Dominion Energy, Inc. (D) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 5, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steven Ridge
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being with us this morning. The materials we've released for earnings, which include the remarks we prepared for today, might include forward-looking statements and estimates that carry a range of risks and uncertainties. We ask that you look at our SEC filings—among them our latest annual reports on Form 10-K, Q, and our quarterly reports on Form 10-Q—where factors are discussed that could lead results to come in differently than management's estimates and expectations. During this morning's session, we'll go over certain ways of measuring how our company has performed that aren't the same as those recognized under GAAP. The reconciliation of our non-GAAP measures against the GAAP financial measures that are most directly comparable, which we are able to calculate, appears in the earnings release kit. We'd also urge you to go to our investor relations website, where you can look over the earnings conference call materials, the earnings release kit included. On the call with us today are Tom Farrell, our Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer; Jim Chapman, our Executive Vice President, Chief Financial Officer, and Treasurer; and additional members of the executive management team. At this point, I'll hand the call over to Tom.
Tom Farrell
executiveThank you, Steven, and good morning to everyone. To begin, we want to convey how thankful we are for the medical workers and other frontline responders who are carrying out a truly heroic mission to help the people hit hardest by the COVID-19 pandemic. We honor what they are doing, and we feel tremendous gratitude, while also offering our condolences to every family that has endured the loss of a loved one to this illness. I'd also like to recognize our own field crews, who are delivering an essential public service by quite literally maintaining power and keeping critical energy supplies running. Behind these frontline team members stand many thousands of additional colleagues who deliver service of equal importance to our customers. Anyone who tracks Dominion is aware that nothing matters more to us than keeping our employees safe. When the pandemic first started to appear, we moved swiftly so that our people would be ready to deal with the virus's effects; we have relied on the crisis response plans we rehearse regularly, and those plans are now constantly updated using the latest guidance from health authorities and government officials. Among our actions, we put suitable social distancing measures in place and brought our remote connectivity systems online, which has allowed over 50% of our staff to work from home. We have adhered to leading practices for distributing and using PPE, and we are expanding health and paid time off benefits, along with launching a financial assistance initiative for employees that offers grants of as much as $2,000 to those facing need. In addition, we contributed $1 million to the American Red Cross and local nonprofits to support coronavirus relief directly. That comes on top of the millions of dollars we give every year to customer assistance programs and charitable causes across the communities we serve. This reflects the One Dominion Energy value put into action. Although a single case of COVID-19 is cause for real concern, we have been lucky that among over 19,000 employees spread across 20 states where we operate, only a very small number have tested positive, with most of those showing no symptoms or only mild ones, and the majority have already come back to work. Those employees remain in our thoughts, and we will stay focused on the health and well-being of our whole workforce, while never forgetting our fundamental responsibility to deliver reliable, affordable energy. Our customers are in our thoughts too. We recognize the difficulties so many of them are going through. That is why, for instance, we chose on our own to pause non-payment service disconnections and eliminate late fees throughout every one of our utility service territories. We will additionally provide our customers with tools meant to help them get past whatever financial difficulties they might encounter. As the economies of our states and regions start to reopen step by step, we are putting preventive measures in place to make certain our workplaces remain safe and our customers get the finest customer service we can deliver. At this point I'll hand the call to Jim, who will go over our quarterly results and share our thinking on the impacts related to COVID.
Jim Chapman
executiveThanks, Tom. To start, I'll refer to slide four and share that when you adjust for typical weather, our operating earnings per share for the quarter hit or came in above the midpoint of the guidance range we provided — making it 17 quarters in a row. For the first quarter of 2020, operating earnings came to $1.09 per share, and that figure absorbed a $0.09 blow because conditions were far worse than usual. In Virginia, it ranked as the third hottest first quarter ever recorded. On a weather-normalized basis, we landed at $1.18 per share, which was above the midpoint of our guidance range. As you may remember, weather last year in the first quarter cost us $0.06, yet across the next three quarters we recovered more than enough to end the year with weather providing a total benefit of $0.02. And even if you set weather aside entirely, this marked the 17th straight quarter where results fell inside our guidance range. On a GAAP basis, earnings for the quarter were — $0.34 per share. That figure stems partly from a non-cash charge tied to the planned early shutdown of some coal and oil-fired generating units in Virginia, which aligns with what the recently passed Virginia Clean Economy Act requires. Shutting down those units had already been factored into earlier iterations of our integrated resource plan and was officially made public in late March; we also recorded a non-cash effect from unrealized losses on our nuclear decommissioning trust funds, and just to remind everyone, we classify those unrealized gains and losses on the funds as non-operating. Schedule two in the earnings release kit lays out a summary of the adjustments bridging operating and reported results; moving to slide five, we're kicking off second quarter 2020 operating earnings guidance in a range of $0.75- $0.85 per share. In addition, we're reaffirming our annual guidance range of $4.25- $4.60 per share. As always, normal weather is assumed in these ranges, and deviations could push results toward the top or bottom of them. Our second quarter and full-year guidance ranges also incorporate our preliminary views on how COVID-19 will affect our financial results. Before I go through each operating segment, let me tackle some likely questions about how we expect the economic recovery to take shape and how quickly it will move. In reaffirming our annual guidance today, our assumption is that the economy starts picking up by late summer, though as you'll see shortly, demand in Virginia so far has been strong compared to recent years even with the pandemic. Naturally, shifts in how long the recovery lasts and how severe it is could wind up affecting our financial results by more or less than what we're currently forecasting. It's hard to know what lies ahead, which is exactly why we're restating the demand-related earnings sensitivities for our two electric utilities. Our hope is that this helps analysts and investors adjust their models to match their own views on how the economic recovery will unfold. Either way, exactly like we've done from the start of March, our intention is to give regular public reports on the different ways this crisis is hitting our operations, covering load figures too, as we move through the economic reopening, which is happening step by step, though it kicked off yesterday in South Carolina and should start in Virginia in 10 days; so now let me discuss our businesses, beginning with Dominion Energy Virginia, our biggest segment. Updated load data appears on slide six; that chart shows daily weather-normalized load for the PJM Dom zone measured against a two-year historic weather-normalized average. It's clear from this that COVID-19's effect on zonal demand hasn't shifted significantly since what we previously disclosed, and Virginia load keeps demonstrating remarkable resilience. We credit four things, shown on slide seven. To start, residential usage, normally making up roughly 45% of segment revenue. Last month, we observed YoY weather normal residential load rising roughly 3%. As is evident, residential customers add more to revenue per unit of usage than our bigger volume classes do. Number two, the growing number of data centers within our service territory. Even with a statewide stay-at-home order, April weather-normalized commercial load dropped just 3% because of COVID-19, largely driven by the stabilizing influence of data center demand growth. Number three, our limited industrial exposure. Although industrial demand fell roughly 3% in April, industrial usage represents just 6% of DEV's revenue. And lastly, government, military, and other demand, making up 16% of revenue, which rose nearly 4% YoY last month. I'd also like to highlight several elements of our regulatory framework, which matter when thinking about the financial consequences of the COVID-19 crisis. Roughly 40% of DEV's rate base sits in rider form, permitting an annual true-up for sales volume changes. Beyond that, revenue tied to fuel pass-through gets adjusted yearly as well, to reflect, among other things, over or under recovery from usage. Though the load data we've provided doesn't show it, together these two mitigants make up half of DEV's operating revenue and amount to effective decoupling from load changes. We keep watching the situation carefully. Looking at the data available, we currently aren't projecting significant COVID-driven revenue effects from lower load at Dominion Energy Virginia for the rest of 2020. Naturally, things remain dynamic, so for your reference we're repeating our earlier published rules of thumb for load variations by class. With nearly 45% of our operating earnings, DEV is by far our biggest state-regulated utility exposure to COVID-related demand swings. Now let me move to slide eight to go through the same data for Dominion Energy South Carolina's electric operations. Since the executive order took effect on March 31st, we've observed a clear drop in weather normal demand relative to the two-year historic average. To be more specific, electric demand during April declined by nearly 10% in relative terms. Although we anticipate higher residential demand, our operations in South Carolina—unlike Virginia—don't gain from the same stability in data center load and, as slide nine shows, face greater exposure to industrial load. At least some production has been temporarily halted by 10 of DESC's top 30 industrial manufacturing customers; nonetheless, plans to resume production within the next several weeks have been conveyed by all but two among those 10. As is the case in Virginia, certain structural mitigants exist in South Carolina that lessen the load impact on revenue. Rider form, with monthly true-ups, covers roughly 25% of DESC's total rate base. An additional nearly 10% of rate base comes from South Carolina gas distribution operations regulated in a manner that trues up each year. Lastly, revenue tied to fuel pass-through for electric and gas operations gets adjusted yearly to reflect, among other things, over- or under-recovery caused by usage. Though the load data we've provided doesn't reveal this, close to 50% of DESC's operating revenues are accounted for by these three mitigants combined, which amount to effective decoupling from load fluctuations. Additionally, given that Dominion Energy South Carolina's overall earnings contribution represents about 10% of Dominion's forecasted operating earnings, COVID's effect on our financial performance in South Carolina is likely to be comparatively less significant financially.
Jim Chapman
executiveLooking ahead is hard to do, but at this point we anticipate that load patterns will pick up little by little as the summer winds down. That said, this is a moving picture, so we are restating once more our rules of thumb for how load shifts by class for DESC's electric operations. Keep in mind these sensitivities are built on a complete 12-month period and a 1% shift in load. April by itself makes up just a modest share of annualized load, because for one thing, it usually has the smallest sales of any month, and naturally, it is merely 1 of the 12 months in a year. I want to mention as well that we asked, of our own accord, for a 60-day postponement of our pending South Carolina electric base rate case. Under the merger agreement, it had been slated to start later in this quarter and wrap up with new rates taking effect January 2021. Our view is firm that this is the wise course to follow. Let me move to slide 10 at this point to discuss our other segments, which I can get through more swiftly. To begin, gas distribution, which makes up roughly 15% of operating earnings. More than 80% of segment operating margin is shielded via decoupling or fixed charges, such as riders and gas pass-through mechanisms. These well-designed rate structures cut down substantially on the effect we anticipate from demand swings tied to COVID. I should mention too that we are now in a stretch of several months covering off-peak and shoulder demand seasons for gas distribution. Gas transmission and storage, which represents close to a quarter of operating earnings. A handful of things to note here. Number one, contracts normally follow a long-term, take-or-pay format, with reservation or capacity charges that mostly do not depend on utilization. For pipelines and storage that already exist, the average remaining contract life runs 6 to 7 years, and considerably longer for Cove Point Liquefaction and ACP. Number two, demand pull drives this segment above all. As we told everyone at Investor Day, roughly 80% of the revenues tied to segment assets come from demand-driven counterparties like utilities. Number three, counterparty credit quality stands high because of the regulated utility tilt in the customer base. When shippers fall short of our tough internal credit standards, we generally demand protections above the industry average, such as collateral through cash or a letter of credit that frequently spans multiple years of exposure. Last of all, Cove Point Liquefaction contracts are take or pay and permit shippers to send cargoes to any location worldwide that U.S. policy does not forbid. Customers must pay no matter how much they use. I would point out that as of today, customers keep nominating volumes at the plant's design capacity. And lastly, contracted generation runs mostly under long-term PPA or hedge arrangements, which COVID-19's effects are unlikely to touch in any material way. Stepping back for a moment, we are likewise monitoring payment arrears data closely throughout every segment. So far, we have observed small upticks, which line up with what we expected. Having said that, we'll be working closely with our customers in the months ahead to offer choices and instruments that help them keep their service running and bring their accounts back to good standing. We don't anticipate that bad debt expense above what we've budgeted will be a significant factor driving the year. Although it isn't a direct comparison, back during the financial crisis, we saw yearly bad debt expense at DEV, for example, rise by only about $20 million; in our electric business, as is true for most of our peers, bad debt gets handled through periodic base rate case proceedings. At nearly every one of our gas utilities, we can recover bad debt expense fully or partially through real-time rate mechanisms, for example dedicated trackers or fuel pass-through adjustment clauses. The impact of COVID-19 on our financial results in the first quarter was muted, but we aren't assuming that will last forever. So we're stepping up our efforts to find ways to cut costs broadly across our businesses as we aim to be ready to hit our affirmed annual guidance range. I can't quantify a total amount today, but some simple examples would be cuts in business travel, office supply, and operational fuel expenses, plus the effects of putting a hiring freeze in place; we'll keep watching these and other O&M reduction options. Now moving to liquidity, which is on slide 11. When volatility in capital markets rose sharply in March, we acted quickly and opportunistically to strengthen our liquidity position out of an abundance of caution. Across roughly 15 days, we brought in almost $5 billion of available or funded debt capital. On slide 12, we're updating our annual financing plan for issuance so far this year. To remove any doubt, as of today there's no change to our long-term debt financing amounts, our external equity need of $300 million under our DRIP program, or our CapEx guidance for the year. We have looked, and will keep looking, at the possibility of delaying small amounts of capital investment where safety and reliability won't be compromised. Any delay of that kind would be fairly small and short in duration. We haven't seen any major disruptions to any of our key supply chains. Last, a few remarks about our pension on slide 13. We began the year at a 92% funded status, a meaningful increase over the prior year. It's far too soon to say where we'll end up at year-end 2020 when we remeasure assets and liabilities, but a few factors matter. First, discount rates, which rest on long-term all-in corporate bond yields, sit at roughly the same levels seen at the close of last year, even with lower Treasury rates. Second, at the end of January this year, we chose to hedge the equity exposure in our plan assets through the futures market. When March brought a drop in public equities, we seized the chance to cash in the bulk of our hedge position at levels 25% and 30% in the money. Those cash proceeds are now starting to be put back to work in equity exposure. Plan assets through April sit nearly unchanged for the year, a result that stacks up well against the big losses typical pension portfolios might be expected to see. Let me say again, a great deal of time remains until the next expected remeasurement date, December 31st. No matter where funded status lands for the year, we anticipate no need for pension plan contributions this year or next. Moving to slide 14. To sum up, we posted our 17th consecutive quarter of weather normal results at or above the midpoint of guidance, and our 17th consecutive quarter of results falling within our guidance range. In our view, our businesses are well-positioned when it comes to COVID-related demand impacts; we are watching the situation closely; we reaffirmed our annual operating EPS range of $4.25-$4.60 per share. We're also affirming our post-2020 guidance of 5%+ annual operating EPS growth, as well as our dividend per share growth of 2.5% per annum, subject, as is customary, to board approval. I'll now turn the call back over to Tom.
Tom Farrell
executiveThank you, Jim. Even with the global pandemic causing so much disruption, the people who work here have stayed intently focused on keeping operations safe and dependable for the people and families, the companies, the industries, and the government bodies we feel lucky to serve as customers. Public service is our line of work, and what we do has a direct effect on the lives of those we serve and the communities around them. I'd like to walk through three concrete cases, all from the past 6 weeks alone, happening on opposite ends of the country, and they appear on slide 15. On the morning of March 18, the Salt Lake City Valley felt the biggest earthquake to hit that area in 30 years. That 5.7 magnitude quake produced close to 1,800 service calls along with 1,400 gas distribution work orders, and both figures were more than 20 times the usual level. Our crews got moving right away to deal with any safety concerns and to keep service dependable for homes and businesses in the middle of winter. As evidence of how solid our infrastructure is, and thanks to the major investments in integrity and pipeline replacement programs that our regulators approved, we identified zero material gas leaks anywhere on our system stemming from the earthquake. Under 4 weeks afterward, on April 13, 21 tornadoes came down in South Carolina, with 4 of them rated EF3 strength, carrying winds reaching 165 mi per hour, and 1 rated an EF4 tornado, with winds reaching 200 mi per hour. It stood as the busiest single day of tornado activity in South Carolina over the past 35 years. Inside 24 hours, our crews brought back 96% of the 117,000 customers of ours who had lost service in the storm. Over the 2 days that followed, our people put in extremely long hours across devastated areas to complete the restoration work and, in the process, help those communities recover some sense of normalcy. After the storm passed, the South Carolina Office of Regulatory Staff put out a press release praising the commitment and hard work of the state's electrical personnel, the men and women who labored tirelessly so power systems would come back online even while a global pandemic was underway. That same day, 300 mi to the northeast, intense rain and winds gusting to 70 mi per hour throughout Virginia and North Carolina cut service to almost 200,000 of our customers. Inside 24 hours, our crews had brought back 95% of customers, and the remaining 5% were reconnected across the next 12 hours. I take pride, though it doesn't surprise me, in how our Dominion Energy team members have stepped up for our customers through this difficult period. Now to safety, our first core value. Our safety results for the first quarter put us at number one within our southeastern peer group and keep us on pace for yet another year of record performance. As of the end of March, our OSHA recordable rate comes in at roughly half of what it was in the first quarter of last year. Additionally, fourteen days ago, seven of the gas infrastructure operating businesses we own earned recognition from the AGA for exceptional safety results. For the rest of what I've prepared to say, I'll cover what came out of the Virginia General Assembly session along with where things stand with the Atlantic Coast Pipeline. The Virginia legislative session officially wrapped up in the prior month. On April 11, Governor Northam put his signature on the Virginia Clean Economy Act, or VCEA, which works alongside the Grid Transformation and Security Act that was already on the books from 2018; that earlier statute created a broad structure governing utility regulation and investment within Virginia. As slide 16 illustrates, the VCEA puts our company on a course toward delivering the largest clean energy investment program mandated by legislation anywhere in the United States. Consequently, Virginia stands ready to emerge as a national leader in zero-carbon buildout across the coming thirty years. This requirement will generate thousands of jobs, assist local communities, strengthen Virginia's economy, draw in businesses and families, enhance the environment, and act as a model for other states pursuing equally bold, sustainable energy objectives. The plan additionally advances our company-wide goals of net zero methane and carbon emissions by 2050. The VCEA mandates and determines, as being in the public interest, the creation of renewable generation and energy storage resources in the following amounts: 5,200 MW of offshore wind, with 100% of it eligible for utility ownership, 16,100 MW of solar or onshore wind, with 65% of it eligible for utility ownership, and 2,700 MW of energy storage, with 65% of it eligible for utility ownership. These goals must be achieved within the coming 15 years, alongside further targets by 2045. Beyond setting a public interest determination for these programs, the statute lays out particular regulatory approval standards and confirms rider eligibility for every one of those programs. I'll go through each in order. With respect to our previously announced 2,600-MW Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind project, the commission must presume costs to be reasonable and prudent provided the project clears three essential tests, as slide 17 shows. First, competitive procurement and solicitation standards for components are satisfied; we have satisfied this standard on our Virginia projects for many years. We have consistently worked to lower costs while simultaneously balancing performance and reliability so as to optimize value for our customers. Second, the projected Levelized Cost of Energy, or LCOE, is reasonable when measured against a particular EIA benchmark. Our preliminary estimates for project LCOE of $80-$90 per megawatt hour stack up very favorably against this benchmark. This range leaves out the advantage of any federal tax incentives that may be available, which we are striving to protect for customers' benefit. Third, the project's construction begins before 2024 or has a plan to enter service by 2028. Our project meets both milestones. We're happy with the progress so far on both our pilot and full-scale deployments. Even with the pandemic, the main pilot project components have come in from Europe, as the cover slide shows. We anticipate installation getting underway this quarter, with commercial in-service by year-end. We've kicked off the subsea survey work too, which will back our submission to BOEM of the full-scale offshore construction and operation plan before this year wraps up; the Virginia fishing industry has come on board with us on this effort. We keep collaborating with equipment makers and service providers to push for Virginia becoming the hub of the U.S. offshore wind sector; we're heading up a consortium of industry specialists and participants building a vessel for installation that fully complies with the Jones Act, outfitted to manage every turbine technology in use today plus the next-generation sizes of 12 MW and above. With these mega turbines, there are fewer foundations and lower construction and maintenance costs, which brings down the levelized cost of energy. Funded by consortium participants, Dominion Energy among them, the vessel starts service in 2023 and will run without interruption for several years under contracts with a number of major U.S. offshore wind developers. According to our present estimates for fully installed costs, which we anticipate will decline over time, offshore wind, as the VCEA directs, accounts for somewhere between $8 billion and $17 billion in capital investment across the next 15 years. At the low end, that range matches the cost estimate we previously announced for our 2,600-MW project.
Tom Farrell
executiveThat higher number includes an additional opportunity mandated by statute — 2,600 MW must come online ahead of 2035. As a result, for this program we're pulling our five-year growth capital estimate forward by one year. The updated total is $3.5 billion, which reflects the full deployment ramp during 2024. Previously, that number was only $1.1 billion. We plan to make an initial rider filing at some point in 2022. Now on to solar and onshore wind, shown on slide 18. Onshore wind resources in Virginia are somewhat constrained, so we expect most of what the law calls for in that category will be met through a major solar expansion inside the commonwealth. As mentioned before, the legislation calls for over 16,000 MW by 2036, with 10,000 MW that utilities may own; in other words, Dominion will average about 700 MW of solar added each year over the next 15 years. To date, we've completed more than 70% of our prior commitment of at least 3,000 MW by 2022; in the first quarter, the Virginia Commission approved our third solar rider application. Meeting the VCEA's ambitious targets will require us to push even harder on this front. We've already begun significantly increasing our activity. In deciding on solar and onshore wind approvals, along with energy storage, the statute tells the commission to consider, quote, "The promotion of new renewable generation and associated economic development, projected fuel savings, and the RPS standards of the law." Assuming utility ownership reaches 65% as permitted by law, solar generation translates to about $19 billion in capital investment over the next 15 years. Our rolled-forward five-year growth capital forecast is now $5.5 billion, because we intend to accelerate spending so the law's milestones are achieved. The prior number was $3.7 billion. Switching to energy storage, which includes our work to develop a pumped storage facility in southwestern Virginia. Four battery technology pilot projects — totaling roughly $30 million and about 16 MW — recently received commission approval; hitting the 2,700-MW target set by law will demand a highly aggressive effort in the coming years. Assuming utility ownership reaches 65% as permitted by law, energy storage translates to about $7 billion in capital investment over the next 15 years. Our present five-year growth capital plan, which we're adjusting only modestly as we roll forward one year, already included roughly $1 billion for pumped storage. Slide 20 shows the result of updating five-year growth capital estimates for just these three programs — an increase of $4 billion, or over 70%, with $2.6 million of that tied to the initial phase. At this time we aren't refreshing existing five-year CapEx figures for other programs or segments, though we don't expect anything material to differ from our latest guidance. Later on, we'll look for an opportunity to provide a comprehensive update covering all segments. Looking further out—please see slide 21—those three legislative priorities, wind, solar, and energy storage, combined total roughly $34 billion to $43 billion of growth capital across the coming 15 years, based on present cost assumptions and pending regulatory approval. On top of that come the rider-eligible investments we'll make during this decade: electric transmission, nuclear relicensing, strategic undergrounding, grid modernization, and renewable-enabling quick-start generation. Taken together, those projects amount to nearly $16 billion in growth capital, again pending regulatory approval. To give some perspective, Dominion Energy Virginia's rate base closed 2019 at about $24 billion. Now look at slide 22: according to our latest integrated resource plan, we expect typical residential customer bills from 2019 through 2030—including authorized passthroughs related to Virginia's participation in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative—to move in line with average historic inflation, and we view fuel savings from dispatching additional renewable generation as a significant benefit to customers. Of course, we continually strive to hold rates competitive and affordable, and our record there is strong, as today's rates demonstrate—they sit below state, regional, and national averages. Let me also note that the typical bill our customers pay now is almost 40% lower than what the average RGGI-participating state charges. Looking ahead, we expect our rates to stay well beneath those states' by a very wide margin. Beyond that, the VCEA expands on existing programs designed to direct funds toward assisting lower-income customers. With renewable yet intermittent resources proliferating across our system, we must also sustain substantial investment in transmission infrastructure, because solar sites are cropping up statewide. It will also demand an ever more modern grid—which explains why the commission's recent ruling rejecting certain, though certainly not all, elements of our latest Grid Transformation filing disappointed our company and our customers most of all. We will continue seeking full deployment of smart meters and other upgrades throughout the system, which will greatly enhance how we interact with customers, as well as our ability to operate an energy delivery network that is increasingly two-way. In the years ahead, the VCEA and associated legislation will profoundly transform our generation fuel mix. What will not change is the duty we owe customers: providing 24/7 energy with as few interruptions as possible. The COVID-19 pandemic has made that message unmistakably clear. Current battery technology's capacity to discharge baseload power over multiple days confronts technological, operational, and economic constraints. Factor in that in Virginia, at least, periods arise when no wind blows and no sun shines—periods lasting days rather than hours—and it becomes certain that natural gas-fired generation will continue playing a vital, low-emission role in our network for many years to come, with $2.6 million in related investment already committed. That’s exactly why policymakers wisely inserted language in the VCEA, in multiple places, explicitly allowing system reliability and energy security to be considered as a whole before ruling out any low-emitting fuel such as natural gas. This aligns with our unwavering commitment to achieve net zero by 2050. Still, one point is clear: less efficient, higher-emitting electricity sources, such as coal and oil, will be removed from our system. To that end, beginning in early 2019 and continuing through this first quarter, we have taken steps to retire more than 3,300 MW of power stations fueled primarily by coal and oil. Due to recent legal changes, the commission is no longer statutorily obligated to provide period expense treatment for those retirements. For customers, period expensing is the best method, and long-standing commission precedent over many years requires it. Under the triennial review in the GTSA’s established framework, if the Commission determines we have excess earnings—whether by choosing to reverse that precedent and amortize plant retirement charges over a longer period, or because our financial results otherwise warrant such a finding—we will offset those excess earnings through dollar-for-dollar Customer Credit Reinvestment Offsets, or CCROs, including our $300 million offshore wind pilot project investment, as well as $2.6 million.
Tom Farrell
executiveA one-time customer refund and rate reductions capped at $50 million via the subsequent triennial review, wrapping up in late 2024, could only be mandated by the Commission if excess earnings cannot be completely offset using CCROs. Turning to the Atlantic Coast Pipeline and Supply Header Project. Slide 23 provides our summary of where things stand with permits for certain projects. Starting with the Appalachian Trail crossing: oral arguments in the case were heard by the Supreme Court on February 24. In the next few weeks, we anticipate the court will decide in ACP's favor. Should that happen, the project's authorization to move forward on the current route would be restored. Even with the pandemic, the court is still meeting by phone and issuing orders on cases argued earlier in the term. Moving on to the biological opinion: work is proceeding in spite of COVID, with us supplying information that answers what FERC and the Fish and Wildlife Service have asked for. By the close of this quarter, we anticipate the authorization will be issued again. That span would represent almost a complete 12 months from when the court struck down the earlier version in July 2019, which shows how thoroughly the permitting agencies are working to resolve the issues the court flagged; regarding the air permit for Buckingham Compressor Station, additional data and analysis have already been submitted by us to the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality, something we think offers sufficient justification for the initial decision to approve the air permit — the toughest minor source air permit anywhere in the country — and tackles every concern the court raised. By year-end, we anticipate the permit will be issued again. Last, concerning Nationwide Permit 12, granted to the project by the United States Army Corps of Engineers, our expectation had been that the permit would be reissued soon after the biological opinion came out, given that the Corps has recently been taking actions responding to the Fourth Circuit's concerns. A recent ruling by the District Court in Montana involving the Keystone Pipeline could have consequences for virtually every critical infrastructure investment and the jobs tied to it nationwide. That takes in the delivery of drinking water, electricity, and fuel, internet, radio, television, telephone, and other communications, and is poised to affect service to the public, governments, defense installations, hospitals, schools, and other businesses and industry. More than 38,000 uses of the Nationwide Permit 12 program have occurred since its March 2017 renewal, and according to the Court's estimate, over 5,000 further notifications are waiting for action. The Department of Justice requested expedited review of its motion for a partial stay pending appeal, and that request was granted, with every reply coming due this Friday. Our expectation is a concentrated push involving industry, commerce, and labor organizations, along with the Department of Justice, to bring clarity and resolution to this matter promptly. When it comes to ACP, our view is that it's too soon to determine what effect, if any, this ruling will have on the project's existing timeline and cost, which we are otherwise reaffirming today. If the matter gets resolved promptly, we can hold to the current schedule and cost estimates, provided we're able to benefit from the tree felling season running from November 2020 through March 2021. We'll keep watching the situation and communicate with investors as needed. Given these expectations, our confidence in the project reaching successful completion remains strong, and we note there are no revisions to the financial contribution estimates for 2020 and beyond that Jim gave during our fourth quarter earnings call. This infrastructure is needed by customers today more than at any prior point to guarantee a reliable energy supply. So we recently wrapped up negotiations with the major customers to deliver a fair rate of return for the project owners and to strike an appropriate balance of project costs among the parties. In addition, our confidence remains firm regarding Virginia regulatory approval of the prudency of capacity contracts within Dominion Energy's fuel filing cases as the project approaches operation. Legislation enacted during the recent Virginia General Assembly session set up fuel case review criteria acknowledging how important energy reliability is, and it closely tracks the prudency standard the commission already applies. That said, here's my summary of today's call. On safety, we're on pace to establish a new company record for the lowest OSHA recordable rate. We delivered weather-normalized operating earnings above the midpoint of our guidance range for the 17th quarter in a row. We reaffirmed guidance for 2020 earnings. We confirmed that our EPS growth expectations apply plus percent post-2020. We're enthusiastic about the opportunities created by recently enacted Virginia legislation to make our generation fleet more sustainable, which will also support our corporate-wide commitment to net zero carbon and methane emissions by 2050. Across every one of our capital investment programs, we're achieving meaningful progress that benefits our customers. At this point, we'd be glad to take your questions.
Shar Pourreza
analystHey, good afternoon, guys.
Tom Farrell
executiveGood morning.
Jim Chapman
executiveMorning.
Shar Pourreza
analystYou gave solid figures on CapEx plans covering solar, onshore wind, and offshore wind following the law's approval. Clearly, your company raised the capital budget for clean energy through the planning horizon. Is there any structural factor you could identify that might block you from accelerating more spending, given that your overall investment opportunity set is substantially larger—meaning bill headroom allowing it? Offshore wind could face certain obstacles, sure, but how should we consider additional onshore or solar spending being moved up? Just trying to gauge possible upside to the near-term blueprint and that current plus 5% growth path, which is looking fairly achievable.
Jim Chapman
executiveHi Shar, morning. This is Jim.
Shar Pourreza
analystHi, Jim.
Jim Chapman
executiveI appreciate that. What we've done here isn't a complete Monty-style roll forward covering the entirety of our capital spending, nor have we tackled our long-term growth rate and similar items in a more comprehensive way. Today, the only thing we've handled is an update — a roll forward covering a fresh 5-year stretch — and it touches just 3 programs, all inside a single segment. Naturally, that broader, more comprehensive look happens on a less frequent basis; we carried it out in 2016, and we carried it out in 2019. That isn't on the agenda for now; at some point ahead we'll locate an occasion to conduct a complete walkthrough and give somewhat more color regarding the other moving pieces, beyond merely these 3 updates concerning the particular spending programs inside DEV.
Shar Pourreza
analystUnderstood. So the main point, and tell me if I've got this backwards, is that if this strategy is turning into something far more viable over the long haul, then eventually you'll have the ability to dial in that growth rate above 5%.
Jim Chapman
executiveRight. Just remember, at the point when we.
Shar Pourreza
analystYeah.
Jim Chapman
executiveBack in March, at the point we made public that 5%+ growth rate, our thinking was that a spending program along these lines would keep going, or possibly grow, in Virginia and other places. That is correct. Once we are no longer in the middle of a worldwide pandemic, we will return and tackle this in a more holistic way. Our view was that now was not the appropriate moment.
Shar Pourreza
analystUnderstood. Understood. And I agree with you on that, incidentally. One final quick item regarding ACP. You mentioned something about a prompt resolution for Nationwide Permit 12, correct? Could you share anything further on that? If that resolution slipped to a later point in the year, at what stage would you begin reconsidering the schedule? Tom, could you perhaps go into a bit more detail about the most recent contract talks you've been having with customers? What has the discussion centered on? Where has the tension or momentum been, or is the bigger issue simply COVID-19, which has caused something of a slowdown? If you could expand just a little more on those negotiations, I'll rejoin the queue. Thanks.
Tom Farrell
executiveThank you, Shar. I'll take the first portion of your initial question. Diane will handle your second one. As we've mentioned, the crucial dates for us revolve around tree-cutting season, which extends through March of next year. To accomplish what's required, we need roughly 10 weeks of tree-cutting time — 10, 12 weeks. Bear in mind that along this 600-mi pipeline, we've already cut trees on 250 mi. Trees aren't present on every mile. In fact, hundreds of miles have none. The truly critical thing for us is reaching that tree-cutting season. We'll find out what unfolds. The judge's ruling caught many people off guard. You ought to anticipate a number of amicus briefs getting submitted that highlight this. What he addressed was every type of utility infrastructure — not merely an oil pipeline in Montana. It covered each utility infrastructure program across the nation. It appears possibly to be a bold move from the judge, perhaps not entirely warranted by the matter in front of him. We'll simply need to observe how it develops. Naturally, you can then go to the Ninth Circuit and so forth, but we'll assess that as things progress; regarding the second portion of your question, I'll hand things over to Diane Leopold.
Diane Leopold
executiveAlright. Good morning — I think what you asked about had to do with the talks with customers. If that isn't what I'm addressing, just tell me.
Shar Pourreza
analystAll right.
Diane Leopold
executiveWe've wrapped up discussions with the customers. Those were finalized across the quarter, meaning the rate along with every remaining term and condition is now set, so the project is assured a fair rate of return, and it weighs what customers need against what customers pay.
Shar Pourreza
analystUnderstood. Is there any modification to the return assumptions that would be significant enough to warrant disclosure?
Diane Leopold
executiveNone.
Shar Pourreza
analystGreat. Thanks, everyone. Congratulations. That's a really resilient plan. Congratulations.
Tom Farrell
executiveThanks.
Shar Pourreza
analystAppreciate it, everyone.
Steve Fleishman
analystThank you. Good morning, and I hope everybody is doing well.
Tom Farrell
executiveThank you, Steve.
Steve Fleishman
analystJim, I can't wait for the complete Monty roll forward. The whole Monty roll forward — I'm eager for it, Jim.
Tom Farrell
executiveThat's a bit more than I can take.
Steve Fleishman
analystTo make that image a bit clearer, is there anything you can share about how the need for financing might shift given the larger capital plan? Perhaps that arrives alongside a roll forward, but how are we meant to approach it?
Jim Chapman
executiveYes, I'd say that's reasonable. It will arrive alongside the roll forward. What we're laying out here are spending plans that are sizable, though they stretch across a 15-year time period. On the financing side, we'll stick with our practice of providing that one year and at times multiple years ahead of time. Nothing shifts in the near term, and definitely nothing shifts this year, but we'll take another look at what the financing mix will be, broadly speaking, when we do a more holistic update. I'd point out, however, so there's no doubt, that for these programs we've discussed under the VCEA, every bit of the financing will sit at DEV, meaning the VEPCO legal entity. Project financings or similar arrangements aren't something we're looking at. It will be a combination of regular way financing at VEPCO. There's more to come when we offer more holistic updates.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. So this might be somewhat specific, though it's also a big-picture one, and it's for Tom. Looking at the entire Virginia situation, this plan clearly comes across as a very green, clean, sustainability-oriented program. Could you share a little detail on the broader picture — what the state is attempting with this, and how you're viewed within the state's context? In particular, regarding this portion of the plan, the new Jones Act vessel piece, any detail on how that would function and perhaps how it fits within this broader Virginia plan?
Tom Farrell
executiveSure, Steve. Let me bring everyone up to speed on where Virginia politics stand. In this General Assembly session, for what I believe is 30 years, we held elections last year; our state legislature — both the Senate and the House of Delegates — is always in an off year, and for the first time in either 20 or 30 years, I can't recall exactly how many decades, you had the Democratic Party controlling both chambers as well as the executive branch. A great deal of interest existed among the new House and Senate members in pushing forward a number of policies across many fronts, not only energy. There was legislation of all kinds regarding gun rights, for instance, and various other matters. Minimum wage, and so on. An effort had been underway — we'd spent years working alongside a number of groups, particularly on solar, on ways to guarantee that it arrived in Virginia efficiently and cost-effectively. We collaborated with a broad range of policymakers to make certain these objectives are attainable and remain affordable for our customers. As you can see from our IRP filed last week, we anticipate that even with this spending plan, our plan B under the IRP is the most probable plan. At minimum, we believe it's the most probable plan. Others will weigh in, naturally. Will run at roughly traditional inflation rates. We've joined RGGI, and our rates — well, comparing our rates now to the RGGI states, we're 40% below the average RGGI state; we're half of the highest RGGI state. That leaves plenty of room for us to remain extremely competitive. Steve, I think on the whole, from a big-picture standpoint, it was part of a broader effort across many different areas of policymaking to have a more progressive outlook, as those policymakers would describe it, a more progressive outlook on a variety of factors. Your second question concerned the vessel, which I'll hand over to Bob Blue.
Bob Blue
executiveMorning, Steve. I'd frame this vessel against the whole East Coast, not only Virginia, and Tom gave a solid description of that state. From New England down through Virginia, you'll find many offshore wind projects at different points in development. Every one of them needs a Jones Act answer for installation, and that includes ours. It's great that we're playing a leading role in a consortium made up of possible infrastructure investors and other industry players, working on a vessel that can handle the installation of bigger turbines while staying Jones Act compliant. That project, in our view, lines up really well with the offshore wind build-out we're watching along the East Coast.
Jim Chapman
executiveJim Chapman here — mind if I throw in a couple of points?
Bob Blue
executivewould that be over in Virginia? Yes.
Jim Chapman
executiveSorry. Sorry about that.
Bob Blue
executiveAll right.
Jim Chapman
executiveRegarding what that vessel's profile looks like, to be clear, it's going to be a fully contracted, long-term profile. As for the percentage ownership we plan to hold, we don't have a figure yet. Through our contracted generation segment, we will hold an owner position, though from that business profile we anticipate infrastructure-style returns, and because of that we expect infrastructure investors along with other industry participants to show interest in co-funding that project.
Steve Fleishman
analystInteresting.
Jim Chapman
executiveThank you.
Steve Fleishman
analystOkay, great. Thank you.
Tom Farrell
executiveThanks, Steve.
Steve Fleishman
analystThanks.
Michael Weinstein
analystHey there, hello everyone.
Bob Blue
executiveGood morning.
Michael Weinstein
analystHey. Good morning.
Tom Farrell
executiveMorning.
Michael Weinstein
analystMy apologies for that. Now, regarding the Jones Act vessel — when it comes to its cost, that investment, does it fall under the future cost of the offshore wind? Is it counted within the CapEx profile for that?
Jim Chapman
executiveNo, Michael, that's a good question. It isn't. The amount, which is yet to be determined, will have our stake invested via our contracted generation segment, not within DEV, and it won't be included in the capital spend we laid out for offshore wind.
Michael Weinstein
analystAll right. For the additional 2.6 GW of offshore wind you have in the pipeline across the coming 15 years, what's the schedule? When does that second 2.6 GW come in? Is it unambiguously following the first 2.6 GW?
Bob Blue
executiveYes, without question. The location is still undecided. Our IRP has it arriving in 2034, though it will follow the initial project Tom walked through, which we anticipate entering service at the close of 2026.
Michael Weinstein
analystSorry if this came up earlier, but I'd also like to ask about when the money goes into storage — battery storage, that is. What's the schedule looking ahead? Is there some particular tech advance you're holding out for prior to committing serious capital there?
Bob Blue
executiveYes, this is Bob speaking once more. No, I wouldn't frame it as us holding out for particular tech advances. We do, as you're aware, have a requirement written into the statute. Our expectation is that storage gets paced out over the period ending in 2035. It's going to be a few years on our end before we begin layering it in. Once more, should you look at the IRP, this is generic storage, clearly. At this moment we haven't scoped out particular projects, though we begin layering it in around 2026 — that's when, per the models we're describing here, you'd see it start to go into service.
Michael Weinstein
analystAll right. A final item regarding data centers. The burden on those facilities has risen. What's driving that is existing data centers, I suppose, operating at greater capacity levels, I guess, because more individuals are doing their jobs from home. Is that roughly how you see it?
Bob Blue
executiveThis is Bob once more. Yes is what I'd say to that. They're increasing. Data centers have an associated ramp rate; typically we'd expect them to reach a peak at a later point in the year, yet this year they are hitting that peak sooner. I'm not certain. One could speculate that this ties back to the pandemic situation and things beyond that, but all we know is that it's taking place.
Michael Weinstein
analystDo you know of any intentions to grow and put up additional data centers because of this—perhaps beyond what would have been constructed before the crisis hit?
Bob Blue
executiveYes, data center expansion across our service area has been robust for a while now, and we anticipated it staying robust well into the future. There has been zero deceleration on that front. Looking ahead, we'd anticipate data center growth remaining very robust.
Michael Weinstein
analystAll right. Thank you very much.
Bob Blue
executiveThank you.
Durgesh Chopra
analystHi there, and good morning, everyone. I appreciate you letting me ask something.
Bob Blue
executiveGood morning to you.
Durgesh Chopra
analystI apologize if I overlooked this. Good morning, and sorry if I missed it. Virginia is clearly performing quite well. Regarding South Carolina, what decline patterns for the remainder of the year are you factoring into your 2020 guidance?
Tom Farrell
executiveI couldn't catch the final portion of your question.
Jim Chapman
executiveYeah, Durgesh, we couldn't hear quite the last part of your question.
Tom Farrell
executiveWhat was the assumption on what for 2020?
Durgesh Chopra
analystIn your 2020 guidance, what about those South Carolina demand decline trends?
Jim Chapman
executiveUnderstood. Yes, apologies — we ran into a few technical issues. I'm with you now. What assumptions sit behind that? Sure, there are a couple of factors. Clearly, in Virginia there's no material impact as of yet, but we're now watching these steps begin, with the economy reopening in Virginia and South Carolina. In South Carolina, word came yesterday of modest steps getting underway. An immediate snapback isn't what we anticipate. Our guidance isn't built on that assumption. Through late summer, we expect a slow recovery. Regarding our guidance, we have clearly reaffirmed both the annual guidance and the long-term outlook, and there are a couple of gives and takes in there. Weather is one. That isn't your question, but weather cost us $0.09. Over the remainder of the year, as happened last year, we anticipate recovering some of the ground lost on weather in the first quarter. Virginia, as you pointed out, has no impact, and the same is what we'd expect. In South Carolina, our expectation is that loads have bottomed out, and then, once more, through late summer we're going to see that gradual recovery.
Durgesh Chopra
analystUnderstood. Many thanks. A brief additional question regarding the expenses of financing. Could you give us some quantification, or simply relative to the plan — you've completed a great deal of financing activity here — so what effect has that had on financing costs compared with the plan that was in place when the year started?
Jim Chapman
executiveYes, Durgesh, that's a good question, since our financing plan, though it remains unchanged for the full year, has been somewhat adjusted, as we moved a number of our financings forward into that March window I mentioned during my prepared remarks. This year's financing cost is something we're monitoring quite carefully, and while I can't give you a precise figure, I can offer a bit of color. Clearly, we raised $5 billion sooner than we would have done otherwise, part of that being short-term debt. A portion of it merely substitutes for commercial paper that would already have been included in our plan. As one illustration, one of those short-term financings — one-year financings that come to mind, which we completed during that window — carried LIBOR plus 50 with no fees. That's roughly not far from where CP would have landed in any case. Not a major factor. Now, looking ahead from this point, the markets have rebounded in spectacular fashion, as you're aware, particularly the fixed income markets. For the coming three quarters, the issuance rates from here forward, based on how things appear at present, are actually lower on an all-in basis than they were in January. Yes, there's some modest pressure from having done things sooner within our plan than we otherwise would have anticipated, but we now expect to likely offset part of that, since all-in rates have come down.
Durgesh Chopra
analystUnderstood. I really appreciate it, everyone. The granular breakdown by segment regarding COVID is extremely useful. Nice work on a strong quarter, and I'm grateful for all the information provided.
Jim Chapman
executiveThanks, Durgesh.
Tom Farrell
executiveThanks.
Jeremy Tonet
analystHello there, and good morning.
Tom Farrell
executiveGood morning to you.
Jeremy Tonet
analystI just wanted to ask a follow-up about ACP, and I appreciate it. Thanks for sharing so much detail already. I'd like some clarification, if I may. For FERC's approval to resume construction there, is Nationwide Permit 12 something you actually require? And are there other obstacles at FERC that you foresee?
Diane Leopold
executiveDiane Leopold here. Clearly, for most of the linear construction work, our major permits must be secured. As Tom mentioned earlier, the main factor we're monitoring when it comes to our forecasts is having a productive season for felling trees from November through March. Now, under Nationwide Permit 12, hand-felling of trees doesn't require that permit; the Army Corps Nationwide Permit 12 doesn't regulate that activity. If FERC gives its approval, we might be in a position to start hand-felling trees during that season. For linear construction to ramp up fully, we would expect to need it.
Jeremy Tonet
analystAll right, that makes sense. I appreciate the explanation. So, still on ACP, what kinds of things might affect the project's cost and schedule from this point until the window for felling trees opens? Do you currently have visibility into the latest estimates, provided the permits are secured before November?
Diane Leopold
executiveThat's right. The forecast range we've provided, which hasn't shifted since last quarter, encompasses a broad set of scenarios and isn't significantly affected, once again, assuming this winter gives us an efficient season for cutting trees.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. That's all from me, then. Appreciate you fielding my question.
James Thalacker
analystOh, hello there. Thanks for the opportunity. Am I coming through okay?
Jim Chapman
executiveYes, we hear you. Good morning.
Tom Farrell
executiveYeah. Good morning.
James Thalacker
analystHey, maybe let's shift our focus somewhat to your other regulated operations. You had put off that rate filing with Dominion Energy South Carolina, as I recall. You moved it into the fall, and with everything happening on the demand side, do you think there's a chance to put forward something with a bit more of a formulaic approach there, or possibly explore whether a rate plan incorporating decoupling could be part of what you propose?
Tom Farrell
executiveNaturally, we remain engaged in putting that plan together. As things stand, our schedule has us giving notice on July 15th, then actually submitting the case during August. Assuming nothing else comes up, that's what we anticipate at this moment. That rate case is still being worked on, and we'll find out how it shapes up and when the notice gets filed.
James Thalacker
analystGreat. Thanks for the time, guys.
Tom Farrell
executiveThank you.
Jim Chapman
executiveThank you.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings today’s morning conference call to a close. You’re free to hang up your lines, and have a good day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Dominion Energy, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Dominion Energy, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Dominion Energy, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.