Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 14, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being here. Just a quick note that the deck we're using today — you can grab it from our site, citigroup.com — might include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects, and they come with uncertainty as well as shifts in circumstances. Results in reality could end up differing significantly from what's in those statements, because of many factors, such as the ones we outline in our SEC filings. So with that said, over to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jen, and a happy new year to all of you. It's great to be with you once more today. Well, things have been hectic, and there's plenty for us to cover today. I'll begin by giving you the latest on our strategy refresh. After that, I'll offer my perspective on the fourth quarter, and I'll wrap up with all the headway we've achieved on our major priorities. As you noticed earlier this week, we made public our plan to narrow our Mexico franchise's focus exclusively to institutional and wealth management businesses, which means we will leave the consumer small business and middle-market banking operations in that country. This wasn't something we decided casually. We gave our Mexico franchise a clear-eyed examination, and we reached the difficult realization that the noninstitutional businesses don't match our updated strategic direction; to be clear, these franchises are excellent, they're scaled, and they deliver high returns, but our strategic aim is to put money into businesses completely in line with our core strengths and to make our firm simpler. While doing this work, it also became evident that a huge opportunity remains for our Institutional Clients Group in Mexico. Citi stands as Mexico's top institutional bank; we've worked with corporate clients and investors in that country for nearly 100 years, and that will stay the same. Mexico's future looks bright, and we're dedicated to helping shape it in an important way. We anticipate Mexico will be a key destination for worldwide investment and trade flows in the coming years. So we intend to keep a substantial, locally licensed bank in place there and put money in to seize growth in a core, high-returning hub of our institutional network; this transaction won't be straightforward. We've devoted the past several months to figuring out how to achieve the best outcomes for our shareholders while staying true to our local stakeholders. The separation process starts right away, and we anticipate kicking off the sales process in the spring. And naturally, there will be a chance to give excess capital from the deal back to our shareholders. This marks our last decision regarding market exits as we wrap up our strategy refresh and get closer to Investor Day. I'm eager to speak with you about the future Citi on March 2. Today, we'll walk you through the modifications we're making to bring our organization and financial reporting in line with our refreshed strategy. Now these modifications will also let us cut structural complexity and the costs that come with it. Among other benefits, this will make Citi simpler for our investors to grasp. You'll be able to view and evaluate more easily the core businesses that will comprise Citi going forward. First, we're establishing a new personal banking and wealth management segment, which Anand Selva will lead. It will be made up of 2 distinct reporting units: our U.S. personal banking businesses; and our global wealth management business, which is going to include the private bank. Next, regarding the institutional division, Paco Ybarra will keep leading it. Our reporting will shift to 3 segments: services, banking and markets. Treasury and Trade Solutions along with Securities Services will fall under services, showing how vital we consider these operations for Citi's future. Last, a fresh segment called Legacy Franchises will be established to contain every business we plan to leave; we'll start reporting our financials by these segments and reporting units by no later than Q2 so you possess the details required to gauge our advancement and keep us responsible, and we're eager to outline our approach and intentions for how these operations will collaborate and produce returns for shareholders during Investor Day in March; shifting now to earnings. 2021 ended reasonably well for us. On Slide 2, you'll notice the quarter concluded with net income at $3.2 billion and EPS at $1.46. This encompasses a $1.2 billion reduction to EBIT mostly tied to winding down our Korean consumer business. Without those effects, net income would stand at $4.2 billion with EPS at $1.99. Our full-year net income of $22 billion indicates a better credit landscape, leading to a RoTCE of 13.4%. Within ICG, we enjoyed a robust quarter in investment banking and picked up share throughout the year in M&A; we keep investing heavily in talent, and a quite strong transaction pipeline lies before us; although fixed income performance during the quarter could have been more balanced, equities wrapped up 2021 rising 25% over the year. The recovery TTS experienced in trade flows and cash volumes fell short of countering the present rate setting, yet it signals positively for 2022. In fact, we believe this business's cycle has shifted and stands ready to gain as monetary policy evolves and growth speeds up. Mark and I have discussed enhancing the revenue mix of our institutional operations as a key focus, and it's producing outcomes with yet another quarter of robust fee growth momentum across offerings. Certain consumer operations still face COVID's unsettling effects on how customers behave; within the U.S., elevated payment rates kept offsetting solid purchase sales, though loans rose in branded cards during this quarter. Deposits and AUM kept expanding, with digital deposits climbing almost 20% over the full year; throughout the year, we gave back close to $12 billion in capital to shareholders and lifted our tangible book value per share by 7% to $79.16; we concluded the year with a CET1 ratio at 12.2% on a standardized basis, having accumulated the capital necessary to handle SACR's impact. Remember, that regulatory shift only kicked in on January 1. Although that led us to hit the brakes on repurchasing shares for a while, we're going to start those buybacks up again during this quarter, since that issue has now been taken care of. And as you can see on Slide 3, we're carrying out and making good on what we set out to do: refreshing the strategy, the transformation effort, and our culture — and we're approaching all of it with genuine urgency. Starting with strategy: our attention is fixed like a laser on quickly and effectively putting into place the strategic calls we reached across the last year so that returns to our investors improve. Deals have been inked in 6 of the Asia consumer markets, among them the pact to divest 4 markets that we told you about yesterday. What that means is that less than 8 months after deciding to leave these 13 businesses, we've got a clear route forward in a majority of them, and in the remaining markets we're already deep into the process. In Korea, we acted decisively in concluding that the best route for our shareholders was to shut down our consumer operation, and we managed to put most of that charge behind us during this quarter. Wealth management is another place where we've moved without delay — there we added a net 800 advisers, relationship managers and others across the year.
Jane Fraser
executiveDuring 2021, these efforts brought in roughly 750 private bank customers along with 45,000 Citi Gold clients. Over in what we refer to as U.S. Personal Banking, adoption has been solid for newly introduced offerings like the custom cash card, and we've been expanding digital platforms so we can seize chances in installment lending. Beyond the headway made in TTS, we've likewise been developing our security services platform. Words can't express how happy we are to strengthen ties with BlackRock by stepping up as the biggest custodian for their iShares ETF. Our second priority is continuing to carry out the transformation plan so we can visibly reinforce risk and controls while bringing our bank up to date for a digital era. This undertaking forms the bedrock for all our ambitions. We're refining our operating model to boost efficiency over the long haul and enhance how we serve clients. When it comes to the consent orders, we're fully immersed in carrying them out. We remain engaged in productive conversations with our regulators, gathering their input and weaving it into our active execution and project blueprints. Third, and tied to that, we're cultivating a culture that anticipates greatness and requires responsibility. We're advancing this through multiple approaches, among them a stronger performance management framework at the close of last year, adjusting the compensation blend to line up more closely with shareholder interests, and several initiatives aimed at changing culture. A culture of greatness likewise involves establishing a track record of accomplishments that our staff can take pride in. One domain where our employees feel especially proud is our ESG work. Before this month ends, we'll present our strategy for achieving net zero by 2050, a pledge I made on day one as CEO 10 months back. Naturally, we'll pursue all of this with an unwavering emphasis on clients as we assist them in getting through COVID. We truly hope Omicron marks the last disruptive stage of this pandemic, yet plenty of other matters need navigating too, be they macroeconomic like inflation or geopolitical like tensions with Russia. We've witnessed the strength and significance of Citi as we stood by our clients through unfamiliar territory, and we'll remain alongside them into the coming chapter. With that, I'd like to hand things over to Mark, after which we'd be glad to field your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, Jane, and hello everybody on this morning's call. There's quite a bit for us to get through today. To begin, I'll take you through the modifications to financial reporting that we intend to implement, with more specifics. After that, I'll cover how the 13 Asia market exits, along with Mexico, will affect 2021 financially, plus the adjustments coming to our financial disclosure. And after that, the results for the quarter. As part of refreshing our strategy, we've begun implementing changes aimed at better aligning with our vision and strategy; we updated the earnings presentation and added extra metrics and key drivers for the ICG businesses. What we're aiming for is to make financial reporting simpler so investors can far more easily grasp how we're performing and what our key assets are. If you look at Slide 4, we set out what the reporting changes Jane referenced involve. To start, we plan to place Citibanamex's consumer, small business and middle market banking operations, together with the 13 Asia consumer exits, into a newly created segment named Legacy Franchises. That way, you can more clearly see the financials of what remains of the company once these exits are complete. We've been through the process of running businesses that are being divested, and we're assembling a dedicated team to run this new segment. This lets the management teams of the go-forward businesses devote themselves entirely to carrying out the firm's strategy. Next, we're rearranging our reporting units so that you can more easily grasp the financials of our businesses and what value they deliver to Citi. Beginning with ICG, TTS and security services will be placed into a reporting unit named Services. These businesses are foundational to us, holding a unique position thanks to their global footprint and the full suite of products they offer. As a result, Markets will stop including security services and will instead cover only equity and fixed income markets. And finally, at ICG, banking will cover only advisory, equity underwriting, debt underwriting and corporate lending. The Global Consumer Bank, GCB, gets a new name: Personal Banking and Wealth Management, PBWM. The Private Bank is being shifted from ICG into PBWM. As you'll recall, we said back in January of last year that we'd formed a single wealth management organization within Citi Global Wealth, which is now known as Global Wealth Management and stands as its own distinct reporting unit. Establishing this unit brings the wealth management teams together onto one integrated platform, serving clients right across the wealth continuum, from the affluent segment through to ultra-high net worth clients. North America Consumer becomes U.S. Personal Banking and stays a reporting unit within PBWM. Branded cards, retail services and retail banking will all remain part of this unit. For the new reporting units shown on this page within the ICG and PBWM segments, we intend to supply the financials beginning no later than the second quarter earnings. Additionally, our Investor Day is going to be a perfect moment for pulling together everything accomplished during the last year and presenting our medium-term vision along with the strategy for the company. On Slide 5, you can see what the Citibanamex businesses we intend to exit contribute, plus what comes from the 13 Asia markets. This should help you understand more clearly what the financial results look like for those exits combined. Then, in the appendix on Page 18, there's additional detail regarding the 13 Asia exit markets and the deals announced so far. Moving to Mexico. Like Jane said, our commitment to Mexico stays firm, and we'll keep serving institutional and private bank clients in that country. Having said that, after extremely careful thought and analysis, we concluded we are no longer the best owner for the businesses being exited. The Mexico consumer and small business banking operations covered by the intended exit make up the whole Latin America Global Consumer Banking unit, along with the Mexico middle market banking business presently sitting within Citi's Institutional Clients Group segment. On the left side of the page, key figures appear for 2020 and 2021 covering the businesses we intend to exit in Mexico; during 2021, those businesses brought in $4.7 billion of revenue and $1.1 billion of net income. Altogether, these businesses held $20 billion of loans, $31 billion of deposits and roughly $4 billion of allocated TCE. Once again, no transaction exists yet and we are exploring multiple divestiture paths, meaning the final financial impact from a transaction remains unknown. We'll keep you informed about our progress as we conduct a thoughtful process weighing what serves the best interest of our shareholders, along with our clients and employees in Mexico. Beyond the chance to give additional capital back to shareholders, these divestitures will let us streamline the management and organizational structure throughout the firm; now moving to Slide 6. While carrying out our strategy refresh and simplification, we've been examining our disclosure and terminology, and determined the time is right to align more closely with our peers. First, revenue we used to call net interest revenue is now net interest income, while revenue we used to call non-NIR is now noninterest revenue. Second, as the page shows, we've changed how insurance paid on our deposits gets accounted for, including FDIC and foreign deposit insurance. Previously, deposit insurance was accounted for as a contra revenue and net interest income. Starting this quarter, though, we'll report it as an expense and take it out of net interest income; and keep in mind, this change is earnings neutral. This adjustment was made so that comparisons between us and other companies become simpler for you, and for the sake of comparability across 2019 to 2021, we've restated earlier years using that identical reporting approach, and the remaining portion of today's presentation likewise incorporates these 2 modifications. Slide 7 gives you the financial results for the entire company. In the fourth quarter, as Jane said before, net income came in at $3.2 billion, with EPS of $1.46 and an RoTCE of 7.4%, on revenues of $17 billion. Within those results sit costs of roughly $1.2 billion, mostly tied to the voluntary retirement program offered alongside the wind down of our Korea consumer business, plus certain additional Asia exit impacts, which from here on I'll call the Asia divestiture impacts collectively. If you set those impacts aside, EPS would have reached $1.99, with an RoTCE of roughly 10%; during the quarter, total revenues rose 1% compared with a year ago, since strength in noninterest revenue, led by ICG — TTS, Security Services and Investment Banking in particular — was mostly offset by lower net interest income across GCB and ICG. Expenses of $13.5 billion appear in our results, up 18% against the prior year. Without the Asia divestiture cost, that expense growth would have been 8%. The rise in expenses came mainly from investments in our transformation, business-led investments and higher revenue-related expenses, partly offset by productivity savings.
Mark Mason
executiveDuring the quarter, credit costs actually worked in our favor. That was mostly because we released about $1.4 billion from our allowance for credit losses, reflecting a better macroeconomic environment and ongoing gains in the quality of our portfolio. Switching now to the whole year: our revenues declined 5%. That came from market normalization and from consumers paying at elevated rates, though it was partly balanced out by robust growth in noninterest revenue throughout ICG — especially in investment banking, TTS and security services. Our expenses for the entire year rose 9%, yet if you set aside Asia divestiture costs, they rose 6%. Additionally, across the full year, we produced RoTCE of 13%, or 14% once Asia-related divestiture effects are excluded. Keep in mind, we enjoyed a benefit of nearly $9 billion from ACL releases over the whole year. Slide 8 presents an expense walk covering the full year along with the main underlying drivers; during 2021, once Asia divestiture effects are excluded, expenses climbed 6%, matching what we had previously guided. Going forward, we know there is significantly more work ahead of us. The divestitures give us a chance to streamline how we manage and organize the company; we are likewise examining our structural expenses closely, aiming to run things as efficiently and soundly as we can while having investments pay for themselves. There is much more we plan to share on this topic at our Investor Day; Slide 9 covers net interest income, deposits and loans. Net interest income rose by roughly $130 million from the prior quarter during the fourth quarter, with North America Consumer driving that. Quarter over quarter, net interest margin stayed about the same. Measured against the same period a year earlier, net interest income did not change. Also compared with a year earlier, average deposits rose during the quarter, since we keep strengthening ties with our institutional clients and our consumer clients, especially those in North America. Average loans stayed approximately level versus a year earlier, as ICG growth got offset by a decrease in GCB. Given that the likelihood of higher rates has grown over recent quarters, allow me to offer some thoughts about what higher rates could mean. Our 10-Q lays out interest rate sensitivity under a parallel shift combined with a runoff balance sheet. That differs from the approach our peers use, which usually assumes the balance sheet stays static. If we assume a static balance sheet plus a parallel shift of 100 basis points, we would anticipate Citi's total net interest income across every currency rising by more than 3x the figure disclosed in our third quarter 10-Q — approximately $2.5 billion to $3 billion in net interest income. Slide 10 lays out our summary balance sheet together with the key capital and liquidity metrics. Our balance sheet remains very strong. Out of a $2.3 trillion balance sheet, roughly 25%, or $530 billion, is made up of HQLA. On top of that, we kept total liquidity resources at about $960 billion. We keep working to optimize the balance sheet, putting excess liquidity to work in securities since we capitalized on market opportunities, and we brought down both short-term and long-term debt on a sequential basis and versus a year earlier. Turning to loans: corporate loans account for roughly 60% of total loans, and lending to corporates based outside the U.S. makes up about 30% of total loans. As we've said before, around 80% of our total corporate loans carry an investment grade rating. Looking at capital, we closed out the year with a CET1 capital ratio of about 12.2%, as we got ready to adopt SACR on January 1. Now that SACR is in place and we've held to our capital ratio target, buybacks restart this quarter at levels comparable to those seen in the second and third quarters of 2021. As we think about the rest of the year, capital faces several variables. These include regulatory headwinds hitting us and the broader industry, like higher GCIB surcharges, plus the timing and effect of divesting the 13 Asia exits and Mexico. Given that, you should expect us to manage toward a CET1 ratio nearer 12% by year-end, because of the anticipated GCIB surcharge increase at the start of 2023. That said, we stay focused on every aspect of capital, aiming to keep a CET1 ratio of 11.5%; and as you're aware, the SCB framework lets us evaluate the appropriate level of buybacks quarter by quarter, and we'll keep doing that all year long, with the aim of returning excess capital to shareholders. On Slide 11, we present the fourth quarter results for our Institutional Clients Group. Revenues rose 4% from a year earlier, powered by investment banking, private bank and security services fees, partly offset by a drop in markets. Expenses climbed 10% versus the prior year, driven by transformation, business-led investments and revenue-related expenses, partly offset by productivity savings. Cost of credit was a net benefit of roughly $300 million, since an ACL release more than offset net credit losses. We keep seeing strong credit performance, with net credit losses falling year-over-year and nonaccrual loans lower sequentially and year-over-year. That produced net income of $2.5 billion, a decline of approximately 22% from the prior year, mostly because of higher expenses and a smaller ACL release than a year earlier. And ICG posted a 10.8% RoTCE for the quarter; we also recorded 5% growth in both loans and deposits year-over-year, as momentum remains good and we keep deepening relationships with existing clients and bringing in new ones. Now turning to the whole year, ICG generated net income of about $16 billion on revenue of $44 billion, with an RoTCE near 17%; Slide 12 breaks out revenue results by business and the main drivers for our ICG segment in the fourth quarter. Treasury and Trade Solution revenues came in a bit lower than a year earlier, as ongoing rate headwinds were partly offset by an 18% increase in fees. That was, in fact, our strongest fee quarter on record. Revenue also rose from the prior quarter, lifted by both net interest income and robust fee growth. We keep seeing solid underlying drivers in TTS compared with a year ago that point to sustained strong client activity. Because this marks the first occasion we are presenting key metrics that illustrate this momentum, let me take a moment to go through each one and explain what it stands for. U.S. dollar clearing transactions rose 4%, representing the clearing and settlement activity of commercial and treasury flows for financial institutions. Cross-border flows climbed 15%. Those flows capture our worldwide payment activity, through which we deliver cross-border solutions to clients, fully integrated across our TTS and Markets business and spanning more than 145 currencies. And crucially, this client activity produces recurring fee revenues and creates sizable operating deposits. Commercial card volumes, which capture travel, purchase and virtual card activity across all clients, increased 48%. Once again, these metrics serve as indicators of client activity and fees, and together they drive about 50% of total TTS fee revenue. Investment banking revenues grew 43% year-over-year, powered by gains across products, among them record advisory performance — our strongest advisory quarter in more than a decade.
Mark Mason
executivePrivate Bank revenues rose 6% compared with a year earlier, and we keep seeing robust momentum when it comes to bringing in new clients. Across all markets, revenues fell 17% against last year. Different forces shaped how fixed income and equity markets performed, but that performance comes up against an exceptionally strong quarter a year ago. Fixed Income Markets revenues dropped 20% year over year. We did see healthy expansion in FX and commodities, yet that was outweighed by weaker rates and spread products. Equity Markets revenues fell 3% versus a year earlier, since gains in prime finance balances and structured activities were canceled out by a drop in cash. Security Services revenues climbed 5% compared with last year, with fees rising 11%, helped by greater settlement volumes and larger assets under custody, though interest rate pressures partly held that back. Moving now to Slide 13. Here we present results from our Global Consumer Banking business for the fourth quarter in constant dollars. Revenues dropped 6% versus a year earlier, pulled down by weaker revenues in every region. Expenses climbed 34% year over year, pushed up by the Asia divestiture costs. If you set those costs aside, expenses rose 9%, lifted by transformation and business-led investments, partly held back by productivity savings. Cost of credit came in as a $105 million benefit this quarter, since an ACL release outweighed net credit losses. The NCL rate this quarter was 1.2%, which is 61 basis points lower than a year earlier and 20 basis points lower than the prior quarter. We freed up more than $900 million of ACL this quarter tied to ongoing gains in our economic outlook and portfolio quality, partly offset by volume growth. That produced a 42% drop in net income and an RoTCE of 8%. Without the Asia divestitures impacts, net income would have risen 44% and delivered an RoTCE of 20%. Turning to the full year, GCB generated $6 billion of net income from $27 billion of revenues, with an RoTCE of 17%, or 22% once Asia divestiture impacts are excluded; on Slide 14, we lay out GCB revenues by product along with key business drivers and metrics for the fourth quarter. Branded cards revenues fell 3% compared with last year on higher payment rates and portfolio mix. Underlying drivers look encouraging, with new accounts rising 43%, card sales volumes climbing 24% and average loans increasing 3%. In fact, fourth quarter acquisitions topped the same quarter in 2019 by 2%, the first quarter to achieve that since the pandemic began. Retail Services revenues fell 10% versus a year earlier, driven by a 2% drop in net interest income from elevated payment rates and by higher partner payments stemming from better credit performance; even so, underlying drivers are positive, with account acquisitions rising 6% and spend climbing 16% year over year. We're encouraged by these underlying drivers in both cards businesses, yet payment rates remain stubbornly high, which weighs on our loan growth and revenue growth in both cards businesses. Retail banking revenues fell 6% compared with last year, driven by lower deposit spreads and lower mortgage revenue. Even so, the fundamental momentum stayed solid: deposits climbed 13%, Citigold households rose 9%, and assets under management grew 8% versus a year earlier, as we keep carrying out our North America retail plan, centered on the global wealth unit. In Asia, revenues fell 7% from the prior year, mostly because of rate headwinds and increased payment rates. Results at the wealth hubs outperformed the region as a whole, posting deposit growth of 12%, AUM growth of 13%, and 16% growth in Citigold and CPC clients. Latin America revenues dropped 3% compared with a year ago, chiefly from reduced loan volumes across both retail and cards. Slide 15 lays out Corporate/Other results for the fourth quarter. Revenues rose versus last year, primarily on higher net revenue from the investment portfolio. Expenses fell versus a year earlier, mainly from winding down legacy assets. Cost of credit was benign. Normally at this stage we'd provide a full year outlook. But with our Investor Day set for March 2, we intend to pull everything together then to discuss 2022 within the complete context of our strategy and medium-term performance expectations. As part of refreshing our strategy, we aim to be as simple and transparent as we can; I hope the new earnings presentation appeals to you, and we'll keep refining it as we go. With that, Jane and I are glad to take your questions.
John McDonald
analystMorning. Mark, I appreciate the thorough breakdown, and Jane, thanks for walking us through strategy. Mark, could you revisit how the net interest income sensitivity was restated? I just want to confirm we understood it correctly. What changed to produce this new format? And what are the main factors shaping your net interest income guidance for this year? No specific figure needed — but perhaps your thinking on trading as well as core NII card growth.
Mark Mason
executiveOf course. Thanks, John. That was addressed on Slide 9. As you'll remember, John, our disclosure historically used a run-off balance sheet. Deposits, of course, decline as they term out, and loans decline as they mature. A different method involves a static balance sheet, correct? So we ran the analysis assuming a static balance sheet, plus a 100 basis point parallel shift in a rising rate environment, naturally, across every currency. We also hold a blend of U.S. dollar and foreign currencies. Running that analysis now, with the balance sheet held static — meaning deposit levels, loan levels, and so forth — produces 3x what we reported in the Q during the third quarter. That equals the $2.5 billion to $3 billion of net interest income. So clearly, keeping — or rather assuming deposit levels remain unchanged — lets us produce more net interest income, and that's a significant factor behind the number range, or the range I gave.
John McDonald
analystGot it.
Mark Mason
executiveIn terms of — sorry?
John McDonald
analystYeah. No, I'm glad that was useful.
Mark Mason
executiveRight, excellent. Regarding what lies ahead, as you said, I won't be providing guidance. That said, a few items matter a lot and are what we're focused on for 2022. First, there are the drivers we discussed previously. A great many of the fundamental drivers across our franchise appear quite robust and are producing solid growth in fee revenue. And given a positive GDP outlook, my expectation is that this keeps working in our favor during 2022. Second, I'd highlight the interest rate hike assumptions for 2022. Depending on which economists you follow, I've got anywhere from 3 to 4. And clearly that will also work to our benefit when you consider how many accrual businesses we have, be it our TTS franchise, our private bank, etc., etc. So those factors carry real weight for the top line, and we anticipate they'll help deliver some growth as we come out of 2022. I brought up loan growth on the branded cards portfolio. When it comes to cards, payment rates are really the key, along with how they taper off — hopefully taper off. Through all of 2021, they've stayed stubbornly high. So hopefully we begin to see some tapering off, and in the back half of the year we get a bit of growth in average interest-earning balances, but those are significant factors that need to play through into 2022.
John McDonald
analystAll right, that's helpful. And for my second question, when it comes to how you're handling capital, you said that buybacks would come back at some level during this quarter, plus there's a substantial amount of capital you anticipate unlocking through deals that are still pending. So how are you approaching this, I suppose? Once that future capital arrives, you'll put it to work. It fits into how you think over the long term, yet my assumption is you don't intend to tap into it at any point during this year?
Mark Mason
executiveRight. Clearly, when we examine capital planning, it's done against the backdrop of our strategy and our capacity to genuinely put that capital to use, while also giving back the greatest amount of surplus capital possible to our shareholders. Thus, when we consider the divestitures — they're in progress — as that capital becomes available, that's something we'll build into the capital plan covering the year and the quarter; and wherever possible, we'll hand that back to shareholders; accordingly, quite a few transactions are set to close in 2022. That's going to be incorporated into our plan, and we're eager to pursue those moves later in the year.
Mike Mayo
analystJane, this one's for you, and once I've asked my 2 questions I'll get back in the queue. There's a lot I want to cover.
Jane Fraser
executive<<inaudible>>, Mike.
Mike Mayo
analystThanks for putting together the fresh deck. The thing I keep hearing from investors, and honestly it's my own top question too, is this: once everything is finished and the dust settles, what exactly is Citigroup? If you had to boil it down to one sentence, how would you describe what Citigroup stands for and what it is? .
Jane Fraser
executiveThat's a wonderful question to get; here's how I'd put it — what we're aiming for at Citi is to become the foremost bank serving institutions that operate across borders. In wealth, we intend to be a leader — a worldwide leader; in consumer payments and lending within our home market, we'll be a significant participant; that's the Citi of tomorrow and the vision we hold for it. It comes across as streamlined and tightly focused. The connections are far stronger; running it is undeniably less complicated, marked by a culture built on excellence and accountability; and, as I'm hopeful we've demonstrated today, it ought to be something everyone can grasp more easily and that sits completely in line with what our shareholders want.
Mike Mayo
analystAnd in that same vein, are you unlocking roughly $11 billion in capital at this point? And as far as plans go — Mark, I constantly hear you mention that you'll put money into the business, that you'll handle supply for growth, and after that repurchase shares; however, when it comes to a share price that's this depressed, I mean, compared with the financial index, the share price sits at one of the lowest points ever. Shouldn't you elevate buybacks in the order of priorities? Or what other action can you take or statement can you make to demonstrate that shareholders count? Jane, I mean, you've accomplished so much regarding the E side. You've clearly accomplished plenty regarding the S side. However, the G in ESG, as it pertains to shareholders, shareholders have been neglected for such a long time. Just curious what more you could possibly do or say concerning acknowledging shareholders and their wish to see a share price that performs better?
Jane Fraser
executiveOur shareholders matter enormously to us. And Mike, I realize we must make the bank more aligned with shareholders and friendlier toward them, and we're doing that; so allow me to offer you 4 illustrations. Our strategy is going to produce results and we're going to give excess capital back to shareholders. And as you point out, considering where the stock trades, it renders buybacks extremely appealing. Second, we're making structural and strategic choices to place the bank in the strongest position to propel shareholder value. And you can observe that we're carrying things out and we're delivering rapidly, and we're intensely focused on pushing the valuation to a much higher level than where it stands now. Third, we're altering numerous aspects of financial reporting to make it simpler for our shareholders to comprehend the bank, and we're going to be as transparent as we can be so you're able to gauge our progress and results. And I believe the structure that Mark described and that I outlined at a high level, it's going to make that task considerably simpler. And lastly, and a subject I'm aware you've spoken about quite forcefully, we're additionally implementing changes to compensation. So a greater number of our senior business leaders will receive PSUs for this coming year. We've shifted to 100% deferred stock rather than a blend of stock and cash in the geographies where we're allowed to do so. And we're boosting how much returns count when determining performance evaluations. There is a myriad of — and rounds of various actions that we're taking because our shareholders matter to us. And we want to lift our valuation to one that we believe has — fulfills its full potential.
Glenn Schorr
analystFor the purpose of actually hearing what you have to say, I'll switch this head on. Speaking for myself, I really like management teams that have their own money tied up in the shares they urged investors to buy. If you're aiming to lead in every one of those spaces you're targeting and in the assets connected to that question, keeping pace is going to require heavy spending. So what I want to know is, how do you reconcile all of that — the profitability gap on one side, and on the other, putting enough money in and nourishing your franchises so they stay ahead, while also watching the expense side? It looks incredibly difficult. I'd really like to hear what you think.
Mark Mason
executiveI owe you an apology. A big chunk of that question got cut off for me. Could you please just say the last part over again. The line has a lot of static right now.
Glenn Schorr
analystOf course. My apologies. I'll take it from here...
Mark Mason
executiveCould you elaborate a bit further? There's quite a bit of noise on the line. Shall we return to this later?
Glenn Schorr
analystSure thing.
Mark Mason
executiveSorry.
Betsy Graseck
analystSo, a few things I'd like to ask. First, I'm trying to trace the path from where CET1 stands right now to the close of the year, since you said you'd finish at 12%. Some operations are being sold off, and my assumption is that ought to bring risk-weighted assets down. Yet on top of that, you've also got share repurchases flowing through. And simultaneously, my guess is you'd likely be aiming to expand those RWAs? From what I understand, RWAs fell 5% in Q2, and perhaps that contributed to FICC coming in somewhat soft. So can you walk me through how we ought to view that path and what's driving the CET1 movement, since it'll shape how we regard revenue growth in the markets division.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. That's a fair question; so clearly, we're examining the way we keep putting money into the franchise, especially in places where growth exists. At the same time, making sure we're providing buybacks, or returning funds to our shareholders. When I look at the CET1 ratio, we're finishing the year at roughly 12.2%. As you're aware, SACR takes effect — or took effect on January 1. So we're finishing, on January 1, at approximately where our goal sits. And across the year, we'll manage to take on expansion in the businesses that require it while still finding offsets to SACR and to low-returning assets we might hold, shedding those, and producing income along with capital from the divestitures we'll manage to complete over the year. So when we consider that plan, the year's outset, near our goal, by late 2022, we'll need to rebuild it to roughly 12% so we can take on the GCIB headwind, presuming no relief is given for it, which then takes effect at the start of 2023. And so throughout the year, we'll draw on RWA, we'll unlock capital and give capital back to shareholders. We'll produce additional earnings. But when the year closes, we'll have to sort of finish at the upper end, or near that 12%.
Betsy Graseck
analystCan you give a sense of how big the gain to GCIB or SCB ought to be from every one of these divestitures you're carrying out? Honestly, when I caught the Mexico headline this week, I figured that might be among the reasons you chose to put — to get out of the Mexico consumer business, is the possible uplift that comes your way, given you said it turns you into a simpler company, and that ought to flow into SCB, I'd imagine. .
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. It isn't a big factor behind the choice, the way Jane has sort of laid it out; however it is — however it does play into the items you've brought up. So looking at GCIB, there's, I'm not sure, roughly $31 billion of deposits connected to our Mexico consumer business. That would produce around 10 basis points, or 10 points I mean, on the GCIB score. Across all the divestitures that were — that we've designated, it comes to roughly $85 billion in deposits; therefore you can work out that we'd receive some gain from it. You're correct, and I don't have figures that I'd be able to share right now, but — and partly since the Fed needs to run their analysis. Still, you're correct, from a CCAR standpoint, whenever you consider the stress capital buffer, there is an effect on PPNR, yet more significantly, on stress losses that will flow through too. As you're aware, that effect along with the deposit effect won't truly kick in until we've completed these transactions. Yet it definitely is a consideration in how we approach longer-term capital planning, and it definitely is something I'll discuss further at Investor Day on March 2.
Betsy Graseck
analystAll right. Regarding those low-yield holdings you mentioned pulling back from — is that essentially things such as rates along with the fixed income division? And ought we to anticipate some effect from that? Or, once more, I'm merely attempting to connect the 5% drop in RWAs with the remark that the fixed income division was somewhat soft this quarter.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. Yeah. There's — I don't intend to get granular about which low-returning assets are being exited, though we are definitely reviewing our markets franchise to identify where such low-returning assets sit, and also to identify where client relationships are single product and don't necessarily connect throughout the franchise; so this is a matter that Jane and I, together with Paco, are sharply focused on. We recognize that although we've witnessed expansion in markets and in FICC, that has been accompanied by expansion of the balance sheet, and we want to ensure we are optimizing how capital gets used.
L. Erika Penala
analystFor my first question, I'd like to direct it to Mark. Also, I want to say thank you very much for this fresh approach to financial disclosure — in my view it's going to prove quite useful — and for the NII sensitivity too. I realize March will bring us far greater granularity. Still, when we consider what the cost structure will look like once the exits you've named are complete, can you assist us in gauging how much additional expansion remains in remediation-related costs? How bold do you intend to be regarding investment spending during 2022? And do you believe you've located sufficient wasteful costs inside the franchise to finance a portion of those — both sets of initiatives?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, excellent question. I won't provide guidance regarding 2022, but allow me to attempt to lay out our thinking, since I believe that matters. Jane and I both acknowledge that we've got — there's plenty of noise coming our way, pardon me. So regarding costs, clearly our cost structure is large. Growth has materialized during this year; yet I believe genuine possibilities exist down the road to go after that cost structure, and that is precisely our intention. So consider the divestitures — I'll begin there briefly. Roughly $6.8 billion in costs are connected to divestitures. Once those divestitures are finalized, a portion of that will disappear on its own. The remainder, typically called stranded cost, already has a team being assembled by us to concentrate on going after and eliminating that stranded cost. The next item I'll raise on this subject concerns the transformation. This year, the transformation produced 3 percentage points of growth. I anticipate additional growth connected to it, especially given that we continue hiring more people. Greater technology spending will also be necessary. Yet in time the transformation will generate efficiencies, will cut down manual touch points, will enable straight-through processing and consequently, will let us lower our costs. And the last element I'll note is the strategy. Jane referenced in our strategy a concentration on core businesses. That is going to let us examine the organizational structure and spot additional simplification possibilities in how we oversee and operate the company. Each quarter we generate roughly $300 million to $400 million in productivity savings; that isn't sufficient. We believe greater efficiency potential exists beyond that. And those are the possibilities we'll pursue in order to finance a portion of this investment spending that we anticipate over the coming couple of years. Further details at Investor Day.
L. Erika Penala
analystThanks for setting that up. Jane, the following question is directed at you. Earlier, when you answered Mike's inquiry regarding how you see Citi, you opened by describing Citi as the world's corporate bank, to put it another way. What does your picture of Citi encompass when it comes to the funding base? There's plenty of discussion, especially early on in a rising rate cycle, about the inherent gap between you and your biggest U.S. competitors when it comes to your deposits that naturally carry higher rates, correct? So how do you see your funding base changing down the road? Also, would you be interested in substantially expanding your U.S. retail deposit franchise?
Jane Fraser
executiveErika, our funding base is fairly diverse. On the institutional side, we hold the #1 TTS franchise worldwide. That brings substantial funding from our cash management operations and our leading position in cash management. Our wealth business, spanning ultra-high net worth all the way down to affluent clients, likewise provides substantial and highly appealing deposits and funding. Clearly, we are exiting international consumer banking. Meanwhile, we've concentrated on the U.S. retail bank: pushing digital deposit growth and making certain that this business delivers steady, low-cost funding for the firm here in the U.S. We anticipate continuing to expand that moving forward.
Mike Mayo
analystThat came in earlier than I had anticipated. I have one more question regarding the adjustments to pay. Right, it's encouraging that individuals are contributing through equity rather than only money and equity; however, you introduced the fresh incentive plan. I had assumed that wasn't yet settled; yet under this new incentive plan tied to the financial goals for the coming 3-year period, does it remain entirely money? Alternatively, is it a mix of money and equity? Or perhaps it's equity?
Jane Fraser
executiveI believe you mean the transformation award. Am I right about that, Mike?
Mike Mayo
analystAll right.
Jane Fraser
executiveCorrect. Regarding that particular one, although the initial 2 portions are disbursed in cash, the remaining 50% is tied to how our stock performs over 3 years. In our view, that represented the right equilibrium. As we've mentioned before, the transformation sits at the very top of our priorities. The concerns that have been raised must be dealt with effectively, and doing so is entirely aligned with what benefits our shareholders. A key element of this is that collective accountability is necessary for us to succeed in resolving those concerns and in changing our culture; consequently, this award hinges on shared achievement rather than incentives for individuals. So it plays a significant role in getting things done. Naturally, should we not deliver — if the transformation's results fall short and execution proves unsuccessful — then no award will be granted.
Mike Mayo
analystAnd as for when we learn those targets — my guess is that happens at Investor Day, which answers that. On the PSU side, what amount had been granted in stock cash previously? And how many individuals does this cover now compared with before?
Jane Fraser
executivePSUs go to the executive management team, and we are now broadening that out to the wider operating team, whose members include the heads of our biggest businesses. That information will come through in the proxy we put out in March, so you will receive everything at just about the same moment.
Ken Usdin
analystMark, I wanted to ask whether you might spend a moment discussing the card business overall — clearly some of that balance is beginning to appear. But I'd like you to address, first, what trajectory you anticipate for that balance. Second, spending against lending, and how much of each you're observing? And third, losses are plainly extraordinarily low, so how do you expect card normalization to unfold?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, absolutely. So — like I've said previously, when you examine what's happening with cards, in every segment, spend volume is rising. Branded card spend volume has grown 24%. Retail services spend volume has grown 16%. So spend volume is quite healthy. Customers are using our cards, and that's positive. Regarding the liquidity still present in the market, although savings rates have begun to normalize, a considerable amount of liquidity remains in the market. That is reflected in payment rates for both branded cards and retail services and, honestly, in certain international card businesses too; and it hasn't diminished. And so growth in branded cards loans has indeed begun to appear. Average loans are up 3% for branded cards. End-of-period loans rose 5%. What counts enormously when emerging from a crisis such as this is the way you reinvest. And so we've devoted considerable time to targeting new customers and generating new account acquisitions. New account acquisitions for branded cards are up 43%; and we've been generating that broadly across retail services too; so receiving a good — a very good response in terms of new accounts joining. We've also concentrated on ways to drive installment lending activity, simply to widen the lending we do with this customer base, and we've witnessed substantial growth in our Flex Loan and Flex Pay products as we've targeted customers who historically were transactors to genuinely shift them onto that product. So growth there is very good; actually, during 2021, we've achieved not only growth in aggregate; but looking at installment lending specifically, 90% of total installment sales are digital sales, which is yet another low-cost acquisition approach we've adopted; so underlying indicators there are good. But once more, it won't happen until payment rates begin to diminish. We would expect, hope that, that would begin to appear toward the back half of 2022. As for losses, which was the other portion of your question, loss levels are very low. You heard me reference the delinquency rates earlier. When I look at — or the loss rates earlier, when I examine delinquency trends, there's truly nothing there to focus on. They remain quite low. At this point, we aren’t seeing any indications or trouble spots, I’d say; though my expectation is that those 2 would begin returning to normal once payment rates begin declining.
Ken Usdin
analystThanks, Mark. One more question. You talked about the record — or at least the best quarter for advisory in some time. I'd like to hear your general thoughts on the investment banking pipelines across the product groups.
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Our investment banking pipeline is quite robust. We closed out the year with notable advisory growth, rising 146% versus the prior year, comfortably ahead of the wallet. Our share there has increased. ECM rose roughly 16%, also ahead of the wallet, and that really shows some fees originating from SPAC activity. So the growth has been quite good. Both EMEA and North America are up compared with a year ago thanks to ongoing M&A momentum. So our confidence is high. The pipeline, in our view, remains quite robust. We believe the investments we've made in adding bankers within certain sectors that required strengthening — sectors like health care, technology, and the sponsors group — are clearly beginning to deliver returns; so we're confident about it.
Glenn Schorr
analystOkay, let's give it another shot.
Jane Fraser
executiveThat's a lot better, Glenn.
Glenn Schorr
analystSo my sense is that we've got a solid long-term process underway, and it's something you measure across a period longer than 1 year. That said, how do you view this — it seems as though returns need to decline before they can climb. I realize your broad objective is to narrow the distance to peers. Yet when you consider the capital being released, the GCIB buffer along with the denominator, capital markets partly returning to normal, some stranded expenses sitting on sole franchises, and then the ongoing work on these transformations — is that acceptable, and is that typical? In our models, I believe it's partly assumed that we drop first and then come back up?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Thank you, Glenn. So here's how I'd put it: if you look at 2021, with a 13.4% RoTCE and reserve releases approaching $9 billion, I would say yes, correct? The reason is that those reserve releases account for a substantial portion of that figure. It's also key to set that against 2020, when the impact ran the other way, since we were adding sizable reserves. Still, as I — as we turn to the forward view, which we'll walk you through in greater detail, and as Jane said, our attention is on the core areas of the franchise that demonstrate room to grow and the potential for better returns. And that's — those are the places our efforts will be directed, and we believe that is what will help generate stronger returns as time goes on.
Glenn Schorr
analystThat's fair — the reserve does at minimum make a sizable difference. All right. Regarding that expansion, I believe a few questions have circled this topic, so I'll keep it brief. Still, considering how you described what Citi currently is and aims to become — a premier franchise across those industries, or business lines, rather — how do you reconcile doing what benefits stockholders now, pushing stock performance, against ensuring you're putting money into the future? Since every single one of those areas is intensely competitive. Every one of them faces rivals who, whether starting today or very recently, are pouring enormous sums into competing there. How do you reconcile investing for the long haul, which would be wonderful, against boosting the stock in the near term?
Mark Mason
executiveSure; I'll begin, and Jane, jump in if you'd like. The initial point I believe matters is the emphasis we're placing on those core franchises that generate returns over time. So we're setting priorities for how our resources and investments get allocated, partly via the divestiture activity. What I'd also mention is that we're putting money into the franchise for the long haul, correct, rather than aiming to satisfy some near-term metric. That means directing those funds toward places where clients want us and where it capitalizes on the competitive edges we've built. That's how we handle this, once more, aiming to make sure we stay clear and transparent with our investors. And when there's surplus, we hand it back to our shareholders, so it isn't merely parked on the sidelines failing to deliver the returns they'd anticipate from us.
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me add a few thoughts here as well. If you examine the various segments we're putting money into, they generate strong returns, which is what Mark mentioned. Our services operations, for instance, require far less capital and deliver high returns. It's the same story with wealth management. The chances we keep finding to steadily grow our share in investment banking represent yet another business with strong returns. So over time, that should definitely assist with the mix you just referenced. And not every single thing demands a massive outlay. Take wealth, for instance — you combine the various components we already possess, and we're bringing them together into one unified business and offering. These aren't efforts beginning from zero. So much of this is additive.
Vivek Juneja
analystJane and Mark, one quick question to start. Since you're pulling out of Mexico, Singapore and Hong Kong weren't included among the exits back when you announced you were leaving the 13 markets in the consumer business. Will you keep operating the consumer business in those locations, meaning the same kind of traditional consumer business you've run for years? Or will that shift?
Jane Fraser
executiveNo, what we see is that the franchises we hold in Singapore and Hong Kong, given what they are like, are genuinely and inherently connected to the wealth franchise we're building and putting money into there through our already very solid platform, as you mentioned. So our expectation is that we'll keep offering the full range of services and capabilities that we have, since they're so complementary and they help support our wealth business in 2 of the world's most major wealth hubs.
Vivek Juneja
analystAll right, excellent. And one more thing, if I could ask. Regarding the NII revision, Mark, that you introduced — what assumption about deposit beta sits behind it? And what portion of that adjustment originates from U.S. net interest income as opposed to other currencies? .
Mark Mason
executiveRight. Well, we've chosen not to disclose our deposit betas. Still, as one might expect, institutional-side betas are typically larger than those on the retail side. And that element — apologies, what was the latter half of your question again? Vivek?
Vivek Juneja
analystHello?
Mark Mason
executiveHello, Vivek?
Vivek Juneja
analystAll right, am I coming through?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, you're coming through. Sorry — what did the latter portion of your question cover?
Vivek Juneja
analystFor the second part, when it comes to the shift in net interest income driven by the interest rate sensitivity change you're implementing, Mark — what portion is U.S. net interest income compared with the other currencies?
Mark Mason
executiveThat rise leans mostly toward the international side; therefore out of a $3 billion increase, my estimate would be roughly two-thirds, one-third international.
Vivek Juneja
analystAll right; and is that simply due to the runoff assumption you had there?
Mark Mason
executivePardon?
Vivek Juneja
analystThat's the part where you were building in a larger amount of runoff from the balance sheet.
Mark Mason
executiveCorrect.
Charles Peabody
analystYes. I've got something about the regulatory and political danger surrounding share repurchases. The reason I bring this up is that earlier this week, during the Powell renomination hearings, if you caught the final 2 minutes of that testimony, Sherrod Brown launched into a tirade against buybacks in the banking industry. And then last year, I believe President Biden gave 2 speeches where he came out against buybacks. So I'm trying to figure out, is there — I mean, a transaction tax won't prevent you folks from repurchasing shares. But beyond mere moral suasion to discourage buybacks, are there other measures being talked about out there?
Jane Fraser
executiveWe're going to act in the best interest of our shareholders. And at present, especially considering where the stock is trading, buybacks are a very, very significant and probably top of the stack for us action that we take. So no, we're very clear in terms of the importance of giving our shareholders back our excess capital.
Charles Peabody
analystNo, I get that you'd like to. What I'm attempting to get at is this: how much danger do your ambitions face coming from regulators or politicians?
Jane Fraser
executiveMy view is none at all. Our capital position is exceptionally strong. From Washington, we keep hearing the same message about how confident they are in bank capitalization, both before and after the pandemic, so that particular issue doesn't worry us much.
Mark Mason
executiveNaturally, we're going to follow whatever regulations are in place or whatever form they take as things change, but you've got that precisely right.
Charles Peabody
analystOkay. Then, as a second question on that same topic. If these regulators have only just taken their positions, it's likely they won't be capable of taking any action regarding buybacks during this year, yet my assumption is they will attempt to act on buybacks in the following year. So you'd want to maximize buybacks in the near term, and you've mentioned returning to something like a $3 billion pace in Q1. How long can that $3 billion pace be maintained?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. Well, look, I'd say — to start with, under the SCB framework, our capital action decisions get made each quarter. Clearly, another CCAR run is going to occur, and that will establish at minimum a portion of the capital stack; and then clearly, the GCIB is also entering the picture. So every one of those elements gets taken into account by us. On our end, while we put the capital plan together, we'll additionally examine the divestitures. In certain cases, those divestitures will produce TCE that we can give back to shareholders. There could be additional effects stemming from divestitures that are short-lived in nature and require consideration; but this forms part of a comprehensive yearly capital planning process we undertake that incorporates every one of those elements.
Gerard Cassidy
analystCould you two tell us where things stand with the strategy refresh — is it 75% done, or 80% done? Mark, you mentioned that certain markets businesses might not be delivering the returns you're after. Maybe it's some area. But where do you stand on that? And should we expect it to be finished by the Investor Day?
Jane Fraser
executiveAs far as the schedule for this goes, this specific effort is wrapping up — what I'd describe as the big step back as a new CEO. So we've stated that this is the final major structural decision we're making in Mexico, and right now our attention is on bringing together everything for Investor Day. That's also where the new reporting structure we announced today, I believe, serves as a really key foundation. So I have confidence that we've made the correct big structural decisions, and we're eager for Investor Day, to set out the vision, the strategies and the plan going forward.
Mark Mason
executiveLet me make this crystal clear, Gerard, in case my earlier point wasn't. I'm not saying that we're pulling out of any portions of our Markets business — that's simply not what I meant. What I am saying is this: as has always been our practice, we continuously search for ways to make better use of our balance sheet, our capital, our RWA, and so forth, and when we spot a need to shed assets that generate low returns, we act on it, correct? So when rule changes come along, such as SACR and similar things, either prices will move accordingly, or we'll need to examine some of those assets closely to determine whether holding them still adds up. That captures what I was getting at far better than any claim that we were leaving a piece of the Markets business behind.
Gerard Cassidy
analystNo, that's quite straightforward. And only as a brief additional question. Clearly, a few of the operations you've dedicated yourselves to, TSS plus the investment banking segment, you folks plainly are significant participants in those spaces. You possess economies of scale. Regarding the remaining operations that you've pledged to remain involved in, from where will the substantial effort originate, the point at which you genuinely elevate your game to achieve economies of scale comparable to those that are pretty self-evident?
Jane Fraser
executiveThat's accurate; we have several operations that are already massively scaled across both markets. Looking at TTS, we're processing $4 trillion in volume every day there. So those are ones in which the spending is far more centered on digitization, centered on data. And as for where we're aiming to gain more — to expand our scale, commercial bank is plainly one where we hold a commercial banking footprint across 30 distinct markets globally; and they're highly concentrated on the identical target market I mentioned in the vision, which means those mid-market companies that have global needs or multi-market needs. And then the remaining areas regarding wealth, where we've already started, as you can tell from our earlier remarks, developing our frontline scale atop the platforms and other investments we're making.
Mark Mason
executiveAnd regarding what you mentioned, Jane, within Commercial Bank this year there's a massive chance to make greater use of the TTS offering we possess. We are already observing diversification inside the commercial bank when it comes to CMO along with other markets products, plus revenue for this year rose 12% versus the prior year, with comparable momentum in gaining new clients in wealth, yet those represent 2 critical areas. I concur.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystLet me just ask a couple of quick follow-ups. Mark, regarding capital return, I want to confirm that we're hearing you properly. As we consider that $3 billion figure you're going to return to in 1Q, going forward, does more upside risk exist for that $3 billion? Or might it actually be less? I just want to be sure we've got that correct when it comes to expectations.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. I won't provide expectations regarding quarter-by-quarter decisions on capital buybacks, partly because, as I said, thanks to the new SCB rule, we can review it each quarter; so beyond that, I'm not offering guidance. We'll discuss the capital plan in greater detail on March 2 broadly, correct?
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystSo, I suppose, Jane, if we return to U.S. retail for a moment, the real question is whether there's anything more substantial we ought to be anticipating at the Investor Day. And it's perfectly fine if you'd rather keep it under wraps until then. Since, if my memory serves me, you had a partnership with Google. That never came to fruition. What investors are really asking is whether there's a clearer way to define the U.S. retail franchise. And I'm simply curious, will that come to us at the March Investor Day, or is there nothing drastic in the works, at least in the near term when it comes to U.S. retail?
Jane Fraser
executiveYou will definitely be hearing straight from Anand, the person in charge of that business, on Investor Day. And he will set out our entire U.S. personal banking strategy, what we're examining, covering both our top 2 cards franchise and our efforts in personal lending, plus our work in wealth; and then, of course, the retail bank and the supporting part it plays for those 2 core growth drivers for us in the States. So yes.
Jim Mitchell
analystMark, regarding costs specifically, I understand there are many variables at play because of the divestitures, and you won't provide a full-year figure for expenses. Could you still assist us with where we stand entering the first quarter? Sequentially, compensation rose roughly $1 billion. What portion of that stemmed purely from the comp adjustments? Or should we treat that as a solid baseline? So any help with just that first-quarter starting point would be useful. .
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Honestly, I can't offer you additional guidance on that point. What I can tell you is that, once more, several factors from 2021 will carry significance into 2022. First, because of the hiring we completed, we will experience a full year's effect from it, or at least a portion of that effect, during 2022. So that will unfold. Regarding the composition of transformation spending — which combines new hires, third-party costs, and technology — that composition will gradually move away from third-party work, certainly, and toward the remaining categories. Consequently, some of that shift will begin appearing in 2022. As for comps, particularly during the fourth quarter, clearly our comp results for the entire year are linked to revenues. Since we anticipate some forward growth driven by the factors I referenced before, we'd anticipate comp tied to that emerging throughout 2022. However, I would prefer not to dive into details at this stage, since we will provide you with a clearer picture in early March.
Jim Mitchell
analystAll right. And perhaps to build on that point, so I can grasp what's driving the move from one quarter to the next — are you saying incentives are the main factor? Or was it more about people we've brought on board, or a mix of the two? Just the shift from 3Q to 4Q? .
Mark Mason
executiveRight. Between 3Q and 4Q, you're seeing new hires and incentive compensation alike.
Matt O'Connor
analystI wanted to ask a follow-up. You mentioned that selling Mexico would not be a straightforward deal. I was hoping you might say more about that. Also, on a related note, you mentioned that capital tied up in the business is being released. But do you have any early sense of whether this transaction — exiting the business — will produce a gain or a loss, when we consider the combined or overall capital effect?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me start on that, and, Mark, feel free to chime in. I made the point that this won't be a straightforward deal, since what we're doing is splitting the bank between its institutional operations and the ones we intend to leave. That work got underway just yesterday. After that, our plan is to approach the market during the spring and engage with prospective purchasers over the coming months. So the real challenge here comes down to how complicated it is to carve up the bank. We have solid plans supporting this effort. And, as I mentioned earlier, these franchises are excellent, they have scale, and they're outstanding. Naturally, there was plenty of press speculation, and it's genuinely too soon for us to say anything about that. Still, we believe this asset would be a real prize for whoever gets it. It's just not for us.
Mark Mason
executiveThat's right. And I'd say it's too early to be guessing about how the deal would be structured and that kind of thing. You're correct that roughly $4 billion of TCE sits with that business. Then there's another complicating factor, which is the CTA, and you've heard us talk about this before when we discussed the Australia sale. I call it a complication because there's an accounting treatment tied to the CTA that occurs at signing, and that's distinct from the capital effect that occurs at closing. So when you have a CTA, the capital impact runs through AOCI, yet it becomes neutral once the transaction closes. And in Mexico, the consumer business would carry a DTA of slightly under $3 billion; so that's one more element in play with this transaction.
Jane Fraser
executiveThe correct term is CTA, not DTA.
Mark Mason
executiveDid DTA come out of my mouth? My apologies — CTA, currency translation adjustment. Thanks. CTA. Many thanks, Jane.
Steven Chubak
analystBefore I get into my question, I'd like to add my voice to what others have said — the fresh deck and the extra granularity are genuinely useful, so thank you for that disclosure. Mark, I had intended to pose a single item, though in truth it breaks into 3 parts. You may want to have a pen and paper handy. What I'm hoping to do is dig into a few of your remarks regarding NII sensitivity and the reporting gaps relative to competitors. You pointed to an increase in NII of more than 3x under a static balance sheet assumption, yet plenty of investors remain skeptical about your rate sensitivity profile, in light of the rather modest NII growth delivered in the prior cycle. For part one, I'd like to begin by asking whether, with your larger institutional deposit weighting, it wouldn't be sensible for us to anticipate that deposit runoff on your end would in fact exceed that of peers. Second, is liability sensitivity within the markets business factored into the NII guidance? And might you assist us in estimating the size of that possible drag? Finally, a broader catch-all: are there any idiosyncratic items you could highlight that would argue for an improved NII result, or a larger benefit from rates, relative to the prior cycle?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, sure. Look, we gave the sensitivity because comparability matters to us here. And the size of that gap, as you can see, is quite substantial. A gap between peers and us will persist, though it shrinks once you align things on a comparable footing. Our mix does lean toward institutional clients, and those clients come with a higher beta attached. That said, we also lean toward foreign currencies, and we earn attractive spreads in that space too. As for how markets get affected, the effect — my view is that it can show up through many different channels. Moves in rates, along with other uncertainty and volatility in the market, can lift broader markets revenues, which we might capture depending on the ways investors need to reposition their books. On the final portion of what you asked, nothing else comes to mind that I'd flag. I mean, clearly, given the excess liquidity we've observed and have been holding in the market, we've been deploying it into investments. Our investment portfolio has grown by roughly $70 billion. We took duration out to approximately 2.85, and we retain considerable dry powder as well, usable either for client demand or in a rising rate environment, which is what we anticipate.
Jeff Harte
analystMy apologies — I ought to have removed myself from the queue. You've already answered my questions, and everyone on this call must be feeling exhausted by now. So that's all from me.
Mike Mayo
analystJust one more. Which aspect of the cultural shift is proving most difficult?
Jane Fraser
executiveBreaking down certain silos has probably been the toughest piece. And that — the element regarding the principles we set out, Mike, being linked together is truly essential to this; we introduced some fresh leadership principles during the last year, and they center heavily on how we make the firm deeply interconnected and genuinely capture the complete synergies; so dismantling a number of those longstanding habits, I'd say, with the new structure definitely assisting us across the various initiatives we're pursuing.
Mike Mayo
analystAnd what kind of timeline do you figure that requires? Since what you're doing is dismantling a mindset that has been deeply rooted over a considerable period.
Jane Fraser
executiveRight. I'd tell you the progress has me genuinely pleased. One of my earliest moves after stepping into this role was to set out an honest picture of where our culture stands, and we have a fantastic group of colleagues who have been devoted to this effort for a year. So the advances we're making leave me quite pleased. My sense is that everybody understands. Our aim is for the culture to reflect accountability, excellence, and a sense of urgency, and portions of that are already well in motion. Even so, a bit more time will be needed.
Jen Landis
executiveI appreciate everyone being here on today's call. If anything else comes up, don't hesitate to contact IR. Enjoy the rest of your day. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThis concludes Citi's fourth quarter earnings call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.