Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 10, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone. I'm the conference operator. Thank you for being with us, and welcome to Crédit Agricole's First Quarter 2023 Results Conference Call. I'd like to remind everyone that this session is being held in listen-only mode. Following the presentation, you'll have a chance to ask questions by pressing star and one on your phone. If anyone requires help at any point during this call, they can reach an operator by pressing star and zero on their telephone. At this point, I'll hand the conference over to Mr. Jérôme Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Crédit Agricole S.A., responsible for steering and control. Sir, the floor is yours.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. I'm glad to be hosting this call, and it's a pleasure to present such strong results. I'll aim to keep my remarks fairly brief and quick so there's time left for your questions. As a reminder, of course, you're well aware that this quarter marks the first quarter of IFRS 17 implementation. To be very clear, every comparison we make, Q1 versus Q1, is done on a like-for-like basis — that is, all Q1 2022 figures have obviously been restated under IFRS 17. As for the remainder of the year, we will progressively publish the upcoming 2022 quarters under IFRS 17. Starting straight away on page four, just a few simple messages there. The first message: we are publishing very good, excellent results overall, with a first quarter that is a record for Crédit Agricole S.A. The second point: this quarter we clearly benefit from the diversification of our revenue sources and our businesses. The third point, also important to keep in mind: we have continued to maintain very strong discipline on the cost base, despite inflation in our environment.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe final item, naturally, is that beyond what I'd call running the business day to day, we've kept working on structural operations aimed at further strengthening our capacity to generate revenue down the road, and we'll get a chance to talk a bit about those operations. On page five, you'll find CASA's key figures. As you can see, stated net income stands above EUR 1.2 billion. In fact, that's a doubling versus Q1 2022, restated once more under IFRS 17. Revenues have risen sharply, +10.5%, Q1 compared with Q1. That holds even though last year we enjoyed roughly EUR 100 million of TLTRO benefits, which are gone in this quarter. The cost base is up just 2.5%. This clearly gains from the lower contribution we make to the Single Resolution Fund. We also see a very moderate change in the operational cost base. Cost of risk has fallen sharply, -31%. Naturally, in Q1 22 we booked significant one-off provisions tied to the Russian invasion of Ukraine; even so, this cost remains quite benign. Finally, underlying net income is likewise a touch above EUR 1.2 billion, up 61%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOver on the right side of this page, the cost income ratio is shown, and excluding the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund, it comes in at 54%. Solvency: the CT1 ratio at CASA stands at 11.6%, helped by the transition to IFRS 17. Return on tangible equity is roughly 14.5%, which is also a very high level. I'll move now to page 6 for the figures on Crédit Agricole Group globally: net profit is also higher, +23.6% Q1 on Q1, at around EUR 1.7 billion. Revenues are up roughly 2% on an underlying basis. The cost base is up only 0.9%, also helped by a reduction in the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund. Gross of 13 income is slightly higher, +3.6%. Cost of risk is down for the same reason, -21%. Underlying net profit, +12.5%, close to EUR 1.7 billion. For the group globally, the cost income ratio sits at 59%, and the CT1 ratio at 17.6%, stable as compared to end of 2022. On page eight, there are some elements regarding the activity and the commercial momentum we've had this quarter, which was very good. Just a few highlights. The first element: customer capture is dynamic, +555,000 new customers in our different retail banks in France and the rest of Europe.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe keep raising the share of equipment our customers hold with in-house offerings, PNC insurance policies in particular. As for new loan production, consumer credits have been lively, retail banking for professional and SME loans has been lively, home loans less so, yet even so, new loan production at LCL, the Regional Bank of Crédit Agricole, and Crédit Agricole Italia stayed ahead of the overall trend in their markets. On page nine, there are a few points on the new structural operations that were either concluded or closed during this quarter. The first operation — one we've talked about a great deal for probably one year now — is finished and went live in the second quarter. It is the reworking of our agreements with Stellantis and the new joint venture formed between Crédit Agricole Consumer Finance and Stellantis leases, set to become one of the leaders in long-term car rental in Europe. It was completed through the acquisition of certain activities from ALD and LeasePlan in Portugal and Luxembourg. At the same time, we are acquiring 100% of the capital of Crédit Agricole Auto Bank, formerly known as FCA Bank, and Drivalia.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis entity will also gain 70,000 additional cars from the acquisition involving ALD and LeasePlan across Ireland, Norway, the Czech Republic, and Finland. Turning to payments, we recently finalized an agreement with Worldline to establish a leading force in French payment services. We're effectively merging the strengths of Crédit Agricole, the French leader in acquisition, with Worldline, the French leader in acceptance. Our aim is for merchant payment services growth in France to reach double the market's pace. Regarding real estate, Crédit Agricole Immobilier has purchased Sudeco, a property management firm, which strengthens Crédit Agricole Immobilier's ability to offer property management services across various customer segments. Looking at page 10 and this quarter's revenue generation, you'll notice that no matter how you examine the revenues, the growth is quite steep. On a stated basis, it's +9.5%. Underlying, it's +10.5%. Finally, if we adjust those numbers to reflect that we no longer benefit from TLTRO, growth becomes even steeper at +12.5%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe second interesting point is that this strong revenue generation can be seen across three of our four main business divisions. That holds true in the asset gathering division, where the modest decline in revenues at Amundi, driven by a lower level of performance fees, is more than offset by the solid revenue level in the insurance activities. It also holds true in the large customers business division, where both CACEIS and CACIB are performing very well. And it holds true in the retail banking business division, where the pressure on net interest income at LCL is more than offset by the momentum we are seeing in Italia, in Poland, and in Egypt. As for the specialized financial services division, we have a more or less stable level of revenues, which reflects the combination of good business development with, again, a significant rise in the production of new loans at CACF. Nevertheless, margins — production margins — continue to be a little bit under pressure, even though they have started to improve this quarter compared with Q4 last year. All in all, the increase in the top line is very strong, and this is, I would say, a feature that we continue to post, since at least six years in a row.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning to page 11 now and the cost base: what's visible there is a positive JAWS effect — however you choose to view it, whether on an underlying basis or a stated one — since our operational cost base is up 6.2%-6.9%, depending on the figure you pick. Beyond that, in the asset gathering business division within SFS and in the retail banking activities, the cost base is roughly flat. It isn't solely in the large customers business division — where revenue growth has been the most dynamic — that we're seeing a meaningful rise in the cost base. Of that cost base increase, in fact, over half consists of a provision for future and potential variable compensation, which of course depends on how the remainder of the year performs. Even so, a very positive JAWS effect overall, and a positive JAWS effect in most of our business lines as well. Moving to page 12, we can see that we post, as I mentioned, a significant drop in the cost-to-income ratio, which now stands at 54.1%. When we published the Medium Term Plan back in June 2023, we said that thanks to IFRS 17, we would bring our cost income target down to 59%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe mechanical impact of moving to IFRS 17 is actually larger than we had anticipated. Our target is being restated once more: the medium-term plan target for the cost-income ratio after IFRS 17 now stands at 58%. As we can see, we are already well below that target. On page 13, there are some points about the cost of risk. The cost of risk, as I mentioned, is markedly lower than in Q1 2022: -31% on the CASA perimeter and -21% for the group as a whole. A second point worth noting this quarter is that, naturally, within this cost of risk, the portion coming from coverage of incurred risks is rising. Even so, we booked EUR 75 million of S1 and S2 provisions this quarter. Perhaps the final point is that this quarter the cost of incurred risk, at EUR 284 million for CASA and EUR 464 million for the group globally, is under the average we had in 2019, that is, prior to the COVID crisis. We can see the cost of risk in basis points relative to outstandings at 28 or 30 basis points for CASA and 23 or 19 basis points for the group, depending on whether we view it on a four rolling quarters basis or on an analyzed annualization of Q1 this year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThese levels sit under the assumptions we set for the Medium Term Plan, taken across the cycle, I would call them assumptions. Cost of risk worldwide remains moderate. On net profit, what you see is the outcome of that steep revenue rise, solid management of the cost base, and a lower cost of risk, and together these are driving a big jump in net profit, +61% on an underlying basis and more than a doubling on a stated basis for CASA. This is coming from nearly, once more, every business line. Asset gathering, large customers, and retail banking each add meaningfully to that increase. Another interesting point is that this increase combines a substantial gain in gross operating income. Naturally, we have that reduction in the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund. We also see a notable drop in the cost of risk. Naturally, corporate tax is higher, and the bits and pieces are a bit less profitable, EUR 56 million, than in Q1 2022. Taken altogether, that is a rise in net profit of EUR 655 million. Moving now to page 15, a few elements on the group's overall strength and the group's CTE1 ratio.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe ratio held steady at 17.6% for the quarter. That reflects a positive IFRS-17 impact of +10 basis points, largely cancelled out by the continued phasing in of IFRS-9, which subtracted 13 basis points. Retained earnings are at a solid level across the group's perimeter, and we've seen a meaningful rise in RWA consumption in the business line, particularly at the regional banks of Crédit Agricole. Taking everything together, our distance to CEPT stands at 870 basis points, which remains best-in-class among European GC — clear evidence of a very strong capital position for the group. Turning to CASA, this quarter we recorded a sharp rise in the CTE1 ratio at CASA, reaching 11.6%. That's an increase of 40 basis points. The IFRS 17 transition delivers a very substantial boost, +32 basis points. Our guidance had been for an improvement of at least 15 basis points. In fact, thanks to the fine-tuning done since that guidance three months ago, we've managed to enhance this first-time application effect of IFRS 17 even further. Beyond that, retained earnings produce a net gain of 15 basis points, even though we've already provisioned EUR 0.18 per share for the future dividend.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRemoving IFRS 9 costs 10 basis points. The remaining items are essentially flat. For the business lines this quarter, we've stayed extremely restrained when it comes to RWA movement. Moving to liquidity, we begin on page 17 with a handful of points about our deposit base. As you can observe, across one year — from end March 2022 to end March 2023 — the customer deposit base has held steady. That customer deposit base consists of two-thirds of deposits originating from households plus SMEs and self-employed professionals. Indeed, among our various retail banks throughout Europe, we serve 37 million retail banking customers, so the deposit base is highly granular. We also have 21% of our deposit base arriving from corporate, 10% arriving from financial institutions, and 2% arriving from sovereign and public sector institutions. One final point perhaps on this page: close to EUR 600 billion of our customer deposits are covered by one of the various guarantee schemes that exist in the countries where we operate. On page 18, there's an update on where our liquidity reserve stands. A slight decrease occurred between the end of December last year and the end of March this year — entirely non-significant. It stems mainly from the fact that we've begun to amortize certain real estate claims that remain eligible at the central bank through the end of June this year, but they will not be renewed after June.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe have not replenished reserves within this category of eligible claims. Even so, LCR ratios remain at a very elevated level, for both the Group and CASA, and both on the basis of the last 12 months and in terms of figures at end of March this year. Our surplus stands far above EUR 100 billion. The stable resources position remains very significantly positive at EUR 217 billion, and significantly within our monitoring target of EUR 110 billion-EUR 130 billion, restated from the future repayment of TLTRO. I will end this presentation with some update on the asset quality of our balance sheet. First, on page 19, what you can see is that the level of non-performing loans remains very, very low. It is at 2.7% for CASA, stable versus end of last year. 1.7% for the regional bank, slightly up 4.1 percentage point as compared to end of last year. Globally, 2.1% for the group, which is again, stable. Group, globally, EUR 20 billion of provisions. This represents 83.4% of coverage ratio, which is a very, very high level, a little bit up as compared to end of last year. What you can see is that those very high coverage ratios compare very well with the rest of our peers.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen it comes to this area, Crédit Agricole Group is certainly among the front-runners among European banks, and at CASA too, with 71%, we sit in the upper tier of the peer sample we track. This clearly goes hand in hand with a loan book that is very diversified as well as very secured, at both the group level and the CASA level. I'll bring this presentation to a close now. Right after that, we have all the usual pages, business line by business line, and we can certainly turn to them if needed so that we can answer your questions properly.
Operator
operatorThanks very much, sir. We’re ready to start the question-and-answer portion now. If you’d like to ask something, press star and one on your touchtone phone. Should you want to be taken out of the question queue, press star and two. When you ask your question, please lift the receiver. Our first question is from Tarek El-Majjah at Bank of America.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystHello there. Good afternoon, everyone. I have two questions, if I may. First, regarding JAWS. Your Medium Term Plan guidance called for half a percentage point of JAWS and a cost-income ratio of 60, which now stands at 58%. You have exceeded the JAWS guidance several quarters running, with some ups and downs of course, but the direction leans toward further improvement. Could you perhaps indicate where you expect JAWS to go from here? Particularly regarding the drive for 17, where do you see it? Do you reaffirm the half point, or do you see upside beyond that? My second question concerns capital and dividend. I am glad this is no longer a topic that worries the market. I believe you generate more capital than you are able to distribute, and you adhere to 50% payouts. Do you think a pleasant surprise could come at year-end, where you deliver at least a flat DPS, offsetting and compensating for the EUR 0.20 paid last year for the 2019 skipped dividend? Perhaps just one more question about the Single Resolution Fund contribution. I understand this is something that will vanish at the end of the year; how do you explain the decline in SRF?
Tarik El Mejjad
analystIs that similar to what your competitor described last week regarding the revised rules, or the proportion you're allowed to place on versus off the balance sheet with respect to the SRF? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Tarik. On the first item, the JOES, yes — we're ahead of schedule when it comes to delivering this positive JOES effect. We won't be restating our target just one quarter into the MTP; you know how keen we've been on trying to beat our target — whether that's the cost income target, the JOES target, or the net profit target across the last two medium term plans. Rest assured we will do everything we can in order to beat our targets. Please don't ask us each quarter to restate the target, because we'll never be done restating targets. Second point on dividend: what I've already said on this front is that, first, we have an official payout policy, which is 50% of the distributable profit. Second point, yes, we are generating some capital thanks to the good efficiency of our activity, the good level of return on equity that we generate, and so on and so forth. We have always been shareholder friendly, and there is a perfect alignment of interest between our majority shareholder and the market on this front. Of course, at the end of Q1, it's far and away too early to discuss this issue.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe still haven't validated and distributed the 2022 dividends at the general assembly meeting. So please give us a bit of time before we discuss the 2023 dividend. As I said, our track record has been investor friendly. On the Single Resolution Fund, the decrease comes from a combination of two elements, but the first one matters most. Deposits in Europe have gone down — or rather, the deposit base is evolving much less dynamically than the Single Resolution Board anticipated 1 year ago. At this point they are somewhat ahead of schedule when it comes to collecting the final contribution needed to hit this 1% target. That is the reason the total amount to be raised is lower. On top of that, it's true we have the option of slightly increasing the share of this contribution that we can pay in the form of a payment commitment. The biggest factor is the reduction in the overall target for the size of the fund.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystThanks, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies.
Flora Bocahut
analystYes, thank you. Good afternoon, Jérôme. My first question concerns the insurance business, since when I look at the Q4 performance under IFRS 4 and now at Q1 under IFRS 17, in both cases the revenue and the net profit run rate are much stronger than what we were used to seeing over previous quarters. What I really want to know is whether that performance is sustainable. Specifically, this quarter, with the accounting change, was there anything tied to the first-time application of IFRS 17 that affected the P&L? Not capital here, but really the P&L for insurance specifically? Should we treat the P&L run rate you just reported for Q1 as normal and something that can recur? My second question is broader and concerns the structure of capital within the group. About a month ago, the regional banks announced that they have finished buying Crédit Agricole S.A. shares on the market. I believe they now own 60% of Crédit Agricole S.A. versus 57% before. They could go up to 65%. At the end of the day, the main reason for CASA to be listed is around M&A.
Flora Bocahut
analystSo I guess the main thing I'd ask is how you're thinking about M&A. Is that still on your radar as something you'd pursue that might come together near term? And what kinds of things might catch your interest? Anything you can share to expand on the M&A picture would be useful. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks, Flora, for those questions. Regarding insurance, I'll do my best to be clear even though IFRS 17 represents a pretty radical shift in how we recognize revenues and profit in the insurance business division. To put it plainly, the revenue level in EUR in Q1 23 has nothing to do with one-offs tied to the transition to IFRS 17. That revenue level is exactly what it should be when you first consider the production of new policies and the amount we've brought in as new inflows this quarter in insurance, in life insurance activities. Second, market conditions, because as you know the IFRS 17 mechanism establishes a link between market conditions and how much profit we can recognize in a given quarter. None of that has anything to do with one-offs connected to the IFRS 17 transition. What might be connected to the transition is the fact that comparing revenue levels in Q1 2023 against Q1 2022 — with Q1 2022 restated under IFRS 17 — is probably somewhat, or partly, artificial, simply because we actually applied the IFRS 17 accounting standard to a quarter, Q1 2022, that had been managed under IFRS 4, meaning all the decisions we made at the end of Q of 2022 to de-sensibilize the asset portfolio so as to better accommodate IFRS 17 were not applied in Q1 2022, by definition, since we took them at the end of 2022.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLooking at how the revenue base moved from Q1 2022 to Q1 2023, the transition probably gave it a partial boost. As for judging what revenue level we saw in Q1 2023, that has nothing specifically to do with the transition. Looking ahead, the factors that will affect the revenue level we acknowledge and recognize under IFRS 17, particularly in life insurance activities, will come down to two things. The first is new contract production that can generate future profits, and the second is market conditions, which will affect the effective value of all the portfolios on our balance sheet. As it happens, in Q1 2023, new contract production was dynamic, meaning we were able to keep growing the base of future profits. Second, market conditions were good, and that also worked in favor of revenue recognition this quarter. Obviously, under the same conditions of pressure and temperature, we should, going forward, recognize roughly the same revenue level. Turning now to the group's capital structure. It's true that the regional banks currently own 60% of CASA's capital, and they have said they could go up to 65%, in what I'd call an opportunistic mode, if they believe the conditions are met.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, we're entirely at ease with the regional banks holding a stake at this level. And honestly, I must say, we have nothing to comment on regarding it. That call comes from the majority shareholder. When you claim that M&A is the sole rationale for CASA's listing, that isn't quite accurate, since if you look at the group's solvency on a global basis, a meaningful portion of it comes from CASA's minority shareholders. Obviously, CASA gains plenty of advantages from being listed — not merely this hypothetical chance to pursue M&A via a listed vehicle. It's neither required nor a precondition.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright, that's very clear. Thanks, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorMoving on, we have a question from Pierre Chédeville at CIC.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes. Good afternoon, Jérôme. Going back to insurance — perhaps I missed it among the slides, but I did not see the CSM figure. Could you remind us whether anything has changed when it comes to amortizing that CSM? That might follow on from a question Flora Bocahut asked. On consumer credit, you spoke of strong production. Comparing with peers, I wonder whether later in the year you might see production fall because of a more cautious stance given the macro economy. My last question concerns your business in Europe outside Italy. We have observed a sizable margin improvement. When you actually look at the numbers, and at bottom line numbers, the contribution is quite small — under EUR 20 million. Profitability below 7%, or thereabouts. I was wondering what levers you see for improving that, and how you expect this part of your business to evolve. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI'll begin with insurance. We haven't said what the CSM amount is, though on a worldwide basis, the rough order of magnitude is likely in the neighborhood of EUR 20 billion.
Pierre Chédeville
analystApologies. Why aren't you making it public? Since it's a matter that is.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIFRS 17.
Pierre Chédeville
analystUnder IFRS 17, that's a crucial piece of information, I guess.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, I agree. IFRS 17 is a new thing. Like everyone, we're learning how to communicate about IFRS 17 — which metrics really matter when it comes to assessing the business. In the end, the 2022 year-end figures under IFRS 17 haven't been audited yet. That will happen at the end of June, so at that point we'll be in a position to give more detail. What I can say, though, is that the CSM's order of magnitude sits at roughly EUR 20 billion. The second point, and it matters, is that CSM at the end of Q1 '23 exceeds CSM at the start of Q1 '23 — in other words, through developing the business we generated more CSM that still has to be recognized down the road than what we actually recognized this quarter, which is clearly a sign the business is growing and developing. In consumer credit.
Pierre Chédeville
analystMy apologies — that was the amortization and the duration.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAs for CSM.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe amortization runs at approximately 10% per year, I'd say. That figure can shift over time, since it hinges on market conditions and a number of parameters. Broadly speaking, this is the order of magnitude we keep in mind for the duration of this CSM. Turning to consumer credit, will we see a decline in new loan production going forward? We'll see. What's certain is that, with the expansion of the leasing business — car leasing — and with all the initiatives we've launched lately in this consumer credit entity, I believe we have every capacity to keep growing our activities dynamically. Naturally, should a recession hit Europe over the coming quarters, this business will slow down, but that isn't the base case we have in mind. One last point on the retail banks abroad, outside Italy: it's true the figures are small, and far smaller than Italy on its own, but I don't quite see where your return on equity figure comes from, because what I have in mind is that the return on equity sits well above the cost of equity for this business.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIts return level is quite relative when you set it against the rest of the group and against the overall 12% target we have for CASA.
Pierre Chédeville
analystWhen you look at building out this business—especially in Poland—do you feel there's still space to grow it organically?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo, actually, we don’t look at it as one global business — we see three separate entities, each with its own characteristics. There’s Egypt, where return on equity is very high. Very high. It’s sometimes generally above the cost-income ratio, which is an interesting feature. It’s a very profitable business. Then there’s Ukraine, where of course, for the time being, the situation isn’t very simple, but even so, it isn’t a loss-making business nowadays. And there’s Poland, where we’re trying to build the same kind of setup that we have in Italy, for example. All the business lines are present there. We have a very important challenge, which is developing our customer base. For the time being, we’re a second-tier or third-tier player in Poland, but our goal is to increase the number of customers significantly — +60% over the Medium Term Plan. We’re on track, because I don’t have the precise figure in mind, but we’ve kept attracting a significant number of new customers. I think it’s close to 100,000 new customers in Q1 this year, which definitely illustrates the fact that we’re on track.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright, thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorDelphine Lee from J.P. Morgan has the next question, sir.
Delphine Lee
analystYes. Good afternoon, Jérôme. May I briefly revisit insurance and what IFRS 17 has done? I suppose grasping the actual effect may not be simple, but if you could put some numbers on it — taking what it did to the insurance division and the corporate center, on both revenues and costs — could we annualize that, or do you feel it isn't relevant, and that we should simply use the run rate observed so far in Q1 for revenues and costs? This is just to get a sense of how to forecast that division. My second question concerns French retail. Revenues are down 5%. Do you anticipate additional NII pressure over the next quarters, or would you describe the current level as the run rate — and even if Livret A goes up in August, could that be offset through other items so the negative effect is managed? The final, really quick question is on capital. I believe your earlier guidance pointed to 10 basis points of TRIM. Is that still expected, or not really? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, Delphine. Regarding insurance activities, naturally I'll leave it to you to form your own views on what constitutes a relevant run rate for our revenues and our cost base. What I can tell you is this, first: the revenue level we report for Crédit Agricole Assurances in Q1 '23 contains no one-off item tied to the IFRS 17 transition. It was clearly a strong quarter for Crédit Agricole Assurances — strong commercially, with a significant volume of inflows, and inflows of good quality since they came mostly from unit-linked products in the life insurance business. A strong quarter as well for net premium income in the PNC and protection businesses, and strong too on the technical side in PNC, where the combined ratio came down relative to its level one year earlier. Overall, a strong quarter for Crédit Agricole Assurances' activity, and a strong quarter in market terms as well. Once again, that now matters a great deal when you're assessing revenues at Crédit Agricole Assurances. The level we post this quarter has nothing to do with one-offs. On the cost base, obviously it's far harder to judge what it ought to be, because as you know that cost base has probably been divided by three relative to last year's figure, given the IFRS 17 transition.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveA portion of the cost base is directly hitting revenues, and that offsetting within the cost base makes it probably harder to judge what a good run rate for the cost base actually is. Maybe just an illustration showing that we remain very cautious about the cost base of the insurance activities is the fact that when it comes to budgeting the cost base of the insurance activities, of course, we will keep looking at the global cost base and not only at the cost base that is recognized under the cost line. LCL — well, you've said it yourself, we are, we don't know exactly how far rates are going to rise, we don't know exactly whether it be the rate for regulated savings accounts or the rate, market rate. We have to expect the end of the normalization of monetary policy to fully assess what the run rate of net interest income at LCL is under a stabilized rate environment. Which is not the case now, but which is probably going to happen in the middle of the year. When we talked about globally 2023 for LCL, what we had in mind was that the Livret A effect on LCL revenues could be around EUR 200 million of deflation of the top line between 2022 and 2023, with the assumption that the Livret A was going to bear, in average for 2023, a 3.5% rate, which is compatible, I would say, with a further increase next August.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOnce more, we need to determine precisely when rates settle before we can claim that a run rate at LCL has been achieved. Regarding the capital headwinds facing us, there are 2 elements we can point to in addition to everything tied to M&A transactions. As you know, we will complete the purchase of RBC European activities at the start of the third quarter of this year. On the regulatory headwinds side, there are 2 elements: TRIM, which will account for the final slice of what I believe is EUR 4 billion of RWA this year, and the last stages of the IFRS 9 phase-out, which will be 5 basis points in 2024 and another 5 basis points in 2025.
Gulnara Saitkulova
analystI really appreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Gulnara Saitkulova at Morgan Stanley.
Gulnara Saitkulova
analystGood afternoon, Gulnara from Morgan Stanley here. Thanks for taking my question. My first one concerns asset quality. We've observed quite a benign cost-of-risk trend so far, and right now you're sitting below pre-COVID levels. How do you see cost of risk developing over the next few quarters? Do you think it will stay resilient through the second half of this year, or should we anticipate some meaningful deterioration? Which portions of the books are you watching most closely? A second question follows up on M&A, since you've recently disposed of some assets — in Morocco, Romania and Serbia, for instance. Do you believe there could be more to come as you simplify your business perimeter? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. On asset quality, to give you the most precise picture of what we're seeing today: there are some minor indications of weakening, and those actually account for most of this quarter's rise in cost of risk, across two areas. The first is consumer credit. We mentioned this back in Q4 last year, and we're saying it again now. CACF has in fact already put measures in place to tighten lending criteria, so as to temper any further potential rise in cost of risk. This is a fully identified area, and we know we have the tools to contain the situation should that be needed. The second area where we're seeing some minor indications of weakening in cost of risk concerns retail activities — mainly regional banks and, only marginally, LCL in France. It relates to self-employed professionals or very small SMEs, particularly new SMEs whose business models haven't yet been tested under current economic conditions. Those portfolios account for no significant volume of loans at LCL and CASA, but we are watching the situation closely. As for the other loan categories, particularly the large ones — above all the corporate loans at CACIB and the home loans across the group — we see no indication of deterioration whatsoever, and we continue to observe very, very good asset quality and a very benign risk environment.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the M&A and disposal front — or potential disposal — there’s no specific project we have. We aren’t working on any disposal at all, and we believe the current perimeter of activities — the ones we now have and now steer — is perfectly coherent and perfectly satisfying. No specific project going forward.
Gulnara Saitkulova
analystThat’s very clear. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorMoving on, we have a question from Jon Peace at Credit Suisse.
Jon Peace
analystThank you. Hello, Jérôme. This quarter is a good one for Clotilde to depart on. I have just a single question regarding revenues, if I may. You clearly spent a fair amount of time discussing the outperformance in insurance, yet international retail also delivered a notably strong beat, as did large customers. I realize FIC can be rather volatile, but are there any elements you would flag as unsustainable? Do you view that 3.5% CAGR you have in your 2025 plan for revenues as potentially rather conservative? My second question, please, concerns Russia. I believe the balance declined somewhat. My guess is it will likely speed up as the year progresses, but it remains a fairly sizable figure. Do you expect any additional provisioning will be needed? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Well, once again, on medium-term targets, we're always conservative—that's certainly true. It could be a default setting, but it is definitely in our DNA. We won't be updating or raising our revenue target. When we look across the board at the various revenues we've posted this quarter in particular, there's of course going to be some volatility at CACIB, particularly in the fixed income business. What we firmly believe is that CACIB is gradually strengthening its standing, I'd say, in the market—strengthening its positioning with its major clients and strengthening its teams' capabilities. The actual revenue level going forward will definitely hinge on our customers' appetite to take on new operations. If they do want to grow their business, Castille is going to be increasingly one of the preferred providers for those clients. I think this is broadly creating a new normal revenue level for Castille. In the other businesses, well, we've been growing the balance sheet. We've been growing the loan portfolio, particularly at CACF, and we plan to keep growing those portfolios. That should indeed support revenue development going forward.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, we're comfortable with the 3.5 CAGR revenue level going forward, and if we can beat that target, we're happy to do so. On Russia, there's a slide page giving some details about the Russian exposure. I'm going directly to page 47 myself. We're now at EUR 2.7 billion of exposure at the end of March, and it's actually EUR 2.4 billion at the end of April. It keeps decreasing quite smoothly without additional costs. As we see it now, there's absolutely no reason why we should increase the provision level. Actually, since we don't consume those provisions, and since the total amount is progressively reducing, the coverage ratio keeps increasing permanently. No, no worry on this front. Of course, we continue to monitor the situation closely. We take advantage of every opportunity to accelerate the exit if possible, but for the time being, no need for additional provision and nothing is foreseen on this front.
Jon Peace
analystThank you very much — that's great.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorStefan Stalmann from Autonomous Research has the next question.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMm-hmm. Hi there, Stefan.
Stefan Stalmann
analystHi, Jérôme. Are you able to hear me?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah, absolutely.
Stefan Stalmann
analystPerfect, and thanks for the question. I appreciate the extra detail you provided on deposits. On that topic, I have two things I'd like to ask. First, the sole deposit category showing a meaningful decline versus a year ago is the one with financial institutions, and that's down by a double-digit amount. I'm curious whether there's a specific factor worth pointing to that accounts for this drop. Conversely, regulated deposits clearly rose substantially, up 17% year-on-year. That isn't surprising. If you had to estimate, how much of that gain stems from clients moving deposits — other deposits — into regulated deposits, and how much instead originates from off-balance sheet savings, perhaps insurance contracts? Tied to that, assuming rates stay put — ECB rates especially — if they hold at current levels, do you expect regulated deposits to grow another leg up, or has this trend mostly played out by now, given where rates stand today?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMm-hmm.
Stefan Stalmann
analystThanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, those are fair questions, Stefan. Being very precise is hard, since we'd obviously need to examine how each of our 37 million customers behaves, and that's difficult. That said, on deposits originating with financial institutions—and the same holds for sizable customer deposits—the driver is plainly pricing, both on our clients' side and on ours. What that means is we can always transmit price signals so as to draw in or temper deposits from those two client categories. This is something we do, and I'd call it part of the ongoing monitoring of the group's liquidity position. There is a committee—I sit on it myself—that meets every two months and deals specifically with these matters, so as to fine-tune how we track our liquidity position. This is entirely natural, and it is genuinely handled in a completely different manner from the 67% of our deposits that originate with individuals and SMEs, where things are of course far more granular. Rates do matter, but it is definitely a far more granular deposit base, and its behavior differs. As for inflows into regulated savings accounts, my sense is that most of the inflows we have observed actually originated in sight deposits.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe haven't observed shifts from off-balance sheet savings into Livret A or Livret de Développement Durable, since off-balance sheet is mainly life insurance. As things stand right now, the profit-sharing rate on euro-denominated contracts in life insurance activities remains under the 3% rate offered on a Livret A. Taking money out of a life insurance policy and placing it on a Livret A is a rather complicated operation. Most of the inflows we've seen into the Livret A and other regulated savings accounts came from sight deposits, which is entirely natural. Looking ahead, the future evolution of amounts deposited on Livret A will of course partly hinge on the level of rates, but it will also be affected by the ceilings that apply to these regulated savings accounts. There is a ceiling of EUR 20 thousand or EUR 22 thousand for a Livret A, and once that level has been reached, putting in additional money isn't possible. What we think and what we observe is that more and more, all the households with sufficient liquid savings, with sufficient cash, have progressively saturated their Livret A and other Livret de Développement Durable.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHigher rates will mean a cost on our side, will work in their favor, and won't automatically become a huge driver of additional shifting between sight deposits and regulated savings accounts.
Stefan Stalmann
analystOh, that really helps a lot. Thanks so much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorAmit Goel from Barclays has the next question.
Amit Goel
analystThanks. I have two — well, actually one that's more of a follow-up. I understand you'd rather not be pushed too hard on the targets as such. I just want to get a sense of the revenue trajectory, since it was clearly very strong this quarter. Are you thinking — if I subtracted the 3.5% from the original 2021 revenue base, I came out at roughly EUR 26 billion in revenues. With IFRS 17, there may be some rebasing. Do you still expect to hit a similar figure, or better? Second, cost control has again been strong, I appreciate that, but if you can bring in somewhat more revenue, would you want to put a bit more investment into the business, or would you keep running at the same kind of cost run rates? Just one small extra question on consumer credit revenues — I want to be sure I understood the remarks about a contraction in product margins in 2022 weighing on the year-on-year comparison. Is that contraction now over, or is it still going on at present? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. Let's begin with revenues. That 3.5% CAGR year-on-year across the Medium Term Plan accounted for lower revenues stemming from what we call attributable expenses, which now hit the top line directly within the insurance activities. It did not factor in the restatement of what we call the internal margin — a matter that remained unresolved and still being discussed at the time we released the Medium Term Plan, and which brings a further reduction effect on both the cost line and the top line simultaneously. As you have observed, the first effect, the one inside Crédit Agricole Assurances, accounted for 1 percentage point on the cost income ratio. The second one, the internal margin restatement, adds another 1 percentage point on the cost income ratio. That means, in terms of revenue evolution under IFRS 17, the impact has doubled relative to what we anticipated when the medium-term plan was published. So hitting that 3.5% under these circumstances is already a challenge, I would say. That said, if we can surpass it, we would be glad to. On the cost base side, naturally, we hold some cushion, since we currently sit at 54% cost income ratio while aiming to stay under 58%, so we clearly do have a margin.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat this does is give us the confidence not to, you know, just spend and lose sight of that cost discipline, which is genuinely embedded in our DNA, but potentially to put money to work, and as you know, we want to fund the growth of those new businesses tied to the energy transition and to bringing all of our customers onto health services across the territory. We'll be watching to see if we can speed up how those businesses develop going forward. Naturally, that comes without undermining our ability to hold to the target of a cost income ratio below 58%, no matter what the circumstances. One last thing on consumer credit margins — perhaps I wasn't clear enough earlier. Margins on new loans contracted substantially across 2022, and they began to recover slightly at the start of 2023, in Q1 2023. We're moving toward additional margin improvement on new loans at CACF. That is very clear now. Once again, the reason is that, gradually, the usury rate has risen and is now going up every month in France. That clearly assists a great deal in lifting the customer rate and in lifting the margin on new loans.
Amit Goel
analystUnderstood. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorChris Hallam from Goldman Sachs has the next question.
Chris Hallam
analystGood morning, everyone. Good afternoon, all. I have two quick questions for you. I realize there’s no guidance for 2023, but if guidance did exist, do you believe you would have to increase it today? Which businesses, roughly speaking, are doing the most ahead of what you yourselves expected? Second, slide 27 mentions that higher financing rates are affecting revenue growth in leasing and factoring. Could you discuss a bit how you anticipate higher rates will affect those businesses in the future, and how that environment of elevated rates shapes your view regarding the wider medium term mobility ambitions?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt's tough, of course, and internally we do try to reassess on a regular basis where we'll land at the end of 2023. What's certain, and what now represents an improvement—all things being equal—versus what we had in mind three months ago, is the lower contribution to the Single Resolution Fund. That clearly is an improvement relative to what we had in mind globally for 2023. Beyond that, of course, we expect a significant portion of the improvements seen in the 1st quarter, in the 1st quarter, to be sustainable. You know that with CIB activities there is always a certain volatility, not because of our capacity to generate revenues, but mostly because of how customers behave. And for retail activities, as I've said, we continue to depend on how rates evolve in the future. And it's difficult for us to assess the run rate before we see rates stabilizing, probably in the middle of this year. Providing guidance is not only not a habit for us, but it's probably also too early definitely to be sure of what's going to take place in the second part of the year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen it comes to leasing and factoring, higher financing rates are clearly squeezing margins. Outstanding balances keep growing pretty substantially in leasing. On the factoring side, the encouraging part is that with inflation where it is now, every contract we signed previously is actually rising, thanks to inflation in how our customers bill their own customers. Overall, this is a setting where volumes will rise, and we hope that step by step we'll manage to pass along the financing-rate increase to customers.
Chris Hallam
analystAll right, thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Anke Reingen at Royal Bank of Canada.
Anke Reingen
analystThank you so much for the question. I wanted to ask about the financing activities in the large customer segment — it just keeps surprising me positively. I'm curious, since conditions aren't exactly favorable for large corporates right now, where is that growth actually coming from, I suppose across the different products? Also, are you picking up market share, and how do you see the outlook for your large corporate financing activity? And then perhaps on the margins in the financing piece, because I imagine TLTRO would have had a role there too. I was just wondering how successful you've been at passing that cheaper funding cost through to your customers. Thank you very much. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen it comes to CIB's financing activities, keep in mind that we're entirely at ease with this approach. CIB exists mainly to provide financing for corporate clients. That can happen either via our balance sheet or via the markets — debt capital markets or securitization. Without question, the core of CACIB's business is being out there in front of big corporate clients around the world and giving them the various financing solutions they require, while continuously evaluating how the different options we can offer are priced relative to one another. Plainly, we believe this — let me call it the raison d'être of CACIB — stays relevant, I'd say, more or less at all times. What we observe around us is that a lot of large corporates still have substantial projects and substantial investment they wish to undertake, particularly when it comes to energy transition. The growth potential for this business remains very strong. On being able to pass along the financing cost — you know, this is a business that is largely a margin spread business. Passing on to the customer the rise in market rates is not very hard. As for the TLTRO drawing we've taken, well, we know that for the group this amounted to EUR 200 million globally per quarter in additional revenues.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThose aren't with us anymore. It isn't truly a problem as such. That's revenue that's going away. From the end of 2023 onward, we won't have that basis effect anymore, and it doesn't affect how we relate to our customers. I believe that's essentially all I can say about it.
Anke Reingen
analystYeah. Thanks so much. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Kiri Vijayarajah — apologies — of HSBC.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystYes, sir. Good afternoon, Jérôme. I have a couple of questions. First, on slide 9, returning to the mobility topic and the acquisitions you have made there, I am curious why some of the portfolios you purchased from ALD LeasePlan end up in the joint venture. Then, in certain other geographies, you book the acquisitions into your wholly owned subsidiary, you know, the new CA Auto Bank. What is driving that differentiation? Also, what is your growth priority? Is it the long-term contract fleet in the JV, or is it the CA Auto Bank fleet that you would prioritize for growth if you had to choose between those two portfolios? Second question: when I look at Crédit Agricole Group, you are showing revenue growth of 1.8%, and of course, CACEIS, you know, much stronger, you have posted growth of 10%, over 10% this quarter. I am just trying to reconcile slides 5 and slide 6. That kind of implies revenue contraction at the regional banks excluding CACEIS, if I am right. Just really what is driving those kind of revenue headwinds at the regional banks ex CACEIS. From what you were saying earlier, I am not sure there is any — I do not think there was any distortion there in terms of IFRS 17.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystI'm just trying to pin down those revenue headwinds for the regional banks ex CACEIS, if you don't mind. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Kiri. To start: why did we divide the acquisition from ALD and LeasePlan between the JV and CA Auto Bank? That's quite straightforward. Certain countries fell under the JV agreement with Stellantis — Portugal and Luxembourg are examples — and in those places we hold exclusivity. So it was clearly essential to move those activities into the JV. As for Ireland, Norway, Czech Republic and Finland, while those markets aren't part of the JV, they are covered by Crédit Agricole Auto Bank, so we've folded those acquisitions in, and we will fold them into our own 100% setup. It really comes down to which countries the JV covers and which ones only we cover. On your second question — what are our priorities? Our priority is to grow both the JV and Crédit Agricole Auto Bank at the same time. Their client bases and their business scopes don't match exactly. The JV serves all Stellantis branches across a set of European countries for the fleet business — long-term car rental fleet operations in a given number of markets — and the car maker involved is Stellantis.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveCrédit Agricole Auto Bank and Drivalia serve distinct businesses. Crédit Agricole Auto Bank focuses on car financing—car loans, not car leasing. Drivalia handles car renting, car sharing, and various mobility services. Um, and they cater to all small car makers that aren't big enough to have, uh, their own, uh, uh, car loan captive, and also, uh, some independent car dealers that aren't tied to a specific car maker. Uh, and so, uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, we're going to grow the JV as quickly as we can with Stellantis, and at the same time, we're going to build up Crédit Agricole Auto Bank in those particular businesses, uh, as fast as we can, uh, simultaneously. Regarding the gap between the group's revenue gross, 1.8%, and for CASA, 10%+, well, the difference is clearly, as you mentioned, the fact that we've had a revenue depletion at the regional banks' level under IFRS 17, but of course there's no IFRS 17 impact within the regional banks. That revenue depletion is explained by the regional banks no longer having the TLTRO or drawing, that they have a significant amount of Livret A and other regulated savings accounts.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThey still hold a substantial volume of state-guaranteed loans carrying fixed rates that are extremely low — roughly EUR 12 billion at an average of 0.5% — which will amortize gradually but are expensive to refinance. All of these factors, of course, put pressure on net interest income at the Regional Banks. Even with fee and commission income rising by 1.6%, the revenue base overall for the Regional Banks is down 9.3%.
Kiri Vijayarajah
analystAlright, thank you, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Mate Nemes at UBS.
Mate Nemes
analystGood afternoon, and thank you for the presentation. I have two questions, if I may. My first concerns Italy. You clearly had a very strong revenue turnout this quarter. The loan book is flat, and clearly you're seeing quite some margin expansion there. I'm just wondering whether you could give us a sense of margin dynamics over the next few quarters. Should we expect a margin peak, perhaps, in the next one or two quarters, or do you expect this to be more of a longer duration story? My second question is on the joint venture with Worldline and payments. I was just wondering about the potential, the revenue potential of this JV. What should we expect here? To what extent is this JV factored into your other EUR 300 million revenue aspirations, in payments, that you presented last year? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLet's begin with Italy. There, the net interest income model differs from the one in France, obviously. Clearly, asset yields are resetting very quickly, since, you know, half of the loan book is either floating rate or adjustable rate. Definitely, the average customer rate on the asset book is climbing quite rapidly. From the start of 2022 to the start of 2023, it has roughly doubled. At the same time, the cost of customer liabilities has risen significantly, but far more slowly. That is driving this very sharp rise in net interest income. Definitely, looking ahead, there will not be another doubling of customer rates on the asset side, on the loans, because again, we don't know exactly where rates will end up or at what point. I do not expect the level of rates to double again going forward. I think that really, over the last few quarters, we have had the biggest part of the increase in net interest income, and we are going to progressively see things stabilize. Again, it depends exactly when the movement in rates is itself going to stabilize.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the Worldline joint venture, the agreement has been signed. We're now putting in serious effort to get the JV launched and to establish the entity itself, likely by the end of this year. That JV will invest and will gradually take on the contracts we hand over to it and bring into it. This will be a gradual process. The revenues we'll be able to draw out of the JV will likely arrive after the Medium-Term Plan horizon, meaning beyond 2025. Up to that point, payment-related revenues recorded at the regional banks within LCL will grow more sharply and faster than the market on average. That's our target. This will support growth in our retail banking operations in France over the course of the Medium Term Plan.
Mate Nemes
analystJerome?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorMatthew Clark from Mediobanca has the next question, sir.
Matthew Clark
analystHello. I'm afraid this is about IFRS 17 again. I'm just trying to get a handle on what you originally said — I think it was a year or two back — that there'd be a trade-off between how IFRS 17 hits the P&L on a go-forward basis and the upfront capital impact. Originally your guidance, or what you were saying, was that you'd manage the capital impact such that there was a negligible P&L effect on the go-forward earnings contribution. So first, did I have that original approach right? In the out term, the capital impact was clearly much better than you'd originally expected. I'm wondering whether the run rate P&L impact of IFRS 17 has also changed versus your original expectation of a negligible impact, and if so, how has it now changed? There are obviously some very material swings happening across the P&L and insurance and corporate center. Just trying to look at the big picture, are things better than you originally expected, and should we be reflecting that in our expectations going forward? Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes. It's accurate that 1 or 1 and a half year back, we were steering toward that trade-off involving P&L and upfront capital impact. That is completely true. Two things have occurred since then. First, the unrealized capital gains we held at that point — that is, one and a half year ago — have turned into a substantial unrealized capital loss. To be sure, what we had in mind was that this unrealized portion of our balance sheet would partly be moved into our own funds. That situation has changed radically. I would say the shift to IFRS 17 has resulted in up-fronting the bulk of the pool 2 par we anticipated going forward, tied to the OCI reserves. While the OCI reserves were positive, the pool 2 par was set to be negative. Up-fronting 1 of the pool 2 par represented a negative impact. Once the OCI reserves turned negative, the up-fronting of the pool 2 par delivered a one-off improvement of the capital position. Beyond that, naturally, IFRS 17 is a highly technical regulation. What the teams at Crédit Agricole Assurances did was seek to optimize as far as possible the breakdown of the asset books so as to moderate as far as possible the potential negative impact on the P&L, and where possible, to enhance the positive impact on the P&L.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSince work began on IFRS 17, Crédit Agricole Assurances has made some significant changes to how its asset books are organized, aiming to accommodate this new regulation as well as possible, and it proves to be efficient.
Matthew Clark
analystSo what you're saying, then, is that versus staying on an IFRS 4 basis, you now anticipate the move to IFRS 17 will have a positive effect on the P&L across the coming few years?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLook, comparing the IFRS 17 P&L we'll report going forward against what it would have looked like under IFRS 4 simply isn't something we can do. That comparison just won't be feasible. On the potential run rate for our revenues under IFRS 17, here's what I've said: the figure you saw in the first quarter of 2023 — subject, naturally, to market conditions and to how much commercial activity we generate — isn't unique to that first quarter, and I'd say it's something far more replicable.
Matthew Clark
analystAlright, sorry — just one last follow-up. As far as market conditions go, the kind that could mean you wouldn't be able to produce that type of result down the road — what sort of, you know, could you give an example of a quarter that would have had a material adverse...
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell—
Matthew Clark
analystHow is that affecting things?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAs you’re aware, IFRS 4 creates a far tighter connection between how assets and liabilities evolve when market conditions shift. Typically, the volatility tied to market conditions is partly offset because liabilities ought to move in the same direction as assets. Even so, with assets under IFRS 9, there can, of course, be some mismatches. I’m not sure what specific example I could cite, but there are certainly situations where particular market movements lower the IFRS 9 value of the asset book, while at the same time we cannot recognize a decrease in the value of our liabilities under IFRS 17. We’ll keep learning, quarter after quarter, how this behaves. I believe we’ve done everything we could to dampen the volatility as much as possible. Now, IFRS 9 plus IFRS 17 means we are on a mark-to-market basis on both the asset side and the liability side.
Matthew Clark
analystAlright. I appreciate you taking the time to answer, and thanks.
Operator
operatorBenoit Valleaux from ODDO BHF has the next question.
Benoît Valleaux
analystGood afternoon. I have two brief follow-up questions from my end regarding insurance. The first concerns capital. We observed roughly a 50% rise in the SCR during Q1. I'm curious whether you could provide some detail on what drove that increase. For instance, did a change in the EIOPA reference portfolio affect you in Q1? What might the impact have been from financial markets? Related to that, could you tell us how the solvency margin of your insurance activity has evolved, and perhaps more specifically for Predica? The second question relates to IFRS 17, where you mentioned assets. I have just one question about your real estate portfolio. I'd simply like to know whether the entirety of your real estate portfolio is carried at cost, or whether some portion is carried at fair value through P&L, just to understand if potential liquidity valuation could impact the contribution from insurance or not. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLots of technical questions there. The first one concerned the STR. I don't have the specific details in mind to respond to what you asked. Clotilde, I'm not sure whether you can offer Benoit any clarification.
Speaker
unknownI’ll come to you next, Benoit, but for this quarter, what I’d say is that beyond the strong revenues—especially in savings and retirement and at PNC—we also saw a favorable claims trend that brought our combined ratio down. That’s something that could shift. All of it stems from activity or the environment, not from any change in the EIOPA reference portfolio.
Benoît Valleaux
analystAll right, when it comes to Solvency II at Predica, do you have any perspective on where the trends are heading?
Speaker
unknownWe aren’t disclosing any information about solvency movement in the first quarter, as you’re aware, since we’re holding to the solvency numbers we reported at the close of 2022, and those were very strong. As you know, our solvency figure incorporates the reserve we refer to as the PPE, which came down slightly at the end of 2022 and stayed quite strong. Higher rates also provide a favorable effect ahead on this front. We feel very comfortable with our solvency ratio.
Benoît Valleaux
analystYeah.
Speaker
unknownAs of today — and this holds true even in Q1 — we’ll provide you with the matching figures when we get to Q2.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah. Just keep in mind that at the end of last year, the Solvency II figure was well above 200%.
Speaker
unknownYes.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe definitely remain, I'd say, even beyond the target we set for ourselves.
Speaker
unknownRight.
Benoît Valleaux
analystOkay. As for how sensitive we are to real estate valuation?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, so Crédit Agricole Assurances and Predica do hold real estate assets on their books, though that amount isn't especially large. Within Predica's total assets, it accounts for under 10%. It's meaningful, yes, but certainly not enormous. Beyond that, in today's climate, certain property holdings are under strain owing to how they were financed — specifically, some investors funded their real estate purchases using debt. Naturally, they're now confronting a potentially sizable rise in their borrowing costs. That is creating pressure for them. An insurer, by its very nature, doesn't operate that way; its funding comes mostly from policyholder deposits, so leverage of any sort isn't a concern. These days rents are gaining from inflation. Income produced by property assets is climbing right now.
Benoît Valleaux
analystAlright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur last question comes from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveJacques-Henry, hi there.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystYes. Good afternoon, everyone. First off, Clotilde, many thanks for all of it. I was just about to invite you to respond to that follow-up yourself — you've spoken already, that's fine. If you'd like to answer it, go ahead. It's a follow-up regarding the outlook. It's fair to say that when you read the Q4 2022 press release, it comes across as rather dry. I recall the wording: in 2023, continued adaptation to the new rates context. I grasp the reply you gave my colleague concerning the SRF variation, which had a large impact, and that's accurate. Even if I were to raise that 2022 SRF contribution by EUR 100 million, you would still have exceeded consensus by 20%. I'd like to know whether you saw activity pick up toward the latter part of the quarter, or what essentially led you to be so conservative? That's my first question. The second one: the good old AT1 coupon is somewhat higher, given your outstanding of roughly EUR 8 billion. That implies a yield of 7.8%. Is that a decent yield to assume for the remainder of the year, or is it too high, too low? Just some guidance.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystAppreciate it. French.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, I’ll give Clothilde the final word. Perhaps just a brief comment on what we said at the close of 2022 and why our stance looks somewhat cautious. Keep in mind that 3 months earlier, there was considerable uncertainty about how quickly and how far central banks would raise rates. And we knew that, at group level, we would lose several hundred million EUR in revenues tied to the TLTRO. I’d say we were somewhat doubtful about how the economic outlook might develop, since at that point there was a meaningful chance of a recession occurring in France and Europe. In my view, conditions have improved markedly since then. What we clearly observed in the first quarter of this year was activity across every area that came in well above what we had envisioned under the gloomier scenario we held at the end of 2022. Clothilde, perhaps you can also address the AT1.
Speaker
unknownRegarding the AT1?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, Jacques-Henri Gaulard raised a question about the AT1.
Speaker
unknownNo — someone did ask about the outlook and the consensus, correct?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding the AT1.
Speaker
unknownSomeone also raised a point about AT1 — my apologies. I missed that AT1 question. As you're aware, we don't reveal anything about our AT1 plans, since that falls outside of.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt comes down to compensation.
Speaker
unknownWell, that comes down to the coupon.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah, the coupon.
Speaker
unknownThose are quite elevated. Right. Well, as you're aware, everything here hinges on market conditions, and we'll see how the calls play out based on where the market stands. Since those conditions have shifted, we always need to stay flexible when it comes to these AT1.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMy view is that, on a worldwide basis, those coupons aren't divided equally.
Speaker
unknownIn the same way, I would say no.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding Q4 — same thing for the year's fourth quarter. If you were to look at the average cost of our AT1 based just on Q1, my sense is that you wouldn't necessarily arrive at the relevant average cost for AT1 bonds.
Speaker
unknownAlright.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo I suppose that settles it. There's one final question. Jacques-Henri, my apologies — you were meant to be the last, but someone comes after the last. Clothilde will handle this final question.
Operator
operatorSharath Kumar from Deutsche Bank has the final question. You can proceed.
Sharath Kumar
analystHello. I have just one question outstanding regarding your LCR ratio. The press release does state that your medium-term target is 110%. Is that a floor, or do you realistically see yourselves bringing your LCR down over the medium term? While I appreciate that you are keeping a higher level of liquidity in the current circumstances, I just wanted to get some possible medium-term color on what those targets could mean. Thank you.
Speaker
unknownActually, let me take that one, since it came to me. I apologize — I didn’t catch Jacques Henry’s question, but I did hear this one. Yes, the target is indeed 110%, and as of today we are comfortably above it. As you know, we’re also above that target thanks to the TLTRO. The surplus we hold right now is, of course, larger than the TLTRO. When we set our MTP targets, we framed them both in terms of the liquidity coverage ratio and in terms of stable resources positioning, on the assumption that we would need to repay the TLTRO — which we will do. We feel quite comfortable with those targets as we go forward. They do factor in the TLTRO repayments.
Sharath Kumar
analystAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright, I believe that was definitely the final question. Thank you all for joining this meeting. And thanks as well to Clotilde for the — I haven't tallied how many there were, but probably.
Speaker
unknownRegarding the six
Jérôme Grivet
executive... 15 or 16 meetings. We're glad to have Cecile on board — she's been listening in on this call quite attentively. Starting tomorrow, she'll be ready to serve as your point of contact. So long, everybody.
Speaker
unknownThanks, everybody — goodbye.
Operator
operatorThanks, everyone, for being here. That wraps up today’s conference. You can go ahead and hang up your phones now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.