Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 8, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon. I’m the conference operator. Welcome, and thank you for being with us on Crédit Agricole’s Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results Conference Call. Just a reminder that everyone is in a listen-only mode. <<operator_script>> At this point, I’d like to hand the conference over to Mr. Jerome Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Credit Agriculture S.A., in-charge of Steering and Control. Sir, please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveGood afternoon, and thank you very much. I appreciate your joining this conference. I'd like to begin right away with the presentation, on Page 4, if you're ready. The first point I want to emphasize is that we are delivering very strong results for this year, 2023, and in fact, for Crédit Agricole S.A., we are reporting a record level of net profit. That leads us to propose to the General Assembly meeting a dividend for 2023 of €1.05 per share, which would represent an increase of 24% compared with the 2022 dividend, excluding, of course, the portion of that dividend tied to 2019. In the fourth quarter, the insurance activities were affected by weather related claims, but it was nonetheless a good quarter, with revenues, excluding insurance revenues, up more than 9%, a recurring cost base that is completely under control, with an increase of 3.7%, and a cost of risk that remains in line with what we reported in the previous quarters. One last point on this page: let me remind you that we organized a dedicated workshop on climate strategy at the end of last year, and we remain committed to improving our policy on climate change and to deploying all the trajectories that we have published for the different sectors.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveTurning to Page 5, where the P&L for Crédit Agricole S.A. is shown, the first thing you'll notice is a full-year net profit of €5.9 billion. Underlying, that's an 11% increase versus 2022, and for the full year it comes to €6.3 billion, which is up nearly 20% against the stated net profit for 2022. Full-year revenues rose nine and a half percent, while the cost base grew by 8.9%. That gives us positive Jaws for the full year, and as a result we further improve the cost income ratio at the global level. Moving to the next page, which shows the figures for Crédit Agricole group, again you'll see a full-year net profit of €8.3 billion on a stated basis, up 3.3%, and €7.6 billion on an underlying basis, down 1.5%. So once again, a very high profit level for the group overall. Let me now go a bit deeper into how our strategic plan is being rolled out at the CASA level. Page 8 gives you some reminders of the global strategies we pursue on an ongoing basis.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo again, this demonstrates how efficient our model is — it brings together client capture, better equipment rates, and a lasting expansion of the range of products and services we offer to clients. Over on the right side of the page, you can see we managed to complete various acquisitions and close several partnerships recently, which gives further momentum to our business lines. And that takes us to the bottom right of the page — it produces a steady rise in our top line, which has grown roughly one third over the last six years and again nearly 10% in 2023 alone. Page 9 gives a few extra details on Crédit Agricole S.A.'s net profit for 2023. Just two points here. The first: the record profits we're reporting — an improvement of €1 billion in net profit on a stated basis and €600 million on an underlying basis — are spread across every business line: asset gathering, large customers, specialized financial services and retail banking activities. And on the right side of the page, a few indications that this gain in net profit is mainly, and almost exclusively, powered by the improvement in gross operating income.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe remaining items are either insignificant or actually negative, given the rise in the tax level and the other items. On Page 10, there are some items concerning profitability, which is and remains at a very elevated level. To repeat, 12.6% return on tangible equity at Crédit Agricole S.A. For a third consecutive year, we are above 12%, and if I look at Crédit Agricole S.A.'s profitability averaged across the past seven years, it has been roughly 12%, nearly without interruption. This again produces the dividend per share of €1.05, and you can observe that this is a threefold multiplication of the dividend level between 2024 and 2023 across the last nine years. Page 11, a reminder of the 2025 targets that we had established for the medium-term plan, and you can judge that we are exactly in line with those targets, with Net income Group share of €5.9 billion on an underlying basis, thus near the €6 billion level that we are committed to reach by 2025. I simply want to stress that this €6 billion level and above for 2025 comes together with the assumption of a cost of risk of 40 bps, which is somewhat higher than the one we had this year, indeed.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveReturn on tangible equity came in at 12.6%, a figure achieved during 2023 — ahead of the 2025 objective — and on the cost income ratio, our aim is to stay permanently under 58%. We currently sit at 55.4%, so we are comfortably beneath that ceiling we set ourselves. CET1 at the close of 2023 is 11.8%, which is clearly and comfortably inside the 11% target, and the last point: we are committed to distributing 50% in cash of our net profit. That is more than achieved given the dividend level of €1.05 for this year. So no issues on that point either. We keep moving forward along the strategic lines set back in 2022, developing the new business lines we announced last year, Crédit Agricole Transition and Energies and Crédit Agricole Sante & Territoires. We are continuing to build out the activities and to progressively put in place the different businesses that will fuel those two new operations, and we keep making headway on customer satisfaction and on digitization of our services and products, which leads to a good level of customer capture — close to 600,000 new customers net captured since the medium term plan began. Last page on these elements concerning the medium-term plan: we continue to develop our climate strategy, and at the end of last year we committed to net zero trajectories for five additional sectors, so that we now cover ten sectors, and the global strategy rests first and foremost on accelerated development of financing for low carbon and renewable energy sources, with some very ambitious figures shown on this page — among them a multiplication by three of the financing put in place by Crédit Agricole Transitions and Energies, and an increase by 80% between 2020 and 2025 in Crédit Agricole CIB's exposure to low carbon energy financing — and at the same time we are speeding up our disengagement from fossil fuels, with a sharp reduction we forecast of 75% in the emissions we finance through the oil and gas financing we have in place by 2023; the previous target was only a reduction by 30%.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll of this is fully integrated into our offers, into internal processes—including how we handle budgets—and of course into our reporting; tighter rules on reporting and disclosure are what push us to do this. Now let me go a bit deeper into the numbers, beginning on Page 15, with some details on what we did in 2023 and particularly during 2023's final quarter. Once again, customer acquisition was very strong—you can see the figures here: nearly two million new customers, and a net gain in the customer base of almost 200,000. We keep equipping those customers, improving what they have, through our various products and services—above all P&C insurance policies—and this year, and in the year's last quarter as well, production of new loans has slowed relative to 2022; that is naturally tied to higher rate levels, yet loan outstandings kept rising, and the rest of our businesses carried very good momentum, both across the full year and especially in the final quarter. I can offer some examples from CIB activities, where we recorded a very high level of activity in the last quarter—very close to what we had back in 2022, a record year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOn the asset management side, we saw robust inflows across the whole year, and particularly in Q4, which pushed assets under management back above €2000 billion. Insurance activity has also been really healthy for the full year, with a record share of unit-linked products within new inflows in life insurance, and very buoyant business in both P&C and protection, where premium income rose sharply. We're also giving you some figures on Crédit Agricole Italia, where new loan production has climbed significantly. Now let me go a bit deeper into how revenues moved. For the full year, revenues grew 12% on a stated basis and 9.5% on an underlying basis — a sharp rise — and for the quarter, we obviously need to split the revenue trend between insurance and the other businesses. On the other side, revenues rose 9% in the quarter, and that holds for the large customer division, for the specialized financial services division, and for retail banking as well. Turning to asset gathering, Amundi's revenues were at a solid level, and the effect we saw this quarter is concentrated in the insurance operations.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveRegarding insurance activities, revenues are down significantly versus the fourth quarter of 2022, which we restated under IFRS 17. Three main elements account for this decline in revenue. The first and most significant is that during the fourth quarter of 2023 we experienced a very high level of claims from weather events that occurred in that same quarter, compared with a fourth quarter of 2022 that had a low level of weather-related claims. As you know, IFRS 17 no longer permits smoothing the effect of such weather events through the use or build-up of specific provisions. We have mentioned this multiple times previously, and this is an illustration of it. The impact of those events has to be taken as a one-off. All the same, for the full year, revenues in the insurance business division stand at a very good level. The remaining two elements behind this quarter's lower revenue from the insurance business are, first, the restatement of Q4 '22 under IFRS 17, which raised the revenue level by roughly €100 million compared with what it was under IFRS 4.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThen the second piece is that we booked certain one-time items this quarter, and those accounted for roughly €100 million in the quarter as well, and they can't be repeated. So overall, on revenues, a solid level of activity and a steep rise in revenues for the full year, with momentum continuing at the same rate in the fourth quarter. Moving now to Page 17 on how the cost base evolved — again, a few specific items I'd like to address for the fourth quarter. In the fourth quarter there's evidently a sizable increase in the cost base of nearly €500 million on an underlying basis — sorry, on a stated basis, and even at €500 million on an underlying basis. But really, the largest portion of that movement is explained first by scope effects. We now have Crédit Agricole Auto Bank within our perimeter, and we also have the European activities of RBCs, which weren't in our perimeter a year ago. That accounts for nearly €200 million of cost base. We also have certain non-recurring items — base effects in 2022 of close to €100 million, plus certain one-time items in this quarter, the last quarter of 2023, again for close to €200 million.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo all in, the underlying cost base — the recurring cost base — rose just 3.7% this quarter. That's exactly consistent with the inflation level we're currently seeing in France and Europe, where most of our cost base sits. And for the full year, our cost base evolution is around 8%. Again, we have meaningful scope effects and some nonrecurring items, and if I restate the full-year cost base evolution to strip out those scope effects and nonrecurring items, the evolution comes closer to 4%. Still, even if I take the 8.1% or 8.9% cost base evolution, when I compare it with the top line evolution, we definitely have positive jaws. Moving now to Page 18, on gross operating income, what we see is that in the fourth quarter, if I set aside the asset gathering business division because of the specific elements related to the insurance activities, all business divisions show further improvement in gross operating income. And that's very much also the case for the full year, where every business division, including the asset gathering business division, is significantly improving its gross operating income levels this quarter.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOver on the right side of the page, the cost-income ratio at CASA keeps declining, whether or not you factor in the single resolution fund, and on this measure we remain in the strongest part of the peer sample of European banks we track. Moving to Page 19 and beginning with the cost of risk, you'll notice that in this year's fourth quarter the cost of risk held fairly steady, both compared with the fourth quarter of 2022 and compared with the third quarter of 2023. So overall, the cost of risk moved only very modestly across the full year — roughly 9% at Crédit Agricole S.A. and 6% at the Group — even with growth in outstanding loans. So credit quality has not deteriorated, either across the full year or in the fourth quarter. As you can see, that holds true across most business divisions. Turning to Page 20, I'd like to highlight that within CACIB's financing activities, the cost of risk remains very, very low.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHonestly, this quarter it's near zero, and for the full year it's quite moderate. At the consumer finance entity level, our cost of risk has now more or less leveled off at a higher point than in 2022, yet there's no further worsening at a level that, in absolute terms, sits well beneath the sharp peaks we might have seen previously. At LCL, and likewise at Crédit Agricole's regional banks, our cost of risk stands at roughly 18 bits, and it is concentrated in certain segments of small businesses or self-employed professionals that have been weakened either by rising energy costs or by particular difficulties in the real estate building business in France owing to — among other factors — the increase in interest rates. Moving to Page 21, the figures and trends are the same: a high level of loan loss reserves approaching €10 billion for Crédit Agricole S.A. and exceeding €20 billion for the Group globally, with non-performing loans overall at low 2.6% for Crédit Agricole S.A., 2.1% for the Group, and a coverage ratio that remains high, above 70% for Crédit Agricole S.A.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd well above 80% for the group worldwide. You can see this on Page 22, which shows that both the Group and Crédit Agricole S.A. compare very favorably against most of their European peers, and the diversification of the loan books we hold at both the Group and Crédit Agricole S.A. explains quite clearly why this cost of risk is low and why asset quality is so strong at this level. Let me move now to solvency on Page 23: at CASA the CET1 ratio held steady from the end of Q3 to the end of Q4, even with the top up we chose to propose for the dividend. The ordinary dividend level, applying our 50% payout policy strictly, would have meant an impact of 16 bps on our CET1 ratio. And the top up we decided to propose to the General Assembly meeting adds 6 bps. So overall, even so, we kept roughly 10 bps of solvency this quarter. Thanks to the strong level of profits, organic growth in our business lines accounts for just 8 bps, and since the other elements are fairly marginal, that in fact explains why the CET1 ratio at CASA is stable, well above the 11% target we have.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveLooking at the Group overall, the picture is broadly similar. Our solvency level remains the highest among all European G-SIBs, well ahead of the second-best capitalized G-SIB in Europe, and the absolute figure held steady across the quarter at 17.5%, which is a distance to target of 820 bps. On liquidity, to begin with customer deposits, these rose by nearly 3% during the quarter to a very elevated level, surpassing €1100 billion, and the diversification of those customer deposits remains very sound, which underpins the stability and the momentum of our deposit base. That in turn produces liquidity indicators that stay very well oriented, with liquidity reserves rising again this quarter by close to €450 million, bringing LCR ratios above 140%, both for Crédit Agricole S.A. and for the Group, whether measured at period end or across the whole period. One final point: we still have €27 billion of TLTRO left to repay. Naturally, our reserves are more than sufficient to handle those repayments, which fall due mainly in March and June of this year. That concludes my presentation. To sum it up briefly, we have enjoyed a very, very good year, with a momentum and dynamic that remained very active through the final quarter, and so we confirm our 2025 targets with plenty of comfort, and as ever we will do everything we can to exceed them.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it — I'm set to take your questions at this point.
Operator
operatorRight now, the opening question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley. Go ahead, please.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, hello there?
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystYes, hello there. Are you able to hear me?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHello? We can’t hear you. Yes, we’ll take the next question and then come back to you right after, since we aren’t able to hear you.
Operator
operatorI’m sorry about that. Our next question comes from Delphine Lee at JPMorgan. Please go ahead.
Delphine Lee
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for taking my question. I have two. The first concerns cost, and income, and cost more broadly. You're at 55% already, which is obviously much better than your long-term target of under 58%. So I'm just wondering whether the plan over the next couple of years is to keep delivering positive jaws of just 0.5 percentage point, or how that fits with your targets in '25. My second question is about capital and payout. Could you remind us of the components of capital between the acquisitions and the trim? And then, on payout, 105 bps is the new floor, so do you plan to stay flexible on the payout ratio and potentially pay out closer to, I don't know, 55%, 60% going forward? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you, Delphine. On the cost income ratio target, we feel at ease with that goal of staying under 58%, since we believe that given the business model we operate, given the kinds of risks we assume, given the size of the balance sheet we put to work, a cost income ratio of 58% is prudent enough — or under 58% is prudent enough — to let us absorb any level of credit risk that may emerge, and so for us this represents a very high degree of security. We don't see value in permanently improving the cost income ratio and permanently aiming for further gains in the cost income ratio. And we believe there is probably a better route to remunerating our shareholders and to boosting our development, which is to take the capacity we have had to generate cost cutting and improvements in the cost income ratio and keep investing. So definitely there is no intention on our part to change this level. We target and we've committed to staying under 58%. We will do whatever we can in order to remain under 58%, that is clearly a commitment, but we are also happy to invest in order to enhance our development capacities going forward.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo there’s no change to the cost-income ratio commitments. And no — naturally, there’s no decision to raise the cost base without a purpose, and we have the capacity to invest whenever needed to further enhance development. And the story will be more or less the same when it comes to the capital trajectory and how we view the capital situation. Let me begin with the first part of your question about the moving pieces that will occur with respect to capital going forward. The elements that are known for the coming 1 or 2 years are trim. We still have another €4 billion of RWAs to take, and it’s not certain whether that will be in 2024 or 2025. We have the closing of the Degroof Petercam acquisition, which will take place this summer. Again, the exact date is not set at the moment. We keep gathering the various authorizations we need to have before closing the deal, but it will be either the end of Q2 or the start of Q3. And we know this operation will represent a hit of between 25 bps and 30 bps of CET1 ratio at the CASA level.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAfter that, we have the final stages of the IFRS 9 phase-out — just 5 bps this year and another small 5 bps the following year. Then Basel IV kicks in starting January 25, and our view remains that, as things stand, it will be neutral for CASA when it comes to capital consumption and solvency. And again, on the output floor phase-in, at the end of the period — so in 2030 and even 2032 — it will bite, but only at the Group level, not at CASA's level. So these moving pieces are definitely small, clearly identified, and entirely compatible with the capital level we hold today. And going forward, we stick — and excuse me, there's one final point, which is a current development, since it's a deal announced only yesterday. Amundi's acquisition of Alpha Asset Management is set to close in the coming weeks, I believe. It's not a particularly complex transaction. And for us, it will mean 6 bps of capital consumption.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo again, that fits perfectly with the capital level we currently have. As for the dividend policy and payout policy, we'll keep adhering to the 50 to 50 policy, since we believe it's entirely normal to reward our shareholders generously, and we've demonstrated in the past that we're highly flexible when it comes to rewarding them. But we also don't want to put our growth capacity at risk. And we've also shown that we can grow both organically and inorganically in a profitable way. So we continue to anticipate further development of our business lines. Mostly organic development, but ready to look at opportunities if we spot some. So the 50% cash payout policy strikes us as perfectly aligned with this intention of being able to keep growing.
Delphine Lee
analystThanks a lot — that’s great.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. Let's return to the earlier question. I believe Morgan Stanley is now on the line. Is that correct?
Operator
operatorYes, our following question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley — go ahead, please.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi there, Giulia.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystHey Jerome, can you hear me at this point?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYeah, we can hear you.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystAlright, great. Perfect. Okay, so I have two questions. First, as you mentioned in your earlier response, Basel IV essentially won't affect you, and 11%, I believe, stays as your floor. So when it comes to capital generation, that leaves you with some surplus capital. Are there any bolt-on opportunities on the horizon? And what would you be looking for there — a continuation of what we've already seen, or any change? And second, if I look at the revenue trajectory on slide eight, I think there's of course been some very solid growth. Looking ahead, where do you see the most growth coming from across your divisions, and is there any part that is perhaps more challenged instead? Thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you for those two questions, Giulia. As far as bolt-on opportunities go, right now we aren't pursuing any particular one, which means there's no file we're actively working on at present that would turn into an opportunity in the very near future. Even so, I'd describe this as a standing focus for us and across the different business lines — while of course keeping up the strict discipline we've shown over the past two or three years when it comes to acquisitions, return on investment, return on normalized equity, the ability to integrate without any difficulty, and so forth. So we stand ready to seize opportunities. Nothing very concrete is on the horizon as of now. Though naturally, that's the very nature of opportunities — they can come up at any moment. Turning to the growth possibilities we see — mainly the organic growth possibility — for us it's limitless, because, once again, and Page 8 illustrates this strategy perfectly through continuing to draw in new customers, through upgrading those customers' equipment with the range of products and services we're already able to offer them today, and through seeking expansions, further expansion of that range of products and services, we have very solid growth engines, and so we remain of the view that Crédit Agricole S.A.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveIn the years ahead, that’s going to be a growth story.
Giulia Aurora Miotto
analystI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorJacques-Henri Gaulard from Kepler Cheuvreux has the next question. Go right ahead.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystGood afternoon. I only have a single question. Sorry — it concerned the one-off, the one-off items you reported, first in insurance and then more broadly across your cost base. One impression is that this was a decision rather than something forced, perhaps along the lines of thinking: well, the nine months had already been fantastic, we had already had a really very good year, so we might as well not make the year that exceptional and leave ourselves a little bit of leeway for 2024. Is that the right way to look at it? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell, Jacques, naturally we must apply every accounting rule to the letter, so there isn’t a great deal of flexibility—but of course, when you reach September with a result that strong, there’s always some room to fine-tune a bit how profit develops going forward.
Jacques-Henri Gaulard
analystThanks, Jerome.
Operator
operatorThanks. Our following question comes from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. You have the floor.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveHi Tarik.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystHi, Jerome. Your response to the previous question caught me a little off guard, to be honest. In fact, it's still on my mind. The way I see it, you're aiming to deliver surprises each quarter rather than simply steering expectations — so, moving on. My real question was about how you see profitability from a strategic standpoint. I realize that when you say above 12, that could mean anything, correct? Perhaps your budget has 13 or 14 in mind, or whatever figure. From where we sit, though, we can't extend you much more credit than that — than 12. As you noted, you've consistently delivered on average the same for 7 years, and above 12 across the past several quarters and years. You've been quite busy on both M&A and, I'd imagine, all of it very profitable, high-margin business, and you're still targeting the same net profit group share of above 6. So is it that you're being genuinely conservative and holding firm to your discipline of not shifting targets within the plan, or are there certain elements you believed could have gone better but didn't pan out that way? And then you have some positives from growth elsewhere, and you still feel that's the correct figure. And perhaps one question — you don't have to answer it, but I'll ask anyway: do you believe consensus reflects all the latest M&A, or bolt-on M&A, that you've completed?
Tarik El Mejjad
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell, thank you, Tarik. Well, I believe what we really ought to have done is place side by side the sequence of return on tangible equity figures we've published over the past seven years. That means somewhere between 11 and 12 and 13.1%, to be precise, since those represent the various levels we've hit. So on average, roughly 12, and on that same page, the trajectory of our top line, because obviously what we intend to offer shareholders isn't a return aimed at improving forever, since at some stage, trees don't grow to the sky, and certain profitability levels might be somewhat unsustainable or could generate excessive risk. Thus our value proposition is a growth story. So we're expanding the top line, we're expanding, naturally, the equity base — the tangible equity base — and we're offering a very stable return level on that expanding equity base. That's the value proposition we hold out. So a number of our rivals aim to raise their return level, and it's amusing to examine the gray bars in the bar chart on Page 10, where it's visible that between 2020 and 2023, certain competitors succeeded in substantially lifting their profitability, now nearing ours.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveBut is this also expanding alongside a rise in the base against which that profitability gets measured? I'm not sure. Still, our value proposition is plainly to keep delivering, to the greatest extent we can, very strong profitability levels over time while growing at the same time.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystThanks. I mean, the downside of that is, you know, in a quarter like the one we're in right now, when insurance volatility shows up — which is normal under an IFRS 17 valuation and isn't always particularly well grasped — you end up getting penalized, and that's part of your value proposition, of tangible book and so forth. So I hear you, and I respect that approach. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes. Perhaps I can use your comment as a chance to say something about how profitable the insurance business is. This quarter, even with such a high level of claims from weather events, we recorded a profit of close to €350 million in the insurance business division, and for the full year it's €1650 billion, which is up 12.5% compared to last year. So we're definitely very pleased with the insurance we have — even though this quarter was a bit more bumpy, it posted a very decent level of profitability, and in both cases, for the quarter and for the full year, it accounts for around 25% of CASA's net profit.
Tarik El Mejjad
analystSure thing, Jerome. Thanks.
Operator
operatorChris Hallam from Goldman Sachs has the next question. Go right ahead.
Chris Hallam
analystYes, appreciate you taking my questions. Two very quick ones, I think just regarding the cost of risk in consumer finance, €170 million in the fourth quarter. I believe you mentioned during the call that this was a normal level. So I'm just wondering whether that's the correct level to run rate or to annualize for 2024. So maybe some clarification on what you said earlier, and then just secondly, perhaps a broader question on the deal with Worldline — maybe could you just remind us what the strategy is there, and what do you think you can do with a 7% stake in Worldline that you weren't able to do before?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSure, Chris — those are both good questions. On the first one, about the cost of risk at CACF: on average, for the loan book that gets consolidated inside CACF, the cost of risk runs at roughly 120 bps. So it has more or less settled around that level. The assumption we built into the medium-term plan for this business, in terms of cost of risk — let's say through the cycle, or the cost of risk we consider compatible with the capacity to reach €6 billion of net profit — was closer to 160 bps. So overall, we sit below that peak level of cost of risk. Still, what matters from where I stand is that this is a business where we can fine-tune the credit granting criteria very quickly to adjust how much risk we are taking. I think we've stabilized, and that's fine by us. Naturally, we would like to see it come down at some point, and we hope it will. That said, 120 bps is perfectly okay. On the second point, regarding Worldline, the strategy is very clear.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOur plan is to finalize an industrial partnership with Worldline. We've been at work on this for many, many months now — actually even longer than that. We signed the agreement with them last year, in the middle of last year — I believe it was July. We're still awaiting approval from the European Commission for setting up the joint venture. And my sense now is that this approval from the European Commission will likely come through in March this year — so next month — which will let us formally create the joint venture. And it will go live very quickly, because naturally we've been preparing it for many, many months now. Then this joint venture will already begin working to broaden the range of products that the Group offers to its merchant clients. And this joint venture will also apply for a specific license so it can propose payment services directly to customers. And it will build its own business in partnership with the Group and their clients. So that's the strategy — to conclude and to develop an industrial joint venture and an industrial partnership with Worldline.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAfter what took place at Worldline toward the close of last year—the steep drop in the share price and a few other factors of that sort—we felt it made sense to demonstrate our confidence in Worldline and in its capabilities by acquiring this stake at a price we consider reasonable. And that, I would say, sits outside the scope of the industrial partnership we have concluded. So what really matters to us, what is key, is the creation of this joint venture, the growth of its business, and, step by step, the expansion of our industrial and commercial partnership. The 7% is a separate matter. It comes along with it. It was not a necessity. It was driven more by the circumstances, and it does not form the basis of our strategy.
Chris Hallam
analystAll right, thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorUp next, we have a question from Geoff Dawes at Societe Generale. Go ahead, please.
Geoff Dawes
analystGood afternoon, everyone. This is Geoff Dawes calling from Soc Gen. I have a couple of questions, if that's alright. To start with, regarding Amundi and, of course, the Alpha acquisition that was announced yesterday: in the past you've stated that you'll aim to keep acquisitions and integration work to a single one per operating division at any given time. Does Alpha count as large enough to meet that bar? Is that roughly your operational capacity for bolt-on deals in asset management for the year, or is it possible to run other things alongside it too? That's my first question. Moving to my second question, on French retail: as you begin to restart production somewhat in the mortgage book, could you give us a sense of what margins, pricing, ROE — whatever metric you use — new mortgages in France are actually producing, just so we get an idea on a standalone basis, before any cross-sell and all the rest? Those are my questions. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. So, the deal Amundi signed and closed — which we announced yesterday — matters a great deal to Amundi, since it adds meaningful complementary capability to the real asset operations of Amundi. That said, this is a very small operation. So I don't think it truly warrants or justifies a much longer acquisition ban, to borrow your phrase, because in my view this one is fairly straightforward to slot into the rest of Amundi. It isn't as complex, and, as I would put it, as big when it comes to assets under management and to the teams that need integrating as, say, the Lixor transaction, just one and a half year ago. So it's definitely not the same category, that's for sure.
Geoff Dawes
analystAnd it's available for transactions if necessary.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd I think Amundi is constantly laying out their strategy when it comes to possible acquisitions. On French retail, what we're observing right now — let's start with volumes, then discuss volumes, and then evaluate pricing a bit. On volumes, they were again somewhat subdued in Q4 of last year, as they had been for most of the year. And we've even seen a decline between Q3 and Q4 in new loan production. But at the same time, we've seen customer rates continue to rise, which we've been able to justify to our customers. So loans produced during Q4 carried rates on average 46 bps higher than those on loans produced in Q3. But you know that banks — French banks have been lagging behind the rise in the Azure rate ceiling over the last one and a half year. So I think we've now reached a level where that ceiling is no longer biting quite as much. Nevertheless, the rates that we've signed and not yet put in place.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAt the start of 2024, the average rate was 4.4%, which is, naturally, well above the back book. So this is, of course, a positive factor for LCL's future net interest income and for the market as a whole.
Geoff Dawes
analystExcellent. That makes it quite clear. Thanks.
Operator
operatorSam Moran-Smyth from Barclays has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Sam Moran-Smyth
analystHello, and thank you. Hi, Jerome. I have two questions, both about LCL. First, on this quarter specifically, you experienced a fair amount of cost inflation. In the slides, I believe you're calling out hierarchy and staff costs. So I'm wondering how much of that we should expect to affect each quarter going forward, or whether some of those higher staff costs are specific to Q4. Second, something a bit more strategic. At your CMD 18 months ago, you announced that BforBank would be relaunched. We haven't heard much more about it since. Looking at customer numbers alone, it appears to be somewhat behind the curve. So I'm wondering whether there's a reason a digital bank brand seems to carry less importance for CASA than it does for peers. Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you. If we begin with the cost base at LCL, we have booked certain one-offs at LCL, and also in other business divisions. Allow me to identify two of them for LCL. The first concerns a ruling in France from the Supreme Court, the Cour de Cassation, on how certain specific provisions relating to paid leave have to be calculated. As a result, every employer was required to recalculate those paid leave provisions. That produced an increase that was actually fairly substantial for LCL, given that LCL employs a large number of staff. So for LCL, I believe it came to roughly €10 million in extra cost, and it is a one-off — entirely a one-off. This will not recur quarter after quarter. It is merely an adjustment to the level of the provision. And from this point onward, the provision will be computed under the new rules laid down by the Supreme Court, so there is nothing to anticipate going forward. The second item relates to certain IT costs. We have chosen to write off some IT investments held on our balance sheet that would have generated amortization over time, and for various reasons — whether linked to obsolescence or other factors — we decided to remove those items from our balance sheet, thereby reducing the amortization effort over time.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd this represents, I think, somewhere between €10 and €20 million for this particular item. So altogether, at LCL, the non-recurring portion of the rise in the cost basis comes to €32 million in the quarter by itself. And moving forward, we'll keep watching the cost base at LCL much more closely, in line with what you saw over the recent period, which is likewise the situation globally for 2023, with a full-year increase that was held to under three and a half percent. Then as for BforBank, it isn't shifting the needle when it comes to the figures for Crédit Agricole S.A. globally these days. But we fully relaunched BforBank back in September, and so at present we have a very stable pace of customer acquisition, roughly 2000 customers per week, and it has been improving steadily over the last four months. And so we are on track. The aim is not to spend heavily to attract customers who will leave us very quickly, but to genuinely build a customer base that will stay loyal to BforBank over the long run, and that will value what BforBank specifically offers their customers.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveSo we're on track, and right now there's no concern about BforBank at this point.
Sam Moran-Smyth
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThank you.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. Please go ahead.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, Stefan?
Stefan Stalmann
analystHello, Jerome. Trust you're doing well. There are a couple of items I'd like to raise, if I may. On slide 19, the slide covering your cost of risk, roughly €66 million shows up under other provisions. Would you be able to walk us through what those involve? A portion of them, it appears, sit in Italy. My second question is also a risk-related one, this time about U.S. commercial real estate, which has become something of a hot topic lately, with individual banks in the U.S., Japan and Europe getting caught out. Most importantly, do you see any fault lines emerging in your own commercial real estate book, or are you entirely at ease with how that portfolio looks and the way it is provisioned?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThe €66 million provision at CASA globally is split between CACIB, on one side, and CA Italia, on the other. It consists of various types of provisions tied to legal claims, covering different matters. So it isn't a single particular problem — rather, it's assorted pieces of provisioning on a range of topics that aren't connected to credit risk, and there's nothing very specific involved. Nothing there, I'd say, is going to recur over time; although it doesn't fall under IFRS 9, it's more a matter of prudence than anything else. On commercial real estate, had we been observing indications of trouble within our portfolio, we would surely have booked some extra provisions, particularly given how the cost of credit risk at CACIB stood at almost nil this quarter. But what we clearly see is that no weakness has been identified in our portfolio — not globally, and not specifically in the U.S., where our portfolio is fairly small relative to the size we have worldwide. So no — naturally we are watching what is happening around the world, but there is no particular concern about our portfolio. And on Page 65 we give some further details about our portfolio.
Stefan Stalmann
analystThanks, Jerome.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Guillaume Tiberghien at BNP Paribas. Please go ahead.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThank you. Good afternoon. I have two questions and one point I'd like clarified, please. On the clarification: earlier you mentioned that the new business rate for LCL in Q4 was 4.4. Were you referring specifically to mortgages, or was that overall? And does it remain at 4.4 in January? The two questions are as follows. First, on cost: you appear to indicate that the underlying cost rate — cost growth — is roughly 3.7. Is there anything in 2024 that leads you to believe we could ease from that 3.7 level? Then the second question, a small detail, but on the RWA slide you flag plus €2.9 billion at corporate center stemming from some FX impact. So will we recover that €2.9 billion in Q1? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right. Thanks for those very specific questions, Guillaume. On the 4.4, as usual, if we're talking about the rate level, the home loans we approved in January — those loans aren't in place yet, and they weren't in place in the fourth-quarter figures, so by definition they'll progressively be put in place over the course of the fourth quarter and the first quarter of this year, and that level was already around the same level back in October. So I think what we can acknowledge is that we've hit some kind of plateau when it comes to pricing on new home loans in France, at least in our activities. On the cost base — what do we see going forward in 2024? In the first quarter we're going to continue to have some scope effects, in the first and second quarter, because the Crédit Agricole Auto Bank integration happened only at the beginning of the second quarter of 2023. So the first quarter is going to have a scope effect, and the integration of RBC's European activities took place only at the beginning of the third quarter. So again, in the second quarter we will still have the scope effect regarding RBC.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd then, naturally, we'll have the Degroof Petercam integration happening around mid-year, and there will be some integration costs tied to both RBC and Degroof Petercam. So those items are certainly going to factor into the overall cost base for 2024. But naturally, we'll give you all the specifics on those particular cost items. As for the corporate center RWAs, I can say that a first transaction accounting for €1.5 billion of RWAs has already been completed. So that portion is already out, and the second portion—I'm not sure precisely when it will arrive, but we'll look into that. But the one and a half is already gone as of the end of January. It was a specific provision we had to take given the RWA calculation rules, because we purchased the dollars to repay an 81, and repayment of the 81 has indeed been made. So at this point the dollars are no longer on our books, and therefore we no longer have the impact in terms of RWA.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystThanks. Perhaps my question about cost wasn’t understood correctly. What I was really trying to get at is whether, on the underlying basis and excluding the scope, you can do better than the 3.7 where we ended the year.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe’ll see. Of course, we’ll do everything we can to keep an eye on the cost base. We’ll definitely have the full-year impact of certain salary increases that we granted in the middle of last year. So during the first part of the year, that’s going to have an effect. But apart from that, we have adopted our budgets. We don’t disclose the budgets. Still, I can tell you that we’ve had some tough discussions with the various business lines to restrain as much as possible what they request in terms of their ability to spend.
Guillaume Tiberghien
analystI appreciate that.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Anke Reingen at RBC. Go right ahead.
Anke Reingen
analystYes, thanks so much for taking my question. There are two follow-ups I have. First, regarding the earlier question from <<inaudible>> about the 105 being a floor, I believe your response mentioned the 50% payout ratio. But my guess is that wouldn't rule out you revisiting where you land at year end and then potentially topping up. And second, on the cost of risk, around 40 basis points versus your current run rate, I guess that just assumes some buffer for the financing area, or is there a structural shift that we should be expecting that uses up the 40 basis points? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWell, we haven't described 105 as a floor. It just happens that, for specific reasons, it has stayed at that same level over the last three years. But in fact, this year's 105 isn't the same as the 105 we had in the previous two years. So I'll leave it to each of you to judge whether a floor exists or not. But we're not committing to any kind of floor, and the sole commitment we make regarding dividend policy is the 50% payout policy in cash. On the cost of risk, the 40 bps rests on an assumption that's actually a blend across the different businesses — retail banking activities, corporate banking, consumer credit. So it is a blend. It's a conservative assumption of what the cost of risk could be, I'd say, across the cycle. And it's also a component of the commitment on net profit, because what we're aiming for is to be able to deliver a net profit above €6 billion, even with a 40 bps cost of risk. So it's a calculation element, not a forecast, not a target. Of course, it's simply a component of the explanation of how you should view the over €6 billion net profit target for 2025.
Anke Reingen
analystAll right, thanks so much — that was clear. Thank you.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Pierre Chedeville of CIC. Please proceed.
Pierre Chédeville
analystYes, good afternoon, Jerome. One question about insurance, since we see that people are focused on that. Do you believe you'd have to alter your underwriting policy or your reinsurance policy for P&C, given the fact that now, unfortunately, we're probably living in a new world of Nat cat, more frequent, notably. And do you think there's something of that kind to do so as to stabilize your technical ratio? And I was also wondering, if we get a decrease in the rate, notably in the second half of 2024, do you think you'll have significant sensitivity regarding the discounting effect on your reserves that may probably disturb the understanding of your results in that part. And do you think it would be useful to provide any sensitivity of your technical ratio regarding evolution of rates in IFRS 17? My second question is about Italy. You mentioned that you've reached a ceiling on interest revenues, which is understandable regarding the high growth last year. But in the meantime, some of your competitors, Italian competitors, said that they see a continuing growth next year, less than in 2023, but still a growth in their interest margin.
Pierre Chédeville
analystWhat's your explanation for that? Thanks a lot.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, I'll take your final question first, since the answer will actually be pretty quick. I don't want to make any comment about what one of our competitors has said. What I observe — and in fact we're already observing it during Q4 — is a degree of stabilization at a high level in net interest income at Crédit Agricole Italia, and we're probably not in exactly the same position as the other Italian banks, because in Italy we have likely written more fixed rate loans than the market average, since we believe that is good for consumers and therefore, ultimately, good for our cost of risk. On the P&C insurance side, regarding underwriting criteria or re-insurance policy, it's obvious that each year, as we prepare for the following year, there are certain elements we're going to work with. Naturally, we build the cost of risk of year x into how we price the new policies for year x plus one. And certainly, following a year in which the cost of risk — the cost of weather events — has gone up significantly, that gets reflected in the pricing of the policies.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThat will happen, naturally. The second piece is that we are in discussions with the various reinsurance companies to adjust how much reinsurance we take on. And there is a constant trade-off between what this reinsurance costs and how much protection it gives us. Beyond that, you may have noticed that last year Pacifica, the Group's P&C Insurance Company, issued a cat bond to supplement its coverage of natural catastrophe impact going forward. So this is an ongoing adjustment. We have to work on these different elements to adapt to what we can anticipate regarding the intensity and cost of weather events. But it is quite certain that the cost of weather events will rise going forward, and the only way to cover that rise in cost is through the level of premium we have to apply. By definition, there is no way for us to absorb the charge in place of our consumers. Then, regarding the impact of rates on the discount dimension of the combined ratio, I do not have any sensitivity in mind on this topic.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI’ll see whether we have anything like that on hand. If we do, I give you my word that we’ll follow up with you. But I can’t recall any sensitivity analysis of that kind.
Pierre Chédeville
analystAlright, thanks a lot. Alright, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveI believe there's still one more question left. Two, three? Go ahead, please.
Operator
operatorAlberto Artoni from Intesa Sanpaolo has the next question. Go ahead, please.
Alberto Artoni
analystGood afternoon, and thanks for taking my questions. Yes, just a quick follow-up regarding cost. I'd like to get a sense of whether it's fair to say that surpassing your 12% return on tangible equity target would matter more to you than exceeding your cost-income target of below 58%. And the reason for that would be the kind of bolt-on acquisition you've completed, where you might end up with a higher cost income but a very attractive return on tangible equity. Then my second question, very quickly. My understanding was that you anticipated some recovery at LCL during the second half of 2024. Does that still hold? Has anything shifted on that front? Thank you.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAlright, let me begin with your first question, since it's a tough one. And I hope that up to this point we haven't had to make a trade-off between the cost-income ratio and return on tangible equity. Because on average, every bolt-on acquisition we've completed had a cost-income ratio, after synergies, of 58% or lower. So in terms of our commitment, nothing about that dilutes our cost-income ratio. So no, I'd say there's no jeopardizing of our commitment to hold the cost-income ratio under 58%. And at the same time, all of those operations were producing a return on tangible equity — a marginal return on tangible equity, on normalized equity, of more than 12%. So all of those operations satisfied both criteria simultaneously. I can't think of any operation that could raise the question of a trade-off between those two elements. Of course, that would be a puzzling situation, but as things stand, I can't think of any operation that would pose such a question. Turning to 2024 and the forecast at LCL. Of course, when we say we expect a pickup in NII at LCL at some point in 2024, that rests on a certain number of assumptions about how rates evolve — namely, that rates would not begin to fall too quickly and would not fall too sharply, because of course, if rates drop again very fast, and I don't expect that to happen, the situation would shift a little, but under the assumptions we've made — and that assumption is namely that rates won't decline before probably September — this is what we expect.
Alberto Artoni
analystI appreciate it.
Operator
operatorBenoit Valleaux from ODDO BHF has the next question — please go ahead.
Benoît Valleaux
analystYes, good afternoon, Jerome. I have two questions on. Hello? Can you hear me? Yes, okay. Sorry. Two questions about insurance. One on P&C, one on life — maybe starting with P&C, just a kind of follow-up question about the profitability outlook. You mentioned price increases after Nat cat losses. So how do you view the level of profitability? So is this year — I mean, is it fair to assume, for example, that your combined ratio could return to the 2022 level at, I don't know, 95% or below that under IFRS 17? And the second question? In life, we've seen a decrease in outflows on traditional life insurance product in Q4 versus Q3. Despite this, you have reduced your level of PPE reserves, meaning that you've tried to boost your level of crediting rate paid to policyholders. So I just wonder if it's a kind of defensive move in order to preserve your book of business, or do you see this business as being profitable and therefore you'd like to push sales on this product going forward?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveOkay, two solid questions, and they're not easy to address. Put simply, naturally, the combined ratio went up in 2023 relative to 2022. And I'd say that every factor I brought up before — underwriting pricing policy, reinsurance policy, CAT bond insurance — all of those are in place so that the combined ratio keeps improving as we move forward. We can't promise that in '24 we'll return to where we were in '22, but we definitely intend to bring that combined ratio down going forward. On the life insurance side, we've been deploying the PPE for precisely the reason it was created. In fact, the PPE exists to go along with rising rates so as to protect the portfolio, grow the business, and remunerate the clients — the policyholders. So we've used a modest portion of the PPE we held. We still have 4.5% or 5% of Euro denominated products outstandings in PPE for the future. But obviously the whole point of the PPE was for it to be used, and by law we have to use it within the eight years following the building up of the PPE. So it's there to be used, and we've used it for all the purposes you mentioned — to preserve the book, to remunerate the customers and to improve their loyalty and to increase their loyalty, and also to apply our client policy, which is a policy that needs to be client friendly.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAnd so we considered that it was reasonable to do that.
Benoît Valleaux
analystAll right, thanks.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur final question comes from Societe Generale. Please go ahead.
Analyst
analystHi, this is <<inaudible>> calling from SocGen. Are you able to hear me?
Jérôme Grivet
executiveYes, without a doubt.
Analyst
analystHi there. Many thanks. I appreciate you taking my questions, and actually I have 2 please, both about your Italian retail business. So sorry ahead of time if I'm overlooking anything here, but you're describing a pretty strong performance in that business this quarter. Yet when we look quarter on quarter, it actually appears that your revenues in the division are down rather significantly. So could you explain that for us, and also say whether you expect NII growth to slow quite sharply over the coming quarters, even amid a context of gradual potential rate cuts, as you put it earlier. And then second, again on Italy, but more broadly, you're giving us a figure for customer acquisition in the business this quarter. Could you remind us what your retail market share is in the country and whether you've been pleased with how it has evolved over the recent past? Those are my 2 questions. Thank you very much.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveThanks. Regarding that final question of yours — which nation are you referring to? Italy once more?
Analyst
analystStill Italy. Yeah, that's right.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveAll right. So in Italy, what we saw over the last quarter was that revenues, of course, rose globally for Crédit Agricole Italia — if you can just bring up the page — revenues were up 4.4%. And the net interest margin came down slightly between Q3 and Q4. So it's exactly what we've already been saying between Q2 and Q3, meaning that we've more or less hit some kind of plateau when it comes to NII in Italy, because rates have stabilized and even begun to come down a little if we're talking about long-term rates. So this is fully consistent with what we had in mind, and I think there's nothing further to add there. Of course, the same assumption for how the feds will evolve going forward applies as for LCL. Regarding development in the country, the last significant operation we made was the Creval acquisition, an inorganic growth operation. But right now we're working on organic development at Crédit Agricole Italia. And when it comes to the number of new customers we've managed to capture in Italia, we've managed to attract 175,000 new customers at Crédit Agricole Italia, which was an acceleration compared to 2022.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveWe therefore mix inorganic expansion whenever opportunities arise with organic expansion whenever it can be done. And let me just note that in retail banking in Italy, our market share now stands at 5%, the highest level we have ever reached.
Analyst
analystAppreciate it.
Jérôme Grivet
executiveMuch appreciated. That was, I believe, the final question. So once more, thank you for being on this call, and we look forward to connecting with you over the next few weeks or months. Goodbye.
Operator
operatorThank you, everyone, for taking part in this call — that's the end of it now, so you're free to hang up your phones.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.