Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 10, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Anh Huynh
executiveThanks, everyone. With me today are Richard Mack, our CEO and Chairman at Claros Mortgage Trust; Mike McGillis, President and a Director of Claros Mortgage Trust; and Jai Agarwal, CMTG's Chief Financial Officer. Also joining us are Kevin Cullinan, an Executive Vice President who heads MREC Originations, and Priyanka Garg, an Executive Vice President who heads MREC Portfolio and Asset Management. Earlier, before this call, we sent out CMTG's earnings supplement. Please use those documents alongside what we present today. Should any questions come up after this call, feel free to reach out to me. Everyone should be aware that forward-looking statements may be part of today's call, as defined under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Various important factors, among them those covered in our other SEC filings, could cause actual results to differ materially from what those forward-looking statements indicate. Any forward-looking statements we make today reflect our views only as of today, and we have no obligation to update them. We'll also reference certain non-GAAP financial measures, including distributable earnings, which in our view may matter to investors when assessing our operating performance. For non-GAAP reconciliations, please see the earnings supplement. I'll now hand the call over to Richard.
Richard Mack
executiveHello, and I appreciate all of you being here on this call about our results for the third quarter. Saying that market swings and doubt remain the dominant story might be putting it mildly, as investors and borrowers deal with elevated inflation, climbing rates, supply chain problems, geopolitical dangers abroad, and political fractures and ambiguity within the country. The economic figures are still inconsistent, and valuations are spread out broadly while investors in every asset class evaluate the Fed's rate approach and argue over whether it can achieve a soft landing. Even with all of this, we think the American economy is in better shape and more capable of bouncing back than it was in earlier downturns. It is the strongest large economy anywhere, and the U.S. real estate industry should prove more durable than those overseas. That said, our position now is that a downturn will probably take place at some point during 2023 while the Fed works to fix the inflation we're seeing. Going forward, in the short run, we expect additional strain on property values caused by increased rates and, for some, weaker NOI growth, though the effect will differ greatly and depends heavily on the kind of property, the quality of the asset, and the location. On a brighter side, we should acknowledge that chances exist for lenders with solid capital and strong positioning that have shown they can navigate tough economic times, such as CMTG. Our approach to investing centers on transitional lending chances backed by top-tier assets with institutional-level sponsors; we take a rigorous tack toward underwriting and building the portfolio, and we place just as much emphasis—perhaps even more—on managing assets. Because of this, we think our portfolio sits in a good spot given the market conditions we're seeing evolve. Almost every loan we hold carries a floating rate, so we've gained from the rate climate that exists now. If everything else stays the same, further increases in the benchmark rate might lead to additional earnings expansion given the present portfolio, and over 90% of the loans in our floating rate book have rate caps arranged; when it comes to where our assets are allocated, multifamily carries the heaviest weight, making up over 40% of what we hold. Our office exposure is comparatively small, and we hold nothing in stand-alone retail. Right now, our portfolio focuses solely on investments within the U.S., and we carry zero exposure to Europe. Over the past 2 years, we've been shifting our mix away from coastal areas, taking advantage of the positive demographic shifts along with job and rent expansion in specific markets that we expect will hold up better if an economic slump occurs. To accomplish this, we've drawn on the research and perspectives of the larger Mack Real Estate Group team, which has recently put equity into several of those markets. On top of that, given that our portfolio's average LTV sits at 68%, and because we intentionally keep leverage low on the balance sheet, we think we're nicely protected from swings in real estate asset values; our balance sheet management style is conservative, and from the day we were formed we've consistently run with comparatively low leverage. When the economy is uncertain, we feel that a cautious stance on leverage, sufficient liquidity, and the ability to access capital matter greatly, and we want to point out that at the close of the third quarter we held over $500 million in liquidity. We think our business, along with a portfolio built strategically, will keep proving resilient even with the market landscape's uncertainty. Our senior management team brings several decades of experience investing in global real estate across many economic cycles. Every market cycle is different, yet our team is picking up on factors in today's environment, both familiar and new, that are shaping where we concentrate. Through the third quarter, we kept carrying out our strategic priorities; targeted originations, proactive asset management and balance sheet management make up those priorities. As clear evidence, we leveraged our liquidity position and the dislocation in the market to originate $878 million in new loans, achieving strong historical spreads while keeping our focus on high conviction themes in the residential sector, high-growth markets, and one more drive-to hospitality loan. We're happy to report that nonaccrual loans made up under 1% of the portfolio when the quarter ended, a drop from 4% at the year's start. What's more, even with a tough capital market environment, financing remains available to us. In particular, we closed a $1 billion non mark-to-market match term financing facility alongside JPMorgan. Jai will add more detail on this exciting closing. To sum up, we feel our quarterly accomplishments reflect the strength of our management team, our portfolio and institutional relationships, as well as our sponsor's integrated real estate lender, owner operator, developer and property manager business model. Going forward, we intend to be selective in targeting origination volume, grabbing only those opportunities we view as offering the best risk-adjusted returns, all while staying defensive. How quickly we deploy will hinge on where we find prudent and accretive leverage, plus how fast the existing portfolio repays, which might slow given the broader softening in transaction volume and the difficult refinancing climate. It's worth repeating that we believe we're well positioned for what's ahead. Volatility, uncertainty and lasting dislocations are likely to accompany economic disruptions. And we believe that despite the challenging capital markets—and because of them—this environment will bring many compelling CRE lending opportunities in the year to come. We believe CMTG has the scale, balance sheet and team needed to pick and choose our investment opportunities and execute in today's environment. Now, before I hand the call to Mike, I'm pleased to share that our Board of Directors recently authorized repurchasing $100 million of the company's common stock. Our view is that this choice demonstrates how strongly we believe in both our corporate strategy and our financial prospects over the long haul, along with our dedication to boosting shareholder value. At this point, I'd like to hand things over to Mike.
John McGillis
executiveAppreciate that, Richard. On an unpaid principal balance basis, CMTG's portfolio grew 4% versus the prior quarter, reaching $7.4 billion, since new originations and follow-on fundings came in ahead of loan repayments. With $461 million of cash on hand when the third quarter began, plus $559 million of repayments, we were well positioned to take advantage of a number of appealing investment opportunities over the quarter. As Richard noted, across 6 investments we closed $878 million in total loan commitments. Those carried a weighted average credit spread of 530 basis points over SOFR, along with a weighted average LTV of 67%. By loan commitment, 60% of what we originated was multifamily investments, an asset class we regard as defensive. Multifamily remains our biggest asset class concentration, accounting for more than 40% of the portfolio. Also, we kept pushing into several high-growth markets during the quarter, and the third quarter marked our entrance into the Salt Lake City, Utah MSA. We closed 2 multifamily loans there, with aggregate loan commitments of $252 million at weighted average LTVs under 65%. Of those 2 loans, the bigger one is a $176 million construction loan for a high-rise tower made to a well-known and respected sponsor. The other loan provides $76 million of acquisition financing for an existing multifamily asset. Through these transactions we had chances to execute at credit spreads wider than usual while further improving the geographic diversification of our portfolio. For us, the Salt Lake City MSA is a target market, given that it ranks among the country's fastest-growing MSAs and has shown strong population, job and wage growth. Although the interest rate environment has helped our portfolio yields, we understand that borrowers and operators have felt the pressure of higher financing costs. Beyond our asset management team keeping a close watch on borrowers' capacity to pay debt service, our loan documents contain a number of structural protections meant to lessen the effect of rising rates on the borrower's ability to pay debt service. Among these are interest rate caps, lender controlled cash management accounts and interest and carry reserves. At this point I'd like to hand the call over to Jai.
Jai Agarwal
executiveThanks, Mike, and thanks, Richard. In Q3 of 2020, distributable earnings came to $47.1 million, or $0.33 per share, while GAAP net income reached $42.1 million, or $0.30 per share. The dividend we currently pay is $0.37 per share, translating to an 8.2% yield to book value. Results for this quarter got a $3 million boost, equal to $0.02 per share, from fees accelerated on 2 early repayments. If you set aside that $0.02 along with the gains and losses recorded in the prior quarter, our distributable earnings rose $0.09 per share from one quarter to the next, driven mainly by higher benchmark rates and growth in the net portfolio. We are positioned to gain from the steep forward curve, and assuming the portfolio stays static as of quarter end, a rise of 100 basis points in rates would produce $0.04 in quarterly earnings; worth emphasizing is that benchmark rates have already climbed 70 basis points since the quarter closed, and right now we can cover our dividend. Our general CECL reserve sits at slightly more than 100 basis points of aggregate principal balance. From the prior quarter, that CECL reserve grew by roughly $2.5 million, reflecting net portfolio growth and deteriorating macroeconomic indicators. Seasoning, plus an improved credit profile, offset that. Keep in mind, we carry essentially 0 specific CECL reserves. Now to the balance sheet. We still hold a conservative net leverage ratio of 2.0x, and our leverage target continues to be 2.5 to 3x of equity. Even with capital markets conditions proving difficult, we managed to tap the secured financing market through warehouse lines and note-on-note financing. Most significantly, as Richard noted, after the quarter ended we closed a facility of up to $1 billion with JPMorgan and at the same time financed 3 loans on it, with an aggregate maximum financing commitment of about $400 million. This financing remains matched non-mark-to-market. As of September 30, we had $4 billion drawn under our $5 billion of warehouse lines across 6 counterparties. Worth pointing out is that the weighted average advance rate on these facilities came in at a conservative 67%. That 67% splits into, one, a 75% advance rate on multifamily loans; and 2, 60% across all of the property types, both being weighted average figures. Finally, we keep strong liquidity. At quarter end, liquidity stood at $507 million, made up of $230 million in cash and $277 million of approved and undrawn capacity on our warehouse lots. As of today, we hold more than $0.5 billion in liquidity. We think this leaves us well placed to play both offense and defense. I would now like to hand the call over to the operator for questions.
Don Fandetti
analystIt's encouraging to hear what you said about dividend coverage. Could you share a bit about the conditions you're observing in New York City regarding office and hotel, and whether things keep getting better?
Richard Mack
executiveAbsolutely. I'll address this broadly first, then I'd like to hand it over to Priyanka so she can describe what's happening with our hotel portfolio. The overall strength of New York's economy keeps catching us off guard. Even though far fewer international visitors are coming, tourism seems to have recovered, and we're seeing multifamily rents and occupancies at record levels. That said, the office sector, in my view, keeps lagging. What we've been observing — and have pointed out repeatedly over time — is still playing out. Top-tier buildings are performing well, though I believe we're beginning to notice some resistance even among the best buildings when it comes to rents, specifically around concessions, while weaker properties are truly having a hard time. It's therefore a market of haves and have-nots. Utilization rates remain far under what they were before the pandemic, and far under those found in the fast-growing Sunbelt markets. So, our worry about New York's office market persists. In our view, some categories of buildings will succeed while others won't, and the chance to — along with the necessity to — convert many outdated buildings or demolish them within the office market will keep going, and we'll need to — New York City overall will need to collaborate with its government to determine how to build 24-hour collaborative communities throughout the city, so that the places where people work feel as lively as the places where they live. That's a long-term transformation requiring patience. Certain stretches of New York will simply no longer make sense for office use. Thus we remain worried about New York's office market, while we're far more optimistic about hotels. Priyanka, would you like to share what you're observing across our portfolio?
Priyanka Garg
executiveAbsolutely. Thank you, Richard. Hey Don — regarding the REO hotel portfolio, the third quarter was extremely robust. I believe we're observing that throughout the hospitality industry in New York. Top-line results were excellent. What's notable is that hospitality has genuinely established a new baseline for ADR, one that sits above where it was in 2019. Occupancy remained quite solid for the entire third quarter, primarily fueled by leisure transient demand, though group and corporate business is beginning to return. A major financial institution booked a sizable block of rooms at one of our properties during the fall. So it's great to see compression return, with the final rooms commanding a substantial premium. Overall, we're highly encouraged by the fundamental performance of the REO portfolio.
Rick Shane
analystLook, I believe you folks have pointed out that in certain respects, we find ourselves at a pivotal juncture regarding the market and fundamentals. And because of your modest leverage and the strong position you hold, you basically have 3 options. You could expand assets, you could buy back stock, or you could stockpile liquidity given the possibility of extended asset duration. What's your thinking on those 3 options? Clearly, you raised the buyback authorization. And what's your view on taking on more leverage in the business right now?
Jai Agarwal
executiveI'll address the final question first; regarding leverage, we currently carry conservative debt at 2.0x. And as we've mentioned before, we do anticipate leverage rising to roughly 2.5x and a maximum of 3x. And on your other point concerning assets, asset growth, buyback, liquidity, we discuss this daily within the company, and it's genuinely a debate; in the current environment, whether we repurchase shares, whether we retain liquidity or we put money into assets, we're being extremely selective about where we allocate capital since returns are quite robust today. But at the same time, we also understand how important it is to maintain liquidity. Richard, would you like to add on?
Richard Mack
executiveYeah, Rick, I'd basically say this: across each of those 3 sectors, we're looking to seize whatever chances come our way. Should the market present an opening for us to take on more leverage in a way we judge to be accretive on both the offensive and defensive sides, then we'd probably act on it. If the market hands us what we see as risk-adjusted returns that are outsized, we'll deploy additional capital. That said, it also hinges on the amount of capital coming back to us through repayments, and on making sure we keep a bit of extra cash on hand. As for the shares, our inclination is to stay opportunistic and prudent regarding where we repurchase shares, should we choose to repurchase shares. So in my view, it's an ongoing, day-to-day process of analysis and conversation within the team concerning how to seize opportunities across those 3 areas. That's a genuinely excellent question; there simply isn't a flawless answer for it.
Rick Shane
analystYeah. Look, this is tough. Consider what we've been through staring at our monitors over the past 24 hours — yesterday was incredibly disheartening, and today the markets are abulent. I mean, it's — and I'm certain the same goes for managing it on your end. When you consider the portfolios you've built right now and the opportunities currently available, do you — is the — should that extra dollar go into what you already own? Or is the incremental opportunity out there so compelling that putting the next dollar back into the market simply makes sense?
Richard Mack
executiveI mean, again, that's a topic we debate daily. And we remain active in the market so we can examine the risk-adjusted returns on what's in our portfolio and what resembles our portfolio, what diversifies our portfolio, and what those returns look like. So it's — again, it's sort of a daily task as we seek to maximize value for shareholders.
Rick Shane
analystAll right, and once more, we truly value how clear you were thematically regarding how the portfolio is constructed. It becomes far simpler to grasp the risk and, in a way, where you sit among competitors. So thanks for going over that again.
Steven Delaney
analystWell, regarding your choice to repurchase stock and how you allocate capital, shares are up 10% today, so your near-term thinking on that could shift. I'm only kidding when I mention it, though it's good to witness. What caught my attention in the report you issued was that new JPMorgan facility — $1 billion, with terms and a structure that are highly advantageous for you. My mind goes back to March of 2020 — I mean, from March of 2020 onward, or that spring of 2020, what we've endured during these past couple of months is likely the most volatile and uncertain stretch. I'm curious what you think about the reason banks are staying committed this time around. It seems to me that perhaps back in 2020, folks worried about a credit event stemming from the pandemic's economic fallout. And perhaps now, as you pointed out, Richard, regarding New York City's economy, this is being viewed as a rates event brought about purely by the Fed's stance and tightening. And for certain parties, the banks don't appear to be pulling away. I'd genuinely value perspectives from you, Richard, or Mike, or Jai — whoever has been in discussions with the banks — and broadly what you sense the banks' attitude is toward extending credit to real estate firms such as yours.
Richard Mack
executiveI believe each of the 3 of us will hold somewhat differing views on this, so I'll begin by noting that banks are exercising far greater caution in the way they conduct business. And they — it does strike me that they're being much more selective about whom they choose to work with. And when it comes to JPMorgan, I believe we've shown them that we're the kind of counterparty they wish to engage with. And they — they're looking to deploy capital at rates that are elevated for them too, yet they'll only do so with a chosen few. And I think that makes for a highly beneficial setting for a business such as ours. A situation of haves and have-nots when it comes to who has been able to access capital.
Jai Agarwal
executiveSteve, one more thing I'd mention is that not every bank is open for business. A number of them have told us they've simply stopped lending in this area; so that's happening too, but we're in a good position because we still have access to capital.
John McGillis
executiveWhat I'd throw in as well is on the money center banks — Richard and Jai, I'm totally with you on how they feel — yet when it comes to the regional banks, for the proper projects that carry the proper size characteristics, we keep seeing them stay active as financing counterparties for us throughout our business lines. So there's genuinely a distinction here between the regional banks and the money center banks, especially the ones that are quite relationship oriented and centered on who exactly their borrower is; so that's a fascinating development we've witnessed over these last couple of years.
Steven Delaney
analystThanks for that. One last item from me. $878 million makes for a sizable quarter, especially considering the portfolio you entered with was around the mid $6 billion mark, or perhaps the high 6 as you went into the quarter. Does that include anything outsized, perhaps some kind of large portfolio opportunity? And when I look at it, clearly, with spreads wider, this is an opportunistic moment — a fine time to lend provided you've got the capital and can locate quality deals; but should we anticipate that across the coming quarter or so you might keep posting robust origination quarters? Or was this third quarter merely a small chunk?
Kevin Cullinan
executiveThere's nothing especially outsized in the third quarter, there — that came from 6 separate investments. And we entered the quarter with a very strong balance sheet position along with a very strong liquidity position. And I believe most people have likely observed that the market, or transaction volume, has retreated somewhat, and we were positioned to step up and fill part of that gap. So we're quite pleased with the positions we established in the third quarter. I do anticipate that during the fourth quarter, volume will ease somewhat. But that ties back to what we've discussed throughout this call, where we're balancing the different opportunities our balance sheet has given us to invest, whether that's internally within the company or continuing to capitalize on what we consider a very strong but somewhat more <<inaudible>> opportunity to test the market.
Jade Rahmani
analystCould you discuss the loan maturities coming due? On the slide, there's $576 million. Is that your expectation for 2023? And I assume that's only a few sizable transactions, but do you expect them to be repaid? Anything further you might mention regarding credit risk within the portfolio.
Priyanka Garg
executiveYeah. Jade, this is Priyanka. I'll handle that. Broadly speaking, we — we hold a relatively modest amount of loans that are paying down and — or whose maturities have been completely extended in 2023; that's roughly — it's under $500 million of UPB and it spans 6 loans. So we — a number of those, I believe, will be positioned to repay. The rest will likely involve some form of discussion with the borrower; we were bracing for the worst yet hoping for the best with every one of our borrowers; and — yet from a structural standpoint, Mike mentioned this before, we have very solid safeguards in place. We're comfortable with the exit risk in our basis and the capital our borrowers will want and need to protect at that moment. So when I examine the maturities coming up, I don't have any sort of isolated worries.
Jade Rahmani
analystRegarding the single-family rental and build-to-rent areas where you've been doing business, what's your take on the prospects there? I realize this isn't the precise lending category you're involved in, but hard money lenders—not only Broadmark, which came out with results this week, but a few others too—are struggling in that segment and have experienced quite a significant credit decline; and naturally, homebuilders are staggering when it comes to too much inventory. Meanwhile, a number of those single-family rental companies are posting some weakening in NOI. So I'd just like to hear how that portfolio is performing? And could you also give some context on its size?
Kevin Cullinan
executiveSure, Jade, this is Kevin. So that's a very good question. We clearly are monitoring what you're seeing with homebuilders. I believe that could work in both directions. I believe that might actually open up a bit more opportunity for bigger, well-funded, and institutional single-family rental proprietors. Home affordability is definitely trending lower across most of the nation; and that is producing rather strong fundamentals in the SFR sector in the markets where we've been operating. As part of the whole CMTG portfolio, it's a comparatively modest slice of our balance sheet that's allocated to the SFR sector. It's mainly across one portfolio, much of that portfolio remains under construction, and it has been presold to a major institutional developer too; so there are — there is a timeline of units being delivered over the course of this year and next. But we, and we have been pretty pleased with the early lease-up of certain communities. But we're also considering a forward sale here that has substantially lowered our risk exposure too.
Richard Mack
executiveOne additional point — I believe there's a difference that hasn't been made sufficiently clear yet and that will likely develop as time goes on, separating the SFR category from the build-to-rent SFR category. It's worth noting that our loans are tied to built-to-rent SFR, which connects far more tightly to the multifamily market than most people seem to realize. Therefore, it functions somewhat as an outgrowth of the multifamily market; and we're putting this up in Phoenix, where demand for the product is strong and it essentially runs like horizontal multifamily. Consequently, certain of the weaknesses and strengths of the multifamily market can plainly, or more plainly, show up in these products.
John McGillis
executiveJade, I want to make sure this is clear — the Phoenix development that Richard brought up actually falls under the equity portion of our operations. So to put it plainly, it isn't part of MPT's portfolio.
Jade Rahmani
analystHow much exposure in dollar terms do we have to CMTG?
Jai Agarwal
executiveYou'll find it on Page 11, Jade — approximately $200 million; that figure has been made available on Page 11 within the earnings supplement.
Priyanka Garg
executiveThat amounts to 2% of everything we've committed, and the unpaid principal balance today is really modest, simply because every one of these is still being built.
Richard Mack
executiveThanks, and I appreciate all of you for being here. Our most recent quarter leaves us feeling quite positive. Looking ahead to the questions, I believe it will be demanding — something we believe we can handle — to steer both the possibilities that arise in the marketplace and the hurdles that accompany those possibilities. So we're quite enthusiastic about it. We believe our position is strong moving forward, given our liquidity, our capacity to raise leverage, our capacity to repurchase shares, plus excellent access to deal flow and the capacity to resolve problems, as we've shown we can do within our portfolio. We anticipate having somewhat more of that work ahead as we keep navigating this rather disruptive, dislocated market for probably more than a year; so I'm grateful to everyone for being here, and we look forward to talking with all of you before long on our upcoming quarterly call.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's call. Thanks so much for joining us. At this point, please go ahead and disconnect your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.