Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. (CMTG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 20, 2025

New York Stock Exchange US Real Estate Mortgage Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) earnings 37 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Anh Huynh

executive
#1

Thanks. With me are Richard Mack, who serves as Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Claros Mortgage Trust, plus Mike McGillis, our President, Chief Financial Officer, and Director at Claros Mortgage Trust. Also joining us is Priyanka Garg, an Executive Vice President who oversees portfolio and asset management at MREC. Ahead of today's call, CMTG's earnings release and supplement went out. We ask that you look at those documents alongside what's presented during this call. Should you have questions, reach out to me. A reminder that forward-looking statements may be part of today's call under the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Those forward-looking statements indicate certain outcomes, and actual results could differ materially due to a range of important factors, including the ones covered in our other SEC filings. Any forward-looking statements on this call reflect our views only as of today, and no obligation is undertaken by us to update them. Certain non-GAAP financial measures will also come up today, including Distributable Earnings, which in our view may matter to investors when assessing operating performance. Reconciliations of non-GAAP measures to their closest GAAP equivalents can be found in the earnings supplement. I'll hand the call to Richard now.

Richard Mack

executive
#2

Thanks, Anh, and good morning to all of you for being with us on CMTG's call covering the fourth quarter's earnings. A major transition period is still being experienced across commercial real estate. Although fundamentals at their core remain largely solid and signs of healing have been appearing in the capital markets, the rebound has been sluggish, and movement forward has been neither straight-line nor felt everywhere. Concerns about valuations driven by interest rates, along with the rate environment staying higher for longer, remain major themes that weigh on those investing in commercial real estate. During 2024's fourth quarter, transaction activity at CMTG totaled $300 million, encompassing repayment proceeds received from borrowers as well as loan sales that we managed to complete at or close to par. Later in this call, Mike will give you more detail. Credit migration also occurred within the portfolio, since borrowers keep getting squeezed by the difficult real estate climate. Even though we have been pushing to resolve loans on the watchlist, some pending sales of loans and assets that we had projected for the fourth quarter failed to come together because of circumstances specific to each individual case. Consequently, our goals of securing resolutions while simultaneously boosting overall liquidity got deferred into 2025. On top of that, as lots of you know, in November the outlook for interest rates turned uncertain once more and became less upbeat when the Fed indicated rate cuts would be fewer than what the market had been projecting at that point. With that in mind, and recognizing that the entire industry will keep steering through an elevated rate setting, we concluded that taking a cautious approach to how we manage the capital we have available was the wise move. Consistent with that, in December our board of directors — after factoring in that CMTG had already satisfied its REIT taxable income distribution obligations for 2024 — chose to halt the quarterly dividend as a way to protect capital and improve financial flexibility. Looking ahead toward 2025, the industry momentum we're witnessing gives us encouragement. Commercial real estate is starting the year right after quarterly gains in transaction volume. Over in the CMBS market, spreads have narrowed substantially across the last few quarters even as primary issuance levels have risen. With that as the backdrop, we see this shaping up to be a decisive year for CMTG as we carry out our strategic priorities for 2025. At present, our portfolio holds a subset of loans carrying risk ratings of four or five, along with non-accrual loans, plus REO assets. Speeding up resolution of these watchlist loans will let us achieve the following goals. Number one, lessen the drag on earnings. Number two, improve our overall portfolio credit metrics and liquidity; and number three, put that extra liquidity to work by deploying capital toward more accretive purposes. That could involve delevering the portfolio and putting money into opportunities inside the existing portfolio that we've already identified, for example foreclosing on select multifamily assets. Mike will get into this in greater depth later during the call. As an asset manager, we’ve aimed to secure the greatest possible value from each holding. Our executive team saw this play out in earlier cycles, patiently resolving troubled loans and watching asset values come back sharply. That stance has involved a readiness to collaborate with borrowers so they can carry out their plans, while also remaining ready and capable of taking properties through REO. Still, there have been moments when pursuing maximum value forced us to make tough choices regarding liquidity. As we look ahead to 2025, though uncertainty persists, our base case is that refinancing activity and demand for real estate assets will stay at levels permitting us to move a significant portion of our non-earning or lower-earning assets out of that status. Regarding CMTG’s stock, we feel the recent trading levels fail to properly capture the value built into our portfolio. So we’ll keep executing and stand ready to take steps aimed at strengthening credit metrics and liquidity, cutting leverage, and putting capital back to work in an accretive way. Should we succeed, we think that will produce a valuation for CMTG’s stock that better mirrors our underlying business and portfolio. At this point, I’d like to hand the call over to Mike.

Mike McGillis

executive
#3

Thanks, Richard. For Q4 2024, CMTG posted a GAAP net loss of $0.72 per share, along with a Distributable Loss of $0.59 per share. Before realized gains and losses, Distributable Earnings came in at $0.18 per share. Our held-for-investment loan portfolio shrank to $6.1 billion as of December 31st, down from $6.3 billion on September 30th. That sequential decline was driven mainly by loan repayments along with loan sales. In Q4, we collected $99 million total in loan repayments, which included three loans being fully repaid, amounting to $80 million in UPB. Countering those repayments, we funded $75 million on existing loan commitments. We also completed three loan sales totaling $205 million in aggregate UPB during the quarter. The first two had already been disclosed as third-quarter subsequent events and appeared as held for sale on the balance sheet when Q3 closed. Loan one was a $30 million subordinate loan backed by to-be-developed land in Miami, which went for 99.5% of UPB. Loan two was a $115 million senior loan secured by a multifamily property in Colorado, which sold for $111 million. The third loan we sold — a $60 million loan collateralized by a multifamily property in Las Vegas — went at 99% of UPB; beyond that, we closed another loan sale that occurred after year-end: a $101 million senior loan secured by a hotel in San Diego. That loan sat as held for sale on December 31st since the sale wrapped up in early January at par. 2024 proved to be a busy year for transaction activity. Across the year, CMTG completed $1.3 billion in aggregate realizations, evenly divided between repayments and loan sales. We see loan sales as a plus for the portfolio, since they let us speed up repayment activity while eliminating the risk that a borrower couldn't obtain refinancing when due amid capital markets turbulence. Over 2024, five out of seven loan sales closed at or above 97% of par, which reflects the credit strength of those loans. The two outliers involved loans carrying future funding obligations and construction risk, which we didn't consider the most accretive deployment of CMTG capital. Also during the quarter, we moved the REO New York Hotel Portfolio into held for sale and wrote the asset to a value reflecting where we think it might trade in the market. As a reminder, that portfolio consists of seven limited-service hotels spread across Manhattan, and back in 2021 we foreclosed on the mezzanine borrower. Since that foreclosure, the portfolio's revenue has climbed back to record highs. As we've said on earlier calls, we've routinely looked into selling the portfolio, kicking off a process last summer. That process got held up temporarily by what ended up being the New York City Safe Hotels Act legislation, which passed in Q4 2024. Now that that's handled, we've moved forward on getting the portfolio sold and can't wait to share where things stand. Our view is much the same for the 5 multifamily loans that carry a risk rating of 5 right now. Together, those 5 multifamily loans make up 50% of the loans we've rated 5. In our view, these multifamily loans ran into short-term valuation strain because rates have been elevated and because our borrowers lacked access to capital or other means to run these assets well. From where we sit, there's considerable upside in these loans if we manage them and put in a modest amount of capital. So we intend to foreclose on these assets over the next few quarters; ahead of those foreclosures, all of these loans now carry a risk rating of 5, and we've booked specific CECL reserves averaging 12% of the UPB, which line up with their estimated fair values and will be charged off when foreclosure happens. That said, in other cases we've concluded foreclosure isn't the best route, since we prioritize the best uses of our capital even though we have faith in the long-term value of the underlying asset. Take, for instance, a $390 million loan we originated in 2019 backed by a multifamily building in Manhattan. Across its five-year term, the loan paid as required under its terms. This loan hit maturity in November, and after lengthy talks with the borrower, we consented to let the borrower meet its principal repayment obligation through a discounted payoff option, provided certain conditions are satisfied, such as keeping up with debt service. Although we still think the long-term collateral value backs the loan, we think the incentive to monetize our investment, producing roughly $100 million of net liquidity, better positions us to seize accretive capital allocation opportunities as we head into the second half of 2025. Because of the contingencies tied to the modification, this loan was downgraded to a risk rating of 4, and we reserved for this potential loss inside our general reserve. Going forward, we expect to keep pursuing loan sales, foreclosures, and/or discounted payoffs. That said, before we do that, we'll first try to maximize value by way of loan modifications and credit support. For instance, during the third quarter, we modified a loan on a New York City mixed-use asset that involved a $7.2 million principal repayment and split the loan into two loans, with one secured by a retail property and the other a well-structured personal loan to individuals of significant net worth. After this modification, the office portion of the original collateral was recently foreclosed on by a ground lessor, which meant our sponsor lost its collateral; put differently, a third-quarter modification allowed for an exchange of collateral to steer clear of losses on the office component that has now been foreclosed. CMTG's foresight helped sidestep a tough spot where a major loss or drawn-out legal fight would have been probable. Also, in the wider context of what we're doing to manage assets, we're going after guarantees tied to loans that have defaulted—especially where the person backing the loan has substantial net worth and we can go after that guarantee through a streamlined, short-form litigation route. Now on the liquidity side, as of December 31, we had $102 million in total liquidity, and that figure takes in cash along with credit capacity that's approved, undrawn, and based on collateral we already hold. Like Richard said, strengthening where we stand on liquidity, bringing down watchlist loan levels and assets that either aren't earning or earn less than they should, and cutting leverage on the balance sheet—all of that will be something our team concentrates on across 2025. On that note, we're expecting resolutions to pick up speed, and that covers the held-for-sale loans that remain, the hotel portfolio, and loan repayments we've been anticipating. We've got sales and refinancing deals in motion right now, and those could bring in gross realization proceeds of just under $2 billion; somewhere between 1/3 and two-thirds of that amount should close over the next few quarters, and roughly 40% of those proceeds will boost our liquidity, which we plan to redeploy in a way that's accretive. At this point I'd like to hand the call over to the operator.

Rick Shane

analyst
#4

Hi, everyone. I appreciate you answering my questions today. Now, you both just mentioned the change made in the third quarter to the New York City mixed-use property. There have been many inquiries from us regarding that. As I understand it, that involves Loan 33, which your disclosures identify as a land loan. And I suspect that because of that restructuring, calling it a land loan might create some confusion. Is that in fact correct? In light of the modifications you just outlined, how should we view Loan 33?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#5

Hello, Rick. This is Priyanka. I'll address that. The modification Mike discussed, as well as the mixed-use asset, have nothing whatsoever to do with Loan 33; from the very beginning, and at all times since it was originated, that has been a land loan. If it would be useful, I can speak to the modification Mike mentioned.

Rick Shane

analyst
#6

Yeah, that'd be excellent, since once more, this is a very prominent matter, and it's drawn quite a few inquiries.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#7

Absolutely. Yes, and precisely because of that, our usual practice is to stay silent regarding individual loans, yet here, with everything you've just pointed out, we'll make clear that our exposure to the Chrysler Building is zero. Previously, we did hold exposure to that asset, though we revised the loan during Q3, as Mike noted. Through that revision, a 15% paydown came our way, and we enhanced the collateral package, which as of now leaves out the leasehold interest tied to the Chrysler Building or anything connected to the Chrysler Building, and perhaps more significantly, that revision established a quicker route to being repaid. This loan, now revised, gains from amortization payments and is up to date on every obligation.

Rick Shane

analyst
#8

Understood. That's quite useful, and I believe the clarity there will be genuinely valued by investors. Thanks.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#9

Thanks for posing that question, Rick.

Doug Harter

analyst
#10

Thank you. Turning to page 11 in your materials, regarding those assets you've rated as risk category 4, you mention that two multifamily properties are expected to be repaid soon. You covered the one in New York. I was hoping you might discuss the California property and what the prospects look like for its repayment.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#11

Yes. Hello, Doug. This is Priyanka. I'll handle that question. Along with the borrower, we're pursuing a resolution process on a near-term timeline for that asset. So the discussion is cooperative in nature. It's continuing. I'd rather not go into further specifics, but things are moving along favorably. That's what I can share.

Doug Harter

analyst
#12

Then, regarding those 2, could you explain the way we determine the reserve amounts for each of them, plus to what extent does the close-in resolution and clarity on those play into setting that reserve?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#13

Yes. Regarding the first, which Mike covered somewhat more thoroughly during his prepared remarks, we increased the general reserve so it equals the discounted payoff we've negotiated with the borrower. That's the outcome we anticipate happening. As a result, it sits entirely within the general reserve; it hinges on several conditions that must be met, and that's the reason no specific reserve exists. As we said, we believe asset value is above that threshold, yet this truly came down to a liquidity choice we made; for the second, we believe the process we're working through with the borrower to generate liquidity needs no extra reserves past what the general reserve holds; this asset enjoys a very strong location; it has gained from an enormous volume of leasing over recent months, and it ought to be extremely well-positioned to become liquid in the current market, especially considering the bettering capital markets inflows within the multifamily sector.

Doug Harter

analyst
#14

That's helpful context, Priyanka — thanks for walking us through it.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#15

Happy to help. Thanks so much.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#16

Thanks. When it comes to financing, does the company intend to bring leverage down further during 2025? Would financing be tied to any REO acquisitions? Also, could you speak to whatever plans exist regarding the secured term loan?

Mike McGillis

executive
#17

Of course, Jade. Mike here; regarding deleveraging, the response is affirmative — we do plan to keep deleveraging the portfolio, especially paying down certain of our higher-cost assets. As for the assets we intend to take REO on, we're in the process of finalizing a financing that would let us get that done at financing levels quite consistent with where those assets are presently financed on repo lines. So ideally, that answers that. And that facility will let us accordion it upward and downward as we resolve REO assets or add additional REO assets going forward; so we believe that's a highly effective financing solution for what we're trying to accomplish there; and then regarding the Term Loan B, which carries an August 2026 maturity, we are — and so we come inside one year of maturity in August of 2025. We anticipate pursuing either an A&E transaction or a replacement financing transaction on it over the middle quarters of this year. Specifics aren't something I can really discuss right now, but that's the plan.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#18

All right. Then turning to deleveraging — given the $100 million of cash we hold plus unfunded commitments, could you walk through the various pieces? How large is the deleveraging effect? Of the unfunded commitments, what portion gets funded during 2025? And is there any plan or consideration around issuing some kind of additional equity-like instrument, maybe a preferred or something similar, that might strengthen both the liquidity profile and the capital buffer?

Mike McGillis

executive
#19

Sure. Above all, when it comes to our liquidity position, our financings carry minimum liquidity requirements. To start, we must stay in compliance with them. We remain in compliance, though for clear reasons we would prefer to hold somewhat more liquidity. Let's see. On the subject of raising capital, I believe we'll keep examining what we see as the optimal route to producing liquidity, which is working out some of these four- and five-rated loans and turning them into cash; our balance sheet carries fairly low leverage, so a decent amount of liquidity sits tied up in certain loans that we believe we can free up by grinding through a number of these situations. As for raising additional equity capital, clearly that's something we consider often, but at present we have no plans.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#20

And then Mike, if I could just jump in, Jade.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#21

Yes, please go ahead. Thank you.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#22

Apologies, Jade. Beyond all the points Mike raised, I simply want to restate something he mentioned during his prepared remarks: a number of deals are already in progress that would bring in $2 billion of gross realization proceeds. A substantial portion of that should occur over the next few quarters, and that will definitely shift the liquidity profile — which is exactly where our attention is — and also settle some non-earning and lower-earning assets; so that comes on top of everything Mike just covered.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#23

When it comes to valuation, you said the stock is appealing, or that it doesn't reflect fair value. What's your thinking there? Do you have some sort of trough book value or NAV figure in mind?

Mike McGillis

executive
#24

Sure. I'll handle this one. So looking at our GAAP book value, it comes to about $14 per share. On our loan portfolio, we hold reserves of roughly 4.3%; clearly, we're monetizing quite a few of those loans. We believe the outcome will be recoveries well above the level at which the stock trades right now. And I think as we build liquidity, move through deleveraging, including the TLB across the coming quarters, resolve the 4 and 5-rated loans so we keep bringing those down, and monetize REO, along with enhancing operating performance at two assets set to become REO. Our view is that this ought to eventually lift the share price to a point that better approximates value.

Jade Rahmani

analyst
#25

Thank you so much.

Chris Muller

analyst
#26

Appreciate you fielding our questions. And I'd like to praise the team for how open you've been. Your deck contains a great deal of genuinely useful granularity, and from where we sit that's extremely valuable. So turning to the watchlist — Mike addressed this somewhat in his remarks — but I suppose how forcefully are you intending to move on getting those loans resolved? Will it lean more toward the patient method you've traditionally taken, or might we begin seeing some sizable resolution figures arrive in the near term? And the second piece of that: ought we to anticipate additional loan sales as part of that approach?

Richard Mack

executive
#27

This is Richard. I'd like to direct that to Chris. Thanks for raising it. I want to hand things to Priyanka, though my view is we've been extremely, extremely resolute about squeezing out every single dollar; and with a renewed emphasis on liquidity, we're going to need to act more forcefully when it comes to generating liquidity across 2025. That's essentially our strategy. There are numerous levers available to us for that, yet liquidity is where our attention sits; and we recognize that by fixing liquidity we'll lift our share price. That's genuinely the reason we're viewing things through a liquidity lens at this moment.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#28

Right, let me just piggyback on that. Thanks for raising it, Chris. I'd also point out that since deal activity is picking up and the capital markets are opening up considerably more, we believe this better backdrop for transactions gives us a genuine chance to deploy discounted payoffs along with short sales as a mechanism. That ties into our more aggressive stance on clearing out those watchlist loans. Chris, regarding what you mentioned, the first example you're seeing is, I think, the loan Mike talked about in his prepared remarks. And we'll keep striking a balance between what liquidity we're able to achieve and the timing, certainty, and faster resolution; so I believe you'll keep seeing more of that from us.

Chris Muller

analyst
#29

Yeah, that's really useful. Then I just have a clarifying question about the REO fair value marks. Since REO gets marked to fair value when you take the asset back, was that the second write-down for that hotel portfolio? And if that's the case, could you discuss what shifted after you took it back? I suppose by now it's been nearly 4 years, but just any changes that caused that write-down.

Richard Mack

executive
#30

Sure. I'll begin, and then I'll let Priyanka wrap up. Thanks, Chris. Back in 2021, when we foreclosed on the asset, we marked it to fair value. Our original loan was a mezz loan, and there was a securitized senior financing tied to it. When we foreclosed on the asset, we marked it to fair value, and that produced a modest gain on the asset as part of the foreclosure. And probably the main factor behind the change in the mark is mostly the safe hotel legislation that New York City recently passed, which, I think, has sort of introduced a bit of uncertainty around hotel pricing, especially for non-union hotels. Priyanka, if you'd like to maybe elaborate on that, it would be helpful.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#31

Sure. So, I mean, if you look at the core results, especially the revenue side, and even the margin conversion, it's been extremely robust. In 2024, these properties generated higher EBITDA than they did in 2019, before the pandemic. So our confidence in the fundamental performance remains really high. We've all seen the reports about the favorable demand and supply trends, plus the new supply picture, and all of that works in New York City's favor. The real problem has been the New York City Safe Hotels Act, which the New York City Council first brought up in August 2024 — that landed right in the middle of our sale process, and it forced us to hit pause on that process for a while. Then it eventually became law in October; so that's genuinely what drove the value adjustment. But again, Chris, staying on your first question about liquidity and unlocking capital, we are fully committed to the sale; that being said, we're running a dual-track approach so we can execute a CMBS refinancing if a sale doesn't happen.

Chris Muller

analyst
#32

Understood, and I appreciate the help. Thanks for fielding our questions.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#33

Thanks. I've just got one thing to ask. Regarding those five-rated multifamily loans you intend to move into REO, does that 12% reserve mirror what you could get for the assets if sold right now, or does it capture the worth you anticipate after putting in additional capital and bringing the assets to a stabilized state?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#34

Thank you, Tom. That's a good one, and the answer is a mix of the two. We look at values from multiple angles — what we believe a sale might fetch at present against our view of stabilized value. Pinpointing today's sale price is quite difficult, especially for a loan whose borrower has, in numerous instances, drained the asset of capital. So leaning on that factor by itself strikes us as not making a great deal of sense. That said, we also hold third-party appraisals that back up the values behind those reserves.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#35

Understood. So can you give me any sense of roughly how much extra capital you'd likely need to sink into those properties?

Priyanka Garg

executive
#36

As you can probably imagine, that figure keeps shifting, and it will hinge on when we take those assets through REO, at which point we'd have greater control over the decisions being made. Yet one reason we singled out these particular assets for REO rather than certain others is that they're generating cash flow and don't demand a huge amount of capital. Much of what we'd need to spend would go toward unit renovations when residents move out. That said, in the current economic climate, we're noticing better renewal rates, with tenants remaining in their units longer. So many variables will play into this, in my view, though we don't anticipate needing an enormous sum of capital. Given how these assets have done so far, we believe a modest outlay will stretch quite far.

Tom Catherwood

analyst
#37

Got it. I'm all set. Thanks, all.

Richard Mack

executive
#38

Thanks.

Priyanka Garg

executive
#39

Thanks.

Richard Mack

executive
#40

Thanks once more, everyone, for being here. Let me make this crystal clear as I lay out where we're headed in 2025: our attention will be on strengthening the balance sheet and boosting liquidity. Maximizing value won't be the main thrust, even though we're prepared to seize value selectively when it comes to REO. Any market rebound will stay sluggish. It will stay uneven, and our job is to answer that and match what the market is doing. So with rates still high, and even as spreads tighten, we won't sit around wishing for valuations to shift in any big way. That said, we do anticipate that across 2025, based on what's happening in the capital markets, they will. Even so, as a broad principle, we intend to match the market and work at moving assets both out and in while boosting liquidity. That said, when necessary, we won't hesitate to take assets back, so it comes down to striking that balance, though we'll tilt somewhat further toward liquidity and somewhat away from REO or from being very tough during 2025, with liquidity as the true priority, since we're convinced that once liquidity is repaired, how our stock is valued will improve considerably. So we appreciate everyone for being here, we can't wait to talk with all of you down the road, and thanks once again. Take care.

Operator

operator
#41

This concludes today's call. Thank you for joining. You may now disconnect your lines.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Claros Mortgage Trust, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.