Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 6, 2024

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 70 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Hello, everyone. The operator here speaking. Good morning to you all, and thanks for being with us for Crédit Agricole's presentation of results for the third quarter and the first nine months of 2024. I should remind everyone that you're all in listen-only mode for now. Following the presentation, you'll have a chance to pose questions — just press star and 1 on your phone. If you require any help while the call is underway, pressing star and 0 will bring an operator to you. I'd now like to hand things over to Mr. Jérôme Grivet, our Deputy Chief Executive Officer. Sir, the floor is yours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Thanks so much. Morning, everyone — I'm glad to walk you through the numbers we're releasing today. Once again, we're reporting really strong results for the third quarter of 2024, and in short, they come very near what we posted for the second quarter of that same year. Net profit at Crédit Agricole S.A. for the first nine months of the year comes to EUR 5.4 billion, and for the third quarter alone it's EUR 1.7 billion. On the face of it, that's down roughly 4.7% Q3 on Q3, but if you restate it for a reversal of home purchase savings plan provisions that we booked and discussed last year, then in fact Crédit Agricole S.A.'s net profit this quarter is up 8.2%. On top of that, I'd point out that across the first nine months of the year we still have a really, really strong cost-income ratio, 54.4%, and a Return on Tangible Equity that remains comfortably above the 12% target, at 14.5%. And the final item on this first page: our CET1 ratio is up 10 basis points, at 11.7%. Turning to the next page, page five, you'll find the key figures for both the group and Crédit Agricole S.A.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

Just a few quick remarks on the group's performance over the first nine months of the year. Net profit for that period is flat, though if we once again restate for that particular provision reversal we recorded a year ago, net profit for the group rose roughly 4% across the first nine months. Turning to Crédit Agricole S.A., restating for that same item, net profit over the first nine months would have shown a 12.2% increase. Two more points on this page. The cost of risk — which we'll discuss in greater detail later in the presentation — is broadly unchanged at a moderate level, for both the group and Crédit Agricole S.A. Then, finally, the group's CET1 ratio rose another 10 basis points quarter on quarter, reaching 17.4%. On page six, a few items concerning activity in the quarter. To sum up very briefly what took place during the quarter, we can say that we keep demonstrating how efficient our model is. Customer base expansion at all the regional banks and all the group's retail banks is driving, and will keep driving, growth across the business lines.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

Expansion and progress in this business line are likewise boosting how appealing the group's retail banks look, which lifts customer acquisition even more. Once again in this quarter, we brought in roughly 500,000 new customers across the group's various retail banks in Europe, lifting the customer base by a net amount above 100,000 customers. Retail-related activities developed in a fairly solid way during the quarter, and it may be worth noting that home loans are beginning to bounce back in France, with a sizable rise at both the regional banks and LCL in Q3 versus Q2. Turning to the Large Customers' businesses — CIB, asset management, and insurance as well — the third quarter of this year delivered a very strong period of activity. Among the various items I could cite, Amundi is once more hitting a record level of assets under management. Revenues at CACIB also reached a record level, and the assets administered by CACEIS keep climbing this quarter. If I go a bit deeper into revenues on page eight, let me begin with the bar chart on the left-hand side of that page.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

On an underlying basis, revenues rose 7% for the quarter, an increase of 425 million EUR. Looking a bit at how the various business lines performed, we can note that Asset Gathering activities were sharply higher, up 214 million EUR. Naturally, that reflects the benefit of integrating Degroof Petercam into Indosuez, but even so, as you've seen, Amundi is reporting a strong rise in revenues — you saw Amundi's publication last week. It is only the insurance activities — and perhaps we'll take questions on this — that posted roughly flat revenues this quarter, even though Crédit Agricole Assurances is delivering a sharp gain in its bottom line for certain technical reasons we can go into. In Large Customers' activities, both CACIB and CACEIS are showing a sharp revenue increase. There was no scope effect this quarter. So the EUR 166 million rise in the top line is purely organic. Within the Specialized Financial Services division, results were more or less stable for the quarter. That ties to the fact that at Crédit Agricole Personal Finance & Mobility, we're still lagging somewhat on margin following last year's sharp rate increase and also the end of 2022.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

As you’re aware, quite some time passed before we could hand on this rise in refinancing rates to customers. As a result, the margin on new loans keeps getting better, though that isn’t entirely true of the margin across all outstandings globally. In retail banking activities, revenues appear to be down slightly, by EUR 36 million, but when restated for the reversal of a home purchase savings plan provision at LCL of EUR 52 million, the division is overall a bit higher, reflecting higher revenues at LCL, higher revenues at the International Retail Banking entities outside Italy, and a modest decline within Crédit Agricole Italia tied to lower market rates. Finally, the Corporate Center shows what looks like a steep drop in revenues, minus EUR 187 million. Yet here too there is a base effect linked to the home purchase savings plans provision reversal, which came to EUR 230 million last year. That means, restated for this item, Corporate Center revenues are up considerably. On the right-hand side of this page, you can see that we keep delivering a strong rise in revenues quarter after quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

And across the past seven years, that works out to roughly a 40% increase that we've managed to deliver. On the next page, a quick closer look at the cost line. When you examine how the underlying cost line moved on the bar chart at the left of that page, there's a sizable rise, up 8.2%. But the analysis shown on the right side of the page tells you that three significant items need to be taken out of that increase before you can judge how the cost line is really trending on a recurring basis. The first item is obviously the scope effect tied to bringing Degroof Petercam in. That adds a cost base of EUR 112 million sitting inside Indosuez this quarter. The second item is that at both Indosuez and CACEIS, we carry certain integration costs specific to this integration period that won't remain in our cost base indefinitely, roughly EUR 30 million. And finally, last year we also had a one-off in the cost line — a positive one — which came from a reversal of the bank levy in the U.K.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

for EUR 30 million. So leaving aside those three items, the recurring cost base moved up by just EUR 141 million during the quarter. That works out to a 4.1% increase. And interestingly, that marks a meaningful deceleration relative to the same recurring increase we reported in the second quarter of this year, which came in at 5.7%. Turning to page 10, there are some points on the cost of risk for Crédit Agricole S.A. The overall cost of risk level is quite stable, both against Q3 2023 and against Q2 2024, in fact slightly lower than in Q2 2024. This naturally reflects a mix of different developments and different cost of risk levels across the various business lines. To put it really briefly, what we can say is that at CACIB, cost of risk remains stable at a very, very low level, at roughly 15 million EUR of net cost of risk at CACIB. Cost of risk is likewise stable, at a higher level of course, in the Specialized Financial Services division, particularly within the consumer credit business line, yet measured in basis points against outstandings it keeps edging slightly lower. At LCL, cost of risk is somewhat higher, both in absolute terms and in basis points relative to outstandings, and you would observe a similar pattern in the regional banks, which means that in the retail banking activities in France, above all for self-employed professionals and SMEs, we keep seeing a modest rise in cost of risk, with an overall level that again remains moderate relative to what we could have seen back several years ago, and then in the international retail banking activities, cost of risk is down quite significantly once again this quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

That is very much what we see in Italy, and the same holds for the other International Retail Banking entities, including a reversal of provision at Crédit Agricole Ukraine among other items. On NPL ratios, CASA's continues to be stable and low at 2.5%, and at group level it is even lower, 2.2%. Coverage ratios remain very high — above 70% at CASA and above 80% at group level. All in all, and you'll see this on page 11, we are once again posting very good results for this quarter. Net profit is up 10.9% on an underlying basis. That's what the left-hand side of the page shows, with net profit rising across most business lines, especially when restated for last year's home purchase savings plan provision reversal. That's the case quite significantly for the asset gathering division. It's also true for the large customers' division. Net profit is more or less stable in the Specialized Financial Services division. And in retail banking activities, if you restate for the home purchase savings plan provision reversal, plus a specific element at Crédit Agricole Ukraine — namely the fact that the corporate tax rate in that country has been raised, and this quarter we are one-off topping up the corporate tax provision since the start of the year by an amount of EUR 40 million.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

That accounts for the bulk of the seeming decline in net profit at the retail banking division. Overall, then, we saw a substantial rise in net profit, in underlying net profit, and in spread across the majority of our business lines. On the right side of the page, you can see that once you strip out the 2023 home purchase savings plan provision reversal, we are reporting Gross Operating Income that is higher by slightly over 100 million EUR and, once more, net profit that is up 126 million EUR, or plus 8.2%, again with that item excluded, so overall a solid level of profitability, and we keep on building that profitability. Turning to page 12, a few points on solvency, beginning with CASA, so as I mentioned, the solvency ratio, the CET1 ratio, has risen 10 basis points this quarter. In fact, it is slightly above 10 basis points, nearer 15 basis points, though the rounding effect produces that 10 basis point figure. Retained result is strong, contributing 19 basis points of retained result solvency effect, even after an additional reserve for dividend distribution of €0.25 this quarter. As a result, we now have EUR 0.83 of dividend accrued on our books as of the end of the third quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

Organic expansion within the business line creates a solvency drawdown of 14 basis points, yet within that figure I should note a 5 basis point rise tied to the higher carrying value of the insurance activities, which did not upstream any dividend or dividend element this quarter. As you know, whenever the insurance activities upstream a dividend, that lowers the carrying value and produces a meaningful cut in RWA consumption. This quarter we also have some positive items related to OCI and other methodological elements. That brings us to an 11.7% CET1 ratio at CASA level, which is 3.1 percentage points above the regulatory requirements. At group level, on the next page, our CET1 ratio stands at 17.4%, again up 10 basis points, and broadly the same factors explain this improvement: a high level of retained results, a fairly high level of organic growth in RWA consumption from the business lines. Also that item concerning the insurance activities, plus the fact that both at the regional banks and at LCL, we see a rise in RWA consumption in the corporate segment tied to some downgrades of certain counterparts, which of course lines up perfectly with what I said about the cost of risk.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

Turning to the remaining solvency ratios — whether that's the leverage ratio, TLAC or MREL — those are comfortably above the requirements as well. Page 14, the next page, gives you some details on where the group stands in terms of liquidity. Our liquidity reserves remain very high; there is a EUR 12 billion reduction, which isn't significant, but at EUR 466 billion — sorry — the liquidity reserve level is clearly well above the target we use to steer that position. And the various ratios we disclose, LCR and NSFR alike, at both the CASA level and the group level, continue to sit very substantially above our targets. We still have a tiny EUR 700 million of TLTRO left to repay, but that is absolutely non-significant. As for customer deposits, on the right-hand side of this page, the same point I made last quarter applies again: we are seeing the overall level of customer deposits stabilize. And, even better for the average cost of our customer liabilities, we are also seeing the mix of customer deposits across the different categories stabilize. Page 15, the next page, shows the more detailed income statement for Crédit Agricole S.A.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

I don't think I'll get into the detailed P&L during this initial presentation, but naturally I'm glad to take questions if there are any. And perhaps before I wrap up this introduction, a few points about how we keep supporting the energy transition, with fresh climate commitments that Crédit Agricole Assurances has announced, including something interesting we're discussing today: the fact that we've signed an agreement with the Caisse des Dépôts in France. As you know, a substantial portion of the regulatory savings accounts we collect has to be centralized at the Caisse des Dépôts, and the Caisse des Dépôts has agreed to transfer some liquidity collected on our regulated savings accounts back to us, on the condition, of course, that we use these amounts to finance green loans and green projects. So we've entered into this agreement, and the Caisse des Dépôts is committed to upstreaming to us a little bit more than EUR 5 billion of liquidity under this scheme over the course of this year and next year. And then we're also providing an update on the various KPIs we track regarding the growth of the financing we provide for the energy transition.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

To wrap up these opening remarks, let me just repeat that, with the help of the strong results from this year's third quarter, we confirm we will hit every one of the financial goals we set out originally for 2025 as early as the close of this year. That includes, among other things, the goal of exceeding EUR 6 billion in net profit in 2024 — as early as 2024. Thanks once more, and I believe we're ready now to take your questions.

Operator

operator
#15

Thanks very much, sir. Speaking as the conference operator, the question-and-answer portion of the call starts now. If you'd like to pose a question, you can do so by pressing star and 1 on your touch-tone phone. Should you want to take your question back out, press star and 2. When you ask your questions, please lift the receiver. Our first question is from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#16

Morning, Jérôme — thanks for taking my questions. First one is on the French budget and the tax increases. As I understand it, Crédit Agricole generates roughly 40% of its income in France. What kind of impact do you expect? Is that figure right, and what effect do you anticipate from the higher corporate tax? That's my first question. Then, moving to the business side: insurance. Results there were somewhat volatile this quarter because of the crop insurance effects, if I've got that right, on a revenue basis. How much of that can we extrapolate? Given climate change, perhaps this is something that persists. And on a profit before tax basis, does your usual guidance of mid-single-digit growth still hold, or how do you see earnings developing in insurance? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#17

Thanks, Giulia. Those are two key questions. On the first one, about the extra corporate tax charge the French government is going after, for both 2024 and 2025 — as we understand it, the rate would peak in 2024 and then come down in 2025. So giving you a precise answer on the impact is a bit tricky. First, since the exact rules aren't known yet. Second, since we don't know exactly what our taxable result base will be for the whole of 2024, particularly given that we actually have several French taxpayers within the group — some Crédit Agricole S.A. subsidiaries sit outside our French tax group because we hold no more than, I believe the threshold is 90% of them. That's true for Amundi on one hand, and I think Amundi gave some guidance last week on the possible impact for them, and it's also true for CACEIS, which has a substantial tax base in France, yet isn't part of the tax group because we hold only 70% of CACEIS. So as far as the tax group goes — which brings together CASA, the 100% subsidiaries, plus the regional banks, which sit outside the listed vehicle but are in that same tax group — just as a reminder, back in 2017, when a similar type of mechanism was introduced, I think the total extra charge we had to pay, split between the regional banks and Crédit Agricole S.A., came to roughly EUR 300 million.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

I’m not claiming the figure will end up being the same amount, since a lot has changed, but to give you a sense of it: in 2017 the tax group of Crédit Agricole in France paid roughly EUR 300 million, and that was divided between the regional banks and Crédit Agricole S.A. along with some of its subsidiaries. That’s really the best response I can give you on this first subject. Turning to insurance, once again, we know IFRS 17 didn’t do much to bring clarity or a clear link between how the business evolves economically and the various numbers, particularly when we look at the top line alone. If you look at the bottom line of Crédit Agricole Assurances, you can see that for the quarter we’re reporting higher net profit, up 16%, and for the first nine months of the year it’s up 11%. So there’s absolutely no concern on the net profit side. But of course, you get ups and downs across the different lines of the P&L, and I understand there were questions this morning, and the teams are ready to provide as much clarity as they can.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#19

Starting with the top line — the revenue line — there were a few negative impacts. The first is that, in fact, P&C activities worldwide tied to crop insurance recorded a lower contribution to revenues this quarter, due to some adverse events, with claims this quarter exceeding what we saw a year earlier. That's the first point, and it can be volatile. On this item, I'd note that, naturally, we believe that given climate change, claims levels may rise in the future, yet at the same time, of course, each year we will adjust pricing in line with the claims level we'll need to handle annually. So this will definitely produce two kinds of consequences: a higher premium level and possibly also a higher claims level. But normally, in economic terms, this shouldn't alter the profitability of the business much over time. Then there was a second item, a very technical one, which has nothing to do with how the business is evolving. In its financial structure, Crédit Agricole Assurances is gradually moving from AT1 debt issued on the market to Tier 2 debt.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

And it turns out that AT1 coupons get recorded on the minority interest line, while Tier 2 coupons are actually recorded and deducted from the revenue line. So this is a gradual shift. Over time, you'll see the cost of minority interest go down, and you'll see an impact of the same magnitude, a slight one, on the revenue line. On top of that, whenever there's a call on an AT1, there may be some lump sum that has to be paid on the minority interest line. And that's why this quarter, we have an impact on the revenue line without a benefit on the minority interest line. So we're not talking about massive amounts, but nevertheless, over time, this can represent some, let's say, EUR 15 million as a run rate on both lines. Then the last point is that we are progressively tuning the level of CSM allocation that we fuel into the P&L, and we've been reducing the level of CSM allocation a little bit. For the full year 2023, I think the CSM allocation rate was around 8.5%, and for the first nine months of 2024, we are a little bit below 8.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#21

This isn't massive, I'd call it fairly technical. It does actually carry a consequence, which is another meaningful lift in the CSM level that we keep holding onto in order to fuel future profits and revenues, but it's also producing a small effect on the top line. Then the final point: as you know, when it comes to managing the assets at Crédit Agricole Assurances, occasionally we can realize some capital gains, and those may be affected by a corporate tax rate lower than the average one. That's why we have less corporate tax in Crédit Agricole Assurances' P&L this quarter, but also less revenues, and the two are linked. So that explains why the top line is a bit down, but we're talking about -1.2% for the quarter, and we're still up 5.5% across the first nine months. Ultimately, what matters, of course, is the business's contribution to Crédit Agricole S.A.'s net profit, and that keeps rising. Again, the guidance we've given, so long as the business stays positive, is clearly to move in step with how the business evolves.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#22

Thanks a lot. I just want to clarify the first point—the tax, that EUR 300 million figure you mentioned for 2017. So we can treat that as the worst-case scenario, I suppose, and it'll actually come in lower, since that amount will be split with the Caisse Régionale, I'd imagine.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#23

And once again, that will be divided with the Caisse Régionale, since the Caisses Régionales are simply generating profits, and therefore they are contributing toward this tax surcharge.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#24

Alright, that's clear. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#25

Our following question comes from Guillaume Tiberghien at BNP Paribas.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#26

Yes, thanks for the question. First, on insurance again. You previously guided us toward roughly 5% net profit growth. So, as we did before, should we look past revenue volatility and simply assume 5% profit growth? Second, back to tax. I understand that in 2017 you paid EUR 300 million more, but your PBT this year is going to be around 50% or 60%. I'm not asking you to confirm that 50 or 60, but the order of magnitude versus 2017. So should we expect the tax you're going to pay to grow by a similar amount? And then a final clarification, if you don't mind: LCL's RWA seemed to have increased by EUR 1.6 billion this quarter on hardly any loan growth, and loan growth was mostly on mortgages. Is there any change in model? If so, is it going to be material going forward, or is it just a one-off adjustment? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#27

On RWA at LCL, the main explanation is essentially that a portion of their corporate exposure — and by corporate, I mean that naturally includes SMEs — has been downgraded within our internal model. That, in turn, is producing a surcharge on RWA. So this is ordinary volatility. And as the economic picture deteriorates somewhat, it is entirely normal to observe some rise in RWA levels with no change at all in the level of outstandings, purely as a result of that downgrading. So we don't anticipate the same magnitude of increase each quarter, but clearly this ties to what we're seeing regarding the overall soundness of that customer segment. And actually, you see the same pattern at the regional banks, with a larger figure given the size of those banks' portfolios. Turning to the corporate tax surcharge in France, it's true that the group's overall profit has risen considerably relative to 2017, but even so, I can point you to the fact that a substantial share of that increase was likely not connected to French-based activities. And on insurance, once again, my guidance is that net profit will increase in line with the overall volume of business.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#28

I'd say roughly 5% is a reasonable figure to point to over the medium to long term. In a given, more specific stretch, it could come in above that. And in fact, what this year has shown is that we're running well ahead of that 5%. Once again, during this year we've achieved a faster rate of growth in the business, with considerable net inflows across the savings and retirement operations as well as the P&C activities, which also rose substantially when it comes to new contracts, new policies, and premium volume.

Guillaume Tiberghien

analyst
#29

Thanks, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#30

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#31

Tarik El Mejjad from Bank of America has the next question.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#32

Yes. Hi there, Tarik.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#33

Morning. Morning, Jérôme. I have just two questions, please. Let me step back a bit and consider your profitability over nine months, which is close to 15%, or 14.5%. I don't anticipate any significant headwind. In Q4, it's actually the reverse, with certain businesses turning the corner and growing more quickly. So why not take a more constructive view when it comes to the outlook? I mean, we're not requesting a new plan, but you did bring forward the full year above EUR 6 billion, net profit pre-AT1, from 2025 to 2024. That happened last quarter. But what stops you at this point from being more constructive on this? And my second question concerns M&A. You've had quite an eventful day on all fronts, but regarding consolidation, are you now more inclined to consider some larger opportunities in Italy? I think it's fair to say that the golden power rules in Italy are difficult to enforce, given how vocal the government was in supporting a deal in Germany for UniCredit. Is that an opportunity for you? Would you contemplate it? Now, Creval is, I think, digested, and you've never hidden your ambitions in Italy. So any comments there would be very useful.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#34

I appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#35

Thank you, Tarik. On the question of the profitability level we're aiming for across the whole of 2024, we won't be revising that target. We're nearly at the middle of November. Why would we come out and say that rather than EUR 6 billion plus, we're now targeting, I don't know, some other figure? So our statement is that we will land above EUR 6 billion. What we can also tell you is that this will happen even with the corporate tax surcharge in France, which is one more factor we likely didn't have in mind three months back. Still, I believe there's little value in attempting greater precision. And once more, for a range of reasons, at some point during 2025 we'll need to work out fresh medium-term targets. That will be the moment for us to establish new targets and offer new guidance. And I believe there's little value in trying to move the calendar forward. On M&A, we never discuss specific situations. So I won't be offering comments on what kind of initiative we might or might not pursue in various countries, various geographies, various entities.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#36

Italy is obviously a highly important market for us. Obviously, in Italy we have a setup that is extremely, extremely comprehensive and very significant. We have plenty of options. So we're constantly evaluating the situation and trying to determine what's relevant for us. But obviously, I won't state beforehand what I intend to do. I'd rather talk about what I did.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#37

All right, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#38

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#39

Our next question comes from Flora Bocahut at Barclays.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#40

Yes. Thanks. Good morning, Jérôme. My first question concerns LCL, where you saw a modest private equity gain within Q2 NII. And this quarter, I believe you point out in the slide pack a favorable extraordinary impact stemming from an equity investment's revaluation. So I was simply wondering whether you could put a number on it, so we get a clearer picture of the sequential change in underlying NII at LCL. The second question returns to insurance. I just want to grasp the rationale for reconsidering the financial debt structure. What are we meant to infer from this regarding AT1 versus Tier 2? And perhaps you could provide a few figures — the Tier 1 size compared with Tier 2 — so we can evaluate? Because you described it as a progressive shift, so it appears more is still to come, so we can better anticipate where revenues might land in the coming quarters. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#41

LCL, it's evident that given how we must record these items within NII, most of our revenue comes from managing the balance sheet, along with occasional small items that add a bit of noise, so to speak, to the NII level. So NII is up roughly 2% Q3 over Q3, excluding last year's home purchase savings plan reversal, though I'd say it's slightly down if we also restate for this revaluation of equity investments. I'm not claiming we'll never see another positive revaluation of various equity investments or odds and ends here and there, but looking strictly at what the balance sheet produced, it was slightly down Q3 over Q3 this year. What's positive in the current situation is that we keep seeing a gradual repricing of the outstandings on the loan book, since we keep booking new loans at a rate now in the region of 3%, I'd say. And that replaces amortizing loans that were yielding much, much lower. And the second piece of good news is that there is, and there appears to be, a continued acceleration in the production of new home loans in France, both within the regional banks and at LCL.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#42

This is a potential acceleration when it comes to improving the yield on the asset book. And at the same time, on the liabilities side of the balance sheet, again, I want to stress the fact that the breakdown across the different categories of customer liabilities has stabilized. There's also potential to bring down the cost of certain liability categories. For term deposits, clearly, pricing is coming down, shrinking a little bit in line with the level of market rates. And when it comes to regulated savings accounts, we don't know what the decision will be regarding Livret A, but a decision has to be made at the beginning of next year. And mechanically, the Livret A level should probably be set at 2.5% instead of 3%. So this is clearly also a potential for improvement going forward. When it comes to the structure of the balance sheet of the insurance activities, what they did is they repaid an old AT1 back in the fourth quarter of 2023 for €500 million. They've also bought back another AT1 at the beginning of September this year for €750 million. We still have around EUR 500 million of old AT1s on the balance sheet.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#43

We won’t be specifying the timing or the method for handling what’s left of the AT1, but as of today we have completed the largest portion of it.

Operator

operator
#44

Kiri Vijayarajah from HSBC has the next question, sir.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#45

Yes, Kiri.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#46

Yes. Good morning, Jérôme. First, may I return to the optimism you expressed about demand for French home loans? I mean, what portion of that depends on 10-year and 20-year swap rates falling further as we head into next year? Or is it rather that the pipeline you're able to see already looks quite strong, and it will come through no matter where interest rates go in the near term? I ask because expectations for rates have been quite volatile lately. So just some color on the quality of mortgage demand and the pipeline there. And then the second question actually is still on the volume side, more about your fleet leasing business. I know you've signed additional partnership deals and made bolt-on acquisitions. But my question is more about the next two to three years: what is the steady pace of asset growth or volume growth in mobility fleet leasing? And also, it feels as though much of the consolidation in that small subsector has already taken place by now. So when it comes to just natural organic growth, and if you find bolt-on deals harder to do there, what steady state growth would you like us to pencil in for the fleet mobility side of the business?

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#47

Appreciate it.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#48

Alright, regarding French retail — I'm not sure "optimism" is quite the right term, but I feel more positive and more constructive, simply because I can see the numbers. And again, I noted that from Q2 to Q3, new home loan production rose 73% at LCL, and I believe 20% at the regional banks. Comparing Q3 with Q3, the regional banks were still lower, while LCL was slightly higher. So this suggests we truly appear to have passed the trough in loan production across the market. And looking at what I'd call more granular data, in September alone, it looks like both the regional banks and LCL are above the production level we saw back in September 2023. So all of this is feeding the sense that the bottom is behind us. Beyond that, if I look at how the market is behaving, rates have come down. That's very clear. So that's better for the borrower. There's some stabilization in home prices. And the final point is that even though it took them a while to recognize it, borrowers — potential borrowers — have gained, over the past two and a half years, a certain number of nominal salary increases, which is also boosting their purchasing capacity.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#49

Okay, so that covers why I believe a few factors are in place for the home loan market to recover. We'll keep watching the situation closely, and our stance is more positive now, though saying optimism might be a bit too strong a word for where things stand. When it comes to the car leasing business, the state of the car market—particularly in Europe—remains unclear as of today. There are some industrial reasons, I'd say, and also some regulatory ones, since a large share of potential car buyers feel somewhat confused by all the uncertainty over which technology is the right one, how quickly they need to switch cars, and so on. So it's clear that for the time being, market prospects aren't very, very bullish. Up to now, though, we've managed to ride out this tough market thanks to the new agreements we've signed with Stellantis. In fact, we're growing the portfolio, because we essentially started from zero a year and a half ago, and we keep building it up.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#50

This is going to drive our growth from here on out, but in a market that won’t be very clear or very bullish quickly.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#51

Alright. Alright. Yes, that comes through very clearly. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#52

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#53

Joseph Dickerson from Jefferies has the next question.

Joseph Dickerson

analyst
#54

Hello, and thanks for taking my question. One quick point on consumer finance. I have to admit the revenue yield in the quarter caught me a bit off guard. My assumption had been that this business is fairly liability sensitive. You've mentioned previously that front-book margins outperform back-book. Has anything shifted in those dynamics within consumer finance? Thanks very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#55

Thank you. In consumer finance, the real shock probably came about one and a half or two years back, when refinancing costs for the business rose very sharply, since this business is largely funded through the market. Neither we nor our competitors could pass on the rate increase to customers as quickly as we experienced it in our own refinancing. So we did accept a substantial deterioration in the margin on new loan production. Since then it has been recovering steadily. The margin on new loan production was stable Q3 over Q2, but it is still up 86 basis points Q3 over Q3, which is far better. As things stand, we have not fully recovered the margin level on the outstanding book that we had two or two and a half years ago, but we still expect that to come through over the coming quarters. So this is definitely a business where, when market rates rise, it is not really possible — especially in countries like France, where usury rate regulation applies — to pass that on to customers right away. Of course, when market rates fall, we try as much as possible, depending on the competition, to retain that decrease in the cost of funding and to avoid passing it on to customers immediately.

Joseph Dickerson

analyst
#56

Understood. Could I pose an additional question regarding insurance?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#57

Right.

Joseph Dickerson

analyst
#58

On the crop claims specifically — I suppose, looking at this quarter, there's been flooding in different regions of the country, particularly in the south. Is that the sort of event we should expect to keep seeing around these weather occurrences? Or do you think that, with IFRS 17, you may have already accounted for even the current weather conditions within this quarter?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#59

No, obviously the flooding and the other weather occurrences we've experienced in France from the start of October—so during the fourth quarter—need to be reflected in the fourth quarter. So far, given the kinds of events we've seen, given that they were heavily concentrated in a few very specific regions, and also taking into account the reinsurance arrangements we hold, I don't expect a huge effect on the fourth quarter figures. But certainly, particularly with IFRS 17, that wasn't really the situation previously under IFRS 4, where we were able to record some provisions to more or less smooth out how the cost of risk evolved. Under IFRS 17, though, it must be recognized when it comes. That means we've had certain weather events during the fourth quarter that will be recognized in the fourth quarter. But once more, what took place in France bears no relation to what took place in Spain, for instance.

Joseph Dickerson

analyst
#60

Right, exactly. OK, that works. Thanks very much.

Operator

operator
#61

Matthew Clark from Mediobanca has the next question.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#62

Good morning, so I have a few questions, please. First, regarding the capital markets and investment banking division, it doesn't look like much operating leverage is coming through there. Could you comment on why that is? Do you view this as the appropriate level of operating leverage, or why aren't costs being contained more relative to revenues there? Second, in the consumer finance business, thanks for the commentary on the financing cost. But looking at sequential revenue trends, you were up quite strongly in the second quarter and then gave most of it back again in the third quarter. Could you just comment on what's driving that quarter-to-quarter volatility? Was there some kind of lumpy item last quarter, perhaps? And then my third question is on the Worldline stake. If you could just remind us how that's accounted for. Is it marked to market? I was a bit surprised that you called out the BAMI stake as affecting the Corporate Center, but I don't think you mentioned the Worldline stake. So just some explanation of why, if that hasn't impacted, why it hasn't impacted. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#63

All right. So at CACIB, it's fair to say that during this quarter the cost base moved in a way that was pretty much consistent with how revenue moved — 8% on revenue, 7% on costs — so we still have positive jaws there. That said, bear in mind that across the first nine months of the year we're running at 52.6% on cost-income ratio. That's likely among the strongest cost-income ratios you'll find for CIB activities anywhere in Europe. And again, we believe that keeping CIB activities inside a band of, say, roughly 55 is entirely consistent with the kind of business we conduct and the kind of risks we carry on our balance sheet. So our preference is to put money into growing the business, into developing it further, rather than chasing that extra one point of cost-income in this activity. Broadly speaking, that's our usual approach. When we get to a cost-income level that we consider consistent with what a given business line does, we'd rather direct the capacity we create toward expanding the business instead of pushing cost-income optimization further, since that could in fact end up shrinking the scope of the business somewhat.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#64

I believe someone isn't on mute. There's some noise coming through the line. No. My second point concerns Worldline and BPM — actually, both are accounted for within the Corporate Center, though it happens that BPM is accounted for against P&L for certain technical reasons tied to how we structured the stake. When it comes to Worldline, however, it isn't against P&L. It's against equity. So changes in the valuation of the Worldline stake are, of course, taken into account, but they hit equity directly. As a result, they don't feed into the P&L.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#65

Appreciate it. Turning to consumer finance?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#66

Consumer finance. Sorry — could you remind me what your question was?

Matthew Clark

analyst
#67

The question was simply about why the cost/income ratio has moved around sequentially. I believe it rose roughly 4% in the second quarter compared with the first quarter, and then fell around 3% in the third quarter compared with the second quarter. I was just wondering what drove those quarter-to-quarter shifts so far this year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#68

Honestly, I don’t have the exact figure at hand, but keep in mind that inside Consumer Finance’s revenues, you naturally have most of the revenue, which comes from interest revenue—so it’s the gap between refinancing cost and the income generated by the loan book—yet there are also some revenues tied to services we sell to insurance revenues and similar items, so that can shift from one quarter to the next, so I’d guess this is driven by that component and perhaps by insurance revenues, but we’ll need to verify, and the team will follow up with you to confirm that answer.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#69

Thanks a lot — that’s great.

Operator

operator
#70

Up next, we have a question from Stefan Stalmann at Autonomous Research.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#71

Hi there, Stefan.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#72

Morning, Jérôme, and thanks a lot for taking my questions. I've just got two small ones remaining. First, looking at the U.K., where there's this slow-moving train wreck involving legal claims tied to motor finance — is Crédit Agricole involved in that, and exposed in any material way? And my second question returns to insurance. I believe you touched on it, but I didn't catch the full explanation. What caused the risk-weighted assets in insurance to go up by EUR 3 billion? Was that purely organic, or did a capital injection play a part? Thanks very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#73

Thank you. I'll begin with the insurance side. The mechanics are quite straightforward. Insurance operations create RWA usage tied to the carrying value of Crédit Agricole Assurances. So when those activities produce earnings that stay inside Crédit Agricole Assurances, the carrying value goes up, and that feeds into RWAs at a ratio of 370%. That means for each EUR 1 of profit booked in a single quarter, RWA rises by EUR 3.7. Naturally, whenever results are upstreamed to CASA in the form of a dividend, the carrying value comes down, and therefore RWA comes down as well. No capital injection has occurred, nothing along those lines — it's just that the quarter's results produced this lift in carrying value, along with certain items related to unrealized capital gains on the asset portfolio that sit against Crédit Agricole Assurances' own funds. This is purely internal to Crédit Agricole Assurances, and each time a dividend gets upstreamed, the carrying value will fall and consequently the RWA usage will fall. Typically, the pattern is a yearly dividend paid in the second quarter, plus a first dividend tranche in the fourth quarter.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

Our expectation is that during Q4 of this year, we will lower the carrying value of Crédit Agricole Assurances and bring down the RWA consumption tied to this activity. In the U.K., our motor finance activity is actually very tiny, and it's connected to the business we have with Stellantis. So it's extremely, extremely small. Naturally, we're watching the situation closely, but we are definitely not among the tier one or even tier two players in this market. So for us, it's not a very significant matter.

Stefan Stalmann

analyst
#75

That's very clear. Thanks a lot, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#76

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#77

Anke Reingen from RBC has the next question.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#78

Thanks so much. A few questions that are a bit different. I mean, throughout this call, we've discussed flooding, crops, and similar topics quite a bit. And I'm just curious: is there a scenario in which you'd reassess your credit risk regarding climate change and possible risk weighting, and also set aside extra provisions? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#79

All the risks affecting our loans and our credit have to be factored in. Naturally, we make every effort to consider this within the technical limits of what is feasible on our side, but the effect of climate change on our customers and on their creditworthiness must be taken into account. That is, of course, something our teams, the risk teams, do factor in. Beyond that, I can note that the ECB is watching this very closely. You may have noticed that Mrs. Buch, who heads the SSM, keeps stressing that she wants banks to genuinely factor that element in. In fact, we must give the ECB some materiality assessment of how climate change impacts our risks. This is already something we incorporate in the credit criteria when a loan is granted and in assessing counterparties' creditworthiness as we monitor the portfolio.

Anke Reingen

analyst
#80

All right, thanks very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#81

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#82

Jacques-Henri Gaulard from Kepler Cheuvreux has the last question.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#83

Jacques-Henri. Good morning.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#84

Hey, Jérôme. This is the final question. Honestly, it doesn't bode well for my career, I'm telling you. But regardless, two things. First, I think one of the major forces behind the stock price is really the significant governance change that's coming your way quite soon. From your vantage point, maybe you could share your view on whether there might be any shift in strategy, or whether you'd alter the country priority or the businesses, given that clearly, based on what you report quarter after quarter, if it ain't broken, don't fix it, as the English say. And my second question concerns LCL — you had that RWA migration you talked about. The cost of risk has risen a little. Is there potentially any tendency toward asset quality worsening somewhat more than you anticipated in France over the coming year, actually? Thank you so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#85

I can't see into the future, so predicting how the cost of risk will move in France isn't something I can do. What we observe in our LCL accounts and at the regional banks matches what the papers are reporting, namely more defaults, more delinquencies, more difficulties among various categories of corporates and SMEs. A wave of delinquencies and defaults is not what we're seeing. A massive rise in difficulties is not what we're seeing. It is concentrated in certain segments, particularly certain activity segments, contractors, tied to what we've discussed regarding the residential loan market over the last two years. It also relates to some self-employed professional segments, agriculture especially, so there are pockets of risk in some areas, but no wave of deterioration as of now. What will happen next year I'm not predicting, but truly, it is not a wave. Once again, we still have a cost of risk that is moderate overall by historical standards. On the governance change you mentioned, I'm not in a position to comment. I'm fairly confident in saying I don't expect this to result in a significant shift in strategy, because the strategy in place for the last 10 years is entirely the group's strategy, not merely one man's strategy.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#86

This is certainly a group that will keep acting the way it has not just over the past 10 years, but across the last several decades as well. A major strategic shift isn't something I anticipate, and since I don't believe it's broken, I also don't see any need to fix it.

Jacques-Henri Gaulard

analyst
#87

That's great. Thanks, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#88

Thanks. Jacques-Henri, as you mentioned, I believe that was the final question. So once more, thank you all for joining this call, and we'll speak with you soon. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#89

Thank you, everyone, for being here. That brings this conference to a close, so you’re welcome to hang up your phones now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.