Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 5, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorHello, and thanks for being with us today. Welcome to Crédit Agricole's conference call on our first quarter 2022 results. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the speaker's presentation, we will hold a question and answer session. If you'd like to ask something during that session, please press star one on your phone. Please note that this conference is being recorded today, and should you need any further help, just press star zero. At this point, I'd like to turn the conference over to today's speaker, Jérôme Grivet, our CFO. Please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. I'm glad to walk you through these Q1 results for Crédit Agricole S.A. and the group. Let me begin right away on page four of the presentation, where it shows the net profit we report for the group as a whole landing at EUR 1.3 billion in the stated format, as I'd put it, while underlying net income group share stands at EUR 1.5 billion. The gap this year pitting stated against underlying is largely accounted for by a specific provision taken on Ukraine, though I'll come back to that point later. Turning to the next page, for CASA's figures, you can observe a solid revenue dynamic. Revenues have risen 7.5%. We also see gross operating income climbing by close to 5% quarter-over-quarter, Q1 against Q1. Our cost of incurred risk is very low, and indeed it is coming down relative to Q1 2021. Working the opposite way, there's a substantial rise in what we contribute to the Single Resolution Fund, +25%, and we have certain specific provisions being booked in connection with the Russia-Ukraine crisis, but we'll go into that in a bit more detail a little later. Moving now to page seven, specific information is laid out there on exactly this, the Ukraine and Russia situation.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe’re still doing what we did right after the crisis broke out at the end of February. In Ukraine, we began giving material and financial support to our employees and their families. To those employees, I really want to say thank you, because since that date they’ve done a wonderful job continuing to support their own customers. In fact, even now, on a daily basis, almost two-thirds of our branches are still open as usual. In Russia, since the start of the crisis, we have halted all new financing to Russian counterparties, and we have also stopped all commercial activity in our Russian entity. On risks, the proven risk on Russian and Ukrainian counterparties is very low. Actually, this quarter we had EUR 43 million of provisioning, bucket three, I would say, provisioning on Russian counterparties, and EUR 20 million directly within the books of our Ukrainian subsidiary. But we have been much more conservative in taking additional provisions. On Ukraine, we booked EUR 195 million of additional provision in CASA’s books, which actually leads to a full write-off of the value of the equity we hold in our Ukrainian subsidiaries. We can say that after this, after booking this provision, all our potential risk regarding Ukraine is now fully covered.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding the Russian counterparts, we have booked roughly EUR 350 million in provisions — bucket one and bucket two — against Russian performing exposures. On managing that book — the credit exposure book tied to Russian counterparties — the total size, across all the different compartments of exposures we may hold, is down about EUR 600 million from the end of last year. In the press release we published at the beginning of March, we provided end of December figures. In fact, the decline since the crisis broke out is even larger: a reduction of EUR 1.1 billion in the overall size of the book. On page eight, just a few extra remarks about what took place this quarter. Beyond what I just said on Russia and Ukraine, commercial momentum has been very good, with significant net customer capture and continued growth across all activities — credit, savings inflows, insurance, equipment, and so on and so forth. That feeds into the financial figures I already provided and will detail a bit further later on.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning back to page nine, we again see strong customer acquisition — over 500,000 new customers during this quarter across our retail banks in France, Italy, and Poland. From the start of the medium-term plan that we will complete this year, we have brought in roughly six million new customers at our various retail banks. Naturally, this leads to, or accounts for, the fact that, as I would put it, all the volume or scale measures have also risen markedly. That holds for new loan production at our retail banks. It holds for premium income generated by P&C insurance operations. It also holds for growth in consumer and leasing production during the quarter. Now let me move to revenues on page 10. As you can observe, first, revenue — the top line — is climbing substantially, 7.5% for the quarter, an extra EUR 421 million in revenues. Second, it is distributed across every business division. Third, this rise in revenue is driven both by organic growth and by inorganic growth. Since, on a pro forma basis, the Creval and Lyxor acquisitions, which happened in the middle or at the end of last year, the revenue increase has remained substantial, +4.1%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveEven without the corporate center—which is more volatile and, by definition, isn't truly a business center—the pro forma increase from the acquisition comes to 4.3%. One last point on this page: this revenue growth isn't new for us. It actually falls within a series of regular increases going back at least 5 years, quarter after quarter, as shown on the right-hand side of this page. Let me turn now to cost evolution. This quarter saw a significant cost evolution, +9.5%, +EUR 300 million. If you exclude the acquisition and the integration of Creval and Lyxor, the increase is much more muted, 5.4%. Outside the corporate center, it's even lower, +4.2%. Of the overall EUR 300 million rise in the cost base, EUR 130 million is explained by the increase linked to Lyxor and Creval. EUR 180 million reflects organic growth, of which EUR 50 million is explained by the corporate center, mainly due to a technical—I would say—intra-group restatement effect. Let me move now to gross operating income. As you can see on page 12, gross operating income is improving again across all business lines. The increase is +EUR 115 million over the quarter, +4.9%, and excluding the corporate center, it's even +7%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe cost income ratio we reported for this quarter, at 59%, remains comfortably under the 60% ceiling we set as a target under the current medium-term plan. Now let me move to the risk side. Page 13 shows two elements. The first element: the cost of risk is very low, and in fact it is even declining versus both Q1 2021 and Q4 2021, and it truly sits at a very, very low level. The second element is that, naturally, we have raised this cost of risk quite substantially owing to our highly conservative stance on Russia outside Ukraine, which is restated and therefore not reflected in those figures given its very specific characteristics. Still, when I factor in this provisioning on Russia, we keep a cost of risk measured over the last four rolling quarters that stays in line with, and even somewhat below, the assumption we had made for the current medium-term plan — namely, as you recall, 40 basis points for CASA and 25 basis points for the group globally. On asset quality, our figures remain very good.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt CASA, the NPL ratio is 2.4%, while at group level it's 2%. Given the substantial new provisions we booked this quarter, the coverage ratio kept climbing considerably — 77.5% for CASA and nearly 90% for the group globally. You might notice that we reduced somewhat the volume of loan loss reserve held on our balance sheet, but that's purely technical. The reason is that we declassified our Morocco entity following the signing of a sale agreement in the final days of April. Now let me move to page 15, which explains how underlying net profit evolved between Q1 2021 and Q1 2022. As you can see, this is another way of assembling the picture: the change comes down to two positive factors and two negative ones. The positives are a rise in gross operating income of EUR 114 million and a drop in what I'd call incurred cost of risk, or effective cost of risk, of EUR 227 million. The negatives are a higher contribution to the Single Resolution Fund of EUR 126 million and a substantial rise in cost of risk tied to Russia of EUR 389 million.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo overall, what that does is bring underlying net profit down from EUR 932 million to EUR 756 million — a drop of EUR 176 million, so roughly 19%. That said, when you set it against the Q1 2022 number, it sits about 12% higher than the Q1 2020 figures. Turning to page 16, you'll find return on tangible equity, and this quarter it lands above 11.5% — a strong level for a Q1, which as usual carries the IFRIC 21 accounting constraint. Now let's dig a bit deeper into the individual business lines, beginning with asset gathering and insurance. For this division overall, on page 18, there are two things worth keeping in mind. Commercial momentum has been really strong right across every activity, and in fact assets under management globally stand well above where they were a year ago. During the quarter, the decline is attributable purely to market and Forex effects. Net profit for this division is up substantially, +11.5%. To be specific, insurance had an excellent commercial quarter across all its businesses — life, P&C and protection. Revenues are up sharply, and the division's net profit is up sharply as well, +17%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt Amundi and in the asset management division, we saw positive net inflows in medium- and long-term assets, which more or less offset the outflows from treasury funds and money market funds, along with a solid level of revenues and a solid level of profit—and that profit is rising compared with Q1 2021, which was already very significant. Beyond that, the integration of Lyxor is progressing very well, and we keep growing the Amundi Technology business. Turning to the large customers division, starting with CIB: overall revenues for CA-CIB this quarter were good—probably the highest level for a first quarter since 2016—thanks to a very good performance in the financing activities. Fixed income activities were a little bit more muted, but even so, that was almost compensated by a very strong performance in investment banking and the equities market. On the cost base, a quarter of the increase is explained by the Forex effect. The cost of risk outside the Russian provision is very low. Indeed, we had a reversal of loan loss provision outside the EUR 389 million of provision regarding Russian counterparties. RWAs increased quite significantly this quarter at CA-CIB, with more than half of the increase being in connection with the very strong increase in the risk weighting of the Russian exposure.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn CACEIS, activity levels have been quite strong. Revenues rose sharply, and so did the contribution to the single resolution fund for CACEIS, just as was the case for CA-CIB this quarter. Moving to the specialized financial services division and the consumer credit business: new loan production reached a high level in Q1 2022 at CACF, driven in particular by Agos and by the other international activities. As for car financing, it is somewhat more muted in Europe but very dynamic in China. The managed loan book is growing. If you look at the P&L excluding the effect related to CACF Netherlands, which as you know is in run-off mode, we are almost flat on revenues, on cost, and on cost of risk. On revenues, what we actually see is higher refinancing costs, which have not yet been fully passed through to customers. On leasing and factoring activities, again a very good commercial dynamic. We are currently integrating Olinn, which was acquired at the end of last year, and for the time being this is marginally adding a 100% cost income ratio to CAL&F.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, we're addressing Olinn's cost base. Even so, revenues have risen considerably. Cost of risk has fallen considerably, and profit at CAL&F has climbed sharply. LCL, on page 23, also delivered a very strong quarter — very strong commercially, with growth in customizing the customer base, expansion of the loan book, robust inflows into customer savings, and greater uptake of the various insurance products across that base. On the financial side, revenues have risen sharply, driven partly by business growth and balance sheet expansion, and to a minor degree by certain one-offs — positive one-offs — particularly within the net interest margin. Operating costs are nearly flat once you exclude the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund and the French Guarantee Fund. Cost of risk has fallen, so overall this produces a very sharp rise in net profit at LCL. Italy is focused on integrating Creval, and indeed the legal merger of Creval and Crédit Agricole Italia occurred at the end of April, only a few weeks back. Globally, the market in Italy is somewhat more subdued.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis has also been true for Crédit Agricole Italia. Even so, because of the Creval integration, revenues have risen sharply and the cost of risk has fallen sharply, reflecting all the decisions we made last year. Overall, that means a very substantial gain in net profit at Crédit Agricole Italia. The remaining international retail banking operations are somewhat harder to read across this quarter, so allow me to break them out by entity. Poland and Egypt had a solid quarter, with revenues developing well and the cost of risk coming down, so profitability improved markedly. In Ukraine, naturally, the bank's financial figures are under pressure, yet the Ukrainian subsidiary is still reporting a small net profit this quarter. We sold the Serbian entity, with closing on April 1 this year, so there is no effect on RWA in the first-quarter figures. You will see that in the second quarter. On April 27 we signed the sale of our Moroccan subsidiary, Crédit du Maroc. Closing should therefore happen before this year ends, and we have reclassified Crédit du Maroc, which is now carried under IFRS 5.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the corporate center, not much to report. There's always some volatility there, but when I look at it overall, the net impact is roughly in line with last year. Now let me move to solvency — sorry, to the regional banks of Crédit Agricole, on page 28. The trends you'll see are more or less the same as those I just described for LCL. Customer capture is at a good level, the loan book is developing well and is sharply higher, and customer assets are up 6% as well. Revenue growth is a bit less pronounced than at LCL, since portfolio revenues at the regional banks were somewhat weaker in Q1 2022 than in Q1 2021. Even so, revenues are up close to 2%. Cost of risk is slightly lower, though the largest portion of it actually consists of bucket one and bucket two provisioning, again at the regional banks. The incurred cost of risk is indeed very low, and net profit is up 10% overall. Let me now turn to page 13, on solvency — first at group level, then at CASA.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLooking at the group level, the solvency ratio is down by 50 basis points, landing at 17%, and that leaves us with 810 basis points of margin over the Pillar 2 requirement. That 50 bps decline reflects, of course, a substantial amount of profit after distribution, offset by a meaningful RWA impact tied to the Russian crisis. As I mentioned earlier, at CA-CIB we saw RWAs rise by close to EUR 6 billion, purely from the higher risk weighting applied to our Russian exposures. There was also notable organic RWA growth at group level, plus the OCI effect in the insurance operations, driven first by a big drop in equity markets and, even more significantly, by a sizable rise in rates, which reduces unrealized capital gains at Crédit Agricole Assurances. On top of that comes a regulatory effect, mostly because — even though we dispute it — the ECB has asked the French banks to once again deduct from their solvency the commitments they made to the Single Resolution Fund to pay certain contributions. That produces an impact of 17 basis points at the group level.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen we look at CASA, the broader trend matters more. Globally it accounts for 90 basis points, though the drivers are identical. That brings us to 11%, which—I’ll say it again, since it sometimes appears hard for people to accept—is precisely where we set our target, and it sits over 300 basis points above the Pillar 2 requirement we must meet. On liquidity, there isn’t a great deal to add regarding page 31. Our liquidity reserves are extremely ample, and the TLTRO drawdowns have given them a lift. If we adjust for those TLTRO drawings, our liquidity position remains very comfortable. Page 32 also shows this has been supported by our market funding program being well advanced: it stood at 84% completed for CASA as of the end of April, and across the group overall we had raised nearly EUR 18 billion by the end of March. That is a very substantial effort, and it is paying off, because credit spreads on the market have risen quite sharply since then. I think this is a good place for me to stop, and we can return to the question if you’d like.
Operator
operatorThanks. Just a quick reminder—to ask a question, hit star and one on your keypad, and if you'd like to cancel, press the hash key. So that's star and one to ask a question. Our first question today is from Omar Fall at Barclays. Go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there, Omar.
Omar Fall
analystHi, Jérôme. Thanks for taking my questions. First, could you just highlight what remaining impacts on capital, whatever they might be, we should anticipate for the rest of the year, whether there's anything left on TRIM, IRB repair. I think on the disposal side, Crédit du Maroc is, like, 10 basis points. And then Serbia was announced last year, but that's pretty immaterial. Just any of the other moving parts aside from earnings we should expect.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere are two main components we can pinpoint exactly, though Crédit du Maroc can't provide a specific date for one of them: the disposal of Crédit du Maroc, which will likely add slightly more than 10 bps. We'll know the exact figure once closing happens. Then there's the final TRIM layer's effect, set to occur in Q2, which will mean an extra EUR 5 billion of RWA at CA-CIB — EUR 5 billion or EUR 6 billion, I can't recall precisely. Those are the two main items you should keep in mind, with their precise quantitative impact. Beyond that, there are moving parts for which we can't give exact amounts. As a reminder, each year during the second quarter, as you'll recall, dividend payments flow from the various Casa subsidiaries up to Casa. When the payment comes from a banking subsidiary to the banking parent, there's no effect. When it comes from the insurance businesses to the banking parent, the effect is significant and positive, naturally. That will happen, as it does every year, in Q2. Naturally, we're able to fine-tune how much that dividend will be right up to the end of the quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThese are the primary items that can be pinpointed, as I would put it, particular and non-recurring. As for everything else, naturally, that will just be business as usual. You'll see organic growth in RWAs across the various business lines. Take CA-CIB, for instance — what I can say is that the bulk of the increase CA-CIB is capable of delivering for the entire year was already accomplished during the first quarter, which accounts for the exceptionally high level of results and revenues we observed in the financing division at CA-CIB. Naturally, you also have retained earnings accumulating quarter after quarter, which will of course feed the capital ratio of CASA and of the group.
Omar Fall
analystThanks. This is a quick follow-up on a separate matter — specifically the interest rate sensitivity from the annual report that you detailed on slide 40. You haven't shared this with us before over a multi-year period, so I just have a couple of clarifications. I believe you used to describe the group's sensitivity to rates as low, but this looks like, you know, 100 basis points is roughly a quarter of last year's earnings. Maybe you can give some color there, especially since it's strange that your sensitivity doesn't rise over future years like most of your Northern European peers. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt does actually go up across the year, over time, though there's a technical effect at play, and I believe that's explained on page 40 here. In year one, since the first year is affected in the way you can see, that can affect how you see the overall impact of this rise. It's the TLTRO premium coming to an end at the close of H1, plus the Livret level increase that happened at the start of this year. That's why you could instead focus more on the plain bar in the bar chart: EUR 0.4 billion in the first year, then EUR 0.7 billion, then EUR 0.8 billion. There is a gradual rise in how the impact spreads through the P&L.
Omar Fall
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Please go ahead.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystGood afternoon, and thanks a lot. I’ve got a question about capital too. I get that 11% is your target, but next year there could be IFRS 17, and there could also be a bunny insurance joint venture. So what I’d like to ask is: what floor would you be willing to operate at, even though I understand the target is 11%?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight. The financing for IFRS 17 will come, in some way, from the insurance operations themselves. Our thinking is that, particularly given the rate increases we're currently witnessing, rising rates are simultaneously driving a substantial strengthening of solvency in the insurance businesses. It's solvency measured against a capital requirement standard that generates this outcome. At the same time, it lowers the OCI reserves and weakens the solvency of the banking parent company. We'll work on the leverage level we're able to inject into our insurance operations so as to more or less offset the IFRS 17 effect on solvency at group level. Our view is that we can absorb this without having to take, or at least not to any significant degree, an extra hit to solvency at CASA. You also brought up possible additional bancassurance arrangements with third parties, in Italy for instance. Those wouldn't be carried out directly by CASA, but by our insurance activities. In terms of the solvency impact at the CASA level, it would certainly be whatever actually occurs with regard to those partnerships. It wouldn't result in a significant hit to CASA's solvency.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLet me address your two specific points about IFRS 17 and possible new bank insurance partnerships. Coming back to your broader question regarding 11%, the target, and all the rest of it. The target is 11%. That's what we're aiming for. Naturally, we'd like to sit at 11%. Ideally we'd be at 11% — comfortably, I'd say — but we don't need to stay permanently at or above 11%. Again, when we're at 11%, as we are right now, we hold 310 basis points of margin over the Pillar 2 requirement. We have 300 basis points of excess above the minimum distribution amount. There's no stress whatsoever for us at 11%. If we happened to be at 10.9% next quarter, which isn't what I expect, that wouldn't be a problem, because once again, 11% is the target. It isn't the floor.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystWhat decline in flow would you be willing to accept?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt's a goal, and naturally we have our own internal management buffers, so to speak. We keep an eye on what we're doing so that we can stay on course toward that goal. We won't reveal an exact number, since that would amount to a flow. What we disclose is a target. We want to feel comfortable about our ability to distribute, and that's the reason we're glad to have those 300 basis points of margin on top of the MDA threshold. What I can say — though naturally I won't be disclosing the figures — is that I refresh my capital trajectory on a regular basis, every quarter. What I can say is that under my central scenario, that capital trajectory will translate into a modest rise in our solvency over the remainder of the year. Again, that's within the central scenario, and 11% is a target, and a target is a target.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThat's very clear. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Delphine Lee at JPMorgan. Go ahead, please.
Delphine Lee
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for clarifying the capital points. I wanted to return to the interest rate sensitivity figure you give in the annual report. What assumptions sit behind the deposit and Livret rate inputs for that sensitivity? Is it something like a 100% rise in the Livret rate? Or what are you assuming for sight deposits and the other items? I'm just trying to get a handle on which deposit assumption underlies that number.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah.
Delphine Lee
analystTurning to capital as well — regarding that sensitivity, is there any way you could give us something like a sensitivity of capital to rates, in terms of the OCI reserves? How much in OCI gains do you still have left? I'm just trying to get a sense of what the effect of rate movements would be. Thank you so much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright. Regarding sensitivity to interest rates — that's a rather academic exercise, since in reality things never unfold precisely the way a sensitivity scenario depicts. Certain assumptions have to be made. The first one concerns what we term the pass-through rate, meaning the ability to pass higher rates along to customers on the asset side. We've given two separate assumptions: one at a 50% pass-through rate, and the other at 100%. The second assumption — a strong one — is that it rests on a constant balance sheet structure. That is to say, no particular assumption is made about migration of liabilities from one bucket into another. The third assumption, naturally, is that the rate increase gets translated across the various categories of rate-sensitive assets and liabilities. This means, on the Livret side for instance, it is factored in. In fact, the increase — and this is what I briefly explained when I replied to Omar a bit earlier — the February increase of the Livret is captured in the central scenario, so it sits in the base scenario. Then any additional increase that could occur in August is captured in the sensitivity.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right?
Delphine Lee
analystOkay, so what about the effect on capital?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the OCI side, to summarize it briefly: should interest rates and the yield curve rise by 100 BPS worldwide, the effect on CASA's CET1 would come to roughly 20 BPS overall, we'd say. Naturally, you have to look closely at precisely how that unfolds — whether it comes alongside a decline or a rise in equities, and so forth. That's broadly the size of what we saw during this year's first quarter. Rates went up by about 100 BPS. An effect tied to depletion of the OCI reserve amounted to 20 BPS on CASA's CET1. Such sensitivity remains unchanged. Once more, something I'd like to flag, since perhaps not everyone is fully aware of it: when rates go up, the solvency of Crédit Agricole Assurances under Solvency II gets better. After all, you're familiar with how the solvency requirement gets computed for insurance operations. It rests on a set of scenarios, and naturally, whenever those scenarios assume rising rates, that generally strengthens the insurance activity's solvency down the road.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat this does is provide us with extra room to move when it comes to pushing capital up or down between the insurance operations and CASA.
Delphine Lee
analystGot it. Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question is from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. Your line is open.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYes. Good afternoon. There are two questions. First, returning to costs — this isn't the first instance where the company has come in slightly short versus consensus. My question for you concerns how you handle the cost base. Would it be fair to say, "Alright, we're under the 60% target, so it doesn't really matter whether operating leverage is as strong as it might be, since the target is 60% and I have to stay below 60%"? Is that how you're approaching it, or is there another factor? The second question concerns the CVA impact from the Russian counterparty on your CIB business. It would be helpful if you could provide us with that number, since I presume it won't be coming back in the next quarter. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. So, regarding the cost base, perhaps we could turn to page 11 of the document. Once again, what's interesting on a global basis is to look a bit at how the roughly EUR 310 million cost base we've had has evolved, excluding the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund during the quarter. There are two main components: the scope effect, Lyxor and Creval, at about EUR 130 million, and the rest of the group, at EUR 190 million. Outside the scope effect, within the EUR 180 million, there are two categories. The corporate center, at around EUR 50 million, mainly explained by technical accounting intragroup restatements. So this isn't truly an increase in the running cost base — it's technical. EUR 50 million. The remainder for the business lines is EUR 130 million. Perhaps we could do an exercise consisting of taking all the business lines and seeing how much they increased their cost base by, and what the explanation is. The largest increase is at CACEIS, EUR 40 million. EUR 10 million from the Forex effect and EUR 30 million of IT expenses related to various projects and development. You have Crédit Agricole Assurances, an increase of roughly EUR 20 million. It's mainly development, and when you look at how the business in the insurance activities has developed year after year, it's money that is well invested.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn consumer credit, CACF, EUR 20 million once more. That's essentially just a scope impact. The impact related to CACF Netherlands — as you're aware, IFRS 5 led to deconsolidation, and then we reconsolidated since we ultimately decided to run it off. This generates an impact between Q1 2021 and Q1 2022. There's also a second scope impact, namely the integration of SoYou, the Spanish subsidiary. Virtually no organic growth at CACF. LCL, EUR 20 million, almost entirely accounted for by the contribution to the French Fonds de Garantie des Dépôts. No organic growth, or virtually none. Amundi, EUR 15 million excluding Lyxor. That's primarily driven by Amundi Technology and the rollout of the ALTO project. Then you have leasing and factoring activities. Again, a EUR 15 million increase, of which Olinn, the new integration, accounts for roughly half. You have the wealth management business, a EUR 10 million increase, mainly explained by projects and developments within Azqore, the subsidiary dedicated to servicing third-party private banks. You have CACEIS, roughly EUR 5 million. That's entirely explained by CACEIS moving from its current site to a new site, and for two or three quarters they must pay two rents, two terms.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIf you look closely at where our costs went up this quarter, the increase is fully accounted for. It isn't surging everywhere at once. What you're seeing is a set of separate choices, each of which we consider entirely reasonable and consistent with a priority that remains very important to us: watching the total cost base and holding it below the 60% ceiling. As I said, 11% is a target. The 60% figure isn't a target — it's a ceiling we intend to honor. Cost management stays decentralized, meaning every business head answers for his or her own cost base, in line with the revenue that business can generate. I'm not sure whether that came across clearly.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystThat's great, Jérôme. Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIf it was worthwhile getting up this morning.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystRight — on the CVA, if you’re able to, please just answer that question.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, thanks. Regarding the CVA, we recorded an impact of roughly EUR 35 million this quarter, while in Q1 2021 there was, I believe, a positive CVA reversal of EUR 15 or 20. Between Q1 2021 and Q1 2022, the gap comes to approximately EUR 50 million. I'm not certain I share your view that it will never be written back. As you may recall, in 2020, during the height of the crisis — the pandemic crisis — when the market was under severe strain at the outset, we saw CVA reach a far larger level, which has been gradually written back and is now fully recovered. CVA is typically there to be recovered.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystI really appreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question comes from Giulia Miotto of Morgan Stanley. Go right ahead.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystYes, hello there, and good afternoon.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystI have two questions, if I may. The first concerns Ukraine. You've set aside a provision of EUR 195 million, which matches the equity amount. Is there any scenario in which losses could exceed that equity, or essentially, what's the outlook for your exposure to Ukraine?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMm-hmm.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystMoving to Russia, I’d appreciate some clarity there. First, regarding how mature that loan book is: if you simply let it run off, when would you be clear of it? And second, based on your best judgment, what would the worst-case loss scenario look like? That would really help.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right, let's begin with Ukraine. It's actually the combination of the EUR 20 million loan loss provision taken locally within Crédit Agricole's books plus the EUR 195 million, and together those more or less represent the equity value — but that's a detail anyway. Could we lose more than that? The only way we could lose more than that would be a situation in which we chose voluntarily to inject additional equity into our subsidiary before losing all of it. Because as things stand today, if we don't add any capital — any additional capital — in Ukraine, the only possibility would be a complete write-off of this asset, and then there would be almost no additional effect. With one detail, which is that we have a Forex reserve in our books that would then be recycled through P&L. It's around EUR 200 million, so there's no effect in cash and no effect in solvency either, because of course it's already deducted from our solvency as of now. If there were somehow a termination of our activities in Ukraine, we would have to recycle this reserve through P&L with no effect, again, in cash or in solvency, and of course not in dividend either, given this absence of effect on solvency.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat would be the sole extra impact, unless we once again choose of our own accord to put more capital into Ukraine. Turning to Russia: first, regarding how the various exposures are maturing, you can find them on slide 38. As you'll see there, for the on-balance sheet offshore exposures, 2/3 of the remaining maturities sit under three years. For the off-balance sheet piece, whether onshore or offshore, 70% carries a residual maturity of under 1 year. I'd describe it as a portfolio that is fairly short to medium term.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs far as our worst-case assumption goes, I’m not sure. What I can say is that in evaluating every counterparty we hold, nearly all of them are in a really strong economic position. On pure credit risk, there’s no danger tied to these various exposures. Our sole danger comes from political, legal, or sanctions stress. Yet from an economic standpoint, the degree of credit risk we perceive across these exposures remains very low.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystGreat, thanks. Just as a follow-up regarding the Ukraine exposure, when do you expect to make the call on whether you'll contribute additional equity to that division?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNobody has actually posed that question. I was merely tackling it in, let's say, a hypothetical sense, yet at this moment the local bank is entirely solvent. As I mentioned, it managed to record a very small but positive profit during the first quarter. So there is no cause for such questions to be coming up.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystAlright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question comes from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. Your line is open.
Stefan Stalmann
analystYes. Good afternoon, Jérôme. Two questions from me, please. First, about your Russian subsidiary: since you've booked a provision against the equity value of your Ukrainian subsidiary, and the outlook in Russia is probably no better — perhaps worse — do you anticipate that a provision there could also become necessary, or that you might choose to take one at some stage? Second, perhaps I missed it, but are you providing an update on Crédit Agricole's solvency ratio for the first quarter, and on the policyholder participation reserves as well? Thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight. Regarding the Russian subsidiary, the picture isn’t really the same as Ukraine’s. First, unlike Ukraine, Russia has no war. Second, it’s a far smaller entity, with total assets of roughly EUR 700 million. That makes it half the Ukrainian bank’s size. Over half of that exposure consists simply of deposits held at the Russian Central Bank. So it’s only customer money that we’ve placed back with the Russian Central Bank rather than lending it to local counterparts. The actual local credit loan book is, I believe, somewhere between EUR 200 million and EUR 300 million. That’s a very small portfolio, and half of it relates to Russian subsidiaries of multinational companies. For those exposures, we hold the mother company’s guarantee. The situation is definitely not the same. Absolutely not the same — as of now, we have no intention of taking the same stance on the Russian entity that we’ve taken on the Ukrainian entity. The solvency ratio for the insurance activities was 244% at the end of last year. We haven’t published that figure at the end of Q1.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHere's what I can share: it has risen again from that level, since a positive increase in the rate benefits an insurer's solvency. As for the participation reserve benefiting customers, meaning the policyholders, it stands slightly above EUR 13 billion, and this quarter it is up by nearly EUR 500 million relative to the end of last year.
Stefan Stalmann
analystThanks. That's very clear. Jérôme, could you perhaps provide a broad sense of how sensitive the solvency ratio is—say, if rates were to rise by a hypothetical 100 basis points, what effect would that usually have on the solvency ratio?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI don’t have that exact figure in mind, so that’s a good question, and we’re going to address it more formally as we prepare the communication going forward.
Stefan Stalmann
analystOkay, thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYou pointed that out.
Stefan Stalmann
analystHappy to do that. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMy concern is that it isn't entirely linear.
Operator
operatorAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes.
Operator
operatorJust to remind everyone again, if you'd like to ask a question, press star and one on your keypad. Our next question is from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC. Go ahead, please.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure thing, Kiri.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystHi. Sure, I have a few questions about French retail. The rise in the Livret A rate has helped. You provided the effect on NII, but what I'd like to know is how much you're beginning to observe an effect on customer behavior — for example, shifting back into certain of those regulated savings products and away from some of the other savings and investment vehicles you offer. Staying with French retail, moving to the asset side and French mortgages: volume growth remains fairly strong, but I was wondering how pricing is developing right now. The funding curve has been rising. Have you managed to pass that through in the mortgage rates you offer? Do you get the sense customers are somewhat willing to pay more right now to lock in relatively low rates ahead of rate increases? Does that help you push through some of those price increases? Just a bit of color on the pricing dynamic for French mortgages, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the liability side, that’s the first question for now, though naturally it won’t remain that way indefinitely—particularly if rates keep climbing, especially given the inflation level, since the Livret A yield is partly tied to inflation, as you’re aware. Because inflation has kept rising from the start of this year, our view is that the Livret A will go up. At the next reset date, in August, the Livret A rate will rise, and likely that will be another meaningful increase. At some point, probably, customers’ behavior will shift regarding how they allocate their cash between a side deposit earning zero remuneration and the Livret A or whatever else. So far, nothing significant has occurred, but it could happen down the road. Besides the Livret A and other products, we also have a term deposit. We also have unregulated savings accounts. There’s a whole series of products available to use. Naturally, our aim is to keep monitoring, I’d say, the weighted average cost of our liabilities in the most efficient way possible.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMoving to your second question, the thinking is, naturally, that as the cost of our liabilities rises, that will progressively show up as a higher yield on our assets. So far, the pricing of new loans has gone up only modestly, for at least two reasons — plus one, I'd say. The broad, overall reason is that competition in France remains quite fierce, and naturally, no one wants to give up ground in this market. Beyond that, there are two more technical factors that explain why it trails the movement in market rates by a significant margin. First, between the time you set the rate on a home loan and the time that loan is actually in place, a certain amount of time can pass — sometimes several months. What we're putting in place now is loans that were negotiated a few months back. Only gradually will the rate increase take hold and have an effect on our yields. Second, in France, as you know, we have a regulation concerning taux d'usure. That too is slowing the movement in the pricing of new home loans, because for different categories of loans — mainly for different buckets of maturity — a regulation requires that one not exceed four-thirds of the average market rate that was in effect on the market during the previous quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat that means is that within one quarter, there's a ceiling placed on how much the customer rate can be raised.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystAlright, that helps. Appreciate it, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right, thank you.
Operator
operatorThank you. Our next question comes from Pierre Chédeville at CIC. Go ahead, Pierre. Are you still connected? Can you hear us? That line appears to be muted. We'll go on to the following question, which comes from Matthew Clark at Mediobanca. Please go ahead.
Matthew Clark
analystGood afternoon. May I put a few questions to you regarding Banco BPM? I suppose the first one would be whether you can say with certainty that you would never pursue an offer for a controlling stake. And then, if that is the case, what is the reason? I simply want to gain a clearer picture of what you intend to do there. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo your question is whether we're ruling out making an offer for BPM — is that what you're asking? The connection wasn't very clear.
Matthew Clark
analystYes. Yes, it was.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo, we've been pretty clear in what we've communicated. We've stated that we did not seek the approval required from the ECB in order to exceed 10%. That's quite clear.
Matthew Clark
analystLooking back, it's clear. Looking ahead, it isn't. So what I'm asking is: can you give us something forward-looking?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNo,
Matthew Clark
analystIt's a commitment that looks ahead, not one that looks back.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe've also made clear that this stake was meant to strengthen the cooperation between our group and BPM across the various specialized business lines. We've said, first, how large a stake we've acquired. Second, that we haven't sought the option of exceeding 10%. As for why we took that approach, I believe it speaks for itself and needs no defense. No further remarks on that are necessary. It's entirely clear.
Matthew Clark
analystAll right, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThank you. Our next question comes from Guillaume Tiberghien at Exane. Please go ahead.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystYeah, thanks. I just want to pick up on the French mortgage margin. I get that there's a delay between committing and when you actually lend the money. So let me put the question another way. The government bond in France is at 1.5% today, the ten-year. At this point you ought to be committing to lend at around 2.5% on new business. Are you doing that, or are you still well below 2%?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGuillaume, you already know the answer to this perfectly well. For the new loans we extend, the market rate sits at roughly that level, and as you're aware, those new loans typically carry an average maturity near or even beyond 20 years. You're fully aware that the rate we lend against is nearer to 1.20. As things stand right now, it definitely doesn't line up with the ten-year swap rate or the ten-year OAT. Once more, some period of time will be needed before we gradually arrive at a more normal situation, since in duration terms a 20-year amortizing loan roughly corresponds to a ten-year bullet bond. The reference rate you have in mind for home loans does matter, yet reaching that level is going to require time.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystWhy not just halt lending entirely until the margin feels comfortable, and put the money into government bonds instead?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe reason is that we’re not a hedge fund—we’re just a bank. We have customers, and our goal is to retain them, grow our customer base, and maintain a long-term relationship. That’s the distinction.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystWhen rates shift quickly, I get that people may see this as temporary—but at this moment, it shouldn't be viewed that way. You ought to tell your clients, “I'm sorry, but the world has changed. This is a new normal.” In certain countries, we're seeing that. In the Netherlands, banks are lending 100 basis points more than they were at the start of the year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight, but the way banking works in France isn’t the same as how the Dutch banks are acting. In France, not every bank acts in exactly the same manner. You know that inside our group, we have a DNA that is truly built around preserving, developing, and permanently enhancing the relationship with our customers. If we were just a financial investor, we would certainly arbitrate between bonds and loans based only on the financial conditions, but we are not a pure financial investor. We are a bank and a relationship bank.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystAll right, that works. Appreciate it.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our next question comes from Pierre Chédeville at CIC. The line is yours.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, good afternoon. Are you able to hear me?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, Pierre.
Pierre Chédeville
analystApologies—I'm having a lot of trouble with my phone, and I'm not sure why. On the first question: I recall that Philippe Brassac, in an interview—though I can't remember the exact details—expressed a fairly genuine ambition when it came to growing P&C Insurance for corporates, and especially for SMEs. I'd like to know where you currently stand on developing that kind of product and that kind of customer. The second question concerns LCL. Your production figures are quite impressive—very impressive, in fact. I'm wondering whether that's simply a matter of catching up relative to 2021, given that in 2021 you had the catch-up from 2020. I'd like to know when that catch-up will end—whether this is about catch-up at all, or whether it's about a marketing campaign in Q1. Because when you see growth in production that impressive, it raises questions. My sub-question is this: what is the philosophy behind your financial communication, when one can say that you are among the only large European banks that provides no guidance on the cost of risk? I understand that providing guidance is always tricky, but when we are in unusual times and we see that all—as I said—the large banks in Europe provide such guidance, why do you not provide any guidance on this subject?
Pierre Chédeville
analystThanks a lot. And once more, apologies about the connection.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure, Pierre. Business P&C insurance — for SMEs and corporates — has already been launched and is growing, though it takes considerable time, and the good news is that we're patient. Take collective group insurance policies for businesses in protection, for instance: we launched those roughly five or six years back. Today they account for a few hundred million EUR in annual premiums. Yet reaching that point required five or six years. Developing P&C insurance for businesses will likewise take time. Still, it's clearly already live, and several regional banks have already been developing it. LCL — at that level — began at the very end of 2020. By now we have a little bit more than a full year of, I'd say, test and learn on this business. With LCL, well, we don't want to put a brake on growing LCL's customer base or on equipping LCL's customers with various products and services. We're very happy to see the loan book develop. We're very happy to see the progression of equipment across different P&C and protection insurance policies. All of that is very positive.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, whenever we issue new loans, we keep applying those same credit standards. We certainly don't intend to loosen them. Provided we remain within our standards, we're glad to see production grow. What you're observing in terms of dynamics, I believe, stems from the fact that LCL is a bank entirely focused and dedicated to its own market — namely, being a retail bank across all of France. Regarding cost of risk and guidance, I'm not sure precisely what you mean by guidance. Our approach is to establish medium-term assumptions, and we state that our financial targets align with those assumptions. As you know, the assumption at CASA is an average cost of risk of around 40 basis points. What I shared with you and showed in my presentation is that, including the very specific provisions we've taken concerning Russia, we're more or less at the target. Beyond that, I can say that the incurred cost of risk — since most of the Russian provisions are not on incurred exposure, risk exposure — is purely prudential.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen you look at just the incurred cost of risk, that level is quite low. It's roughly — I don't have the exact number in front of me — but it sits well below the 40 basis points assumption. At this stage, we aren't seeing any indication of meaningful deterioration in the asset quality of our exposures. What we're saying, put simply, is that plenty of uncertainty lies ahead, and the situation could potentially worsen. As of right now, we are not observing signs of significant deterioration across the various credit exposures we hold right across the board. Perhaps one final point, though it's important to bear in mind: we have raised our Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions very substantially since the pandemic began back in 2020. At CASA, we currently hold roughly EUR 2.5 billion of Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions. No — at group level, we have increased our Stage 1 and Stage 2 provision by EUR 2.5 billion, and at CACF we have raised our Stage 1 and Stage 2 provision by EUR 1.3 billion since the crisis started. That is a very, very significant level.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright — thanks so much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question is from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies. Your line is open.
Flora Bocahut
analystYes, good afternoon. There are two things I'd like to ask about the financing business within CIB. My first one concerns revenues. You know, you posted quite a strong quarter in Q1 where revenue growth is concerned. I believe you remarked earlier during this call that CA-CIB has by now deployed the bulk of the capital earmarked for the year. I just wanted to verify whether that might imply that organic growth in financing over the remainder of the year could be held back by the capital expansion we clearly witnessed in Q1. My second question also relates to financing, though this time it's about provisions. You know, you noted that you actually recorded a write back this quarter, excluding the provision related to Russia. I understand the reason, since obviously your NPL coverage is high, but the timing comes as somewhat of a surprise, in the sense that I'd argue risks for large corporates have probably risen when we consider, you know, elevated inflation, higher raw material prices, and supply chain disruption in certain sectors. I was hoping to understand better the rationale behind this provision write back in financing, and whether there is any concern, or in fact no concern, regarding the underlying risk there.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNow, regarding financing activities, revenue growth isn’t tied to a permanent expansion of the loan book. Revenue growth comes from activity, and that activity consists of issuing new loans as well as distributing assets, covering assets, and freeing up capacity to issue new loans. That’s a lasting shift. What I meant is that when it comes to the ability to expand the loan book and the size of the RWAs — and this tends to happen regularly in Q1 — the budget includes a fresh assessment of development capacity. Naturally, since the loan book generates revenue over time, it’s generally important to try to seize opportunities early in the year so as to generate revenue across the whole year rather than only gradually. Revenue in financing activities isn’t tied solely to the carry of the book; it’s tied to transactions, and the ability to undertake new transactions is also connected to the ability to distribute, free up room, and then take on new operations. CA-CIB is very agile in that respect.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveCA-CIB's ability to keep growing its business is, of course, limited—but it isn't zero in the quarters ahead. On provisions and write-backs, that's not a discretionary matter. We can't simply say, "We feel like booking new provisions, and we feel like writing back provisions." The simple fact is that in Q1 of this year, setting aside the Russian exposures, the credit exposure behavior at CA-CIB—the quality improvement—was such that a write-back was entirely relevant and necessary, given all our models and all our internal provisioning rules. That's the crux of it. When a provision sits against a loan that defaulted and that in the end gets repaid, there's nothing to do but write the provision back. Overall, we have not written back Stage 1 and Stage 2 provisions at the CASA level. We have even slightly raised, again, excluding the Russian provision, we have even slightly raised the Stage 1 and Stage 2 provision level across the quarter, at CASA.
Flora Bocahut
analystAlright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThank you. At this point we don't have any more questions, so I'll return the floor to the speaker for some closing comments.
Jérôme Grivet
executivePardon me. That wraps up all the questions. Well, many thanks to all of you. We look forward to seeing you on June 22nd, 2022, and I believe this time it will be face to face, I suppose. I hope so, at least for most of us. Until then, enjoy the rest of your day, and we'll see you shortly. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings today's conference to a close. We appreciate everyone joining us, and you're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.