Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 10, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm glad to take you quickly through the document we published this morning and to show you the key highlights of our results. Let me turn straight to page four, where the main figures for Crédit Agricole Group as a whole are set out. As you can see, for this quarter we report a net profit of roughly EUR 2.2 billion, on both a stated basis and an underlying basis. That's up 25% on a stated basis and up 15.6% on an underlying basis. Over the first nine months of the year, net profit comes to EUR 6.7 billion on a stated basis and EUR 6.2 billion on an underlying basis. Perhaps three further observations on this page. First, you'll notice that this quarter the gap between underlying and stated is extremely small. Second, this high level of profit — actually a record high for a nine-month period — has again been achieved, I would say, through the same virtuous mechanisms, namely growth in the top line, which generates a strong and solid rise in gross operating income, along with a significant reduction in the cost of risk.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNow let me turn to Crédit Agricole S.A.'s own numbers, and there you'll notice broadly the same pattern. Net profit came in at EUR 1.4 billion for the quarter, on both a stated and an underlying basis. That works out to a 43% rise on a stated basis, and close to 27% on an underlying basis. Over the first nine months of the year, net profit stands at EUR 4.4 billion stated, and EUR 3.9 billion — nearly EUR 4 billion — underlying. That's a gain of almost 38%. Now let me move to the key messages we want to stress for this quarter. Once again, I'd say our commercial activity is very robust, and we keep bringing in new customers each quarter. That is driving a sharp rise in revenues and a sharp rise in net profit, and profitability remains at a high level — again, 13.1% return on tangible equity for CASA across nine months. This leads us to reaffirm our friendly stance on shareholder remuneration with, as you know, a second share buyback operation that is under way these days, which will add EUR 500 million.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe switch mechanism will be fully unwound this quarter, on November 16 — that is, next week — which comes one year earlier than the prior commitments we had made on the matter. We then confirm our intention to repay the remaining EUR 0.40 per share of dividend that we consider still owed to shareholders following the skipped 2019 dividend, and this will be carried out via a top-up across the next two dividends. One last point, perhaps, on this page: we confirm our very strong commitment to supporting the transition toward a decarbonated world, and we will provide some highlights on this highly important topic at a dedicated press conference scheduled for December 1, in three weeks' time. Let me now move to page eight, where some figures illustrate what I have just described — namely a strong level of customer capture and also a very good level of activity, shown through three items here: loan production at the retail banks in France, revenues from sales of new P&C insurance policies, and the rebound in production of new consumer loans.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, we might have shown this pattern using a lot more numbers. I'll move to page nine now, which gives us a few signals about how the top line developed in this quarter and across the first nine months. In this quarter, growth in the top line is highly dynamic: +7.6% for the quarter and +9.1% across the first nine months of the year. That's also a very robust change relative to the same period in 2019 — the pre-pandemic period. Even when those numbers are restated for some scope effect, the top line still evolves very dynamically: +4.4% Q3 on Q3, and +7.3% nine months on nine months. Perhaps one more remark on this page — details are available in the appendix of the document. The mix of our revenues keeps shifting progressively toward a larger portion devoted to fees and commission relative to net interest income. Taking everything together, the top line's movement from the first nine months of 2019 to the first nine months of 2021 amounts to an extra EUR 1.7 billion of revenues. Let me turn now to expenses and the cost base on page ten.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat we’re seeing is that costs have indeed gone up this quarter and across the first nine months of the year. If we once more restate the numbers for scope effects — and scope effects were indeed pretty significant this quarter, with, for instance, the Creval integration, along with some technical adjustments tied to the accounting of Crédit Agricole Consumer Finance Nederland and a few additional items — if we restate how the cost base evolved excluding those scope effects, we show for this quarter a rise of 3.8% in the cost base, and +3.4% over nine months, which tells us that in both periods we still have a positive jaws effect. Perhaps one final point on this cost base topic. The quarterly increase comes to a little bit more than EUR 100 million, restated for the scope effect. Nearly half of that increase is driven by some additional provisions linked to compensation — variable compensation, whether bonuses, individual compensations, or also collective remuneration, particularly at entities with a large number of employees such as LCL. On page 11, we show what is truly a key feature of the business model of Crédit Agricole S.A.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOver the past 4 or 5 years — and here we're giving the figures starting from 2017 — what becomes clear is that in each quarter, whether it's Q1, Q2, or Q3, we have managed, since 2017, to grow the revenue base. Simultaneously, we have managed to bring down the cost-to-income ratio fairly consistently. Looking back at the first 9 months of 2017 and comparing that with where we stand today, we've actually picked up nearly 5 percentage points on the cost-to-income ratio. Moving on to asset quality and cost of risk, page 12 shows that asset quality remains very strong, both within the Crédit Agricole S.A. perimeter and at the regional banks, which leads to a very impressive 2.2% NPE level for the group as a whole. Because we have stayed prudent on provisioning — including adding further bucket one and bucket two provisions again this quarter — the coverage ratio of our non-performing exposures, across the various provision categories held on our balance sheet, has kept rising substantially. We now stand at 75% on the CASA perimeter and 87% for the entire group.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIf you turn to page 13, the cost of risk is falling very steeply compared with Q3 2020. Versus Q2 2021, it's roughly flat. As I mentioned, that figure reflects not just Stage 3 provisioning but also a modest positive adjustment to Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisioning tied to certain sectoral approaches that, as you're aware, the group carries out under the local forward-looking approach. Our macroeconomic scenarios remain unchanged for now; we'll revise them for the fourth quarter, which probably means some movement in the Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisioning level at the end of this year. That feeds into the net income Group share evolution shown on page 14, where, as I've already noted, net income Group share is up sharply, both for the quarter and across the first nine months of the year. Taking the first nine months overall, you can see we managed to lift net profit by roughly EUR 1.1 billion over nine months — a combination of a very sharp rise in gross operating income of plus EUR 900 million, a substantial drop in the cost of risk of minus EUR 1.2 billion and, of course, some negative items, chiefly corporate taxes, up by around EUR 1 billion.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo this is how that EUR 1.1 billion rise in net income came about — really a balanced mix of gross operating income and the drop in cost of risk. Page 15 — we already showed this slide with the second quarter results, but once again, the trend is very stable and very steady. We're posting a return on tangible equity that is not only at a high level and significantly higher than last year, but also significantly above the average of our peers, and once again we're close to 3.5 percentage points above the average of the sample of 10 European banks that we've continued to follow this quarter. Page 16 — just to look back at all the elements regarding shareholder remuneration that took place or that are going to take place this year. As a reminder, two share buyback operations representing above EUR 1 billion and around 30 basis points of CET1 invested. Two trenches of switch dismantling, one that took place beginning of March, and the second one that is going to complete the unwinding, middle of November this year. All in all, this represents 80 BPS of CET1 invested.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe first set of actions—the share buyback—will clearly lower the share count. The second set of actions, dismantling the switch, will produce an improvement in net profit. Taken together, this benefits earnings per share. Beyond that, we reaffirm our dividend policy, and I would say it will let us fully repay the skipped 2019 dividend across three installments. The first, €0.30 per share, happened at the start of this year, and the remaining two will come alongside payment of the ordinary dividend for 2021 and 2022, for the remaining €0.40. Taken together, across this medium-term plan, we will have fully honored our commitment to give shareholders 50% of attributable profit in cash. Now let me move to some additional highlights, business line by business line, beginning on page 18 with the asset gathering and insurance business division. On page 18, you can see how the assets we manage have evolved. They are, naturally, sharply higher, thanks to a positive market effect among other factors. This business division is posting a very strong rise in its contribution to the group's net profit, +24%, close to 25% for the quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the insurance side specifically, activity was really buoyant this quarter. We saw strong inflows in savings and retirement, and those inflows are increasingly tilting toward unit-linked, plus really robust activity in P&C and protection as well. The contribution from this division to group profit rose sharply — up 13% this quarter — helped by a softer revenue level (we can go deeper into that during the Q&A if you'd like) and also by a very low corporate tax level, which relates to realizing some capital gains, long-term capital gains that carry a low corporate tax rate. Turning to Amundi and asset management, it was a very good quarter on the commercial side, with meaningful medium- and long-term inflows, excluding the joint ventures, where we had a one-off outflow, and very strong revenues, whether management fees or performance fees. Once again, Amundi posted a very good cost-to-income ratio, which is now a common feature for this entity. Its contribution to the group's net profit is very significantly up, plus 44% on the quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLooking at the large customers division, worldwide, revenues are a bit lower than in 2020 — down 2.5% — yet they're sharply higher than in 2019, up 9%. Costs are managed well, and the division's contribution to the group's net profit has risen considerably, +33%. Turning specifically to CACIB on page 22, there's a very balanced mix: strong performance in financing activities, where revenues climbed 13%, alongside a softer showing in capital market activities. That's because, as is true across the market worldwide, fixed income activities were weaker this quarter on a global market basis. Still, when we set our capital market and investment banking revenues for Q3 against Q3 2019, we remain up in revenue terms. The cost base is up a little, though only very moderately given these good operational performances. The cost of risk has come down very substantially, which drove another very significant rise in CACIB's net income group share this quarter, +35%. Moving to the specialized financial services division on page 23, beginning with consumer credit activities: production of new loans has returned to the 2019 level.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the managed loan book, it's taken a bit of a hit from the supply-chain disruptions in car manufacturing, and that's holding back growth in car financing, a business where we're quite active. On top of that, the consolidated loan book now stands at its highest point since 2014. Turning to the P&L — leaving aside certain technical restatement tied to Crédit Agricole Consumer Finance, Netherlands — the direction is strongly positive: revenues are higher, costs are handled well, cost of risk has come down, and overall the contribution is up another 7.5% in this quarter. In leasing and factoring, a solid quarter of activity, revenues higher, cost of risk lower, and this division is announcing a sizable acquisition this quarter. That acquisition is Olinn, a professional equipment leaser set to round out CALF's range of offerings. Moving on to retail banking and beginning with LCL, activity there is at a very elevated level, which fully bears out the rebound of the French economy, with record output of new loans, particularly home loans, plus customer acquisition, savings, and growth in customer savings. All of this is driving a substantial rise in the top line, up 5%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe cost line is a bit higher, but that's mostly because of the extra provision we've set aside for future collective variable compensation — as we put it in French. Combined with the cost of risk, which has fallen sharply, this is once more producing a substantial rise in LCL's contribution to the group's net profit: plus 30%. Turning to international retail banking, beginning with Italy, we first attempt to read through these numbers so as to gauge, let's say, how the historical Crédit Agricole Italia has performed. On that perimeter, activity has grown, and revenues are somewhat higher. The cost of risk is flat. The cost base is flat, and the cost of risk has dropped markedly. Crédit Agricole Italia's contribution — on the historical perimeter, I mean — is up considerably, plus 44%, Q3 on Q3. Beyond that, this is the first quarter in which Creval is fully consolidated within our perimeter. Creval accounts this quarter for a top-line contribution of EUR 145 million, along with a contribution to net profit of an extra EUR 15 billion. In this quarter, there was no one-off tied to the Creval acquisition. As you'll recall, we recorded the initial estimate of the bad will related to Creval at the end of June, and the purchase price accounting will be fully finalized in the fourth quarter, so nothing has been booked on that matter this quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning to international banking outside Italy, our retail banking operations there represent, I'd say, a continued normalization following the low point we hit in the middle of 2020 — a trough caused by the pandemic and by the monetary responses to it in the various countries where we operate. Revenue is on the rise. Once more, there's a particular accounting matter this quarter when you look at gross figures, since we have declassified our Serbian activities, which are now reported under IFRS 5; but restated for that — again, a scope effect — revenues are higher, cost of risk has fallen significantly, and this business division's contribution to CASA's net profit has risen very sharply, up 50%. On the corporate center this quarter, there's not much to note apart from one point: because the average level of the corporate tax rate shows up as a revenue rather than a cost for the corporate center. Since the average corporate tax rate we have this quarter is lower and is especially low, the tax profit level this quarter for the corporate center comes in below expectations and below the average, which accounts for the slight deterioration in the corporate center's PNL this quarter — but there's nothing structural in that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNow let me turn to Crédit Agricole's regional banks, to round out the picture of all our group operations. The trends you'll see are broadly similar to those at LCL — activity at a very dynamic level, plus solid customer capture. Over 900,000 new customers brought in during the first nine months of 2021. Loan books up significantly, and the digitization of the banking channels we run with our customers has also sped up. As you know, it first accelerated during the pandemic, and after the various lockdowns ended, rather than fading away, it remains very dynamic. Customer take-up of those tools is genuinely improving. Top line is up 3%, costs are managed very well, and the cost of risk is low. It's rising sharply versus Q3 2020, but Q3 2020 was entirely abnormal — we flagged and discussed that a year ago. In absolute terms, the cost of risk in Q3 2021 is very low for Crédit Agricole's regional banks. Now let me move to the capital position, beginning with how the risk-weighted assets evolved.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGlobally speaking, for this quarter, I'd say there has been no meaningful change in the level of risk-weighted assets — not within the CASA scope, and not for the group as a whole. There were modest increases tied to business growth, both in the large customers division and at the regional banks of Crédit Agricole, and there was no regulatory impact this quarter either. So in terms of how RWA evolved, I'd call it a very simple and straightforward quarter. That is producing a further rise in solvency levels — 12.7% for CASA, and 17.4% for the group. For CASA, naturally, this comes before the impact of the two operations I mentioned earlier, namely the second share buyback operation and the switch unwinding. Taken together, those two items will hit CASA's solvency by roughly 70 to 75 basis points, and that will be booked at the end of this year, so in Q4. Beyond that, in Q4 we will also have the impact of the Lyxor acquisition at around 15 basis points, and the Olinn acquisition at around 5 or 6 basis points. On the other side, we will get the benefits from completing the Creval acquisition, since, as you know, we consolidated only Creval's RWAs at the end of June, and we will now bring the goodwill accounting into our capital position, so around 10 basis points.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere's also the advantage from the capital increase being proposed to the employees, which will add roughly 5 basis points of capital. But overall, we're probably looking at somewhere between 5 and 10 basis points of capital depletion globally, tied to all of these operations during the fourth quarter. On liquidity, page 33, there isn't much to say. Our liquidity position is very ample, and there's not much to comment on. As for the market funding program, it's about 90% completed as of the end of October. Again, not much to mention, and nothing really significant this quarter. Perhaps by way of concluding this presentation, we can stress once more that our level of results is high — high relative to the past, but also high relative to our peers. That comes from a very virtuous combination: an increase in revenues, an increase in gross operating income, and a decrease in the cost of risk. This produces a strong capacity to finance our development — organic development — and also, here and there, non-organic acquisitions, along with a strong level of remuneration for our shareholders. Thank you very much, and I believe we can now take your questions.
Operator
operatorThank you. We're moving into the question-and-answer portion now. Just a reminder — to pose a question, hit star one on your phone and hold until your name is called. Kindly wait a moment while we put together the Q and A lineup. That won't take long. Should you want to withdraw your request, just press the hash key. To repeat: press star one if you'd like to ask something. Our first question is from Giulia Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Go right ahead.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystHello there, and good afternoon, Jérôme. Thanks for walking us through the presentation. My first question concerns your medium-term target. Essentially, you're running well ahead of plan and meeting most of the goals. As I recall, annualized revenues of roughly EUR 22 billion, a cost income ratio under 60%, and ROT above 11%. So when might we see an update to those? Do you have any thoughts on that? My second question relates to IFRS 17. Different banks have communicated quite differently on this during the quarter. Could you offer us any guidance on that, please?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright, thank you for those two questions. The first one is pretty straightforward to address. Without a doubt, we will provide fresh targets for the close of 2022. That is certain. We aren't fond of the notion of revising the target on a frequent basis, since that amounts to firing at targets that keep shifting, and that isn't truly a sound method of letting you gauge our ability to set a sensible target and subsequently endeavor to hit it. So we do have targets for 2022. It is conceivable that some of those targets get achieved ahead of schedule. We will definitely set new targets for probably 2025, which ought to be a sensible timeframe. That will happen at some point during 2022. I can't say precisely when, but you can well imagine that work on it is already underway. Regarding IFRS 17, once more, I would suggest we hold off a bit on the point when we'll provide you with specifics, but perhaps just to condense a few points about IFRS 17. To begin with, it is chiefly and nearly entirely a matter of shifting the results generated by insurance operations—primarily life insurance operations—across time, over time. It does not alter, in economic terms, how our businesses perform.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveFor the most part, it's about shifting the timing of when you recognize those profits. As you know, certain trade-offs come into play once you begin the migration process toward IFRS 17, and we haven't yet fully assessed all of the arbitrage we'll need to make for the first-time application of IFRS 17. Perhaps just one more point on that. We're doing everything we can to be thoroughly prepared for this transition to IFRS 17. You may have noticed that this quarter, once again, we further bolstered our PPE provision in the accounts of Predica, the group's life insurance company. Globally, that provision now stands at roughly EUR 13 billion. A level like this will help us accommodate IFRS 17. That's clearly a significant point. It shows that we are preparing everything within our power, as much as we can, so that we're ready and the transition can be as benign as possible. It won't come without any effect, but we're working to make it as benign as possible.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystThanks. To pick up on that first item, essentially we're expecting to see new targets during the back half of 2022, I suppose.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt some point during 2022.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystAlright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure.
Operator
operatorThank you. The next question is from Delphine Lee at J.P. Morgan. Please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveDelphine, hi there.
Delphine Lee
analystHello there. Good afternoon, everyone. I have a couple of questions. First, I'd like to revisit insurance. I realize profits have performed well and are up meaningfully versus a year ago, whether you look at Q3 or the nine-month figure. I'm just trying to think through the top line to get a sense of how to forecast the volatility that can arise from capital gains or other matters. So any remarks or color you could offer would help us understand a bit better what's happening there. My second question concerns capital. I just wanted to verify something. Thanks for the Q4 update. I also hoped you might, if possible, provide any news on the Basel IV impact, now that the text is out. And please confirm that this quarter you didn't take any remaining trim impact. As I remember, there's still another 6 to 7 billion to come over the next six quarters. So I'm wondering when those impacts should be expected. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright, thank you. Regarding insurance, once more, I believe this has already taken place previously, yet it remains somewhat unsettling when you attempt to evaluate the insurance numbers—the results under banking accounting rules. Allow me to try once more to clarify what occurred specifically during this quarter. Among the assets in Predica's portfolio, there is a sizable holding that had been owned for a very extended period and underwent a full restructuring, which produced a very substantial capital gain. That gain was subject to taxation at a low corporate tax rate, given that it qualifies as a long-term capital gain. What this means is that we managed to generate the profit level we consider appropriate for the quarter without, shall I say, recording a large financial margin, which appears in the top line under the banking accounting standard. You have a collection of financial revenues, and as you are aware, inside those financial revenues, one portion is assigned to the shareholder, while the remainder goes to the policy holders. Within what gets recognized and allocated to the policy holders, there is a further split you can make, which separates the provision for the year's profit-sharing rate from the PPE provision—allocated to the policy holder but set to be distributed at a later point.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo what we did this quarter is that, because of that low corporate tax applied to the capital gain, we booked a very small amount of financial margin attributed to the shareholder, which means a large amount of revenues went to the policy holders. Inside those revenues allocated to policy holders, we've kept building up the profit-sharing rate level, which needs to be paid at the end of this year more or less in line with what was paid last year. The remainder, and it's quite significant this quarter, is being set aside to keep strengthening this PPE provision, which firstly provides solvency to Crédit Agricole Assurances and secondly, as I mentioned, is going to support the transition to IFRS 17. That's technically what we did this quarter, and it has already happened at times in the past. I understand that forecasting this is a little bit tricky for you, that's for sure. Really, I think when it comes to the insurance activities, what matters is not necessarily the top line, but what's probably most important is the ability to keep generating a profitability level that's in line with how the business is developing, and of course, that contributes significantly to the net profit of CASA.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding that point—
Delphine Lee
analystMay I—
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah, absolutely.
Delphine Lee
analystSorry, may I just ask a quick follow-up to that point? Would it be reasonable to think that insurance growth might be somewhat, you know, limited over the next 2 to 3 years, while you continue building up PPE reserves ahead of IFRS 17?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNo, we aren't. To start with, we are definitely not putting a cap on growing the business — that's certain. We make every effort to keep accelerating in the P&C activities and in the protection activities. As for the life insurance activities, where the business is more stable, we keep trying to develop the unit-linked sector and unit-linked products as much as we can, compared with euro. You may have noticed that this quarter we have now reached a share of UL in the portfolio that sits at the target we had set for 2022, namely 26%. Plainly, we have no hesitation at all when it comes to developing the business. What we do is, of course, as I said, prepare as much as we can for the transition to IFRS 17, a regulation we did not ask for. It is something we must apply, but plainly it was not a request from our side. You can imagine that. Once again, further building up the PPE forms part of the preparation for this transition.
Delphine Lee
analystAlright.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning to your question about capital. Our reading of the commission's draft proposal is that the output floor will be the harshest element of Basel IV, and secondly, that floor will be applied at the topmost consolidation level, at least within a single country. What that means is that Crédit Agricole Group will be the entity that has to absorb the toughest portion of Basel IV. I can't pin down precisely what the effect on CASA itself will be, though it will be considerably smaller than for the group as a whole. Naturally, when we refresh the medium-term plan, we'll provide a more exact calculation of how Basel IV affects capital consumption at CASA and of the capital trajectory CASA will need to follow. On TRIM, it's entirely correct that we still have roughly EUR 6 billion-EUR 7 billion of extra RWA to integrate through the end of 2022. As things look right now, my guess is that this will occur only in 2022 — in other words, I don't anticipate anything happening before the close of this year.
Delphine Lee
analystThanks very much, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. Go right ahead.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYes. Good afternoon, Jerome. I have two questions. First, regarding the cost-income ratio: you're now firmly running the group at 60% or below — specifically 58% to 59%. Would you be tempted to try managing it at 55%, or do you simply not think that's wise, for a variety of reasons — activities, investment, or whatever else? That's my first question. Second, French retail appears to be shifting considerably. Looking at the consolidation bids currently underway — FLOA, HSBC, ING, in no particular order — and the fact that certain retail chairmen have voiced complaints about how PSD2 is being implemented, the overall picture seems perhaps somewhat better than it has been across the past five or six years. I'd just like your view on how you see it developing over the coming three years. Thank you, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate the questions. On the cost-income ratio: right now, the goal is to stay under 60%. That target holds through the end of 2022, and, as I mentioned, we won't be revising it—or that particular objective—until we put out a new medium-term plan. Second, naturally, we strongly believe that operating as efficiently as we can is an essential pillar of the group's overall model. We've had multiple occasions previously to lay out how we achieve that in order to enhance the cost-income ratio—how responsibility for running the group's cost base gets decentralized within the business lines, and so on and so forth. That highly disciplined way of managing the cost base is not something we intend to alter. Even so, I have some doubts regarding the notion of continually ratcheting the target downward—"forward" in the sense of lower and lower.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystMm-hmm.
Jérôme Grivet
executivePutting out a fresh goal of 55% — which is definitely off the table right now — doesn't strike me as particularly, shall we say, well-founded from where I sit. What we'll do as we get ready for the upcoming medium-term plan is take a close look at every cost saving available to us on, let's say, the ongoing cost base, plus all the investment we need to fund so we can keep adapting our setup. After that we'll run the numbers, and we'll see where that lands us, and if the path, and if the level we land at looks sensible, that will turn into our new target. We won't begin by picking a number whose sole virtue is that it's a round one, such as 55%. Alright?
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystThanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Turning to French retail — honestly, this question still strikes me as somewhat odd, since for us this isn't a business where we'd say, alright, we're going to make trade-off decisions because the outlook looks brighter, so we ought to hold a bit more French retail than previously, and should conditions worsen, we'd then examine ways to cut back our exposure to French retail. French retail truly is the foundation of the group. It is genuinely the circle upon which we were built. By definition, being as efficient as we can, as aggressive as we can, as conquering as we can in this market and in this kind of business is absolutely essential for us. Naturally, after years of real strain on margin and real strain on profitability, we're delighted that prospects appear somewhat better on a global basis. Regardless, this sits at the very core of the group's DNA, and the place we give French retail within the group admits no debate whatsoever.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystAll right, thanks, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Jacques-Henri Gaulard.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Please go ahead.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystYes, good afternoon. I have two questions. First, returning to the jaws, let me put the question another way. Do you believe that once the restructuring charge is excluded, there remains room for the cost income ratio to improve? The second question concerns net interest income in Italy, ex-TLTRO and ex changes in the scope of consolidation, so ex Creval, because you point out that revenues are up 1%, but inside that, fees are up 19%. My guess is that NII is down roughly 8% year-over-year, and I would like to understand whether that is a new normal level, or whether there are any incidentals in Q2 in Q3 that might account for such a decline in NII excluding TLTRO and Creval? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Regarding the jaws effect, we will keep working to enhance cost efficiency in every single business as we move forward. I believe that at some point we have to be sensible, and the improvement cannot continue forever at the same rate. Once again, I am fully convinced that in nearly every business, here and there, there remains room for additional improvement. There is also a second factor you should factor in, namely that the mix of the various businesses within the group is constantly shifting. This can lead to changes in the weighted average cost-income ratio, since the larger the share of businesses such as the insurance operations or Amundi, the asset management business, whose cost-income ratios sit below the group average, the more favorable that is for the average cost-income ratio. Again, it is hard to put it so plainly, but I would say: trust us, we know how to manage the cost base, and we have been quite efficient at it. We will not do anything that would not be sensible, but we cannot keep reducing the cost-income ratio forever at the same rate.
Jérôme Grivet
executivePerhaps a final remark on this topic: managing the cost-income ratio isn't solely about costs—it also hinges on revenues. Being able to keep expanding the revenue base matters a great deal. That will likewise support the cost-income ratio. Regarding NII in Italy, it's accurate that NII declined rather markedly this quarter. That has been our experience. It has also been the experience across most of the Italian market. We've examined how competitors performed, and clearly margins remain better in Italy than in France, yet they are under pressure. That is 100% certain. That's why in Italy, as in France, and globally for the group, we endeavor as much as possible to build up the fee-based portion of revenues. So if at some point the yield curve improves, and if that enables us to finally generate, I would say, an enhancement of NII, so much the better.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystAll right, thanks. Could I get some clarification, please, regarding how SoYou affects both the revenue and the cost?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure. I’m just verifying the numbers, but at the moment, SoYou has not yet hit breakeven. My understanding is that it will get to breakeven in 2023, unless I’m misremembering. As things stand right now, Clotilde, do you not have the cost and revenue amounts?
Clotilde L'Angevin
executiveOver to Philippe.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah.
Speaker
unknownIf we leave SoYou out of the picture, revenue went up 2.6%, while on a basis that includes bringing SoYou in, with full consolidation, the increase was 3%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveClotilde, are you able to hear me? When you compare how the top line moved with SoYou versus without it, the gap comes to 0.4%. Sure, we can explain things the way we report in euros, but that is roughly how big the difference is. On timing, once more: SoYou has not yet hit break even.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystMuch appreciated.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. Our following question is from John Hughes with Goldman Sachs. The floor is yours.
John Hughes
executiveHello, and good afternoon. Two questions from me — the first concerns cost of risk, the second large customers. On cost of risk: across the sector we've now watched provisions sit at very low levels for several quarters, and that applies not just to Crédit Agricole but to a great many banks. Rather than asking when it will rise again or return to normal, or some variation on that, what I'd like to ask is this: what would it take for it to stop remaining where it currently sits, in a sense? The heart of the question is that this situation appears to be persisting, and in your view, what would need to happen to push it back up? On my second question, about large customers: there's been some growth in risk-weighted assets in that area, and revenues are roughly in line, or somewhat lower. Looking at the nine months, my question is this — I would have imagined that last year, given all the growth, particularly with state guarantee and so forth, we wouldn't be seeing this much growth at this point. I'd just like to understand what within this business is growing, and whether you regard these as deals that are happening now, as the lending activity and so on suggest, or whether you believe these revenues carry some recurring characteristics and form a good base going forward?
John Hughes
executiveAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll begin with your second question. Truly, when it comes to financing activities, the revenue momentum is distributed across every one of the sub-business lines we have in that area. That holds true for the structured finance division, and it holds true for the commercial banking activities, syndicated loans, trade finance, and so forth. It really is a very strong dynamic, one that is entirely tied first to the macroeconomic outlook, which is positive around the globe, not just in France. Second, it's also tied to the fact that at no point during the last 24 months had we, I would say, pulled back from the market; we've been there the whole time alongside our customers, ready to finance them. It is absolutely certain that we've improved our ranking and positioning among the core bankers of our corporate customers. What that means is that whenever they have an operation to finance, they come to us for support. Without question, I believe we've picked up some market share. It's hard to put that into words or to quantify it, but we've improved our positioning in the field of financing activities through the pandemic and the crisis. As for the cost of risk, it's very hard to say what would be required for the situation not to evolve, if I've understood your question correctly.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat I can say is that our approach to cost of risk and provisioning is quite prudent. That's the reason why, through the third quarter of 2021, we kept adding to our Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions. Some of our peers — U.S. peers, certainly, but European peers as well — began writing back Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisioning one or two quarters ago, and we actually had the ability to do that, because the macroeconomic scenario we use to calculate those Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions for now still assumes GDP growth in France for 2021 of under 6%, and we know perfectly well that it will be significantly higher than 6%. That is one of the items we will refresh in the scenario we will apply in the fourth quarter. We have been prudent, meaning that if conditions were to worsen somewhat over the next few quarters, we would surely have some room to maneuver to absorb that without a massive hit to the PNL from a sharp rise in provisioning. But naturally, we depend on the overall macroeconomic environment.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveShould the macroeconomic environment take a sharp, substantial turn for the worse from here, I just don't see a way for us to sidestep it. Our preparation is stronger than that of most peers, yet avoiding it would not be possible for us. Given how large we are, particularly across Europe — I believe we account for roughly 5% of the global banking balance sheet in Europe — any serious event that occurs is going to hit us.
John Hughes
executiveLet me put that another way. If the cost of risk in the coming year turned out to equal this year's figure, would that catch you off guard?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNot always. That isn't a projection, nor a premise we're assuming, and it isn't guidance either. It could certainly happen, since — to repeat — what sets this crisis apart from earlier ones is how effective and how sturdy the official responses have been. As of now, those official responses keep proving adequate.
John Hughes
executiveAll right, that's very clear. Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it. Our following question is from UBS, with Lorraine Quoirez. The floor is yours.
Lorraine Quoirez
analystHi, Jérôme. I've got what I'd call a couple of questions, and they lean more toward the strategic side. First, when you laid out your 2022 plan, you spent a lot of time on forming partnerships to distribute your products across Europe. Since then, obviously, quite a bit of consolidation has happened, along with management changes too. You may have found that this approach has turned out to be risky in certain cases. I was wondering how you view the future development of your product factories, and whether we ought to be considering perhaps more concrete international opportunities — maybe more acquisitions rather than partnerships down the road. That's my first question. The second one concerns your payment strategy. Maybe I missed something, but I believe there hasn't been much of an update since the partnership with Wirecard came to an end. I just wanted to know whether you've actually upgraded your customer offering to, you know, improve it, particularly when it comes to e-commerce. What's the plan going forward for payments? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, two questions, and they're closely linked, since ultimately everything comes down to partnership. On the partnership side, to build out the core product factories we have, if you look back at what we've done from 2019 onward, there's a really significant set of operations we've carried out. I'm not talking about acquisitions here — you know, the Creval or KAS Bank acquisitions. But there's the Sabadell partnership in asset management, which sits somewhere between an acquisition and a partnership. There's the Banco Santander partnership in custody. There's the creation of Amundi Technology and the growth of Amundi Technology's client base. There's the Bank of China joint venture. There's ABANCA. There's the expansion of Azqore — the platform, the back-office and IT platform for private banking activities in Switzerland — with this new and very important client, Société Générale. A lot of developments. We believe this will keep being a key driver for growing our businesses. Naturally, it's far simpler when it sits entirely within the group, where you can, you know, equip your own clients with your own product factories.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt isn't always feasible, and in our view the approach of seeking to leverage — I'd say — the critical mass we hold across most of these business factories, so that we can deliver our products and services to other banks' customers in a win-win manner, remains and will keep being a highly significant route for growing our product factories. Once more, as you said, this is a strategic matter, and we will definitely make the trajectory clear in the upcoming medium-term plan. Regarding payment services, well, most of what we did over recent months and quarters came from internal development. It isn't very visible. It doesn't show up as public announcements, but we are building some significant features, such as the acquisition and integration of Linxo, an account aggregator, into the various banking offerings we have across the group, such as the development of biometric cards, and also the participation we are taking in the EPI initiative. We are working quite intensively at present. I'm not claiming it will occur anytime soon, but it could happen, since this is a field — like the other areas of the dedicated product lines — where we can quite readily see the relevance of entering into new partnerships.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight now, we've been handling a lot of work inside the company — quietly, I'd say — but it's paying off, and we're continuing to grow the activity. And again, by definition, this will be a highlight of the next medium-term plan.
Lorraine Quoirez
analystAlright.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right?
Lorraine Quoirez
analystI'll be ready for that. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThank you. Our next question is from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. The line is yours.
Stefan Stalmann
analystGood afternoon, Jérôme, and thank you for taking my questions. I'd like to revisit the cost-income topic, if I may, from a somewhat different angle. Essentially, you're running, let's say, 3 percentage points better than the 2022 target you established. I was wondering whether you could identify what differs from how you'd have expected to be performing at this point in the plan, and what the underlying drivers are behind those differences that have pushed the cost-income ratio below where you anticipated it would land — whether that's mix, volume, competition, or productivity. Anything in that vein would be very helpful. My second question concerns leverage. I believe you've provided a new disclosure point on your daily leverage ratio. I suppose the first part of my question is whether this 3.9% daily leverage ratio is on the same basis as the quarter-end ratio of 4.6%, so excluding ECB deposits? Assuming the answer is yes, and it's on the same basis, then it appears you have very, very significant intra-quarter changes to your balance sheet. It seems that during the quarter, your balance sheet is almost 20% larger than at period-end, and you say it's coming from securities financing reverse repos.
Stefan Stalmann
analystBasically, then, you could work backward and conclude that during the quarter you're running perhaps EUR 300 billion of repos on a daily basis, rather than EUR 120 billion. Orders of magnitude like that would leave me somewhat surprised. Could you perhaps say a little about what is going on there? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLet me begin with the cost-income ratio. As you mentioned, for the time being we're guiding the group at a cost-income ratio level that sits 3 percentage points under the target we originally set. There are many different factors behind that gap. The first is that, naturally, when we announced the target, we aimed to be somewhat conservative, and when everything moves in the right direction, we can outperform it. That happens regularly. Then, naturally, as I mentioned, the cost-income ratio is revenues divided by costs. What we recognize today is that we've not only handled the cost base very efficiently, but we've also produced revenues that are probably above what we had in mind when we set that 60% cost income ratio target. On managing the cost base, we've been efficient because, again, we use this approach of decentralizing responsibility for managing the cost base — the various cost bases of the various businesses — to the heads of those businesses. That's a very efficient method of ensuring that within every business we pursue the last mile of cost cutting so as to be as efficient as we can, and it works far better than across-the-board cost cutting exercises.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI have to say the pandemic itself created certain opportunities for reducing costs. Some of those were temporary, yet several are inclined to become somewhat more lasting, since it's very likely that in the future we will structurally travel less than we used to, along with many other things of that kind. We are probably securing some extra savings beyond what we anticipated at the time we issued that 60% target. Keep clearly in mind that on the revenue side, we are likewise probably well above what we expected when we published our targets. As for the leverage ratio, it is entirely correct that computing the leverage ratio each day is very similar, and it is fully similar to how the calculation is done at quarter-end. It is equally correct that we have been rather, I would say, nimble at monitoring balance sheet size within a quarterly period versus at the close of the period, given that until lately the only binding constraint was the ratio at the period's end. I should note that, globally, the market works that way, because worldwide, when we asked our counterparts to cut exposures and activity volume beginning a few days prior to quarter-end and then start expanding once more right after quarter-end, that was, I would say, standard market practice.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBeyond being standard industry practice, this was also fully visible to the supervisor. I'd say there's nothing really unusual on that front. When it comes to how the exact calculation is done, I'm not able to confirm the specific figures you mentioned with precision. What I can confirm is that we've clearly been tracking the size of the balance sheet, and it varies quite a bit between within a quarter and the end of the period.
Stefan Stalmann
analystThat’s great, and it really helps. Thanks so much, Jérôme.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Matthew Clark at Mediobanca. Go right ahead.
Matthew Clark
analystGood afternoon. I have a couple of questions, please. First, regarding the PPE reserve in insurance, I'd just like to hear your thinking on when it will be sufficient. Over the past few years, you've been adding roughly EUR 1 billion or EUR 1.5 billion each year. I mean, once IFRS 17 has been adopted, is that pace now adequate? Could you slow down, so that some of that reserve build flows to shareholders rather than policyholders? In practical terms, is this something you really must keep building into perpetuity, and should we think of it not so much as a cushion but as, you know, an essential element of your provisioning — so provisioning against likely future outlays rather than potential future outlays? My next question concerns the Italian retail banking division. I guess first, would you call the third quarter revenue base a reasonable run rate? There were no particular positive or negative lumpy items in it. Second, in Italy, could you provide some kind of guidance on the outlook for restructuring charges from Creval? Also, now that you've signed the agreement with the unions, are you able to talk about synergy potential?
Matthew Clark
analystThanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right. As you mentioned, the PPE is a reserve, but I want to emphasize that point. It gets allocated at the end of the year at the latest. When it comes to quarterly reporting, in the interim quarters, it is provisional, and it can be modified by year end. On an annual basis, once it has been booked in the yearly accounts, it is fully allocated to the policyholders, and it cannot be moved back to the shareholders. The question is when it will be drawn upon to top up the yearly profit sharing rate, which is in fact paid to the policyholders, yet it cannot be shifted back to the shareholder. It can assist the shareholder in obtaining its portion of the financial revenues, because if it is drawn upon to top up the revenues produced on an ongoing basis by the asset portfolio, then it can allow a greater portion of this year's financial revenues to be allocated to the shareholder. It cannot be moved back to the shareholder directly. The use of this PPE is, I would say, threefold. The first advantage we already derive from the PPE's existence is the fact that it supplies solvency to the life insurance company.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure — at the end of the day, this either helps Crédit Agricole S.A. upstream a higher dividend level, or it lets Predica adjust somewhat how its assets are broken down so it can generate more revenues down the road, even though that's more costly from a solvency standpoint or whatever. It's first a component of the life insurance company's solvency, and in itself it benefits the shareholder. The second point — and this is very specific to the current period — is that it will help accommodate the transition to IFRS 17. The metrics aren't very straightforward or very clear to explain, but definitely having a higher PPE is going to help in this arbitration we'll have to do between building the contractual service margin, the initial service margin we'll have to book, and recognizing results going forward. The third point, which is why we haven't been using PPE significantly up to now, is that it's going to be very useful when rates increase again. Because clearly, the moment when we could be in a situation where we lack financial revenues compared to customers' expectations is the moment when long-term rates on the market will be significantly higher than they are now.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe asset portfolio won't bring in sufficient revenue to meet what policyholders expect. So the PPEs will then be drawn on to, you know, top up the yearly revenues and to keep the policy portfolio as stable as possible. That's exactly the point at which we can see that holding a high PPE is going to help. For the time being-
Matthew Clark
analystAnd the-
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAbsolutely, go right ahead.
Matthew Clark
analystOnce you reach that stage, would you expect to stop putting the same level of gross contributions into the PPE reserve?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAbsolutely. Once we reach the point where we recognize that the annual revenues from the asset portfolio won't be sufficient to simultaneously cover shareholder remuneration and the expected profit-sharing rate for policyholders, it will become very important to be able to supplement those revenues with a portion of the PPE. As things stand right now, our PPE equals roughly 6% of total euro outstanding, which is quite significant and provides us with considerable room to maneuver, should such a period arise. Regarding Italy, there are no particular or highly specific factors in this quarter's revenues. I'm not sure whether we can call that a run rate, but what I can say is that there are definitely no specificities that would push me to be either cautious or more aggressive about the ability to replicate the same revenue level going forward. As for restructuring costs, the plan is that when we complete the finalization of the PPA at the end of this year in the fourth quarter, we will of course fund the required restructuring provisions by drawing on the PPA, through this PPA.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe thinking is that moving forward, we won't have to absorb any further restructuring charges in the P&L — in the ongoing P&L of Crédit Agricole Italia. As for synergies, revenue and cost alike, we've given some details on the target we have in mind. I believe we'll be in a position to update those targets at the time of the legal merger at the end of this year. Clearly, we're on track to hit that return on investment above 10% — and significantly above it — that we had in mind when we acquired Creval.
Matthew Clark
analystAll right, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies — go ahead, please.
Flora Bocahut
analystYes, good afternoon, Jérôme. Two questions on retail banking, if I may, to begin with. The first concerns loan growth in France. Given the strong rebound we saw this quarter, I just wanted to ask what we should expect going forward — for instance, should we anticipate a slowdown in mortgage growth, since the rules were tightened recently? And do you think loan growth in consumer credit and corporates in France will keep picking up from here, or is it still very difficult given the huge amount of household savings and corporate liquidity? The second question is about fee performance, specifically in French retail and also in Italy, where it has been very strong. Could you explain a bit what has driven this growth and whether you expect it to continue from here? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn loan growth — yes, the Haut Conseil de Stabilité Financière has tightened the home-loan rules quite considerably as of late. So far, though, we haven't observed any pullback in demand for credit from our customers. Naturally, we're now bound to comply with those rules. We have to ensure we honor the duration cap of 25 years maximum, the effort-rate ceiling of 35% maximum, and the limit on exceptions we're permitted to make, which is 20% maximum. Whenever we review a home-loan credit application, we need to confirm that these rules are being followed. As for output — the newest generation of new home-loan production — you know, over this summer, we were complying with the rules. Even so, we managed to generate the highest loan-production levels on record. At present, the market can handle both strict adherence to the rules and a strong volume of new-loan production at the same time. Looking ahead, it's possible that at some point the momentum will ease.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveUp to now, no deceleration in credit demand has shown up in what we're seeing. Turning to the other credit demand categories — business credit and consumer credit — on the consumer credit side, I'm quite upbeat, since household spending has been a major engine behind the economy's rebound over the last month. French customers' willingness to spend remains very strong. On top of that, one can anticipate that eventually the bottlenecks that are somewhat holding back the growth of particular subcategories of credit — consumer credit demand, that is, cars, plus certain other equipment goods — will get resolved, and we'll witness a pickup in purchases of new cars or new household equipment goods. Truly, on consumer credit, my sense is that the outlook is very favorable. Regarding businesses, each poll we conduct, each survey we run among our customers or that we observe in the market, indicates that investment intentions among corporates and businesses stand at their peak. Businesses are eager to invest, so they will embark on two financing operations.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, that will tie in closely with how they interpret the economic picture and the outlook for the economy, but at present they remain favorable. Obviously, I believe there’s also no reason to anticipate a near-term deceleration in business loans. If I look further out, naturally, uncertainty is quite elevated, since we’re in territory that is so unfamiliar—given the mix of public instruments, the vigor of the recovery, and so forth—that it is highly uncertain. As for the quarters ahead, I’m quite optimistic. Fees in the retail banking operations—the makeup, the split of fee income in Italy versus France—are not identical. In Italy, it is entirely driven by off-balance-sheet management products. So long as the inflow of new savings from our customers stays substantial, we’ll maintain a solid level of fees. What we’re trying to accomplish in Italy is, as far as possible, to alter somewhat the composition of the fees and to rely less on one-off fees tied to flows and more on management fees that are driven by the outstanding.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt this point, I have to say the main thing driving this is the flows. Within the French retail bank, fees and commissions break down across a far wider set of areas. There are fees tied to securities and off balance sheet savings, plus fees connected to insurance policies — whether life insurance or non-life insurance — and that is growing fairly fast. There are also fees coming from various services attached to the payment account, to payments, or to the sight deposit account, sight account, current account. As you know, it is spread much more across different categories, and in France it is probably steadier and more stable than in Italy. One last point: in Italy, of course, we will progressively equip Creval's customers with our own product factories, likely with better efficiency. Already this quarter, Amundi is now plugged into Creval's customer base so it can begin distributing its products, which will generate fees.
Flora Bocahut
analystAlright, thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC — apologies for that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there.
Operator
operatorKiri, you have the floor.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveKiri?
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystIs this coming through now? My apologies — I believe my line was muted. Yes, indeed. Hello there, Jérôme. To start with, circling back to insurance, though somewhat indirectly, I'd like to hear your view on the Banques Populaires CNP transaction. In your assessment, will they emerge as a more formidable and better-integrated bancassurance competitor within France as time goes on? Clearly not right away, of course, but maybe gradually. Then, second, regarding capital, once the switch has fully run its course, ought we to anticipate any effect on your Pillar 2 requirements? Might some advantage materialize when your subsequent SREP letter arrives concerning the Pillar 2 element? Many thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveKiri, hearing that second question of yours is genuinely wonderful. Perhaps that's something you ought to put to the ECB instead.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystAlright.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI honestly don't know about that, but having that kind of reasoning would certainly be useful. As for La Banque Postale and CNP, what I see happening is essentially a form of normalization. At the start, La Banque Postale was the sole retail bank in France lacking its own home life insurance company. After that, it became CNP's parent company, though CNP remained listed. Now they will be in the same position as every other banking group in France — an in-house life insurance company operating alongside the network. Naturally, it will probably be slightly more efficient. Keep two things in mind. First, CNP is already, I'd say, on equal footing with us as the leading player in French life insurance, so for them this won't be a game changer. Like us, they already sit at the top. Second, and this matters, remember the sociology of La Banque Postale's customer base. It isn't the wealthiest customer base available in France.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystAll right, that’s very clear. Thanks, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOf course.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Pierre Chédeville at CIC. You have the floor.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there, Pierre.
Pierre Chédeville
analystHi, Jérôme. I’ve got one question about the CA Mobility project. It also ties into partnerships. Do you plan to build this business fully by yourselves, or are you looking to bring in a partner—particularly when it comes to platforms for maintenance or tire replacement, those sorts of things that matter a lot for this business? Could you share some—or maybe it’s too early, I’m not sure—some of your ambitions for this project in terms of break even or in terms of number of contracts. My second question concerns Crédit Mutuel’s proposal to remove the health questionnaire for insurance.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveCredit insurance.
Pierre Chédeville
analystOn mortgages — right, sorry. I was hoping to hear your perspective on this proposal. If you were to adopt a measure like that, what effect might it have on LCL or on the Crédit Agricole group? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Those are two solid questions. Regarding CA Mobility, let me be very precise: CA Mobility will be a platform dedicated to individuals and professionals. It isn't exactly the same as the big platforms that already exist in Europe and sometimes in France, which handle, I would say, fleet management for large clients. What we want with CA Mobility is to be able to offer our individual and professional clients, within our own networks, a car-as-a-service offering, I would say. Naturally, it matters to reach a critical size as soon as possible so that we can have efficient cost management for all the services we intend to provide to customers, as you mentioned. The target we set initially is to manage, as quickly as possible, perhaps within the next five years, at least 100,000 cars. That isn't massive when you bear in mind that the big players in this business manage 1.5 million cars across the globe, or at least across Europe. Again, bear in mind that it isn't exactly the same business, since our own business will focus on individuals and professionals.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the small side —
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveClients.
Pierre Chédeville
analystJérôme, if I could, one more question. Say I have an LCL client, for example, and I'm after long-term vehicle leasing. Would you offer, under that long-term leasing contract, to handle my car's maintenance and to look after my tires once they're worn?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveDefinitely.
Pierre Chédeville
analystWhat I want to know is how you'll accomplish that using your own platforms, or will you bring in a partner? Since it's-
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt the end of the day, that's the idea.
Pierre Chédeville
analystThat's not something my agent in the branch could do — change my tire.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight, right. Exactly. The clear notion here is that we'll have to secure arrangements with professionals who actually deliver the service, since hiring tens or hundreds of mechanics ourselves to serve our clients isn't something we're going to do. Naturally, we will need partners with whom we hold agreements to supply that service — that much is certain.
Pierre Chédeville
analystSo you'll be building the platform using specialists who reach out to garagistes, say, to handle the maintenance?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNo. I’m not sure whether that’s what you’d call a platform, but we’re going to have arrangements with professionals who are already out there — dealership branches of particular automakers, that kind of thing — and those parties will be in a position to deliver the service to our own clients. What we’re aiming for is the part where we bring all the services together, supply the financing, supply the insurance, and then give the customer the use of a car for one straightforward monthly amount.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat's right. As for creditor insurance and what Crédit Mutuel has announced, well, we're still looking into the proposal a bit — though it isn't really a proposal, it's a decision-
Pierre Chédeville
analystCorrect.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat’s been announced so the impact can be assessed in full. When it comes to this credit insurance business, I’d say there are two extremes. One option is that you want to mutualize as much as possible so the service can be offered to all or most of the population — including the segment that is in a bad condition and that carries a higher risk of triggering the guarantee — and that is entirely respectable. We understand that Crédit Mutuel’s proposal is going in this direction. The consequence then should be to give more stickiness to the portfolio of policies that you have. Until now, every evolution of the regulation was going in exactly the opposite direction, i.e., giving more and more liberty to the policyholders so they can pick and choose their insurer and leave their insurer in order to take a new one. This is guiding towards exactly the opposite direction, in which the individual policyholder is able to get the best adapted offer for his own risk, i.e., then a situation where the pricing can be very, very different between a very good risk and a very bad risk.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, given who we are, Crédit Mutuel’s priorities are very much our own, and we would be glad to see any regulatory change that trims somewhat the gap between the highest and lowest prices and that would, naturally, at the same time, require an insurer operating in this line to accept good risks along with bad ones. You cannot simultaneously have complete freedom for policyholders and for borrowers and then no distinction between good risks and bad risks. That is a catch-22. At this point, naturally, we have made no assumption or hypothesis regarding how this decision will affect our own portfolios, but this is a highly significant matter that we are working on.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright, thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. Thanks. I believe that's the final question.
Operator
operatorYes, the final question is from Omar Fall at Barclays. Go ahead, please.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there, Omar.
Omar Fall
analystHi there, I'll keep this brief since I only have two questions. First, regarding CIB costs, which rose 5% for the quarter and really for the first nine months as well. From reading some of the write-ups, it looks like this reflects investments and head count growth rather than simply the bonus variable compensation patterns we've observed elsewhere. Could you shed some light on that? Because it's perhaps somewhat surprising that you're expanding here at this stage of the cycle, when talent is possibly rather pricey and your model isn't as aggressive as some competitors in CIB. My second question concerns SFS and the medium to longer-term revenue trajectory in consumer finance. Because there are, I suppose, a fair number of headwinds at present. There's the supply chain shortages, and who knows how long those will persist. Structural factors surrounding buy now, pay later. Lastly, we have all this retail savings parked in Livret A and current accounts, which don't really assist consumer re-leveraging. Some perspective on that would be useful.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIf you look at how the CIB cost base has evolved over the first nine months rather than just the quarter, a significant share of that rise is tied to the higher provision for paying future bonuses. I don't have the exact share in mind, but it should be — it's quite significant. Let me do a rough calculation; it should come to roughly one-fourth of the increase, so it's quite significant. Again, this isn't a commitment to pay those amounts by the end of the year. It will depend on the full results of the year. Nevertheless, at the same time, I already stressed that we've been building up our franchise a little bit in certain CIB activities, whether in the financing activities or also in the fixed income markets. Of course, we've been complementing our teams a little bit, whether with staff or with the IT tools, in order to be as efficient as possible and as relevant as possible. It's a mix, and it's not only — but it's partly due to the will to strengthen our position, not across the board.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat we're not trying to do is claim this was an extremely strong quarter in equity derivatives and that we now want to rebuild a franchise overnight that will produce revenues next quarter. What we want is to keep building on our strength — steadily, regularly, slowly, but actively — so that we can keep generating additional revenues. Naturally, there's the matter of provisioning bonuses, which so far haven't been granted to the beneficiaries, and we'll wait until January or February to be more precise about that. If I understood your question correctly, it was about consumption and the prospects for further consumption in the French market, given all the savings that have built up and all the tools that are, I would say, inducing the consumer to act — these pay now pay later, buy now devices and so on and so forth. Well, I think there clearly is an appetite for consumption among the French population. And clearly, part of that appetite for consumption is, for the time being, somewhat held back by the bottlenecks and disruptions in the supply chain. If you want to buy a new car in France right now, it's very likely that the delivery date will be somewhere around the middle of 2022.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHonestly, this does hold back consumption growth somewhat. People genuinely want to spend, so order books remain extremely busy.
Omar Fall
analystAll right, that's excellent. Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of the question queue. At this point, I’ll turn things back to the speaker for closing comments.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right, thank you so much, everyone. I appreciate your tuning in to this conference, and I look forward to getting together again — that won't be 3 months from now, but rather at some point in December, I believe. All right, take care, and bye-bye. Talk to you before long.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.