Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 11, 2021

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 111 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for being with us. And welcome to Crédit Agricole’s conference call on the results for the fourth quarter and the full year 2020. Right now, everyone attending is in a listen-only mode. Following the speakers’ presentation, there will be a question and answer session. <<operator_script>> Please be advised that today’s conference is being recorded. I’d now like to turn the conference over to today’s speaker, Mr. Jerome Grivet. Please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good afternoon, everyone. It's true that 2020 has proven to be quite an unusual year, and I'm glad to turn things over to Philippe Brassac, who is here with us today to walk through his presentation of the results.

Philippe Brassac

executive
#3

Okay, thank you, Jerome, and good afternoon to all of you. This is Philippe Brassac here, and naturally I am still hoping to be able to get together with you as we make use of the opportunity to do the SA in London. But of course I do hope that will be feasible again next year. In any case, I am truly, very, very glad to present, and to — all my key figures, I will stay pessimistic for 2020, and I want to say that I am particularly happy to report that we are able to both commit enormously to the economy and to our staff, helping them get through the crisis, since that is our core mission. And at the same time to achieve a high and consistently high level of profitability, given that return on tangible equity stood at 9.2%. I believe we must rank among the best benchmarks when it comes to return on tangible equity, at least within the French banking group. That is why the Board is presenting this as a special mechanism regarding dividends, to demonstrate our loyalty toward all our shareholders, since that is of course our foremost objective in terms of our relationship with shareholders. And I think we managed to — optimize the dividend and simplify our financial organization, since you saw that we chose to fully unwind our switch mechanism at the next — the final decision was to — for 50% at the end of the current plan and thanks to the level of our solvency.

Philippe Brassac

executive
#4

We chose to announce close to the 100% mark, and I'm glad to say that I'm confident we deliver real value to our economy and to our customers, so we can achieve a high level of profitability and then return to our shareholders to hand them, with this mechanism allowing us to give you the highest level of dividends we could decide, while at the same time simplifying the group's financial organization. That is my main message for the introduction, and I'll hand the floor straight back to Jerome.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Thanks, Philippe. I'll turn back to Page 4 to walk through the key figures for the Group and for Credit Agricole SA, covering both the last quarter and the full year of 2020. Let me begin with CASA on Page 4. Naturally, you'll recall that in December we announced we would partially impair — and quite significantly, in fact — the value of our stake in the capital of Credit Agricole Italia. That, of course, affects the stated net profit figure for the quarter. But as you heard, it has no effect on either our cash position or our solvency. So I'll set this element aside. That means the stated net income Group share, before this goodwill impairment, puts CASA's net profit at about €900, and for the full year it stands close to €3.5 billion. If I restate those figures for the exceptional items — which I'll describe a bit later on in the introduction and in the Appendix — we arrive at an underlying net profit close to €1 billion for the last quarter and close to €3,815 million for the full year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

The decline is just “16%” when measured against the whole of 2019. That comes from a really strong mix: top-line growth exceeding 2% in both the quarter and the full year. Meanwhile the cost line has edged lower, which once more demonstrates our agility, and that brings the cost-to-income ratio to under 60% at this point. As a reminder, that was the goal we had set for 2022. So we have gotten there 2 years early. And this very robust group of operating numbers produces gross operating income rising near 5% across the full year and even approaching 8% in the single quarter, and it absorbed rather well a sizable jump in the cost of risk, which naturally is partly — an insignificant part — tied to provisioning of performing loans. Beyond those items, I should note the solvency at CASA, which at the end of 2020 comes in at 13.1%, including our disposition for this year that I will discuss a bit later. And as Philippe mentioned, we are reporting a return on tangible equity of 9.3%, very solid. Of course it is lower than the figure near 11% that we reported last year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

Part of that decline stems, naturally, from the lower net profit, yet another portion comes from the very solid capital position we again hold this year, reflected in the 13.1% solvency CET1 ratio we are reporting. On Page 5 you will see the matching figures at the Group level. I'll move straight to the underlying net income Group share: €1.4 billion for the Group during the year's final quarter, and roughly €6.1 billion overall across the full year. Once more, that's a healthy mix of a top line that is expanding and a cost line that is shrinking. So we see a solid performance in gross operating income, which absorbs the cost of risk — more than doubled across the full year — including a very strong positioning of the performing loans. That ultimately brings us, at the Group level, to 17.2%. This is a record level, an all-time record for Credit Agricole Group and probably among the strongest figures within the European CC bank space. I believe we can skip Page 6, since Philippe covered most of the elements shown there, and move directly to Page 8, where we give some indication of how we have actually been generating these financial performances.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

If you look at the left side of the page, toward the bottom — the upper portion — you'll find an indication of how the French economy moved across the whole year, month by month. What this chart shows you is that, in fact, the second lockdown had less of an impact than the first. And the second point: each time a lockdown comes to an end, you see activity levels rebound very strongly. For us, this is leading, broadly across all our business lines, to a very strong level of activity in the fourth quarter of the year. That was true for the insurance activities, with a very strong rebound in sales of new policies in P&C and protection. It was also true in asset management activities, where we had a very strong level of net inflows. It was true as well in retail banking activities, in the consumer credit businesses, and also in the CIB. For the full year — and I think it's worth keeping that in mind — we see in retail banking a very positive evolution of loan outstanding, plus 5% excluding these state guaranteed loans, since we often carry the image in our minds that the networks spent most of their time in 2020 producing state guaranteed loans.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

That isn’t accurate. They’ve also been active in home loans, consumer credit loans, and equipment loans for professional and SME customers. Beyond that, I should note that, on a global basis, the three retail banks — the Group in France and Italy — drew in 1.5 million new customers during the full year of 2020. That means we kept concentrating on capturing customers, which is, naturally, essential to the Group’s future development. One last point, on the bottom part of the left-hand side of the page. Taking everything together, after this uneven year, we achieved solid production levels across the Group’s main activities, and those levels come very near the high mark we attained in 2019. For instance, in home loans — new home loan production in France — we succeeded in generating 96% of the home loan production we generated in 2019. So overall that’s a very strong performance. And the picture is similar, for example, for sales of P&C insurance policies, which are close to the same, and for new consumer loan production. On Page 9 there is some indication — some analysis of how our revenues evolved in the last quarter and in the full year of 2020.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

To wrap it up briefly: first, there's the advantage CASA gains from having diversified businesses. That means when certain businesses take a bigger hit from the context in a given quarter, we know others may well outperform — and that's held true both for the quarter and for the full year. The second key point: three quarters of our revenues come from contracts, policies, or items already on our balance sheet. So this means we don't depend so heavily on new transactions to bring in revenue. And the third important point: just 37% of our revenues come directly from net interest margin, which matters a great deal given the situation we faced in 2020, when we saw new rules on interest rates. On the expense side, on Page 10, you'll see we were once again quite agile and quite disciplined in managing our cost base, which is down minus 1.1% for the quarter and minus 0.3% for the full year, leading to a very low cost to income ratio of 59.6%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

We're already hitting the medium-term target level two years early. On Page 11, there's some indication regarding the quality of our loan books, and what you can see is that, globally for the Group and for CASA, we have leveled our NPAs, which continue below 3.2% at CASA and even 2.4% at the Group level. And in both cases, that's down 0.2% compared to the end of September. So it means we're in the situation some people like to describe where all the bank customers are getting worse and worse. And on top of that, we have improved over the quarter the coverage ratio of these NPLs with our loan loss provisions. At CASA level, we have a coverage ratio now at 71.5%, at Group level at 84% — that's 20 percentage points ahead of the average of European banks, as we have seen on the EGA semiannual transparency exercise. The global amount of loan loss reserves that we have at the end of this year stands at 19.6% at Group level and €9.6 billion at CASA level. It's a little bit above what we had at the beginning of this year. So, globally, it improved this year — our capacity to absorb future losses.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

Looking at cost of risk itself on Page 12, the first thing you can see is that the level of additional provisioning in Q4 has come down somewhat relative to Q2 or Q3, both at CASA level and at Group level. And the second key point, which is important to keep in mind, is that across the full year, at CASA, nearly three quarters of the rise in provisioning stems from performing loans, and at Group level it's even more — close to 100% of all the additional provisioning relates to performing loans. So that clearly means this year has been marked by significant efforts, fully consistent with the IFRS 9 regulation, through a cover of future and potential losses and not attuned to risks. Moving to the analysis of net income on Page 13, what you can see is that gross operating income — so the operational income — has grown by close to €500 million over 2019 if I strip out the completion of the supervisory costs, and the decrease in net income between 2019 and 2020 is more than explained by the increase in supervisory costs and by the increase in the cost of risk at stage one and stage two, meaning the cost of the provisioning of performing loans.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

Turning to page 14 and the dividend. Philippe noted that the Board of Credit Agricole SA has resolved to put before the General Assembly Meeting scheduled for May a proposal to pay our shareholders a dividend of €0.80, €0.80 per share. A scrip dividend option is available to investors, and our majority shareholders have stated their intention to elect that scrip option. Thanks to this, we have been able to put forward a dividend at this level, which works out to a dividend yield of roughly 8% for all our shareholders relative to the present share price. The scrip dividend option that our majority shareholders are going to elect will, at the outset, clearly produce a number — a substantial number — of new shares, and therefore a degree of dilution that will hinge on how many new shares we end up issuing, meaning the actual reference price of that issuance is set for next May. And so that we offset this possible initial dilution, we are pairing the dividend proposal with two further mechanisms. The first one, which Philippe also referred to, is to strengthen and amend our commitment regarding the unwinding of the switch mechanism. Originally, the commitment we made was to unwind 50% of the switch by end 2022, and we are now changing that commitment so as to reach 100% of unwinding by end 2022.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

The second thing is that we're also going to introduce a special share buyback program so that this initial dilution gets fully offset. I'm certain you'll have a few questions about these various aspects of the dividend policy. So I suggest we leave the explanation at this point for now, and we'll likely come back to it during the Q&A. Let me move on now to some other key reporting items about what we did in 2020, because beyond the financial numbers, as Philippe said, we kept rolling out our Group project and we kept acting toward our customers in line with our DNA and also in line with our own best interest. That's why we were very active in supporting customers by granting state guaranteed loans, and in fact we gave French customers 27% of all the state guaranteed loan attributed in France. We were also very active in granting payment holidays on pre-existing loans, and at the peak of 2020, more than 550,000 payment holidays had been granted in France for €4.2 billion of deferred maturities. About 80% of all these payment holidays have now ended, and in 98% of the cases, the payments have resumed completely normally.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#15

Beyond that, we have also been quite active when it comes to giving direct assistance to our customers. That was true — with Credit Agricole Europe, which delivered very strong and excellent backing to its small business and self-employed professional policyholders during the second quarter. The same applied across various entities of the Group, which together supplied more than €70 billion in solidarity donations and various forms of support in 2020. We kept building out our global relationship model in 2020, and at the same time we enhanced our digital features, while also continuing to raise the quality, the efficiency and the empowerment of all our staffs who deal with customers, so that we stay compliant with our commitment to deliver the best of digital and the best of human relation to all of our customers. We have kept working in line with our commitments on support to societal conditions, both toward being an ESG leader — which was the case in the investment field of the Group and Credit Agricole SA Europe — and also in the banking areas with CIB, with LCL and with the network of the regional banks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#16

We’ve likewise been quite active on our inclusivity commitment, since we strongly believe in the social role we play around inclusivity, and we have been, for instance, a rather significant employer when it comes to hiring people again and when it comes to offering traineeships to students. We have kept rolling out our global strategy, and as you know, CASA’s strategy is both to continually reinforce how intensely it relates to its customers and to give its specialized business lines the ability to deploy their activities across additional customer bases through all sorts of different partnerships. And indeed we have been very active, notwithstanding the difficulties in Europe, in closing new partnerships in Europe and in Asia across the various specialized business lines we have in insurance, in asset management, in consumer credit or in wealth management. Finally, we have kept divesting non-core assets so as to remain permanently focused on our main strategic lines. Let me now begin with Page 22 and give some additional comments on how the different business divisions of the Group performed, starting with the asset gathering and insurance activities on Page 22. What I think we have witnessed over this year in the asset gathering and insurance business division is a very difficult beginning of the year, with markets in perfect turmoil and then perfectly recovering, and in Q3 as well as in Q4, we have had at once a recovery in the market valuation of our assets, plus strong inflows, and that was again the case in Q4 both in the asset management and the life insurance activities.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

All right, so taking it as a whole, it was a solid quarter — and one that wraps up with the business division's total contribution, which of course took a hit from the very tough start to the year, and that adds up to something quite favorable for the full year. Looking more closely at the insurance operations, what we observed during the year's final quarter was a really robust pickup in activity, with net premium income overall rising 3% versus Q4 2019 and climbing nearly 20% from Q3 to Q4 2020, and this showed up particularly in non-life. That means the P&C and protection operations, which keep delivering a meaningful year-on-year rise and keep posting a very sharp market-share gain in France as well as in the other countries where we operate. On the financial side, the quarter came in very strong, with the top line 3.5% higher and the cost line, helped by taxes, markedly lower. As you may notice, the tax level is up very substantially. That stems from our having booked certain provisions on some assets that weren't tax deductible.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

And one final thing to keep in mind, since Q3, is that the cost of the 81 deaths at Credit Agricole Insurance is now booked directly into P&L rather than against equities. That's why you're seeing a minority interest on the non-controlling interest line that's negative by €34 million this quarter and €80 million for the full year. That said, it has no impact on earnings per share. It's simply a different type of accounting. And so, we stated "from these elements" that the net profit of the business division would have been close in 2020 to what it was in 2019. Amundi and asset management — I think the quarter can be summarized with this idea that we posted two records in 2020 — in Q4 2020. A record level in terms of assets under management at above €1.7 trillion and a record level in terms of net profit on the single quarter. So it's definitely been a very dynamic and positive quarter for Amundi concluding a very good year. LCL on Page 25, very solid quarter and a very solid year indeed. The quarter — this quarter the activity was certainly impacted by the second lockdown that was lifted in Q2 and this explains how we've been able to post a significant increase in the level of loans outstanding on our customer assets.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

Looking at it financially, once again, for both this quarter and the whole year, there was a strongly favorable twofold impact that pushed gross operating income higher, alongside, naturally, a rise in the cost of risk driven by provisioning on performing loans, as has happened across every other business division. On balance, it was a really strong and resilient year for LCL in the transaction. In Italy, the start of the year was likely hit harder by lockdowns than was the case in France, which explains the subdued activity in Q1 and Q2. Things began to bounce back in Q3, and that recovery actually carried on into Q4, and in Q4, for the first quarter of the year, we succeeded in posting top-line growth at Credit Agricole Italia. On top of that, we have of course been recording some extra provisions, yet this was helped by a very sizable sale of an NPL portfolio. We have kept improving the NPL level, which is lower, and the coverage ratio, which is higher this quarter. So it was a very resilient quarter for Credit Agricole Italia. Overall, in Italy, you can find the various figures we typically report about our — regarding our Italian operations on Page 27.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

What I can say is that, on a global basis in Italy across the entire year, we succeeded in maintaining a very elevated level of profitability — €571 million of underlying net income Group share for the full year, which represents a decline of only 11% versus the identical figure in 2019. Perhaps also worth adding a few points regarding the Creval transaction, which is progressing exactly in line with the original timetable. We announced the offer on November the 23rd, having completed all the filings in mid-December. We obtained the final clearance from the European Union regarding antitrust authorities at the start of February. Approval from the Italian authorities has also been received. As a result, we must now await the ECB approval, after which we can submit the offer file with the consult so as to effectively launch the offer. We are therefore entirely on schedule. Turning to the remaining international banking activities on Page 28, obviously it has been a tough year, since in the majority of countries where we operate, two unfavorable factors have arisen. The first consisted of a substantial drop in interest rates, delivered as the monetary authority's response to the crisis, and that has placed considerable pressure on revenues; on top of this, we found ourselves obliged to set aside a significant additional provision.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#21

However, we're now gradually rebuilding that coverage ratio—across all these business divisions, our non-performing loan coverage sits above 100%. Beyond that, at the start of January we announced that we've signed a deal to dispose of our banking operations in Romania, which had been up for sale for a rather long time. Turning to the specialized financial services division—consumer credit card financing, leasing, and factoring—once again, the year's final quarter stood out for a sharp pickup in activity levels, and to illustrate, December actually turned out to be the strongest month of the year, which isn't normally the case. So that helped keep the decline in global loans outstanding to roughly minus 1.3%. Naturally, that wasn't quite sufficient to protect the top-line. Still, what I find remarkable is how this business division can readjust its cost base to try to preserve profitability as much as possible. In the last quarter of the year alone, the cost-to-income ratio comes in under 49%. So it's a highly reactive approach. Cost of risk for the quarter is higher than in Q4 of 2019, yet somewhat lower than in Q3 2020.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#22

So it's clear that within this business division, we're not facing a scenario of a severe credit crisis deterioration once more. Turning to the large customer division, what stands out is that volumes were somewhat lower in Q2 and Q3 of the last quarter, yet even so, activity has held at a very solid level compared with Q4 2019, since globally our revenues are up slightly above 1%. In asset servicing activities, we're now in a position where the integration of Santander Security Services into the assays perimeter is progressively paying off, and so we will gradually offset the minority interest we recognized for our minority shareholder Santander. Drilling down on taxes now on Page 31, this quarter we saw top-line stability, which is actually attributable to Forex effects, because absent those Forex effects, revenues would have been slightly higher. What's interesting to note, though, is that for the full year we're posting revenues up close to 9%, helped by very good cost control. Gross operating income in this business is up close to 15%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#23

Even with the very sharp rise in the cost of risk — which is a multiplication by five for the full year — keep in mind that in H1 2019 we were still in a situation of loan loss provision reversal. So we’ve been able to absorb it very significantly. This raised the cost of risk. We are keeping a very high level of profitability for the CIB division, close to €1.2 billion for the full year. And again, I want to note the very attractive cost to income ratio as stated. On Corporate Centre, we continue to improve it structurally since in Q4 of 2020 we were a little bit down as compared to Q3, but actually that’s mainly due to the tax effect. If I zoom on the revenue line or on the cost line, the improvement continues to be here quite significantly this quarter again. For the Regional Banks of Credit Agricole, of course, we will find more or less the same trends as the one we have seen at LCL, a very dynamic level of activity in Q4. Very good cost control. Of course with an increase in the cost of risk, but if you see the performance for the full year, you will note that again for this perimeter, whole of the regional banks of Credit Agricole, the configuration to the net profit of the Group is down only 14% despite a multiplication by more than two in the cost of risk.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#24

So again, that very strong resilience in the other portion of the P&L has been able to absorb both the rise in cost of risk — and once more, this increase in cost of risk consisted mainly of provisioning for performing loans. Across the full year, Credit Agricole's regional banks succeeded in bringing in over one million new customers. So customer attractivity is very significant. Moving now to Page 36, that covers financial strength and solvency at the CASA level. In terms of RWA evolution, you'll see we did very well this quarter. And indeed, overall RWA evolution is slightly down — let's call it stable between the end of September and the end of December. That comes from a combination of a decrease in the business line's contribution, a modest rise in the insurance contribution owing to the net profit not yet paid to CASA in the form of a dividend, and then some methodological and regulatory effects, which altogether amount to an increase of a little bit more than 5 billion RWAs. This leads to a solvency ratio rising significantly between the end of September and the end of December. That is, of course, a result of the Group's profitability level, plus the fact that our dividend policy will have a smaller impact on solvency than the one we had provisioned and approved at the end of September.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#25

There's a favorable impact from the distribution this quarter, which is a bit counterintuitive. The RWA evolution, given what I've mentioned, is also positive, and then you get certain technical, methodological, and regulatory effects that slightly bite into the solvency ratio. But we closed the year at 13.1%, and if I subtract right away from that level the effect of the announced decision that 15% of the switch mechanism will take place at the end of March, it will still leave us with a solvency of 12.9%. So, well above any regulatory requirements. At the Group level, we also have a very high solvency level with more or less the same elements. A fairly flattish evolution of the RWA basis, up 2 billion over the quarter. A very strong level of results integrated into the solvency, and all the other technical elements don't play a significant role. So, all in all, a 17.2% CET1 ratio, which of course also triggers a very high level of TLAC and annual ratio as well as a high leverage ratio. Liquidity is definitely not an issue. Our LCR ratio reserves, all our indicators are at their highest levels ever.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#26

It's just worth pointing out on this page that regarding TLC's overall growth, we finished the year with €133 billion in total outstanding for the Group worldwide. On funding markets, funding on Page 39, the 2020 program was certainly completed under very favorable conditions, and we've announced a 2021 program that will be smaller given the ample liquidity we hold, and it will focus on TLAC eligible debt rather than senior preferred unsecured debt. I think we can wrap up the presentation now, and I'm more than happy to take your questions. Naturally, Philippe will be here if you'd like to put some questions directly to him.

Operator

operator
#27

Our opening question is from Giulia Miotto of Morgan Stanley. Go ahead, your line is open.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#28

Yes. Hello. Good morning. Are you able to hear me?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#29

Yes. That's exactly right.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#30

All right, great. So let's return to that €0.80 dividend if we can. Would you mind clarifying — apologies — the timing around this statute? As I understand it, the share buyback is what occurred in Q4. And then second, the 20 basis point reduction in capital requirements communicated by the ECB — how significant was that announcement, speaking to it? That's my first question. Then for my second question, we've noticed some shifts in the competitive landscape in France, and I was wondering whether that carries any implications, and whether the Group is contemplating any senior movement? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#31

Regarding the dividend, let me be exact: the share buyback will take place in 2 stages. The initial stage is permissible prior to the conclusion of the current ECB recommendation, since it falls within the dividend policy we have communicated to the ECB. Allow me to clarify it in this manner. The ECB has given us approval to distribute this dividend on the understanding that the majority shareholder will elect the scrip dividend option, along with the employees' mutual fund. So, roughly 60% of the dividend will be distributed in the form of shares. And our conservative assumption — which is procurement carrying a 20 BPS CET1 impact at Group level — is that the remaining portion of the dividend will be distributed in cash. That remaining portion of the dividend is therefore 40%. Should some proportion of minority shareholders opt for scrip instead of cash, that will generate extra shares and extra capital beyond, shall I say, the conservative assumption we have established with the ECB, and all shares created beyond that conservative assumption may be repurchased and cancelled prior to the conclusion of the recommendation.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#32

Honestly, I can't tell you precisely how big this initial tranche of the buyback will end up being, since by definition I don't yet know how much the minority shareholder will take up. It most likely won't be — that much is certain, and looking back historically it has consistently come in around the conserved level. But what it will be this time around, I can't say for sure, and the one thing I do know is that every one of those shares is eligible for repurchase before the close of September. After that, we'll carry out a severance buyback operation, and that one has to wait for the ECB's recommendation period to end, plus it will need a specific authorization from the ECB. So under no circumstances will it happen ahead of the end of September. And that second operation will be sized so that it offsets — so that it fully offsets the final piece of dilution that might still be left once the switch has been unwound and once the first tranche of the buyback is done. That's exactly why pinning down the buyback amount with precision is so hard for us. So as we've stated, it could reach a maximum of 5% of the capital, and it hinges entirely, first of all, on the share price at which we'll issue in May.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#33

Also, regarding how many minority shareholders participate — I’m not sure whether I’ve made that fully clear, and I hope I have. But I believe your second question about the dividend has also been addressed: namely, we assume no participation from minority shareholders, and therefore the assumption that 14% of the dividend will be paid in cash is the figure consistent with the 20 BPS effect on the Group’s CET1 ratio. Turning to the competitive situation in France, we have always operated in a highly competitive market there, that is certain. And we have shown — through the regional banks of Credit Agricole on one side and LCL on the other, as well as CACEIS for wholesale banking activities — that we know how to operate within a competitive environment and how to seek market share and win customers. So we have not observed any meaningful shifts in France’s competitive landscape, particularly in 2020. Our focus has been, first, on adapting our set-up to the environment and to the COVID crisis, and second, on trying to keep developing activities. But clearly, the landscape was competitive, it remains competitive, and we do not expect it to become less competitive in the future.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#34

I appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#35

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#36

Thanks. We now have a question from Jacques-Henri Gaulard of Kepler Cheuvreux. Go ahead, your line is open.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#37

Yes. Good afternoon, gentlemen. Two questions from me, both returning to that €0.80. It breaks down into two parts. First, I'd like confirmation that this entire set-up is genuinely specific to 2020, distribution obviously included. And if so, are you going to revise somewhat the way you split the excess capital among acquisitions, capital returns, and the minimum fees requirement — does that change relative to your 2022 plan, given what you have announced? That's the first set of questions. And the second one: it's remarkable how this set-up really demonstrates how you are relying on the mode of interest within the Group — between clients, between shareholders — which is a big efficiency here. Could you have done that five, six years ago? Or do you feel that only now, with the way the Group is organized, is there something that could effectively be done? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

Thanks for those questions, Jacques-Henri. I’ll try to address every part of what you asked in a single response, since what we’re doing this year really is specific. We’re in a particular set of circumstances — one that the ECB’s constraints have created. It’s specific because we still have that remaining 50% in the switch mechanism, which we intend to use at some point, and we now have the opportunity to do so; and we’re certainly in a specific situation that will persist, since it’s part of our DNA: we have these majority shareholders. So yes, we are adopting specific measures to deal with this year’s particular situation, drawing on the Group’s specific organization. But we won’t keep repeating this particular combination of elements going forward, because we don’t want to — what we’re aiming for, as Credit Agricole SA wants for its shareholders, is to behave like an investor-friendly vehicle. So we consider it relevant this year to address the specific situation through this specific set of measures. But going forward, we will return to a normal cash dividend payout, in the hope that these constraints won’t be there in the future.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#39

So what will we do to make up for the portion of the dividend that wasn’t paid in 2019? We’ll see. The thinking is that, clearly, we’ve observed that once all these operations are done, we’ll end up with an excess of capital that will remain significant. Again, it hinges on the price at which the new share gets issued and therefore the count of new shares; probably, after all these operations, we’ll land near 12% in solvency terms. That’s well above our 11% target. So we’ll have some timing question, but probably, once the situation is clear, to reassess and update our capital trajectory, and that’s something we’ll probably do during this year.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#40

Great. Thanks so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#41

I appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#42

Thanks. The next person to ask a question is on the line from Goldman Sachs Group — Jean Neuez. Go ahead with your question. Your line is open.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#43

Yes, good afternoon. So I'll need to pick up a bit more on the dividend topic. Put simply, my question is this: will that €0.80 — looking back over the past, it's a larger figure than the dividends under the regular — than when it was meant to be paid. And I just wondered whether — so you hinted that perhaps the next one comes after 2020, since you still have so many shifts remaining from 2019. But I simply wanted to grasp whether, in your view, and given that you've described this €0.80, so to speak, as our precedent, you consider it acceptable from here if it has to come down again — you see, plenty of companies dislike having — the dividend fall back down, and what they term a special dividend. So I just wanted to understand your thinking on the somewhat more forward-looking portion of the DPS, which matters for income funds. And the second item I wanted to raise is about asset gathering and your approach of plugging your product factory into networks. So for instance, right now you're also doing this, potentially with the acquisition of Creval. But for example, we observed that renewing the agreements with certain banks has caused them to opt for open architecture, which to some degree weakens — one could argue — the competitive position, or the exclusivity, of some of your product factory.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#44

I'd like to get your view on what lies ahead, especially if consolidation takes place across European banking — are you considering accelerating growth in acquiring networks, or adding them through acquisitions, or do you see more chances to form fresh partnerships that would compensate for those that might become somewhat weaker down the road? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#45

Thank you, Jean Neuez, for those questions. Let me return to your first one. Honestly, it is far too soon to say what we will do beyond 2021. What is clear in our thinking is that we will pay a dividend of €0.80, on the basis of a total intended dividend that I would describe as €0.70 for 2019 and probably somewhere around €0.60 for 2020. That means we will have paid roughly €0.80 out of €1.2 in dividends that could be accrued based on our results for 2019 and 2020. So we believe we have the capacity, over the coming two to three years, to in some way supplement our usual traditional dividend policy for shareholders. That said, I cannot give you anything precise about the level, how it would be spread out, how it would translate into a commitment, and so on and so forth. It is far too early. I will give you a — I will make your assumptions hypothetical for you. It is simply that, if you look back, the bulk of what has just been explained, with all these operations, is that we would have paid €0.80 out of €1.2.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#46

When it comes to gathering assets and how we can keep building out our distribution capability going forward, I think you've seen that — we did that during 2020 in spite of the year's difficulties. The plan is clearly to keep signing partnerships, and at times we will sign partnerships with banks that later change their mind or end up in a merger that terminates the cooperation with us. But the point is that we are able on a regular basis to sign new partnerships, because our business lines — specialized business lines in asset management, in the insurance business, but also in consumer credit and so on — are strong. They are attractive, and they can give our partners the ability to improve what they offer their customers. So if one of our partners decides to terminate the partnership or to move to an open architecture, well, then we — again, we have the ability, and we demonstrated it once more in 2020, to keep launching new partnerships so as to keep growing the distribution capacity of all our business lines.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#47

Right. So compared with how things used to be, that doesn’t make buying banks any more appealing? I realize that’s…

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#48

No. No. No — look, clearly the operation we've launched on Creval is very specific, and it's tied directly to the fact that we're already a retail bank in Italy. So we have the capacity to generate cost synergies, revenue synergies, and funding cost synergies by merging Creval and Credit Agricole Italia. But we don't need to grab control of additional distribution capacity. We still think that for banks that are successful in their banking business, in their core business, but need to enhance the quality and the variety of their product offer, it's attractive for them to enter into partnerships with our business lines.

Jean Neuez

analyst
#49

All right, thank you. That's very clear.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#50

Thank you.

Operator

operator
#51

Thanks. We’ll take the next question from Omar Fall at Barclays Bank. Go ahead — your line is open.

Omar Fall

analyst
#52

Good afternoon there. Is my voice coming through to you okay?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#53

Omar, thanks — go ahead.

Omar Fall

analyst
#54

Okay, a few questions from my side. If I look at roughly 800 million of stage one and two provisions, you're essentially reaching your 11% ROCE target under the MTP without doing much else — and keep in mind you're holding more capital than your target. Are you still comfortable with that 11% goal? Because I'd imagine for most banks hitting a double-digit figure is a struggle. So, assuming the macro backdrop plays out as expected, what other headwinds should we consider that could keep you from reaching that number? Is it simply normalization of capital markets revenue? I don't expect you to say you'll be on target for none of them — I'm just trying to figure out what the potential headwinds are. And then, a broader question: from your presentation, there's mention of the potential transformation of all those excess retail deposits from individuals due to the pandemic — the possibility of shifting them into linked products, mutual funds. I would have thought this trend would be a key one for you — for all the banks. Is that because you don't see solvency yet, or do you think these extra savings will just sit in, say, deposits, and indeed they are?

Omar Fall

analyst
#55

Appreciate it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#56

Regarding your first question, it is accurate that we came near an 11% return on tangible equity back in 2019. During this year, we incurred this extra stage one and stage two provisioning, and that explains why we are down again to 9.3% — yes, indeed, 9.3% for this year. That is a very solid and strong-performing level. Our target remains 11%. We are watching which positive and negative factors will assist us and which will prevent us from getting there. I am certain plenty of uncertainties still lie ahead. So I am certain we will have to work hard to get back to that 11% level once more. And I cannot say, of course, that we will lift this target, because we came close to it this year if you restate the numbers once again for S1 and S2 provisioning. So headwinds may arise. Tailwinds may arise going forward. I believe our thinking and our commitment is to attempt to hit the target under virtually any mix of headwinds and tailwinds.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#57

Looking ahead, money shifting into products built for longer-term saving could become another source of business for both our insurance operations and our asset management operations. During 2020 we did not observe a particularly strong pattern of customers making that kind of move, and what we saw instead was a steadily rising level of side deposits, and they are impaired and so on. Because there has been some, I would say — from our customers, and I think this will not change until the sanitary situation is — settled, which we expect to happen probably around the middle of this year and not before. So naturally we are ready — Amundi is ready, Credit Agricole SA is ready — to present offers to customers who would like to invest those amounts over longer horizons as soon as they gain more clarity about their own future. For the moment, though, that is not really what we are seeing, but of course we are ready to be clear if and when customers wish to make longer-term decisions with their savings.

Omar Fall

analyst
#58

Thanks. And a cheeky little follow-up, if I may. Just on NII and LCL, very quickly — there's a big jump there that you said came from favorable refi conditions. Sorry if I missed that. Is that TLTRO, which I thought you did in most of the acquisitions?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#59

I'd say it's a mix of factors at LCL. NII goes up roughly €30 million from Q3 to Q4, and close to €50 million, if I recall right, on a Q4-over-Q4 basis. That gain stems from a volume effect — by definition, loans outstanding are rising, and that helps. Refinancing conditions play a role too, and the TLC carry accounts for part of it. There's also something we've talked about: LCL — again, this is a plus from the global group we belong to — has sold a portfolio of loans to Credit Agricole Europe. Credit Agricole Europe wants assets that are both safe and offer better returns than bonds, while LCL is eager not to tie up too much liquidity. So they offloaded a home loan portfolio — about €400 million of loans — to the creditor during the last quarter, and it locked in a capital gain that's small but significant given how the NII moved. That's a piece of why the NII improved this quarter.

Omar Fall

analyst
#60

Thanks, Jerome.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#61

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#62

Thanks. We’ll go next to Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Go ahead with your question. Your line is open.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#63

Yes. Good afternoon. Our first question is about Basel 4. Could you bring us up to date on what the effect will be and, if you can, provide some specifics regarding the timing and the range of areas where that effect will be felt? The second question concerns the partnership in consumer credit: apart from the 89 million dispute on FCA Bank, it is only 50 million, whereas we were accustomed to 70 million or 80 million each quarter, so starting from the 51 in Q4, what would a sort of new normal look like in Q1? And then the last one, if I may: your present liquidity targets were announced before 5, article 104. So will you be lowering it? And so, if you could give a story of the next strategic plan, the story in one year? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#64

Basel 4 feels like a story with no ending. It has been delayed. As things stand, the schedule calls for it to take effect in 2023, and we are still awaiting the European Commission's draft proposal for the directive. And the full ramp-up of the output floor through our mechanism is probably going to land somewhere around 2027 or 2028, placing things positively. So it is definitely a long shot. And right now we do not have complete clarity on how the various elements will be fine-tuned. Once the European Commission's draft proposal is available, we will be in a position to assess the impacts more precisely. But let me remind you that, when the medium-term plan was published, we stated this would mean a 60 bps impact on CASA's CET1 at the point of entry into force. So for the time being we are holding that order of magnitude in mind, but we will fine-tune this better and assess this impact more accurately once we have the commission's draft directive, which is probably expected this spring. Nevertheless, I think that — and this also ties to your last question — as I said earlier, we were going to update our capital planning going forward.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#65

We can accomplish that by incorporating the Basel 4 impact and also taking fully into account this article 104, a. That has a favorable effect that ought to result in — on the CET1 requirement given that a portion of the PR2 requirement is coverable with subordinated debt. So, clearly, this might lead to the conclusion you have in mind. As for the various changes in the car financing business and in the consumer credit and car financing business, well I believe the drop in the contribution level this quarter stems mainly from the fact that, aside from the one off — positive one off effect on the FCA disputes, all these NPTs have been booked as they land directly at TACS additional provision over the last two or three quarters. So this has — a modest decline in the equity accounted contribution, but production at the car financing entities has been very good in the last period of the year, both in China and in Europe. And the other entities accounted for on this line are beginning to recover as well. So, I expect that this level you are mentioning is a bit of a low point that we will be able to recover going forward.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#66

Much appreciated.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#67

Thanks, Guillaume.

Operator

operator
#68

Thanks. The next question is from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. Go ahead, your line is open.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#69

Hello there, and good afternoon. I have a few questions, if I may. To start, let's revisit the dividend. It clearly took some engineering, though it is welcome. I was simply wondering why you chose not to remain within the limits the ECB requires until the end of September and then make a large payment — big payments — after that point. Because, if I am not mistaken — please correct me — the approach you are taking means ownership will rise somewhat from the — to spell it out, you will raise a bit, since even with the buyback, would that fully offset the share issues? Please correct me if I have that wrong. Second, on the — on capital, regarding the switch to repayments: do you believe that could trigger anything lower than your guidance on script, or was there no concern from the ECB, or any add-ons, in relation to that? Finally, on cost of risk, I know we ask this every time, but could you give us an indication of the 2021 cost of risk level and how it will compare with the slightly cost of risk guidance of 40 basis points? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#70

Thanks, Tarik, for those questions. The first one: why not just hold off until September and then make an extra payment in the final quarter? Honestly, that was our plan last year. Our thinking last year was that we'd wait for Q4, and during Q4 we'd manage to pay something. What actually happened is that, for certain reasons we can understand, it simply wasn't possible. So this year, clearly, we decided that since we had the capacity, with some engineering, to give our shareholders that optionality right away, we felt it was better and gave more assurance to our minority shareholders to provide this optionality. A one-off straight away in May, as in a normal year, and after that it's our job to ensure that at a certain point in time we can carry out the share buyback we have in mind so as to fully offset the valuation. That's why we considered it relevant to put in place this engineering you're referring to. This will, or this may, indeed result in some dilution of the accessibility in CASA's capital — that's true.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#71

But it's going to be small nonetheless, and bear in mind that each and every year, with these capital hikes earmarked for the reviews, the size is capped in some way. So overall, there are movements, and accessibility has always been — and always will be — in that area of 55% plus, up to 57%, 58%, whatever. That has shifted considerably. That's versus the capital of the Group, and it wasn't much of a comeback given all the benefits we're extending to our minority shareholder through this security and this optionality that we're offering them directly. Will the switch dismantlement cause a change in the guidance? I don't know. I'm absolutely not able to say, and we'll see down the road once it has been carried out and finished. How the ECB will respond to that — it isn't part of our thinking. That fits perfectly. It's a very tough question. If we're correct — that is, if our reading of this crisis is correct, if our reading of the fact that the public policies enacted in response to the crisis is correct, and so far they have been correct — then the pandemic will be monitored and held under control somewhere in the middle of this year, and if the various public support measures aren't withdrawn too quickly, we believe the improvement in the economic backdrop could be very sharp, and even sharper than most observers expect.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#72

So clearly, we believe this ought to bring about a situation in which the cost of risk for 2021 comes in below what we saw in 2020. But once more, the key word in this environment is uncertainty — and particularly uncertainty around the timetable. In my view, what is certain is the fact that at some point the pandemic will be brought under control and will come to an end. What remains uncertain is the timetable, the precise timetable, and it is important to keep that in mind.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#73

Thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

Much appreciated.

Operator

operator
#75

Thank you. We now take a question from Azzurra Guelfi at Citi. Go ahead — your line is open.

Azzurra Guelfi

analyst
#76

Good afternoon, and thanks for taking the questions. I have two. The first concerns volume and what demand will look like over the next few months, since some restrictions appear to still be in effect — how will that impact demand, particularly given that corporate demand has been, shall we say, more stable during the fourth quarter on a sustained basis? And any color you can offer on the state guaranteed loans would be helpful. My second question relates to large corporate and revenue, which has come in somewhat soft relative to what you typically deliver — and also relative to PS. Could you explain whether you are seeing anything there, and do you have any plan in place to address the currency consideration?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#77

Okay, Azzurra — I'll begin with the final question you raised, since that one carries real priority. It is accurate that SIC activities delivered strong results in certain segments during Q4. However, that strength showed up in segments where our presence is limited, and those segments are the commodities markets — and commodities is not a space where we operate. It is the hedge fund portion of the client base, and hedge funds are not a segment we serve. And it is, in particular, U.S.-based activity, where our footprint is smaller than that of most of our rivals — our direct competitors. That is the reason it may look as though we underperformed somewhat this quarter. Yet one really ought to examine more closely which business lines did well versus those that were softer — not just for us, but across the whole market — and you will see that what took place in Q4 is entirely normal and reveals no sort of malfunction in our businesses. So my confidence is high. To the contrary, we strengthened our overall positioning in the CIB field during 2020, and that will be consolidated as we move ahead. Now let me turn to your question regarding credit demand volumes, and so on and so forth.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#78

Naturally, it's hard to say for sure. What I can say is that we remain active, our networks remain active, and we still see a certain level of demand for new state-guaranteed loans. As you're aware, the mechanism in France has been extended given that business restrictions are still in place, and we keep seeing a certain amount of credit demand. And you know that with this extension of the TLTRO benefits that we may claim from June 21 to June 22, we now have to track how eligible loans evolve from the start of October 20 through December 21. That's the new reference point for qualifying for the extension of the premium. And so far, I can tell you that volumes since that date at the start of October remain higher within this perimeter in France. Okay?

Operator

operator
#79

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#80

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#81

Our next question is from Pierre Chedeville at CIC. Go ahead, your line is open.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#82

Yes. Are you able to hear me?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#83

Yeah, Pierre, that's absolutely right.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#84

Alright. The first question concerns insurance, and to be more specific, I'd like to know whether — you've talked a great deal about the partnerships you want to build in order to grow overall, but my focus is on insurance, and I'd like to know if, aside from Italy, you have any expansion plans in other countries, and I was thinking, for example, of developing creditor insurance, given your significant presence in consumer credit, or other kinds of insurance products internationally, since in France you are number one. And in Italy, you are already number 6. That's the first question. The second question: like most of us, we're trying to work out the magic behind the very good figures at LCL, and I was wondering where you stand on the private bank activity within LCL, because we don't see many figures on this aspect of the question inside LCL, and we know that your main competitors are putting a lot of focus on private bank in their retail network. And my last question concerns the TLTRO — one of your competitors explained to us what he did and took some benefit in this account with regard to the TLTRO, because as you probably know, you have some holdings regarding the way we account for the TLTRO as long as we don't use it.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#85

So my question is this: you're taking a more aggressive position on this accounting matter, and I'd like to understand the reason behind that. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#86

Appreciate the questions. Let me start with insurance activities — it isn't quite accurate to say we limit ourselves to Italy when it comes to building our partnerships, since, as you may be aware, we closed the partnership in Spain to grow a P&C insurance business, and we've also raised our stake, pushing it all the way up to 100% of the capital of NOVO BANCO Insurance in Portugal. So we definitely aren't confined to Italy, and we consider it reasonable and feasible to broaden our insurance footprint into other European countries. Beyond that, I should note that our creditor insurance business actually follows our consumer credit business throughout Europe. And in fact, we've had a creditor insurance company based in Dublin, Ireland, that offers its products throughout Europe using European passports together with our consumer credit activities. So we are indeed active in creditor insurance, and we generate a great deal of creditor insurance product sales across Europe simply by accompanying our consumer credit business. At LCL, well, I'd say it is doing well overall. LCL has made choices about concentrating its development in certain areas and about being very customer-centric and customer-oriented.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#87

If you look at the assets that LCL manages, they stood at €46 billion at the close of 2018, and today that number is €54 billion. So in the space of two years, that's really a substantial rise, and at the same time — wealth management, meaning the dedicated private banking entity we have. Assets under management, which are larger in volume terms, dipped slightly owing to the refocusing of the business that we've carried out. So it's clear that private banking at LCL is developing quite dynamically, and that shows up in the higher fees LCL earns from this activity. So that's one more factor explaining LCL's strong performance.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#88

And what about the TLTRO?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#89

Now, on the TLTRO — sorry — we've directly recognized and accrued the benefit from that first premium, the one running from June 20 to June 21. We accrue it as time goes by, spread across that one-year period, simply because the condition required to earn the premiums has already been satisfied. So we saw no reason to accrue this premium across two years when the condition had already been met. And from looking at what all our competitors have published, we've seen that we weren't the only ones doing this. It appears another competitor is accruing it across three years. I don't know precisely why, but for us it's very clear: given that the condition was met, accruing over one year was the only reasonable accounting treatment, and in fact our auditors have fully validated it.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#90

Alright, that's not an issue. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#91

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#92

Much appreciated. We now move to Jon Peace of Crédit Suisse, who has a question for us. Go right ahead — your line is open.

Jon Peace

unknown
#93

Thanks. Hey there, Jerome.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#94

Hello there, Jon.

Jon Peace

unknown
#95

I’d like to pose Tarik’s question about cost of risk a bit differently. Several of your Benelux peers have now indicated that cost of risk will be only slightly above the through-the-cycle rate in 2021. And if economic conditions were favorable enough for them to actually achieve that, given your strong coverage—your superior coverage—would you expect your trends to differ from those peers? Then my second question concerns the switch. Once we’re past the first quarter of 2021, how quickly do you plan to retire the remaining 60%? Should that be linear, or back-end loaded with retained earnings? And since you’ve decided to retire the switch, could we interpret that as meaning you don’t foresee any larger M&A over two years—just bolt-on deals? Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#96

Okay, good questions once more. Starting with the risk side: yes, it's a fact that our coverage ratio sits above that of most peers. Yet that's plainly embedded in our DNA. So it doesn't imply we're simply here to bring that coverage ratio down should risk increase, and therefore we will manage through time with a structurally elevated coverage ratio, since that is unmistakably embedded in our DNA, and we will move alongside how the economic landscape develops and we will record whatever provisions become necessary as we go forward. And so, I can't say precisely what the cost of risk will turn out to be. What I will say is that, assuming our assumptions hold, it ought to be, in 2021, lower than was the case in 2020. Across a cycle, the assumptions we'd formulated were that at the CASA level it ought to be roughly 40 BPS and that the level of the — it ought to be roughly 25 BPS. We stood at 62 and 38 respectively last year. So a certain gap exists between those two figures. And once more, our business is more about achieving our performances rather than concentrating on them, so we will keep concentrating on delivering rather than on fine tuning our forecast, if you'll permit us.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#97

Regarding the switch, I can't tell you right now precisely what the schedule will look like. Naturally, we're once again operating in a fairly unpredictable setting. So we felt that the clearest way to convey our dedication was to state that we had pledged to cover 50% of the mechanism by the end of 2022. We've simply adjusted the scale of that pledge, saying that we will unwind 100% by 2022. That slide should give you some hints about timing and so forth, but I don't know. We'll see. All of this, of course, is quite recent activity dating from December 15, the date on which the ECB released its recommendations, and we've been talking with the ECB to confirm that our dividend arrangement was acceptable to it. We haven't had much time to fine-tune the schedule for unwinding the switch mechanism. So we'll see, but the commitment is to have it finished before the end of 2022. And your last question, Jon, was about, excuse me?

Jon Peace

unknown
#98

Yes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#99

The way we see it, the goal isn’t to accumulate surplus capital so we’re ready for M&A. What we want is to operate with a capital level that satisfies all our constraints and sits as near as we can get to the target we’ve set. Right now we’re well above that level. That isn’t because we’re building a case for M&A — it’s down to all the constraints you’ve pointed to over the last 18 months or 12 months. So it turns out we’re carrying a higher solvency level. And that isn’t intended as a reserve built up for M&A. These are two separate matters. First, we monitor how our solvency evolves in the ordinary course of business; then, if an M&A opportunity is appealing enough to warrant raising equity to fund it, well, naturally we’d have to demonstrate that it’s worth doing, and we will. And it’s clearly not about holding surplus capital just in case a good M&A opportunity comes along. Okay?

Jon Peace

unknown
#100

Yes. Thanks very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#101

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#102

Thanks. We’ll take the next question from Delphine Lee at JPMorgan. Go ahead—your line is open.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#103

Good afternoon, and thank you for taking my questions. I have just two very quick ones on capital, if I may. The first is simply to revisit buybacks. Historically, I believe as a group you have tended to favor dividends over buybacks, and clearly this one that you are starting for 2020 is meant to compensate for the dilution from the scrip. But I was just wondering, going forward in terms of kind of excess capital, do you still have a preference — your own preference — with dividends, or is buybacks going to become a bit of a — a bigger component of capital distribution, and are you concerned about the level of free float, or do you not mind because that doesn't really affect your decision-making process? Just checking. Second question is on the capital headwinds that we feel should expect. So, you mentioned Basel 4 and trim — just checking that beyond the 20 basis points for trim, you've taken in Q4, how much is there still coming, if any in 2021? And maybe as longer term, I think one of your peers have started estimating a bit the impact of IFRS 17. So just wondering if you have any indication to give us at this point?

Delphine Lee

analyst
#104

Thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#105

All right. On the buyback first — as I mentioned, we've implemented an exceptional response to exceptional conditions. So the share repurchase program we plan to carry out over the course of this year truly is an exceptional response to exceptional conditions. As such, it isn't something we plan to keep doing down the road. The free float, naturally, isn't a worry — naturally, it's a factor we bear in mind. In our view, a free float of more than between 40% and 45% of CASA's capital, given how large the market gap is, is genuinely ample. But naturally, we wouldn't embark on a process of gradually and permanently building up the free float. That would actually make no sense. We're highly attentive to what matters to minority shareholders, and the free float is one of those interests. Another thing that matters to them is the capital pressure on their company, and we're clearly seeing that in the global combination we're putting to them. Fully unwinding the switch — that is, normalizing the capital structure of — is a very positive factor. Looking ahead, on the capital headwinds into trim, we still have several billion euros of extra RWAs to absorb, probably around 8 billion of additional RWA between 10/21 and 22.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#106

The exact schedule isn't fully locked down, since we still have to wait for the clear inspections to wrap up. The letter needs to arrive. The responses need to be talked through, and so on and so forth. Still, this is our best estimate. Naturally, the focus will be squarely on the CIB. That's what we have in mind. That's what we have in mind. IFRS 17, naturally, is a matter we're actively addressing. Technically speaking, it's a highly complicated matter. We're working on it alongside our counterparts in the insurance operations. I believe it's premature to offer a precise sense of the possible impact, since plenty of elements remain in flux, including how we prioritize overseeing the shift to IFRS 17. As you're aware, there are a number of options open to us, and we haven't yet settled on which ones to choose. So it's early days, though at some stage we'll need to have a discussion about it.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#107

Alright, thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#108

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#109

Thanks. We now have a question from Kirishanthan Vijayarajah at HSBC. Go ahead, your line is open.

Kirishanthan Vijayarajah

analyst
#110

Yes. Good afternoon, Jerome. I’ve got a couple of capital questions again. The first is really only a clarification. I realize there are many moving parts, but the main one is for scrip, and then the buybacks were finished. Are you indicating the share count ought to be flat versus where it stands today, aside from the normal employee shares? I believe you gave us that commitment on the share count. The only reason I’m asking is this: is this a rather clever, over-engineered method of returning cash to shareholders, when in fact, you know, 12 months from now we don’t necessarily know what your share count will be, given all the various moving parts? And then, second, very quickly, regarding the RWA decline shown under business line contribution, I’m just wondering whether you’ve activated any special levers there, or is it mostly a little positive ratings migration and then some seasonality driving those favorable RWA movements in the fourth quarter? Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#111

When it comes to the share count, I can't make a precise commitment about the future number of shares. What I can commit to, first, is this: regarding earnings per share dilution, the switch unwinding combined with the buyback will more than offset the EPS dilution. And of course, our operations — earnings per share, all things being equal — should be higher than they would have been without all these operations. And in fact, the size of the buyback will also be aimed at correcting the tangible book value per share dilution that needs to be <<inaudible>>. The exact amount will depend, again, on the price at which the new shares are issued and the price at which the shares can be repurchased. So those are the moving pieces, but really the commitment is to more than offset the earnings per share dilution through a combination of the switch and the buyback, and to correct the tangible book value per share dilution. As for RWA evolution across the business lines, there is nothing very special.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#112

It's the mix of all the optimization work we're doing right now, along with progress on migrating the underlying portfolios and so forth. And, naturally, there's some flight effect as well, and beyond that, of course, part of the trim impact we saw recently in this quarter. But that's called out specifically. As for everything else, it's migration plus routine optimization plus Forex.

Kirishanthan Vijayarajah

analyst
#113

Alright, thank you, Jerome. That is useful.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#114

Much appreciated.

Operator

operator
#115

Thanks. We have time for one final question, and it's from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. Go ahead — your line is open.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#116

Yeah — Stefan.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#117

Yes. Good afternoon, Jerome, and thanks for taking my questions. There are two, please. The first returns to TLTRO. Could you perhaps remind us — if this guidance has been provided previously — approximately what portion of the €133 billion group balance is attributable to CASA? And also, do you in fact have additional firepower to increase TLTRO and outstandings this year? Then the second question also goes back to this year's payout strategy. I think if you add up the cash that will go to the CASA minorities and the cash that will go to the Amundi minorities, together that is roughly worth 20 basis points of Group risk-weighted assets. So that is basically the SSM guardrail, I guess. Does it mean no room remains for the regional banks to make their payouts? Or will that not be captured? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#118

Alright. I’ll take your final question first, since naturally it matters a great deal. Regarding the payments made by the regional banks, those are part of the calculation we’ve already walked you through. Naturally, within our global assumptions we have allowed room for the regional banks to make payments to their outside shareholders, meaning the CCA and CCA holders. Beyond that, they pay to their local banks, which form part of them. That too is treated as internal payments. On the question of CASA’s subsidiaries that have minority shareholders, the cash actually paid out is excluded from the calculation, since the minority interest — the capital minority interest of those subsidiaries — is capped when we compute solvency ratios at CASA and at Group level. What that means is that the cash outs Amundi will pay to Credit Agricole Italia, which also involve minority shareholders, have no effect on the CET1 ratio of CASA or of the Group. So it is not discounted in the overall assessment of how we comply with the ECB’s recommendation. And once more, this has been made very clear with the ECB. So there is no ambiguity there.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#119

On TLTRO — TLTRO — we haven't given an exact figure for the spread between what sits in CASA and what is passed to the regional banks. Just as a rough guide, naturally, we're not especially distant from where the loans that let us draw on the TLTRO are originated. By definition, as you're aware, that means the regional banks hold a meaningful share of the total, since they originated a meaningful share of those loans and they likewise hold a meaningful share of the collateral required to access it, as we know. Do we have additional firepower? In fact, the extra firepower any bank has comes from the ceiling rising to 55% from 50% of eligible loans capacity. So that is the extra firepower available to us.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#120

Thanks a lot, everyone.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#121

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#122

Much appreciated. We now take our last question from Matthew Clark, who is with Mediobanca. Go ahead, please—your line is open.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#123

I have a couple of questions, if I may. First, on the TLTRO again: is it being offered within the retail banking divisions, or do you follow some specific allocation approach — for instance, booking the bonus effect in the corporate segment, or something along those lines? Any guidance on that would be helpful. My second question is just to confirm the switch repayment: it doesn't require ECB approval, I assume. Is that the right way to think about how things might move through the channel? And then my final question comes back to the trim in risk-weighted assets that you mentioned — could you be a bit more specific about which portfolios those are, and perhaps which portfolios drove the fourth-quarter trim impact, just so we can reconcile them? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#124

Now, regarding the trim impact, it comes from a mix of a great many separate pieces, some quite small — for instance, some of them hit for as little as €100 million or €200 million, that's the probability of default uncertain portfolio, plus the not given default uncertain other portfolios, plus whatever else, and so on. So really, it's a blend of a great many minor components. There's actually nothing large in this series. It's a very — I believe we have ten or 15 separate lines that make up what we must book in this year's fourth quarter, and when we look at what will happen in 2021 and 2022, roughly 8 billion RWAs that we forecast. That too is a mix of probably 12 to 15 separate items. So it's plainly nothing massive, but rather a series of elements all pointing in the same direction, of course. Switch — it's clear that, like any element that will affect the solvency of CASA, even the switch dismantling has no effect at the Group level. We will need to obtain authorization from the ECB. But clearly, I don't anticipate any difficulty on that front. So, once we judge that it's the right moment for us to proceed with the unwinding, we will of course do whatever we have to do with the ECB in terms of paperwork.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#125

Still, I really don’t see any trouble ahead on that point. As for TLTRO, there’s nothing I can add beyond what I told Stefan when I answered earlier. The way the trim drawings get allocated internally within the Group weighs several factors, just as I noted, and we won’t be giving any finer detail on those factors.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#126

All right, thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#127

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#128

Thank you. At this point we don’t have any more questions. Please continue.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#129

Much appreciated. I'm grateful for the questions — they always get me thinking — and thank you for being part of this conference. I look forward to our conversation the next time around. Take care.

Operator

operator
#130

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings today's conference to an end. We appreciate your participation. Everyone may now disconnect. Thank you.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.