Crédit Agricole S.A. (ACA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 5, 2025

Euronext Paris FR Financials Banks earnings 77 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good morning, everyone. I'm the conference operator. We're glad you could be with us for Crédit Agricole's call covering fourth quarter and full year 2024 results. Please note that everyone attending is in listen-only mode. Following the presentation, you'll have a chance to ask questions by pressing star and one on your telephone. If anyone requires assistance at any point during this call, they can signal an operator by pressing star and zero. I'd now like to hand the conference over to Mr. Jérôme Grivet, Deputy Chief Executive Officer of Crédit Agricole S.A., responsible for steering and control. Sir, the floor is yours.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#2

Good morning, everyone. Thanks for joining our call. I'm delighted to walk you through the 2024 results and the figures for the final quarter of 2024 — results that are truly excellent. I'll begin right away on page four of the presentation, and I'll start by setting our 2024 results against the goals we originally laid out for 2025 as part of our most recent medium-term plan. As we've said a number of times since early last year, we are in fact reaching, already in 2024, every objective we had set for 2025, and I'd note that this has become a pattern, since for the third consecutive time we've succeeded in hitting our profitability goals a full year early. Yet it's not simply about hitting those goals — I also want to stress that we are exceeding the various targets by a wide margin. That holds for net profit, which comes in 20% higher than the target. It holds for return on tangible equity, which is two percentage points better than the target. And it holds as well for the cost-income ratio, which sits well under the 58% ceiling we had established.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#3

This was definitely a really solid set of results from the group worldwide, and particularly from Crédit Agricole S.A., both for the quarter and for the whole of 2024. Moving to page five, we've got a few key messages about this set of results. The first one is that it's clearly a big step up versus the prior year and versus the last quarter of 2023. It's also a record level when it comes to profit for any fourth quarter, and a record for full-year profitability as well. And this result was achieved — we'll go into some detail on this — in particular thanks to a really high level of revenues. Profitability is also very high because 14% is indeed the best return on tangible equity we've ever posted. Our capital position and liquidity positions are very, very strong, and we're proposing to the General Assembly meeting taking place in May an increase in the dividend — the cash dividend — which will be EUR 1.1 plus 5% compared with the one paid on 2023. On the next page, we see all the figures for the group worldwide and for Crédit Agricole S.A.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#4

To be specific about the full year and the quarter: for those figures I just cited, every indicator has risen. Revenues are up, gross operating income is up, and net profit is up. They're higher for the quarterly results and for the full-year results alike, and higher both at group level and at Crédit Agricole S.A. The cost-income ratio shows improvement on both perimeters, and the cost of risk remains extremely, extremely low by historical standards. Let me move now to page eight, beginning with the level of activity we recorded across all business lines during the year's final quarter and across the full year 2024. Once again, this was a year of exceptionally strong activity right across the board, in every business and every entity of the group. That was very much true for retail banking activities and for all activities aimed directly at individuals and households, with particularly good news in France, where home loan activity rebounded in the last quarter. New loan production there is up 18% versus the last quarter of 2023. We're also continuing to see growth in corporate loan production, as well as in the level of lending and credit activity at the international retail banks, and in consumer finance the activity level is stable and high relative to the last two or three quarters — so a good level of activity in the consumer credit business as well.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#5

Finally, I want to note that the deposit mix in France is still stabilizing, which matters a great deal for further improvement of the net interest margin down the road. Turning to CIB, asset management and insurance, activity levels are very high and at times setting records. That's true in insurance, where outstandings in life activities reached a record level, and net premium income also hit a record in 2024, at EUR 43.6 billion of premium for the full year. The same holds for Amundi, with net inflows of EUR 55 billion for the full year and EUR 2 trillion 240 billion of assets under management in outstandings. And for CACIB, it has also been a year and a quarter of record revenues. If I go a bit deeper into the revenue analysis for the last quarter of 2024, page nine shows that this sharp rise in revenues — plus 17.4% on a stated basis and plus 18.2% on an underlying basis — this sharp rise is spread across nearly all of our business lines.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#6

In asset gathering, that's very much the picture, with activity running at a high level across the board, and there's also a favorable base effect on the insurance side. As you may recall, during the fourth quarter of 2023 we recorded a significant amount of weather-related claims, and nothing comparable occurred in the fourth quarter of 2024. On top of that, we gain the benefit from integrating Degroof Petercam, which wasn't part of the picture back in 2023. Even so, revenues are elevated and climbing quickly. The same holds in the large customers' division — CACI plus CACEIS — with no scope effect at all, just a very strong showing from every activity in that business division. Turning to specialized financial services, the good news is that revenue did rise by 35 million EUR, marking the first such increase in 2024. That illustrates how, at CA PFM — meaning the consumer credit entity together with the car leasing entity — we're now witnessing the positive impact of higher margins on new loans, which is feeding through into a modest improvement in the margin on outstandings. Finally, in retail banking activities, revenues are holding steady, with some minor fluctuations among France, Italy, and the other international retail banking entities.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#7

Finally, at the corporate center, we saw a sharp rise in revenue levels, partly driven by a higher valuation of Banco BPM shares than the one we had back in the fourth quarter of 2023. Even so, the other elements within this business division, or within this corporate center, are also trending well. On the right-hand side of the page, you can see that revenue's annual growth rate over the last 10 years was 6.5%, and it has been very steady. So that's a very positive element, and we're happy to illustrate it there. On the next page, we have some elements concerning how the cost basis evolved. What you can see is that the increase — plus 5.6% on a stated basis and plus 4.4% on an underlying basis — is less dynamic than what we had in the first nine months of the year. So there is clearly a slowing down in how the cost base is evolving. That's perfectly consistent with how inflation has evolved in most of the countries where we operate, especially France. And this is also illustrated by the graph on the right-hand side of this page, where you can see that recurring expenses rose by a mere 3% this quarter, which compares quite favorably with the same calculation we did for the first three quarters of the year, which were more in the region of 4%-5% at the beginning of this year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#8

So of course, we’ll keep investing. We’ll keep paying our staff, but things are slowing in step with how inflation is moving. On page 11, there are some items about the cost of risk. At Crédit Agricole S.A., the cost of risk level is visibly higher, whether you compare it with the fourth quarter of 2023 or with the third quarter of 2024. But what stands out right away is that this rise is mostly and essentially caused by IFRS 9 provisions — that is, stage one and stage two provisions. And if you go deeper into the figures and examine only the stage three provisions, they are lower than both the third quarter of 2024 and the fourth quarter of 2023. This increase in stage one and stage two provisions stems from two things: a revision of certain IFRS 9 models at certain entities — especially in the consumer credit business and also at CACIB — and a positive migration of certain counterparties from S3 to S2, meaning from doubtful loan to only sensitive loans, I’d say, which is definitely positive. Naturally, the provisions tied to these loans move in the same direction.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#9

So overall, what we're seeing is that NPL ratios — both at the group level and at CASA — came down slightly in Q4 2024 versus Q3 2024. Coverage ratios, meanwhile, keep getting better. On the next page, there's more granular detail about cost of risk across the different business lines. Let me just flag two of them. In CACIB's financing activities, there's what looks like a sizeable rise. But the first thing to note is that it remains, and continues to be, quite low. Seven basis points is clearly a very low level. And secondly, that figure consists solely of stage one and stage two provisioning. So when it comes to cost and incurred risk, it's still hovering around zero. Then within CA PFM, there also appears to be a steep uptick, but in fact two specific items are driving it, which I wanted to call out. The first is a EUR 50 million provision booked in connection with a revision of IFRS 9 models, which I referred to earlier. So that's a one-step increase in the provisioning level. Naturally, the model will keep evolving down the road, but this is simply the updating of the outstanding reserve in light of this provisioning model.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#10

Moving to the second item: it's a reserve of EUR 30 million that has been set aside for legal risks, which of course includes that U.K. matter — the U.K. car loans issue. You're fully familiar with that story; it affects the entire banking sector, and our share of that market is only a very modest 1%-2%. On the next page, there's an analysis showing how net profit evolved by business line on a quarterly basis. What it shows is that this quarter, the contribution from the asset gathering business division and the retail banking business division improved quite significantly. It's stable for the large customers division, reflecting the higher level of provisioning at CACIB, though still at a very low level. It's also slightly down at the SFS business division, again related to the cost of risk I mentioned, which includes, among other elements, two significant one-offs. On the right-hand side of the page, there's a breakdown of how net profit evolved on a yearly basis by P&L lines. What it shows is that overall, the sharp rise in net profit — plus 11.6% on a stated basis, and even plus 21.1% on an underlying basis — is mainly driven by higher revenues, plus EUR 2 billion, with only EUR 750 million of increase in the cost base, and then a slight increase in the cost of risk for the full year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#11

Obviously, there's a pronounced rise in the tax level along with a reduction in that other line containing the equity accounted entities, which stems from certain changes to our perimeter. Still, without question, the growth in net profit is being powered by how revenues have evolved and by how gross operating income has evolved. Moving to the next page, there are a few items concerning the solvency ratio at CASA. Our target remains 11%, and we're holding steady at 11.7%. Retained earnings sit at a high level once the distribution reserve is accounted for. There's also some momentum in how the business line's organic growth of RWAs is evolving, partly pushed along by certain rating migrations. Then we have various bits and pieces bundled together under M&A effect, regulatory effect, and so on and so forth. What matters most there is that, starting now in the fourth quarter of 2024, we have begun prudentially consolidating the leasing activity, which counts among the provisions of Basel IV. That produces a one-off cost for solvency of 12 basis points. Across the full year, the solvency ratio came down by 10 basis points in spite of the sharp organic growth of our activities, in spite of some technical elements too, like the one I just cited on the leasing, and in spite of some M&A operations as well that were closed during the year.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#12

Absolutely — plenty of room to maneuver on solvency, especially when you factor in the 11% target. And of course, this is happening within a group that still enjoys a very large cushion above every regulatory threshold: a 17.2% CET1 ratio at group level, plus 740 basis points of headroom over SREP requirements. So there's definitely no concern when it comes to the group's solvency. The same dynamic showed up in solvency during the quarter with a somewhat different overall effect, which is, naturally, entirely tied to how strong the group's solvency is. At a level that high, each extra billion of RWA requires more capital to cover it if you want to hold the ratio steady. As for the other solvency measures — leverage, TLAC, MREL — no problem at all, and always a meaningful buffer above every requirement that applies to the group. Turning to the next page, page 16, there are a few points on the group's liquidity, with nothing major to flag. Reserves keep climbing modestly through the quarter. Customer deposits likewise rose somewhat during the quarter, and the mix of those customer deposits remains very steady following the sharp move we saw once rates began to rise.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#13

At this point, it appears we've arrived at a level that is, once again, extremely stable. As for the liquidity ratios, the LCR ratios remain well above the 110% target — 131% at Crédit Agricole SA and 127% for the group as a whole. Let me now move quickly through the next few pages. Page 18 gives you an update on our transition plan and the strategy we're pursuing to support customers in their own energy transition, accelerating the development of financing for renewable and low-carbon energy sources. The second point covers everything we offer customers to help them transition, and the third point follows from the first two — the gradual reduction of financing for carbon-based energy, with a target of exiting it over time. On that point, what we can say is that we're far ahead of the curve when it comes to hitting our medium-term targets. This comes through on the next page, page 19. There you can see that the mix of financing we provide for energy production has shifted very substantially between 2020 and 2024. And today, each time we free up 4 euros of fossil fuel financing, we can allocate 14 euros to low-carbon energy financing.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#14

There are a few points about how the medium-term plan rolls over, plus the obvious one that we hit the target a year early. Page 21 shows something worth flagging: in most of the business lines where we operate, our market shares keep rising. That is exactly how the organic component of the group's development plan is meant to play out. And we keep adding customers — 1.9 million new ones per year in our retail banks since this medium-term plan began. So the group's organic growth path is clearly still functioning in precisely the same manner, true to its DNA. Page 22 then complements this with the inorganic growth initiatives we've undertaken. We thought it worthwhile to glance back at every transaction we've signed and closed over the last four or five years. A substantial amount of capital went into those deals. That funding was entirely self-financed, whether through our capital or our capacity to generate earnings, and also helped by certain disposals, and these operations add a meaningful complement on the revenue side. If you total the deals closed between 2019 and 2021, which we regard as fully integrated, together with those closed more recently, altogether they should represent close to EUR 4.5 billion of revenues in 2025, with an average cost-income ratio very near the level we're targeting on average — so a very positive takeaway from all these inorganic initiatives.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#15

On pages 23 and 24, there are some elements about the trajectory we've been able to track over the last 10 years. Overall, we've grown the top line steadily year after year, averaging a very high 5.6% ratio annually, so that's a very high pace of increase in our top line, and at the same time, we've improved the cost-income ratio at CASA by 15.15 percentage points over the last 10 years, so with a very, very steady, very linear trajectory. On page 24, again, with the same level of historical data, the trajectory of return on tangible equity. Actually, we should have started in '16, in 2016, not in 2015, because 2016 was the year the Eureka transaction was completed, through which we reorganized the group completely, and so we started with a level of return on tangible equity of around 8.5%. We are now reaching 14%, and we've been permanently above 10% with the exception of 2020, which was the year of COVID. But definitely, even in this year, we've managed to post a return on tangible equity which was above 9%. And in the same period of time, we've multiplied the dividend per share in cash by more than 3, 3.1, to be very precise, reaching this level of EUR 1.10 per share.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#16

That's where I'll wrap up. I believe that's the key takeaway from this presentation. And at this point I'll turn things over to you for questions.

Operator

operator
#17

Thanks very much, sir. Speaking is the conference operator. Our question-and-answer session starts now. If you'd like to pose a question, just press star and one on your touch-tone phone. Should you want to drop out of the queue, press star and two. When you ask your question, please lift your receiver. Giulia Aurora Miotto of Morgan Stanley has the first question.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#18

Hi there, Giulia.

Operator

operator
#19

Ms. Miotto, it seems your line might be on mute.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#20

We’re still on mute. Perhaps we can take this next one, and then we’ll return to Giulia after that.

Operator

operator
#21

Absolutely, sir. Tarik El Mejjad from Bank of America has the next question.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#22

Hello, and good morning, Jérôme. Congratulations on the excellent results — truly great quality. So, as I usually do, I want to ask you again about how you're reviewing your guidance upward. I think we'll all need to wait another few months, but still on that topic: you've been posting record-high ROTE, 14% for the full year 2024, and it appears you aren't yet firing on all cylinders. So do you believe the bank has structurally shifted to a materially higher ROTE compared with earlier plans? If I recall, in the last few plans you essentially raised your ROE by 50 to 100 basis points, plan after plan. Now we're well above the prior plan target. So is this a structural shift, or are there some elements that flatter your ROE somewhat? For instance, I'm thinking of the CET1 ratio of 11%, but you seem adamant this is the right level for you. And still related to that, on the Capital Markets Union: a few weeks ago you wrote a very detailed article on securitization and its benefits to Europe, tying it to your Draghi report. Should we expect in your new plan, after raison d'être, perhaps a new plan in which you try more to leverage on European working together and securitization within the CMU?

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#23

A competitor of yours said yesterday that they're now factoring the CMU into their medium-term profitability guidance. Does that apply to you as well? Then for the last question — I mean, I have to ask it. Let's see how much you can say on that. But on Italy, I know things remain very fluid, but I wanted to see where you stand here. You often frame it more as defending your interest. There were a few headlines again this morning. But I think it's quite the opposite. I think you have a big opportunity here to leverage on your stake. So in BPM, can you maybe update us on where you sit there and what kind of timeline we should watch? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#24

There are quite a few questions there, Tarik, but I'll do my best to get through them promptly. Starting with guidance: it's obvious that a new CEO will take the helm in mid-May. He has in fact begun working on a medium-term plan for the future. Naturally, though, that will require some time. So you shouldn't count on seeing a fresh medium-term plan before roughly the fourth quarter of this year. We'll revise the targets and set out new ones, probably for 2028. Even so, 2025 must proceed on its own track. What I can say about 2025 is this: first, we haven't set aside the original goals from the last medium-term plan. We therefore remain focused on a return on tangible equity for 2025 that ought to exceed the 12% threshold set in that previous medium-term plan. We also, naturally, still aim for a cost-income ratio below 58% — and potentially well below. As for net profits, you're aware that in 2025 we'll encounter both tailwinds and headwinds, as some of our competitors have noted. Overall, though, our sense is that we're capable of delivering broadly the same kind of performance we were able to report for 2024 — on a structural basis, I would say.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#25

We all certainly get it — you'd rather hear updated targets right now. But we're in a transition phase, and it isn't a brutal one. Things will be quite fluid. We just need a bit of time, pardon me, before we can publish new targets. As for Return on Tangible Equity, that will sit within this new Medium-Term Plan. Naturally, we're factoring in how our businesses are now split differently, and the fact that we've brought into our scope of businesses some activities with low capital requirements. We also have to fully factor in Basel IV's impact, which isn't yet completely reflected in the most recent figures we've published, since it's still being rolled out. So clearly, we're well positioned when it comes to return on tangible equity. We don't intend to give up that strong position. But once more, this will form part of the new medium-term plan. On securitization, clearly it's a significant possible avenue for developing the group's activities across several areas. That's certainly true for CACIB, though CACIB already employs these tools to monitor and fine-tune how much capital it consumes.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#26

CACIB is using this securitization operation, and it will keep doing so with various investor categories, again, so that its capital consumption stays monitored. Of course, it's also a potential target for Amundi when it comes to building out activities across all those credit funds. So that's definitely something we'll be examining closely over the course of the next medium-term plan. And then on Italy, what we're seeing is that how the situation there evolves won't be decided by Crédit Agricole itself. Crédit Agricole has a significant setup in Italy. We act as much as we can as a good Italian citizen when operating there, and we believe we have a good image in the country. But what we're seeing is that, at the end of the day, the reshaping of Italy's banking landscape won't be decided by us. And what we want is to be in a position where we have the capacity to defend our interests — again, to use that expression, which doesn't mean we're passive, but we are actively defending our interests.

Tarik El Mejjad

analyst
#27

Thank you, Jérôme.

Operator

operator
#28

Moving on to the next question. Pardon me, sir.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#29

No, no — what I meant was, are we returning to Giulia?

Operator

operator
#30

Yes, that’s right. Moving on, our next question comes from Giulia Aurora Miotto at Morgan Stanley.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#31

Yes. Hello. Good morning, Jérôme. Are you able to hear me at this point? Let's give it another try.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#32

Yeah. 100%.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#33

Alright, thanks a lot. And apologies — I'm not sure what was going on with my phone earlier. So I've got two questions too. On Slide 22, you lay out how bolt-ons generated value — I think that's a good slide. Right now you're sitting above the 11% CET1 target, and obviously I'm aware Basel is coming, but at this point what are you prioritizing when it comes to that excess capital? Where would you deploy it at the margin — which kinds of businesses or geographies? And would that mainly be bolt-on activity, or is a larger deal possible? That's my first one. My second question: you referenced risk migration on RWAs. Is there anything we ought to begin worrying about, maybe regarding France — whether asset quality is deteriorating or not, really? What are you observing there? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#34

I'll go straight to the second question. No, this is technical. And even when an asset moves from default to sensitive, you can get a rise in the level of RWAs. So really, it's a result of all the migrations we've observed. But the key point is that in terms of actual cost of risk, we see no indication of deterioration. So the same areas remain sensitive. That's true for many, many small businesses that are, for instance, tied to the car-making business. It's also true for all the SMEs in the building contracting sector. And we've viewed those sectors as sensitive for many quarters now, but there's no overall indication of deterioration and no concern on our side. But simply, we have to acknowledge that all the regulation sometimes has some volatility effect on capital consumption because of the models that we have and all these elements. This is what happened, with a very moderate magnitude, definitely, in the fourth quarter of this year. The second point regarding the usage of the excess of capital, we do not decide in advance where we will be able to make acquisitions because an acquisition is a matter of availability of opportunity, and so we cannot decide in advance.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#35

One thing we're certain about is that our focus stays on bolt-on acquisitions far more than transformational ones. The reason is that the past acquisitions succeeded, and that success was plainly tied to how easy those operations were to integrate. If we want to be sure we capitalize on those operations and that the capital we can generate is put to good use, then it's very important that we make certain the integration goes smoothly. The surest route to a smooth integration is acquiring entities that fit with what we do today and that are simple to integrate.

Giulia Aurora Miotto

analyst
#36

I really appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#37

Delphine Lee from J.P. Morgan has the next question.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#38

Yes. Morning, and thanks. Appreciate you taking my questions, Jérôme. Perhaps I could just dig a bit deeper into overall strategy within Italy. I take your point that the landscape there isn't something you control, but what would the ideal situation look like from your perspective and for Amundi broadly? What would be on your wish list? Then my second question is also about M&A. You've had a lot of success with bolt-ons, and I fully agree those are simpler to integrate. But if you were considering opportunities that are somewhat larger, which countries would you prioritize first, in your opinion?

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#39

Alright. Those are pretty tough questions, so I’ll begin with the wish list. Designing the wish list is in fact fairly straightforward, since it would plainly involve being able to grow all the partnerships we currently have, to close new partnerships, and at the same time to expand the retail bank network we operate in Italy. So that is very straightforward. We want to grow. We therefore have 2 ways to grow our activities: directly via our own network and indirectly via partnerships. So the wish list would be being able to grow simultaneously along those 2 directions and, I would say, at the same magnitude. M&A, which country? Again, I believe the starting point would be that, if we want to integrate what we are buying, it means we need to buy entities, to buy objects connected with activities we already have. So by definition that means either we do deals in business lines we already own, and possibly that could bring us to complement the geographical footprint of certain businesses. That was the case, for instance, when CACEIS acquired KAS Bank in the Netherlands.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#40

That gave CACEIS a stronger position in the Netherlands. Or take the deal where CACEIS bought Santander Security Services in Spain — that added to what CACEIS had built in that country, where CACEIS hadn't really been present. So that's a first angle, geographical. And of course, looking purely from retail banking, where we're able to make acquisitions, the countries where we already have some activities, because launching a brand-new retail bank franchise in a country that's new — I'm not ruling such a strategy out entirely, but it isn't really what's on our minds these days. And what we know best how to do is clearly to integrate some additional setups in places where we already have some activities.

Delphine Lee

analyst
#41

Thanks — I appreciate that.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#42

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#43

Up next, we have a question from Kiri Vijayarajah at HSBC.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#44

Right, Kiri.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#45

Yes. Morning, Jérôme. I have a few questions. First, regarding the interim dividend — or should I say the absence of one — I must admit I'm somewhat taken aback, since I recall that in our earlier conversations you sounded fairly open to the idea. I believe you also said your largest shareholder would likely support it. So what is the reasoning behind not doing what your peer announced yesterday concerning the interim dividend? Then a more technical point about the FX impacts within CIB on slide 14, the 2.7 billion of RWAs. That presumably stems from a stronger U.S. dollar. I suppose I'm a little surprised you aren't hedged better, but is it reasonable to expect more of the same in Q1, given how the euro/dollar exchange rate has moved year to date? Just, yes, some guidance on the non-euro denominated RWAs, please. Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#46

I'll begin with the second item, since that one is pretty clear-cut. The truth is, we aren't hedging the RWAs. What we're attempting to hedge is how rate movements affect the solvency ratio. That means we try, as far as possible, to keep the share of capital components denominated in dollars, for instance, aligned with the share of assets denominated in dollars, so that the solvency ratio is immunized to the greatest extent possible. But we don't hedge the assets specifically. Our preference is to hedge asset and liability items together so that, once again, the ratio is immunized as much as possible. Turning to the interim dividend, well, we are quick. We can respond fast, but expecting us to respond today to something a competitor announced yesterday is perhaps a bit too fast. So I'd say I have no fixed doctrine on this interim dividend question, because in itself, distributing the dividend twice a year rather than once a year doesn't generate a single euro of extra value. It's a technical matter. So I have no opposition in principle, and I have no inclination in principle, I'd say, to do it either. We'll watch what the competitors do.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#47

I've certainly noted that one of the major French banking rivals said it intended to take that step. We'll see what is feasible for us, what we want to do, and what we judge sensible to do, and we'll proceed on that basis. But once more, that in itself doesn't generate a single euro of extra value.

Kiri Vijayarajah

analyst
#48

Alright, that is extremely clear. Thanks, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#49

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#50

Barclays' Flora Bocahut has the next question.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#51

Yes, Flora?

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#52

Yes. Yes. Good morning, Jérôme. So I have two questions as well. I'd like to return to the dividend, but focus more on discussing the payout, since obviously you have excess capital. There are moving parts in Italy. There is bolt-on M&A that you do here and there. I know Basel IV is also coming. But what's your appetite here to potentially revisit the payout again, or is there absolutely no will on your side to change the 50% payout? And then the second question actually concerns the announcement today from the regional banks that they're going to buy up to 500 million EUR of Crédit Agricole S.A. shares and that they have no intention to go beyond 65% ownership. I know I should ask them rather than you, but you're also part of the group more generally. So I'd be interested in your view on a few things there. First, why that 65% limit? If you could explain, that would be helpful. And then, obviously, they continue to pile up excess capital in the regional banks. So what is the view once they're at 65%? Are you considering within the group changes to the capital structure, or is there absolutely no discussion there?

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#53

So you believe it’s already optimal the way it is? Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#54

Let me return to the second question. 65 isn't some kind of magic number. It was just the number they gave when they launched that first operation to reduce shares — the capital reduction at Crédit Agricole S.A. And I believe — though again, you were right on this — they're in a better position than I am to speak to it. My sense is they intend to hold to what they said 2 years ago, and that strikes me as reasonable. Do we expect any change in the group's capital structure? There is absolutely no discussion of that inside the group at present, I can tell you. From where I sit, I see no particular reason we'd want to alter that capital structure, since it has proven efficient, since it gives the group a vehicle that is extremely capital efficient and that delivers a high return on tangible equity, while at the same time the regional banks don't focus all that much on their own return on equity. What matters to them is their profit level, which is of course very important. But as for profitability measured as return, that's not so significant to them. And they wish to keep building capital so they can keep growing their activities locally and also help provide the most efficient coverage of all the capital structure requirements we face at group level, because, again, their very high solvency lets us cover our various ratios — TLAC or MREL, for instance — with the most efficient mix of elements: subordinated debt and tier one and tier two debt at CASA, but mainly CET1 capital at the regional bank level, which results in a capital structure for the group that is both very robust and very cost-efficient.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#55

From that angle, there's really nothing that needs altering. As for the dividend and payout policy, that is naturally something we will revisit within the medium-term plan, just as we always do. That said, between you and me, I seriously doubt we'll be shifting our position. Once again, it has shown itself to work well under the last medium-term plan — and by working well I mean we managed to produce a very solid return for shareholders. At the same time, we were able to capture opportunities that sped up our growth. So even if it isn't particularly scientific, we believe the 50/50 split between dividend and the capital we keep for development makes sense.

Flora Bocahut

analyst
#56

Got it. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#57

Our next question comes from Pierre Chedeville at CIC.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#58

Yes. Hello, Jérôme. I have one question about insurance. I recall that when you launched the prior plan, Philippe Brassac was quite optimistic about how things would develop with SME customers. At the time, I remember being somewhat skeptical, given that AXA, for instance, and other pure players in insurance were targeting these kinds of clients very heavily. Looking at your nice slide 21, I can see that your P&C business in terms of market share is fairly stable. I was hoping to get a view, perhaps, on the development and SMEs. Was it as good as Philippe thought back then? That's the first question. My second question has to do with Asia. Yesterday we saw that Amundi is doing very well in Asia, and not only in the JVs, with more than EUR 400 billion of assets under management, ex-JVs in Asia. And I wanted to know whether you can connect this development with other parts of your business, especially CACIB, and whether over these last years during the plan you have seen a significant increase in your revenues in Asia. And do you see a link between Amundi and other parts of your business in Asia? And the last question concerns LCL.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#59

Could you elaborate a bit more on how macro-hedging affected things this quarter? I didn't quite follow why your margin is going down this quarter. And can you confirm that in 2025, as far as rate movements go, that margin should go up? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#60

All right. Insurance, and building out P&C coverage for SME customers. We're taking a patient approach — genuinely embedding a new business line alongside the insurance entities and the Caisse Régionale or LCL does take time. It has begun, in fact, with certain regional banks that are fairly active. At this point the global figures aren't very large, but that isn't really what worries us, since we know perfectly well that when we launched the life insurance business, or the P&C business for households and individuals, a little time was needed before it became, I'd say, fully part of the DNA and of the everyday behavior of all our commercial staff across the territory. So I have no precise figure to hand you on this business right now. It is progressing correctly relative to what we had in mind, and it will remain an area of future development for Crédit Agricole Assurances and for the group. Asia is clearly a very important geographic region for Amundi. You put it well, because Amundi has chosen to concentrate on Europe, the Middle East, and Asia, and in the weeks or months ahead we will close the deal with Victory Capital in the U.S., through which Amundi will reshape its U.S. setup, obtaining 26% of Victory Capital's capital in return for contributing its own U.S.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#61

To start, then: on a purely standalone basis, Amundi’s real focus is Europe, the Middle East, and Asia. And of course it is growing nicely in Asia, and it is also growing when it comes to cooperation among all the entities located in Asia. I can give you one example, because I recall some years back, when I was running the insurance activities. We have a small life and protection insurance operation in Japan, and the growth of that operation was made possible only thanks to support from CACIB on one side and Amundi on the other. So it is clearly a policy we apply in every country where we have several subsidiaries or branches of our large global business lines. It is essential that we arrange things so that they work together and try to help one another grow their activities locally. So that is definitely the situation in Asia between Amundi and CACIB. And have you seen revenues increase over the course of the plan? I do not have the revenue breakdown, the geographic split of revenues, at CACIB. We may be able to give you somewhat more precise figures later, but in CIB activities it is always hard, as you know perfectly well, to say exactly where revenues originate, because you can allocate revenues either in the client’s country, in the country of the commercial team, or in the country where you book the asset.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#62

So there are various scenarios, and it's somewhat tricky to fully allocate and dissect CACIB's top line across the individual countries. Still, one thing is certain: CACIB is expanding in Asia. That was a goal under the prior medium-term plan, and my guess is it will also be a goal for CACIB in the upcoming medium-term plan. And once more, for the same rationale — the biggest players are U.S. firms. They're headquartered in the U.S., which makes the U.S. market extremely tough for European banks, whether in CIB activities or in asset management activities. And that's plainly why we aim to grow as much as we can in other regions where domestic players aren't so dominant. Next, on LCL macro-hedging: why did NII fall in the fourth quarter, and what do we anticipate for 2025? As you're aware, macro-hedging overall consists of a set of swaps where we pay the long fixed rate and receive the short-term rate. And what occurred in 2024, and what keeps occurring in 2025, is that short rates are dropping quickly in line with the ECB's decision.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#63

So that's the fourth-quarter story, and it's not surprising in the least. What we expect for 2025, though, is this: first, the weighted average cost of customer liabilities keeps coming down; second, refinancing in the market that we have to supply to LCL gets cheaper; and third, the loan book reprices gradually as production of new home loans speeds up, we hope. And although macro-hedging will go on contributing less, we'll see LCL's net interest margin steady and then rise in 2025, and the same at the regional banks.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#64

However, that's not a rise — not a substantial rise, not a substantial rise.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#65

Honestly speaking, we expect a modest uptick.

Pierre Chédeville

analyst
#66

Alright. Alright. Thanks. That's very clear. Thanks so much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#67

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#68

Our following question comes from Alberto Artoni at Intesa Sanpaolo.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#69

Alberto, go ahead.

Alberto Artoni

analyst
#70

Good morning, and thanks for taking my questions. I have a couple of questions about the asset gathering business. First, do you think a lower rate will keep supporting business momentum—especially in life insurance, asset management, and wealth management? My second question is broader. There's been a debate about active fixed income funds and products: some argue that going forward, competition should reach the same level we've seen in active equities. Others say that because fixed income and equity markets differ, competition won't be as tough, and active fixed income products face a much brighter future than traditional active equity products. So how do you see that debate? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#71

Regarding your second question, were you referring to asset management or CIB?

Alberto Artoni

analyst
#72

Yeah, generally speaking. Yeah, asset management, but that also ties into life insurance products, and indirectly into wealth management too.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#73

So lower rates do affect how outstandings are valued — particularly when you have a sizable fixed income business within asset management and within insurance, and you're aware that fixed income assets make up a big share of the insurance asset portfolio. So it's a mixed picture, because a decline in rates creates a positive valuation impact at the same time as, going forward, the new assets you're able to purchase yield less — so it's a mix. And I think ultimately what matters is being capable of adapting to whatever rate environment you face. We've demonstrated that holds true for us, in both life insurance operations and asset management operations. What matters is commercial demand when it comes to savings products and savings support. So long as our clients wish to put their savings into various categories of savings products, we have the complete range available, and we can serve them. On competition, it's fierce. It's becoming fiercer across every category of business — whether equities or fixed income products.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#74

The key thing is to be a low-cost producer to the greatest extent you can. Size, naturally, if you handle your size in a smart way, is a real benefit when your goal is low-cost production. We've got that size, and we've got the habit of producing at low cost. That's true for Amundi, whose average cost on assets under management is probably among the lowest anywhere in the market. And the same holds very much at Crédit Agricole Assurances.

Alberto Artoni

analyst
#75

Alright, thanks a lot.

Operator

operator
#76

Just a quick reminder — if you’d like to ask a question, press star and one on your phone. Our next question comes from Matthew Rosso at RBC.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#77

Yes, hello.

Matthew Rosso

analyst
#78

Good morning, and thanks for taking my question. Morning. I have a couple of questions on consumer finance. First, given the assumptions behind the provisions you've taken, are you making any assumption about the Supreme Court ruling that's coming up in the U.K.? And second, related to that, are there any other places—elsewhere in Europe, in other parts of the business—where you'd expect European regulators to take similar actions regarding discretionary commissions? Thank you very much.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#79

In the U.K., it's clear this is a very early stage of the case, because what we've observed is that the number of claims we've actually received is very limited for the time being. The second point is that we've seen the U.K. Minister of Finance now putting some pressure on the regulator to be moderate when it comes to setting the framework of potential indemnification, especially, of course, taking into consideration the potential impacts on U.K. banks, but also willing to frame a scheme in which there would be no windfall profit for some of the customers, which we deem perfectly reasonable. All in all, it's a preliminary provision. We do not know exactly if and when we are going to need to book additional provisions, but what I can tell you is that, first point, we will continue to have provisions according to our respective size on the market, which is very limited, again, 1%-2% of market share. So it's a very, very limited proportion of what is going to be booked by U.K. players. Second point, most of these activities were performed at a time where Crédit Agricole Auto Bank was FCA Bank and was a JV between FCA and ourselves, which means that at the end of the day, there is a loss-sharing scheme with Stellantis.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#80

The third thing is that, as far as we know, whenever regulators in the past 10 years have issued detailed guidance on how these activities should be carried out, our organization and our operations there have put those new rules straight into practice. So our view is that we have acted as diligently as we can in this U.K. market. Taking everything together, that leaves us quite confident this won't become a significant problem for us. Naturally, though, we need to keep watching the situation carefully. Turning to the final part of your question — do we expect further areas with similar difficulties or disputes? We don't anticipate any additional areas where a case like this would be opened. Naturally, we set out all the risk elements across our businesses in the risk section of the presentations. So there are a few pages in the appendix. Naturally, in the registration document, we also refresh our risk factors on a regular basis.

Matthew Rosso

analyst
#81

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#82

Sharath Kumar from Deutsche Bank has the next question, sir.

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#83

Thank you, Jérôme, for taking my questions. I still have a few more. First, returning to French retail, and expanding a bit further on what Pierre asked. I'd say it was encouraging to see mortgage loan production pick up more. In the current political climate, where do you think the appetite is for further improvement? I note the ECB lending survey pointed to some softness in the first quarter versus the prior quarter, so any comments on that would be appreciated. The second one concerns personal finance. Again, it's encouraging to see a good sequential recovery, although I note some one-off elements, but the underlying growth is still encouraging nonetheless. So in the wake of lower interest rates in 2025, where do you see margins and volumes developing? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#84

Sorry, could you clarify which business your second question was about, specifically?

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#85

On the personal finance side, or should I say specialized finance —

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#86

Alright, personal finance. Let's talk French retail and how willing customers are to take out home loans. In my view, our clients' desire to purchase a home has never been weaker — no, has never been stronger. What has weakened is their actual ability to borrow, given the steep rise in interest rates we witnessed in 2022, 2023, and through the start of 2024. So without question, French consumers' willingness to become homeowners has not shifted. What is shifting and getting better is their real capacity to borrow and to buy their homes, and on that point, the political uncertainty in France has no effect, because whether a budget gets passed or not doesn't really influence your desire to buy your house, to buy your home, so clearly, it doesn't change much, at least for the vast majority of the population. Naturally, for the higher end of the population, the person who invests in real estate and who purchases properties to rent them out, then, naturally, they will hesitate somewhat and wait to see whether there is going to be an extra tax burden on this business.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#87

However, for the vast majority of home loans that we grant, it's to people who want to borrow against their home, and so political uncertainties have no impact there. What matters going forward is how rate evolution continues. In my opinion, given where customer rates stand as of today and given the cost of refinancing, we should see customer rates stabilize, which is coherent with market rates and also coherent with our clients' capacity to borrow. So we expect further development of the home loan market in France and in our network, both LCL and the regional banks. Then in consumer credit, the good news in the fourth quarter of this year was that the progressive improvement in margins at inception of new loans began to translate into an improvement of the overall margin on the outstandings, which again was good news, because we had seen a very sharp decrease in margins with the increase of refinancing rates back two and two and a half years ago. We were expecting this moment when the price effect would start to invert.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#88

That's where we are now, so looking ahead to 2025 and beyond, we have high expectations for this business.

Sharath Kumar

analyst
#89

Thanks, Jérôme.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#90

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#91

And the last question comes from Matthew Clark, who is with Mediobanca.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#92

Hello there, two questions if I may. First, returning to the macro-hedging at LCL — apologies if that was already covered. I just want to verify: does this macro hedging apply to the mortgage portfolio? And if it doesn't, then specifically which products is the macro hedging on? My second question concerns the tax rate. Could you provide guidance for the coming year? Thank you.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#93

The macro hedging isn’t tied to any single portion of the balance sheet. When we set and carry out the macro hedging policy, our first step is to evaluate every customer-driven item on the balance sheet. On the asset side, that means fixed-rate loans, particularly home loans. On the liability side, we have several categories of customer deposits. There are sight deposits, treated as a fixed-rate liability carrying a zero-rate cost. There are also all the regulated savings accounts, where one rate component is tied to market rates and another component is linked to inflation. Then there are term deposits, where the rate is set and depends on how long the deposit runs. After that, we aggregate all these positions according to their rate components, which leaves a gap between assets and liabilities, and we cover that gap. Generally, the gap has, in a sense, a sign such that we need to complement it and book some swaps in which we pay the fixed rate.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#94

What that means is we offset the fixed-rate liabilities — the customer liabilities — using these swaps, so that the rate level we receive and the rate level we pay line up as closely as possible, leaving just a small residual gap between the two. So this is macro hedging, as opposed to micro hedging, where you'd hedge each individual item on the balance sheet one by one. And that's the situation we're in: we hold a sizable swaps portfolio where, taken together, we pay a fixed rate that's known and we receive the short-term rate, which changes each quarter or even daily.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#95

Got it, thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#96

All right. Regarding the tax rate and this extra tax, it looks like we'll only have the definitive answer later today — that the government won't face a no-confidence vote in France. That means the finance bill will get through. Within that finance bill sits an additional corporate tax surcharge that large French corporates, ourselves included, will have to pay in 2025. Clearly, the corporate tax level we face will rise in 2025. We can't yet pinpoint exactly where this leaves us amount-wise, but what we can say is that, more or less, it resembles somewhat the one we already had to pay back in 2017, with the same kind of mechanism, which points to a charge potentially, for the group, of between, let's say, EUR 200 million and EUR 300 million. Then there's a split of that burden between CASA, the listed entity, and the regional banks, and that isn't fully settled, since we sit in the same tax integration group. So it's far too early to say precisely what it will amount to.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#97

We obviously are going to face an extra corporate tax surcharge in 2025, and with luck that will turn out to be a one-off.

Matthew Clark

analyst
#98

Got it. Thanks.

Jérôme Grivet

executive
#99

I know that was the final question. So once more, thanks for joining the call, and I look forward to talking with you soon. Bye-bye, everyone.

Operator

operator
#100

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for joining. The conference is now over, and you may disconnect your telephone.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Crédit Agricole S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Crédit Agricole S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Crédit Agricole S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.