eDreams ODIGEO S.A. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 15, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David de la Roz
executiveMorning, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. I’m David de la Roz, Director of Investor Relations at eDreams ODIGEO. As usual, the results materials — including the presentations and our results report — are available in the investor relations sections of our website. I’d like to let you know that today’s presentation will run longer than usual. It will be split into two parts. Part one will cover our results for the first half of the current financial year. Part two will cover our performance since our Capital Markets Day one year ago, plus an update on our progress toward our three-year guidance. I’ll now hand things over to Dana Dunne, our CEO, who will walk you through the first part of the presentation.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, David. Morning, all, and I appreciate you being with us today. During the opening six months of this fiscal year, FY 2023, the travel market has kept on strengthening and recovering substantially. Despite the war in Ukraine, despite heavy inflationary pressure, despite flight cancellations and COVID-19 flare-ups, it's obvious people want to go places and are ready to put their money toward it. We've made this point for more than a year, drawing on consumer survey findings and on real evidence of how consumers behaved across the last 50 years whenever major macroeconomic shocks hit. I realize this runs against quite a few well-compensated industry pundits and their studies, and so far their claims have proven incorrect. Against that market backdrop, we've delivered outperformance relative to our industry. As a matter of fact, we've now posted bookings above pre-COVID levels for five consecutive quarters, and no other travel company globally has managed that. Our model is distinctive, leaning more on a steady flow of recurring revenue from subscription businesses than any other travel firm does. Go to slide six, please — it summarizes how we performed in the first half of fiscal year 2023.
Dana Dunne
executiveDuring the opening six months of FY 2023, we once more delivered robust bookings, hitting 8.6 million. Our market share keeps expanding, and as a result we stay firmly on course to beat the guidance we set for FY 2025. A few of the main points for today's presentation: first, we have once again posted robust growth in bookings. Bookings in FY 2023 rose 50% year-on-year and stood 48% higher than pre-COVID-19 levels. That happened even with all the turmoil in the travel market caused by COVID, the Ukraine war, flight disruptions, and inflation. We're aware the travel market has not yet completely returned to pre-COVID levels. Even amid these macroeconomic headwinds, our latest booking figures continue to demonstrate robust growth, with October bookings 45% higher than 2019 pre-COVID levels. From the 1st to 8th of November, they were up 45% again compared with 2019 levels. Without question, consumers want to travel, and they want to travel with us. There's a reason travel is the biggest seamless category online. Travel delivers a unique experience that people treasure and long for and are ready to spend money on. The second highlight we'll share with you today: both Prime and our market Prime — that is, our market-leading subscription product — along with eDO keep outperforming. eDO bookings keep outperforming and are materially better than the market.
Dana Dunne
executiveAlthough the market is still under pre-COVID levels, we keep trading well above where we were before COVID, and we've now delivered our fifth quarter in a row above pre-COVID levels. Most importantly, the pivot to subscription has made our business higher quality. Repeat rates are higher, and it gets more profitable each year as Prime customers renew. In Q2 FY 2023, we hit 3.6 million subscribers, at a run rate of 479,000 per quarter during the first half of FY 2023. That's up 8% against the FY 2022 quarterly run rate and up 47% against FY 2021 quarterly run rates. More than a year ago, we began seeing extremely high growth in new Prime member additions. A year later, net new adds are now leveling off, with the effective churn from all those new members added over a year ago. Today's third highlight: in the first half of FY 2023, revenue margin and Cash Revenue Margin rose above pre-COVID-19 levels for the second quarter in a row since April 2020. Revenue margin and Cash Revenue Margin in the first half of FY 2023 beat pre-COVID-19 levels by 3% and 12%, respectively. Cash revenue margin in the first half of FY 2023 rose 69% versus the same period last year, with bookings up 50% and revenue margin per booking up 15%.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks to the improved quality of our business that came with the shift to subscription. All in all, during the first half of FY 2023 we continued to see the positive trends from FY 2022, and we returned to profitability. Cash Marginal Profit came in at EUR 74.4 million. That represents a 51% rise compared with the figure in FY 2022. As we expected, Cash EBITDA was strong in the second quarter of FY 2023, giving us EUR 34.5 million for the first half of FY 2023. That is 78% higher than in the same period a year earlier. As we said in the first quarter, the rapid growth in Prime members during their first year holds back growth and profitability, because a Prime member's profitability increases in the second year. It's worth noting that had we reached 3.5 million members at the end of Q2 FY 2023 rather than 3.6 million members — meaning just 110,000 fewer net adds — eDO would have posted an 18% Cash EBITDA margin rather than the 13% you see reported. In other words, the Cash EBITDA margin would have been five points higher. All because we brought in 110,000 fewer net subscribers. Fourth highlight. A year after we laid out the targets we set for ourselves for FY 2025, we are firmly on track to hit them.
Dana Dunne
executivePrime members. We've seen a lot of negative macroeconomic factors since setting our goal of 7.25 million members by the end of FY 2025, but we remain on track to hit or beat that number. Our run rate for net adds is ahead of expectations, churn rates are slightly improving, and we're confident we will meet or exceed the target. ARPU. ARPU is converging with our guidance of EUR 80 per user, and we are confident we will meet the guidance. Cash EBITDA. Our Q2 FY 2023 results demonstrate that as the percentage of Year 2+ Prime members increases, our margins increase. Our most recent results clearly demonstrate we are well on track to meet our target of over EUR 180 million of Cash EBITDA in FY 2025. In sum, we really believe we've got the right model, right people, right structure to seize and deliver the exciting opportunities ahead of us. Now I'll take you through more details. Please turn to slide eight, where I'll go through eDO's outperformance. As I referred to earlier, eDO achieved strong bookings growth in the first half of FY 2023, reaching 8.6 million bookings in the semester. This is 48% greater than the pre-COVID-19 levels.
Dana Dunne
executiveWhen we look at the latest numbers for October and November, we've kept seeing robust growth running 45% above pre-COVID-19 levels in October and across the first eight days of November. And all of that came about amid the Ukraine war, COVID, heavy inflationary pressure, flight disruptions, and so on. I'd also like to note that even with that outstanding performance in October and November, as we move past COVID comparisons, we do expect a return to a more typical autumn and winter trading pattern. What that means is we'll probably begin to see more normal seasonality return, which in turn would mean likely fewer absolute bookings in the months before Christmas, and so, of course, a higher absolute booking figure in January and February as well. Kindly turn to slide nine. As IATA public data and recent results from low-cost carriers show, eDreams ODIGEO has consistently outperformed its peers. That translates into market share gains and underlines both our superior proposition to customers and the strength and adaptability of our business model. That said, I'd also like to point out that as corporate travel comes back, this gap will probably close as well.
Dana Dunne
executiveRelative to regular airlines, we do perform better — by 54 percentage points against IATA, and by 20 percentage points against low cost carriers, in the second quarter of this financial year. Now please turn to slide 10. As we already pointed out in our FY 2022 results presentation, passenger traffic has, for the most part, grown over the past 40 years, even through recessions, energy crises, high inflationary environments, et cetera. There is always uncertainty in a future situation with a unique set of factors, but based on prior market performance, in fact only three years between 1980 and 2019 saw passenger numbers decline. The biggest decline was 2.6%, which happened in 1991. Please turn to slide 11. Even with inflation, we benefit from a highly variable cost structure, which results in us being less impacted, as most of the variable costs are linked to volume levels. 85% of our costs in the second quarter of FY 2023 and the last 12 months are variable, and this is on a business that is profitable and growing. With that, let me now hand it over to David, who will walk you through our financial results in more detail.
David Corrales
executiveThanks, Dana. Everyone, please go to slide 13 in the deck, where I'll walk you through the financial results in greater depth. Our new KPIs demonstrate the robust expansion in Prime Cash Revenue Margin and marginal profit over the last 12 months, which stems from the exponential growth in Prime members. As we've already pointed out, our average revenue per user, or ARPU, is converging toward guidance of EUR 80 per user. That said, as previously noted, we did not anticipate the earlier levels would be sustainable, and we are keeping our long-term guidance of EUR 80 per user. As expected, the movement this quarter came from the phasing out of the second quarter of fiscal year 2022 within the last 12 months calculation. During that quarter we saw a material rise in revenues, and travelers jumped suddenly because of the vaccination rollout. The robust expansion in Cash Revenue Margin and Cash Marginal Profit means that 42% and 64% of our last 12 months Cash Revenue Margin and Cash Marginal Profit, respectively, are now delivered for Prime members, compared with 38% and 50%, respectively, only one year ago.
David Corrales
executiveLet me remind everyone that Prime member profitability rises considerably starting in year two, since the costs of acquiring customers drop quite sharply. As the share of our Prime members who are in their second-year cohort grows in later years of membership, Prime's profitability will keep getting better. Kindly turn to slide 14 of the presentation. Throughout the pandemic, we kept investing and innovating in the subscription offering, and we have since witnessed outstanding results. Cash revenue margin already sits 12% above pre-COVID-19 levels, and Cash Marginal Profit and Cash EBITDA are set to improve thanks to the big rise in Prime members this year, as Prime member profitability jumps from the second year onward. In the first half of fiscal 2023, deferred revenue growth tied to Prime has clearly sped up after 1.9 million more new members subscribed over the course of the year. That comes to EUR 27.5 million, which is up 48% year-on-year. Cash EBITDA including the full Prime contribution reached EUR 34.5 million in the first half of the fiscal year, an improvement of 78% in just one year. As expected, strong Cash EBITDA in the fiscal year's second quarter was EUR 20.5 million on its own, a 42% increase versus the prior quarter, the first quarter of this fiscal year.
David Corrales
executiveLet's move to slide 15. During the first half of fiscal 2023, revenue margin and Cash Revenue Margin stayed above where they stood before COVID-19, by 3% and 12% respectively. That held true even with macroeconomic headwinds and industry disruptions. Revenue margin for the first half of 2023 rose 72% compared with the same period a year earlier, thanks to bookings that were up 50% and a 15% rise in revenue margin per booking, which came from the better quality of our business as we pivoted to subscription and from strong growth in our revenue diversification. Variable costs were up 76%. That increase resulted from the growth in bookings and an 18% rise in variable cost per booking, from EUR 24 million in the first half of last fiscal year to EUR 28.2 million in the first half of fiscal 2023. Cost per booking went up because of higher acquisition costs for bringing in Prime members and because merchant costs rose, which is tied to higher basket values. Overall, in the first half of 2023, we saw the improving trends we guided you on in the fiscal 2022 and first quarter of fiscal 2023 results presentation. Cash Marginal Profit grew to EUR 74.4 million.
David Corrales
executiveThat represents a 51% increase over what we achieved in the prior year. Cash EBITDA was up 78% compared with the same period a year earlier. As we guided before, the strong growth in Prime members during their first year holds back growth and profitability, and profitability climbs in year two. Across the coming few quarters, we anticipate profitability gains as the share of Prime members in their second year and beyond grows. Fixed costs rose by EUR 10 million, primarily due to higher personnel costs and external fees, both tied to recruiting new employees, plus some negative foreign exchange impact. I'd like to remind you that we don't expect the rise in fixed costs to be linear from EUR 63 million in fiscal 2022, the last one, to the EUR 100 million target in fiscal 2025, because recruitment is front-loaded so we can deliver on our business plan. We'll show you more detailed figures on the phasing later in the presentation. If you look at Note 9.2 of our financial statements, our workforce is up by 201 employees year-on-year. With 170 of them brought in between March to September, only six months. That's 34% of our target headcount in under 15% of the time.
David Corrales
executiveJust to remind everyone, altogether we intend to bring on 500 additional staff members by March 2025, and a large share of that hiring comes early in the period. Consequently, Adjusted EBITDA came in at EUR 7 million. That figure is EUR 34.5 million, factoring in the entire contribution of Prime against a profit of EUR 19.4 million during the first half of fiscal 2022, again with the Prime contribution included. Adjusted Net Income showed a loss of EUR 19 million in the first half of fiscal 2023. Moving to slide 16, I'll walk you through the cash flow statement. During the first half of fiscal 2023, notwithstanding the Ukraine war and European industry disruptions, which hit sizable parts of the first quarter, along with macro headwinds, we closed the semester with positive cash flow from operations of EUR 33 million, driven largely by a working capital inflow of EUR 19.5 million. That inflow for the first half of 2023 is lower than the one recorded in the first half of fiscal 2022, because volumes recovered more than they had in the second quarter of fiscal 2022. That means July, August, September of 2021. As you may recall, that took place immediately following the large-scale vaccination effort and the lifting of a substantial share of travel restrictions, whereas across these past six months, volumes have tracked more closely with normal seasonality, without such a large jump.
David Corrales
executiveOur liquidity has been handled effectively, which reflects both a robust business model and proactive management. We pulled this off even with travel restrictions that lowered trade volumes. Throughout the pandemic, liquidity stayed stable and more than adequate. At the close of fiscal 2023 in September, our liquidity stood at a solid EUR 167 million, following repayment of EUR 3.8 million on the government-sponsored loan plus a further EUR 3.4 million in refinancing-related costs. During the first half of 2023, EUR 16.2 million in cash went toward investments. That figure is EUR 4.5 million above the prior fiscal year, driven by expanding our development capacity and, in turn, greater capitalization of software development. Cash used in financing came to EUR 50 million, versus EUR 14.9 million generated from financing activities a year earlier. The EUR 35.5 million swing in financing activities is mostly tied to repayment of the super senior revolving credit facility totaling EUR 30 million and EUR 3.8 million on the government-sponsored loan. Those changes are offset by a EUR 28.5 million rise in bank overdrafts, which includes the line bank overdrafts usage shown in the cash flow statement. I'll hand the presentation over to Dana now for the first segment on how our strategy has performed in Prime one year after the Capital Markets Day; that section will give a strategy overview along with two of our self-imposed fiscal 2025 targets, namely Prime members and ARPU.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, David. Now let's turn to our strategy performance update, one year on from the Capital Markets Day. First, some context. Since our Capital Markets Day in November 2021, a number of factors have occurred. Omicron, the Ukraine invasion, flight disruptions, high inflation levels, et cetera. How are we doing, and how is the investment thesis? Exactly the same. The investment thesis in us remains exactly the same. Nothing has structurally changed. While some may think that the world has crumbled under our feet, our investment thesis is the same, and we are fully on track to meet our FY 2025 guidance. Please turn to slide 19, where I'm first gonna cover some strategic priorities. As you recall, our position for the future success due to our innovative approach in travel has been proven in other industries. There are a number of real reasons in why we are so strong in position for future growth. One, we're in pole position in an attractive market. The eDO addressable market is sizable, growing and attractive, and eDO is positioned in the right segments, online and leisure. eDO market is one of the largest in the world. It's growing and attractive.
Dana Dunne
executiveWe're still in recovery mode, having come up from an all-time low, and growth keeps happening. On top of that, leisure consumers have shown repeatedly that they want to travel and that they'll put travel ahead of other things. You can't substitute leisure travel. In our year-end results, we're sharing survey data indicating that consumers would sacrifice other discretionary spending rather than travel. What some retail companies have published over the last few weeks, set against our results and those of other travel companies, already confirms this in actual data. You've seen our bookings for the past year and for the latest quarter. For five quarters now, we've been substantially above pre-COVID levels. Kindly turn to slide 20 of the presentation. Reason number two, within travel, eDO is the global flight leader, excluding China, and more than 3x bigger than the second player in Europe. Kindly turn to slide 21 of the presentation. Reason number three, eDO has shown it can capture new customers via the Prime program while also converting existing customers. Prime ranks as the number one travel subscription program worldwide, with over 60% of our Prime customers being new customers who have not used an eDreams product during the last three years.
Dana Dunne
executiveWhat this showed is that the Prime offering draws people in and resonates not just with those already with us — that is, the more than 24 million customers who have made bookings with us during the last couple of years — but with new members as well. That partly accounts for the market share gains we are seeing. Among the many strengths of Prime is its power to bring in new members — almost 2 million in just the last 12 months. However you frame it, Prime works: it delights customers, expands our market share, and benefits everyone involved — our customers, the company, and shareholders. Kindly go to slide 22 of the presentation. I want to stress once more that we believe, no matter the present macroeconomic uncertainties, our business model and track record put us in a position to beat the industry. We have proven that we are the platform where customers would rather book their travel. The reasons are, first, that through Prime we provide the best prices, value, and customer experience. Second, we satisfy customer needs better than competitors do through the depth of choice, the speed of the overall experience, after-sales service, and so many other things that have taken us years to perfect. That produces higher customer satisfaction scores than our competitors achieve.
Dana Dunne
executiveThird, in tougher economic conditions, customers will place even greater emphasis on price when their discretionary income is under pressure. That aligns with our strengths and our value proposition. Fourth, beyond all of that, we have scale and resilience through Prime, with more than 3.8 million subscribers, which delivers business resiliency, thanks to subscribers' highest stickiness, margin expansion following initial acquisition, and giving us a far larger share of wallet of the travel industry they keep consuming. Let's move now to slide 23 of the presentation. Consequently, as you can see, we are well-positioned and well-financed, and we are on track toward our self-imposed FY 2025 targets. I'd like to remind you of what those targets are. Target one, Prime members above 7.25 million. Target two, Prime ARPU of EUR 11. Target three, Cash EBITDA net debt of EUR 180 million. These three targets were announced to the market one year ago. A very valid and important question is: how are we doing one year later? We'll now spend time discussing each of these three targets in greater detail to explain, based on actual performance, why we are so confident one year on that we will hit and surpass each of these three FY 2025 targets.
Dana Dunne
executivePlease turn to slide 26. I'll begin with the first target, Prime numbers. We remain on track to hit 7.25 million members by FY 2025. Why do we have such confidence? There are five reasons. First, our quarterly Prime net adds run rates achieved so far are well ahead of the implied member run rates we need in order to reach the target, in a market that remains below pre-COVID levels and with all the external macroeconomic effects we've discussed since setting the target. As part of this point, we should also remind you that one year after super high growth in Prime net adds began, gross adds will be partly offset by churn applying to a larger Prime member base. Looking ahead, sustaining levels of circa 500 net adds per quarter will become harder in the short term. Beating the implied figure required on a quarterly basis from now through March 2025 is absolutely achievable. Beyond that, we still have improvements to launch for Prime, which lifts our run rate, and launching Prime in new countries also lifts that run rate as we expand our total addressable market.
Dana Dunne
executiveOn top of that, a market rebound could lend a hand too. Taken together, these factors leave us fully confident that we will hit our FY 2025 goal of 7.25 million Prime members. Kindly turn to slide 27. The second reason we believe we can surpass 7.25 million subscribers by March 2025 is that our addressable market is enormous, and the assumptions we have layered in are highly realistic, even conservative. We keep converting the customers we already have. We are drawing on a pool of 24 million non-Prime customers who have been with us across the last three years. Beyond that, we keep converting an exceptionally large base of people who are not yet customers. Our share of the European Prime market stands at just 5%, and over 60% of new Prime members are newcomers to us. So even though our market share is climbing sharply, honestly, 95% remains still to be captured. Our assumptions are likewise very realistic. Reaching 7.25 million members by FY 2025 implies a Prime penetration target of 2.4% of households across the nine markets where we offer Prime today. That figure also presumes we will not introduce Prime in any further markets. And in France, the market where we have operated longest, we already sit at 3.8% penetration of French households.
Dana Dunne
executiveTo reiterate, 2.4% is quite a cautious figure. There's one key fact I want to highlight. France, which is our most established market, continues to expand remarkably well, so it is nowhere close to reaching its long-term growth levels. That's a positive signal for 2026 through 2030. Considerable growth remains available even once we hit our FY 2025 targets. Across the other Prime markets where we operate in Europe, by their third year on average they've achieved 1.5% household penetration. That's actually somewhat ahead of the penetration we see in France after year three. Nothing prevents us from reaching, in those remaining European markets, the same household penetration that France has after five years, and then driving toward substantially higher levels. Kindly turn to slide 28. This ties into my previous point and to our long-term growth prospects past 2025. Subscription businesses demonstrate strong growth and penetration across many years, and our own data for eDO backs that up too. Kindly turn to slide 29. We believe, for example, that Prime has shown it can win customers even amid major macroeconomic events such as COVID, the Ukraine war, flight disruptions, high inflation, and so on. Prime keeps drawing in new subscribers.
Dana Dunne
executiveLet's go to slide 30. One more thing worth flagging is that churn rates are coming down a bit. If you could now move to slide 33. In this part we cover our second KPI, ARPU, which we established a year back. Twelve months after launching ARPU, it's also on course to hit our FY 2025 guidance. We've said again and again across recent quarters that ARPU would converge toward the FY 2025 guidance of EUR 80 per user, and that's precisely what's taking place. What drove the movement this quarter was Q2 FY 2022 dropping out of the trailing 12-month calculation. During Q2 FY 2022 we saw a substantial revenue lift from a sharp jump in travelers tied to the vaccine rollout in early 2021. We do expect — and this sits inside our three-year plan — that ARPUs will trend in the mid-70s over the coming few quarters, since a larger Prime member base narrows the difference between average and end of period members. Down the road, with new Prime products and features rolling out, ARPU will move back toward our FY 2025 target of EUR 80.
Dana Dunne
executiveI'll hand the presentation over to David now so he can go through the final one of our self-imposed FY 2025 KPI targets, Cash EBITDA, and after that I'll return to give you a few closing remarks before we open up the webcast for Q&A.
David Corrales
executiveThank you, Dana. We'll turn now to the third KPI, Cash EBITDA. As you saw in the first part of today's presentation, Cash EBITDA is beginning to deliver the results we wanted, just as expected. This metric matters a great deal, and we believe it's worth walking through in detail both our progress here and the fundamentals behind it. As Dana mentioned, the investment thesis in us is unchanged. Structurally, nothing is different, and the figures ahead of you demonstrate that we remain on track and are moving toward the fiscal 2025 target we set ourselves of more than EUR 180 million in Cash EBITDA. Please turn to slide 36. This slide, or one much like it, was shown at the Investor Day, and it illustrates how Cash Marginal Profit margins rise as Prime members mature. You'll remember that during Year 1 of a customer's membership, we take on sizable customer acquisition costs, or CAC. But starting with the second booking and following renewal, profitability accumulates, and after that there is no significant CAC. Slide 36 gives you three separate perspectives on cash margin, or profit margins.
David Corrales
executiveThe one on the far left is what we showed 12 months ago at the Capital Markets Day. It was an illustrative example assuming just one customer signs up on day one of the first year. In the middle version on the chart, we're showing the actual figures as of September 2022. Obviously, not every customer joins on day one of a quarter within a financial year, so this factors in all the timing differences and the aggregation across all of those customers. The right side displays our expectation for fiscal 2025. As you can see, we remain on track with our financial target for fiscal 2025. Overall, our cash margin or profit margins are on track to meet our fiscal 2025 guidance. Please turn to slide 37. This slide shows the breakout of our subscribers between Year 1 and Year 2 onwards. As that percent changes, so too does the average company cash margin or profit. On the left-hand side is the Prime cash margin or profit margin with the current mix of Year 1 and Year 2, which is 61% of revenue coming from Year 1, 39% of revenue coming from Year 2 and subsequent years.
David Corrales
executiveIf you take the margin figures from the prior slide and multiply them by the real revenue split between Prime members in year one and those in year two and beyond, that gives us the total cash margin, or profit, for the Prime side of the business. On the right-hand side we illustrate the same mechanic, except using the figures we expect to hit in fiscal 2025 under our business planning guidance. It's clear that as the share of revenue from Year 2 and later members grows, the aggregate margin rises in a mathematical fashion. Conceptually, margins go up as the portion of Year 2+ members goes up, because CAC for Year 2 members is very low. So, as you can see, margins will climb progressively between now and fiscal 2025. That said, with travel seasonality back to normal, there can be quarter-to-quarter variations. Kindly turn to slide 38. Here's another example where we show this mechanic, but covering the last three quarters we have published — specifically those last three quarters. As the weight of Year 2+ members increases starting in the fourth quarter of 2022, that is clearly reflected in the Cash Marginal Profit of the Prime business.
David Corrales
executiveWhen Year 2+ rose by 15 index points between the fourth quarter and the first quarter of 2023, that produced a 4-point gain in cash margin, or profit margin. In the Prime business, a 45-point rise in Year 2 from the last quarter of last fiscal year to the second quarter of this fiscal year delivered a 12-point improvement in cash margin, or profit margins — 3x the 4 points, so the two are totally correlated. What this demonstrates is that the gradual margin improvement came from strong growth in Prime Year 1 subscribers over the past 12 months. As that shifts with time, the effect becomes visible on Prime margins and on the margins of the business overall. Kindly turn to slide 39. A different way to view this is to run a sensitivity analysis on Prime members, using the following assumptions as a base. Across all the numbers in this chart, churn is held stable, and member growth is varied by changing investment in paid channels — i.e., more investment in paid channels means more members. Less investment in paid channels means fewer members.
David Corrales
executiveThat would mean buying fewer Prime units upfront and also securing fewer non-Prime bookings. Different member growth rates, as the chart shows, lead to either a higher or a lower cash margin or profit margin. Faster growth over the near term brings margins down, while slower growth lifts them. Kindly turn to slide 40 at this point. This finishes the picture further down the P&L and the cash flow. Previously, we provided the fiscal 2025 year-end figure for fixed costs as well as for CapEx. Both are tracking to plan. Because of how successful we've been, and since we're pressing ahead to bring in additional talent so we can build the new products and services that we're confident our member base wants, spending is weighted more toward the front in 2023 and 2024. That naturally affects Cash EBITDA over the short term, though it's already accounted for in our 3-year plan budget. Now please turn to slide 41. This slide is the same as the one for cash margin or profit — it shows the Cash EBITDA margins. It's the identical analysis we showed two slides earlier, except that it incorporates the fixed costs into the sensitivity results.
David Corrales
executiveSo as you can see, assuming a run rate of 547,000 net Prime members each quarter starting now through fiscal 2025, that gets us to 9 million Prime members in fiscal 2025, with Cash EBITDA margins at 18%. If instead the run rate were 364,000 members per quarter — the linear progression from where we stand today up to 7.25 million members — we'd get to Cash EBITDA margins of 22%, in line with guidance. Now let's turn to slide 42. A lot of you have asked how margins might look past fiscal 2025, when our fixed costs have stabilized at a base of EUR 100 million that will rise with inflation, and CAC keeps coming down as the weight of Year 2+ members keeps increasing. Again, to be clear, this is for illustrative purposes only. These aren't final targets. This isn't guidance. It's simply the outcome of a sensitivity analysis on Prime member growth. We've run two scenarios for you. Scenario one is a static scenario: what happens if we grow zero after fiscal 2025? That's completely unrealistic, but it's just a case so you can see what would happen to margins.
David Corrales
executiveSuppose household penetration doesn't rise at all in existing markets, and we don't launch Prime anywhere new. There are no new products and no Prime fares. None of those are realistic assumptions, but even under them, our Cash EBITDA margins would climb from 22%-27% simply by doing nothing. In scenario two, we assume we hold the net quarterly adds run rate at 364,000. That's the scenario that takes us from today in a straight line to fiscal 2025, to reach 7.25 million members. As you remember, in fiscal 2025 we get nowhere near what would be a reasonable household penetration figure, so there are years more growth to achieve. As you can see, the Cash EBITDA margins, despite the growth, can grow from 22%-26%. Again, this is too far away. This is hard to predict, but we thought the sensitivity analysis will help you to understand the business better and help you as well to build your models. Most importantly, it should help you to understand the huge potential which will drive superior returns, excellent service for customers, at the same time transforming and revolutionizing the industry. I will now turn the presentation back to Dana.
Dana Dunne
executiveThank you, David. As you can see, one year on from the Capital Markets Day, we are well on track to meet or exceed our FY 2025 guidance. Beyond FY 2025, the potential in front of us is enormous. On top of that, we'd like to walk you through some additional KPIs that support the strong long-term fundamentals of our business. Please turn to slide 45. Customer advocacy is a key KPI, and it drives sustainability as well as growth. You've watched Prime expand so quickly, and none of that would be possible without strong customer advocacy. As you're aware, at present we don't advertise Prime as such, and we depend mostly on word of mouth. As the slide shows, our NPS scores have kept climbing since our Capital Markets Day one year back. Even a year ago, they were exceptionally high for travel-related products. Could you please turn to slide 46. Another lens on customer advocacy is third party surveys such as Trustpilot. Trustpilot is the review platform on which people worldwide rate their experience with different businesses from one to five. It demonstrates that we rank meaningfully better than any other OTA or airline. Second, we are the only one that has improved over the past 12 months, despite all the flight disruptions that there have been.
Dana Dunne
executiveLet's go to slide 47. For our customers in eDO, Prime offers a win-win proposition. As this slide shows, members of Prime come to us more frequently and make repeat bookings at a higher rate than people who aren't Prime members. Let's turn to slide 48. Overall, we have delivered significant value creation for eDO through Prime, and we will keep delivering it. The strength of our Prime model shows up in two ways: the fast growth in member count along with the value it generates, and a business with higher LTV and lower CAC over the long run. Our LTV to CAC range remains between 2x and 3x. Before we go to the Q&A session, let me offer one last closing remark. Kindly go to slide 50. On the whole, we firmly believe eDO is unique when it comes to profitability and growth. This subscription model has already proven itself in other industries — Netflix for video streaming, Costco for groceries and goods, Spotify for music streaming, and the list goes on and on. We aren't simply copying. We are innovating and doing certain things that nobody else has done. As a proof point, we continue to satisfy the Rule of 40.
Dana Dunne
executiveActually, we outperform every one of our subscription peers on that front — and those are profitable businesses with solid growth. On the whole, eDO has turned into a far better-quality company as we've pivoted toward our subscription model. That model brings in loyal customers who keep coming back, which makes for a business that's more profitable and easier to predict, along with lasting ties to those customers. Our underlying profitability is strong, and the room to grow is enormous. Everything here will produce superior returns for shareholders. Customers will get excellent service from us, and at the same time we'll be transforming and revolutionizing the industry.
David Corrales
executiveThank you, Dana. So with that, we'd like to open things up for your questions now, and any questions submitted to us in writing through the webcast will get answered. Questions will be handled on a first come, first serve basis. Since our prepared remarks ran longer than they typically do, we'll be grouping together questions that are similar in nature. Anything that's clearly a repeat, I won't bother reading out. If time runs short and we can't get to some questions on the webcast, the investor relations teams will ensure those get answered afterward. Let me begin with the list I have in front of me. The first batch comes from Juan Peña at GVC Gaesco. His first question reads, "I see that the revenue per booking is rising and that you already have a good base of second year Prime clients. Why doesn't it show in the operating profit and EBITDA margin in the sense that both dropped versus the second quarter of fiscal 2022?" Well, two factors account for that. First, marketing investment is running higher in order to drive growth of Prime members overall, and it's significantly above where it stood in the second quarter of fiscal 2022, having climbed further, I'd say, starting in the third quarter and fourth quarter of fiscal 2022.
David Corrales
executiveThat's the key piece. When more customers are coming into the travel market overall to do travel searches, that's when we've ramped up our marketing spend, because there are simply more customers who could potentially become future Prime members. And that's the primary reason. In fact, if you look at how margins have been trending sequentially rather than comparing with the second quarter of fiscal 2022, you'll notice margins are improving quite healthily. In the fourth quarter of 2022 and the first quarter of 2023, Cash Marginal Profit stood at 21%. In the most recent quarter we reported, it's 26%. I'd urge you to take another look at that — those are the aggregate margins for the business. I'd also encourage you to look again at the slide I just went through, which focuses specifically on the Prime side of the business, where you can see very clearly how the margin correlates with the rising percentage of customers coming from Year 2 and six months. The next set of questions comes from Chadd Garcia of Schwartz Investment. The first one reads, "Your note on the churn says that it's a weighted average of involuntary and voluntary churn.
David Corrales
executiveCould you walk us through how those categories differ and how big each one is relative to the others?" I believe you should field that question.
Dana Dunne
executiveSure. So first, voluntary churn refers to a customer actively choosing to stop being a customer. For instance, they might phone our contact center, or open the app and tap to cancel Prime, and so on — it's driven by an action the customer takes. Involuntary churn works the other way: the customer has done nothing at all. When the renewal date arrives at day 366 and we attempt to present, or collect, the renewal charge, so to speak, we can't do it — that's a failure to collect. This issue shows up more often and is more widespread in Europe, where the system differs from the one in the U.S. A typical leisure travel customer carries a credit card that, in most countries, lasts three years on average. It expires and gets renewed. In many countries, they'll issue a fresh set of numbers. The mechanism for passing those numbers along and so forth isn't nearly as well set up and established as it is in the U.S., the States. What that means is we see a disproportionate level of failure to collect, or what we term involuntary churn. As we've mentioned before, the involuntary churn category is also a far bigger bucket within total churn.
Dana Dunne
executiveI believe that's
David Corrales
executiveThe second question is about how, with the cash we're generating and the growth in EBITDA, the business ought to begin deleveraging on its own. What leverage level do you anticipate at the close of fiscal 2025? That's explicit guidance we provided at the Investor Day 1 year ago, and we've restated it. You'll find it, as clearly laid out on the slide where we address the investments and the fixed costs. There's a bullet point there that restates what I'm about to tell you, which is that we expect at the end of fiscal 2024 — so 1.5 years from now — to be just below 2x net leverage. That means net leverage where net debt sits in the numerator and Cash EBITDA sits in the denominator. By the close of fiscal 2025, we'll be between 1x and 2x. So yes, we do expect some material deleveraging to take place, since we currently stand at 6.5x. We moved from 6.5x in 1 year to just under 2x, and in 1.5 years to just under 2x, and in 2.5 years to between 1x and 2x. The next question reads, "Given your success in growing Prime, is it fair to say that once you return to normal travel seasonality, your revenue and earnings should be less impacted as you are becoming more driven by Prime subscriptions as opposed to bookings?" It is true that we will become less dependent on seasonality.
David Corrales
executiveAnother thing to keep in mind is that Prime revenue comes from the subscription, correct? Of the EUR 80, EUR 55 comes from the subscription, and that's the stable portion. You have another EUR 30, EUR 25, EUR 30 coming from revenue tied to bookings made by customers during the period. And those bookings made by customers during the period will be related to seasonality. Will the weight of seasonality be smaller? Yes. Will it disappear? No. There will always be some element of seasonality. The next question from this investor is, "I would assume," this is the last one. "I would assume that after the first year, a Prime customer knows whether they like the program or not. Does your LTV to CAC range of 2x-3x assume a finite life for a Prime member, which may not happen?" You are correct that our LTV calculations, and therefore the LTV to CAC, cover a period of two years. It only includes the first renewal. It doesn't include the second, the third, the fourth renewal. Now, other companies choose more, let's say, lax ways of measuring LTV, and they go to 36 months or to 48 months.
David Corrales
executiveOur approach is especially strict. We consider only a 2-year window. The return we measure is what a customer delivers across 24 months. Will that customer vanish—right?—and stop doing any further business with us? No, we don't believe so, correct? That's how LTV and the LTV-to-CAC ratio get calculated. Panos Farewell brings the next batch of questions. The first reads, "Marginal profit margins in France dropped 500 basis points year-on-year. Since this is your most mature market, why shouldn't we expect that figure to rise?" Well, growth in Year 2 members does genuinely help, but 2 factors counteract it. First, in Prime and France—our oldest market—we've hit record-high levels of new subscribers. In fact, on the slide showing household penetration progression in France, the count of households is unchanged, so everything comes from movement in the numerator. Across the past 6 months, we set records for new adds in France. Sign-ups there remain very, very strong. Second, something somewhat distinctive about France: during the prior year, France already enjoyed a stronger recovery than other countries, and various factors drove that.
David Corrales
executiveTake one example: France provided state support for free testing related to travel. PCR tests cost nothing to people, and in certain locations those had been over EUR 100. French citizens also received unemployment assistance, which produced a solid level of savings. The second question asks, "Why was there an outflow in working capital in the quarter?" What drives that for me in this specific quarter — looking at Q2 on its own — is that working capital reflects the final two weeks of June trading compared with the final two weeks of September trading. Across that stretch, on a comparative basis, the back half of September saw a modest decline in bookings, roughly 1%-2%, and airfares came down a little as well. Basket size on bookings made during the latter half of September ran somewhat below basket size on bookings made during the latter half of June, and that is seasonally normal. As you move toward autumn, airlines typically lower fare prices, and this year that has occurred too. To return to my earlier point, what we're seeing now is more typical seasonality.
David Corrales
executiveThis investor's third question notes that most rivals — Booking, Expedia, lastminute.com — are back at pre-COVID operating profit levels, while eDreams has not yet reached that point because of higher marketing spend, and asks us to talk through the short-term versus long-term trade-off. Well, each competitor operates a different business model. Ours, as you've observed, now has over 50% of it driven by subscription, and that is a fundamental distinction between us and the other travel companies. Our model is more sustainable and more stable. In the first year you get that, right — the CAC is comparatively high and profitability is low — and right now we are seeing a super high increase in Prime members. We spoke at the start about a sensitivity, right? That sensitivity was the one where, had we grown by 110,000 fewer net adds instead of 400,000, so 290,000, then rather than a Cash EBITDA margin of 13%, which is what we printed for the quarter, we would have had 18%. Now over the longer term, which the question also mentions, we gave you three or four different slides with sensitivities to look at — at the cash margin or profit level, at the Cash EBITDA level from here to fiscal 2025, and even simulations of what could happen beyond fiscal 2025, depending on the different levels of growth in the Prime member base.
David Corrales
executiveI think there's a lot there for you to take in, and, you know, I'm looking forward to taking your questions once you've had a chance to absorb all of it. This investor's fourth question notes that value per booking appears to have declined this quarter compared with the prior quarter, and asks whether there's any specific cause. Now, I have to assume that what's meant by value per quarter is the basket size of the bookings, because when I look at Cash Revenue Margin per booking, it has risen steadily across the last four quarters. If I look at Cash Marginal Profit per booking, it has climbed consistently over the last three quarters, from a level of about EUR 7.5 to almost EUR 10. So it has to be basket size. Now, on basket size, I just answered that two questions earlier. At the end of June, our basket size was approaching EUR 400. At the end of September, our basket size was approaching roughly EUR 370, more or less, in broad terms. That is determined by how airfares have moved in the market. Then this investor's last question says you mentioned new features that will drive ARPU in later years.
David Corrales
executiveCould you elaborate a bit more on those features? Sure—I can speak at a high level, since typically we don’t reveal a feature that’s still upcoming until it actually launches, as that would hand our competitors unnecessary hints. That said, you’re aware we have multiple initiatives in development—new products and services. By and large, they’ll fall in the hotels space and in additional new ancillaries that we can make available to customers. This aligns with the growth in development resources we’re bringing on board, since there’s a great deal to do and we have items we’re confident will see strong customer demand, and we’re working to build them and launch them as fast as possible. We have a group of questions from Carlos Treviño at Banco Santander. The first asks whether the anticipated ARPU decline in coming quarters is entirely due to the mathematical denominator effect from Prime additions that was explained, or whether other factors are involved—and if so, which ones? The answer is quite straightforward. It’s primarily the denominator effects. This isn’t us cutting fares or ramping up heavy discounting or anything like that.
David Corrales
executiveWhat we're seeing here is a denominator effect rather than a numerator one. In the second question, it's also noted that you anticipate hitting the EUR 80 target by adding new Prime products. Pardon me — there's a bit of scrolling happening on my page. It also says you expect to get to the EUR 80 target through new Prime products and features. So does that imply that under the current Prime offering, your ARPU would sit under that level? Well, under the current Prime offering, our ARPU will trend — as we've said — toward roughly the mid-70s over the coming three quarters, and that comes from a mathematical denominator effect. The Prime offering will improve substantially thanks to the software developers we have in-house, along with the new ones we're bringing on board. The third question asks: if we might see seasonal bookings in the third quarter come in lower than in the second quarter, should we likewise expect Prime net adds in the third quarter to be lower than in the second quarter? Yes. That's right, since ultimately, how many people we add to the Prime member base depends on how many people are searching for travel in the market. Of course, fewer people search for travel between October and December than search for travel between July and September.
David Corrales
executiveOn the flip side, we anticipate that the count of individuals seeking travel during January through March will exceed that of the quarter concluding in December. It is our expectation that the customary seasonality of this business is plainly returning, both for declining periods such as Q3 and for rising periods such as Q4. We now have a question from Vyacheslav Shilin of Veles Capital. His first question reads, "On page 30 of the presentation, you mentioned that churn has improved by 2% from Year 1 members and 4% for Year 2+ members. What level is this improvement from?" Unfortunately, we do not disclose that. It is a fiercely competitive metric. In fact, you won't find any subscription company serving consumers — B2C rather than B2B — that reveals it. We believe we should not be disclosing that figure. The second question is, "The cash balance is down to EUR 2.8 million, excluding overdrafts and other short-term borrowings. How comfortable are you with liquidity given we are entering a seasonal low H2 for bookings and working capital outflow?" What I would say is that the cash level isn't all that relevant. That figure of EUR 2.8 million is one from which you have deducted the overdraft, which is simply another means of drawing on the revolving credit facility.
David Corrales
executiveThe metric that truly matters is total liquidity, and that includes all the availability we have under our credit facilities. That figure comes to roughly EUR 170 million. To be precise, it is EUR 167 million. And bear in mind, we're now in mid-November, so six weeks of the low seasonality remain. Yeah, we're quite comfortable that this amount is more than sufficient to carry us through that stretch. The next question asks, "Have you talked with rating agencies about the company's improved performance and positive outlook? And what feedback and indication have they given on when they might consider upgrading the company's low credit rating?" Well, we have. I believe we just published this, so we haven't yet had a chance to go over this set of results with them. You know, to temper what I'd call your very rational desires — the rating agencies do have insight into our budget projections, and what we're publishing aligns with what's in the budget. So I don't think their perception changes, other than seeing one more quarter of us delivering on the results and proving that we do what we say we're gonna do.
David Corrales
executiveWe still need to see exactly when the rating will change. The following set of questions is from Bruce Wellman at Cheyne Capital. His first question asks, "What were the gross adds for Prime in the first half of 2023?" Unfortunately, we do not disclose gross adds. And the remaining two questions are repeats. The next batch of questions comes from Eduardo Lega at Société Générale. His first question asks, "Do you expect revenue from classic customers to recover to pre-pandemic levels? This figure is still well below pre-pandemic levels, and while total revenue margin has almost recovered to pre-pandemic levels." Well, classic customer revenues include the discounts to Prime members within them, whereas they do not include the increase in referral revenue. I would say that, being a subscription company and having now more than 50% of our bookings of profits coming from Prime members — which is going to increase to more than 80% according to our guidance in fiscal 2025 — I don't think we will ever recover the revenue from classic customers that we had before the pandemic. What matters is the total revenue that we get in the business and, in the case of subscribers, the ARPU that we get from them.
David Corrales
executiveThat brings us to the end of the questions we have. So at this point, we're going to wrap up the presentation. We'd like to thank all of you for participating in the webcast. And before we finish the call, I want to let you know that on Thursday the 23rd of February, we'll be holding our conference call to discuss the third quarter results of fiscal 2023. Until then, we'd be very glad to take your questions through the investor relations teams or via the investor email address, which is investors@edreamsodigeo.com. I hope you all have a very nice day.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, everyone. Bye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete eDreams ODIGEO S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to eDreams ODIGEO S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in eDreams ODIGEO S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.