Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 8, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon. I’m the conference operator. Welcome, and thank you for joining us for the Crédit Agricole third quarter 2023 results conference call and webcast. Please note that everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the presentation, you’ll have a chance to ask questions by pressing star and one on your telephone. If anyone requires assistance during the call, they can signal an operator by pressing star and zero. At this point, I’d like to hand the conference over to Mr. Jérôme Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Crédit Agricole S.A., responsible for Steering and Control. Sir, please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, everyone. It's a pleasure for me to present the results that we've published this morning. Let me go directly to page 4 of the presentation. I think these results that we're publishing today really illustrate another time, and once again, the strength of the models that has been built by Crédit Agricole Group and Crédit Agricole S.A. over time. These results show a certain number of characteristics that we find almost every quarter. High level of results and profitability, that's the first point. The second point is that, again, we are generating additional capital that is fueling our growth, both internal and external. We continue to have a very solid asset quality and a very good liquidity profile, despite the strengthening of the monetary policy by the ECB. And last point, we continue to be very involved in helping the energy transition, and I want to mention the fact that we are going to have a dedicated workshop on December fourteenth this year on additional topics regarding Net Zero convergence and all our efforts in this energy transition. If I go to page 5, with the main figures for Crédit Agricole S.A., what we can see on this page, and some elements I will comment a little bit more in detail later on, but first, highlight, it's the very high dynamic for revenues, which are up 13.4% on the quarter and 13.1% on the nine months.
Jérôme Grivet
executivePoint two: we're still extremely disciplined when it comes to watching our expense base, which is producing a really powerful Jaws effect — nearly 5 to 6 points for the quarter and for the nine months. Point three: the cost of risk is genuinely rising, though only slightly, in truth, given how overall activity has developed. And the final point: our results are at a very high level — EUR 1.5 billion underlying and EUR 1.75 billion stated for the third quarter, with four point six billion and five billion for the nine months. That translates into a return on tangible equity of 13.5% for the nine months. Turning to the next page, you'll see the group's figures globally, where the trends are more or less the same, though somewhat amortized relative to Crédit Agricole S.A. Even with that amortization, we still post a sharp rise in the top line: +7.5% for the quarter and +6% for the nine months. A positive Jaws effect, on both the quarter and the nine months. A very moderate rise in the cost of risk, and a high profit level, higher on both an underlying and a stated basis, and on both the quarter and the nine months.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMoving a bit further into the document, to page 8, there are some elements about the activity driving these financial results. What I think we can take from this page is that yes, indeed, there is a slowdown in new loan production within the retail banking activities in France. However, the overall solid performance across all our business lines more than offsets this, which again illustrates the strength of the model. We keep growing the customer base, with a strong rise in the number of new customers — plus 445,000 new customers across all our retail banks in Europe. We keep increasing the equipment of those customers with our various products and services, and on top of that, we keep developing the business that directly targets large customers, whether for CACEIS, for CACIB, and for the institutional investors who are the customers of Amundi. On the next page, you have what I would call a wrap-up of the different strategic operations we've carried out over the last three years. It's an interesting summary of what we've been able to seize in terms of opportunities, and to integrate into our different business lines, into our different specialized platforms.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveEvery one of these operations is being self-financed through our capacity to generate capital. And on the right-hand side of this page, we've given two figures that are interesting. The first is that, taken together, these various acquisitions will result in an extra EUR 1.9 billion of NBI. For 2025, naturally, we've estimated that a portion of this NBI already sits in our accounts, though a portion does not at all, and a portion has still to be materialized. The second interesting point is that once the cost synergies have materialized, the incremental cost income ratio of the additional business those operations generate will be exactly in line with the targets set for the medium-term plan, which is 58%. On the next page, there are some reminders about the activities of the new business lines, Crédit Agricole Transitions & Énergies, launched this year. Earlier in October we held a dedicated presentation on these activities. But just so you keep in mind that Crédit Agricole Transitions & Énergies will be a 50/50 JV between CASA and the regional banks, and it will deploy its activities around two business lines. The first is to be able to produce renewable energies and to distribute them locally.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe second business line involves delivering advisory solutions to the various customer categories we serve across the board. On page 11, there are some further details about how revenue was generated at CASA during the quarter and over the nine months. What this page shows, I think, is this: first, revenue growth has been very sharp, both for the quarter and for the nine months — +13% on an underlying basis, and even +19% and 15.5%, close to 16%, on a stated basis. The second point, which is interesting, is that every business line contributed to this sharp rise in revenues. The third point, also very important to bear in mind, is that even if we restate those figures for the scope effect — you know that we integrated some activities during the first nine months of the year, with the integration, the full integration of Crédit Agricole Autobank, with the acquisitions CACF has made in the leasing business across Europe, and also with the integration of RBC by CACEIS at the beginning of Q3. So if we restate revenue growth for the effect of those acquisitions in the period, we continue to post a very sharp increase in revenues.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYet organic growth came in at 7.7% for the quarter, and it was even 10.2% across the first nine months of the year. That is happening following a number of years marked by precisely the same capacity for producing extra revenues. Page 12 shows this. Quarter after quarter, you can see that we have managed to grow the top line at CASA in a very, very steady way. And on the whole, over the past six years, we have raised CASA's revenue-generating capacity by roughly one-third, more or less. Page 13 offers a few further points on a matter that has prompted plenty of questions recently, particularly where French banks are concerned — namely how net interest income is evolving. It is entirely true that in French retail operations, the rate rises we have seen since the start of 2022 initially place some pressure on net interest income. You know exactly why: on the asset side of our balance sheet, the vast majority of loans carry fixed rates, home loans above all, so asset-side yields adjust very slowly. At the same time, though, the cost of liabilities climbs rather quickly, since a significant share of our liabilities reprices directly with rising market rates — regulated savings accounts, for instance — and so does the portion of the balance sheet that is funded via the market.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYet we also have hedges in place, and those hedges perform efficiently, so overall this is producing a situation in which net interest income at LCL — the French retail banking operation of CASA — fell by just 9% from Q1 2022, likely the final quarter of the zero-rate era we had experienced recently, to Q3 2023, the last quarter of that period, so minus 9%. At the same time, though, international retail banking activities raised their net interest income considerably, averaging for CASA a rise of roughly 48% across that same stretch. Combined with CASA's other activities that record a portion of their revenues as net interest income, all of this is producing a situation in which net interest income at CASA rose by approximately 24% from Q1 2022 to Q3 2023. Let me now move to page 14, to the cost side of our activities. The cost base rose by roughly 8% on the quarter and 6.6% over the first 9 months on an underlying basis. On the quarter, however, two-thirds of that increase comes directly from the scope effect, and over the nine months, 40% of the increase stems from the scope effect.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhat that means is we're still handling the organic change in our cost base in a very efficient way. Page 15 has a few items on gross operating income. It's rising quickly — up 20% for the three months of the quarter and up 34% across the first nine months of the year. That growth shows up in every business line, and naturally it's this growth that accounts for the rise in net income. The remaining P&L components — cost of risk and equity accounted entities — are going up, and corporate tax is either flat or up slightly. So it's clearly gross operating income driving the entire net profit increase. One last thing, perhaps a further remark about the cost income we're reporting. So, 53.4% over the first nine months of the year, and 54.5% when the contribution to the Single Resolution Fund is included, so we can compare with the sample of European banks — and we remain massively more efficient than that sample of European banks. Page 16 covers a few items on how cost of risk is evolving. It is indeed up a little, +19%, for Crédit Agricole S.A., and +9% for the group globally.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYet the levels we've gotten to remain quite moderate, and the cost of risk measured in bps per outstandings is still quite moderate as well. So for CASA it's 3 bps, which is clearly well under the assumptions we built into the medium-term plan, 40bps, and for the group globally it's 24 bps. Once more, that's a very moderate level. If we dig a bit further into where the cost of risk comes from, you can see as well that it's concentrated in consumer credit, small businesses, and professional, which means that for the two big categories of loans in our loan books, corporate on one hand and home loans on the other, it remains very, very low. On page 17, a few additional elements on the provisions we hold in our books. Close to EUR 10 billion of provisions in CASA's books, and close to EUR 21 billion in Crédit Agricole Group books globally, and we keep a low level of non-performing loans, 2.7% for CASA, and 2.2% for the group globally. So this produces a very high coverage ratio. On page 18, the usual comparison of the group and CASA with other European banks when it comes to coverage and NPL ratios, and we remain, I would say, on the safe side, and even the very safe side of the sample, as usual.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlso on the right side of the page, this graphic shows once more that home loans and corporate loans—the largest portions of our loan portfolio—account for the overwhelming bulk of that portfolio while carrying a very low cost of risk. Taken together, this brings us on page 19 to how net profit has developed. Once again, net profit has risen sharply: +23% for the quarter and +29% across the first 9 months of the year. And once more, that gain is distributed quite evenly across every business line, with all of them feeding into the improvement in our P&L bottom line. Turning to solvency and financial strength on page 20, you'll note that during this quarter CASA's CET1 ratio went up by roughly 20 bps. That reflects a mix of several factors. The first factor, naturally, is that given this solid level of results—and notwithstanding a further rise in the dividend provision, which stood at EUR 0.76 a share by the end of September—we retained 20 bps of capital through retained results. Organic growth across the business lines uses up just 15 bps of capital.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveDuring this quarter, we have a one-time item — which is a permanent one-time item — and that's a change in how we account for goodwill in the insurance business, in line with a response from the EBA to a question that was raised quite a while back, in fact. Restating the treatment of goodwill in the insurance business results in a 15 bps lift to our CET1 ratio. The M&A activity this quarter amounts to only a 4 bps hit. To be precise, that's 13 bps of cost tied to the acquisitions of the RBC and ALD leasing operations, offset by the benefit from a synthetic securitization tied to Crédit Agricole Autobank loans that was closed slightly earlier in the year. So overall, CASA's CET1 ratio stands at 11.8%, well above the 11% target we set in the medium-term plan. For the group as a whole, there's actually a modest decline, from 17.6% to 17.5%, but this clearly reflects the combination of two different effects — CASA are moving in the same direction for the group, so that produces an increase in the group's CET1. But you may recall that during the third quarter — actually at the start of the third quarter — SAS La Boétie, our main shareholder, which represents the shareholding of all the regional banks, announced it had decided to launch a new acquisition of EUR 1 billion of CASA shares.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, this acquisition's effect gets reflected in the group's CET1 ratio starting this quarter, even though the deal isn't finalized yet. That produces a 17 bps hit, which is precisely why the group-level CET1 ratio moves slightly downward in this particular quarter. Even so, at the group level we still hold the largest distance to SREP among all European G-SIBs, at 820 bps. You'll also notice that Crédit Agricole S.A., not a G-SIB itself but globally part of the group, reports a distance to SREP of 360 bps, which stacks up very favorably against certain European standalone G-SIBs. Turning to page 22, there are some items you're now quite familiar with concerning customer deposits on our books. First, you can observe that across the third quarter, customer deposits overall rose by roughly EUR 18 billion, +1.7%. Second, this customer base keeps the same characteristics — it remains highly diversified and benefits from various categories of guarantees covering around, and even more than, half of the total amount.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn page 23, regarding liquidity reserves and how we manage liquidity worldwide, we raised the amount of liquidity reserves during the quarter, and those now stand at close to EUR 420 billion, spread across various categories — central banks, deposits, HQLA securities, and other asset types eligible for central bank refinancing, along with different categories of claims. The second thing is that our LCR ratios remain at levels that are very high relative to our target. That target is still 110%, and the figure averages around 150% over the last 12 months, and was above 140% at the end of the period, even though we again repaid some TLTRO amounts during the third quarter. And perhaps the last item on this page is that, as we announced three months ago, we increased CASA's market funding program by around one quarter in the middle of this year, because we wanted to seize good market windows to boost our medium to long-term funding. And this new market funding had already been completed by the end of the third quarter, so it is now 100% completed, with the new level at around EUR 25 billion.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat brings my presentation to a close. Let me just wrap up by saying once more that this has been a really strong quarter for CASA and for the group. And once again, it demonstrates how solid our model is, since it's adjusting remarkably well to the different environment. And the environment we're in right now, marked by a steep rise in rates and a notable economic downturn, isn't holding back our ability to expand and to produce profitability. Thank you very much. And at this point we can move straight to your questions.
Operator
operatorThank you, sir. At this point we'll move into the question and answer portion. If you'd like to pose a question, you can press star and one on your touchtone phone. Should you want to drop out of the queue, press star and two. When you ask your question, please lift the receiver. Our first question is from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystGood morning, and thanks. I have two brief questions. First, regarding the macro hedges in French retail: how sustainable would you say they are, and what contribution did they make per quarter over roughly the last year? Second, your strategy for growing the product factories has proven very, very strong and effective — the revenue momentum in these highly profitable divisions is clear. Well done. My question, though, concerns funding for further growth. You said last quarter that half of it came from disposals. I'd like to understand which levers remain for financing continued growth through bolt-ons. Which areas would you regard as non-core? Obviously, I'm not asking you to name any specific entity — divisions are enough. And also, how much more room is there on synthetic securitization and RWA optimization? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Tarik. To begin with the macro hedge: it seems that many people are only now becoming aware that macro hedging exists in retail bank management, particularly in France. Yet this is a practice we have been familiar with for a great many years. I recall that 25 years ago, when I began my career in banking, this was practically the first subject I had to examine and work on, since it is truly essential, especially, once again, in the setting of French retail banking operations. Thus, when rates are more or less steady, hedging represents a cost, and we factor that cost into how we manage our P&L. When rates move substantially, macro hedging makes a considerable contribution to the NII, and that is precisely the function it should serve. So we will not break down within the NII exactly which portion stems from asset remuneration, which portion stems from the cost we must carry on the liabilities, and which portion reflects the impact of the macro hedging. Doing so would be overly complex and would in fact require extensive explanation of our hedging strategy and so forth.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd I'd say that's largely a question of conventions, so it isn't especially relevant. Still, it matters a great deal that you recognize we apply a steady macro hedging approach at all times. We don't alter it simply because rates move; our aim is to stay as consistent and stable as we can — not to shield ourselves from every consequence of rate movements, since that can't be done, but to smooth, to the greatest extent feasible, how rate evolution affects our P&L. And I believe we've done that rather well, since the proof again comes from how NII at LCL moved: down 9% quarter on quarter from Q1 2022 to Q3 2023. Perhaps the final point I'd emphasize is that, from Q2 2023 to Q3 2023, it appears that at both LCL and the regional banks of Crédit Agricole, we're now seeing some stabilization in NII — meaning that, given a certain set of assumptions, of course, about competition among banks to draw deposits and so forth, and with a certain number of assumptions, we can feel fairly confident that we're not far from the trough where net interest income is concerned.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThere's perhaps one more point here that you need to bear in mind, and it's an impact we'll begin to feel in Q4. You've clearly noticed that the ECB has chosen to halt remuneration on mandatory reserves. That took effect on September 20th, so for the group as a whole, it will amount to roughly EUR 100 million per quarter in impact. Therefore, all else being equal, our NII will take a hit of approximately EUR 100 million, distributed fairly evenly across the regional banks and CASA, and among the various activities within CASA, but you need to keep that in mind. As for our ability to keep doing bolt-on acquisitions and how we might fund them: we looked back over the past — I believe it was the past — 4 years, so from 2019 onward. In terms of net results, we generated roughly 650 basis points of capital. We distributed 350 basis points, covering both the dividends and the 81 coupons. That left us with approximately three hundred basis points of capital available to us, for both organic growth across the different business lines and the bolt-on acquisitions we've referred to.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveDuring this period, we have naturally been able to take advantage of chances to sell off non-core businesses, but making divestitures solely to fund those acquisitions is not a necessity. Because, once again, given the very high profitability level that we have, we can manage perfectly well, simultaneously, to pay the dividend in cash, to fuel organic growth of the business line, and to keep a certain amount for bolt-on acquisition, especially if we are now finished, and we hope that is the case with all the regulatory strengthening.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystYeah, thank you.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Flora Bocahut at Jefferies.
Flora Bocahut
analystYes, thank you, and good afternoon, Jérôme. No, I simply wanted to discuss the 2025 targets. I realize you prefer not to revise them mid-year. Just to point out, the 9-month performance relative to your 2025 guidance — right now you're annualizing at roughly EUR 6 billion of net income. In 2025, you're aiming for just above that level. After 9 months, your ROTE is north of 13%, and that sits on a Common Equity Tier 1 above the 11% target set out in the plan. So clearly, at the moment you're somewhat over earning compared with the 2025 target. So my questions are very simple: would you call the 2025 targets conservative? If you don't see them as conservative, then where do you believe the P&L will deteriorate relative to the current run rate in 2025? And can we expect an update to the 2025 targets alongside full year 2023? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveFlora, as you're aware, we're conservative by nature—it's baked into who we are. Those 2025 targets we published came out a bit over a year back, roughly a year and a half ago. So considering everything we had available to us at the time, I believe that was the strongest target we could set. Naturally, we're fully aware that we're likely somewhat ahead of schedule on the path from now to 2025. Even so, as of today it's far too soon to begin talking about that. Right now we're focused on the 2024 budget. Those budgets will naturally incorporate certain thoughts about 2025 and even 2026—that's how we operate internally. Once we've evaluated all of these pieces, we'll obviously have a clearer picture of our ability to hit, and perhaps even exceed to some degree, those results we laid out for 2025. But I'd say we're not in a rolling-forecast mindset, so we won't be refreshing our medium-term target every single quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSince otherwise, there's a real chance we'd be forced at some point to lower our targets. So for now, let's keep the targets as they stand and trust us to deliver as much as we can, even if that ends up above the targets.
Flora Bocahut
analystAll right, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorGiulia Aurora Miotto from Morgan Stanley has the next question.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there, Giulia.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystHello, good afternoon, Jérôme. Regarding capital allocation, my first question: 11.7 is well ahead of the 11%, which, as you know, gives you space to potentially do more bolt-ons. But what about the 50% distribution policy? Might you think about, say, a special dividend, or perhaps raising it to 60%, so the dividend could stay flat year-over-year? That's my first question. Second question — and listen, I realize the corporate center isn't the best or most strategic division, but costs there are pretty volatile, and right now they're essentially zero, I mean, -EUR 2 million. Should that stay that way, or, like Q4 last year, are they likely to rise? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Giulia. When it comes to capital distribution, again, this is something we... So there's a policy in place, and then each year we make a decision about the exact dividend level that we propose to the general assembly meeting at the end of the year. So, we're only at the end of the third quarter, and this is definitely a question that is not on the table right now. But just keep a certain number of elements in mind. First point, we have announced, and this is now a yearly commitment, that during the fourth quarter, we are going to conduct a share buyback in order to offset the effect of the capital increase reserved to the employees that took place in the summer. This is going to represent a hit of 98 to 99 bps on our CET1 ratio, depending on the price at which we, we buy those shares. Second point, we have, in the course of the first half of 2024 to finance the acquisition that has been announced of the Degroof Petercam. This could be between 25 and 30 bps of capital. The third point, we still have a last layer of TRIM impact that is going to take place probably in 2024.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat adds up to EUR 4 billion in extra RWAs. After that come the final, truly final stages of IFRS 9 phase-in — another 5 bps during 2024 plus 5 bps during 2025. Every one of those items is factored into the capital trajectory, and what matters to us isn't the level reached at the close of any particular quarter, but our ability to keep tracking a path that stays consistent over time. So the thinking we do constantly on this trajectory, along with the thinking done annually on the dividend level, will naturally happen alongside the results at the end of 2023, just as it does each year. On the corporate center, it's fair to say that reading across it is somewhat difficult. It's also fair to say that this year in particular brings a new element affecting both NBI and the corporate center's cost base — namely our decision to book there the impact of a certain IFRS 17 provision, the one concerning internal margins. That comes to roughly EUR 200 million of negative NBI per quarter and EUR 200 million of negative costs per quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThis one is somewhat tricky, and somewhat hard to follow. It comes down purely to accounting. The net effect is zero, naturally, but it hits the corporate center, and that does not help. I agree with you—it isn't helping much at all with being able to fully read how the corporate center is evolving. Just bear in mind, for this corporate center, that we intend to keep watching the total expense of that corporate center at a level at or under EUR 750 million of net cost per year.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystUnderstood. Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMm-hmm.
Operator
operatorStefan Stalmann from Autonomous Research has the next question.
Stefan Stalmann
analystActually, that's Stefan Stalmann, not Steven Goldman.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveStefan here!
Stefan Stalmann
analystHey there. I nearly overlooked this call entirely, yet here I am. So—
Operator
operatorMy apologies, sir.
Stefan Stalmann
analystThat's fine, no problem at all. It's at least a solid, solid connection. I'd like to ask about slide 9, which I found quite useful, where you give some financial metrics regarding previous M&A transactions. Could you perhaps share what sort of return on investment you'd expect to produce on the basis of that NBI and that cost income guidance, should it come through in 2025? And in addition, out of the EUR 1.9 billion NBI, could you give us a rough idea of how much is already reflected in the nine months, 2023 figures? My second question concerns chart 13, which I also found very helpful — the NII trajectory across your different businesses. Taking a longer view, after some of those structural differences in product mix and timing differences stemming from them have played out, is there any reason to think that LCL's net interest income or net interest margin shouldn't catch up to what we're already seeing in the international businesses?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveStefan, those are two very interesting and difficult questions. The first one — no, actually the first one is quite easy. When it comes to validating bolt-on acquisitions, we have very strict financial discipline, and we definitely do not accept any transaction that wouldn't lead to a minimum return on investment of 10% after 3 years. And what we can say is definitely that all these acquisitions summarized on page 9 have already generated, or are going to generate, once they are fully ramped up, this minimum level of return on investment — and sometimes it's quite significantly above this level. Every time we announce a specific transaction, we give an idea of the type of return that we are targeting, and definitely, it's in general quite significantly above 10%. But 10% is the minimum, and it's verified very, very carefully. As for which proportion of the EUR 1.9 billion of NBI is already on, in our books, that's a difficult question because this 1.9 is a combination of the initial NBI of the acquisitions that we are making, plus the organic evolution of these acquisitions, plus also the effect of the revenue synergies that we are targeting. So it's difficult.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveFor the recent acquisitions, we've given fairly detailed information about what's included in the Q2 and Q3 figures. Take RBC as an example: in the Q3 numbers, we have EUR 100 million of NBI and, as things stand, EUR 100 million of costs. So that's zero profitability for this quarter on its own, naturally. Regarding Crédit Agricole Autobank, we shared the figures from last quarter and gave some specifics on, you know, the NBI generation tied to that acquisition. You can probably — and forgive me for answering this way — you can probably work out some of the math by combining the various elements we've provided, but we aren't able, and honestly aren't willing, to claim we're 53% of the way toward the EUR 1.9 billion. That would likely be overly precise and not particularly useful on its own. On NII, of course, what we anticipate going forward, assuming we truly are at the peak of rate movement in the market and from the ECB, is what I mentioned: some stabilization in NII, followed by a gradual pickup for French retail banking activities. At the same time, it's entirely natural to see a peak reached for NII in non-French retail activities, and likely stabilization or even a modest slowdown, since the same causes produce the same effect.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat said, how much the two curves will actually come together — the one for French retail and the one for international retail — there is no reason whatsoever that they must converge in a strict sense. A lot of different factors come into play in how those two evolve. So there's no basis for expecting full convergence. Beyond that, and we've stressed this point a good many times, one of the defining characteristics of the French retail model, with its fixed rate on home loans and on various other loan categories, is that as time passes it produces a far lower level of cost of risk than other models elsewhere in Europe. So to properly gauge, I would say, the convergence, we would also need to factor in the cost of risk line.
Stefan Stalmann
analystThanks a lot for that. Appreciate it, Jérôme.
Operator
operatorJust a quick reminder — if you'd like to ask a question, hit star and one on your touchtone phone. Our next question is from Amit Goel at Barclays.
Amit Goel
analystHello, and thanks. I have two questions. First, to follow up—I appreciate the guidance you provided on the NIM for domestic retail and for international retail. I'm just wondering: if I combine those two for total retail NII, what trajectory ought I to be modeling going forward? And second, regarding the capital markets and IB performance, I'd like to know how much of that nine-month performance I should be extrapolating forward. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay. On the first answer, it's hard to say once more, since a great many assumptions will shape how net interest income develops across the various perimeters and geographies going forward. How will rates actually move? We're assuming we're peaking, but will that hold true? And how will competitors respond? In France, as you know, there is a degree of competition to attract customer deposits, so will that push the cost of liabilities up further or not? How will customers behave when it comes to credit demand? So far, we've seen, in French home loans for instance, a substantial decline — less substantial for us than for the market, yet still substantial — simply because a number of customers are giving up owing to the level of rates. Will things stay at this level, or will some customers eventually decide that their income has risen with inflation and reach the conviction that at some point the price of homes probably won't fall any further, which might generate stronger credit demand?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo every one of those elements will come into play, and modeling that mathematically into a trajectory for upcoming quarters is hard to do. Still, I think you now have the key factors, I'd say, that will shape how things evolve going forward. On CIB capital market activities, and particularly fixed income, it's fair to say we've reported a really strong revenue level. And this isn't the first quarter where we've managed to edge past the market a bit when it comes to how fixed income revenues develop. I believe that comes down to the fact that we're largely, and nearly entirely, propelled by what customers ask for, and by their readiness to enter into transactions — whether that's bond issuances, hedging, securitization, or operations along those lines. So customer demand is the first driver. The second driver is that, with those same customers, we keep steadily expanding our positioning and our ranking. As one illustration, CACIB ranked number two worldwide in the third quarter for bond issuance in euros. So naturally, should a substantial volume of activity in debt capital market persist, CACIB is very well positioned to benefit from it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveShould debt capital market activity volumes slow down, CACIB will move in step with that trend. Still, the stronger positioning CACIB has achieved almost certainly accounts for a meaningful share — perhaps only part, but a significant part — of this outperformance, and that is not going away.
Amit Goel
analystAlright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorDelphine Lee from JP Morgan has the next question.
Delphine Lee
analystGood afternoon, Jérôme, and thanks for taking my questions. First, coming back to net interest income — and thanks for that slide 13. I'm just trying to get my head around LCL's net interest income, the -9%, which is clearly a weak spot compared with other players in the market. Would you say hedging explains it, or is there something else you could point to on the commercial side, in terms of volumes? You seem to have, you know, more resilient lending, or deposits — anything that could just help us understand a bit better the relative performance? And my second question concerns the leasing activities within SFS. So other players are flagging the normalization of used car prices, which is on its way. Do you view that as a problem for yourself, or less so? And if you could just expand a little on that topic, thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWhen it comes to how NII evolves, comparing French banks with each other is hard, since the split of liabilities between regulated and non-regulated savings products isn't identical at every bank. Since mid-2022, banks haven't all acted the same way when it comes to writing new loans. For instance, on the market for new lending, Crédit Agricole's regional banks and LCL were considerably more active than the typical French bank. So every one of those factors matters. And naturally, the specific hedging technique matters too. I can't tell you the exact share, because I don't know precisely what role hedging played at our competitors, but for us it is plainly significant. For us, the revenue that hedging generates is plainly significant. And once more, that is precisely what hedging is for. It costs money when rates stay still, and it contributes extra revenue when rates move. That is precisely the aim. Turning to leasing and the question of used-car valuation: it's true that this is a very significant risk element of the business. When you model the monthly rental level for a car you lease, making sound and prudent assumptions about what the used cars will be worth at the end of the process is very important.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIt's also true that over the recent period, for a range of reasons, used car values went up quite substantially, which gave a boost to the profitability of leasing businesses. As for our own business, the largest portion of what we're booking is new business, so at the moment we don't rely very heavily on used car valuations — on what the industry calls the remarketing of used cars — because quite simply, our business ramped up fairly recently. So we make sure to be prudent in the assessment we make when valuing a used car at the end of the contract. But at the moment, most of the contracts in our portfolio are relatively recent.
Delphine Lee
analystGot it. Thanks very much for that. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorPierre Chedeville from CIC has the next question.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, good afternoon. Am I coming through okay?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, Pierre.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, thanks. My question relates to slide 26, on insurance, since I'd like to—
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe insurance slide is one you prefer.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, since I’d like to strengthen how I understand IFRS 17. You referred to a 55.2% combined ratio, with discounting and unwinding of reserves included. You also referred to the movement of minus 5 points over a year, tied to climate impact. Yet nothing was said about any movement linked to discounting and unwinding. That surprised me somewhat, because rates have moved over the past year. So when we look at your slide, it gives us the impression that climate impact alone is driving that, and I found that a little surprising, since to my mind the minus 5 points also reflects discounting and unwinding of reserves. So it would be useful if you could clarify that. Also — perhaps it is a bit early to judge whether there is an impact — but could you tell us whether your exposure to the Ciarán tempest for Q4 is more or less severe? My other question, on slide 26, is that you cited an impressive increase, +22%, in protection, which is quite a significant figure. I’d like to know what sits behind that growth figure. Is there any consolidation involved somewhere? I don’t see where it would be, and it cannot be purely volumes or price effect.
Pierre Chédeville
analystCould you walk us through what's driving that increase? Thanks a lot, Jérôme.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. As always, the questions are very technical and precise. For your first question, I don't have an exact answer, but my guess is that, by definition, the new combined ratio we're reporting factors in all the elements it ought to factor in. That is, naturally, the drop in the level of sinistrality, but also every financial element must be factored in under the new IFRS 17 accounting standard. So I have no doubt that this evolution factors in—is factoring in—discounting factors tied to how rates are moving. But I don't have the breakdown of those two elements. The larger portion probably comes from the improvement in sinistrality, and the smaller portion comes from the discount effect, but I don't have a precise figure to give you. Perhaps my colleagues on the IR team will provide you with more details. Second point, naturally, we are exposed to the new weather events that occurred over the last few days. That is absolutely certain, and we are tracking, I would say, day by day, how many claims are arriving at our back offices.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe volume of claims is already fairly substantial. I'll take this chance to note that 20% of those claims get resolved right away through the initial phone call, which speaks to the commercial advertising around how efficient our insurance is — the Predica insurance operations. Naturally, though, Q4 numbers will be affected by what these events bring. That is very, very certain. Then the final point on protection: I can't identify anything besides commercial dynamism to account for the 22% rise in revenues from death and disability policies. So there's no particular event, no acquisition, no integration or anything like that — it's purely the business developing.
Pierre Chédeville
analystSorry to interrupt, but do you happen to know — just as an example — whether you have any sense of market share in that area, or anything like that?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMy take is that it's premature to say anything about market shares, for two reasons: we get those figures annually, and they arrive a number of months after the year has closed, so any indications would come far too soon. Still, it's obvious we've been busy on that front over the past month.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright, thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorMatt Clark from Mediobanca has the last question, sir.
Matthew Clark
analystGood afternoon. Two questions, if I may. First, I'm afraid it's about net interest income once more. Let me quote your remarks from last quarter, when you stated that a meaningful pickup in French retail net interest income wasn't expected until the second part of 2024. Yet clearly, this quarter showed a 7% sequential rise. So I'd like to ask what occurred that you hadn't anticipated when we last spoke — whether in terms of market rate movements or client behavior. Why did that improvement arrive already this quarter, when previously you didn't expect it to begin showing up for another year or so? Second, on the digital euro: perhaps you could comment on how, if at all, you are getting ready for it, and what impact you anticipate on Crédit Agricole's business over the coming years. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. Well, regarding NII, I fully stand by what I stated 3 months ago, but back then — first thing — we're not discussing a huge step up from Q2 to Q3. In fact, it's more accurate to describe it as stabilization. So as things stand, there is no improvement between Q2 and Q3. Second, what we're observing is likely a better level at LCL for new loan production than what we might have anticipated 3 months earlier, since new loan production between Q2 and Q3 — keeping in mind that Q3 includes the summer vacation month — shows a decline of only 3% at LCL from Q2 to Q3, and that is probably contributing to the NII stabilizing across those 2 quarters. And then, naturally, there are numerous other moving parts concerning the cost of the various liabilities, and those have also had a part in this stabilization. But if we're talking about genuine improvement, I confirm it will happen in 2024, and not truly before that. On the digital euro, you're aware that we are somewhat, I'd say, skeptical regarding customer appetite for the digital euro, and as of now we aren't entirely sure about the objectives being pursued through implementing a digital euro.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveNaturally, we do have teams focused on this. We're attempting to anticipate what use cases might exist for our customers, what could be incorporated into the digital euro to enhance their ability to manage cash, to utilize cash, to make small payments, and so forth. There's also a component of the digital euro that addresses large payments, and we're working on that at this very moment. And when it comes to large payments and large amounts, the benefits in terms of cost efficiency for those transactions are much more evident to us. But regardless, this is something that's expected to happen no earlier than 2027, so we still have some time to prepare. Once again, we need a clearer picture of what the digital euro's objectives are, and what form the digital euro will take for the individual customer, and among the many questions we're asking, one is particularly important: Will it be a token, or will it be somewhat like a bank account held at the central bank level?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveEvery one of those questions matters a great deal, and we are actively addressing them.
Pierre Chédeville
analystMuch appreciated.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. I know that was the final question, so once more, many thanks to everyone for asking them, and I'll see you soon. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, thank you for joining. The conference is now over, and you may disconnect your telephones.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.