Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 6, 2020

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 113 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for being on the line, and welcome to Crédit Agricole's Q1 Results 2020. Right now, everyone attending is in listen-only mode. Following the speaker presentation, a question and answer session will take place. I'd now like to pass the conference to today's speaker, Jérôme Grivet. Sir, please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Afternoon, everyone. First, my apologies for the small hiccups we ran into as this conference got underway. I know a number of you have been waiting in line to get connected. My suggestion is that everyone can keep following the conference and the presentation via the webcast. Naturally, I expect that once the presentation wraps up, you'll at last be able to speak on the call. I'd like to open by thanking all the teams in the financial department of Crédit Agricole group, along with the various departments of the different subsidiaries, for having put this set of figures together under circumstances I'd describe as very particular and unusual. The entire effort was assembled fully remotely and, to my mind at least, when it comes to the quality of the analysis and the documents, we are entirely at our usual standard. Once again, my thanks go out to all the teams. Joining me are Philippe Brassac, who is on this call directly, and Clotilde. With the help of the teams, who are also online, we'll try to answer your questions following this presentation. Let me begin now with the key figures found on page four of the document.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

As you can see, the Crédit Agricole group overall is reporting net profit for the quarter of a little more than EUR 900 million — EUR 908 million, to be exact — which is minus 32.8% versus the first quarter of 2019. The underlying figure would come to EUR 981 million, -31.6%. At CASA level, the numbers are EUR 638 million for stated net profit, -16.4%, and EUR 652 million, -18.1% on an underlying basis. I think these figures need to be viewed through two different prisms. The first is that of the group's activity and that of our various businesses, which was quite positively oriented throughout the entire first quarter of this year. Naturally, the second element that weighed on those figures — and that fully accounts for the net profit slipping somewhat — is the fact that, naturally, from the beginning or the middle of March, we have been confronting some major turbulences, both in the market and also in the day-to-day life of all our activities. Let me now turn to page five, where you will see more precisely what happened exactly during the quarter. Because, as you will see, at CASA level, in fact, we are reporting gross operating income that is up 7.9% on an underlying basis, and up even more sharply on a stated basis, which combines a very good level of revenues, up around 5%, with good cost control.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

In fact, at the CASA level the cost-to-income ratio got better again, gaining over 1 percentage point to hit 62.2%. And then naturally, the decline in net income stems from the higher cost of risk, which is itself chiefly caused by provisioning on performing assets. On the CASA perimeter, the cost of risk comes out roughly 3 times higher, at 2.8x, and on the group perimeter it is even 3.3x. Although solvency this quarter was somewhat affected by various items, both at CASA and at group level it stays very solid: 11.4% at CASA, well above our target and even further above any minimum regulatory requirement. At the group level, it comes in at 15.5%. That figure is consistently among the highest you would encounter anywhere in the European landscape. Finally, on this page, I would like to stress that the group's liquidity has in fact improved markedly over the course of this first quarter of 2020. Moving now to page six, let me dig a bit into revenues at CASA. As I mentioned, revenues on an underlying basis rose by nearly 5%, more precisely 4.8%, reflecting a combination of differing trends across the various business lines.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Honestly, our retail banking operations have shown really strong resilience, and among the group's retail banking businesses — the CASA group — LCL delivered a very good result, with revenues rising by over 2%. We also saw quite solid results in the large customer division, with revenues higher at CACIB and climbing even faster there, though of course a positive scope effect played a part. In the specialized financial services division, competitive pressure remains very strong, and we also saw a decline in new loan production in March across our various markets, which accounts for the pressure on the top line. Finally, in the asset gathering division, activity was very good, though revenues were clearly affected by some end-of-period valuation. I'll naturally go into these points in a bit more detail. This was partly offset by a stronger contribution from the corporate center, where we have more or less a partial offset of the depreciation recorded in the asset gathering division. If I try to gauge, in the end, what the market dislocation cost in terms of the overall revenue level at CASA, it's not, I'd say, an audited figure I'm giving you, but roughly we estimate that this market dislocation — netting the positive and negative elements — amounted to a hit to our revenues of somewhere around EUR 200 million to EUR 210 million, and a hit to the bottom line, the profit line, of approximately EUR 150 million.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

Moving to page seven now, I'll say a bit about the cost line. Globally, I believe we've monitored the cost base very well across all business lines and for the group, with costs rising 2.9% on an underlying basis. Within that increase of slightly under EUR 100 million for the quarter, we saw some tax effects, both in the insurance activities and in the consumer credit business. We also clearly have the scope effect at CACIB, which by itself accounts for more than EUR 35 million of additional costs. As you can see, IFRIC 21 costs keep climbing at a much faster pace, including the contribution to a Single Resolution Fund. I can't rule out that we might need to top up this provision for the Single Resolution Fund during the second quarter, because obviously it appears the requests from the Single Resolution Board were even higher than what we have booked in our accounts. Going to page eight now, I'd like to point out some key elements concerning how the cost of risk has evolved and the quality, beginning with the quality of our portfolio.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

As I mentioned, the cost of risk has risen sharply—roughly a threefold multiplication. This is happening while asset quality remains very strong. In fact, NPL levels, both for the group and for CASA alone, are somewhat lower than at the end of last year. The figure is 3.1% at CASA and 2.4% at group level. With the additional provisions we are recording this quarter, coverage ratios keep rising substantially—72.4% at CASA and 84.3% at group level. Obviously, the cost of risk is mainly driven by anticipating future risks, meaning provisioning for bucket 1 and bucket 2 assets. In that provisioning, we have factored in both the economic downturn and the expected impact of all public measures decided and announced, which are beginning to be implemented, particularly with our own assistance since the end of March. This produces a cost of risk on outstandings of 61 basis points annualized at CASA. At group level it is 40 basis points—clearly well above the levels we reported last year, which were approximately 32 basis points and 20 basis points.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

It's also quite a bit higher than the level we had in mind across the cycle — the levels we assumed when we published our medium-term plan in June last year, where we assumed an average cost of risk across the cycle of around 40 basis points at CASA and 25 basis points at the group level. If I turn now to page nine, what page nine shows is that we haven't had any leeway, I would say, on the level of bucket 3, cost of risk. You see at CASA that this quarter we have EUR 382 million of cost of risk on non-performing assets. That compares to an average in 2019 of EUR 362 million. At the group level, the figures are EUR 516 versus EUR 476. Clearly, there's no significant deterioration in the cost of risk with regards to non-performing assets. This is the same situation you will see on page 10, where we have the breakdown of bucket 1 and bucket 2 on the one hand, and bucket 3 on the other hand, provisioning on the different business lines. You can see that within the regional banks, within LCL, within CA Italia, within CACF, and within the financing activities of CACIB, we have the same type of breakdown with a rather stable level of bucket 3 provisions, and the increase, mainly or mostly explained by the additional bucket 1 and bucket 2 provisioning.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

This brings us to page 11, and it's leading into how net profit has moved in each business line, and clearly it's down. At group level, that's -18% globally. Averaged across the different business lines, it comes to -23%. Obviously, the main or essential driver here is how the cost of risk line has moved. In most cases — and this has been especially true for the retail banking activities and for the large customers division — the operational level performed very well at the start of this year. On page 13, I don't think I'll go through the figures you have there at any length. It says exactly the same thing, namely that across all business lines we enjoyed a very positive commercial momentum in the first quarter of 2020. I just want to dwell a little on one figure, which is customer capture at the retail banks in France and Italy. During the first quarter of this year, we succeeded in capturing an additional 416,000 new customers in a single quarter, and that is driving a further increase in the customer base. As you can see, every one of the traditional activity indicators — outstandings, number of policies, and so on — is up this quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

Yes, certainly — revenues have taken a hit because of the situation. Our net interest margin has held up quite well. Commissions are showing a mixed picture, with results varying by the type of commission. Naturally, the most negative impact has been on all those revenues affected by depreciation tied to unfavorable market dislocation. Now, if I look a bit more closely at each business division, beginning with asset gathering and insurance activities, I think the most interesting point to note on page 14 is that, in fact, across this quarter, net inflows came in at around zero, I would say. There were no massive outflows in March, and we still benefited from positive inflows in January and February. Conversely, the market effect was absolutely massive — it represented a hit on global assets under management of above EUR 125 billion. Even so, compared with the end of March 2019, assets under management remain slightly up. I just want to zoom in a little on this page regarding how the wealth management activities performed, which posted their best performance in three years' time. That reflects significant efforts undertaken over the last 18 months to improve the efficiency of this business, plus the fact that our customers behaved very actively in the first quarter, facing the very volatile markets that we had.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

Regarding insurance operations, to put what occurred during the quarter briefly, activity levels have been quite strong. That was certainly true in non-life operations—both the P&C and protection segments—where, once again, premium income rose 7%-8% for the quarter versus the first quarter of 2019. The same held for savings and retirement operations, in the life business, where premium levels were naturally below those of a year earlier, yet unit-linked inflows reached a record amount. On revenues, as I mentioned, they are heavily affected by the crisis, particularly through impairment of certain assets recognized via profit and loss. Additionally, given how the market moved, we had to record an extra EUR 60 million of technical provisions related to unit-linked operations. Most of these items should reverse if and when markets eventually recover. On cost trends, this quarter's cost movement is in fact shaped by a tax effect, since excluding that tax effect, the cost base at Crédit Agricole Assurances is roughly flat for the quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

Finally, I want to address the solvency of Crédit Agricole Assurances, which remains at a very high level — 234% under Solvency II. Regarding Amundi and asset management, all the information you might need on this business is available, since Amundi has already published its quarterly results. Perhaps we should bear in mind that Amundi saw, during the quarter, a very light level of outflows, with a strong performance from retail networks plus the JVs, nearly offsetting the outflows among institutional and corporate customers. The P&L demonstrates very good resilience, with a good level of operational revenues, which are up, and a good level of cost control. The P&L is simply affected by — as was the case at Crédit Agricole Assurances — market valuation on the financial portion of revenues. Moving now to page 17, French retail banking activities, LCL: it was a very good quarter in terms of activity and in terms of customer capture. Of course, with a significant slowdown beginning mid-March, when all customers changed their priorities and the entire network began to dedicate its means and its activities to answering these new customer needs and to maintaining the functioning of the network's basic services for its customers.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

Outstanding loans have risen. Customer savings are also up considerably, even though equity-market-linked savings took a negative market hit. Revenue is 2.2% higher. The cost base is once more lower by nearly 1.5%. Naturally, as you can see, gross operating income has climbed markedly. Net income group share has fallen, tied to a substantial rise in the cost of risk — again, from provisioning of performing loans. In Italy the picture is broadly similar, although the different figures are evolving somewhat less dynamically. Clearly, activity in Italy began slowing sooner, and in fact what we observed is that following a very dynamic January and February, new loan production and new activities overall dropped by 30%-50% in March versus the January-February average. Thanks to very good cost control, Crédit Agricole Italia actually succeeded in holding its cost-to-income ratio steady and absorbing that decline in revenue. Once more, we see that because of increased provisioning of performing loans, cost of risk is up by a quarter and net profit is down by roughly 20%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

Moving on to the remaining international retail banking operations, there isn’t a great deal to report. We did record certain prudential provisions within cost of risk here as well, but beyond that, I believe there is nothing further worth noting. In specialized financial services, the origination of new loans has been hit very hard. As you are aware, CACF either consolidates directly or at minimum manages a loan portfolio with two major areas of focus outside France — Italy, together with car financing operations. Without question, those two lending segments were affected directly and extremely severely by the COVID crisis. To be specific, new loan production in March came to only EUR 2.6 billion, versus EUR 7 billion during the first two months of the year. That represents a decline in March production to a quarter of the January–February average. The fall has been even steeper, naturally, at Agos and across the car financing JVs. Our consolidated loan book is essentially flat relative to the end of last quarter. Because competition remains extremely intense, margin pressure persists, and that is what accounts for the lower revenue level. Once again, we observe a rise in cost of risk, driven again by provisioning on performing loans, and that is what explains the movement in net income group share.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#15

On the leasing and factoring side, the picture is pretty much the same, with solid commercial activity in both leasing and factoring. Revenue there is affected more by the mix of activities—no particular concern about margin levels—but the mix shift was less favorable, along with a cost of risk that comes entirely from provisioning on performing loans. Now let me turn to the large customer division, which delivered very positive numbers for the quarter. Overall, I'd say activity was at a very good level, and of course the contribution was affected by the higher cost of risk at CACEIS. Still, starting with CACEIS, I should note that this quarter was the first in which we saw the full effect of integrating KAS Bank, on one hand, and Santander Securities Services, on the other. For CACEIS, that is producing a very sharp rise in the level of assets, whether held in custody for funds or administered. Revenues are up close to 30%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#16

Costs are, naturally, 25% higher, though just 6% of that is organic. The remainder comes from the scope effect. Net profit at CACEIS has jumped sharply, by 27%, notwithstanding the minority interest we now carry inside this business division, of course. It's also worth noting that CACEIS is supplying a considerable amount of liquidity to the group, and that hit record levels during the first quarter of this year. Turning to CACEIS, on page 22 — to sum it up briefly, how the first quarter of this year unfolded was a clear demonstration of how relevant CACEIS's business model is, a model built around attempting to meet the financing needs of its corporate customer base by deploying every tool required to do so, including capital market activities, of course. Capital market activities that are plainly there to help serve customer needs rather than to produce trading revenues on their own. This produced a quarter in which we saw, of course, a level of revenue in the financing activities that was somewhat lower, with the year getting off to a slow start and then speeding up from mid-March, along with capital market and investment banking revenues that are up significantly, plainly propelled by customer demand and accompanied by a very low level of volatility in our capital market activities, with a VaR level that rose a little, by definition, in the highly dislocated markets we face, yet without reaching elevated levels and with no meaningful volatility in the P&L of our capital market activities.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

The cost base is up a bit, though not as much as revenues have grown. The cost of risk, by definition, is up significantly. In fact, versus the first quarter of 2019, when we still had some minor loan loss provision reversals, there's an inversion in the cost of risk — roughly half of CACEIS's cost of risk this quarter comes from, again, provisioning of performing assets. That leads to very good resilience at CACEIS this quarter, with net income group share down only 13.5% despite this very sharp rise in the cost of risk. RWA are up roughly EUR 12 billion, half of which is explained by regulatory effects on securitization, which we had already mentioned before the quarter began. We were perfectly aware that this would happen this quarter and with this type of amount. The remainder is explained specifically by either the credit line drawdowns or some market effect, with a significant increase in RWA related to credit risk on the trading book. The corporate center on page 23. As usual, we'll analyze the structural corporate center separately, and then the volatile component of the corporate center.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

On the corporate center's structural side, we're seeing a slight decline, though that's mostly tied to non-recurring items — things such as certain components within the cost of risk or how the cost base is distributed over the course of the year. Nothing that's genuinely structural. This structural portion of the corporate center keeps posting regular revenue gains. Turning to the division's other components, the notable improvement stems from the favorable impact of intragroup elimination this quarter. That relates to debt issued by CASA and bought either by Amundi or by Crédit Agricole Assurances for their own operations. When consolidating those two entities, we have to eliminate the effects of that debt, which tends to be positive — as it was again this quarter — when market conditions are volatile, and negative in the opposite situation. As I've already mentioned, it offsets, in part — only in part, naturally — the adverse market impact we recorded within the revenue lines at Crédit Agricole Assurances or at Amundi. Moving now to page 25, there are some points concerning Crédit Agricole's regional banks. On the activity front, you'll see broadly the same patterns as those observed at LCL — namely, a solid level of activity, a strong rise in loan outstandings, up 7%, and equally strong growth in customer assets.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

That brings revenues to a certain level — and if we look at operational revenues, they're up roughly in line with LCL. At the Regional Banks, revenues worldwide also took a hit from market conditions, since a big chunk of the high-quality liquid assets they hold for liquidity purposes isn't held directly; it sits in mutual funds, which run through P&L. That produced a sizable P&L impairment this quarter, and it accounts for how revenues at the Regional Banks moved. This, naturally, stems from putting the international accounting standard into effect. As you can see, under the French GAAP standard this doesn't translate the same way in full, and the net profit trend at the regional banks under French GAAP looks far more similar to what we saw at LCL — roughly minus 22%. That's plainly the result of how the cost of risk moved, which is very pronounced here for the regional banks, given that their cost of risk level in the first quarter of 2019 was unusually low — just EUR 56 million — taking it to more than EUR 300 million this quarter, though once again, this is driven by provisioning of performing loans.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

That's still at a low level compared with international standards, I'd say. Now if I turn to page 27, you'll see how RWAs evolved both at group level and at CASA level. Let me begin with CASA. As you can see, RWAs rose quite substantially, from EUR 324 billion at the close of last quarter to EUR 348 billion at the close of this quarter. Several elements are behind this, and I'd like to describe them a bit. I already mentioned the regulatory effect on securitization, which added EUR 5.5 billion. Growth within the business line — covering not only how their lending activities developed but also forex effects and the rise in credit risk tied to the trading book at CACIB — comes to EUR 11 billion in total. There's a drop in the equity value of the stake held in the insurance companies, tied to the decline in OCI reserves, and that accounts for a reduction of nearly EUR 5 billion in RWA. This brings about, I'd say, a normal — quote, unquote — "evolution of RWA" from EUR 324 to EUR 336. Then comes a further EUR 12 billion, resulting from a decision we made last year, which we announced at the end of last year — or confirmed, I'd say, at the end of last year — namely the partial dismantling of the Switch mechanism.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#21

Naturally, that results in a rise of EUR 12 billion in RWAs. At the group level, you'll notice we'll observe the same patterns I just described for CASA. On the outside, naturally, the RWAs tied to the unwinding of the Switch, since as you're aware, at group level, the unwinding of the Switch is entirely neutral. The EUR 5.5 billion of growth tied to regulatory effects, the EUR 11.7 billion tied to expansion in the business line, including Crédit Agricole's regional banks, and the minus EUR 4.7 billion tied to the decline in the value of the stake in the insurance activity. This brings us to a solvency ratio at CASA that now stands at 11% at quarter end. 11.4%, sorry, at the end of the quarter. That 11.4% comes from a set of elements laid out in the waterfall on this page 28. We begin at the 12.1% level we had at the end of last year. The dividend we had originally provisioned in the 2019 accounts, which we will not be paying following the ECB's decision, is reintegrated into our solvency.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#22

There's a regulatory effect of minus 20 basis points. Then we have this quarter's retained earnings. I should clarify that when I say retained earnings, I mean we've already subtracted from that figure the AT1 coupons along with a provision for the 2020 dividend at 50%, in line with our standard dividend policy. Our OCI reserves went down by 33 basis points of ratio. RWA movements used up roughly 40 basis points of ratio. That brings us to a level of 11.8 at the end of March. On top of that, there are 44 basis points of solvency consumption, which again stems from the decision we made and announced, and which will generate further results at CASA down the road, taking us to the 11.4% figure. I'd like to stress that this gradual unwinding of the Switch mechanism was announced and represents a perfect reflection of the group's policy of managing CASA with a solvency ratio that of course stays well above every regulatory requirement, yet isn't excessively high, so as to preserve the ability to deliver the best achievable return on equity for CASA's shareholders.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#23

Naturally, the thinking is that the group’s surplus capital must be held at the highest level—that is, at the regional bank level—which then produces the ratio at group level. That explains our current position. Let me wrap up this page by noting that, in fact, even with this decline, at the end of last quarter we had a cushion over regulatory requirements amounting to 340 basis points of capital. That cushion did improve during this quarter, rising by 10 basis points, and now sits at 350 basis points, reflecting the various decisions announced by the ECB and by the other central banks regarding Article 104a and the easing of counter-cyclical buffers. This reduces the requirements for CASA by close to 80 basis points. It does, in fact, improve the cushion that CASA maintains above this minimum requirement. At group level, you will see the same waterfall, with the same items accounting for the movement between the end of 2019 and the end of Q1 2020, with a solvency ratio—CET1 ratio at the end of March—of 15.5%. Once again, the same phenomenon applies: the cushion over any minimum requirement, which was 620 basis points at the end of last year, now stands at 660 basis points.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#24

During this quarter, it went up 40 basis points. The TLAC ratio, along with the MREL ratio measured against RWAs, remains covered with no inclusion of any eligible senior debt component. As for the MREL ratio in TLAC terms, the decline is entirely accounted for by growth in balance sheet size tied to the various refinancing operation we implemented in March this year, seizing the different windows that opened, specifically those from the ECB. On liquidity, I've already touched on that. Now I'd just like to provide a few figures. The group's liquidity position got better. Liquidity reserves have risen by nearly EUR 40 billion, moving from EUR 300 billion at the end of last year to EUR 340 billion. The LCR ratio also strengthened, and at the close of this quarter it stands even above 140%, while our stable resources position remains significantly over EUR 100 billion, at EUR 132 billion in fact. Market funding, page 31. By the end of April, we had finished 2/3 of our medium and long-term market funding program. In fact, we were able to capitalize on April's market improvements to carry out two major benchmark operations, one being a covered bond and the other a senior non-preferred bond, and both proved very successful.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#25

With that, I'll wrap up the presentation and move straight to your questions, simply by noting that we find ourselves in a highly specific and highly unprecedented situation. We are confronting it from a very strong, very robust, very solid standing. Our business model is balanced and diversified, and it fits this situation perfectly. Our operational efficiency is very good. Our risk management reflects a conservative DNA or culture, I would say. Our capital position is very strong and our liquidity position is very good. We are fully operational, and over the last eight weeks we have actually demonstrated it, because the banks in their various capacities have kept functioning in a completely operational way. We are acting in a fully coherent way with our raison d'être, with the model we elaborated and published in the middle of last year, which is to act every day in the best interest of all of our customers. What I think is really very important to note is that we are able to play fully the card of the strategy put in place by the various public authorities in France and in Europe at the European level, the monetary and fiscal authorities, which is to offer all the businesses and all the households the capacity to get from one side of the shutdown of the economy to the other side, with banks helping by providing liquidity and funding to all their customers.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#26

The reason is that we are fully engaged in this process and have mobilized to shape this policy, which allowed us—right at the start of March, and you'll find those details on page 35—to begin establishing moratoriums on business loans for our customers as a way to assist them. By the end of April, the total moratoriums granted had reached over EUR 3 billion. It's in that same spirit that we moved very proactively to implement the state guaranteed loan program in France, and by end of April we had now reviewed and, I'd say, processed nearly EUR 20 billion of state guaranteed loans. Along those same lines, we've set up dedicated, specific support for professional customers who hold their professional multi-risk insurance with us, which covers business interruption but does not cover the pandemic scenario. We took the same approach in Italy, where we established EUR 6 billion in dedicated loans to support corporates. It's likewise in this manner that we've been assisting our individual customers, in both France and Italy, via our retail networks and through CACF.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#27

That's it. That's the presentation I was hoping to give today. I'm certainly ready now to take your questions. I'm not sure whether someone is handling the questions. I hope so.

Operator

operator
#28

Yes, our first question is from Delphine Lee at JPMorgan.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#29

Yes.

Operator

operator
#30

Please, the floor is yours.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#31

Hello, and good afternoon. Thank you for the presentation. May I ask about your cost of risk — could you perhaps share some of the assumptions behind the impact for this quarter? On slide 37 I can see that you include some GDP forecasts. I'm not sure whether those are the ones you're using; if you wouldn't mind, it would also help to get a bit more color on the provisioning you hold against the sectors that are most affected. If by any chance you have something like a range for the full year in terms of cost of risk, any guidance you could give would be welcome. Second, on capital, if you could give us just a little on what we should expect over the next few quarters. Is there any impact from credit ratings migration? Is the TRIM impact still expected for this year? And perhaps over the more medium to long term, do you still expect to achieve 50% reimbursement on Switch 2? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#32

Delphine, those are two significant and thought-provoking questions, so thank you. On cost of risk: you're familiar with how IFRS 9 operates. We're establishing various scenarios, assigning weights to each of them, and our method blends a top-down analysis — with top-down provisioning — together with a bottom-up approach. Throughout the organization, we've built out scenarios, given each one a weighting, and we'll refresh them at the close of every quarter so we can stay fully consistent with our macroeconomic assumptions and our financial figures. That top-down method produces, let's say, an initial layer of extra cost of risk and extra provisions, and then we add to it a bottom-up approach. This is built entity by entity and factors in both the geographic dimension — since, as you're aware, we operate in various countries, and within France, across various regions — and, in this local forward-looking exercise, as I'd call it, we also factor in particular industrial sectors. Clearly, what we have factored in is the hotel, restaurant, and entertainment sector, which confronts particular difficulties and which in all likelihood will emerge from the shutdown at a later point than many, indeed most, of the industrial sectors.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#33

We’re factoring in the oil and gas sector as well, since by definition that industry is especially affected by how oil prices move. We’ve also been accounting for the particular circumstances of the air transportation sector. It’s a combination. I won’t provide you with figures for each industrial segment, for each entity, or for each geography, but the amount of the bucket 1 and bucket 2 provision comes out of those two approaches. I’d describe it as the central forward-looking approach, which is top-down and supplemented by bottom-up, local forward-looking approaches. Regarding prospects, that’s very hard for me to answer, because by definition we close the March-end accounts using all the information available to us at that moment. We will close the Q2-end accounts with updated information and with revised assumptions that we need to make. Given the circumstances we’re dealing with, the volatility of the assumption can be greater than in what I’d call normal times. We’ll reassess all of these hypotheses by the close of the second quarter. It wouldn’t surprise me if that review of the assumption resulted in additional provisioning for bucket one and bucket two.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#34

In essence, the tasks we set for the first quarter were completed within that quarter. I won't provide guidance or projections for the entire year. I don't believe that's particularly relevant, and plainly, our view is that a portion of the solution rests with us — that is, the more efficiently we deploy the various tools I was presenting at the close of my remarks, the stronger and quicker the recovery and upturn will be. We are committed to doing everything within our power to make that happen as swiftly as we can. What I can say is that should the trajectory of the cost of risk, or its level, stay roughly where it stands today — where it has stood during this quarter — across the remaining three quarters of the year, that would not stop us from continuing to support our customers and extend lending to them, nor would it put at risk our solvency or our ability to stay on the safe side among all European banks. That is the best response I can offer.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#35

On the capital side — well, those two questions tie together. Obviously, we're committed to dismantling half of the Switch mechanism. 35% is done. There's still at least 15% left to go. We'll get it done. There's time for that, since this commitment is meant to be fulfilled by 2022. Time is on our side, but the intention remains to carry it out, clearly. No issue there. Even after this first layer of dismantling, we're still at a very comfortable solvency level at CASA — 11.4% against the target we have. We note that our target now sits more significantly above the minimum requirements. That's an element worth keeping in mind as well. At group level, we have absolutely no doubt that we'll continue to rank among the best capitalized banking groups in Europe. From our viewpoint, capital is not a real issue. We'll keep taking into account all the modifications of the regulation when they take place. We understand that some elements are going to be decided by the European Commission in the next weeks in order to be applied by end of the second quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#36

We’ll put into practice any elements that the regulation provides for.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#37

Regarding TRIM, I'd like to add something about those beneficial effects that stem from the adjustments made by the European Commission.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

Well, I read — and you probably did too — that the European Commission was considering tweaking somewhat how the IFRS 9 first-time application effect might be factored into the solvency calculation. As I understand it, it's also reflecting on the software deduction. Those bits and pieces, we'll put them into practice once they're applicable.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#39

All right, TRIM?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#40

Regarding TRIM, we were nearing the completion of that process. Actually, when we discuss TRIM, we did include in this process what indeed happened during the first quarter — namely, the EUR 5.5 billion rise in securitization, which isn't directly a TRIM impact. When we published the capital planning within the medium-term plan, we had provided some guidance on all the regulatory impact we might have to face. Clearly, one of the major pieces of that was securitization. As for TRIM itself, the remaining portion of TRIM has been officially postponed, if I understand correctly what the ECB said. Probably 2021.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#41

All right, that's excellent. Thanks very much.

Operator

operator
#42

Thanks for that question. Our following question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Your line is open — please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#43

Hello? Yes.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#44

My apologies — I had myself muted. Are you able to hear me at this point?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#45

Right.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#46

Is someone there?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#47

Right.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#48

Oh, all right.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#49

We hear you.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#50

Apologies—my line was muted. I have two questions, one about cost of risk and one about revenue. Regarding cost of risk, when you consider the diversified mix of your businesses, which one concerns you the most? Which business are you watching most closely? Is it Consumer Finance? Is it Italy? Any color you can provide there would be quite interesting. On revenues, what do you expect on the revenue side? Perhaps any early signs you have observed regarding loan growth or margins, or any comment there would be helpful. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

Well, to respond to your first question, I'd respond to all of them, since we are constantly monitoring every one of our portfolios, and in fact each business line is — and has the responsibility for — tracking all of its portfolios. Put simply, we're examining the various portfolios, factoring in all the elements, and you brought up, for instance, consumer credit. Well, the consumer credit business in France, where most households, most individuals benefit from social — I'd say — fallback and security elements, is not the same issue as in the U.S., where many people lose their jobs and lose their revenues at the same time. It has to be examined, taking into account the full context. That's why each business line is better positioned to assess globally the state of the quality of its risk portfolio, factoring in all these elements. The risk department and the risk chief officer are definitely tracking all the various portfolios with a closer look, probably at the few industrial sectors I already mentioned as being quite sensitive in the present context. With all the uncertainties that we face, we must examine all the categories of risks and all the context elements.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#52

I've been going over all the social security measures that exist in France. And of course I can also bring up the fact that, for businesses and corporates, we'll now be benefiting from the state guarantee on the new loans we're currently putting in place. The second question concerned revenues. Well, on revenues, naturally, we remain active. We keep developing our various activities, and we hope that with the confinement period now nearing its end in France and in Italy, we'll see business activity return to a more normal level — beyond the liquidity facilities we need to provide in order to assist businesses and households. Our hope is — and we'll work toward it — to carry on with what you might call our "normal" course of business. Clearly, revenue is not the line that will primarily drive profit. Clearly, the cost of this will have a larger impact — as indeed it already did this quarter — on the bottom line than on the top line, clearly.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#53

Understood — thanks a lot. May I squeeze in one very quick follow-up regarding the capital topic raised a moment ago? Per your plan, the floor is 11%, or at least that's what it indicates. Naturally, you hold a fairly sizeable cushion relative to SREP. Might you contemplate dipping under 11%, or does 11% remain your floor?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#54

Okay, so the goal remains 11%. We won't be revising that goal each quarter. What we're seeing, as I mentioned, is that this goal gave us a cushion of roughly 230 basis points over any minimum regulatory requirement at the end of 2019. As of now, thanks to all the changes that happened during the quarter, that cushion sits above 300 basis points. Naturally, that's something we have to factor in, but the 11% target has not been altered.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#55

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#56

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#57

We appreciate the questions. Everyone, just a quick reminder—if you'd like to pose a question, please press star and one on your phone. Press star one to ask a question. Our next question is from Jean-François Tremblay at Goldman Sachs. Your line is open, please proceed.

Jean-François Tremblay

analyst
#58

Thanks for taking the call. I just wanted to ask — and maybe, as you said yourself, the cost of risk will be the main swing factor for the P&L this year. I guess you were also around in 2008 and 2009, so I just wanted to understand what you think — even though you won't necessarily want to give a baseline scenario — where you think loan losses could floor out, or the profitability of Crédit Agricole S.A., if there's any level below which you think, I just can't see that happening. At least share some sensitivity, particularly regarding the degree of corporate guarantees you plan to issue and measures of that type. Second, I just wanted to ask about dividends. You said that you could, as BNP said yesterday — at least when I read the ECB press release regarding the suspension of the 2019 dividend, I felt there was also a recommendation not necessarily to sound too optimistic about 2020 dividends, but obviously I must have read this wrong. What's your level of certainty that if you make money in 2020, you'll be able to pay your 50% payout, and maybe beyond that, depending on what your capital level is, whether you can pay the 2019 dividend as a special or an exception or in some shape or form, at least part of it.

Jean-François Tremblay

analyst
#59

Much appreciated.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#60

Thanks, Jean-François. I believe what we're facing right now bears no relation to what happened in 2008 or 2009. Attempting to figure out where the bottom might be on cost of risk by drawing a comparison with our circumstances in 2008 and 2009 really doesn't get us very far. Back in 2008 and 2009, the banks sat at the center of the trouble. They were fragile — or at any rate, weaker across the board than they are today — and the uncertainty and the risks originated on the banks' own balance sheets. That is absolutely not where we stand. We have a precise knowledge of what sits on our balance sheets, we understand the risks we have taken on, and we are assisting our customers in getting past — I would say — the shortfall in activity they have confronted for sanitary reasons, and we are here to help. This will create some extra risks, there's no doubt about that. The public authorities are plainly assisting us in taking on those risks by giving their guarantee, which is clearly a crucial element and a crucial component of how we are assessing things as of now. The monetary authorities are likewise lending their support so as to supply the banking systems with all the liquidity required to fund the financing needs of our customers.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#61

We're definitely not in the same situation at all. I won't sit here doing arithmetic just to hand you the risk level for whether this or that happens. You've got everything you need to work that out yourselves, and you can quite clearly see what level of cost of risk leads to what level of revenues, or of net profit, under whatever assumptions you'd like to make. What I can say is that our overall read on the environment isn't naive, but it does factor in a strategy that we're contributing to, and one that we believe will — on a timetable we don't fully control — move all our customers, corporates, SMEs, self-employed professionals, and individuals to the other side of this output gap. That, naturally, is baked into the assumptions we make regarding cost of risk. On the dividend side, the ECB's recommendation doesn't stop us from accruing a dividend provision. It simply states that we can't make an irrevocable decision to pay the dividend before the end of Q3 this year. We aren't making an irrevocable decision to pay the dividend, since we are accruing it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#62

We're simply being prudent, and we're simply confident in our ability to keep going at a given moment, to keep rewarding our shareholders. That's it. I believe doing so shows respect both to our shareholder and to the ECB at the same time.

Jean-François Tremblay

analyst
#63

When it comes to 2019?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#64

On the subject of 2019, we mentioned this at the time our press release came out: we'll be reviewing where things stand at the start of Q4.

Jean-François Tremblay

analyst
#65

All right. So if I'm getting this right, you haven't yet approved the accrual, nor do you have any indication that everything is going to work out fine and so forth. I believe that matters to investors.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#66

I couldn’t hear you properly. Jean-François, the connection isn’t very good. I didn’t quite catch your previous question.

Jean-François Tremblay

analyst
#67

What I'd ask is whether there's been any kind of conversation, even an informal one, regarding the payout.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#68

Honestly, we did talk with the ECB before that recommendation came out. Right after it was issued, we had a few fairly brief discussions so we could get a clearer picture of how it ought to be put into practice. At this point, though, it isn't something we're still discussing with the ECB. We're fully aware that this matter now has to be reopened after the summer, on both our side and the ECB's.

Jean-François Tremblay

analyst
#69

Alright, thanks a lot for that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#70

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#71

Thanks for the question. The next question comes from Jon Peace at Credit Suisse. Your line is open — please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#72

Hi there, Jon.

Jon Peace

analyst
#73

Thanks. Hello, good afternoon, Jérôme. Could I get some clarification regarding the question about the 2019 special dividend? As we reach the fourth quarter, is the process simply a matter of comparing your CET1 at that point with your 11% target and distributing the difference? Or are you taking a forward-looking view of how cost of risk may develop and where capital could end up, and might you prefer to hold a buffer against further uncertainty? My second question is also a clarification about cost of risk. For this quarter's provisioning, are you basing it on the GDP scenario shown on slide 37? If I can fit in a third, on the insurance business and the decline in unit-linked product flows: do you view this as the beginning of a trend, given more underlying markets, or do you expect it to stabilize? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

I'll take your final question first, if that works, since what's clearly emerged during this year's first quarter is a really strong pace of money coming into unit-linked products. In fact, that's a pattern we've observed on a broader scale among French households — during March and again in April, they showed somewhat greater appetite for equities than had previously been the case. It's likely partly a consequence of the spare time many of them had while staying at home. And it's probably also a consequence of a certain amount of financial education — the idea that it pays to take an interest in equities while stock markets sit very low, rather than once they've climbed very high. Plainly, we have not observed any attempt to flee equities or to flee unit-linked products over the recent period. I'd go so far as to say the opposite. Turning back to the dividend issue, I believe the only thing I can do is restate what I said a moment ago. We will undertake a full reassessment of the situation at the start of the fourth quarter. It will be entirely new, because as it happens, there won't be a 2019 dividend.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#75

Right now that can't technically happen, for the simple reason that French law requires us to make the payment before the end of September, while the ECB refuses to consider any dividend distribution prior to the start of October. As things stand, it's simply impossible. We'll revisit the dividend question at a later point. From where we sit, it seems only prudent to keep accruing the dividend against the 2020 result so that we're well positioned no matter what, and regardless of which decision we choose to make at that moment. Your final question concerned the cost of risk and the kind of hypothesis we adopt. Honestly, particularly given the current situation, in which even though we managed to deliver these accounts and this presentation on schedule, things are somewhat less smooth. Naturally, we had to record the Q1 provisioning somewhat earlier, and I can't claim that our most recent economic assumption has been fully reflected in the provisioning level. As I mentioned, we will carry out a full reassessment of our assumptions in June so that we can entirely refresh the bucket 1 and bucket 2 provision inventory in the accounts.

Jon Peace

analyst
#76

Got it. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#77

Thanks. I’m not sure whether there’s another question.

Operator

operator
#78

Yes, sir, there's another question coming from Tarik El Mejjad with BofA. Go right ahead. Your line is open.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#79

Hello, and good afternoon to everybody. I have a few questions, if I may. The first one concerns costs. I realize that you operate more efficiently than your counterparts in France, and that you keep pushing on improving cost efficiency. Given the conditions in 2020, ought we to anticipate some natural reduction in costs? Are you actively searching for fresh sources of cost efficiency so as to counterbalance a possible rise in provisions? My second question, Jérôme, relates to what you said about revenues not really being — I agree that cost is clearly the main swing factor, but revenues ought to be affected in some way or another. Your remark that this wasn't really a concern surprised me, particularly without covering every division, obviously, but I would think that in French retail, the trends you saw last year ought to slow, and with negative interest rates still biting, the same goes for certain financing businesses and so on. Just to return to dividend accrual: the spirit of the ECB's letter was that you should build up as much capital as possible before paying a dividend. Yes, you set aside 60 bps, but the intention was not to accrue as well, so that you can build capital more quickly should matters deteriorate beyond expectations.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#80

Right, you're operating within the spirit of the letter, and at the same time, you likely have 30 basis points, 40 basis points of capital accrued for dividend that you actually could have preserved to sustain stronger shocks. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#81

Thanks. Well, I’ll begin with the last question you raised. Plainly, solvency isn’t something that holds back our lending activity. Holding a few extra bits of capital this quarter wouldn’t increase, to any degree, our ability to support customers and keep lending. We face no constraint. We’re doing what has to be done, and this isn’t a constraint. Naturally, you’d assume that before we made this decision to accrue the dividend, we had simply informed the ECB that this was our intention. We’ve had absolutely no reaction—no negative reaction—to that intention. Again, I consider it prudent to do so, and it isn’t stopping us from running our business. Turning to revenues and to cost, since in fact those two each year are connected. As you know, that’s our philosophy. We don’t work on Crédit Agricole S.A., and even less on the group as a whole, when it comes to cost efficiency and cost-to-income ratios. We work on the basis of businesses, because clearly it’s at the level of each business that this cost efficiency has to be addressed. What you saw in the first quarter of this year is that, in retail banking activities, we kept improving cost efficiency and the cost-to-income ratios at LCL, and we managed to hold them stable at Crédit Agricole Italia.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#82

We've also managed to boost cost efficiency at CACEIS — that is, bringing in extra revenues without taking on extra costs. That has likewise been true at CACEIS, and notably, CACEIS is now engaged in fully integrating its recent acquisitions. That will produce some further gains in cost efficiency. In the specialized financial services division and in the asset gathering division, we clearly saw the cost-to-income ratio worsen this quarter. Within those two divisions, we are working on reassessing what kind of revenue we could reasonably expect and what kind of cost base that supports. This will be carried out business by business. We believe that is the most efficient approach. I would say we are not indifferent to the cost issue, but on the other hand, we are not in a position where we think it would be helpful to announce a major company-wide cost-cutting push to confront the current situation. The current situation will bring about some mechanical cost savings, but I would say we are not really relying on those reductions in travel and expenses to finish the job.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#83

Thanks, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#84

Absolutely.

Operator

operator
#85

Thanks for the question. The next question comes from Omar Fall at Barclays. Your line is open — go ahead.

Omar Fall

analyst
#86

Hello, Jérôme — good afternoon.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#87

Good afternoon to you as well, Omar.

Omar Fall

analyst
#88

I have just two questions. First, I'd like to return to Sofinco — sorry, consumer credit. Can you take us through your view of the cost of risk outlook in more detail? Because I suppose there is less direct government protection and fewer moratoriums than in other businesses. The EUR 37 million stage 1 and 2 provision perhaps seems somewhat low. One of your peers identified this as a key concern for them, and they have maybe 3x the size of your consolidated loan book, but they've set aside much more than 3x the provision. I know you mentioned individual protections in France, but I suppose if my salary was 100% before and is now 84%, I might pay my mortgage but not my car loan or credit card. Some color would be really appreciated. The second is just on insurance. I know it's volatile. I know it will revert, but why was there such a large market effect? In the past you've had violent market moves and haven't seen these kinds of fair value impacts compared to some others, like in Q4 2018, for instance. I suppose generally the market assumes this business will see a limited impact in this crisis, if I look at consensus estimates on this.

Omar Fall

analyst
#89

So, leaving aside these market shifts, would it be fair to assume that? And what particular features of the crisis would prevent you from arriving at that fairly steady figure of EUR 1.3 billion of uncertainty in net income? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#90

All right. Regarding the consumer credit business, just bear in mind that our activities are broken down, and they're either consolidated or structured as JVs. In fact, one of the riskiest pieces of the business — the corporate financing portion of car financing — isn't consolidated; it sits in the JVs. In truth, we have only, I believe, a few — 2%, 3%, 4% — of the loan book, the direct loan book within our consolidated car financing operations, that consists of corporate lending. The overwhelming, very large majority of Sofinco's direct lending in car financing, which represents roughly 40% of its business, is direct lending to a household, backed by the car and by all the mechanisms you know well. Obviously, on this portion of the business, the individual protection we have in France — tied to the household's interest in keeping its car — clearly leads us to be, I'd say, not over-optimistic, but that's a key element of the analysis we performed when assessing risk. Obviously, at CA-CF, we've been booking provisions on the assumption that about 1/3 of CA-CF's business is corporate-driven.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#91

Unlike what we see in direct consolidated home loans, I think the gaps versus certain peers you mentioned come down to how each of us treats the car financing business differently. On insurance, bear in mind that Crédit Agricole Assurances — as we noted during the dedicated workshop on the insurance activities — now runs under IFRS 9 with an overlay approach, and that overlay covers, I'd say, 2/3 of its assets. For certain technical or regulatory reasons, 1/3 of the assets fall outside the overlay approach, meaning they sit under IFRS 9, and since IFRS 9 was implemented this has produced some swings in the P&L level. We flagged that point back then, and plainly it isn't something we can simply sidestep. Once again, this is largely reversible, and it in no way, I'd say, puts at risk our intrinsic profitability in the insurance business. Plainly, profitability in insurance remains very high, whether in P&C, protection or life activities.

Omar Fall

analyst
#92

Thanks. That’s really clear — I appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#93

Thanks for the question. The next question comes from Kirishanthan Vijayarajah at HSBC. Your line is open — please go ahead.

Kirishanthan Vijayarajah

analyst
#94

Thanks. Good afternoon, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#95

Good afternoon, everyone.

Kirishanthan Vijayarajah

analyst
#96

Two questions, if I may. Yeah, hello. First off, may I return to the Switch 2? With all the regulatory pressure you're facing to keep capital levels intact, do you feel that securing approval for the next tranche of the Switch unwind has become somewhat more difficult? Second, regarding the loan hedges in the large corporate book. I'm just wondering whether you've been increasing your use of hedging in that area. Could you give us a bit more detail on which specific sub-sectors inside the large corporate loan book you've actually applied the hedges to? In which sectors are you obtaining the protection? Perhaps also some indication of what the notionals are, maybe at some of the CDS levels, just so we can get a sense of how large a hedge you currently have in place on the corporate side. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#97

Regarding Switch, I really see no restriction whatsoever, and no regulatory pressure, in my view, that would cause us to push back, delay, or call off the additional dismantling we're planning. In fact, as you're aware, this moves capital up from CASA to the regional banks, yet it wipes out not even a single EUR of capital at the group level. From a supervisory standpoint, dismantling Switch destroys no capital at all. All that happens is a relocation of capital between CASA and the regional banks. At group level, capital stays at the very same level. I don't anticipate any trouble from the supervisor about carrying on with the Switch dismantling, provided that at CASA we keep operating with a capital level that is satisfactory, given that CASA is part of Crédit Agricole group and enjoys the group's solvency. As for the CDS hedging CACIB's credit book, that book is there mainly to help us manage our RWA consumption. The nominal is, I believe, slightly above 5 billion EUR, if my memory is right. The reason we don't factor this into the underlying figures is that our intention — since it exists to help us manage the RWA level — is to hold on to the CDS, so as not to crystallize the gain.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#98

Market value fluctuations for this portfolio are possible, but the portfolio itself is permanent.

Kirishanthan Vijayarajah

analyst
#99

Understood. All right. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#100

Appreciate the question. The following question comes from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Your line is open — go ahead.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#101

Good afternoon, and thanks. My questions are about RWA. There are three, actually. First, could you explain why corporate center RWA went up by EUR 2.5 Billion? I'd like to understand what that is and whether we should expect more. I realize it's small, but it still uses up most of your retained earnings when it comes to capital consumption. My second question concerns RWA in asset gathering, excluding the Switch impact and excluding the impact of the insurance equity accounting. There's a EUR 1 billion increase, which also looks fairly high. I'd like to know what that is and whether we should expect more. Last, on the French guarantee scheme, if I'm not mistaken, there's roughly a two-month gap between when you write the loan and when the RWA drops to zero for the guaranteed portion. Could you perhaps give us a sense of what RWA impact we should see in Q2 from the loans that are guaranteed but that won't get the benefit of the 0% weighting in Q2? Thank you. Given your ramp up.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#102

Right, precisely. Obviously, April saw a really elevated level of new loans backed by the state, and given that two-month lag you brought up, those loans will get the full benefit of the state guarantee at the end of June. There won't be any RWA impact for us. I can't say at what speed new state-guaranteed loan production will carry on through May and June, but one thing is certain: those loans will sit on our capital ratios at the end of June before being unwound, I'd say, as the state guarantee takes effect during the third quarter. Obviously we could see a peak. I don't know what the amount would be, but a peak in RWAs is possible at the end of June, before the state guarantee comes into force. Given the mix of state-guaranteed loans we're originating these days, the bulk of that peak will show up in the regional banks, since they produce the most state-guaranteed loans in the group. As of now, I can't tell you what new loan production will be in May and June, or what the RWA impact will be at the end of June.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#103

Clearly, it’s going to be there. On the second question, that was about the rise in RWAs in the asset gathering division, apart from the insurance and private banking activities. Inside Amundi, we’ve seen some increases in collateral demand, I believe, tied to various products that Amundi manufactures and sells to its customers. The collateral calls that Amundi had to make by the end of March are plainly resulting in higher RWAs. In the corporate centers, I think we have a mix of different elements. Honestly, I don’t have the full explanation in mind. Perhaps we’ll come back to you with something more precise.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#104

Jérôme, just maybe on that last point — do you figure these bits and pieces will come up again, or is it a one-off, given that they used up roughly EUR 300? Sorry.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#105

These are clearly mostly one-offs, and beyond the fact that they won't recur, I'd expect this to unwind progressively.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#106

All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#107

Thanks for that question. Our next question comes from Anke Reingen at Royal Bank of Canada. Go ahead — your line is open.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#108

Thanks so much for the question. First, you brought up several instances where the business environment slowed considerably in March compared with January and February, and I believe the remark about Italy was fairly severe. Would you agree that, given this, Q1 obviously shouldn't be viewed as a run rate, and instead we ought to focus on March across a number of areas? I understand you're not discussing intra-quarter commentary, but several banks have mentioned a rather robust April in fixed income, and given your Q1 strengths, I was wondering whether there's anything you could add there as well. Second, on insurance, I was just wondering, conceptually, whether there's a risk that a few of your customers essentially ask not to pay the insurance premiums. Would that pose a risk to your top line, or would you still account for these premiums as coming in in case you have to grant a moratorium? How would it essentially affect the top line? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#109

To address your initial questions, I'd say the impact will differ across each business line. Obviously, during the first weeks of confinement, retail banking activities saw the traditional business development come to a more or less complete stop. There were no new home loan originations, no meaningful volumes of insurance policy sales, and so forth. This will gradually pick back up. It has already begun to recover to some degree, simply because people require certain products and services. During the first week, everything was paused. Once a certain amount of time passes, the basic needs return. Naturally, it will be slower for home loans, since the entire process must restart. That process begins with a household visiting various properties, followed by negotiation, then discussions with the bank to secure the loan, and so on. The process can take a long time. When it's just a matter of obtaining new home insurance or car insurance, it can happen faster. Clearly, in those activities, March was very significantly lower. April will not be massively higher. Let me give you an example.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#110

Looking at China between January and February, we saw roughly a 90% drop in new car loan production. From February to March, that figure tripled. Naturally, you're not back at January's level, yet the recovery was already underway. Within CIB activities, particularly fixed income, late March proved extremely busy. Early April and the entire month of April have been highly active as well. CACIB has clearly ranked among the leaders in the bond issuance market, above all in euros. We took part in a very large number of new issuances from late March through April. Plainly, this will produce direct and indirect revenues for CACIB. That will differ across business lines. On insurance, I noted that we had chosen to allocate to our professional clients, who are hit very significantly by the shutdown process. We chose to provide them a fixed amount of partial indemnification for their operating losses where they held a policy with us covering operational losses — though not covering, as I said, a pandemic, since nobody really covers that case. This amount will be folded globally into our technical results.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#111

In our technical results, we're going to see both positive and negative elements. This is going to be a hit, but I'm not claiming it will pass straight through in full to the bottom of the P&L. Many other elements will offset it, along with some positive elements we may see in other technical results within the P&C insurance activities' accounts.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#112

Alright, thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#113

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#114

Thanks for the question. The next question comes from Matthew Clark at Mediobanca. Your line is open — go ahead.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#115

Hello. I have two questions. First, can you tell us what the PPE reserve was this quarter? I wasn’t able to locate it anywhere. I apologize if it has been disclosed. Second, regarding risk weights, do you anticipate any material effect from credit rating migrations as the year goes on? Maybe share your views on any headwinds in that area. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#116

Okay, regarding credit migration — we will recognize that migration as it shows up. So far, it hasn't been very significant. Again, you really need to keep in mind what's happening with all these mechanisms of state-guaranteed aids. As long as the state provides its guarantee to a corporate customer, the quality of the risk doesn't deteriorate, even if that customer is losing a significant part of its turnover. Clearly, the migration effect — of course, some corporates are going to face negative migrations — but as of now, it hasn't been very massive, and this has to be read across while keeping in mind the very specific context we're in, and keeping in mind all the public tools that have been put in place in order to help the situation. This is probably going to help significantly on this aspect of risk migration. Your first question was on which issue exactly?

Matthew Clark

analyst
#117

The reserve for policyholders.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#118

Oh, all right.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#119

Regarding the interest.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#120

Oh, okay.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#121

That came to roughly EUR 10.8 billion, or thereabouts. Is that right?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#122

Yeah. I'd say it went up by roughly EUR 100 million this quarter. That's basically nothing. Honestly, I'd call it even a rounding effect, since it's just flows shifting between the provisional profit-sharing level we include in our quarterly accounts and whatever remains for the customers, the policyholders, and isn't retained by the insurer, which goes into the PPE. It was a EUR 100 million rise, but truly not material on a first-quarter basis.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#123

Alright, thanks a lot.

Operator

operator
#124

Thanks for asking. The next question is from Jean-Pierre Lambert at KBW, on the line. Please go ahead — your line is open.

Jean-Pierre Lambert

analyst
#125

Good afternoon, Jérôme and team. I'd like to return to the topic of public support, since it seems to be a fairly significant element that you brought up. In what way did you incorporate the public support? From a technical standpoint, does it sit within loss given default? Does it appear in probability of default scenarios, or instead in improved GDP expectations? On that same point, if we consider the EUR 223 million sitting in buckets 1 and 2, what would that figure have been absent public support? I'm just trying to get a sense of the sensitivity. My second question is also about sensitivity. Banque de France tells us that each additional confinement period would cost roughly 3% of GDP 2020. What sort of sensitivity does that imply for your bank's earnings, revenues, or cost of risk? It would help if you could offer some quantification or indication. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#126

Jean-Pierre, I suspect I'll let you down somewhat here, since we aren't the technical specialists you take us for. No tool of ours directly links a GDP hypothesis to a given level of bucket one and bucket two provisions, and so forth. Our process moves from GDP assumptions to a provisioning level, but we lack the efficiency to run various scenarios daily and perform that kind of sensitivity analysis. Should the global lockdown stretch by one more month, our macroeconomic assumption would shift significantly. That isn't the hypothesis we're working under now. In our view, as everyone says, May the 11th isn't a precise date dividing a full economic shutdown from a full economic restart. In some areas the economy had already begun functioning again ahead of May the 11th, and certain industries had already resumed work ahead of May the 11th, so a gradual acceleration will follow. We couldn't claim on that basis that one extra week equals X million more in bucket one and bucket two provisions.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#127

On the public sector guarantee, I actually see it serving two purposes. The first is that a state guarantee attached to a particular loan keeps us from having to risk weight that loan — apart from the initial two months, for the reasons we touched on a bit earlier. When a company that's struggling due to the shutdown of the economy gets a loan backed by the state, that generally strengthens its solvency and should bolster its ability to withstand this economic shutdown. Technically speaking, does it improve the probability of default or the loss given default? Honestly, I can't give you a precise answer to that question. We'll check with the risk team, the modeling specialists, and then we'll get back to you.

Jean-Pierre Lambert

analyst
#128

Thanks a lot, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#129

Absolutely.

Operator

operator
#130

Appreciate the question. Sir, we don’t have any question.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#131

All right. I believe there's a single question that came to us by email.

Clotilde L'Angevin

executive
#132

Yes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#133

Clotilde will be the one posing the question.

Clotilde L'Angevin

executive
#134

This comes from someone at CM-CIC. There are two questions about P&C Insurance. First, what's your take on the combined ratio, which is still quite low at 95%? How do you expect that to develop? Then the second one concerns the cooperative support mechanism from insurance. Could you share a bit more detail on what the figures are behind that?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#135

Those two questions are really linked. The first one: the combined ratio for our traditional P&C insurance operations is a core part of who we are in the insurance business. We don't see any reason it should move away from the very good levels we hit regularly. Naturally, we'll keep holding to that, since it's thanks to this very good combined ratio that we keep providing very broad coverage of our insurance policies to our customers. As for these special mechanisms we've chosen to offer our customers, to sum it up briefly, roughly 50,000 customers will be affected, and we'll grant them an indemnification that varies with their size and with the type of activity they're in, ranging from EUR 1,500 to EUR 10,000. That produces a global gross cost of slightly more than EUR 210 million, which naturally will then be folded into the overall claim indemnification cost we cover for all our insurance customers. Clotilde, I believe that was the final question we had. Thank you all for joining this meeting during a very particular and special period of time.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#136

Once more, I’m sorry about the trouble some of you had getting connected, and I look forward to speaking with you again no later than the start of August — and likely sooner than that, for a particular meeting, roadshows, or whatever the case may be. Have a good afternoon, and take care. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#137

That wraps up today's conference. Thanks for joining us. Everyone may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.