Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 4, 2020

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 112 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and thank you for joining us. This is the call covering our third-quarter and first-nine-month 2020 results. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the speakers' presentation, we'll open things up for a question-and-answer session. If you'd like to ask something during that session, just press star one on your phone. Please be aware that today's call, Wednesday, the 4th of November, 2020, is being recorded. I'll now turn things over to today's first speaker. Please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good afternoon, everyone. I'll aim to keep this presentation quite brief, particularly today, since I suspect some of you may be thinking about other subjects and concerns beyond just our results. Let me begin right away on page four of the presentation, where the key profitability figures for the group are shown. I'd like to offer just a few remarks on that page. To start, bear in mind that from a macroeconomic standpoint, as well as from the group's perspective, this year's third quarter was marked by a very substantial pickup in activity levels. What this page demonstrates is that our operational performances have been very strong, reflected, for instance, in a gross operating income that has risen for both the group and CASA. Our net profit remains very resilient notwithstanding the cost of risk level. I'll come back to that matter later. As you can see, for the group and for CASA alike, particularly when you look at the underlying figures, the profit level is very close to, or perhaps slightly higher than, what we reported a year earlier for the same period.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

Capital adequacy is moving ahead quite quickly and has now hit record highs, for both CASA and the group. One final item on this slide: return on tangible equity at CASA, at 10% annualized across the first nine months of the year, remains, again, very resilient, even given how much capital CASA holds. Moving to the following slide, I mentioned that gross operating income rose for both CASA and the group quarter on quarter. That reflects a top line rising in both cases alongside a cost line falling in both cases. What this means is that cost income ratios have improved markedly across the two perimeters. Beyond that, the quality of our loan books stays very high, and NPL coverage remains very comfortable. During this quarter we also kept carrying out transactions that simplify the group's scope — through the disposal of our residual stake in Banque Saudi Fransi and through the sale of a small Spanish bank, Bankoa, which belonged mostly to one of Crédit Agricole's regional banks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

Finally, regarding the launch of the sale process for CACF NL — our consumer credit business in the Netherlands — that entity is now declassified under IFRS 5. Beyond that, I would note that the key items accounting for the gap between stated and underlying profit figures, both for CASA and for the group, are precisely these last two: the declassification of CACF NL and the disposal of Bankoa. Moving to page 6, you will find an illustration of what I have just described — namely, the very sharp rebound in activity levels for the group, with all the indicators presented on this page clearly recovering quite substantially and dynamically following this spring's lockdown period. As you can see, in most cases we are not merely returning to pre-crisis levels but actually exceeding them. That matters especially for customer capture, where our customer bases in retail banking continue to expand. Turning to the following page, just a few points to underscore the group's contribution during this highly unusual period on behalf of our clients across the board.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

We have been quite active in providing state-guaranteed loans to our customers, with a total amount of close to EUR 30 billion in France. We've also been very active when it comes to granting payment holidays to our customers. On more than 500,000 occasions, we have granted payment holidays to our customers. By the end of September, two-third of these payment holidays had come to an end, and each time the normal repayment date has passed, 97 of the payment have resumed without any difficulty, which shows that this payment holiday was actually a very useful and practical tool for us to help our customers. Moving to the following page, just an illustration of why we've proven so robust and so able to navigate through this very special year without any major impact on our P&L. It's clearly the result of the strength of our business model, universal banking model, with a very solid customer base in retail banking activities, more than 50 million customers in our own retail network. Plus the addition of a very significant series of strategy partnership, 24 as of today, which give us access to many more customers in order to sell the product of our different specialized business lines.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

Obviously, when you put those two things together, it gives the group a great deal of solidity and resilience. Moving to the next page, this is a summary of what I'd describe as the group's robustness indicators, laid out here. A CET1 ratio of 17%, a loan book of very high quality where NPL stands at just 2.5% at the end of September. A provisioning approach that is very prudent, resulting in a coverage ratio on those NPLs of 80% — above 80% at group level. And finally, a liquidity position that is very comfortable, with liquidity reserves exceeding EUR 400 billion at the end of September. Let me now go a bit deeper into how Crédit Agricole SA itself performed, beginning with revenues on page 11. As you can see, both for the quarter and for the first nine months of the year, we succeeded in delivering positive growth in the top line: +1.5% for the quarter and +2% for the first nine months of the year. That's a very good performance, and it clearly stems from the diversification of our businesses as well as the high share of our revenues that is recurrent.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

We attempted to work out what share of our revenues is tied to recurring activities, recurring contracts, or recurring services that we provide to customers. In fact, we come to the conclusion that over three-quarters of our revenues are plainly recurring, meaning they give resilience and solidity to the top line. Moving to the next page, the cost line, page 12, what you can observe is that during the quarter we succeeded in bringing down the cost base slightly, by 1.2%, and in fact it stayed stable over the first nine months of the year. What's even more interesting is that in the business lines where we had to book a decline in the top line, which occurred in a few of our business lines, we simultaneously succeeded in lowering the cost line so as to preserve profitability as much as possible. That's another illustration of how efficient our approach to monitoring the cost base is. Every business line is accountable for its cost base, and it must defend its own cost-to-income ratio as much as possible. This is the most efficient manner of monitoring the cost base globally in a very decentralized group such as ours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

The result is really strong cost efficiency performance right across the board. Taking a broad, helicopter view of this cost efficiency topic, and looking back to where we stood in Q3 2015, I recognize that over five years we managed to bring down CASA's cost-to-income ratio by over 11 percentage points, from 69.4% down to 58.1%. That is a very impressive and solid performance. Turning now to risks and the quality of our loan book. As I mentioned, at group level we have a 2.5% NPL ratio and a coverage ratio above 80%. At CASA level we also have exposure of very high quality, with an NPL ratio slightly under 3.5% and a coverage ratio near 70%. You may notice that the coverage ratio across those two perimeters is somewhat lower than at the end of June. That is almost entirely explained by a technical factor which, to put it in a nutshell, leads to a slight increase of stage three, so the non-performing loan bucket, without requiring an increase of the provision in the same proportion, because it consists of default under observation and not real defaults.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

When it comes to cost of risk this quarter, page 14 shows it remains considerably higher than the cost of risk we reported in Q3 2019, though it has begun to come down relative to Q2 2020. The decline has in fact been fairly substantial — a third lower on CASA's perimeter, and close to a halving at the group perimeter. A meaningful share of our cost of risk still consists of provisions on performing loans in the portfolio — the provisions tied to stage one and stage two assets. In fact, within our loan loss provision outstandings, a quarter of these provisions at CASA and nearly 30% at the group level come from stage one and stage two provisions. Moving to page 15, which gives some detail by business line, you can see that in every case we observe the same kind of pattern I described at the global level — namely, a significant portion of provisioning made up of stage one and stage two provisioning, plus a lower level of additional provision compared with Q2. One point worth mentioning, which is very specific to the consumer credit business: this new definition of default has indeed triggered a significant shift between bucket two and bucket three.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

What this produces is a substantial one-time effect: we cut bucket two provisioning by a large amount and substituted an equal amount of bucket three. Naturally, the total cost of risk sits at what you'd call a "normal" level given the circumstances we're in today. That flows through to the net income figure at the group level shown on page 16. You can observe that net income has indeed fallen, both for the quarter and for the first nine months of the year, particularly when restated for the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, which again rose this year versus last year. The quarterly figure is -9% and the nine-month figure is -8.8%. I'd call that a very impressive performance — delivering such resilience in net profit while the cost of risk has gone up so much year over year. Looking at each business line, the trends differ. Perhaps I should flag just one item for this quarter. In the asset gathering business division, net profit is down by EUR 42 million.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

The explanation goes beyond an accounting matter—it comes down simply to the fact that, within Crédit Agricole Assurance's scope, we changed this quarter how we account for AT1 coupons issued by Crédit Agricole Assurance. Until now, those were recorded against equity; at present they are recorded directly in the P&L under minority interest, yet economically nothing changes. Let me zoom in a bit now on the various business lines, beginning exactly with the asset gathering and insurance division. Globally, on page 18, what you can observe is that activity has been quite dynamic, notably with a very high level of net new inflows at Amundi, near EUR 35 billion, along with a positive market effect. As I mentioned, outside this technical and accounting matter, the contribution of this division to CASA's net profit will have been stable—which, again, changes nothing from an economic standpoint. Insurance activities, in a nutshell, saw a very good quarter activity-wise, despite total premium income having decreased—in fact it has been declining because of life insurance activities, and within life insurance activities we have nevertheless managed to maintain a positive level of net inflows.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

Once again, unit-linked products have accounted for a very substantial share of net inflows. On the other insurance side, new policy production has been captured in a very impressive way, which means premium income is up roughly 10%, for both P&C and protection. That is producing a very solid financial result, since, again, looking at page 19 on the P&L, you will notice net income is up 1%, and only minority interest is what causes the decline in net income group share. Moving now to Amundi, I will keep this very brief, as you saw Amundi's publication last week. Very positive new inflows. Revenues continue to be under pressure where management fees are concerned, but the cost line delivers an almost complete catch-up, and all in all, profit is slightly higher this quarter, as is the contribution to CASA's net profit. Turning to retail banking, beginning with LCL, another very good quarter at LCL, with every indicator moving in a positive direction. That has been true for customer capture, for how loans outstandings evolved, for customer savings, and for equipping our customers with additional services and products.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

From a financial standpoint, it has also been the case that revenues rose, driven by a solid mix of fees and net interest margin, while costs fell and cost of risk climbed, yet net income group share for this quarter was still up 14%. In Italy, Crédit Agricole Italia saw a healthy level of activity and a strong quarter when it came to catching up on production of new loans and new contracts with our customers. Revenues there were nearly flat, costs edged slightly lower, cost of risk rose significantly though it stayed below the prior quarter, and profitability was decent overall. The remaining international retail banking activities took another hit this quarter, largely due to the mix of a substantial drop in interest rates and flattening yield curves across the various countries where we operate. There is also a Forex effect, negative as well when we translate locally generated revenues into euro. Even so, we keep monitoring those activities within a very safe framework, and local self-financing of the loan book continues, which is good, along with coverage of the NPLs that stands above 100%. Specialized financial services. This is the division where we have these very specific effects tied to the reclassification under IFRS five of CACF NL.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

On the consumer credit side, and regarding its operations, new loan production this quarter was quite strong — in fact, it came in higher than consumer loan production in the third quarter of 2019. Revenues restated for the perimeter effect tied to CACF were really only slightly lower, at -1.4%, while expenses fell more sharply, at -2.5%, which produces stable gross operating income and net income that is down only marginally on an overall basis. That's very solid resilience and a very solid rebound following the lockdown period in the second quarter. Leasing and factoring had a tougher quarter. New contract production was healthy, but conversion of those new contracts into actual revenues is trailing somewhat, so we're looking for an improved fourth quarter. Turning to the large customer division: this is clearly the division where the top line was most dynamic, up close to 12% overall, with every activity indicator moving in a positive direction, for both CIB and the asset servicing businesses. Within asset servicing, we're still working to integrate Santander Securities Services into our organization, and we're also continuing the integration of KAS BANK.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#15

We only received the final authorization allowing us to move forward with the mergers a few days ago, as a matter of fact. A great deal of work lies before us if we are to produce further cost savings. In CIB — page 26 specifically — you can observe that we recorded growth of roughly 10% in the top line, which reflects an exceptionally strong momentum in capital market activities. On the financing side, results were restated for Forex effects and for a base effect tied to the fact that in Q3 2019, for the final time, this division had recorded a dividend received from Banque Saudi Fransi. Revenues in the financing division of CIB are up as well. Costs rose only modestly, in line with the healthy activity level. Cost of risk is clearly much higher than it was a year ago. It comes close to a fivefold multiplication, and the largest share of this provisioning relates to performing assets. In fact, during this quarter, the stage three provision accounts for just a very small portion of overall provisioning. Finally, the RWA level at CACIB declined quite substantially in this quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#16

That also contributes to better profitability overall. Turning to the corporate center on page 27: we're still pursuing the same approach, namely a gradual lowering of the corporate center's structural costs. In this quarter, we also gained from an extra contribution, which, taken together, results in an exceptionally low cost level for the corporate center. On page 29, the regional banks of Crédit Agricole: the trends we observe there are broadly similar to those at LCL — that is, solid customer acquisition and growth of the customer base, a very dynamic development of the loan book, a very dynamic development of new insurance policy production built on our customer base, which leads, all things considered, to higher top line, lower costs, and, thanks to these technical effects related to the new definition of default, a substantial decrease in the cost of risk as well. Taken together, the regional banks' contribution to the group's net income is globally higher this quarter, +12.5%. Let's now move to page 31 to examine how we have managed to raise our solvency so significantly.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

It comes down to a lowering of the RWA level, which you can see on the left side of the page. Usage of RWAs across the various business lines has declined, even with the momentum of new loan generation, since in fact the fresh loans we originate are home loans at LCL or Crédit Agricole Italia. The decline has occurred in the loan portfolio that carries a higher level of RWAs. We also got a boost from the Forex effect and from technical effects, and taken together these produced that decrease in the RWA level. The remaining items are roughly offsetting each other. That is what drives this drop in RWAs. If you put that decrease together with a solid level of profitability after setting aside a dividend for payment in 2021, weather permitting, along with certain methodological effects that are positive this quarter, you arrive at this very high solvency level at CASA, 12.6%. Naturally, that sits well above every regulatory requirement and also well above the targets we have set. At the group level, the story is more or less identical. We see a decline in the RWA level for the same cause, -EUR 11 billion. We have a good level of results.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

Of course, we set aside funds for the dividend due to be paid in 2021. There are also certain favorable methodological impacts. Taken together, on this quarter alone this produces a 90 basis point rise in the group's solvency, along with a buffer exceeding 800 basis points over the Pillar two requirements. Regarding liquidity, I believe I can move quite quickly, since once again we find ourselves in a very comfortable position, thanks both to the monetary policy implemented by the ECB and to our strong ability to reach collateral and to mobilize it whenever needed. The same applies to the group's market funding programs, which stand completed at 97% for CASA and above 80% for the group globally as of the end of the third quarter. Overall — and I am now on page 36 — I think the conclusion is fairly straightforward. A very solid operational and financial performance this quarter, a very robust group and a very robust CASA from a balance sheet standpoint, once more reinforced by this strong financial performance, and a group fully prepared to keep playing its part in managing this very particular crisis that we are navigating through.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

Thanks. At this point, I’ll open it up for any questions you may have.

Operator

operator
#20

Thanks again. Just a quick reminder — if you’d like to make a comment or ask a question, press star one on your phone. I’ll wait for your name to be announced. That’s star one for a comment or a question. If you want to cancel that request, just press the hash key. Our first question is from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. Your line is open. Please go ahead with your question.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#21

Hello, Tarik El Mejjad here.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#22

Hi there, Tarik.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#23

Two questions from me, if I may. Hello, Jérôme. The first concerns Italian M&A, which doesn't come as a shock. Since those headlines appeared, your stock has trailed the index by 15%, 17%. I have not really heard you deny it, and neither has the market. Could you just say whether this is something you rule out, or perhaps refresh us on your overall stance regarding consolidation, and specifically in Italy? My second question is about cost of risk. Once again you haven't provided full-year guidance or expectations, and I believe the press release said Q4 might be harder for certain corporate and retail clients. Do you still anticipate adding further management overlay or stage one and two provisions like you did in Q3, or do you feel that right now, under the second lockdown assumptions and so forth, you are sufficiently reserved — particularly in the financing activities, where we continue to see a somewhat higher level of stage one and two in Q3? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#24

Thanks for those two solid questions. I'll begin with Italy. I'll begin by explaining what our activities there consist of and what we've been doing in that country for roughly 30 years now. We have a presence in Italy not just in retail banking but also — and I'd argue primarily — through our specialized business lines. That covers asset management, consumer credit, car financing, leasing, factoring, CIB, wealth management, and so on. Every one of our specialized business lines operates in Italy. In most cases — actually, I neglected to bring up insurance, naturally — all of these lines are there, not solely drawing on our own retail banking customer base, but also through a whole set of partnerships that have let us expand our business line beyond where our retail footprint reaches. The model matches the one we've used in France, though it's simply a bit tilted, I'd say. In France, we hold the biggest market share in retail banking, and from that customer base we built out all the specialized business lines, and we work hard trying to grow our market shares across the various specialized business lines to match the size of the retailer's.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#25

In Italy, we made the decision that since our retail footprint was considerably smaller, we had to find scope through those partnerships. Globally, this leads to a situation where two-thirds of the net profit we generated in Italy last year — and the same holds for the first nine months of this year, and it was also true in 2018 — 2/3 of the profit comes from the business lines, while 1/3 comes from retail. Does that mean we don't want to grow in retail? Absolutely not. We try as much as possible to grow organically, and all the performances we post regularly demonstrate that we are indeed able to grow above the market and more than the market across the different product lines distributed by our retail banking branches. That's also been the case this quarter in home loans or whatever. Does this mean we aren't ready to seize opportunities to accelerate this organic growth, taking advantage of, again, some opportunities? We've done it in the past, and I think we've done it quite successfully. Always keeping in mind that we have a prudent approach on M&A transaction, we may take opportunities.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#26

Bear in mind that this is a global strategy — not a purely retail one, and not one where M&A would be given the leading role. That's the approach we take in Italy. It's the approach we have pursued over the last, again, 30 years, and particularly across the last five years, and we plan to keep going along those same lines — prudently, but with determination. The second question concerned cost of risk and guidance. Again, I'm not fond of giving guidance, particularly in an environment this uncertain. Conditions are genuinely hard to read across the board, above all from a sanitary standpoint, and that carries consequences for the economic situation. We gave no guidance on cost of risk at the end of Q1 or at the end of Q2. Nor will we give guidance at the end of Q3. What I can say, even so, is that the macroeconomic scenario underpinning our bucket one and bucket two provisioning has not been altered for the third quarter. For the end-of-year accounts, we will probably revise that scenario. Will this produce a significant rise in the level of provisioning, that is, in bucket one and bucket two provisioning?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#27

Not necessarily, since our bucket one and bucket two provisioning consists of two layers—two extra layers. The first is what we refer to as the central forward-looking piece. That's the impact of the macroeconomic scenario applied horizontally to every business throughout the group. Each business line can, if it considers it necessary, add to this central forward-looking a local forward-looking component, which rests on a more precise view of particular portfolios or particular geographies. This quarter, in fact, the largest portion of the stage one and stage two provisioning—the additional provision we booked—came, within CACIB and within LCL, for instance, from such local forward-looking. Naturally, if we alter slightly the global macroeconomic scenario that drives the central forward-looking, this will absorb, so to speak, all those local provisions booked in the third quarter in certain business lines, again, such as LCL or CACIB. That is another reason I don't anticipate a massive rise in stage one and stage two provisions. To sum up my answer, we will change the scenario. It may result in additional S1 and S2 provision, but a massive increase is not what I expect. Regarding the S3 provisions, we will simply observe what the situation is at the end of December.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#28

Thanks. So if I've got this right, back when you were putting together those Q3 stage one, two provisions, you had some form of lockdown in mind — and probably not a national lockdown — so you'll need to make an adjustment for that? Yeah.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#29

Yes. Actually, the scenario we set at the end of the first lockdown — at the end of spring, the start of summer — turned out in September to be somewhat more pessimistic than most official forecasts. We discovered it was pessimistic enough to be used for the Q3 accounts. We now have a few weeks to fine-tune and to try to assess as best we can the consequences of the new situation we face. Again, it is a moving situation. It is very difficult to precisely assess what will happen at the beginning of 2021, the end of 2021, 2022, and so on and so forth.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#30

That's crystal clear, Jérôme. Thanks so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#31

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#32

Thanks. We'll take the next question from Jon Peace at Credit Suisse. Your line is open, so go ahead with your question.

Jon Peace

analyst
#33

Yeah, thanks a lot. Hey there, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#34

Hello.

Jon Peace

analyst
#35

Let me start with the CET1 ratio question. Can you remind us what headwinds and tailwinds we should be thinking about — software being one example — as we move toward year end? You mentioned the 60 basis points for the 2019 dividend effectively sitting in your ratio, so how are you thinking about the possibility of paying something extra beyond your 2020 accrual? Would you view it as prudent to keep a buffer for economic uncertainty, or even for M&A? My second one follows up on Tarik's question. What would you regard as your normalized, through-the-cycle cost of risk? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#36

All right. In fact, our view on the "normalized cost of risk" through the cycle hasn't shifted from what we assumed when we set the medium-term plan on June 29. At that point, we said the normalized cost of risk through the cycle stood at roughly 40 basis points at CASA, and at about 25 basis points at the group level globally. Our thinking really hasn't changed. We'll see whether we move toward those levels quickly or perhaps more gradually. We see no reason to revise our view of what the cost of risk through the cycle ought to be, given the business mix we have across the different parameters of CASA on the one hand, and under the group on the other. As for the CET1 ratio, what we expect for the end of this year is, as you said, the potential benefits from the decision on the software. Calculating the impact in full is very cumbersome, but it will come in basis points, not tenths of a basis point. My expectation is that it could be as much as 10 bps of additional benefits for both CASA and the group.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#37

Not a great deal more. Once again, working it out is fairly laborious, since we must examine every one of our IT investments to determine how much amortization remains and so forth. On the headwind side, the TRIM exercises are still ongoing, and we will likely need to factor in a few billion of extra RWAs, particularly within the CACIB perimeter. Exactly how many billions, we don't know. Might it be roughly EUR 5 billion? I can't say. It will probably be, perhaps even more than EUR 5 billion. We still need to go through the various TRIM reports and hold discussions with the ECB, and so forth. We have no firm guidance on timing. Both headwinds and tailwinds are anticipated, yet overall, nothing that would materially alter the picture given the strong solvency position we currently enjoy. As for the 60 basis points dividend provision we retained, in fact there was no alternative, because the moment the decision came that no dividend could be paid in 2020, our only option was to add the 60 basis points of solvency back into our ratio. Well, we won't be rushing to form a view about what to do with that amount.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

From what I gather, the ECB plans to clarify what will be feasible to carry out in 2021. We'll hold off until the ECB speaks and shares its position. Certainly, should the ECB's remarks show any receptiveness, we are definitely the type of bank that stands to gain from such openness, given how strong our solvency is. Perhaps a final note: if CASA uses 60 bps by paying its dividend as it planned to in 2020 but was prevented from doing, that costs only about 15 bps at the group level overall. Plainly, the dividend matter is not a solvency concern for us.

Jon Peace

analyst
#39

Yes. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#40

Perhaps just one final remark. When I discussed headwinds and tailwinds, naturally, that occurs inside the worldwide context of 60 basis points that we described concerning Basel IV implementation, which we stated at the outset when the medium-term plan was published. It needs to be viewed within this, I would say, approximate envelope.

Jon Peace

analyst
#41

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#42

Thanks. We now take a question from Jacques-Henri Gaulard of Kepler Cheuvreux, whose line is open. Go ahead with your question.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#43

I have two quick questions. First, since your AT1 costs have clearly fallen a lot over nine months, can I just annualize that figure as a proxy for the full year and for later years as well? Second, you brought up the TLTRO and called it a reversible gain — if you could put a number on that, that would be great. Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#44

So what occurred, as I mentioned, is that for accounting methodology reasons, we needed to slightly adjust how we treat a portion of our AT1s — specifically those issued by the insurance company. We took back, I'd say, EUR 43 million this quarter that until now had been booked directly against equity, and we had to recycle it through the P&L. Once again, from a net asset perspective or an earnings per share perspective, nothing changes, but the way the P&L looks shifts somewhat. That EUR 43 million will rise in the fourth quarter by, I believe, roughly EUR 25 million more, which will go through exactly the same channel. Looking ahead, approximately EUR 75 million of AT1 coupons from the AT1s issued by Crédit Agricole Assurances will now show up in the P&L. As for the AT1s issued directly by CASA, we're aligned on that, meaning the average yearly cost, which isn't spread entirely evenly across quarters.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#45

Yeah.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#46

That comes to roughly EUR 420 million.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#47

Sounds good.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#48

Just a bit over EUR 400 million.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#49

Thanks. Turning to the TLTRO.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#50

On the TLTRO — sorry, Jacques-Henri. Regarding the TLTRO: across the group, we've built up roughly EUR 125 billion of TLTRO III. We've assigned specific portions of those drawdowns across the various business lines. Every business line gets a set amount based on how much it contributes to credit levels — that is, the volume of loans that qualify for TLTRO funding. So a sizable share went to the regional banks, some to LCL, to CACIB, to CACF, and even to FCA Bank, and naturally a portion went directly to CASA. That covers the TLTRO amount. As for what it generates in revenue, I'll leave that calculation to you, since we now view this TLTRO drawing as part of our overall funding. Every entity carries a mix of liabilities, some costly and some cheap. The TLTRO is plainly a cheap liability, particularly during the first 12 months. We also hold some home purchase saving plans that are very costly. Each business line manages a combination of liabilities using its own ALM tools. The TLTRO's benefits really are distributed across the different business lines, and each one has made its own choice about whether to adjust the remainder of its funding.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

Across the world, the group has drawn EUR 125 billion under TLTRO III.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#52

Thanks. That's very clear.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#53

Yeah.

Operator

operator
#54

Moving on, the next question is from Phelbe Pace at Société Générale. Your line is open — go ahead with your question.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#55

Hi there, Phelbe.

Analyst

analyst
#56

Good afternoon. This is Phelbe Pace calling from SocGen. Thanks for the opportunity to ask. My question follows up on the one about Italy, though it's somewhat broader — it concerns how you approach M&A, if I may. Clearly, your capital position is very comfortable at present, and that gives you the option to pursue external growth should you choose to. Still, I suspect that even with the size of your excess capital today, it might prove rather constrained were you to go after bigger, more structural transactions — not the bolt-on kind. So, two questions, please. First, would CASA be willing to take on larger M&A deals that could not be funded purely with cash? Second, do you believe CASA has the capacity to carry out a larger acquisition in the near term? Naturally, one can imagine integration being slowed considerably, and in particular proving harder to execute given the current environment. Those are my questions. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#57

Thanks for that question. First point on this. What drives our strategy or our M&A strategy isn't the amount of surplus capital we're sitting on. It works the other way around entirely. When we spot an operation that fully makes sense strategically, that's accessible, that fits with what we're trying to do, and where every operational aspect is under control. You're quite right to bring up the fact that integrating certain acquisitions is likely harder right now, simply because it's difficult for people to get together and meet. In that kind of situation, we work out how we would finance the deal. It isn't the reverse, where we'd say, "Well, we've got a few billion of excess capital. What could we do with it?" That's absolutely not how we approach it. Are we prepared to enter into an operation that might require more than just our excess cash? Well, we did one in the past. It actually came through Amundi, but Amundi carried out a significant acquisition that needed a capital increase. In fact, CASA gave a guarantee for that capital increase to succeed.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#58

We have shown that it is entirely acceptable on our side when a big subsidiary such as Amundi enters into an M&A deal that cannot be funded purely from its cash position. What matters, once again, is the action we take, rather than the way we fund it. Naturally, after deciding on what we intend to do, we need to arrange financing that fits with what the group is. We begin with the transaction itself. You did mention that, of course. For us, the crucial factors in determining and stating whether a transaction makes sense are, of course, confirming that we can integrate it and that we can produce the kind of profitability we demand from such a transaction. That includes, among other things, the ability to achieve a return on investment of at least 10% after three years, and mainly through cost synergies or genuine synergies, I would say.

Analyst

analyst
#59

That's very clear. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#60

Sure.

Operator

operator
#61

The following question is from Lorraine Quoirez at UBS. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.

Lorraine Quoirez

analyst
#62

Hello there, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#63

Hi there, Lorraine.

Lorraine Quoirez

analyst
#64

Thanks for taking my questions. I've got a couple of follow-ups on M&A as well. The first one: in the past, I believe you stated quite clearly that you weren't interested in acquiring an entity and then having to handle non-performing loan issues. I'd like to know whether that's still true. Then I have another question that's maybe a bit more general. I think near the start of this call — at least in the Q&A session — you mentioned that you operate various kinds of models, clearly through partnerships, where you distribute the products made by the product factory, and that you also effectively own a distribution network. So my question is: do you believe a business model in which you don't own the distribution network at all and instead only work through partnerships is a sustainable one? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#65

Alright, thank you. Well, my position has always been that managing an NPL portfolio was never our business model. I've consistently noted that certain investors specialize in this area. They perform that role very effectively. Typically, they earn substantial profits from it. That isn't our line of work. I'll say it again. In whatever type of operation, what draws our interest isn't the ability to earn money by managing an NPL portfolio, and we state that plainly. As for partnerships and the ability to build business models resting solely on distribution partnerships rather than directly owning distribution networks, well, that's already very much the situation. Since in reality, the complete universal banking model — the ideal version — exists only in France and Italy. In Spain, for instance, you can see our insurance companies have entered into partnerships to distribute their products without controlling any distribution network. The same holds for the consumer credit business. It also holds for Amundi. Even for CACIB. Spain is a classic example of a country where, via partnership, we've succeeded in identifying and running various partnerships without having a retail network or a direct customer base there.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#66

It really fits perfectly with what we do.

Lorraine Quoirez

analyst
#67

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#68

Thanks. The next question is from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#69

Yeah, hello there — good afternoon, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#70

Hi there.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#71

I have a couple of questions too. The first is about cost delivery. In your presentation you said things have been very solid on that front so far this year, and I was wondering whether there is more you can do, or any new ways of operating — particularly with the help of digital channels — that could produce additional savings down the road? That is my first question. Just a few quick ones. On the Corporate Center specifically, is there any guidance for the revenue line? It is rather volatile. Last, you have already talked about the possible effect of lockdown on provisions. If I recall correctly, in earlier quarters you also saw some effect on the insurance side, because you chose to make certain voluntary, let's say, payments, even though there was no obligation, since pandemic risk is not covered. I was wondering whether you are planning to do that again now? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#72

Okay, let me begin with that final question. We can’t definitively exclude things of that kind. As of now, we don’t have any concrete plans for an operation like that. We made a voluntary and quite substantial contribution to all of our professional customers who were affected by the lockdown during the first part of the year. That was entirely voluntary and had no connection to our policies. I believe customers appreciated it greatly for that reason. It isn’t, I’d say, a permanent feature now built into our contracts. Nothing is scheduled at present. On corporate centers — well, clearly that is, and it will stay, fairly volatile. What matters for the corporate center is the trend. Overall, the trend remains positively oriented toward lowering structural costs. Beyond that, we have some more volatile elements that affect the corporate center. We have certain businesses outside the main business lines, and this year they are doing much worse than last year. That is specifically true of the private equity business that we have kept within this corporate center. We also have, as you know — and this also has a significant impact on the revenue line — we also have certain accounting effects stemming from the elimination of intragroup debt issued by CASA and subscribed by Crédit Agricole and Amundi, which are not accounted for in the same way by CASA on one hand and by the investors on the other.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#73

There's some elimination in there that has an effect. Usually the pattern is—take the latest instance, the accounting elimination of intragroup debt—on average it ought to head toward zero, yet it generates volatility. The key point to recognize is that every one of our efforts is producing a gradual decrease in what the corporate center costs. On the cost line, let me begin by noting that we're already under the target we originally set for 2022. Naturally, whenever we're able to outperform the target, we do so. Bear in mind that we committed to a target of coming in under 60% in 2022, and we're now well below that target. We'll keep working on the cost base. Wherever possible, we'll seize the advantage offered by every digitization tool we can access. Incidentally, digitalization doesn't only, and doesn't automatically, bring costs down, since we see digitalization as one more tool, one more feature we offer our customers. It isn't solely, and isn't mainly, a means of lowering the cost base.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

We put a lot of money into this. Across the various business lines, we've pooled a number of IT resources so that, over the medium term, we can produce further cost savings. That takes investment. The good news is that given the very low cost income ratio we've already managed to post, we have the capacity to invest.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#75

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#76

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#77

The next person in our queue is Jean Neuez with Goldman Sachs. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#78

Good afternoon. My first question is a fairly straightforward one about French retail. Commissions came in very strong, especially compared with BNP, which reported yesterday, and they were particularly driven by securities management as well as the insurance business. Securities management could involve somewhat more transactionality, but on insurance — which rose 4% in the first quarter, 18% last quarter and 13% this quarter, all year-over-year — those figures no longer correlate as closely as they once did with the life insurance outstandings you disclose for the same dividends. So I was wondering what drove that, and what you would attribute the discount — or, if you like, the rise in distribution margin, if that's the right term — in that specific business line to. Second, on LCL, the net interest margin is holding up fine. In fact, looking at the aggregate Banque de France data, the front book margin appears to be rising. I just want to understand whether any drag from interest rates is still to come, or whether the commercial margins we can observe at Banque de France are a good indicator for where the margin in that division goes next.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#79

My second question is also about capital ratios, though more at the group level. Clearly, the Caisses Régionale don't distribute much. The group capital ratio now stands at 17%. I take your point that simply having money doesn't mean you suddenly start figuring out how to spend it. Even so, that is a really high capital ratio. In a sense, one could argue it isn't being employed very productively. I just wanted to understand the outlook, because it's building up really fast at group level. For instance, in the investment bank, you might want to, I don't know, originate more and distribute them to revenue seekers such as the Caisses Régionale and things like that. Just to try to understand how the reallocation of that capital could work.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#80

Let me take the second question first. It's a hard one, and interesting too, but there's also an easy way to respond. The thing is, it's structural for the regional banks: they keep raising their capital levels because their cost of equity isn't the same as CASA's, for instance. As you're aware, the capital at the regional banks — the prudential capital behind that solvency level — consists mainly of accumulated reserves, and those reserves don't belong to the mutual shareholders. The mutual shareholders hold a mutual share; what they're entitled to is repayment of that mutual share's nominal amount. They're entitled to remuneration on that nominal amount. The reserves pile up without being allocable — to a clearly identified owner, I'd say. So we don't face the necessity CASA has, or any listed bank has, of remunerating all the prudential capital that's put to work. That's a comfort, no question. It's highly efficient when it comes to generating security and robustness within the group, I'd say. It's also something that matters in the group's overall capital structure, since all the capital we've managed to build at group level with CET1 is capital we don't have to cover with AT1 or Tier two debt — or even TLAC debt — when it comes to constructing the group's various capital ratios.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#81

Oddly enough, that’s an inexpensive method of strengthening our capital ratios. We don’t have to pinpoint investments we might undertake in order to deploy this “excess of capital.” Turning to LCL and the fees LCL recorded this quarter, bear in mind that insurance fees don’t stem solely from life insurance operations. They likewise come from non-life operations. In fact, LCL’s non-life contract portfolio is expanding quickly, since LCL has sharply stepped up equipping its customers with non-life insurance policies. That is producing a cumulative stream of fees ahead, with possibly some volatility tied to the risk level inside this portfolio — the claims experience. Still, it is producing a growing volume of fees, along with fees produced by the life insurance policy. Net interest margin. Well, everyone concentrates solely on home loans, yet that isn’t the sole loan component generating margin for LCL. It’s accurate that for home loans, we witnessed during this quarter a compression, a fairly substantial compression of the gap between the front book and the back book. Approximately, it now stands near 30 bps, whereas historically it has been nearer to 100 bps than to roughly 50 bps to 60 bps.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#82

A 30 bps figure means that, should conditions keep developing the way they have over the recent stretch, we could see the loan yields on the front book and the back book come together, likely sometime around 2022. That would be a positive development, since it would ease the substantial drag currently weighing on the net interest margin in our retail activities.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#83

Alright, Jérôme, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#84

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#85

Thanks. The next question is from Azzurra Guelfi, who is on the line from Citi.

Azzurra Guelfi

analyst
#86

Thanks. Hello, and good afternoon. I have a few questions. First, regarding the volume outlook for France: looking at the most recent ECB lending survey, expectations seem to have softened somewhat from a very high base. Your lending, even when you exclude the state guarantee program, remains quite solid. Could you give us some indication of the outlook across the various parts of the loan book? A couple of quick questions on Italy. First, can you provide the details on the moratoria loans and how those are developing there? The second is just to return to M&A, but very briefly. If I understood correctly, you said you would only consider a deal that makes sense if one arises, and for a retail franchise, it could only be interesting if it also includes the ability to cross-sell for your asset management business, Amundi, or the insurance. Is that a correct understanding of what you mentioned? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#87

Thanks, Azzurra. Let's look at volumes in the French market. Performance has been solid right across the board. In business lending, we actually saw a very sharp deceleration during the second quarter. What we observed in the third quarter was a catch-up, following a period in which state-guaranteed loans accounted for nearly all of our activity. So there's a catch-up effect, but there's also a degree of momentum. In fact, if you look closely at GDP growth for the third quarter, you'll notice that business investment made a substantial contribution to it. The catch-up in the third quarter in France has occurred not just in lending to businesses but in business investment as well. What about the outlook? Honestly, it's very hard to say, because, once again, we're in a sanitary situation that is highly uncertain and constantly shifting, and that is producing some effects on the rest of the activity, and it is certainly generating a wait-and-see stance, particularly regarding investment. In summary, yes, loan evolution in France has shown very good momentum. That has partly fed through into a very significant rise as well in the volume of money placed in on-site deposits, by households and by businesses alike, since at the same time, those liquidity lines have not been drawn down as quickly as they were granted.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#88

In Italy, we have extended roughly EUR 1.8 billion in state-guaranteed loans, and that figure is more or less on par with France — not identical, but roughly similar. We have also offered approximately EUR 800 million in payment holidays, or moratoria. Those have been prolonged through the end of this year, or possibly January 2021. As things stand, we lack the ability to say how it will perform, purely because we are still within the payment holiday period. On M&A, I won't restate what I've already covered. Cross-selling is what our business model consists of, and it consists of getting different business lines to work together. That is all I want to say about that.

Operator

operator
#89

The following question is from Guillaume Tiberghien. Your line is open, so go ahead and ask.

Analyst

analyst
#90

Yes, good morning — or good afternoon. I have a pair of questions. First, once more on the AT1: apologies, but I ended up somewhat confused. You're now telling us to expect above EUR 400 million annually, which is the figure I had in mind prior to Q3. So is that EUR 400 million per year or more below the line, plus a further EUR 200 million per year in insurance? Does it equal the total of those two?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#91

No, no.

Analyst

analyst
#92

So that comes to EUR 400?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#93

Quickly on that question, to be exact: for the full year 2020, EUR 405 million was below the line, meaning booked directly against equity, and roughly EUR 75 was above the line, meaning it ran through P&L. Looking ahead, what gets accounted for on the minority interest line should stay at about EUR 75 million annually, unless Crédit Agricole Assurance makes a new issuance or a repayment. That pace, EUR 75 million above the line, is what we expect going forward. Regarding the AT1 issued by CASA, the EUR 405 this year could be somewhat higher next year, but I gave an indication of EUR 420, simply because we have actually raised the outstanding amount by issuing an additional AT1. That was in September, if I recall correctly. October.

Analyst

analyst
#94

Yeah, EUR 750 million.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#95

Right, exactly — that EUR 750 million one. This adds up a small amount of coupon, and EUR 420 will reflect the full-year effect of this new AT1. I don't want to give any indication of any kind regarding what we could do going forward with all these outstanding AT1s.

Analyst

analyst
#96

Alright, thanks. On the second question — apologies again, since we're dealing with large figures here. Regarding the Corporate Center, the remark you made about TLTRO isn't entirely clear to me. Would it be fair to put it this way: I take Q3 revenues, and within those I assume you've accrued an additional 50 basis points on the EUR 125 billion, or on the CASA share of that EUR 125 billion, and that this will come through for four quarters before coming to an end?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#97

Yes.

Analyst

analyst
#98

Alright, that works.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#99

That's the question, and I don't want to get into the specifics of it—the precise share of what CASA has retained as opposed to what CASA has lent out to the various business lines. Here's the reasoning behind that.

Analyst

analyst
#100

Right, okay. The final question concerns international retail excluding Italy. Clearly, they're dealing with reduced rates and weaker FX. Should we expect additional headwinds from lower rates, or is the present level the new run rate? The follow-up on international retail outside Italy is that the ROE at those businesses, even with a higher cost of risk, is now nearing zero. So the question comes up: wouldn't it eventually make sense to divest those operations so as to be somewhat purer regarding the business model?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#101

Well, first off, the run rate right now — unless there are further local interest rate moves — we're at the run rate, so the minimum run rate, since the most recent rate cuts happened in the second quarter. This level is definitely the new normal. That's before the impact of all the local efforts to grow the top line by improving the revenue mix, generating additional commissions, and so forth. Of course, this level of activity and this level of profitability don't satisfy us. Strategically, what you can see and perhaps what you can recognize is that whenever we believe that, within the scope of businesses we manage, there's a business that doesn't make sense, that doesn't generate the minimum level of profitability we want to post, and that isn't strategic, we don't hesitate to dispose of it. For the time being, we've sold, in several transactions, our 31% in the capital of Banque Saudi Fransi. We've sold Bankoa. We've sold the Bulgarian activities. We're in the process of selling the Romanian activities. We're in the process of selling CACF Netherlands. We don't hesitate, when we deem it necessary to fine-tune our perimeter, in order to be more coherent and more strategically aligned.

Analyst

analyst
#102

Thanks a lot, Jérôme — that’s great.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#103

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#104

The next person to ask a question is Flora Bocahut with Jefferies. Your line is now open, so please go ahead with your question.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#105

Good afternoon. My first question concerns the Switch unwinding. I'd like to know whether you might also consider unwinding the remaining 50% to which you haven't committed, should that become possible down the road. Turning to Crédit Agricole Consumer Finance, where the revenue margin is rebounding this quarter. Based on the slide you referenced, there's a favorable shift in product mix. Could you say more about how that mix is evolving there? My final question relates to the wealth management business, where costs came in significantly better this quarter. Could you elaborate on what drove that and how sustainable it is? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#106

Yes. Let me begin with the Switch. First, two years remain, but over that period we have to honor our pledge to unwind 50% of the Switch mechanism. A further 15% of the total is still outstanding, and before that can happen, we need to see the clawback mechanism function for the triggering at the end of June. Prior to any step, we must wait for the clawback mechanism to operate. Looking at that last 15% will be the first priority. The remaining 50% — five, zero — is definitely a possibility. We have not committed to any kind of timetable, but it is definitely a possibility. On business mix in the consumer credit operations. Well, there are various moves. A tendency exists, set off by regulation, that leads to a permanent decline in the share of revolving loans and a permanent rise in the share of amortizing loans. This is generating a series of different effects. The first effect is that it shrinks somewhat the net margin we generate, but going forward it improves the cost of risk, by definition. A second move is creating more or less the same effect, namely the fact that we have more and more loans granted on the basis of a dedicated investment, such as a car, such as some equipment for the house.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#107

Once more, on margin terms this tends to be somewhat less attractive, yet the risk profile is better, and we'll acknowledge that as we move forward. It's a mix, and naturally we continually try to refine what we offer so that, first, it fits what our customers need and, second, it delivers the greatest efficiency in the blend of revenue, cost and risk. Over the last maybe two years, I'd say we've accompanied the margin pressure we felt with considerable efforts to shrink the cost base so as to adjust the scope of our business. On these consumer credit matters, perhaps I can offer you a rendezvous, since we plan to hold a workshop — a dedicated workshop — on consumer credit activities, similar to the ones we ran a few years ago on insurance and last year on CIB, and it could happen next December, probably on the eighth of December. We'll then have the opportunity to give far more clarity and detail regarding how consumer credit activities are evolving.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#108

Alright, let's turn to the wealth management cost question, please.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#109

On the wealth management cost — sorry, I've lost track of which one that was. Well, regarding the wealth management cost, it's true that for a year and a half now, we've been working extremely hard to improve the profitability of the wealth management activities. In fact, we've succeeded in lowering the cost base of the business and in setting it on a downward trend. During the first nine months of last year, that cost base came to roughly EUR 560 million. This year it stands at around EUR 520 million. That's a meaningful reduction, and we're keeping up our efforts to adapt to an environment where revenues are, without question, somewhat harder to generate.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#110

Thanks. I just want a quick clarification regarding the NIM in CACF. Did you use TLTRO III in that case as well, or was the benefit essentially coming from lower funding costs? That's interesting.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#111

Just a bit. It varies by activity — CACF in France holds a banking license, which means it can tap the TLTRO. FCA Bank is in the same position. Agos, by contrast, is not. That hasn't been true across the board.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#112

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#113

Delphine Lee from JPMorgan has our next question. Your line is open — go ahead and ask.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#114

Hello there, and good afternoon, Jérôme. I have a few follow-ups for you. To start, regarding Italy, could you give us an update on how you're viewing Agos? I believe you've had discussions about the JV — if you could offer some detail on what's happening there. On partnerships more broadly, I'm trying to understand where in Italy you feel you still need to grow, or where there's room for growth when it comes to revenues across the business lines in Italy. My second question concerns capital and how the excess capital gets used. You mentioned Switch, I think, but I'm wondering whether you'd consider buybacks as a way to redistribute some of that excess. Would you ever think about raising the payout ratio a bit from the 50% level it sits at now? If you could share your thinking on that, thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#115

All right. Agos — the picture here is quite straightforward. 61% is held by us, while BPM holds 39%. Between the two of us there's an agreement under which Agos products get distributed across their network. Within that agreement sits a particular clause granting them a right — though naturally, the current climate isn't exactly the ideal moment for exercising it. That clause lets them set an IPO of Agos in motion. Obviously, at this point in time, triggering an IPO in today's conditions isn't something anyone genuinely wants. What the talks center on is how to handle this clause. Should its validity be extended? Under what circumstances might we consider extending that validity, and so forth. This is fairly technical stuff, and none of it alters the fact that the distribution agreement remains fully operational and now spans every BPM branch — something that wasn't true at the outset. As for the partnership in Italy or beyond — well, when we look at how strong the group is, we believe that across a number of business lines — asset management, consumer credit, insurance, both life and non-life, and potentially leasing, factoring and custody as well — we sit among Europe's top players. We've got the expertise, and we've got excellent products.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#116

Our expertise is widely acknowledged. Whenever we can find a way to reach a new customer base, provided it fits with our other partnerships, that represents a good opportunity. We're not out there saying, for instance, that in Italy we need an extra five market share percentage points in this business or that one. It isn't steered by Crédit Agricole SA itself across all the business lines. Rather, it's mostly driven by whether the heads of each business line can identify new partners to work with. Truly, opportunity is what governs it, but rest assured we are constantly working to create new partnerships, and recently. In this quarter by itself, and this appears on slide eight of the slideshow. We received a license in China to establish a new joint venture between Amundi and Bank of China, where we will hold the majority shareholder position. We finalized a partnership with Europ Assistance in France, Europ Assistance, which falls within the scope of Generali. We purchased the remaining 25% stake in GNB Seguros' capital that we did not previously hold, together with consolidating the distribution agreement with Banco Novo.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#117

Obviously, we’re always working on ways to grow those partnerships. Capital. We won’t address the matter of “excess of capital” or undistributed dividend until we get some clarity from the ECB. I think there’s no point in considering all the theoretical possibilities. Once a new framework is in place, we’ll see what we can do, what is relevant, what fits with our DNA, and we’ll give clarity on that. Obviously, we have the ability to pay a dividend, and over the long run, CASA keeps positioning itself as a dividend payer.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#118

Thanks — I really appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#119

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#120

The following question is from Pierre Chedeville, who is with CIC.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#121

Yes, and good afternoon to you, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#122

Yes.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#123

Starting with question one on page 41. In the nota bene, you referenced how sensitive the ECL is if the unfavorable scenario gets weighted by over 10 points or something along those lines, whatever it may be. I was curious whether you take the same approach as U.K. banks, for example, which tend to prefer showing what the deterioration in provisioning would be with the central scenario weighted at 100%, in the case, say, of a degradation of 100 basis points to GDP. I wanted to know whether you had carried out this type of exercise, which in my view is more pertinent for feeling exactly what the risk of an economic degradation that this type of exercise entails.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#124

Honestly, the notion that someone could take every one of a bank's parameters and condense them into one giant spreadsheet — then try to work out what's actually happening and what would occur if you changed a figure in this cell or that cell — strikes me as somewhat of a fantasy. Forgive me for putting it that way.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#125

No, I completely agree there. Yes, I'm on board with that. What I'm getting at is the method, since you're doing the very same thing when you say.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#126

Yeah. We have to do the same, because.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#127

You do exactly the same thing. What I was referring to was the approach of taking a single scenario and giving it a 100% weighting.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#128

Mm-hmm. Instead of

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#129

Instead of three scenarios that I control, I'd put it this way.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#130

So ultimately, once you weight those various scenarios, what you land on is, I'd call it, a synthetic scenario — and that's something you can, I'd say, reverse engineer as well. You're able to say I want that end game scenario, and then I tweak the weighting of the three base scenarios so that I produce the scenario I'm aiming for. Those calculations are something we can run. Whether it meaningfully improves the picture we present to the market, I'm not sure. We'll look at what's possible if we go down this route.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#131

No, I only brought that up since I took part in a debate with Ernst & Young not long ago. We saw that the exercise U.K. banks carried out produced a rise of over 60% in ECL under that kind of exercise. Whereas for French banks, we observe just a modest bump in provisioning when this exercise happens. That was simply my comment.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#132

Judging risk purely from the provision movements in one quarter, or even across an entire year, is hard to do. What you have to begin with is the stock of provisions already sitting on your balance sheet. For the group, that means EUR 20 billion of provisions on our balance sheet, and that already gives us 80% coverage of our NPLs at group level, and 70% at CASA level. That's higher than the average among our peers in the European space.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#133

All right, moving to page 11 for another question. You pointed out that a key strength is net interest income making up just 37% of net banking income. That stems from the savings businesses — some of your savings businesses — within your business model. It also comes from monetary policy, and from the effects of the confinement as well. So my question is more this: if you could dream, what would be the ideal share of net interest income in your business model?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#134

Well—

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#135

Do you see what I’m getting at?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#136

Right, I get your point. What we're showing for the first nine months of 2020, I'd say, isn't all that far off from what we had across the whole of 2019. It's pretty steady, in fact. What's true is that, taking a helicopter view and looking back over roughly the last 10 years, you'll notice a steep drop in how big a share net interest income is of our total revenues, and there are two reasons for that. We've grown the activities that generate non-interest margin substantially, and also, in retail banking, the net interest margin has been squeezed a great deal as we've moved forward. When we laid out the medium-term plan one and a half year ago, we said already that net interest income accounted for about one-third of our revenues and was expected to come down by two percentage points over the course of the medium-term plan. So that's a feature that's already been identified and, in fact, genuinely built into our business model, and not just during the lockdown period.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#137

Alright, my final question has to do with Europ Assistance.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#138

Yes.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#139

From where you sit, was the shift in the partnership about making a cost center better, or was it about making a revenue center better?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#140

It's not truly a switch of partner, actually. What it is, is a switch in business model. With the earlier partner, we were simply a customer holding a long-term contract, and the assistant supplied us with assistant services. Today we're in an entirely different position: we hold a partner stake in the capital of this assistant's French operation. That means, naturally, we've brought our business into this joint venture, yet the joint venture is with Europ Assistance. The strategy differs, and in fact it shows precisely what we have done across the non-life insurance activities from the outset, probably 20 years ago. We begin by learning as a customer of another insurer with more experience than us, or of a reinsurer where needed. Once we've made some progression on the yield curve, we aim as far as possible to be autonomous, to run the business ourselves, or to enter a joint venture via a partnership.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#141

When it comes to our strategy in China.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#142

Perhaps the Chinese strategy too.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#143

Amundi won't be the one using it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#144

We'll hold the majority stake in the new venture we plan to establish alongside Bank of China in China.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#145

Absolutely, and thanks so much for that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#146

Thanks, Pierre.

Operator

operator
#147

Anke Reingen from Royal Bank of Canada has our next question. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#148

Thanks so much for taking my question. First, sorry, this is just a follow-up on the M&A. Could you remind us what the financial criteria are for deals when it comes to EPS accretion and return on investments, and over what time frame? Then second, coming back to cost control. Obviously, performance has been very good on operating leverage and it keeps positively surprising. As you said, you're already at your 2022 target. Can you maybe talk about what has been—or where you've done better than expected when you put the plan together? I don't want to sound negative here, but is there a risk that 2020 benefited from less travel and entertainment, and then we could see a bump up maybe going into next year when things return to somewhat normal? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#149

Thanks. Now, regarding M&A, we apply various criteria, though the key one is our desire for every acquisition to deliver a 10% return on investment after 3 years — and to achieve it in a highly secure way, meaning through either pure cost synergies or revenue synergies that are credible enough. As you're aware, in M&A deals we can often be overly ambitious about revenue synergies. Those tend to be harder to achieve than cost synergies, which are more within reach. That's clearly the primary criterion we'd examine in any such transaction. On cost control, I believe what we've done well — and will keep doing the same way — is decentralizing responsibility for how the cost base evolves across the business lines. After all, who better understands what the relevant cost base at LCL should be than LCL's CEO? He knows precisely where he's headed on revenues as well. He knows exactly what he requires when it comes to branch number evolution and IT development. He fine-tunes the level of the cost base far better than CASA ever could.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#150

That's precisely the approach we intend to keep taking — pushing responsibility downward while also checking on progress at regular intervals and ensuring that plans for corrective action get identified and implemented. It's fair to say that over the past six months, we've seen some benefit from lower spending in certain areas, particularly travel and entertainment, owing to the COVID crisis. At the same time, we've incurred some extra costs tied to the COVID crisis, and those are not negligible. On balance, the net savings are probably genuine, though they aren't all that large. They're likely to stick around, at least in part, since I believe that going forward we won't travel and entertain at the same intensity we did previously. To be clear, certain costs might rebound once this whole health crisis ends, but we will not return to the level we had before.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#151

All right, thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#152

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#153

Thanks. The next question is from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#154

Good afternoon, Jérôme. Thanks for the question. Yes, overall CIB delivered a good performance, but on structured finance specifically, I was just wondering how the deal pipeline was shaping up as you moved into October, since Q4 tends to be somewhat quieter on the CIB financing revenue side seasonally. I'm wondering whether we should build in a somewhat sharper drop-off in the fourth quarter this year. And more broadly, looking across all of your loan books, I wonder whether you've instructed your loan officers to tighten lending standards at all as we head into this second lockdown. I know one of your peers was emphasizing yesterday how this second lockdown is going to be very different from the first. It would just be helpful to hear your views on that topic, please. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#155

Yes. So regarding CIB revenues ahead and the pipeline: the pipeline is accurate — that is, we have been improving considerably over recent years in how we are positioned with our customers. What that means is each time a client of ours wants to engage in an operation — a financing operation, a bond issuance, whatever it may be — we are increasingly often among the banks that could be picked to lead that operation. From that standpoint, the pipeline is quite satisfactory. When our clients will actually trigger the operation depends on circumstances, on their needs, on how the sanitary crisis evolves, probably on how the American presidential election turns out, and so on and so forth. We are very much dependent on clients' decisions about the timetable for their operations. Each time a client of ours wants to engage in an operation, the odds that we get chosen to lead it have risen over the recent period. Did we tighten our credit criteria? That we cannot say. What is certain is that the current lockdown period differs from the earlier one. That is certain. During the first lockdown in France, it was very simple.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#156

There were certain activities that were off-limits, such as restaurants, cafes, bars, and similar establishments, along with some retail stores. A handful of activities were mandatory, and in fact, banks fall under the essential category and were required to keep their branches operating. As for the remaining activity, which makes up the largest share of the French economy, the guiding principle was that you work only when remote work is feasible. This clearly resulted in a very steep drop in activity levels. The principle now is entirely different: you work, and whenever remote work is feasible, you do it remotely. At other times, we know that all businesses, all factories, and all offices have implemented sanitary measures and sanitary protocols that allow work to be carried out on-site safely. That is why I think the impact of this second lockdown will be entirely different on global output and on how GDP evolves. In fact, some economists have already estimated that the impact will probably be at least cut in half compared with what it was during the first lockdown.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#157

Thanks a lot, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#158

I appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#159

That's all from us, sir. Please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#160

All right, thank you all. I’m not sure whether we’ll get together in December the way it was originally planned, but we will talk. Have a good afternoon. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#161

Appreciate it. That brings today’s conference to a close. Many thanks to each of you who took part in today’s call. At this point, everyone may disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.