Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 6, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Mortgage Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) earnings 34 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Anh Huynh

executive
#1

Thanks, everyone. With me today are Richard Mack, who serves as Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of Claros Mortgage Trust, plus Mike McGillis, our President, Chief Financial Officer and Director of Claros Mortgage Trust. Also joining us is Priyanka Garg, Executive Vice President, who heads up MREG Portfolio and Asset Management. Earlier today, before this call, we put out CMTG's earnings release along with the supplement. Please use those documents as you follow along with what we present today. Should you have questions, reach out to me. A reminder that forward-looking statements may be part of today's call, as defined under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Various important factors, including those covered in our other SEC filings, could cause actual results to differ materially from what those forward-looking statements indicate. Any such statements reflect our views only as of today, and no obligation is undertaken by us to update them. Today's call will also touch on certain non-GAAP financial measures, including distributable earnings, which in our view may matter to investors when assessing how we're performing operationally. To see how non-GAAP measures reconcile to their closest GAAP equivalent, please look at the earnings supplement. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Richard.

Richard Mack

executive
#2

Thanks, Anh, and good morning to all of you for being with us on CMTG's call covering results for the second quarter. Over 2 years have passed since the Fed began lifting interest rates in reaction to climbing inflation. And to put it mildly, the commercial real estate sector has not had a smooth stretch. Stepping back to examine the larger landscape, plenty of forces are clearly in motion. Unlike other industries that managed to hand off higher costs to consumers, property owners have lacked that pricing leverage. Waning office demand plus fresh supply arriving in multifamily and industrial have lined up with sharp jumps in real estate expenses and capital costs. The result has been fast declines in property values pretty much everywhere. Because commercial real estate requires time to construct and time to halt construction, it trails the broader economy. Over the near term, inflation and rate shifts have hit this industry especially hard, yet the same dynamic can produce outsize gains once the pattern flips. New building activity has shrunk considerably against a backdrop of a mostly resilient consumer, easing inflation and widespread market belief that the Fed is ready to start lowering rates. On top of that, plenty of investors foresee rents rising again in both multifamily and industrial, because new supply is constrained and demand is steady just as rates could begin coming down; this dual tailwind has prompted some investors to call the bottom, particularly given that construction costs have climbed markedly too. So it comes as little surprise that we are beginning to notice green shoots in commercial real estate, pointing to a healthier path for the industry potentially ahead. Though it remains premature to call it a sea change in investor sentiment, sizable and notable deals are closing. Lenders are gradually coming back as new private credit sources appear; amid this slow pickup in liquidity, still subdued versus recent historical norms, borrowers have managed to obtain financing willingly and successfully even with rates elevated. As for our portfolio, we stay constructive on the multifamily sector's long-term prospects, and it remains our biggest concentration. We anticipate that population gains, migration into many of our existing and target MSAs and constrained housing supply will keep fueling the broader fundamentals we observe in rental housing. In addition, we have achieved meaningful progress in boosting value across our 2 REO assets, and we credit that success to our management team's experience and hands-on approach to asset management. Going forward, much of the real estate industry anticipates that rate relief will reinvigorate the real estate capital markets, delivering valuation tailwinds to most asset classes. And although liquidity stays our focus, we likewise think the optimism surrounding the Fed cutting rates gives us a compelling chance to reassess how we deploy and direct our capital in anticipation of rising asset values. Even though both the watch list and the count of assets sitting on nonaccrual went up during this quarter, the pace at which they grew slowed down, which points to a cycle that is getting better. Given that kind of backdrop, it is our view that the designations currently attached to the portfolio fail to capture what our portfolio is genuinely worth across the medium to long term. Taking every one of these considerations into account, our Board of Directors reached the decision to reset our quarterly dividend at $0.10 per share, with that change taking effect in the third quarter of 2024. Our belief is that this move lets us go after capital allocation strategies aimed at protecting and growing book value, while at the same time putting the portfolio in position for earnings growth. Among the capital allocation moves we might make are putting money into our existing and possible future REO assets, retiring high-cost debt, repurchasing our term loan, or repurchasing CMTG stock, which in our view is significantly undervalued at the levels where it currently trades. At this point I'd like to hand the call over to Mike.

John McGillis

executive
#3

Thanks, Richard. Looking at Q2 2024, CMTG posted a GAAP net loss of $0.09 per share, along with distributable earnings of $0.20 per share. Before realized losses, distributable earnings came to $0.21 per share, matching the $0.20 per share figure from Q1. Expected seasonality gave the New York City area hotel portfolio a better second quarter, driving a $0.05 per share gain in earnings versus the prior quarter; that was partly counteracted by a New York land loan that went on nonaccrual during the quarter. I'll share more details about that nonaccrual loan afterward in this call. Starting on the asset side, CMTG's loan portfolio increased modestly, reaching $6.8 billion as of June 30, up from $6.7 billion on March 31. This sequential change reflects follow-on fundings of $143 million, partly offset by partial loan repayments that came to $41 million. At quarter end, our multifamily portfolio was flat versus the previous quarter, and it remains our biggest exposure, at 40% of the portfolio. As Richard noted, the imbalance between supply and demand keeps favoring the housing market, and our bullish view on the sector's long-term fundamentals is unchanged. That said, borrowers keep facing difficulties, since elevated interest rates raise their cost of carry, among other things. Consequently, we downgraded 3 loans to a 4-risk rating during the quarter, with a total carrying value of $370 million. Two of those loans, with a UPB of $161 million, are backed by multifamily assets in the Dallas MSA under the same sponsor. Today's rate environment has put serious strain on the sponsor's capacity to run their wider portfolio effectively. The downgrades on these loans stem mainly from pressure on the sponsor, not from the long-term real estate fundamentals underneath, and we will probably take ownership of these assets, together with other for rated multifamily loans, over the next few quarters. The third loan downgraded this quarter, which is unencumbered, was secured by a for-sale condo project in California. Here, the sponsor, who depended on offshore capital sources, ran into financial trouble unrelated to this specific investment. Before defaulting on the loan, the sponsor managed to sell a number of condo units at prices well above CMTG's basis per square foot; even so, the sponsor has hit financial difficulty, and we have been working alongside them to find a way to resolve this loan, whether through a loan restructuring, a loan sale, or our REO. No new fibrate loans arose this quarter. We did, though, move an existing 4 rated land loan into nonaccrual status. This loan carries a value of $88 million, and its collateral is a development site located in New York City zoned for a mixed-use building. It has held a risk rating of 4 since the fourth quarter of 2023, because the borrower hasn't moved forward with its business plan and has fallen behind on interest payments. As of June 30, total CECL reserves measured against UPB rose to 3.1%, up from 2.6% in the prior quarter. Specific CECL reserves accounted for 23.1% of the UPB on our loans that carry specific CECL reserves. The general CECL reserve, at 2.1% of UPB, was made up of 3.3% of UPB on 4-rated loans and 1.5% of UPB on the rest. In the quarter, we booked provisions for CECL reserves totaling $34 million, or $0.24 per share. The general CECL reserve grew mainly because expected loan duration lengthened, third-party historical loss rate data on comparable loans rose, and, to a smaller degree, risk ratings and accrual status of loans in our portfolio shifted. Now let's move to financing and liquidity. As of June 30, total liquidity came to $191 million, covering cash along with approved and undrawn credit capacity tied to existing collateral. Unencumbered assets consisted of loans with $490 million of UPB, 94% of which were senior loans, plus our mixed-use REO carrying a value of $146 million. These unencumbered assets give us extra flexibility to maintain the liquidity levels we target. After quarter end, repayment activity kept speeding up; we collected full repayments on 3 loans with $244 million of UPB — a $22 million loan secured by a build-to-rent portfolio, a $99 million loan secured by an industrial asset, and lastly a $123 million loan secured by a 4-rated New York City office loan. That loan had carried a risk rating of 4 since the fourth quarter of 2023. This transaction lowered our office exposure and brought down our overall leverage. Year-to-date, we've brought in a total of $873 million of loan proceeds via payoffs or loan sales. Within that figure, construction loans made up roughly $646 million. Also, loans totaling approximately $400 million were risk-rated 4, which shows continuing progress in working through watch-list loans. Before I hand the call to the operator, I'd like to give some further color on certain of our financing arrangements that carry the most restrictive financial covenants. In the second quarter, we substantially grew our relationship with our largest financing counterparty, and we also finished covenant modifications across each of our repurchase facilities. On the whole, we lowered our minimum required interest coverage levels and our tangible net worth covenant levels. We think these changes give us the flexibility we need to preserve enhanced book value, while also showing we can work constructively with our various financing counterparties amid challenging market conditions. Operator, I'd now like to open the call for questions.

Rick Shane

analyst
#4

Alright, I want to spend a bit of time on the REO strategy. Previously, when foreclosures came up, you went down different roads — at times offloading the property, at times keeping them managed. And my sense is the possible investment needed plays a big role. It sounds like more REOs are headed your way. You cut the dividend to boost liquidity, and Richard mentioned having capital available to put into the REO. I'm wondering whether that approach is shifting, or whether the REO you plan to hold on balance sheet will generate positive cash flow.

Richard Mack

executive
#5

So, I'll let Priyanka walk through some specifics on the asset, but let me just — Rick, thanks for the question. This is Richard. Let me address the macro picture. Where we stand right now, we believe we ought to be opportunistic when it comes to REO. In the past, I'd say our emphasis was more on building liquidity. But at this point we feel this is the moment where we've got, particularly the cash flowing multi, where we want to play hardball with borrowers; and if they can't run the property as well as we can, and they aren't contributing cash, we want to take those assets and ride the value back up. We've only taken 2 assets back, and that has proven the right call on both of those. We've been very cautious about it; we're going to stay cautious. I think we feel right now that, again, while calling the bottom is difficult, this is about as good a time to be acquiring assets at a discount, and I realize it's not exactly acquiring assets, but this is a pretty good time to seize opportunities on our own balance sheet and improve value significantly. Garg, do you want to just respond on the specific assets?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#6

Absolutely. Thank you, Richard. Rick, the one point I would tack on beyond what Richard shared is this: when you examine things through the lens of credit migration, over the past 2 quarters, the attention has genuinely centered on residential assets. Within that area, we firmly hold the view that no secular change in value has occurred. What we're seeing is more a snapshot in time. That means being able to move these assets onto our balance sheet — as Richard mentioned — and manage them far more effectively than the sponsors do in many instances, then benefit as values climb once we observe rates declining and cap rates tightening. So, in our view, right now there's an especially attractive opportunity.

Rick Shane

analyst
#7

I’ll go ahead with the…

Richard Mack

executive
#8

Apologies, Rick. Allow me to include one additional…

Rick Shane

analyst
#9

Richard Shane here — I was simply going to note, Richard, that — please continue, my apologies.

Richard Mack

executive
#10

all I'd add is that there's a chance borrowers catch us off guard, secure rescue capital, and settle up with us once we move more forcefully, since we perceive genuine worth in these assets — if we didn't, we wouldn't be pursuing them. That isn't what we anticipate, though I believe the moment has arrived to move with relative aggressiveness.

Rick Shane

analyst
#11

Honestly, I'd say what you're describing aligns much better with the strategy you've historically followed. And I get it — we've just come through a fairly tough stretch in which, rather than maximizing results through active management, the priority became liquidity. Still, it does look as though you're returning to your initial plan.

Richard Mack

executive
#12

You're exactly right about that. We've been operating on the assumption that rates would stay elevated for an extended stretch, and now we're approaching what we see as the conclusion of this tightening cycle — definitely that, and there's a strong chance of a meaningful reduction from here. The moment has come to shift back toward our foundational approach when it comes to assets, and our capacity and ability to generate value, I believe, will become evident across the coming few quarters.

Doug Harter

analyst
#13

You mentioned coordinating with your lenders regarding covenant adjustments. Could you explain whether you needed to make any concessions to secure those changes, or simply describe how the discussions unfolded?

John McGillis

executive
#14

Absolutely, Doug. Mike here. I'll handle that question. I'd say our relationship with repo counterparties has consistently been quite constructive. It has also been extremely cooperative. And when we examined what you might call a standalone portfolio, we stayed well ahead of the curve regarding managing assets that were showing difficulties, lowering leverage on those assets so it better matched what conditions at present resembled. So I'd just say — since, in my view, we've acted very proactively in bringing down leverage across our balance sheet. We've been extremely open with our lenders about where we anticipated things were going across roughly the coming year, and we showed them that obtaining some covenant relief while we address some of these matters, which includes moving certain loans into REO and enhancing cash flow. That won't occur instantly, yet it will occur gradually. The covenant relief required for us to carry out those strategies, from an interest coverage as well as tangible net worth standpoint, was acknowledged, and we managed to complete those modifications.

Doug Harter

analyst
#15

Then, to add on, what's the situation regarding the covenants tied to your term loan? And what's the right way to consider the remaining pieces of the capital structure?

John McGillis

executive
#16

The term loan carries an interest coverage covenant that's comparable, though the calculation method differs. We remain in compliance with the interest coverage covenant on our term loan. Having now addressed some of those repurchase agreement facilities, and with the term loan maturing in August 2026, as we move through the back half of this year, we'll shift toward talks with the lenders about amending, extending, or making any paydowns required to push out the facility's term. It's too soon to say how that will play out, but we aim to stay far in front of it well before maturity arrives in 2 years.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#17

Richard, during your prepared comments you said that expectations for reduced rates alongside increased property values are prompting a fresh look at where you'd prefer to put capital, and you went through quite a few possible choices. My assumption is that this sort of assessment requires time — naturally, adding more assets to the balance sheet and deploying money into them isn't quick. Among those investment possibilities, are some capable of being carried out in the near term instead of down the road, whether that means repurchasing stock or repurchasing debt, and which others would more probably be medium-term possibilities?

Richard Mack

executive
#18

Great question. Certain items before us will be acted on swiftly, since we had anticipated this shift in the market. I won't claim we foresaw the extreme sell-off, or the warning shot the market is firing at the Fed. That's the reality. Still, we did anticipate that some degree of change was coming, given what we're observing in real estate capital markets and the return of liquidity. So this was already something we expected — though the magnitude of the move will probably exceed what any of us would have guessed merely 7 days ago. As a result, we were genuinely positioned and prepared to move, essentially staying ahead of these developments. So yes, we believe there are actions we can take fairly quickly. Naturally, every option remains available, and the greater the number of payoffs we achieve, the more probable it becomes that we shift away from REO — or we'll determine what share REO will represent — toward alternatives such as fresh originations, retiring debt, and buying back stock. We want all of them available, because repayments have been speeding up while the rate of troubled assets has been slowing down. And so truly, every option remains available. At this point, we've reached the stage where we're prepared, and we've been waiting for a signal that resembled a floor before making those moves. I hope that answered you adequately.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#19

That connects nicely to what I want to ask next, and this may be one for Mike. With repayment activity having picked up, particularly after the second quarter, how do you see repayments playing out for the remainder of the year? And how do you plan to divide those possible proceeds between the committed fundings you must satisfy this year and accumulating liquidity for the more opportunistic investments Richard brought up?

John McGillis

executive
#20

Sure. We believe we have fairly solid visibility into rather substantial repayment volumes across the balance of this year and through the early portion of 2025. Whenever we hold excess capital, it always comes down to a capital allocation choice — what will we do with it. As Richard pointed out, we do anticipate taking assets back into REO. That involves a judicial process, so there are timing factors you must navigate to reach that point. But often, we determine that timing ourselves. Clearly, there are some rather accretive ways to deploy that liquidity, including repurchasing some of our higher cost debt, reducing leverage, and possibly share buybacks or new originations, though at that moment it will be a matter of deciding what to do with that capital. Many of those considerations played into our choice to reduce the dividend this quarter. And I don't believe it ought to be seen purely as a signal of where we expect distributable earnings to land. We tended to view it through the lens of what dividend level is required to preserve our REIT status. And since we've distributed essentially all we must distribute from a dividend standpoint to preserve our REIT status, we concluded it was preferable to retain that capital within the system and deploy it toward things that would assist us in growing earnings or growing book value.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#21

And then, Mike, this is my final question. You brought up repayment of an office loan after 2Q. Regarding the noncash consideration portion, was that discounted loan a piece of the senior position, or was it a mezz position? And what were the 2-equity interests that accompanied that repayment?

John McGillis

executive
#22

How about this — Priyanka, would you like to take that one?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#23

Absolutely. Let me back up briefly to walk through our thinking on that deal. Essentially, what we did was exit a Brooklyn office property with no tenants, which lowered our exposure to New York City offices — and that ties to what was said earlier about value changes, distinguishing a fundamental shift from one driven by capital markets. In our view, the exposure we sold reflects a fundamental decline in value that probably won't reverse. To address your specific question directly: we moved into a per mortgage position backed by a cash flowing asset rather than an empty one, with performance getting better and momentum moving in a positive direction within a sector on the upswing — retail has become a sector that's improving. Plus, as noted, there's extra credit support from other assets the sponsor holds. So from an asset quality perspective, I see this as a strongly favorable swap, with clearer visibility into repayment compared to what we held before.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#24

So will those equity positions be reported as REO? Or are they simply going to be grouped under other holdings of yours?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#25

Mike, would you like to handle that one? That is simply going to fall under other income depending on — sure, go ahead.

John McGillis

executive
#26

Right. We anticipate that we will record it, and there won't be any basis for it in our financials under the current expectation, and if we do get distributions, they'd be on a cash basis. That's what we expect.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#27

This is simply more collateral. It amounts to extra credit support; that's the situation — it strengthens the assets underneath.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#28

How many dollars in loans do you anticipate moving into REO?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#29

Putting an exact figure on that strikes me as difficult, simply because in some cases we're negotiating with borrowers, and the outcome there remains uncertain. However, regarding that particular sponsor from whom we saw substantial credit migration — from 3 to 4 — across earlier quarters, that alone represents roughly 5% of our UPB. So my expectation is those probably turn into REO. That being said, contingent on how things shake out with other sponsors, further loans could be involved.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#30

does that 5% figure sit outside the Dallas multifamily?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#31

no — Dallas multifamily is counted inside it.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#32

Now let's talk about risk ratings. I'm wondering, for loans you anticipate moving into REO, why are they given a risk rating? Shouldn't they be classified as risk 5?

Richard Mack

executive
#33

Jade, that really depends on whether or not you — Priyanka, you're equipped to take this one. I believe part of what's behind the question relates more to GAAP accounting rules; however, simply because a loan is anticipated to become REO, that doesn't automatically require a specific reserve — a specific reserve could be needed depending on the appraisal obtained for the asset before foreclosure, yet in every one of these cases, we're quite comfortable with the long-term collateral value we will be taking on. Priyanka, would you like to add anything there?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#34

No, you've got it precisely.

Richard Mack

executive
#35

Alright, I'd simply like to express gratitude to everybody for being with us on today's call, and for the inquiries, and really wrap up with the central message of this call, which is that in our view the momentum will probably keep shifting toward additional repayments and greater liquidity in the marketplace; and with that as the backdrop, it's the backdrop that gives us confidence that the moment has arrived to act with more decisiveness and opportunism regarding our capital. And we look ahead with optimism toward a somewhat more upmarket environment and toward being in a position to seize the opportunities sitting right in front of us. So, thanks to all of you for being here. I'm certain we'll hold follow-up sessions with some among you, and we're grateful for your questions. Thank you, everyone.

Operator

operator
#36

That wraps up the conference call for today. We appreciate everyone taking part. You're welcome to disconnect your lines at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.