Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 7, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorHello, and thanks for holding. You're welcome to the Credit Agricole Q1 Results 2021 Conference Call. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the speaker presentation, a question-and-answer session will take place. <<operator_script>> Kindly note that this conference is being recorded today. I'll now pass the conference to your CFO, Jerome Grivet. Thank you. Over to you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. I'm glad to walk you through the results for the Group and for Credit Agricole SA for the first quarter of 2021. I'll move through the slideshow fairly quickly so that we leave time for your questions. Starting on Page 4, you'll see the group reporting a net profit of €1.75 billion, which is nearly double what we posted in Q1 '20. When we restate for the usual specific items — and I'll come back to that shortly — the underlying net income group share comes in at €1.6 billion, still up 63%. The main item we restate this quarter is that the Single Resolution Board has given us approval to restate our contribution for the last five years, from 2016 to 2020. That gives us a positive one-off for the quarter — the quote <<inaudible>> — which we book this quarter, amounting to €185 million for the Group and €130 million for Credit Agricole SA. Since this item is of course nonrecurring, it gets restated and isn't included in our underlying figures. Moving a bit further down the Group's P&L overall, you can see that these results are not only very strong and solid, but also of good quality.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRevenue is up very substantially, and the cost base—excluding the usual contribution to the Single Resolution Fund—is flat at plus 8.5%, while the cost of risk has fallen 42%. That produces a net profit of €1.6 billion at group level and a solvency ratio, the CET1 ratio, of 17.3%. Moving to the next page, with the CASA figures, the same trends can be seen. Net income Group share, stated above €1 billion for this first quarter, is up 63%, 64%. For this specific restated item, the underlying net income group share comes in at €932 million. That is up 43% Q1 on Q1. Once again, the same patterns show up inside the P&L, with revenues up 7.2% versus Q1 '20. They are also 4% higher than Q4 '20. The cost basis, excluding the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, is flat and is even marginally lower than Q4 last year, minus 0.5%. The cost of risk is down 38% versus Q1 and also minus 23% versus Q4 '20. Perhaps I can go straight to Page 8 and give you a few points on what took place during this first quarter of 2021.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat I think matters to keep in mind is that back in 2020, the first quarter was, for the most part, still a quarter of normal activity, and all the restrictions on activities — on economic activities — began only at the end of March. This first quarter of 2021 has indeed been marked by the continuation of some significant restriction measures. And despite that, we've managed to keep developing our activities across the board. And you can see that we've succeeded in attracting new customers this quarter — a significant number of new customers: 469,000 new retail banking customers in France and Italy. And we've also managed to increase the main activity indicator of loans outstanding, customer assets, consumer credit outstandings, and also the number of nonlife insurance policies. So that means we've learned how to keep operating under restrictions, and we've been quite active from this viewpoint. If I go now to Page 9, just to take a look at the way the revenue line has been built, as CASA <<inaudible>> in this first quarter of 2021, you can see that all business lines contributed to this increase in the top line of our P&L.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat has very much been true for the asset gathering division and for the large customer's business division as well. Yet you can also observe it in the retail banking business division, where we succeeded in posting an increase in the top line. Only in specialized financial services did we have a top line that stayed flat in Q1 versus Q1 '20. But it's also worth noting, on the right-hand button, the top part of the page, this series of net revenues posted over the last five years for the first quarter of the year. And you can see that steadily, year after year, we have managed to raise the level of revenues. That has also been the case for the following quarters of the year — Q2, Q3 and Q4. We'll see whether we manage to keep this trend going for the remainder of this year. If I look at how the cost base evolved, I told you the cost base was globally flat, Q1-on-Q1. Excluding the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, that has been more or less true in every business division, with a slight increase in the asset gathering and large customers business divisions, which were the ones posting the highest increase in the evolution of their revenues, while the cost base kept declining in the specialized financial service division and in the retail banking division.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs you can see, the cost-to-income ratio, of course, keeps falling substantially. Excluding the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, it now stands at 58%. Perhaps one final point on this Single Resolution Fund matter that I wanted to bring up: this quarter, as I mentioned, we have booked one positive item, which is restated and not part of the underlying figures. And we have booked the customary yearly contribution of €510 million for this year. That number compares with a published underlying figure of €360 million in Q1 '20. But in '20, in fact, we had to book a top-up to that contribution of €79 million in Q2. So the €510 million booked this quarter, which will represent the entire contribution for the full year — no top-up is anticipated in Q2 — must be compared with last year's level, which overall was €439 million, though it was booked across Q1 and Q2. Moving now to Page 11 on asset quality, I think the key messages are quite simple. Asset quality stays very, very strong, with the level of nonperforming loans relative to total outstanding stable.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveFor Credit Agricole SA as well as for the group worldwide, coverage ratios keep edging up a bit — 72% at Credit Agricole SA and 84.4% for the group globally. So the loan book's quality stays extremely strong. As for the cost of risk itself, what this quarter shows is that at both the group level and the SA level, cost of risk came down overall. As you know, two components make up the cost of risk. The first is the extra provisions we set aside on Stage 1 and Stage 2 loans. And this quarter, that piece of the cost of risk is lower than a year earlier — whether you look at Q1, at Q4, or at the average over the whole year — simply because last year we put substantial effort into provisioning performing loans. But this quarter, we see no reason to toughen or make harsher our macroeconomic scenario. And so the added Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisioning we recorded stems only either from the natural evolution of our credit portfolios or from certain additional prudential approaches on specific sectors.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis figure matches both the Group level and the Credit Agricole SA level. The second component of the cost of risk consists of provisioning for nonperforming loans. What you can observe is that, once again, for both the Group and Credit Agricole SA, S3 provisioning sits significantly under what we recorded in Q1 '20, and is more or less stable relative to Q4 '20. So there is again no indication that the credit quality of our loan book is deteriorating. This produces a very favorable change in net income group share overall, shown on Page 13. That holds true division by division, where you can see that within every business division we have succeeded in raising the bottom line substantially. The sole exception is the corporate center, though that stems mainly and solely from a base effect in 2020. Looking at it another way across the P&L as a whole, you can see that net profit rises by approximately €280 million. That is driven by a very substantial rise in revenues, plus €317 million, along with a significant drop in the cost of risk of minus €240 million. The two negative items are the higher contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, plus €150 million, and the rise in property taxes and other elements of plus around €180 million.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning to Page 14, I'll quickly touch on a couple of items from the quarter. The first one is Amundi's move into exclusive negotiations to acquire Lyxor. Obviously, this will not only strengthen Amundi's position in asset management across Europe on a global scale, but it also drives a very significant enhancement of its standing in the European ETF market. The second item is the success of the tender offer we launched in Italy for CreVal. It succeeded, since we were able to secure over 90% of CreVal's capital through that tender offer. That will let us delist CreVal, and we've just reopened the offer so as to squeeze out the remaining shareholders and to reach ownership of 100% of CreVal's capital, which will make the integration process easier down the road. Now let me move to Page 16, with a few points about how the group mobilized to support and protect the economy throughout the crisis. I won't go into detail on the state guarantee loan process, since you're quite familiar with it by now. I'll simply note that it carried on during this quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis quarter, we've extended an extra close to €1 billion in additional state-guaranteed loans. As for payment holidays, that program is now wrapping up. In most cases — 98% of them — it's ending well, since payments are returning to normal without issue. And we've also been — let me remind you that we've also stayed active when it comes to safeguarding vulnerable customers. On Page 17, the key thing is what lies ahead for us. What's coming is an economic recovery. It's recovering in France, in Italy, in Europe, and across the rest of the world. And we absolutely have to be part of that, because every one of our competitors is out there active. So we're now at work on the next steps of this economic recovery, and we're ready to take a massive part in the PPR initiative in France — Prêts participatifs Relance — together with our life insurance company, which is one — which is the largest contributor to the fund, a step — that is being set up to finance these loans. One last point on Page 18: throughout this stretch of time, we've kept accelerating the group's contribution to social transformation.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe've acknowledged that this crisis clearly confirms how relevant our group project is, and how relevant it is to integrate environmental and societal concerns into our Group project, and we're accelerating on those elements. Let me now move quickly through the different businesses, beginning with the asset gathering and insurance business division. Just to note on Page 20 that we've managed to grow the volume of assets we manage quite significantly, and that this business division's profit has rebounded significantly this quarter, plus 43.7%. When it comes to strictly insurance activities, on Page 21, what we can say is that we've had very positive commercial activity at the start of this year. And with an acceleration in March, we've seen that especially in inflows into life insurance policies. The leadership positioning of Credit Agricole France <<inaudible>> has been strengthened further this year — last year on the French market, and it continues to be the case with continued market share gains in the nonlife insurance activity. This business's net profit rises by 45% this quarter compared to Q1 '20. On Page 22, Amundi, and Amundi published its results last week so you know them perfectly.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere are a couple of points I'd like to highlight. First, Amundi has once again hit a record level of assets under management, at €1,755 billion. Second, Amundi is reporting a record profit level for this quarter, along with a 54.4% rise in Amundi's contribution to our own P&L. Moving to Page 23, the large customers division. So for CAL&F plus CACEIS, I believe what was noted on Page 23 is that overall, activity was very dynamic. That was particularly true at CACEIS, where we saw a significant rise in assets under custody and assets under administration, plus a significant rise in CACEIS's contribution outside the Single Resolution Fund contribution. Turning to CAL&F on Page 24, just to illustrate where things stand, this quarter — the first quarter of '21 — was the second best quarter in five years in terms of revenues for CAL&F, and that performance was achieved both in capital market activities, where we see a significant increase of 13%, and in financing activities, with a good level of credit demand coming from customers. The cost base remains very, very much under control, excluding, again, an increase in the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe cost of risk is coming down a lot, and because of that, net income group share at CAL&F is up 37.6% this quarter. In specialized financial services, with the consumer credit business, we saw a good level of production of new loans this quarter. That's an increase of more than 4% quarter-on-quarter. So this is more or less protecting the level of loans outstanding at CACF at the end of March compared with the end of March 2020. MBI is more or less stable excluding the scope effect. That scope effect is the consolidation of the CACF panel, which is in the process of being sold. And the cost of risk at CACF is declining quite significantly, which is leading to a strong improvement in CACF's contribution to the group's profit. It's more or less the same story for the leasing and factoring activities, with a good level of commercial activity in the quarter, a good level of revenues too, a significant decrease in the cost of risk, and a doubling of the contribution to our profits. Turning to retail banking activities, starting with LCL. Despite the restrictions, LCL managed to grow its customer base and grow its loans and deposits outstanding. Revenue is quite resilient, with an increase of close to 2%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe cost base is still going down by about 2%. And the cost of risk is falling considerably as well. It's split roughly evenly between S1 and S2 provisions and S3 provisions. So against that backdrop, LCL's net profit is 12% higher this quarter. Moving now to international retail banking and beginning with Italy. As you recall, Italy was one of the earlier countries to trigger lockdowns in 2020. That means the activity comparison between Q1 '21 and Q1 '20 shows a very substantial rise in activity levels and in both the number and the amount of product sold to our customers. So in that context, the top line is rising quite substantially, the cost line is stable, and the cost of risk fell by about 14%. So Credit Agricole Italia's net contribution is up quite substantially, plus 76.6%. As for the other international retail banking activities, the lowest point for revenues came in Q2 last year. That means the Q1-on-Q1 comparison is still challenging. Nevertheless, since we've managed to keep the cost base under control and also bring the cost of risk down a little, the change in net profit is only slightly lower, minus 13%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd it would have been stable excluding ForEx effects. So this activity had a resilient quarter. I'll wrap up with the corporate center, where the structural reduction in costs keeps working. There's a base effect that's quite tough, since you'll recall that in Q1 '20 we had very significant intra-group restatements that produced €175 million of revenues within the corporate center, which we no longer have this quarter, but restated for these elements the improvement is very solid. Maybe just one additional point: in the corporate center, since the start of this year we are now booking the contribution of BforBank, which is now held by Credit Agricole SA with a stake of 50% plus one share, so it is equity accounted and it is generating a loss of €5 million this quarter. And we expect this to continue over the coming quarters and for at least some years before we reach breakeven. So you'll now need to take that into account. On page 31, the regional banks of Credit Agricole. They've had a very good start to the year with good activity levels, good customer attraction as well, and a net level of revenues that was also boosted by the effect of the market improvement on their portfolio of assets.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOur cost base hasn't moved, the cost of risk came down a lot, and as a result the regional banks' contribution to the Group's net profit has doubled compared with Q1 2020, a quarter that was far tougher. Now let me turn to solvency, beginning with the level at Credit Agricole SA. RWAs rose notably this quarter, by roughly €12 billion, but in fact €5 billion of that comes from unwinding a further 15% of the switch mechanism during the quarter. On top of that, we saw an increase of about €5 billion to €6 billion in RWAs attributable either to ForEx effects, rating migration or trim. So the genuine organic growth in RWA is considerably smaller. Credit Agricole SA's CET1 ratio comes in at 12.7%, which is, of course, well above every requirement. At Group level, the ratio is 17.3%. That exceeds the set level by 8.4 percentage points, and it's up 10 bps this quarter, with nothing else much to add. Liquidity is definitely not a concern, on Page 35. What may be worth noting is that we have slightly further raised the level of TLTRO drawings we've taken as the TLTRO window.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBy the end of March, we had €152 billion of TLTRO, and those funds are allocated across the group's different businesses, while our liquidity reserve sits at its highest level. One final point on the group's financial management: progress on the market funding program is fully on track. Perhaps one more thing worth mentioning is that just two days ago we announced the call of AT1, which will take place in June and will have an effect in terms of AT1 coupons beginning in Q3 this year. I think I can stop there so that we can move on to answering your questions.
Operator
operatorAnd your first question comes from Jacques-Henri Gaulard of Kepler. Your line is open. Please go ahead with your question.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYes indeed. Good afternoon, Jerome. I have two questions, if I may. The first concerns CreVal. Could you verify that the synergies cited in the offer document will stay roughly unchanged, with nothing specific shifting? In that document, what perhaps caught a few people off guard was the size of the restructuring charges, which were in fact rather elevated. A comment on that would be great. My second question relates to the group's perimeter, which has been extremely busy with a great many initiatives across essentially every one of the key businesses. I was wondering whether you think that perimeter will now stay more or less steady until the new plan is unveiled in '22, or whether you see any major opportunity emerging? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Jacques-Henri. As you're aware, at this point everything in the tender offer document — all of our assumptions and each element — was based solely on information that's publicly available, since CreVal was obviously a listed company and we naturally couldn't get hold of certain private data. So there's no reason for us to alter our assumptions just because the offer succeeded. Naturally, though, we'll need to fine-tune those assumptions. The same holds true for the cost of risk attrition. Once we've really dug into CreVal — which will happen when we have a new Board of Directors; you may have noticed that a General Assembly Meeting has been convened for June the 18th — so that will be the occasion for the Board to be changed in line with the company's new shareholding. And of course we'll carry out some audit within CreVal so as to again fine-tune the capacity for generating cost and revenue synergies and to fine-tune the cost of putting those restructurings in place. So up to now there's no reason to change these figures, but we'll have to fine-tune them. And that fine-tuning will have to happen within the purchase price allocation process, which is probably going to be done in two steps.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis is something we'll do very quickly, though it will be rough and very conservative — and likely a second step before year-end, with figures that are more precise. On the question of the Group's perimeter, we have always stated that our strategy isn't built on M&A. It isn't built on acquisitions that we would identify well ahead of time and then try to complete so as to hit our strategic goals. The Group's strategy is genuinely organic, but we have said that, given some very precise financial criteria, we would be prepared to seize opportunities should they come up. That has happened recently — you mentioned two significant transactions announced at roughly the same time over the past few months, Lyxor and CreVal — but we could perfectly well go several quarters in a row without announcing anything; it isn't a must.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorDelphine Lee with JP Morgan has the next question.
Delphine Lee
analystYes. Good afternoon, and thank you for taking my questions, Jerome. For the first one, I'd like to ask about the payout ratio. I'm just trying to get a bit of clarity on your 50% policy, which you said would be topped up with a small portion of the full year '19 dividends. I believe you mentioned $0.40. I'm just wondering how soon those additional dividends, let's say, could appear, and whether they'd take the form of specials or would be — would they form part of your standard dividend policy? And more broadly, I mean, you're still targeting 11% CET1, I assume, and I'm just wondering how you reach that given the capital level you have now? And would you consider speeding up somewhat the switch to reimbursement in that context? Then the second question concerns cost of risk. I think you mentioned — you still said that cost of risk is expected to decline this year. The question is a bit about how much, given how the year has started, and you've walked in 37 basis on Stage 1, Stage 2 provisions as well. So should we expect more of that Stage 1, Stage 2 provisioning again over the coming quarters, or should it normalize, and would you have guidance for us for '21?
Delphine Lee
analystThanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, let me begin with the dividend. You're clearly eager for some details. We're still working through the 2021 results, so by year-end we'll evaluate what the standard dividend would be under the usual 50% cash payout policy, and what sort of top-up we might consider. But that's a matter we'll only address in Q4. So please don't push too hard on this question. We still need to pay the 2020 dividend, which the General Assembly meeting next week will vote on. So there's time to think about this year's dividend policy a bit later, but definitely we continue to target 11%. So of course, given the 12.7% ratio and where we stand now, the margin is fairly wide. Please keep in mind that we'll have to finance the CreVal acquisition somehow, which will represent maybe close to 20 bps, and the Lyxor acquisition, which for Credit Agricole SA will represent maybe 15 bps of ratio. We still probably have some 4 billion or 5 billion of trim RWA to take this year, which will also have a significant impact on our CET1 ratio.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs you correctly mentioned, we still have that remaining 50% of the switch to unwind before the end of 2022. So this is definitely a commitment we have made, and it will be honored no matter what. Those are essentially all the key moving parts that will occur with respect to our capital and that will of course definitely affect our dividend policy. Turning to cost of risk, it is extremely difficult to say in advance where we will land on cost of risk for the full year. What I can say is that in this quarter we saw a meaningful reduction in the additional S1 and S2 provision, as I explained. What I can also say is that the remaining additional S1 and S2 provisions we booked this quarter were tied to, let's say, extra prudence — meaning either sectorial provisions taken by LCL or by CAL&F on certain sectors, or simply the straightforward consequence of the natural evolution and change in the breakdown of our assets between S1 and S2. But it is really very small, and we do not expect to have to change the macroeconomic scenario this year, which would be the primary driver of any significant movement in S1 and S2 provisioning.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOur approach to provisioning is quite conservative. I'd say the provisioning levels carried in our books show this. At Group level, we hold nearly €20 billion of provisions, and at CASA level nearly €10 billion. Within those provisions, at CASA level we have €2.7 billion of Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisioning, and at group level close to €7 billion of S1 and S2 provisioning. We do not plan to write those provision amounts back going forward, and they sit there simply because we expect them to confirm how prudent our approach is when it comes to cost of risk. But definitely, what we are seeing in the macroeconomic environment shows no sign of deterioration in the credit environment as of now.
Delphine Lee
analystThanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Jean Neuez at Goldman Sachs. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.
Jean Neuez
analystHey there. Hi, Jerome — good afternoon. I'd like to ask about the retail revenues in France and the retail revenues in Italy, since versus the domestic Italian peers that have reported so far, and also in France versus BNP and SocGen, your revenue appears to be holding up quite a bit better. I saw some securities gain in Italy, but even so, up 5% year-over-year is a large number, because I don't believe you have much in the way of trading revenues. I don't think that's in there, and likewise in France, the net interest margin looks considerably more resilient. So I recall you unwound some swaps a few years back. But I just wanted to try to understand, first, in Italy, what the trend in your net interest income was, and also what you'd attribute the resilience in net interest margins to in those businesses?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, so in Italy, as you mentioned, on the top line you've got that one-off item we already flagged. We also saw really solid performance in what we call managed savings for our customers' accounts, which produced a meaningful amount of fees this quarter. Naturally, fee levels can swing around, but this quarter we did very well on that front. And of course, we'll keep pushing in that same direction. So clearly, in Italy the net interest margin is under pressure. Customers are renegotiating — not their rates, since lots and lots of loans are floating-rate based, so it isn't the rate they renegotiate, it's the spread. That means we feel real pressure on net interest revenues in Italy, and in France too. But we manage, through the volume effect and through growing the fees, to offset it and to keep the topline moving dynamically. In France as well, we always repeat the same point: the volume effect is positive there, and it's helped, indeed, by interest rates coming down. We've got fees and commissions growing. And we have — I'd say — the determination to keep bringing in new customers so we can grow our customer base.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe profit and loss statement for LCL is really quite simple, since it operates purely as a retail bank within France. There aren't any other activities involved, and there are no other tricks in its P&L. So I'd say it's fairly straightforward.
Jean Neuez
analystRight. It's only that, when you stack it up against the peers, it comes out a little different.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat’s a question you’d want to direct to the peer.
Jean Neuez
analystWe put that question to them as well. Today it’s your call. Either way. Thanks, Jerome.
Operator
operatorGiulia Aurora Miotto from Morgan Stanley has the next question. Your line is open, so go ahead and ask.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystGood afternoon. My first question concerns deposits—specifically the fact that their growth continues to outpace loans. So I'd like to know what you're observing on the ground. Also, do you believe there's scope for an acceleration in the shift from deposits into investment products, particularly across your retail networks? How large is the potential revenue opportunity there? That's my first question. My second question returns to the €5 billion 2022 guidance for net income group share. I'd like to know whether you have any updates on that for us, and whether it would also take in the recent acquisitions. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. It's accurate to say that deposits — customer deposits — are changing very, very quickly. And in fact, that has been true at LCL. It is also true among Credit Agricole's regional banks. It is true across the entire banking industry. I believe that at present this is happening because all of our customers, whether households or SMEs or corporates, are being very cautious given the circumstances. So they want to hold large liquidity buffers, each one at his or her own level. So naturally, once the situation becomes entirely clear, once the pandemic is regarded as entirely under control, all these people — whether households or businesses — will probably make choices about their cash position. And those choices could go in various directions. We think, we expect, and frankly, we hope that a substantial portion of the savings that households have built up in their deposits will be converted into spending, since that will considerably assist the acceleration of economic activity and that will be good for the country as a whole. So we are not going to attempt to push them, I would say, against their will to turn these savings, or these deposits, into long-term investment products.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, if a portion of that cash makes sense to put to work over the long term, we're present and prepared to do exactly that, and to assist our clients in identifying an answer, since we happen to offer an entire array of options. There's our life insurance offering; there's our asset management offering. We also have the real estate offering. So we're able to offer customers the full spectrum of long-term investments should they want that. But plainly, we won't actively attempt to push them toward those avenues instead of spending, if spending is what they prefer, once they judge that confidence has returned. And an environment that's stable lets them spend more. Much the same holds for companies. Your second question, then, concerned our target of €5 billion in net profit for 2022. What we observed in Q1 '21 — naturally, Q1 doesn't make up the entire year. But what we observed in Q1 '21 doesn't dissuade us from keeping our sights on that profit level for next year. Let me phrase it that way.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystThanks a lot. Appreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane BNP Paribas. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystGood afternoon. I have a few questions regarding CIB. Your medium-term goal includes a cost-income ratio under 55%. Right now you're sitting at 50%. Presumably you won't provide a fresh target until '22 is over. Still, could you give us a sense of whether you believe you can keep running at roughly 50%? Does that mean the earlier target was somewhat optimistic, or do you feel CIB is currently performing a bit above where it should be? My second question concerns CIB RWA in financing activity. Those have risen substantially. What's the outlook there, please? Finally, on capital targets: you haven't revised your targets since CRD 5 article 104A. So does that imply you won't change the targets, and as a result you're not seizing this opportunity? Or does it mean you wait — before moving it to 10%, you wait for conditions to improve? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Guillaume. Starting with the cost-to-income ratio at the CIB. It's always been our view that a low cost-to-income ratio in CIB activities is a key element in the stability of the CIB. Because when you have a high cost-to-income ratio in this business, you are more or less induced to take the risks whatever they are in order to generate revenues. And this is the moment when you take the bad risks. So clearly, we have designed our CIB to be operated with a low cost-to-income ratio. 55% is the target and we think that 55% is already very competitive, as compared to most of the other CIBs operating in Europe and in the world. So it happens that this quarter, we managed to go below 55% and we are around 50%, which is all the best. Of course, we are not going to change for the time being the target. We have to reassess that in a steady exercise, when we will reframe our medium-term plan and so on and so forth. But we're happy to be below the target for the time being. No, doubt about it. RWA in the financing activities well, it's always a little bit volatile, because if I take a series back last year, we started at €74 billion in Q1.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIn Q2 we rose to almost €75 billion, then in Q3 we came down to €72 billion, and at present we stand at €78 billion, which includes the ForEx effect, the impact of negative migration, and partly the trim effect. So there are a great many components that weren't tied to — I'd put it as — the portfolio's organic growth. So whenever regulatory requirements get somewhat stricter regarding how RWA is calculated, we then attempt afterward to optimize that and to bring the RWA level back to a stable point. So we'll aim to do so over the next few quarters. However, I'd rather have a CIB carrying this RWA level and this cost-to-income ratio than push too aggressively when it comes to taking market risk, say, and taking risks that RWA does not entirely capture. In my view our CIB is stable, and that is precisely what we're after. One final point on the capital target. We are fully mindful of it, and that one, article 104 A, permits us to lower our target, all things being equal. The calculation you can perform, just as I can, would take us to roughly 10.5% instead of 11%, all things being equal.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHowever, given that we're currently sitting at 12.7%, I honestly don't see much reason to go ahead and change the official target. So as you've observed, there are still quite a few significant items ahead of us that could have an effect on our CET1 ratio. It feels a bit early to formally revise that target, but article 104 A is still on our minds.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThe next inquiry is from Omar Fall at Barclays. Your line is open, so go ahead with your question.
Omar Fall
analystHello, good afternoon. Starting with insurance: typically you give us net profit figures rather than the full P&L, right? So is this €300 million a normalized base, after last year's pandemic disruptions? I ask because you cited something like a lower CE3S social contribution charge, and I can't tell whether that's a one-off and how it gets accounted for. Put differently, it used to be the case that Q1 is the weakest quarter for insurance, with net profit then improving as the year goes on. Is that still broadly what we should expect? Second question, on LCL. Looking at loan growth excluding guaranteed loans, over the last three quarters it has been plus 5%, plus 4% and plus 3% this quarter. Why should that get better once the economy reopens? Because businesses hold tons of liquidity and will spend time getting rid of the guaranteed loans. Mortgages aren't elastic to reopening, judging by other countries, and consumer credit is smaller than in the networks. This seems especially important for us here, since you're the only bank in Europe where NII is growing in line with loans somehow?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn insurance — yes, this quarter really has been a rather pleasing one when it comes to generating profit. I'll begin with a couple of technical items that will affect how profitable the insurance business is going forward. The first, and it's a negative, is that, as you're aware, starting in the middle of last year we record our Q1 coupons in the P&L rather than against equity. That comes to roughly €20 million per quarter in cost, and it sits in the non-controlling interest line. The second item, which is a positive, is that the unwinding — the continued unwinding of the switch mechanism — is producing some positive revenues. So in Q1 it was absolutely marginal, since the unwinding happened at the start of March, but you'll see a full-quarter effect beginning in Q2, ahead of the next stage of unwinding the switch mechanism, which is meant to occur before the end of 2022. Then there's the ordinary course of business. Q1 '20 will get there first, because of market effects. Q1 '21 is good — not exceptionally high, but good where premium volumes are concerned. And it's good in terms of how the market is evolving, which is preserving the value of our assets.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, some fluctuation is inevitable, yet I'd argue this quarterly figure isn't entirely without meaning. Regarding LCL, how credit demand is developing, and LCL's outstanding loans? What we can say with certainty is that a great many of our business clients intend to put money into launch projects once the health situation settles down. Naturally, some of them hold at least part of the cash in their accounts, since they have already secured it. Others will need to obtain financing from their bank. So they stand ready to proceed. This applies both to SMEs and to the self-employed professionals who form a vital part of LCL's customer base. As for households, we detect no indication of a deceleration in demand for mortgages. What we observe is that the high accounts for financial stability has imposed certain constraints that could deter some households from getting a home loan, yet households' appetite for purchasing their homes remains substantial at this point in time.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd it's clear that home loans activity has been at a healthy level once again in this quarter. So at LCL, I can't see any reason we'd end up with the loan book moving in a negative direction over the quarters ahead.
Omar Fall
analystOkay. And as a really fast follow-up regarding consumer credit, you said March was nearly at the 2019 level. What's the average duration, roughly, of the loan book that's consolidated the most?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRoughly 30 months. Around 30 months is the figure.
Omar Fall
analystUnderstood. Understood. Excellent. Many thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorTarik El Mejjad from Bank of America has the next question. Your line is open — go ahead and ask.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystHi, good afternoon, Jerome. I have just two questions, please. First, on the minimum capital review: do you believe operating a bank with a balance sheet that large at under 11% would be acceptable? I realize there are required ratios, but what level is acceptable for running the bank at <<inaudible>>? At the time, we were discussing roughly 10%, which then became 11% and 12%. So I'd just like your view on that. And would you revise it — and apply article 104 and 5 <<inaudible>>? Would you likely just tie it to Basel 4 and essentially set a new target under Basel 4, which would then be 10.5, absorbing Basel 4? What <<inaudible>> sort of logic would you follow? Then the second question. Maybe it's too early. But what's your view on the debate over the resolution fund contribution? As a large bank, again, it affects you materially. So what's the latest there? And what do you think? A few banks are certainly lobbying to have it stopped by end of 2023. But what's your view on that?
Tarik El Mejjad
analystMuch appreciated.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Tarik. On the first question: we don't plan to carry a big balance sheet, as you put it, at 10.5% or 11% — we manage it at 17%. What really counts is the group's solvency. And the group sits above 17%. Let me remind you that our target was to reach 16% in 2022. We're already past 17%. And there's no reason we shouldn't keep strengthening the capital solidity of the group's revenue. CASA sits within the group and gains from the strong solvency of the regional banks, and doesn't need to be managed at such a lofty capital level. This is exactly, I'd say, the appealing trait of the group's structure that genuinely helps us produce and deliver a solid return on equity for CASA's minority investors while staying on the safe side globally, in solvency terms, thanks to the group's solvency. So I see no reason we shouldn't apply article 104 A precisely as it should be, thus producing a cut of roughly 50 bps in CASA's official target, as long as CASA remains part of Credit Agricole.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, looking ahead there's one more significant variable in play, namely Basel 4. And as you say, that's an additional reason we feel no urgency about formally adjusting our targets, since the timing and manner of Basel 4's transposition remain uncertain. What we have picked up, though, is that a draft directive could potentially become available at some point following the summer. So at that stage we'll determine precisely how to deal with it. Your second question, apologies, concerned the Single Resolution Fund, apologies again. Right, so officially the Single Resolution Fund will be fully ramped at the end of 2023. Following that, our only contributions should go toward keeping the Single Resolution Fund at that 1% of covered deposit level. That's what should normally occur. So it's premature to say whether that will indeed hold, but you can include us among the banks that will attempt to — how shall I put it — nudge the public authorities toward halting the ramping up of the Single Resolution Fund at the pre-identified level. Given the significant amount we put into this fund, the earlier that happens, the better for us.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Pierre Chedeville at CIC. Your line is open, so please go ahead with your question.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, good evening, Jerome. One question about fees at Amundi. It seems that this was quite significant this quarter. And I understand there's a reform being prepared by the ESMA <<inaudible>> concerning how their fees are calculated — not over one year, but over five years. And I wanted to ask whether you have any sense of the impact this could have on Amundi's revenues in the years ahead if that reform goes through. That's the first question. Second question. We've seen some articles lately about, I don't know the term, more fragmented payment in leasing — they're more fragmented.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveFraction.
Pierre Chédeville
analystFraction — sorry, that came through broken up. I wanted to ask: what's CACF's view of this business, and are you in it? If you aren't, would you want to be? My final question concerns shipping — as one of the major players globally, can you give us any color on shipping, not just on the risk side but on the revenue side as well? Thank you, Jerome.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Beginning with Amundi and performance fees: naturally, we're fully conscious of this possible change in the rules governing how performance fees are calculated. Amundi already aligns quite considerably with what this regulation newly demands. As a result, going forward there could be an adverse effect, though it should be fairly limited and genuinely introduced gradually over five years. So this isn't something that will materially alter the picture where performance fees are concerned. That said, performance fees are far more sensitive simply to market volatility, since from Q1 2020 to Q1 2021, how performance fees moved accounts for €70 million of the difference in revenues at Amundi. That works out at roughly 40% of the revenue increase at Amundi. So it's very substantial, and by its nature it's volatile, given that it depends on the performance delivered by the portfolio managers at Amundi. On CACF and the fraction payments, it's evident that this is a growing trend in the market and that a rising number of consumer credit operators are offering it to their customers — and those customers are not only the end customer but also the retail partners. So CACEIS is certainly working on this. I can't say precisely where they are in terms of developing the offer, but they are fully conscious of it and they are working on it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, so shipping — shipping is one of the areas where CAL&F is quite active. It's a sector that experienced some notable declines last year. Shipping market prices have risen very substantially over the past several months, driven not only by the worldwide uptick in economic activity but also, as you're aware, by that Suez Canal incident, which set off a very steep jump in shipping pricing. So this is a business where we carry meaningful exposure. Roughly €12 billion to €13 billion of exposure at default. So it matters, it's significant. It isn't enormous, and it's just one of the various activity sectors in which CAL&F operates. And it forms part of the balanced business model at CAL&F. Within the shipping activity itself, we're exposed to a number of sub-segments — whether leisure shipping, whether every category of carrier, plus the ship makers as well, and so on. So the exposure we hold is quite diversified.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAnd when it comes to leisure and carriers, does that situation concern you?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo, globally speaking, that falls under shipping. Our commercial shipping divisions are doing really well. Yes, the leisure side is basically at a standstill, but that won't go on indefinitely.
Pierre Chédeville
analystWe'll see. Thanks, Jerome.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorKiri Vijayarajah from HSBC has the next question. Your line is open, so please go ahead.
Kirishanthan Vijayarajah
analystGood afternoon, Jerome. Yes, my first question concerns capital. I just want a quick clarification: could some of those negative effects you’re calling out this quarter possibly reverse in the quarters ahead? On that slide they look entirely permanent to me, but I wanted to make sure I hadn’t overlooked something. Then my second question is about those equity loans tied to government backing that sit in the pipeline. Since you own a big insurance company and you also have Amundi, I’m wondering whether your exposure to that vehicle will ultimately exceed, say, your natural market share — your natural banking share in France — given how that particular fund is structured. So really I’m just after guidance on where you expect your aggregate exposure may eventually land, taking into account all the different entities across the wider Credit Agricole. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right. So let's begin with the capital headwinds we faced this quarter, as I mentioned. RWAs rose by roughly €12 billion, and €5 billion of that came from the switch differently. Naturally, that piece is here to stay. We saw close to €2 billion from price effects. That is entirely reasonable, and it will fluctuate over time. We also had €1.2 billion of negative rate migration affecting some counterparties in CAL&F. And that is only one portion of the €5 billion recorded across the last four or five quarters. So this is clearly a trend for the time being, but assuming the economic recovery plays out as we anticipate, it should progressively reverse. Then, of course, there was the trim effect, which accounted for close to €3 billion of negative RWA movement. That is huge to stay, until we identify ways to optimize the trim — the RWA calculation, which happens regularly. So there you have it — I am not sure what can be labeled as steady and what must be labeled as well as I, but those are the main elements explaining how the RWAs evolved.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd then there's the decrease tied to rising interest rates, which has caused the equity stake in our insurance business to lose value. So this can shift over time as well, depending on market parameters. But for sure, we're not worried in the slightest by this quarter's movement, since typically there's always a drop in the CET1 ratio, because Q1 is generally a quarter in which we'd see significant regulatory effects — negative regulatory effects — and Q1 is also the quarter of fiscal '21. So it's a quarter in which we produce fewer results than a normal quarter. Then the equity loans you mentioned are part of the new mechanism the French government put in place. It's true that we're going to account for a significant share of the investors in the fund that will finance these loans — €2.25 billion is going to be invested in the fund by Credit Agricole France. At the same time, Amundi will be the fund manager, operating alongside another French bank. And what matters for us is that we're going to work hard to make sure our bank networks originate a significant proportion of these equity loans for their customers and for ours, because when we talk about the €2.25 billion that Predica <<inaudible>> is going to invest, I would say the liability side of the fund.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat matters, though, is the fund's asset side — who's actually making those loans, the equity loans, and we intend to be quite active so that a meaningful share of them comes from us. Then ultimately, when it comes to risk, as you're aware, these loans carry a 30% government guarantee, and that is genuinely shielding the investors.
Kirishanthan Vijayarajah
analystThanks, Jerome — appreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorAnd the next person to ask a question is Matt Clark from Mediobanca. Your line is open. Please go ahead with your question.
Matthew Clark
analystHi there, good afternoon. I have a couple of questions, if I may. First, could we revisit the insurance division and its topline? I mean, is there any signal in the revenue level relative to the insurance assets under management there, which appear somewhat below where they used to be? Or is that actually a red herring, and should we instead focus on a different metric to assess the revenue power of that division? Any guidance or thoughts on that would be appreciated. Then my second question concerns cost of risk and the Stage 1 and 2 provisions booked this quarter. I'm curious why you are still recording Stage 1 and 2 provisions. What was it about how the macro environment developed during the first quarter or year-to-date that meant you are still taking these? I would have thought you took quite a lot of them last year, and that perhaps there would be a chance for them to fall to zero, with only Stage 3 provisions showing up as defaults come through. So why are you still taking them, and will you continue taking them in the quarters ahead?
Matthew Clark
analystAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBringing insurance revenue into Banking Group’s P&L is, in fact, always rather complicated. So the level — the topline in insurance activity is always in some way difficult to read across through a Banking Group lens. Still, what we have observed this quarter in insurance activities’ topline partly reflects a solid level of activity and a solid level of risk in non-life activities, plus, in life activities, some favorable effects from the recovery in valuation of certain assets that we had to provision in Q1 ’20, owing to market movements, and that we could write back, I would say, in Q1 ’21. So that is the combination of those elements. What matters in the life insurance business is the ability to keep generating the profit level that we target. That clearly has been true this quarter. And what also matters in life insurance activity is the ability to maintain, for the Euro portion of the book. And incidentally, you may have noticed that we have kept raising the unit linked portion of the book. But for the Euro portion of the book, what matters is the ability to keep preserving a spread — a meaningful spread between the yield of the asset book that we manage and the profit-sharing rate that we intend to pay to our customers.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd during this quarter, the yield on those continues to be pretty meaningful — a bit under 100 bps — which gives us good comfort. That let us both deliver the profit level we're reporting here and keep building up this provision that had been set aside gradually, so we can safeguard our ability to pay the profit-sharing rate to our customers down the road. That provision — this specific provision — now stands at €11.8 billion. It went up again by roughly €300 million, just in the quarter, and it now equals about 5.6% of the outstanding at Predica. So that's where the insurance activity stands. And the cost of risk — as I mentioned, the extra provisions in S1 and S2 have various justifications. They could stem from a tougher macroeconomic scenario, if one were needed. That isn't the case, and we haven't changed the macroeconomic scenario, since we're confident in what we've assumed within it. They could also stem from how the loan portfolio evolves. So either new loans grow — which expands the S1 category and therefore calls for some ECL, a one-year ECL, so it's a very small amount.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlternatively, when loans migrate from S1 to S2, that requires more provisioning, since the provisioning level rises when a loan moves from the S1 bucket into S2 — and this quarter that hasn’t really been the case much either. So the last reason, which matters a great deal — I’d describe it as part of our DNA, the prudence we build in — is the top-up on the provisions we book routinely, because LCL, because the regional banks, because CAL&F considers it necessary to book an additional provision for a particular sector or a particular geography. And that really accounts for the largest share of the S1 and S2 provision this quarter. Again, because all of these extra prudent measures were taken locally, but this does not stem from the central forward-looking scenario that we normally embed.
Matthew Clark
analystAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the questions for now. Please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell, thank you all very much for joining this meeting, and I hope we'll get to meet each other in person at some point. In the meantime, take care. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's conference call. Thanks for joining us. You can disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.