Dominion Energy, Inc. (D) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 4, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David McFarland
executiveHello, everyone, and welcome to this morning's session. The materials we've provided for earnings, which include the remarks prepared for today, feature forward-looking statements and estimates that carry a range of risks and uncertainties. For a conversation about the factors that could lead to outcomes differing from what management estimates and expects, please look at our SEC filings, among them our latest annual reports on Form 10-K along with our quarterly reports on Form 10-Q. Later this morning, we'll go over certain ways of measuring how our company has performed that are not the same as what GAAP recognizes. You can find a reconciliation of our non-GAAP measures against the GAAP financial measures that are the closest match and that we are able to calculate inside the earnings release kit. I'd urge you to check out our investor relations website, where you can look over the webcast slides and the earnings release kit too. With us on today's call are Bob Blue, our Chair, President, and Chief Executive Officer; Jim Chapman, our Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer; Diane Leopold, our Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer; plus additional members of the executive management team. At this point, I'll hand things over to Bob.
Bob Blue
executiveThank you, David. Good morning to all of you. Our third quarter performance came in strong, and we're in a solid position to hit the targets we've set for this year. On top of that, we've been making consistent progress carrying out our investment initiatives centered on decarbonization; that successful implementation is already delivering benefits for our customers, our communities, the environment, and our investors. Let me start with safety. Through September, the OSHA recordable rate stood at 0.53, which is still low compared with where we've been historically and far beneath industry averages. We're proud of how tirelessly we concentrate on safety, and it ranks as the number one of our company's core values. Now I want to give you some background on this morning's news that we're kicking off a comprehensive review of the entire business, with the aim of making sure Dominion Energy is positioned as well as possible to generate substantial long-term value for our shareholders. Over the past several years, we've carried out a set of strategic moves, both via M&A and through choices about capital allocation, to significantly grow the state-regulated share of our business. Our approach stays grounded in this pure play state-regulated utility operating profile, which centers on premier states that embrace the idea that a common sense approach to energy policy and regulation puts safety, reliability, affordability, and increasingly, sustainability first. These states also do their part to create conditions that support smart economic expansion, and just like a rising tide, that growth raises everyone up. With our state-regulated utility model, investors get clear long-term earnings visibility, and that model is made even stronger because we concentrate on these states that are growing quickly, that are constructive, and that are friendly to business. Obviously, we're paying attention to what's going on in the wider economy. Along with everyone else, we're observing inflation, constraints in supply chains, and fuel prices that are higher, and all of these things affect customer rates as well as the strength of our balance sheet; we're very aware of the economic strain on our customers, and we take seriously our central mission of providing reliable, affordable, and clean energy to them while also generating value for our shareholders. Our company has handled this new environment effectively. We've kept up solid performance when it comes to safety and reliability. While we carry out our decarbonization investment programs—the best in the industry—at a steady pace, the energy we deliver has to stay affordable. So it makes us proud that residential rates across our electric utilities are still far under both state and national averages. We've come up with inventive ways to give customers some relief too. Here are a few things we did lately. To start, we backed legislation in Virginia that offered customers a clean slate by wiping out $200 million in customer arrears during the worst of the COVID crisis. In South Carolina, we likewise committed to forgiving over $11 million. Also, we made the choice to get back $200 million by using the base rates that are presently in place, which relates to Rider RGGI being suspended while Virginia moves toward leaving that program. Then, in Virginia, we chose on our own to stretch out recovery of the under-recovered fuel balance across three years so that customer bills take less of a hit. While accomplishing all of that, we kept advancing our growth plan and turned in results that matched our financial guidance, which is exactly what we did once more this quarter. You can likely tell that these accomplishments fill me with a great deal of pride, and I want to express my thanks to each Dominion Energy colleague who played a part in them. We still have a lot of work ahead of us. Two things sit behind the review we announced today. First, lifting shareholder value. Second, making sure the long-term breadth and length of our regulated decarbonization investment opportunity remains sustainable. Let me start with lifting shareholder value. We've posted safety and reliability results that lead the industry, carried out our substantial investment programs, secured constructive regulatory outcomes, and turned in results that hit our financial guidance. Even so, our relative share price hasn't done what we hoped, including across the last several years, while we were successfully carrying out that plan. I believe strongly in the approach we take as a state-regulated utility, and I should point out that feedback we receive from investors shows nearly unanimous support for where we are headed strategically, but in my view, this is the appropriate time to begin the review. Next, we have significant chances to invest that focus on decarbonization and reliability, extending well beyond the timeframe of our five-year plan. As a matter of fact, they stretch far into the decade that follows. Such initiatives, which deliver benefits to customers, are components of our diverse approaches to generating energy and reducing methane, designed to provide clean energy while simultaneously meeting the requirement for affordable and dependable energy grids along with gas distribution networks. Even so, we need to ensure that immediate financial strain on the economy and on customers' bills doesn't prevent the energy transition—and the long-term capital investment connected to it—from being fully achieved. Because of those two factors, I initiated this review of strategic moves or alternatives that could maximize value relative to our current business mix and capital allocation, as well as any regulatory choices that could assist customers in handling costs and provide more predictability for our long-term state-regulated utility value proposition. Several guiding principles inform this review. We stay dedicated to our state-regulated utility profile, which offers an industry-leading investment opportunity focused on decarbonization. Our commitment to the existing credit profile and the dividend hasn't changed. We're also still dedicated to boosting shareholder value and being transparent. Of course, we routinely look at how our businesses are put together to confirm we're getting the most shareholder value possible. Even so, having cautiously considered how our stock has performed relative to others across the past few years, as well as what today's macroeconomic conditions suggest, we decided that a more structured and comprehensive examination is the appropriate move at the appropriate moment. Now let me address what I think could be obvious questions regarding this examination. Number one, the scope. Number two, the timeline and key milestones. Number three, how it affects our financial plan. So, what does this examination cover? I've directed our team to take a look at each of the businesses we run, checking for chances to boost long-term shareholder value compared with how things stand now. That includes looking at where our capital sits in businesses that might be seen as non-strategic, or that might just be worth more to somebody else than they are inside the regulated profile we have today. In the same way, we'll carefully weigh every option that helps customers keep their expenses in check and gives them better visibility into what our long-term state-regulated utility value proposition looks like. Our focus remains on what matters to customers, and we back energy policy that brings an inexpensive, clean transition along with lasting predictability for the utilities we run under state regulation. Moving on to what we expect in terms of schedule and key steps — the team is already working on this. We plan to share more details when we report fourth quarter earnings in early 2023, and we also expect to hold an Investor Day sometime later that year, giving stakeholders a more complete picture of our strategy and the biggest sources of value in each of our business segments. Finally, what does this mean for our financial plan and guidance? We're keeping our 2022 financial guidance unchanged. Compared with what we've said before, there's no difference, other than a tighter annual EPS guidance range reflecting where we are in the calendar year. Looking at 2023, we identify routes toward meeting existing targets, since we believe we could surmount macroeconomic difficulties through expanded unregulated investment activities and additional initiatives; nevertheless, those non-regulated earnings drivers, along with other portions of our business, fall within the review we disclosed this morning.
Bob Blue
executiveI want to flag that results in line with the guidance we already have can only be reached if our review comes back with the status quo. So although we aren't adjusting that guidance as of today, we're signaling that this review could quite possibly produce outcomes — both in quality and in quantity — that differ when it comes to our earnings growth over the long term. Once more, unless the review lands on that status quo outcome. What probably won't come out of it, though, is any shift in this company's main engine of earnings growth: continuing to execute on what we see as an industry-leading, highly visible opportunity to invest growth capital in regulated decarbonization. To say it again, none of the options under review would harm the dividend we pay now. A bit more detail on how we're framing the possible results of this review and on getting past the headwinds I mentioned. Naturally, we intend to examine every lever available to us that might soften any effect on our financial plan. The first place we'd turn is O&M management, an area where we've generated meaningful value for customers and shareholders alike, and Jim will cover more on that shortly. That area holds some promise, though it probably isn't a game changer, considering everything we've already done. Beyond that, we'd keep working to assess capital allocation efficiently, in light of our strong regulated growth programs, and at the same time weigh carefully how customers' rates would be affected. Through this more formal review, though, we'll run analyses aimed at identifying the most efficient capital sources to fund our most appealing utility growth programs, all the while weighing numerous factors that serve the best interests of our EPS growth and our credit profile. To sum up, our team keeps delivering on the essentials of safety and reliability. The long-term scope and duration of our regulated decarbonization investment opportunity remains very much in place, and we're set to hit our goals for 2022. We provide an appealing state-regulated decarbonization investment profile, with operations and growth opportunities concentrated in premier states that have constructive regulatory regimes. That said, in light of how our share price has continued to perform relative to others and the macroeconomic difficulties, we believe a top-to-bottom review is the right move at the right moment to make sure we're positioned as well as possible to maximize long-term shareholder value. I'll now move to other business updates. On slide six, I'll begin with Dominion Energy Virginia. Last week, we disclosed a settlement agreement tied to our petition asking the SEC to revisit the performance guarantee contained in its August order, reached together with the Office of the Attorney General and other parties. This agreement strikes a balanced, reasonable approach that keeps the project advancing so it can serve the Commonwealth's public policy and economic development priorities along with our customers' needs. Should it win approval, notable customer benefits would include shielding against unexpected construction cost increases beyond the project's budget and stronger SEC performance review replacing a performance guarantee. We're anticipating a ruling from the SEC at some point later in this year. Now let me shift to how that project is being executed, where we've further reduced certain development risks, which bolsters our confidence that we'll stay on schedule and within budget; we've kept collaborating closely with the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management and other stakeholders to help keep the project's timeline on track, since we still anticipate getting a draft environmental impact statement before this year ends, we've pushed forward engineering and design work so that major equipment can be released for fabrication without delay, we've moved ahead on procurement and other pre-construction work tied to the onshore portion of the scope, and we've finished an independent project review and construction readiness assessment, plus a thorough evaluation of schedule and cost. Work on developing the project has proceeded without interruption so the schedule holds, and by the end of the first quarter of 2023 at the latest, we expect more than 90% of project costs, not counting contingency, to be locked in, versus roughly 75% at present, which further de-risks both the project and its budget. As I've said previously, the economic development and employment advantages that offshore wind brings are transformative for Eastern Virginia and the remainder of the Commonwealth, including its diverse communities. During construction and operations, CVOW could generate more than 2,000 direct and indirect jobs while drawing companies to invest in Virginia, establishing it as an offshore wind hub. To illustrate, work has lately begun on upgrades at the Portsmouth Marine Terminal, where we've leased 72 acres for staging and pre-assembly of foundations, transition pieces and wind turbines. Finally, our Jones Act-compliant turbine installation vessel is now more than 60% complete. We still anticipate that it will be in service before the 2024 turbine installation season begins. Moving to other notable DEV updates on slide nine, we submitted our third clean energy rider filing. This submission covered ten solar and energy storage projects and accounted for approximately $1.3 billion in utility-owned and rider-eligible investment, which further de-risks our growth capital plan. We anticipate an order from the SCC during the second quarter of 2023; regarding data centers, as I noted on our second quarter earnings call, we're actively pursuing a range of solutions to serve as much of the rising demand as we can while we push to speed up transmission solutions so the grid stays safe and reliable. Last week, we filed with the SCC for a new 500 kV transmission line, with an expected in-service date of late 2025. This filing encompassed roughly $700 million in capital investment. Moving to other business updates on slide 10. At Dominion Energy South Carolina, our crews worked around the clock in response to Hurricane Ian. At the storm's peak, more than 110,000 Dominion Energy customers in South Carolina were without power after it made landfall with winds reaching 85 mph and heavy rain fell across the low country and other portions of our service area. Within fewer than 18 hours, the company had brought that figure down substantially to approximately 15,000. The reason we could restore service so efficiently comes down to planning we do all year long via an active program for managing vegetation, and that work involves protecting above-ground power lines from trees and plants that pose dangers. Our team members' response for the sake of our customers makes me proud. Turning to regulation, we submitted our 2022 IRP update during the previous month. Accelerated decarbonization potential is reflected in the preferred plan we put forward, and it presumes that every coal-only unit will be shut down before the decade finishes. We're eager to work with all stakeholders throughout this planning effort. Over at Dominion Energy Utah, within the coming weeks we'll wrap up the testimony and hearings portions of our rate case. By the time this year ends, we anticipate receiving an order from the commission, with new rates taking effect in January of the following year. Regarding our agricultural-based renewable natural gas platform, which already leads the industry, we're happy to share news about our growing project backlog. Out of the 4 projects that are presently generating negative carbon renewable natural gas, 1 has entered service while 3 are going through commissioning; beyond that, we have 11 projects at differing construction stages and anticipate breaking ground on 5 additional projects before the year is over.
Bob Blue
executiveTurning to what's ahead, we can now see $1 billion in possible growth capital investments within this segment spanning 2023 through 2026. Clearly, we are well along the path toward our objective of deploying as much as $2 billion by 2035, and we anticipate the chance for further additions to the long-term backlog. Before I wrap up my prepared remarks and pass things to Jim, I want to offer a few thoughts regarding the organizational change announced earlier today. Steven Ridge, currently the head of our Western natural gas distribution operations, is being promoted to Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, taking over from Jim. Following close to a decade working in energy investment banking, Steve, who is seated here with us today, came to Dominion Energy and has devoted the past eight years to leadership positions spanning mergers and acquisitions, corporate strategy, financial management, and investor relations. Throughout much of that period, he collaborated closely with Jim and me, as well as the remainder of our senior leadership team. Over the past year, he has successfully led our Western gas operations, which serve close to 1.2 million customers. His finance experience is extensive, he is familiar to many of our investors, and he is a strong, capable leader. Having him step into this new role is a real stroke of good fortune for us. Jim is departing the company to become Vice President and Treasurer at ExxonMobil. Jim is a remarkable leader and has been an exceptional partner to me. Jim was instrumental in our swift shift toward an asset mix largely characterized by state-regulated utility operations and a capital plan focused on decarbonization supporting public policy goals and our dedication to our customers, communities, the environment, and our investors. Watching him leave is hard, though we wish him great success in the next chapter of his career. In the meantime, Jim will assist in ensuring a seamless transition, which includes being with us at the upcoming EEI Financial Conference. Steve will obviously be present too. Steve will be essential in pushing forward our strategy of delivering value to our customers and shareholders. This company's leadership depth is remarkable. Steve stands as a prime illustration of that bench strength. With that, I'll turn things over to Jim.
Jim Chapman
executiveBob, thanks for those generous remarks — I truly value them. I noted in this morning's release that I feel genuine gratitude for the chance to have spent 9 years alongside truly exceptional colleagues right here at Dominion. The achievements we secured together for the customers and shareholders of this wonderful company make me proud. Naturally, there will be further achievements ahead. Plenty of our investors, drawing on what they've witnessed with Steve through the years, already understand this well: I am without question passing the CFO role to somebody enormously skilled. For me, it's a move from one wonderful company to another wonderful company. Let's proceed, and I'll walk through what was a wonderful quarter for Dominion. Operating earnings for our third quarter 2022, which you can see on slide 11, came to $1.11 per share, and for this quarter that reflected normal weather across our utility service areas. Those results landed above the midpoint of our quarterly guidance range. Positive factors versus the third quarter last year include increased regulated investment across electric and gas utility programs, sales growth, and margins. Other factors versus the prior year include interest expense, tax timing, and share dilution. GAAP results for the third quarter of $0.91 per share reflect the non-cash mark-to-market impact of economic hedging activities, unrealized changes in the value of our nuclear decommissioning trust funds, and other adjustments. Schedule 2 of our earnings release kit contains a summary of every adjustment between operating and reported results. Now to guidance on slide 12. For the fourth quarter of 2022, we anticipate operating earnings between $0.98 and $1.13 per share. Positive factors versus last year are expected to be return to normal weather, normal course regulated rider growth, sales growth, the absence of a Millstone planned outage, absence of last year's COVID deferred O&M, and tax timing. Other factors versus last year are expected to be interest expense and share dilution. Given where we stand in the year, we're narrowing our 2022 full year guidance range to $4.03-$4.18 per share, preserving the same midpoint as our original guidance. Now to slide 13. Naturally, the review we announced this morning remains early and every detail has yet to come, but we've given you a sense of how we're thinking about the process. We expect to provide formal 2023 guidance on the fourth quarter call, which, as always, will include an annual guidance range to account for variations from normal weather. However, let me share some preliminary drivers for 2023 at this point. Positive factors versus 2022 are expected to be normal course regulated rider growth, Millstone margins, and sales growth, which has been trending above our long-term target. There are also plenty of chances for us to invest in unregulated areas, including solar and RNG development, and keep in mind that ITC benefits under the Inflation Reduction Act apply to both of those; we are additionally exploring more O&M management possibilities. When compared with 2022, other items expected to factor in are a second planned outage at Millstone, greater interest expense, share dilution, and pension expense. Finally, when it comes to how the Inflation Reduction Act affects us, we keep reviewing it to determine how fast we can roll out the options available for bringing customer costs down over time. Keep in mind the quite detailed comments I gave during our second quarter earnings call, so nothing has changed from what was previously communicated. I should add that measuring the impact is a tough exercise since the Treasury guidance and implementation process remains a moving target, so expect further updates on this as well. To sum up, we identify routes to reaching our existing guidance, though they remain subject to the review. What probably won't happen, though, is any alteration to this company's core earnings growth driver, which is continued execution of our industry-leading, highly visible, regulated decarbonization growth capital investment program. Now I'll move to other financial highlights. On slide 14, let me cover electric sales trends. Sales on a weather normalized basis rose 2.6% across the 12 months through September versus the prior year. Among the components of that growth: a modest decrease in residential, which is what you'd anticipate given the ongoing back to work trend, plus stronger growth in the commercial segment, fueled by data center customers in Virginia; for 2022, we anticipate staying above our long-term run rate of 1%-1.5% each year; once again we've included demand-related earnings sensitivities for our two electric utilities in today's appendix materials. Moving to slide 15 and briefly touching on O&M management. For context, we've laid out our electric O&M management against peers over time. As Bob said, our O&M efforts have generated material value for customers and shareholders alike, which we consider quite an accomplishment. As a reminder, our guidance assumes flat normalized O&M achieved by pushing costs down via better processes, creative technology use, and other best practice cost initiatives. This is a dynamic process. We deliberately examine every one of our segments, every one of our assets, every one of our locations, seeking opportunities to embrace technology, to enhance business processes, and to get better in areas such as smart buying throughout our platform. As Bob said, O&M definitely is an area with some potential to offset headwinds, though probably not a game changer, considering what we've clearly already been doing. Moving to slide 16, we've illustrated how our floating rate debt along with all fixed rate debt maturities across the coming three years stack up against peers. As you can see, our repricing exposure during this period is very much in line with the peer average. I'd like to give you some perspective on how we view the effect that increasing rates have on our operations. To begin with, our planning and guidance naturally incorporate what the market anticipates; naturally, we don't assume rates simply stay level. Fixed-rate instruments make up over 80% of our balance sheet, and those have a long duration — an average tenor exceeding 13 years. Then, roughly 50% of our exposure to interest rates — meaning that same floating-rate debt plus every fixed-rate maturity coming due within the next three years — sits within our regulated utilities, where it's treated as a cost of service. As you'll recall, roughly 35% of the rate base we currently have, along with more than 75% of our growth capital, qualifies for riders, which permits prompt yearly true-ups. When we look toward upcoming long-term debt issuances, we handle that interest rate exposure via various hedging and treasury efforts, among them nearly $9 billion notional of pre-issuance interest rate hedges, which will assist us in holding future costs down both at the parent company and at our regulated utilities. So what's the takeaway? That portfolio lets us secure treasury rates for issuances occurring between now and 2026 at levels nearly as low as 1%. Finally, keep in mind that economic growth, inflation, and elevated interest rates all factor in when authorized ROEs are set across our utility businesses through our periodic rate proceedings. To wrap up, today's rate environment keeps shifting, and we're watching it carefully.
Jim Chapman
executiveRight now, though, we aren't experiencing any hit to earnings from meaningfully elevated interest rates through this year, since those higher rates have largely been counterbalanced by what I described earlier. We'll absolutely give you an update on rates, interest expense, hedging strategies, and other mitigants when we update everyone on our business review and guidance during our fourth quarter call early next year. Moving to slide 17, let me talk about customer bill. According to data from the U.S. Census Bureau, the portion of our customer's wallet going to their utilities customer bill has fallen over the years, which speaks to our ongoing commitment to providing affordable energy to our customers even as household income rose overall during that period. I'd also point out that our progress on affordability has been outperforming national utility averages by a wide margin. And when it comes to where relative rates start from, we take pride in rates today that stay well under national and various regional averages. Now on slide 18, fuel costs. As Bob said, we're actively collaborating with regulators to assist our customers in managing costs. Naturally, we have very straightforward pass-through mechanisms for fuel costs at all of our utilities, but let me give you some detail on our current position. At our two electric utilities, we rely on a diverse portfolio for generating electricity. That covers many different fuel sources along with our small but expanding renewable fleet, which, naturally, doesn't create fuel costs for our customers. Nuclear power makes up roughly 40% of our generation portfolio right now. As we expand our renewable fleet and add it alongside our nuclear fleet, our customers will gain from carbon-free power at rates that are predictable and stable and aren't exposed to fossil fuel markets and volatility; we also have long-established risk mitigation strategies, such as hedging and natural gas storage, with most fuel prices trued up to customer bills on a delayed basis, a structure that helps smooth out the bill impact of commodity swings. In Virginia, we voluntarily agreed to spread the recovery of the under-recovered fuel balance across a three-year period to lessen the effect on customer bills. In South Carolina, we filed a mid-period fuel adjustment instead of our usual annual cadence to avoid a single significant customer bill increase down the road. If approved as submitted, our typical residential customer bill would rise by approximately 14%, and customers would see the increase in bills starting in January 2023. In our gas distribution service areas, we use storage capacity to offset peak day requirements and proactive gas supply hedging and contract strategies to help customers manage costs; in Ohio, where the majority of the gas is supplied through third parties, access to storage and lower-cost gas plus fixed-rate customer contracts all help mitigate gas price exposure. In our Western states, our unique cost of service gas production also helps customers avoid price spikes. All told, as of September 30, we're sitting on an under-collected balance for fuel costs of roughly $2 billion; we're engaging regulators in a proactive way to tackle these costs and will keep relying on these and other mitigation steps so that any bump to customer bills stays as muted as we can make it. Okay, moving to 19 and a quick word on credit. We've shaped Dominion Energy into what is increasingly a pure-play utility regulated at the state level, with a clean energy transition profile that sets us apart. Our work over recent years to strengthen our credit profile has meaningfully bolstered both our financial and our business risk profiles. This ongoing move toward a regulated utility profile has historically meant a reduction in our credit metric downgrade and upgrade thresholds. What we've shown here is how our credit metric upgrade and downgrade thresholds at Moody's stack up against those of our large cap integrated peers. Naturally, circumstances specific to each company drive differences in thresholds. Broadly speaking, those sitting at lower downgrade thresholds hold limited non-utility assets, scale and diversity, and they operate in appealing states with constructive regulatory relationships. Our belief is that the agencies will keep factoring in the intentional de-risking of our business profile when they evaluate our credit down the road. Going forward, we anticipate no change to our credit guidance. Our targets are the high triple-B range at the parent and the single-A range at our opcos. Now let me wrap up our remarks on slide 20. Safety stays our top priority and our first core value. Our quarterly results came in above the midpoint of our guidance range. We've narrowed the range for our 2022 earnings guidance and remain on track to hit that guidance. We keep moving aggressively to carry out our decarbonization investment programs, serving our customers' needs while generating jobs and driving new business growth. We submitted a settlement agreement offering a balanced and reasonable path that lets our offshore wind project keep advancing on schedule and on budget. We're carrying out a top to bottom business review aimed at making sure Dominion Energy is best positioned to deliver significant long-term value for our shareholders. Finally, Bob, Diane, Steve, David and I are all eager to see many of you in person at the EEI Financial Conference in roughly 10 days. With that, we're ready for questions.
Shar Pourreza
analystHi there. Good morning. Hello, good morning, everyone.
Jim Chapman
executiveGood morning, Shar.
Shar Pourreza
analystTo start, congratulations to Jim and Steven, obviously. I suppose this means Mr. Ridge won't be skiing in Park City anymore, but congratulations to the two of you.
Jim Chapman
executiveThank you, Shar.
Shar Pourreza
analystBob, could you expand a bit more on what you said earlier, given that you're examining a variety of possible paths? A lot of people would figure you'd begin by considering a monetization of the contracted assets, but from where we sit, those really aren't the reason you're trading at a discount or the reason the stock has underperformed. There are those who'd say local politics might be behind the performance. So I'm wondering, might we see something more dramatic, such as divestitures where you'd concentrate solely on Virginia, or perhaps even selling the whole company, in order to truly maximize shareholder value? What do you expect this to ultimately look like? February feels like a very compressed schedule for an update, so I want to ask whether you've genuinely moved the needle in this effort. Thanks.
Bob Blue
executiveYes, thanks Shar. I'll take the last part of that question first — if you're thinking about corporate M&A, that isn't what's happening here. This is a business review, a full top-to-bottom look, exactly as we said in our prepared remarks, assessing strategies that maximize value, business mix, capital allocation, everything along those lines. We're going to make decisions, the same way we do with any strategic choice about the company, based on what's best for our shareholders, our employees, and our customers. Basically, we examined our performance and our stock's performance, and what the market's signaling is that we aren't delivering what investors anticipate. In our view, that justifies a thorough top-to-bottom examination. This effort is just getting underway, and beyond shareholder value and how our shares are doing, we will clearly also take into account the current macroeconomic conditions and ensure we're able to achieve our growth plan at the level we're aiming for. As I mentioned at the start, let me say again that we're steered by our dedication to our state-regulated utility model, to our credit standing, to the dividend we pay now, and to openness and protecting shareholder value. When we considered this, we realized we could simply continue along the existing path. As we noted, we do have a route to 2023. There are those who might say that repeating identical actions while anticipating a different outcome isn't particularly logical. We had the option to simply make an announcement, yet it seemed far more logical to tell everyone we're undertaking this review, gather feedback from shareholders, and determine what best serves our shareholders, our employees, and our customers moving forward over the long term.
Shar Pourreza
analystUnderstood. And finally, Bob, regarding that 6.5% growth rate you've put out there. Clearly, on slide 13 of your prepared remarks, you're suggesting that the target could be revised depending on the review. Clearly, the market's reaction in share price this morning suggests a reduction to that growth rate. Is there a scenario that could actually be accretive, or even supportive, of the target you've laid out? Particularly if we take the trend of privates and financial players paying fairly healthy multiples for assets, with proceeds that you can redeploy organically at 1x rate base. I mean, does a deal have to dilute growth? Do the numbers worry you?
Bob Blue
executiveYeah. We're clearly nearer the start of this process than the finish. We're going to have to work through it, and find out what the final outcome is before I'm able to speak to that, Shar. I get why you'd want more clarity on that today, but unless we've completed the process, that's a question we simply can't answer. Again, I'd return to the point that earnings quality and earnings predictability are our big focus; that's what shareholders are telling us they're after. That's what we'll concentrate on as we move through this review.
Shar Pourreza
analystAll right. Fantastic. Thanks, everyone. I'll get back in line. Appreciate it.
Ross Fowler
analystGood morning, Bob. Good morning, Jim.
Bob Blue
executiveGood morning.
Ross Fowler
analystPerhaps we can turn to offshore wind — I know the strategic review will prompt plenty of other questions, but let's spend a minute on offshore wind as we look at slide six and then, in a sense, slide eight in the deck. I think, you know, simply getting the settlement finished, which of course still requires approval, changes how investors perceive risk — away from that performance guarantee tied to capacity factor, and now toward cost. Maybe you could lay out what the cost risk looks like from here, given how costs are shared. The second piece of my question: you mention 75% fixed as of today, and then you're aiming for that 90% in the first quarter of next year. Could you give us some kind of framework? What does fixed actually mean or imply? Is it locked and settled? Is there any chance it moves? What do we have there, excluding the contingency?
Bob Blue
executiveAlright, I'll begin with the opening portion of what you asked. On the previous call, we mentioned that the performance guarantee introduced a risk level we understood our investors would not be happy with, and it simply didn't add up. From the instant we first envisioned this project, our attention has been on what it costs to construct it; that's our business; Cove Point was delivered on schedule and within budget, and we fully anticipate constructing this one the same way. Development is quite far along at this point; and just as you pointed out, and just as we mentioned during our opening remarks, 75% of cost fixed, expecting 90% by early in 2023. We're very much on target. The estimates leave us feeling very at ease. Contingency amounts have actually gone up compared to when we filed, which only bolsters our confidence further. During our opening remarks we noted that we're collaborating closely with regulators, making our way through the environmental permitting process. This project remains very much on track. We hold a strong degree of confidence in our capacity to construct it on schedule and within budget. I'll turn it over to Diane, who can go through some additional specifics on that.
Diane Leopold
executiveAll right, thank you, and good morning to everyone. I'd like to add some further detail on the various dimensions of this project. As you go through it, permitting comes first. Like Bob mentioned, we're making our way through the draft environmental impact statement process, and it remains on track for release before this year is over. We're coordinating closely with the regulators — BOEM and NOAA — tackling problems as they emerge so we can reduce any chance of schedule problems. I'd also remind everyone that from the very beginning we concentrated on taking schedule risk out by securing 2 piling seasons, 2 construction seasons, for installing those monopiles. The turbines themselves aren't even put in until season two. That creates schedule de-risking on the construction side, and that's how we view it as the project proceeds. Next, regarding our vendors and suppliers, we chose the global experts in offshore wind so that our contracting wouldn't introduce any added risk. Naturally, those were fixed-price contracts, and throughout, the variable components offshore were commodities and fuel. That's the reason you're seeing 75% fixed at this point. As we aim to keep advancing toward fabrication, every manufacturing slot is secured. A large portion of the steel plate is already ordered, and deliveries have in fact begun; indeed, fabrication work on our offshore substations and our cables is already underway. That explains the shift you're seeing from 75% toward 90%. The mills are up and running. Our vendors aren't worried about them being shut down because of fuel problems in Europe or anything of that nature. As Bob noted, in examining the whole project across this period, we've managed to preserve and even grow our contingency. We feel quite good about our position. I believe I've genuinely addressed that follow-up question about the ramp from 75% to 90%. It really comes down to receiving those deliveries and finalizing the rest of the metals and the fuel. The last component of the move from 75% to 90% sits on the onshore side — that onshore transmission — and getting those contracts locked in.
Ross Fowler
analystAll right, thanks for that. Bob, perhaps this one's for you regarding the strategic review — just building on what Shar asked about the growth rate. I'm just attempting to get a bit more clarity on what exactly you're trying to convey there. The 6.5% figure was where you stood, and that's what you're stating for 2023, correct? For the long-term growth rate. Today, without the strategic review, you see a route to that. I don't want to be putting words into your mouth, but I believe what I picked up from you was that outcomes in 2023 might differ depending on what the strategic review produces. Once that's done, one has to consider how long-term growth will appear. At your regulated utilities, rate-based growth sits at roughly 9%, a figure above 6.5%. If that's where your attention is, I'd say that's a positive. What I don't believe you're telling us today is that the strategic review will involve actions that dilute value.
Bob Blue
executiveYes, I believe that's the point we're making. Once more, I realize you want a definite answer, but we're at an early stage and have only just begun. What we're centered on — as you rightly pointed out — is regulated, high-quality earnings that can be counted on down the road. As for how all the figures ultimately land, we'll disclose that when the moment arrives. That's the reason we're telling you now that there's a path plus a status quo scenario, yet what comes out of the review might produce growth that differs in both quality and quantity.
Ross Fowler
analystOkay. Thank you. I'll jump back in the queue.
Steve Fleishman
analystYeah. Good morning. Hi, Bob. First, regarding that sort of status quo scenario, I believe for 2023 you said it was possible, though it would call for additional unregulated investment on your part. Could you elaborate a bit on what you mean by that?
Bob Blue
executiveYeah. I'll have Jim go through the various components of that.
Jim Chapman
executiveOkay, Steve — I'll take a broader view than the specific point you raised, though I will get to that as well. So what is happening with our guidance? Regarding 2022 — I realize that isn't what you asked about — we reaffirmed, we narrowed, and we remain on track on EPS and credit for 2022. As for 2023, we have never provided specific guidance for a forward year on our third-quarter call, and we aren't doing so now. I will return to that subject with more detail in a moment to add some color. On our long-term growth rate: we have not altered it, nor have we pulled it. As you pointed out, we likewise have not expressly reconfirmed it in light of the review. As shown on slide 13, we view these as routes toward hitting our long-term guidance. We have tools to get past certain macroeconomic headwinds that Bob referenced, through greater investment on the unregulated side plus other initiatives. A number of those tools and businesses happen to be the very ones covered by this review. Naturally, the review touches everything. Bob, in his prepared remarks, warned that long-term results in line with our current guidance are genuinely attainable only if the review's outcome preserves the status quo. In any case, to put it briefly, that covers the color on 2022, 2023, and the long term. On slide 13, we lay out drivers for the 2023 targets. Let me go through each line item in the path to our 6.5% in 2023 and give some detail. $4.10 for 2022 — that is the midpoint of the guidance we just narrowed. Simple math: 6.5% implies, and analyst consensus stands at, $4.37. So, $4.10 to $4.37. Naturally, bridging that involves certain helps and certain hurts. Let's walk through them as they appear on that slide. Sales growth: on the electric side, as we've discussed, it's moving along at a healthy pace, 1%-1.5%, a bit stronger on the data center side; yet the financial effect, combined with the margin effect, is likely flat. We've supplied further detail on margin dynamics, including Virginia, on slide 31. We're glad to follow up after the call and go through all of it. Those two items together: flat. Regulated investment, which we've said is this company's long-term earnings growth driver — call it $0.27 year-over-year. Roughly: $6 billion of growth CapEx, 50% equity ratio, 10% ROE across all our businesses. Millstone margins: a $0.08 year-over-year benefit. Here too, we've given extra disclosure on page 32 regarding our hedging position for Millstone over the coming several years. $0.08. ITC — an increase in ITC. We have chances to finish projects and boost our ITC contribution in 2023. That might be in solar, as we've done in the mid-teens for years now, or it might be recognition of an RNG ITC. $0.05-$0.11 as a placeholder; for RNG, that would assume roughly $200 million-$400 million of projects reaching COD in 2023. The final bucket I'll bring up: other. $0.17-$0.20. There's quite a bit packed into that. O&M programs are part of it. Regulatory results are in there too, Utah among them, plus a bit of assistance on the Wexpro side, RNG, the non-ITC contribution, and miscellaneous items; within that category, $0.17-$0.20, and a quarter of that effect comes purely from the Utah regulatory outcome. There are also some headwinds that people have brought up. The double outage at Millstone occurring every three years, regular as clockwork, $0.06. Interest expense — let's simply use figures viewed from the outside. We possess many instruments available to us for hedging and for managing this more dynamically. Suppose you say, fine, nearly 20% of your debt balance is variable. Let's simply assume rates have risen 2 to 3 percentage points year-over-year. That would amount to $0.13-$0.19 of damage. Then there's share dilution, a modest $0.03. Lastly, pension, which we've discussed; through most of this year, my position has been that it's too early to discuss pension. Just one date counts in our pension world, 12/31. Sitting here in November, that date is drawing nearer, so we can sort of box it up. There's a headwind. Like everyone else's, our assets are down. Like everyone else's, our discount rate is up 2.5% or so. The headwind stemming from that is modest. We're placing it in the high-single-digit pennies range, thus $0.06-$0.09. Those represent views along one path we must keep following for the 6.5% growth rate through 2023. Formal guidance, together with updates regarding where our review stands, will arrive on the fourth quarter call.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right. My apologies — there's one more thing I wanted to ask. I wasn't anticipating an answer that lengthy, though it did prove useful.
Jim Chapman
executiveYes. I appreciate that.
Steve Fleishman
analystWell, um—
Jim Chapman
executiveSo this is the final opportunity I'll have to speak with you for some time.
Steve Fleishman
analystYeah. I suppose this is somewhat unconventional when it comes to handling a matter such as this, but let me try to give some context on how you're approaching things in this review. In your view, Bob, and in the board's view, what's causing the stock to perform poorly? Is it because of the modest set of non-utility operations still left, or is the real issue Virginia and that fairly distinctive setup there? Could it be the offshore wind, along with some of the commotion you've had? Like, what are you—it's sort of difficult to form a view on this review when we don't understand what you believe the causes are.
Bob Blue
executiveYeah. Steve, I'd say it might be a combination of everything you just mentioned. Perhaps I'd put it another way: it comes down to what investors say they want from us. They want predictability. They want quality in earnings. They want to feel confident about growth over the long term.
Steve Fleishman
analystCorrect.
Bob Blue
executiveOnce more, throughout this evaluation process, those items are what we will concentrate on, aiming to deliver, on behalf of investors.
Steve Fleishman
analystAlright. What I'd say is, clearly, through this move, you folks have introduced a greater degree of uncertainty, so it becomes somewhat difficult to.
Bob Blue
executiveYeah.
Steve Fleishman
analystAt this point, it sort of turns into a self-reinforcing cycle.
Bob Blue
executiveSteve, here's how I'd put it — perhaps this isn't the conventional approach, even though I believe other businesses have come out with reviews. It may be somewhat unconventional. Once more, like I mentioned earlier, if we keep doing exactly what we've done up to now, we could very well wind up with the identical outcomes we got previously. We are going to hear what the market has to say. We're eager for the chance to talk with investors and hear their views while we make our way through all of this. Once again, what we're aiming for here is to reach a result that delivers predictability and quality, and our intention is to do that in a highly transparent manner.
Steve Fleishman
analystAll right, thanks.
Jeremy Tonet
analystHello there, and good morning.
Bob Blue
executiveHi, Jeremy.
Jeremy Tonet
analystHi. If I could, I'd like to keep going with the review for a moment. I was hoping to hear, perhaps phrased somewhat differently, which possibilities are no longer being considered, aside from the non-regulated operations. Might you consider divesting a few of the LDCs? We've observed other players in this sector achieving considerable success on that front. On a separate note, regarding the pressure on customer bills, as you mentioned, could you explain what actions Dominion could take to tackle that? Is there a method of tackling it that wouldn't hurt EPS or credit?
Bob Blue
executiveYes. Jeremy, allow me to take your first point. What's no longer being considered versus what remains under consideration? The response regarding what's excluded matches the response regarding what's included, which is that we've launched a comprehensive review, and once more, steered by the principles laid out during our opening remarks; regarding your question's second portion, namely policy initiatives, you know, we offered illustrations of measures we've taken across our states during the past several years to assist customers, including forgiving arrears, recovering RGGI costs via base rates, distributing fuel across several time frames. As we collaborate with policymakers and reason through the most sensible methods to guarantee that present customer bills don't impede long-term customer investment, we'll be considering those very approaches we've employed previously and ensuring we secure constructive regulatory outcomes, something I believe we've shown across many years that we excel at attaining here.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood, that's a big help. Switching gears here, I realize the review is getting plenty of attention, but I was hoping to check in on the RNG front and hear what new efforts might be underway, or get your latest thinking.
Diane Leopold
executiveMorning, Jeremy, Diane here. That pipeline keeps growing and things are moving along nicely. Like Bob mentioned, when you tally it up, 20 projects are in progress at this point. Four are generating, 11 are being built, and another five should enter construction before the year ends; the ones already generating are performing exactly as intended, and their CARB scores are coming in really strong. You're aware of how carbon negative they are, given our emphasis on the ag RNG operation across dairy and swine. A total of $1 billion has been or will be put into this, and we anticipate it generating roughly $200 million by 2025. Everything is going quite well.
Jeremy Tonet
analystUnderstood. Excellent. If I may slip in one final brief question. Returning to the review discussed here, did the approaching triennial factor into your thinking in any way?
Bob Blue
executiveNo. Once more, numerous elements are influencing our operations, and it's impossible to single out just one. As we've stated, what matters most to us is how our shares are performing and what steps we can take to guarantee we keep up our capital investment programs for the long term.
Jeremy Tonet
analystGreat. Thank you very much.
Operator
operatorThanks. That wraps up today's morning conference call. You can go ahead and hang up your line, and have a great day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Dominion Energy, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Dominion Energy, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Dominion Energy, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.