Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 14, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jen Landis
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, everyone, and thanks for being here. Just a quick note that the deck we're using today — you can grab it from our site, citigroup.com — might include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects and they come with uncertainty and shifting circumstances. There are many factors, including the ones laid out in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings, that could cause actual results to come in materially different from what those statements suggest. With that said, I'll hand things over to Jane.
Jane Fraser
executiveThanks, Jen, and hello everyone. This quarter may not have packed the same punch as the first one, but it certainly had its share of notable developments. The world economy is still showing impressive resilience, even though conditions vary considerably from one major market to another. With most of the tightening now completed, central banks are acting forcefully against inflation and have signaled plainly that the rate-hiking cycle has not finished. Over in the U.S., the constrained labor market keeps delaying when that hard-to-pin-down recession will arrive — now expected later in 2023 or into 2024 — while solid demand for services acts as a cushion for the economy. The Eurozone, too, has outperformed forecasts, yet many nations in that region face strain from labor and energy expenses that undermine longer-term competitiveness. China stands out as the largest letdown, since growth slowed following an initial bump once reopening occurred. I visited there last month, and suffice it to say that hardly anyone on the ground anticipates China will propel worldwide growth this year to the degree some had anticipated. So, to sum up: around the globe, the quite difficult macroeconomic landscape we encountered in the first quarter persists. At Citi, we keep realizing the advantages of a diversified business model and a solid balance sheet; we stay intently focused on carrying out our strategy and on making our bank simpler and more modern. Even with the volatility and macro conditions during the first half, we are progressing according to the plan presented at Investor Day, and we stay dedicated to that strategy along with our medium-term RoTCE goal. This day, we posted net income of $2.9 billion alongside EPS of $1.33. Our revenues ex divestures are roughly unchanged versus a year ago, and we are still positioned to hit revenue guidance of $78 billion to $79 billion for the year. We are likewise set to achieve this year's expense guidance and, in line with what we outlined at Investor Day, we are chasing cost-saving chances to help counterbalance major transformation investments; within services, TTS keeps performing well, with revenues climbing a solid 15%. That came from both net interest income and noninterest revenue as we secure fee-generating mandates from new clients while strengthening ties with existing large corporate and commercial customers. We take pride in holding the #1 ranking among large institutional clients, and this week we unveiled our newest innovation, CitiDirect Commercial Banking — a digital platform enabling our expanding commercial clients to access our worldwide network. Security Services revenues likewise rose 15%, fueled by higher interest rates spanning currencies. We are genuinely happy with how this business is executing as we keep adding new assets under custody and administration, which have grown by roughly $2.4 trillion over the past year. We picked up 100 basis points of share year-over-year thanks to the investments we have been making. Markets revenues fell 13%, measured against an exceptionally strong second quarter a year ago. Starting in early April, as the debt ceiling situation unfolded, our clients stayed on the sidelines, and throughout the quarter we kept seeing extremely low volatility. Even so, corporate client flows have stayed robust, and once again this quarter we hit our medium-term revenue to RWA target; within Banking, momentum in investment-grade debt has carried over into other DCM products, yet the rebound in Investment Banking that everyone has been waiting for still hasn't arrived, and it was a disappointing quarter both in terms of the wallet and our own results, with Investment Banking revenues falling 24%. We keep rightsizing the business to fit the environment while investing in select areas like technology and healthcare. In the U.S., our cards businesses combined delivered double-digit revenue growth, helped by customer engagement and payment rates continuing to normalize. In Branded Cards, spend remains solid in travel and entertainment, and acquisitions are still pretty healthy; this is a terrific franchise, and we've rolled out a whole set of new innovations, from overhauling our ThankYou rewards platform to the enhanced value proposition for the premium card with our long-time partner, American Airlines. Credit normalization is occurring more quickly in Retail Services because of the portfolio's profile; and on the whole, I'd describe the consumer as more cautious, though not necessarily recessionary. Wealth revenues dropped 5% as the business keeps getting hit by the deposit mix shift, especially in the Private Bank, and by lower investment revenues; even so, activity has picked up somewhat in Asia for 2 quarters, with net new assets growing. Referrals coming from the U.S. retail banks are rising, and globally, new client acquisition in the Private Bank and Wealth at Work has increased substantially, supported by our investments in our network of client advisers and bankers. Now to expenses. As we expected, they were elevated this quarter. That includes the extra repositioning actions we took to rightsize certain businesses and functions given the current environment. So far this year, severance comes to roughly $450 million, with $200 million of that in the quarter. Apart from repositioning, we're still committed to bending our expense curve by the end of '24 via 3 significant efforts. First, we keep investing in our transformation and other risk and control initiatives, which are needed to modernize our infrastructure, automate our controls, and improve the client experience. As we've noted previously, the more material benefit from these investments will begin to show over the medium term. Second, through our simplification efforts, we anticipate closing the sales of our remaining 2 Asia consumer franchises by year-end, and we intend to restart the exit process in Poland. As this slide shows, we made excellent progress this quarter in the consumer businesses we're winding down, helped by material asset sales. And now we're going after stranded costs and closing out the TSAs in the markets we've already exited. You witnessed how committed we are to getting things done when we chose to take Banamex public following our review of a possible sale. The work of fully splitting the 2 businesses apart ought to wrap up next year so we're ready for the IPO; and the advances being made on the ground please me. Acceptance testing on the new systems for the retained businesses is just about to get underway. Because of all this, by the time the year ends — given how far the divestitures and wind-downs have come — legacy franchises will have cut its exposures substantially and will mainly be limited to Mexico, Poland, Korea, plus eliminating whatever stranded costs remain. So as we progress through the back half of the year, we'll be able to turn our attention to the third leg, which is lowering our expense base via a leaner organizational model. These 3 efforts, taken together, explain why we can say with confidence that on an absolute basis we will begin bending the curve by the close of 2024 and keep reducing expenses across the medium term. Let me finish with capital. Well, it won't surprise you that the bump to our stress capital buffer left us disappointed. We've been in active discussions with the Fed so we can better grasp where our model and theirs diverge on noninterest revenue. And the whole industry is waiting for more clarity on capital requirements and, just as important, when they'll be implemented, coming out of the holistic review the regulators have carried out and the anticipated Basel III endgame NPR. What the final rules will look like remains uncertain. And we, in common with the rest of the industry, will have to work through what they mean. Leaving 14 international consumer markets, combined with what our transformation investments have produced and a shift in business mix, will help bring our capital ratios down. On top of that, we hold other levers we can pull as time goes on, including capital allocation, DTA utilization, our G-SIB score and our management buffer of 100 basis points; we remain dedicated to giving capital back to our shareholders, as you saw when we decided to repurchase $1 billion in common stock and raise the dividend. We closed the second quarter with a CET1 ratio of 13.3%. That's 100 basis points above the requirements we'll soon face, after having returned a total of $2 billion in capital, and we lifted our tangible book value per share to $85.34. Considering the environment, we'll keep reviewing how much capital we return on a quarter-to-quarter basis. On the whole, the progress we've achieved pleases us, but plenty of work is left. We'll keep updating you each quarter on how things are going; and with that, I'd like to hand things over to Mark, and then the two of us would be delighted, as always, to take your questions.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks, Jane, and hello everybody. I'll begin by covering the company-wide financials, looking at how the second quarter compared with the same period a year earlier unless I say otherwise, and I'll take a bit more time on costs and capital. After that, I'll go through what each segment delivered. Turning to Slide 4, you can see the financials for the entire firm. For Q2, net income came in at about $2.9 billion, alongside EPS of $1.33 and an RoTCE of 6.4%, on revenues of $19.4 billion. Those figures include roughly $92 million in after-tax impacts tied to divestitures. Once you strip those out, EPS stood at $1.37 and RoTCE was 6.6%. For the quarter, overall revenues were down 1%, and that holds true whether you look at reported figures or strip out divestiture-related effects. Gains in services, U.S. Personal Banking, and investment portfolio revenue weren't enough to counter drops in Markets, Investment Banking, and Wealth, plus the lower revenue tied to closed exits and wind-downs. On expenses, we recorded $13.6 billion, a 9% increase, again the same on a reported basis and when excluding divestiture-related costs. Cost of credit came to roughly $1.8 billion, mostly reflecting continued normalization in cards net credit losses and ACL builds that were largely tied to growth in card balances. This quarter, our effective tax rate came in at 27%, largely because of where our pretax earnings were generated geographically. If you set aside the impacts tied to divestitures in the current quarter, that rate would have been 26%. We closed the quarter with total reserves north of $20 billion, and our ratio of reserves to funded loans stood at roughly 2.7%. For the first half of 2023, our reported RoTCE was 8.7%. Turning to Slide 5, we break down how expenses changed both quarter over quarter and year over year for the second quarter. Our costs rose by 9%, and several things contributed to that. We put more money into risk and controls, made both business-led and enterprise-led investments, and saw volume growth along with macro pressures such as inflation and severance. Productivity gains helped counterbalance this, along with lower spending resulting from the exits and wind-downs. Severance for the quarter came to roughly $200 million, and it reached $450 million for the year so far, since we took additional steps in Investment Banking, Markets and the functions. We are putting money behind carrying out our transformation, and our spending keeps moving away from third-party consulting toward technology and full-time employees. During the prior quarter's call, we outlined the areas where our transformation and technology funding is concentrated: making platforms and processes simpler; modernizing security and infrastructure; improving what clients experience; and upgrading data. Within those areas, technology spending reached $3 billion this quarter, a 13% increase, mostly because of change the bank expenditures. Even with a larger sequential expense base, we're still tracking toward our guidance for the entire year of about $54 billion, not counting divestiture-related impacts or the FDIC special assessment. Slide 6 covers net interest income, deposits and loans; my comments there will focus on quarter-over-quarter changes. Net interest income for the second quarter rose roughly $550 million, with dividends accounting for most of that. Higher rates and expansion in cards drove most of the increase in net interest income excluding Markets, though the shift in mix toward deposit products with higher rates inside PBWM partly offset that. Average loans were flat, as PBWM growth got offset by the wind-down of markets and a decline in ICG amid our continued optimization of the loan portfolio, which included another reduction in subscription credit facilities. A 2% drop in average deposits occurred, largely tied to TTS, where we saw some nonoperational outflow that we had anticipated given quantitative tightening. Despite that, underneath it all, operating accounts grew robustly as we continue onboarding new clients and deepening relationships with existing ones. Net interest margin, meanwhile, increased 7 basis points. Slide 7 covers the main credit metrics for consumers and corporations. For the current climate, we carry strong reserves — more than $20 billion in total. The ratio of reserves to funded loans came in at about 2.7%. U.S. Cards accounts for 7.9% of that. Inside PBWM, U.S. Cards makes up 44% of lending exposures, and within that, 80% is owed by customers with FICOs of at least 680. Meanwhile, NCL rates stay below where they were before COVID and are moving toward normal in line with our expectations. The remaining 56% of PBWM lending exposure sits largely in Wealth, mainly Mortgages and margin lending. Across our ICG portfolio, investment grade represents about 85% of total exposure. On the international side, roughly 90% is either investment grade or tied to multinational customers or their affiliates. Corporate nonaccrual loans remain modest, sitting near 44 basis points of total loans. This page lays out our commercial real estate lending exposures split between ICG and PBWM, totaling $66 billion, and 90% of that is investment grade. So even with an uncertain macro and geopolitical environment, we remain quite confident in our asset quality, our exposures and our reserve levels, and we keep reviewing and stress-testing the portfolio under many different scenarios. Turning to Slide 8, you'll see an overview of our balance sheet, plus the main capital and liquidity figures. Ours remains a very robust balance sheet at $2.4 trillion, supported in part by a $1.3 trillion deposit base that's well diversified across regions, industries, customers and account types, and that gets put to work in high-quality, diversified assets. The way our balance sheet is built reflects both our strategy and our well-diversified business model. We leverage our distinctive assets and capabilities to serve corporates, financial institutions, investors and individuals who have needs around the world. Institutional and operational deposits make up the bulk of what we hold — $818 billion — and they span 90 countries; on top of those institutional deposits, we have $427 billion in U.S. retail consumer and global wealth deposits, which you can see in the bottom right portion of the page. We're sitting on roughly $584 billion in HQLA, alongside about $661 billion in loans, and when you add it all up, our total liquidity resources come to a bit under $1 trillion. The LCR held steady at 119%, while our net stable funding ratio finished above 100%. When the quarter ended, the CET1 ratio was 13.3%, and tangible book value per share reached $85.34 — that's a 6% gain versus the same period a year ago; on Slide 9, there's a sequential CET1 walk that gives you a closer look at the drivers behind this quarter's changes. Starting from where we ended the first quarter, net income to common was $2.6 billion, which added 22 basis points. Next, we gave back $2 billion through common dividends along with share repurchases, and that pulled things down by roughly 18 basis points. Then the last piece, a decline of 15 basis points, came mainly from RWA growth as card balances kept expanding, partly offset by RWA optimization in Markets and Corporate Lending. Our CET1 capital ratio at quarter end was 13.3%, and that figure includes a 100 basis point internal management buffer; we anticipate a regulatory capital requirement of 12.3% for October of 2023, reflecting the bump in our stress capital buffer from 4% up to the preliminary SCB of 4.3% that we announced a couple of weeks ago. And we'll keep talking with the Fed to gain a clearer picture of why their model's results differ from ours, particularly when it comes to noninterest revenue.
Mark Mason
executiveHaving said that, our approach is built to broaden what our business is made up of even more, so that revenue comes in a steadier, more forecastable and repeatable way, while also lowering risk and making our company simpler by pulling out of 14 consumer markets outside the U.S. Together, that strategy and the streamlining, plus what we gain from our transformation spending, will let us strengthen RWA and capital as time goes on. Continuing to fine-tune our balance sheet ought to benefit SCB and bring RWA down as well. That will help counter part of the headwinds we expect around capital requirements and RWA. And we'll keep reexamining how and where capital gets put to work, and we'll keep reexamining what the right size of our management buffer should be as time passes; turning to Slide 10, we present the second quarter results for our Institutional Clients Group. This quarter, revenues fell 9% since growth in services was more than outweighed by Markets and Banking. Expenses rose 13%, largely because of ongoing investment in TTS along with risk and controls, plus roughly $120 million of severance tied to Investment Banking and Markets, partly offset by productivity savings. Cost of credit came to $58 million, with net credit losses partly offset by an ACL release; that produced net income of about $2.2 billion, a 45% decline, mostly from lower revenues and higher expenses. For the quarter, ICG posted an RoTCE of 9.2%, and 11.4% across the first half of 2023. Average loans dropped 6%, which speaks to discipline regarding our strategy and returns. Average deposits rose 1% as we keep bringing on new clients and going deeper with the ones we already have. On Slide 11, we present how revenue performed by business and the main drivers we described at Investor Day. Over at Treasury and Trade Solutions, we saw a 15% rise in revenues, with net interest income up 18% and noninterest revenue up 8%. Also worth mentioning is that on an ex FX basis, TTS revenues were up 20%. The underlying drivers at TTS remain solid, reflecting consistently strong client activity: U.S. dollar clearing volumes were up 6% in the quarter and also 6% in the first half; cross-border flows grew 11%, outpacing global GDP growth, again both for the quarter and the first half; and commercial card volume was up roughly 15%, driven by travel spend. And in fact, similar to recent quarters, client wins are up about 41% across all client segments. A number of those are flagship deals where we serve as the client's main operating bank. Over at Security Services, revenue also climbed 15%, driven by stronger net interest income across various currencies. We're pleased with the direction of Security Services as we continue bringing on assets under custody and administration, which are up about 11%, or $2.4 trillion, and we're feeling pretty optimistic about the pipeline for new deals in that business. Just to reiterate, the services businesses are central to our strategy and rank among our two higher-returning businesses, with significant synergies across the entire firm. Turning to our businesses: Markets revenue fell 13%, with declines in both fixed income and equities compared with an outstanding quarter a year ago, plus muted volatility during this period. Fixed income came in 13% lower, since gains in our rates franchise were outweighed by reduced currencies and commodities results. Equities dropped 10%, mainly because equity derivatives declined; even so, in line with our strategy, prime balances keep expanding thanks to client wins. Corporate client flows are still robust and steady, and we keep delivering good progress on our revenue-to-RWA component. Then Banking revenue, once you exclude gains and losses on loan hedges, declined 22%, led by Investment Banking as elevated macro uncertainty keeps weighing on client activity, along with weaker Corporate Lending revenue. Although our pipeline stays solid and we observe early signs of activity, we know additional effort is needed in ECM and M&A; even so, we think the investments we've directed toward health care and technology coverage will pay off eventually. So on the whole, though conditions in the market stay difficult and more remains to be done, we are advancing our strategy within ICG. Moving now to Slide 12, where we present results for our Personal Banking and Wealth Management segment. We saw revenue increase by 6%, driven by a 7% gain in net interest income, which was partially offset by a 6% decline in noninterest revenue due to lower investment product revenue in Wealth. Expenses were up 5%, primarily from investments in risk and control. Cost of credit came to $1.6 billion, driven by higher net credit losses as our card portfolios continue to normalize, along with a reserve build of about $335 million, largely related to card balance growth. Average loans were up 7%, with support from cards, Mortgages and installment lending. Average deposits decreased 1%, mainly because Wealth clients shifted cash into fixed income investments on our platform. Personal Banking and Wealth Management delivered a return on tangible common equity of 5.5%, both for this quarter and throughout the first six months of 2023, reflecting to a large extent the challenging environment for Wealth along with higher credit costs; Slide 13 provides a breakdown of PBWM revenue by product, along with the main business drivers and metrics. Revenue from Branded Cards increased 8%, driven primarily by higher net interest income; the fundamental drivers remain solid, as new account acquisitions climbed 6%, card spend volumes grew 4% and average loans were up 14%. Retail Services revenue surged 27%, helped by increased net interest income and lower partner payments. Taking the two card divisions together, payment rates continue to decline, and combined with the investments we've been making, that drove a 17% increase in interest-earning balances for Branded Cards and 12% for Retail Services. Retail Banking revenue was down 9%, which reflects the movement of relationships and the associated deposits over to our Wealth business. And consistent with our strategy, we continue to leverage our retail network, generating 25,000 Wealth referrals year-to-date through May, an 18% gain versus a year ago. Wealth revenues dropped 5% on account of persistent investment fee pressures and elevated deposit costs, particularly within the Private Bank. Wealth at Work revenues, however, climbed more than 30%, driven by solid lending performance, primarily in Mortgages. In the second quarter, we saw a 1% drop in client advisers, which is a reflection of how we're pacing our strategic hiring. At the same time, new client acquisitions were up almost 40% in the Private Bank and roughly 60% in Wealth at Work. There's obviously still more to do in Wealth, but the underlying drivers are showing solid momentum. Slide 14 covers how our legacy franchises performed. Revenue was down 1%, since the lift from higher rates and volumes in Mexico was outweighed by declines tied to closed consumer exits and wind-downs; worth pointing out that Mexico's revenue grew 22%, or 10% ex FX. Expenses came down 2%, largely because of closed consumer exits and wind-downs. If you strip out divestiture-related impacts, expenses were down 8%. Slide 15 contains our Corporate/Other second-quarter performance. The investment portfolio generated more net revenue, which was the main reason for the revenue rise. Costs went up as well, due to inflation and severance. Turning to Slide 16, I'll give a quick overview of what we expect for the third quarter and for all of 2023.
Mark Mason
executiveOur full-year revenue outlook stays at $78 billion to $79 billion, leaving out the impacts tied to 2023 divestitures, even though the mix has moved around a bit. For the whole year, we're raising our net interest income forecast from $45 billion to just over $46 billion, excluding Markets, with that gain offset by softer noninterest revenue, mostly from Investment Banking and Wealth; meanwhile our expense outlook holds at about $54 billion, again excluding 2023 divestiture-related impacts and the FDIC special assessment. Card net credit losses ought to keep normalizing over the rest of the year, with both portfolios hitting normalized levels by year-end; and we now anticipate a full-year tax rate near 25%, excluding discrete items and divestiture-related impacts. Turning to the third quarter, we expect ongoing momentum with clients, among them fees and the benefits of U.S. and non-U.S. rates on NII. We also expect expenses to rise sequentially, pushed by ongoing investments in transformation and risk and controls. Card net credit losses ought to keep normalizing as expected. And our effective tax rate for the quarter should come in near 25%, excluding discrete items and divestiture-related impacts; on buybacks, we'll keep deciding that quarter by quarter. Before we get to Q&A, I want to close with a few points. We keep carrying out the strategy of simplifying our firm, bettering our revenue mix and lowering both expenses and capital over time. We see strong momentum in the underlying drivers across most of our businesses and, as we noted at Investor Day, the financial path won't be a straight line, yet we stay focused on hitting our medium-term RoTCE target; and with that, Jane and I are glad to take your questions.
Glenn Schorr
analystI'm really interested in this whole revenue-to-RWA issue, particularly given some of the shifts that are on the way. So perhaps you could shed a bit more light on, say, the additional cutback in the subscription credit facility. I believe I came across something saying that was roughly an $80 billion book reduced to $20 billion. Feel free to fix that if I've got it wrong. But typically, those are large, significant clients that have relationship lending arrangements tied to them. So I want to know how you weigh the capital advantage, the obvious capital advantage, against the effect on clients and what your thinking is there. Are there other business blocks currently in motion?
Mark Mason
executiveThank you, Glenn. I appreciate the question. Well, there are a few points regarding that. First, we've been extremely focused on the revenue-to-RWA metric within our Markets business, and across the ICG more widely too. And we've achieved substantial progress there. That matters because the way we deploy the balance sheet and making sure we're optimizing its use helps us enhance returns over time. You're correct to mention the subscription facility, credit facility, lending that we provide; we lowered that quite dramatically. The figures you mention are considerably bigger than the portfolio. But the key thing here is that when we examine that, we consider a few factors. First, the character of the relationship and whether clients are leveraging the full range of what we can provide; second, the profitability and returns tied to the product, to the degree that it sits within a wider relationship, and where those returns are weak, below standard and the potential for doing more has turned out to be unproductive, we reduce it. And that's what we've done with a substantial portion of that book, just as we set it against other chances to deploy balance sheet where clients are using the broader franchise and consequently, are producing better returns; and we'll keep doing that; we've done so to boost the revenue-to-RWA metric. We've done it selectively on parts of the portfolio such as SCF; we've also examined our wider Corporate Lending portfolio and where those pledges of stronger relationship returns aren't showing up, we haven't renewed those loans. And as we consider upcoming regulatory changes, taking these actions proactively becomes extremely important. When I reflect on what we've done over the past couple of years, we've cut RWA by around $120 billion across the last 2 years. And roughly 75% of that is mostly due to balance sheet optimization and reviewing client activity that involves low-margin business. So it's vital for us to continue doing what we've been doing.
Glenn Schorr
analystThanks for that, Mark. I'd like to ask one more quick thing. Regarding NII, I raised this same point three months ago. Your first-half annualized figure, excluding Markets, is roughly $1.5 billion above what the guidance suggested. Is that simply because of how unpredictable all the moving pieces are, and you're trying to stay cautious? Or is there something else about the second half you have in mind?
Mark Mason
executiveAppreciate it, Glenn. Right, we raised the guidance to slightly higher than $46 billion, up from $45 billion. I suppose a few factors are at play, and this is excluding Markets, naturally. A few items deserve consideration when it comes to the headwinds and tailwinds flowing through that number. First, you've previously heard me bring up that terminal betas have been reached in the U.S.; second, deposit volumes along with the shift in mix as consumers move toward products offering higher returns and higher yields; and third, the wind-downs, exits, and reduction, which will affect NII. So when we consider the forecast and the rest of the year, those represent 3 headwinds. Clearly, some possible tailwinds exist on the opposite side, among them rate movements in non-U.S. dollar terms and growth in card volume. Taking those headwinds and tailwinds into account, our present view is to raise it, though $46 billion or a bit more seems like the appropriate figure when total revenues are between $78 million and $79 billion.
Jim Mitchell
analystPerhaps we could turn to costs. Mexico is now staying with you until at least 2025. That means it remains on the books for a longer stretch. How should we frame that bend-the-curve conversation? And in particular, could you help us think through bending the curve for the businesses that aren't legacy? Are we starting to see — is Q4 merely a slowdown or a sequential step down? Should we think of it in year-over-year terms? I just want to be sure I grasp the entire bend-the-curve idea and how to approach it.
Mark Mason
executiveThanks. I'll handle that one. A few points from me. First, I'd restate the expense guidance we provided for the full year. That's about $54 billion excluding divestitures, or the effect of divestitures, and excluding any effect from the FDIC special assessment. Second, when it comes to bending the curve, I'm looking at 2024 and our aim is to lower absolute expense dollars from Q3 to Q4. So that bending of the curve is going to happen. It will happen even with Mexico still inside the franchise. Clearly, Mexico still being there affects how large the bend is, but the bend from Q3 to Q4 will happen. After that, across the medium term, we expect the curve to keep bending. Once again, Mexico affects how large the bend is, but we're extremely, extremely focused on reducing our costs and bending that curve. You've also heard us talk about the parts or elements of our business that help drive that, not the least of which are the exits, and Mexico is one of them — you mentioned the timing there — plus the gains from the investments we've been making in transformation, risk and controls, and moving away from manual processes toward technology-enabled ones. The last piece concerns simplifying our organization. As you heard in Jane's prepared remarks, as we keep making progress on those exits, it creates the opportunity for us to push harder into that simplification. So our focus is on both the guidance and the bending of the curve, as you note, and we look forward to delivering that and taking steps to make sure we do.
Jim Mitchell
analystSo, to build on that, when you think about 2025 and afterward, as much of the automation across the non-legacy operations gets completed and you become far more efficient in those areas, can we say there's a clear story of absolute expense reduction in the core business? Or does that depend more on — you need revenue growth in order to achieve better returns?
Mark Mason
executiveOnce more, it will come from both continuing to bend the curve and lowering our costs. Clearly, we've provided guidance on operating efficiency of less than 60%, and some of that will come from top line growth, but it's the 2 combined.
Betsy Graseck
analystLet me just verify something regarding CET1. There's a 100 basis point buffer you hold above the regulatory minimums. That implies the 13.3% you reported this quarter matches where you intend to keep it moving forward. Is that accurate?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. You've got it right — we came in at 13.3% this quarter, slightly lower than the 13.4% from the prior quarter. Starting October 1, the 4.3% SCB takes effect. That works out to a 12.3% regulatory requirement when you assume the 100 basis point management buffer, and roughly a 13.3% target that we'd manage toward. A couple of points I want to flag that I'm certain are clear to you, Betsy. First, this stress capital buffer applies to the 12-month period that begins October 1. Second, the strategy we've laid out, discussed, and begun executing is deliberately built to help shift the business toward a steadier, more predictable, more consistent revenue stream, with growth in fee revenue, while also lowering our expenses over time and exiting these markets. Those efforts ought to help bring our stress capital buffer down over time and lift our returns; but to answer you directly, yes, the 13.3% would represent where we'd be aiming as of October 1, for the time being.
Betsy Graseck
analystAnd given that you said you're looking at buybacks one quarter at a time, I suppose what I want to ask is how I should weigh that against the fact that Basel endgame is due to come out before long, because obviously, when you sit at 13.3% versus the new rate cap SEB, you — it points to a larger chance for buybacks in the quarters ahead. So how am I meant to think about that?
Jane Fraser
executiveI'd say it lines up with what we've been saying. There's plenty of uncertainty around the new capital rules, both regarding what they'll look like and when they'll take effect. My sense is the industry anticipates greater clarity on that once the comment period arrives. On top of that, the macroeconomic backdrop is rather uncertain right now. So Mark and I both believe it's wise to keep doing that evaluation until some of this uncertainty gets resolved as to what exactly we'll do. You can be confident that we're at the levels, management buffer included, that we expect to hold for the remainder of the year. We've demonstrated a solid case of being able to build capital. That's certain over the last 2 years. And take comfort too, we raised the dividend; we returned $2 billion of capital in the prior quarter. So our intentions are plain when it comes to returning capital wherever we can, while also being prudent in how we go about it, given the environment and the regulatory uncertainty at present.
Mike Mayo
analystLet me ask one question on the downside and one on the upside. On the downside, you mentioned bending the cost curve, but in my view, for the second quarter on a year-over-year basis, it's bending in the incorrect direction. And you're saying that 6 quarters from now, it ought to bend the opposite way. So what is it that we aren't seeing in the financials that makes you so confident? Because judging by the results of this quarter, it feels a bit more like a story that requires trust. And on the upside, TTS kept up its double-digit growth. You keep putting more money into that business. In what ways are you monetizing greater money emotion with your multinational clients and your other clients?
Jane Fraser
executiveThank you, Mike. I'll start us off, and then I'll hand it over to Mark. On the expense side, I believe we've been extremely transparent regarding the arc of our investment spend tied to the transformation and to other things as well. We'll keep providing that transparency, Mike. During the prior year, we achieved our expense guidance. In the current year, we're on track for the guidance of approximately the $54 billion ex FDIC and divestitures; and going forward, we keep guiding on what the 3 levers are that will produce the reduction in the expense curve beginning at the close of '24. It comes from the exits, and I think you have a clear picture of the progress we've been making on the divestitures; and so, as we've discussed, we're pivoting to concentrate now on truly taking on the stranded expenses as we finish the last couple of sales there in Asia over the coming months; we'll capture the benefits from our investments in transformation and controls across the medium term; we'll also gain from the remediation work being completed and the expenses associated with it disappearing. And the third lever will be simplifying the organization, as we've discussed. So we'll keep walking you through, step by step, the various actions we're taking and what we're doing. And with luck, we're establishing that track record of doing what we say we will do each quarter. Mark, anything you'd like to add?
Mark Mason
executiveOn the cost front, there's just one more point I'd make, and after that you might want to address the TTS. So my single addition regarding expenses is this — we're incurring repositioning charges, Mike. What I mean is that we aren't standing still while we move through this stretch of uncertainty, during which wallets in particular segments of the industry face considerable strain. And by incurring those repositioning charges, expense reductions will follow that ultimately materialize across the coming 12-month period. So beyond what Jane brought up concerning exits and the benefits tied to the transformation, that's the additional element that will feed into the cost base over the next 12 months.
Jane Fraser
executiveRegarding TTS, everyone here likely feels the same excitement you do about this business — both for the growth potential we've already been delivering and that we anticipate will keep coming, though it's now settling toward the medium-term guidance across the coming few quarters, where we see high to medium single-digit growth ahead. This is a business that returns a great deal, and a few of the signals showing how those relationships are being monetized include new client wins, which rose 41% in this quarter. On new deals spread across various client segments, our win loss ratio holds steady at 80%. Beyond that, we're beginning to see real momentum build from our Commercial Bank, along with expansion among middle market clients globally as that franchise grows out. Fee growth has also been quite strong, which, as Mark notes, and as I always say, is something we concentrate on heavily — so cross-border rose 11%; U.S. dollar clearing rose 6%; commercial cards rose 15%, and so forth. We keep putting money into the business too, ensuring that 80% win ratio stays where it is. So we were first bank to launch 24/7, 365 dollar clearing, U.S. dollar clearing. There's the instant payments platform we recently introduced for e-commerce clients. Payments Express is now live in the U.S., and we're on track for 5 markets by the year-end. So this is a tale of innovation. It's a tale of investment. Returns are excellent. It makes for a solid growth story. And it simply — it carries on; and I don't want to leave out Security Services either. That's another business similarly seeing substantial client wins, up 65% versus last year as well. Much of our strategy there has centered on taking share among asset managers in North America. A couple of years ago, our share sat down at 2.6%; now we're up around 4.3%. In that key growth area, our goal is roughly 5.5% there in 2025. I realize there's plenty to appreciate here as well.
L. Erika Penala
analystI'm sorry that I need to bring up the cost topic once more, yet I believe it matters a great deal, since there are genuinely 2 possible long-only theses for investing in Citi, correct? The first involves the buyback, since your tangible book value sits at $85 while the shares trade at $46, and the second concerns bending the expense curve. Therefore, allow me to pose Jim's question in a different manner. If we look back at 2017 — and I focus on 2017 purely because that lets me separate legacy from core — and then jump ahead to 2022, your revenues excluding legacy franchises came to roughly $61 billion during 2017 and roughly $67 billion during 2022. The matching costs, once more excluding legacy franchises, totaled approximately $34.5 billion during 2017 compared with $43.5 billion during 2022, meaning you exceeded the revenue gain across that stretch by $3 billion. My question, I suppose, is this: you seem extremely confident about when these expenses will arrive, and I want to know what portion of that $9 billion is able to disappear; we recognize there's plenty of room to reinvest into the core business. Still, I think every one of us finds it hard to truly grasp that size; and I believe the investor community and the market completely get the legacy franchise narrative and understand that the exits will require time. Yet what interests them most, I think, is the core business and how much of it can be removed.
Mark Mason
executiveYes, of course. Look, there's no reason to say sorry for raising the topic once more. It's a significant — it's a significant subject. Let me mention a few points; first, we absolutely can examine history, yet I want to stress that we find ourselves here because we had to put more money into our franchise; therefore, without a doubt, our cost base will rise in a way that mirrors prior underinvestment, along with strengthening safety and soundness and genuinely progressing toward operations and infrastructure that are more automated or more modernized; so that element certainly exists. That being said, efficiencies accompany those investments. As we shift from manual work toward automation, eventually, benefits to our cost structure will emerge from such investments. That forms part of what will bend the curve across that medium-term window. Another point I want to stress is that, clearly, regarding the legacy franchises, $7 billion of expense ties to them, and that figure will decline. However, that — however, thanks to the Mexico transaction, we will remain stuck with it somewhat longer because of the IPO process. It doesn't significantly impair our capacity to reduce stranded cost and, incidentally, it arrives alongside top line revenues and has historically added to our profitability and returns. So I want to stress — I won't provide you with any sort of fresh guidance regarding where our expenses will ultimately land. What I'd direct your attention toward isn't just the 54 for this year — approximately 54 this year — and it isn't just the way the curve bends in Q3 and Q4, or from the third quarter into the fourth quarter of next year. Beyond that, we've provided guidance on top line growth, revenue of 5%, call it CAGR across that medium-term period, and we've also laid out operating efficiency targets, and our intention is to deliver on all of it, which mirrors that curve bending through every driver we've discussed. So hopefully that answers it, Erika. I appreciate the attention paid to both capital and expenses. Our focus there matches yours, and we recognize exactly how critical it is for hitting those targets. Beyond simply executing what we laid out in that strategy articulation, we're also responding to the environment we currently find ourselves in. In our view, that supports our capacity to hit the targets and achieve the bending of the curve, and we're aware there's a further opportunity Jane mentioned regarding simplification of the organization as we make what I'd call substantial progress on the exits as this year winds down; and every one of those elements matters for making sure we reach that lower cost base, which we will do.
Jane Fraser
executiveAnd we're keeping an extremely tight focus on this, making sure the plans and the execution are there so we can actually get there. This is an area where we're very hands-on, working to ensure it gets accomplished across all the various drivers that Mark mentioned.
L. Erika Penala
analystOkay. Following up on that point. I suppose you've all made the schedule quite plain, and you've all made it quite plain why that curve is going to bend. What I'm trying to figure out is whether the only reason we aren't getting those sorts of dollar figures — the ones that might disappear thanks to the transformation — comes down to schedule. Is schedule the sole factor? Or do you remain in a spot where it's unclear how much would have to be put back in to get to that 5% revenue CAGR?
Mark Mason
executivePardon me, was your question about the costs, or about the top line?
L. Erika Penala
analystLet's talk about costs. We fully understand the reason this curve is going to bend, and we fully understand the timing of when it will bend, correct? And obviously, some of those costs are catch-up costs, and some are transformational costs tied to everything Jane described; that point has come through very clearly. What I'm curious about is that you haven't shared what might be removed from those costs, since this is only a matter of timing. Is it July 14 rather than the fourth quarter of '24? Or have you still not decided how you might direct those costs — specifically, whether you need certain of them to expand your revenue base toward that 5% CAGR, as opposed to letting them drop to the bottom line? Sorry, that's my question.
Mark Mason
executiveUnderstood. Jane, would you like to begin, or should I?
Jane Fraser
executiveNo, please continue.
Mark Mason
executiveYes. So a few points come to mind. First, Erika, clearly, alongside that revenue CAGR there will be volume-driven costs that unfold. Yet we're also paying attention, plainly, to costs not tied to volume, and I'm not handing you an exact figure since how big that bend is, correct, matters, right? Thus, clearly, Mexico, say, like I said before, affects how large the bend is, correct? And we will, and actually already do, if you examine our cost base even across this quarter, we've put money into Mexico to fuel that top line 22% revenue growth, 10% ex FX. Consequently there will be subtleties in how the business is run, in a manner that guarantees we're maximizing shareholder value, which affects how large the bending of that cost curve is. Investments I must keep making in TTS so as to hold that #1 position and that competitive advantage we possess. And so those items will affect how big the bend is; we've been, I believe, quite transparent as we enter each year, providing you concrete numbers. What I'm saying is the curve will bend; and as 2024 gets nearer, we'll provide you more guidance on how large it is for that year and beyond.
Steven Chubak
analystI’d like to ask about capital. With the recent bump in your SCB, I was hoping to get a clearer picture of why 11.5% to 12% is still viewed as the right long-term goal. And as we get ready for Basel III endgame, and think about the capital gain from selling assets down the road, could you address whether that will show up as operational risk, specifically capital relief, since it’s less obvious whether those advantages will build even when those asset sales are completed?
Jane Fraser
executiveRight. I’ll start, Mark, and then hand it over to you. When we look at it — we’re confident we will hit an 11% to 12% RoTCE target over the medium term. The main drivers of how we get there have not changed. First, it’s the revenues we expect to increase at a 4% to 5% CAGR as we keep executing on the strategy. On expenses, there’s a clear path to bend the curve by the end of ’24, bringing those costs down over the medium term; and third and importantly, it’s continuing to optimize our balance sheet, including improving RWA and capital efficiency. And as we mentioned earlier in the prepared remarks, there are different helpful drivers in that: exiting 14 international consumer markets; changing our business mix. And I’d also point out that the transformation brings benefits not only for our efficiency, but it will also support RWA and capital optimization; that said, there’s uncertainty around future capital requirements in the industry and importantly, the timing of their implementation; we, like everyone, will have to work through those implications once we know what they are. But as we said, keep in mind, we’ve got some other levers to pull over time: capital allocation; DTA allocation and utilization; our G-SIB score; and our management buffer of 100 basis points. So that’s where you hear the confidence from us around the path to executing and that remaining consistent. But, Mark, why don’t I hand over to you just around consumer market sales and operational RWA relief.
Mark Mason
executiveOkay, so once more, when you examine those deals we've already completed, roughly $4.6 billion in capital has been unlocked or produced through them. The 2 still left to finish during the rest of the year should free up approximately another $1.2 billion. That matters for the strength of our capital position. Naturally, we need to wait and see what the proposal actually says when it arrives, along with the NPR. There will be a period for us to provide feedback on it. Our hope is that when it lands, the regulators take our comments and perspectives into account; it's evident that references to RWA increases and possible operational risk consequences are going to appear in there. My honest view is that leaving these 14 markets before the proposal is visible, and without clearly understanding how those rules could change, does help not just in lowering our SCB under stress scenarios or as it emerges from stress testing and analysis, but ought to also contribute to bringing down risk-weighted assets and possibly operational risk too. Still, we have to wait and see how the proposal reads and work our way through it. What matters most, I believe, is that no matter when it appears or what form it takes, as we break it down and analyze it, we'll determine how to handle it, correct — whether by dropping particular products, pursuing pricing changes with regard to customers, clients and the markets, or carrying on with optimizing RWA the way we've been doing quite aggressively, we'll find a way to manage.
Jane Fraser
executiveI also want to add something here, since the spring and the test results we saw recently made clear that big U.S. banks aren't just sitting in a solid capital position — we've also managed to serve a key stabilizing function for the whole system, and that's a duty we treat with real seriousness. And it's certainly our hope that when the specifics of the capital frameworks come out, all of this gets weighed properly, including how it affects U.S. competitiveness. What we need is a level playing field with Europe, not one that's gold-plated. And we share the worry that raising capital levels will without question push up the cost of capital for medium-sized and smaller enterprises and especially for consumers, and will send more activity toward nonregulated and less capitalized players, which doesn't serve the system's interest. And our hope is that this gets weighed properly here, because we will make moves on businesses, and we will make pricing moves, just as the whole industry will.
Mark Mason
executiveThat's a genuinely key observation.
Steven Chubak
analystI appreciate that insight, Jane — nicely put. Let me ask just one brief follow-up. Regarding fee income trends in PBWM, with partner payments coming in lower, obviously the Wealth fee trends would indicate they were fairly muted this quarter. I was hoping to get your view on the near to medium term — what caused part of the softness this quarter? Do you think that's something likely to stick around, particularly with some of the market tailwinds we've been witnessing? I would have thought Wealth fee income specifically would show a bit more resilience.
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. As we said, Wealth came in down roughly 5%. It's genuinely tough to discuss a rebound in Wealth while the environment remains so uncertain — the one we find ourselves in. Disconnecting those macro factors — rates, inflation, the possibility of a recession — from what's happening in Wealth is difficult. I'd say 2 dynamics have been at play. The first is the movement by our customers, and customers generally, away from deposits and toward products with higher yields. The second involves fee revenue from an investment management fee standpoint. As you can imagine, with rates higher, clients have chances to earn more. Only once there's more certainty around the broader macro factors do I think we'll begin to see genuine momentum build there. That said, a couple of points deserve repeating: we're witnessing quite strong referral momentum coming out of the Retail Banking business and moving up through the Wealth continuum, so to speak. Since May year-to-date, we've had roughly 25,000 referrals from our retail branches into our wider Wealth business — that's a positive. The count of clients we've onboarded has risen rather significantly, in the Private Bank and across Wealth more broadly. That's also a positive. Those things put us in a good position for when more certainty emerges and these clients begin putting monies back to work across the broader investment platform and offering we provide.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystMark, I've got a single brief item for you. Regarding the consumer cards portfolio, you shared a few figures. First, could you remind us of the assumptions behind your reserves — specifically the unemployment rate and macro outlook? And in the event that we encounter a <<inaudible>> zero market, would that automatically translate into a significant step-up in credit reserves relative to where they stand today? Any additional detail on that would be useful.
Mark Mason
executivePardon me, I only caught the tail end of what you asked — if we do see what, exactly?
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystSure. First, what's your assumption right now for the unemployment rate? And if the jobless picture gets worse—say, across the coming 6 to 12 months—does that imply you've already set aside enough? Or should we expect provisioning to jump sharply again because of it?
Mark Mason
executiveUnderstood. Thanks. Well, the reserves we hold today—since you know we approach this through CECL—come from 3 separate scenarios. There's a base case, an upside, and a downside. What we've booked now draws on a blend of all 3 macroeconomic scenarios; on a weighted basis, it implies an unemployment rate of about 5.1% across the 8 quarters, and that's more or less level with the prior quarter. Naturally, that tells you our downside scenario carries a jobless rate well above that figure—nearer to 7%, or roughly 6.8%. That's essentially the way we've been framing unemployment. When we revisit reserves every quarter, we clearly examine the macro factors and how they're moving. A mild recession is what our base case presumes at present, and going forward reserves will take into account how our weighting toward downside, upside, and baseline might shift depending on our outlook and on volumes; those 2 things determine whether reserves go up. One more thing I'd flag: beyond unemployment—and given how stubborn it has proven, so to speak—we also treat debt service coverage ratio as a key consideration when we look at our consumers, at their balance sheet, and at the risk they could be up against. So unemployment matters a great deal. Still, we've adjusted our thinking given the environment and given how behaviors keep shifting, and that too plays a major part in how we approach reserves. I'm quite confident in where our reserves stand. As you heard us say before, we hold $20 billion of reserves; the whole portfolio is well reserved, and all of those pieces matter to that picture.
Ebrahim Poonawala
analystThat helps. Let me ask something quite basic. Whenever you speak with your biggest investors, the hopeful ones believe you'll reach your RoTCE goal in the medium term, by 2025. Is that a sensible expectation, given — and I realize Basel changes factor in, and you've already fielded roughly 10 questions about expenses? Still, ought we to anticipate that the spadework done across '24 gets us to that medium-term objective in '25, or what's your level of confidence?
Mark Mason
executiveYeah. Once more, the point I'd make — and, Jane, jump in if you'd like — is that our discussion centered on reaching medium-term returns of 11% to 12%, where the medium term spans 25% to 26%, correct? So, to be clear, it isn't merely 25%. And our confidence in our capacity to achieve that remains very strong. You've heard us reference the levers we believe will help deliver it. Clearly, capital matters, along with how it develops, and we keep striving to optimize the balance sheet while serving clients well and, crucially, expanding the robust, high-returning businesses we already have.
Matt O'Connor
analystReally, this is a credit-related follow-up. You mentioned that credit card trends would keep normalizing during the latter half of the year. So I'm curious — with those normalized loss rates shown on Slide 22, do you still believe you'll reach them, maybe as you exit this year or in early next year? Also, I believe you noted at one point that they could rise somewhat above that mark before eventually returning to a typical level. Does that remain true?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. I appreciate the question. Yes is the answer; for both portfolios, we continue to anticipate reaching those typical levels at some point near the end of the year. Those typical levels, as you mentioned, appear on that page for branded as well as for retail services. Again, depending on how and when this mild recession unfolds, we would anticipate that they would move above that point before coming back within that range. Yet once more, everything here connects to the way we've determined our reserves; the delinquencies we observe; the composition of the portfolio, which once again leans toward your higher FICO scores and the customer behaviors we observe, which flow through not just that cost of credit line, but also flow through the growth we mentioned earlier in the top line. Still, the brief answer is yes, that remains our view.
Jane Fraser
executiveAs Mark mentioned, our stance as a prime player feels solid to us, and we also have a robust credit offering. Demand has been picking up for products driven by credit, including value cards and bulk on installment loans, plus engagement led by service for customers who are more prime; therefore, that will likewise serve as a meaningful element fueling both growth and profitability.
Matt O'Connor
analystThen moving on to my second question — this isn't really about Citi in particular, but rather the card business, where plenty of banks participate. Everybody keeps discussing how we'll reach those normalized figures, let's just say over the short run, meaning the coming 2 quarters. I suppose I'm just curious for your take on arriving at that normalized loss level while unemployment sits at a record low and pay is rising. Sure, inflation is putting on pressure, yet it's still somewhat striking — again, I'm not talking about Citi here — that we're approaching this normalized point while conditions appear quite strong.
Jane Fraser
executiveRight, though I'd note that the normalized point back in 2019 was quite strong too. So nothing you'll hear from Mark or me amounts to warning signals regarding the American consumer. In our view, that consumer is resilient; we've described them as cautious, yet they aren't in recession mode. We are observing added strain among borrowers with lower FICOs. Our portfolio doesn't hold many of those, but that's precisely where we notice more of the normalization taking place — in payment rates, for instance, plus other behaviors there; so it's fairly concentrated, though I don't believe we ought to be excessively worried about how healthy the American consumer is. And as Mark mentioned, the environment we're in is highly unusual. Greater inflation, these interest rate levels, and a robust jobs market. Given such circumstances, the debt service ratio, per his remarks, strikes us as the better leading indicator, one we monitor very carefully.
Mark Mason
executiveJust remember, it's a return to normal.
Jane Fraser
executiveYes.
Gerard Cassidy
analystMark, could you tell us — in the financial supplement, you clearly provide solid detail on the credit picture, and credit is what we're discussing at this moment. For the past 12 months, nonaccrual loans have stayed completely level, both for your firm and across the industry. Meanwhile, as everyone is aware, Fed funds rates have climbed more than 500 basis points. Could you explain why we haven't witnessed more of an impact? This is largely corporate, naturally, yet everyone has held up remarkably well given how much rates have risen. What are your customers saying to you, or what are you observing, that has allowed them to stay so healthy despite a 500 basis point rise in interest rates?
Mark Mason
executiveYes. Gerard, I'd highlight a few items. First, keep in mind that our focus is on the big multinational names, mostly of investment-grade quality. That's a key consideration when you look at our ICG and corporate exposure. Second, it's important to recall that a great number of these businesses had, and continue to have, quite robust balance sheets, and they steered through the COVID and pandemic period, which left them well positioned. Third, as you've heard from us, we are handling the possibility of a recession in a proactive manner. When I speak with fellow CFOs, and I know Jane does the same with other CEOs, they are likewise examining their expense line. They are likewise examining how efficient their organizations are and where there's room to boost that efficiency given a possible slowdown or recessionary conditions. Then the last item: I believe many companies were proactive during the low-rate period in strengthening those balance sheets. That said, you've also heard us raise the possibility of a rebound in capital market activities, and sooner or later that must occur. But returning to your credit question, I genuinely believe those are the factors showing up not just in our extremely low NAL, but also in the extremely low credit losses and credit cost visible in our business.
Gerard Cassidy
analystAnd as a follow-up to that, given what the Fed's tightening has looked like over the past 12 months, institutions such as yours have adjusted their balance sheets to match, and I know Michael from the BancAnalysts Association of Boston did a nice job walking through the way you manage that balance sheet. And how — looking ahead, do you expect any changes, because if the Fed stops raising the Fed funds rate, once we reach a terminal rate, how are you positioned on the balance sheet, in your view, going forward?
Mark Mason
executiveLook, we are always actively managing the balance sheet, taking into account not just what our clients need, but also the way we expect the broader macro environment to develop and shift. And as you're aware, and I know you've observed this and we've discussed it previously, we disclose in our Qs our perspective on, or our estimate of, interest rate exposure and what takes place with a 100 basis points swing in rates one way or the other throughout the curve across currencies. You've watched that move across the last several quarters, up to the most recent quarter, when that IRE estimate stood at roughly $1.7 billion, though heavily tilted toward rates and currencies outside the U.S. dollar; and I believe as we consider how rates will develop, you'll see that shift keep going. I think when we report this quarter, that figure will likely decline somewhat where interest rate exposure is concerned and lean even further toward currencies other than the U.S. dollar, given where rates sit in those markets. And the U.S. dollar will probably be fairly neutral given what that curve looks like right now. But once again, it's something we manage actively, starting with an eye on what client demand and needs will probably be for use of our liquidity, while also considering how the macro environment could develop and what we're picking up from central banks globally.
Mike Mayo
analystI had wanted to ask sooner about how we're bending the cost curve, but let's say you lined up the various initiatives by how much is done — maybe the exits are sitting in the eighth inning, the transformation in the sixth, the remediates in the fifth, and simplification down in the first or second inning — do those figures hold up? How would you characterize them? And when it comes to bending the cost curve, which areas are further along, and which are only just beginning?
Mark Mason
executiveMike, I'm fond of you, but that's a game I won't be playing. What I can tell you is that we obviously have work underway when it comes to the exits, and we're seeing really solid progress there — not only in getting the exits closed but in making a dent in the stranded costs tied to the exits we've already closed. So, as Jane said during her prepared remarks, once we reach the end of the year, excluding Mexico, we'll have achieved a meaningful amount of progress there, and that opens up room to do more when it comes to simplifying the organization, so that simplification is clearly at an earlier inning, so to speak, while the exits are at a later one. Regarding the transformation, the spend, the investments and all of that — look, we are firmly in execution mode, as you've heard from us previously; and as I've said, the expense base tied to that will keep shifting away from money spent on third-party consultants, which aided in crafting the plan, toward technology, toward the people who are essential to carrying it out, and then along a declining path toward the benefits that technology delivers through lower operational expense. So this is a journey spanning multiple years. We've discussed that. We have a number of years left to keep executing against it. But the key thing is we understand what needs to be done, both in how we put that money to work and in staying disciplined about our cost structure and bending the curve. And once again, that's exactly what we intend to do.
Mike Mayo
analystAnd let me try once more — could you remind everyone just how many staff members are involved in the transformation remediation, and what the price tag on that is?
Mark Mason
executiveSure. So again, we have — I believe what I mentioned was roughly 13,000 people, give or take, who are working in a broad sense on these efforts; we haven't broken out the specific costs. As you know, it sits inside the overall figure. But what I'd repeat is that we understand exactly what we need to deliver and execute on, and we're keeping a very tight grip on that expense. We're always examining ways to achieve those transformation deliverables in a more efficient manner, making greater use of technology, applying AI in certain cases. So we aren't simply accepting those execution plans the way they were originally put together and then delivering on them. Instead, we're hunting for efficiencies even within the execution plans as they stand right now; and continuing to do that matters a great deal to us.
Ken Usdin
analystI realize we're running over on time here. Just one quick item — Mark, I simply wanted to hear your read on how clients are feeling, across both the Markets division and what the deal pipelines look like over in Investment Banking, plus your sense of the overall mood?
Jane Fraser
executiveLet me take that one. Companies remain fairly hesitant. There's one more Fed rate increase coming; friction between China and the West; OPEC and so on, and a broad feeling that growth will be more constrained. Still, I believe for some time now clients have been attempting to grasp and come to terms with both the macroeconomic picture and where markets are headed. My sense is they've now largely come to terms with today's conditions being the new normal, and they're starting to place themselves on a global basis. So worldwide, anxiety about funding has eased, since most big corporations are accepting the reality and paying up to seize issuance windows. Balance sheets are being strengthened. A large cap credit crisis is definitely not something we foresee ahead. As for the IB side, it stays — the pipeline is strong. Plenty of accumulated appetite exists for M&A, though predicting the moment that pipeline opens up is difficult. ECM enjoyed real momentum during Q1, and we're likewise seeing sponsors, shall we say, displaying indications of getting better, yet each of those starts from an extremely, extremely low base. Turning to investors, the majority remained on the sidelines throughout Q2. The debt ceiling drew more attention than economic headlines did, and after that came a very low-vol setting. With the slight uptick in volatility over the past few days, we noticed a small pickup at the start of — but I wouldn't yet label that a trend.
Charles Peabody
analystI've got a question regarding net interest income tied to your Markets segment. And prior to posing it, I recognize you operate those operations as a whole, and that NII is likely a leftover result; nonetheless, I have a few questions concerning Markets-related NII. To start, you saw quite a significant increase in Q2 compared with Q1. And I simply want to know whether that's mostly tied to seasonal dividend matters. Then second, your NII result is positive, whereas many of your money center peers will post a negative NII result for markets. And I'm curious what accounts for that gap. Is it the FICC business being outsized compared with equities? Or the international piece? Or the way you hedge? What explains it? So those are my 2 questions.
Mark Mason
executiveI appreciate the question, and I appreciate you recognizing that we manage our Markets revenues in total. So thank you for that. Regarding the Markets' NII, you've got it right, which is the dynamic occurring between Q1 and Q2 is, indeed, dividend season. And once more, because our franchise is global, the dividend isn't merely a dividend in one single region, but rather a dividend across multiple regions unfolding throughout the first and second quarter. I'm unable to address the peers at this point. But what I'd note is that you're aware our book leans more heavily than peers toward corporates, and that matters; and clearly we also possess a very, very robust FICC business overall. So dividend season, the primary factor behind that rise.
Charles Peabody
analystAll right. And as a second question, can you provide any sort of directional steer regarding NII tied to Markets? I mean, does it — to the degree that the second quarter got a boost from dividend, that reverses lower in the third quarter, but then does it rise again in the fourth quarter? So would the back half be roughly equal to the front half?
Mark Mason
executiveCharles, I truly appreciate the effort there; however, I won't offer any additional guidance on the breakdown of the NII. I will restate the ex Markets' NII gain, incidentally, to plus 46, but thank you for the question. I appreciate that.
Vivek Juneja
analystA couple of things I want to ask about. First off, on capital, Jane and Mark, returning to that topic — based on what you've said, and with all that's happening on the regulatory side, should we be thinking that the ratio where you sit right now ought to build up ahead of what might arrive or probably will arrive from all this regulatory activity? Or will you aim to hold it nearer to that 13.3%?
Jane Fraser
executiveMy sense is we'll wait to see precisely what the framework turns out to be, plus the timeline for putting it into practice, and after that consider modifying the plan — and I'm also hopeful the comment period gets treated seriously and the various points I raised before are factored in. After that we'll sort out whatever changes we end up making — pricing, reallocating capital, and so forth — the playbook you'd anticipate, the very one we applied with SACR and with several other items. And on top of that, we'd like to see our SCB land somewhere different, for the same reasons I mentioned earlier, Vivek, since that SCB carries a great deal of volatility, hinging on whichever scenario emerges each year. And I'd add that, with the changes we're making to the business model, we'd anticipate that figure declining.
Mark Mason
executiveOne more point I want to make is that, once again, with a CET1 ratio of 13.3% on October 1, the required level would be 12.3%, plus a management buffer of 100 basis points. That's the standard we'd be subject to as of October 1. Like Jane said, when the NPR comes out, we'll review it to determine whether it affects the CET1 stack, though it's more likely to affect risk-weighted assets, correct? What matters greatly there, beyond the highly significant considerations Jane raised about looking at wider factors, is when whatever that final rule contains would take effect. And clearly, the longer the implementation timeline, the greater the industry's capacity to figure out how to handle the consequences.
Vivek Juneja
analystStill, my assumption is you'd prefer to move faster instead of waiting, since the market will be looking for that — not a whole 3 years or whatever length the Fed decides to allow.
Mark Mason
executiveHonestly, what I'm focused on right now is getting a look at the proposal, and after that we'll get the opportunity to genuinely respond, both as a sector and as a company.
Vivek Juneja
analystLet me shift to something completely different, if that's okay. On noninterest-bearing deposits, what's your read, considering how much of your business is corporate? Looking at your point-to-point, since a full average balance sheet isn't provided, only the interest-bearing piece is there, while noninterest-bearing figures come just at period end. From what I can see, the U.S. saw a significant decline this quarter. Is there anything out of the ordinary? Is it speeding up? What are your clients telling you? Are people still waking up? And how does that feed into your NII guidance?
Mark Mason
executiveWell, once more, the key thing I'd say is that we keep observing clients move away from noninterest-bearing deposits toward interest-bearing accounts, CDs, and other products with better yields, reflecting the rate environment we're in. And I'd anticipate those kinds of moves will persist, depending on how rates develop. Also, on the corporate side, what we've observed in the U.S. is clients arriving at that terminal — those terminal betas, rather — whereas beyond the U.S., rate increases, I believe, remain ahead, as Jane mentioned, and terminal betas haven't really been hit yet. Regarding noninterest-bearing, though, that pattern is indeed unfolding.
Operator
operatorAppreciate everyone joining, and that wraps up Citi's earnings review for the second quarter of 2023. Feel free to drop off the line whenever you'd like.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.