eDreams ODIGEO S.A. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 25, 2021

Bolsa de Madrid ES Consumer Discretionary Hotels, Restaurants and Leisure earnings 82 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen <<inaudible>> results presentation. I'm Daisy, and I'll be operating this call. At this point I'll turn things over to your host, David de la Roz of eDreams, to get us started. David, the floor is yours.

David de la Roz

executive
#2

Thanks. Good afternoon, everybody. We appreciate all of you being here for the presentation of our Q3 fiscal year 2021 results, covering the 3 months that ended on 31st of December 2020. I'm David de la Roz, Director of Investor Relations at eDreams ODIGEO. You can, as usual, locate the materials for these results — the presentation as well as our results report — in the investor relations area of our website. I'll now hand things over to Dana Dunne, our CEO, who will walk you through the first portion of the presentation. Thank you.

Dana Dunne

executive
#3

Thanks, David, and good afternoon, everyone — appreciate you joining us. In today's remarks, I'll walk you through an overview of our Q3 FY 2021 results along with how trading is currently shaping up. After that, David Elízaga, our CFO, will take you through our financial performance in greater detail. Then I'll wrap up with some closing remarks. If you'd please turn to slide four, that slide summarizes how we performed in Q3 FY 2021. Throughout Q3, travel restrictions kept weighing on our short-term trading. Even so, we're glad to report solid liquidity and better strategic positioning. As you'll see later on, our trading beat the airline industry — both regular and low-cost carriers — as well as most of our OTA peers. Market share gains have kept coming. Our revenue margin for the third quarter of FY 2021 fell 77% year-on-year, landing at EUR 30 million. The drivers were travel restrictions and uncertainty stemming from the COVID-19 situation, which brought bookings down 65%. Revenue margin per booking declined because the average basket value of bookings was lower owing to the COVID-19 situation — that is, customers flying shorter distances, fewer passengers, et cetera. Marginal profit, meaning revenue margin minus variable costs, came in at a positive EUR 6 million for third quarter FY 2021, even with us putting short-term investment into higher call center costs to support our customers amid flight cancellations and uncertainties.

Dana Dunne

executive
#4

Adjusted EBITDA came in as a loss of EUR 10.4 million. Now on liquidity: our liquidity has stayed strong even with the near-term trading difficulties. What drives that is how variable our cost base is, solid cost control, and the distinctive nature of our business model. On top of that, our average monthly cash burn went down — that's excluding working capital and tax, while adding the rise in Prime deferred revenue from EUR 13 million to EUR 7 million. We saw working capital inflows thanks to higher volumes and gross sales, improved cash collection from suppliers, and refunds that we collected. And finally, we got a benefit from lower income taxes paid. All of this produced positive cash flows and strong liquidity. To be specific, net cash from operating activities came in EUR 31.4 million better. We closed the quarter on a positive note with cash flow before financing of EUR 13 million. That is the first time we have hit this mark since the fourth quarter of FY 2019. It's remarkable, particularly given a weak market in which revenues fell 77%. Our liquidity position has been handled well. It stood at EUR 125 million in December and has held steady since September 2020, even with the short-term softening in trading. As we pointed out in our July, our August, and our November results presentations, we are taking advantage of this COVID-19 period to strengthen our strategic positioning.

Dana Dunne

executive
#5

You can see this through Prime, our pioneering travel subscription program, which keeps standing out even in these difficult times, and subscriptions keep rising. As an example, during the third quarter of FY 2021, Prime members hit 758,000. That represents a 55% rise compared with the same period a year earlier. Prime is showing itself to be a successful and appealing offer for customers. Even in this market that resembles the COVID period, we added 94,000 new subscribers in just one quarter. Prime's share of our total bookings keeps growing and hit 37% in the third quarter of FY 2021, against 9% a year earlier. One more thing worth flagging, since we don't think the market knows about it, is that Prime deferred revenue has hit EUR 20 million. That's a 126% rise compared with the third quarter of FY 2020. This revenue consists of Prime subscription fees that are not yet recognized in revenue until the Prime customer makes another booking or the renewal date arrives. Although revenue margin per booking is affected in the short term, had we included this revenue, revenue margin would have come in above what we are reporting now. I'm very glad to share that on Prime, despite everything that has happened, we are fully on track to surpass 2 million subscribers by 2023.

Dana Dunne

executive
#6

Next, on strategic positioning: we keep beating the market — our third quarter FY 2021 bookings came in at -65%, which is still better than the overall European market at -79%. As for current trading, the near-term picture is mostly beyond our control and is being shaped by travel restrictions stemming from COVID-19. January and February are tracking at -76% to -73% bookings growth year-on-year. Given the uncertainty surrounding COVID-19 and travel restrictions, we are still not providing any guidance for this financial year. I'll walk through the points I just raised in greater detail on the upcoming slides. Please turn to slide five, where we address our diversification revenue KPIs. On the whole, diversification revenue keeps getting better and is now the biggest contributor to our revenues. Both the product diversification ratio and the revenue diversification ratio have improved. The product diversification ratio rose from 82% to 89% — a 7 percentage point gain in one year. Likewise, the revenue diversification ratio climbed from 51% to 55% in the third quarter FY 2021. That's a 4 percentage point improvement, once again, in a single year. Please turn to slide six, which shows the progress we've made on three other KPIs.

Dana Dunne

executive
#7

We keep setting the pace for the travel sector when it comes to mobile innovation, and once more we have distinguished ourselves on mobile, which is a good sign for what lies ahead. Over the past 5 years, bookings made via mobile have climbed exponentially, going from 18% of our total bookings to 58%. Mobile has consistently been a leading priority for us and a key area of focus. The move to online, and particularly to mobile, sped up by the pandemic, puts us in a very strong position to capitalize on demand in the future. Let's turn now to the shifts in the acquisition cost per booking index, which showed a year-on-year improvement of 45 percentage points. That reflects how adaptable and flexible our business is. Still, I want to be clear that such a very low level cannot be sustained over the long term. As travel restrictions loosen, we anticipate higher spending on online marketing, and so this ratio will move back toward more normalized levels. Finally, on KPIs, I am pleased to discuss with you how well Prime has done as a customer proposition. Prime is delivering strong results in this weak market. As we have said, our aim is to transform the travel industry and how consumers interact. We want to build unique relationships with consumers that, again, transform how people think about travel and about travel providers.

Dana Dunne

executive
#8

Prime stands as a solid illustration of how we deliver that and keep pushing innovation in travel. Prime has been doing well even through the pandemic. Subscriber numbers have kept climbing, up 94,000 over three months — that is, between Q2 and Q3 of FY 2021. On the right side of the chart you can see the Prime subscription rate and Prime's share continuing to rise. To be specific, Prime members in Q3 FY 2021 were up 55% compared with the same period a year earlier, climbing from 490,000 in Q3 FY 2020 to 758,000 in FY 2021. Prime's portion of our total bookings quadrupled, going from 9% in Q3 FY 2020 to 37% in Q3 FY 2021. We also brought Prime to new markets — the U.K., the U.S., and .com — in November. New products came too, with hotels launched across all our Prime markets, including France, Italy, Spain, Germany, U.K., U.S., and .com. If you could now go to slide eight, I'll walk you through current trading. Current trading indicates the near-term outlook is being affected by travel restrictions. Even so, we keep outperforming the market. Current trading has been shaped by the wave of travel restrictions put in place because of a rise in COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations across autumn into winter.

Dana Dunne

executive
#9

Once the first lockdowns from last spring ended and restrictions came off, consumers returned to the market fast, and nearly 50% of our bookings came back inside two months. At present, the newest round of restrictions is holding our bookings at minus 70% in the low range. Set against the market, our trading pointed to outperformance relative to the airline industry, covering both regular and low-cost carriers. That means we are taking market share from supplier direct thanks to superior quality, fuller content, flexibility, and a customer focus, along with distinctive innovative products and solutions, and naturally, an emphasis on leisure travel. Kindly turn to slide nine. We are glad to keep reporting solid liquidity, which follows from our robust business model and the active way we have managed the situation. We got there even as travel restrictions grew, which lowered the amount of trade. That left us with a liquidity position of EUR 125 million at the end of December and EUR 122 million at the end of January. It has stayed steady at that level since September 2020, even with the short-term softening in trading. We reached this through three sources. The first is working capital inflows, arising from greater volumes in gross sales, improved collection from suppliers, refunds gathered, and increases in Prime deferred revenue.

Dana Dunne

executive
#10

Second, there were lower income taxes paid. Third came our active handling of the situation, and that produced greater variability across most of our costs, along with cuts to fixed costs and CapEx, plus an extra EUR 15 million in financial resources from a government-sponsored loan maturing in 2023, and a lower average monthly cash burn — excluding working capital and taxes, but including the rise in Prime deferred revenue — which went from EUR 13 million down to EUR 7 million. I'll now pass things over to David Elízaga, who will walk you through our consolidated results.

David Elízaga

executive
#11

Thanks, Dana, and good afternoon to all of you. Please turn with me to slide 11 in the presentation, where I'll walk you through the financial results in greater detail. It's clear that the pandemic hit hard during the final quarter of last year, and that effect has carried over into the first nine months of this fiscal year. Let me lay out how we performed financially in the third quarter of fiscal 2021. On slide 11, if you look at the income statement for the third quarter of fiscal 2021, revenue margin fell by 77%. The reasons were a 65% drop in bookings along with a lower revenue margin per booking, which came from a reduced average basket value of bookings because of COVID-19. On average, customers are booking with fewer passengers per trip and choosing destinations nearer to home. Consequently, the revenue we receive from providers is lower, and the classic and diversification revenue we receive from customers is lower as well. Once travel patterns normalize, we anticipate that revenue margin per booking will rise above where it stands now. Turning to costs, variable costs were down by 70%, reflecting how our business model has adapted to the new mix of bookings customers have made during COVID-19, even with higher short-term call center costs.

David Elízaga

executive
#12

Following what we laid out for the second quarter of fiscal 2021, we put money into raising our contact center capacity by a substantial amount so that we could serve customers better. Our estimate is that we incurred roughly EUR 1.3 million in extra call center cost to support customers, on top of what had already been expensed in the prior quarter, which was the second quarter of fiscal 2021. Once travel patterns return to normal, we again expect the variable cost per booking to rise above where it sits today. Those dynamics left us with a marginal profit that was positive at EUR 6 million. As a reminder, marginal profit means revenue margin less variable cost. Fixed costs fell 22%, helped by lower personal costs as we took advantage of the government HR support programs, along with savings on IT and external fees, and this happened even though the negative foreign exchange impact grew by EUR 1.5 million in the quarter compared with the third quarter of fiscal 2020. Consequently, adjusted EBITDA for the third quarter of fiscal 2021 came in at a loss of EUR 10.4 million. Moving further down the income statement, you will see that the EBITDA loss stood at EUR 12 million. The gap is adjusted items, and those were down EUR 2.2 million against the same period a year earlier.

David Elízaga

executive
#13

You can find all the details on adjusted items in our condensed consolidated interim financial statement as well as in the Excel file. D&A and impairment rose 29%, which is tied to the increase in capitalized software that was finalized in March 2020. Our overall financial loss went up 4%, driven mainly by drawing on the revolving credit facility and by the new government-sponsored loan due 2023. Income tax comes to EUR 3.7 million in the third quarter of fiscal 2021, versus income of EUR 5.9 million in the third quarter of fiscal 2020 — largely reflecting lower tax expenses from group tax losses, for which a deferred tax asset has been recognized, along with the reduction in provision for group tax contingencies. That was offset by higher tax expenses stemming from the absence of a one-off revival of U.S. foreign tax credits in fiscal 2021, an increase of a tax rate applicable to deferred tax liabilities, the write-off of tax attributes in the U.K., and other minor differences. Lastly, adjusted net income came in at a loss of EUR 23.4 million. In our view, adjusted net income is a better reflection of the real ongoing operational performance of the business. Full disclosure of adjusted net income appears in section 7 within the condensed consolidated interim financial statements and notes.

David Elízaga

executive
#14

Moving on to slide 12, I'll walk you through the cash flow statement. During the third quarter of fiscal 2021, even with travel restrictions tightening, net cash generated by operating activities rose by EUR 31.4 million, and we closed the quarter with positive cash flow before financing of EUR 13 million — the first time that has happened since the fourth quarter of fiscal 2019. The main driver is a working capital inflow of EUR 29.9 million in the third quarter of fiscal 2021. Lower income tax paid also helped us. The group's balance sheet remains strong, with a solid liquidity position of EUR 125 million maintained in the third quarter at the end of December, including EUR 107 million undrawn from our super senior revolving credit facility. That puts us in a position of strength once normal trading conditions come back. Cash position net of overdrafts was EUR 18 million at the close of December. Cash performance in the third quarter of fiscal 2021 came from, first, net cash from operating activities improving by EUR 31.4 million. That mostly reflects a working capital inflow of EUR 29.9 million driven by higher volumes in December versus September, worth EUR 10 million, higher gross sales per booking worth EUR 5 million, better collection from suppliers worth EUR 5 million, refunds collected for another EUR 5 million, and the Prime deferred revenue increase for EUR 3 million.

David Elízaga

executive
#15

Income tax paid went down by EUR 7.3 million, from EUR 7.6 million to EUR 0.3 million. The main reasons were lower taxable profits in Spain, no advance payments of Italian income tax in fiscal 2021, the refund of Spanish income tax advance payments, and some other minor differences. Adjusted EBITDA declined by EUR 40 million, reflecting the drop in bookings, along with better non-cash items. Items accrued but not yet paid rose by EUR 3.5 million, mainly because of the variation of provisions. Cash used for investments came to EUR 6.5 million, in line with the same quarter a year earlier. Please note that for fiscal 2021, we estimate finishing at around EUR 21 million, a 30% reduction versus the same period of last year, driven by the implementation of cost-saving measures to minimize the temporary impact of COVID-19. This is ahead of the 25% decrease versus the third quarter of fiscal 2020 in fixed cap costs plus CapEx that we guided the market to in April of last year. If we ran the same scenario today, we would be at minus 28%, with annual cash flow savings of EUR 33 million, which is EUR 5 million ahead of what we guided.

David Elízaga

executive
#16

We spent EUR 1.5 million in cash on financing, which matches the same quarter a year earlier. Before passing things to Dana, I want to highlight once more how Prime affects our financial figures, particularly on the profitability side. As we've noted, cash comes in through the incremental deferred revenues that subscriptions generate when someone subscribes or renews, depending on the situation. Right now, the growth in deferred revenue from Prime sits inside the working capital movement, yet its dynamics differ from the rest of working capital. Our working capital shows an inflow or outflow primarily because bookings rise or fall between one period and the next. By contrast, the deferred revenue increase for Prime represents cash coming in, and that won't blow up. It is simply a question of time before it gets recognized as revenue and profits in the P&L, since no additional cost is tied to that new revenue in the P&L. I'll now hand the presentation back to Dana for the closing remarks.

Dana Dunne

executive
#17

Thanks, David. If you could go to slide 14, I'd like to wrap up with an update on how I view the leisure travel sector, drawing on the recent news about vaccines and so forth. Broadly, I think we are ahead of forecasts where the vaccine is concerned. Before it went into stage 3 trials, forecasts suggested the vaccine's average efficacy would land between 50% and 70%, leaning closer to 50%. The expectation was that a vaccine would likely be rolled out in the second half of 2021, though there were scenarios — quite plausible ones — in which rollout would happen in 2022, and some skeptics doubted whether any vaccine with reasonable efficacy would reach rollout within two to three years. Thankfully, the reality is that we are ahead of schedule. Efficacy of up to 95% has been shown for vaccines, rather than 50%-70%, and they are being rolled out in the first half of 2021, rather than the second half, and definitely not in 2022. Mutations and new variants have emerged, and we will probably see more. The vaccines currently available still offer a good level of protection, and booster shots can be given to guard against new variants. In certain industries, people say COVID sped up online progress by three years in the space of just three months.

Dana Dunne

executive
#18

A big portion of the leisure travel sector has shifted online, or was there already to a significant degree. COVID is accelerating online penetration, particularly in some segments — the older demographic, for instance, which will have grown more comfortable with the internet during lockdowns, using it to stay in touch with family and to buy things online. Plenty of people have discovered an entirely new digital world and gained a completely new confidence when it comes to buying online. For this kind of customer, the largest obstacle is a matter of trust, and that is precisely where recognized brands and market leadership clearly pay off. At eDreams ODIGEO, our brands lead the market. In flights, we hold the number one or number two position across every major European country, and we are number one in Europe with more than 30% market share. Mobile represents the other big digital shift and keeps growing in importance. Consumers feel more at ease making e-commerce purchases on this platform. In mobile, eDreams ODIGEO has led the travel industry — and, in fact, every e-commerce industry in Europe. Nearly 60% of our bookings are now actually completed on a mobile device, and that share will keep rising. My strong belief is that leisure travel has a bright future ahead, and all the evidence points to a rapid rebound.

Dana Dunne

executive
#19

We're a business focused solely on leisure, a leader in our market, and that's why we believe a rebound in online leisure travel will probably come sooner than the first forecasts suggested. Moving to slide 15, I'd like to share what our most recent trading has shown us, which underscores strong pent-up demand for leisure travel and that travelers are eager to come back as soon as it's practical. Following news of approved COVID-19 vaccines, sentiment toward travel among Europeans has gotten better. The European Travel Commission has been tracking sentiment for domestic and intra-European travel. Key points from their latest survey: 52% of respondents plan to travel within the next six months. 52%. Notably, a 20% increase in the share of Europeans willing to take a trip during April to June 2021. The 50% will adjust plans to make sure their trip still happens. In addition, 40% of respondents said they intend to visit another European country, and the intention to travel by air is improving, as 52% of respondents now plan to fly to their next destination, and leisure remains the primary purpose of travel. We see that leisure travelers really do want to return as soon as possible. Our own evolution of searches on long advanced trips also bears this out.

Dana Dunne

executive
#20

So that refers to departures occurring over 90 days after the booking search, correct? And during the last four months, that metric has gotten considerably better — 1.7 times compared with searches made in October 2020. Moving to slide 16, I'd like to wrap up with a brief summary of how we see things overall. We think we're setting ourselves up for genuine success in the world after COVID-19. Our financial strength, the flexibility of our business model, the fact that the vast majority of costs are variable, and the mitigating steps we took throughout the pandemic let us come out of this crisis strong and well-positioned. At the end of January we had a solid liquidity position of EUR 122 million, including no short-term financial debt payments and our secure notes. The new government-sponsored loans and bank facilities all come due in more than 2.5 years from now, which means the second half of 2023. Our Prime subscription program keeps going from strength to strength. Even during the pandemic, we added 94,000 new subscribers in this last quarter, and its share of total bookings is rising quickly. Our business is still financially strong. We remain marginal profit positive, and we've kept our teams intact and motivated so that we can take maximum advantage when restrictions are lifted, as we are building for the future.

Dana Dunne

executive
#21

eDreams ODIGEO is agile and nimble, which lets us adapt fast whenever needed. Product development and innovation remain a point of pride and a source of leadership for us — things like Prime, mobile, customer management, et cetera — and we are driving the transformation of the leisure travel industries and of how consumers interact with providers in this industry. We keep building and offering innovative solutions, we take care of our customers, and we are optimally positioned and ready to seize market growth as travel restrictions are lifted. So we clearly believe our future is bright. We will emerge a winner from these unprecedented times. Thank you. With that, let's turn it over to questions. We will answer the questions sent to us in writing in the webcast. We will take questions on a first-come, first-served basis, we will also try to group questions of similar nature. If we do not have time to respond to all the questions from the webcast, the investor relations team will make sure those are answered afterwards.

David Elízaga

executive
#22

Thanks, Dana. I'll go ahead and take the questions, reading each one and then answering. Our first comes from Lenny Senkovsky at Eaton Vance, who asks, "Could you walk us through a cash flow bridge from the EUR 125 million of cash at December to the EUR 122 million of cash at January? Bookings fell sharply versus the third quarter. Did working capital go out the door during the month?" Appreciate that, Lenny. You're right that, taking the month in total, as you note, January brought in fewer bookings than December did. Still, I'd like to remind you and everyone else that our typical payment window with providers — the airlines, above all — runs roughly two weeks. When it comes to working capital swings, what matters more is comparing, since you brought up month-to-month, the back half of December with the back half of January. Across those two stretches, booking volumes came in quite close, because the December bookings — a solid stretch of new leisure bookings set off by people taking last-minute Christmas trips — landed far more in the first half of December than in the second.

David Elízaga

executive
#23

When you look at bookings, the back half of December resembles the back half of January quite closely. In terms of working capital movement driven by volume, those two time periods you're comparing are actually more or less neutral. Moving from EUR 125 million to EUR 122 million, that reflects our average cash burn, including the Prime deferred revenue, which comes to roughly EUR 7 million. There are probably some other movements in there too, but those are of minor importance, since you can see the delta between one month and the other is only EUR 3 million. The next question comes from Neill Keaney of CreditSights. He asks, "Could you remind us of the covenants on your revolving credit facility and any discussions you've had with your lenders regarding these?" We're privileged to enjoy a very good, strong relationship with our banks, which have been banks of the company for an extended period of time and whose relationship with us extends beyond lending. They also participate on the asset side of the business and help us move the payments, get cash from our customers, and a number of other things. They know the insights of the company really well.

David Elízaga

executive
#24

As you'll probably recall, we talked about this roughly a year back now: when we needed to renegotiate the covenants during spring 2020, the terms we got were actually better than those of nearly every company in our universe. Raising extra liquidity wasn't necessary for us, and we didn't have to take on an alternative covenant or accept any other, so to speak, detriments to our business. What we still have is highly fluid communication with our lenders. Each month there's an exchange covering not just our historical liquidity but our projected liquidity as well, so our banks get very good visibility into what lies ahead. We keep hitting or beating every projection we've provided to our banks, and that builds a tremendous amount of trust. They genuinely understand what's happening within the company and in our trading. That said, we have a single covenant at 6x gross leverage, and it's a springing covenant. What that means is the covenant is only tested when we draw more than EUR 52.5 million of cash under the super senior revolving credit facility. In our results you'll notice that at December, we had EUR 65 million drawn, and we still had EUR 18 million of cash available.

David Elízaga

executive
#25

Back then, had we simply chosen to return EUR 3 million, we would have found ourselves unable to spring. Since that moment, as you'll have noticed, we've maintained solid liquidity. There's no particular urgency in our conversations with the banks at present, and we're confident those discussions will prove highly productive as we move ahead, just as they were previously. Now, onto the next question, sent in by Savan Shah from Oaktree. How should working capital be viewed moving forward? A follow-up question asks, "What share of refunds remains outstanding?" On viewing working capital ahead, if you strip out the rise in Prime deferred revenue — a steady item that we expect will keep bringing inflows in the future, thanks to the success of our Prime program — it's genuinely dictated by how much volume we trade, as you're aware. This will hinge on volume recovering gradually as vaccination rates rise, on one hand, and on how occupied beds are in hospitals and hospital ICUs, which lets governments ease some travel restrictions.

David Elízaga

executive
#26

What we're quite sure about, and we showed this in the presentation as well, is that pent-up demand in the market is extremely high, which is reflected in the growth in the number of travel searches we're seeing. People are simply waiting for travel restrictions to be lifted so they can go ahead and make their bookings. Once that volume arrives, working capital will come in a positive way. You saw that even in the Q3 we reported — the end of that period was better than the end of the period in Q2, when we already had a very good working capital inflow. On your second question, what proportion of refunds remains outstanding? Refunds, unfortunately, are an ongoing dynamic. Because in Europe, airlines have been exempt, and continue to be exempt, from the 80/20 rule on slot usage at airports on the routes. So they keep canceling around 50% of their scheduled flights in Europe on an ongoing basis, which means cancellations stay at a high level. There was a very large level of cancellations — about 95% of flights — back in the first wave of the virus.

David Elízaga

executive
#27

That hasn't gone away since then. It's still happening, just at a reduced level, since the number of scheduled flights is lower — yet even so, 50% of those flights are being canceled. So the refund dynamic is here to stay. Refunds keep coming in from the airlines, and we keep passing those refunds along to our customers. It's a permanent flow, and I'm afraid that until Europe changes that regulation and returns to enforcing the 80/20 rule, this stream of cancellations will keep showing up. The next question is from Wolfgang Felix of Sarria Limited. He asks, "On working capital, could you break out the EUR 140 million of payables? Which components are still elevated relative to your bookings turnover, and for how long? Thank you." The broad distribution of that EUR 140 million of payables is as follows: first of all, you'd have the Prime deferred revenue, which we can't stress enough, for EUR 20 million. That isn't really a payable. I'd describe it much more as a parking slot of cash until it gets recognized as revenues in the P&L. You have around EUR 40 million for the payable to airlines, and that would be for bookings of the last two weeks.

David Elízaga

executive
#28

A portion of those payables relates to marketing, which is our largest cost driver in the P&L. Other trade payables would make up the remainder. Inside that, you've got refunds owed to our customers. That figure would mirror the cash we've already collected from the airlines and are currently reconciling and matching, booking by booking, against the customers who are owed those refunds, after which we go ahead and pay the customers back. That's the piece that, as I said in my answer to the earlier question, represents a permanent flow. Which component is elevated relative to bookings turnover? It's definitely the refunds portion, since everything else moves with the volume levels we carry, while refunds track the volume of cancellations in the market rather than the level of our bookings. Our next question comes from Chadd Garcia at Schwartz Investments. He asks, "Could you talk about why the Prime program keeps growing? And how is the U.K. launch of Prime going?"

Dana Dunne

executive
#29

Absolutely. I'll take that one, David. Hi, Chadd. I believe you've got two questions there. Let me start with the one about Prime in general and the reasons behind its growth. In my view, there are two significant macro-level things we're doing that make growth possible, and I'll go through them from most to least important. The first concerns the customer proposition. We've kept making it better, genuinely over the course of this year. I should mention, by the way, that price changes aren't the driver here, which I think is what someone else is asking about too. When it comes to the customer proposition getting better, I'd split that into two elements as well. The first piece of that improvement is simply about experimenting with how to really get this across to customers, and to have them both grasp the proposition and then, not only once they grasp it, to also get them to come back and do it again. These are just some insights we've kept iterating on, and they do take time, because while other industries have a subscription product, like Netflix for streaming, like Spotify for music, Amazon in consumer goods and delivery. In travel, no one has done this before.

Dana Dunne

executive
#30

We keep conducting experiments and customer interviews, really getting to grips with all those individual — almost what you might call — moments of truth, and how customers actually perceive things. A number of these A/B tests, or experiments, have genuinely given us distinctive insights into this, and into how we position our proposition with customers. That's probably the single biggest driver behind this one. Second — I mentioned there were two parts to the customer proposition improvement — and the second part is that we've given customers more value. If I go back 12 months, when a customer took Prime, they'd receive a truly fantastic proposition for flights, covering both price and non-price elements. During the past year, we've extended Prime to hotels. So now, for the identical subscription fee — that is, with no increase — you still receive the same flights proposition, and on top of that you now receive a hotels proposition too. We've added extra value inside the proposition for customers. That would be the second piece of the first point, about enhancing the customer proposition. I did mention there was a second major bucket, which is essentially expansion into new geographies. Across the past year, and especially during the quarter, we've launched it in a number of new markets, among them the U.K., which was one of your questions.

Dana Dunne

executive
#31

We've also launched in a few additional markets, and that contributed as well. On your second question about Prime in the U.K. — is it going well? The answer is absolutely yes. Customer satisfaction, interest, and take-up of Prime look about the same as in our other markets. Obviously, it's only been several months, whereas in some markets we have several years on it. Still, all the indicators we see suggest this is roughly on par with any of our other core markets or core geographies. David?

David Elízaga

executive
#32

Thanks, Dana. On to the next question, which is from Mounia Chaoui at RLAM. She says, "Hi. Thanks for all the details. Could you please clarify how deferred revenues work for Prime? Is the subscription paid yearly, and how gradually will those deferred revenues be recognized over the coming quarters?" Since several questions are tied together, instead of reading all of them and then answering, I'll read one and respond to it, one at a time. I believe that will be clearer for everyone on the call. Let me take this one first. Take a single customer: you pay — it varies by country — but let's say on average you pay roughly EUR 55 for the subscription. With that subscription, you make a first booking. Okay? With that booking, we will recognize as revenue a portion of the EUR 55, tied to the specific savings you get from being a Prime customer on that particular booking. The rest — let's just pick EUR 20 for the sake of the argument, okay? There was a discount of EUR 20, so we recognize EUR 20 as revenue. You have EUR 35 left. Say you make a second booking a few months later, and you get another EUR 20 in savings.

David Elízaga

executive
#33

Another EUR 20 of subscription revenue will be recognized. Of the original EUR 55, you still have EUR 15 left. Suppose no additional bookings are made over the 12 months. That EUR 15 gets recognized at the close of the 12-month period. Right? Imagine you're that same customer, highly satisfied with your two bookings plus the service level and discounts Prime gave you, and you renew. You pay EUR 65 more. Since that renewal includes no booking on the renewal date, revenue recognition starts at zero. As bookings come in, the same mechanics I described for your first year of membership would apply. That's how it works. From the same investor, a second question: "Could you please give some color on working capital change in January 2021?" That has already been answered. Liquidity is flat even though bookings fell further in January versus December. Could you please give some color on that? I did that as well. Could you also speak to the ongoing customer refunds? Is eDreams still advancing refunds for airlines, and how much in refunds is currently outstanding to be collected from the airlines?

David Elízaga

executive
#34

I believe I partly addressed this already in terms of how the dynamic works and how, unfortunately, this isn't a permanent stock of cancellations — instead, there's a fresh flow of cancellations coming in, and so airlines again need to refund our customers through us. We keep paying out on old cancellations and refunds. We keep receiving new funds from the airlines for cancellations refunds. It's a permanent flow. On the advancing refunds, that refers to the comment we made in the second quarter that during that quarter, we had paid EUR 40 million more than we had received from the airlines during the quarter. You'll have seen in what I said today that in the third quarter, the opposite happened. We refunded EUR 5 million less than we received from the airlines during the third quarter. The next batch of questions comes from the analyst Carlos Treviño from Santander. The first one is — I'm going to take them one by one again, like I did with the previous investor. Could you update us on your booking performance of last days following recent announcement from the U.K.'s government? I don't think we can give a specific numbers because it's not what we do usually.

David Elízaga

executive
#35

What I'd say is that the pattern we're seeing mirrors what happened before: whenever customers gain visibility into what lies ahead or get more freedom to travel, they immediately begin booking. Over the past several days, booking performance has generally improved compared with what we observed in early February, before that news came out. Some countries, like the U.K., have been quite — I'd say — detailed about giving month-by-month visibility into what people will be permitted to do. In that market, we've seen a spike, for example, in reservations for departures more than 100 days out — a booking segment we hadn't witnessed for quite a while, since customers are generally wary of committing that far ahead. That surge has shown up in the U.K., specifically in the over-100-days-to-departure segment. Carlos Treviño now asks, "If you look at your acquisition cost per booking, despite sitting at historically low levels, it has risen over the last two quarters — from EUR 48 in the first quarter, to EUR 52 in the second quarter, and to EUR 55 in the third quarter.

David Elízaga

executive
#36

What's driving that rise? The increase comes from the fact that right at the start of the pandemic, investment levels shifted very sharply across the board, since the revenue we could expect from searchers was extremely low at that moment, and putting money in didn't make economic sense for us. Now we're seeing opportunities where we can put marketing spend to work and get a return on it. Another thing that's happened since Q1 — and you'll have noticed this too — is that Prime is achieving a very high success rate among our customers. As we've often said and explained, an average Prime customer's lifetime value is far greater than that of a customer who isn't on Prime. That also gives us room to put more into marketing, because we know that on a lifetime value basis, we'll recoup more and more of what we invest. Actually, yes. The follow-up — I thought it was a different question, but it follows up on Carlos and applies to the earlier question too, particularly given that bookings from Prime subscribers rose to 37% from 18% during that period, which ought to have a favorable impact on acquisition costs.

David Elízaga

executive
#37

So that beneficial impact does occur. When a Prime subscriber makes their second and later bookings, those come through inexpensive channels — and overwhelmingly, bookings arrive via cheap channels. At the same time, it's accurate that, as I mentioned earlier, we're putting in extra investment since we now have greater visibility into the revenue available to us, and on a lifetime value basis, that investment makes a great deal of sense. The following batch of questions reads, "Could you please spend a bit more time on Prime? Did you do any incremental marketing to drive the product on your website? Have you reduced prices? Has anything else changed? Could you remind us, is a Prime customer profitable on the second booking, or does it take longer to reach breakeven? How do you view what your U.S. competition is doing with a similar subscription product?" It's sort of several questions amalgamated around the topic of Prime, and I think probably Dana is going to take this one.

Dana Dunne

executive
#38

Thanks, David. On the first part of your question regarding Prime, I believe it was about marketing and essentially asking whether we've been putting money into marketing to push the product to our website. The answer is no. Let me clarify what that no means. We haven't spent anything offline to drive people to our sites for Prime. We don't run any visual-based advertising. Visual can be offline, so you can picture a billboard or TV, but likewise, you can picture a YouTube commercial or even a display ad banner. We've done none of that for Prime at all. As you've seen in our P&L, we do put some money into marketing, for instance in search engine marketing, which would be on Google and the like, but none of that is specific to Prime, per se. For that, the answer would be no. We've really concentrated on building a great product for Prime, and we keep really investing our time, effort, and energy on that. Clearly, as the market returns to more normal levels, there's an opportunity for us to potentially put some money, let's say, into more visual-based kinds of advertising.

Dana Dunne

executive
#39

Up to now, we haven't spent any money on that. The second part of your Prime questions concerned prices—whether we'd lowered them or anything else had shifted. I believe I covered most of that in the earlier question Chadd answered. To restate it: our prices have not been reduced. What I think you're getting at is whether we actually cut prices below the market, below our competitors on our Prime product, and versus what we were doing, say, six months or a year back—and whether that could therefore have driven more bookings. The answer to that is absolutely, 100% no. That's not it at all. Nothing. Zero. Now, let me be very clear on prices. Market prices fluctuate constantly. While a ticket, say, from London to Barcelona might have cost, say, EUR 400 at one point, and perhaps prices fell, in an absurd example, to EUR 100, obviously we track the market, correct? We would be tracking the market, and that's our machines, since our pricing isn't set by people but by machines and our AI, in terms of really driving and ensuring our prices stay competitive.

Dana Dunne

executive
#40

Nothing has been added on our side with the specific aim of undercutting the prices we charged previously, or of drawing in additional customers and boosting pick-up. Every factor behind what we're seeing in, say, our subscription take-up was covered in the response I gave to Chadd's question on that topic. The follow-up part of that question concerned whether Prime is profitable by the second booking, or whether breakeven takes longer to reach. Our pricing of Prime is not set so that we lose money on it, whether that's the first booking or the 21st. We generate profit on all of it. Let's see what else you raised here. What's your read on how U.S. competitors are approaching a comparable subscription offering? Let me offer a few points. To begin with, we've spent a number of years developing Prime, and we've conducted a solid—let's say at minimum 50,000, possibly more—one-on-one customer interviews. That isn't a single survey mailed to 50,000 people. These are genuinely detailed interviews with customers individually, and not at just one moment in time; in fact, we keep gathering customer insights and carrying out customer research on this each month.

Dana Dunne

executive
#41

Those give us distinctive insights that genuinely help us develop the product in that space. We do testing and A/B testing, and across Prime we have conducted thousands of A/B tests, all aimed at truly grasping customer behavior and insights. Honestly, when I look at this competitor, or this company providing it, their offering differs from ours in several significant respects. In the same way, I'd note that whenever somebody does something truly well and demonstrates genuine potential, others will probably arrive and replicate it. That advantage is ours, along with the legacy of all that institutional knowledge and learning, and on top of that we keep growing it, which means we have it across many, many countries. It's present not in a single product but across multiple products. It's there not only as a price proposition, since non-price elements factor in as well. There are quite a lot of things, and as you can see, even through the pandemic, each time I join this call every three months, there have been a number of fresh updates on our side, and we keep moving forward and forward, making Prime a more robust proposition than it was three months earlier.

Dana Dunne

executive
#42

Just picture it — three months down the road, or six or nine months from now, it will be even stronger than what you're seeing today. David, I'll hand things over to you for the remaining questions.

David Elízaga

executive
#43

Right. The next question asks, "Based on your current internal projections, over the next few years, when will eDreams be able to return to the revenue levels it produced in fiscal 2020?" That's a terrific question. We aren't providing guidance either near term or longer term. What I can do is remind you of the dynamics that set us apart from the rest of the market, since what we're confident about is this: we'll get back to our pre-crisis activity level ahead of the rest of the industry. If you examine the data we've shared on our volumes compared with industry volumes, you'll have noticed that, broadly speaking, a gap of between 10 points and 20 points exists — it depends on which month you're looking at — in performance between us and the industry. A lot of factors sit inside that now. There are things such as the fact that we're 100% leisure, that we're 100% online, that we hold very clear leadership on mobile, which we've shown with 58% of our bookings now coming on mobile. At the same time, we have, I believe, a way of treating customers and being customer-centric that sets us apart versus everyone else.

David Elízaga

executive
#44

In that context, our Prime subscription program plays a highly prominent part, since it basically lets us grow, over time, the portion of each customer's spending that comes to us. Those dynamics, I believe, will keep going, because the reasons beneath them, I think, will keep going too. The next question is, "In a typical year, how does Easter impact bookings, and what are we likely to see this year?" The first part of your question is very different from the second part of your question. The first part of the question, how does Easter impact bookings? There is a general rule in our industry that when people is on vacation, they don't book vacation. Easter in Europe is, depending on the country that you look at, is a week of vacation that happens either the week before Easter Sunday or the week after Easter Sunday, depending on if it is a northern country or more southern country. Those two weeks are two weeks in which our booking performance is muted because the customers are actually on vacation. They're still not booking their next one. You will see in the run-up to Easter, usually there are some latecomers in the two weeks prior to Easter or so, in which you have a little bit of a bump in bookings.

David Elízaga

executive
#45

So that's a typical year, and that's the first piece of your question. As for what we're likely to see this year, honestly, that's really hard to forecast. On pure seasonality, Easter Sunday fell on the 12th of April in 2020. This year, Easter Sunday lands on the 4th of April, so roughly a week earlier. But last Easter, hardly anyone was permitted to travel across many of the markets where we were operating. This year, I believe some domestic travel will be permitted, fairly comparable to what we saw at Christmas. We're already seeing some advance bookings now, as we mentioned, in response to the question some other investors asked earlier about the surge we've seen in the U.K. in advance bookings following the government's announcements about what will likely happen with de-escalation over the next few months. We truly don't know what will happen across the next five weeks, six weeks, until Easter arrives in the remaining markets where we operate. Telling you exactly what we're likely to see this year would be a bit adventurous on our part.

David Elízaga

executive
#46

This final investor question asks, "Might fixed costs stay around the same annual level seen in fiscal 2021, even during fiscal 2022?" Well, fixed costs break down into multiple components. The largest piece — though not the sole one — is personnel expenses. One factor that sets fiscal 2022 apart from fiscal 2021 is this: we won't get the benefit we enjoyed this year, for roughly a six-month stretch, from government-backed HR support programs — mainly in Spain, where most of our staff are based, but also for a handful of employees in other markets. That, at minimum, will represent one difference. As in the past, we'll work hard to keep fixed costs efficient, but as for the precise figure, I don't believe we can offer guidance on that at this moment. Now let me move to the next batch of questions, which come from Guilherme Macedo Sampaio at CaixaBank BPI. How would you account for such growth in Prime membership amid a pandemic in which customers have so little visibility into whether subscribing actually pays off?

Dana Dunne

executive
#47

I'll take that one, David. Yes, I'll handle it. Guilherme, to start with, I believe everything I mentioned in response to the two earlier questions really does apply here. Let me offer a few extra thoughts on the matter. First, when a customer subscribes to Prime — suppose the average across countries is, say, EUR 55 for a one-year subscription — what they receive includes not only a flight but, as of now, hotels too. Correct? Hotels are the key part, and during the pandemic hotels have grown more important, and on top of that you simply receive greater value from it. I'll return to that shortly. Another thing you receive is that, provided the person is traveling with it, you're able to add far more additional people to it. Correct? Family members and friends and the like. You actually get a benefit enabling family to use it. It isn't only your own individual travel — there are benefits for others too, and we observe that as well. The third element, which I consider especially important in the current pandemic context, is that we provide what you might call VIP premium customer service to Prime customers.

Dana Dunne

executive
#48

What that means is — to put it plainly, to convey the gist — they skip ahead in line. Should they wish to reach us through email, chat, or voice, they'd be moved to the head of the queue. On top of that, our finest agents would be the ones serving them. You genuinely receive excellent customer service. Given all the uncertainty that's been swirling around out there — will I get my money back or won't I? — that matters. Consider how many of our rivals simply can't be reached at all, and I mean not only competing OTAs but even airlines where no contact is possible. So there's real worth in this premium level of service too. To bring that down to a concrete illustration, suppose two people were traveling for, say once more, four days. Since, during the pandemic, we're less inclined to do, say, two weeks, so four days. It's easy to save EUR 100. Keep in mind, two people on two return flights, and on top of that three nights in a hotel for two people. On Prime, EUR 100 in savings is easy to find in that. I think that gives you some sense of what's running through certain customers' minds when it comes to choosing Prime here.

Dana Dunne

executive
#49

That's the reason I genuinely can't wait for this. Once the market actually comes back and travel restrictions truly lift, and if this is how we're doing in a market that's so shrunken, I feel very optimistic about how Prime will truly perform in a more normalized market. I think, David, was there another question regarding call center costs?

David Elízaga

executive
#50

I believe the next question is directed at me. What should we anticipate for how call center costs will trend from here? As we mentioned, during the third quarter we had roughly EUR 1.3 million in call center investment above what we'd consider normal. We expect that level to persist and grow somewhat, perhaps getting to around EUR 1.5 million in the fourth quarter. After that, I think we'll see it come down gradually and get back to more typical cost per booking levels for us. Your following question actually ties into this one. Could you share additional specifics about your strategy here and the efficiency gains you're targeting? As we've said, one of the three areas where we're putting our product and IT resources is automating a great deal of our customer service interactions. We're progressing very well on that front, and we believe only a few months remain before we complete that effort. To realize the full benefit, so to speak, we do need volumes to come back, since that's when we'll be able to handle those contacts without extra costs, as they'll be managed by self-service tools and machines instead of physical agents assisting our customers.

David Elízaga

executive
#51

I'd anticipate that taking place far more as we move toward the summer rather than over the coming few months. On the final part, how worried are you about your super senior revolving credit facility and the debt covenant? That's something I believe I've already addressed. With this next batch of questions, I'm beginning to notice a bit of repetition. Pierre Merveille from ODDO BHF: "Good afternoon. Could you update us on the accelerated refunds in Q3?" I've already covered the refunds. Over the quarter, did that outflow in Q2 rise or fall? It fell by EUR 5 million, as I said before. What's the year-to-date cash movement on schedule with proactive refunds? Could you give a direction? That's largely the same thing again. Could you give direction for working capital in the fourth quarter? The direction for working capital in Q4 will, I think, depend entirely on what happens with travel restrictions. Should the travel restrictions and visibility improve — whether that's for the next month or for the months ahead — we could see bookings rise. In that case, you'd get a positive working capital performance. If not, you'll see a more muted sort of working capital performance.

David Elízaga

executive
#52

Spread Research sent in another question, and we’ve already addressed that one as well. There was also a question about working capital performance, which we’ve covered too. All right, we now have some new questions from Thiemo Bischoff at Robus Capital Management. Are you aware of any competitor that has exited the business, such as smaller OTAs? I believe that one’s for you, Dana.

Dana Dunne

executive
#53

Okay, let me clarify what “dropping out” means. What we’re seeing is that certain OTAs may have shifted into what you could call a more dormant mode, since depending on where that OTA is located geographically, they might have been able to obtain some type of government support there and may have, so to speak, cut back their operations substantially. By dropping out, I’d be more inclined to mean, let’s say, a bankruptcy. I’m not aware of OTAs that have specifically gone bankrupt, though there very likely are plenty of them. As you may recall, we encounter roughly 100 OTAs across the whole European market, although not in every geography—just across the map. The majority of them are in fact private. So we wouldn’t know whether they have, let’s say, completely ceased trading operations. It seems fair to assume, based on what we observe, that a number of competitors are struggling. I think the real place where we’d see the answer to your question is once we emerge from the pandemic and government support in those particular geographies is actually pulled away from those companies, and at that point they need to survive and thrive on their own.

Dana Dunne

executive
#54

David?

David Elízaga

executive
#55

Yeah, I believe that covers it fully. As for the second portion of Thiemo's questions — whether we've seen any meaningful uptick in bookings, say for summer vacations, during the February days following the encouraging news about COVID vaccine reliability — I think I already addressed that in response to an earlier investor's question. Next, there's a follow-up from Wolfgang Felix at Sarria Limited. Thanks for taking my first question. What size is your balance of refunds payables? What size is your balance of refunds receivables? Thanks. To begin with, let me explain when a payable gets recorded in our financial statements, and when a receivable gets recorded in the financial statements, since these reflect two quite distinct dynamics. Whenever a customer asks us to handle a refund request, we do that, yet nothing appears in our financial statements. At the point we actually get the money from the airline, that is when we record a payable. There's a processing period — I'd say two to three weeks — for the information that has to arrive. It must be reconciled so you can determine which customers are due a refund, for what amount, et cetera.

David Elízaga

executive
#56

After that, we complete the cash out, and the liability is gone. A receivable only shows up once the customer files a chargeback on their credit card. That is the point at which we record a receivable. It might relate to a request we've already made to an airline, or it might relate to a different booking where we haven't made the request, since the customer never asked us to push the refund through on their behalf. On volumes, our payable currently sits at an order of magnitude of EUR 50 million, and for receivables, it's an order of magnitude of at least EUR 10 million or so. Those figures shift daily, I'd say. The final questions for this good and enriching set of questions we've gotten from our investors this quarter come from Chadd Garcia of Schwartz. He asks, "One more. Given your success growing Prime in this challenging environment, is your goal for total Prime members too conservative?"

Dana Dunne

executive
#57

As David attempted to express earlier, we lack guidance for both the upcoming quarter and the coming year, and that is plainly due to the macroeconomic situation—specifically, the pandemic. This is a once-in-a-lifetime kind of occurrence, which makes issuing formal guidance difficult, and especially so for us, since we take pride in having always surpassed or fulfilled the guidance we have provided ever since I became the company's CEO. I believe it would be reasonable—the feeling behind your remark, Chadd, is reasonable. In the same way, if you run the figures, where you simply state that assuming the market sits at -65 and we are achieving, once more, using just round numbers, nearly 100,000, you multiply that by three, and you arrive at a considerably larger figure that, based on when the market would genuinely come back to a more typical size, you can simply total it up and observe numerous scenarios that reach a path far beyond 2 million for that. Once again, we will give you a fuller update at the end of May regarding our results in Prime. I believe that as you begin to witness the market coming back, I think at that point you will also see, on an absolute basis, the overall figures in Prime expanding quite considerably.

Dana Dunne

executive
#58

David, go ahead.

David de la Roz

executive
#59

All right. That covers everything we have to ask today. Thanks to all of you for being on the webcast and conference call with us. As we wrap up, I want to let you know that our call for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2021 will take place on Thursday, 27 May, and until then, we would be glad to take any questions you send through our investor relations teams or to the investor email address, investors@edreamsodigeo.com. Many thanks.

Dana Dunne

executive
#60

Thank you. Goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete eDreams ODIGEO S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to eDreams ODIGEO S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in eDreams ODIGEO S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.