Citigroup Inc. (C) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 12, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 89 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jen Landis

executive
#1

Thanks, operator. Hello everyone, and I appreciate all of you being on this call for our Q1 2024 results. With me this morning are Jane Fraser, our Chief Executive Officer, and Mark Mason, our Chief Financial Officer. Just a quick note that the presentation we're using today can be downloaded from our site, citigroup.com, and it could include forward-looking statements. Those reflect what management currently expects and are subject to uncertainty and shifts in circumstances. Because of various factors, including the ones laid out in our earnings materials and in our SEC filings, actual results might differ materially from those statements. So with that, I'll hand things over to Jane.

Jane Fraser

executive
#2

Thanks, Jen, and hello everybody on this call. Before walking you through how we're progressing, I want to spend a moment on the macro backdrop, and after that I'll get into the quarter. Last year, global economic performance was surprisingly out of sync, yet lately the narrative has held steady: economies have proven resilient, underpinned by tight labor markets and the consumer. This year, growth appears set to decelerate across numerous markets, and broadly speaking, conditions point toward disinflation. Several central banks in emerging markets have already begun lowering rates; here in the U.S., more and more people expect a soft landing; Europe, though, still presents a tale of 2, with Germany suffering from soft goods demand while Southern European nations like Spain and Greece gain from firmer services demand; over in Asia, Japan now counts among the bright spots, and China's economy has picked up additional traction, even if its property sector continues to worry us. Against that backdrop, our attention stays fixed on carrying out our strategy and bringing the best of Citi to every stakeholder. I've said that 2024 would be pivotal for us, since we are largely putting business and organizational simplification behind us and concentrating on 2 key priorities: the transformation, plus the performance of our businesses and the firm. The organizational simplification we told you about in September wrapped up last month. What we have now is a management structure that's cleaner and simpler, one that lines up with and supports our strategy completely. Our orientation toward clients has strengthened. Decision-making has already gotten quicker, and we can see a nimbler organization in action. Accountability is clearly defined, beginning with my management team, with fewer layers, wider spans of control and, honestly, far less bureaucracy and unnecessary complexity. All of this will help us operate the company more efficiently, sharpen what our clients experience and boost our agility and capacity to execute. And although cutting expenses was never the program's main objective, in the end more roles were affected than the 5,000 we mentioned in January; on top of that, we took other actions to sharpen business focus and lift returns — repositioning businesses so they capture synergies better, pulling out of particular businesses in markets that simply didn't align with our strategy, and right-sizing the workforce in wealth. Thanks to these combined moves, simplification included, we are removing roughly 7,000 positions, which will produce $1.5 billion in annualized run-rate expense savings. Pairing these actions with the steps we're taking to remove what's left of our stranded costs will deliver $2 billion to $2.5 billion in cumulative annualized run-rate savings over the medium term; we're watching execution of these efforts and overall resourcing closely so that we protect our commitment to the transformation. As you're aware, because of its size and scale, the transformation is an effort spanning multiple years to fix problems that accumulated across over 2 decades. We've been making consistent headway as we shut down a number of older systems, simplify processes from start to finish and bolster how we manage risk and controls, all of which we need both to satisfy what our regulators expect from us and to deliver better service to our clients. A change effort on this scale, well, it never follows a straight line. So although we've advanced nicely in lots of places, a handful of areas are getting more of our attention, like automating some regulatory workflows and the data tied to regulatory reporting. We're determined to fix those properly, and we intend to pay for the required investments ourselves. Now on to the quarter. We got off to a solid beginning in what is a critical year; net income came in at roughly $3.4 billion, EPS was $1.58 and RoTCE reached 7.6% on revenues exceeding $21 billion. Excluding divestitures, our top line grew more than 3% versus a year ago, and the main factor there was the $1 billion gain from the India consumer sale in the prior year. Our costs edged lower compared with the prior quarter, once you set aside the FDIC special assessments. Services keeps delivering strong results and producing highly appealing returns. For the quarter, revenue rose 8%. The two businesses each brought in new mandates and went deeper with clients they already had. Service fees climbed a gratifying 10% from a year earlier, powered by what we've invested in our product lineup, platforms and client experience. Within Securities Services, we picked up share once more this quarter. And at TTS, cross-border flows kept growing faster than worldwide GDP and commercial card spending stayed strong. We're eager to explore these 2 businesses further at our investor presentation on services in June. Markets recovered from a difficult final quarter in '23. Although revenue fell 7% because reduced volatility weighed on rates and currencies, that comparison was against a very robust first quarter a year ago. Client activity was healthy in Equities and in spread products, where new issuance and securitization both proved especially strong. We've completely folded our financing and securitization capabilities into our Markets business, and the advantages of a single spread product offering for clients began to show. Banking's recovery accelerated through the quarter, driven by near-record investment-grade debt issuance as better market conditions let issuers bring activity forward; and following a somewhat sluggish beginning, ECM improved in the back half of the quarter, especially in convertibles. Strong results in both DCM and ECM lifted Investment Banking revenue by 35% and total banking revenue by 49%. Although M&A revenue remains weak throughout The Street, I was glad we took part in several notable deals announced during the quarter, including Diamondback's merger with Endeavour Energy and Catalent's merger with Nova Holdings. Given better market valuations, we are cautiously optimistic about a modest reopening of the IPO market in the second quarter. Sentiment among companies is fairly upbeat, particularly in the U.S., and customers of ours worldwide hold really solid balance sheets. We're eager to bring Vis Raghavan on board at Citi to head up our Banking franchise at the start of June. Just like the other top-tier new hires who've come aboard, he'll bring in fresh perspectives that help us reach the full potential of this firm. Over in wealth, although revenues declined during the quarter, we increased fees and brought in roughly $22 billion in net new assets across the last 12 months. As you've observed, Andy is still building out his team and has 3 priorities in focus: first, streamlining the cost structure; second, igniting growth by concentrating on investment revenues; and third, upgrading our platforms and capabilities so the client experience improves; these things won't come together instantly, but nailing them will let us capture more than our fair share of the $5 trillion in assets that clients keep elsewhere; and that gets us to the returns this business needs over the medium term. U.S. PB delivered double-digit revenue growth for a sixth consecutive quarter; we're confident in our standing and our resilience as a prime lend-centric issuer, and momentum looks positive throughout both proprietary card and partner card operations. Solid spending growth carries on in branded cards, mainly fueled by our wealthier customers. In both portfolios, rising credit demand keeps powering substantial growth in interest-earning balances. And though they represent just a minor slice of our portfolio, we're watching customers in the lower FICO bands. We're also still seeing robust engagement with digital payment options, including Citi Pay, as a point-of-sale lending product that integrates easily into merchants' checkout processes. Plus, we're extracting more value from our retail branches while also getting the cost structure right so returns there improve. Our balance sheet remains strong in every respect, a deliberate outcome of our high-quality assets, sturdy capital and liquidity positions, and strict risk management. In the first quarter, we gave back $1.5 billion in capital to our common shareholders, which includes $500 million via share buyback. Our CET1 ratio rose slightly to a preliminary 13.5%, and tangible book value per share climbed to $86.67. We have an excellent franchise globally, with excellent clients supported by excellent colleagues. I'm happy with where we stand and thrilled about where we're headed; with organizational simplification now behind us and a solid quarter completed, we've begun this pivotal year on the right foot; while there will certainly be bumps along the way, we'll keep executing with discipline, and we remain dedicated to hitting our medium-term targets. With that, I'd like to hand things over to Mark, and then the two of us will be happy, as always, to take your questions. Thank you.

Mark Mason

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Jane, and good morning to all of you. My plan is to begin with the company-wide financial results, and I'll be concentrating on how the first quarter compares year over year, unless I say otherwise, after which I'll devote a bit more time to the business. Turning to Slide 6, you can see the financial results for the entire firm. During the first quarter, net income came in at about $3.4 billion, alongside EPS of $1.58 and an RoTCE of 7.6%, all on revenue of $21.1 billion. On a reported basis, total revenues declined 2%. If you set aside divestiture-related impacts — which mostly consisted of the $1 billion gain from last year's sale of the India consumer business — revenues rose by over 3%, powered by growth in Banking, USPB and services, though that was partly offset by decreases in Markets and wealth. Expenses reached $14.2 billion, which is 7% higher on a reported basis. Once you exclude the divestiture-related impact along with the incremental FDIC special assessment, expenses grew 5%. Cost of credit stood at roughly $2.4 billion, mainly because of higher card net credit losses, partly offset by ACL releases in wealth, Banking and legacy franchise. When the quarter closed, total reserves were close to $22 billion, with a reserve-to-funded loan ratio of about 2.8%. Slide 7 shows how expenses have trended across the last 5 quarters. We reported $14.2 billion of expenses, a figure that included the incremental FDIC special assessment of about $250 million. This number also reflects $225 million in restructuring charges, mostly tied to the organizational simplification. All told, we've taken on roughly $1 billion of restructuring costs across the last 2 quarters. Through these actions, we anticipate about $1.5 billion in annualized run rate saves over the medium term, linked to cutting our head count by approximately 7,000; on top of the restructuring, we incurred approximately $260 million in repositioning costs, mostly connected to firm-wide efficiency efforts, including a reduction of stranded costs tied to the consumer divestiture. The savings we expect from these moves will let us keep funding additional investments in the transformation during this year; and measured against the prior year, the rest of the expense growth came mainly from inflation and volume-related expenses, partly offset by productivity savings. For the rest of the year, we anticipate a more normalized level of repositioning, which is already baked into our guidance. So you should expect our quarterly expense trend to decline from this point, consistent with our $53.5 billion to $53.8 billion ex FDIC expense guidance. Slide 8 covers net interest income, deposits and loans, and here I'll address sequential variances; during the first quarter, net interest income fell by $317 million, mostly because of markets, producing a 4 basis point drop in net interest margin. If you exclude Markets, net interest income was essentially flat. Average loans grew by $4 billion, mainly from loans in spread products and Markets, as well as card and mortgage loans in U.S. Personal Banking, partly offset by decreases in service. Additionally, deposits averaged an increase of almost $7 billion, largely powered by services, as we keep expanding high-quality operating deposits. Moving to Slide 9, we present important credit metrics for both consumer and corporate segments. During this quarter, we modified our FICO distribution so it better matches industry reporting standards, and we now display our FICO mix applying a 660 cutoff. Within branded cards and retail services, roughly 85% of card loans go to consumers whose FICO scores are 660 or above. We also remain strongly reserved, with a reserve-to-funded loan ratio of 8.2% across our entire card portfolio; within our corporate portfolio, most of our exposure is investment grade, which shows up in our minimal nonaccrual loans at 0.5% of total corporate loans. As a reminder, our loan loss reserves factor in a scenario weighted average unemployment rate of about 5%, and that includes a downside scenario unemployment rate of nearly 7%. Because of this, we feel quite comfortable with the almost $22 billion in reserves we hold given current conditions. Moving on to Slide 10. I want to briefly emphasize how strong our balance sheet, capital and liquidity are. We keep a very robust $2.4 trillion high-quality balance sheet, up 1% quarter over quarter. Even with that growth, we managed to lower our risk-weighted assets, which demonstrates our ongoing optimization work and emphasis on capital efficiency. Our balance sheet mirrors our risk appetite, strategy and diversified business model. Funding rests on a $1.3 trillion deposit base, well diversified across regions, industries, customers and account types. The bulk of our deposits, $812 billion, are corporate and reach across 90 countries. Most corporate deposits sit in operating accounts that are essential to how clients finance their day-to-day operations worldwide. In most instances, we are fully embedded in client systems and assist them in managing operations efficiently via our 3 integrated services, payments and collections, liquidity management and working capital solutions, all of which substantially boost these deposits' stickiness. The majority of our other deposits, roughly $423 billion, are well diversified across the Private Bank, Citigold, retail and Wealth at Work, as well as across regions and products. Now shifting to the asset side. Over the past several years, we have kept a strong risk appetite framework and have been very intentional about how we allocate our deposits and other liabilities into high-quality assets. This begins with our $675 billion loan portfolio, well diversified across consumer and corporate loans. And the total portfolio's duration is about 1.2 years. Roughly 1/3 of our balance sheet sits in cash and high-quality, short-duration investment securities that add to our almost $1 trillion of available liquidity resources. And during the quarter, our LCR was 117%. To sum things up, when it comes to running our balance sheet we are proactive and intentional, and you can see that in the quality of our assets along with our solid capital and liquidity standing. Slide 11 lays out the quarter-over-quarter CET1 walk, giving you a closer look at what moved things this quarter. To begin, net income to common shareholders came in at $3.1 billion, contributing 27 basis points. Next, we gave back $1.5 billion through common dividends along with share repurchases, and that produced a roughly 13 basis point decline. Then there was a rise in our disallowed DTA, which brought about a 10 basis point reduction. Last, the residual benefit of 6 basis points came mostly from lower RWA. We closed out the quarter with a preliminary CET1 capital ratio of 13.5%, which is roughly 120 basis points, or more than $13 billion, higher than the 12.3% regulatory capital requirement we face. That being said, our simplification work, the gains from our transformation, and the complete execution of our strategy are not yet captured in our present capital requirement, and we anticipate all of those will reduce capital requirements down the road. Let me now move to Slide 12. Before discussing the businesses, I want to remind everyone that during the fourth quarter we put in place a revenue-sharing arrangement inside Banking, and also between Banking services and Markets, to capture the advantages businesses receive from our relationship-based lending.

Mark Mason

executive
#4

Revenue sharing's effect sits within the all other line for every business in our financial supplement. Over in services, revenues rose 8% this quarter, powered by ongoing momentum in both TTS and Securities Services. Net interest income climbed 6%, helped by wider spreads on deposits and trade loans. Noninterest revenue grew 14%, mostly thanks to sustained strength across the fee drivers underneath. Within TTS, fourth quarter volumes rose 9%, U.S. dollar clearing volumes rose 3%, and commercial card spend volume rose 5%, every bit of it coming from robust corporate client activity. Over at Securities Services, our preliminary assets under custody and administration rose 11%, aided by better market valuations plus new client onboarding. Growth in these two businesses stems directly from our ongoing investment in product innovation, the client experience and platform modernization so we can gain share across every client segment. TTS keeps holding its #1 spot with large corporate and FI clients and we see solid momentum in the commercial client segment, while we keep gaining share in Securities Services. Expenses rose 11%, mostly from ongoing investments in technology and product innovation. Cost of credit came to $64 million as net credit losses stay low. Net income stood at approximately $1.5 billion. Average loans rose 4%, chiefly from robust demand for working capital loans in TTS. Average deposits fell 3% as quantitative tightening's effect outweighed new client acquisitions and deepening with existing clients; even so, it's worth noting that we keep seeing solid operating deposit inflow, and services keeps delivering a high ROTCE of 24.1% for the quarter. On Slide 13, we show results for Markets in the first quarter. Markets revenues fell 7% as weaker fixed income revenues outweighed growth in Equities. Fixed income revenues dropped 10%, pulled down by rates and currencies, which fell 21% amid lower volatility and a strong quarter a year earlier; strength in spread products and other fixed income partially offset this, rising 26% from more client activity, particularly in asset-backed lending; and we keep seeing solid underlying momentum in Equities with revenues up 5%, lifted by growth across cash trading and equity derivatives. And we keep making progress in prime with balances up more than 10%. Expenses rose 7%, mostly because a legal reserve release did not repeat from last year. Cost of credit came to $200 million, chiefly from macroeconomic assumptions tied to loans and spread products that hit reserves. Net income stood at approximately $1.4 billion. Average loans rose 8%, chiefly from asset-backed lending and spread products thanks to better market activity. Average trading assets rose 4% sequentially, mostly from seasonally stronger activity in the first quarter. Markets delivered an RoTCE of 10.4% for the quarter; on Slide 14, we show results for Banking in the first quarter. Within banking, revenues rose 49%, with the increase coming from expansion in Investment Banking and corporate lending, plus smaller losses on loan hedges. As I noted earlier, results in corporate lending include revenue sharing coming from Investment Banking, services and Markets. Investment Banking revenues climbed 35%, powered by DCM and ECM, since better market sentiment produced more issuance activity, especially investment grade, which is operating at close to record highs. Advisory revenues fell because of how few mergers were announced during the prior year; even so, during the quarter we took part in the broader rise in announced M&A across sectors, among them areas where we have been putting money to work, like technology and health care. Corporate lending revenues, once mark-to-market on loan hedges is excluded, were up 34%, mostly because of a larger revenue share. This quarter we delivered positive operating leverage, with expenses dropping 4% from steps taken to rightsize the expense base. Cost of credit came in as a benefit of $129 million, mainly from shifts in portfolio composition. The NPL rate stood at 0.3% of average loans, and the quarter closed with a reserve-to-funded loan ratio of 1.5%. Net income came to roughly $536 million. Average loans fell 6%, since we keep strict discipline regarding capital efficiency while optimizing corporate loan balances. RoTCE reached 9.9% for the quarter, which mirrors a rebound in activity, reserve releases and ongoing expense discipline. Slide 15 presents our wealth results for the first quarter. Wealth revenues declined 4%, caused by a 13% drop in NII stemming from lower deposit spreads and higher mortgage funding costs, partly offset by greater investment fee revenue. Momentum in noninterest revenue looks good, rising 11% as we gained from higher investment assets across regions, helped by increased client activity and market valuation. Expenses grew 3% because of technology investments aimed at risk and controls along with platform enhancements, partly offset by early savings from expense reductions as we keep rightsizing the workforce. Cost of credit was a benefit of $170 million, coming from a reserve release of approximately $200 million tied mostly to a change in estimate as we improved our data concerning margin lending collateral. Net income was $150 million. End-of-period client balances rose 6%, helped by higher client investment assets. Average loans stayed flat as we keep optimizing capital usage. Average deposits dropped 1%, mostly reflecting lower deposits in the Private Bank and Wealth at Work and the ongoing move of deposits into higher-yielding investments on Citi's platform, which more than offset the transfer of relationships and related deposits from USPB. Client investment assets rose 12%, helped by net new investment asset flows and the benefit of higher market valuation. RoTCE was 4.6% for the quarter. Going forward, we will boost the returns of our wealth business by carrying out our 3 foundational priorities. As Jane said, this will take time, but across the medium to longer term, we see this as a business returning greater than 20%. Slide 16 covers what U.S. Personal Banking delivered in the first quarter. Revenue there rose 10%, helped by an 8% gain in NII and reduced partner payments. Branded cards saw a 7% revenue rise, supported by a 10% increase in interest-earning balances while payment rates keep moderating. Spend volumes also keep growing at a healthy pace, up 4%, mostly from our more affluent customers. Retail services revenue climbed 18%, mainly because partner payments fell on account of greater net credit losses plus a 9% rise in interest-earning balances. Retail banking revenue was up 1%, helped by better deposit spreads, loan growth and improved mortgage margins. Expenses came in roughly flat as reduced compensation costs, repositioning included, were offset by volume-related expenses running higher. Credit cost was about $2.2 billion, up 34%, mostly because NCLs rose to $1.9 billion as card loan vintages originated across the last few years had their maturation delayed by the unprecedented government stimulus seen during the pandemic and are maturing now; for branded cards, the NCL rate was 3.65%, matching what we expected.

Mark Mason

executive
#5

When it comes to Retail Services, our NCL rate came in at 6.32%, which was a bit higher than the top end of the guidance range we'd given for the full year, and it's probably going to stay above that range during the second quarter, which reflects the usual seasonal patterns we see. That said, with inflation still hanging around, interest rates elevated, and ongoing sales pressure at our partners, we now think we'll land nearer the upper end of the full-year NCL guidance range for Retail Services. That outlook, combined with the ongoing mix shift from transactors toward revolvers in both portfolios, drove an ACL build of roughly $340 million. Net income fell to $347 million. Average deposits were down 10%, since moving relationships and their related deposits over to our wealth business more than made up for underlying growth. RoTCE came in at 5.5% for the quarter. We know this business is up against quite a few headwinds on the regulatory side and from elevated credit costs given where we sit in the credit cycle, and both of those are weighing on returns for the quarter and for full year 2024. Even so, that doesn't change how we see this business over the longer term. We're confident in our standing as a prime and lend-centric issuer; we'll keep taking mitigating actions to navigate the headwinds, get past the credit cycle and extract more value from retail banking and retail services while making the business more operationally efficient overall, and all of that should ultimately produce a business with better returns over the medium term. Turning to Slide 17, we present results for all other on a managed basis, which takes in Corporate/Other and legacy franchises while leaving out divestiture-related items. Revenues dropped 9%, mostly because of closed exits and wind-downs along with higher funding costs, partly offset by stronger revenue in Mexico. Meanwhile, expenses rose 18%, largely due to the incremental FDIC special assessment and restructuring charges, partly offset by lower expenses from the wind-down and exit markets. Slide 18 lays out our full year 2024 outlook and medium-term guidance, and neither has changed; we've gotten a lot done over the past few years and made significant progress simplifying our business and organizational structure. The year has started well, as we're laser-focused on executing the transformation and enhancing the business performance. These 2 priorities will not only make us a more efficient, agile company but a client-centric one that brings together the best of Citi to drive revenue growth and improved return, and we're on the path to reach our 11% to 12% return target over the medium term. With that, Jane and I will be happy to take your questions.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#6

Okay, so those 7 months of work to simplify the organization are now finished, and you said 7,000 positions are being eliminated plus $1.5 billion in cost reductions. That's fairly precise. But looking at the bigger picture, after 20, 30, or 40 years under a matrix structure, which has now been reduced to 5 lines of business that you report on and describe differently, I think a lot of people are asking whether this is simply a new format for presenting those lines of business, or whether you're actually running them differently?

Jane Fraser

executive
#7

Mike, thanks for asking that. The simplification we've just completed, it is exactly what we described it to be. It represents the most far-reaching set of changes not just to our organizational model but to the way we operate the bank. It's brought the structure into line with the strategy; it's made the bank simpler. It's removed unnecessary complexity. It's delivered more transparency into the five businesses and how they're performing, as you're able to see. What this has done is strengthen ownership. To put it plainly, it has allowed our people to keep their focus on clients while still getting work done and delivering on what's coming next. To paint a clearer picture: our first move was to raise up the five businesses, which took away the ICG and PBWM layer. We then put everything those businesses needed to run end to end, operations included, straight under the five business heads. It has created openness and greater responsibility, along with this comprehensive, whole-company focus on the P&L—meaning a focus on the bottom line, on returns that drive growth, on keeping expenses in check, and similar matters. We also repositioned our businesses so they align with the strategy. For instance, Banking now sits entirely beneath one roof—the investment bank, corporate bank, and commercial bank—which genuinely helps us create synergies in that space. We put finance FNS and securitization inside markets, giving us one unified spread product there, and we're beginning to see the benefits of that this quarter. That's one example involving the businesses. However, I do want to highlight a few other areas tied to this change. What we did was take out the regional layer and put in place a far slimmer, less burdensome management setup across the geographies. That has let us keep every country focused on serving clients and handling legal entity matters, and the whole shadow geographic P&L is gone. A large number of committees in the geographies have also been eliminated. This is the area where a great many functional management positions were trimmed and cut away across the past 7 months. Beyond that, we broke the regions into smaller, lighter clusters, which enables us to capture much more effectively the big changes in trade flows, financial flows and so forth that are occurring worldwide. It is just far more agile. The third element: we set up the client organizations. That team makes sure the things we're best at and the ways we work get used everywhere in the company, and that's what creates revenue synergies. Once that was in place, the government side of things got a lot easier. It used to eat up a huge amount of our time, and now we've set much clearer mandates. We've reduced how many committees we have by over half — more than 200 of them are gone from the company, either by merging them or getting rid of them entirely. This holds true there, and if you don't count me, 98% of the company now runs inside eight layers. What that gives you is decision-making that moves much, much faster. Things get executed a lot quicker too. It also lets you get very close, very quickly, to where the engine of the company actually is. Our accountabilities are clear. The majority of our co-heads have departed. Matrix reporting has been reduced, and our ratio of producers to nonproducers now looks better. What all that adds up to is what I've been describing: a simpler organizational chart, letting us concentrate intensely on how those 5 businesses are performing plus the transformation effort. The difference is already noticeable. Sitting around my table, I find myself far more connected to both the businesses and the clients. That makes it far simpler for Mark, myself, and everyone else on the team to operate this bank as an operator rather than as someone running a holding company. There's no longer a need to push through those aggregator layers just to accomplish things. And we have finished, exactly as we promised we would, at this stage; the last consultation window is now coming to a close. The last several months have been tough on the company, and we've had to part ways with some truly talented individuals. We've pushed a great deal of transformation through the organization. With that period now behind us, we're eager to return to business as usual, and to keep pushing ahead on making things simpler and improving our processes, among other things. Going forward, though, our real priority will be capturing the complete value of everything we've changed across both the business and the organization, and continuing to move ahead.

Glenn Schorr

analyst
#8

I believe this demonstrates how much clearer you've made the organization for us. People seem to have fully embraced the cost narrative. So you deserve a lot of praise. Where I, and I think others, still have lingering questions is around revenue and how we reach those 4% to 5% medium-term goals. Could you walk us through, at a conceptual level, where you expect that expansion to come from, starting at the baseline we're sitting at today? And feel free, if you'd like, to fold in my second question and describe the positive things happening within the Investment Banking division that might help answer part of that.

Jane Fraser

executive
#9

That's not the one, Glenn. I'll begin with a portion of this, hand it over to Mark, and then circle back to Banking; so here's the thing — we are intensely focused on growing and lifting the returns of these businesses to where they ought to be, and will be, over the medium term. It isn't solely about growth, but let me ground it in those medium-term return objectives. In services, we aim to stay near the mid-20s for RoTCE. Banking ought to reach roughly 15%, Markets 10% to 13%; so we'd prefer to land at the upper portion of that band; USPB returning to the mid-teens and then progressing toward the high teens over the medium term; and finally, as Andy and Mark have mentioned, bringing wealth to a 15% to 20% return over the medium term, though the ambition is the mid-20s over the longer term. We're confident our strategy will generate revenue growth at a 4% to 5% CAGR over the medium term. That reflects preserving our leadership in some businesses while picking up share in others. Our client growth is solid. Consider our win rate, for instance, in TTS at more than 80%. Our commercial bank is also onboarding new clients in the mid-market and assisting them in speeding up their growth and success globally. But Mark, let me turn it over to you.

Mark Mason

executive
#10

Absolutely, and we appreciate you recognizing the work on expenses. As you're aware, that's been a major area of emphasis for us, and we've been putting in serious effort to make sure we follow through on our commitments there. On the revenue side, I'd start by noting that if you look back to Investor Day, we've actually hit the medium-term guidance we provided — that 4% to 5% top line growth. Yes, the rate environment was different, but the growth we achieved across the last couple of years came from a combination of revenue and fundamental business strength. When you consider the guidance we shared for this year, we said NII ex Markets would be down modestly. That indicates the forward momentum and expansion we anticipate are going to come from noninterest revenue. This quarter, I believe, demonstrates quite clearly where and in what manner that will probably appear — with the top line for revenue rising more than 3 percent. Yet when you look through each of the businesses and review every page where we report revenue, you will see the underlying NIR growth shown in the bottom left-hand corner of each of those pages, and that is showing up as well. Take Securities Services, which rose 14%, with increases in both TTS through cross-border, clearing, commercial cards, and also — and Securities Services, correct, with the growth we are seeing from ongoing momentum in assets under custody. We think that pattern will keep going, both with the clients we already have and others — plus brand-new customers, along with expanding what we do in our commercial market middle — commercial middle-market operations, sorry, so growth in NIR there. The Investment Banking component serves as the additional force behind fees. That wallet appears to be recovering, and we're involved in that recovery. The deals that have been announced, we're involved in them within industries where we've been putting money to work; we're adding fresh people to assist us in capturing and going through that. Take wealth, for example. A 4% drop in top-line results this quarter isn't something we're happy about. Still, digging deeper, NII growth in wealth was solid during the period, climbing 11% compared with a year earlier. That growth sits in the space Andy and his team are prioritizing — specifically investments — and it's happening not in a single region but everywhere. Last, USPB is also delivering healthy NII growth. To put it simply, the momentum we've seen in fees should carry forward, driving the 4% increase implied by the $80 billion to $81 billion range, which supports both our work for clients and our steady movement toward the medium-term goal.

Jane Fraser

executive
#11

Okay, let me jump in here — apologies, I know Jen Landis is going to shoot us a dirty look for slipping in a second question, Glenn. But let me follow up on Banking and where things stand; we've got a really clear plan that we've been carrying out for the past couple of years, essentially to build the groundwork for growth in Banking. North America is where our top focus lies. It's the largest piece of the worldwide IB wallet. Tech, health care and industrials will probably make up more than 50% of the fee wallet down the road. So we've realigned our resources more effectively to set the franchise up for this, protecting places where we've traditionally been strong, like industrials, energy, while putting money into high-growth sectors, including health care and technology, bringing in some strong talent. Financial sponsors hold an estimated $3 trillion of firepower, and they have incentives to put it to work; so they'll probably account for between 20% and 30% of global Investment Banking fees. We have excellent relationships with this community. We've built those across many years and decades. You'll see us more active in levfin in the appropriate situations for our key clients. And we'll keep making sure we're well positioned and active around this major opportunity. You'll probably see us trying to stay competitive in the private capital asset class; that can be a significant source of liquidity for a lot of clients; and the middle market will be fertile ground for hunting corporate and private equity deals. And our investment bank and commercial bank are going to work in close coordination to gather the deal flow globally. And in fact, the new org structure I just mentioned truly allows us to push a more joined-up, client-centric strategic coverage spanning corporate, commercial and investment banking; so beyond the wallet recovery, Mark and I can stay very laser-focused on making sure we're driving revenue growth from a more holistic emphasis on wallet share across flow and episodic activity. Vis Raghavan is the right choice to step in at this crucial moment for our Banking franchise. The momentum we've been building with the groundwork we've been putting down — his aim is to speed that up. He'll concentrate on raising our performance intensity, boosting productivity and disciplined growth, and he'll keep us solidly on the path to delivering on our commitments, fundamentally lifting the operating margin, producing higher returns and that all important fee revenue.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#12

I suppose I have a few questions. Well, I realize we already discussed the institutional securities business regarding nudging that expense ratio down somewhat. Might we go a bit deeper into the wealth side? The reason is that the expense ratio there is coming in somewhat elevated, so it would help simply to grasp the pace, speed, or timeline for when we ought to anticipate that beginning to turn.

Jane Fraser

executive
#13

Yes, certainly. And part of it, only as a reminder, the steps we have been implementing around org simplification and that Andy has likewise been implementing within the wealth business, we will get through notice periods over the coming weeks. Consequently, you will begin — you will observe the effect flowing through in our head count figures and in wealth and the expense base next quarter. Look, as Mark stated during his opening and Andy has been discussing, this ought to be a sort of up to a 30% pretax margin business. Andy is concentrated on rationalizing the expense base. He is also, as Mark stated, activating the growth engine. He is boosting platforms and capabilities to lift the client experience. The core of the opportunity for us rests with our current clients. They are a remarkable client base, yet they are underpenetrated. The operating efficiency is honestly going to be — is going to arrive on the revenue side here. Having said that, Andy has undertaken a number of fairly decisive moves this quarter regarding the expense side. Mark, allow me to hand it over to you.

Mark Mason

executive
#14

Right. So look, I'd say the 3% growth in expenses you're seeing this quarter doesn't yet capture what Andy has been working on so consistently. We still have some spending in there on technology and on the platform, and that matters; but I think as we come out of the first quarter, you'll begin to see part of the expense reduction that comes as a byproduct of those efforts; and those efforts have touched every part of the cost base in the wealth business. That covers non-client-facing positions and support staff. It also covers examining how productive our existing bankers and advisers are; and reductions of that kind will begin to show up in the quarters that follow. I should note, like Jane said, this is a business where we're growing. So on a few of the metrics on Page 15, in the bottom left, you can see some encouraging indicators of investment momentum; and I bring that up because as costs decline thanks to some of those efficiencies, we'll need to keep investing and refill low-performing or low-producing bankers and advisers with resources that can actually produce the revenues we're counting on and seize the client opportunity ahead of us. So that's a long-winded way of saying there's definitely some operating efficiency upside for us. It's a mix of the top line and the expense we're working through over the rest of the quarters and the year here.

Jim Mitchell

analyst
#15

Jane and Mark, I really appreciate what you both said about where you can grow and how you're pushing that forward. A lot of the time, the top line is set by macro conditions, and that sits somewhat beyond what you can influence. Could you speak a bit to how much room there is on the cost side? For 2026, you've given a range of 51 to 53. So if sales land under the goals, is it fair to think you'd sit right at the bottom of that range? Or — and my sense is that some top-line expansion is assumed in there — is there room to move lower if the revenue backdrop gets harder, so you can still hit your targets?

Mark Mason

executive
#16

Yes. Look, on the top line, as we've said before, growth is a CAGR of 4% to 5%. That goal is out there, with 51 to 53 as the range we're aiming toward; we've laid out clearly how we intend to reach it, including the $2 billion to $2.5 billion of reduction by that point. We've already flagged the $1.5 billion that sits ahead of us. The truth is, when revenue is soft, that's exactly why a range exists. Clearly, costs tied to volume would decline if revenue weakens. And based on what's causing that softening, we'd review the investments we're making throughout the business and ensure they're properly sized for where we are in the cycle and what the top line is showing us. That said, we must keep funding the transformation; we won't sacrifice that. It's something we'll have to keep spending on to make sure we stay on track; but that's roughly how this works. On the top — we have a blend of businesses that, I believe, have shown resilience over the last couple of years. We expect them to keep generating some top-line momentum, but we have levers ready if they don't.

Ebrahim Poonawala

analyst
#17

I suppose I've got just a single item, Mark, regarding capital. You mentioned $13 billion above the regulatory minimum. From my perspective — it seems like you could be doing twice the repurchasing you completed in 1 quarter, perhaps even more. Obviously I realize you'd rather not discuss upcoming quarters, but give us some indication of at least this quarter: ought we to anticipate that the rate of buybacks will rise? And if you might offer more detail as we consider the remainder of the year, that would be very much appreciated.

Mark Mason

executive
#18

Certainly. Look, as you know and as I've stated many times, and Jane has stated many times, considering the level at which we trade, we believe repurchasing is wise. And we'd prefer to do as much as we can and as much as is sensible given the uncertainty that exists. We've been running at roughly $13.5 billion this quarter; that leaves us capacity beyond the $13.3 billion. But it's crucial to remember that client demand will keep changing. We need to ensure we can serve the clients who wish to conduct business with us, whether that's in Markets or elsewhere in the franchise; and then there remains uncertainty regarding how capital regulation develops. The encouraging part is that we're hearing somewhat positive signals about how the Basel III endgame proposal might change, but that hasn't occurred yet. It isn't finalized, it isn't in effect yet. So we want to observe how that carries on unfolding. We're clearly in the middle of a CCAR process; we want to see how that develops. And we'll keep making the buyback choice quarter by quarter; but we acknowledge that an opportunity exists there, and we'll pursue it as soon as it makes good sense for us.

L. Erika Penala

analyst
#19

What's coming through loud and clear on this Q&A is a fair amount of doubt regarding your revenue goals, particularly when you consider the expense reductions — and honestly, as analysts, we're partly just echoing what we've been told by long-only investors who haven't bought the stock yet. With that in mind, I'll pose Ebrahim's question a bit differently, and then I'll ask about card late fees. How are you striking that balance — obviously, your valuation implies buybacks should be increased beyond $500 million. Yet if revenues grow at a 4% to 5% CAGR, that could mean some capital gets pulled back into the business. So how do you weigh those two, especially since the push for buybacks is stronger at Citi than at any other money center peer? And can you help us understand what card late fees amount to and how an earlier October implementation would affect the $80 billion to $81 billion figure for the year?

Mark Mason

executive
#20

Thanks, Erika; regarding your first point, I'd simply want to remind you and everyone else that our focus is on the long term, correct? So we've established certain medium-term targets. Clearly, Jane has reworked the vision and the strategy. I believe we're making strong headway on that front. But our focus is on the long term. What that requires is that we keep investing in the franchise. That's partly why I provided a range for the expenses. That's why I've kept emphasizing how important it is to safeguard the transformation and risk and control spend; and that's why I began my response to Ebrahim's question by noting that we need to make certain we can satisfy client demand out there in cases where the returns justify it. And so we must balance the deployment of capital and other resources against that longer-term strategic aim and use them where it's sensible and produces solid returns, versus the alternative of giving that back to shareholders; and so this is — we'll keep doing that. It's a daily evaluation. It's a daily conversation with the teams. Honestly, that's why mechanisms such as the revenue sharing have been introduced, to sharpen the dialogue about which clients we're extending balance sheet to and to make sure we're generating wider revenues across the platform. And so that's roughly how we go about making that trade-off routinely, on top of, clearly, the wider regulatory landscape we find ourselves in. As for your second point regarding late fees, we haven't revealed the dollar figure associated with the late fees. What I can tell you is that we did factor that in, and it has been factored into the $80 billion to $81 billion. The sole point I would tack on is that this has sort of been put into practice somewhat sooner than our expectation had been. Even so, once more, it falls within the bounds of the outlook I provided to you regarding the full-year top line revenue.

Jane Fraser

executive
#21

As a quick note, 85% of the 2 card portfolios we hold are prime. And within CRS, the segment where you're more likely to encounter lower-income households, that presence does exist for us. The financial impact of the fee modification is going to be split with our partners in CRS. So our aim is for customers to make timely payments. There are multiple tools at our disposal for that. But when it comes to the financial side, I believe we, together with the broader industry, will be introducing offsetting measures as time goes on, and a few of those are already in the process of being rolled out.

John McDonald

analyst
#22

Mark, could you add a bit more detail on where you stand regarding credit card charge-offs? The guidance for the year was kept in place. You brought up the upper end for Retail Services. Do you still expect a peak to occur this year? And which metrics are you monitoring when it comes to delinquency formation and seasoning, so that you can support the belief that card charge-offs might top out during this year?

Mark Mason

executive
#23

Yes. Thanks, John. It's — clearly, this portfolio has been managed by us in a very active way all along. Top line growth has kept coming. Growth in average interest-earning balances has also kept coming. We've discussed our expectation that the cost of credit would normalize, and that has kept occurring. On branded cards, the range we provided — we're sitting inside it. If you examine spend throughout the portfolios, the spending is truly taking place among affluent customers more than anywhere else. So we are keeping an eye on the lower-income customer profile, or the customers that we have. That said, as Jane said, we skew toward the higher end from the start. The place where pressure is genuinely showing up is what I referenced with Retail Services. And there, current NCLs exceed the high end of the full year range I gave. Yet looking backward, that aligns with seasonality observed previously in that portfolio, in which the first 2 quarters come in above the back half of the year, partly due to emerging from the holiday season and how the — and how losses tend to mature or materialize through that process. So my expectation is to see them above the average range not just in Q1 but in Q2 as well, before they decline. And then in 2025, I still expect that they tend to normalize further and come down somewhat from these ranges. But look, the reality is we keep watching it, and the factors out there that matter include how unemployment evolves, what happens with inflation, what happens with interest rates. Those will be significant factors in how loss rates keep evolving over time. One last point I think I'd make, which I brought up in the prepared remarks, is that we must keep in mind that loss rates across both portfolios reflect multiple vintages maturing simultaneously. And you'll remember — this is an industry dynamic spanning the COVID and pandemic period — losses hit an all-time low, payment rates reached all-time highs, backed by government stimulus. Now, coming out of that, the COVID vintages are maturing, though at a pace lagging what would be normal. And the incremental acquisitions we've completed are beginning to mature at their typical pace. So these loss rates get exacerbated by that impact, and that's a crucial factor we cannot lose sight of. But the bottom line is we're watching it. The macro factors matter. We feel good about the quality mix we have, and we'll kind of see how things evolve from here.

John McDonald

analyst
#24

All right. And regarding the branded side, you continue to anticipate the peak occurring this year — you remain within the range for the full year and expect that in 2025 you could go lower on branded charge-offs?

Mark Mason

executive
#25

Yes. I continue to anticipate that trajectory of peaking and then declining somewhat in branded.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#26

Could I build on that card-related discussion and ask Mark to share a bit about the cost of credit? Even with what you just said and softer seasonal loan growth, we still saw some card-related build this quarter. So stepping back, how should we keep thinking about reserve builds going forward, and how does that shape your cost of credit outlook?

Mark Mason

executive
#27

Yeah, absolutely. When I consider reserve builds, the same set of drivers applies. Clearly, the macro view matters a great deal, and at present, among the main macro variables affecting the cards portfolio, the weighted unemployment assumption sits at roughly 5%. On the downside, it's around 7%, weighted across the period. So how that plays out will matter significantly. How HBI moves would also be an important consideration for this portfolio, and beyond that, what happens with volumes feeds into reserve builds and how much they rise or fall. Then there's mix, which ties back to the revolver point. As mix shifts from transactors toward revolvers, that will influence how much reserve we need to keep building on a lifetime basis. That's why, in answering John's question, I stressed the importance of watching interest rates, inflation, and the lower-income customer base, since all of those, combined with how we weigh our scenarios, will factor into reserves. That said, Ken, looking at what we have this quarter, I feel very good about reserve levels. The 8.2% combined ACL-to-loan ratio seems appropriate for this portfolio's mix, and we'll keep monitoring it.

Ken Usdin

analyst
#28

All right. Then a different item regarding TTS; the NII tied to TTS has been quite impressive as rates climbed during this quarter. Admittedly, one day was lighter and currency effects might be present. For Q1, that pullback, I'm simply asking where that sits in terms of its asset liability sensitivity, the TTS/NII? And how do you view that component of the NII picture moving ahead?

Mark Mason

executive
#29

Certainly. Yeah. I guess I would mention a few points. We do have some Argentina flowing through the NII line. What I'd say is the cleanest way to frame it is the underlying beta activity; and we've observed — this is a corporate client, it is an institutional client. We've observed betas, especially within the U.S., at roughly normalized or terminal levels and working through that somewhat; we're observing betas beyond the U.S. keep climbing when it comes to the TTS client base; yet all of that, once more, falls within the range we've discussed. I don't anticipate seeing year-over-year growth on the NII line, anywhere near what we've witnessed in earlier years, earlier quarters, simply given how the rate environment's changed and given quantitative and tightening and the effect on deposit levels. The final point I'd offer here is we will keep driving and seeing growth when it comes to the operating deposits. And that's going to be a significant tailwind that flows through.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#30

Jane, Mark, I've got a question, perhaps about Argentina. You showed $100 million in NII, along with a total net income benefit of $500 million after tax; that likely suggests somewhere around $500 million, $600 million of benefit from noninterest income. Which line item — sorry, which segment did that flow through? And can that be sustained?

Mark Mason

executive
#31

Yes. Look, clearly there's a combination of factors behind that net income, among them a tax impact following last year's Argentina devaluation activity, which sits in that line. But to put it briefly, when you consider what kind of business we conduct in Argentina, it's a significant piece of our institutional client relationships. The main activities encompass certain TTS-type things we've discussed, such as liquidity management, payments, custody inside the services business. So a solid share of the Argentina activity would show up in the services business, with some in Markets too. But once again, most of the activity is in services.

Scott Siefers

analyst
#32

Robert, I believe you brought up part of this a few questions back, but perhaps give us a general update on where you stand with rate positioning. The reason I ask is that it seems we could be beginning to see global rate paths move apart, if we possibly head lower in Europe while rates stay elevated here for some time. Taken together, do these sorts of things make managing the situation harder, or do they leave you feeling more or less optimistic regarding the company's overall NII momentum?

Mark Mason

executive
#33

Sure. I'll attempt to address that in 2 parts, I suppose. First, when I consider how the rate implies have moved from the 3 to 6 to now a bit above 1 relative to what I anticipate for our performance, there's no significant effect on the guidance I provided of $80 billion to $81 billion. That's partly due to how I view the timing of the planned cuts, which were largely weighted toward the back end, along with certain other elements that come into play. For instance, Argentina announced a reduction in its policy rate just yesterday or a couple of days ago. Should rates remain somewhat elevated for longer, we'll monitor how the betas keep developing. I noted before that the late fees in the cards business arrived somewhat earlier. In fact, late fees get recorded within our NII line. Those elements leave me feeling that there will surely be pluses and minuses in how that rate curve shifts. As a result, I'm quite at ease leaving the guidance as it stands. To address your wider question about how we're positioned, I'd direct you to the 10-K we've published. Within that 10-K, we provide, just as we've done previously, several IRE scenarios for plus or minus 100 basis points and what that means for our business. If you examine it, you'll find that for the combined firm at Citi, U.S. dollar and non-U.S. dollar, we are asset-sensitive. Thus, when rates rise, we ought to see our NII performance improve. Yet if you check the breakdown, and that's roughly — I believe it was around $1.4 billion or so regarding the effect of that movement. But if you check the breakdown, what it will reveal is that for U.S. dollar, at this stage, we're neutral. So whether rates moved up or rates moved down, there'd be no significant effect on our revenue. When it comes to non-U.S. dollar, we remain fairly asset-sensitive, correct? That should give you a sense that at that — and we acknowledge the constraints of IRE. It presumes a 100 basis point parallel shift along the curve, a static balance sheet, and so on. Still, that ought to give you a bit of a feel for what the shifts in the rate curve mean for our book of business.

Gerard Cassidy

analyst
#34

Mark, could you tell us — clearly, there's been quite a bit of discussion regarding charge-offs on credit cards and the credit quality in that area. If we turned to the corporate segment, which clearly is quite strong. We've observed spreads tightening in the markets for high-yield corporate debt, leveraged debt, and so forth. Things are quite robust out there. But given global geopolitical risk, do you expect those spreads to widen? Could you tell us what you're observing in the corporate segment when it comes to competition? Are underwriting standards becoming somewhat looser now as firms attempt to expand their books? What are you seeing there?

Mark Mason

executive
#35

Look, demand for corporate credit remains solid. What I would say is that we have stayed quite disciplined regarding where we choose to play on the risk profile here. We've remained quite disciplined when it comes to the investment grade, large multinationals that we serve. And from an underwriting standpoint, that hasn't changed. We have observed areas such as private credit picking up considerably; and that, I believe, will keep evolving. I think crucially, when we consider our corporate lending activity, you'll notice that in fact, we've stayed quite disciplined about how we choose to deploy balance sheet. And part of that, once again, results from the revenue sharing that we've put in place, where there's been healthy debate and discussion regarding the names we wish to keep serving and whether they're positioned to benefit from the broader platform that we have. And so I think the space will keep evolving. I think there's been solid, healthy demand despite a continued strong balance sheet; and part of that demand stems from where rates are likely to head and keep evolving. And I think we're well positioned to be thoughtful about that; but Jane, you might want to add a couple of points to it.

Jane Fraser

executive
#36

Absolutely. If you take a global view, both the companies we serve and our mid-market commercial banking customers are in a very strong financial position. On top of that, market access is steadily becoming more available, and that helps high-quality issuers no matter which asset class they're in. We've observed issuers benefiting from this, and investors too. Order books on these deals are heavily oversubscribed. That's been a plus as companies evaluate what they need in terms of financing. Another thing worth pointing out is that we've recently seen big M&A announcements across a number of sectors, which signals growing confidence among CEOs and Boards. As supportive capital markets breed confidence, more active conversations are happening while people weigh bigger strategic deals; that will drive acquisition finance, bridge financing, and certain higher-margin capital markets and lending activity. So looking ahead, I believe it's about acknowledging how some of the drivers have shifted — away from companies simply investing or refinancing or seeking out opportunities to diversify how they raise capital across different quarters. But let me finish by saying I'm completely with you on geopolitical risks and fragility. In my view, the market is being too — it's pricing risk too favorably when it comes to some of these factors.

Mark Mason

executive
#37

Important for us to take this <<inaudible>>.

Matt O'Connor

analyst
#38

During your prepared remarks, you discussed ramping up specific initiatives concerning regulatory processes and data, referencing Slide 4. I was just curious whether you might expand on what you're doing or attempting to do differently in that area, and whether there's any notable financial effect.

Jane Fraser

executive
#39

Yes. Look, Matt, I believe, as we've discussed on numerous occasions, transformation ranks as our number one priority. That will remain true for the coming few years. It serves as the foundation for our future achievement, both when it comes to executing the strategy and the medium-term financial path. And we've been placing considerable investments behind it, not only regarding the consent order but also ensuring we possess this modern, efficient infrastructure. Right now we are deeply engaged in an extensive amount of work, improving our data architecture, automating manual controls and processes, and merging fragmented tech platforms. Each of these assists in boosting our business performance more widely, not merely risk and control over the medium term. As I've mentioned, however, there are certain areas in which we are stepping up our processes and data remediation, especially those tied to regulatory reporting. We're dedicated to getting these right. The organizational changes will assist us with execution and ensure that we're — we possess the momentum and everything required behind it, the investments that we need. We maintain careful attention on execution, ensuring we have the proper level of resourcing and expertise. And we will invest whatever is necessary to ensure we tackle these various concerns. Obviously, I can't provide much more detail regarding our CSI. But with something of this scale, you'd anticipate that we'd have some areas showing good progress and others where we must intensify efforts.

Mark Mason

executive
#40

Absolutely, that's spot on. In conditions like these, and right after the regional bank turmoil of last year, it makes sense that stress scenarios would be under review. Our CCAR processes are being strengthened. Our resolution and recovery processes are being strengthened as well — all of this simply to, in a sense, ensure we're reinforcing our capabilities. And honestly, you would anticipate seeing that throughout the industry.

Saul Martinez

analyst
#41

Let me shift direction slightly; still, I'm wondering whether you can share anything new regarding the Mexican IPO. To be more precise, what I'd like to understand is how fixed that IPO course really is. A new administration is on the way. And suppose it's the candidate from the same party — she might take a less combative stance toward the private sector, possibly being more willing to let a local bank capture value by acquiring a bank. So I suppose, were conditions on the ground to shift, might you consider putting a sale back on the table? Since this really looks like a case in which a private market valuation could come in higher — perhaps even substantially higher — than what a public market valuation would show.

Jane Fraser

executive
#42

Our guiding principle, which has been consistent throughout, is ensuring that whatever decision we make serves the best interest of our shareholders and is what makes the most sense for them. We are — never say never, but our focus is squarely on the IPO route; we think it's the correct one for our shareholders. In Mexico, we're progressing well along that path. We're delighted to have Ignacio Deschamps join as Banamex Chairman to help steer the IPO process. Earlier this quarter, we announced some management teams for the 2 banks. We've advanced considerably toward the technological separation of both banks, followed by the full legal separation during the second half of the year. Clearly, the election is approaching fairly soon; even so, we don't expect that we would depart from the IPO path. That's the path we're currently following. I'll never say never. Yet we do believe this is the right one. Still, we'll monitor developments in Mexico, just as we always do.

Chris Kotowski

analyst
#43

One quick thing for Mark. Earlier, you mentioned "bending the cost curve" from Q3 to Q4 of this year. And during this call, I believe I heard you indicate it's essentially bent, that Q2 ought to be lower and we should decline sequentially going forward. So did that simply occur 6 months sooner? Or does additional bending remain that arrives later this year?

Mark Mason

executive
#44

I'll handle it. I'll take that.

Jane Fraser

executive
#45

Shoot, that was the one I was after.

Mark Mason

executive
#46

I'll claim it — what I mean is, I'll accept the victory, a path that trends lower starting now until the year wraps up, consistent with our outlook of 53.5% to 53.8%, so indeed.

Steven Chubak

analyst
#47

I wanted to ask about DFAST and the SCB, since I realize this is our final chance before those results are published. The macroeconomic scenario and the Fed's assumptions appear pretty close to what we saw a year ago; however, considering how much transformation is currently taking place, the repositioning moves, and the fact that earnings were nearly depressed during the prior year, I was hoping to get a sense of whether any particular factors might cause the SCB to swing more widely in the upcoming exam, plus any bigger-picture perspective on where the SCB is headed over the longer term, especially in light of the organizational simplification work now in progress.

Mark Mason

executive
#48

Yes. Steven, honestly, the opening portion of what you asked simply cannot be answered, right? What I mean is — clearly we've run an internal base scenario. We've run a severely adverse scenario too. A balance sheet was included as part of what we submitted. Yet in the end, the regulators must take the information we've given them and put it through their own models, and whatever comes out of that shapes the stress capital buffer. Our visibility into that process isn't as strong as we'd prefer. So making a call right now is genuinely difficult. On the latter portion of what you asked, I believe you're exactly right, and I touched on this somewhat during my prepared remarks: we have medium-term targets that have been established. We remain in the middle of executing our strategy, evolving the business mix and the business model, shifting toward revenue streams that are more consistent, predictable, and repeatable, which would affect PPNR, along with the simplification effort, which clearly flows through an expense base that will be smaller by the time we reach that medium-term period. So every one of those elements — the divestitures and what they signify, how they could affect the G-SIB score and similar matters, and the capital that gets freed up, of which we've already released roughly $6 billion — all of that has yet to be incorporated, and we think it will prove advantageous for the SCB across the medium term.

Mike Mayo

analyst
#49

Following up on that, Mark. Regarding TTS, your remark was that operational deposits would expand for us. So I'm curious about the source of your assurance that this will happen. Alternatively, is it speeding up, holding at the same rate, or something else?

Mark Mason

executive
#50

Operating deposits did increase during the quarter. That assurance stems from the attention we've directed toward clients we already have, plus the expansion from clients newly brought on board — handling additional business with current ones, extending into additional nations, and reaching further into the commercial middle-market segment. Consequently, we've concentrated deliberately on the deposit types that clearly deliver the greatest worth to us and likewise offer the strongest retention where that connection is concerned. So indeed, that assurance rests on the underlying operating deposit expansion we're observing, which includes what happened within this quarter.

Jane Fraser

executive
#51

Beyond that, a great deal of the money we've been putting to work is what powers much of the expansion we're seeing; we've got product breakthroughs that lead the market, and those keep producing solid returns and solid growth. Whether you're talking about Citi Token Services, Citi Payment Express, 24/7 — every one of these pieces genuinely adds up to a business that our clients find completely invaluable and impossible to do without, and the loyalty of the deposits, including the operating deposits, follows from that. So we're pleased with that expansion; and you're going to hear additional detail on this too, Mike, at the Investor Day in mid-June, which I believe — we're hopeful will be extremely useful for everybody so you can truly wrap your head around the way this business runs, earns money and understand why we refer to it as a crown jewel.

Vivek Juneja

analyst
#52

Mark, since I believe I grasped your response, let's pivot to an entirely separate subject—perhaps what you said was only about the tax advantage for my earlier inquiry. So we'll stop there. If it turns out to be something else, I'll need to dig into that aspect; however, the thing I actually joined to ask was this: you mentioned that among private label and retail partner cards, the share of revolvers is climbing compared with transactors. Could you tell me what that share is? And how does it stack up against the level before the pandemic?

Mark Mason

executive
#53

Yeah. I don't—we haven't provided a breakdown of the transactor versus revolver mix, so I won't delve into those specifics. What I can say is that revolver levels have at minimum returned to their prepandemic point, and I'll stop there; nevertheless, we're observing ongoing revolver activity, which is what you'd anticipate considering how the cycle has unfolded and considering that payment rates have begun to ease and the stimulus has largely dissipated. Consequently, all of this aligns with what we expected, though clearly it plays a role in reserve levels, as I said before.

Betsy Graseck

analyst
#54

On expenses, I simply want to confirm a single point. You've previously mentioned that first-quarter costs would run somewhat high because of restructuring, and you reported $225 million for that period. Turning to 2Q, ought we to keep anticipating a sequential decline? And does that decline consist only of the $225 million dropping away? Or might there be additional restructuring showing up in 2Q too? Put differently, do I merely model a sequential fade across 2, 3, and 4Q to arrive at your full-year figure? Or should I still anticipate a larger drop in 2Q?

Mark Mason

executive
#55

Sure. To respond quite directly, you ought to simply fade it. However, I'd add that Q1, when examined closely, contains the $250 million FDIC charge. Once you remove that, we actually landed below our guidance, correct? Even so, I'm stating the same thing — making the identical point — that is, expect a declining trajectory from now until year-end; and although no further restructuring charge will appear, ordinary BAU repositioning activity will continue to flow through; so ideally that addresses your question, Betsy. The guidance remains intact, and the downward path is what we're steering toward as we move through the rest of the year.

Jen Landis

executive
#56

Appreciate everyone being here. Should anything else come to mind afterward, just give us a ring, and we'd be glad to speak with you. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#57

This concludes the Citi First Quarter 2024 Earnings Call. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Citigroup Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Citigroup Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Citigroup Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.