Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 3, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Anh Huynh
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for joining. With me today are Richard Mack, who serves as both Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of Claros Mortgage Trust; J. Michael McGillis, our President and a Director of Claros Mortgage Trust; and Jai Agarwal, CMTG's Chief Financial Officer. Also on the line are Kevin Cullinan, an Executive Vice President who heads up MRECS Originations, and Priyanka Garg, an Executive Vice President who oversees MRECS Portfolio and Asset Management. Ahead of this call, we sent out CMTG's earnings supplement, and we'd ask that you look at those documents alongside what gets presented today. Should any questions come up after we finish, feel free to reach out to me directly. Let me note for everyone that forward-looking statements may be part of today's call, as defined under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Because of a number of significant factors — among them the ones covered in our other SEC filings — actual results could end up differing materially from what those forward-looking statements suggest. Anything forward-looking that gets said today reflects where we stand only as of now, and we're not taking on any duty to revise it later. Today's call will additionally touch on some non-GAAP financial measures, distributable earnings among them, which in our view can matter to investors when evaluating how we're performing operationally; for the non-GAAP reconciliation, take a look at the earnings supplement. At this point, I'll hand things over to Richard.
Richard Mack
executiveHello, and thanks to all of you for being with us on CMTG's second-quarter earnings call. CMTG turned in yet another solid quarter, and we keep building momentum on the strategic priorities we've laid out: originations, asset management, and activity in the capital markets. In Q2, we originated roughly $1 billion in new loans, which shows our ongoing emphasis on the residential sector along with high-growth markets like Dallas and Atlanta. Our asset management team likewise achieved meaningful progress over the quarter. As we mentioned on the prior call, we were able to resolve our biggest non-accrual loan, which produced a favorable result for our stockholders and brought non-accrual loans down substantially, to about 2% of the portfolio. We continue to aim at clearing up the non-accruals that are left at some point in the future. Also, I'm happy to report that despite turbulence in capital markets, we added to our financing strength by securing a further $150 million bridge acquisition facility. As for the markets more generally, growing uncertainty now stands as the leading theme, creating hurdles for investors in every asset class. Up to now, the top stories involved inflation at record levels, supply chains thrown into disarray, monetary policy getting tighter, and geopolitical difficulties. Mixed economic data plays a part in our assessment. Among the things we look at are segments where economic growth is slowing, places where inflation runs hot, places where inflation is mild, costs of borrowing that are higher, corporate margins that are weakening, a dollar that is gaining strength, commodity prices that are falling or swinging wildly, and corporate commentary that is all over the place. These signals conflict with one another, and they obscure the economic picture while making the narrative around potential economic outcomes even more complicated; not surprisingly, plenty of debate remains over whether the Fed can achieve a soft landing. In our view at CMTG, a modest recession is what's most likely, though it's far from guaranteed. What is guaranteed is that the conversation keeps evolving and expanding in scope and complexity as we think harder about how interconnected the U.S. economy is with other major economies, and what that implies for our economic outlook here in the U.S; and more specifically in real estate. Turning to something more encouraging: in the current investment climate, transitional real estate lending continues to stand out, because alternative lenders now face an increasingly appealing range of opportunities — particularly when it comes to floating rate approaches, like the strategy CMTG uses. During the last few months, credit spreads have widened sharply, as banks and the securitization market have pulled back on risk. On top of that, rates are rising at a pace never seen before, which means the loans we are newly originating could deliver stronger total returns while carrying the same level of risk, or even less, than what was possible only half a year ago. What's more, it looks like the recent hikes, along with possible further increases, will continue to give our sector a tailwind and drive better returns. Looking further ahead, it's possible that credit spreads will narrow somewhat, since absolute returns continue to rise to a level where we think money will start flowing into our sector instead. Given how attractive the environment is right now for transitional real estate lending, one point has to be acknowledged: when benchmark rates rise and credit spreads widen, it creates uncertainty about equity valuations. Our position is that if an asset is tied to medium- or long-term leases with small rent escalations or none at all, or if it's located in a rental market that isn't rapidly inflating, its valuation should be written down. That means public equity REIT markets are, in fact, already reflecting lower property values. With that context in mind, CMTG has zeroed in on providing loans secured by residential rental properties that have brief lease terms and are located in markets experiencing rapid expansion and insufficient supply, since income streams there should climb more quickly. At a time when property valuations remain murky and buildings generating consistent income may be declining in worth, we believe CMTG's strategy — participating in the capitalization structure as a creditor, especially at a level where a substantial layer of junior capital rests below our position to protect what we've invested — is more relevant than it has ever been. From where I sit, this stands out as one of the best opportunities to operate as a lender in the real estate space that I've seen throughout my professional life. The thing that allows CMTG to seize the opportunity in front of it isn't just being in the right sector at the right time. It's the institutional nature of our platform. That means investment processes and procedures that have been proven, combined with the experience across generations and cycles that Mack Real Estate Group delivers as an owner, operator, manager, and developer. We anticipate these factors will stay the primary drivers of our results. When it comes to how we invest, we focus on transitional lending opportunities that are secured by high-quality assets and backed by institutional-grade sponsors; we mostly originate floating-rate senior loans at attractive LTVs, with a focus on major markets and chosen high-growth markets. Given our position among the biggest commercial mortgage REITs, we have the size needed to provide financing options for a number of the world's best-capitalized real estate sponsors. On top of that, the standing we've earned and the know-how we've accumulated have allowed us to form dependable, long-lasting lending ties as our operations have expanded. We anticipate that the liquidity reach those ties give us is going to become increasingly essential, since some financing counterparties are growing more cautious or are even choosing to stay out of the action entirely. The $150 million bridge acquisition facility we closed recently, while capital markets were in upheaval, shows we can bring in extra capital during a stressful stretch and reflects both how solid CMTG's credit quality is and how capable our capital markets team is. As we look ahead, we think our achievement will come from combining all these elements—our know-how, what we're capable of, the connections we've built, our ability to obtain capital, how solid our balance sheet is, the fact that we carry little debt, and our capacity to secure financing. It's lucky for us that being careful has meant holding more cash than usual, especially since lenders are offering increasingly attractive terms on spreads and rates. So in this market that keeps changing, with new chances appearing all the time, we feel we're in a great spot to act very selectively and seize the right moments. Now I'd like to turn it over to Mike McGillis, who will take us through the portfolio.
J. Michael McGillis
executiveThanks, Richard. We've been shifting our portfolio toward asset classes we consider defensive, and toward sectors with solid supply-demand fundamentals that can keep supporting revenue growth at the asset level. On top of that, we keep putting capital to work in select high-growth markets that show favorable demographic trends along with job and wage growth. Our Q2 origination activity mirrors our ongoing emphasis on these high-conviction themes. In the second quarter, we originated roughly $1 billion in total loan commitments spread across eight investments, which lifted originations for year-to-date 2022 to $2.2 billion. About half of what we originated in Q2 was in multifamily, and that drove a 9% quarter-over-quarter rise in our multifamily exposure. We also kept adding build to rent and industrial investments to the portfolio, while taking advantage of attractive opportunities we sourced in hospitality and mixed-use. Multifamily remains our biggest property type, making up 41% of the portfolio's UPB as of June thirtieth, and we expect it to stay an overweight allocation for us. To illustrate, we originated a $152 million floating rate loan secured by a portfolio of multifamily assets in Dallas, Texas. The borrower is well known for extensive value-add experience and a significant presence in that market. The business plan responds to demand for renovated multifamily product in a desirable Dallas submarket that has shown strong double-digit rent growth and low vacancy rates. Our portfolio UPB stayed relatively flat quarter-over-quarter at $7.1 billion. Initial and follow-on fundings offset the elevated repayment activity we saw during the quarter. Out of $782 million in repayments, including loan sale proceeds from the non-accrual loan Richard mentioned, $562 million were collateralized by assets in New York, which drove the 8% quarter-over-quarter decline in our New York exposure. That reduction in New York exposure spanned a mix of property types, such as hospitality, office, for sale condo, mixed use, and land. As noted earlier, one of our priorities has been to diversify the portfolio further by geography, and we think we've made excellent progress there. At June 30, New York accounted for 25% of the portfolio, versus 44% for the same period a year ago; apart from California, comprising 21% of the portfolio in the D.C. Metro area, comprising 12% of the portfolio. No other state made up more than 10% of the portfolio. We've also been deploying capital and growing our presence in Texas and Georgia, which represented 10% and 8% of the portfolio, respectively, at June 30. As Richard mentioned, we successfully resolved our largest non-accrual loan during Q2, the $116 million New York land loan. Because of our ownership mindset approach to lending, we believe we can benefit from taking a longer duration view on certain investments, given our conviction in our underwriting and the quality and basis of the underlying collateral. This land loan serves as a solid illustration of the way our strategy for investing and managing assets allowed us to produce an appealing result for those holding our stock. From this investment came a levered gross return of roughly 12.5%, and through this resolution we booked a gain of $30 million, equal to $0.21 per share, in Q2. At this point I'd like to hand the call over to Jai.
Jai Agarwal
executiveThanks, Mike and Richard, and good morning to all of you. In Q2, distributable earnings came in at $71.5 million, or $0.51 per share, excluding realized losses; that's up against the previous quarter's $33.5 million, or $0.24 per share. On a GAAP basis, net income reached $63.2 million, or $0.45 per share. Two main factors drove the sequential rise in distributable earnings: first, a gain of $0.21 per share tied to resolving the non-accrual land loan; second, stronger operating results from our New York City REO hotel portfolio, which added $0.03 per share to distributable earnings versus a $0.03 per share loss in the prior quarter — a six-cent per share swing. Additionally, we took an $11 and a half million charge-off, equal to $0.08 per share, on a $16 million dollar loan sitting on non-accrual status. That loan is backed by the estate of a former borrower, and we had previously held a $6 million dollar CECL reserve against it. This quarter, reflecting a proposed settlement offer, we booked an extra $5 and a half million CECL reserve and wrote off the entire $11 and a half million reserve as a realized loss under GAAP; going forward, we anticipate recovering $3 and a half million on this loan. Our general CECL reserve now sits at $73 million, which equals 1% of our outstanding principal balance. That's $3 million higher than the prior quarter, driven mainly by portfolio growth and macroeconomic assumptions. On liquidity: we closed the quarter with more than $460 million in cash alongside $735 million in unencumbered loan assets; we also put in place a $150 million bridge acquisition facility, letting us close loans unlevered and giving us as long as 6 months to pursue optimal financing. We keep carrying excess liquidity for both offense and defense. As for interest rates, following the recent rate hikes, we've turned asset sensitive now that we've passed the crossover point where portfolio earnings move positively with benchmark rate increases; our estimate is that a 100 basis point rise in rates above spot rates as of June thirtieth would lift annual net interest income from our existing portfolio by $0.12 per share. Rates have already gone up and are still climbing since June thirtieth. At quarter end, leverage stayed at 1.9 times, among the lowest in the industry. We anticipate that figure rising as we put more capital to work, while still targeting leverage of 2.5 to 3 times. Finally, CMTG stock joined the Russell family of indexes during the quarter, and we keep seeing daily trading volumes in our stock increase. I'd like to now open the call to questions. Operator, please go ahead.
Rick Shane
analystHello, everyone. Is my voice coming through?
J. Michael McGillis
executiveThat's right.
Rick Shane
analystGreat. Hey, Richard. In some respects, I believe I'm picking up on a couple of different points from you, and I'd really like to sort of square them with each other. On one hand, I think your message is, "Hey, the markets are out of whack. When investors are frightened, that's an opportune moment to deploy capital," and you've set yourself up nicely to do exactly that. And I get that touring can feel a bit unsettling, but I think it's reasonable. Yet at the same time, when we reflect on what came up during earnings calls this quarter, the consensus trade still seems to be multifamily Sun Belt. How do you square the notion of going contrarian with the question of just how crowded that specific niche might potentially be?
Richard Mack
executiveWell, I appreciate that question, Rick Shane. Honestly, I don't believe any squaring is actually required; maybe we aren't being as opportunistic as we possibly could be, since what we can do is put money into concessions that, as a lender, but generate returns in cash flowing assets where previously we might have needed to make a construction loan to get a comparable return. Essentially, given the backup in the market, we're taking a fairly conservative stance regarding what we lend on and the LTV/LTC we lend at. Thanks to the backup in the market, we can get returns that look a lot alike for reduced risk compared with what we did previously. It's possible that we aren't being as opportunistic as we could be at every moment; we're going to be choosy about construction and alpha generating trades. We feel fairly confident that we can step down in risk and earn comparable or superior returns; that's more or less how we've been playing the market here. I believe we'll keep barbelling this with more conservative cash flowing Sun Belt multi, where we view the demographic demand as very strong and we consider it about as close to recession-proof as anything we see. Plus with short-term leases that can capitalize on the inflating market and shield you from interest rate moves. We'll keep doing that where capital is scarce and be opportunistic when we genuinely believe we're getting paid to take on more risk. Hopefully that answered you.
Rick Shane
analystThat's really responsive and quite useful, and it provides a great deal of insight, and it helps me grasp what's happening far more clearly. I appreciate it.
Richard Mack
executiveI appreciate it.
Don Fandetti
analystYeah, could you share a bit about what you're expecting for net portfolio growth across the coming few quarters? It seems as though in Q3, the portfolio might have shrunk somewhat, and sort of how that connects to your capacity to cover the dividend from core earnings.
Richard Mack
executiveJai or Kevin?
Jai Agarwal
executiveDon, that comes down to repayments. As we receive more of them, our ability to expand the portfolio increases. Regarding your next question—whether the dividend is covered—we have confidence on that front, particularly when you consider the forward curve for SOFR. If you turn to page 16 of our deck, you'll see we've become asset sensitive, meaning any rise in interest rates flows directly to the bottom line. Whether deployment moves more slowly or repayments come in more slowly, or even with both happening, we anticipate covering the dividend across the entire year.
Don Fandetti
analystWhen it comes to how the net portfolio grew, you contracted somewhat during this quarter, and from what we've observed regarding Q3, it seems the decline was a bit larger. Should we expect that trend to keep easing? Could you share some thoughts on the deal flow happening on the ground? Is there sufficient activity to roughly offset the repayments?
Jai Agarwal
executiveYeah, I'll begin. , we hold $460 million in cash, which means we're staying highly selective about where we put that money to work. We're seeing plenty of opportunities out there, and Kevin can provide additional perspective on the market. , if repayments likewise continue to be a drag, that means loans outstanding on the ground will, should borrowers not pay, potentially get extended, and that would allow us to produce additional earnings.
Kevin Cullinan
executiveOkay, Kevin Cullinan speaking. I want to add a few thoughts on the pipeline in front of us. From where we sit, it's still quite strong, and we are always reviewing a great number of possibilities for putting money back to work while repayments come in. I'd even say this somewhat reflects what Richard mentioned before — we believe we can accomplish that in a way that adds to earnings, given where spreads and rates stand today, relative to certain repayments we're getting right now. Our view stays constructive about redeploying funds into assets that are accretive and possibly carry even lower execution risk.
Don Fandetti
analystYeah, no. Look, it's definitely encouraging to see those repayments come in, especially considering the New York, New York exposure and everything that's happened historically. I was just hoping to understand whether you believe you can return to a growth mode. Thanks.
Jade Rahmani
analystThank you so much. Setting aside multifamily in the Sun Belt, which you described as defensive, where do you find the strongest opportunities? Could you share any detail about what kinds of situations those are?
Richard Mack
executiveKevin would like to—
Kevin Cullinan
executiveOf course, Jade. This is Kevin, and I'm glad to address that, Jade. Beyond the multifamily segment, where we have clearly maintained a high level of activity, we've finalized and are currently pursuing several properties in what we'd characterize as upscale leisure-focused hospitality, an area where we believe relative value remains quite strong. This holds true even with the structural safeguards and underwriting standards we're putting in place to account for potential significant economic volatility throughout the life of the loans we're presently structuring; that's a market segment where these assets are delivering solid results. They're bouncing back strongly as we emerge from the pandemic. We're observing rather steady increases in ADR, RevPAR, and occupancy across 2022, along with future bookings, which is key; competition here is somewhat thinner; we anticipate continuing to review and assess these opportunities, though with a high degree of selectivity regarding both the properties themselves and the pricing levels we're prepared to commit at within those specific capital structures. Another area where we believe we hold a slight advantage is definitely the industrial category. During Q2, we finalized a deal in industrial that was intricately structured and bolstered by credit support from both the borrower and a partner who has arranged a future takeout for that property. We're quite pleased with how that balances risk and reward, and we're engaged in comparable ventures where we're achieving some alpha, substantial credit strengthening through available deposits and cash reserves, plus forward takeouts on certain of those assets. Outside of multifamily, where we identify highly appealing relative value if one can navigate past the distractions, I'd point to lease-oriented hospitality and newly constructed industrial.
Jade Rahmani
analystTurning to multifamily, when it comes to its defensive characteristics, historically during downturns in the economy, rents haven't fallen or turned negative. That said, we've just come through an incredibly strong stretch of inflation and rent increases, and over the past 10-plus years, multifamily has been — I'd call it — the favored asset class. When you're underwriting transactions, how do you factor in a multifamily value correction that I think is already happening, plus a moderating outlook for rent growth, into your underwriting? Thanks for taking the question.
Kevin Cullinan
executiveNo, great question, Jade, and glad to take that one too. I'd frame it as twofold. At a minimum, we fully anticipate rent growth slowing across many of the markets we're active in and evaluating. We're underwriting those assets with that in mind. More significantly, I'd say, given the levels at which we're lending and investing, we're entering at debt yields or cap rates on our position that we believe are protected from day one and don't depend on rent growth down the road. The rent growth, of course, represents upside and matters to the equities business plan. But when we're coming in at mid-single digit debt yields, maybe there's a modest amount of upside in a rent roll. Maybe the market offers some rent growth ahead; we aim to size our positions so that we aren't counting on any of that at all, and so that our debt yield is backed by forward-looking cap rates, incorporating certain assumptions about interest rate shifts over time and where we think the 10-year will sit when we consider either initial maturity or past that point. We're approaching this with our eyes wide open, and we believe we're choosing our spots wisely and not depending on that. That kind of future growth — anyone can reach the conclusion that it's hard to maintain over the long run.
Jade Rahmani
analystThanks.
Steven Delaney
analystMorning, and I appreciate you fielding this. It's just that we're beginning to pick up on some signals stemming from credit repricing in the market for assets that are comparable — comparing now with half a year back, let's say. Could you speak to that, plus the spreads above LIBOR you're getting on loans that are similar? Where might you say things have shifted over, let's say, the trailing 6 to 12 months? Thanks.
Kevin Cullinan
executiveAppreciate it, Steve. I can handle that one once more. What I'd say is, I'll zero in on the past 6 months, since in this kind of market and this kind of environment, a full 12 months comes across as a fairly distant memory by now.
Steven Delaney
analystThat's precisely right.
Kevin Cullinan
executiveWhen you compare equivalent risk across equivalent asset classes and business plans, I'd say that during the past 6 months, or maybe from the close of the year onward, we could say spreads have widened by at least 100 basis points.
Kevin Cullinan
executiveYeah. And that's unfortunate, and we ought to mention that a portion of it is coming from the bank financing market, or rather the shortage of securitizations that have turned out to be somewhat obtainable in the market; that isn't entirely ROE, but
Richard Mack
executiveWe are observing that return on equity growth, or net interest income generated by those underlying assets, adds value to our position and benefits the portfolio over the long term. On the liability side of the balance sheet, we are certainly having to put in more effort to ensure we assemble the most optimal capital stack.
Steven Delaney
analystUnderstood. So clearly, $1 billion came through the door, and then roughly $600-$700 million went back out as new loans. From how you're laying that out, Kevin, I'd take it that the freshly originated loans are carrying noticeably better spreads than whatever got paid off. At least on the asset side of the balance sheet, your yields are getting better rather than worse.
Richard Mack
executiveThat's the trade-off, exactly. The whole loan.
Steven Delaney
analystAll right.
Richard Mack
executiveWithout a doubt, when it comes to putting money into fresh investments, the rates are above what we see coming back through repayments, by and large. And we're paying close attention to ensuring the capital stack is optimized.
Steven Delaney
analystregarding the refinancing terms you have to work out — how would you characterize that? Is it widespread? In other words, does this stem from conditions in the market overall, or is there one specific bank pulling back and attempting to make its lending criteria stricter? Or do essentially all the lenders share the same stance when it comes to that financing?
Jai Agarwal
executiveI'm able to address that, Steve.
Steven Delaney
analystAppreciate it, Jai Agarwal.
Jai Agarwal
executiveSure thing, Steve. I want to make one thing clear — what we're talking about is credits getting repriced when they're financed anew, not credits that are already on the books.
Steven Delaney
analystGot it. Oh, yes.
Jai Agarwal
executive.
Steven Delaney
analystExactly.
Jai Agarwal
executiveHow this plays out depends on each institution — it differs from one bank to the next. Let's say a couple of banks simply aren't writing any new business at all. By and large, though, the loans banks are pricing carry wider spreads than what they offered before. Our situation has been favorable. We've found ourselves well placed to secure financing, whether through our warehouse counterparties or via the note-on-note structure. Things are working in our favor. Beyond that, there are banks involved. Banks have grown pickier about whom they're willing to lend to. My sense is that banks are focusing their lending operations on bigger participants, the way we are.
Steven Delaney
analystYeah. Thanks to you both for the remarks.
Richard Mack
executiveThanks. I'd simply like to express my appreciation to everybody for being here. Regarding a few of the inquiries, I'd wrap up by noting that we possess capital ready for deployment. Through repayments, we'll end up with even more. Being a lender right now is genuinely great. In numerous respects, I believe being a borrower is difficult at present. I believe the current climate allows us to operate in a growth posture while simultaneously lowering our risk regarding how many cash flow assets we lend against, and by diversifying what's in our portfolio. This is especially true when we lend on multifamily properties in high growth markets at cap rates where virtually no rent growth is required. Such assets align with our guiding principle. They're properties we'd be glad to hold in markets where our experience and expertise run deep, at a basis we consider compelling, which is essentially how we view things. The spreads we're achieving were once tied to heavy transitional deals, but now apply to light transitional ones; that exchange appeals to us greatly. As Kevin noted, we can also obtain industrial exposure in a manner unavailable to us before. We'll keep enriching our portfolio through alpha generation, continuing to leverage our development capabilities and originate some construction loans, especially within the industrial segment. We'll also originate loans in hospitality to generate alpha where we identify opportunities that are mispriced. Despite worries about asset valuations, being a lender is quite thrilling at the moment, thanks to the degree of capital subordination we can secure, resulting from the capital markets backup. I appreciate everyone for listening, and I wanted to convey just how bullish we currently feel about the environment. I'm eager to speak with all of you once more on the upcoming quarterly call.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, that concludes today.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.