Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 14, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveAppreciate it, operator. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being here with us. Just a quick note before we start — the deck for today's call can be downloaded from our site, citigroup.com, and it might include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects, and they come with uncertainty as well as shifts in circumstances. A range of factors — among them the ones laid out in SEC filings — could cause actual results to come out materially different from what those statements suggest. So with that said, I'll hand things over to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThank you, Jen. To begin, I want to say again how grateful I am to everyone who joined us for Investor Day last month. Getting the chance to take you through the strategy we've refreshed and what we plan for the coming years means a great deal to us. Since we devoted so much of that day to strategy, our focus today will be on the quarter. Even so, just as we promised, we'll continue bringing you updates on how things are going, and Slide 2 shows the most recent report card. This also marks the first quarter in which we're presenting results under the new segmentation, which should make it easier for you to follow what we're doing. Honestly, saying a lot has occurred since Investor Day feels like an understatement. So the macro environment is where I'll begin. Once I've covered the quarter, I'll explain our approach to Russia, and Mark will also walk through that in greater depth. From the moment the possibility of war appeared, we've been on the front foot, and that's where we plan to stay. The invasion of Ukraine by Russia, along with the sanctions that followed, delivered a massive supply shock to the globe, adding more fuel to inflation and putting serious strain on worldwide growth. Having just returned from meetings with clients in Europe and the Middle East, I can tell you that security, energy, food, defense, cyber and operational resilience now sit at the top of their strategic conversations. For the remainder of the year, the macro outlook is nothing if not complicated and uncertain. My role is to get ready for every possible outcome, and our belief is that robust nominal income growth together with ongoing momentum in the labor market will assist in supporting near-term growth for the U.S. economy despite inflationary pressures. That said, we anticipate meaningful regional variation in how this plays out, with economic growth among individual consumers and businesses in Europe suffering the most. As central banks react to inflation, we're moving into a stretch of higher rates and a flatter U.S. yield curve. Energy and commodities sit at the heart of the storm worldwide, yet we don't think we're at the beginning of another lengthy super cycle, and we do anticipate prices coming down to more typical levels. Against that background, I'd say the firm did reasonably well in the quarter. We reported earlier today net income of $4.3 billion, EPS of $2.02, and an RoTCE of 10.5%. Impacts tied to the divestitures are baked into those figures, so the underlying business performed better by roughly 150 basis points of RoTCE. Now let's look at how our five main reporting units did. Because we've been emphasizing services, I'm especially happy with what Treasury and Trade Solutions delivered, where fee growth, trade loans and cross-border transactions, lifted by higher rates, produced revenue growth of 18% year-over-year. Even with market pressures, Security Services turned in a solid performance, posting a 6% revenue increase. Within our Markets division, our traders handled a turbulent backdrop pretty effectively, helped by our business mix, with standout results among corporate clients and significant upside in FX and commodities. That pushed revenues to nearly the same level as the highly active first quarter of 2021. Investment Banking, as you'd probably anticipate, tells a different story. Our advisory results were decent, but I believe we can do somewhat better in equity and debt capital markets moving forward, even if the wallet stays smaller. Our pipelines look healthy and loan demand keeps building. That said, we don't anticipate a strong rebound in capital markets activity across the industry until both the geopolitical backdrop and client sentiment get better. Over in U.S. Personal Banking, the cost of credit and payment rates continue to show us just how healthy and resilient the consumer is. We're seeing solid engagement across key drivers like card loans and growth in spend volume. So we're pleased with the direction this business is taking. Geopolitics weighed on Global Wealth Management's results this quarter. Revenues did improve in the U.S., but clients in Asia scaled back on new investments, which is something we also observed in our Markets franchise. As you're aware, we're bringing on bankers and improving our client offerings, including Citi Alliance, launched last month as a unique platform to serve independent advisers. Thanks to these efforts, we keep adding clients in both the private bank and Citi Gold. On the capital front, we gave back $4 billion to shareholders via stock buybacks and dividends in the first quarter. Our common shares outstanding are now roughly 6% lower than they were a year ago. Meanwhile, a steep jump in interest rates hurt our capital through OCI and was largely responsible for our common equity Tier 1 capital ratio landing at 11.4% this quarter. I want to be candid with you: the macro and geopolitical environment I mentioned, together with the effects of our divestitures, generate both headwinds and tailwinds for our capital ratios this year. While this will affect how much we buy back this year, we have a route to our 12% year-end target, and Mark will take you through those specifics. Let me be clear — we're still dedicated to returning excess capital to our shareholders. As you heard at Investor Day, our focus is on transformation, and we're investing in our infrastructure, risk and controls, plus our talent and culture, to modernize our bank and make Citi a winning firm. I realize these investments have an effect on both our costs and our returns over the near term. However, I strongly believe that doing well here will both allow us to meet our regulatory requirements and boost how competitive we are, along with our returns, over the medium term. During this year so far, we've announced additional agreements to divest 7 more consumer businesses across Asia and EMEA, with India and Bahrain being the latest ones. In Mexico, we're kicking off the sale process, and there's considerable interest in this iconic franchise. As I've said before, this isn't a simple deal, since we'll be separating our operations so that we can keep our institutional presence. We're going to take whatever time is needed to get this right and to determine which transaction serves our shareholders best. And we'll update you on anything that happens with the three markets still left: China, Poland and, naturally, Russia. Back in January, we began deliberately scaling back our operations in Russia and our exposures to it, and we gained from moving early on this. We've been bringing down our financial exposures in both size and makeup, and they sit at a sensible level, particularly considering the extra reserves we set aside in the quarter. We've also added reserves tied to the second and third order effects of the war outside Russia and Ukraine. And we still intend to sell substantial parts of our local business in Russia. We're constantly in touch with the U.S. government, and we keep doing our share to uphold the sanctions regime; yet words fail me when it comes to describing how tragic the war in Ukraine is. I stay immensely proud of the way our people have stepped up from every part of our firm. Our staff in Ukraine have maintained our bank's operations there, enabling them to assist NGOs in delivering aid on the ground and to help society keep functioning as well as it can. And a great many of our colleagues have welcomed refugees into their homes, and we'll keep assisting however we're able. So, with everything happening around the world, we stay sharply focused on carrying out our strategy and our transformation. I anticipate the macro environment will stay unpredictable, to put it mildly, against the backdrop of the war, which is just as tragic as it is needless, and a pandemic that drags on. On that last point, I can speak from experience, having just gotten over a short bout with COVID — much as I'd like to, I can't pin it on Paco. Now, let me hand things over to Mark, and after that we'll be happy to field your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks, Jane, and hello everybody. I'll begin with the company-wide financials, using year-over-year comparisons for Q1 unless I say otherwise, and then I'll take a bit more time on Russia expenses before finishing with how each segment performed. Turning to Slide 4, we present the financials for the entire firm. As Jane noted before, during Q1 we posted net income of $4.3 billion and EPS of $2.02, alongside an RoTCE of 10.5% on revenues of $19.2 billion. Built into those results are Asia consumer divestiture-related impacts, which the appendix of the presentation lays out in detail. During the quarter, total revenues fell 2% because strength in net interest income, driven by Services and PBWM, was more than offset by weaker non-interest revenue across businesses. Still, we keep seeing robust performance in the key business drivers we discussed on Investor Day, and I'll take you through those in detail in a moment. Total expenses came to $13.2 billion, up 15% or up 10% if you exclude the Asia divestiture-related impacts I just referenced. Cost of credit was $755 million, as net credit losses of $872 million were partly offset by a net ACL release. Within that net ACL release sits a Russia-related build of roughly $1.9 billion. That figure includes $1 billion tied to exposure to Russia and about $900 million to reflect the broader impact on the macro environment; those were more than offset by a release tied to a COVID-19 uncertainty reserve, mainly in U.S. Personal Banking, reflecting the continued resilience of the underlying portfolio, particularly in the U.S. As of today, we hold about $17.9 billion in total reserves, with a reserve to funded loan ratio of 2.35%. On Slide 5, we lay out an expense walk for Q1 along with the key underlying drivers. As I said earlier, we took on some divestiture-related costs this quarter. Those costs were largely tied to a goodwill write-down incurred in legacy franchises as part of our resegmentation and divestitures. Worth noting: the goodwill impact is capital neutral. If you exclude the divestiture-related costs, expenses rose by roughly 10%. 3% of the increase was driven by transformation investments, with about 66.6% related to the risks, controls, data and finance programs, and approximately 30% of that is related to technology investments. About 2% of the increase came from business-led investments as we keep hiring commercial and investment bankers as well as client advisers. Beyond that, we are investing in technology across services, wealth and cards. 1% was due to higher revenue and volume-related expenses largely in markets and cards, and approximately 4% was driven by inflation and other risk and control investments, partially offset by productivity savings. Across all of these buckets, we continue to invest in technology, which is up 12% for the quarter; on Slide 6, we provide an update on our exposure to Russia. To follow up on what Jane said, by the time the quarter closed, what we still had at risk in Russia was roughly $7.8 billion, compared with $9.8 billion when the year began. And the important part is that the composition of what remains has moved in a favorable direction. Our direct country risk tied to Russia went from $5.4 billion down to around $3.7 billion, made up of loans, AFS, derivatives and off balance sheet exposure. What's left beyond that, which used to add up to $4.4 billion, is now $4.1 billion, and it consists of deposits and cash held with the Central Bank, reverse repos and cross-border exposure. On top of that, our net investment in the Russian entity now comes to roughly $700 million, versus about $1 billion at the close of the year. The currency translation adjustment, or CTA, tied to that net investment, sits at $1 billion. As I noted earlier, we booked credit reserves of roughly $1.9 billion, of which about $1 billion covers direct exposure to Russia and another approximately $900 million addresses wider effects from the macro environment. So at this stage, we believe our reserving has been prudent. Running stress scenarios across a range is part of how we normally plan and manage risk, and we've applied that same discipline to Russia; because of the steps we've taken to bring risk down, we now estimate that across a set of severe stress scenarios, our possible loss is around $2.5 billion to $3 billion, which is a meaningful drop from the figure I gave at our Investor Day. Slide 7 lays out net interest income, loans and deposits. During the first quarter, net interest income rose by about $50 million quarter over quarter, since interest income from loans and better deposit spreads were partly offset by day count. Strip out day count, and net interest income was up by roughly $290 million. Quarter over quarter, net interest margin improved by 7 basis points, as reduced average deposits in services and stronger loan interest income were partly offset by balance sheet growth in Markets; measured against the same period a year ago, net interest income climbed by approximately $370 million, powered by cards, deposit volumes and spreads along with investment portfolio income, partly offset by weaker net interest income in Markets, and average loans grew roughly 3% in both ICG and PBWM. Slide 8 presents our summary balance sheet plus key capital and liquidity metrics; our balance sheet stayed very strong. Out of a $2.4 trillion balance sheet, roughly 23%, or $551 billion, is high-quality liquid assets, or HQLA, and total liquidity resources came to approximately $960 billion. On capital, we closed the quarter with a CET1 capital ratio near 11.4% under both standardized and advanced approaches, with standardized still the binding ratio, lower than 12.2% at year end. During the quarter, we adopted SACR and absorbed a significant hit from the sharp move in interest rates. We'll dive deeper soon into what moved capital during the quarter. Still, it's worth stressing that even with these effects, we keep anticipating that we'll run to a CET1 ratio of 12% by year-end, because of the projected GCIB surcharge bump to 3.5% starting in 2023. We figure net income generation, DTA utilization, and capital from closing a number of the consumer exits in Asia will together be enough to get us to that 12% CET1 ratio by the end of the year. As we stated at Investor Day, we're dedicated to giving excess capital back to shareholders. And once we see a pull to par in the investment portfolio, which would reverse that $4 billion interest rate driven impact, we'd anticipate being able to put that capital to work over time. And as you're aware, within the SCB framework and with the macro environment so uncertain, we look at the appropriate level of buybacks every quarter, and we'll keep doing that all year long; for the second quarter, we anticipate just a modest amount of buybacks, and we'll assess that level throughout the quarter, factoring in market conditions.
Mark Mason
executiveTurning to Slide 9, you'll see a sequential walk of our CET1 capital ratio, which gives a closer look at what moved the needle this quarter. Like I said earlier, we closed out the year with a CET1 capital ratio of 12.2%, having accumulated capital to cushion the effect of SACR on our RWA. Once SACR was adopted, our ratio came in at 11.8% on January 1, 2022. Because a few of the drivers were fairly sizable, I'd like to take a minute to go through the pluses and minuses this quarter and explain how we finished with a CET1 ratio of roughly 11.4%. To start, net income we generated contributed 35 basis points. Next, dividends and buybacks totaling more than $4 billion produced a decrease of roughly 36 basis points. Then the interest rate effect on AOCI through our investment portfolio brought about a 35 basis point decline. After that, the rise in disallowed DTA — mostly stemming from the drop in CET1 caused by the interest rate effect I just referenced — produced a further 15 basis point decline. Last, the rest came from a mix of other items, among them a decrease in RWA. Having said all that, as I noted earlier, we have a route to reach a 12% CET1 capital ratio by the end of the year and stay dedicated to giving excess capital back to shareholders. Moving to Slide 10, we present the results for our Institutional Clients Group. Revenues fell 2%, mostly because of Investment Banking, partly offset by higher services revenue. And Markets was down a bit versus a strong quarter a year ago. Expenses rose 13%, pushed by transformation investments, business-led investments and volume-related expenses, partly offset by productivity savings. Cost of credit came to almost $1 billion, mostly due to a $1.5 billion build tied to our exposures in Russia plus the wider effect on the macro environment. And beyond Russia, we keep seeing solid credit performance throughout our portfolio as clients' balance sheets stay healthy. That produced net income of $2.6 billion, a drop of about 51%, mostly because of the higher expenses and an ACL build compared with a release in the prior year. Average loans grew 3%, mostly due to trade finance. Average deposits rose 2% as we keep seeing good momentum and deeper relationships with existing clients plus new client acquisitions, and ICG posted an RoTCE of 11.2%. Turning to Slide 11, we present revenue performance by business and the key drivers we set out at Investor Day, which we'll keep showing you every quarter. In Services, we keep seeing a very strong pipeline of new clients and deeper relationships with our existing clients, and we expect that momentum to carry on. In Treasury and Trade Solutions, revenues rose 18%, driven by growth in net interest income along with strong fee growth with both commercial and large corporate clients; and we keep seeing strong underlying drivers in TTS that point to continued strong client activity with U.S. Dollar clearing activity rose 2%, cross-border movement increased 17%, and commercial card transactions jumped 54%. Once more, these figures serve as signals of client engagement and fees, and when combined, they account for roughly half of all TTS fee revenue. Securities Services income climbed 6%, with net interest income rising 17%, fueled by elevated rates across various currencies, while fee income increased 2% thanks to greater assets under custody. Total markets revenues slipped 2% against a robust quarter the previous year. During this period, activity got a boost from clients repositioning and solid risk management amid Fed moves and broader geopolitical uncertainty. Fixed Income Markets income fell 1%. We experienced robust client involvement, especially among corporate clients in FX and commodities, while our rates business also gained from increased volatility. Spread products took a hit from reduced client activity. Equity Markets income dropped 4% relative to an exceptionally strong prior-year stretch; this quarter brought solid equity derivatives results and growth in prime finance balances. Banking income, not counting gains or losses on loan hedges, fell 32% as rising geopolitical uncertainty and the wider macro environment weighed on debt and equity capital markets activity. Investment Banking income dropped 43%, pushed by the pullback in capital markets activity, partly balanced by M&A growth. Corporate Lending income declined 6%, mainly because of lower average loans. Now moving to Slide 12. We present results for our Personal Banking and Wealth Management segment. Revenues fell 1% since net interest income was outweighed by reduced non-interest revenue. Expenses climbed 14%, fueled by transformation investments, business-led investments, and greater volume-driven costs, partly countered by productivity savings. Cost of credit was a $376 million gain as an ACL release exceeded net credit losses. We recorded a net release of more than $1 billion of ACL tied to COVID-19 uncertainty reserves. I want to point out that even following this release, we held over $9.8 billion in credit reserves against our U.S. cards portfolios, or roughly 7.6% of total loans. This produced a net income drop of 23% and an RoTCE of slightly above 23%. If we adjust for the ACL release, RoTCE would have come in at about 13%. On Slide 13, we display PBWM revenues by product along with key business drivers and metrics. Credit cards revenues decreased 1% due to higher average payment rates and increased acquisition and rewards costs, as we keep finding appealing investment opportunities and strong customer engagement. We are observing promising underlying drivers, with new accounts rising 24%, card spend volumes also climbing 24%, and average loans increasing 7%. Retail services revenues were unchanged as greater net interest income was offset by higher partner payments, which stemmed from better credit performance. And we are witnessing favorable underlying drivers, with spend rising 14% and average loans up 1%. Although payment rates stay elevated, we think we have at last started to see some normalization. So because of that, interest-earning balances in our branded cards stayed pretty much level from one quarter to the next, whereas Retail Services increased those balances 3% quarter over quarter, even with card spending volumes lower due to seasonal patterns. Retail banking revenues fell 6%, mostly because mortgage originations were lower. Wealth revenues dropped 1%, with reduced client activity and investments behind that, partly offset by higher deposits. Investment revenues fell as geopolitical tensions weighed on the capital markets, and that led clients to cut back on trading, especially in Asia. Still, the underlying drivers are strong: average deposits rose 14%, average loans rose 5%, client assets rose 4%, and client advisers rose 6%. Slide 14 shows results for the legacy franchises. Revenues fell 14%, from lower revenue across the exit markets, mostly because of the Korea wind down and the muted investment activity in Asia. Expenses rose 31%, mostly from the goodwill impairment I mentioned earlier, but again, that is neutral to capital. Cost of credit came to $160 million for the quarter, from net credit losses, and because of that, net income fell significantly. Slide 15 shows results for Corporate/Other. Revenues rose significantly, mostly from higher net revenue in the investment portfolio. Expenses are down mostly on lower compensation expenses.
Mark Mason
executiveNow, just a quick note on how we see the whole of 2022. As things stand, our expectation remains revenue expansion in the low single digits, along with expenses rising at a mid-single-digit pace — in each case leaving out the effects tied to divestitures during this year. With that said, Jane and I are ready to take whatever questions you have.
Glenn Schorr
analystHello there, how are you doing? Alright. When I initially saw the reserve release, even taking into account that $1.9 million Russian reserve, we thought, hold on, what kind of economic scenario are they writing to, since everyone else was adding provisions. But now that you've shared some of the color, I'm starting to get it. So it seems to me — and tell me if I've got this wrong — you were just slower when it came to releasing the COVID reserves, and it sounds like there's still plenty sitting in the coffers, with that 7.6% you brought up. So I'd just like to know if you could shed a bit more light on what you reserved for versus what you released, and whether you adjusted your economic scenarios at all to arrive at the current reserve, if that's not asking too much?
Jane Fraser
executiveGlenn, why don't I start things off and then hand it over to Mark; you're absolutely correct. We'd taken a fairly conservative stance when it came to releasing our COVID-related reserves in the U.S. Personal Banking business last year relative to some others. We felt good that this quarter, that was the right move given where COVID and the U.S. economy stood. And with — as the numbers show, with a 2.35% ACL coverage ratio and with the ratio we have in cards, 7.6% specifically, I'm quite comfortable that our reserve level is prudent and appropriate; but let me turn it over to Mark for the down and the dirty.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely. Glenn, good morning — I believe you've got the picture correctly, in that we clearly carried out a build, and a significant one, tied to Russia. Most of that release, in truth, was connected to the COVID-19 management adjustment Jane mentioned. When we considered these scenarios, as you're aware, there's a base scenario we run. We adjusted it somewhat by lowering the GDP assumptions relative to where they stood in the fourth quarter, and that clearly had an effect on the later years within our assumptions as well. Then there's the other element: looking at the downside scenario — our CECL analysis combines a base scenario with a downside scenario. Within the downside scenario, we raised its severity to reflect, once again, a portion of the present conditions all of us are navigating. So those gains and losses essentially offset each other, producing what you see reported — a net release, though mostly attributable to those two factors.
Jane Fraser
executiveAlso, let me mention that, as Mark noted when he gave his prepared remarks, we set aside an extra $900 million in reserves tied to the second and third order effects of the war, along with consequences for supply chains and other elements that, going forward, worried us with regard to the global economy. How all of that plays out represents an enormous source of uncertainty.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely, that falls under that $1.9 billion figure. What I'd highlight is that if you examine how the portfolio is performing beneath the surface, it continues to hold up really well — whether you're looking at our consumer customers' NCL rate and its trajectory, or the 90-day delinquency trend, both remain very strong. And on the corporate side as well, once you strip out the Russia-related build, which accounted for some of the NAL increase, performance there is still quite robust too.
Erika Najarian
analystHi, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Erika Najarian
analystI'd like to pose something to both Jane and Mark regarding CET1, and I want to be sure your investors receive the right signal. Starting from that 11.4, you indicated that net income, capital freed up through divestitures, and use of the DTA would drive us toward a 12% CET1 by the close of 2021. Naturally, AOCI is an unpredictable variable. Could you help us understand whether the buyback should simply be viewed as the residual piece of that calculation? That's my first item. Second, in a stress test year like this, what's the appetite for raising the dividend, even by a small amount? And third, how did the DTA effect, which dragged in Q1, flip into something positive? Also, Mark, well done on RWA. I suspect everyone feared it might come in as a sizable negative figure this quarter.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks. That's quite a lot to work through, so I'll do my best to address everything, and please flag anything I overlook. Let me begin where you started, with the 12% and the path back to it. We closed the quarter at an estimated 11.4, so reaching 12% implies somewhere in the range of $7 billion to $8 billion of capital needed. As Jane and I both noted, numerous puts and takes flow through that figure. You identified several. All of you have your own projections for net income across Q2 through Q4, so you can model what that contributes. There's likely an additional benefit of roughly $1.6 billion from the DTA. To clarify what I mean: $800 million of that reflects the utilization I've mentioned previously. The remainder comes from removing the amount we exceeded the threshold by this quarter. So two elements carry forward and affect the DTA. Beyond that, there's the timing difference, which has represented roughly 10% of our capital. This quarter, we actually breached that timing difference piece of the disallowed DTA, partly due to how the OCI reduction flowed through. As that reverses over time, we'd anticipate capital building up, which lifts that threshold and lets us unwind the quarter's DTA-related increase. The third piece is capital generated from exits — you didn't bring that one up. As you're aware, several exits are slated to close by year-end, and they'll add roughly $4 billion of capital into that equation. Finally, the OCI impact bleeding back in should contribute approximately another $1 billion. Alright, so those are the positives. Those are the elements that really factor into the capital generation picture. Then when you look at what offsets that, you have preferred dividends, you have common dividends, plus whatever growth we deploy or allocate from an RWA standpoint, and whatever remains after that is what's left for repurchasing shares. As I said during my prepared remarks, given all those various ins and outs, we'd anticipate a modest amount of buybacks during the second quarter. The encouraging part is that the headwinds we've discussed — assuming nothing else changes, meaning no additional rate movements — a lot of those headwinds gradually reverse over time, which lets us deliver on what we've promised, and that's giving capital back to shareholders over time. When it comes to dividends, we consistently evaluate that within the CCAR filing and as part of our wider capital planning, but I'll — we're going to see what CCAR results look like, though I'd emphasize something we've needed to point out repeatedly now, which is that considering our current trading level, buybacks make a great deal of sense. So we'll probably keep favoring that approach rather than making significant changes to the dividend. But keep watching as capital planning keeps developing.
Mike Mayo
analystHello. Could you share some details regarding Treasury and Trade Solutions, specifically looking at how things stood in the first quarter? I suppose security services performed better—is what you're observing a mix of interest rates, increased corporate need, and the complications stemming from the worldwide circumstances? Then, on a broader note, regarding the collaborative calling initiatives you all are pursuing involving lending and payments, so focusing on the specific rather than the general.
Jane Fraser
executiveAlright, perhaps I'll begin with a few elements and then turn it over to Mark. Honestly, Mike, what we have witnessed this quarter across every area has been the worth of that global network we've discussed, whether in Markets, where there was considerable strong corporate activity and FX, we experienced enormous activity for TTS, excellent with our commercial banking clients, and we noticed numerous connections throughout. And clearly, it was a robust quarter for us in trade since, once more, given the global network, the capacity to deliver end-to-end solutions to clients in this intriguing world we inhabit is something they truly depend on us for. Thus, you observed trade loans rise 16%. You observed that many of the drivers we presented to you at Investor Day were executing especially well; however, Mark, why don't I hand things over to you?
Mark Mason
executiveSure, I’ll offer a few observations. First, let me note once more that TTS delivered a solid quarter. Revenue rose 18% compared with the earlier quarter, and that figure reflected an 8% increase from the same period a year ago relative to the preceding quarter. Part of this, yes, came from rates flowing through. Net interest income climbed 18%, while non-interest revenue, if you look at it, rose 19%. So, Jane, as you suggested, we are also benefiting from healthy growth in fee revenue. Security Services had a favorable quarter, with revenue increasing 66% year-over-year, and fee revenue expansion contributed to that as well. Thus, as you noted, there is strong, active client involvement, and we are assisting them in navigating some of the present uncertainty, especially around supply chains, supporting them as they coordinate with their partners through the trade lending expansion we are observing, and generating solid progress on the commercial client offering too. In short, I would describe it as a very good quarter—a very strong one for TTS—and we anticipate that momentum will carry forward.
Jane Fraser
executiveRegarding what you asked about the combined calling initiative, we're taking great care to handle in a forensic manner the synergies we discussed across calling efforts. Paco and I are, I believe, both happy with the way those are progressing. This quarter served as an illustration of that.
Matt O'Connor
analystHello. I’d like to follow up on the Russia update shown on Slide 6. First, why aren’t you putting away more reserves for a potential worst-case scenario? I don’t claim deep expertise here, but from what I’ve seen in reporting, things look pretty bad, and it seems that, broadly, other firms—not only banks, but companies in general—are taking bigger hits than $1 billion on $10 billion? Also, on a related point, can you say more about what the wider effects would be? I have to say it caught me a little off guard that the amount set aside for that ended up matching the reserve tied directly to Russia, given that the two were about the same size?
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely, let me take that one. First off, I want to point out that we aren't sitting at 10, right? When we closed out 2021, the figure stood at $9.8 billion. By the end of the quarter, our exposure had come down to $7.8 billion. That means we trimmed $2 billion off that exposure over the past three months. I'd add that a few different items played a big role in that. If you turn to Slide 6, you'll notice the loans — covering both ICG and consumer lending, though mostly ICG and mostly corporate — are down by $600 million. Basically, that means our risk exposure has gone down, correct? Borrowers are paying what they owe, and we're being more careful about giving out new credit, among other things. On the AFS securities side, there's been a $600 million drop, and sales are mostly what caused that decrease. So we're out of those securities now. Sure, there are some mark-to-market losses, but they aren't material. That goes through OCI — not material. And as you can see, the off-balance sheet unfunded commitments have also been declining. Cash and cash equivalents are up, and the reason is that those loans have actually been getting repaid and coming back to us. Given certain restrictions that exist, we've had to park that money at the Central Bank. At the same time, we've been steadily reducing the reverse repo assets, which are essentially backed by sovereign bond exposure. We've also been cutting back our third-party cross-border exposure. So a great deal of effort has gone into getting that exposure down to 7.8%. And when you consider the $1 billion figure I mentioned, that works out to roughly a net of $6.8 billion, correct? Regarding the latter portion of what you asked — our approach to reserves and the pieces that make them up — we start by examining each named borrower we're exposed to and how those entities are rated given current conditions. That rating then gets fed into our models, which produce the reserve we deem suitable. The $1 billion number reflects what we hold directly against those Russian clients and entities. As for the broader impact, that captures the knock-on effects that could reach other names or sectors outside Russia, driven by factors such as commodity pricing and similar dynamics. Another element involves the worldwide unpredictability such a situation creates. We therefore built up the reserves after considering all those different factors together. One more point worth noting: when you look at certain of the borrowers, a number of them are big global companies that hold this risk inside the country, and on top of that they extend parent-company backing to a portion of the exposure sitting here. So we really tried to examine everything thoroughly and in depth, and to set the reserves at a level we see as cautious, while understanding that alternative outcomes might develop — ones we intend to be prepared for and have a perspective on as well.
Gerard Cassidy
analystHi, Jane. Hi, Mark.
Mark Mason
executiveHi. Good morning.
Jane Fraser
executiveHello.
Gerard Cassidy
analystMark, you did a nice job walking us through the CET1 ratio. What’s the new piece that all of us haven’t yet seen on a recurring basis? Is it the SACR, that 49 basis points which brought your CET1 ratio down? Could you tell us how that operates going forward? Will that figure remain steady, or does it shift each quarter depending on whether risk in this area rises or falls?
Mark Mason
executiveWhat we’re seeing is growth in our risk-weighted assets, and that’s mostly connected to the derivative exposures we hold. Obviously, the way someone handles their exposures, their balance sheet, and their client interactions will have an effect on that. But just as importantly, there’s a market dynamic that still has to unfold. So, when more RWA and capital are needed for positions of this kind, there has to be — it’s going to affect returns, and in the end it will affect pricing once the market begins to factor in this now greater requirement. So it will keep changing. What I’d direct you toward is that when we consider running our businesses, especially markets. You heard us say at Investor Day that we are searching — constantly searching for chances to optimize the balance sheet, optimize RWA, correct. And so we discussed aiming for a revenue to RWA target for our markets business, and we’re actively pursuing that right now; and that will matter as we keep managing not just the balance sheet requirements we face, but our goal of trying to give more capital back to shareholders and lift our returns.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystGood morning Jane and Mark.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystStaying on the topic of capital, I have a question with two parts. First, Mark, should it keep climbing, is there any way for you to hedge the AOCI? Second, could you take us through the Banamex situation — assuming you reach an agreement at some point during this year, how would capital be affected when the deal is announced compared with when it closes? Thanks for that.
Mark Mason
executiveCertainly. Look, what we've incorporated — what's baked into our forecast and the path back to 12% — is the forward curve as it stood at quarter-end. That's the basis for our numbers. When we consider it, the 2-year moved quite sharply during the quarter, by 160 basis points. That's reflected in our expectations now. We've also assumed additional rate movements may occur, essentially as a buffer when I think about the outlook and the walk. We hold hedges connected to certain positions we have and to OCI, and we'll keep managing those so that we lessen the exposure to rising rates — something, incidentally, we've been doing actively for the last couple of years. If you consider how the balance sheet has changed, we've been shifting out of AFS and into held to maturity for the last couple of years, which lowers the danger of an adverse effect on OCI. And looking at the DVO 1, we've brought it down from a peak of $60 million to roughly $30 million; so we've been managing this actively, focused on how to lessen that sensitivity. Let me have Jane address the Mexico part.
Jane Fraser
executiveRight, so like I mentioned, this is a pretty involved separation and transaction. We're carving out our large, market-leading ICG business in Mexico from the consumer and small business operations that we're going to sell. Working through all of that is going to take some time. It's a great business. And since we've begun some very early-stage talks with potential buyers, it's drawing quite a bit of interest. That's because this is a once-in-a-lifetime kind of opportunity, and there are a range of paths open to us, I'm confident — from an IPO to a sale, and so on. But it's going to take time; we want to get it right. And when I say time, I mean a few quarters. So at this very early point, I don't think we're predicting whether it lands this year or early next year. But Mark, why don't I hand it to you to talk about how we view the CTA impact from that one?
Mark Mason
executiveRight, so as you pointed out, Jane, the key thing here is making the correct call — for our people, for the company, and just as crucially for the folks who own our stock — and we will definitely see to it that happens. As for how this unfolds, I believe you're aware, and I've said this previously, that we carry about $2.8 billion to $2.9 billion in currency translation adjustment tied to our consumer Mexico franchise. So once the deal is signed, that amount will run through the P&L and in the end be offset when we close. That means, again, you'd see another gap in timing between what shows up in the accounting and what the actual economic result is, but that's essentially the piece that would come into play upon signing, whenever that might happen.
Betsy Graseck
analystHi. Good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Betsy Graseck
analystTwo things, if I may. First, this may be a bit in the weeds, but regarding the NIM sensitivity figures you provide in the 10-Q and the 10-K, it would help to know what portion of that sensitivity originates from the non-legacy operations. And once you divest the businesses you've flagged, how much of that NIM sensitivity will remain?
Mark Mason
executiveRight. That breakout isn't something I have, Betsy. What I mean is, we'll need to follow up with you on that. I don't have that breakout.
Vivek Juneja
analystHey Mark, Jane — a quick one, and it's likely aimed more at Mark. Did the RWA go up because of the greater volatility you'd have had in your trading assets during the first quarter? And what offset that?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, look — during the first quarter, what we've mostly seen driving things is really the credit risk side when you look at RWA, and that really came down to SACR. That's the largest factor behind the fourth quarter, the first quarter RWA increase we've seen. So, on the market risk side, RWA was largely unchanged, and that's because of decreases in trading book securitizations — those are, kind of, the main things behind it.
Jane Fraser
executiveWhat I'd add is this — and you definitely picked this up clearly from Paco during Investor Day — a significant part of the approach involves ensuring our capital is being optimized; we keep a close eye on the returns we're producing and on the way we allocate and deploy capital; and during this quarter, Andy and Paco, who are running the businesses, have kept a close eye on that as well. So that contributed too.
Mark Mason
executiveRight. So as I mentioned earlier, securitizations would work as an offset, and the same goes for a portion of the equity derivatives.
Steven Chubak
analystHello, and good morning. It was definitely encouraging to hear all of you restate the '22 guidance: revenue growth in the low-single digit range, and expenses up in the mid-single digits. That said, considering how revenues positively surprised this quarter, and with more rate increases now incorporated into the forward curve compared to your previous update, I'd like some insight into why the revenue forecast wasn't raised. Also, given how investments are paced and timed, when we look toward 2023 and past that, what's the right way to think about when you can return to positive operating leverage?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Well, on that — allow me to address it. Regarding revenues, as you've heard from us before, there were gains and losses that worked their way through the quarter, and a good deal of uncertainty remains present; so although rates have moved higher, and we've observed and anticipate some upside flowing from that, banking revenues have also taken a hit, since that uncertainty is producing a situation where corporate clients are holding back, especially when it comes to equity capital markets and debt capital markets. So, as I said, there are counterbalancing effects at work. That's why we were at ease keeping our guidance for the top line; when it comes to expenses, as I noted at Investor Day, the spending we're doing on expenses matters greatly. And we're still increasing them for transformation and for business-led investments. On the business-led investment front, the positive development is that we're beginning to witness some of that top line momentum, driven not only by rates but also by items such as fees, exactly as we projected. On the transformation front, progress continues. And we've discussed how essential that is for our operations down the road. We anticipate that it will peak, or arc, as we put it at Investor Day, and that's going to happen in the near term and will serve as a significant counterbalance to the structural expense base we carry, as the efficiencies from that spending come through.
Jane Fraser
executiveI also want to add my perspective: we remain fully dedicated to putting money into both our transformation efforts and our growth initiatives. In our view, each of these matters enormously. At the same time, we hold the same level of dedication when it comes to handling our cost structure wisely and with real scrutiny. If our figures offer any reassurance, it's this: we're pressing ahead. We aren't wasting time. That's what you've witnessed with the divestitures, and we're taking the same approach with our transformation and with the investments we're making, staying sharply focused on ensuring we produce the outcomes you'd anticipate from them. You'll observe a comparable pattern once we begin divesting and completing the various transactions, and we'll update you on our efforts to pull out any stranded expenses and stay concentrated on that. So expect to see us pursuing different parts of our cost base fairly aggressively whenever the timing makes sense.
Jim Mitchell
analystHi there. Good morning, Mark and Jane. Perhaps one thing regarding — simply building on what was asked previously, might you provide a particular revision concerning NII expansion during this year, since the forward curve sits materially above 100 basis points? Also, what's your overall thinking on NII? Then, within that, how should we consider your deposit base, or mainly the portion that's more institutional, performing amid an aggressive QT backdrop? Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, absolutely. Well, I'm not providing any sort of guidance that's, say, broken out for revenues. The full-year guidance we've discussed is what we're sticking with. Clearly, as rates have shifted in the manner they have, we'd anticipate seeing a bit of enhancement on the NII line, yet no particular guidance broken out for those two lines has come from me. Regarding the deposit base we hold, as you're aware, we've got a combination of consumer plus corporate client deposits. We lean somewhat more toward the corporate client deposit side. That typically carries a greater beta; therefore, they'll probably respond more and respond earlier to rising interest rates. And quantitative tightening is sure to leave a longer-term mark on how many deposits exist out there. Having said that, neither our near-term plans nor the Investor Day forecast as we've laid it out depend on meaningful deposit growth. Some growth is what we'd anticipate, yet growth in line with roughly pre-pandemic levels, though that isn't oversized growth, and we think our strategy — which extends beyond merely pursuing deposits, but truly centers on solutions for corporate clients and the complete range of financial services for the consumers we serve — will let us capture a suitable amount in step with how the economy develops.
Erika Najarian
analystHello. In fact, Chubac and Jim already raised what I was going to ask. Mark, I believe it could be useful for the coming quarter if you separated out the NII guidance, considering the uncertainty every one of us faces when trying to forecast trading and investment banking? Many thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, Erika.
Betsy Graseck
analystHi. I'd like to inquire about your approach to the U.S. card business. In this space, it seems as though in certain respects, you've fallen behind somewhat, while in others, you're speeding up. And I'm hoping to understand your view on where things are going this year specifically, given that it's among the higher-margin operations you possess, and clearly it ties into the reserve ratio somewhat as well? Thanks.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes. It's surprising to hear you say we were lagging, since we don't — that's definitely not our view. I've felt genuinely encouraged by the performance of the cards franchise across a number of different metrics — client acquisition, spend, and some of the fresh offerings we've introduced. Anand shared with you the growth in proprietary cards. Installment lending expanded by 75%, though it started from a small base during this quarter. So there are many different angles here. So, I believe it's — we're quite happy to watch this business truly gaining traction. And as I mentioned, Betsy, during my prepared remarks, I'm encouraged by the direction this business is taking. Part of that, I think, is that my optimism about the U.S. economy and the U.S. consumer exceeds my outlook for really any other region globally. And that's supported by so much momentum in the labor market. We continue to observe a substantial amount of excess liquidity resting in our consumers' back pockets, along with very strong balance sheets. I believe payment rates have topped out. So we're only now beginning to witness the earliest indications of those declining. And I think that's a positive thing, because it represents a return to — it ought to represent a return this year to healthier behavior. Spend has clearly been extraordinary. It's risen in the mid-20% range. It's also wonderful to see the experience side and that services side rebounding once more. And we've been observing that in travel. We've been observing it in apparel. People enjoy dressing up to go out to dinner at a restaurant again. Those sorts of things — it's great to watch normality returning. So I feel fairly optimistic both about the cyclical direction of this, the recovery from COVID, and where it's going. And I'm also quite satisfied with the strategy Anand presented and the headway we're making on it. So, I think there are some positive developments ahead here.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah, and the one thing I'd throw in there is just a handful of figures. So sales have climbed 24% compared to a year ago, and they're now above where they stood before the pandemic in every category. Acquisitions have risen 23% versus a year earlier. Again, that's about welcoming new cardholders into the fold, so to speak. Revenues have slipped 2%, though you have to look past the investments we're making in acquisitions and the rewards expenses tied to them, since those are what drag revenue down by 2%. Strip out the acquisition costs, and in fact revenue would be 1% higher than a year ago. So I'm fully with you, Jane — we feel really good about how far we've come, and we're starting to see that same kind of momentum show up on the retail services side too. The quarter-over-quarter movement in average interest earning balances is a solid indicator of how this will unfold, and we still feel confident about the growth we projected for the latter part of the year.
Andrew Lim
analystHello, and thank you for allowing me to ask. I have a feeling that your NII guidance may have caught you off guard, since previously you formally presented it as resting on a runoff balance sheet, whereas now it seems to rest on a static balance sheet. A few quarters back, I believe you stated that under the identical assumption — a static balance sheet — your NII would rise by roughly $2.5 billion to $3 billion given a 100 basis point parallel shift. Are you still holding to that? And regarding the composition of that figure, what portion came from the short end rising by 100 basis points? My sense is that you have considerably greater sensitivity to the short end climbing. Could you share an approximate number for that?
Mark Mason
executiveCertainly. Good morning, and I want to distinguish the NII guidance from the IRE sensitivity and disclosure we provide. You are completely correct, and I am not shifting — we are not shifting away from our IRE disclosure whatsoever. The analysis shows that with a parallel rate shift of roughly 100 basis points, we observe an increase of approximately $2.5 billion to $3 billion flowing through. As you are aware, and as I have previously mentioned, that spans currencies, with roughly two-thirds attributable to non-U.S. currencies and the remaining third, clearly, to U.S. So from an ROE standpoint, that remains our position. We have not — our view on that has not changed.
Mike Mayo
analystHey, just a quick follow-up. I suppose none of this is breaking news, but the cost level is simply enormous, and we haven't heard that 4% inflation figure coming from anybody else, and perhaps competitors can counterbalance it somewhat more effectively. Then there's the 1% tied to volume, when you, Jane, noted that you don't anticipate this degree of capital markets activity to persist. So I suppose I'm just — I'm struggling with something that's persisted for quite some time. I understand. You've got the correct sequence, you've got the transformation, you've got business sales. You acknowledged underinvesting previously and all the rest; yet, I mean, there are 1,200 basis points separating your expense growth and revenue growth, and that just appears extremely large. However, you're also guiding toward what I believe is roughly 300 basis points of that gap across the full year. So does that imply this represents the worst point, and that gap ought to shrink? And just a few of those other items — inflation, volume costs, expenses broadly — because it's aggravating for investors.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. So let me grab that and sort of attempt to walk everyone through it. So the initial point I'd make is that the 10% increase we posted this quarter aligns with the guidance. I simply want to be clear that during Investor Day, that's exactly what we described. We'd prefer the figure were otherwise, but we recognize and we're aware that this is necessary to bring the franchise to the place it must reach. And so we're making those tough calls. We're directing funds to the areas that require them. We're being careful about it to ensure we aren't squandering resources in that process. But we don't wish to establish or endure the circumstances we've endured previously regarding insufficient investment. And so we intend to steer clear of that. The next point is, and you recognized that somewhat when you brought up transformation and business-led investments. Regarding structural investment spending, I ought to clarify, roughly half of it stems from inflation, so not the entire 4%. Some of it also comes from non-consent order risk and control spending we're undertaking, items such as the financial crime unit, items such as cyber spending, items such as the efforts we're pursuing around our wholesale credit operations, significant items; and there are certain productivity savings that flow through that; and then the last component concerning volume relates to transactional costs tied to the activity we conduct on the trading side, the spending we undertake to generate that activity. And the mix is important. And so although revenues sort of unfold one way for the quarter, the composition of the market's activity influences how much volume-related expense gets produced through those transactions. Alright, so those are a few items. Once again, we're staying aligned with our guidance. We think we're on pace to hit the mid-single digits we provided for the entire year. And we're eager to create the efficiencies that result from this spending and make a dent in our structural expense base over time.
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely. And Mike, I want to add something here too, since this is a matter that Mark and I are extremely conscious of. We're handling it with tremendous attention to every last particular across several fronts. We're applying what we've learned — we have to absorb a certain amount of near-term hurt in order to put ourselves where we must be over the medium term and the long term. And whether it's the stranded costs or the divestitures, we recognize there will be chances in that space. We mentioned Investor Day as well, and being in a spot to streamline the management structure and remove a portion of those structural expenses. So Mark and I will keep concentrating on this area, making certain that beyond steering the arc and making sure one exists, we also deliver the benefits to our shareholders from all of it. And I hold myself to an extraordinarily high level of accountability for this, as does the management team; we understand it.
Jen Landis
executiveWe appreciate all of you being here with us right now. Should any additional questions come up afterward, feel free to get in touch with our investor relations team. Have a great rest of your day. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorAnd this concludes Citi’s first quarter earnings call. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.