Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 10, 2022

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 104 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone. This is the conference operator speaking. Welcome, and thank you for being with us for Crédit Agricole's Third Quarter 2022 Results Presentation. Just a reminder that all participants are in listen-only mode. Following the presentation, you'll have a chance to ask questions by pressing star and one on your telephone keypad. If anyone requires assistance during the conference call, you can signal an operator by pressing star and zero on your telephone. At this point, I'd like to hand the conference over to Mr. Jérôme Grivet, the Deputy CEO in charge of steering division. Please go ahead, sir.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good afternoon. It’s a pleasure to be here with you this afternoon to present the results for our Q3 and the first nine months of the year. I’ll go straight to the main figures. I’ll try to keep the presentation as brief as possible so we have time for your questions afterward. Let me begin on page four, where CASA’s main figures are shown. Maybe just a few highlights on this page. In the quarter, revenues are up close to 1% compared with Q3 2021, which was already a record quarter in terms of revenue. Again, this is the highest level ever for a third quarter. Second point on the quarter: you can see the cost of risk rising moderately compared with a 2021 basis that was very low. Third element on this page: the CET1 ratio at 11% is at the target. Last point: return on tangible equity is at 12.5%, which is again above the target we had set for 2025. If I now look at the first three quarters of the year, the nine months, revenues are up more sharply over the first nine months, +5%, almost 5%. The cost income ratio for the first nine months at 58% is below our ceiling, below our commitment, and at a very comfortable level.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

The key takeaway: net profit for the first nine months — underlying net profit — came in at close to EUR 4 billion, EUR 3,937 million, sorry, and it's flat, nearly flat versus the first nine months of 2021, a record level. Moving to page five now, which shows the group's main figures, the trend is broadly the same, meaning quarterly revenues are roughly stable, while for the first nine months revenues are up substantially, +3%. Cost of risk has risen more sharply across the group as a whole, but you'll notice that at the regional bank level we booked once again this quarter a sizable addition to S1 and S2 provisions, so this does not reflect any sort of rise in incurred risks. Net profit remains at a high level even with a slight decline versus 2021, both for the quarter and for the first nine months. Finally, at group level the solvency ratio stands at 17.2%, which is 8.3 percentage points above the stress level. Turning now to page seven and the main messages we wanted to highlight this quarter, what I think is interesting to note is that during the third quarter of this year we continued to face an adverse environment in terms of markets.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

Rates kept climbing sharply, and as you'll notice, that isn't purely a positive development. Equity markets fell considerably during the third quarter, just as they had in the first two quarters, and that has weighed heavily on a number of our businesses. In the Forex market, the euro carried on dropping quite substantially, particularly against the dollar. Inflation remained elevated, and likely above what we had originally anticipated. Finally, as you're aware, this quarter — at the start of the third quarter — marked the end of the bonus mechanism tied to the TLTRO, which had added a substantial amount to our revenues through the close of Q2 this year. Even so, we succeeded in maintaining a strong level of revenues, as I mentioned, along with strong profitability, together with solvency that stayed at the target for CASA and, naturally, stood at a very high level for the group as a whole. We have kept executing the various priorities of the medium-term plan, including, among other things, the signing of the agreement between CACEIS and RBC, under which CACEIS will become the shareholder and owner of RBC's European operations, over the course of next year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Moving to page eight now, where there are some details about the activities, the underlying ones. What I believe we can observe is that we have remained highly engaged with our customers when it comes to lending. Loan production kept growing across retail banks, regional banks, as well as LCL, and in consumer and leasing businesses too. That was, naturally, quite favorable for the group's activity. Once again, this quarter we brought in close to 500,000 new customers across our various networks — retail banking networks in Europe, France, Italy and Poland. Altogether, since the start of this year, we have attracted 1.5 million new customers into our networks. Naturally, that is driving a further rise in revenues from additional activities such as insurance, non-life insurance activities, where once again we recorded growth of close to 7% in premium income. On page nine, there are some further details about our revenues, our top line. As I mentioned, across nine months the momentum is absolutely excellent — up close to 5%, and even close to 3% at constant scope. In the third quarter, naturally, the market conditions I referred to earlier made things somewhat harder for several of our businesses, including the asset management operations and also within the specialized financial services division, where we saw a significant rise in our refinancing costs.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

Across the board, because of strong results in the large customers division as well as retail banking activities, for the businesses alone we achieved a top line that improved by roughly 2% for the quarter. Once more, this is shown on the right-hand side of this page. And again this quarter, we posted a higher level of revenues than we did in the same quarter a year ago. That has been consistently true quarter after quarter over the last five years. Turning to page ten, there are some points about costs. Over nine months, the cost base grew about 3.9% at constant scope, and it comes in under 3% overall when you exclude the Forex effect. For the quarter alone, the increase for the business lines is capped at 2.9% at constant scope. This quarter that is an increase of roughly EUR 90 million, of which close to EUR 20 million relates to the salary increase we chose to grant in the middle of this year. I brought this up on the previous call as well. There is also EUR 30 million of Forex effect. Moving now to page eleven, the evolution of gross operating income.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

Focusing just on the business lines, you can see that for the quarter, gross operating income is very close to last year's figure — down 1% — and for the first nine months of the year it's up 2%. On average, the gross operating income we post is very significantly higher than what we had back in 2019, so pre-pandemic. One last point: our cost income ratio keeps holding steadily below the 60% ceiling we set. It's also worth noting that, consistently over the last five years, it sits five percentage points under the average of the biggest European banks. That's the chart on the right-hand side of this page. Moving now to cost of risk. What we can say about this quarter is that, in terms of proven risk, we're back at the quarterly average of 2019. Looking back at how we were describing cost of risk in 2019, we considered it very moderate at that time. Clearly we still have a cost of risk that is very, very benign, despite some increase when we compare it with the same quarter last year, when it was abnormally low, I would say.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

On the ratio side at CASA, our cost of risk globally sits at roughly 30 basis points against outstandings, whether you look at it over the last four quarters or annualize the most recent quarter — and that's below the medium-term plan assumption. For the group overall, we're at 22 to 23 basis points, and that includes another significant add-on this quarter from the regional banks on the S1 and S2 provisions. That was already the situation in Q2. What it tells you is that the regional banks keep being very prudent about preparing for the future and once again topping up their prudential provisions. You can see this illustrated on page 13 that follows, where at group level our overall level of provisions has stayed in the same region for three years now — roughly EUR 20 billion. What's interesting is that within that EUR 20 billion, the share of S1 and S2 provisions has risen markedly. It now accounts for 42% of the total, and at CASA we see exactly the same pattern. At CASA, S1 and S2 provisions make up 37% of the loan loss reserves we hold globally.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

On the coverage ratio side, we still have very strong coverage ratios — 73% at CASA and 87% at group globally. That shows up, and you have it on page 14, in a situation where both CASA and the group post among the best performances in terms of coverage ratio, in the space of European banks, which is illustrated on the left-hand side of the page. It comes from the fact, as illustrated on the right-hand side of the page, that we have a very diversified loan book, in addition to a very strict credit standard. Let me go now to the net profit on page 15. As you have seen, we have a slight decrease Q3 on Q3, -10%, which is largely explained by the corporate center in which the deterioration of the level of profit comes significantly with some temporary and non-cash elements. We can go back on this point later on. On the first nine months, it's very stable, -0.6%, and it's 20%, 20.6% above the level we had back in 2019, so before the pandemic. In terms of profitability, page 16, you can see that the return on tangible equity, as I said, is at 12.5%. It's again 2.5 percentage points above the average of the biggest European banks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

Now let's turn to solvency, and I'll begin with CASA. On the waterfall chart on the left side of this page, you'll notice that CASA's CET1 ratio fell roughly 30 basis points during the quarter, and that decline is more than accounted for by certain market effects — both from a further worsening of the OCI reserves tied to the insurance business and from a meaningful market impact on the RWA of the capital markets activities at CACIB. Turning to the first nine months of the year, shown in the waterfall on the right-hand side of the page: the reduction comes to about 90 bps, of which the day-to-day business improved the capital position by 34 basis points, retained results contributed 47 basis points, and the various items stemming from the group's day-to-day management consumed 13 basis points. That reduction is entirely — indeed more than entirely — accounted for by certain market effects. The OCI reserves arising from the insurance activities amounted, over the first nine months of the year, to a global impact of 84 basis points, while the RWA and market effect on capital consumption from CACIB's capital markets activities came to 24 basis points. On top of that, as you'll recall, in the first quarter of the year we recorded a significant deterioration in our exposure to Russian counterparties.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

That fed into a higher provision — the S1 and S2 provisions — and also into a rise in the RWA density on those exposures. One thing worth noting is that a substantial share of these effects will reverse going forward as time passes. That's particularly true for the OCI reserves tied to the insurance activities. To sum up where we stand, at the end of 2021 our CET1 ratio was 11.9%, and within that we had 30 basis points of unrealized capital gains that will be brought down to zero over time. Today our CET1 ratio is 11%, and that figure carries a negative component of 50 basis points stemming from the OCI reserve. Once again, this negative piece will converge to par over time, as the bonds — the underlying bonds — mature progressively. That is precisely how things developed across the first three quarters of the year. At the group level — and you can see this on page 18 — in this quarter we see more or less the same effect and the same impact as the one we described for CASA. The group's CET1 ratio declined from 17.5% at the end of June to 17.2% at the end of September.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

As you can see — and naturally you're fully aware of this — at 17.2%, the group ranks among the best-capitalized G-SIBs in Europe. When it comes to distance to SREP, at 830 basis points, it stands as the best-capitalized G-SIB in Europe. Beyond that, CASA, which isn't a G-SIB, still has a distance to SREP above 300 basis points, and that compares very favorably with some of the G-SIBs in our sample. One last point on this section. If we look at CASA's performance for the first nine months of 2022 on page 19, you can see that we are perfectly in line both with the targets we had set for 2022 in the previous medium-term plan and with the new targets we updated in June this year for 2025. That's true, of course, for the return on equity, it's true for the cost income ratio, and it's true for the CET1 ratio. On profit, of course, we'll see what the situation looks like at the end of this year. Clearly, from this standpoint, we are not in a very uncomfortable situation.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

One final item on this page. The dividend accrued at the end of September comes to EUR 0.58 per share. Let me move quickly now through the different business lines, beginning with asset gathering. On page 21, clearly, for the asset gathering business division, this was a tough quarter given a very negative market effect, along with a slowdown in inflows and even negative flows at Amundi. Even so, the business division keeps up a very good level of profitability, with net profit for the quarter down only 3%, and for the nine months down only 1.5%. Turning to the insurance activities, specifically page 22, the messages are very simple. As for life insurance activities, exactly what we saw globally for the business division: flows this quarter were more or less close to zero. Nonetheless, in P&C activities and protection businesses, we continue to have premium income at around 7%. That is if you restate the gross figures for the fact that La Médicale de France was sold at the beginning of the third quarter. This disposal of La Médicale de France generated a capital gain of EUR 100 million, which has been restated, so it is not in the P&L shown on this page.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

Even after that capital gain restatement, the insurance division still shows profitability improving by roughly 4% in this quarter and 5% across the first nine months. Turning to Amundi, page 23 again — market conditions proved very negative, with equity markets declining, rates rising, and therefore bond values falling along with a weaker euro. Globally the market was negative, and outflows were very significant, particularly in Europe. Against that backdrop, Amundi's activity held up quite well. Outflows stayed limited when it comes to medium and long-term assets. Revenues, when compared with Q3 2021, show a slight increase versus the second quarter of 2022. Naturally, the drop between Q3 2021 and Q3 2022 is more than explained by the sharp fall in performance fees. Moving now to page 24, the large customer division, beginning with CACEIS. During the third quarter of this year, activities were globally good, with revenues up close to 5%. Within the quarter, the engine that performed best was clearly the financing part of CACEIS. Capital market activities proved more difficult. The reason, of course, is very simple as always.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#15

Our role is to fund our customers, whether that comes from our own balance sheet or via products in the capital markets. It so happened that globally, the DCM market had a weak quarter. Since DCM is a key engine behind our capital markets operations, naturally there was a modest dip in revenue for that subdivision in this quarter. At CACEIS, revenues overall moved higher. Looking at the first nine months of the year, the growth is actually steeper still, +10%, and every sub-compartment of the business was up meaningfully. On cost of risk, the rise versus last year is significant, though last year was close to nil. You'll notice that for this quarter, the EUR 32 million figure is quite low. For the first nine months, bear in mind that in the first quarter we set aside substantial provisions tied to Russian exposure. Taking everything together, profitability at CACIB is somewhat lower, yet it still stands at a solid level, above EUR 1 billion across the first nine months of the year. Turning to the large customers division, and again the asset servicing activities, we wanted to shine a bit more light on what's going on at CACEIS, since CACEIS is increasingly turning into a very major piece of the group's equilibrium and of the group's business model.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#16

There are two items on this page. First, CACEIS reached an agreement in principle with RBC a few weeks or months back to acquire its European investor services operations. For CACEIS this will truly change the game, making it the top player in Europe by assets under administration. It would reinforce its standing as second-largest in assets under custody. This is a highly significant deal, one that will be strongly accretive, with a return on investment above 10%. Completion and closing of this transaction are expected around the middle of next year, likely in the third quarter of next year. In the current environment, CACEIS's assets declined this quarter, naturally because of market movements. Even so, revenues rose markedly, and CACEIS is beginning to reap the benefits of the cost-cutting plan introduced last year. Taken together, this is producing a very sharp gain in CACEIS's profitability — up 37% for the quarter and up 23% over the first nine months. Specialized financial services, page 26. Starting with consumer credit, the message is very straightforward. Production was highly dynamic this quarter, with the strongest driver being the car financing businesses, both through the joint ventures we hold and through the car financing loans we extend within Sofinco's perimeter or directly at Agos.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

Margins remain somewhat squeezed, particularly in France, since refinancing expenses have climbed faster than our ability to pass that added cost along to customers—largely due to the usury rate mechanism—though this will be progressively absorbed as time goes on. Costs are well controlled, so the cost income ratio is marginally lower when measured against both Q3 2021 and Q2 2022. The cost of risk has risen, yet that increase is relative to a third quarter of 2021 that was exceptionally low, especially at Agos, where technical reasons led to some reversal of provisions back in 2021. On leasing and factoring, it was likewise a very strong quarter activity-wise, with a very healthy revenue level and a cost of risk that is declining. Overall, profitability at CAL&F is climbing notably. Commercial activity in French retail and at LCL is highly buoyant, and new loan production was once more higher this quarter, particularly for self-employed professional and business lending, while home loans dipped only very slightly. At LCL I believe that was -2% or -3%, in a setting where the market worldwide fell far more steeply.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

Our financial performance is really strong. Revenue grew 0.6% even with the net interest margin under pressure. As you're aware, midway through the summer, regulated savings accounts saw a second cost increase. Since the start of this quarter, we've also lost the 50 basis points premium on the TLTRO drawing. Fees and commissions are trending very favorably. Expenses remain well contained, +1% for the quarter, even with the salary increases I mentioned affecting all our French staff. The cost of risk has risen, yet it stays quite low, in fact, in absolute terms, in absolute numbers. Italy presents a somewhat different picture. The Italian market has performed well for businesses and for consumer credit, though it has been far more subdued for home loans. We observe these same trends at Crédit Agricole Italia. Even so, Crédit Agricole Italia is picking up market shares in home loans, and Crédit Agricole Italia is also gradually reaping the benefits from the Creval integration. Overall, revenues are modestly yet positively higher. Operating expenses are nearly unchanged, 4.6%. Gross operating income has climbed 1.5%. The cost of risk is lower and very low.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

Crédit Agricole Italia's net profit rose 12% quarter on quarter and 33% over the first nine months. Turning to the remaining international banking operations, international retail banking posted very good momentum in both Poland and Egypt. In Poland, we set aside a provision tied to the moratorium imposed by the Polish authorities. That provision amounts to EUR 20 million, booked at Crédit Agricole Bank Polska and restated, so it does not appear in the P&L on this page, but it is an exceptional item. Cost of risk in those two countries remains very low. In Ukraine, once again, as we did over the last two quarters, we booked provisions that nearly fully offset gross operating income, which came in quite nicely this quarter in Ukraine despite the context, at EUR 35 million. As a reminder, we hold a provision at CASA covering the entire value of the equity invested in Ukraine. Corporate Center declined this quarter. The decline stems especially from revenue, in particular the elimination of intra-group securities issued by CASA and subscribed by Predica and/or Amundi. In addition, part of the TLTRO was booked at CASA, within the Corporate Center.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

Naturally, the Corporate Center is shedding that 50 basis points premium, just like every other part of the group. There's also, I'd say, a degree of prudence in how we assess the tax level we'll be booking at the Corporate Center by year-end. Now, the key points on CASA. Turning to page 32, there are some highlights on Crédit Agricole's regional banks. The trends you'll see are broadly similar to those at LCL — that is, a really solid pace of loan production across business loans, consumer credit loans, and home loans. Globally, as you can see, the regional banks keep drawing in new customers. Once again it's close to 300,000 new customers this quarter, and 900,000 across the first nine months. That strong attractivity probably also stems from the fact that we remain very active when it comes to loans, when it comes to lending. Over time, this will pay off more broadly. The top line is lower at the regional banks, linked not only to the fact that, as at LCL, there's some pressure on the net interest margin, but also, as you know, to the regional banks holding sizable asset portfolios.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#21

Considering the context, the fair value of those assets came in negative for this quarter. Cost of risk has risen considerably, but really, you have to take into account that within the EUR 273 million of cost of risk for the regional banks this quarter, there is EUR 160-something million of S1 and S2 provisions. That is exactly the same for the first nine months. Credit provisions account for more than half of the cost of risk level at the regional banks. Moving now to page 34, you can see that the group's liquidity situation remains very comfortable. Perhaps on top of that, given the new rules applying to the TLTRO cost from November 2023, we will certainly bring down the outstandings before year end, even if after November 2023, the TLTRO amount will simply represent a zero cost liquidity reserve for us. On page 35, just as a reminder, this has been the case steadily since the start of this year. We are ahead of the curve when it comes to deploying our market funding program. By end September, we have now raised EUR 14.5 billion of medium and long-term market funding, and probably, I think it's EUR 1 billion more at end October.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#22

Looking at the group as a whole worldwide, the amount we have raised since the start of this year comes to EUR 35 billion. These are the key numbers and the key points I wanted to highlight in this presentation, and I think at this stage I will hand things over to you for your questions.

Operator

operator
#23

Thank you. Speaking as the conference operator, we will now start the question-and-answer portion. If you would like to pose a question, you can press star and one on your touchtone phone. Should you wish to take yourself out of the question queue, press star and two. When asking questions, please lift the receiver. At this point, anyone with a question may press star and one. Our first question comes from Jacques-Henri Gaulard of Kepler Cheuvreux. Please go ahead.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#24

Yes. Good afternoon, everyone. I just have a question regarding how the regional banks are involved in Casa's capital. If you bring them in more closely, aren't you essentially running two risks? The first is that you materially reduce the liquidity of the shares, and at the same time, you're actually preserving the option of taking the company private at a potentially low price. Because, you know, in any event, SAS Rue La Boétie would have no commitment to maintain any sort of price if that were the case. So wouldn't that make the long-term investment case for Casa a little bit pointless, basically? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#25

Okay, Jacques-Henri, given what we're discussing here, I'd say your concerns are somewhat overblown. On materially reducing liquidity — we're discussing a transaction that could reach up to EUR 1 billion, running up to the middle of next year. Relative to the scale of the liquidity and the free float of CASA, that isn't very significant. So my view is that the worry about a decline in the liquidity level carries little weight. Let me point out that during 2021, we ourselves carried out two share buyback programs, amounting in total to more than EUR 1 billion. We understand what that figure means — EUR 1 billion for CASA — and it doesn't materially alter the liquidity. Turning to your second point, the intentions you're alluding to, about possibly taking the company private: the shareholder was very explicit that they have no wish to go beyond the 65% threshold in any way, which is a long way from any kind of take-private. So I'd say firmly that this is not the majority shareholder's intention. Nothing about the governance will change as a result. They won't gain any extra governance rights or anything of that sort.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#26

This is genuinely a technical and financial move — and, if I may put it that way, an opportunistic one too — when you take into account what the regional banks are financially capable of, and also the condition of the market.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#27

Appreciate that, Jérôme — that's very clear.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#28

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#29

Our following question comes from Delphine Lee at JPMorgan. You have the floor.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#30

Good afternoon, Jérôme. Thanks for taking my questions. First, on net interest income: if you wouldn't mind sharing the benefits from TLTRO that will be lost, or what has perhaps already been booked in the first half, so we can get a sense of how much will drop away next year, both at French Retail and in the corporate center. On that same point, do you believe French Retail NII can expand next year despite those headwinds, and also given that the Livret A is likely to climb well above 2%? My second question concerns capital. You said those headwinds would reverse, and I follow what you mean regarding the OCI and the pull to par effect. Could you perhaps give us some timing on that? And on market, going the other way, inflation — given the volatility, might we see some reversal of that in the quarters or years ahead? I'm just trying to get a sense of the speed at which capital could return to where it used to be. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#31

Alright. On your first question about NII, the advantages from the TLTRO, Livret A, and so forth, I want to begin with a really key reminder. Where the CASA perimeter is concerned, we're speaking of half of NBI at LCL. At the global level, that comes to 10% of CASA's worldwide revenues. That matters a great deal, yet it isn't the largest slice of the revenues we record at CASA. Naturally, it carries far more weight at group level, since the regional banks altogether amount to roughly five or six times CASA — LCL, pardon me. What's clearly essential is that grasping what will occur with NII matters greatly, yet the effect will be felt far more by the regional banks than by CASA. Next point, TLTRO. It's publicly known that the group as a whole has drawn approximately EUR 160 billion at the TLTRO window. Pinpointing for you an exact figure for the TLTRO benefit is very hard, and I have consistently been quite reluctant to do so, since the purpose behind the TLTRO was to better the financing conditions across the European economy. Naturally, a substantial share of the advantages from this low-cost resource has been handed to customers through how loans are priced.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#32

But even so, when we stand to lose that cheap funding source—because it will turn into a resource priced at the deposit facility rate—then we know precisely what the loss will be. Since we'll need to substitute that funding either with a different type of resource, a market-based one, or simply by cutting the deposits we place with the ECB by an equivalent amount. Naturally, we will gradually repay EUR 160 billion of TLTRO, and that is the foundation on which we enjoyed the 50 basis points premium through the end of Q2. Once more, as a reminder, since I've already covered this, the gains and the sum were divided roughly equally between the regional banks, on one side, and CASA and its various activities, on the other. Broadly, if you take 160 billion at 50 basis points over a year, that works out to roughly EUR 800 million, hence EUR 400 million in 2022, and zero in 2023. That is perfectly clear. Regarding Livret A and everything similar to Livret A, such as the LDD and so forth, at LCL, the total figure following centralization at the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations comes to approximately EUR 10 billion at LCL.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#33

Back in 2021, this resource cost us 4.5%. Across 2022, the average was 1.5% — 1% during the first part of the year and 2% in the second part. That works out to a EUR 100 million difference globally, concentrated in the second half of the year. For 2023, our best guess is that Livret A will probably cost us 3.5% on average, which means an additional EUR 200 million of cost for LCL. Naturally, that is going to put negative pressure on net interest income across the retail banks in France globally — at LCL, in the amounts I was mentioning, at the regional banks, and in all banks that hold a significant amount of Livret A and products of this kind. On capital, the timing of the pull to par is hard to assess because it will depend, of course, on market movements. If we assume rates have now stabilized — and rate is not the only question, because of course you have the equities market in a much smaller proportion, but they play a role. We also have the credit spread, because part of the bond book of Predica is made not only of sovereign bonds, but also of corporate bonds.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#34

The credit spread component is certainly a meaningful factor. We should assume that Predica's bond duration is on the long side. That means the impact will be distributed across the next several years, I'd say. Maybe five, six, seven years. Clearly, it isn't something we anticipate happening tomorrow morning. Until now, I'd describe us as having had an overhang on our solvency tied to this unrealized capital gain component. We now possess an engine that will progressively feed our solvency as we move forward. Turning to the short term, what I can tell you is that at the end of September, risk-free rates were more or less unchanged, so no meaningful movement. Corporate credit spreads actually tightened quite substantially since the end of September, probably by around 20 basis points. Equity markets have gained roughly 10 or 12% since the end of September. I'm not claiming that will be the picture at the end of December, but naturally we're watching this on a nearly day-to-day basis, and I can tell you it has clearly been improving over the first part of the quarter, whereas it had been steadily deteriorating throughout the first three quarters.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#35

Regarding market risk?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#36

Regarding market risk?

Delphine Lee

analyst
#37

Mm-hmm.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

Regarding market risk, the assessment and calculation of market risks involve various components. We have a VaR that's based on a historical methodology, which means that gradually, as time passes, the market events that caused this increase are going to fade away, I'd say. That will take time — probably 1 or 2 years — but it's going to progressively diminish, at least in part, as time goes on.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#39

Thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#40

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#41

Our following question comes from Tarik El Mejjad at BofA. Go ahead, please.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#42

Hello, good afternoon, Jérôme. I have a couple of questions, please. Staying on capital for a moment. I get the reversal of that negative effect stemming from market and rate volatility. But is that—I mean, it puts a lot of strain on the markets regarding your capital adequacy and so forth. Isn't it now obvious, given that we've been through two rate cycles, that raising your buffers as a target makes more sense—above 11%, so you essentially soak up that volatility and people feel comfortable that you can remain above 11% at any point? I'd like to hear your view on that. The second question concerns costs in France and perhaps more broadly. If you could update us on the most recent negotiations for next year and the year after. I know in France you've pre-booked next year's cost, but perhaps you can give some detail on where you see costs going, and also maybe the windfall taxes in any jurisdictions where you operate. Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#43

What's the reason you'd want us to stay permanently, at any point in time, above 11%? I've consistently said 11% was a target rather than a floor. I believe that when we presented the medium-term plan, we said the floor we actually set is a buffer of 250 basis points over SREP. Right now we're at 310 basis points. Naturally, we're aware that the SREP level, which takes in the counter cyclical buffer, will go up modestly but genuinely at the start of next year — I think in the second quarter, in April. However, that's only going to mean a 20 basis points increase, I guess. We're sitting at 310 basis points of buffer above SREP. Our floor is at 250 basis points. At group level we hold more than 800 basis points of buffer, so there's definitely no need whatsoever to change our guidance or change our target, and we're perfectly happy with that. On costs, the negotiations with the social partners aren't finished yet. We're holding to our position, which is that through this general capital increase we granted in the middle of 2022, we've completed a significant part of what we intended to do at the beginning of 2023.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#44

I don’t want to lock in ahead of time where these talks will land or what the final outcome will be, you know. We’re definitely holding to the view that we already completed part of what we set out to do at the start of 2023. That means the start of 2023 will represent just a portion of what you might expect.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#45

Let me just ask a quick follow-up about capital. I fully get the explanation you gave. Some factors are outside your control — where rates move, where the equity market goes — and that produces a lot of volatility in your capital. I'm not suggesting you're undercapitalized at around 11%, but it does create these large swings that can be somewhat harmful for your equity story. That was the point I was making.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#46

Right. Actually, we haven't seen swings, since swings move in both directions. Since the start of this year, the movement has been one-way. We've managed to accommodate that. Of course, we all realize rates won't climb by roughly 100 basis points each quarter over the coming three, four, five quarters. That isn't possible, it isn't rational, and it doesn't match what an economic standpoint would lead us to expect, because if we anticipate a slowdown of the economy, that will somehow temper the rise in long-term rates. That's absolutely clear. What we've been observing for six or seven weeks now is exactly this, I would say, asymptote in how rates are evolving.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#47

Thanks, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#48

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#49

Our following question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Go right ahead.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#50

Yeah. Hello, and good afternoon.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

Hello.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#52

I have two questions as well. First, I'd like to return to the 2019 dividend and that 20 basis points catch-up. I fully understand everything you just said about being well capitalized and comfortably above SREP, but I was wondering: if you continue to see some OCI pressure, wouldn't it be possible to reconsider that one? Or is it simply out of question — you will definitely pay that? That's my first question. Second, I was wondering about the investment banking performance — I think your FIC was quite a bit weaker than peers — and I was wondering whether there were any marks or any specific negative impacts in the quarter that you would call out. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#53

Thank you, Giulia. No, regarding the EUR 0.20, I believe it's referenced again in our slide this time, and we restate that on a permanent basis. Our intention is to pay this additional EUR 0.20 per share in 2023. That is absolutely clear. It's an intention, because you know perfectly well how an intention differs from a commitment. The moment I speak of a commitment, precisely, I must set aside the amount within my solvency ratio, and naturally, I don't wish to do that too early. I want to do it as near as possible to the point when I will be paying this amount. I will convert the intention into a commitment exactly when it becomes necessary. We clearly hold this intention, and this is a discussion we will have with the board when we close the 2022 accounts, so probably in February next year. In our investment banking performances and FIC precisely, it's very hard to compare FIC with FIC, if I may put it that way, because how each bank breaks down activities — whether placed in capital markets, in FIC, in corporate banking, in global banking, or whatever — differs greatly.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#54

Nothing particular has come up as a hit of any sort across what we do. The softer showing from our capital market operations in this quarter — which differs from what we saw over the first nine months — is entirely accounted for by customer behavior, with a weak DCM market, particularly in Europe. You can, I think, conclude that this is purely a market trend rather than something specific to CACIB. Issuance activity levels and volumes for new coco bonds and, above all, corporate bonds were quite weak during this quarter. Conversely, credit demand directed toward us proved fairly substantial. That accounts for the strong showing in our financing activities. Truly, nothing specific and nothing troubling showed up in how we performed this quarter.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#55

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#56

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#57

Moving on, we have a question from Guillaume Tiberghien at BNP Paribas. Go right ahead.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#58

Thanks. Good afternoon, Jérôme. Turning to capital, could you remind us that in Q4 we'll see +10 basis points from Crédit du Maroc, minus 15 or 16 related to the dividend catch-up, and minus 28 from IFRS 17? Can you confirm if there are any other moving pieces, beyond the capital build, obviously? The second question concerns the Stellantis partnership and relationship. My understanding was that toward year-end — or perhaps I have the timing wrong — you would consolidate the loans. Could you explain what impact that would have on revenues and possibly PBT, if any? On the capital impact, I believe the idea with Stellantis was to avoid any capital effect, but is it an impact on RWA that offsets an impact on equity tier one, or is there truly no impact at all on either side of the ratio, please?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#59

About the capital in Q4 — you're correct on Crédit du Maroc. And you're also correct on the EUR 0.20 catch-up. On IFRS 17, you're running slightly ahead, since that standard takes effect in Q1 2023 rather than Q4 2022. We haven't fully pinned down the amount yet, though it will come in well below the 28 basis points figure you cited. As for Stellantis, that too lands at the start of 2023. My understanding — though I need to verify the mechanics precisely — is that the solvency impact will be roughly neutral. I should call a friend to confirm whether it's neutral by nature, so to speak, or whether that's because effects hit both the RWAs and the capital. We'll look into it and get back to you shortly.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#60

Thanks. You're asking about Q1, right?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#61

That covers the first quarter.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#62

All right, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#63

Even in H1 — I can't say yet whether that lands in Q1 or Q2, but H1.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#64

All right, thanks. And will that also hit the P&L?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#65

Yeah. Beyond that, as we move forward, it's going to make the P&L better. That's clear.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#66

All right, have you put a number on that?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#67

That's not something we have at this point.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#68

Alright, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#69

We do have some concepts in mind, though we haven’t shared any sort of quantification.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#70

All right. You’re welcome to share it if you’d like. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#71

We'll take our next question from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. Please go ahead.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#72

Good afternoon, Jérôme? Thanks for taking my question. I'd like to return to the capital markets point, please, since you're flagging some value adjustment effects on revenue. You also have this market risk-weighted asset impact, and on top of that you saw fairly substantial growth in fair value assets through the P&L, nearly 10% during the quarter. I believe we haven't seen that from any of your peers. I'm wondering whether anything else might explain these relatively unusual moves. The second question relates to a point that emerges from the EU Council's proposal on implementing Basel IV, where it appears they're suggesting the output floor would effectively apply at solo entities, though there could be national discretion not to do so. Have you actually ever disclosed what difference applying the output floor would make to CASA in your case? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#73

Thank you. Regarding assets valued through P&L, nothing significant or specific comes to mind, so I can think of two points on that. One would be a Forex effect, since clearly, given that euro-dollar parity has shifted rather dramatically this quarter, a great many balance sheet items have moved considerably just because of that effect. The second possibility would be that we hold certain assets on the insurance company's balance sheet that could likewise be valued through P&L. We need to verify this precisely. There is nothing, I would say, notable or remarkable, nor any change in the scope of activities, that this movement in the volume of assets valued through P&L could signal. On the output floor, we have believed from the very start that the only relevant level at which to apply the output floor was the highest consolidated level. French public authorities have steadily confirmed us in this view. What we observe in the various documents issued by the commission, by the parliament, and even by the council — you know that within the council we have several countries that, being host countries, really want a direct grip on the solvency of banks in their jurisdiction.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

The council document itself allows for applying the output floor at the top consolidated level — that is, at the group level for Crédit Agricole Group. We understand that if that becomes the rule in principle, we will apply it. If instead it is an option, the French authorities have been very clear that they will take that option and permit us to do the same. There is no doubt it will apply only at group level. We don't need to disclose any impact if it were applied at CASA level.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#75

All right, that's very clear. Thank you, Jérôme.

Operator

operator
#76

Matthew Clark from Mediobanca has the next question. Go ahead, please.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#77

Good afternoon. I'm afraid I have two more questions about capital. First, returning to the point Guillaume raised regarding IFRS 17: you were kind enough to indicate that the effect would be under 28 basis points. Could you make clear whether that refers to the gross impact of IFRS 17 coming in below 28 basis points, or whether it incorporates an assumption of additional capital being upstreamed from Crédit Agricole Assurances? My second question also concerns capital, this time Basel IV. Is that the scale of your insurance operations measured in risk-weighted assets, and I suppose the book value, or carrying value, of your investment in them has contracted considerably since you provided guidance of a negligible Basel IV impact a couple of quarters back. Do you need to revise that Basel IV guidance because you won't be getting as strong a gross benefit from the Danish Compromise as you perhaps expected a few quarters ago, given that insurance has shrunk in regulatory balance sheet terms since that time? If not, why not? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#78

With IFRS 17, we aren't focusing on either the gross or the net amount at the moment we disclose a number, since no number has been disclosed by us. Obviously, once we get more precise on this — and we'll likely manage that when the Q4 accounts come out — you'll receive both the gross and the net figure from us. My expectation is that the net figure will come in extremely tiny, if there is one at all, given that we again have a certain flexibility, and the aim is for no net impact whatsoever to arise from the IFRS 17 transition, which is what we've stated from the start. Regarding Basel IV, I'm not certain I completely grasped your point, because what I see in writing is that 370% will turn into 250% regardless, and nothing appears to have shifted from that perspective. Naturally—

Matthew Clark

analyst
#79

If, at the time

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#80

Right.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#81

At the moment you provided that initial guidance, your insurance risk-weighted assets stood at roughly EUR 50 billion — or above EUR 40 billion.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#82

Mm-hmm. Alright.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#83

You know, the effect of moving from 3.70% to 2.50% would be larger in—

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#84

Mm.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#85

in terms of euros in the billions than it would be at present when your beginning point is

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#86

Yeah. All right.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#87

Eight billion euros.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#88

Sorry. Sorry, I didn’t catch that correctly. No — when we state that, once you exclude the output floor and after all the trimming we carried out over the last two or three years, when we said at the start of 2025 that implementing Basel IV would be net zero, I’d say for CASA overall, that factors in, naturally, the update to the carrying value of the infrastructure, which we applied at 250, as well as the routine updates we must make on the other elements of Basel IV. Net zero factors in the reality that we have fewer RWAs inside the insurance business division.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#89

All right, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#90

Thank you.

Operator

operator
#91

Our next question comes from Amit Goel at Barclays. Go ahead, please.

Amit Goel

analyst
#92

Hello, and thanks for taking my questions. I have a few follow-ups. Would you mind talking a bit about the revenue trends for the main businesses as we head into 2023, specifically the moving parts we haven't already covered? Second, maybe focusing a little more on the insurance business — I'm curious about the revenue growth there and, for example, on unit linked sales, whether savings behavior will have an impact going forward. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#93

Thank you. As you're aware, within the insurance operations, when you convert them into a banking accounting framework, gauging the revenue level is invariably quite challenging. We are fully aware that in any given quarter, revenues arising from insurance operations can swing significantly, whereas the bottom line keeps showing a very stable, consistent and favorable trajectory. In fact, the guidance we provide for the insurance operations focuses more on the bottom line. I believe that a few quarters back we shared a historical data series on the profitability of the insurance business, demonstrating that roughly the bottom line expands at about 5% per year, which is fairly in line with non-life activities expanding faster at roughly 7% per year, and life insurance activities expanding at a rate concerning the outstanding of around 2% or 2.5% or 3% per year. Perhaps, should rates settle at a higher level than previously, the capitalization effect on life activities will likely enhance somewhat the rate at which the outstanding grow within the insurance operations. That might slightly improve how the bottom line evolves.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#94

Remember that historically, the bottom line from our insurance operations has come in at roughly 5% annually. Looking ahead, we expect that pattern to persist. Speaking again about IFRS 17, we now feel quite confident that although it could be somewhat more volatile owing to the contractual service margin mechanism and similar factors, the profitability profile of the insurance activities will not shift in a significant way. That is closer to the kind of guidance we have in mind, as opposed to guidance centered on the top line.

Amit Goel

analyst
#95

Understood. As far as any other significant sorts of shifts we ought to consider for next year compared with this year, where top line is concerned? Regarding the businesses.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#96

It could take quite a while if we try to evaluate things one business at a time, given that every business has its own drivers. Of course, at Amundi, the primary driver, as you know, is how asset valuations move, since management fees make up the bulk of revenues. And the good news is that management fees are holding up well for the time being — better than well, in fact, since they improved between 2021 and 2022. What's declining is performance fees. We've discussed net interest income at the retail banking entities at length. At CACIB, in the consumer credit business, when we use the balance sheet, it's more of a spread business. Naturally, we may face some temporary difficulties in passing along the rise in refinancing costs to the customer. That's the situation at Sofinco in France right now. These businesses are spread businesses, and ultimately, once things stabilize, they stabilize at a spread that covers all the costs, all the cost of risk, and so on and so forth. We expect that to improve going forward. Of course, CACF will progressively benefit from the acceleration set off by the inclusion of the leasing activities coming from the deal with Stellantis.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#97

CACEIS is plainly set to serve as an additional engine of growth down the road. Even today, that's thanks to the advantages CACEIS gains from improved compensation on its cash operations, and likewise moving forward, step by step, after the deal closes and RBC Europe is integrated.

Amit Goel

analyst
#98

Okay, thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#99

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#100

Our following question comes from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies. You have the floor.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#101

Yes, thanks, and good afternoon, Jérôme. My first question goes back to capital once more, though this time from a more technical angle. If I compare the 10.7% fully loaded figure with the 11% phased in, that leaves a 30 basis points gap, which is larger than peers and which appears to have been widening as the year has gone on. So the first question is simply to try to grasp what accounts for the difference between phased in and fully loaded for CASA, and when convergence will happen and at what pace, given that the gap is fairly notable at 30 basis points. The second question concerns Russian risk. You saw roughly EUR 200 million of reduction in Russia exposure during the quarter. Could you give us an update there? Is that exposure still performing? Are you not observing greater risk stemming from it? Perhaps you could remind us of the provisions you have set aside against that exposure, please?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#102

The gap between the phased-in and fully loaded CET1 ratio is in fact 25 basis points, not 30. What leads you to believe it's 30 basis points is the rounded figures we give out. It's 25 basis points. Between now and the end of 2023, that's going to be halved. All things being equal, it will be roughly 12 basis points at the end of 2023, and then halved again in 2024, so probably a negligible 6 basis points at the end of 2024, and after that it will vanish entirely in 2025.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#103

I just want to make sure this is clear — it moves toward the fully loaded figure, correct?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#104

Right. With everything else held steady, it does move toward the fully loaded figure. Right. That's an adverse effect we'll need to absorb progressively.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#105

Alright.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#106

Regarding Russia, I believe most of the exposures we still hold are medium- to long-term ones, so we don't anticipate a swift or meaningful further decrease in these exposures moving ahead. We took a provision — an S1 and S2 provision of roughly 300 basis points, if my memory serves me — during Q1 of this year. At that point, we stated that we were finished with what I'd call this political provision. Now each of these exposures is back to its ordinary life on a case-by-case basis. It's possible that in a given quarter, one of these exposures must be reclassified from S1 to S2, or from S2 to S3. Naturally, when that happens, the provision level changes. And since we never discuss individual exposures, we won't give further details about how the portfolio evolves. Should anything occur with this portfolio in a particular quarter, it now falls under what I'd call the normal cost of risk. The original provision, returning to your question, was meant to be booked. I don't recall the precise figure. Was it EUR 300 million or EUR 400 million?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#107

I'll get straight to the number.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#108

Basically, nothing changed in Q2 or Q3.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#109

Oh, no, no.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#110

Alright, that's clear.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#111

Alright.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#112

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#113

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#114

Our following question comes from Pierre Chédeville at CIC. You have the floor.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#115

Yes, Pierre.

Operator

operator
#116

Mr. Chédeville, perhaps you're muted.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#117

Pierre, since Pierre is quiet right now, I’ll jump in and note that the provision we recorded in the first quarter came to roughly EUR 400 million — to be exact, EUR 389 million. Pierre?

Operator

operator
#118

Mr. Chédeville, your line is open — perhaps you’ve muted yourself.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#119

Pierre, we’ll take the next question now, and then we’ll come back to you after that.

Operator

operator
#120

Our following question comes from Anke Reingen at Royal Bank of Canada. You have the floor.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#121

Thanks a lot for the questions. My first one concerns cost control. Your cost-income ratio is clearly comfortably inside the target, of course. But the jaws have been negative year to date. I'm just wondering, as we head into 2023, should we be expecting — and obviously, given your business mix, markets play a big role — but I was wondering whether you think you can hold your cost-income ratio in line with your targets? Is it the cost-income ratio, or do you also, yes, keep an eye on the jaws? Then second, on your consumer finance book, I was just wondering whether you could say a little about asset quality as we go into a possible recession, or in a recession, and a cost of living crisis. What are you watching? Are you being somewhat more restrictive in your lending? How worried are you about what level of interest rates you regard as somewhat more alarming? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#122

Thanks. Regarding costs, obviously our commitment is to keep the cost income ratio under 60%. That commitment is framed in terms of cost income ratio. In the medium term plan we've put together a forecast that, all things being equal—and naturally it can shift quarter to quarter or year to year, but all things being equal—we could aim to further enhance the cost income ratio by delivering positive jaws of 4.5% on average each year. That's an average across the medium term plan's duration. It isn't a pledge to keep up such positive jaws every quarter following the prior one. As for 2023, we're currently in the budget process, and you can be sure that we are holding, and will hold, very detailed conversations with each business head so as to genuinely gauge their ability to hit their own cost income ratio targets, given that there will be some volatility in how far they can meet their revenue targets. Naturally, we have to acknowledge there's some inflation. In fact, inflation even in France, where it runs lower than elsewhere, sits around 6%, 6%-6.5%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#123

In that context, keeping the cost base evolving at roughly 3% isn't bad. We also intend to maintain our ability to honor what we've committed to on the cost income ratio. That forms part of the budget talks currently underway with the business heads. At CACF, and on asset quality in the consumer business, it's clearly a business where we are highly reactive, and we have tools giving us the ability to adjust via pricing, and to adjust credit standards very quickly, should we observe deterioration that would be excessive in the cost of risk. We are fully aware that the cost of risk in this business last year sat below the average, below the level we target across the cycle. We now have a cost of risk of about 130 basis points. In fact, it's better than that if you reallocate all the components of the P&L of the car JVs, which are equity accounted. If you factor in, if you truly factor in their cost of risk and their asset, you'd be closer to 100 basis points globally. It definitely is not an alarming level.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#124

We keep a very close eye on the cost of risk in this business, and if at some point we believe things are getting too hot and could lead to a potential worsening of the situation, we won't hesitate to adjust pricing and credit standards.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#125

All right, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#126

Thanks. Pierre, perhaps you could go ahead.

Operator

operator
#127

Yes, the following question comes from Mr. Pierre Chédeville at CIC, so please proceed.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#128

Hi, are you able to hear me at this point?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#129

Absolutely, Pierre.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#130

I apologize, but I have another question about OCI, which everyone's talking about today, and IFRS 17. This week AXA gave a presentation on the IFRS 17 transition, and they made clear, as you did, that PNL won't see any major impact. But they mentioned something quite interesting. They said IFRS 17 mechanically pushes OCI toward zero, since if mathematical reserves get replaced with best estimate, the best estimate liability moves more or less the same way as the asset side under IFRS 9, and so OCI gets neutralized. What I want to ask is: at the end of the day, if you adopt IFRS 17, on the implementation date you clearly have an impact, because your OCI will be reduced by the liability increase. But ultimately you won't have volatility anymore, as far as I understand, if you apply IFRS the same way a pure insurance company would. Am I wrong, or is there something I'm missing there?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#131

Nope.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#132

Ultimately, this is really positive news for you regarding the adoption of IFRS 17 between. Since it’s going to eliminate the OCI volatility.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#133

You're right that OCI's volatility will come down. That said, the picture is somewhat more complicated, since certain exceptions under IAS 39—or how IFRS 9 is being implemented at present—come into play. I wouldn't call your description 100% accurate, though broadly speaking it holds: with IFRS 17 coming into force, we're moving toward a more stable environment. The interesting part is what you'll get. Personally, I'm not a fan of IFRS 17, so having to identify its positive sides is a bit unsettling for me.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#134

Yes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#135

With the CSM, you'll get a sense of how much future profit sits here and is available going forward. That's also going to be something reassuring.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#136

No, I'm fine on CSM. But for me — at least where AXA is concerned, though I could translate this to another company — the key fact is that OCI volatility more or less vanishes. My second question was whether you can disclose the combined ratio. And finally, you brought up the TLTRO impact, the negative one. You said at the end of the day that a portion of the TLTRO went toward lending to SMEs. Repricing SMEs is far easier than repricing mortgages. At the end of the day, you cited a negative impact of EUR 400 million in 2023. At the end of the day, some of that negative impact ought to be offset by faster repricing on SMEs. Am I wrong here once more?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#137

I'll begin with the combined ratio. At Pacifica, the P&C operations, it has worsened slightly. It now stands at 98.7%. From a risk standpoint, the year has been somewhat challenging, particularly given certain climate events. Naturally, the entire French population has heard about the various events that occurred this year, and especially this summer. Still, it remains well under 100%. Naturally, in the situation we're in, the pricing policy for 2023 will, naturally, be a highly significant factor. Turning to TLTRO. Well, once we have set the rate on a loan for any customer — whether an SME, a self-employed professional, or a household taking out a home loan — it is fixed, and we will not change or raise that rate just because the cost of the resource has gone up. Certainly, all things being equal, the higher cost of this resource, which the TLTRO represents, will affect us directly. Naturally, looking ahead — and this is precisely why we believe we need to consider this situation with a dynamic perspective — going forward, there will be a gradual repricing of the loans we extend to our customers.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#138

As you can see, we haven't discussed this specific topic on the call, but home loan pricing in France and across our various networks has risen fairly substantially since the start of this year. What comes to mind, for instance, is that at LCL the pricing on loan approvals we granted in October was around 2.2%-2.3%, which isn't the case for the loans being implemented right now, because a time lag always exists between approval and implementation, but it demonstrates that a repricing of the loans is underway. That repricing would have occurred even without this hit on the cost of the TLTRO. Put the other way around, the cost of the TLTRO is a hit. The rise in the TLTRO's cost is a hit in itself.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#139

Correct, though the repricing offsets that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#140

Yes, but even so—

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#141

We shouldn't put a negative 500 and.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#142

Yes, Pierre, the repricing would have happened regardless of whether the ECB had altered the TLTRO's pricing.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#143

Alright.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#144

That's exactly it.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#145

Alright. Thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#146

Mm-hmm.

Operator

operator
#147

Our following question comes from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC. You have the floor.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#148

Yes. Good afternoon, Jérôme. Thank you for taking my questions. I have a couple, and they come back to the share purchase matter with the regional bank. In the press release, they state that their ownership will not exceed 65%, but since they are at, well, whatever, 56% right now, might we see additional purchases by the regional banks going forward? Because, as you mentioned, today's transaction represents just 3% of the share count. At least factually, if 65% is the cap they have set themselves, could there be more deals similar to today's announcement? And second, should we view this transaction as potentially merely a matter of timing — that the regional banks are holding those shares temporarily for a period when it is better or more convenient for, say, Crédit Agricole, let's say, to carry out a proper buyback? For instance, say, once your CET1 ratio is back above 11%, and then you can purchase those shares directly from the regional banks at a moment that suits you better. Is this, in a way, a stepping stone toward a proper buyback, or am I reading too much into the situation there?

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#149

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#150

First, obviously, with the share trading where it is right now, EUR 1 billion would not take the regional banks to 65. That much is very clear. But I think their thinking was to say, we're setting a target, or a ceiling, that is here to stay, and we don't want to potentially revisit that level if another operation comes along. On top of that, 65 has the merit of being a round number, because depending on the share price, EUR 1 billion above 57.1% could have taken them to 60 point something. It was hard for them to say, "We don't want to go above 60," since with this EUR 1 billion they could be a little bit stretched. I think 65 is a round number. It's easy to articulate. It's a reassuring number because it's well below 2/3 of the capital. It has many virtues. It doesn't carry any specific meaning or signification. Its only virtue is being simple, clear-cut, round, and so on and so forth. I think you shouldn't read too much into this number. Are they warehousing stocks before CASA itself buys back the shares on the market? I think this is going very far in terms of subtlety.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#151

No. If we did a buyback — and we will, by the way, on a regular basis, since, as we've mentioned, each time there's a capital increase for the employees, we'll repurchase shares on the market so those newly created shares get eliminated. No, there is no connection whatsoever between any buyback Crédit Agricole S.A. might carry out and the regional banks' intention to put some surplus capital to good use.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#152

Understood — that’s perfectly clear. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#153

Benoît Valleaux from ODDO has the next question. You can go ahead.

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#154

Good afternoon. I have a few questions about insurance, starting perhaps with life insurance. I just want to get a sense of how you recorded the nine-month figures for investment margin on euro-denominated products. In other words, did you assume an investment margin that held steady versus last year, or not? Second, do you have concerns about a meaningful rise in the lapse rate at the start of next year? And in terms of ALM policy, how are you protecting yourselves? Then, on P&C, you cited a 98.7% combined ratio, which was actually flat in Q3 compared with H1. And as you noted, Q3 saw a lot of net cat losses in France. Could you quantify the amount of net cat losses you booked? Taking into account price increases and claims inflation, can you confirm that you intend to bring your combined ratio down to 95%, perhaps 96%, over the course of next year? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#155

Thanks. The connection wasn’t great, so I tried to fill in the rest of your question. The first one concerns the investment margin. You’re referring to the investments in the life insurance operations—is that correct?

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#156

Right, exactly. What I mean is, that's the margin on the euro product. So did you assume the investment margin stays stable versus last year, or not?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#157

No — the reality is that we do invest on a regular basis, and that naturally hinges on net inflows as well as on redemptions from the existing assets sitting on our books. Our investing happens regularly, and it takes place at market prices. We aim to stay nimble: when yields strike us as weaker than they might be, we trim our investments somewhat, and when conditions look better, we try to step up the pace. As for the yield on the investment we plan to make in 2023, there's no specific forecast. What I can tell you is that during 2022 we already lifted the reinvestment rate on our assets step by step relative to how things stood in 2021. Naturally, we anticipate that this will carry on.

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#158

Oh, okay, my apologies. Perhaps I didn't put that quite right — I mean, I was simply pointing to the difference between what we earn on investments and the crediting rate that goes to the policyholder.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#159

For full-year 2021, Predica’s investments earned an average return of roughly 2.5% in 2021. What we credited to policyholders came to, I believe, 1.6%—sorry, 1.3%. Between the return on assets and the profit-sharing rate, we enjoyed a spread exceeding 100 basis points. I can’t say precisely what asset yield full-year 2022 will bring, though our expectation is that it lands more or less where it did last year. As for the profit-sharing rate, I don’t yet know the figure. An increase can’t be ruled out, but as you’re aware, we hold the PPE, from which we can draw whatever is required to top up asset yield should the need arise. The PPE accounts for, I think, 7% of that 6.5% of outstanding. It truly is a substantial reserve for us, and it will assist us in absorbing, if necessary, any shortfall or any narrowing between asset yield and the profit-sharing rate. Your second question concerned ALM policy, but I’m not certain I grasped it completely—my apologies.

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#160

Do you think — I mean, because interest rates have gone up — that we might see some lapse rate, like a lapse ratio, at the start of next year? And on that point, if you'd rather, in that scenario, how do you guard against that possibility?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#161

And that includes the insurance operations too?

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#162

Correct — that falls under life insurance.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#163

Sure, we do routine stress tests — internal ones — to gauge how well we could withstand redemptions, including heavy ones. There's a liquidity ratio we maintain at a consistently very high level. Our view is that we can handle any sort of redemption stress, should it arise. Right now, we aren't seeing any redemption activity at all. And again, this PPE exists to demonstrate to our policyholders that we stand ready to top up, if necessary, the return on the assets, specifically so that no redemption movement occurs.

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#164

Mm-hmm.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#165

Our solvency ratio remains really strong. At the end of June, it stood above 220%. We haven't released the ratio for the third quarter. Our practice is to publish it only two times per year. That ratio is quite elevated, and it sits well above the framework we use for risk appetite. In fact, the risk appetite framework we have is considerably lower than that. Should the need arise, we have room to be flexible. Okay?

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#166

Alright.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#167

Appreciate it.

Benoît Valleaux

analyst
#168

Yes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#169

Thanks. I believe that was the final question. Thank you very much, everybody. Enjoy your day, and for anyone who isn't working on 11 November, have a great weekend. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#170

Thanks, everyone, for being with us. That brings the conference to a close, so you're free to hang up your phones now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.