Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 13, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being here. Just a quick note that the deck we’re walking through today — you can grab it from our site, citigroup.com — might include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects, and they come with uncertainty and shifting circumstances. Because of a range of factors, among them the ones laid out in our SEC filings, actual results could end up differing materially from what’s in those statements. So with that said, I’ll hand things off to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jen, and pleased new year to everybody who's with us on this call. We've hit the ground sprinting as 2023 gets underway. What I'll do today is give you our read on the macro picture, then run through how we did in Q4. After that, I'll spend a few minutes looking back at what we accomplished in 2022 and where our strategic focus sits for the year ahead. The worldwide macro backdrop unfolded pretty much the way we'd expected through the back half of last year. Coming into 2023, conditions have held up better than any of us had forecast, at least for now, even with Central Banks tightening so aggressively. Over in Europe, a milder December eased pressure on energy availability, and inflation has started coming down from its high point. Even so, we anticipate economic conditions will soften throughout the Eurozone this year, reflecting certain structural difficulties the region is dealing with. Turning to Asia, though the public health consequences in China will sadly probably be serious, the sudden abandonment of COVID Zero ought to start fueling growth and lifting sentiment more broadly. Domestically, the job market is still robust and holiday spending came in above forecasts, partly since shoppers have been tapping their savings. The Fed, though, stays determined to fight core inflation, so our view remains that the U.S. will slip into a mild recession during this year's second half. Now let me get into our results. In Q4, net income came to $2.5 billion, with EPS at $1.16. For the whole year, revenue rose 3% ex-divestitures, matching the guidance we provided at Investor Day, and expenses landed in line as well. We posted an ROTCE of nearly 9% alongside a CET1 ratio of 13%. During the quarter, our businesses turned in results comparable to what they showed all year, and we feel quite good about some while being less pleased about others. Services keeps generating outstanding revenue growth. Our markets franchises are handling the climate extremely well, and momentum in U.S. Personal Banking looks solid. On the other hand, investment banking suffered from a dramatically shrunken wallet in ’22, and conditions in wealth stayed difficult. To break that down a little, services turned in yet another superb quarter, and we've picked up considerable share in both Treasury and Trade Solutions and security services. TTS — the unit that best embodies what our global network can do — saw revenues climb 36% year-over-year as we carry out the plan we set out at Investor Day. With robust business drivers plus elevated rates, TTS is outpacing what we'd projected. In the same vein, Securities Services rose a healthy 22%. We closed out the year having brought on board $1.2 trillion in new assets under administration and custody. Markets enjoyed its strongest fourth quarter in recent memory, with revenues climbing 18% versus 2021. During the year's first three quarters, we held the top FICC franchise on the street, and fixed income gained 31% in the last quarter. Equities declined because the mix of client activity once again didn't align with our derivatives strengths. With the wallet shrinking considerably, our investment banking revenues fell roughly 60% this quarter. Although the pipeline appears stronger and client sentiment is getting better, pinpointing exactly when things will shift in ‘23 would be difficult. Wealth Management's results fell short. Revenues dropped 6% for the quarter, as the macro backdrop pressured investment fees and AUM worldwide, though Asia felt it most sharply. That said, we've been consistently enhancing the business, as shown by ongoing momentum in client acquisitions across all segments and net new investment flows. In the same way, we keep expanding our client advisor ranks, though more slowly given current conditions. We'd anticipate these investments bearing fruit once markets rebound. Over in U.S. Personal Banking, both cards businesses achieved double-digit revenue growth for a second consecutive quarter, driven by strong ongoing gains in purchase sales and revolving balances. Meanwhile, in retail banking, clearly there's additional work ahead. As you're aware, we've been proactively managing our balance sheet and risk. Our cost of credit rose consistent with our guidance. We added reserves in Personal Banking this quarter due to volume growth and in preparation for a mild recession. And within the U.S., net credit losses in cards keep normalizing as anticipated, remaining far under pre-COVID levels. Corporate credit stays healthy, and our low overall cost of credit matched last quarter, highlighting our corporate loan portfolio's quality. On capital, we raised the CET1 ratio roughly 70 basis points to 13% in the fourth quarter. Lastly, our tangible book value per share rose to $81.65, and we gave back $1 billion to shareholders via our common dividend; now, let me step back and talk about what we achieved in 2022. A key objective last year involved establishing a strategic plan meant to generate long-term value for shareholders and to launch it quickly. I'm happy with the considerable progress already made. We simplified the bank, completing sales of our consumer businesses in 5 markets, including 3 during the fourth quarter. And we've moved fast to wind down our consumer business in Korea plus our franchise in Russia; we keep investing in our transformation to resolve our consent orders and to modernize our bank. We're streamlining our processes and making them more automated while enhancing the quality and accessibility of our data. This will make us a better bank; we attracted very strong talent, achieved our representation goals and strengthened our culture by boosting accountability and shareholder alignment. With that in mind, I'm happy that we hit the financial guidance we set for the year. Beyond that, we put out our initial blueprint for achieving net zero emissions by 2050, grew our impact investing, and shared what an outside law firm found when it examined our racial equity work in the U.S. Last, I take real pride in the way our team navigated the macro and geopolitical shocks that shaped 2022, standing behind our clients and communities with excellence and compassion the whole way. Before passing things to Mark, let's look ahead to the coming years, especially how we get to the medium-term return targets shown on Page 5. At Investor Day, we described that journey as unfolding across three phases, where Phase 1 involves both disciplined execution and investment. 2023 continues Phase 1, building the groundwork for long-term shareholder value. Our emphasis is on shifting our business mix to lift revenues and returns, and we expect our businesses to finish '23 in a competitively stronger position. Services came into '23 carrying strategic momentum plus a pipeline of major new innovation and market-leading product capabilities. Markets ought to keep gaining from our active corporate client base, with the franchise moving further ahead thanks to investments and the businesses centered on capital productivity.
Jane Fraser
executiveBanking and Wealth are set up nicely for the moment the cycle reverses. That comes thanks to what we've put into attracting top talent and building technology, plus the synergies we've captured throughout the franchise. As you noticed, we concluded now was the moment to bring in new leadership for well, and a search got underway to find the business's next head. I've asked Jim O’Donnell to move into a different position centered on senior clients throughout the entire firm. That move draws on his extensive knowledge and connections, and paired with the new GoG’s added responsibility as North America Head, the aim is to help us seize more of a sizable business opportunity right here in our home market. U.S. Personal Banking keeps gaining from the rebound and from borrowing, making the most of our digital platforms that lead the market along with new offerings, especially when it comes to cards. We'll push ahead on exiting international consumer operations, which lets us streamline the firm and bring down our cost base. And naturally, we'll stay focused on clients, strengthening ties and adding new ones consistent with our strategy. Disciplined investments in our franchise will keep going, among them spending on our transformation and controls. Even so, some business investments will be slowed to match the operating environment. Further ahead, we'll start bending the expense curve so we can hit our medium-term targets; we'll get there by combining our divestitures, capturing the financial gains from our transformation, and simplifying further, and Mark will walk through that in more detail soon. We're fully aware this holds down our returns in the near term, yet we're intentionally making the hard strategic moves and the investments required to achieve our medium-term return targets and build long-term shareholder value; we're bringing not only our momentum but our resolve into 2023. Even with macro headwinds, we remain very much on track toward the medium-term return targets we laid out for you at Investor Day. Our strategy was deliberately built to deliver for shareholders across varying conditions; we're operating the bank in a different way, with an unrelenting emphasis on execution, and we'll keep sharing our proof points with you transparently throughout. With that, I'd like to hand things to Mark, and then we'll be happy, as always, to field your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, Jane, and hello everybody on this morning's call. There's quite a bit for us to get through today. My plan is to begin with the Q4 and full-year financials, and I'll emphasize comparisons against the prior year unless I say otherwise. I'll then walk through how we're tracking toward our medium-term KPI objectives, and finish up with the outlook we're providing for 2023. Turning to Slide 6, you can see the financials for the entire company. During Q4, net income came in at roughly $2.5 billion, alongside EPS of $1.16 and an ROTCE of 5.8%, on revenue of $18 billion. Within those figures are pre-tax impacts tied to divestitures of about $192 million, mostly from gains on those divestitures. Strip those out, and EPS would have been $1.10, with ROTCE of roughly 5.5%; during the quarter, overall revenues rose 6%, or 5% once divestiture-related impacts are removed, since strength in services, market and U.S. Personal Banking was partly offset by weaker investment banking, wealth, and the revenue decrease from the completed exit. Expenses came in at $13 billion, which is 4% lower than the comparable period a year ago. If you set aside divestiture-related costs for both this year's fourth quarter and last year's, expenses were up 5%, mostly reflecting spending on our transformation, business-led investments, and greater volume-related costs, partly offset by productivity savings and the expense decrease from the exit. Cost of credit totaled about $1.8 billion, mainly due to ongoing normalization in card net credit losses, especially within retail services, plus a $645 million ACL build tied largely to cards growth and some worsening in macroeconomic assumptions. Looking at the whole year, net income reached $14.8 billion, along with an ROTCE <<inaudible>>. Turning now to Slide 7 for the full-year revenue walk: 2022 revenue was about $75 billion, a 3% increase once divestiture effects are removed, matching the low single-digit growth we had told you to expect. Treasury and Trade Solution revenues rose 32%, boosted by continued rate advantages as well as business moves such as actively managing deposit repricing, expanding relationships with existing clients, and attracting new clients in all segments. Wins have accelerated as a result of the investments we've made in market leading product capabilities, among them the industry's first 24/7 U.S. On the dollar clearing side, we've got the seven-day cash suite that launched earlier in the year, plus instant payment, which is now live in 33 markets and reaches over 60 countries. So while about half of this year's growth came from the rate environment, the other half came from business action and investments. Turning to Security Services, revenues climbed 15%, with net interest income up 59%, supported by higher rates across currency, though that was partly offset by non-interest revenue falling 1% due to the impact of market valuation. Looking at the full year, we added about $1.2 trillion in assets under custody and administration from significant client mandates, and we continue to feel quite optimistic about the pipeline for new business. In markets, revenue climbed 7%, driven mainly by strong performance in rates and FX as we continue supporting corporate and investor clients while making better use of capital. This was partially offset by challenges in equity markets, primarily due to reduced client activity in equity derivatives. Meanwhile, banking revenues, excluding gains and losses on loan hedges, dropped 39%, pressured by investment banking as elevated macroeconomic uncertainty and volatility continued to dampen client activity. On the cards side, revenue increased 8%, since we continue to realize gains from what we invested back in 2022, plus consumer borrowing has come back up. Over in wealth, revenue fell 2%, mostly because of how markets were valued during China's lockdowns. If you take out Asia, revenue rose 3%. Corporate Other got a lift too from stronger NII, partly because our investment portfolio's shorter duration let us take advantage of elevated short-term rates. And the slide shows that across legacy franchises, once you set aside divestiture-related effects, revenue dropped roughly $1.3 billion, reflecting the closure of 5 exit markets and our ongoing wind-down of Russia and Korea consumer. Looking ahead, we anticipate that our older business lines will keep dragging on total revenue growth as we complete the shutdown of what's left in the exit market. Slide 8 lays out a full-year expense walk along with the main drivers behind it. During 2022, once you set aside the effects tied to divestitures, our expenses rose about 8%, which matched what we had guided. Transformation was up 2%, and roughly two-thirds of that gain came from the risk, control, data and finance program, while around 25% of the money put into those programs goes toward technology. Roughly one percent of the higher costs came from investments led by the business — things like making our TTS and Security Services platform more scalable and improving it, making client experiences better throughout every business, and building out new product capabilities. We're also still putting money into front office talent, though we're doing that more carefully now because of the environment. Expenses tied to volume rose one percent, mostly because of market and cards. The rest of the increase came from structural expenses, which take in more spending on risk and control to back the front office, plus macro effects such as inflation. Productivity gains, favorable FX translation, and savings from leaving that market helped counterbalance some of that spending. Companywide, tech costs rose 13% for the year. Slide 9 compares our 2022 outcomes against the medium-term KPI goals we introduced at Investor Day — a view we'll keep providing as we move forward. When it comes to macro factors and market conditions — among them those caused by monetary tightening at levels we hadn't expected when Investor Day took place — certain KPIs were affected favorably and others unfavorably; even so, by executing against our strategy, we managed to offset a portion of those impacts. Within TTS, healthy underlying drivers remain evident, pointing to consistently robust activity from clients both new and existing as we roll out new product offerings and put investment into the client experience, a key element of our strategy. Across all segments, client wins have risen by roughly 20%. Once again, these feature marquee transactions in which we act as the client's primary operating bank. Looking at the third quarter and the year so far, we figure we gained somewhere near 70 basis points in share, and we kept our top spot among big institutional clients. Beyond that, over 8,700 suppliers have come on board this year, which lets our clients handle their supply chains as the global situation keeps changing. Now for Security Services: newly brought-on client assets helped counter some of the drop in market valuation. As of the third quarter this year, we estimate we've added about 50 basis points of share in Security Services, including in our home market. When it comes to markets, we strengthened our lead in fixed income by picking up share, and we're making headway on our revenue to RWA card. On the cards side, growth in loans beat our forecast across both branded cards and retail services. Spending volume on cards increased by 14%, loans at period-end were up 13%, and — the key point — interest-earning balances grew 14%.
Mark Mason
executiveEven so, in certain businesses such as investment banking, our share slipped during the year, though we held onto our market position. And in wealth, although we've added new advisors and new client assets, because of what market valuation did, that has not yet shown up as growth in client assets or in top line growth. So to sum up, we achieved solid progress on our medium-term KPI targets even with the considerable shifts in the macroeconomic backdrop that have occurred since Investor Day. That demonstrates our diversified business model can adapt to a wide range of environments, and that we have the right strategy in place to hit our return targets over the medium-term. Now, going back to the fourth quarter on Slide 10, we present net interest income, deposits and loans; during the fourth quarter, net interest income rose by roughly $710 million quarter over quarter, mostly powered by services, cards and markets. Average loans declined, since growth in cards was more than outweighed by decreases in ICG and legacy franchise. If you strip out foreign exchange translation, loans were flat. And average deposits fell by roughly 1%, mostly because of decreases in legacy franchises and the effect of foreign exchange translation. Strip out foreign exchange translation, and deposits rose 2%. On a sequential basis, average deposits climbed on the strength of growth in ICG and PBWM, and our net interest margin went up by 8 basis points. On Slide 11, we lay out key consumer and corporate credit mix. We hold ample reserves for the present environment, with more than $19 billion set aside. Our reserves to funded loan ratio stands at roughly 2.6%. Within that figure, PBWM and U.S. card come in at 3.8% and 7.6% respectively, both slightly above Day 1 CECL level. And we feel quite confident about how high quality our portfolio is. In PBWM, 45% of our lending exposures sit in U.S. cards. Of that amount, branded cards account for 66% while retail services account for 34%. On top of that, slightly more than 80% of our total card exposure goes to prime customers; and NCL rates remain well under pre-COVID levels. In our ICT portfolio, more than 80% of our total exposure is investment grade. As for the international exposure, around 90% is investment grade or exposure to multinational clients or their subsidiaries. And corporate non-accrual loans stay low and match pre-pandemic levels at roughly 39 basis points of total loans; that said, we keep analyzing our portfolios and concentration across a range of scenarios. So although the macro and geopolitical environment is still uncertain, we feel quite confident about our asset quality, exposures and reserve levels. On Slide 12, we lay out our summary balance sheet along with key capital and liquidity metrics. We keep a very strong balance sheet. Out of our $2.4 trillion balance sheet, roughly a quarter, or just under $600 billion, is made up of H3LA, and we maintained <<inaudible>>. And our tangible book value per share came to $81.65, which is up 3% versus a year ago. On Slide 13, we present a sequential CET1 walk, giving you more insight into what moved the numbers this quarter and what we're aiming for across the coming few quarters. Starting from where the third quarter ended, first, net income to common came in at $2.3 billion, contributing 19 basis points. Second, we returned $1 billion through the common dividend, and that produced a decrease of roughly 9 basis points. Third, AOCI impacts from our AFS investment portfolio produced an 8 basis point gain. And finally, the other 56 basis points of increase came mostly from completed exits, RWA optimization and market movements late in the quarter. We closed the quarter at a 13% CET1 capital ratio, roughly 70 basis points above the prior quarter. As you can see, we reached our 13% CET1 target, which includes 100 basis points of internal management book. That gives us room to absorb any temporary effects tied to the Mexico consumer exit at signing while still having plenty of capacity to serve our clients; and when it comes to buybacks this quarter, we'll stay paused and keep making that call quarter-by-quarter. On Slide 14, we show results for our Institutional Clients Group in the fourth quarter. Revenues rose 3% this quarter, with TTS climbing 36% on sustained NII strength; Security Services revenues gaining 22%; Markets revenue rising 18% on fixed income strength, partly offset by an equity decline; and Investment Banking revenues falling 58%, which falls within the range of the overall drop in industry volume. Expenses rose 6%, driven by transformation, business-led investments, specifically in services and volume-related expenses partly offset by FX translation and productivity savings. Cost of credit was $56 million, driven by net credit losses of $104 million, partly offset by an ACL release. This produced net income of approximately $1.9 billion, down 18%, driven by higher cost of credit and higher expenses. ICG delivered a 7.9% ROTCE for the quarter. And average loans declined slightly, largely driven by the impact of foreign exchange translation and our continued capital optimization efforts. Excluding FX, loans rose 1%. Average deposits were roughly flat. Excluding the impact of foreign exchange translation, deposits rose 3%, and sequentially, deposits rose 4%. As for the full year, ICT grew revenues by 3% to $41 billion and delivered approximately $10.7 billion of net income, with an ROTCE of 11.1%. Now turning to Slide 15, we show the results of our Personal Banking and Wealth Management business. Revenues rose 5% as net interest income growth was partly offset by a decline in non-interest revenue driven by lower investment product revenue in wealth and higher partner payments in retail services. Expenses rose 7%, driven by investments in transformation and other risk and control initiatives. Cost of credit was $1.7 billion, which included a reserve build driven by card volume growth and a deterioration in macroeconomic assumptions. Net charge-offs rose, showing continued normalization, especially within retail services. Loans averaged 6% higher, whereas deposits averaged 1% lower, mostly because clients moved cash into fixed income investments on our platform; and PBWM posted an ROTCE of 1.4%, which was driven by the ACL build this quarter and higher expenses. Across the full year, PBWM generated an ROTCE of 10.2% on $24.2 billion in revenue. Turning to Slide 16, we present results for legacy franchise. Revenues fell 6%, mainly because of the closing of five exit markets along with the impact of the wind down. Expenses dropped 38%, chiefly because last year included divestiture-related impact tied to Korea; on Slide 17, we present fourth quarter results for Corporate/Other. Revenues rose, mainly because of higher net revenue from the investment portfolio. Expenses declined because of lower consulting expenses; on Slide 19, we lay out our guidance for 2023. As Jane said before, 2023 continues Phase 1; we will keep executing and investing, building the foundation for what comes next while aiming to drive long-term shareholder value. Against that backdrop, we anticipate revenue between $78 billion and $79 billion, excluding any potential 2023 divestiture-related impacts, with expenses of roughly $54 billion, likewise excluding 2023 divestiture-related impact.
Mark Mason
executiveWe anticipate that net credit losses in cards will keep moving toward more typical levels. And, as mentioned before, we hit our CET1 goal of 13%, and we'll keep assessing that goal as we move through the upcoming DFAST cycle and complete further exits and announce additional ones. On Slide 20, over on the right-hand side, we present our revenue for 2021 and 2022 along with what we expect for 2023, leaving out the effect of divestitures. During 2023, we anticipate the revenue growth I referenced a moment ago will come from NII and NIR; in TTS, we anticipate revenues will rise, though more slowly, because of interest rates and business actions; and in Security Services, we anticipate some tailwind from higher market valuations and the onboarding of more client assets; we likewise assumed a degree of normalization in wealth as China's lockdowns and market valuations begin to recover. And we anticipate investment banking will start to recover as the macroeconomic backdrop turns more supportive of client activity. Regarding market, we anticipate it will stay roughly flat given the activity level observed in 2022. Now shifting to the NII guidance for 2023, we anticipate that both ICG and PBWM will add to NII growth as we expand volumes, especially in cards, and we keep benefiting from U.S. and non-U.S. rate increases in our services business. As a reminder, the revenue guidance accounts for the decline in revenue from the exit and legacy franchises we shut in 2022, and we anticipate closing this year, 2023. Moving to Slide 21. During 2023, the expense increase I referred to a moment ago mirrors a set of decisions we've taken to advance our transformation and carry out our strategy; and the primary drivers are, first, transformation as we keep investing in data, risk and control and technology to strengthen our infrastructure and eventually make our company more efficient. Second, business-led investments as we carry out our strategy. Third, volume-related expenses consistent with our revenue expectations. And fourth, high inflation levels mostly hitting compensation expense, partly offset by productivity savings and expense benefits from the exit; and we are investing in technology throughout the firm, with total technology-related expenses rising by 5%. While we acknowledge this is a sizable expense increase. These are investments we must make and I am confident these investments will make us a better, more efficient company down the road; and finally, let's discuss the medium-term targets a bit. At Investor Day, we stated the medium term was 3 to 5 years. That period meant 2024 to 2026. So although much has shifted in the macro environment since Investor Day, our strategy hasn't, and we are on track for the 11% to 12% ROTCE target over the medium term. Our outlook remains that revenue growth at the top line, a meaningful decrease in expenses, and capital levels broadly in line with our medium-term CET1 target range will all help us reach our 11% to 12% ROTCE goal. So allow me to take you through our current position. On the revenue side, interest rates have climbed considerably and more rapidly around the world, which sped up NII growth. That, combined with our strategy's execution, has enabled certain businesses to pick up pace. Meanwhile, other businesses, including wealth and investment banking, have decelerated. Even so, in line with Investor Day, we anticipate a 4% to 5% revenue CAGR over the medium term, factoring in the continued decline in revenue resulting from the closing of the exit. On the expense side, as we presented at Investor Day, costs will have to normalize across the medium term; and we now anticipate bending the expense curve near the end of 2024. The three primary drivers behind the expense reduction we need will be benefits from the exit, which will be included in legacy franchise, the benefits from our investments in transformation and control, and the simplification of the organizational structure. First, allow me to remind you that, at this point, ongoing expenses within legacy franchises sit at approximately $7 billion. Out of that $7 billion, about $4 billion goes to the buyer at closing or via a transition services agreement that generally runs for roughly a year. The other $3 billion is tied to potentially stranded costs and wind down, which takes time to remove. Second, as our investment in transformation and control initiatives mature, we anticipate capturing efficiency as those programs shift from manually intensive processes to technology-enabled ones. And finally, we stay focused on simplifying the organization, and we anticipate creating additional opportunities for expense reduction going forward. On the credit side, we continue to expect net credit losses to normalize, and any future ACL build or releases will depend on macro assumptions and volume; so in summary, although the world has changed dramatically and the components have moved, we remain on track to reach the 11% to 12% ROTCE over the medium term. And Jane, the rest of the firm, and I are ready to keep showing proof points along the way and demonstrating our progress. With that, Jane and I would be glad to take your questions.
Glenn Schorr
analystThank you very much, and I truly value all of these outlooks. They're quite useful; so regarding the outlook, my question is this: if you examine the present medium-sized return on tangible and how it gets to your target, I heard a lot of remarks saying the route toward reaching it remains on track. Is it the expense spend at the close of ‘24, which represents the substantial increase from where we are now to where we need to be, so to speak, and/or does credit act as a truly major factor in this process? So I'm attempting to connect the numbers from the return on tangible targets we have today. Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveYes, of course. Good morning, Glenn, and thank you for asking. So we did provide you with some guidance here — we gave it to you on both the top line and the middle line for ‘23. And then, crucially, when we discuss the medium term, it involves both the ongoing revenue growth, the 4% to 5% CAGR that I mentioned, and also lowering the expenses from this ‘23 forecast; and I noted in the prepared remarks the drivers behind what will reduce these expenses. The mix of exiting the businesses and the expenses disappearing in connection with that, together with the benefits that we begin to produce from the transformation spend, and then org simplification that this sort of strategic restructuring, so to speak, in leaving all these countries will open up an opportunity for. And so it involves a mix of revenue growth, expense bending of that curve and heading downward. The cost of credit is, as we've discussed for a while now, normalizing across the coming couple of years at levels that align with what we've observed, so to speak, before this COVID cycle that we've been navigating through.
Glenn Schorr
analystThat's appreciated, thank you. One brief poly follow-up — not something I'd typically do, but usually I attempt to honor this kind of process. Mark, we view you as an extremely vital piece of this transformation. There's been reporting out there that you're in discussions with one of my other companies — could you say anything about that? You brought up some moment staying on — apologies for putting you on the spot, but I believe a great many people are interested.
Mark Mason
executiveThat's appreciated, Glenn, and Citi is a significant firm. I serve as this firm's CFO, and alongside Jane this strategy is what I'm concentrated on, making sure we carry it out properly and in a manner that generates shareholder value for our investors; therefore we are dedicated to accomplishing that.
Jane Fraser
executiveTogether.
Mark Mason
executiveTogether.
John McDonald
analystHey Mark, I'd like to get more detail on the 2023 revenue outlook. At roughly the midpoint, it seems to suggest around 4% revenue growth for this year, which lines up with the 4% to 5% you mentioned. So for 2023, based on the guide, NII looks like it's directed to rise approximately 3.5%. And the markets you're assuming are basically flat. So what gets you to that 4%? Which drivers come in above 4%? Is it a few of those fee businesses? A bit more detail on that would really help.
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely. First, let me say something about NII. Bear in mind that the figure I provided on the page includes the growth happening in certain of our key services businesses, and that stems from the annualization of the rate hikes we experienced in the latter half of the year, plus anticipated further increases, especially beyond the U.S.; and because of how our franchise is composed, that will add to NII growth; then also remember that we're expanding against the legacy franchise NII reductions we'd expect during 2023. So beneath all that, there's genuine momentum in NII, even though the pace is slower — indeed slower than what 2022 delivered. On the NIR side, I noted that we do anticipate some normalization in market valuation. That would show up in banking, normalizing of course compared with what we had this year when it's down 50% to 60%, and also some normalization in wealth, and those would land on the NIR line, exactly as you're saying.
John McDonald
analystAll right. And then — apologies if this has already been made plain. But regarding this notion that the cost curve bends at the close of 2024: does that imply that during the first stretch of 2024, expenses will more or less climb higher than they were in 2023, and afterward they will more or less reach a high point and flatten out as we move into the latter portion of '24? Is that the way we ought to picture it?
Mark Mason
executiveI won't get into guidance for '24. We'll work our way through '23, and I have confidence in our capacity to reach that approximately 54 figure that I provided for '23. I have just as much confidence that this curve will be bent by us, and we will lower it to whatever levels are required so that we can arrive at the ROTCE target, but I won't get into, John, the particulars of 24, other than to state that as '24 comes to a close, that curve will be seen bending.
Erika Najarian
analystHi, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Erika Najarian
analystFor my first question — once more, I appreciate the slide's clarification. Jane and Mark, clearly, excellent work. Yet when we consider what bending the curve actually entails, I believe your shareholders value that you're speeding up these investments in relation to your transformation. When thinking about the point at which Citi can reach that medium-term ROTCE, how ought we to understand what bending the curve truly means? I'm not seeking guidance, strictly speaking, but when we consider moving beyond that hump, what's the superior method of measurement — should we — is the efficiency ratio the answer? You brought up, I believe, something along the lines of whether it's that 60% to 63% efficiency ratio versus the 4% to 5% revenue CAGR that you believe you'll manage to achieve by 2025? Is that a valid way for us to think about it?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. At Investor Day, we did discuss it, and we stay consistent and dedicated to that. We discussed reaching an efficiency ratio below 60% during the medium-term period; therefore that will definitely be among the metrics we achieve as we lower our costs. Another item I'd bring up is that you raised the how, and I believe a few significant elements exist — the exits are clear regarding those costs disappearing, at least a share of them is. The share connected to stranded cost — Jane has been extremely, extremely explicit with our whole management team regarding how crucial it is to rethink the organization and make sure those potentially stranded costs disappear, and that involves rethinking how we conduct business and how we run various parts of our operations. The third component, I believe, is technology, correct? So at present, much of what we do is manual. As we keep investing in technology — and technology is up quite a bit this year, roughly 14% — we anticipate it rising 5% next year. That technology build-out, so to speak, will let us cut back a great deal of that manual work, and that will lower the operational cost of running the firm. So those are a few illustrations, I hope, of the how. Yet I believe crucially, you'll begin to notice it through better operating efficiency across that time span and by reaching the target we discussed at Investor Day.
Jane Fraser
executiveWhat I'd add is that you're able to gain a certain amount of assurance regarding what's behind us on a lot of these items, given how quickly we're carrying out the divestitures — take the closing of those transactions, for instance. And beyond that, we've made an effort to give you the greatest possible transparency concerning when these deals will wrap up and how fast the wind-downs we're doing will proceed. So that should be of help. Like Mark mentioned, three major structural forces shape what shows up in that curve.
Erika Najarian
analystThanks. And Mark, my apologies for saying that incorrectly. I had the wrong borrowing efficiency in front of me. There are around 15 slides open on my computer.
Mark Mason
executiveNo problem,
Erika Najarian
analystFor my follow-up, Jane, this one's probably for you. I believe your shareholders have valued how quickly you've moved on the divestitures. That said, the thing nobody's saying out loud is that the market had basically been looking for news on Banamex by now. So I want to know: is a straight sale of Banamex still on the table, or are you weighing other alternatives, an IPO among them?
Jane Fraser
executiveWe're talking with people right now, so clearly I won't get into specifics here. As you'd imagine, we're still running two tracks at once, since each one remains a genuinely workable route; once we can offer some clarity, we will. On timing, I believe our position has been pretty straightforward. We're additionally carving the two franchises apart — the institutional one from the consumer one that's being sold — since we view the institutional side as a critical piece of the worldwide network. In the current climate, as you can picture, Mexico matters enormously to numerous corporate customers of ours across the globe when it comes to their supply chains. We hold a highly significant role in that market; the separation itself involves a great deal of effort. The headway being made on that foundational work makes me very happy. Still, the two parallel tracks are what we're advancing, and the moment there's news to share, we'll be thrilled to share it.
Mike Mayo
analystHello. I’m still grappling with what you’ve said about revenue and expense guidance; so does that mean you’re suggesting operating leverage will be at least flat, or possibly positive, in 2023? Have I got that right? On one side, you won’t be bending the cost curve until late 2024. On the other side, your guidance points to positive operating leverage for 2023. Is that an accurate reading?
Mark Mason
executiveMike, if you run the numbers, I don’t believe it reaches positive operating leverage during 2023. But as the slide shows, we are aiming at a range that does capture top-line growth. That growth will probably be slightly lower than what the 54 figure would — approximately what that 54 figure would imply, yet we’re moving in the right direction; and we’re getting there in a manner consistent with the strategy we discussed. And we do feel confident about our ability to deliver on the guidance we’ve provided here, similar to delivering on the guidance we gave last year, recognizing there are a lot of things going on in the broader environment.
Mike Mayo
analystAll right. Then a second follow-up — or rather a follow-up, and after that I'll get back in line for my remaining question. Right now your CET1 ratio sits at 13%, and my understanding is that came two quarters sooner than what consensus anticipated. According to you, it rose 70 basis points. So shouldn't that make buybacks possible at this point? Or, as I understand it, were you to proceed with a sale of Banamex, that might cause a short-lived hit to capital. So my thinking goes something like this: don't sell Banamex, avoid that short-lived capital hit, and begin repurchasing shares at a fraction of your tangible book value. So where does my reasoning go wrong, or which piece of it can you address?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me step in on the don't sell Banamex part, Mike. As you might picture, we are selling the consumer franchise. It doesn't align with the strategy we set out at Investor Day. This is an emerging market consumer franchise, and our clear focus is on multinational clients and on institutions and high net worth individuals with cross-border needs, exactly as we laid out, along with businesses that have strong connectivity between one another. So from that standpoint, we don't view Banamex as having strategic fit within the consumer franchises; and once we work through all the math, selling that franchise and deploying that capital to our shareholders or into some of the investments at higher returns serves the shareholders' interest. What you're proposing is a very short-term move; and as I think the actions we're taking make clear, our focus is squarely on the medium and long term, and we won't take the short-term path that we'd regret over the medium and long term.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystHi there, good morning. I suppose my single follow-up question concerns capital. When we look at what comes after the latter six months of this year, hypothetically speaking, you have absorbed the blow from Banamex. Yet once this test is behind us, do you have any instinct, Mark, whether anything would cause Citi to suffer a disproportionately large adverse effect stemming from the Basel endgame changes? Simply offer us some indication — I am merely asking, since ideally we will not face yet another letdown while our expectations build for repurchases during the back half, and there might be something peculiar regarding the composition of your business that ends up damaging the bank? I would welcome whatever insight you can offer on that?
Mark Mason
executiveAbsolutely. So, as we noted, throughout this year we have accumulated a considerable quantity of capital; we have surpassed the objective established for the midpoint of the year, the midpoint of the year. Certain divestitures are going to create a short-term effect on that CET1 ratio. And clearly there is a DFAST ahead of us, and we must wait to learn what result that effort produces. In my view, the Basel endgame, along with conclusive opinions and choices regarding it, remain undecided. Once those become accessible, we will need to factor them in. That represents a sector-wide circumstance that will unfold in whatever manner it does; and much like SACR, we will pursue it aggressively and substantially to guarantee our capacity to manage any obstacles or favorable conditions that accompany it. Still, offering a precise judgment right now about what that ultimately signifies for the sector is genuinely hard, given that conclusive regulations have not yet been issued.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystUnderstood. Now, circling back to those targets you laid out for the medium term. My take is, if we do reach that bending the curve point by the close of '24, then this company ought to have an earnings power above $10 at 25%, even assuming the low end of the guidance. Is there something I'm overlooking? Or does that logic hold up?
Mark Mason
executiveThe sole item I would highlight is what we've laid out — what I've laid out, what Jane laid out, which is that the medium term means '24 through 2026; and — we've provided guidance for '23. Our aim is to reach those return targets over the medium term. I haven't provided you with detailed guidance for any individual year among those, and we'll sort of handle that one year at a time. So just keep that in mind. What I believe matters is that you have a perspective on '23, and I think we've offered you extra clarity regarding how we plan to arrive at that medium term, and I think that matters.
Betsy Graseck
analystHi, good morning.
Mark Mason
executiveGood morning.
Jane Fraser
executiveHello, Betsy.
Betsy Graseck
analystI'd like to dig a bit into what we're doing with Personal and Wealth Management. Jane, I recall you mentioning earlier that — you've made it known you're searching for a new leader to drive that business forward. Could you give us a sense of where you see the biggest opportunities for growth inside that franchise, since it has quite a few components — some in the advice channel, some leaning more toward fees, and some tied more to the balance sheet. You've already pointed to the U.S. as a place to expand, so I'd like to hear, from your vantage point, which pieces matter most to get right. That would help us grasp how you intend to shape this business from here. Thank you.
Jane Fraser
executiveExcellent question, Betsy. Mark and I are both grinning, since I'd say the answer covers all of it. If we unpack it, where are the different sources of upside? A significant rebound is coming in Asia. You saw it in our results last year, and among peers with an Asian tilt broadly, that region took a heavy hit from COVID in China, the lockdowns, and a slower exit from COVID there relative to Asia overall and to the U.S. So we anticipate some thrilling growth prospects from the plain fundamentals in Asia across the region. You're certainly right about the U.S., where we begin at a smaller scale; we've been uniting the various pieces of that business. The wealth of work franchises, one that's enjoyed especially gratifying growth. We've likewise seen solid growth as we assembled a comprehensive offering for our customers. The largest upside there lies in the investment product; and I'd argue we have a robust balance sheet franchise, so to speak, especially deposits, some margin lending and the like, mortgages, yet the real story is the investment offering in the states. Lastly, I'd point to enormous opportunity in the synergies too, and we've been demonstrating this through the connections among our commercial bank, our banking franchise, the referrals coming up from U.S. Personal Banking. We've recorded roughly 60,000 referrals this year in the U.S. by itself. Beyond that, market also delivers important results and even TTS. So with client referrals, there are business synergies across common platforms; thus we truly see a chance for these multidimensional growth drivers in wealth on top of the investment space recovery that everyone in the market ought to gain from. And we'll keep investing — appropriately — in developing that front line too. So this is a hugely important piece of our strategy; we're enthusiastic about it. This is also a crucial element of how our business composition will evolve down the road, when we consider the medium term. Plus, we're eager about the upcoming stage of expansion and the attention it will get here.
Betsy Graseck
analystWould you characterize the money that needs to be spent to capture those revenue opportunities as probably speeding up from this point, or has that spending already happened, meaning the investment is now flatter rather than rising?
Jane Fraser
executiveWell, consider that in the conditions we face right now, as we've noted — both Mark and I have said this going back to roughly the midpoint of last year — we're managing the pace of this, yet we keep putting money in behind you. That expansion shows up in our client advisors. And keep in mind that the net increase in client advisors reflects the divestiture we completed in Uruguay, as an example. So it's quite robust. There isn't a tremendous amount we still need to put in, since a lot of the platform's components are already there, and the task has mostly involved bringing them together, then ensuring the correct digital and other spending sits behind them, though that outlay isn't especially big for realizing the business's upside. And we'll adjust the pace of it to fit market conditions. Mark, anything you'd like to add?
Mark Mason
executiveThe one thing I'd mention — Betsy, as you're aware — is that during a typical stretch of the cycle, this business delivers high margins and high returns; that's something we've witnessed before. So our goal is to be positioned well for the moment the market shifts, having added client advisors and having drawn in new clients via client acquisitions, which rose 24% in 2022. So I believe we're set up well for that. That said, as Jane said, considering where we stand, we need to be prudent regarding how the dollars get deployed; therefore we'll swap that out when needed, but make sure we're prepared for the point when things turn.
Jane Fraser
executiveAlso, let me mention that the strategy was unveiled and we began carrying it out a few years back. As a result, we're benefiting from those past investments, and the factors behind them are performing nicely, as I mentioned. So once the market shifts, we ought to be in a strong position.
Matt O'Connor
analystHello. I’d like to build on what was said regarding markets staying fairly level in ’23. Clearly, the fourth quarter was quite strong; and I realize I had worries about certain aspects of RWA management and FICC over the last few quarters; and I believe, looking back, that won’t be a problem when you consider leadership and revenue; but when you look ahead to ’23, the wallets have been robust for several years now. And as you mentioned, your leadership was solid this year. How much conviction do you have in that roughly unchanged market? And perhaps what’s behind that expectation? Thanks.
Mark Mason
executiveThis is a market-dependent business, correct; and so you’re well aware of the swings that any markets business can experience. That said, our FICC franchise is extremely, extremely strong. We enjoyed a strong year, a strong year this year. I believe we’re well positioned with our client base, and we’re well positioned to keep our number one spot as we head into 2023. Now, the way that market and market wallet shifts, I think, will hinge on several factors, among them how the macro keeps developing and how central bank actions keep developing and how currencies fluctuate and so forth. But once again, I feel we’re well positioned to preserve our standing, or even pick up additional share as that unfolds. And so I think level compared to a year in which we were up as substantially as we were, is a sensible assessment given what we know at this point.
Jane Fraser
executiveBeyond that, we've noticed certain pockets of this business that had been performing well are now somewhat subdued. Take equity derivatives, for instance — that was genuinely the standout area, an equity derivative year. So there's a bit of that, plus the corporate segment, given all the volatility coming from the macro geopolitical backdrop, is another place where we're genuinely strong. Whether that's good or bad, we anticipate that strength carrying on, at least based on what we've seen up to this point.
Matt O'Connor
analystAll right, thanks.
Jim Mitchell
analystHi there — morning to you, or afternoon.
Mark Mason
executiveAfternoon.
Jim Mitchell
analystMark, I want to dig into NII for a moment. Looking at 4Q on an annualized basis, there's a fairly meaningful step down. Yet if you examine your deposit franchise and the mix of business against your peers — where they're likely facing retail deposits in the U.S. that are lagging, and pricing that will weigh on second half NII — you folks already run high betas, largely institutional. You brought up the benefit from non-U.S. rates, and deposits are growing. So why would NII follow a similar trend to peers when your dynamic is pretty different? I'm just trying to work through that, because the legacy drag doesn't appear very large in your chart.
Mark Mason
executiveAre you saying similar dynamics in '23, or are you referring to the fourth quarter? I'm not certain I followed.
Jim Mitchell
analystNo, what I'm doing is comparing you with others in the industry. A few of them have issued guidance that's also down from the annualized run rates of the fourth quarter, yet your situation is quite distinct when it comes to growth in deposits, gains from rates outside America, and a beta that's significantly larger.
Mark Mason
executiveRight. So on the NII front, I suppose there are a few points I'd highlight that apply specifically to us. First, and this matters, as you noted and as I brought up, if you look at how our deposits are mixed, roughly 65% sit in ICG, while the remaining 35% are in our PBWM business. We definitely lean toward the U.S. dollar, though around 30% is non-U.S. dollar. When I consider what's possible, along with the forward curves and the way rates are probably going to shift in the coming year, we stand to gain from additional hikes on the non-U.S. side, correct. So if I look at where we operate internationally, betas are generally lower than what we see in the U.S., including within our Corporate Clients segment. That leads me to believe there are re-pricing chances we'll keep managing in an active way, just as we've done in the U.S. So I really do believe that global footprint, the worldwide reach of our franchise, works in our favor for 2023. Another point that's clear to us as we put together this forecast is that volumes keep growing. With that volume growth, you've already witnessed momentum building on the card side, with considerable expansion in interest-earning balances; we'd anticipate that carrying on, especially as NCLs return to normal and payment rates begin to ease; so I'd say those will be two key drivers. Mix clearly matters too. As you mentioned, we'll be growing past some of the drag or decline tied to legacy, but it's the active management of client engagement that we have across both portfolios, which I believe will be crucial elements in us achieving the growth I described.
Jim Mitchell
analystUnderstood, that’s reasonable. Perhaps I didn’t word my question correctly, though.
Mark Mason
executiveWhat I meant was that excluding markets, I believe your 2013 projection would come in below the fourth-quarter run rate outside of markets, and still you just— Mark Mason: Apologies, go ahead and finish what you were asking. My apologies.
Jim Mitchell
analystOkay, you just laid out several factors that make your franchise somewhat distinct. So I'm just attempting to understand what is causing the drop from the 4Q figures.
Mark Mason
executiveWhat you need to recognize, I believe, is essentially the legacy franchise along with the NII. If you examine the product mix and the client base we serve in that area, a significant portion of legacy franchise revenues consists of NII revenues. Therefore, I believe that represents the key piece here—one we haven't put a specific dollar figure on, yet it accounts for why growth appears subdued compared with what you would have observed during the fourth quarter. Clearly, additional elements exist, but that one matters.
Analyst
analystI am Mark Hernandez <<inaudible>>.
Mark Mason
executiveGood afternoon.
Jane Fraser
executiveHello. Please proceed.
Analyst
analystMark, could you tell us about what you've said concerning — and this applies to others in your space too — how credit losses are returning to normal levels down the road, given that this sector has seen unbelievably small amounts of such losses? So, in terms of branded cards, retail sales, or retail services, what's your outlook on how that unfolds across '23? Someone else in your peer group mentioned that they believe by the close of '23 they might hit that normalized figure they use for their modeling; but I'm simply attempting to understand the path you all have in mind?
Jane Fraser
executiveRight. I'll step in first, then pass it over to Mark. Under the path we're on, my expectation is that loss rates will get back to where they were before COVID more toward the end of the year or the beginning of '24. Take branded cards — if I had to put a number on it, roughly 20% of the way there at present; for CRS, we're at approximately 40% of the way there at present. Naturally, in CRS we get an advantage from loss sharing arrangements with our partners, which works in our favor; but hopefully that provides some idea of where things stand. Perhaps the biggest factor we'd been uneasy about was how clear things were around payment rates; and I believe we now have far more clarity as those began moving toward normal. So that's creating considerably more confidence about which way things are heading. Honestly, the larger issue is what's going on with spending rather than the normalization at this point. That's where the greater uncertainty lies. Mark, anything else you'd add?
Mark Mason
executiveGerard, the one point I'd tack on is that, based on how things unfold, you might witness NCL rates rising past typical ranges and afterward declining back to typical ranges within the timeframe Jane outlined. Once more, it simply hinges on how the macro factors keep developing. That said, as we're sitting here discussing these NPL rates, it's worth highlighting too that our reserves are quite robust throughout every one of these portfolios. So in a sense, setting aside macro assumptions and setting aside volumes, those NPLs are essentially covered by the reserves already put in place. Even so, the trajectory is precisely what Jane laid out, only acknowledging that a rise past typical ranges could occur and then it would fall back down.
Jane Fraser
executiveAdditionally, what makes this market so atypical is that the labor market's strength stems, candidly, from a shortage of supply as much as from demand; on top of that, consumers still hold very substantial savings that they're drawing down, and we're noticing somewhat more activity taking place at the lowest end of everything; even so, this won't resemble a typical recession. That's the reason you're marking time here, since what will matter for everyone else is how manageable and how mild it proves—assuming one does arrive.
Analyst
analystAlso, when you’re planning for that sort of path, what unemployment levels are you assuming? Do we reach 5% unemployment in the first quarter of ’24?
Mark Mason
executiveThere are a few points there. First, our base case, considering what we’ve just discussed, incorporates a mild recession, and based on how we projected it, the downside case would be somewhat worse than that. I’d say we’ve set aside reserves for an unemployment rate of roughly 5%, broadly speaking, when you take the average across the various scenarios we’ve modeled.
Ken Usdin
analystHello, and thank you. I have a pair of brief items to ask about. The first concerns cards — the card NIM has remained more or less level. Obviously, that ties back to the way you assign funding to it internally, I realize. Still, could you walk us through what is going on with rewards, or with the rates being offered on certain newly added relationships? And is expansion in the card NIM something we ought to expect going forward?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. Ken, I won't offer any sort of steer on NIM. What I can tell you is that during the opening stretch of this year, we've recorded solid momentum when it comes to card acquisitions. That momentum has been quite strong; and Jane, perhaps you'd like to speak to the nature of our ties with certain partners and with American; on top of that, we've brought out several new offerings that I believe are contributing to the expansion we've posted following those investments, along with part of the rise we've recorded in spend rates and part of the growth in average interest-earning balances and loans that we've posted. That said, at this moment I truly have no interest in discussing NIM direction either for cards or on a consolidated basis.
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely. We possess, you know, an outstanding cards business. And whenever we examine the impressive history in digital, plus the additional innovations fueling expansion, fueling profitability, fueling returns across both our own products and our partners, we're truly witnessing every one of those forces performing extremely well right now. Regarding custom cash, it accounted for 28% of new account acquisition. So that's a significant new product refresh pushing things forward, with 80% of customers interacting digitally. Innovations such as America is simply a wonderful partner for us, genuinely elevating that to another level. And you can observe that through the rise in spend within the category; therefore, I believe there are plenty of reasons to feel quite enthusiastic about the increase in return, the margins, and the other trajectories here, and as I mentioned, a prime portfolio, which is always beneficial.
Ken Usdin
analystGreat, thank you. For my second question — there was a piece this week about a management change up in the wealth management business. I'm curious if you could speak to that, and also about how much progress you're making within wealth management against the KPIs and targets you laid out at Analyst Day. Thanks.
Jane Fraser
executiveSure. Two years ago, I asked MacDonald to assemble the wealth business out of the different pieces we had throughout the firm. Now we're entering the next phase, and as we've said, this is a strategically important business. I felt it was the right moment to bring in new leadership, also because Jim will have a significant role going forward, supporting Paco on the ICG strategy we presented at Investor Day. He holds many relationships with investors, family offices, private equity, sovereign wealth funds. Along with other investors, he'll be helping drive those forward to ensure we deliver the firm's full capabilities to these clients. So I believed the timing was right for this move. As we've indicated, we will strictly go out and search for the next leader of that business. In the interim, it's business as usual as we grow and stick to the strategy we have, and we're looking forward to the market turning, as I'm sure everyone is, and we feel we're well positioned for that.
Sheng Wang
analystHello, and good afternoon. Sheng Wang here, covering for Steven. Regarding credit, a peer of yours mentioned earlier today that under CECL, assuming 6% unemployment, they'd anticipate roughly an extra $6 billion in reserves. I was hoping you might offer a comparable sensitivity around reserve levels, and also help us understand how the provision trajectory should be viewed relative to the 4Q base, given your macro outlook along with possible growth math headwinds?
Mark Mason
executiveYes, thank you. I'll take that one. I won't attempt to walk through sensitivity scenarios with you off the cuff here. What I can tell you is that when we build these reserves, we do so against three scenarios — the base scenario I referenced, plus a downside scenario and an upside scenario — and we apply weightings to them. The base we used this quarter assumed a mild recession, and within that baseline, the unemployment assumption was roughly 4.4%, call it. We also had a downside scenario, where unemployment reached approximately 6.9%. Then there was an upside scenario as well. Across the quarters, the weighted average came to about the 5.1% I mentioned, and those factors fed into the reserve we set during the quarter. Broadly speaking, when you consider the weightings assigned to those scenarios, they skew toward the base and the downside. The reserve we established this quarter was mostly in the consumer business, PBWM, and specifically tied to cards. That really related, quarter-over-quarter, to the change in HPI. That said, it also reflects, as I noted earlier, a cards portfolio that is still of very good quality, with loss rates sitting well below where they'd land in a normal cycle. It also captures the volume growth we saw in that business during the quarter. So I won't run scenarios for you, but hopefully that provides some perspective on what sits beneath the models we used to set these reserves. And clearly, we do this quarter by quarter.
Jane Fraser
executiveThere's one more point I'd like to address, because it's an area where the firm is occasionally misunderstood — namely, what happens on the corporate credit side. Take a look at the portfolio of corporate clients we hold: you shouldn't assume that the places where we assume credit risk line up with where we operate around the world. On the international side, multinational companies along with their subsidiaries account for 90% of that exposure, and all of it — this is investment grade. So that strikes me as another spot where, when assessing how solid the corporate loan book is, the way you witnessed with Russia and other situations, our approach to reserves will be cautious; still, I believe it matters to grasp just where it is that we're actually taking on that corporate credit risk.
Sheng Wang
analystThat's very useful. Thank you. As a follow-up, it appears that a portion of your 2023 revenue goals hinges on certain environmental improvements. For instance, equity markets steadying, an IB rebound? And Jane, you also mentioned that the medium-term targets are built to be reachable across varying conditions. So, should the revenue backdrop stay difficult as it was in 2022, could you discuss a few of the levers available to you that could serve as an offset?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, it somewhat hinges on what the drivers are behind a different environment, correct. Since you might have — I'm not expecting this, but you might have ongoing strain in investment banking, yet you might also have ongoing swings in rates or currencies, and that could bring more upside than a flat result for the markets business. So, many puts and takes exist that one can scenario out. What I believe truly matters is that we hold a diversified set of businesses with strategic connectivity among them. Consequently, that permits us, when the environment changes in a manner we might not have foreseen, to frequently still generate substantial performance, just as we did this year. Thus, without specifying precisely how it will differ from the current situation, that is what provides our confidence regarding the guidance and truly to stay steadfast on the strategy we have discussed and really drive execution, and that is precisely what we are doing.
Jane Fraser
executiveAlso, a significant element of 2023 involves not only how the cycle affects things, but you'll likewise observe how the various investments we've been making affect things. And you've definitely witnessed that. Take services during this year, for instance, and we've been quite open regarding that 70 basis points gain; we've witnessed it in wallet share across the 12 months preceding the third quarter. So, what you have are not merely drivers related to market conditions, but additionally the strategic drivers are increasingly coming into play alongside each other, just as Mark mentioned regarding synergies.
Mark Mason
executiveJane, that’s a really good observation, since it might not consistently appear in the top line, and that’s exactly why we’ve shared those KPIs. Frequently, there are signals pointing to some of the potential gains that are still ahead as the market develops.
Jane Fraser
executiveHello.
Mike Mayo
analystHey Mike. I've got one question, plus a follow-up. On your slide, the CET1 target is 13% by the middle of the year, yet you're already at that level. Going back to the Banamex situation, does that target assume some possible capital effect from divestitures, or why set a goal six months out when you've already hit it?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. Mike, honestly, I'm a bit surprised Mexico is what you're asking about, considering how long we've worked together — but I get it. Here's what I'd say: there are a couple of points. First, we know exactly what our market valuation is, and it doesn't satisfy us. Given our approach, we believe we deserve a better trading position than the one we currently have. So whenever repurchasing shares becomes possible for us, we'll act on it immediately—that's one method we use to return value to those who own stock in the company. Regarding the second point: reaching 13% happened ahead of schedule, which once again reflected our success in carrying out the plan we set. In the segments we operate, especially our markets division, the team has performed strongly against the target we set for revenue relative to RWA. Reaching that goal hasn't come at the expense of the franchise, and that's evident in how that unit keeps performing well, above all in fixed income. Looking forward, as you correctly noted, there are several divestitures we still need to complete. There will be pluses and minuses among quite a few of them, yet Mexico especially is going to create a short-term effect on our CET1 ratio. Because of that, we need to keep this in mind while steering things through the coming two quarters, allowing us to take that in. We're also making sure we're set up to keep supporting our customers in the coming two quarters and beyond — but definitely through the next two quarters — as we handle the drag, which is temporary, coming from that departure. So I hope that clarifies things a bit, but this is something we're on top of. And we haven't taken our eye off how important it is to give capital back to shareholders.
Jane Fraser
executiveAbsolutely, and I’d like to emphasize that point too. It really matters a great deal to us. Like Mark mentioned, we’re fully aware of where our stock is trading. We’ve taken several steps to bring our compensation and management incentives in line with what benefits our shareholders, across all those different aspects. And we simply want to ensure we achieve what we’ve committed to doing and keep performing in line with what we’ve promised to deliver. With the CPA effect, mainly in Mexico, we want to be certain we’re factoring that in.
Mike Mayo
analystUnderstood, that's quite straightforward. Now turning to the final item, your net interest income outlook, leaving aside anything tied to markets, comes in higher for 2023, yet I believe that suggests a modest decline relative to where things stood in Q4 — though nowhere near the roughly 10% quarter-over-quarter drop that JPMorgan guided toward. My assumption was that there could be some lagging upside from operations beyond the United States. Could you walk through the various puts and takes?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. There are several elements at play here. First, we aren't going to experience the same net interest income trajectory that 2022 delivered, since betas are beginning to climb within ICG and are approaching their terminal levels — that will naturally dampen or weigh on pricing as we move through '23. That said, a few other significant growth engines remain. One is the full-year effect of the rate increases that took place toward the end of last year, which becomes a tailwind for 2023. You'll additionally observe, as I noted previously, certain rate moves we expect beyond the U.S., and because of how our business is mixed, that works in our favor during 2023. On top of that, volume will play a role in driving that net interest income expansion, especially given the solid momentum we keep seeing and expect to keep seeing on the card front. The counterweight comes from the legacy franchise; as those exits and wind-downs proceed, as I said before, the revenue composition tilts more heavily toward net interest income. Consequently, we must expand past that baseline, and we will expand past it in order to reach the objective we've established. So those represent the favorable and unfavorable factors.
Jen Landis
executiveI appreciate all of you taking the time to be with us here. Should anything else come to mind afterward, feel free to get in touch with our IR team. Wishing you all a wonderful day. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThat brings an end to this Citi earnings review call for the fourth quarter of 2022. You are free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.