Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 6, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for standing by. Welcome to today's Crédit Agricole 2020 second quarter and first-half results conference. I would like now to hand the conference over to your speaker today, Mr. Jérôme Grivet. Please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. First of all, I wanted to express my thanks for joining this conference, and to mention that a few messages have come in requesting that I give a brief, quick presentation. I'll do my best to take you very swiftly through the document, and after that we'll move on to the Q&A session. I'm going to begin on page four, where you'll find the key figures on how we performed this quarter and this semester. Let me just point out a few numbers. Net income group share for the group globally, which comes in at EUR 1.5 billion, and on an underlying basis at EUR 1.8 billion. For CASA, EUR 950 million as a stated figure and EUR 1.1 billion as an underlying figure. This quarter, the items accounting for the gap between stated and underlying figures sit alongside the usual DVA loan hedges and home purchase saving plan elements. Two main points regarding the group globally and CASA specifically. The first is the cost of a liability management operation we carried out in June, through which we repurchased roughly EUR 3 billion of debt that we swapped for cheaper debt. The cost of this operation, which is booked in the quarter, is about EUR 40 million of cost booked in the negative revenues.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe second factor—actually more important—is what we spent on indemnification that we chose to pay voluntarily to the self-employed professionals who are our customers, for their insurance policies. As you're aware, those policies provide business interruption coverage, though not when a pandemia is involved, and despite that we made the decision to indemnify them anyway. At CASA level this cost came to roughly EUR 140 million, and at group level it reached EUR 240 million. It also counts as negative revenue. The final item, which concerns CASA alone and is neutral at group level, is the activation this semester of the switch mechanism for a quite small sum, EUR 65 million, which is a profit for CASA where the cost of risk is concerned. Symmetrically, it is a cost for the regional banks, and at group level it is neutral. The second and last thing I wanted to raise on this page is how high a level of solvency we have attained this quarter, at both group level and CASA level. At the group, CET1 is at 16.1%, and at CASA level it is at 12%. Moving now to the next page, I think that among the points worth noting here—since the rest will be handled by the pages that follow—is that this quarter has been quite specific in terms of profile, with activity falling significantly in April and also in May, and then a very sharp rebound in June, which is still the case throughout July.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMoving on to the next page now. A handful of points just to remind everyone that we were extremely busy assisting our customers generally in getting through this very unusual lockdown stretch. In France, as a matter of fact, we handled state-guaranteed loan applications totaling EUR 28.7 billion, and we likewise gave our customers over EUR 4 billion equivalent in deferred maturities of payment holidays across the various credits. Beyond that, we also referred to this indemnification that was voluntarily provided once again to customers of our insurance operations. The final item is that in Italy too, we were active in providing state-guaranteed loans and credit moratoria. On the next page, a few points about this. Through the second quarter, despite the lockdown period, we actually kept working on the group's medium-term plan and its three pillars. Given the kind of crisis we were facing and given what we managed to accomplish across those three pillars, I think this proved highly relevant. On the page that follows, just a few points to explain how we view the economic situation in France and, more broadly, in Europe. We stated that our forecast was for a V-shaped crisis, and what we are seeing now is definitely converging with that scenario.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHousehold confidence and the business climate have rebounded very sharply, and every hot indicator we track — particularly those we can monitor through our own operations — bears out that steep upturn in activity levels in France. Moving to the next page, which points in precisely the same direction, our own commercial activity showed a very sharp rebound in transaction volumes during the latter part of this year's second quarter. As you can see, that held true for the count of new customers we succeeded in bringing in across our various retail networks, with a low of 46,000 new customers in April and a very high figure of around 150,000 new customers in June. This is driving a sharp rebound across the different business lines — whether home loans, consumer finance agreements, savings accounts both on and off balance sheet, or the sale of new P&C insurance policies across the networks. Let me now turn to the financial figures, and on page 11 you'll find the evolution of revenues at Crédit Agricole S.A.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen we look at Q2 '19 versus Q2 '20 on an underlying basis, revenue levels stayed pretty much flat. That's a really strong result, especially when you remember that most of what we do involves individual customers, and for the majority of the quarter, retail operations had essentially ground to a halt, with all our networks focused on state-guaranteed loans and other specific items tied to managing the COVID crisis. As a result, revenues for the first half of the year are up 2.5%, which is a very good trajectory for our revenues. Turning to page 12, the cost base has been kept firmly in check. In Q2 alone, costs are down nearly 2%. Across the whole first half, they're up just 4.5%. That's a tightly managed cost base, and it shows once more that running costs close to the operational level in each business is the best way to ensure every effort actually pays off in keeping costs in line. This brings the cost-to-income ratio for Crédit Agricole S.A. in Q2 2020 to 57.4%, a decline of 1.2 percentage points.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt's a really competitive and robust level, and it's already under the 60% target we had set for 2022. The jaws effect is positive both for the quarter and for the first half of the year. One last thing worth bearing in mind: this quarter we had to book an extra contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, and it's a sizable amount. It comes to EUR 80 million at CASA level, roughly EUR 80 million, and even EUR 110 million at group level. On the next page, a few points on the risk situation, beginning with a look at the quality of our loan books. The NPL level didn't move much over the quarter. The NPL ratio is 3.2% for Crédit Agricole S.A. and 2.4% for the group as a whole. It's more or less stable versus the end of March. Given the substantial additional provisioning we booked this quarter — and I'll return to that point on the next page — we're hitting very high coverage ratio levels: 73.4% at CASA, and even close to 85% at group level overall. We now hold more than EUR 10 billion of loan loss provisions on CASA's balance sheet, and over EUR 20 billion globally for the group, in spite of the very good quality of our asset books.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe next page shows the loan loss provision flows we booked this quarter, and you'll see that our provisioning level remains significantly above what we recorded in the same quarter last year. For CASA, it's two and a half times the Q2 '19 level, and for the group globally, it's two times. You can also see that a significant portion of this increase is actually tied to an additional provisioning effort on stage 1 and stage 2 loans. This quarter, stage 1 and 2 provisioning came to EUR 236 million for CASA, and more than EUR 400 million for the group globally. This extra provisioning on stage 1 and stage 2 loans mainly results from an update of our economic scenarios within our model, and you'll find details on the scenario in the appendix of the document. As you can see on page 15, this is leading to — well, page 15 shows that the situation is more or less the same across every single specific business line. It's obviously massively the case for the regional banks, where the level of additional stage 1 and stage 2 provision is very high; it's also the case for LCL, for CA Italia, and for the financing activities of CACIB, and a little bit less the case at CACF because the type of credit risk we have there is less relevant when it comes to forward-looking provisioning.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding net income, the numbers I cited earlier are visible: EUR 1.1 billion of underlying net profit for the quarter, and just under EUR 1.8 billion across the first half of the year. Resilience has been very strong — even leaving aside the sizable rise we had to record in our contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, net profit would have moved only minus 5% in the quarter and minus 8.5% for the semester. That strong net profit resilience stems chiefly from excellent operational efficiency, with gross operating income rising over the semester and flat in the quarter, helped by the strong diversification of our business model. Return on tangible equity comes in at 8.5% for the first half of the year. Spreading the IFRIC 21 taxes over the whole year would bring it to close to 10%. Zooming in briefly on the individual businesses now, beginning with asset gathering and insurance on page 18, what you see is that net inflows were more or less nil in the quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveA really strong market impact, and on top of that, EUR 75 billion of extra assets coming from how the markets moved. Even so, that's smaller than the negative market impact we had to absorb during the first quarter, which came to minus EUR 125 billion. Even with that, this business division's contribution to CASA's net profit is markedly higher than in the second quarter and nearly flat across the first half of the year. Looking a bit more closely at the insurance activities, when it comes to commercial activity, the insurance business division was hit hard throughout the lockdown period. What's really encouraging is that turnover for June alone was globally 74% higher than what we saw in May, and May was itself above April's level. The pickup is genuinely here. Perhaps one or two other points I can mention. Revenues in the life insurance activities rose this quarter, helped by a reversal of some depreciation we had to book on certain assets during the first quarter. That reversal is only partial at this stage. The other revenues were quite positively oriented, and the cost base is very well controlled. On asset management and Amundi activities, what we can say is that net inflows this quarter came in close to zero, with actually a positive movement of inflows on long-term assets and still negative net outflows on money market funds.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe P&L showed very strong resilience. Revenues went down because market indexes on average were lower in Q2 than in Q1, but at the same time, the cost base dropped significantly. The last point I can mention is that this quarter we closed the acquisition of Sabadell Asset Management, and we recently announced the renewal of the partnership with Société Générale. If I move now to retail banking activity, starting with LCL, once again we'll see the same shape of the quarter, with a level of activity that was very low in April and again in May, and a very sharp rebound in June. All in all, actually, loan outstanding outside the state-guaranteed loans are up significantly 7% between June 2020 and June 2019. Revenues are a little bit down. The net interest margin is actually down, mainly because of some valuation effect, i.e., the fact that in Q2 2019, we had some dividends coming from Visa shares or some revaluation coming from the Visa shares that were at that time within LCL balance sheet. The decrease in fees and commission is mainly explained by the commissions on payments, because of the decrease in the volume of payments in the first half of the quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere's also a decline in commissions tied to accounts, since LCL chose to be quite restrained with that kind of commission throughout the lockdown. Operational expenses keep falling. At LCL, this marks the fourth consecutive year in which we've recorded a reduction in the cost base. Net contribution remains strongly positive even with the steep rise in cost of risk. In Italy, the trends look broadly similar — in fact, somewhat more pronounced. Activity dropped more sharply early in the quarter, and that is indeed producing a steeper fall in revenues. The cost base in Italy is lower as well. Cost of risk has risen considerably. In fact, you can see that this quarter we raised our NPL coverage ratio substantially. I'd say we deliberately nudged up provisioning on our NPLs a bit, even though the NPL level didn't rise much, so that we're positioned to seize opportunities from possible sales of NPL portfolios. As for the remaining international retail operations, the pattern is broadly the same across every country where we operate.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere's an adverse jaws impact from pressure on the net interest margin, stemming from the drop in interest rates tied to how monetary authorities in the various countries responded to the COVID crisis. Then there's a rise in the cost of risk, driven mainly, in fact, by a further uptick in provisioning for performing loans — so bucket 1 and bucket 2. Over in the specialized financial services division, beginning with consumer credit, this is a business where the average loan duration is just 30 months. That means if you lose two or three months of new loan production, it clearly results in a lower level of outstanding. That's what happened at CACF. Consolidated outstandings fell 1% over the quarter, so versus the end of March. This accounts for the decline in revenues, also linked to the fact that some revenues get recognized at the inception of new loans. One more thing I can add is that the rebound in June is quite sharp. To illustrate, new loan production came to only EUR 1.3 billion in April, EUR 2.1 billion in May, and EUR 3.6 billion in June.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere was a really steep rise from April to June. By June 2020, we were at just minus 13% versus June 2019. Cost control remains strong, so we've kept this division's cost-to-income ratio under 50%. Cost of risk, naturally, reflects the situation. In leasing and factoring, new leasing loan production came to a full halt through mid-June. We did manage to grow commercial production of new factoring contracts, but the turnover actually being factored is down considerably. That again explains the lower revenue level this quarter. Now, large customers division: overall, this division is delivering top-line growth of nearly 21%, with strong momentum across the board in both corporate and institutional. In custody, naturally, we keep gaining this quarter from the scope effect and from integrating Santander Securities Services and KAS BANK. Even so, commercial efficiency has been very good too, with a significant number of new contracts signed, and the liquidity this business generates is being managed profitably — that is up sharply.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning to page 26 for the CIB activities: what we've observed this quarter is a stepping-up of financing activity, tied of course to credit demand from our customers, along with a really solid level of activity across our various capital market businesses — particularly in the fixed income currency division, where revenues rose 44%. Market risks remain at a very low level, and the VaR was EUR 14 million at the end of June. The cost basis is in fact very well controlled. On the face of it, costs are up 3.4% on the quarter, but in Q2 2019 we had actually booked a significant write-off of a provision for HR-related costs of roughly EUR 20 million. If we restate the figure for that provision we were able to write off last year, the cost base at CACIB this quarter is more or less stable. We've seen an increase — a very significant one — in the cost of risk this quarter, against a level that was still very low in Q2 2019. Even with this sharp rise in the cost of risk, net income group share at CACIB is more or less stable for the quarter, at a very high level.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveA 43% cost-to-income ratio is quite low. Regarding the corporate center, in short, its structural component keeps getting better, and that improvement is fairly substantial relative to Q2 2019. The volatile component is weakening somewhat. This is the opposite of what we saw in Q1. As you're aware, intragroup transactions account for the biggest share of that volatile piece of the corporate center. In short, whenever Crédit Agricole S.A.'s credit spread tightens, those intragroup items turn negative. The reverse happens when the spread widens, which is what occurred in Q1. Moving to page 29 now, the regional banks of Crédit Agricole: on activity, you'll notice broadly the same patterns as at LCL, with commercial activity at a very weak level in April and May — at least through mid-May — followed by a very sharp bounce. As at LCL, this also produces growth in loans outstanding from June 2019 to June 2020, excluding state-guaranteed loans. That growth comes to roughly 5%. Beyond that, COVID-related activity has been very significant, with about 400,000 payment holidays granted, along with close to EUR 18 billion of state-guaranteed loans.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat's a really steep rise. In this quarter, regional banks' contribution to Crédit Agricole Group's net profit has climbed 18%, and the cost income ratio shows a substantial improvement. Moving to page 31 now, on solvency, beginning with CASA's Solvency. The CET1 ratio sits at 12%. That's 60 basis points higher than at the end of March. Several elements combine to produce this. As you can observe, one of those elements is the heavily watched movement in the level of RWA, since in fact the RWA level is roughly flat, and it contains close to EUR 2.5 billion of temporary penalization tied to the state-guaranteed loans. As you're aware, the state guarantee only begins to apply two months following the loan's inception. That means for every loan granted in May and June, we carry a penalization in RWA terms at the end of June, and it will vanish during the third quarter. Excluding that element, the RWA level would actually have declined slightly, by around 1%. The remaining elements accounting for how the CET1 ratio evolved are, naturally, the results we've published. As I said again, this result is net of a dividend accrual booked in the second quarter, precisely as we did in the first quarter, against our 2020 profit.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOCI reserves, which were heavily negative in terms of how they moved during Q1, are recovering step by step. That gives a positive contribution to solvency this quarter. We also get a positive contribution from the quick fix effect, plus a negative contribution from certain other items, such as the purchase of Sabadell Asset Management, which carries a cost of roughly 10 basis points of ratio. Taking everything together, our ratio comes in at 12%, and fully loaded of the IFRS 9 transitional effect it would be 11.7%. At 12%, that leaves a distance of 4.1 percentage points to the Pillar 2 requirement. Turning now to group solvency overall, you'll notice once more that RWA evolution is quite modest. In fact, it rises only EUR 1 billion from March to June. We see the same state guaranteed loan effect, which is larger at group level given the market share the regional banks hold in distributing state guaranteed loans. This item accounts for EUR 7.5 billion of RWAs, and those will drop away over the course of Q3. The CET1 ratio movement is again explained by the strong profit level, which is kept and retained, by how the OCI reserves evolved, by RWA evolution, then by the benefits we obtain from the quick fixes, along with other regulatory and methodological effects, all of which bring us to this 16.1% CET1 ratio at the end of June.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat figure sits 7.2 percentage points above the Pillar 2 requirements. Naturally, the remaining capital measures — TLAC, MREL, and the leverage ratios — all meet or exceed the various targets we have set. On liquidity, there is not a great deal to add. Our liquidity position is extremely comfortable, with reserves exceeding EUR 400 billion. That represents a rise of nearly EUR 70 billion versus the end of March. Naturally, we have made substantial use of the TLTRO mechanism introduced by the ECB, and by the end of June we had actually grown by EUR 90 billion at this window. The LCR ratio stands at roughly 155% for the group and 151% for Crédit Agricole S.A. A very strong liquidity situation. Our medium and long-term market funding program was in fact completed by the end of July. We succeeded in continuing to issue during the first phases of the lockdown period, and in fact we have fully finished the funding program of Crédit Agricole S.A. That is all. To conclude, I want once more to stress the high level of profitability we are capable of delivering during this very particular period we are navigating. Second, I also want to restate the very low cost to income ratio, so the very good operational efficiency we have managed to provide, the high level of return on equity, particularly if we spread the IFRIC 21 taxes across the full year, and of course, the very high robustness of the group, both in terms of solvency and in terms of liquidity.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks a lot. At this point, I’m ready to take a shot at responding to what you asked.
Operator
operatorThanks. A quick reminder for everyone on the line: if you'd like to pose a question, just press star and one on your phone. Our first question is from Jon Peace at Credit Suisse. Go ahead, please.
Jon Peace
analystYes, good afternoon, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight.
Jon Peace
analystLet me start with a question on impairments. For the second half of this year and as we move into next year, how should we think about those? If your macro assumptions don't need to be changed again, do you believe it should return to some underlying rate? On that note, may I also ask about your relationship with Wirecard? Has it affected operations at all, or do you expect any impact going forward? And if I can ask one more, do you view the switch any differently right now — either favorably, since it benefited this quarter, or, with excess capital today, might you speed up the retirement? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right. Let's begin with the impairment. It's accurate to say that absent any major alteration to the scenario, our only task would be updating bucket 1 and bucket 2 provisioning in line with how outstandings evolve. That means how the amounts move, and potentially also loans migrating between bucket 1 and bucket 2, or between bucket 2 and bucket 3. During this quarter, on top of all that updating, we had to bring in an entirely new scenario, which certainly accounts for a meaningful portion of the rise in stage 1 and stage 2 provisioning. Looking ahead, my expectation is that the evolution of impaired loans will be the primary driver of how the loan loss provision moves. On that front, visibility is limited. The one thing I can say is that we are not anticipating a sharp jump in defaults ahead, at least over the very next quarter, simply because every state mechanism put in place to relieve and support the economy remains in operation. Regarding Wirecard, what we have actually lost is time, since we had been counting on that partnership to develop and strengthen our offer, with the aim of growing our business on e-merchants.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTo be honest, we put some energy and a bit of operational expense into building out features tied to Wirecard. Everything on that front has now been halted as a result of what took place with Wirecard. We've lost time. That isn't a disaster on our end, since in fact our positions in payments are already quite strong. In France, we rank as the number 1 card issuer. Our share among retail merchants is very strong, and so forth. Time has been lost, and we've already begun setting up a plan B so we can build the functionalities ourselves that we had been expecting from Wirecard. Regarding the switch, what I can say is that in reality, its biggest advantage doesn't really come at the moment it's triggered, because what you've observed here is that triggering the switch produces only a very modest compensation between the regional banks and Crédit Agricole S.A. The advantage lies in the capital relief, and it's true that given our strong capital position, we feel very comfortable with the notion of carrying on with dismantling the switch, in line with the commitments we had made for the medium-term plan.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveFrom a technical standpoint, we have to hold off on any further dismantling until the clawback has occurred. Given how low the trigger level actually was at the end of June, the clawback would typically arrive as early as the end of this year.
Jon Peace
analystThanks a lot. Appreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. Go ahead with your question.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYes. Good afternoon, Jérôme. I have two questions, and they're quick ones. I recall the outlook you shared on the previous call for Q1 — it was extremely cautious — and yet, listening to your reply to my colleague Jon, it genuinely looks as though conditions are improving. Even if we don't compare ourselves to 2021 and perhaps look more toward 2022, would you be at ease just keeping the plan's targets exactly as they stand, with an 18-month horizon? That's my first question. My second one concerns LCL's net interest income performance, since if I follow correctly, the item that was one-off in nature was the Visa dividend in Q2 2019. My reading would be that rather than declining 3.6%, the underlying net interest income would have come in roughly flat, which is a remarkable result against competitors. Is there some specific reason behind that really strong showing at LCL? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLet me begin with the second question. Actually, I brought up Visa dividends — really, that was more a valuation impact from the Visa shares. Even so, it amounts to the same thing. It's a base effect that existed in Q2 2019 and is no longer present in Q2 2020. Clearly, the net interest margin at LCL is showing strong resilience, thanks to the commercial dynamics, since, as I said, loan outstanding outside state-guaranteed loans rose 7% between June 2019 and June 2020. This is definitely generating the same mechanisms we already referred to, namely a net interest margin that remains somewhat under pressure, since new loans keep getting booked at a lower rate than the average level of older loans, with a volume effect offsetting that. Overall, yes, the top line at LCL is fairly resilient, but our view is that this ought to keep going in the future unless something unexpected occurs. The 2022 targets. Well, we haven't concluded that it was necessary at this stage to either withdraw or review those targets. The key targets are a profitability target, 11% of return on tangible equity at 11% of CET1 ratio.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere's a cost-to-income ratio goal, a solvency objective as well, and naturally a net profit target too. As things stand right now, we're still putting in the work to try to get to those targets.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystGot it, Jérôme — that's very clear, and thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Giulia Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Go ahead with your question.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystYes. Hello, and good morning. Thanks for taking my questions. There are two from me. The first concerns consumer credit origination. You mentioned a strong rebound. I'm curious how, when it comes to underwriting consumer credit, you're weighing the uncertainty around unemployment as government measures taper off. That's my first question. Basically, will that produce slower consumer credit loan growth, given the more uncertain outlook, or is the answer no, you remain comfortable, and so we should see good growth? Second, on loans in moratorium, what is the total for Crédit Agricole S.A.? I believe you disclosed the French figure. I'm not certain I've seen the total group number. How are you provisioning for those? Are you booking any provisions, or do you still assume they are performing at this stage? Also, still on the credit moratoria, could you comment on how that book has been evolving? Is it coming down? Are you still receiving requests? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll begin with the first question. Regarding consumer credit origination, yes, there has indeed been a sharp rebound. As I said, we're not yet back to where we stood in June 2019, but that rebound is pronounced. At the same time, there are also some shifts, I'd say, in the loan mix — we're increasingly issuing equipment loans instead of pure treasury loans. That means a smaller margin on those loans, but going forward it also means a reduced level of risk. In France, as you're aware, the usury rate exists, and it actually stops consumer credit lenders from genuinely addressing the lower end of the market, since the lower end of the market would need rates that deliver a decent risk-reward level but would run above the usury rate ceiling. That's why, structurally in France, consumer credit shows less dynamism, and a whole fringe of the population is, de facto, not eligible for this category of loans. Clearly, going forward, this may well become a constraint on how consumer credit loans develop. Conversely, once more, equipment loans growing is a good thing, and they're proving quite dynamic these days.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt made up a substantial share of credit demand in June. Regarding the moratoria, of the EUR 4.2 billion in capital we have deferred — the payments we have deferred — EUR 3 billion relates to the regional banks and EUR 1.2 billion to LCL. Such moratoria carry no specific consequence for provisioning. What that means is we keep booking provisions by assessing borrower quality and assessing whether or not a payment incident exists. Your final question asked whether we continue to grant new moratoria. My view is that this has now more or less halted, or at minimum slowed very significantly, since it was really designed to cover the lockdown period. We are in a much more normal situation now. I think the amounts are not going to increase.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystThanks. Apologies — could I just ask a quick follow-up? You provided the figure for France. What is the figure in—
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding Italy?
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystYes, or anywhere else.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe remainder is in Italy. In fact, when we mention that we have extended roughly EUR 2 billion of COVID-related facilities in Italy, it splits roughly evenly between state-guaranteed loans there and payment holidays. The capital tied to the payment holidays we have extended in Italy comes to approximately EUR 900 million or EUR 1 billion.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystThat’s great. Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from John Ruiz at Goldman Sachs. Go ahead with your question.
Analyst
analystHello there. Good afternoon, Jérôme. I have a brief question regarding the dividend extension—or rather, the extension of the ban. It appears there may be an option for banks, or for companies belonging to a group, to upstream dividends. I believe a few Spanish banks have suggested they might take advantage of this. If that is accurate, do you see it as something Crédit Agricole S.A. could do, or is it not really the wisest move right now? Looking ahead to 2021, on capital returns again, if dividends were permitted once more—for instance, some Italian banks have kept saying they wish to go ahead with payments in place of the canceled dividend for last year—would that be something you would also consider pursuing? I just wanted to ask about French retail banking, again, in light of Jaco's question; it seems quite noteworthy in fees and in net interest income across every revenue line. I wanted to understand whether you could compare and contrast your performance and what you believe LCL did better than peers. I am simply trying to figure out whether that is a solid base to build on, or whether anything exceptional was in there.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright, regarding the dividend, our capital position is quite straightforward. You can see it right there: a 12% CET1 ratio at CASA, and above 16% at the group level. Both figures sit well beyond the target and well beyond the various constraints we need to comply with. We absolutely have the capacity to pay our dividend — that's the first thing. Second, you already have the numbers in mind, but had CASA paid its dividend with respect to 2019, that would have meant a hit of roughly 60 or 70 basis points on its capital ratio relative to where we stand today, so still above 11%. Given the high retention of results at group level, if CASA pays its dividend at the level originally forecast, that would represent about 15 basis points at group level, taking into account the 56% retention of this dividend by the regional banks. That's where things stand. That said, we will never do anything that doesn't comply with ECB regulations. I think it's rather unproductive to try to comment at length on this situation. The recommendation is there. Discussing what the situation might be if it weren't there isn't really useful. Again, we have the capacity to pay — that's certain — both at group and at CASA level.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYou mentioned something about a group assessment, so yes, at the group level it's a very low impact, but we won't take any action that isn't compliant with the ECB's instructions.
Analyst
analystAll right, turning to sustainability in French retail?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the French retail side, I think this just shows that our business model — the one where we try to develop cross-selling between the different business lines as much as possible, and emphasize the customer's interest in the overall relationship as much as we can, which is a relational approach rather than a transactional one — is efficient. We know that this model is actually more widely developed at the regional bank level than at LCL, but LCL is constantly trying to catch up with the parameters and the figures of the regional banks, and clearly this is proving efficient. There's nothing exceptional in the Q2 2020 performances, and we don't see any reason those performances wouldn't continue.
Analyst
analystAlright, that's very clear. Thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. Go ahead, please.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystHello, Jérôme. Good afternoon. I have a few questions, please. Regarding the cost of risk in your scenarios for the second half of the year and for next year, how are you incorporating the danger of some deterioration in your portfolios once all these government guarantee schemes and supports are unwound? I'm certain you're factoring that in somehow, but could you just explain to us a bit how that is weighted in your risk scenarios? Second, in Italy, can you comment on how the Intesa-UBI consolidation will affect the competitive environment and pricing, and do you need to take any management action to correct the trajectory of your growth, given this consolidation? Lastly, coming back to Jean-Francois' question on dividend. I believe the ECB put in a press release that if any banks can justify some legal obligation to pay a dividend, then it could be looked at. I understand your point that there's no point in challenging the ECB recommendation, but is there a case for you that you have to pay a dividend to the parent to support the economy even more and so on? That's an argument you've tried to make already back in April. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the cost of risk — as you're aware, whenever we measure the cost of risk and assess it, we build various scenarios into the model. Page 39 describes the main one. We've also included a scenario that's more favorable, plus one that's less favorable. We have an entire set of scenarios, each carrying a different weighting. Naturally, each of these scenarios comes with its own narrative. Under one unfavorable scenario, the narrative is that the various fiscal measures we're expecting from the government don't prove effective enough, and that this also results in the largest portion of the extra savings that individuals in France have set aside being retained rather than spent. That is built into, I would say, the less favorable scenario. The second point is, of course, that as you can see, the central scenario we've incorporated is less favorable than the one used in Q1, since obviously we've watched the situation develop between the close of Q1 and the close of Q2. My third comment on this question is that so far, all the information we receive and all the data we gather clearly demonstrate that our central scenario is what is unfolding at present.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat doesn't imply it will hold true through 2021 and 2022. Right now, what we're seeing in reality matches precisely what the government forecast, and it's clearly how the government in France—as well as elsewhere around the globe—intended to handle this health crisis. At least for the moment, I see no reason for us to revise our position on that. In Italy, consolidation has, admittedly, been a watchword and an open question for several years now. It's also true that a sizable transaction occurred recently. Naturally, as always, we keep the situation under constant review. As I've consistently stated, you're well aware of the kind of operation that might interest us. The large consolidation deal that happened recently isn't the sort we'd be interested in, since in the past we've successfully completed incremental consolidation transactions. On the dividend question, commenting in depth is very difficult. Could we claim that a legally binding obligation exists for CASA to pay a dividend to the regional banks?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI wouldn't frame it as something we're looking to open up. What matters most to us, beyond the legal and technical aspects, is staying compliant with the ECB's instructions.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystAlright, thanks, Jérôme.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Delphine Lee at J.P. Morgan. You have the floor.
Delphine Lee
analystGood afternoon to you as well, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, everyone.
Delphine Lee
analystI have just a couple of questions. First, returning to capital — I'd like to get a better sense of your priorities when it comes to deploying excess capital. You're carrying a fairly sizable buffer above MDA. If you do have surplus capital, is the plan to first fully reimburse, and then look at possibly buybacks or a special dividend, or would it be small bolt-on deals? I'm just trying to grasp the thinking around capital management. My second question concerns TLTRO. You mentioned the EUR 90 billion. Could you help us understand what benefit we should anticipate for net interest income in the second half of this year? I assume mainly in LCL. My last question is about cost of risk. Looking at your slide 15, we can see some increases from stage 3, obviously from low levels. Do you expect these trends to persist, or will the second-half level of stage 3 provisions be significantly lower? Thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, let's begin with capital management. We won't pursue M&A deals just because we happen to hold capital that could fund them. Obviously, we don't approach M&A thinking, "we've got excess capital." Those two matters are clearly kept apart. As we've consistently stated, over the long term — meaning aside from the current circumstances — our objective, our aim, is to return half of our earnings to shareholders, and to deploy the remaining solvency we generate toward developing our various activities in a productive way. That is plainly the long-term target. As it stands right now, the dividend policy is subject to constraint. We will not revisit the long-term capital management policy merely because there is, at present — and we hope this won't persist indefinitely — a constraint affecting one element that is key within our capital management policy, namely the dividend policy. Beyond that, what I can add is that unwinding the switch has always been, in our thinking, a means of trimming somewhat, opportunistically, a portion of excess solvency so as to boost our earnings per share, without needing to alter our dividend policy and without needing to launch a share buyback policy, which would be somewhat detrimental to minority shareholders given the presence of a majority shareholder who would not, all the same, take part in such a share buyback policy.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere's also this extra tool we have, which helps us fine-tune—I'd put it that way—our capital trajectory, namely the switch mechanism, and we're committed to reaching at least 50% of dismantling by 2022. Those, I would say, are the main elements of our capital management policy. At present, we don't wish to change these main elements of our capital management policy, purely because a temporary constraint exists on distributing dividends. TLTRO. We regard the TLTRO as a means for us to finance our balance sheet globally. We aren't in a position where we say we'll take a certain amount of TLTRO that we'll dedicate to a certain type of asset. We manage the group's balance sheet globally. We constantly try to combine security and, I would say, profitability. Security, since we want to avoid a situation where we face a liquidity cliff at a certain point in time. Profitability, since we constantly try to have the cheapest possible way of financing our balance sheet. Clearly the TLTRO is among the tools that can help reduce the cost of our funding, and that is exactly what we had in mind when we decided the level we have drawn at this window, with the idea, of course, that at the same time our asset book is going to grow significantly, because we are very active in lending to the economy.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe’ve been quite active, for instance, in creating and issuing loans backed by the state. Obviously, the increase we’ve made in this amount up to the TLTRO is going to benefit our P&L as we move forward. At the same time, keep in mind, for instance, that we’ve placed several billion Euro of state-guaranteed loans onto our balance sheet, with a customer rate level that sits at around zero. Ultimately, profitability comes down to the gap between what the liabilities cost and what the assets yield. Cost of risk ahead. I’ve already noted that movements in stage 1 and stage 2 provisioning will hinge on our ability to keep the scenario—and the main scenarios—that we used at the end of June. For now, as I mentioned, we don’t see any reason to alter this set of scenarios. The second piece of the cost of risk is certainly stage 3 provisioning, and that relies heavily on how our counterparts evolve. What occurred in the second quarter, which accounts for a significant portion of the change in stage 3 provisioning, is the fact that—First, some counterparts that were already very fragile prior to when the lockdown started, so fragile that in fact they couldn’t apply for any state guaranteed loan or similar support, defaulted as a result of the lockdown and moved into stage 3.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe other thing we observed, particularly at CIB, was that some of our counterparties around the globe turned out to be fraudulent counterparties in fact. That accounted for a fairly material piece of the stage 3 provisioning in the second quarter, and we do not anticipate that happening again as we move forward.
Delphine Lee
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Go ahead.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystGood afternoon. First, a request from me. Could you share the NPL ratio for the sensitive sectors? You give those in Q2, which is really helpful, but might we get the Q1 level as well, so we can track how it moved quarter on quarter? And obviously, if you could keep providing that going forward. My second question, number 1, is on SFS. The margin is clearly under a lot of pressure. You had flagged it well, but could you give us some outlook for the margin in consumer credit going forward? The second one goes back to capital. Your current target is 11%. I'm not asking you to spend your excess capital, because you can't at the moment, but actually it's more about the target. Given the reduced MDA, should you not lower it? Maybe just to follow with a small third question on your scenarios: you explained the different weightings of those scenarios to get to stage 1 and stage 2. What weightings of base versus adverse versus group scenarios are you using currently? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll take your final question first, since it won't take long to answer. The weighting across the various scenarios is something we don't disclose. My apologies, Guillaume, but we won't be revealing that immediately. Sorry. Turning to your second question, on the CET1 target: it's correct that, with this margin over SREP sitting above 400 basis points, we're well beyond the kind of buffer we'd want to hold over the long term in order to stay above the Pillar 2 requirement. We don't really believe now is a well-chosen moment to change the target, because, first of all, this is a matter that has to be discussed with the ECB, and second, it's a matter that has to be explained to the market in a calm way. In theory, it's true that, all things being equal, the various regulatory requirements have come down relative to where they stood at the end of last year by at least 60 basis points for CASA, and again, all things being equal and in a normal period, that could set off a proportional decrease in the level of our CET1 target. This is something we're fully mindful of and that we will tackle when the time comes.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning now to specialized financial services, I believe we're seeing a structural change in the composition of the loans we extend, particularly in France. As you're aware, there's been a trend in France for several years now toward fewer revolving loans and more amortizing loans, driven by legislative changes. That obviously places some pressure on the customer rate, yet over the long run it probably delivers a better cost of risk level. This mix has also been affected recently by growth in car financing at both Agos and Sofinco. What that means is that beyond the car financing operations we conduct via FCA Bank, there's additionally rising demand for car financing loans coming straight to our Agos or Sofinco branches as of late, and that too is a movement pointing in the same direction — longer loans, meaning less risky loans, but lower rates as well. Several significant shifts are underway in the consumer credit business these days, and we're going to evaluate them. The business's initial response is to watch the cost base as tightly as possible, which is what happened this quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe best approach is to keep watching the cost base so we can adjust to this medium-term margin level that could potentially be lower.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Pierre Chedeville at CIC. You have the floor.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, and good afternoon to you, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there, Pierre.
Pierre Chédeville
analystRegarding insurance, I have a single question. This morning I listened to AXA's conference call, where they said that in their combined ratio, the effect of business interruption claims was offset by half through improved motor claims results. What I'd like to ask is whether you can offer any insight on that — on how business interruption and better motor claims balance out? You also said that EUR 143 million has been paid to professionals for business interruption, but you said that this was a volunteer-
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah.
Pierre Chédeville
analystIt's a mutual action, though I assume you've paid as well, since the contract required it. Right?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah, obviously, that's a key thing to flag, since as you're aware, over in France — given all the noise that surrounded the business interruption coverage question — the local insurance regulator, the ACPR, carried out an audit.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYeah, I’m aware of that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTo be clear, the ACPR completely recognized that on this particular question, our policies were in no way ambiguous. From what I can tell, we've received no claims—or practically none—from any of our customers about this matter. This was a decision we made purely, entirely, and wholly on a voluntary basis. We took it in our own interest, since looking ahead it's clearly going to be commercially beneficial for us, and we expect it to produce and to further strengthen customer loyalty as well as our attractiveness. As for the policies themselves, there was absolutely nothing on our side that could result in any sort of arrangement like the ones mentioned for certain other insurers. Plainly, there's no problem whatsoever with our policies.
Pierre Chédeville
analystOn the motor side?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the motor side,
Pierre Chédeville
analystThe combined ratio is still pretty low, in fact.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah. The combined ratio is still really strong. In fact, the relationship between claims paid worldwide and the premium we collected got much better in Q2 versus both Q1 of this year and Q2 of last year. That's correct. That is definitely correct.
Pierre Chédeville
analystDid motor claims drive that?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe car insurance business played a huge part in that.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYeah.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSadly, when it comes to car insurance, we don't hold as large a piece of that market as we do, say, in home insurance.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAll right. I suppose robbery was lower as well.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight, and you're aware that home insurance premiums come in lower compared with what you'd pay for auto coverage.
Pierre Chédeville
analystMy second question is just technical, a very quick question. Your buffer against SREP is 410, your buffer against MDA, as far as I understand, is 380. The difference is 30 basis points. What exactly are these 30 basis points? Is it P2G or is there something I don't know?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat isn't P2G — the reality is considerably more technical. I believe it gets laid out in the credit update we posted online today as well. On page 24, you'll find the various components that account for the gap to P2R, to SREP, and to MDA, since what matters here is the Tier 1 capital ratio rather than the core Tier 1 capital ratio. All the details are there, and Emily, for instance, would be more than happy to run a dedicated session on this if you'd like.
Pierre Chédeville
analystI have no doubt about that. Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Pierre.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Flora Bocahut at UBS. Go right ahead.
Flora Bocahut
analystYeah, hi there, good afternoon. My question is about the corporate center. Looking at slide 27, you mention lower financing costs, operating expense, and so forth — obviously there are quite a few, I'd call them, one-off or specific items this year. I was wondering if you could give us some indication of how we should think about the corporate center, especially for next year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo the structural piece consists of three separate buckets, as you're aware. And I believe we're now providing a bit more clarity around those three buckets. The first is what we refer to as balance sheet and holding, and that's the one where the trend is always toward reduction. Our expectation, and what we're working toward, is to keep bringing down the cost of that bucket. There are two further buckets that are structural. The first covers all the businesses that don't fit inside a dedicated business line. Typically that's the real estate business, which is a small real estate development business. We also have the private equity business, and we have a few other minor activities, which sit structurally within the corporate center but which can introduce some volatility into their P&L. Obviously this quarter they produced a negative P&L, because the largest portion of that bucket consists of private equity activities. The valuation of the private equity funds we hold there moved in a negative direction. Then the third part is structurally converging toward zero, since it's a set of support functions that work for the group. They incur costs, but they bill those costs to the business lines on a regular basis.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat that means is that in any given quarter, the P&L might come in slightly positive or slightly negative, but overall, over the long term, it is moving toward zero. The biggest item — the one we push hardest on to bring down — is what we refer to as balance sheet and holding. As you can see, that is steadily improving, and we hope, and we are working, to keep it declining. Then comes the final piece, the volatile portion, which I will explain quickly. Structurally, this can be quite volatile, with levels that are significantly higher or lower. Once again, on average it is more or less converging toward zero, but the volatility — tied especially to intragroup accounting elements — may be significant in a particular quarter.
Flora Bocahut
analystMaybe just a quick follow-up on the balance sheet and holding side — how quickly should we expect the financing cost impact to improve?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt's really a combination of both volume and price effects. What we aim to do is bring down how much debt this corporate center carries. Whenever we're able to upstream a dividend from a subsidiary, that lowers the level of debt we need to hold. And whenever we succeed in cutting the cost of the funding that the corporate center still requires, we likewise bring down the overall cost. Those 2 elements are clearly the main drivers. The average cost has come down substantially over the last few years and will keep shrinking thanks to market conditions. On the volume side, it hinges on how much capacity we have to upstream dividends, so it hinges on how profitable the subsidiaries are, and sometimes it also hinges on the acquisitions we've made. For instance, when Amundi acquired Pioneer Investments, Amundi required a capital increase. We took part in that capital increase at CASA, and that therefore led us to pay a significant amount, so all at once we had to increase the cash out on this corporate center again.
Flora Bocahut
analystThanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorWe now move to Azzurra Guelfi from Citi, who has the next question. Kindly proceed.
Azzurra Guelfi
analystHi, good afternoon. I have a couple of questions for you regarding deposits. Looking at how deposits have evolved, they've been really strong across various areas of the business. How do you see this issue playing out ahead when it comes to customers' risk appetite? Will they move into asset management products, or do you think they'll stay liquid, or lean toward a switch that's more consumption-oriented? On LCL, could you tell us how you expect the business to develop over the second half of the year and into next year, particularly on the financing side, since I understand the market component is harder to forecast? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell, in both of those areas I'm afraid I'll be somewhat of a letdown for you, Azzurra, since what happens in each case is largely driven by how customers behave. Regarding side deposits in particular, naturally we hope and expect to see the volume of cash sitting in those side deposits come down, as that would actually demonstrate genuine household confidence. We anticipate that at least some portion of this surplus cash placed in side deposits will go toward higher consumption. For now, we must wait, because consumption has indeed risen considerably, yet set against the very large sum of cash that accumulated in side deposits, only a modest share of it has been drawn down so far. The situation is broadly similar in the large customers division and in financing activities, since we stand ready here to respond to whatever financing needs our customers may have. Naturally, should business sentiment weaken at some point and our corporate customers show less appetite for raising financing to grow their operations and invest, then we will simply have to contend with that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt the moment, no deceleration is visible to us, yet one is coming — the normal summertime dip. We see nothing indicating that business sentiment has worsened, though in either case, confidence and business sentiment will be the crucial factor.
Operator
operatorThanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC. Go ahead, please.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystYes. Thanks. Good afternoon, Jérôme. My first question concerns costs. At the group level, you've performed really strongly on costs. I just want to get a better grasp of the cost outlook within large customers. I recognize that some perimeter effects have distorted the first half. Really, are you pursuing cost efforts within large corporate similar to what you appear to be doing elsewhere in the group? Or is it more that, look, you've had this revenue windfall in the first half, and, you know what, there's no pressure to really address the cost base in large corporate? So really, first question on the large corporate cost outlook. Secondly, in car finance, was there any sort of impact from second-hand car residual values? It doesn't appear that you've taken anything. You haven't flagged anything. I wonder whether that's something you might need to do toward the back end of the year? What's your sort of outlook for car residual values in the car finance segments? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll begin with the large customers division. It's obvious that in this division—just as in every other one—we've established targets for the cost to income ratio, and the head of this business line, like the head of any business line, is responsible for hitting his own target for cost to income. Naturally, given the strong revenue level this quarter, there's an additional improvement in the cost to income ratio. I'm not claiming we'll be able to keep this business line at a cost to income ratio of 43% on a permanent basis. Over the past few years, we've run the CIB with one of the lowest cost to income ratios among all European CIBs, and we intend to keep doing so. We're addressing the cost base within the CIB the same way we do in every other business line. In car financing, it's true that, since we're a big car financing operator, we constantly keep an eye on the residual value of cars. In fact, the bulk of what we do in car financing is retail business. That means what matters to us is, of course, first, the borrower's ability to repay the loan rather than our repossessing the car.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs you're aware, with retail car financing loans, the residual financial value is actually considerably lower than it is for fleet financing. What that means is that the protection the car provides is actually greater than in the case of fleet financing. As with any business where your guarantee consists at least in part of a real asset, you have to regularly assess whether that asset's value can stay at or above the remaining capital. That's the necessity.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystAll right, understood. Thank you, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Omar Fall at Barclays. Go ahead, please.
Omar Fall
analystHello there, and good afternoon, Jérôme. I appreciate you fielding my questions. I have just two. First, apologies for returning to the top line in French retail, but the net interest income dynamics there genuinely puzzle me. If I merely divide net interest income ex-PELTRO by loans, it shows something like a slight decrease for the quarter. That's essentially quite similar to Q4, and you've seen strong volume growth on deposits, which outpaces the asset side, with current accounts rising 30%, which is a drag. The state-guaranteed loans ought to be a negative, and swap rates have come down, another negative. So how does net interest margin stay so steady? Perhaps you could offer a bit more detail. Second, please talk about GAC Sofinco specifically. My sense is that, in navigating the crisis given where China stands, that business runs two to three months ahead of the remainder of Crédit Agricole Consumer Finance. I realize it's a distinct market, but how far has it recovered? Is the top line in asset quality essentially back to a normal run rate? You provided some volume changes between June and March, but those are difficult to interpret since we don't really know the pace.
Omar Fall
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right. On GAC Sofinco, I'm looking to my colleagues here to get the exact information, since I don't have it in mind. Regarding LCL, keep in mind that loan outstandings rose quite significantly between the end of June 2019 and the end of June 2020. The mix is improving as well, because again, I don't have the precise figures in mind, but I believe they're in the appendix. LCL has made an effort to further develop, first, consumer credit loans, and second, SME and professional loans, which generally carry a better customer rate than home loans. There's a mix effect that I think has also contributed positively to preserving the net interest margin. Overall, clearly, the volume effect has remained positive for LCL. For GAC, do you have the information?
Speaker
unknownSo, what we saw was a fairly moderate slowdown in activity, with commercial business down 10% versus the second quarter. Since June, activity has picked back up again — particularly at GAC Sofinco, where production rose sharply and once again reached the level we had before the crisis. We are seeing a pickup at GAC Sofinco. We do need to be fairly cautious when it comes to the outlook for GAC in China. The lockdown came earlier, and it also happened during Chinese New Year, which leaves us relatively confident about what will happen this year at GAC Sofinco in terms of the budget.
Omar Fall
analystAlright, got it. Sorry — just one quick follow-up. I suppose loan growth in the back half of the quarter would have been considerably stronger than in the first half?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah.
Omar Fall
analystIf you're suggesting that net margin is actually negative because of how the averaging works, you still sound pretty confident about the outlook. So does that mean volumes really have to come back very significantly from where we are now in order to offset that margining effect?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, it's accurate that LCL's activity level came back fairly strongly during the latter portion of the quarter. What that means is that as we move through the third quarter, the average volume of loans will be considerably above the average amount of loans outstanding we recorded in the second quarter. No — we feel positive despite every constraint that weighs, and keeps weighing, on retail banking operations in France, namely the expense tied to regulated savings accounts and the reality that competition in home loans remains aggressive. Even with those constraints, LCL is performing well, has what I would describe as a very coherent approach to its customers, and is raising the equipment rate of those customers through the various products we offer — and we are positive on LCL.
Omar Fall
analystMuch appreciated, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. You have the floor.
Stefan Stalmann
analystGood afternoon, Jérôme, and thanks for taking my questions. There are two topics I'd like to cover, please. First, dividends again, though from another angle — I believe you touched on this when discussing the corporate center. How exactly have you dealt with intra-group dividends that get upstreamed into CACEIS, from Cardif or the insurance business, et cetera? Could you explain how you've handled this during the first half of the year, please?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAbsolutely.
Stefan Stalmann
analystMoving to the second question, which concerns the consumer finance business. If you strip out the minority interest in consumer from the tax benefit at Agos, it appears that Agos's underlying business was roughly at break even during the second quarter. Would you say that's a reasonable estimate? In addition, net equity income from the joint ventures seems to be holding up fairly well relative to what is going on in the consolidated loan book. I was wondering whether those joint ventures actually apply the same IFRS 9 methodologies, and also the same timing in applying them, as CACEIS does in its main entities, its controlled entities, or whether there are, let's say, time lags or permanent differences in the models being used.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll begin with the dividend question. The principle applied in the first quarter was that every 100% subsidiary had the right to upstream its dividends. What that means is that CACIB and LCL, for instance, upstreamed their dividends. By contrast, none of the subsidiaries where minority shareholders exist could upstream dividends. That means CACEIS, for instance, or Crédit Agricole Italia, or even more plainly, Amundi, were unable to upstream the dividend this year. So it's a mixture of differing situations that we had to handle. On the consumer credit business, let me begin with the equity accounted entities. Yes, naturally, they all use the same kinds of methodologies we apply when evaluating IFRS 9 provisioning, since, as you know, in every case we manage the support and risk function. We are able to truly monitor that. Among the equity accounted entities in consumer credit, we have the car financing entities, where business stayed quite positively oriented once the lockdown period came to an end, and where the cost of risk isn't very significant given the nature of that business. There is also, mainly, another traditional consumer credit business, which is Wafasalaf in Morocco.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt Wafasalaf, the cost of risk went up substantially, and as a result its contribution to the equity accounted entities declined. The -22.7% figure that took us to a EUR 60 million contribution reflects a combination of strong results from the car financing entities and softer results from the Wafasalaf entity. Let me make sure I've got the other part of your question right. What you're putting to us is that, on your math, Agos essentially broke even this quarter. Is that what you're asking?
Stefan Stalmann
analystRight, since the minority interest in consumer finance is essentially the same as the minority interest tied to the tax benefit at Agos.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah.
Stefan Stalmann
analystIt seems like the remainder of Agos essentially wasn't producing minority interest, and so likely no profits either.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, so this quarter the cost of risk at Agos came in much higher — that's obvious — mainly since, as you're aware, the lockdown in Italy was really strict. As you know, in Italy, collecting on loans that have payment issues is done, let's say, in person. What that means is that for a stretch of one and a half to two months, there was basically no — or almost no — in-person collection activity on payment incidents in Italy. Clearly, this quarter at Agos we probably booked an additional provisioning amount, one that was led or triggered by the inability to physically collect the repayments on those loans. We have to wait for things to fully normalize before we can check whether this is an actual payment incident or whether it's simply that once collection can happen again, the loan gets regularized. We'll need to reassess the risk situation at Agos during the third quarter.
Stefan Stalmann
analystRight, thanks a lot. That's really helpful. Appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Matthew Clark of Mediobanca. Go right ahead.
Matthew Clark
analystHi. I have a couple of questions. For the first one, can you help me grasp how the economics work on those French loans that carry a government guarantee? I believe you mentioned that clients were paying roughly zero on them. If you're able to fund yourself at 100 basis points, below that, with TLTRO3 serving as your marginal source of funding, does that imply you're making a percentage point of net interest margin on those volumes? Or is there something I'm overlooking? If so, kindly point out where my reasoning goes astray. My next question concerns the tax rate. Was there anything else in this quarter that contributed to the low tax rate, since the affrancamento, EUR 39 million, appears to account for only part of why it's so low? Is anything else happening there? Last, on rating migration within risk-weighted assets, do you anticipate any headwinds in the quarters ahead? Do you view it as not really a significant effect for you? Should it occur, would it be a next-year effect, roughly timed with the conclusion of government support measures? Any thoughts on magnitude or timing would be welcome. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding loans backed by the state, the interest rate is zero, and all the borrower needs to do is pay a premium, which represents the cost of that guarantee. During the initial year, this premium is fixed, I'd say, at a flat 25 bps. That 25 bps gets divided with 90% going to the state and 10% to the bank, which retains the premium for the portion of risk it takes on. What this means is that on the loan itself, apart from the guarantee, the rate truly is zero. It is nil. Naturally, if we could claim that we are financing a particular state-guaranteed loan at the margin through a particular drawing under the TLTRO, then we could state that we will trigger and record a net margin of one percentage point. In practice, once again, our approach is to manage the balance sheet on a global basis, and that balance sheet shifts constantly, particularly given current conditions, in which customer behavior has changed in many ways. Put another way, the TLTRO will contribute to bringing down somewhat the weighted average cost of funding for our balance sheet. Meanwhile, the state-guaranteed loans will not contribute to raising the weighted average yield on the assets held on our balance sheet.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat answer you get really hinges on whether you're after just a bit of marginal reasoning or whether you actually factor in reality — and reality here means monitoring the balance sheet on a global basis. Rating migration. Well, we review the ratings of our various counterparties on a regular basis. That's something we're required to do regularly. Naturally, whenever a counterparty's credit quality worsens, its rating has to be downgraded in our system, and that sets off a rise in the RWA level. In this quarter by itself, that produced an increase of close to EUR 2 billion in RWAs at CACIB. That's not nothing. Definitely not nothing, and it may well keep continuing as we go forward. This rating migration effect belongs to the broader group of elements that cause a change in the RWA level, but on its own, rating migration will probably remain negative going forward. Once again, EUR 1.9 billion of extra RWAs at CACIB during the last quarter.
Matthew Clark
analystMind if I just verify that?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, of course.
Matthew Clark
analystHow are you evaluating the counterparty rating in that case? Do you do it internally, using things like interest coverage and similar metrics, or do you depend on outside parties and their external ratings? What does that process look like?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis is something we handle internally, factoring in every piece of relevant information, and through that internal process we assign ratings — every one of our counterparties carries an internal rating from us. As you're aware, several entities within the group are able to lend to one and the same counterparty. One entity in the group takes the lead when it comes to assessing that rating. For instance, when it comes to the bigger corporates, that's generally CACIB, though for certain smaller enterprises and some smaller businesses, it could be LCL, CACIB, or one of the regional banks. It all depends.
Matthew Clark
analystThanks. Back to the tax point, where I cut in.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes. Regarding tax — sorry, I was just checking my notes. On the tax side, there's this affrancamento effect, and it's producing a reduction in the tax level of roughly EUR 60 million gross at Crédit Agricole Consumer Finance. Also, as you're aware, two factors typically drive a lower tax rate. The AT1 coupons are tax deductible, though this quarter they don't matter much, since that gets spread out evenly over the various quarters. If my memory serves, the amount this quarter wasn't very significant. Then there's the fact that certain profits from various businesses get booked in geographies where the corporate tax rate is below France's. That's obviously true for a large portion of CACEIS's activities, and it holds for some other activities too. This results in an average tax rate that is structurally below the marginal corporate tax rate in France. On top of that, within the tax line, we can see regular ups and downs tied either to how certain revenues are booked, which enjoy a lower tax rate.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis does occur from time to time in the insurance sector. Beyond that, certain tax uncertainties and tax litigation exist, which is why we set aside some provisions. As a rule, when it comes to tax provisions, we apply the same prudence we do to credit provisions. What that means is that whenever a tax dispute gets resolved, the resolution generally comes at a lower cost than what we originally booked. As a result, in a given quarter we may see some reversal of tax provisions, and that helps the average tax rate. This quarter, across the board, there were some bits and pieces of that kind of element. That is what leads to the provisional tax rate for the quarter, I would say, since, as you know, where taxes are concerned, the reality really materializes at year-end.
Matthew Clark
analystThanks a lot. That's much appreciated.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThank you. Our following question is from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. Go ahead with your question.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYeah, sorry. A few quick follow-ups. On the tax side, Matthew's question was a good one. There's this big EUR 77 million recovery in the financing business, just so we have a sense of what that is. Second question: what's really interesting about how the division performed is wealth management, which is doing very well indeed and has nearly doubled its profitability compared with last year. So again, is that a base we can actually build on? Do you feel comfortable about the return on net equity for 2022, which for this division is, I believe, 25% and would amount to a doubling of current profitability? And finally, I'd be delighted to take part in the insurance one-on-one teach-in with Pierre and Emily. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright. Regarding waste management, it's evident the business has been improving for a number of quarters now. In fact, we had hit a low point in profitability earlier — at the start of 2019, or even at the end of 2018. Jacques Coste, who leads that business, is focused on boosting cost efficiency and on strengthening the capacity to generate revenue. Overall, we expect this trend to keep going. Naturally, there can be some fluctuations quarter to quarter. Revenue-wise, the first quarter was very strong. From a revenue standpoint, the second quarter was somewhat weaker, though it was also better from a tax perspective, to return to that point. On balance, the bottom line got better, but where the profitability target is concerned, we're not there yet. Broadly speaking, your second question regarding the tax rate-
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystThe financing division, yeah, and that's a positive. Yeah.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe need to unpack your question a bit before we can respond. I don’t have that answer right at hand.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystAll right, thanks, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI believe there's one more question?
Operator
operatorYes, the final question is from Phoebe Pace of Société Générale. Go right ahead.
Analyst
analystGood afternoon. This is Phoebe Pace calling from SocGen. I have a quick follow-up question about LCL and mortgages in particular that I would like to fit in, if that's all right. You sound fairly confident regarding the outlook for mortgage volumes at LCL during the second half of the year. But the Observatoire Crédit Logement now estimates that mortgage production levels in France ought to drop by 26% in 2020 assuming the country's GDP fell by 10% this year, and I believe that is your main assumption. So I would just like to understand what gives you confidence that LCL could keep up solid mortgage volume growth in the second half of the year given that sort of market context. Many thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI said I felt sure about LCL. What I didn't do was state specifically that I was confident in LCL's capacity to expand home loan volumes. Around the world, LCL's business is performing pretty well. Naturally, should the home loan market's evolution take a certain downturn, that would be felt at LCL as well. As I mentioned before, LCL has sought to diversify somewhat the mix of its various lending categories — by raising corporate volumes, by raising consumer credit loans too, and by way of loans also targeting professionals. What matters for us at LCL on a global basis is the ability to sustain a good dynamic in loans overall, not just home loans, and likewise a good dynamic in sales of other products and services. Not lending alone, since the crux of retail banking in France is really being able to keep growing the full set of activities around customers. I accept that a slowdown in the home loan business may occur, but LCL doesn't depend on that business alone.
Analyst
analystThat’s very clear. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. That was, I believe, the final question. I'd like to express my appreciation for everyone joining this meeting, and I also want to wish all of you a pleasant holiday—at least those of you who plan to take some time off. That will be my situation as well. Have a good afternoon. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it, everyone. That brings today's conference to a close. Thanks for joining us. You're all free to disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.