quick follow-up regarding capital returns — your total return is quite strong, yet it appears roughly flat versus the $4 billion from the second quarter, even after the Fed eased its restrictions. With so much change happening at the company right now, is this an area where you're being cautious? As you unlock capital from the business exits, and with your stock trading at a low valuation, how do you think about splitting that freed-up capital between putting it back into the business and giving it back to shareholders?

Mark Mason

executive
#8

Yeah, absolutely. Look, our thinking here truly hasn't shifted — you've heard me mention many times that, as we bring in income, as we draw down our DTA over time, as capital is freed up from the deals we complete, we want to make sure we can serve our clients. We want to make sure we can put money into the business, and then whatever is left beyond that we want to hand back to the shareholders; that view hasn't changed. Clearly the SCB lets us make those calls in any given quarter depending on what we expect for performance and depending on all the other elements I referenced, including the capital release and SA-CCR and items like that. We'll keep making those calls with that same philosophy in mind, which is how do we give back to shareholders any excess we have over time.

John McDonald

analyst
#9

All right, thanks.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#10

Hello there. There are a couple of intriguing items I'm hoping you might give us a fast take on. First, your firm turned into the initial custodian to secure regulatory clearance for an onshore custody operation in China. Could you put into context just how significant that chance is? And then, similarly, regarding your intentions to move into Australia's buy now, pay later sector, what does that signify not only for Australia but on a broader worldwide scale, and how are you thinking about it alongside the remainder of your consumer operations? Many thanks.

Jane Fraser

executive
#11

Appreciate that, Glenn. Let me handle that question. When it comes to what we do and how we operate in China, our presence there stretches back 100 years; we have a solid grasp of how that local market works. At present we serve, as you know, an extremely big pool of investors there — 70% of the Fortune 500 companies operating in China — helping them run their businesses on the ground and tap into the country's capital markets. As for us, we're delighted to hold the custody license in China; it should also bolster what we do in Hong Kong, and it fits within the expansion of our Securities Services strategy. You've begun to see the payoff show up in the results for this quarter coming from certain earlier investments, and this represents one more investment we're directing into that business, which we're quite fond of and believe we're strongly positioned in. Turning to buy now, pay later, that's clearly an area where we're exiting our Asian operations, yet we've definitely absorbed the lessons from running those businesses across Asia, and in particular we've been putting them to use in the U.S. over the past few years. It's not as if we've stood still in the U.S. We've been developing our personal lending platform from 2019 onward, and that forms part of the wider digitization strategy for our U.S. consumer business; we've experienced really robust growth in our flex portfolios, both through drawing on certain partnerships we already have, like American Airlines, and through our efforts to add new partners in POS. A space that excites me in particular is the work we're doing alongside the biggest e-commerce company, Amazon, on point of sale lending aimed at our cards customers. Those capabilities are being and will continue to be used with lots of extra partners and channels across the U.S., and into Mexico. Last, as you know, we've been broadening our product suite by creating off-card lending capabilities. As Mark has told you, with our personal installment loans to current card customers, 88% of those total sales occur in digital channels. Looking at the whole picture, I'd say there's plainly a move toward several distinct formats for how a customer can pay and prefers to pay. We're genuinely ahead of the curve here and are generating solid momentum thanks to the investments we've made across the past few years, and we'll keep at it.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#12

Hi, good morning.

Mark Mason

executive
#13

Morning.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#14

I'd like to get a better sense of what you believe is achievable in the U.S. card business. We touched on some of the initiatives you've been working on, I know. When I look at cards, growth is positive compared to last year, yet it's running somewhat under what some competitors are delivering. You have the retail partner card program, and in my view there's room there to modernize it so it becomes as nimble as what your strongest competitors offer. Curious how you approach that. Also on U.S. deposits — now that the Google partnership isn't moving ahead, how are you thinking about using your mobile app across the U.S. in a manner that the investor community perhaps doesn't fully appreciate? Because your app looks excellent, and it simply isn't reaching enough of the opportunity your brand could capture.

Mark Mason

executive
#15

Thanks, Betsy. Betsy, let me begin, and then Jane might want to add something, and I'll address your points about cards first. As I said during my prepared remarks, especially for US-branded Cards, we began to notice an uptick in loan balances. Loans rose roughly 1% versus a year ago. Sequentially, they climbed about 3%. What matters a great deal here, I believe, is reentering the market, since as you can see, purchase sales have grown, but payment rates remain elevated, and we need to watch how stimulus and liquidity unfold going forward. Our attention is on the way we're coming back into the market, and we're doing so via our Custom Cash launch, which is contributing to new acquisitions; in fact, our new acquisition volumes have returned to 2019 levels. More than half of those acquisitions are proprietary cards. We're approaching this carefully. Across the past 5 years, we've been reducing the length of our promotional periods and introducing larger fees on balance transfers while aiming at a smaller share of promotional balances. As you know, those moves will support future average interest earning balances, since our experience shows that approximately half of those balances eventually become revolving over time. That's a significant step. The second point I'd make is simply to echo what Jane noted, which is that we're considering lending in a wider sense; we're generating growth on card lending offerings such as Flex Pay and Flex Loan. Those carry no promotional periods, and they begin producing interest from the very first day. We're sharply focused on this. Clearly we're a major player here. Plainly it's a key piece of our portfolio and produces solid returns. We have to put ourselves in a place where we can seize expansion as the economy keeps bouncing back and behavior returns to normal, plus we must be ready in case behavior doesn't return to normal as fast as we would prefer regarding items such as wider lending products.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#16

Hi there, good morning. Mark, I'd like to zero in a bit on interest rates. It seems like all our attention has gone to U.S. rates, yet considering how much business you do worldwide, Mexico and Brazil have already raised rates. And now the U.K. could be looking at increases before long. So how should we view your exposure to rate moves in other countries, and might there be some upside arriving in the coming quarters when it comes to NII?

Mark Mason

executive
#17

Well, we've clearly witnessed quite a few hikes, plus speculation about more of them taking place in the U.S. When you consider the IRE figure we disclose, sensitivity to either the short or the long end isn't particularly high for us; even so, when rates and prices climb, that works in our favor. We hold substantial liquidity that we can put to work as rates move higher. On top of that, we've got ample dry powder on hand so we can capture client demand once it begins coming back. As you mentioned, for our company, what happens with rates around the globe matters a great deal, and rising rates abroad assist in driving results across portions of the franchise such as TTS and other areas.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#18

Hey, good morning.

Mark Mason

executive
#19

Good morning.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#20

Mark, I appreciate the update you gave regarding the cost guidance that was reaffirmed for this year. It's probably too soon to discuss the following year, I realize. Could you assist us in grasping the underlying components — you know, the transformation of incentive compensation, and what ought to be on our minds concerning, say, run-rate costs going forward? If possible, let's even avoid discussing how growth might look next year. Any insight at all would help; this question certainly keeps arising throughout the major banking institutions, regarding necessary investments compared with other matters taking place at the bank. Thank you.

Mark Mason

executive
#21

Yes, certainly. To begin, let me note that, as I mentioned during prepared remarks, our aggregate expenses align with guidance, if you will — this applies both to the anticipated transformation spending, which has risen 3% thus far this year, and to our overall expenses, which have increased 5% year-to-date. Once more, this matches the guidance. When I consider this, you know, those represent two extremely significant spending categories. According to what Jane Fraser has stated, transformation ranks as our foremost priority. We will allocate whatever is required to accomplish it, and we must make sure we are investing over the long term throughout the franchise. That is what we will keep doing. I'd also point out that expenses are within our control, correct? We are quite intentional regarding the spending you observe. In truth, we are examining each and every expense line we have, correct? To make certain the funds we deploy are deployed in the best possible manner, that they are funds that must be spent; while doing so, we are simultaneously seeking chances for productivity and efficiency gains; indeed, we have witnessed that reflected in the expense figures you currently see. When we examine our expenses, we produced roughly $300 million-$400 million per quarter in efficiencies during 2021, correct? Managing expenses is something we approach with great discipline, with great intentionality, and we manage it in a highly controlled manner, acknowledging the priorities we identified. I will not provide guidance for 2022. What I can say is that our guidance remains unchanged for the remainder of 2021. Clearly, we are currently in the midst of budget season, correct? Once we solidify and complete that, we will share it with you and with our investors at large.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#22

Hello. I'd like to direct my question to Jane. Jane, during this call you described Citigroup as a new company, and I'm thinking about that 8-K filed in August that introduced a bonus plan for senior leadership. Word is it's going to be extended to a much larger group. Those of us who own shares, or who act on behalf of shareholders, are seeing this bonus plan before the targets are made available. So I suppose what I'm asking is whether you actually have those targets. And if you do, would you share them? That said, my hunch is that won't happen before March 2nd. Is it that targets don't exist yet? What's going on? Regardless, this doesn't sit well with those of us who invest. Thank you.

Jane Fraser

executive
#23

Well, Mike, honestly I'm pleased you raised this point, since we did see the note you published recently. If you can give me a moment, I'd like to pull back a bit and begin with how we think about compensation, because I believe it matters a great deal that our shareholders grasp this. Management's pay is structured around performance. Above all, it's tied to what benefits our shareholders. To begin with, every deferred award carries downside risk, and that was plain to see in last year's PSU results, which delivered just 28% against target. Next, through the yearly cycle, leadership is held responsible for outcomes, which again was evident last year when consent orders triggered significant cuts to comp. Turning then to the Transformation Program, as I mentioned at the start, nothing matters more than getting that program executed successfully. It ranks as our top priority. Our goal is ensuring the bank's risk and control environment is brought up to date, and shareholders will gain from that through improved performance at the bank. The board, together with me, holds the senior leaders who are pushing that Transformation responsible for executing it well. I'm personally pressing forward on this program with urgency, and I also have to keep key talent in place, given how tight the market for talent is at the moment, as everyone is aware. That's necessary for us to reach the milestones and deliver at a high standard. To keep people accountable and produce the outcomes, we require incentives and we require penalties. On your question, we'll establish stringent metrics that decide whether rewards are paid at all, and if they are, what percentage gets paid. We set out the criteria within the 8-K, and the final metrics will incorporate feedback from the board, from me, and from the other stakeholders involved, and naturally those will be disclosed in the proxy and so forth. You will see them. So as you can tell, the key point I want to make is that failing to meet expectations will carry consequences, exactly as happened last year for management and for those leading the program. I'm accountable, my team's accountable, and put simply, we have to deliver and we will deliver.

Ebrahim Poonawala

analyst
#24

Morning. Jane, I'd like to return to your comment about being let down when Google Plex decided to withdraw. From your perspective, was that seen as an essential way to bring in clients? Now that it isn't proceeding, is there added pressure to pursue alternative alliances that could strengthen the push to bring in deposits?

Jane Fraser

executive
#25

Yeah. As I noted at the start, their choice left us disappointed, though it represents merely a single element of what we're doing digitally. We never placed every egg into that one container, which is something we've discussed over several quarters. What makes me happy is how strongly digital engagement is performing throughout the U.S. On that measure, the industry here has trailed other regions globally; I'm also pleased by the increase in sticky digital deposits we're seeing domestically. The aspect I favor is that we chose on purpose to build highly reusable capabilities for upcoming alliances and the ones already in place, plus our own in-house initiatives. To bring that to life a little, we've introduced 80 APIs, which genuinely simplify working alongside partners. We've built an entire set of embedded services prepared for deployment. Examples include real-time digital alerts and partner-branded communications. Perhaps most significantly — and this may just be the geek in me — we've assembled new tech stacks, and we've gained considerable knowledge from doing so. That's extremely useful for what we're engaged in today and for alliances ahead. Ultimately, I believe everything we've been undertaking, partly through the work with Google and partly through alliances globally, will advance our digitization strategy in U.S. consumer, keep assisting us in growing and generating the returns here. I'd add that we constantly feel pressure to enhance performance, growth and returns within the consumer franchises. Thank you.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#26

Good morning.

Mark Mason

executive
#27

Morning.

Jane Fraser

executive
#28

Hello, Matt.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#29

This quarter, you handed a plan over to the regulators. Could you give us an idea of the timing you're anticipating for their response, and then what sorts of things you'll be in a position to tell all of us? I realize there are always constraints on what's possible to talk about regarding regulatory matters. Which data points are you watching for on the inside, and what do you figure you can share, and when?

Jane Fraser

executive
#30

I mean, as you've heard directly from me, this ranks at the very top of our list. Getting it finished with excellence, and getting it finished properly, benefits every one of our stakeholders, in my view. Like we told you, during Q3 we handed in our plan. I take a lot of personal pride in it. That plan spans multiple years. It's made up of 6 major programs, as Mark mentioned, and it will put us in a position to run things with excellence going forward in a digital world. Specifically, it sets out extremely clear target states for our risk and controls as well as for the elements of our core operating model. We've now firmly pivoted toward carrying out that plan, as we've told you. I should say, the dialogue we've had with our regulators is highly constructive and, honestly, genuinely useful, and it's been going on continuously. It isn't a case where you hand something in and then never talk again. Throughout, it has been extremely constructive; when it comes to execution, well, we're moving at full speed here. The quality of talent we've recruited, both from within the firm and from outside it, makes me genuinely happy, just as Mark described, so that we can make sure we carry things out with excellence. A few of those areas involve new hires in data. Importantly, in my view, we're devoting just as much energy to culture as we are to modernization. Karen Peetz and the people working with her are making sure we've got the capabilities plus strict governance in place, so that we carry things out in a highly disciplined manner. We produce the outcomes from the investments being made. A fresh accountability framework has been introduced. I should say, our board definitely keeps us firmly and routinely accountable. Obviously, we'll share additional specifics at Investor Day, and also as we move through all of this. The key takeaway from me, I think, is that we've pivoted toward execution and, well, we're pressing ahead with it.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#31

Hello, Jane. I just wanted some clarity regarding that compensation 8-K you mentioned. Obviously, you've always provided short-term bonuses, and you've given long-term incentive compensation to your executives, just like everyone else does. This transformation project appears to sit on top of all that. Shouldn't it fall under what long-term compensation and incentive awards are designed to cover? I'm trying to figure out the reasoning for tacking on another payment here, since management already gets partly paid for exactly that — longer-term moves, changes, and performance.

Jane Fraser

executive
#32

Look, I believe it's precisely as I — first off, thank you. Thank you, Vivek. I think it's as I mentioned earlier, when answering Mike's questions, we want to push this program forward with urgency. We have to hold onto key talent, and the talent market is extremely tight, as you're aware. I want to ensure nobody involved in these programs has any doubt that this is the bank's top priority — to carry it out with excellence. There are incentives and penalties on both sides here. Those flow through the individual program, and through the individual assessments that everyone takes part in annually, plus in this component. I believe this is completely in line with shareholder interests. You want management genuinely motivated to deliver this excellently, yet equally exposed to all the drawbacks if we don't succeed. That's exactly what the program is built to achieve.

Andrew Lim

analyst
#33

Hello, good morning. I appreciate you taking my question; it's somewhat technical in nature. I was hoping you might provide some detail regarding the SA-CCR implementation for the CET1 ratio, specifically the size of the impacts and when the implementation will occur. Thank you.

Mark Mason

executive
#34

Certainly. Thank you. Look, we are aiming for the mandatory compliance date, which is January of 2022. Early adoption of SA-CCR has not happened on our end, and we have no intention of doing so. Clearly, the effect could span from affecting risk-weighted assets to affecting one's GSIB score; but as I mentioned, we are currently working through that. I am not ready to disclose that to you, but it does play a role in how we are carrying out our planning, and we will disclose it once we adopt it at a later date.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#35

Morning to you, Jane. How’s it going? Could you all walk us through—when you look at your Global Consumer Banking business in North America, and in your supplement, I believe it’s page eight—you provide a helpful split among Retail Banking, Citi Branded Cards, and Citi Retail Services. I saw that within Retail Banking, there was a loss during the quarter. Could you offer some context on what might be causing that, and also what the outlook is for that portion of the business? Thanks.

Mark Mason

executive
#36

When it comes to retail banking performance, the pressure partly comes from elevated costs tied to transformation spending, which is flowing through and weighing on income in that area.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#37

Thank you.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#38

Hi. I'd like to ask something further, building on the previous question of mine, and echoing what Vivek Juneja said. Jane Fraser and Mark Mason, you brought up the need to serve regulators — that's point one. Everyone listening, I believe, understands that. You also brought up serving stakeholders. The real issue, I think, is what is actually being delivered for shareholders. Shareholders at Citigroup have essentially been abandoned across virtually every time horizon you could name. Mark Mason, perhaps my view of the philosophy differs somewhat. Your approach states that clients come first, then comes investment in the business, and buybacks come after that. Why ought that philosophy shift at all? The reason is that the gap to book value keeps widening further and further. The gap between you and peers has grown. When it comes to returns, adjusted efficiency, and stock market valuation, Citi ranks as worst-in-class. If your share price presents such a remarkable opportunity, why not adjust that philosophy somewhat toward more buybacks rather than investing? What symbolic steps could you take — for instance, paying everyone in stock? Regarding capital released by the Australia sale, what could you do to deploy all of it toward repurchasing shares? How can you demonstrate that while regulators clearly matter and stakeholders clearly matter, shareholders matter too, given how poorly the share price has performed? And because you're allowing me just one question per turn, a brief additional follow-up about your U.S. consumer strategy — specifically digital deposits, cross-selling into credit cards, and point of sale with Amazon — a bit more detail there, please. Thank you.

Jane Fraser

executive
#39

Alright, Mike, this is Jane, as you know. I'll start us off on this. Without any ambiguity, our shareholders matter enormously to us. Looking at the level at which we're trading, and that underperformance, it's precisely what we're committed to fixing through the strategy refresh, through the transformation efforts underway, and through the work on culture and talent. We will take whatever steps are required to close the distance to our peers; we will make sure the business mix and strategies are right to lift returns. You're beginning to see the direction we're taking, based on the various decisions already made public, and naturally, the full picture will emerge at Investor Day. Beyond that, we'll also achieve this by operating the bank more effectively. On page three of the presentation, we've set out the various priorities so that our investors can recognize the value we believe exists within Citi and understand what we'll be doing to release that value for their benefit. I trust the framework we're applying, and the principles behind it, come across clearly. Like Mark said, regarding the potential we have at Citi — which I honestly think is pretty huge, and I'm quite enthusiastic about it — the next thing to consider is, well, how should we handle the capital we have beyond what we need? I've told you before that since our stock trades at such a frustrating discount to book value, buybacks clearly benefit our investors. Our dividend yield is also solid, but, well, that plays a significant role in the overall approach. The appeal of share repurchases to a shareholder, comparatively speaking, is undeniable. We're definitely going to give that extra capital back to our shareholders, and we'll keep a close eye on the standard that has to be met for putting money into the business itself. You've noticed this in the choices we've taken regarding leaving certain Asian markets, our consumer segment, and a few other shifts: we intend to pull out of operations that, in our view, generate weaker returns, put money back into areas where it makes sense, yet also give that money back to our investors. I can tell my CFO is eager to step in here too.

Mark Mason

executive
#40

Appreciate that, Jane, and I believe you covered it nicely. Let me quickly tack on two or three points. First, whenever we put money into the business — whether that's for clients or across the broader organization — we do so in places where the returns exceed our cost of capital. We're being deliberate about redeploying that capital so we keep closing the distance to our peers. Second, I'd note that during the opening 2 quarters of this year, we fully used up the capital return we had available to deliver prior to the SCB taking effect. That's driven by how much our shareholders matter to us. Third, as Jane said, we lean toward buybacks, once again simply because of where the stock is trading and where our dividend yield sits. Thanks for asking.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#41

Hi there, I appreciate you fitting me in. Morning to you, Jane and Mark. Jane, I wanted to raise the topic of the wealth management opportunity; admittedly, this is a space where competition is extremely fierce. A lot of your big competitors have been pouring money into it for years. I realize you'll address part of this during Investor Day and give additional specifics, but at a broad level, I hoped you might address how Citi's value proposition stands apart from certain rivals in that area, and whether the technology or infrastructure is there to back your growth goals. Finally, can you pursue M&A, or does the consent order block that if you wanted to grow in that space through inorganic means?

Jane Fraser

executive
#42

Thanks a lot, Steven. I feel quite good about what's in front of us, since every element needed for real success is already in place. Among affluent customers, we hold a powerful brand — and I don't just mean within the U.S. through our retail banking business. Our base skews heavily affluent domestically, yet globally, especially when you look at Asia, we're the wealth management brand people there aspire to. On top of that, our client relationships are genuinely broad, and that's where connectivity matters too, tied to those 4 principles we set out for the strategy refresh; we run Commercial Banking operations across 30 geographies worldwide, and they've been up and running for a long stretch now. That business is the world's wealth creation engine. We already hold the ties to the owners. Closer linking of those relationships will unlock synergies that matter a great deal. In the same way, moving affluent clients in our Global Consumer Banking upward toward ultra-high net worth in the Private Bank is clearly a natural place to expand — an elevator we never truly built or thought about in that manner. We've got some excellent platforms. Through our Institutional Clients Group worldwide, our Private Bank clients in particular get to use top two platforms. Our Global Consumer Banking clients can access those too. What's possible here is pulling every one of these elements into one integrated offering spanning the whole range of clients, both in the U.S. and across global offshore wealth centers. I'd add that in Asia we already rank among the top three players. It isn't as though we lack scale or that this is some startup venture. We're already watching it bear fruit fast. Naturally, we told everyone about our wealth focus when the year began. So far this year in Asia, we've brought in 21.5 thousand new to bank clients. Year-to-date, we've brought on more than 500 bankers, advisors, and other front office support. In this year's third quarter, we rolled out one of our largest wealth tech releases, with over 70+ features going live, building on the digital platform that debuted last quarter. Having all these separate elements, and now combining them, is genuinely creating momentum and speeding up what's possible for us. This is a trend. Wealth as a trend will be among those unstoppable ones, especially Asia in the years ahead. We'll consider acquisitions. Right now, obviously, the sharper focus is on digital capabilities and other ways to strengthen value propositions and the technology side. That's not merely buying companies — we've also been putting money into alliances and similar arrangements. The goal is to genuinely support an affluent customer through every aspect of what they require, instead of limiting ourselves the way certain competitors do, focusing only on investment offerings. We enjoy advantages on every front.

Jenn Landis

executive
#43

I appreciate everyone being here for today's session. If anything else comes up, don't hesitate to get in touch with IR. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#44

This concludes Citi third quarter earnings call. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.