Consumer Portfolio Services, Inc. (CPSS) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

October 26, 2026

NASDAQ US Financials Consumer Finance earnings 20 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Charles Bradley

executive
#1

Thanks, and welcome, everyone, to the call covering our third quarter results. If you've gone through the press release and the material we put out, you can see it was a really strong quarter — likely among the strongest the company has delivered on every front in quite some time. On the one hand, you might say, "That's good," but from where we sit, at least inside the company, this is roughly what we've spent two years working toward; we're seeing genuinely solid growth now. Still, when you examine that growth, reviewing last year matters a great deal. If you replay every phone conference call from last year — in 2025 we were expected to grow. We built for growth, we set ourselves up for growth, and we got very little growth. As I believe I noted, 2025 was a deeply disappointing year where actual growth is concerned. What matters, though, about comparing what we did this year with last year is that we brought on the people that growth required. By late last year we were positioned to originate $200 million to $250 million a month; that didn't happen. So what do you do? You can't just let everybody go; we'd devoted all that time to training them until they were ready. On the collector side, we've kept adding efficiencies in collections, whether through more nearshore staffing or through more bot-related AI kinds of tools. Even the collections arm of the company is very well positioned to grow. When growth arrived this year, it worked out perfectly. We were fully set up to handle it on both fronts. One of our goals at the end of last year was to bring on many more marketing reps in the field. We raised that number by 50% or 60% during the first part of this year. All those things we did last year have genuinely kicked into motion this year. It's delivered the growth. It's delivered the efficiencies, so now we're earning more money. Also, collections are as strong as they've ever been. What's interesting there is that the paper from 2022 and 2023 that wasn't very good is now almost entirely run off, so we now hold a much stronger portfolio in terms of both cost efficiencies, collection efficiencies, and the credit models are performing really well. Everything we want is finally coming together in a really good way. One question we hear now and then is, "Does all this growth create a problem?" Of course, it isn't a problem if you set it up correctly. Having been in the business as long as we have, we've been able to put the right controls in place regarding what we buy; we aren't buying any more aggressively today than we were last year. What sets us apart is that our dealership network is far broader, and so is the group of people we work with in the market; we've managed to identify certain areas in our model where we can go a bit deeper on purchases while achieving an improved outcome, plus a couple of spots where we lowered the price to bring in more paper that we genuinely like. There are numerous levers available in the big picture for building that growth. Naturally, alongside all that growth come greater efficiencies, stronger earnings, everything we'd anticipate. It's performed really well on every front in that respect. On the Wall Street side, so to speak, we enjoyed a strong quarter there as well; our Citibank warehouse line was increased from $335 million to $508 million. More recently, we raised our Capital One line from $390 million to $518 million. As a result, we now hold more than $1 billion of warehousing for the first time since the company began, giving us an excellent position to launch from as we go forward and, hopefully, expand a bit further next year. Is doubling the business in growth next year our goal? No. Do we want to keep growing in a strategic, organized fashion? Yes; we now possess the warehousing capacity to accomplish that; we also completed another residual financing worth $80 million during the third quarter, and a good chunk of that money went toward repaying $60 million of an earlier residual financing that carried a higher cost. It's fortunate we acted at that moment, since rates have since climbed; doing it then instead of waiting until now was a pretty smart move. That has likewise enhanced our cost of funds going forward. Broadly speaking, we completed one more securitization; it would have been the largest we'd ever done. We've since done a recent one in the fourth quarter that is larger still. The pattern going forward should be that each of those securitizations is likely a bit larger than the one before. All in all, those were the positives. Interest rates have risen; we've managed to recalibrate our margins to match by raising certain APRs and fees, so we aren't simply surrendering margin because rates went up; on balance, we're keeping pace and holding a steady margin despite rising interest rates. I'll go into more detail on the industry and the big picture once they've covered the financials and operations. I'll hand things over to Danny.

Danny Bharwani

executive
#2

Thanks, Brad. Quarterly revenue came in at $131.9 million, which is a 22% rise from $108.4 million a year ago. Over the nine-month period, revenue reached $365.6 million, up 12% from $325 million last year; those revenue gains are mainly the result of growth in our loan portfolio, which we carry under the fair value method. Our fair value loan portfolio now stands at $4.6 billion and is yielding 11.3%, and keep in mind that this yield is net of credit losses. Quarterly expenses were $121.8 million, a 20% increase from $101.4 million a year earlier. Across the nine months, $338 million in expenses represents an 11% rise from $304 million last year; the higher expenses stem chiefly from greater interest expense and from an increase in the variable expenses needed to support growth in our loan portfolio. Interest expense, to illustrate, came to $70 million in Q3 versus $59 million a year ago, a 19% increase. Since revenue is climbing more quickly than expenses, pre-tax income rose from $7 million in last year's third quarter to $10.1 million this year, a 44% gain; over the nine months, pre-tax income is 29% higher than last year, at $27.1 million this year against $20.8 million last year. Net income has similarly increased this year. Third-quarter net income was $7 million, up 42% from $4.9 million last year, and for the nine months it was $18.7 million versus $14.3 million in the same period a year ago, an increase of 31%. Earnings per share rose 50%, from $0.20 last year in the third quarter to $0.30 in this year's third quarter; across the nine months, EPS is up 36%, from $0.59 last year to $0.80 this year. The percentage gain in EPS outpaces the increase in after-tax income, largely because fewer shares remain outstanding following our buybacks during the quarter. Turning to the balance sheet, cash of $180.1 million is 19% higher than $151.9 million last year. Finance receivables at fair value totaled $4.6 billion in September 2026, versus $3.6 billion a year ago, a 28% increase; this growth in our fair value portfolio reflects strong origination volumes in the third quarter and really since the year began. The $815 million in new auto loans we originated in the third quarter is the highest we've ever recorded, compared with $391 million in last year's third quarter. Debt now totals $4.4 billion. That figure covers all debt, including warehouse, residual securitization, and other long-term debt. It is 28% above the $3.5 billion of last year, and the rise is consistent with the growth in assets on our balance sheet. Shareholders' equity increased 5%, to $324 million this year from $308 million last year. Turning to additional metrics, net interest margin came in at $58.6 million for the quarter, marking a 22% rise from $48.1 million a year ago; across the nine months, it reached $161 million versus $141.7 million, a 14% gain. Core operating expenses totaled $51.3 million, 21% higher than $42.3 million last year. Year to date, that figure stands at $143.7 million, up 9% from $131.6 million a year earlier. As a percentage of managed portfolio, core operating expenses held steady at 4.5% for the quarter and moved from 4.8% to 4.6% year to date, a 5% improvement. Lastly, return on managed assets is 0.9% this year against 0.8% in last year's third quarter. Those same figures, 0.9% and 0.8%, apply to the three months year-to-date period too. I'll now hand the call to Mike.

Mike Lavin

executive
#3

Appreciate that, Danny. One more quick point regarding our originations. Originations came in at $815 million compared with $391 million — that's a 108.5% increase. As Danny mentioned, that makes it the largest quarter in the 35 years we've been in business. Contract purchases for the nine months ended September 30th, 2026, totaled $2.11 billion, versus $1.28 billion for the nine months ended September 30th, 2025. In only nine months, we've already topped our prior origination record of $2 billion set in 2022. As I mentioned on our last call, we've achieved this growth by growing our sales force, building up our dealer base, and increasing applications received. Another key metric we've pushed higher is our capture rate, which has gradually risen from the high 5%s to a bit above 7%. The math tells you more reps means more dealers, which means more applications, and once you add in a higher capture rate, you get record-setting growth. A few more specifics on the sales growth. At the close of last year, we had 93 total sales reps; today we have roughly 150 total sales reps, a 60% increase since the start of the year. That has meant adding close to 6,100 dealership partners over the last 12 months, lifting the dealership base by 90% from approximately 6,800 dealers we had at the end of the third quarter last year to nearly 12,900 dealers now. Along with that, we received 1.3 million applications in the quarter, up from 758,000 in the prior quarter. Most of the new dealership partners are franchise dealers, as we continue to run at a split of 65% franchise dealers versus 35% non-franchise dealers following the growth; that matters because most of our deals remain in the upper tier programs. Naturally, we see less fraud with that franchise dealership paper. Typically, there are a few ways to grow. One, lower the APRs and fees. Two, loosen the credit box. Three, hire more sales reps, new territories, new dealer partners. For us, we chose the third method; it costs a little bit more, but we did this consciously so we could grow without altering the credit tightening trend we have continued since mid-2023. So it's important to note that we continue to underwrite a tight credit box despite our growth. Our payment-to-income and our debt-to-income ratios, which mark the consumer's ability to pay, remain flat through the economic headwinds and over our growth for the last six to nine months. Further and notably, we have grown while experiencing an approval rate that has dropped from the low 50% to the low 40% in the last six months. That means we remain somewhat picky on the contracts we purchase. We are getting a proportional amount of good applications. Most important, we are growing without making credit concessions. On a separate note, we have a prime product that we introduced at the beginning of this year, and it has grown quarter-over-quarter. In a similar vein, we introduced a fresh refinance offering, and it has been seeing quite encouraging expansion from the moment it started. And last, when it comes to fraud — a major concern across the industry — we currently have three best-in-class AI-driven fraud prevention tools supplied by outside vendors, among them two of the three largest credit bureaus, which combat every kind of fraud, such as identity theft, synthetic fraud, and income and employment fraud. In fact, we plan to bring on a fourth one near the close of the fourth quarter of this year. So here at the company we're fairly well positioned to combat fraud. As Danny mentioned, our OpEx is flat to slightly lower versus the prior year-over-year. We constantly seek ways to push our OpEx down further. For instance, given our growth, we're bringing in 5,500 new accounts each month, and on those we're using our nearshore operations and AI platforms to reduce servicing costs as we scale; it's worth noting that, when measured against our competitors, our nearshore collections level is quite low, so there's substantial room to raise it while still remaining a domestic collection company. Moving to credit performance, our total DQ greater than 30 days, including repossession inventory, for the third quarter fell to 12.26%, versus 13.9% in the year period. Every quarter this year has come down relative to the prior year, showing a pattern of DQ contraction. Another encouraging indicator: total annualized net charge-offs for the third quarter dropped to 7.26%, versus 8.01% in the year prior period. As with our DQ, every quarter this year has posted a decline in charge-offs relative to the prior year. That's another favorable performance trend in contraction. Additionally, repossessions and extensions both came down relative to the prior years. On extensions, we ran a data dive and found solid results: three out of every four extensions did not lead to repossessions, and two out of every three extensions did not lead to a charge-off. We've relied on an extension model for years that we brought in a big consulting firm to help us build, and it makes the extension decision more scientific and less subjective for the collector. We're getting a lot of bang for our buck from our extensions now and going forward. Moving to recoveries: net recovery rates on repossessed collateral sold at wholesale auction rose to 32% in the third quarter versus 28% in the prior year period; that's below our historical average of the low 40%, but we expect recovery rates to climb as the 2022 and 2023 portfolio flushes out of the portfolio. As Brad mentioned, right now the 2022 and 2023s account for only 14% of our portfolio; so good times lie ahead on recoveries. My last point, which I always mention, is the ever-important unemployment rate, which finished the third quarter at 4.2%, versus 4.4% for the prior year period. That points to a fairly solid jobs picture. I also checked the Department of Labor's projections, which show the jobless rate ticking up a bit to 4.4% — still low by historical standards. With that said, I'll hand things back to Brad.

Charles Bradley

executive
#4

Thanks, Mike. When it comes to the industry, I'd say the best description is that things are pretty much the same. At this point you've got five or six big competitors, and that's not even counting the banks. Because those companies are so large — us included — the hurdles for a newcomer trying to enter are getting higher all the time. A new entrant would require a substantial amount of equity capital. They'd also have to be in a position to build their portfolio. If you don't have a $1 billion portfolio, you're essentially not a contender. Very few players even fit into that group right now. There are a few, perhaps a handful, that are at roughly $1 billion or below. But once you move up to $2 billion or higher, the field becomes really sparse. So I'd say that's a really solid aspect of the industry; it's a good thing since all the big players are performing well. It ought to keep other entrants out for the foreseeable future. As Mike mentioned, unemployment is among the key items we monitor. Unemployment looks fairly solid. Nothing concerning there. Inflation and interest rates are the two things we're watching very closely. If interest rates rise, it pressures the margins; we're able to adjust to that quite easily and will keep doing so. So we're not too worried. Even more important, as we grow larger and rates ultimately decline at some point down the road, that will be extremely beneficial for the company where profitability is concerned. So on the whole, I'd say we're not too concerned. I believe we've made genuine progress this year when it comes to growth. We've managed that growth in a very efficient and effective way. I expect we'll carry on and complete the year. The fourth quarter is somewhat lighter, so we'll see how that plays out. But on the whole, the year is going quite well. The third quarter came after the second quarter. The second quarter, if you remember, is when growth began for us. We've now had a full six or seven months of really robust growth, yet very efficient and very controlled. So we're quite pleased with where we stand and excited about what's ahead. Thank you all for being with us on the call; we look forward to speaking with you next year.

Operator

operator
#5

That wraps up today's call, everyone. Starting 2 hours from now, a replay can be accessed for 12 months through the company's site at www.consumerportfolio.com. At this point, please drop off the lines, and enjoy the rest of your day.

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Consumer Portfolio Services, Inc. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Consumer Portfolio Services, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.