Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 7, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Mortgage Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) earnings 35 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Anh Huynh

executive
#1

Thanks. With me are Richard Mack, who serves as Claros Mortgage Trust's Chief Executive Officer and Chairman, plus Mike McGillis, Claros Mortgage Trust's President, Chief Financial Officer and Director. Also joining are Kevin Cullinan, an Executive Vice President heading MRECS Originations, and Priyanka Garg, an Executive Vice President heading MRECS Portfolio and Asset Management. Earlier today, before this call, CMTG's earnings release and supplement went out. Please use those documents alongside what gets presented today. Should anything be unclear, reach out to me. Everyone should know that forward-looking statements, within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, might be part of today's call. Because of a number of significant factors, among them those covered in our other SEC filings, actual results could differ materially from what such forward-looking statements indicate. Any forward-looking statements expressed today reflect our views as of today only, and no duty is undertaken to revise them. Certain non-GAAP financial measures will also come up today, including distributable earnings, which we think may matter to investors when assessing how we operate. Reconciliations of non-GAAP measures to their closest GAAP equivalent appear in the earnings supplement. Richard, over to you.

Richard Mack

executive
#2

Thanks, everyone, for being on this morning's call for CMTG's Q1 earnings. Early in the year, the significant easing of inflation gave investors plenty of cause for optimism about rates. Sadly, the picture that has emerged over the past few months tells a different story. Inflation readings lately have swung around and have mostly landed above what was anticipated, so what had appeared to be virtually guaranteed Fed cuts are now anything but certain. When it comes to commercial real estate, our view is that the industry's overall prospects will stay difficult through the rest of this year and on into 2025. We foresee persistent headwinds from the elevated rate backdrop and from the absence of clarity regarding where interest rates are headed. Beyond attempting to anticipate what the Fed will do in an election year, several other factors inject additional complexity into the picture, among them uncertainty about the U.S. economy, rising U.S. debt levels, and geopolitical tensions in Ukraine, the Middle East and East Asia; from where we sit, it is this climate of uncertainty, particularly regarding interest rates, that has left the real estate capital markets frozen. Nobody is willing to recognize declines in value when rate cuts might be imminent. Given this environment, what we have witnessed is cap rates creeping upward and property valuations drifting downward, reflecting thus far not the current level of short-term rates, but rather where investors anticipate they will go. Buyers and sellers are circling one another without making commitments, which has produced dramatically reduced transaction volumes, and that has not only constrained investors' capacity to refinance and recapitalize properties, but has likewise led to fewer new loans being issued and fewer bonds on offer; this scarcity of product has been pushing lending spreads down across many categories of real estate financing even with valuation uncertainty. Though that helps, it still does not amount to a recovery. As in past cycles, real estate investors are waiting for real transaction volume to return and for an active real estate capital market to emerge, which would deliver confidence and a sorely needed infusion of liquidity; signs of this may be appearing, as shown by tightening spreads and investors turning to the revalued real estate sector in search of appealing risk-adjusted returns, yet it is far from conclusive. Real estate deals in nearly every asset class remain subdued compared with historical norms. As you're aware from earlier calls, CMTG has been carrying out our business strategy through the prism of a higher for longer rate environment. Our conviction remains that a conservative, defensive posture is wise, given the uncertainty over where interest rates and loan spreads will eventually land. Elevated interest rates have meant higher financing costs for borrowers, many of whom are still grappling with negative leverage. Consequently, we anticipate that repayments will be sluggish and their timing harder to predict. Moreover, it is likely these patterns will keep affecting our borrowers and portfolio, and looking forward, we stay dedicated to loan resolutions and to maximizing shareholder value. Throughout this stretch, we expect proactive asset management will continue to be a central priority for our team. When we engage with borrowers, what we look for is proof of their dedication to the properties on both an operational level and a financial one. To illustrate, in Q1 we collected payoffs on 2 construction loans, and notably, 1 of those carried a 4 rating. In our view, this reflects both the liquidity that is beginning to come back into the market and the strength of the sponsorship as well as the assets behind our loans. At this point, I'd like to hand things over to Mike.

John McGillis

executive
#3

Thanks, Richard. In the first quarter of 2024, CMTG posted a GAAP net loss of $0.39 per share, along with a distributable loss of $0.12 per share. Before realized losses, distributable earnings came to $0.20 per share, versus $0.31 per share in the prior quarter. That sequential shift mostly stems from seasonality hitting the New York City area hotel portfolio, which drove an $0.08 per share swing, plus 3 loans moved onto nonaccrual in the first quarter, which dragged earnings down by $0.03 per share. We'll get into those nonaccrual loans in greater detail later in this call. As we've said before, the first quarter tends to be the softest one for New York City hotels, especially when stacked against the traditionally strong fourth quarter. CMTG's loans held for investment portfolio fell to $6.7 billion as of March 31, down from $6.9 billion at December 31. That quarter-over-quarter move reflects follow-on fundings of $143 million, which were more than outweighed by loan repayments totaling $146 million and the reclassification of a $216 million 4-rated loan into held for sale. Also, as we noted on our prior earnings call, at year-end 2023 we put 3 loans backed by a mix of asset classes into held for sale and finished selling those loans in the first quarter of 2024 for $262 million. That sale price came in at 96% of the loan's UPB. As mentioned, this loan sale had no effect on the first quarter loans held for investment portfolio, since those loans were already marked as held for sale at year-end. Our first quarter results reflect the resolutions of two 4-rated loans. The first, a $104 million construction loan on a hospitality asset in New York City, had carried a 4 risk rating since 2020. During the quarter, we got full repayment of that loan, covering all contractual interest plus some default interest and late fees. Even though the borrower was slow to execute its business plan, it managed to find another lender and transact a refinancing of our position; we think CMTG's successful result on this loan says a lot about our confidence in collateral values and also points to possible signs of a capital markets environment that's returning to normal. The second loan, a $216 million construction loan secured by 2 multifamily assets in Southern California with $45 million of remaining unfunded commitment, was downgraded to a 4 risk rating in the second quarter of 2023 and put on nonaccrual status last quarter. After weighing it carefully, we determined that selling the loan was the best path; and in April, we closed the sale of the loan at 80% of UPB. Our first quarter balance sheet shows this loan as held for sale, net of a $42 million principal charge-off. Completing the sale let us add liquidity, bring debt levels down, and shrink our future funding obligations. Although our sponsor possesses the multifamily development know-how needed to assume control of such assets, we determined after thorough evaluation that the capital and resources necessary to finish construction, stabilize, and sell these properties could be deployed more productively elsewhere. Multifamily assets made up our biggest exposure as of March 31, accounting for 40% of our portfolio; our confidence in this sector's long-term prospects remains intact, with emphasis placed on chosen high-growth markets. As noted earlier, certain borrowers are dealing with challenges stemming from negative leverage, and we are closely tracking those loans while collaborating with our borrowers. This quarter, we moved 3 multifamily loans onto nonaccrual status, with a combined UPB of $186 million. The first consists of a $97 million loan backed by a 376-unit multifamily complex in the Las Vegas MSA. Number two is a $50 million loan backed by a 206-unit multifamily complex in Phoenix, Arizona. And the third is a $39 million loan backed by a 370-unit multifamily complex in Dallas, Texas. Our favorable long-term view of the multifamily sector persists, and the extensive experience our sponsor brings as an owner, operator, and developer has shaped how we manage these nonaccrual loans. We've been pursuing our remedies aggressively, and we want to point out that these 3 newly nonaccrual loans differ greatly from the multifamily construction loan we sold, which I'll note shared the same sponsor. All 3 of these new nonaccrual loans involve cash-flowing, operating properties with healthy occupancy, and they were downgraded chiefly because the borrowers could not handle how elevated financing costs affected their capacity to carry out their business plan. In contrast, foreclosing on these assets demands far fewer capital resources than the in-process construction loans do, and it could lead to better earnings than keeping the loans on nonaccrual status would in the near term. Given this, we see potential select chances to foreclose on multifamily assets that have in-place cash flow and then carry out the borrower's original business plan, though at a significantly reduced cost basis and leverage levels. Total CECL reserves as a share of UPB rose to 2.6%, up from 2.2% in the prior quarter. Specific CECL reserves accounted for 22.9%, the UPB of our loans carrying a specific CECL reserve. The general CECL reserve of 1.6% consisted of 3.1% of UPB on 4-rated loans and 0.9% of the UPB on the rest of the loans. This quarter, we recorded $70 million in provisions for CECL reserves, $42 million of which is tied to the realized loss on the previously referenced loan that was moved to held for sale and sold in April 2024. Now shifting to financing and liquidity. As of March 31, we reported total liquidity of $265 million, encompassing cash along with approved and undrawn credit capacity. Unencumbered loans came to $419 million, 93% of which were senior loans. In comparison with the prior quarter, unfunded loan commitments in our portfolio went from $1.1 billion down to $890 million. Within that $890 million figure, roughly $115 million is tied to loans where, in our view, the borrower won't satisfy the conditions precedent for funding, which brings our expected future funding levels down to $775 million. To cover that, we hold $453 million in in-place financing commitments, which leaves a projected equity or net funding requirement of $321 million that we anticipate funding across roughly 2.7 years. As of March 31, our total financing capacity stood at $7.2 billion, with aggregate outstanding balances of $5.5 billion. Our overall financing balance came down $226 million versus the prior quarter, largely because of a mix of loan sales and loan repayments, along with proactive voluntary deleveraging of specific assets. During the quarter, voluntary deleveraging payments totaled $82 million, which brings the cumulative figure to $439 million since the first quarter of 2023. Consequently, as of March 31, 4-rated loans and 5-rated loans carried materially lower financing advance rates, at 59% and 47%, respectively, versus 66% for loans rated 3 on risk. As Richard mentioned, we keep managing the portfolio against the backdrop of a higher for longer rate environment. Our management team, we believe, brings deep industry and multi-cyclical experience that allows it to navigate this challenging capital markets and credit environment. Beyond that, we believe our sponsors' experience as an owner, operator and developer gives us extra market insights, letting us effectively evaluate and pursue a broader range of alternatives and maximize recovery in various situations. Going forward, liquidity, proactive deleveraging, loan resolutions, and proactive asset management remain our key priorities. Across the past several quarters, we've shown our commitment to liquidity management and loan resolutions, from loan sales to pursuing our remedies, executing with the objective of maximizing recoveries in a challenging environment. Operator, I'd now like to open the call for questions.

Rick Shane

analyst
#4

I mean, the biggest thing people keep asking about is clearly whether we can keep paying the dividend, or whether it even makes sense to. You mentioned DE before realized losses, or excluding $0.20 of losses — that's $0.05 under what the dividend currently runs at — and there's clearly a drag coming from 650, sorry, roughly $650 million of non-accruals. Given the need to preserve liquidity, does holding the dividend where it is still make sense?

John McGillis

executive
#5

Thanks, Rick; Mike here. Fair question. This is one of those things our Board and we review every quarter. As for Q1, one thing worth remembering is that distributable earnings pre-credit took a hit from seasonality in the New York City hotel portfolio. Once you normalize for that, we land a lot nearer to the $0.25 dividend level. That said, in setting a dividend rate, what we're really trying to gauge is our capacity to pay it across the medium to long term. Still, it's obviously something we go over each quarter with our Board, considering the various scenarios the portfolio might throw at us each quarter. So it remains a regular topic for us and our Board.

Rick Shane

analyst
#6

Understood. That's helpful, thank you. And regarding the seasonality with the hotel, that's a fair observation. Now, another thing investors have asked us about more than once is the fact that a 4-rated loan shifted to a realized loss very, very rapidly. And I recognize that once you reclassify those to held for sale, it pushes things out, which does make the figures easier to follow. But could you walk us through what actually changed there that prompted such a swift response from your team?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#7

Sure. Rick, this is Priyanka. I'll handle that question. Essentially, we simply got new information. At year-end, we were working toward a foreclosure on that asset; our intent was to take ownership, and a foreclosure date had been made publicly available; then, as that date drew nearer in the first quarter, multiple credible buyers started reaching out to us, expressing interest in purchasing this loan; so alongside our development team, we invested considerable time and ran extensive analysis on the trade-offs involved in accepting the discount now and obtaining liquidity immediately versus keeping the asset, foreclosing, developing, and stabilizing it, which would leave it non-earning for a lengthy period. Ultimately, we determined that the price discussions we were having, especially with credible buyers capable of closing fast, offered a really — it was a solid price compared to the profit that might be gained, especially considering the time involved and the effect on earnings. So that's essentially what the migration was. It came down to new information becoming available to us.

Rick Shane

analyst
#8

Priyanka, this is genuinely useful for grasping the reasoning, and honestly, the kinds of situations you all encounter — I suspect that isn't something only you deal with; those calls will need to be made repeatedly; I'm grateful for the background there.

Doug Harter

analyst
#9

Coming back to the topic of liquidity. During the prior quarter, a few of your interest coverage covenants got adjusted. Could you update us on roughly where things sit regarding those covenants? And regarding the covenants tied to your indebtedness, does everything at the asset level get captured there, and how comfortable are you with that covenant too?

John McGillis

executive
#10

Absolutely. Appreciate it, Doug. That's a fair question. Indeed, at the close of Q1, per what our 10-Q lays out, we were in compliance with every covenant; we do anticipate needing to engage our lenders — repo lenders specifically, rather than the TLB investors — regarding an adjustment to how our interest covenant is calculated. Conversations with them have been quite productive, and we anticipate reaching a resolution. Beyond that, every remaining covenant is being passed with room to spare right now. Thus, we anticipate being able to resolve these matters as part of normal dealings with our counterparties.

Doug Harter

analyst
#11

Great. Are there any concessions you must give up during those discussions? Or, if you'd rather, could you refer back to the earlier ones, so you don't reveal what's on the table right now?

John McGillis

executive
#12

No. What I'd say is — much of this really comes down to acting like a dependable counterparty and keeping dialogue with our lenders both candid and open. And as we mentioned, we've been reducing leverage across our portfolio quite aggressively, especially the repo financings, across the last 5 quarters. And behavior of that sort, I believe, pays off — it brings advantages while you're navigating these sorts of matters alongside your counterparties.

Don Fandetti

analyst
#13

Yeah, could you discuss — it appears that the $400 million multifamily California loan got shifted to a 4 this quarter. Could you address that migration?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#14

Yes. Don, this is Priyanka. That is — we had a borrower that possessed an interest rate cap they were required to buy during the first quarter, and as we're observing with certain borrowers, there's reluctance to hedge at the levels that they are at. And so they wished to come to us regarding modification talks. We are in those talks with the borrower at this moment. But because of that messaging from them, we did move them to a 4 and onto the watchlist before this, they have been hedging each month and injecting new capital. We're hopeful about the resolution there. It's a great asset, top-quality, best-in-class type of property. So we'll continue those talks, we're far along in them right now with the borrower and we'll have some form of direction or resolution in the quarters ahead.

Don Fandetti

analyst
#15

So from where you're standing right now, it sounds like a 5 isn't where this is headed, at least as things appear today?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#16

Given what we know right now, no.

Steven Delaney

analyst
#17

I'd like to inquire regarding activity around selling loans; we have noticed Claros along with TRTX, TPG, are the two commercial mortgage REITs that have participated most heavily in this space. So that's what I hoped to ask about. That figure of $172 million, Mike, which appeared on the books as of March 31 — how many loans does it cover?

Richard Mack

executive
#18

Well, that consists of 2 loans made to one sponsor, secured by a few distinct assets that are cross-collateralized, so.

Steven Delaney

analyst
#19

Alright. And I think you also disposed of 3 during Q4, correct?

Executive

executive
#20

<<inaudible>>. Actually, what I meant to mention is that we placed 3 loans into loans held for sale <<inaudible>> during the fourth quarter. Then there's this separate one — the sale of which we closed in April, sitting in loans held for sale as of the close of Q1 — and we look at that as effectively 1 loan, despite being 2 loans, with the same sponsor and cross-collateralized.

Steven Delaney

analyst
#21

Understood. Moving to the next question — this touches on something somewhat new here — it relates to asset management, and it's tied to dealing with the challenges, and I suppose navigating the downturn we're currently experiencing in real estate. That said, could you share what you've noticed, given that you and Richard have been at this for a long time: what's the depth like in this loan sale market? And who's doing the buying? Are credit hedge funds the ones involved — or is it actual property investors pursuing a loan-to-own approach to pick up appealing assets for investment? I'd really value your high-level perspective on this?

Richard Mack

executive
#22

Of course, Steve. Mike, do you want to take that one?

John McGillis

executive
#23

You can go ahead, it will be the same.

Richard Mack

executive
#24

All right, so I'd say it's a mix of things. There are lots of different types of purchasers. When it comes to the loans we've offloaded at something very near par — and there have been a good number of those — or right at par, the buyers are mostly hedge funds. They're really struggling to navigate what they see as a deeply troubled real estate market, since there simply isn't as much activity there as you'd anticipate. Then regarding the deal we just closed at a big markdown, that buyer was a family office working alongside a developer, and their view is that this gives them a route into an asset at a steep discount, even though they know they'll have to work through a lot of complications to pull it off. So my sense is plenty of players are out there hunting for truly high-yield chances, and with so few deals getting done right now, we're just — there isn't all that much distress around; as a result, the market looks pretty deep compared to what's actually on offer. If a greater number of assets were up for sale, the picture might shift somewhat. Still, at this moment, demand to purchase loans seems sufficient — maybe even broad — regardless of whether they carry fairly big discounts or trade at par.

Steven Delaney

analyst
#25

That's genuinely helpful information. To be honest, when it comes to money flowing into commercial real estate and the commercial mortgage REITs, this is the most optimistic commentary I've heard in a long time. So it's nice to have the opportunity to discuss it, and I appreciate the information you provided.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#26

On the $150 million Connecticut office loan, could you give us an update? It was originated prior to COVID, so presumably today's conditions weren't part of the underwriting. And the maturity date was February of this year. I had another question — since it's a $150 million facility, that's a pretty big loan, which makes me think it's tied to a sizable market, maybe Stanford or Hartford, and could you also share anything about how the leasing of that property is progressing?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#27

Yes. Jade, thanks for asking. This is Priyanka, and I'll handle that one. So — the loan is in — it actually came due this quarter; we're on the verge of getting an extension done. A lot is happening on the sponsorship side that I'd rather not get into in detail, but a transaction is on its way. Thus, the adjustment we make with that borrower will probably be brief in nature, and afterward there would be a larger adjustment, contingent upon where the deal I’m mentioning stands; even so, leasing obviously hasn’t matched the initial underwriting assumptions. Even with that, their success at keeping tenants in place has been quite strong. Occupancy satisfaction among tenants is high, and they are extending their agreements, though for limited durations, which means the weighted average lease term hasn't looked as strong as we'd prefer. That said, the key point I'd highlight on a broader scale is the substantial credit backing in place, mainly through repayment guarantees provided by financially sound lending entities. This is therefore a sizable loan that receives a great deal of our attention, and the sponsor is equally engaged, for the reasons I just outlined.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#28

Could you tell us which market that happens to be?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#29

That would be Stanford.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#30

All right. And regarding the remaining 2024 maturities? There are a fair amount of sizable ones, such as that New York condo loan. A peer of yours ran into trouble in that area, particularly at the upper end. Then there's the New York land loan, plus the California hospitality one?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#31

Right; I'll keep my comments general about the maturities we see approaching. For most of 2024, there are only a handful of initial maturities and — pardon me, final maturities; and when it comes to those final maturities, we're in a position — for a lot of them we have a route to repay. We know what deals our borrowers are pursuing. And for some where we'll need to go past that final maturity date, we also can see modifications coming. As for initial maturity dates, over 50% of those loans will satisfy every extension test they have right now. So a handful of modifications will be necessary. We'll cooperate with borrowers — to return to what Mike said — provided they're ready to inject some capital and possess the operational know-how. We'll partner with the borrowers. Holding these assets isn't our business, though for the proper transactions we're glad to modify them. On the particular items you brought up, there are none — we hold no high-end condos in New York City. One New York City condo loan, quite small, comes due in 2025 and was extended, yet overall we feel quite confident about our condo exposure.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#32

All right. Then one more thing about the dividend. I get why your remarks stress the potential for earnings over the long haul. But conditions right now are rather unstable, with plenty of uncertainty, and all of you appear to be deeply involved in the daily grind of handling asset management as well as overseeing liabilities. So why not go further and cut the dividend, which would open up more room to maneuver and safeguard book value too? If what you're distributing exceeds what you're bringing in, that pushes book value lower. So investors obviously expect book value to hit a trough. Do you have anything to say about those points?

John McGillis

executive
#33

Jade, we talk about these matters routinely with the Board. Every point you made is valid, and we always take such things into account.

Richard Mack

executive
#34

Appreciate it, and thanks to everyone for being here. Let's say it again — conditions in real estate right now are difficult. Almost the entire market has seized up, with transactions happening at very low volume. Yet despite that backdrop, we're looking to seize opportunities while steering through this down part of the cycle; we're pursuing payoffs on loans; we're offloading loans, we're reworking loan terms, we're completing foreclosures when the timing makes sense, we're reducing our leverage. And we're preparing to start lending once more, since we understand this period won't last forever; so thanks to you all for being here, and we're grateful for your backing.

Operator

operator
#35

That wraps up our discussion for today, everyone. We appreciate all of you joining in. At this point, please go ahead and hang up.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.