Dye & Durham Limited (DND) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 10, 2022

Toronto Stock Exchange CA Information Technology Software earnings 29 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone. Colin here — I'll be the conference operator for today. Right now, I want to welcome all of you to Dye & Durham's earnings call for the first quarter of fiscal 2023. At this point, I'll hand things over to Ross Marshall, who handles investor relations for Dye & Durham. Mr. Marshall, the conference is yours to begin.

Ross Marshall

executive
#2

Thanks, operator. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Dye & Durham conference call. Before we begin, we want to remind you that every amount we discuss on this call is in Canadian dollars unless we say otherwise. Please be aware that what we say today may contain forward-looking statements, as well as information and future-oriented financial information about Dye & Durham and its businesses, along with disclosure about possible events, conditions, or results that rest on information management currently has available, which reflect management's expectations for future growth, operating results, business performance, and business prospects and opportunities. These statements are made as of today's date, and Dye & Durham takes on no obligation to update or revise them to reflect events, disclosures, or circumstances except as applicable securities law requires. Statements of this kind carry significant risks and uncertainties and do not guarantee future performance or results. Several of these risks or uncertainties could cause actual results to differ materially from what we discuss today. In light of these risks and uncertainties, you should not place undue reliance on such statements and information. For more information, please see the forward-looking statements and information and future oriented financial information section of our public filings, including, without limitation, our MD&A and the earnings press release we issued today.

Ross Marshall

executive
#3

On today's call we have with us Matt Proud, who serves as Chief Executive Officer of Dye & Durham, along with Frank Di Liso, Dye & Durham's Chief Financial Officer. After that, there will be a question-and-answer session with the formal results for research analysts. At this point I'll hand things over to Matt, who will give the opening remarks. Matt?

Matthew Proud

executive
#4

Thank you, Ross, and good afternoon to everyone. During the first quarter, our business kept performing well even though the real estate market was extremely challenging, especially in Canada. We have built a company that is diversified across three geographical markets and across a range of product lines. People often ask me how resilient the business is when the real estate market is deteriorating. Since December 2021, real estate transaction volumes have been under significant pressure, particularly in Canada. Inflation has risen, it is high, and in our view it will stay high for a while. We have witnessed the quickest rise in interest rates since the 1970s. In Q1, despite these challenging headwinds, we reported a good quarter. Our results show the strength of our underlying business, with more than CAD 120 million in revenue during the quarter and CAD 64.4 million of adjusted EBITDA. We achieved this consistent performance even as monthly year-over-year real estate transaction volumes in Canada were down between 25%-32% in the July to September period. One reason the business is resilient is our revenue exposure to the global real estate market, which stands at 68%. Just 68% of our volume is exposed to real estate transactions.

Matthew Proud

executive
#5

One-third of our global business isn’t directly linked to real estate transaction volume. Looking more closely at our biggest market, Canada, 43% of our revenue is exposed to the Canadian real estate market. Although both figures are still significant, what we frequently observe is modeling that applies the real estate transaction growth rate or decline in Canada to the whole business. In our view, that is a vast oversimplification of the business. We’ve done a good job managing through the deteriorating market transactions with an increase in the price per unit, the EBITDA we buy, and the synergies we realize with acquired businesses using the capital we deploy. Remember, a lot of our model has to do with capital allocation. Touching on the deteriorating market: I’ve always been a large believer in running a business with operational and financial discipline. That is more important than ever right now, given the macroeconomic environment remains extremely challenging and continues to deteriorate in many cases. As such, I’ve decided the company needs to act more aggressively and decisively to protect its business and financial position. Therefore, we will be implementing cost reduction initiatives to reduce the current overhead operational cost by at least 10% commencing in the second quarter of fiscal 2023, i.e., the current quarter.

Matthew Proud

executive
#6

This is taking place right now. We keep carrying out our approach of allocating capital with discipline in order to build a business of scale via acquisitions and by investing in the platform we already have. Through these acquisitions and investments, the platform gains enhancements and new capabilities that boost our customers' efficiency and productivity. Compared with where things stood at the time of the IPO two and a half years ago, the business is now dramatically bigger. We are creating a global leader in the B2B software and services space that serves legal and business professionals. As you can see, we have built a business that is highly resilient and highly reliable, one that generates digital infrastructure cash flows. Because our revenue has an annuity character and our cost base is relatively fixed, we have operated in an extremely disciplined way through the recent inflationary period, and that yields tremendous levels of productivity in our revenues as well as adjusted EBITDA. It also lets us achieve the high EBITDA margins we do, since revenue can scale dramatically without matching cost increases. Importantly, this afternoon we announced a substantial issuer bid, or SIB, of CAD 150 million. In light of the dynamics in the capital markets, the consistency of our business despite real estate headwinds, and the strength of our balance sheet, we believe there is no better use of capital at this point — particularly given the significant discount, some might even call it a silly discount, at which we trade in the market, given the scale of our business today.

Matthew Proud

executive
#7

The earnings release contains the initial SIB details. After the earnings blackout ends, we'll share additional disclosure regarding the terms of the modified Dutch auction style bid. Beyond the SIB, we've also been utilizing the normal course issuer bid announced in September, and Frank will cover the specifics of that normal course issuer bid shortly. Disciplined and effective capital allocation underpins our entire business strategy. Look, we've shown repeatedly that we can acquire assets, integrate them, and scale them while keeping margins strong. In our view, the SIB extends this capital allocation strategy. What does that mean for future acquisitions? We can walk and chew gum at the same time. We believe a recessionary environment will create stronger opportunities for additional M&A over the long term, which is a tailwind for our business. We're going to come out of this stronger. As the Link Administration disclosure shows, we're in discussions with them to acquire their corporate markets and BCM business. We would retain their BCM business and then look to divest the majority of that business in due course.

Matthew Proud

executive
#8

We think their corporate market operation is a compelling asset — one that would diversify what we do even more, across both product line and geography. It's also a business that performs well when rates are higher, and that would pair very nicely with ours. As of today, we have nothing new to share regarding where those talks stand, and, as is true with any M&A transaction, there's no guarantee this deal gets done. Alongside the SIB, we're continuing to advance our strategy of further diversifying the core business through fresh acquisitions that tackle the workflow and efficiency requirements of professionals in the legal market. As part of that strategy, we plan to keep broadening our market reach and to enter neighboring ecosystems in Canada, the U.K. and Australia by way of acquisitions. Our pipeline stays very, very strong. As we've shown across multiple market cycles, we can run the business to deliver consistent and substantial performance — or sustainable performance — as we keep executing our strategy of scaling through acquisitions. We built a business quickly that produces strong top-line growth within an industry offering stable cash flow and a very healthy margin, if I do say so myself. We look forward to bringing you an update on our progress as we move ahead.

Matthew Proud

executive
#9

At this point I'll hand things to Frank so he can walk us through the financials. Frank.

Frank Di Liso

executive
#10

Thanks, Matt, and good afternoon to all of you. I appreciate everyone joining us today. This marks the first time I've taken part in this call. Although my tenure here spans just a few months, I'm thrilled to be on the team. I've observed robust expansion in the business, its operational capabilities, and the well-established cost management practices already in place. We posted revenue of CAD 120.2 million in the first quarter, up CAD 7.5 million or 7% versus the same period a year ago. Adjusted EBITDA came in at CAD 64.4 million, a rise of CAD 2.1 million or 3% compared with the same period last year. We keep sustaining our solid EBITDA margins, landing at 54% this quarter, consistent with our 50%-60% target range. Growth on the top line has been driven both by acquisitions we've closed and by integration work plus our organic growth, including synergies realized through price adjustments. Amid rapid inflation, we've held tight controls over the cost structure. Our cost management discipline is evident, as shown by essentially flat results on a sequential quarterly basis. Total operating costs — covering direct costs, technology, operations costs, and G&A and sales marketing — amounted to CAD 55.7 million for the quarter, or 46% of revenue, versus CAD 50.2 million in the prior year's quarter.

Frank Di Liso

executive
#11

Within operating cost, there's an increase tied to rolling out a new IT managed service platform, amounting to CAD 0.7 million. That initiative assists in making the business more efficient. Going forward, we don't anticipate that expense to persist. Higher other operating costs across the year-over-year comparison stem from costs picked up through acquisitions closed during the period. We anticipate operating costs will remain in the 40%-50% range of revenues. Net finance costs came in at CAD 16.2 million for the quarter, versus a negative CAD 12.6 million in Q1 of the previous year. That rise reflects elevated interest and accretion expense of CAD 18.3 million, mainly tied to the Ares credit facility, plus recognition of a non-cash gain on fair value changes of convertible debentures of just CAD 9.1 million, against CAD 15.3 million a year earlier in the same period. Keep in mind that IFRS accounting rules oblige us to mark-to-market the fair value of these instruments every quarter, so variability in our finance costs should indeed persist. Acquisition restructuring and other costs totaled CAD 18.5 million this quarter, compared with CAD 10.6 million in Q1 of last year.

Frank Di Liso

executive
#12

That rise comes from CAD 11.4 million of higher acquisition costs, driven mainly by activity on the Link transaction, plus CAD 1.8 million in increased restructuring costs versus the same period a year earlier. These were offset by CAD 3 million of privatization costs that did not occur in the current period and a CAD 1.3 million decrease in integration costs. We have built a resilient business. Slide 8 shows the growth we have delivered in adjusted EBITDA over the last 12-month period. Through this period we have managed the puts and takes to deliver consistent performance. Even with fewer real estate market transactions, our adjusted EBITDA performance remains strong. That is a great illustration of how we manage the business through cycles while delivering shareholder value. Our conversion of adjusted EBITDA to cash flow is strong. We reported net cash provided from operating activities of CAD 41 million in the quarter, up CAD 8.1 million, or 25%, compared with the same period last year. After quarter end, we announced the normal course issuer bid that Matt mentioned earlier. Under that program, we have so far purchased and retired 2.8 million outstanding shares, which represents CAD 46.2 million in capital deployed to shareholders.

Frank Di Liso

executive
#13

By the end of September 30 this year, we had more than CAD 500 million in liquidity available for the NCIB and for new acquisitions. That liquidity is made up of cash, our revolving credit facility, and the delayed draw term loan. On a net basis, our leverage ratio stands at 2.5x as of September 30th, and we think that gives us ample headroom, especially with our strong free cash flow conversion of more than 50%. Our plan is to put that capital to work on new acquisitions and the capital repurchase programs currently in place, as Matt mentioned earlier. Earlier today, the board approved a quarterly dividend of CAD 0.01875 per common share, payable on November 23rd to shareholders of record on November 16th. That wraps up my formal remarks, and with that, I'd like to hand it back to the operator for Q&A. Operator?

Operator

operator
#14

Thanks. At this point, women and gentlemen, we're going to hold a question and answer session. Whenever you want to pose a question, simply press star and then the number one on your telephone keypad. Should you wish to take back your question, press star followed by two. In case you're on a speakerphone, kindly pick up the handset before pressing any keys. Just a moment while we get your first question. All right, your first question is from Robert Young of Canaccord Genuity. Robert, please go ahead.

Robert Young

analyst
#15

Hello there. Right, so regarding the substantial issuer bid — and note that this comes on top of the earlier NCIB. In the press release, I believe you stated that you won't be using the NCIB anymore. Across both of those, what's the overall cash outlay? It's roughly CAD 200 million, right?

Frank Di Liso

executive
#16

Robert, it's Frank. So there's the CAD 150 for the SIB, and we've already put CAD 46 million into the NCIB. A small piece of that is still left. But the thing that's really out there at the moment is the SIB, with that smaller part coming afterward.

Robert Young

analyst
#17

After that, if you were to go after a deal for the Link Group business, presumably that would require extra funding. Could you give us some sense of how comfortable you are with the leverage ratio, you know, for that transaction to succeed?

Matthew Proud

executive
#18

It's still elevated, Rob — extremely so. We happen to be in a fortunate position: this is a company whose results remain quite robust. We generate substantial cash and a great deal of EBITDA. And what you're witnessing is that even with difficult markets, those results keep coming through. As we've said all along, we're prepared to let leverage rise for a period, provided we can get it back to that 2 to 3x range reasonably quickly — and we've shown, time and again, that we can do exactly that.

Robert Young

analyst
#19

Alright. Your prepared remarks zeroed in on Canada and its housing sector. So if we look at Canada, the UK, and Australia, how much of a hit to transaction volumes is coming from the macro pressures we're dealing with right now? Maybe walk us through an update with a bit more detail on those markets. That would be great.

Matthew Proud

executive
#20

Yeah. I mean, generally speaking, the volumes we see track the data that comes out of the different market sources in that market. What we're seeing is volumes moving almost precisely in step with that. Obviously, we've raised our PPU in every geography, and that's helping with the downward pressure and easing it. The PPU increase has been a big offset to the decline in volume. Of course, there's obviously the non-real estate portion of our business, and that isn't affected.

Robert Young

analyst
#21

Is PPU the same thing as price per unit?

Matthew Proud

executive
#22

Exactly right. Yes.

Robert Young

analyst
#23

Alright, this is my final question, and then I’ll hand things over. Could you expand a bit on that 10% cost reduction? What’s the plan for getting there? Just some sense of where it comes from would help — are you closing any operations, or anything more you can share? Then I’ll turn it over.

Matthew Proud

executive
#24

Yeah. Look, our biggest expense is personnel, so we’re going to reduce headcount. Beyond that, we’ll be seeking efficiencies throughout the business.

Robert Young

analyst
#25

Can you expand a bit more on the efficiencies? For instance, which kinds of efficiencies are you focusing on?

Matthew Proud

executive
#26

Right. Vendors we don't actually need, or chances to secure better pricing from the ones we do use. You know, the nice-to-have items, discretionary spending. Clearly, the biggest chunk is going to come from cutting people. Again, we're confident we can take out that much cost without hurting the business.

Robert Young

analyst
#27

Yeah. Frank mentioned during the prepared remarks that free cash flow as a percentage of revenue margins is roughly 50%. Is that the level we should aim to keep? I'll hand it over.

Matthew Proud

executive
#28

Of course, we'd prefer that figure to be larger. As you're aware, there are acquisition costs embedded in it that are dragging it lower—especially with Link over the past 2 quarters, where those costs have been fairly significant. Still, that control transaction came with a very high price tag. That won't keep happening as we move ahead.

Robert Young

analyst
#29

All right, thank you. I'll stop dominating the microphone now.

Operator

operator
#30

Our following question is from Thanos Moschopoulos of BMO Capital Markets. Thanos, the floor is yours.

Thanos Moschopoulos

analyst
#31

Hello there, and good afternoon. I'd like to say a bit more about the OpEx cut. My sense is that you probably still have some cost synergies left over from earlier M&A that you're realizing. Is it the case that some of those synergies fall within that 10% reduction, or would there be additional cost synergies stemming from integrating things that could come on top of that 10% reduction?

Matthew Proud

executive
#32

We aren't going to separate out that two. What I think you ought to be watching for is a cut of no less than 10% relative to the OpEx figure we have right now, you know, over the quarters ahead. We intend to carry that out during this quarter, and expect that the bulk of it will show up as it comes out in the quarter after.

Thanos Moschopoulos

analyst
#33

All right. When it comes to a restructuring charge, the usual guideline, I suppose, is to take the cost savings and annualize them. Is that a reasonable way to look at it, or what's the right way to think about how large a restructuring charge is needed?

Matthew Proud

executive
#34

No, that isn’t something we do. If you look at the restructuring cost, it will consist of items such as the one-time expense of eliminating a role, severance. We aren’t including a cost where, say, we removed CAD 100 of cost and so there’s CAD 100 going forward under the restructuring line item. It is simply the expense of taking out that cost that is being restructured.

Thanos Moschopoulos

analyst
#35

All right, is there anything new regarding the sale of TM Group?

Matthew Proud

executive
#36

That process is in progress, and that is really all I can say.

Thanos Moschopoulos

analyst
#37

Alright. Perhaps one final question from me: regarding the areas of the business that don’t depend on property volumes, just to verify — have those remained stable? Has growth occurred? Has any macro pressure appeared? How would you describe the volumes you’re handling across the remainder of the business?

Matthew Proud

executive
#38

Things have stayed fairly consistent. I mean, clearly, yeah, the best way to put it is that it's just been normal operations, same as before.

Frank Di Liso

executive
#39

Thanos, yes, we did make an update in the MD&A. In the quarterly metrics section, you'll find that we've included those percentages, which are driven by real estate transaction activity across the last eight quarters. So once you've had a chance to look through it, you'll be able to see that.

Thanos Moschopoulos

analyst
#40

All right, I appreciate the additional disclosure. I’ll hand it over. Thank you.

Matthew Proud

executive
#41

Sure.

Thanos Moschopoulos

analyst
#42

Sounds good.

Operator

operator
#43

Stephen Boland of Raymond James has the next question. The line is yours.

Stephen Boland

analyst
#44

Hey, everyone. Just a single question: you pulled the guidance for the year, citing conditions. What exactly are you seeing? What's your take on conditions this quarter — it's ongoing — but looking at the next couple of quarters, do you see things leveling off here, or what are you hearing from your vendors and customers about what they expect?

Matthew Proud

executive
#45

Look, from a market standpoint, October has turned out worse than September, and we had been hoping that wouldn't happen. With the volatility out there — and obviously what the market does isn't something we control — we just want to be prudent, so we're removing that guidance. Look, predicting the real estate market is tough. So what are we doing? We're taking steps like diversifying revenue so we have less exposure to real estate, and reducing costs, and the business keeps performing. We always try to flex the pricing power we have, you know, through inflationary times to make sure we operate with an optimal cost structure and charge the right amount for our products. Those are the kinds of things we're doing.

Stephen Boland

analyst
#46

Alright, so my second question is really this. I realize you're constantly evaluating acquisitions. Apart from Link, have you noticed multiples declining recently on other deals out there and potential targets? From their perspective, have you observed any drop in multiples at all — whether materially or otherwise?

Matthew Proud

executive
#47

I mean, what we're seeing in the public market is honestly just a meltdown in multiples, obviously. Setting that aside, on the private side, we're beginning to see multiples soften. There's still a bid-ask spread between, you know, what buyers expect and what sellers expect, but it's starting to shift toward buyers and turning into more of a buyer's market. That's definitely a trend we're seeing.

Stephen Boland

analyst
#48

Alright. So with those multiples — meaning if you look back, say, even 2 years ago — we were discussing multiples in the high teens. Are those multiples now heading toward single digits, or are they sitting at, you know, 10x or something along those lines? I mean, is it still sort of, you know—

Matthew Proud

executive
#49

We can’t quite call it a trend yet in terms of pinpointing exactly where it stands. You know, I came across some figures not long ago. I was looking at U.S. LBOs at just under 11x, or just under 12x, on the multiple. It genuinely hinges on the business and the various factors. You know, better-quality businesses are going to command higher multiples. But broadly speaking, we’re observing it come down. I wouldn’t go so far as to place it in single digits the way you did, though it is approaching that.

Stephen Boland

analyst
#50

All right, thank you, everyone.

Operator

operator
#51

The following question is from Kevin Krishnaratne at Scotiabank. Kevin, the floor is yours.

Kevin Krishnaratne

analyst
#52

Hi there, just one question from me. Obviously, you can't control real estate transactions or the direction they're heading, but pricing and launching new products are things you do control. Could you speak to the opportunities on that front? You're cutting costs. I'm just wondering whether any of those reductions — how should we think about what they could mean for your growth strategy? I know you're considering various products, the Unity product, the subscription product. Could you take us through your thinking there?

Matthew Proud

executive
#53

So in Canada, we're still moving forward with our workflow software product, rolling out subscriptions as a way to provide some protection when the market declines. And we would still put more money into R&D than anybody else in this industry. We're pretty innovative. Culturally, I think this is a company that truly believes in accomplishing more with less — small, lean teams that are extremely focused and get a great deal done, at times outperforming a larger team that isn't lean. So we leverage that strength to make sure we prioritize the things that matter to our customers in the market and push the more nice-to-have items to the back burner. That's a philosophy we've always applied, and I believe we'll keep applying it and lean on it even more during periods of austerity.

Kevin Krishnaratne

analyst
#54

All right. Just, you know, perhaps taking a look across every one of your regions and offerings — is there any competitive movement whatsoever? I realize you hold fairly strong, you know, share. Your products lead the market, so, you know, probably not, but I'm just curious whether anything is showing up, even if only at the edges.

Matthew Proud

executive
#55

Not particularly, no. I mean, it looks good. In other words, churn has been quite steady. As for the business, we aren't really observing much. Our market position is genuinely strong.

Kevin Krishnaratne

analyst
#56

All right, that's great. Best of luck with all of it. I'll hand things over.

Operator

operator
#57

Our following question is from Scott Fletcher of CIBC. Scott, you have the floor.

Scott Fletcher

analyst
#58

Good evening. A lot of what I wanted to ask has already been addressed here. I’ll ask about M&A. If this revised cut of the Link deal does go through, it would appear that you’d need to take something of a pause afterward. Is that still the way you prefer to handle M&A — these larger deals and then wait until leverage comes back down? Or, you know, is it just that, you know, was it simply the opportunity that presented itself?

Matthew Proud

executive
#59

Look, I mean, folding in a small transaction often takes, you know, just as much effort. Do ten small ones and it's a lot — actually even more work. Look, as you've seen from us, you know, we favor bigger, chunkier deals when we can, you know, have a clear path to our return multiples. Obviously we see that in this transaction. Yeah, I can't really say more about it beyond that. That answers your question? I hope it does.

Scott Fletcher

analyst
#60

Yes, that makes sense. As I mentioned, just about all of it has been addressed, so thank you.

Operator

operator
#61

Alright. That brings us to the end of our question period for today. Now I’ll hand things back over to Ross, who has some closing remarks.

Ross Marshall

executive
#62

Appreciate all of you being here today. We're eager to bring you Dye & Durham's results for the second quarter of fiscal 2023 when we update you in February 2023. Good night.

Operator

operator
#63

Everyone, that brings today's conference call to a close. We appreciate your taking part, and we'd ask you to kindly disconnect your line now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Dye & Durham Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Dye & Durham Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Dye & Durham Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.