Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 17, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Anh Huynh
executiveThanks. With me are Richard Mack, who serves as CEO and Chairman of Claros Mortgage Trust, Mike McGillis, the company's President and a Director, and Jai Agarwal, CMTG's Chief Financial Officer. Also joining us are Kevin Cullinan, an Executive Vice President overseeing MRECS Origination, and Priyanka Garg, an Executive Vice President overseeing MRECS Portfolio and Asset Management. Earlier today, CMTG's earnings supplement went out. We ask that you consult those materials alongside what gets presented during this call. Should any questions come up after we finish, feel free to reach out to me. A reminder to all that forward-looking statements may be part of today's call, as defined under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Because of a range of significant factors, among them those covered in our other SEC filings, actual results could differ materially from what such forward-looking statements suggest. Any forward-looking statements we make today reflect our views as of this date only, and no duty is assumed to revise them. Today's call will also touch on certain non-GAAP financial measures, including Net distributable earnings, which in our view can matter to investors evaluating how we operate. Please see the earnings supplement for non-GAAP reconciliations. I'll hand things over now to Richard.
Richard Mack
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being here on the Claros Mortgage Trust call covering our fourth quarter results. There's no need for me to tell this group that 2022 brought plenty of turbulence, and as we speak today, the economy is still sending mixed signals. On one side, markets at large keep confronting robust growth figures, while on the other, inflation refuses to ease. Compared with where things stood at year-end, the signals do look more bullish now. Investors remain intensely focused on figuring out what dramatically higher rates truly mean for the economy, since all of us are trying to gauge how the Fed will read and react to market data as it emerges. For non-office real estate assets, this is likely the single biggest driver, and we believe that right now, in the contest over asset values between climbing rents and climbing interest rates, the rates side appears to be coming out ahead. A great many variables are shifting and could shape the economic picture across the next several quarters. Among just a handful: China's move to abandon its zero COVID policies, ongoing swings in worldwide energy and food prices, and persistent geopolitical dangers. Our read on the economy stays cautious and broadly matches what consensus expects — a mild recession, with the most probable timing being the latter half of 2023. Keeping all of that in mind, CMTG is moving into this year carefully. If we glance back to sum up 2022 briefly, it proved a highly productive stretch for CMTG. The strategic priorities we laid out during the past year were all met, among them preserving liquidity and capitalizing on what we saw as appealing risk-adjusted returns on offer. We finished the year having originated a total of $3.5 billion. That was well ahead of the previous year and pushed the portfolio to a record $7.4 billion in carrying value along with $9.4 billion in total loan commitments. Across the year, our main emphasis was senior floating-rate loans backed by multi-family properties, plus other chosen property categories enjoying favorable supply-demand conditions, for example industrial, life science, and build-to-rent homes; we also grew our footprint in markets still gaining from swift economic and demographic expansion, among them Dallas, Nashville, and Miami. We broke into new high-growth markets, including Phoenix and Salt Lake City. As mentioned on earlier quarterly earnings calls, these rank among the asset categories and markets where Mack Real Estate Group has been ramping up its equity investments fastest and where, in our view, asset valuations are proving most resilient. On top of that, over the year we broadened and diversified where our funding comes from, which involved signing a $150 million acquisitions facility and completing a $1 billion financing facility. Our capacity to diversify and expand financing options despite a tough capital market backdrop, we believe, reflects the credibility of our platform, the quality of our portfolio, our management team, our institutional relationships, and the relatively conservative leverage on our balance sheet; for the real estate industry as a whole, we anticipate 2023 will be a difficult year. We anticipate that a setting of elevated interest rates and wider loan spreads, plus possible softening in consumer demand, will probably result in ongoing strain on real estate valuations and subdued transaction volumes. This holds true even if the recent tightening of spreads speeds up in the high yield bond market, the CLO market, and the CMBS market. Alongside the difficulties we have observed in the office asset class, we are starting to notice early signs of weaker performance at the asset level throughout the industry, particularly in blue states and cities. Although we expect this pattern to persist, we think asset performance will vary widely and depend heavily on property type, asset quality, and market. Broadly speaking, we believe our asset allocations and market selections put CMTG in a position to endure worsening conditions. Later in the call, Mike will give a more detailed discussion of our portfolio. Even with our confidence in the portfolio, we acknowledge that our business and our borrowers are not shielded from the present macroeconomic or interest rate environment. During this period, we have taken a defensive and disciplined approach to managing our business. Keeping leverage lower today could let us grow our balance sheet to seize opportunities that emerge and to be ready for unknown portfolio problems that have yet to surface. Moreover, we believe that staying ahead of our borrowers through proactive asset management and keeping a long-term investment perspective will be essential to delivering shareholder value. Additionally, Mack Real Estate Group's experience in commercial real estate development, ownership, and property management gives us valuable and distinctive market intelligence powered by boots on the ground and a broad network of industry relationships. Our management team possesses extensive global real estate investment experience spanning multiple economic cycles. We recognize that a period characterized by difficult market conditions is an inherent part of managing a commercial real estate portfolio, and that this ought to give us a chance to set our performance apart and to go on the offensive when the moment is right. Looking ahead, I have great confidence in our team's expertise and its ability to steer us through these times and to identify the entry point to return to an opportunistic stance when the tides inevitably shift. Thank you all for your time today. I will now hand the call over to Mike McGillis.
Mike McGillis
executiveThank you, Richard. For the remarks I have prepared this morning, I want to give you an overview of how we invested during the fourth quarter and the entire year of 2022, and after that I'll share our views on the market and what we expect for certain property types — namely multifamily, hospitality, and office. In the fourth quarter and across the full year of 2022, we closed $359 million and $3.5 billion in originations, respectively, all while continuing to diversify the portfolio across property types and geographies. Every origination we made in the fourth quarter was a senior floating rate transitional loan, spread over three investments secured by life sciences, multifamily, and industrial assets, carrying a weighted average credit spread of 600 basis points over SOFR and a weighted average LTV of 58%. Repayment volume during the quarter was quite subdued, totaling $75 million. Because of the elevated interest rate environment, we anticipate this pattern will persist as borrowers take their as of right extensions and shield their investments through additional equity infusions. CMTG's portfolio, measured on carrying value, rose 2% versus the prior quarter, reaching $7.4 billion. As of year-end, that portfolio carried a weighted average all-in yield of 8.6% and a weighted average LTV of 68%. Importantly, our multifamily exposure grew to 41% as of December 31, 2022, up from 30% at the close of 2021, and at the same time we reduced our exposure to office, land and for sale condo. As Richard noted, we further strengthened geographic diversification by growing our footprint in high growth markets and by adding several new markets to our national presence. Over the course of the year, New York's share of the portfolio declined organically, driven by our strong origination volume and the New York loan repayments we collected during that period. At December 31, 2022, New York accounted for 23% of the portfolio, a meaningful drop from 38% at the end of 2021. The rise in portfolio yields, to 8.6% at year-end 2022 from 5.7% at year-end 2021, was driven primarily by the higher interest rate environment. Now I'd like to offer market color and our thinking for the year ahead. Borrowers, we've observed, keep supporting their properties by refilling interest reserves, covering debt service shortfalls, paying operating expenses out of pocket, and buying replacement interest rate caps. That said, as Richard noted, in light of the economic outlook and what's expected for the real estate industry, we are moving into the coming year cautiously. Multifamily remains our largest exposure by property type, making up 41% of the portfolio at year-end. Within the portfolio, occupancy is generally strong, we're seeing positive trade outs on new leases, and renewals are showing rent growth. Even so, rent growth is beginning to soften, which marks the end of the record growth rates the industry reported over the past several years. Although we expect rental demand to stay strong given a more expensive homeownership market, we do anticipate the top line will normalize as owners compete to keep residents and markets absorb new supply. Our view remains that this sector's core fundamentals will typically beat other asset classes when the economy is in recession. Even so, we are watching this asset class closely, since borrowers are grappling with negative leverage as rates climb. So far, what has encouraged us is how willing and able our borrowers have been to defend their equity, though we are also braced for the opposite outcome. Later in this call, Jai will give detail on one of our multi-family loans in which the sponsor chose not to defend their equity. Now to our hospitality portfolio. At year-end 2022, hospitality made up 20% of our portfolio. Across that year, the industry gained from a steep recovery in hotel demand, as consumers shifted discretionary spending away from goods and toward travel and leisure following COVID. As of today, we still observe record-setting ADRs across many markets, plus ongoing occupancy strength once seasonality is factored in. Looking ahead to next year, we are pragmatic. During recessions, consumers and businesses have historically cut back on travel-related spending, and we expect similar behavior in this economic cycle. The wider effect will likely be lower group demand and corporate transient demand as companies rein in travel budgets. We also expect labor costs to keep climbing and pressure the bottom line; because demand may soften and costs may stay elevated, our asset management team has been closely tracking investments collateralized by hospitality assets; we expect that as the year progresses, some loans in our portfolio will need sharper attention than others. In the end, the hospitality sector would depend heavily on how deep and how long a recession is, if one occurs; as for office, it accounted for just 15% of our portfolio at year-end 2022, or 19% when the office allocation inside mixed-use assets is included. Although work from home appears to be fading somewhat, it is still a lasting theme behind much of the uncertainty over the sector's future. On a brighter side, there have been bright spots in office. Office assets in demand are outperforming thanks to their quality and location, and New York City leasing specifically has produced several strong data points. That said, with rates higher, borrowers must decide whether to put in more capital to defend their equity given weaker demand for certain kinds of office properties. We expect a broad range of outcomes, depending on each borrower's source and cost of capital, their capacity to endure a prolonged stretch of uncertainty, and also the location, asset quality, and demand for space in the submarkets where collateral sits. Jai will give some detail on one of our mixed-use loans with an office component in which the sponsor chose not to defend its equity. Our asset management team's know-how, the manner in which we put our loans together, along with the strong ties we hold with borrowers and the wider set of industry connections, give us, in our view, a solid footing to react to any conclusion our borrowers arrive at as they work through their decision-making. Keeping our attention squarely on the difficulties borrowers are up against is a priority for us, since that lets us produce favorable results for shareholders across the years ahead. At this point, I'll hand things over to Jai.
Jai Agarwal
executiveThanks, Mike, and thanks, Richard. During Q4 of 2022, distributable earnings rose to $53.7 million, equating to $0.38 per share, up from $47.1 million, or $0.33 per share, in the prior quarter. The main drivers were elevated benchmark rates, ongoing deployment of capital, and the performance turned in by our REO hotel portfolio. Distributable earnings fully covered the $0.37 per share dividend we declared for the fourth quarter. On a GAAP basis, we posted a net loss of $22.7 million, or $0.17 per share, reflecting growth in both specific and general CECL reserves over the quarter. As of now, our total CECL reserve equals 1.9% of UPB. Our general CECL reserve climbed to 1.1%, up from 1.0% in the previous quarter; we took a specific CECL reserve of $60 million, amounting to 17% of the aggregate loan amount, on two investments that were shifted to a risk rating of five. That equates to almost a 50% reduction in the value of those assets. Both investments continue to generate cash flow, yet rising interest rates forced borrowers to weigh whether to keep supporting the properties. The first is a $209 million investment secured by a mixed-use property in the Times Square submarket of New York. Three components make up this property. One, substantial retail space under a long-term lease primarily to a national pharmacy chain. Two, signage that is well leased. Three, nine stories of sub-performing office space. Against this $209 million investment, we recorded a $42 million specific CECL reserve. The second is a $139 million investment consisting of 20 multifamily properties with a rent-regulated component in San Francisco. Throughout the COVID downturn, the sponsor supported these assets, but could not keep doing so amid the rising interest rate environment. Against this investment, we recorded an $18 million specific CECL reserve; we are now working out the best resolution for each investment, aiming to maximize shareholder value. At year-end, both loans were financed on our facilities. Now to the balance sheet. Our leverage levels remain conservative. As of December 31st, our net leverage ratio came in at 2.2x, a modest rise from 2.0x at September 30th. The weighted average advance rate on loans subject to asset-specific financings held steady at a conservative 65%, which breaks down further into a 74% advance rate on multi-family loans and 58% on the remaining loans. As of December 31st, our liquidity position was strong, exceeding $500 million. Capital markets have displayed modest improvement signs thus far in 2023, and we remain focused on keeping adequate liquidity. At this point, I'd like to open the call for questions. Operator?
Rick Shane
analystThanks, everyone. Morning. I appreciate your time for my question. Now, slide 12 covering the loan maturity schedule is quite useful, considering the current climate. One thing we've been asking — and we've brought this up repeatedly all earnings season — is to connect the loan maturity schedule with when interest rate caps held by your borrowers expire or their term ends. Clearly, that's a possible risk, and I simply want to know if caps are completely extended or if we ought to view them as ending alongside the initial term.
Priyanka Garg
executiveThank you for asking, Rick. Priyanka here. Well, we do have quite a few borrowers whose interest rate caps are set to expire before their initial term concludes. As things stand right now, 90% of our portfolio has interest rate caps in place. We've been extremely explicit with borrowers that replacement caps must be purchased. That's precisely what they've been doing. A handful have already needed to provide the capital to make that happen. One thing we did when going over 2023 budgets alongside our borrowers was ensure they grasped, looking ahead to the next 12 months and the six months following that, at what point in the calendar year they would need to produce that capital and making sure they were talking with their investors — to the degree they had investors from whom they needed to call capital — in order to purchase those caps. So far, borrowers are doing what they're expected to do, but clearly, you're asking for the right reason, which is that costs have gone through the roof, yet we haven't waived those conditions up to now.
Rick Shane
analystUnderstood. Once more, I value how exact the terms of your agreements are, and all of you are extremely careful when it comes to upholding those covenants. If a borrower holding a 3-year loan decided to prolong it, must they take a cap, or does that get worked out through discussion?
Priyanka Garg
executiveEvery one of our loan agreements contains that stipulation, which sits in the dock; for certain borrowers, even when 3 years remain, perhaps they take just a 1-year cap, and that, you know, came about through negotiation when the loan was originated. There are also others we have where, at expiration, they must extend all the way to initial maturity; that differs across the portfolio. I'd add as well that often, we hold guarantees covering that replacement cap purchase. In a handful of situations, we additionally have real reserves that borrowers have cash collateralized.
Rick Shane
analystExcellent. I truly appreciate you letting me ask these questions. Thanks a lot.
Priyanka Garg
executiveAppreciate it, Rick.
Don Fandetti
analystHey there, this is Don. I've got a couple of things to ask. First, it's clear that non-accruals rose during this quarter because of a pair of loans. So, given what you're seeing in the shadow pipeline and what you're hearing from borrowers, do you anticipate a meaningful jump in non-accruals over the course of this year? And then second, could you discuss how loans have been migrating into the four-rated category? It appears the count moved from 7 up to roughly 10 loans. What types of loans are involved there?
Priyanka Garg
executiveAll right. Hello, Don, this is Priyanka once more. I appreciate the question. I'll address them starting with the second one. That's right, we did. As Richard noted during his remarks, we are heading into 2023 exercising a great deal of caution; we anticipate that valuation pressure will persist across the sector generally. With that as the backdrop, we wound up downgrading a small number of loans. We downgraded 2 office loans, 2 hospitality loans, plus the investments Jai referenced that carry the specific CECL reserves. The reason we downgraded those 2 office loans and 2 hospitality loans comes down to the team devoting extra time to them, collaborating with borrowers to make sure a path exists toward repayment. That stems from certain upcoming maturity dates along with business plans that have slipped, and naturally, concerns around lease-up on the office side; those factors are what drove it — the 2 office and the 2 hospitality. It had nothing to do with any particular borrower conduct. Turning to your second question regarding non-accruals, yes, naturally, that figure climbed to 4.8%. There are 4 loans involved, 2 of them carried over from the previous quarter, and the 2 newly added are the same five-rated loans Jai referenced that hold the specific CECL reserves. As for what lies ahead, once again, we remain cautious. Borrowers are navigating a highly difficult environment. We're very mindful of that. We're partnering with borrowers. I honestly can't predict in either direction what will unfold, but I will say there are multiple reasons we take great comfort in how strong our portfolio composition is. First, office exposure represents just 15% for us, and in my view office is the single sector where a genuine fundamental shift in values could occur, yet our exposure is constrained, and it's constrained to office stock that isn't commodity, which gives us greater comfort. My second point echoes what Mike said — 60% of our exposure sits within the multifamily and hospitality sectors. Mike walked through that and described how well those are performing. We take comfort in that as a defensive stance given this environment. My third point is that a third of our portfolio consists of construction. What that means is, once finished, the properties will be top-tier real estate for the sponsors, so in a shaky climate we should perform better, and our exposure when it comes to being repaid goes down. Taken as a whole, borrower actions confirm this. They have been safeguarding what benefits them. Whatever the loan paperwork requires of them, they have been carrying out — covering gaps in debt service, shifting balances on construction loans, you know, buying those replacement rate caps we talked about earlier. For me, that signals sponsors have faith in their long-range business strategies. Although we remain watchful, and I'm reluctant to say one way or the other where non-accruals are headed, our feelings about the portfolio's current position are positive.
Don Fandetti
analystUnderstood, thanks for that.
Jade Rahmani
analystAppreciate it. If we turn to what we hold in multifamily, a sizable number of those loans sit in certain markets that have been growing quickly, and those areas are expected to see a very high level of new unit deliveries across roughly the coming 18 months — that includes Colorado, Arizona, Texas, Tennessee, and Utah. So I was hoping you might give us the latest on those positions, since a portion of that lending may have been made back when the market was at its frothiest point.
Priyanka Garg
executiveJade, this is Priyanka. I'll handle that one. The specific risk you've raised is something we're watching very closely; negative rent growth is definitely showing up in what we see. Growth has decelerated, yet trade-outs remain positive for us. On top of that, the properties in those areas tend to serve a population that isn't as transient, so higher retention rates are delivering a real benefit to our borrowers. In a climate of uncertainty, my sense is that people move less often, and naturally, with rates having climbed, owning a home, you know, has drifted somewhat further beyond reach; that dynamic helps our borrowers sustain and concentrate on economic occupancy. Having said that, for many of those loans originated in the markets you named, the long-term thesis centered on putting a modest amount of capital to work and repositioning from a Class B asset into a Class A asset, and our view is that borrowers remain committed to that long-term thesis. Evidence of this shows up in the fact that many of those very same assets carried interest rate reserves or interest reserves. Given, you know, how quickly underlying rates have increased, replenishment has been necessary, and borrowers have been stepping up to replenish them. Our read is that although growth has clearly slowed, borrowers keep believing in their long-term thesis. Richard, would you like to jump in here?
Richard Mack
executiveSure, happy to. And Jade, one thing worth keeping in mind is that a great deal of the origination we did in those markets came about after the CLO market had its backup. Valuations were still elevated, but we managed to write those loans with fairly wide spreads and at LTVs that were conservative. When we look at the situation now, with so few positive developments, we genuinely like both the compensation we're receiving and our basis in these assets. Regrettably, at this moment, from the borrowers' perspective, they are transitioning out of negative leverage and into positive leverage, in most instances as they mark to market and definitely as they renovate. Relative to our basis, we hold a fairly substantial amount of positive leverage in our position, even in a heightened environment. True, there is softness stemming from greater growth. Even so, I would still prefer to be in the high-growth markets, since we've watched construction starts drop off a cliff. Granted, we're delivering quite a bit in those markets, but my sense is you'll see yet another jump in rent growth as we soak up a large number of the projects currently reaching completion.
Jade Rahmani
analystThanks. Looking at commercial mortgage REITs, and actually certain CMBS loans too, it appears there's something emerging — at least as an outsider would view it — involving borrowers choosing to default on purpose. One of your competitors put it this way: the borrower, they said, is behaving in ways that don't make economic sense, and a portion of the credit underperformance has taken people by surprise. Do you observe borrowers defaulting strategically so they can squeeze concessions out of lenders, since they're aware that plenty of lenders are stuck — you know, caught between a rock and a hard place — because those lenders hold loans funded through credit facilities that have to keep their coverage intact, and on top of that they might not be in a position to issue CLOs? Could you offer your thoughts on that phenomenon?
Priyanka Garg
executiveHi Jade, Priyanka here. I'll kick things off, and after that I'll pass it along to Richard. Regarding strategic defaults, given the way our loans are structured, we really haven't experienced that, since we've got active cash management working for us. Every dollar that arrives, we can direct it to debt service for ourselves before anything else. Borrowers don't have the option to withhold funds, claim a default is coming, and then, you know, leverage that as a bargaining chip. That hasn't shown up in our portfolio so far. Richard, I'm certain you'd like to address that on a wider level.
Richard Mack
executiveRight. I mean, honestly, that approach isn’t especially effective when it comes to us. Our borrowers see that we aren’t scared to take the keys. We don’t encounter this often. Pardon me for putting it that way, but I believe it matters that we—that borrowers realize we are definitely present in nearly every asset class we participate in, and we are major owner/operator developers. We want to collaborate with the borrower so they can succeed. If they’re acting opportunistically toward us, then we’ll act opportunistically toward them.
Jade Rahmani
analystThanks.
Chris Mueller
analystHey, everyone, thanks. I'm filling in for Steve right now. The thing I wanted to ask about is originations, since those decelerated during the quarter, and from what I can tell, that comes from the macro backdrop plus your own cautious stance. What I'd like to understand is how you're viewing portfolio growth for 2023. Should we count on net growth being realistic this year, or is it going to look more like a year of flat asset management?
Kevin Cullinan
executiveAbsolutely. This is Kevin speaking, and I'll address that. Yeah, I believe you've observed, on a quarter-over-quarter basis across this year, that origination or transaction volume has been decelerating; our expectation is that this continues through Q1 or perhaps, going further, through the first half of the year. When we consider total portfolio size, in light of upcoming fundings that we anticipate deploying across the quarters ahead, we do anticipate net portfolio growth once we weigh that against the repayments we project during that same window. On the origination side, it will likely stay somewhat more subdued until capital markets are in a stronger place.
Chris Mueller
analystUnderstood, that's useful, thank you. Turning to the repayments — the schedule you gave is useful. Not many loans come due in 2023. Is it reasonable to expect repayments will stay at the low end through most of the year?
Priyanka Garg
executiveYes. This is Priyanka, and I'll address that. That's what we expect. Our assumption is that there will be very few repayments across the year, and we have very few final maturities in 2023. For most of those borrowers, as-of-right extensions are either already executed or we expect them to be executed.
Chris Mueller
analystGreat. Thanks for taking the questions.
Priyanka Garg
executiveThank you.
Richard Mack
executiveI'd like to express my gratitude to all of you for being here once more, and to wrap up by perhaps stating what should be clear: this team remains intensely concentrated on execution and asset management each and every day. Our belief is that as time passes, the way we underwrite credit, manage assets, and execute through these challenging periods will set us apart. Thanks again for your time, everyone — we're grateful, and we can't wait to talk with all of you on the following quarterly earnings call.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up the call for today, everyone. We appreciate you being with us. You're free to hang up at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.