Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 21, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Anh Huynh
executiveThanks. With me are Richard Mack, who serves as CEO and Chairman of Claros Mortgage Trust, plus Mike McGillis, our President, Chief Financial Officer, and a Director of Claros Mortgage Trust. Also joining are Kevin Cullinan, an Executive Vice President heading MRECS Origination, and Priyanka Garg, an Executive Vice President heading MRECS Portfolio and Asset Management. Earlier today, CMTG's earnings release and supplement went out. Please use those materials alongside what gets presented during this call. Should anything come up after we finish, reach out to me directly. A reminder that forward-looking statements may be part of today's discussion, as defined under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Because of a number of significant factors, among them those covered in our other SEC filings, actual outcomes could differ materially from what such statements suggest. Any forward-looking statements we make reflect our views solely as of today, and no duty is undertaken by us to revise them. Certain non-GAAP financial measures will also come up today, including distributable earnings, which in our view can matter to investors when evaluating how we operate. The earnings supplement contains reconciliations of non-GAAP measures to their closest GAAP counterpart. Richard, over to you.
Richard Mack
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for being with us on the earnings call for CMTG covering the 4th quarter. It's remarkable what a difference 12 months can bring, or at minimum that was the impression when markets opened 2024 on an optimistic note. CMBS spreads even moved higher as investors bought bonds with enthusiasm, expecting rate reductions soon and a bottom in CRE. Yet that initial hopefulness in real estate regarding swift monetary loosening was soon checked by the fact that the U.S. economy keeps showing resilience, solid hiring, and inflation that is modest yet stubborn. GDP remains robust. Employment figures came in above forecasts; and although inflation has fallen considerably, representing real progress toward the Fed's target, it remains higher than that target. And should January and February serve as a signal, predicting Fed actions will prove extremely difficult across 2024. Might monetary policy produce a delayed drag on growth? Could job cuts begin in earnest? Could persistent geopolitical dangers upset supply chains and spark inflation anew? And what about the built-in complications of an election year? Sifting past the noise, the majority of indicators suggest a soft landing, unless you happen to be in property and depending on swift rate reductions. So good news may translate into bad news where commercial real estate is concerned. Apart from January, the capital markets for real estate have stayed tight throughout the past 18 months. Increased borrowing expenses, combined with weak transaction activity, have pushed cap rates upward, and numerous operators face negative leverage unless and until the Fed lowers rates. Because of this, little activity occurred in real estate during 2023, even with severe market swings plus downbeat sentiment and news coverage. The bulk of real estate investors chose to wait and watch, and many put off tough choices that ultimately must be made. Going forward, we think 2024 and even more so 2025 will play out quite differently; during 2024, the prospect of rate reductions, together with the presence or absence of trades in distressed assets, will probably turn into a pivotal turning point for investors who feel the burden of capital waiting to be put to work. That should prove favorable for the start of the unavoidable rationalization of the real estate sector and a degree of agreement on values. Still, our current best estimate is that this occurs gradually during 2024, with rate cuts staying somewhere ahead but taking time to arrive. Because of that, the industry will probably require until 2025 before it fully accepts refinancings and recapitalizations. Unless rate cuts arrive, or there is definitive proof they won't, the system will probably stay constrained. At present, clarity appears unlikely before late 2024 or 2025. Whatever the precise timing turns out to be, we require greater agreement on CRE values and fundamentals, plus more guidance from the Fed regarding rate cuts, before transaction activity can climb to a point where capital markets turn constructive. Even so, we do expect to see additional price discovery and narrower bid-ask spreads during 2024. We anticipate that this will gradually result in increased transaction activity and greater seller capitulation, which in turn will put pressure on some banks and investors to reconcile themselves with falling valuations and deteriorating fundamentals in certain asset classes. So we foresee 2024 being both busier and a harder year for the commercial real estate sector as a whole. On the bright side, the considerable sum of capital parked on the sidelines awaiting deployment can serve as a buffer. When you have money ready to put to work, opportunities exist across a range of property types backed by solid long-term fundamentals. That said, following a sluggish 2023, investors may be losing patience, and a clear signal for a favorable moment to enter is unlikely to appear. Regarding CMTG, our borrowers have hardly been insulated from the elevated rate setting and the accompanying erosion of asset values. Broadly, our portfolio's results are largely traceable to what we observe in the wider market, specifically elevated interest rates and diminished capital markets activity. While we work through this period, it reassures me greatly that our executive team brings deep experience steering portfolios across real estate cycles, and we recognize that this phase will pass as well. We think our equity-oriented mindset will now prove even more vital. Real estate lending is no longer merely about spreads. In this climate, all of us are equity investors, which calls for deep, hands-on real estate know-how; that will be indispensable for bringing a focused, solutions-driven response to the problems that cannot be avoided. In large measure, we were built for this moment. However unsettling such a reshuffling might be, we stand ready. Thank you all for the chance to show what we are capable of in the quarters ahead. I will now hand the call over to Mike.
Michael McGillis
executiveThanks, Richard. For Q4 2023, CMTG posted distributable earnings per share before realized gains and principal charge-offs of $0.31 per share. That topped our quarterly dividend of $0.25 per share, giving us 1.2x dividend coverage. For the prior quarter, distributable earnings per share before realized gains and principal charge-offs came to $0.35 per share. The change from quarter to quarter stems mainly from a California multifamily loan that went on non-accrual in Q4, and I'll get into that in more detail shortly. On top of that, earnings took in the full quarterly effect of two loans that went on non-accrual in the prior quarter, partly offset by better operating performance from the New York City REO hotel portfolio. That quarterly gain in the REO hotel portfolio mirrored the seasonality you typically see with New York City hotels, which generally put up a soft first quarter, then improve in the second and third quarters, before finishing the year with a solid fourth quarter. Distributable earnings per share landed at $0.26 per share for Q4 2023, while GAAP net income was $0.24 per share. CMTG's portfolio, which is mostly floating-rate, stood at $6.9 billion on December 31 versus $7.1 billion on September 30. That decline from quarter to quarter came mainly from reclassifying three loans backed by a mix of asset classes to held for sale, totaling $267 million of carrying value as of September 30, plus $38 million of loan repayments, partly offset by $168 million from follow-on fundings in our existing portfolio. After year-end, a single buyer purchased the three loans held for sale for $262 million. In effect, two loans went for par, while one loan secured by a mixed-use development project sold at 93% of its total loan commitment, given its sizable future funding component and its early stage in the construction cycle. All told, the three loans sold at 96% of UPB. Here, the chance to sell two large loans at par and a smaller third loan at a reasonable discount, while clearing out a meaningful future funding commitment, fits with our aim of maximizing liquidity and deleveraging our balance sheet. This deal produced $77 million of net liquidity, and the fact that the loans sold at a modest discount to par despite a large future funding component and more than $100 million on the mixed-use construction loan says a lot about the credit quality of our portfolio. As of December 31, multifamily is still our biggest exposure, at 41% of the portfolio's carrying value. We've been closely tracking the multifamily sector, keeping a watchful eye on underlying fundamentals. In the short run, we expect the sector will mostly face strain, since elevated benchmark rates are hurting some floating-rate borrowers who bought assets at narrow cap rates. We've been seeing particular properties' NOIs take a hit from rent growth slowing or rents shrinking, on top of increasing labor and insurance expenses. On top of that, the higher-rate climate has put a lot of owners in the tough spot of dealing with negative leverage. Short-term cash flow problems, together with what it costs to replace interest rate caps, refill interest and operating reserves, and valuation strain when loans mature, could intensify the challenges facing multifamily operators. With that in mind, we expect there will be situations where we work alongside our borrowers regarding extension conditions, provided they show ongoing financial and operational dedication to their properties. Even so, our view of the multifamily sector's long-term prospects remains favorable. Scarce housing supply and comparatively elevated mortgage rates tied to buying homes will keep fueling demand in multifamily. Going forward, we think high-growth markets will do better on a relative basis. Our enduring confidence in how strong this asset class is will shape how we engage with borrowers. Should we fail to see ongoing financial and operational dedication to assets, we possess the experience and conviction to seek our remedies. Now, on to portfolio credit. The portfolio's weighted average risk rating rose to 3.3, up from 3.2 in the prior quarter. In the quarter, we moved 5 loans to a 4-risk rating, while no further loans moved to a 5-risk rating. We downgraded 3 among those 5 loans because of recent or near-term maturities. As some borrowers struggle with the higher-interest rate climate and falling valuations that Richard discussed, we are sharply focused on whether borrowers can satisfy as-of-right extension conditions or repay loans when required, so we've added these to our watchlist. It's worth noting that all 3 loans remain current on debt service. A fourth downgraded loan was a multifamily loan, also current on debt service, yet it is facing downward NOI pressure in line with what I mentioned earlier. Lastly, the fifth downgraded loan is a New York City land loan that has been in payment default but comes with a significant repayment guarantee. Furthermore, one loan went on non-accrual in the quarter — previously rated 4, with a UPB of $215 million, backed by two under-construction multifamily properties in Southern California. As of year-end, all accrued interest through the third quarter has been collected. The two assets backing that loan are very well located, and we believe once completed they will be worth well beyond our loan amount. Given that, and our conviction in longer-term tailwinds for the multifamily sector overall, we have started foreclosure proceedings. While we move through this process, a number of possible routes to resolution exist, and we're actively pursuing every one of them; when it comes to CECL, total CECL reserves measured as a percentage of UPB came in at 2.2%, consistent with the quarter before. Specific CECL reserves accounted for 21.5% of the UPB of those loans of ours that carry specific CECL reserves. As of year-end, we have no new specific CECL reserves. The general CECL reserve, at 1.2%, consisted of 3% of the UPB on 4-rated loans plus 60 basis points on the UPB of the rest of the loans. Being proactive in managing our liabilities matters just as much as managing our loan portfolio. Keeping up frequent, collaborative, constructive dialogue with our counterparties stays a top priority. Because of that, over the course of 2023 we've brought down leverage on a number of assets sitting in property types facing more challenges, and we expect that to carry on throughout 2024. In doing so, we keep hunting for chances to deleverage the portfolio and bring down our cost of funding. In times like these, we also think it's wise to take a higher-for-longer stance where interest rates are concerned and to apply a conservative approach to managing liquidity. At December 31, we reported $238 million in total liquidity, comprising cash along with approved and undrawn credit capacity. Unencumbered loans came to $433 million, 93% of which were senior loans. Beyond that, the $147 million New York mixed-use REO property was likewise held unlevered. Our portfolio's future funding commitment has fallen steadily across 2023. At December 31, our future funding commitment stood at $1.1 billion, versus $1.9 billion at year-end 2022. As we look toward the year ahead, our plan is to put liquidity first, which means we'll choose preserving liquidity over putting capital to work through originations until market dynamics shift. At this point I'd like to open the call for questions. Operator?
Rick Shane
analystHi everyone, and thanks for letting me ask something today. At this stage, I'd really like to dig into the topic of dividend policy. With the distributable income from 2023 and the shift into 2024, the current situation means you aren't required to distribute dividends at the same elevated run rate you have now. I understand that lowering the dividend might send a negative message to the market, yet there are genuine benefits to holding onto capital, especially in conditions such as these where opportunities are beginning to appear. Could there be an argument for what I might call—though I don't know the best term—a bullish dividend cut, where you keep capital so it can be redeployed toward strong returns?
Michael McGillis
executiveRick, thank you for bringing that up. That's an excellent question. As you may remember, during the third quarter of 2023 we reduced our dividend, aiming to align it with a more sustainable level, reflecting our view of where moderate-term distributable earnings were headed. Every quarter, our board and we review the dividend. In doing so, we consider portfolio pivots, market opportunities, liquidity needs, and other elements. That's something our board and we will keep assessing. You're right to point out that the cost of capital is quite high at present. Keeping capital could be a wise deployment of funds, but at this moment it's simply too soon to predict anything.
Rick Shane
analystUnderstood. Yeah, I see what you mean — that's a tricky balance to strike. That makes complete sense to me, and I really do appreciate you explaining it. Thanks.
Michael McGillis
executiveThank you, Rick.
Doug Harter
analystThank you. That's great. You brought up continuing to put liquidity first — does that mean you're avoiding issuing any new loans, or do you plan to keep selling loans and lowering upcoming funding obligations throughout 2024?
Michael McGillis
executiveThanks, Doug. Appreciate it. My sense is that we probably won't be entering into future funding commitments for new loans until we observe more repayment activity within the portfolio we already hold. I believe we still see chances to carry out opportunistic loan sales in today's market conditions. As we consider what the business needs in terms of liquidity, that's something we examine constantly across the whole portfolio each day — weighing it against future funding requirements on our existing construction loans, anticipated repayment activity, and opportunities to sell loans in the marketplace. I'd say the real focus is on how we keep generating liquidity from the existing portfolio via repayments, loan sales, or leveraging unlevered assets before we begin considering new origination opportunities.
Doug Harter
analystThen, as a follow-up, I suppose, what's your framework for deciding which assets to sell? Is it the ones where you figure you can come nearest to par, meaning you'd be offloading some of the stronger loans? Or what's your thinking on which assets you'd consider selling?
Michael McGillis
executiveYeah. I'd say this is an extremely granular call. It really comes down to individual loans; and 2 quarters back, we reached a difficult conclusion to dispose of a loan at a steep markdown relative to the UPB. That wasn't easy; but once we examined the potential on that loan along with the underlying collateral, we concluded the smartest path was to absorb the hit and move forward. And in other situations, as with this one, during this quarter, we identified a chance to sell 2 loans that sat very near maturity and payoff. And through pairing them with another loan carrying a sizable future funding obligation, we managed to create near-term liquidity, bring down balance sheet leverage, and shrink a future funding commitment. So that satisfied quite a few criteria for us too. But this is something we review on a routine basis, and it will always be an individual, case-by-case evaluation.
Doug Harter
analystAll right. Thanks.
Sarah Barcomb
analystHi, everybody. Appreciate you answering my question. I realize liquidity has come up quite a bit already, but I was hoping we could take a closer look at that topic, especially since unfunded commitments exceed $1 billion. Could you take me through where your liquidity is coming from to cover those commitments, and in particular the $673 million of additional liquidity sources? That's something you point out in your supplemental. I just wanted to confirm I understood those sources.
Michael McGillis
executiveCertainly. Regarding the supplemental liquidity, I'm not certain which line item you mean, but I can take you through where our liquidity comes from; we have a variety of near-term loan repayments and resolutions we anticipate happening across the near to medium term, plus unencumbered assets made up of roughly just under $600 million of loans, mostly senior loans that we hold unlevered, along with an REO portfolio that is likewise held unlevered; so the financings, and as for the financings already in place, those represent financing commitments we've already secured on our construction loans that carry future funding obligations. And those future fundings, along with the capacity to draw on them, stay available, and they're distributed among a range of asset-specific financings and warehouse facilities, though mostly asset-specific financings.
Sarah Barcomb
analystOkay. Great; so for my next question, shifting topics a bit, could you provide some sense of how large the active loan modifications you're currently working through in the near term might be? And have the repo lenders been supportive when it comes to those modifications? And if they have, could you share some detail on the terms?
Priyanka Garg
executiveYeah. Hi, Sarah. Thanks for asking. Oh. Sarah, this is Priyanka. I'll take this one. So, as you can see, our watchlist. We moved a small number of loans into fours. And those were really pushed by precisely what you just mentioned, which is near-term maturities that are happening or already happened, and also modification talks we're conducting with various borrowers. So if you look at the watchlist, that provides a solid picture of active conversation with borrowers. When it comes to the character of those modifications, it's extremely granular, one deal at a time, depending on market, sponsorship, everything you'd anticipate; but we've truly stayed committed to a pair of guiding principles. First, we require a committed sponsor. And that means both with capital and with operational expertise. So if a borrower is putting some capital on the table that matters to them and also showing that they're contributing value, we're going to work with that borrower; we're in the business of lending, not owning, and that's what we want to do; but the second guiding principle is we have no interest in kicking the can down the road; so we're not saying yes to PIK interest or accruing partial interest. We want to ensure we're not worsening issues on basis at the back end. As we sit here today in our portfolio, we only have 2 small loans that carry any kind of PIK feature, and that's only about 1% of our UPB; so we're being very, very disciplined as we approach these modifications; and then the last part of your question was in relation to our financing counterparties. And they've generally been very supportive. We believe in the early and often when it comes to conversations with them, we're making sure we're effectively having a tri-party negotiation and want no surprises; so depending on the situation and what their own hot buttons are, we'll have discussions around that. But we really want to make sure that we're identifying the issues upfront.
Sarah Barcomb
analystThank you.
Priyanka Garg
executiveYep. No problem.
Jason Sabshon
analystHello. Jason Sabshon here, on behalf of Jade. I appreciate you fielding my questions; it would be useful if you could take us through how overall liquidity has shifted and what the figure looks like now. From what I can see, it stood at roughly $430 million during the third quarter, $238 million when the year closed, and then in the February update it was approximately $215 million; so any detail you can offer on that would be appreciated. Thanks.
Michael McGillis
executiveOf course. What I'd say is that we keep working toward resolving loans that are already in the portfolio, and we keep moving through possible repayments on a number of those loans. Beyond that, we also keep putting available liquidity toward deleveraging. I believe that's mostly what you've observed from the close of 2023 up until about a week ago — a mix of the dividend payment plus reducing leverage on our existing facilities. Naturally, the loan sales brought in net liquidity, and we've directed that liquidity toward paying down borrowings in a way that's accretive. My sense is we'll keep seeing much more of this as we go forward, as we keep trying to move through repayments on existing loans and carry out opportunistic loan sales throughout the portfolio, then apply that liquidity to deleverage the balance sheet.
Jason Sabshon
analystGreat. Thank you. And just to change topics, could you talk about the CECL reserve? Despite the rise in risk 4 loans, it stayed flat quarter-over-quarter; also, the earnings presentation indicates that general reserves fell on both risk 4 and on the 1 to 3 rated loans. So it would help if you could speak to that.
Michael McGillis
executiveSure. The CECL reserve remaining roughly flat even with the growth in four rated loans comes from how we've constructed our CECL model. So those loans that moved into the four category, despite the fact that there were three rated loans, we had already used a projected loss factor multiplier on them because of the underlying property type and of those assets. So that was already reflected in earlier reserves; and then regarding the general CECL reserve, that's largely driven by a lot of the macroeconomic data that feeds the model. And really, between third quarter and fourth quarter, there were somewhat favorable movements in some of the historical loss history. I know it sounds a bit counterintuitive, but that's what the data showed. But that had a relatively small effect during the quarter.
Jason Sabshon
analystFantastic. Many thanks.
Jason Sabshon
analystThanks. I appreciate everyone taking part today and, as usual, for the thoughtful inquiries. To pull together a number of the things asked during this call: naturally, this involves striking a balance among liquidity, playing offense, putting capital to work, and reducing leverage while conditions remain tough. We are seeing lending opportunities in the current market, yet we first need the real estate capital markets to demonstrate stability. Being lightly levered gives us the advantage of probably being able to add leverage and shift toward offense as soon as we feel confident about market stability; in the meantime, and as it always is, the focus is on asset management. We are deep in every asset, ensuring borrowers act appropriately. Should they fail to do so, we are prepared to act; we are prepared to move in and compel them to do so. We think our lending counterparties place great value on this principle, and we communicate with them constantly and transparently. From day one, I believe that has made an enormous difference for our business. So although this period is challenging, we understand how to navigate it. I think we are beginning to anticipate a different capital market. Yet until that becomes visible, we will continue to proceed on the assumption that conditions stay higher for longer and tough for longer, while remaining optimistic about a shift in the market. We appreciate all of your support and for being with us today. We look forward to speaking with all of you again before long. Thank you.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that wraps up our session for today. We appreciate your participation. You're free to hang up at this point. Thanks again.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.