eDreams ODIGEO S.A. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 19, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David de la Roz
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and thanks to all of you for being with us today for the presentation of our Q2 fiscal year 2021 results, covering the 3 months that ended on 30th of September 2020. I'm David de la Roz, Director of Investor Relations at eDreams ODIGEO. You can, as usual, locate the results materials, which include the presentation of our results report, in the Investor Relations section of our website. I'll now hand things over to Dana Dunne, our CEO, who will walk you through the first part of the presentation. Thank you.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, David. Good afternoon, everyone, and I appreciate you being with us. In my remarks today, I'll cover how we performed in Q2 of this financial year, how trading stands right now, and the steps we've taken over the last few months — through the pandemic — to strengthen our strategic position even further. After that, David Elizaga, our CFO, will walk you through the details of our financial performance. I'll wrap up with some closing comments. If you'd go to Slide 4, you'll see a summary of how we did in Q2. In Q2, our performance improved as the market recovered substantially compared with Q1. Even so, we observed fresh softening as the quarter drew to a close. Trading reflects the sharp, swift rebound we saw over the summer. Bookings went from the April low of minus 96% year-on-year to averaging minus 62% in the second quarter of fiscal year '21, even with additional travel restrictions put in place in certain markets from early August. Obviously, July to September 2020 remained an unusual trading stretch, given COVID-19 and the travel restrictions tied to it. Notably, revenue margin fell 75% year-on-year in the second quarter of FY '21, coming in at EUR 34.4 million — twice the figure for Q1 FY '21.
Dana Dunne
executiveThe drop came from a 62% fall in bookings. On top of that, revenue margin per booking declined, and that was because the average basket value of bookings was lower owing to the COVID-19 situation. This leads to reduced classic revenue from customers as well as reduced revenue from providers. As for marginal profit, meaning revenue margin less variable costs, it came in at a positive EUR 11.5 million. That equals 10x what we saw in Q1, and it also reflects greater variability and flexibility in our cost structure as we adapted to the new mix of bookings customers made during COVID-19. The upshot was that marginal profit per booking rose 2.5x versus the Q1 figure in Q2, even though revenues fell by more than bookings did. Adjusted EBITDA was a loss of EUR 2 million, which is an 86% improvement over the Q1 FY '21 figure. One more highlight is the way we are handling our liquidity. Throughout this hard period for the travel sector, we at eDreams ODIGEO have handled our liquidity well. It stays strong even with short-term trading and faster reimbursements to customers. Since our liquidity position is strong, we took a proactive decision to speed up refunding to our customers, who are suffering because airlines, in most cases, take a long time to refund.
Dana Dunne
executiveWhen it comes to liquidity, cash performance improved relative to Q2 of the prior financial year. At the close of September, our liquidity position was EUR 115 million, and at the end of October it was EUR 117 million, both above the March and June levels once you exclude the acceleration of the reimbursements. The key drivers behind this are the highly variable nature of the cost structure and solid management of fixed costs. That was offset by our proactive choice to speed up customer reimbursements relative to the inflows we received from suppliers, along with a decline in bookings caused by tighter travel restrictions. Together, those factors produce a working capital outflow. We have brought our average monthly cash burn, excluding working capital and taxes, down from EUR 13 million to EUR 6 million, and we hold a strong liquidity reserve. Our no-action stress test implies that we can operate the business at current booking levels through the end of 2021. And, as we highlighted in our July and August results presentation, we are using this period to strengthen our strategic positioning. In particular, Prime is shining during these tough times. Prime subscriptions and the share of total bookings keep growing. Prime members in the second quarter of FY '21 reached 664,000 members.
Dana Dunne
executiveThat comes to a 71% rise compared with the same period in the prior financial year. The share of bookings, or share of total bookings, hit 26% in Q2 of this year, up from 7% in Q2 of the previous financial year. Prime is showing itself to be a successful proposition for customers, even in the currently depressed market, with 100,000 new subscribers in Q2 of this financial year alone, versus just Q1 of this financial year. And we remain on track to reach 2 million subscribers by 2023. Turning to current trading, the near-term outlook is largely beyond our control and is being driven by travel restrictions related to COVID-19. October and November figures show bookings growth of minus 67% to minus 73% year-on-year. Given the uncertainty surrounding COVID-19 and travel restrictions, predicting the future with any accuracy is still impossible, and so we continue to provide no guidance for this financial year. I'll now walk through the points I just mentioned in greater detail on the slides that follow. Please turn to Slide 5, where we cover our diversification revenue KPIs. Overall, diversification revenue is proving more resilient than classic customer revenue during these times. And both our product diversification ratio and our revenue diversification ratio have improved.
Dana Dunne
executiveOur product diversification ratio rose to 87% from 80% — that's a 7 percentage point gain within one year. In a similar vein, revenue diversification ratio went up from 48% to 56% during Q2 FY '21. Once again, that is an 8 percentage point increase in just one year. Kindly go to Slide 6, which shows how we have progressed on our remaining 3 KPIs. As anticipated, on an annualized basis, our rate of repeat customer bookings fell because of COVID-19 spreading. The strict method we use for calculating this ratio reflects that. Even so, Q2 results improved substantially compared with Q1 FY '21 and are 3x higher, rising from 7% to 22%. Prime's success as a customer proposition has mainly driven this. Because the COVID-19 situation is distorting how relevant this KPI is, we have chosen to stop reporting this KPI until further notice. Moreover, we have once again really stood out when it comes to mobile, which is a good sign for the future. Over the last 5 years, bookings made via mobile have grown exponentially, from 18% of total bookings to 57%. Mobile has always been our priority and focus, and we have led the industry in Europe.
Dana Dunne
executiveNow, in a post-COVID-19 world, mobile is going to matter even more — and you can see that in the fact that almost 60% of our bookings are now actually finished on a mobile device. Finally, on KPIs, let's turn to the shifts in the acquisition cost per booking index, which came in 48 percentage points better year-on-year. That reflects how adaptable and flexible our business is. And the fact that over 80% of our costs are variable. But I want to be clear: this very low level can't be sustained over the long term. As travel restrictions ease, we expect to put more into online marketing, and this ratio will move back toward more normalized levels. If you could now go to Slide 8, let me update you on our current trading to date and what we've done to strengthen our strategic position during the pandemic. Current trading shows that the short-term outlook is impacted by travel restrictions. We've seen this through the rapid rebound in bookings during the summer. As travel restrictions ease, trading improved from the April trough at minus 96% to minus 59% in August. That's positive in that, within a matter of months, a large portion of the market came back in a very short period of time.
Dana Dunne
executiveNear the end of summer, Europe saw COVID-19 cases rising again, and some governments brought in additional travel restrictions. That pushed bookings down to minus 73%, and more recently they have leveled off. Measured against the market, our trading points to outperformance versus the airline industry, and we are gaining share against supplier direct thanks to better quality, fuller content, flexibility, and a focus on leisure travel. Kindly go to Slide 9, where I bring you up to date on the trading outlook, drawing on analysis from the IATA Economics team that came out on the 29th of September. On the positive side, leisure customers remain willing to travel when permitted. We witnessed that over the summer, and we firmly believe that any additional easing of restrictions or the arrival of a vaccine will probably produce another sharp rebound. The announcements from Pfizer, BioNTech and Moderna about their vaccines, along with the AstraZeneca news this morning and 8 other companies in stage 3 trials, together accelerate scenarios in which travel comes back earlier in 2021, which will benefit leisure-focused travel companies such as ours. Prior to the most recent vaccine announcements, an IATA survey indicated that more than 80% of passengers would return to air travel within 6 months from now.
Dana Dunne
executiveRussia has bounced back to where it was before the crisis, thanks to news regarding its vaccine. Meanwhile, China sits just 20% under pre-COVID-19 levels, helped by robust domestic demand. Now, if you would go to Slide 10. We're glad to keep reporting solid liquidity, which stems from our robust business model and how actively we've managed this situation. We've pulled this off even as travel restrictions have grown and we've sped up reimbursements to customers in order to safeguard our brand. Because our liquidity position is solid, we took the proactive step of accelerating customer reimbursements relative to the inflows coming in from airlines, and that produced a cash outflow of EUR 40 million in the quarter. As a result, liquidity stood at EUR 115 million and EUR 117 million at the close of September and October, respectively — each of those is above the March and June figures, once you exclude the acceleration of reimbursements. We've gotten there through 4 things: one, most of our costs are highly variable; two, fixed costs and CapEx came down; three, we secured additional financial resources of EUR 15 million via a government-sponsored loan due 2023; and four, we cut our average monthly cash burn, excluding working capital and tax, from EUR 13 million down to EUR 6 million. On top of that, our no-action stress test indicates we can operate the business at minus 70% bookings year-on-year through the end of the calendar year 2021.
Dana Dunne
executiveThat minus 70% figure represents how our bookings performed on average between March and October. Worth stressing how conservative this no-action stress test really is. It presumes zero action on either fixed or variable costs. None at all. No working capital improvement, and no betterment in our business of any kind. Please direct your attention now to Slide 11. It's a pleasure to discuss how well Prime has done as a customer proposition. Prime is delivering strong results despite this weak market. Subscriber counts have kept climbing, up 100,000 across 3 months, moving from Q1 to Q2 of this financial year, and that's with all the market conditions we've seen. On the right-hand chart you'll notice that both the Prime subscription rate and Prime's share keep expanding. Prime members during Q2 of this financial year were up 71% against the equivalent period a year earlier. That's an increase from 389,000 subscribers in Q2 FY '20 to 664,000 subscribers in FY '21. Meanwhile Prime's share of total bookings nearly quadrupled, going from 7% in Q2 FY '20 to 26% in FY '21. Beyond that, we brought Prime into new markets, the U.K., most recently in November. We also introduced new products, rolling out hotels in 4 of our biggest markets, namely France, Italy, Spain and Germany.
Dana Dunne
executiveAnd I'm happy to report that our latest survey, which drew more than thousands of customer responses, found Prime customers reporting solid satisfaction levels — matching or exceeding what we saw before COVID-19. Turning now to Slide 12, I'd like to walk you through our customer service efforts aimed at putting us squarely on the customer's side. Above all, with airline cancellations running high right now, our priority is the customer. We want this to serve as a major competitive edge and to bring customers back once travel restrictions ease. Here are the main points regarding how we handle canceled flights: First, 92% of canceled flights have been resolved and processed. Second, we've put money into substantially expanding our contact center capacity. Third, we've built an automated flight cancellation identifier that flags canceled flights automatically, reaches out to customers proactively across every possible touch point, and offers them options. Fourth, we've reached out to every customer who appears to have a solution — for instance, someone who may have gone straight to the airline — simply to confirm that a solution truly exists for them. Fifth, we've let customers know about the long lead times airlines are facing and, wherever feasible, offered a voucher as an alternative.
Dana Dunne
executiveBut in every case, let customers pick between getting cash back or receiving a voucher. Our aim is to stand with the customer, acting as their advocate and agent. Number six, we put automated processes in place that give our customers updates on refund request status in near real-time. And number seven, we've sped up reimbursements to customers relative to the inflows we got from airlines in those instances where we know the future cash reception from the airline is guaranteed. I could keep going, but let's just say that we have taken -- and continue to take -- actions that help our customers and put us on their side. If you'd turn to Slide 13. Let me wrap up my portion by summarizing our 3 top priorities right now. One, Prime, to bring Prime into more of our markets, expand into other travel services and boost its effectiveness. Two, connectivity, to raise content quality by building a content-agnostic platform, which will make it easier to take content from many providers and take even different content. That could be trains, air content, et cetera. And three, customer service automation, to implement an automated customer service system that is volume agnostic. So if customer demand reached much higher levels, the system can handle it automatically with high levels of satisfaction.
Dana Dunne
executiveNow I'll pass things over to David Elizaga, and he'll walk you through the consolidated results for our company.
David Corrales
executiveThanks, Dana, and good afternoon to all of you. Would everyone mind turning to Slide 15 in the presentation? I'll walk you through the financial results in greater detail. Obviously, the pandemic hit hard in Q4 of last year, and that impact has carried over into the first 6 months of this year. But let's lay out how the finances performed in the second quarter of our fiscal '21. Turning to the income statement. For the second quarter of fiscal '21, as shown on Slide 15, revenue margin fell by 75%. The reason was a 62% drop in bookings combined with a lower revenue margin per booking. That came from a lower average basket value of bookings because of COVID-19. On average, customers are booking with fewer passengers per trip and choosing destinations nearer to where they live. Consequently, the revenue we receive from providers is smaller, and the classic revenue we receive from customers is lower as well. Once travel patterns return to normal, we expect revenue margin per booking to rise from where it stands now. On the cost side, variable costs were down by 75%, reflecting how adaptable our business model is to the new mix of bookings customers made during COVID-19.
David Corrales
executiveTo reiterate, once travel behavior goes back to what it was before, we anticipate that variable cost per booking will rise above where it stands now. Those dynamics gave us marginal profit that was positive at EUR 11.5 million. Marginal profit, once more, equals revenue margin less every variable cost. That EUR 11.5 million represents 10x what we saw in the first quarter, which boosts the variability and flexibility inherent in our cost structure. Fixed costs fell by 31%, pushed by lower personnel costs from a temporary reduction in employment, along with IT and external fees IT savings. Consequently, adjusted EBITDA for the second quarter came in at a loss of EUR 2.1 million, an improvement of 86% versus the first quarter of this fiscal year. Moving further down the income statement, you'll see that EBITDA came to a loss of EUR 3.6 million. That stemmed mainly from adjusted items consistent with the same period a year earlier. Complete details on the adjusted items are available in a condensed consolidated interim financial statements and in the excel file you can also locate on our website. D&A and impairment rose by 29%, tied to the increase in capitalized software finalized in March '20.
David Corrales
executiveThe overall financial loss we recorded went down 10%, largely because of foreign exchange differences, though that was partly offset by higher interest expense tied to our revolver usage and the new government-sponsored loan due 2023. Income tax expense comes to EUR 1.3 million for the second quarter, versus an expense of EUR 3.3 million in last year's second quarter, driven mainly by lower taxable profits relative to the comparable period, the write-off of certain deferred tax assets linked to U.K. tax loss carryforwards, no movement in the provision for income tax rates, and no recognition of a deferred tax asset for part of the second quarter of '21 tax losses. Lastly, adjusted net income was a loss of EUR 19.3 million. In our view, adjusted net income is a better reflection of the business's true ongoing operational performance. You can find full disclosure of adjusted net income in Section 7 of the condensed consolidated interim financial statement tenders. Moving now to Slide 16. I'll walk you through the cash flow statement. In the second quarter of the fiscal year, despite tougher government restrictions and faster reimbursement to customers, by EUR 40 million versus the inflows received from airlines, partly cushioned by higher volumes in September versus June, this produced a working capital outflow of EUR 1.8 million in the second quarter of fiscal '21.
David Corrales
executiveOur balance sheet remains solid, with a liquidity position of EUR 115 million as of the end of September. That figure includes the EUR 40 million acceleration of investment to customers versus the inflows received from airlines, EUR 106 million undrawn from our super senior revolving credit facility, and the EUR 15 million new government-sponsored loan to finance the decrease of negative working capital — putting us in a position of strength as soon as normal activity resumes. Cash net of overdrafts stood at EUR 0.5 million at the close of September. Cash performance in the second quarter of fiscal '21 was driven by net cash from operating activities, which improved by EUR 12 million, mainly reflecting the working capital outflow just described. And income tax paid increased by EUR 4.2 million, from EUR 0.9 million to EUR 5.1 million, mainly due to the fact that there were no income tax payments on taxable profits, but we had an advanced payment in respect of an administrative procedure against the Portuguese tax authorities. There was no income tax payment and taxable profits. Adjusted EBITDA decreased by EUR 31.2 million following the decrease of bookings, and we experienced an outflow in noncash items of EUR 3.3 million, when last year, we had an outflow of EUR 2.7 million.
David Corrales
executiveWhat’s really driving this quarter is that the costs tied to COVID-19 flight cancellations were provisioned back in fiscal ’20 year-end, but the cash outflow from that provision actually occurred over the last 2 quarters. We’ve reduced cash used for investments by EUR 2.5 billion, bringing it from EUR 6.9 to EUR 4.4, thanks to cost-saving measures we implemented to minimize COVID-19’s temporary impact. Cash used in financing rose by EUR 40.3 million, going from EUR 12.9 million to EUR 53.2 million, primarily because of the EUR 54.5 million revolver repayment, which was partly offset by drawing down the new EUR 15 million government-sponsored loan. At this point I’ll hand the presentation back to Dana for the closing remarks.
Dana Dunne
executiveThank you, David. Moving to Slide 18. Let me wrap up with a brief summary of where we stand overall. We think we're setting ourselves up for genuine success in a post-COVID-19 world. Our financial strength, the flexibility of our business model — with the vast majority of costs being variable — and the mitigating steps taken during the pandemic let us come out of this crisis strongly and in a good position. At the end of October, our liquidity stood at EUR 117 million, including accelerated reimbursements to customers, which could be drawn on if needed when demand slows. The gross leverage ratio waiver for fiscal year 2021 provides additional financial flexibility. We have no short-term financial debt payments, and our senior notes, new government-sponsored loan, and bank facilities aren't due until 2023. The Prime subscription program keeps growing even in this weak market under extraordinary conditions. Since the end of June, we've added 100,000 new subscribers, and the share of total bookings reached 26%. That's 4x more than the share in the same period last year. We've kept our teams impacted and motivated to compete vigorously and serve our customers well. We are a leader in mobile, product quality and revenue diversification.
Dana Dunne
executiveWe’re genuinely a pioneer when it comes to subscriptions, the customer proposition, and the experience. And we concentrate solely on the leisure travel consumer, in markets that have demonstrated a solid capacity to bounce back quickly once travel restrictions begin to loosen — which, after the news about Pfizer, BioNTech, and AstraZeneca’s vaccine as well, we’re hoping will arrive in the not too distant future. So we think the future looks bright for us. We’ll come out of these unprecedented times as a winner. With that said, I’d like to turn now to your questions. We’ll respond to the questions submitted to us in writing through the webcast. Questions will be taken on a first come first serve basis, though we’ll also try to group together questions that are similar in nature. If we don’t have enough time to answer every question from the webcast, the Investor Relations team will ensure they get answered afterward.
David de la Roz
executiveThank you, Dana. I'll begin by reading the questions that come in to us via the webcast. The first batch, since there are 3 of them, is from Chadd Garcia at Shwartz Investment. The first question asks whether liquidity from ex customer reimbursements would be EUR 157 million versus EUR 167 million at July. Yes, that's correct. Those are the figures, and it will also compare with EUR 132 million in June and EUR 144 million in March. So once you adjust for the acceleration in customer refunds, liquidity would stand at EUR 157 million, which would be above June at 152 and March at EUR 144 million. In the second part of this, the investor asks whether you can provide year-on-year revenue changes by month for the quarter. Unfortunately we cannot provide that. But if I guess what this question is getting at, I would say that if modeling liquidity is what interests you, bookings are a much better proxy for liquidity movements than revenues are, because revenues move from month to month depending on provisions or adjustments to prior provisions, and so they are not as good a predictor of cash movement as bookings are.
David de la Roz
executiveAnd the third piece of this — the investor asks whether we have any thoughts on that jump in mobile bookings as a percent of total bookings?
Dana Dunne
executiveI'll take that one, David. First, just some context — and it comes in 2 parts. Part one: mobile has always been our priority. That isn't true of every company, but from the very beginning we've said we want to build for mobile first and foremost, and then for other platforms. Many other companies actually do the exact opposite. So over time, you've seen us deliver genuinely meaningful gains on mobile. It ebbs and flows quarter to quarter, and it really hinges on how many of our ideas are much more specific to mobile-only versus translating between mobile and a desktop device, so to speak. That's why you do find some variability in the continuous increases of ours. Lately, more of our releases have been more focused really on mobile-based solutions, coupled with the fact that, I think, in the COVID-19 situation, more people are reaching for mobile, and more of these types of customers feel comfortable on a mobile device when doing bookings on a mobile device in these types of market conditions. I still believe, for the future, overall, it's going mobile, no matter what — you can't go around that.
Dana Dunne
executiveWhether that kind of pickup will unfold the way it did last quarter remains to be seen. David?
David Corrales
executiveAlright. I’ll take the next question, and it comes from Tom Gibney at BNP Paribas. First part: if bookings held at today’s levels through the remainder of the quarter, what working capital outflow would you expect in Q3? That’s not an easy one to answer. Let me assume that by current levels you mean the present year-on-year performance, correct? And there’s a seasonal pattern where, normally—and assuming no late-December surge in bookings for Christmas—November and December are seasonally weaker than September and October. So if year-on-year performance stays the same, the absolute number of bookings would actually decline. Our rule of thumb—and we’ve mentioned this before—is that roughly a 10% year-on-year gap translates to about EUR 20 million of outflow or inflow, depending on which way it goes. I think we’d be under 10 points, so likely a range of about 15 points. But as I said, there are plenty of moving pieces in the cash as well. What happens with airline refunds, and how much do we accelerate—or not—relative to customers.
David Corrales
executiveI'd say this is a pretty directional response, honestly. The second question from this investor asks why we've brought cash down to such a low level. The reason is that roughly 1/3 of our revolver credit facility comes with ancillary overdraft facilities. So we're able to draw down right away from the current accounts and overdrop from them. And we're working hard to be really, really optimized on every single cost in the company, interest cost included. By doing this, we end up paying less interest on the debt we're using. And the third part here asks whether you have a sense of how our share of the overall OTA flight bookings market moved during the stronger booking period in July. I think Dana is probably better positioned to answer this one.
Dana Dunne
executiveYeah, there are 2 points there. The first is simply regarding the data. There isn't, shall we say, a market statistic that's easily verifiable which we could cite for this measure. Still, we put substantial resources into our own proprietary information so that we can form an assessment of what it is. And it does appear that we've been gaining market share through the summer months and, in fact, even carrying on into the OTA — every indicator we look at, at least, is clearly favorable for us. Absolutely. I do want to add one qualification. We aren't focused on — I mean, 100% of our energy isn't aimed at winning in the current market, right? The current market at minus 73%, minus 60% isn't the real market. The real game is next summer, right? The vaccine is coming out, people are coming back to travel. And we want to make certain that we're the company of choice for that market. And that's why so much of our teams are focused far more on long-term propositions, on making certain, for instance, on Prime, right? And making certain that Prime is really great. Now we've seen how — the potential of it, but we have a lot more to come and a lot more to do on Prime still from it.
Dana Dunne
executiveSo that's the main thing we're zeroed in on. On the customer service side, you can see how we're putting the customer first and making sure we maintain a solid rapport with them and strong brands for the moment travel genuinely rebounds too. We've also got a customer automation initiative going. The third area, then, centers on our connectivity. Again, that's not really a near-term payoff — I mean current trading or summer trading right now — but it is definitely a longer-term return for us. So hopefully that gives you a sense that we're not only gaining share in the near term, but we're really concentrating more on coming out ahead as the market goes back to something far more normalized. David?
David Corrales
executiveYes. Thanks, Dana. I'll move on to the next question now. Lenice Inkosky from Eaton Bank is up next. Dana said acquisition cost per booking is going to come back to more normalized levels after COVID. What would you view as a more normalized level, and which global travel recovery targets would you use to judge when to turn marketing spend back on? This question has 2 parts. First, what counts as more normalized levels post COVID. The more normalized level would be the pre-COVID level. So you need to look at our third fiscal quarter of fiscal '20 or the fourth fiscal quarter of fiscal '20, though that one already had roughly 6 weeks of COVID impact. So the third quarter is probably the better indicator. And I would take that level. And over time, that level should come down somewhat, because as the share of our bookings coming from Prime members rises, and since Prime members tend to repeat through cheap acquisition channels, they will have a positive effect on lowering the acquisition cost per booking for the company in aggregate. And the second part of the question asks which global recovery targets you would look at -- we would look at when judging when to restart marketing spend?
David Corrales
executiveThe way this platform operates is actually more automatic than that. It's not as if we're going to issue an executive order from the boardroom saying, "Now it's time to restart the marketing spend because we see that the economy is doing X, Y or Z." Each search we get has its revenue probability assessed automatically by our platform. And on that basis, it automatically determines how much to pay for performance marketing. So that's something which happens automatically within the platform. That's one of the reasons it is so flexible on the way down as well, because machines are doing it automatically. I look now at the next question, which comes from Martin de la Concha of H.I.G Capital. It says revenue in the third -- well, it mentions the revenue for the last 4 quarters. And that in the fourth quarter of fiscal '20, we saw EUR 100 million unwind of working capital. Why did working capital not unwind even further in the following quarters as revenue decreased? How is it possible that negative working capital buildup in the first quarter when revenues have decreased to EUR 16.6 million? Well, I think here I'm going to quote myself a little bit earlier today in that revenues are not a good indicator for the evolution of the working capital.
David Corrales
executiveBookings give us a meaningful signal of how working capital is moving. You'll recall that during the final 6 weeks of fiscal '20 — that's 2 weeks of February plus 4 weeks of March — the number of bookings fell very sharply. On average, we pay our airline, which is a principal provider for working capital inflows, on a 2-week period. That means that when bookings decline, the unwinding of working capital occurred just 2 weeks later. So it was already in the month of March that we took the biggest hit to our working capital. After that, as bookings began to improve, even though revenue year-on-year for that particular period showed a big drop. As long as bookings exceed those of the prior period, you will receive an inflow of working capital, and the reverse holds too. So that's how you should view our working capital movements. The next question comes from Jonathan Morgan of CQS Management. And it says, what are you seeing so far in November as European lockdown restrictions have become effective?
Dana Dunne
executiveDavid, I’ll handle that one. Broadly speaking, the market has mostly settled down. In November, our average is roughly 73%. There’s a lot of variability in it today, and that’s normal, even without COVID, so to speak. So it’s much more important to look at it on, say, an overall basis, say, over a week or several weeks. It really has stabilized on that. We don’t see any deterioration at least right now where we are in November. Again, I can’t predict the future from a short-term point of view about it. But overall, it seems to have been roughly stable. David, anything you’d like to add on it?
David Corrales
executiveNo, I believe that covers everything. So let me move on to the next investor question, which comes from Pierre Merveille at ODDO BHF. The question asks whether accelerated reimbursements create high credit risk, given the financial condition of airlines. The answer is no, since we only carry out the acceleration once we are already certain the airlines will in fact refund us. To sum up the process broadly, we handle the refund together with the airline, and at a certain point, through the various information systems, airline by airline, there comes a moment when they approve a particular refund for an individual booking. We get that signal, but the actual cash arrives 2 to 3 weeks later, depending on the cash transfer methodology. So the acceleration applies to refunds already approved but where the cash has not yet reached us, and as a result, we bear no credit risk. The next analyst asking questions is Carlos Trevino from Santander, and he has several. So I'll take them one at a time. He asks: could you elaborate on how your liquidity position evolved in August and September?
David Corrales
executiveIt went from EUR 167 million in July down to EUR 115 million in September. Even if I factor in EUR 40 million of reimbursements to customers, I still would have thought working capital would contribute positively across those months, given the bookings recovery — minus 59% year-on-year in August, minus 63% in September, against minus 63% in July. Okay. Let me address that. During August, working capital definitely saw an inflow, since bookings came in above July's level. In September, though, working capital showed an outflow, as bookings fell below August's level. So you get one movement in one direction and another movement in the opposite direction. That said, other items were also at play across those periods. There's the EUR 40 million outflow, which occurred mainly in August and September. And as you noted, that really bridges EUR 115 million to EUR 155 million. But for example, interest payments and bond payments are made half yearly, and that took place in August to the tune of EUR 12.9 million. You also saw outflows during the quarter tied to items we had provisioned in the books in our March financial statements.
David Corrales
executiveWhen we set aside provisions for GDS incentives, returns, and other kinds of provider revenue, those provisions were booked in March, yet the actual cash outflow landed partly in Q1 and partly in Q2. So there are quite a few moving parts here — not to make the question sound overly — sorry, make the answer overly costly. I'd be glad to walk you through more specifics in a one-on-one meeting afterward. The next piece of your questions asks whether I can explain in greater detail what drove the sharp year-on-year decline in variable costs per booking, particularly given that acquisition cost per booking rose slightly quarter over quarter, to EUR 52 from EUR 48 in the prior quarter. Okay. On that point, just as a reminder for everyone, variable costs contain several components. There's the acquisition cost, which is the Tier 1, but you also have call center costs, merchant costs, and other variable IT costs per booking. So it's really the remaining elements of variable costs that did considerably better in the second quarter compared with the first quarter.
David Corrales
executiveThere are a few factors behind this. First, the call center expense is variable — it varies across a longer stretch of time, since it reflects how many or how few positions you staff in the call center. Given the booking volume in the second quarter, which came in at roughly 3x the first-quarter booking level, we aren't raising call center costs, yet on a per booking basis the cost is significantly lower. As for merchant cost, that cost represents a proportion of the actual euro amount of the bookings. We mentioned earlier on this call and in our presentation that we've observed a different booking mix, where customers book fewer passengers per trip, and customers are booking destinations nearer to their homes. That produces a lower euro amount of the basket. When the basket's euro amount is lower, merchant cost per booking is lower as well. And on the variable costs of IT, I'd say we're doing a very good job, and bringing them down even further. And within those variable costs, particularly in a year-on-year comparison, you have a situation where certain revenues weren't collected — for example, as you know, we discontinued service of cancellation for any reason in January.
David Corrales
executiveIn the year-over-year comparison, that revenue isn't there, but neither is the provision for canceled bookings that we used to collect. Let me turn to the remaining questions from that same analyst. Can you say more about what you're planning in order to raise the quality of your content? Dana, I believe this is a...
Dana Dunne
executiveYes, David. Absolutely, David, glad to take that question. I’ll split my answer into 2 parts, 2 categories of content. The first category is air content. We’re putting investment into securing air content from a wider range of source types. As you can imagine, many different types of sources exist. So we’re able to obtain content from additional GDSs as well as pseudo GDSs. That simply calls for a set of developments on our side so we can bring that content in, followed by optimization work on it and establishing particular kinds of rules so that we extract it in the best way possible. It also lets us weigh one content source against another to determine which one suits us best. So those are several of the things we’re investing in on that front. Obviously, we can also connect directly with certain airlines — 100% — and we have the resources and the scale to make that happen. So those are some things we are in fact looking at doing. Once we believe conditions are right for us, we would look at doing that. If they aren’t, then we go through other sources instead.
Dana Dunne
executiveThe next piece would be the non-air content categories that we're putting money into as well. As you're aware, we work directly with hotels, for instance, and we have proprietary content that we've brought in from hotels, and we keep growing that segment, especially in this market. There are additional content categories too. Past that, you can picture trains or other kinds of lines that we're beginning to bring into our platform too. And that gives both our customers and our shareholders added optionality regarding our business as we move ahead in the future. David?
David Corrales
executiveYes. We still have a few more questions from Carlos. Does this mean you could add more NDC direct connections with airlines beyond the ones you currently have with American Airlines and Lufthansa?
Dana Dunne
executiveSure. As I said when answering the earlier question, that's something I attempted to cover, but the point is that we'd be able to. Once more, provided the circumstances line up and we see a solid win-win situation, then we would do so, without question. That said, there are numerous routes and numerous methods for obtaining content.
David Corrales
executiveNext, the final item — Carlos, you noted that certain deferred tax assets in the U.K. were written off during the quarter. Do you see any risk of additional write-ups on your assets — on your tax assets? The simple response is no. Our next question is from Juan Peña at GVC Gaesco. I realize there isn't much time to analyze this, but I'd like to know whether you're seeing any meaningful rise in bookings following the announcement first from Pfizer and afterward from Moderna, given the strong results in the vaccine studies. Could you share any figures on that? I believe Dana already responded to this when he discussed the training in November, so I'll just point back to that answer. The following questions come from Nizla Naizer at Deutsche Bank. The first part is about accelerated reimbursement — how confident are you that suppliers will reimburse you? Well, I think I've already addressed this question from another investor. Have you increased marketing for Prime? Are you providing any new options to help drive the acceleration we're seeing in subscriber numbers? Have you lowered the subscription price?
David Corrales
executiveDana is going to handle this question.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, David. At the moment, we're not really putting money into marketing. And I think that shows up as well in something like our acquisition cost index, where you can see just how dramatically it has dropped. So yes, I can confirm we truly aren't spending on marketing. What's going on, I think, comes down to a couple of things. The first is that Prime is doing very well indeed. And especially right now, with these difficult COVID market conditions, we're seeing really strong relevance between customers and our proposition. For one, the prices in Prime are excellent. So if you think about it, people are under economic strain and will be for some time. And Prime delivers simply incredible prices. And I don't mean only on air — hotels too, now. We've launched hotels. So when you consider your whole trip, right, traveling to some destination, Prime gives people fantastic savings. The second thing is that given the uncertainty in the airline industry and with COVID-19, and people wanting to cancel, the majority of our bookings and offers are flexible, right? So they come with some form of flexibility to change. And customers, depending on how they wish to reach us — for Prime customers we provide dedicated customer service just for them, so that, in a sense, they go straight to the front of the queue and have a special Prime team.
Dana Dunne
executiveTheir response time is incredibly fast, so when you combine pricing, flexibility, and service—all 3 together—customers genuinely really like it. We observe that in our survey findings, which I attempted to mention briefly in the text of my presentation. The survey results are truly very strong when it comes to customer satisfaction. So that, I believe, is what it really comes down to far more than anything else, and we have not been doing marketing. In the future, as the market comes back and gets going, it absolutely does enable us to do much more on the marketing side down the road. David?
David Corrales
executiveYes. Then Nizla's final 2 questions are: the first concerns the reduction in variable costs — what specific steps have you taken to bring that down? I believe I've already answered that one. How much of that decline will carry on into next year? Will parts of it come back? As I said before, starting with acquisition costs, as revenues grow, I'd expect acquisition cost to grow too. And with things like merchant cost, once the average basket value goes back to normal levels, I'd expect those costs to rise as well. Have you needed to restructure your workforce? The answer is no. We're adopting certain measures, as regulators permit, to cut working hours and pay for our employees. Right now, it is — employees are losing just 10% of their salary, but nobody has been restructured. Which markets were the most...
Dana Dunne
executiveAnd sorry, David. To clarify — it isn't all employees. A large share of our workforce is at 100%. So only a portion of employees, in fact. And I think this decision was made to ensure a couple of things. First, trying to find a win-win — meaning, from our customers' perspective, having people really concentrate on making sure we serve our customers properly. So we've shifted many people around to make sure we're on customer-related items. The second is also making certain we're building for the future as well. And for when the market really comes back, doing this in a way that aligns right with our values inside the company. And we have a highly motivated we-do culture within the company. David?
David Corrales
executiveYes. The final item from Nizla was about which markets showed the most resilience in Q2. And the response is that during the second quarter, the 2 markets that beat the average of the remaining markets were France and Italy. The following question comes once more from Tom Gibney at BNP Paribas. Will the EUR 40 million acceleration of customer refunds effectively reverse, given that refunds have fully worked through and airlines are passing the cash for these on to you? Well, in fact, what we are observing in the market is that the pattern of cancellations that creates the need for a refund has carried on past the first wave. March and April brought a large chunk of cancellations, when virtually almost 100% of flights were canceled. But from that point onward, the airlines have kept up a pattern of scheduling more flights than they actually end up flying. So cancellations continue to arrive. And therefore, we will need to, let's say, serve our customers properly as this pattern continues. The next question comes from Raul Al Feta, a private investor. Given low levels of cash and equivalents, are you considering drawing from your credit facilities?
David Corrales
executiveAnd if that's the case, what would the amount be? I'd describe this as an extremely, extremely fluid situation. And we draw and enroll this — as the term suggests, it's a revolver-recurring facility. So we pull money and pay money back very frequently. So multiple times within the month, in line with the cycles of inflows and outflows. When do you think you'll get back to normal activity levels? Well, I believe the response to that hinges on how the pandemic evolves and on the restrictions placed on people's movement and travel. So I really can't give you a precise answer. We have a set of scenarios, and we track the situation continuously and manage in line with those. The next question comes from Fredrik Sundberg of Tresidor. Please, could you clarify your statement, no-action stress test suggests we can run business at minus 70% through end of calendar '21. What does this mean from a cash flow perspective? Well, what it means from a cash flow perspective, is that the way we run the stress test is that we take no further management action versus what we are doing right now. So the only thing that we input into the model is that level of continuous decline of 70% on a month-by-month basis versus those same months before the pandemic.
David Corrales
executiveSo in 2019. So we aren't cutting any more fixed costs. We aren't reducing CapEx any further, and so on and so forth. That's what no action means. Will you be cash flow neutral, including working capital interest at these levels? Well, the thing about the -- if you're continuously at 70%, there's not much working capital movement. There is a bit according to the seasonality of the different months, but there's no working capital movement. Now just to remind everyone, if you're at 70% and you come from 80%, there is a working capital inflow. If you are at 70%, but you come from 60%, there's a working capital outflow. So actually, it's not a linear answer that we can give to this. It's, unfortunately, a much more complicated model to run. And there is another question from Andre Klotz of Jefferies. Can you please explain the EUR 40 million reimbursement? And how confident you are in airlines paying you back this? I think yes, we've answered this actually twice already. So therefore, we currently have no other questions. And I think that we are going to then finish the conference call for today. Thank you very much for attending and for your -- all of your questions.
David Corrales
executiveBefore we wrap up, we want to let you know that our conference call for the third quarter of fiscal '21 is scheduled for Thursday, 25th of February. Until then, we'd be glad to take any questions you have. You can reach our Investor Relations team, or use the investor e-mail address, which is investors@edreamsodigeo.com. Thank you very much.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete eDreams ODIGEO S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to eDreams ODIGEO S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in eDreams ODIGEO S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.