Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 9, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Philippe Brassac
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. We can begin this meeting. First, I want to thank you for being here or joining us for this session. It's a particular pleasure for me to see some of you in person after three years of remote arrangements for this type of presentation. Well, in a few minutes, Jérôme will recap the key figures, the main metrics for Crédit Agricole S.A., for both the fourth quarter and the full year 2022. Of course, we will try to respond to your questions. At this point, let me introduce Olivier Gavalda, who is here in this room, one of the new Deputy CEOs alongside Jérôme Grivet, since his appointment last summer. Let me give a brief introductory speech for this presentation. I would simply like to return first to the environment, the paradigm we must confront, and then to the situation of Crédit Agricole S.A., very briefly. Regarding the environment, the paradigm in which we are living, I want to tell you that our diagnosis has not changed at all since we launched our medium-term plan in June 2022. Always this very high level of opacity in the very short term, an opacity that, as you know, is absolutely tied to and caused by the accumulation of many impacts from different shock waves around the world.
Philippe Brassac
executiveTo start with those factors: the normalization of monetary policy that was required—likely happening faster than we anticipated where rate increases are concerned. Then, of course, there's the war in Ukraine, the various upheavals surrounding energy, both when it comes to prices and even when it comes to availability, plus the different geopolitical worries that all of you are certainly aware of. The favorable aspects, the right aspects, the encouraging aspects are, above all, that risks remain under control at all times. It's hard to explain this particular point, but my view, my working assumption, is that where corporates are concerned, corporates have probably managed to adjust to this new paradigm, more or less, for the majority of them, through pricing most likely. As for households, and particularly regarding home loans, and particularly for Crédit Agricole in France—a very significant territory for us—the fact that households are shielded by fixed income. Please don't undervalue this favorable aspect for the economy and for the effects on banks. Risk still under control, naturally, while accepting the direct fallout of the war between Ukraine and Russia. The second point, I want to restate this point, and I want all of you to be persuaded that this isn't a theoretical point. The universal development model of the group is neither harmed, nor held back by this opacity, and I want to be very concrete about this point.
Philippe Brassac
executiveBasically, over the very long run, we have free access—free way—to develop from a commercial standpoint and then from a financial one. At the end of the day, each of these axes amounts to organic growth. The first is our capacity to broaden the range of offers tied or linked to what individual customers need, and now to what society needs collectively. Our predecessor chose to launch insurance, and after that a real estate solution. Today we are launching solutions for the energy transition, for healthcare setups, and so on. For us, the ability that comes with being a bank of the global relation—to enlarge, over the very long term, into new kinds of businesses—is an axis that is not saturated for development over the very long term. The second one naturally leads into the first one: our level of equipment. When you look at our equipment, it is increasing, but it is absolutely not saturated. You can look at our different market shares—the strongest one on savings or lending, the smallest one on the very new businesses. Our ability to cross-sell, as you say many times, and for us simply to enlarge the global approach of our customer, is very important and never saturated.
Philippe Brassac
executiveThe third axis is that we managed to build and arrange our business lines so they serve these banks as legal entities that each have their own autonomy, and today every one of these legal entities stands as a leading consolidator in the market for this business. Naturally, we can mention asset management, asset servicing, insurance, life activity, consumer finance activity, and so on. This demonstrates that we have three axes: the breadth of offerings, then the equipment, then the capacity of business lines to build partnerships across different countries and with different other customers. That is why we keep urging you to examine our commercial pace when it comes to development. Naturally, we can see — and you can probably picture — many headwinds that typically have to be faced, and notably in 2023. Those headwinds certainly exist. The chief response of Crédit Agricole Group to this kind of headwind — to face it, to cope with it, and probably to offset it — is development. Look at how Crédit Agricole Group is developing. The various commercial development is very high, and it is accelerating over the very long term. Just look at the key figures of our development. This is simply, or mainly, a question of the group's structure and architecture in terms of office, in terms of a global approach to customers, in terms of the capacity of business lines to grow with partners.
Philippe Brassac
executiveRegarding opacity in the near term: over the very long term, this is naturally a rather unique discrepancy. I've already said that finding this high degree of opacity in the short term was very surprising, along with being so capable of seeing what lies ahead — at minimum the future required for 2030 when it comes to the energy transition, when it comes to health setups for confronting an aging population, when it comes to agri or agro processes that must shift, when it comes to many things. Fortunately or unfortunately, the long term is very clear regarding what we must do today, what we must invest in, what we must develop from a commercial standpoint today — meaning as soon as 2023 for the future. Yes, clearly, the matter of decarbonized energy, health setups, or agri transition, just to take this example, are immediate huge new drivers for business and of course new revenues. That is the vision we hold, driving Crédit Agricole Group regarding our paradigm amid this kind of opacity. The way to develop over the very long term is very clear, and this fills, feeds and fuels our development as soon as the present, and notably for the next 2023.
Philippe Brassac
executiveOkay, just a quick note on where Crédit Agricole S.A. stands, since Jérôme will of course get into the specifics and the details on this. I'll keep it short and try this exercise. If there were just a single number I could hand our shareholders regarding how we performed, I think on balance the one we'd land on is simply, when all is said and done, at the very top of the group, the profitability we manage to achieve on top of the equity our shareholders provide us — 12.6% in terms of return on tangible equity. Just that one number. Because it sits at the peak of all the businesses, all the efficiency, all the risk mastery across Crédit Agricole Group. You know full well this ranks at the top against the benchmark. I'd like to stress that this is a consistent performance for Crédit Agricole S.A. I'll leave it there, and Jérôme, I hand you the floor right away so you can be far more precise than I've been.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Philippe. Good afternoon, everyone. I'm glad to also walk you through these results. I'll aim to keep it short so that, of course, there's time left for your questions. Let me begin with this page, which really contains all the key messages we want to emphasize when presenting these results — and in fact I could limit myself to just this page. The messages are right here. On net profit, this was an excellent Q4 for Crédit Agricole S.A., and in fact the best Q4 ever, with profitability at a record high and revenues rising very sharply across every business line. It has also been a very good year. Let me take you back three quarters, to when we presented the Q1 results. The net profit we reported for Q1 was down 47% versus Q1 2021. What happened in that first quarter was the outbreak of the war in Ukraine, and we chose to book significant prudent provisions to cover the risks we incurred as a result of that event — hence the 47% decline. By the end of the first half of the year, net profit was down 16%, so the catch-up had indeed begun rather quickly.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBy the close of the first nine months of the year, net profit had fallen 12%. In terms of stated figures, though, the decline is only 7%. What that tells us is that through the remainder of the year we have been steadily making up ground on that very significant level of provisions we chose to book in the first quarter. Turning to underlying figures — which are, of course, more readable and more usable for grasping the underlying performance we have delivered — net profit is up, modestly higher across the full year and sharply higher for the quarter. As for the financial targets for the full year, this is the final year of the prior medium-term plan, so it gives us a chance to revisit the goals we set under that previous plan. Naturally, we are at or above the targets on every profitability item. That holds for net profit: EUR 5 billion was the minimum, and we stand at EUR 5.5 billion. It holds for the cost income ratio: we wanted it under 60%, and we are at 58.2%. It holds for return on tangible equity, which Philippe mentioned.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOur goal was to land above 11%, and we've come in above 12.5%, at 12.6%. That's a really, really strong set of accomplishments under this prior medium-term plan. Let me wrap up this page with two more items. The first concerns the dividend. At the general assembly meeting, we will put forward a dividend of EUR 1.05, matching what we did last year. That combines EUR 0.85 under what I'd call the standard payout policy, plus the final EUR 0.20 consistent with what we told you about the 2019 skipped dividend. One last thing, and it's crucial to bear in mind: we stayed agile throughout last year so we could build new partnerships and new activities that will feed our future growth as we move ahead. Turning to the key figures on the following page. Here you have the main figures, and maybe one or two more points to round out what I covered on the prior page. For the quarter, revenues are highly dynamic, at 4.4%, and we also recorded positive JAWS between how the top line moved and how the cost line moved. Second point, cost of risk has risen versus last year, but we'll go a bit deeper into what makes up the cost of risk, and you will see that the bulk of the increase — in fact more than the entire increase — stems from this Russia-Ukraine conflict.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNow, on solvency — for CASA, we're at 11.2% at this point. That's exactly where we want to be, right in line with our 11% target. Globally across the group, profitability is at a very resilient level: we posted above EUR 8 billion for the full year on a stated basis, and above EUR 7.9 billion for the full year on an underlying basis. That's slightly lower than last year, but honestly only modestly so, and it fits perfectly with the global business model Philippe mentioned in his introduction. One last item on this page: the group's solvency rose further this quarter and now stands at 17.6% for CET1, which is, of course, among the highest levels you'll find among European banks. Moving to this page now — you know it well, since we've had plenty of chances to discuss this chart — but here again it's a good opportunity to show how we're delivering this steady growth. We attracted new customers this year: 1.9 million new customers for the full year across our retail banks in France, Italy, and Poland. That's a very dynamic expansion of the customer base. And we've been very active with those customers on lending, because new loan production is up by close to 6% YoY.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe've kept raising the equipment rate for these clients through the various products and services we produce across the group, and we've permanently widened the range of offerings we make available to them. Now let me focus a bit more closely on how revenues broke down in 2022. What's interesting on this page, I think, is first that our top line has been rising, both for the quarter and for the full year. Second, this growth occurred across every business division: asset gathering, large customers, specialized financial services, and retail banking activities. Third, it has actually been the case consistently since 2017 and probably somewhat before 2017 as well, and that's the well-known chart we publish on the right-hand side of the page. Each quarter since 2017, we have managed to report revenues higher than those posted in the equivalent quarter a year earlier. This chart illustrates a very well-established ability to expand the group's revenue base. Turning now to how we manage the cost base. Naturally, the cost base rose this year, rising both for the full year and for the quarter, but there are perhaps one or two extra points to keep in mind when you assess the cost base.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTo begin with, in Q4 we achieved a positive JAWS worldwide at the group level. Secondly, for the entire year, JAWS was also positive for the business lines on their own. Regarding the corporate center — and we'll likely have chances to go into that — there are numerous technical items, restatements, and a few of those are non-cash in nature. That's why judging the situation using the business lines as the basis is more relevant. Across the business lines globally, this JAWS effect was positive for the full year. Thirdly, looking more closely at where the rise in the business lines' cost base, + EUR 380 million, comes from, it consists of three main components. The forex effect, entirely unavoidable, tied to the euro having depreciated relative to the dollar, in particular. For us this means an extra cost above EUR 100 million. We've kept investing in IT and in developing new setups, EUR 90 million of additional costs. Then, naturally, we had to raise salaries, and as an exception, we made an effort to raise them partway through the year, in the middle of 2022.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOverall, this amounts to EUR 130 million in extra cost — additional costs that include a one-off item, a specific premium owed to employees at the start of 2023, though it was booked at the end of 2022 for close to EUR 30 million. The result is that gross operating income has risen, both for the quarter and for the full year. That holds even more strongly for the business lines alone, excluding the corporate center, again for the same reasons I mentioned earlier. The cost-income ratio we report, at 58.2%, sits far under our target and our ceiling, and it is also well beneath the European peer average. Turning now to cost of risk — naturally, it is better to examine cost of risk one business line at a time. Still, if we look at it first on a global basis, at CASA it is up versus 2021, +35%. In fact, nearly half of that cost of risk relates solely to the events in Ukraine. That means absent this event, we would have reported cost of risk edging down slightly relative to 2021. The picture is exactly the same across the group perimeter as a whole, where we do see a modest quarter-on-quarter rise and a sharper full-year versus full-year increase.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure. The largest share of this rise is tied to the fallout from the war in Ukraine. Beyond that, we have kept building provisions in the S1 and S2 buckets, meaning provisions on sound assets, both at CASA and across the group worldwide. That is what the next page shows, since the share of non-performing loans on our books remains very low: 2.7% at Crédit Agricole S.A., 1.7% at the regional banks, and 2.1% for the group overall. That is why, with the same overall volume of provisions — EUR 9.3 billion of provisions in total on our balance sheet for CASA — we have raised it fairly substantially since the COVID crisis began. Within that total, we have lifted the share of S1 and S2 provisions, while the total itself has stayed broadly flat. As for the coverage ratio, it looks like it dips slightly. That is entirely down to one particular file, which I won't name, that moved from S2 to S3 in the fourth quarter, carrying an average provision level below the average for S3 provisions, for reasons that fit perfectly with that particular file.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo this brings us to a position where, once again, the coverage ratios — for the group as well as for CASA — rank among the highest in Europe. They relate to a portfolio that remains highly diversified and, again, very solid. That translates into the net income CASA has reported, for both the quarter and the full year. On an underlying basis, it rose 6.7% for the quarter and 1.3% for the full year. That gain comes off a 2021 reference point that was already very high — a year that was already a record. If we look at this performance against 2020, the increase is, naturally, far steeper: +57% for the quarter and +42% for the full year. One last point on the full year: what you can see is that every business line has delivered a higher bottom line. Let me now turn to solvency, beginning with CASA. During the quarter, actually, the — I would say the ordinary course of business, the recurring course of activity, would have taken the CET1 ratio to 11.4%. On the basis of that figure, we decided to top up the ordinary dividend of EUR 0.85 with this extra EUR 0.20 that we wanted to return to our shareholders in respect of the 2019 dividend we had to skip following the ECB's decision.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLet me walk through how that favorable change unfolded during the quarter. To begin with, the level of results and retained results produces roughly 20 basis points of capital. Second, the RWA consumption by the business lines has evolved very actively and very favorably, particularly at CACIB. That delivers an extra 19 basis points of additional solvency. Finally, on M&A, namely the deconsolidation of generated a 12 basis point improvement in our solvency. The OCI evolution of the insurance activities during this quarter was actually quite stable. That results in a hit of only, let's say, two basis points. And lastly, this dividend add-on accounts for a further 20 basis points of solvency consumption. That is the reason we moved from 11%-11.2% across the quarter. For the full year, we stood at 11.9% at the start of the year. We finish the year at 11.2%, which is a decline of 70 basis points, of which 100 basis points relate to market effects. What that means is that, excluding those market effects, we would have recorded an improvement in the CET1 ratio. Finally, naturally, we began the year with an unrealized capital gain inside our solvency that was set to amortize progressively.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe close the year with a negative item in our solvency, and that will amortize as time goes by. What that means is that moving forward, with everything else held constant, we will see some additional strengthening of solvency. At group level, naturally, solvency stands very high, and the same factors are at play over the quarter for the group: retained earnings, along with RWA evolution across the business lines, plus M&A, plus the dividend top up for CASA. We also factor in the majority shareholder's decision to purchase EUR 1 billion of CASA shares during 2023. Since that decision has been made and announced, it is already reflected in our solvency. Even with all of these items, solvency rises from 17.2% to 17.6%, giving us the largest distance to SREP among European banks. For CASA, the distance to SREP is 330 basis points — once again, a very comfortable level. On profitability, we already cited the 12.6% figure for return on tangible equity. What's worth noting beyond that is the fact that this outperformance relative to the European banks' peer space is a consistent characteristic of CASA. For at least six consecutive years now, we have published a return on tangible equity that sits at least 2.5 or three percentage points above the European banks' average.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOver on the right side of the page, just as a reminder, you can see the dividend sequence we have been paying, based on CASA's results. Those items have already come up. Naturally, we are fully in line with the goal we set for 2022. We are also on track and doing well on the road toward our 2025 targets. This year has not only been a highly efficient period of activity, but also one in which we have been agile and have launched many initiatives to further boost our revenues and our development going forward. We have picked three examples of those initiatives. Naturally, the restructuring of our partnership with FCA Bank, which has now become a very, very promising partnership with Stellantis for growing car leasing across Europe. Second, the negotiation and signing of an agreement with RBC so that CACEIS can purchase their European activities, which is set to be completed in the middle of this year. Last, the signing at the end of December of an agreement with Banco BPM, through which Crédit Agricole Assurances will purchase 65% of their non-life activities in order to grow, over the long run, the distribution of non-life and protection insurance products within the Banco BPM network.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveEvery one of these programs will deliver a minimum of EUR 150 million in additional net profit within three years. We have kept evolving our model — I won't walk through every example shown on this page — but our work has carried on around those three core pillars that define how we operate. First, usefulness for every client, meaning we build offers suited both to our wealthiest clients and to those in the most vulnerable situations. Second, helping every region where we operate grow, naturally by strengthening the backing we give all our customers in their energy transition efforts. Let me now focus a bit more closely on how the various business lines of CASA performed across 2022, beginning with asset gathering and insurance. Taken as a whole, the division enjoyed a strong year, with inflows finishing positive and the division's net profit rising sharply for the quarter as well as for the entire year. Within that division, insurance had an overall solid commercial year, posting net inflows in life insurance and, once again, picking up some market share in the non-life side — both P&C and protection.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the financial side, it was a really, really strong year, with net profit rising sharply both for the quarter and across the full year. Naturally, starting this year with IFRS 17, our insurance operations will see a very substantial change in how they report their financial figures. In this document pack we've included a few slides showing what we can say about that as of now. I expect this will keep coming up in our conversations throughout 2023. On asset management, you know Amundi's results very well. They came out yesterday, and I believe the market welcomed them. The business showed its resilience through 2022. Market conditions were tough that year, yet Amundi still brought in new inflows and kept adapting to the new environment — adjusting its cost base and lifting net profit in Q4 versus Q3. Overall, for the full year, net profit is down only very slightly, and the cost-income ratio remains at a very appealing level of 55%, roughly 55%. On large customers, CACIB had a very busy quarter, posting record-high revenues in both capital market activities and financing activities, particularly in ITB transaction banking.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveCACIB delivered a strongly favorable JAWS impact for both the quarter and the whole year, finishing the year with a cost of risk at nearly zero, driven by a mix of reversals of loan loss reserves plus some added provisions, naturally, though that's just ordinary business activity. Ultimately, the full-year cost of risk stays rather benign for CACIB, even given the Russian situation—the Russia-Ukraine environment. Asset servicing is among the businesses where we gain right away from rising interest rates. At CACEIS, assets under custody or administration dipped somewhat in value due to market movements. Even so, since treasury is increasingly remunerated, overall revenues are markedly higher, and CACEIS's profit is up very substantially across the quarter and the full year. Specialized financial services had a commercially strong quarter and, all things considered, a strong year. New loan production rose during the quarter, and the loan portfolio also grew over the full year. Margins are somewhat pressured, yet the volume effect offsets the price effect. On balance, revenues are flat.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOur cost base is in good shape. Cost of risk ticks up somewhat, yet net profit rose for CACF this quarter and was roughly flat across the full year, which is a solid result. In leasing and factoring, revenues also reached a very high level for both the quarter and the full year, with net profit significantly higher. Moving to French retail activities at LCL: LCL delivered very buoyant activity for the full year and the quarter, capturing a high number of new customers — close to 350,000 new customers for the full year. Activity there featured a significant rise in loan outstandings, along with growth in customer assets, despite the market effect on off-balance sheet assets. Naturally, we are beginning to feel some pain from the contraction in net interest income. Even so, we managed to record growth in the top line overall for the full year. The cost base remains very well controlled. Cost of risk remains quite benign. Taken together, net profit for the full year is up 13%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveItaly operates under a distinct business model. Activity there has stayed highly dynamic, including through Q4. The key point to highlight is that the top line rose very steeply in that fourth quarter. It came in at +14.5%, and that is driving a very substantial lift in gross operating income. Cost of risk stays firmly in check across the board, up 11% or 10% for the quarter and for the full year, at a level well beneath the average we anticipate over the cycle. Overall, profitability improved very substantially, helped as well, naturally, by finishing the integration of Creval into our setup. This page lays out all our Italy activities. Once again, that still accounts for a solid 15% of CASA's net profit. So it remains a highly active, important and growing market for CACIB and for CASA and every one of its activities. Turning to the remaining international banking operations, we need to draw a distinction here, since this quarter was the one in which Crédit du Maroc was deconsolidated. That is no longer a business matter or a business topic.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn Ukraine, activity is at a good level, all things considered given the actual situation — that is, we’re posting gross operating income that’s rising significantly, though very prudently, and we channel all of that gross operating income into topping up the loan loss reserves we book locally. The upshot is that Ukraine is generating a result of roughly zero. Turning to Poland and Egypt, two markets where activity is good and the rate curve is very steep, that’s producing a sharp jump in revenues alongside a low cost of risk. On the corporate center, this quarter, on the structural side of the corporate center, we face a challenging base effect, since in last year’s fourth quarter the private equity investments booked within the corporate center posted a very high level of revenues. We’re now posting a more normal level of revenues, but even so, there’s nothing concerning on that front. On the volatility side, the volatile part of the corporate center, there’s this elimination of intragroup securities among CASA, Amundi, and Predica that generates a negative revenue element this quarter. This will be the last quarter in which we have to report on that, because thanks to IFRS 17, this element is coming to an end, so it will no longer affect our P&L.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning now to Crédit Agricole's regional banks, which sit outside the CASA perimeter yet remain very important to the group — definitely. Once again, it's very satisfying to see that activity was good and quite buoyant. Growth in the customer base, growth in the loan book, growth in customer assets. That is driving a further improvement in the ability of CASA's business line to offer their services to regional bank customers. At the regional bank level, the cost of risk looks sharply higher versus last year, but definitely they have kept booking very high levels of S1 and S2 provisions. As you know, their very prudent stance on risks, so nothing worrying about this evolution in cost of risk, which continues to be all in all low compared to any kind of standards. Let me move now very quickly to liquidity matters. Just to note that we repaid a significant amount of TLTRO at the end of last year in December, around EUR 70 billion. Despite that, we still have a high LCR level above 160%. We still have a very important, very ample excess of stable resources compared to stable assets.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOur liquidity reserves remain at a very high level, and they fall into various categories, as the chart explains. One final item: market funding. Because monetary policy shifted quite sharply around the world, we increased last year's program during the year. We chose to be fairly active in raising market funding. At the CASA level, we raised more than EUR 21 billion of market funding last year, and at the group level globally, close to EUR 50 billion. We have begun this new year very actively by issuing, at the CASA level, close to EUR 6 billion of new debt in January alone. I think that's where I'll stop. The rest of the document contains a very detailed presentation on IFRS 17. Perhaps I can just summarize the key points on IFRS 17 with two or three ideas. The first idea: on day one, the transition to IFRS 17 will create an additional 15 basis points of solvency at the CASA level. Second point: looking ahead, we do not foresee any significant deviation in our earnings trajectory in the insurance business compared with what it would have been under IFRS 4.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMoving to the third item, which you’re already aware of: there will be, I’d say, a contraction in both revenues and costs within our insurance operations, since a portion of those insurance-related expenses will hit the top line directly. That should bring down the cost income ratio at Crédit Agricole Assurances substantially, to roughly 15%. All else equal, it will also lift the cost income ratio at CASA by about 1 percentage point. Naturally, we’ll need to revisit these transformations during next year when we present a different quarter beginning next May. I think that’s where I’ll leave it, and along with Philippe and Olivier, of course, we’ll take your questions.
Philippe Brassac
executiveGo ahead — I’d suggest we begin with the room. Please, you’re welcome to ask your first question.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystHello, this is Tarik El Mejjad calling from Bank of America, and I have a couple of questions, please. The first concerns cost of risk. In 2022, you came in under your 40 basis points through-the-cycle cost of risk, even though, as you noted, it was an unusual year with elevated Stage 1 and 2 provisions and so forth. Looking ahead, do you believe a 40 basis point guide is still necessary? Your business risk is clearly below 40 basis points. Is that because you intend to take on more risk in your business while keeping the 40 basis point guidance, or should we expect you to come in below that? That is question one. The second is about capital. Clearly you have moved away from the 11% kind of danger zone, I would say. Do you actually feel constrained by your capital level when it comes to growing? In your introductory remarks, Mr. Brassac, you said the group has substantial capacity to grow for a number of reasons. Do you feel there really are some businesses you would like to capture — quality, profitable ones — but your capital level does not let you truly grow?
Tarik El Mejjad
analystThen, perhaps, regarding the question attached to that — could you collaborate with the group to actually help fund, in some manner, that potential growth that might arise?
Philippe Brassac
executiveMaybe I’ll take the first question and then the second one, though naturally Jérôme can give you a far more precise answer than I can. On cost of risk, let me return to what I explained earlier. It’s hard to lay out clearly, since cost of risk is inherent in what we do. First, it reflects the nature of the environment. Across our various markets, what we observe is that for corporates, cost of risk is genuinely well controlled — not just at Crédit Agricole Group but at many European banks, and it will be the case for French banks too. Our belief is that corporate banks have adjusted their business model to this degree of opacity, and most are able to adjust via their pricing in response to the environment. The second point — and I want to stress this — concerns home loan outstandings for households: our household customers are shielded by fixed rates. That isn’t exactly true at every bank, obviously, but it matters a great deal, because most households cannot adjust their income to pay 2%, 3% or 4% if they had been able to pay 1%. What I mean is, you can adapt new lending for people who can pay two, three or four, but not for people of whom you were certain they could pay 1%.
Philippe Brassac
executiveI mean, one significant element behind risk stabilizing is probably that companies have adjusted how they operate, with substantial financial backing from governments, you could say. Households — very important, of course, for bank balance sheets in France, particularly in France — are steadied by fixed interest rates. Naturally, that isn't purely a positive in terms of impact, but this aspect is quite favorable. I think Jérôme will tell you that we confirm it. I hope we won't alter our assumptions and therefore our targets for 2025. My main explanation concerns the reasons behind this, these assumptions. Would you like to add anything on cost of risk?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNo, I just want to set the record straight a bit on what you said, Tarek. The 40 bps isn't guidance—it's an assumption. And even using that cost-of-risk assumption, we'd still be able to hit our financial targets for 2025. So it isn't guidance, and it isn't meant as an indication of the cost of risk we expect for next year or the year after. Of course, what Philippe said matters a great deal. Households, for their home loans on one side, and corporates, for their loans on the other, are both very significant components of our loan books. For those two categories, for different reasons, we have a lot of confidence that the cost of risk will actually stay very benign as we go forward. On the capital ratio and what you're calling a capital constraint, 11% is once again a target, not a floor. We've said that on many occasions. We don't regard sitting at 11% as the death zone, to borrow your phrase. You may have noticed over the past year, and you may notice in the year ahead as well, that we can deploy our capacity to generate capital to fund acquisitions. We've funded a number of acquisitions over the last few years.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLooking ahead to 2023, we anticipate one new acquisition — namely the purchase of RBC's European operations. That will likely use somewhere in the range of 10 to 15 basis points of capital, and for us it is absolutely not a constraint. In fact, what we demonstrated during 2022 — and there is a slide covering this — is that CASA's ability to generate capital organically is significant. When you report a return on tangible equity of 12% and something percent, and when your payout policy stands at 50%, that by definition means roughly 6% is free and available right here to fund growth. We face absolutely no constraint. One last point, which you yourself raised: within the group we have exactly the capacity, should something larger require it, to arrange inflows and outflows of capital in some way so as to absorb it. At group level, 17.5+ is, of course, a massive capacity.
Philippe Brassac
executiveI hear this sort of worry about capital levels quite often. I won't dispute the underlying facts — you're well aware that when it comes to solvency, we're the sole entity inside a worldwide group sitting at 17.6% solvency, which is a very secure position. That allows us to avoid holding solvency at an excessively high level for our shareholders, since you cannot expect 12.6% at 11% of core equity. The same holds whether it's 15%, 18%, or 20% solvency. I'd like to clarify this, and let me say again that it truly surprises me a great deal that the market could view this as a concern. Typically, demanding ever more capital is the role of the supervisor, or those folks. As you know, I presently serve as chairman of the French Federation of Banks. We work to make the case that they need to halt, they need to keep the required capital level stable, because if it keeps climbing, it gets captured by the supervisor. That serves neither the economy nor investors. It's quite odd that we see this sort of automatic drift coming from the market, focusing on capital level, even though you know it sits very comfortably relative to requirements.
Philippe Brassac
executiveLet me say that again for everyone here, for our shareholders, and of course for the majority shareholders: 11% is quite comfortable. Quite comfortable. It's neither too high nor too low. As I mentioned, we aim to run around that figure. You know, I've spent many years at Crédit Agricole Group, but I've known supervisors, at least from 2027 onward, right from Basel III's earliest days. Capital levels stood at 5%, 6%, 7%, and later 8%, 9%, 10%, 11%. So if someone asks, "Why not 12%? After all, others average 13%, then 14%." That works against you, against the market. We try to make the case that whatever the capital level might be, it has to be stable. Because ultimately, supervisory decisions capture it. Well, convincing you of this point matters a great deal to me. Naturally, our stance is very clear, and we won't be changing it. Jacques-Henri, please.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystThank you. This is Jacques-Henri Gaulard with Kepler Cheuvreux. I’d like to build on what my esteemed colleague asked and adopt your perspective briefly. First, considering that upon arriving you essentially ensured those circulars and so forth were eliminated, wouldn’t it be entirely counterproductive to reshuffle things inside the group? That’s my first point. If we feel confident about our capital standing alone, why would we even need to examine the group? Second question: as you mentioned on the slide, a portion of what I’d call the negative OCI effect is set to be reversed. Why not say, “Alright, for anything exceeding 11%, I’ll return to you as dividend the amount above that, to demonstrate you’re adequately capitalized”?
Philippe Brassac
executiveGive it a shot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes. No, that’s a sensible thought. I’ve heard of banks that had put that sort of target in place. Anything above a particular capital threshold gets returned through a dividend. That story doesn’t appeal to me much, as you can probably tell. Still, what’s true is that we don’t want to pile capital on top of capital. What we want is to be as agile as we can and as precise as we can in managing our solvency, so that what is available can go to growth, to feed the growth. Up to now, I think we’ve done that quite efficiently and effectively. For the time being, what we’re discussing and what we’re presenting is the dividend for 2022, and we think it’s an attractive dividend for all the reasons I’ve mentioned. We’ll see what we do going forward.
Philippe Brassac
executiveMaybe part of what’s behind your question is that the level of what we’re doing to acquire positions and to sell other positions isn’t fully appreciated. At the size of Crédit Agricole Group, we favor incremental shifts when it comes to acquisitions and when it comes to selling a position. There are some questions about capital, as if our perimeter could stay stable — it isn’t. When you look at our various joint ventures, we signed regarding future development or regarding, for example, Crédit du Maroc, because we are exiting that bank. Year after year you can see that we are genuinely moving, using the level of capital we have. One more point — the last point from me on capital — is that I’m always surprised about giving back capital. We need the right level of capital. We need to pay our shareholders regularly in terms of the value of the share and the value of dividends. For Crédit Agricole Group, the story won’t be over. It’s a very long-term development, with no coming back. When you look at the trajectory of Crédit Agricole Group, including revenues quarter by quarter, we did give you something to see for 2025.
Philippe Brassac
executiveWe’re laying out 2030 for you. The future will be explained to you by those who come after us. For a corporation, handing capital back is quite unusual. I mean, I don’t know what to do with it. I don’t know where I can invest to get profitable usefulness for the society and profitable revenues. It’s very strange. I think I don’t want to criticize around us, but simply we give you a very long-term trajectory on the past and on the future, and we try to be in a balanced situation in terms of means we use, both for liquidity and equity. I think that with this incremental vision to develop, we succeed to have something very, very regular, including the return on tangible equity on which investors are directly linked. Delphine?
Delphine Lee
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for taking my questions. My first one concerns capital—sorry, just to revisit the regulatory impact, can you confirm that TRIM is still 30 basis points? I wanted to get a handle on IFRS 17, this significant change. In the quarter, since you had previously guided toward an impact that was more negative than positive, what has shifted in your methodology approach that makes it so dramatic? My second question relates to French retail. I was hoping for some color from you, because we heard what SocGen said yesterday, which was fairly prudent. I just wanted to see whether you, by contrast, think you can achieve growth in French retail this year. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Delphine. Regarding capital TRIM, what we anticipate at this point is that it will, naturally, change on a permanent basis, since the foundation used to compound the calculation keeps evolving permanently. For 2023, our current expectation is another 4 billion of RWAs. That ought to come to roughly 10-plus basis points of capital. In fact, the 30 basis points you likely have in mind probably reflected 2022 and 2023 combined. We now have approximately 10 basis points plus left for 2023. On IFRS 17, the methodology has not been altered by us in any way. What has been altered is the sign preceding the unrealized capital positions at Crédit Agricole Assurances. One consequence of IFRS 17 is that, in fact, a portion of the OCI reserves will be allocated directly to the contractual service margin and no longer to equity, to the capital position. That means we will offset a portion of the unrealized capital losses. At first, we assumed it would be against capital gains, unrealized capital gains, but we will reduce somewhat the unrealized capital losses that currently weigh on our solvency. Reducing the negative element produces an improvement in solvency, whereas when it was an unrealized capital gain, we would lose a portion of the intangible component within our solvency.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat’s really the sole factor behind the shift from a negative impact to a positive one.
Philippe Brassac
executiveLet me try to respond to that second question regarding retail banking. Allow me to restate the perspective we hold, which differs greatly from what you refer to as retail banking. You can either view it as a singular, standalone activity — retail banking — much the way one thinks of an insurance business or an asset management business, or you can view it as the way the group is organized, its structural organization. It is simply the foundation of the overall relationship with our customers, onto which we attach all the business lines that are able to grow their various activities. What that means is, in such a case, you cannot ask about retail banking in terms of development and then ask what about insurance, what about consumer finance, and so forth. We aim to keep things very simple and to regard retail banking as a single activity as something that does not exist. It cannot exist. The only thing that can exist and grow — and we have succeeded at it — is the global relationship built on a kind of proximity, increasingly remote proximity, but very often genuinely geographical proximity, in order to advise, to follow, and to accompany customers, households, small business, and large corporates across the broad range of their needs.
Philippe Brassac
executiveSo that's essentially the rule. Naturally, we need to provide you with the revenue breakdown, net income, and similar figures. To really grasp what you refer to as retail banking, you need to understand all the direct operations of banks on their balance sheet—loans and savings alike. You must include the revenues contributed by insurance activity, asset management activity, real estate solutions activity, and so forth. Once you're able to see that. In my view, the key criterion is how many new customers are acquired. I'm not certain we've provided you with the. We keep raising this figure annually. Over 1.5 million new customers in proximity banking within Crédit Agricole Group during 2022. That's.
Jérôme Grivet
executive1.9. That's 1.9.
Philippe Brassac
executive1.9. That figure has been climbing over the last four years. This is a rule. Naturally, we need to break down what makes up this activity. When you ask about retail banking, you have to take into account the universal bank's global model. That is quite different from certain banks that could arbitrate between a huge BFC, CIB activities, or simply insurance or simply retail banking. Here, it is only remote banking, with a few — a very low level of profitability, when there is any profitability at all. To answer your question, we remain confident, very confident about what you call retail banking, because we are confident about the development, and we do report on the development of the entire Crédit Agricole group, based on the global relationship with customers and territories.
Jérôme Grivet
executivePerhaps one final thing on that—it's quite specific—but what we call our retail banking operations within the CASA LCL scope isn't involved in any sort of major restructuring.
Philippe Brassac
executiveAll right, let's open it up to questions from those joining us on the phone.
Operator
operatorIf you’d like to ask a question, you can press star and one on your phone. Our first question comes from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies. Please go ahead.
Flora Bocahut
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for taking my questions. My first question concerns insurance revenues. I realize they can swing from quarter to quarter. I know you typically advise us to concentrate on net income, but this quarter both revenues and net income came in especially strong for that division. In the slide pack you noted write-backs on technical provisions, which you attribute to higher rates. My question is how much of this is sustainable rather than a one-off stock effect like the one we saw in Q4? Put another way, what run rate should we expect going forward for insurance, on revenues and/or net income? My second question returns to capital. You previously told us that on OCI reserves we would see a pull-to-par effect, which is reasonable given the substantial OCI losses during 2022. With the new IFRS-17 guidance, does that mean the pull-to-par effect will still occur? How large might it be on top of the 15 basis points positive from IFRS-17, please?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Flora — those are two solid questions. On the first one, about whether the insurance business's profitability level can be sustained: plainly, looking ahead, if commercial activity holds at the level it had not just in the prior year but across the past several years, then what we expect, even under the new accounting standard, is broadly the same earnings trajectory, perhaps with a bit more volatility. You know very well that this is somewhat odd, but that's how it operates. Where accounting and insurance activities are concerned, we typically begin at the bottom line and work our way up through the P&L. That means we have the ability to deliver the kind of bottom line tied to the activity level. We can also maneuver various elements within the top line. It so happens that this quarter, because rates rose, provisioning for certain long-term life risks — longevity risks — could be lower, so we could write back provisions. Naturally, we are able to offset the lack of such write-backs going forward through, say, our ability to pull additional financial margin out of the life insurance activities — something we have done before but did not do this quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveEvery one of these factors is something we actively manage so that the insurance operations can deliver an earnings path that is fairly predictable and steady. In my view, that is quite sustainable, provided, naturally, that on the commercial side we keep managing to grow both the outstanding volume and the policy count. Regarding the pull to par on OCI reserves, naturally, whatever gets folded into our solvency position on day one, January 1st, 2023, will no longer be there for the pull to par. I don't have the exact number at hand, but my sense is there would be roughly 50 basis points of negative solvency against our 11.2 level at the end of 2022, tied to the OCI reserves in the insurance activities. If on day one we take 15 basis points out of that, then the pull to par will only apply to what's left, namely 35 basis points.
Flora Bocahut
analystAlright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Flora.
Operator
operatorChris Hallam from Goldman Sachs is up next with a question. Go ahead, please. Mr. Hallam has taken his question back. Our next question comes from Pierre Chédeville of CIC. Please go ahead.
Pierre Chédeville
analystHi there. Are you able to hear me?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, Pierre.
Pierre Chédeville
analystGood afternoon. I have a question about consumer credit. One of your competitors mentioned margin pressure, and so did you. I'd like to know how you expect the cost income ratio to develop over the next few months, and whether you have a specific measure to offset this margin pressure, as some of your competitors tend to adopt. More broadly on costs, I was curious what your policy is on service centers abroad. Again, some of your competitors are building a large service center abroad, in India, for instance. Could you remind me of your setup for these kinds of organizations, and do you have any project in that regard? On insurance, I was curious about the impact of NatCat this year on your combined ratio, in terms of amount, if you give it, or in terms of basis points, the impact on basis points on your combined ratio. Have you raised your premiums to offset this effect for next year? Do you see some flexibility to improve your premiums? Thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure. I think the way I'd answer your various questions is to say that our focus is far more on continuous adaptation as a foundation than on major restructuring at particular points in time. That holds true for the cost base of the consumer credit business. For several quarters now, we've been fully aware that consumer credit activities will be somewhat more challenging, particularly in countries such as France, where the usury rate constrains the ability to raise customer rates. We continually adjust the setup, and we did the same at LCL previously with no large restructuring plan. In fact, LCL's staff count came down steadily over time, smoothly, without any trouble, and without needing to embark on a risky restructuring operation. Plainly, this ongoing adaptation effort will help us smooth developments at the consumer credit business entity. As one illustration, in 2022 the cost income ratio at CACF stands at roughly 50%, actually slightly below 50%, which we consider a very, very competitive level. We have service centers located abroad.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo we actually run two primary hubs outside our home market. One sits in Singapore, and that one is largely focused on CACIB, handling IT development as well as IT servicing work. The other is a multi-business site located in Portugal, and as I recall it covers some back-office functions plus IT operating activities — not development, but genuinely IT operating work serving various businesses across the group. Again, this isn't a choice we're about to make, and it's not one that would result in moving 1,000 people offshore. On a permanent basis, we review what we currently have and what would serve us best when it comes to distributing our staff and steadily raising the efficiency of our setups. In principle, I'd say we hold no position whatsoever against that kind of organization. It's just that this isn't a one-off policy we'd settle on at some particular point in time. Turning to insurance and NatCat, naturally the start of the year proved somewhat challenging for Pacifica, the group's P&C insurance company. In France we experienced a number of significant weather events that produced a heavy volume of claims across various policies. The combined ratio rose this year to 98% something percent.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveDuring Q4, it began to tick down somewhat. And naturally—once again—this reflects a continuous process of adjusting. We factored those weather occurrences, along with their associated costs, into how the pricing grid for our policies evolved for 2023, and we did so without any particular difficulty. The change is gradual, and there's no major shift in our stance. Okay?
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright, thanks — that all went smoothly.
Operator
operatorWe’ll take the next question from Matt Clark at Mediobanca. Matt, you have the floor.
Matthew Clark
analystGood afternoon, everyone. First question is about CACIB Risk-Weighted Assets. Could you explain just how you got them down so much in the 4th quarter? Or I guess the question is whether this is just normal seasonality and, you know, customer demand that caused them to decline? Or did you have to do work in order to get them to move down that much in just one quarter? Next question is on corporate center revenues. There are a couple of, I think, new items there that you highlighted that produced a negative impact this quarter. I think, some inter-group securities and then also an inflation effect on ALM. Maybe you could just help us understand whether these effects are going to recur in future quarters. Also whether we should be viewing them in combination with offsetting impacts elsewhere in the group or in other line items. Thanks very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right, I'll begin with the corporate center, since honestly that line wasn't great, and we didn't quite get your first question. Fine. The corporate center, as I explained I believe a few quarters back, is somewhere we must record certain Interco restatements. During this quarter, we had substantial Interco restatements tied to debt issued by CASA and subscribed either by Amundi vehicles or directly by Predica, the group's life insurance company, in order to assemble financial products — unit-linked products — that get sold to customers. And, uh, given that the booking and, and the accounting of those, uh, uh, debts differs between Casa as issuer and the various vehicles that, that buy those bonds as, uh, an investor or on behalf of investors, we get some, uh, difference, uh, differences, uh, uh, uh, that must be offset at the corporate center level. So depending on how rates and spreads evolve, credit spreads, we can get positive and negative elements, uh, which get booked in the corporate center. This quarter, this represents, uh, uh, a fairly significant amount of negative NBI, around EUR 150 million, if I remember correctly, the figure.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveUm, and so this, of course, is introducing some volatility — which is entirely non-cash, naturally — inside the corporate center. That will finish once IFRS 17 is implemented. Going forward, we won't have that volatility in the corporate center anymore. The second item — the first question was really about RWA evolution at CACIB. I'd say the answer is a mix of three things. First, we continually require every business division — CACIB included, along with the rest — to optimize and actively manage their RWAs so as to earn the best possible return on capital invested across the various businesses. Naturally, when CACIB takes steps to optimize RWA consumption, it sometimes comes in the form of operations that take a certain time to prepare. Then, once delivered and triggered, that produces a one-off, sizable RWA reduction. This was prepared starting in Q3, launched in Q4, and it contributed quite substantially to lowering the RWA level. The second item is all the market effects — forex and, to some degree, rates too — which have two benefits, had two benefits this quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe euro strengthening against the dollar has somewhat lowered the RWA valuation of assets denominated in dollars. Beyond that, counterparty risks tied to capital market activities have also gone down considerably, thanks to market movements during the quarter. And finally, we've observed better ratings for certain counterparties, and as you're aware, to some degree the ratings assigned to the various counterparties bring about a reduction in the RWA for those counterparties. In Q4, all of these factors work in the same direction, producing this very substantial drop in RWAs at CACIB.
Matthew Clark
analystCan I just ask a follow-up on the risk-weighted assets outlook? I believe you mentioned there were 10 basis points of TRIM remaining. Assuming nothing else is coming, and Basel IV should be neutral at inception for you as I understand it, is it fair for us to expect risk-weighted assets simply to increase in line with business volume going forward?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRight. The starting point will be the organic growth of RWAs allocated to the business line, which we handle each year during the budget process. This year, if I want to look ahead a bit at what could happen, beyond the organic RWA growth of the business lines, in 2023 we'll have this positive one-off stemming from IFRS 17. We'll have TRIM, which will probably account for EUR 4 billion of RWAs at CACIB. We'll also have one of the final years of the IFRS 9 phase-in mechanism, which is going to mean a hit of roughly 15 basis points — 10 to 15 basis points — on our solvency.
Matthew Clark
analystUnderstood.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBeyond that, growth will come mainly from organic evolution and, naturally, any acquisitions. One deal has already been settled and should wrap up around the start of Q3 — namely, the purchase of RBC's European operations.
Matthew Clark
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Amit Goel at Barclays. You have the floor.
Amit Goel
analystHello, thanks. I have two questions — one somewhat broad and one somewhat narrow. For the broader one, I suppose a competitor of yours intends to put a great deal of capital back to work in their operations, outside the retail segment, I believe. So I'm wondering how you view the growth prospects within your own business and what sorts of competitive pressure might arise over the next few years. The narrower one concerns the DPS. Given the catch-ups, as I understand it, the figure has stayed flat at EUR 1.05 for two years now. Could you potentially distribute above 50% next year so as to keep the DPS progressive? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll begin with the second question. DPS is, naturally, an ongoing matter. Right now, our focus is on 2022. We're discussing the dividend for 2022 that will be put to the general assembly we'll be holding next May. That dividend will be paid at the end of May this year. The year has barely gotten underway, and we'll consider the dividend for 2023 a bit further down the road, so to speak. As for growth opportunities, well, we're always scanning for them everywhere. What happens is that, more often than not, those opportunities arise either in certain, let's say, specialized business lines — such as asset management, consumer credit or car leasing, wealth management, which we've done several times before, and so forth. When it comes to retail banking activities, purely retail banking activities, those opportunities have mostly arisen abroad. That was the situation for us in Italy. Such is the landscape, but we are constantly on the lookout for growth opportunities that fit sensibly within our business model.
Amit Goel
analystThanks. Regarding the competitive landscape, if a number of your competitors are aiming to put a lot more capital back to work, do you see that shifting at all, or not really?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah, you know, when we talk about redeploying capital, it can sound a bit like we're acting as portfolio managers—trimming the money assigned to one business while boosting what goes to another, as though we were simply staring at an Excel spreadsheet. You know, putting some numbers into one cell and cutting the figure in another cell. That isn't quite how things work in real life. In real life, every business that belongs to CASA collaborates and also pursues its own opportunities. Whenever they spot a business opportunity, we talk it through. We actually have a dedicated committee, and Philippe chairs it. We look into any opportunity that comes from us, and we don't, you know, say upfront, "This business will get that amount of capital, and this business is expected to return that amount of capital.
Philippe Brassac
executiveMaybe I'd like to push back a bit on this question, because analysts and investors really need to grasp it. Questions about opportunities are normal, but I'd like to share this with you: when you look at it over the very long term, Crédit Agricole Group ranks among the 10 largest banks in the world. The critical size topic is absolutely not relevant for us. The only relevant point is finding opportunities—not just any opportunities, but relevant ones that can be integrated into our architecture in terms of development. Those are the three axes I explained at the very beginning of this meeting. That's probably why, year after year, we find different different opportunities. They always seem very incremental. No rapture about this, because we try to find something to go further quicker, for example, in consumer finance. Jérôme didn't say that in his answer a few minutes ago. I'd like to add this point. For consumer finance, the first point, the first colloid is that we are in a very important momentum of development. I can speak to you about the agreement with Stellantis, with Leasys for our leasing activity with Watèa, with Michelin, and so on.
Philippe Brassac
executiveI mean, there are lots of smaller subjects, but simply introducing incremental additions that fit completely with both the architecture and the strategy behind what we're building. That's the reason whenever I come across something described as an opportunity, my first move is to check whether it's the right size and the right nature to slot correctly and beforehand into what we're currently developing. Take Italy, for instance — Crédit Agricole Italia looks like it never changes, yet it grew every single time by adding new banks step by step, and by year-end it was still Crédit Agricole Italia. I mean, that, in my view, is the proper approach over the very long term when evaluating opportunities. Sadly, whether opportunities of that kind will appear isn't something we get to choose. If you go business line by business line, plenty of things can be examined. I genuinely believe this is the correct path, since making big bets right now on enormous, enormous ruptures in business or in companies is simply too risky. And again, Jérôme is completely correct. We don't run — and Crédit Agricole Group never managed to be run — as a conglomerate of separate activities. It was run truly around deploying the global relationship with every type of market.
Philippe Brassac
executiveWhether we're talking about households, small businesses, or large corporates, this growing and consistent approach to development is really always very successful.
Amit Goel
analystThanks.
Operator
operatorJust a quick reminder — if you'd like to sign up to ask a question, hit star and one on your phone. Coming up next we have Chris Hallam from Goldman Sachs. Go right ahead.
Chris Hallam
analystThanks for taking my questions, and sorry about the technical problems earlier — that was completely on me. I have two questions. The first one concerns the 2023 outlook. Philippe, you said RoTE is really the best metric to look at, and in your response to Delphine's question earlier you noted it's hard to separate retail banking from the broader group effort. My question is whether, given all the inputs this year, you would expect underlying RoTE in 2023 to be higher or lower than the 12.6% you reported in 2022. Second, on slide 8, you laid out the market shares across the universal banking model. Would you expect market share gains to come at a fairly even pace across those businesses? Or, if we fast-forward to 2025, would you expect the order of those bars to have changed significantly?
Philippe Brassac
executiveWell, we typically don't provide specific guidance on numbers for the upcoming year. As for your questions about where we'll stand and where we'll be in terms of return on tangible equity by the end of next year or this year — that's something we won't answer. Excuse me. What we definitely do say is that our target is to be above 12% of return on tangible equity. We'll do everything within our power to honor that target and that commitment. On page eight, and the point that we want to grow our market share in every additional business we've invested in since the group was launched — clearly, philosophically speaking, I'd say we should see each vertical bar on this bar chart progressively reaching the 30% level, because that's exactly what we want to achieve. Of course, that won't happen immediately in all businesses. Take life insurance activities as an example — the life insurance market in France isn't only in the hands of bank subsidiaries. That means a certain proportion of the market will probably be retained over the long run by pure insurance players.
Philippe Brassac
executiveAbsolutely, we have the capacity to ensure that each of our customers can be equipped across all these businesses through our own products rather than something made by a third party. Well, I'd like to emphasize this point. Take the history of Crédit Agricole Group, for instance: between 1987, when we chose to build an insurance business from scratch, hardly anyone could have predicted that within roughly 20 years we would become the top insurer in France. We did it. I mean, and no one could have imagined we would become the leading asset manager in Europe, the number one European asset manager built from scratch. We did it. Not simply because we are so effective at development, but because this demonstrates that when you seek to serve your customer through a comprehensive approach as banking clients, advising them loyally, with a holistic view of their needs, and supporting them over time, you get results of this kind. Bank insurance did not exist. Bankers like us managed to become bank insurers and the leading bank and the leading insurer. We always talk about bank insurance, but one could just as well say bank asset management, with exactly the same logic.
Philippe Brassac
executiveThere's no reason we couldn't turn into the first bank real estate solutioner, to give another example. I mean, this approach of addressing each customer's global needs, and now society's collective needs around transition, isn't some projection — it's simply a reminder that Crédit Agricole Group has genuinely grown through this path. For me, the target and the concern isn't to land at a particular level just because we're very big, very important, very large — because managing each business line, each silo of the group, that could truly be a huge mistake for the group's development. That's why I'll always re-explain the group's global figure and try to manage things so that all of us develop. Take a look at the group's commercial performance for 2022. It might be surprising to see that we're growing everywhere — not especially asset management or especially wealth management, everywhere. No miracle there. We try to develop as a rule, and we succeed, since we manage to have a global approach, once again, to our customers' needs. That's why we don't have special market shares, in terms of targets for 2023, 2024, for each business line, but clearly they all must improve.
Philippe Brassac
executiveIn recent years, they have consistently gained market share. Once again, apologies if this runs a bit long, but this isn't a strategy for growing diversified businesses the way a conglomerate would. It's a strategy for continually building out the same model — the model of the global relationship. Sadly, that model isn't widely understood, and it gets broken many times by analyses of the model's insiders and activities. That's the reason we explain this model. That's the reason Crédit Agricole S.A. is a group, and not merely a holding company of separate activities. We are simply trying to grow. Let me say I'm highly optimistic about this, because even with this very unusual environment and this high level of capacity, just look at our commercial momentum over the past three years. We expanded very fast. Not out of pride. Pride could, of course, be one explanation, but it's simply that the model works — when you take each of our customers in global approaches and offer them different services and products.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI believe we have time for a couple more questions.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have a question from Guillaume Tiberghien at BNP Paribas Exane. Please proceed.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for the question. It concerns French retail. I realize you're a diversified group with asset management and so on and so forth. In 2023, you've got Livret A, you've got the end of the TLTRO, and you've got the usual rewrite. Could you at least give us a sense of how big those headwinds are? From where I sit, I don't have the fine details, but it looks like roughly EUR 300 million to EUR 400 million of headwinds. Do you think that in 2024, without providing an exact figure, you can get to the revenue level you reached in 2022? Thank you.
Philippe Brassac
executiveLet me begin with the answer itself. Luckily, I have the benefit of being someone with a lot of experience — I personally went through the period when rates climbed to 20% 25 years ago, then fell to 0%, and are now returning to a higher level. In the end, we have always been number one in France, always. There is always this kind of question — it is very negative for you to have rates on a declining path, because of reimbursement, because of renegotiations. You get a negative impact because rates are rising. Of course, during the period when the asset side can be higher, to reach the level of the liability side, that will be something — it will have a negative impact on you. That is why — but my view is that, including within the group, I think, we do not really clearly explain the heart of the engine. The heart of the engine is intermediation and the transformation between liabilities and assets. I would simply like to say that when you look at the effects of rising rates, and notably because we protect households with fixed interest, the first point is that these negative impacts are temporary — temporary simply because, of course, in the end, once rates stabilize, the level of NII is the same.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNII.
Philippe Brassac
executiveYes. Regarding banks that have variable rates or fixed rates, that's the first thing. Second, asset-liability management tools partially soak up this effect. That's the reason we run ALM with a substantial volume of swaps, so we don't bear the full impact of the mismatch between assets and liabilities. That is exactly why ALM matters so much inside banks. Second, and finally, the remaining temporary negative effects of this phenomenon are probably largely offset by the fact that this is, at the end of the day, a way to keep the cost of risk under control, particularly for home loans. My conviction is that when confronted with this kind of new headwind, commercial development always holds the answer and the solution. I mean, if you look, for instance, at quarter four, at Q4 for LCL, you can see, for example, a negative effect on the intermediation margin, yet you can see an enormous rise in commissions and fees. Such is life. Nothing stays stable. At the end of the day, the key question is whether you remain number one when it comes to the overall relationship with your customer. Again, forgive me for saying that I have never encountered a stable rate environment.
Philippe Brassac
executiveI've been in the position of being asked whether falling rates could hurt us badly, and whether rising rates could hurt us badly. My answer is short and straightforward: for 2025, our commercial targets and our financial targets always leave us very optimistic. The rise in rates genuinely doesn't worry us. Customers may feel the concern, especially corporates, since corporates hold plenty of variable-rate loans. As for banks—and in particular a bank like Crédit Agricole Group—we simply go along with the shift. That's the color I can offer on the momentum of Crédit Agricole Group as an intervention bank. Jérôme, perhaps you can add more precision.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveJust a couple or three things to round out the answer a bit. First, TLTRO is obviously something that sits, I'd say, outside the bank's ordinary ALM management, since it was so enormous and so unusual in its features that, naturally, pulling the TLTRO back ahead of the date originally scheduled will be something working against us on the basis effect for 2023. That much is certain. The bright side is that no extra expense of unwinding hedges tied to the TLTRO has to be absorbed by us in 2023. I can't say for certain what other banks might have done on that front, but there are no added hedging costs for us to cover in 2023 when it comes to the TLTRO. Second, Philippe is entirely correct. Our model is built precisely to operate hand in hand with ALM policies so that rate movements can be absorbed. ALM exists exactly to smooth out the impact of rate moves. Naturally, 2022 was somewhat extreme. We pushed our models to their limits, particularly since when rates rise by 300 basis points, while at the same time repricing to the customer on new loans isn't possible, given such a large increase because of the usury rate, we sit at the boundary of ALM models.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt's the same situation with regulated savings accounts. Our ALM models incorporate the notion that we need to partially hedge against inflation risk. When inflation jumps all at once from nearly 0% to 6%, once again, that pushes ALM models to their limits. That's an impact we'll need to absorb. Certainly, over the long run going forward, we're able to operate in virtually any rate environment.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystMay I—
Philippe Brassac
executiveI have two questions. All right.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOf course, please continue.
Philippe Brassac
executiveYes.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystLet me try putting the question a different way, if that's all right. For French retail, your 2025 goal was roughly 1%-1.5% of growth each year, and in 2022 you've already gotten close to the entire growth trajectory. If you'd rather not discuss the J shape with us, could you perhaps restate your 2025 target for CACF's revenues?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs you're aware, Guillaume, our targets are never reset. We hit them, and then we go beyond them.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Benoit Valleaux at ODDO. You have the floor.
Benoît Valleaux
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for taking my question. I actually have two questions, if that's all right. The first concerns BforBank. A year ago, you mentioned plans to put money in so that BforBank could grow. I wonder whether you might be able to provide a bit more detail about what your strategy is for BforBank. My second question relates to life insurance in France. Clearly, we have observed a rise in outflows from your product during Q4. Could you perhaps tell us how the trend has looked since the start of the year to date — for instance, whether you have any figures for outflows in January? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, regarding BforBank, I believe the strategy we've presented as part of the medium-term plan is pretty straightforward. The thing is, we're doing a full overhaul of the IT platform. We're actually going to relaunch BforBank, I think before the end of the year or at the very start — in June. In June — Olivier, who's sitting in front of me, is confirming that date. Around the middle of this year, we'll be relaunching BforBank's new offering. It's only a few quarters after that relaunch that we'll be in a position to, let's say, gauge how effective it has been. We'll have chances to talk about that in a few quarters. On life insurance, it's true that in Q4, the outflows from euro-denominated contracts were more or less offset by inflows into UL products. What actually happened at the end of Q4, and what will likely carry on for part of this year, is that certain customers will opt to swap their euro products — even though we raised the profit-sharing rate quite substantially at the end of 2022 — for unit-linked products denominated in various categories of bonds that will probably deliver closer to 4% or 5% instead of the two point something that represents the remuneration on euro products.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere’s a chance we keep seeing that same kind of shift within the global contract — money leaving the euro component and coming into the UC component. UL component, sorry.
Benoît Valleaux
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorThe final question comes from Mate Nemes at UBS. Go right ahead.
Mate Nemes
analystGood afternoon. There are two remaining questions, and both concern costs. The first is about Italy. I believe you still incurred some one-off integration charges during this quarter. Can you confirm those are now entirely finished? If so, what kind of run rate should we anticipate moving forward? The second question also relates to costs, but at the group level. Could you provide some indication of what you expect for the cost trajectory in 2023? During 2022, you still had certain one-off items. Obviously, inflation is running at an elevated level. I am simply wondering how we ought to think about costs and cost growth in 2023. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOver in Italy, the integration of Creval into Crédit Agricole Italia is finished. The legal merger itself actually took place during the first half of last year. As for migrating Creval's operations onto the Crédit Agricole Italia platform, that is now complete. We don't have — and I can't recall having booked — any real restructuring charges, or almost none, during the last quarter, and it's fully wrapped up now. The operations that came over from Creval, because we keep raising the equipment rate among customers who joined us from Creval, and we keep strengthening the distribution capabilities of the branches in the former Creval network. Looking ahead, Italy will be a growth story — that's our hope. On the cost trajectory, in 2023, as you know, what we manage on a permanent basis is the cost-income ratio, not really the cost base itself. Our view — sorry — is that the cost base has to be adjusted continuously to our capacity to generate revenues. Naturally, we take, let's say, a more accommodative stance toward the cost base of, for instance, Crédit Agricole Assurances, where market share rises steadily and the count of policies under management keeps climbing, along with certain other businesses where, for various reasons, the ability to deliver a meaningful lift in the top line is weaker.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveObviously, we keep an eye on cost-income ratios, and we meet with the various businesses regularly to reassess whether they can hit the revenue level set during the budget process. If they can't get to that revenue level, then naturally we push them on whether they can adjust their cost base. We don't want to speak only in terms of a Group-wide cost trajectory, since that wouldn't make sense.
Mate Nemes
analystAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it. I believe that wraps us up. Once more, many thanks for joining this call. Of course, our thanks go to Philippe and Olivier. We look forward to seeing everyone in 3 months. Thanks very much. Thank you. Bye.
Operator
operatorThanks, everyone, for being with us. That brings the conference to a close. You can now hang up your phones. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.