Dominion Energy, Inc. (D) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 12, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Steve Ridge
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for being with us on this morning's call. The materials we've provided for earnings, which include the remarks prepared for today, might contain forward-looking statements and estimates subject to a range of risks and uncertainties. For a discussion of factors that could cause results to differ from management's estimates and expectations, please see our SEC filings, among them our latest annual reports on Form 10-K and our quarterly reports on Form 10-Q. Later this morning, we'll cover certain measures of our company's performance that are not recognized by GAAP. A reconciliation of our non-GAAP measures to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measures that we can calculate appears in the earnings release kit. We'd encourage you to go to our Investor Relations website, where you can review the webcast slides and the earnings release kit. On today's call with us are Tom Farrell, Executive Chairman; Bob Blue, President and Chief Executive Officer; Jim Chapman, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; along with other members of the executive management team. I'll now hand the call over to Tom.
Tom Farrell
executiveThank you, Steve, and good morning to all of you. To begin, I'd like to lay out the strong proposition Dominion Energy offers shareholders when it comes to returns. Our earnings per share should increase at 6.5% annually through at least 2025, backed by a revised capital growth plan spanning 5 years and totaling $32 billion. We provide an appealing dividend yield of roughly 3.5%, which mirrors a target payout ratio of 65% along with an anticipated long-term growth rate for dividend per share of 6%. Taken together, that equals a proposition of 10% in total shareholder return, alongside an ESG profile that is the industry leader, characterized by what we view as the largest regulated opportunity for decarbonization investment anywhere in the country; across the next several years, we plan to deploy tens of billions of dollars in ways that benefit the environment, our customers, our communities and our local economies. A pure-play, state-regulated utility operating profile concentrated on 5 premier states, as Slide 5 shows, is what our approach is built on. The philosophy I'll share is that prioritizing safety, reliability, affordability and, increasingly, sustainability comes from a common sense approach to energy policy and regulation. These states also work to build conditions that encourage smart economic expansion, and that expansion, similar to a tide coming in, raises every boat; as an example, 3 of these state jurisdictions appear regularly among the top 4 best states for business according to independent analysis conducted by CNBC and by Forbes. The utility model we operate under state regulation gives investors greater predictability, and it benefits from our focus on these rapidly growing, constructive and business-friendly states. Moving on to Slide 6. Dominion is a purpose-driven company and has embraced a comprehensive stakeholder approach; what motivates us is the conviction that the strongest companies in the world take into account the interests not only of investors, but also of employees, customers and communities, along with the health of the environment. Everything we do stems from staying true to the five core values we hold, and we treat openness and involvement with those who have a stake in us as defining features of good corporate citizenship. The welfare of the more than 17,000 people who work here matters enormously to our ability to succeed over the long run, and nothing we track carries greater weight than how safely our workforce performs. When we look at 2020, it stands out as the safest period of operations our company has ever recorded, and by a substantial gap — you can see this on Slide 7. That outcome wasn't achieved suddenly. As the slide makes clear, achieving lasting gains requires many years of focused work. I want to recognize my colleagues for reaching this notable milestone. Now let's shift to our customers and the communities we serve. We think safety in energy delivery isn't sufficient on its own — affordability matters just as much. It's good to see that the residential rates offered by our 2 electric utilities stack up well against averages at the state and national level and, in places where that applies, against RGGI states as well. As we look ahead, we anticipate our customers will remain very competitive, even while we make substantial investments aimed at transforming the carbon footprint of our system. Bob is going to cover this in greater depth when he speaks. Now, turning to what our community did in 2020, which you can find laid out on Slide 8. First off, the impact of COVID-19 on our customers throughout 2020 was obviously significant, and that's why we made the decision ourselves to act immediately once the pandemic hit and halt service disconnections. By taking that step, we prevented what would otherwise have meant shutting off more than 255,000 customer accounts. On top of that, we created payment plans that were extended and flexible, which produced more than 330,000 enrollments. We also gave $18 million in direct energy assistance aimed at our most vulnerable customers. Over in Virginia, we backed legislation during the special session that provided customers a fresh start by forgiving more than $125 million in customer arrears. We further agreed to hold off on our South Carolina rate case proceeding, making sure the outcome of that case won't affect customers until late this year. Moving on, we've upheld our tradition of supporting social equity. We're putting $25 million toward 11 historically Black colleges and universities, adding $10 million more for scholarships that serve underrepresented minority groups, and setting up a $5 million social justice fund backing community work addressing racism's effects. Beyond that are the diversity and inclusion efforts within our own company that Bob will cover. Clearly, these achievements fill us with tremendous pride, and I'd like to express gratitude to every one of my Dominion Energy colleagues who contributed to making them happen throughout what was obviously an exceptionally tough year. Let's now turn to Slide 9. Our five-year capital growth plan now covers 2021 through 2025. Compared with the plan we presented to you in spring 2019—after adjusting for the Gas Transmission & Storage sale—that works out to an additional $10 billion, or 43%. For our customers, we anticipate $32 billion in growth capital investment, and more than 80% of it either reduces emissions or makes reductions possible. Of that total, we plan to direct $17 billion toward zero-carbon generation and energy storage, a category that includes regulated offshore wind, solar, and nuclear relicensing. Another $6 billion is being allocated toward upgrades of the electric grid, including transmission and modernization efforts, which will strengthen our network's ability to withstand cyber and climate-related risks and improve its capacity to handle rising amounts of intermittent generation. We also plan to invest $3 billion in upgrading our LDC networks and in renewable natural gas initiatives, which enhance safety and reliability while reducing emissions. Jim and Bob will soon provide additional details about these investment programs, which are leading in the industry. While these short-term efforts are considerable, Slide 10 shows how they compare with the broader scale and timeline of our overall decarbonization potential. Our efforts extend well beyond our 5-year plan. Between 2020 and 2035, we've identified more than $70 billion in green investment possibilities, and virtually all of that should be eligible for regulated cost of service recovery. From what we can tell, no other regulated decarbonization investment opportunity in the industry is larger than this one; on top of that, electrification of transportation is accelerating, which should push demand higher for utility-scale generation that is zero and low-carbon well into the future. Value from our long-term transformation flows to a number of groups. The first is our customers, who want cleaner energy choices. The second is the communities in which we do business, which benefit from economic development and the tax dollars that result from what the company invests. Third, our team members, who are building the leading practices needed for the shift toward a low-carbon future. And fourth, the planet itself, through the emission cuts we show on Slide 11. Through 2019, counting divested assets as well, we've managed to bring down emissions of CO2-equivalent across the entire enterprise by roughly 55%. That's meaningful headway, though plenty of work remains. By 2035, we anticipate pushing that figure to somewhere between 70% and 80% against the baseline, keeping us on track for net 0 by 2050. On the right portion of that slide, you can see that by 2035, we project roughly 95% of the generation we own will either produce no emissions or very low ones — a striking change compared with how we dispatched power in 2005. Before I hand things to Jim, let me recap what happened during 2020 that has set Dominion up to prosper in the years ahead. We looked after each other. And because of that, we set an all-time record for safety. We moved swiftly to collaborate with our customers on dealing with the fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic. We declared our goal of reaching net 0 by 2050. The Virginia Clean Economy Act passed the general assembly, which sets the state on a forward-thinking course toward decarbonization and establishes it as a center for the worldwide green economy shift. We strengthened where we stand strategically by divesting our Gas Transmission & Storage assets so we could concentrate on our top-tier, state-regulated utility business. At the same time, we launched industry-leading rates of earnings and dividend growth; we posted our 20th straight quarter of weather-normal results that hit or beat the midpoint of the guidance we gave for that quarter; and we made changes in both the CEO and lead director positions. With that, I'll pass it to Jim.
Jim Chapman
executiveThank you, Tom, and good morning. As you can see on Slide 14, our operating earnings for the fourth quarter of 2020 came to $0.81 per share, and that figure took a $0.01 hit because of weather that was worse than usual in the areas our utility serves. Results on both an actual and a weather-normalized basis came in above the midpoint of the guidance range we had given for the quarter. For the full year 2020, operating earnings per share reached $3.54, which was above the midpoint of our guidance range and included a $0.09 negative effect from weather. On a weather-normalized basis, the result was $3.63, landing at the top of our annual guidance range. Keep in mind that our fourth quarter and 2020 GAAP and operating earnings, along with the comparative periods, have been adjusted for discontinued operations, including the ones tied to the sale of assets to Berkshire Hathaway Energy; and a summary of those adjustments between operating and reported results is, as always, part of Schedule 2 in our earnings release kit. Slide 15 shows that this marks our 20th quarter in a row, which is now 5 years, of delivering weather-normal results that meet or beat the midpoint of our quarterly guidance range. On the chart, we've marked the July 5 announcement of the Gas Transmission & Storage sale, since it clearly — it clearly affected our original annual guidance, which of course was set before that transaction happened. Even so, we think the consistency we've shown historically across quarterly results deserves attention, and it's a track record we are fully committed to continuing. Now let's move to Slide — to the guidance on Slide 16. As we normally do, we're giving a range for the year, intended mainly to capture deviations from normal weather. We are introducing 2021 operating EPS guidance of $3.70 to $4 per share. The midpoint of that range aligns with the indicative guidance midpoint range we gave back in July. On a midpoint-to-midpoint basis, we anticipate roughly 10% growth in 2021, which is also in line with our July guidance. Over a longer horizon, we anticipate operating EPS growing from the 2021 base at approximately 6.5% annually through 2025. Lastly, we anticipate first quarter 2021 operating earnings per share landing between $1 and $1.15. Moving to Slide 17. We anticipate our 2021 full year dividend will be $2.52, which reflects our target payout ratio of roughly 65%. We are also carrying forward the long-range dividend per share growth rate of 6% from that '21 base through 2025. Slide 18 gives a breakdown of the 5-year growth CapEx roll-forward that Tom walked through. For additional detail on this, I'd direct you to the very thorough appendix materials. We've put real effort into supplying all the more granular detail that we believe will help with understanding and modeling each piece of this growth profile. But let me just point out a few items here; we are projecting a total 5-year rate base CAGR of approximately 9%, split out here by segment and by major driver. I'd note that almost 3/4 of this planned growth CapEx qualifies for rider recovery. The terminology differs, yet money put to work through riders, rate adjustment clauses, or what some places call trackers, permits faster recovery of carefully incurred investments and expenses. These get filed and reconciled no less than once a year through single-issue proceedings, which keeps them apart from the slower and more sporadic general base rate cases; across certain states where we operate, such as Virginia, rider recovery tools rely on a forward-looking or projected test period and/or permit construction work in progress, and all of that reduces the traditional regulatory lag that otherwise can stop utilities from achieving their authorized return levels. Which CapEx programs qualify for riders shifts somewhat state by state, though notable ones for us are offshore wind, solar, energy storage, nuclear relicensing, electric transmission, strategic undergrounding, grid transformation, rural broadband and gas distribution, infrastructure, integrity and modernization spending. Along those lines, moving to Slide 19, we show how base investments and rider investments should trend at Dominion Energy Virginia across the 5-year plan. You'll see the Virginia base investment balance expanding roughly 6% each year, mostly from new customer connections and maintenance spending. Conversely, the rider investment balance in Virginia, which makes up half of DEV's investment base today, should expand by close to 20% per year on average. Because the Virginia rider investment programs get reviewed and reconciled yearly, they fall outside the triennial review process, the first of which, naturally, begins next month. Given these growth patterns, the base investment balance as a share of total DEV falls from 37% to 27% by 2025; it likewise contracts sharply as a share of overall Dominion Energy. On Slide 20, we update our view of sources and uses of cash; thus on average, from '21 to '23, we anticipate annual operating cash flow of roughly $6.6 billion, give back about — roughly $2.4 billion to shareholders via dividend and spend close to $8 billion per year on growth and maintenance CapEx for our customers. Our financing plan presumes we issue approximately $400 million of equity each year through our current DRIP and ATM programs, with remaining financing needs met by net fixed income issuance. Once more, as Slide 21 shows, these figures are multiyear averages. To be clear, during 2021, we anticipate no issuance under our ATM program. This equity guidance matches our earlier guidance covering the '21 through '24 period. We consider this pace of steady equity issuance through existing programs to be prudent, EPS-accretive, and, given our very large growth capital spending program, suitable for keeping our consolidated credit metrics inside the guidelines for a strong credit ratings category. On that note, as Slide 22 shows, our consolidated credit metrics have kept improving steadily, as has our pension plan's funded status. These results make us extremely proud. For our parent company, we keep aiming at credit ratings in the high BBB range, and for our regulated operating companies, single A range ratings remain the goal. Before my summary remarks, allow me to take a brief moment on O&M. Our 2020 results show how we are concentrating on pushing O&M forward via better processes, creative deployment of technology, and additional best practice cost programs, so that normalized O&M stays flat throughout the forecast period. That speaks to the effective ongoing execution of the flat normalized O&M work we covered in greater depth during our most recent Investor Day. Having said that, here is my summary. The operating EPS we reported for the fourth quarter and for full year 2020 came in above the midpoint of our guidance, which stretches our record to 5 years of hitting or beating the quarterly midpoint on a weather-normal basis. We launched 2021 full year operating EPS guidance reflecting a 10% annual increase from midpoint to midpoint. We confirmed 6.5% operating EPS growth from '21 through '25. We rolled out a $32 billion 5-year growth CapEx plan that produces rate base growth of approximately 9%. Across our segment, we anticipate highly disproportionate rider investment spending, and both our balance sheet and credit profile stay in very good health. With that, I'll hand things over to Bob.
Bob Blue
executiveAppreciate it, Jim, and hello everybody on this morning's call. I'll kick things off on Slide 25, where we give you a summary of the Virginia Clean Economy Act. This legislation requires a renewable portfolio standard that shifts the state toward a zero-carbon future across the coming 25 years. To hit those RPS milestones, the statute directs Virginia's utilities to bring on board considerable quantities of wind and solar generation plus battery storage, expands energy efficiency and demand side management offerings, stipulates that Virginia-based renewable energy credits be used, obliges Virginia to become part of the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, and calls for shutting down a substantial share of coal-fired generation by 2025 along with every fossil-fired unit by 2046, contingent on reliability and energy security factors. The single biggest investment arising from the VCEA's enactment is Dominion Energy's initial 2.6-gigawatt offshore wind build-out, which we cover on Slide 26. I won't walk through each line item here, but I do want to call out the following: first, this project, the biggest of its type anywhere in North America, remains very much on schedule. It will deliver a lift to Virginia's expanding green economy through the creation of hundreds of jobs, hundreds of millions of dollars in economic output, and millions of dollars in tax revenue for the state and its localities. It will additionally push Virginia nearer to its aim of becoming a major hub for the fast-growing offshore wind value chain along the East Coast of the country. Second, consistent with what the VCEA envisioned, our intention is for this investment to be 100% regulated and qualify for rider recovery. Lastly, the VCEA lays out quite detailed criteria regarding the presumption of prudency for investment in this project, as you can see here, and we have confidence that we will satisfy them. Over on Slide 27, we set out the key project milestones. Last December, we filed our construction and operations plan with BOEM; we take encouragement from the additional funding Congress appropriated to BOEM late last year, which specifically directed the agency to bolster its resources for handling offshore wind permits, and also from BOEM's recent resumption of work on the Vineyard Wind application. As I imagine most of you are aware, we are the sole owner in the United States to have successfully finished an offshore wind BOEM permitting process. Our 12-megawatt test project, which just recently came into service, wrapped up the BOEM permitting process back in 2019, and we are carrying over lessons from that experience into the application we have pending now. The other point I want to flag sits on the left-hand side of this slide. The lease occupies shallow water, lies outside major maritime shipping lanes, sits away from any other offshore wind leaseholds, and is not located in an area that supports a significant commercial fishing industry. We look for final permits around mid-2023 and expect to wrap up construction of the project near the close of 2026. The VCEA requires an additional 2.6 gigawatts of offshore wind by 2036. For now, our attention is fixed on getting that first deployment done right, but we're also eager to identify opportunities to back the state's further offshore wind capacity objectives. Under the VCEA, customers bear the expense of any offshore wind project solely in proportion to the share we own. Offshore wind might be the biggest single renewable energy project we have, yet the total solar generation capacity the VCEA mandates is more than 3x that size; as the law requires, 65% of the target amount is to be utility-owned. Neither we nor the commission are treading unfamiliar territory here. So far, we've submitted 4 cost-of-service rider recovery filings for solar projects in Virginia. Three of them, accounting for roughly 400 megawatts, have won approval, and the latest filing awaits approval; we anticipate filing additional requests each year as we progress toward the over 10 gigawatts of regulated solar capacity the law mandates. Today's solar technology needs roughly 10 acres per megawatt of installed capacity. So a rough calculation indicates the utility-owned target of approximately 10,000 megawatts will call for approximately 100,000 acres of land. We've worked diligently to obtain sufficient land for our long-range goal; and I'm happy to say that in under a year, we've placed 63,000 acres under option. Moving to Slide 29. What began as an 8-megawatt facility in Georgia in 2013 has grown today into a portfolio exceeding 2.2 gigawatts, representing more than $5 billion of investment. Our initial emphasis was on developing long-term contracted projects, largely outside Virginia, which let us build the expertise and competency needed for the substantial regulated solar build-out in Virginia I just described. Looking ahead, you can see our emphasis shifting, with a very significant majority of our solar capacity investment occurring under regulated cost-of-service recovery mechanisms in Virginia. Growth in long-term contracted solar is limited and driven by large customer requests for bilateral, 100% renewable power supply. As more intermittent generation sources spread across our system, energy storage will be essential to maintaining reliable service. We watched with keen interest the recent example of negative consequences for customers when rapid shifts in intermittent generation aren't accommodated with sufficient storage and/or quick-start gas-fired generation. Thus, the VCEA prudently mandates development of nearly 3 gigawatts of energy storage by 2036, 65% of which is to be utility-owned and rider-eligible. Granted, we're beginning small with developing technologies in this area, 16 megawatts of pilot projects across 3 different sites and 3 different use case scenarios, as shown on the right side of Slide 30. But beginning small has benefits, as we witnessed in both our offshore wind and solar development strategies. We're swiftly building expertise that will ensure we deliver maximum value to customers as we meet the VCEA's targets. From what we can tell, hitting greenhouse gas reduction goals depends on keeping today's nuclear plants up and running. That's the reason we submitted applications for 20-year license extensions covering our 4 Virginia-regulated units. As of now, those facilities supply 30% of all electricity generated in Virginia and roughly 90% of the state's zero-carbon power. Using PJM's carbon intensity rate, continuing to run these plants will keep 16 million tons of CO2 per year out of the atmosphere. Slide 31 lays out the key milestones for the relicensing effort. We anticipate filing for rider cost recovery approval during the second half of this year. Right now we're concentrating on the Virginia unit. That said, if conditions are right, extending the operating life of our other 3 units over the long term could make sense. When nuclear life extension works, customers and the environment both come out ahead. Moving toward a clean energy future requires leaning less on coal-fired generation. As Tom demonstrated, back in 2005, coal-fired generation provided more than half of our company's power production. Come 2035, we expect that figure to be nearer to 5%, or possibly below that, should the South Carolina Commission favor a faster decarbonization plan in our IRP refiling. Looking at it through an investment lens, which roughly approximates earnings contribution, Slide 32 shows how the role played by coal-fired generation in our financial results has shrunk, thanks to facility retirements and investments outside of coal.
Bob Blue
executiveWe recognize that this transition could cause disruption for employees and for communities, so we are deliberately working to reduce any negative effects of that kind. You will also see that zero-carbon generation expands considerably, meaning that by 2025, electric wires plus zero-carbon generation will make up more than 60% of our investment base. Now to Slide 33. I want to talk about customer rates, concentrating on Virginia. To begin, from 2008 through 2020, the rate for our typical residential customer rose by an average of under 1% annually, well below the roughly 2% average yearly inflation during those years. Next, according to EIA data, the amount paid by one of our standard customers is 13% below the nationwide average and 36% below the level in states that entered RGGI the same way Virginia did. Then third, looking ahead, we anticipate ordinary household rates will rise at a compound annual growth rate of about 2.9% through 2030 — a general estimate that includes, among other things, the effect of the decarbonization investment programs we covered earlier today. Were the baseline shifted back to 2008, that growth rate would drop to 2.1%, which is lower than the inflation forecast for 2021. Providing energy that is safe, dependable, steadily more sustainable, and affordable is an obligation we carry. Let's turn to Slide 34, where I'd like to talk about the upcoming triennial review proceeding. Just so you know, we've put together some in-depth slides in the appendix that you should find helpful on this topic. To begin with, that triennial review gets started next month and will finish up toward the end of this year. Next, this review will cover 4 years of performance, running from 2017 through 2020, and it compares the return we earned with the 9.9% return we're allowed, which includes a 70 basis point power. And third, as Jim noted, only the Virginia portion of our rate base falls within this review's scope. Rider investments fall outside the proceeding's scope; and lastly, if the commission determines that available revenues, including adjustments for impairments, weather, and other factors, exceed customer credit reinvestments, it could order a refund along with a forward-looking revenue reduction of as much as $50 million. So allow me to highlight just 2 factors that we know will figure into the first review process. First, we have put nearly $300 million into completing the 12-megawatt offshore wind test project on time and on budget. We have said we will not pursue a revenue increase from customers tied to this project. Instead, we will apply that investment, when needed, as an offset to customer credit reinvestment. Second, we have furnished more than $125 million in arrears relief in Virginia to help customers, many of whom have experienced financial hardship because of COVID. Of course, our attention is on the triennial review filing next month, yet we also field questions now and then about the second triennial review, which should wrap up in almost 4 years. A few observations on that appear on Slide 35. To start, we're only 43 days into that review period, so we're still very early on. Clearly, we have a considerable distance to travel before we can submit the exact regulatory inputs for that proceeding. What we do know, though, is that the review's structure will resemble T1. Take that example: it includes our ability to use offsets stemming from customers' credit reinvestment, which lets us steer money into programs that produce customer benefits. Then, as Jim explained plainly, the sizable expansion of our asset base at DEV centers on investments recoverable through riders, and those fall outside the scope of what the triennial available earnings reviews look at. When you add growth in our other state-regulated operating segments, the share of company earnings and cash flows that triennial earnings tests cover will shrink on its own over the forecast horizon and beyond. Last, being a state-regulated utility means our business fundamentally involves collaborating with regulators to create favorable outcomes for customers and investors alike. That's something we've been doing for many years. Our plan is to carry forward the lessons we've picked up into all the rate cases coming down the road, the triennial reviews included. Our strong conviction is that many different routes lead to one shared aim: taking care of customers, employees, communities, the environment and investors. And looking further out, we couldn't be more enthusiastic about what Dominion Energy plans to achieve long after the next 2 triennial reviews are behind us. To put a finer point on it: across the coming 15 years, more than $70 billion in green capital gets deployed, and virtually all of that spending will drive earnings growth through regulated rider structures, deliver a major reduction in emissions, and do so while customer rates stay competitive. In our view, no other U.S. company can match the length, predictability, and breadth of regulated decarbonization expansion that Dominion Energy provides today. If you’ll move with me to Slide 36, we’ll go over the current situation in South Carolina’s pending general rate case, which right now is in a six-month pause that we backed. As part of that hold, regulators instructed the companies involved to submit progress reports each month regarding their push for a resolution. Obviously, we can't tell you today where those talks currently sit, though we remain ready to continue engaging with the litigants, aiming to reach a suitable outcome that we could bring before the commission for sign-off. In the meantime, nothing changes about how we serve our customers. Across roughly the past 15 years, we've cut average yearly customer outage minutes—known as SAIDI—by 40%. The money we spent in earlier years—among them those addressed in the rate case we filed not long ago—plays an essential role in keeping the grid dependable and in allowing this pattern to keep going, which works to the advantage of the people we serve. Our pledge is to fulfill each of our merger commitments completely, to build confidence among our customers and the communities around us, and to move toward a future for South Carolinians that grows more sustainable over time. On that point, allow me to share news about our integrated resource plan. Plainly stated, the commission asked us to file the plan again while factoring in, together with other changes, a faster pace of renewable energy deployment and heightened sensitivity to the possibility of carbon pricing. In the right-hand table, it's possible to see how a scenario we submitted alongside our initial IRP, known as Plan 8, demonstrates the capacity for faster decarbonization with just a marginally greater expense for customers relative to the earlier base plan. Under Plan 8, 1,300 megawatts of coal-fired generation would be retired in 2028, while 300 megawatts of storage plus 700 megawatts of new solar would be introduced, producing a CO2 emissions decrease of almost 60% by 2030 and costing only about 3% above the base plan. We want to collaborate with all stakeholders during this planning process; you can find the main elements of our gas distribution segment's plan for growth and long-term viability on Slide 38. Our utilities sit in some of the country's fastest-growing areas, and in two of our three largest markets, customer counts are climbing by close to 3% each year. Whether it's for cooking, heating or other residential, commercial and industrial purposes, these customers simply prefer natural gas service. We're also fortunate that the jurisdictions where we operate put safety and reliability first when they regulate.
Bob Blue
executiveMechanisms for decoupling encourage the adoption of efficiency improvements, and those improvements assist in lowering what customers pay; meanwhile, trackers for modernizing infrastructure and maintaining integrity let us make essential investments and upgrades that cut emissions while also lifting the standard for service that is safe and dependable. In the realm of natural gas distribution, geography is significant. We understand that if natural gas is going to stay relevant going forward, our attention must remain on making our service more sustainable. We have set ambitious targets for Scope 1 emissions, yet that alone won't suffice. At present we are examining Scope 3 emissions through pioneering approaches. Our backing for federal regulation of methane has been made official, and we are striving toward purchasing practices that promote stronger disclosure from upstream counterparties regarding their emissions and programs for methane reduction. Beyond that, we are weighing a preference for suppliers and shippers that make a net zero commitment; regarding emissions downstream, our intention is to boost yearly spending on energy efficiency by 45% across the coming 5 years and give customers access to a carbon calculator along with carbon offsets; additionally, we are crafting plans that will demand cooperation with policymakers and regulators so more RNG becomes available to those we serve, and in the end, to launch required RNG blend levels that would work to offset the carbon footprint of our customers; last, we are chasing inventive hydrogen applications, covered in greater depth in the appendix; this encompasses our role as a founding member of the Low-Carbon Resources Initiative, which has just gone past $100 million in funding from more than 30 industry members. I'll wrap up my comments by covering a number of significant items we undertook in 2020 that strengthened our industry-leading ESG profile. In February, we declared an objective of net zero-carbon and methane emissions by 2050. During the summer, as the country started to reconsider key issues surrounding race, we expanded on our established legacy of social equity by dedicating $40 million toward social justice and equity causes. In October, we released our newest Sustainability and Corporate Responsibility Report, which aligns with the leading best-in-class reporting standards, among them the Global Reporting Initiative, the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board and the UN Sustainable Development Goals framework. Also during October, we set a new pledge to raise our overall workforce diversity by 1% annually. Through 2020, we achieved a robust beginning, with half of our company's new hires coming from diverse backgrounds; and in November, we declared our official support for the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, or TCFD, which made us 1 of only 6 utilities to embrace such support. Moving forward, on Slide 40, there is more work ahead. In January, as I noted, we publicly made official our backing for federal methane regulations. In the second quarter of this year, we will release an updated climate report reflecting methodologies recommended by the TCFD; and all through 2021, we will push ahead with efforts to tackle Scope 3 emissions, starting with our gas distribution businesses, as I described earlier. These ESG-oriented efforts, together with others, have earned recognition from top third-party assessment services, as displayed on Slide 41. On every metric, the results we deliver are better than the sector's typical level. CDP has placed us within its leadership band for the way we disclose on climate and water. The CPA-Zicklin report on political accountability and transparency named us trendsetters for a third year running, and JUST Capital included us in the Just 100 for a second straight year in recognition of our work to advance greater equity. I'll wrap up the call at Slide 42, which also came up in what Tom said. Starting today, we're putting actions in motion to set a path that, across the coming decades, will carry this company on an extraordinary journey toward being America's most sustainable energy company. What lies ahead looks bright, and our attention is on carrying out this plan so that our employees, customers and communities, the environment and our investors all benefit. With that, let's open it up for questions.
Steve Fleishman
analystSo, to start off, the growth rate you're showing now extends through 2025, and I assume that includes the 2024 triennial review result. Could you discuss how that factors into what you're projecting? What's your assumption there?
Bob Blue
executiveYes. Thank you, Steve. I appreciate it. As I said before, we are merely 43 days into a 3-year window that will be examined, and we won't even submit the filing for over 3 years, so it's no surprise there are plenty of specifics still to come. Still, I believe it matters that when we build out a long-term growth rate, we consider multiple planning scenarios. For the 2024 triennial or any other significant planning input that distant in our plan, we don't lock in one result. One theme, I'd note, is definitely baked into every one of our projected outcomes. For 2024 or other years, Virginia regulation stays constructive, exactly as it has functioned over time, delivering our customers dependable reliability rates exceeding 10% below the national average along with an increasingly green generation mix. And I think it's also worth keeping in mind, as Jim and I discussed before, that a share of our base rates — the share of our earnings derived from base rates in Virginia shrinks over time, while riders and other mechanisms beyond Virginia become more significant. Our growth from now until the '24 triennial and afterward is fueled by rider investments that sit outside the '24 triennial or any other triennial proceeding.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. So then the takeaway is that you sort of believe you're equipped to handle a range of possible results on that front, or — when you look at the bigger picture — and that's more or less baked into what you're assuming?
Bob Blue
executiveCorrect. This is our line of work. Over the years, that's exactly what we've been doing: collaborating with regulators and policymakers to reach constructive results for customers and for the utility's health; and we absolutely anticipate being able to keep doing so moving ahead.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right, and a follow-up tied to that: I noticed the base piece of the rate base in Virginia, along with the percentages, looked smaller than what showed up in some of your more recent disclosures. Could you walk through what shifted there, maybe, Jim?
Jim Chapman
executiveSteve, sure. I'll handle that one, and I don't know whether everybody has the complete deck with them. Going forward, though, you can find it on Page 60 in the appendix; still, your observation is correct. Nothing about the overall rate base in Virginia has moved, apart from time passing and the year wrapping up; what we actually did was sharpen how we compute the components of total rate base. We'd been presenting that schedule starting around 2019, when this effort began, I believe, at our last Investor Day, when the triennial sat quite far off. We wanted to keep it easy, so certain items got combined. Now we've sharpened it; that sharpening concerns roughly $4 billion of rate base that we'd earlier labeled Virginia-based and other. That $4 billion essentially equals the other; we've since moved it into other categories; so what falls under other? Those are contracts serving assorted entities within the state, municipalities, the state of Virginia itself, the federal government, organizations of that sort, where the agreements carry a different economic construct. A number of them are simply negotiated. In our new — I'm not certain, new slide — those sit in the other category; while others follow certain riders more closely, be it a transmission rider or legacy A6 riders. So we've reallocated things, aiming for greater precision; Virginia-based now stands alone rather than Virginia-based and other; that lowers the figure to roughly $9 billion. I believe that helps people when they run math and sensitivities, since the split across the various buckets of our total Virginia rate base is now more refined.
Dan Ford
analystThis one's directed at you, Bob. Virginia's legislature still has multiple active bills tied to utilities and the energy economy, and Governor Northam has requested a special session. Could you help us make sense of how all the commotion this stirs up looks from an investor's standpoint?
Bob Blue
executiveAbsolutely. Honestly, I can't recall a single fourth quarter call where a question about the Virginia General Assembly didn't come up. I suppose that stems from when our fourth quarter call lands relative to the session, so I appreciate you raising it. Had we not gotten one this year, we'd have felt let down. By now, it's been, I believe, over 15 years since my time working in Virginia's governor's office, yet a handful of things regarding how legislation gets made, I suspect, remain the case. Number one, there's no fixed script the legislature follows. Make an error, or forecast with certainty how legislation will turn out, and you do so at your own risk, and I believe that holds true today. Number two, for a bill to turn into law, it must get past quite a few obstacles; it isn't merely one House or the other; it's both chambers, plus the committees within each. A case in point from this session: a single bill brought forward in the Senate dealing with our regulatory model got voted down in committee, and the bipartisan margin was fairly decisive. And finally, one more thing that remains accurate regarding Virginia's legislature is how fast it operates, so I doubt we'll be waiting very long. As you noted, this year's timing has differed somewhat. The session ran — its constitutionally mandated 30 days, after which the governor summoned a special session, yet things are still progressing at a good clip. Consequently, I expect those bills you mentioned will get settled before too long, since that's how the Virginia General Assembly conducts itself. We'll be watching them, though I think it's worth keeping in mind that they'd still need to overcome obstacles prior to becoming law.
Dan Ford
analystAll right. And I think I have one more as well for Jim. Jim, I appreciate the thorough explanation regarding CapEx moving forward, plus which items qualify under riders and which don't. Could you discuss how the makeup of that CapEx and those rider-eligible projects are going to affect cash flow conversion over the coming 5 years?
Jim Chapman
executiveSure. Thank you, Dan. I'll take that one. As I said earlier, in excess of 70% — nearly 3/4 — of the capital spending within this 5-year plan comes through rider mechanisms in Virginia and other places. The result is that when we put that money to work, regulatory lag doesn't apply. Operating cash flow rises proportionally alongside that investment; thus that's a significant help to our sources and uses of cash plan, given that regulatory lag is absent and given how our rider spending, rider rate base growth, and operating cash flow all advance proportionally. We view that as a rather clever aspect of the structure.
Shar Pourreza
analystLet me handle one quick administrative item first, then I'll ask a brief follow-up. Maybe we can begin with that 2021 outlook. Clearly, you've called out an expectation of growth at 10% or better compared with the 2020 base, yet the low end suggests roughly 6% growth year over year. Given how much visibility the plans provide, I'm just hoping to understand which scenarios, apart from weather, might land you at that bottom end. Also, I understand the range's midpoint sits around $0.025 beneath the previous one. Does that stem from the South Carolina GRC delay? Is it something you can manage? Is some conservatism embedded there?
Jim Chapman
executiveYes. Many aspects of that question are routine. That guidance range was not affected by South Carolina at all — none. Let me take you through the components of our guidance. We maintain a long-term EPS growth target of 6.5%, meant to be more exact than our peers rather than a 200 basis point band. Each year, as we move along toward that 6.5% long-term target rate, we select a midpoint for the annual guidance. And we set a range surrounding that midpoint. As we note every quarter, that range exists chiefly to capture differing weather outcomes. Looking back a few years, the range was fairly wide. Over the last 5 years, it went $0.50, then $0.45, $0.30. Yet the main purpose of that range, this year included, is to incorporate — to accommodate various weather outcomes. The range's midpoint is 3.85, and we're highly confident we'll hit that figure and extend our record of meeting or beating results on a weather-normal basis, as we've discussed across the last 5 years. So a range exists. A midpoint exists; that midpoint, as I noted in my prepared remarks, aligns with the extremely narrow band of possible midpoints we provided in July, and it isn't tied to the South Carolina process.
Shar Pourreza
analystUnderstood. Understood; and finally, regarding the ratings. Clearly, you're showing a very strong cash flow forecast. The business risk profile clearly has gotten better. 9% utility growth, much of that comes from rider treatment, single-issue rate making, 15% FFO to debt levels. Any kind of — an agency clearly also has a positive outlook. The metrics appear to suggest you're nearer to A-. Any read on how those discussions with the rating agencies are proceeding?
Jim Chapman
executiveI'll put it this way. I believe, broadly, among the 3 rating agencies, there is an acknowledgment of senior management's emphasis on credit that has featured in every transaction and financing we've completed over recent years, and there is an acknowledgment of the gains we've achieved; so we're positioned well. Looking ahead, I wouldn't guess about an upgrade; but what I would anticipate, perhaps — I'm not attempting to get in front of the agencies. But what I'd wish for is greater acknowledgment of the quite substantial enhancement in our business risk profile from a credit standpoint overall in recent years and will just — things have hardly settled, correct, on a final step of that involving the divestiture of Gas Transmission & Storage; but I would hope that, that aspect would find its way more into the conversation and even the thresholds that the different agencies use for our company.
Shar Pourreza
analystFantastic. Okay. That's the point I was aiming for, Jim.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystMaybe I can pick up on a few of those earlier questions. I have two quick ones, if that's okay. You mentioned moments ago, regarding the 6.5% and the greater precision, I think Steve raised this before. Clearly, a great deal is built into that 5-year projection through '25. What gives you such conviction about that 6.5% figure you laid out? I mean, clearly, it's deliberate, as you just noted. If you could address it in a bit more detail regarding how much confidence you have in those results producing that number, that would be wonderful. And then I have a brief follow-up, if that's all right.
Jim Chapman
executiveYeah. I mean, I suppose my answer would be straightforward, Julien; back in July, when we announced the 6.5% growth rate, we had confidence, and since that time, nothing has shifted. Our confidence remains. As you've heard today, we've laid out some roll-forward of our CapEx; we have considerable clarity on rider recoverability for that CapEx, and every bit of that plays a role as we more or less build our assumptions regarding our long-term growth rate, which keeps the confidence we held last summer in that 6.5%.
Julien Dumoulin-Smith
analystUnderstood. That's reasonable. Now, if we could shift back to South Carolina for a moment. Of course, I caught your comments regarding '21. Given some of the generation issues, how are you viewing the potential timeline for a settlement there? And then, regarding CapEx, we're clearly watching what's happening with Duke in the Carolinas as well. What's your perspective on CapEx opportunities too?
Bob Blue
executiveSure. Regarding settlement, we're navigating the pause that the commission ordered, which we consented to, with monthly reports on it. We remain optimistic about our chances of resolving cases, since we believe we're quite innovative in identifying ways to address issues that benefit both customers and the company. In the end, it takes all parties agreeing to settle. And it's — I can't speak to what the counterparties are thinking. I can only say we're putting in a lot of effort toward that; and there's a deadline the commission set, saying, "If a settlement isn't reached, we'll resume the case." So we'll reach that point, either through a settlement or by concluding the case; and it's a robust case. We felt very assured about the case we submitted. There hasn't been a base rate case from us in 8 years, and we've put significant money into the system and enhanced it, and we're owed a return on those — a return on those investments. So we believe it's a really solid case. Ideally, we'll settle it. If not, we're quite confident in our capacity to uphold the stance we took in that case. As for possible future growth, I mean, clearly, we have to get through this rate case and then assess. That's where our attention is right now, plus ensuring we keep the promises we made during the merger. The IRP process clearly indicates that, moving forward, there could be additional investment possibilities, and we'll definitely seize those. But at present, our priority is resolving this initial rate case in a productive way.
Michael Weinstein
analystWhat I'd like to know is how much of the extra tax credit extensions, plus some of that renewable stimulus planning you figure the Democrats will deliver in the coming months, has already been factored into the plan? And could there be room for upside, particularly when I think about solar and perhaps also simply regarding what customers can afford? Maybe there's room to take on additional work in areas like undergrounding or grid transformation?
Bob Blue
executiveYes. Michael, that's a terrific question, and your point is correct. In our case, within the regulated setting we're discussing, extending the ITCs and the assorted tax credits works in customers' favor on rates and leaves the investment return untouched, yet it unquestionably lowers what customers are charged. So we'll examine whether opportunities exist; our plan is quite aggressive, as you've observed; and the Virginia Clean Economy Act, which passed last year, laid out an aggressive plan. As a result, we're proceeding at a very rapid pace. Should opportunities arise to move faster, we'll seize them. Still, the primary impact of extending the ITC will be a rate benefit for customers.
Jim Chapman
executiveMichael, Jim here — let me tack on one more point. Regarding those ITCs where we book an earnings gain that isn't tied to a regulatory framework, just so we're clear, that really isn't a growth business for us. Nearly everything we handle involving ITCs happens in a regulated structure, and there it delivers value to our customers, exactly as Bob mentioned. However, back at Investor Day 2 years ago, we provided guidance indicating that ITC recognition and the associated earnings would land somewhere in the range of up to $0.15 each year. And what we've actually delivered sits well beneath that. For '18, the figure was $0.09. In '19, it came to $0.11. During '20, we hit $0.16; even so, our plan is still to stay within that run rate of up to 15% — the $0.15 per year guidance — so this area doesn't move the needle much. It's primarily about the regulated customer benefit side, the way Bob laid it out.
Michael Weinstein
analystOkay, and I want to make sure we're clear — on the regulated side, across any of the projects you have underway, the ITC does not bring down the rate base.
Bob Blue
executiveCorrect, that is precisely the case.
Michael Weinstein
analystFrom what I understand, strategic undergrounding has pushed up against a legal ceiling on how much can be put into it. Given that costs may be coming down thanks to federal tax credits, is anyone discussing possibly raising it?
Bob Blue
executiveRight. That limit you're mentioning comes from legislation; it ties to a share of total rate base. At this moment, nothing is moving through Virginia's legislature on that matter. Were an extension to occur, it probably wouldn't be during this year.
Jeremy Tonet
analystYou laid out what the decarbonization opportunity looks like going into 2035.
Bob Blue
executiveJeremy, it's really hard for us to make out what you're saying.
Jeremy Tonet
analystSorry about that. Is that better?
Bob Blue
executiveYes.
Jeremy Tonet
analystToday you laid out the decarbonization opportunity all the way through 2035. For that stretch, how are you thinking about investments beyond customer growth? And with the size of your clean spend, should we expect it to take a bigger share going forward, assuming customer growth doesn't shift much?
Bob Blue
executiveNo need to apologize. Let's spend a moment on customer growth. Over roughly the last 10 years, growth at our electric utility has been fairly steady, and we'd look for that to keep up. Take Virginia: about 35,000 new customers get connected each year. On the gas side, like we said in our prepared remarks, new customer growth has been strong — very strong. That said, I'm not certain I completely grasped the second half of your question. My apologies.
Jeremy Tonet
analystI just want to ask about the proportion of green CapEx relative to everything else. Is that share going to remain a big chunk of what you folks are pursuing down the road? Or should we be looking at some sizable other places to put money on the non-clean side?
Bob Blue
executiveNo. The way we see it going forward — and I believe that slide really captures this — is that $72 billion opportunity. Every bit of it falls into decarbonization or the enabling kind of investments. So that represents the overwhelming majority of the capital we'll be deploying, and our expectation is that this holds true even past that long-term window. Of course, 15 years down the line is quite a stretch in this industry.
Jeremy Tonet
analystOkay, that helps. Now, when it comes to CapEx that qualifies for CCRO during the second triennial review period, how much room do you have when it comes to timing and recovery? And is recovery of any part of that spending explicitly included in the current plan?
Bob Blue
executiveYeah. As I mentioned, we have a variety of assumptions — there isn't a single one attached to the '24 triennial. A slide shows what qualifies along with the total amount, and we'll take advantage of that once conditions warrant it. It's premature for us to state how much we'd expect to draw on across the '24 triennial. The only thing we know is what we'll likely have available — roughly $200 million on a cumulative basis. That slide sets it out.
Jeremy Tonet
analystGot it. If I could, just one last thing. You mentioned Virginia’s legislation, and I want to ask about South Carolina’s legislation. If securitization gets approved, how would you go about it?
Bob Blue
executiveYeah. There are certain cases where we think securitization makes sense. Look at storm recovery—that’s obviously quite logical. When it comes to new nuclear, obviously, we didn’t think it made sense. So we’ll see if it passes. If it passes in a constructive way, great; we’ll just have to wait and see what it looks like. That bill, as I understand, has been introduced several times before in South Carolina and hasn’t become law, but 385 situations like storm recovery are very logical.
Durgesh Chopra
analystJim, regarding Slide 20, I'm simply wondering. The sources and uses of cash flow extend through '23, along with the planned base. Is that overreading on my part? Or do the sorts of mixes of where cash comes from and goes in '24 and '25 differ as your offshore investment scales up?
Jim Chapman
executiveCorrect, Durgesh. Our choice to present only a 3-year average perspective stems from the fact that, across 5 years, the figures become quite large and perhaps somewhat harder to reconcile between our current position and where we stood in '20. That said — you likely are overreading it. Naturally, we've disclosed our equity financing plan elsewhere, through the period's end, on the following slide. Thus it's clear the financing will keep going. What shifts is operating cash flow, set to expand on a 5-year basis; plus investing cash flow, set to expand a bit as it rose somewhat, backdated, within the 5-year plan. Nothing beyond that strikes me as noteworthy, though.
Durgesh Chopra
analystGot it, that makes sense. All right, so basically more detail and confidence around the years, but nothing major shifts in how sources and uses break down.
Jim Chapman
executiveLarger figures — that's all it is.
Durgesh Chopra
analystYeah. Okay, got it. Then, real quick, a follow-up on Slide 10. Bob, maybe this one's for you, or possibly Jim. That biggest regulated decarbonization plan — I'm a fan. But when I consider any legislative backing you might require, can I reasonably assume that this $72 billion opportunity can be pulled off under the Virginia Clean Energy Act? Or is more legislative support necessary before you can pursue these opportunities?
Bob Blue
executiveYou've got that right. It rests on the Virginia Clean Economy Act along with the Grid Transformation & Security Act from 2018, so everything here already has legislative authorization. Of course, we still must get the commission's approval for projects, and we've shown that works with solar. As I said earlier, the commission has already approved 3 solar filings from us. And our electric transmission spend, along with similar items, has been approved consistently through the years. But no additional legislative enactments are needed — we aren't seeking any — to execute this 15-year regulated book.
James Thalacker
analystI just wanted to revisit what you said regarding bill affordability while you're carrying out your capital plan, and Mike Weinstein actually brought up a solid point. Once we saw the ITC extended at 30% at year-end, could you possibly speak to how that will — how might you quantify it, or how will it affect customer rates and make things more affordable while you're carrying out your capital plan?
Bob Blue
executiveYeah. I don't believe we've put a number on that so far. So we submitted an integrated resource plan earlier in this year and — or perhaps last year, since we're now in 2021. With the 2020 integrated resource plan, we presented a 10-year view at 2.9% that we discussed. Well, I'm updating that with confidence; we definitely have an IRP update coming later this year in Virginia. And I would anticipate that, as part of it, we'll calculate the customer rates. But we lack — we haven't calculated customer rate impacts from that ITC as of now.
James Thalacker
analystThat sounds excellent; still, my guess is that this hands you somewhat greater room to maneuver as we peer ahead?
Bob Blue
executiveYou're completely right about that. Customers will see advantages when it comes to rates, and it provides us with adaptability moving ahead.
James Thalacker
analystGreat. And just, I suppose, staying on that topic. I realize we're looking somewhat further ahead. But perhaps you could speak a bit about a few of the programs or — I'm not sure whether you're prepared to put numbers to it, but how you're approaching the idea of reining in expenses so there's more room to keep carrying out your capital plan across, let's say, the coming 5 to 7 years.
Jim Chapman
executiveYes. I'll address that. This is Jim. ITC is one piece that will clearly help customers, yet O&M is the other piece. And allow me to offer a few broad-level views on it. During our most recent Investor Day, we discussed flat normalized O&M. So normalized means adjusting for new riders that haven't yet been matched with acquired O&M, or items such as pension benefits, where discount rates and similar factors cause that figure to rise and fall; so we adjust for all of that, and then we hold it flat; and back in 2019, we projected that by holding it flat for 3 years throughout our whole company, we would remain, relative to a 2% escalator, roughly $200-ish million on a cumulative basis, and that's what happened. So at present it remains flat, and we're extending that across the entire 5-year span. Now we did experience certain savings that actually declined somewhat in 2019 — pardon me, in 2020 because of COVID, and not all of that is lasting. But our push to hold that O&M flat, thereby offsetting inflation or wage growth and similar pressures, isn't simple; yet it doesn't come through huge moves, like a few of our peers have described, step changes in O&M uncovered during COVID. We certainly had some COVID savings, but our method is somewhat different. It's rather programmatic; it's driving cost reductions as a component of the system, the culture, so discovering ways to apply technology and work smarter across the company. So we have instances of that, which help us hold that flat O&M; they're minuscule next to Dominion: electronic timesheets and electronic signatures, and they've continued along these lines, they're all minuscule, but they accumulate. And that's the sort of thing, the modest efforts throughout the company, every state, every location that let us hold that normalized OEM flat. And the rationale behind doing so is to create space in the customer bill. Yes. It assists on the customer side and possibly also opens room in that bill for the capital spending that likewise benefits customers. So that's essentially our other lever for managing the customer bill — continuing to manage that flat O&M.
Michael Lapides
analystReally appreciated the deck you shared earlier. It was quite thorough. Two things from me. First, could you take us back through — either as a share of rate base or in millions of dollars — how much coal generation sits in rate base, in Virginia as well as South Carolina?
Jim Chapman
executiveMichael, that's laid out for the entire company on Page 32. When you look at it as a proportion of the total investment base — meaning rate base along with fixed assets, the PP&E tied to our smaller contracted assets operation — it comes to 7%, effectively 7% of rate base. Then looking only at the 5-year plan, since there's clearly spending happening in other areas, that figure drops to 4% by 2025 and continues declining after that.
Michael Lapides
analystUnderstood. So looking at things from Virginia's standpoint — and you've already retired quite a few coal units in that state — suppose you chose to shut down some of those coal facilities ahead of schedule. Would that count toward the CCRO during the 2021 to 2024 window? Is that another option I should be considering, where instead of putting in fresh capital that has to earn a cash return, you'd take write-downs on some of the aging coal plants?
Bob Blue
executiveCorrect. A few points on that, Michael. First, we clearly don't base decisions about retiring fossil assets on where a regulatory case happens to sit on the calendar. Those calls get made according to whether the plants remain sustainable moving forward, or if the law changes, or similar circumstances. So I'd say that's a key point to remember. Second, I believe you're blending 2 separate subjects together. The first is the customer credit reinvestment offset, which exists because of statute. Those consist of either grid transformation work or renewable work, and that invested capital can serve essentially as the customer benefit within an earnings sharing mechanism. When the triennial review gets calculated and there are available earnings, an earnings sharing mechanism kicks in, and the customer's share of that can either come as a refund or as one of these renewable or grid transformation projects. What I think you have in mind is that retiring a plant early produces a write-down. That expense would then logically be handled as an expense for the period, assuming available earnings exist. That applies to customers; it's how Virginia has handled this for a long time. So these are 2 somewhat distinct matters you're raising. Each one affects the calculation and the triennial to some degree, though we're clearly quite far off from the second triennial at this point.
Michael Lapides
analystGot it. And returning to the matter of coal generation, in light of the extent to which power prices have declined, and the extent to which CapEx costs for renewables and storage have declined, do you believe your coal units across both states remain economic at present relative to the coal units already in operation? And is there a dramatic difference between those located in Virginia and those located in South Carolina?
Jim Chapman
executiveYes. I'm not sure I would characterize it as a dramatic difference; clearly we review the economics of those plants on a regular basis and determine whether they are viable going forward and whether they are properly valued; so we will do that — keep doing that regularly.
Srinjoy Banerjee
analystTurning to how FFO compares with debt, plus the ratings. Clearly, you have delivered steady gains on those measures, reaching 15% in 2020. When you consider what S&P and Moody's want for a high BBB, I believe S&P needs 15%, while Moody's wants 17%; so how do you expect your FFO-to-debt figures to move across the period? Do you think you'll remain near that 15% level, or do you anticipate getting better thanks to the riders you hold?
Jim Chapman
executiveSrinjoy, many thanks. Nice to speak with you. Right. Our view is that reaching the gain shown on that one slide — arriving at a solidly mid-teens level — was not simple, and we believe it will remain there. So perhaps what you were hinting at is whether an upgrade might be coming? Certainly, we wouldn't oppose that; but what we truly want to see happen eventually is, once more, greater acknowledgment of the improvement in business risk profile; therefore I would not anticipate meaningful metric shifts relative to our current position, relative to what we have accomplished and where we finished. I believe that is a favorable place. It will likely hold. Still, we would really like somewhat more cushion for that acknowledgment I referred to, and we seek that cushion not to sprint past it but simply because we regard more as preferable; so that is roughly our stance on credit.
Operator
operatorThanks; that brings this morning's conference call to an end. At this point you're free to hang up, and I hope the rest of your day goes well.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Dominion Energy, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Dominion Energy, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Dominion Energy, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.