Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 1, 2024

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 77 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone. This is the conference operator speaking. Thank you for being with us and welcome to the Crédit Agricole conference call covering 2024 second quarter and first half results. Please note that everyone has been placed in listen-only mode for the duration. Following the presentation, you will have a chance to ask questions by pressing star and one on your telephone. If anyone requires assistance at any point during this call, they can signal an operator by pressing star and zero on their telephone. I would now like to hand the conference over to Mr. Jérôme Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Crédit Agricole S.A., in charge of steering and control. Sir, please go ahead.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good afternoon — or maybe hello is easier given the hour when we're speaking. Hello, everyone. I'm glad to walk you through the results for the second quarter and for the first half of 2024 at Crédit Agricole S.A. To sum it up briefly, and we'll begin right away on page four, we're reporting very good results for both the quarter and the half year. For the first half, the number is there in front of you: EUR 3.7 billion of net profit, and EUR 1.8 billion for the quarter, which shows a decline of 10% versus Q2 2023. Naturally, we'll go deeper into those figures a bit later. But if you restate the 2023 basis to strip out exceptional items, and if you look across the 2024 numbers, which also contain certain exceptional items, taken altogether, net profit at Crédit Agricole S.A. is stable for the quarter at the high level of EUR 1.8 billion. So, as we already did last quarter, we confirm fully and with confidence our ability to reach and exceed EUR 6 billion of net profit for the full year, which is again the result we initially projected for 2025 and which we now plan to deliver one year ahead of schedule.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

There may be a couple or three more items on this page. Once again, this strong result for the quarter comes from a high level of revenues, and naturally we'll take a look at where those revenues came from. We keep reporting a very efficient Cost-Income Ratio — 53.4% for the first half of the year and 53.2% for the quarter. And perhaps two final points. Return on tangible equity sits above 15% — 15.5%, to be precise. So for the first half of the year, that's a very high return on tangible equity, well above the 12% target we set for the medium-term plan. And finally, the CET1 ratio at 11.6% is down 20 basis points versus the end of March, and we'll go through the reasons why, but it is definitely above — far above — the target we had for the plan, which was and remains 11%. Moving to the next page, the following page, you'll find all the figures for the first half and for the quarter, both for the group and for Crédit Agricole S.A. At group level, clearly, we're having a very good first half of the year, with a net profit that's up EURO 4.4 billion.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

We're seeing a gain of almost 6.5%. Both revenues and gross operating income have risen. Looking a bit closer at CASA's figures, as I mentioned, profit for the first half was at a very high level — EURO 3.7 billion. That's an increase of plus 14%, and EURO 1.8 billion for the quarter. Again, it appears to be down 10%, but when restated for the various exceptional items I was referring to, it's more or less stable compared with Q2 2023. Revenues have increased for both the first half and the quarter, and gross operating income is up for the first half, and — as we'll show a bit later — it's also up for the quarter on a comparable basis. Liquidity and solvency are at very high levels. I've already mentioned solvency for CASA. At group level, it stands at 17.3%, also down 20 basis points for the same reasons, and liquidity is very high — it has even improved over the last quarter. Moving to the next page, there are some indications regarding the activity of the group and its different businesses over the course of the last quarter and the first half of the year. Overall, we're seeing a very good level of activity in the retail banking businesses, with a good level of customer acquisition and customer capture, both in France and in the group's other retail banks in Europe.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Customer deposits rose again in France and Italy during this quarter. Home loan activity in France has stabilized to some degree. That level is clearly far below what we saw before rates began climbing, yet it is leveling off, and that's an encouraging sign. Production of new corporate loans in France is up slightly. As for our other retail businesses outside France, new loan production has risen quite substantially. Finally, on consumer finance loans, particularly car financing, new loan production remains at a very high level — roughly EUR 12 billion for the quarter. Turning to our other activities, beginning with insurance, we had a very strong quarter in insurance, with meaningful growth in life activity flows, and premium income in P&C and personal insurance protection continued its steady growth over the quarter, while the penetration rate, or equipment rate, of our customer base keeps rising across all our retail banks in France and Italy. On asset management, you saw Amundi's results last week — they were very good — and indeed it was a solid quarter for inflows and for the level of assets under management, which hit a record level.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

Finally—though not least importantly—I’d note that CIB activity was once again quite strong this quarter, with CACIB posting a record half year. On the right-hand side of this page you’ll find a set of figures that show this very healthy level of activity across all areas. Moving now to page eight, we’ll look a bit more closely at how revenues at CASA evolved. The reported revenue level is up 1.8% for Q2 2024 versus Q2 2023, an increase of plus EUR 120 million. That said, we definitely need to restate the Q2 2023 figures to strip out exceptional revenue items—mainly revenues tied to the reshuffling of our agreements with Stellantis, which produced a positive one-off of close to EUR 300 million in revenues. You may also recall that in Q2 2023 we booked some exceptional revenues related to the final settlement of a litigation known as Échange Image Chèque, Check Image Exchange. We were able to recoup close to EURO 60 million of revenues—EURO 40 million in the corporate center and, if I remember correctly, also around EURO 20 million at LCL. Restated for these items, the Q2 2024 increase comes closer to 6.7%.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

This quarter saw revenue rise by slightly over EUR 400 million versus Q2 2023. On the right side of this page you can see the consistent quarter-over-quarter growth we've delivered going back to at least 2017. Indeed, since 2017, the top line at CASA has grown 50% for the year's second quarter, even though we moved to IFRS 17 in 2023, which, as you're aware, produced a one-off reduction in the overall revenue level. Page nine contains some details on how the cost base has evolved. So clearly, looking at the reported figure alone, the rise is fairly substantial: an extra EUR 400 million, up 12.5%, roughly 12.5%. But naturally, you need to dig into that number somewhat to see what's behind it. The first factor is that over EUR 150 million of extra costs stem from the scope effect, since this quarter, relative to Q2 2023, includes a full quarter of RBC activities plus one month of Degroof Petercam activities, namely June. Altogether, that amounts to roughly 150 plus EUR 156 million in costs, which must be restated if you want to gauge the organic, underlying movement of the cost basis.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

The second factor is that in Italy, this quarter we were required to record the annual payment to the local deposit guarantee fund, the DGS, amounting to EUR 58 million. In the past, that contribution was recorded in the year's fourth quarter. So it isn't exceptional in the sense that it happens annually, but it is exceptional that it was recorded in Q2, whereas before it was recorded in Q4. So when restated for these two factors, the Q2-on-Q2 rise in the cost base comes to just EUR 180 million, an increase of 5.7%. And once more, if we look a bit more closely at that EUR 180 million rise, you conclude that roughly EUR 130 million comes from higher staff cost and roughly EUR 50 million from higher IT investment costs. As for IT investments, that is clearly tied to the growth of our activities and also, to some degree, to the growth of the various requirements from the regulator across the board, I would say, which obliges us to keep developing certain tools so that we can report some information better to the various supervisors.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

Now, taking a closer look at staff costs: within that EUR 130 million rise, roughly EUR 40 million consists of extra provisions for variable compensation, at both CACIB and Amundi. That marks a gain over the Q2 2023 level, and it clearly reflects the strong financial and commercial results those two businesses delivered. So this is definitely money that hasn't been paid out yet. It's set aside, and whether it gets used will be decided at year-end, based on how those two businesses perform over the full year. One final point on fixed remuneration: the rest of the EUR 130 million, so approximately EUR 90 million. You might recall that a year ago, given the inflationary environment in Europe, we agreed to give general salary raises mid-year, effective from the start of July, which comes on top of our usual practice — a set of individual salary increases occurring at the start of the year, in January. That means a Q2-to-Q2 comparison captures the impact of both raise events: the July one and the January one.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

Naturally, once we’ve worked through the Q3 figures, the only factor remaining will be the impact of the January salary raises, so for the third quarter of the year we should expect a far smaller movement on that part of the cost base. Overall, then, this is a very understandable pattern in the cost base, producing a cost-income ratio a touch above 53%, which is very, very substantially under the 58% cap we had established under the medium-term plan. Turning to the next page, there are some points on cost of risk. In short, it is highly steady relative to earlier quarters, whether measured against Q2 2023 or against the average for the last four quarters. So this is clearly a situation showing no meaningful weakening in the quality of our loan books. That is also borne out by the fact that the NPL level remains highly steady at 2.2%, while the coverage ratio is still very high. I referred to the 2.2%, sorry, for the group, and 2.5% somewhat lower for Crédit Agricole S.A. And the coverage ratios, for both the S.A. and the group, remain very high and are even a little higher this quarter than in Q1.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

So certainly, while we need to keep a close watch on risk conditions in every market, there is no indication of things getting worse, and cost of risk for the Crédit Agricole S.A. perimeter remains under the assumption we built into the medium-term plan. Page 11 gives you the summary of all these P&L items. What's visible on the right side of that page is that, on an underlying basis and leaving out the contribution to the deposit guarantee fund in Italy, we show for this quarter a rise in gross operating income — a modest rise at this point, but a rise nonetheless. Naturally, looking at the acquisitions we've completed, we aren't yet at the point of drawing out all their benefits. The marginal cost income ratio of those acquisitions is still not where we want it once integration is fully done. The remaining items are not material, although the tax level sits above where it stood one year ago. Taken together, this produces stability in net profit at Crédit Agricole S.A. from Q2 2023 to Q2 2024.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

Moving to the following page, I'll share a few remarks about solvency at Crédit Agricole S.A. I referenced the CET1 ratio at 11.6%. That represents a modest decline of 20 basis points relative to the close of Q1 2024. Naturally, it sits well above our SREP requirement — by 300 basis points. In fact, looking at the bar chart on the left side of this page, you'll notice that after distribution, or after reserving for the dividend, we produced 22 basis points of capital, yet 35 basis points were used up because two M&A deals effectively closed during this quarter: the Degroof Petercam acquisition, accounting for 28 basis points, and Amundi's purchase of Alpha Associates, adding another 5 basis points. That is precisely why the CET1 ratio shows a small dip — though there's nothing concerning when it comes to our ability to organically generate a meaningful amount of extra solvency each quarter, beyond what's required to support organic growth in the business line. Much the same picture applies at the group level overall, where you likewise see a modest 20 basis point reduction in the CET1 ratio, to 17.3% — clearly far, far above every regulatory threshold, 760 basis points above the SREP level — along with a leverage ratio holding steady at 5.5%, and the remaining ratios similarly well in excess of any requirement.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

To wrap up, I'll just give you a bit more detail on where the group stands with liquidity, and that picture, clearly, remains a very pleasing one. Liquidity reserves actually edged up a little during the quarter, to nearly EUR 480 million across various categories of reserves. The LCR and NSFR ratios sit well above what's required, and on the LCR ratio, 146%, with only EUR 700 million of TLTRO left to repay before year-end. We repaid EUR 5 billion of TLTRO in June. A stable resources position of close to EUR 200 million, which is, I'd say, well above our steering target. And finally, customer deposits remain high and in fact rose slightly as the quarter went on, with, as always, a significant share — roughly 2/3 — of those deposits coming from individuals and SMEs. Maybe one more point on how the customer deposits break down: when it comes to retail banking activities in France, this quarter we've begun to see a slight increase, a slight rebound, in sight deposits. As you know, over the last two years we saw a strong decline in sight deposits, with switches onto regulated savings accounts or term deposits.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

And at this point, once again, sight deposits are up a little. So over the next few quarters, we'll need to see whether this confirms that the mix of customer deposits has now completely settled. I think at this point I'll just recap the figures I've already gone through by noting that, with EUR 3.7 billion of net profit in the first half of the year, we're clearly on course to hit our goals for the full year. Many thanks, and I'm ready to take your question now.

Operator

operator
#15

Much appreciated. Speaking is the conference operator. At this point we'll open things up for questions and answers. If you'd like to pose a question, you can press star and one on your touch-tone phone. Should you want to drop out of the queue, just press star and two. When you ask your question, please lift the receiver. Anybody with a question can press star and one right now. Our first question comes from Tarik El Mejjad at Bank of America. Go ahead, please.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#16

Hello, and good morning, Jérôme. Tarik here from Bank of America. Actually, just a couple of quick questions. The first one, and maybe asking this so soon isn't fair, but there were some headlines, some news in the Repubblica, about a possible new solidarity levy aimed at Italian banks and, this time, insurance companies too. Do you have any comment on that? Has anything like this been discussed before? It looks like this time there will be more of a consultation with the banks before proposals come out on how it will be calculated. Any views? Second question: you mentioned that Crédit Agricole is willing to be active in European consolidation. Were you referring mostly to the kinds of deals you've done so far in wealth management and other smaller bolt-on transactions, or are you thinking of something bigger? And maybe I'll add a quick one on Degroof Petercam: can you give us an update on the potential impacts after full integration, if you have any newer ones than those you gave us pre-consolidation? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

Thanks, Tarik. On the new bank levies in Italy, I don't have any view on that point. You know that banks are an easy target for governments that want to impose taxes and to raise public money. The main point for us is that competition has to be maintained. So if there is something new in Italy, which is not something I can confirm, it would apply to all banks, and so it would simply mean a change in the conditions under which we operate in this country, which is going to hit all banks. So it's not necessarily good news, but it's not something which is a game changer. So definitely, we remain very cool about that. Consolidation, we continue to stick to the same motto. First point, we do not believe that consolidation in large commercial or retail banks in Europe can take place cross-border simply because there are too many headwinds. We continue to think that there might be some room for further consolidation in specialized business lines. We've been able to seize opportunities in the past. I think we've been able to seize them while maintaining a very good financial discipline on those operations, and we'll continue to do so going forward.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

Finally, regarding the group, perhaps two or three points. The first one is that this is quite new for us, since we only started taking control of Degroof Petercam at the beginning of June, so it's fairly recent. Second, we still aim for an extra contribution to our net profits of between EUR 150 and EUR 2 million by 2028, which I already mentioned on the first quarter call. This quarter, we've recorded two cost items tied to this acquisition. The first is integration costs, which began at a modest EUR 5 million, because, again, the group has only been with us since the start of June. We've also booked — though it's not on the cost line — some acquisition costs, EUR 12 million, so it hits the net profit but isn't on the cost line. And then perhaps one final remark, which is that we've taken the entire solvency impact of this acquisition this quarter. At the end of June, we have only 68, if I recall correctly, 68% of the capital, or 65% of the group's capital. But we will have 80%, or close to 80%, by the end of July.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

So this will definitely mean a bigger stake for us, but we've already accounted for the entire solvency effect of that. We've also factored in the solvency effect of possibly acquiring the remaining 20+% that the minority shareholder has a lock-up on, and they do have the ability to stay involved over the long run. But without question, we've taken the full impact of it. So there won't be any further solvency impact coming from the group. Okay?

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#20

Much appreciated.

Operator

operator
#21

Our following question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley. The line is yours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#22

Hi there, Giulia.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#23

Yes. Hello there. Good morning, Jérôme. My first question concerns capital. Could you remind us of the effects that are coming, particularly on the regulatory side, now that FRTB has been delayed? So that is a straightforward question about numbers. Then, secondly, on French retail, you appeared encouraged by how sight deposits have been developing. Could you share some outlook regarding how you expect that revenue line to evolve over the remainder of the year? And I have a very quick one regarding slide 21, where you remark on large customers. Essentially, the slide states, Good level of activity supported by structured equities. And my question is simply, what do you mean by structured equities? Because I am aware this was a strong quarter for equity derivatives. That is what we heard from every bank that has reported before you, but I did not think that was a big area for Crédit Agricole at all. So yeah, this comment surprises me. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#24

Alright. I'll begin right away with the final question. We have a modest level of activity when it comes to equities — whether that's equity capital market, equity derivative, or the various categories of structured financing for equity acquisition. So this remark applies to all of those equities businesses. For us, it's a small business. If you look at the slide on page 21, it's captured in the light blue element at the top of the bar chart. So it's all combined, and it's also combined with investment banking revenues. So clearly, it isn't a very significant amount, but we simply wanted to note the fact that, just as has been true for much larger players in equity derivatives, we enjoyed a good quarter in this business. On the capital front, what we can say is that, looking ahead, the first point is that we have the final 5 points of the IFRS 9 phase-out still to come. That will happen in 2025, and after that we'll be finished with IFRS 9. Then there's Basel IV. Once again, I confirm that, at the global level, Basel IV will be more or less neutral for Crédit Agricole S.A., but unfortunately it will be neutral across several steps.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#25

So in Q4 we'll see a negative step, and that comes from tighter requirements around leasing activities. That should amount to roughly 13 basis points, or 1/3 of solvency, for CASA in Q4 of this year. After that, the bulk of Basel IV kicks in at the start of 2025, and overall that's going to be positive — positive by more than 13 basis points, probably 15 or 16 basis points. There are many, many elements involved: operational risk, tighter requirements on certain categories of credit risk. But going the other way, there's the easing of the constraint on the carrying value of the insurance activities. So taken together, that should be positive, probably by 15, 16 basis points. Then FRTB, as we see it today, will only bite in 2026. And as of today, our thinking is that it will have a negative impact of a few basis points. I don't know exactly how many bps, but probably 5 or 6 bps, 7 bps. But it's quite uncertain at this point. So overall, more or less neutral, but unfortunately in several steps. And then maybe the last point I can mention, without giving any precise figure, is the fact that we have announced the transaction between Amundi US and Victory Capital.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#26

Our expectation is that at the CASA level, this deal will release some capital, though we can't say at this point exactly how many bps of extra solvency it will produce. And this transaction will likely close in Q4, which is exactly when we'll have to absorb the leasing effect of Basel IV. So it will probably ease the Q4 headwind somewhat.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#27

Thanks. What's the outlook for French retail?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#28

Yes, French retail — of course. I was forgetting that question. And I shouldn't, because I know it comes up on every one of our calls, even if French retail sits within Crédit Agricole S.A. and isn't a huge part of revenue generation. What we saw this quarter is a solid level of NII, actually lifted by some one-offs. So it's hard to say precisely how NII would have moved without those one-offs, but probably a low single-digit change, which is clearly positive, though not as strong as the +11%, 10.9% we are formally reporting this quarter. As I mentioned in my introduction, what we see is a stabilization in the breakdown of customer assets, which is positive because, of course, and even a slight rebound in sight deposits, which will definitely help if it's confirmed, for the overall weighted cost of customer liabilities. The second point, which may help going forward, is the gradual decline in the cost of the regulated savings accounts. So beginning August 1st, as of today, there is a cut from 5% to 4% on a specific category, which is called Livret d'Épargne Populaire.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#29

For LCL this is minor — roughly EUR 2 billion to EUR 3 billion in deposits. At the regional bank level within Crédit Agricole, though, the figure matters far more: approximately EUR 25 billion, if my memory serves. Then, perhaps at the start of next year, we would witness a cut in the Livret A rate, since under the forward curve one should typically observe short-term rates and inflation averaging near 2.5% in the coming year. That would certainly affect a larger base of customer deposits. It would likewise help the average cost of customer liabilities. As for loan book yield, pinning down the exact speed of further improvement remains hard, since everything hinges on new home loan production. Clearly, although new home loan output rose somewhat in Q2 versus Q1, it is hard to say whether, given today's political uncertainty in France, the catch-up will carry into Q3 and Q4. A great deal of uncertainty certainly persists, yet the genuinely encouraging development is that the mix of customer deposits has stabilized.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#30

That’s great. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#31

Thank you.

Operator

operator
#32

Delphine Lee from JPMorgan has the next question — go right ahead.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#33

Yes. Hello. Hi, Jérôme. Thanks for taking my questions. I really just have two quick ones. First of all, on insurance: could you give us a bit of color on how strong this quarter was—anything you can highlight regarding pricing, product mix, or anything in P&C or life insurance that would help us understand it better? And my second question is about capital. You previously spoke about optimizing RWAs somewhat, if I remember this correctly. I mean, do you still have the EUR 4 billion of TRIM impact, I think, coming maybe in 2025? I'm just wondering what we should expect, because organic growth was relatively strong this quarter. And also just a very quick one on the capital increase for employees that you're doing in Q3. Do you intend, like last year, to offset this dilution with a buyback? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#34

I'll begin right away with the final question, since the response is plainly affirmative. So this comes as no surprise. A capital increase is coming that will likely be recognized by the close of Q3, though it will be offset during Q4 through a dedicated share buyback operation. When it comes to insurance activities, what we're seeing is unmistakably strong commercial momentum, which — with all the intricacy of IFRS 17 — is more or less reflected in how revenues evolve and how net profit evolves. But the clear starting point is that we enjoyed a really solid quarter on the commercial side for life activities, a meaningful amount of gross inflows, and for P&C and protection, a healthy level of premium income, and for P&C, a fairly normal level of sinistrality, which likewise supports revenue generation. So overall, once again, given all the intricacy that IFRS 17 brings, activity was solid this quarter, and markets were fine from an insurance standpoint. That, then, translates well into revenues and profits. RWA optimization: we keep working on our ability to optimize our RWAs.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#35

Perhaps just a couple or three extra clarifications concerning the questions you raised. That EUR 5 billion TRIM effect we have discussed for a number of quarters now forms part of the day-one Basel IV impact I mentioned for the start of 2025. So there is no extra integration cost. It is reflected in the +15 or 16 basis points of solvency generated by Basel IV coming into force at the beginning of 2025. As for RWA usage across the business lines, it was a dynamic quarter at CACIB, with one particular item — a technical one that is probably partly reversible — namely that the rules were slightly modified to update the internal rating of our various counterparties, with the ECB's stance until now being that we had one month following the compulsory 12-month period in which to make the adjustment. And now that extra month is no longer required. So this results in a few or several million EUR of additional RWAs this quarter, which we will endeavor to eliminate over the coming quarters. But without question, a solid activity level at CACIB does indeed translate into a greater amount of RWA, which is normal.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#36

Also, keep in mind once more that should we feel things are moving too quickly from an RWA standpoint, we have the option to deploy securitization or other methods to outstream RWAs, even if that comes at a cost.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#37

Thanks — I really appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#39

Moving on to the question from Guillaume Tiberghien at BNP Paribas. Please proceed.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#40

Thanks so much. I have two really small questions about French retail. First, regarding the current account deposit: you mentioned that you're possibly seeing tentative signs of improvement. Could that be because of the last three weeks of June, when people were somewhat paralyzed by the elections and chose to place money—even though it doesn't pay much—into very liquid deposits? My second question is an attempt to quantify the one-off in NII in French retail, since you don't provide it. I noticed the tax rate in French retail is only 22% rather than the usual 25%. Can I work backwards and essentially conclude that this reflects a roughly EUR 35 million untaxed private equity gain in there? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#41

Guillaume, I’ve always appreciated how skillfully you can figure out numbers. So it’s definitely a good path to recognize that level of private equity. What I was referring to is that, probably on a restated basis excluding all the one-offs, the positive change in NII in French retail ought to have been at lower single-digit levels. So definitely positive, but definitely much less than the +11% that we are posting. When it comes to sight deposits, the reasoning you’re making is exactly why I am somewhat cautious before confirming that the customer deposit breakdown in French retail has fully stabilized. We have seen the latest GDP figures for the French economy that were published two days ago. And what we have seen is that, surprisingly, the level of GDP growth for the quarter was good, 4.3%, but was not reached with a good level of consumption, which we were expecting, actually. So there is certainly some attentisme in consumer spending. This attentisme may be linked to the political situation. It’s probably also linked to some more, I would say, conjunctural elements like the weather. Definitely, what we hear on the ground is that many, many restaurants and bars that were planning to have outside offers suffered a lot in June because of the rain.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#42

That is unfortunate, yet it is the reality. There is another factor here: French customers likely have not completely recognized that, on average, their consumption power is actually improving, since salary increases at the start of this year were generally higher on average than inflation. Purchasing power for French consumers is indeed rising, but this has not been fully acknowledged yet. The narrative about the difficulties of daily life for French citizens is probably also fueling this caution before spending. We need to see exactly where this goes. We will also need to see whether this causes some outflows from sight deposits if consumption begins to rebound. We will discuss it during the coming quarter.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#43

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#44

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#45

Our following question comes from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research. The line is yours.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#46

Hi, Jérôme. Thanks for taking my questions. First, I wanted to ask about the insurance business, please. I believe this is the first time in probably 5 years that you've had net inflows into Euro life policies. Do you think there's a more permanent — maybe an early sign of a more permanent switch of clients who actually never quite liked the Unit-Linked and now have an opportunity to go back into Euro policies given the better rates environment? And if that is, in fact, the case, what do you think this means for, let's say, solvency and capital management in the insurance business in the medium term, if anything? And the second question is on your dividend plans or the payout plans. The accrual rate that you apply every quarter seems to be a bit uneven. It's now 54% of EPS for the first half. So it's close to your 50%, but not exactly at 50%. How should we think about the accrual for the second half of the year? Is it going to follow just 50% of EPS? Are there other considerations? And what does this all mean for the dividend for the full year, if anything? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#47

I'll begin with your second question. Really, we ought to look more closely at the figures, since what we're accruing is precisely 50% of the attributable, payable, or distributable results. So I'm not sure exactly what accounts for the gap between the 54% you calculated and the 50% we are in fact accruing. There's likely some technical reason for it, though I don't have it in mind at the moment. We'll look into that and get back to you with the explanation. But the clear intention is to stay with the 50% payout on what we consider normal to distribute. So there is probably a technical explanation. On the second part.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#48

Oh, maybe there was — sorry about that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#49

Yeah, yeah. Go right ahead.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#50

In Q1, there was roughly a EUR 200 million negative 81 FX impact, as I recall. I don't know exactly how you handled that when it comes to your payouts, but perhaps you looked through it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

Right, exactly. So my suspicion was that it stems from the AT1s, because as far as the result goes, there's nothing requiring restatement. So it's items that don't flow into the P&L that are indeed having an effect, and it's probably originating from the AT1. I agree.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#52

All right, I've got it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#53

When it comes to insurance, clearly there's simultaneously greater appeal for Euro products and reduced appeal for UL, since you're aware that the robust expansion in UL products over the last two years came from fixed income unit-linked offerings that we created using bonds issued by the group and wrapped into unit-linked products. And given that long-term rates have peaked and credit spreads have narrowed considerably, we're no longer able to offer the same kind of remuneration on these UL products. So simultaneously, you've got Euro products looking more attractive and UL products looking less attractive. So indeed, this drove those positive inflows for Euro products during the quarter. But to be sure, we're discussing under EUR 1 billion of net new inflows during the quarter. We don't view that as a risk for capital solvency monitoring of the insurance activities. It's positive for our customers. We're pleased about it. We're offering a remuneration that reflects the reality of the assets we can hold in the portfolio. We don't regard this modest level of positive inflows as a threat to how we manage our capital position in the insurance business.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#54

Thanks a lot — that’s great.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#55

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#56

Joseph Dickerson from Jefferies has the next question. Go right ahead.

Joseph Dickerson

analyst
#57

Hello, and thanks for taking my question. Could you talk a bit about how strong the consumer finance business has been, since it really stood out compared with your peers? I believe on the last quarter's call you mentioned that some of the front book margins were beginning to pick up, and I'd imagine that could speed up depending on whatever happens with interest rates declining through the remainder of the year. So what would you say the outlook is for that business, and what's driving it? Because that performance was quite a standout relative to peers. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#58

At the same time, the business is undergoing a profound transformation in how its activities break down, because we've invested heavily to develop what we call mobility financing — that is, the entire car-financing business, which is growing far faster than the rest of the business. On page 23 you can see it's expanding at a pace of close to 14% in terms of outstanding, while the remainder is developing more in the region of around 4%-5%. So that's one point. And the second point is that indeed, we're now slightly improving, and we'll keep improving, the average margin, because we keep benefiting from lower refinancing costs while trying to keep passing on to customers the past rate increases that we had to withstand. So definitely, this is a business developing well from a commercial standpoint and improving from a strictly financial standpoint. And last point, perhaps, we've seen a stabilization and even a slight improvement in the cost of risk of this business. So that's also a final point that is positive for the business.

Joseph Dickerson

analyst
#59

Much appreciated. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#60

Our next question comes from Jacques-Henri Gaulard at Kepler Cheuvreux. You have the floor.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#61

Yes, good morning. There are two questions here, and really they're connected. The first concerns the rise in the regional banks' stake in CASA, which now stands at 62.8%. So my question is, could you remind us what the ceiling is for them — if they've said anything — and how far they can actually go up? And the second question, clearly tied to that one, brings us back somewhat to acquisitions: thanks to what you've achieved with Xavier and Philippe over the past 10 years, your multiple has roughly doubled, and that isn't necessarily true of every French bank. You have a tool that lets you basically buy something — perhaps not large, I'm not talking about a big consideration — but you have optionality to use that multiple in order to develop. Might that be something under consideration, or is it not on the cards at all? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#62

Thanks, Jacques-Henri, for the kind words about what we've been doing. Let's begin with the regional banks' stake: the only thing they've communicated is that they didn't intend to exceed 65%. So in theory, they can move from 62.8 up to 65% without any need to change their formal communication. And clearly, should they wish to go past 65%, the sole requirement beyond the technical ones is simply to declare a new internal stake target. But I have not heard anything about a change to that 65% target. As for using our multiple to finance M&A operations, here's what I'd say: I don't want to rule out or confirm any kind of significant operation. What I do want to say is that any potential M&A transaction must first be examined on its own strategic and financial merits. Then, if it makes sense strategically and financially, we need to check what the best way to finance it is. Definitely, the starting point is checking whether the operation makes sense from a strategic standpoint and whether it meets our financial criteria. Then, of course, on how we fund the operation, we have a series of options.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#63

To this point, the approach we've taken—and it was the most efficient way to handle things—has simply been to draw on our capacity to generate capital beyond what we distribute and beyond the organic growth of the business lines. Over the past 3 or 4 years, that is precisely what we did. That doesn't mean we're obliged to keep to it going forward, but so far, it's exactly the best way to do things.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#64

Thanks a lot, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#65

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#66

Moving on, our following question comes from Flora Bocahut at Barclays. The line is yours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#67

Yes, hi there, Flora.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#68

Yes. Hello, Jérôme. I have two questions. First, about the ECB rate cuts at the end of the quarter in June. Looking at your business mix at Crédit Agricole, it seems rate cuts could actually help many of your businesses a lot. So I was wondering whether it was only a month and there's been noise elsewhere. But have you seen any impact, whether on your businesses, on your client behavior, on the way your competitors reacted across the market post the ECB rate cuts? The second question is about your net profit guidance for this year. You did, obviously, a very strong H1. You've achieved now EUR 3.7 billion of net profit in H1. I know you don't like to change that target too often, but the question is simply, is there anything that we need to expect in H2 beyond the normal seasonality that will explain why you keep that guidance unchanged despite the strong H1? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#69

Thanks, Flora. On that first question, the reduction so far has been quite small, and it happened halfway through June. As a result, there hasn't really been enough time for it to alter anything—whether you look at the direct mechanical effect on our figures or at how customers are behaving. What I'd say is that the one area where a reaction was triggered that really shouldn't have occurred was home loan pricing, since in a country where home loans are provided on a long-term fixed-rate basis, home loan pricing clearly ought not to be affected by a short-term rate cut from the ECB. Yet it was—from a psychological standpoint, I'd say it generated a certain momentum toward fiercer competition among banks, and that has contributed to the decline we've observed. At this stage it remains manageable, but still, there has been a drop in the pricing of new home loans. So what we have to watch over the next quarters is, first, whether the ECB truly stays with what we're expecting—namely, two further rate cuts through the end of the year, and then another two or three cuts the following year, so as to arrive at a neutral rate that we estimate at roughly 2.5%, in a setting where the rate curve would then normalize across all maturities, because as things stand we remain in an abnormal situation.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#70

Yet at this point, the effect on us has not been particularly large. On the net profit path for 2024 — yes, at the close of June we are somewhat ahead of schedule for hitting the target of more than EUR 6 billion by year-end. Seasonality is normal, and as all of you are aware, summer is a softer stretch in some of our businesses. That is plainly true for CIB activities. December brings another seasonal pattern. When the year has gone well, everyone halts work at the start of December. So this may produce a lower level of revenues in certain activities, for both Q3 and Q4. Apart from this usual, standard seasonality, there is nothing negative to anticipate in the second half of the year.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#71

Alright, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#72

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#73

Our next question comes from Anke Reingen at RBC. You have the floor.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#74

Thanks a lot. I’ve got two quick questions. First, regarding that 5.7% year-over-year underlying cost target, are you basically confirming it should be close to a peak, given that your cost base in the second half of last year was already higher? Or should we expect to keep running at that pace when we factor in inflation and possible investments? Second, I wanted to ask whether you have anything to add about the ECB’s review of leveraged finance exposures, and whether you’re comfortable giving any sense of how large the exposure in scope at your bank would be. Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#75

Our cost base isn't hitting a peak, nor is it expanding quickly. I attempted to clarify why we actually saw a rise this quarter, and that was driven in large part by the scope effect — roughly 40% of the total cost increase. So the scope effect isn't a peak. It's a fresh step up that we've taken, and that also leads to a fresh step up we need to take on the revenue side. But without question, within our cost base, we'll have the full RBC scope beginning now, and from Q3 onward there's no longer any sort of scope effect, since it was already there in Q3 2023, and the same will hold for Q3 2024. As for Degroof Petercam, there will be a further increase in Q3 relative to Q2, because during Q2 we had just one month of Degroof, while in Q3 — beginning in Q3 — we'll definitely have a three-month-per-quarter Degroof cost base. Beyond that, there's no plan to massively grow the cost base. We believe inflation is now considerably curbed, and we're no longer inclined to hand out general salary increases mid-year, unlike what we did in 2022 and in 2023.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#76

So we'll keep an eye on the cost base in the usual way, using budgets that set out the level of cost we consider acceptable for the year ahead. And then, naturally, the ability to respond as the year unfolds, since the key KPI we focus on is the cost-income ratio — particularly when it's broken down by business line. That will remain, just as it has been previously, the primary lever for managing the group's cost base. On the ECB's review of leverage finance, we hear plenty about the ECB's worries regarding leverage finance. The ECB monitors us routinely from a range of angles, and that includes leverage finance portfolios. We don't anticipate anything material from the various reviews that have happened before or that could happen later concerning this loan category. So no major concern, and nothing material to expect on that front.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#77

Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#78

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#79

Chris Hallam from Goldman Sachs has the next question. Please go ahead.

Chris Hallam

analyst
#80

Okay, thanks for the question. So first, just on Italy. On the volume side, there's clearly a bit of a change, I guess, in the approach to mortgages. Production had been trending down 13% in the first quarter, and now it's up 40% year-over-year in Q2. NIM is stable, I guess, Q2 versus Q1. I think it was also stable Q1 versus Q4 last year. So just looking through the rest of the year for Italy, how do you expect that business to sort of trend both in terms of volumes and in terms of margins? And then secondly, and maybe just a bit of a broader question on M&A, and perhaps it's a bit of a follow-up to Jacques-Henri's question earlier, but you've done quite a few transactions now, right? Like Alpha, Degroof Petercam, RBC, Worldline. How confident are you in your process and your team in identifying targets, assessing potential value creation, delivering the integration? Is that machine now pretty much as well-oiled as it can be? And does that give you greater confidence in doing something bigger than perhaps you would have felt comfortable doing beforehand?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#81

That's quite a broad question you're raising on this second point. How confident are we in our ability to reach the various opportunities? I'd say every colleague at the investment banks is there to ensure no opportunity slips past us. So if I were to show you how many blue books land on my desk on a regular basis, you'd feel entirely reassured about our capacity to reach every possible opportunity. Our task is far more about digging into them so as to genuinely pick the best operations, rather than simply having access to the deal flow. More seriously, yes, we have a highly seasoned team to assess, to evaluate and to negotiate these operations. I have full confidence that we will keep being able to do so, even if the number of operations grows or even if the size of the operations grows. But definitely, we've carried out quite significant operations in terms of size in the past. So absolutely no doubt that we have this capacity to remain very disciplined in the management of the transactions themselves. Then there is, of course, this very important question regarding integration and the capacity to really take advantage of the acquisitions in terms of enhancing our scope of activities and accelerating our organic growth.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#82

So this really sits with the heads of the businesses. That's why I keep making certain, on an ongoing basis, that no single business head is handling an excessive number of initiatives of this type at once, since pulling off an integration successfully depends on management commitment. We have to ensure that when the leadership of a specialized business line is busy with a transaction, it isn't, let's say, thrown off by the prospect of another deal arriving too quickly. So on that we are extremely, extremely careful. In Italy, new loan production has clearly been positive this quarter. We picked up somewhat, and the pickup was particularly strong in home loans. That much is true. Pricing works as it does in any country: it comes down to competition, and I imagine the major retail banking players in Italy are likewise striving to stay competitive here. So we don't anticipate pricing rising and improving dramatically, but we are finding our way. Given that we aren't especially large in the Italian market, we can stay selective while still achieving a certain amount of organic growth and preserving a solid margin level.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#83

We're feeling good about how things will develop for the business in Italy moving forward.

Chris Hallam

analyst
#84

That’s quite useful.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#85

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#86

Our final question comes from Pierre Chédeville at CIC. The floor is yours.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#87

Yes. Hi there, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#88

Hi there, Pierre.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#89

Moving to consumer credit and insurance, a follow-up here. On consumer credit, you referenced a decline in production and also brought up China. Can you walk us through precisely what took place in that market? Is this a significant trend, or was it a one-off event? And then, apologies, on insurance, you cited the strong commercial momentum, of course, but you also referred to technical experience gaps. I'd like to understand what portion of revenue growth stems from those gaps versus how much comes from commercial momentum. One final question: you also noted solid expansion of creditor insurance internationally. What exactly do you mean by international? Does that refer to Italy, which is in fact your number two market, or does it include other countries as well? Many thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#90

Thanks for those really detailed questions, Pierre. Turning to consumer credit: it's obvious that in Italy—in China, sorry—in China, as you're aware, we operate a joint venture with GAC, a major Chinese automaker. And it's evident that at the start of this year, GAC has been showing some softness, I'd say, when it comes to generating new loans, and there may be two factors behind that. The first factor is the reality that in China, just like everywhere else, there's competition pitting car loans against leasing, and our activity covers car loans only. Beyond that, there's the broader situation in China: consumption has been sluggish over the last several quarters, so that's hurting us too. But the key point, certainly, is that together with our partner we don't cover every channel for distributing car financing in China, since for now we handle car loans only and not leasing. And once more, leasing accounts for a meaningful share of the business. On insurance, I won't be able to say precisely how much of the revenue growth comes from what we refer to as the experience gap, if that's the correct way to put it in English.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#91

On the operating variance — that's what Cécile is referring to, and yes, that's right. So I can't say precisely what share of revenues comes from that. Maybe a simple way to put it is that we do have a positive element from operating variance at the same time, but there's also some unfavorable impact from market movements. So this quarter we have a negative effect on the CSM coming from market elements. So I don't know exactly how that offsets the other piece, but it doesn't go just one way, I'd say. And then the last question had to do with creditor insurance. If I recall correctly, your question was about what we mean when we refer to international activities. So the credit insurance operations within Crédit Agricole Assurances are the operation we have in Dublin, which works throughout Europe alongside our consumer credit business. So it isn't specifically Italy — it spans all of Europe. It's in Germany with Creditplus. It's in Portugal with Credibom. It's in several other countries too. So it's definitely a pan-European business.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#92

All right, thanks a lot.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#93

All right, I realize that was the final question. So this gives me a chance to wish each of you a really happy summer with plenty of rest. For my part, I think mine will get underway pretty soon now. And I'll be glad to talk with all of you once more in about three months. Bye-bye. Have a good day.

Operator

operator
#94

Ladies and gentlemen, thanks for being with us. That brings the conference to a close. You're welcome to hang up your phones now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.