eDreams ODIGEO S.A. (EDR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 23, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
David de la Roz
executiveMorning, everyone, and thanks for being here today as we present the results for Q3 of fiscal year 2023 — that's the 9 months that ended on 31st of December 2022. I'm David de la Roz, Director of Investor Relations at eDreams ODIGEO. You can, as usual, locate the materials for these results — the presentation as well as our results report — over in the Investor Relations area of our website. At this point I'll hand things to Dana Dunne, our CEO, who'll walk you through the first portion of the presentation. Many thanks.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks, David. Good morning, everyone, and thanks for being with us today. Across the last 9 months, we have witnessed how resilient the travel market is. Despite the war in Ukraine and macroeconomic challenges like elevated inflation, travelers keep coming back to the market and have put travel ahead of many other discretionary expenditures. The market has still not completely returned to where it stood before COVID, but this certainly augurs well for what lies ahead. Against that backdrop, eDO has kept developing and trading well, lifting the quality of our business after the pivot to the subscription model. Our margins have improved, just as we said they would, and we have shown superior performance within our industry. In fact, we are proud to report that we have now delivered 6 quarters in a row above pre-COVID levels in bookings, a feat that no other global travel business has achieved. In our view, that is no coincidence, since we believe our business model is unique and very hard for others to replicate. It delivers a growing stream of recurring revenue from our subscription business and has consistently delivered outperformance versus any other travel company. Please turn to Slide 5, which summarizes our performance for our Q3 fiscal year 2023 results.
Dana Dunne
executiveA few of the key points for today's presentation: First, Prime is driving a substantial increase in profit margins as the Prime membership program matures. As we guided, the biggest factor behind profitability is how mature the Prime member base is. That has produced strong gains in profitability as an increasing number of Prime members renew their memberships. As a result, in Q3 FY'23, cash marginal profit and the cash EBITDA margin both improved considerably. Cash margin profit came in at EUR 115.5 million. That was up 44% year-on-year, and in the third quarter of FY'23, cash margin and profit margin rose to 29% from 21% in the first quarter of FY'23. That works out to an 8 percentage point improvement. Cash EBITDA likewise demonstrated substantial improvement. It reached EUR 57.4 million in the 9 months of FY'23, which is 72% higher than the same period last year. In addition, in the third quarter of FY'23 alone, cash EBITDA was EUR 23 million. It is now clear and proven that margins improve as Prime members mature. Cash EBITDA margin in the third quarter FY'23 came to 16% versus 8.8% in the first quarter of FY'23. Excluding a one-off positive FX impact on cash EBITDA margin, that margin was 14.6%, which remains well above the Q1 and Q2 FY'23 levels.
Dana Dunne
executiveTo restate the sequence: a big rise in prime members during year 1 pushed back profitability, and it gets considerably better starting in year 2. Highlight number two. The Prime model works and has been proven. eDO bookings keep beating expectations and perform materially better than peers in the market. The market is still under pre-COVID levels. Even so, we keep trading significantly above where we were before COVID, having now delivered our sixth consecutive quarter above pre-COVID levels, and a business pivoted to subscription has higher repeat rates and rising profitability year after year as Prime customers renew. Put briefly, our business has turned into a far better, more predictable and much higher quality business. Prime membership also rose 81% year-on-year to 3.9 million subscribers. That happened even as the industry shifted toward more normalized seasonality in booking patterns, with the October to December period being the seasonally low point of the year. Across the 9 months of FY'23, we added an average of 427,000 net adds of Prime members each quarter. One year after our superior high growth in Prime net adds began, gross adds have been partially offset by normal churn from a larger Prime member base. The lower net adds in the third quarter of FY'23 were seasonally influenced, landing in the lowest aggregate demand quarter of the year.
Dana Dunne
executiveAs we enter the new calendar year, we're in a solid booking stretch right now. Based on the first 6 weeks of the quarter, the current run rate is 410,000 net adds, and that's already 27% higher than net adds in the third quarter of FY'23. Second highlight: our self-imposed FY'25 targets remain well within reach. All told, we feel we have the right model, the right people and the right structure to capture and deliver on the exciting opportunities in front of us. Let me now walk you through more detail on our Prime performance and explain why the Prime model is a proven success. Please turn to Slide 7. As I mentioned earlier, cash marginal profit margin kept improving in the third quarter of FY'23 as mature Prime members grew. Per our guidance, the maturity of Prime members is the single most important driver of profitability. That has produced strong profitability gains as an ever-growing share of Prime members renew their memberships. In the third quarter of FY'23, cash margin and profit margin rose to 29% from 21% in the first quarter FY '23, with profitability improving from year 2. As Prime member maturity rises, margins improve.
Dana Dunne
executiveDuring Q3 of FY '23, our cash EBITDA margin came in at 16%, compared with 8.8% during Q1 of FY '23. That works out to a gain of 7 percentage points — or 6 percentage points once you strip out the one-off favorable FX effect. Had that one-off FX benefit been excluded, cash EBITDA margin would have been 14.6%, which is still comfortably above the margins we posted in both Q1 and Q2 of FY'23. If you'd please move to Slide 9. Thanks to Prime, eDO bookings keep performing substantially stronger than the rest of the industry. I want to stress that the industry is returning to more typical seasonal patterns when it comes to how travelers book their vacations. We see a seasonal dip during the third quarter — that is, the October to December window. In terms of volume, October through December is the softest quarter for the market. Because eDO offers a superior value proposition to Prime, eDO has consistently beaten industry peers. All through the pandemic, eDO outperformed the airline industry, and that really underscores how strong and adaptable our business model is, with a business whose quality has risen thanks to the pivot toward subscription. At present, the company keeps delivering robust market share gains against supplier direct bookings, driven by better content quality, a more comprehensive offer, flexibility, and our emphasis on leisure travel.
Dana Dunne
executiveUsing the most recent data we have for the 9 months of FY'23, the company's outperformance came in at plus 63 versus supplier direct and 42 percentage points above low-cost carriers. GAAP should close once corporate travel comes back — a market segment where we don't play. Looking at January and February most recently, we kept seeing robust growth, running 31% above pre-COVID-19 levels in January and across the first 15 days of February. Kindly turn to Slide 10 of the presentation. Prime member growth has stayed steady through COVID waves, the geopolitical and macro backdrop, and normalization of seasonality patterns. During the third quarter FY'23, we hit 3.9 million members, up 81% compared with the same period a year earlier. That happened even as the industry shifted toward more normalized seasonality patterns when it comes to travelers booking their holidays. As of the 15th of February 2023, our Prime members totaled 4.2 million subscribers, which keeps good momentum going. Kindly turn to Slide 11 of the presentation. And since net adds of Prime members are shaped by seasonality, they'll rise during higher-volume seasonal periods like the fourth quarter of FY'23. The softer net adds of Prime members in the third quarter FY'23 reflected seasonality, as fewer people are looking to book travel at this time of year.
Dana Dunne
executiveSince Q4 is a period of strong seasonality, and during the first 6 weeks our net adds have been running at a rate that's already 27% above what we saw in the third quarter of FY'23, I'll now hand things over to David, who will walk you through the financial results.
David Corrales
executiveThank you, Dana. Everyone, please open to Slide 13 in the deck, where I'll walk you through the financial results in greater depth. Our new KPIs demonstrated robust expansion in prime cash revenue margin and marginal profit, along with a meaningful margin improvement as Prime members mature. Average revenue per user, or ARPU, is—as we guided—moving toward the mid EUR 70 level and will subsequently converge with our fiscal '25 guidance of EUR 80 per user. In the third quarter of fiscal '23, prime ARPU came in at EUR 76.8 per user, in line with expectations. What drove the movement this quarter was the rolling off of the second quarter of fiscal '22 from the trailing 12-month calculation. That quarter saw a substantial revenue increase, since travelers surged suddenly owing to the vaccine rollout. As the Prime member base expands, a mathematical effect pushes ARPU down, because the average and end-of-period figures draw closer to each other. That effect will persist throughout all of fiscal '24. ARPU will then converge back to the EUR 80 target in fiscal '22.
David Corrales
executiveSolid improvement in cash revenue margin and cash profit margin means that in our last 12 months of fiscal '23, 44% and 56%, respectively, of cap revenue margin and cash margin profit now come from Prime members, versus 40% and 53%, respectively, a year ago. I'd like to remind everyone that Prime's profitability rises substantially starting in the second year, since customer acquisition costs drop very significantly. With a larger share of our prime members now in the second-year cohort and in later years of ownership, Prime's profitability will keep improving. Please turn to Slide 14 of the presentation. Throughout this dynamic period, we kept investing and innovating in our subscription offering and have subsequently seen remarkable results. Cash revenue margin already sits 10% above pre-COVID-19 levels. And cash marginal profit and cash EBITDA will improve thanks to the large increase of Prime members this year, as Prime's profitability jumps from the second year onwards. As a result, in the 9 months of fiscal '23, deferred revenue growth tied to Prime has accelerated after 1.8 million new members subscribed over the course of this year. That amounts to EUR 40.2 million, up 21% year-on-year.
David Corrales
executiveWith a full contribution from Prime, cash EBITDA reached EUR 57.4 million across the 9 months of fiscal '23 — an impressive 72% improvement over last year. As expected, cash EBITDA for the third quarter alone was strong at EUR 23 million, up 12% compared with the second quarter of fiscal '23 and up 64% compared with the first quarter of '23, which came in at EUR 20 million and EUR 14 million, respectively, given the strong growth in Prime members in the first year and the lowest growth in profitability, since that jumps starting in the second year. During the third quarter of fiscal '23, we saw a substantial improvement in margins as Prime numbers mature. Cash margin and profit margins rose to 29% for the third quarter from 21% in the first — an 8-percentage-point improvement. Cash EBITDA margins in the third quarter also delivered very substantial gains, with the cash EBITDA margin at 16% versus 8.8% in the first quarter of '23. Excluding a one-off positive impact of EUR 2.1 million, the cash EBITDA margin was 14.6%, still well above both the first quarter and the second quarter of fiscal '23. Please turn to Slide 15 of the presentation.
David Corrales
executiveDuring the 9 months, fiscal '23 revenue margin and cash revenue margin stayed above pre-COVID-19 levels by 2% and 10%, respectively, even with macroeconomic headwinds and industry restructures. Revenue margin across the 9 months rose 59% compared with the same period last year, thanks to bookings that were higher by 35% and an 18% increase in revenue margin per booking, which came from the better quality of our business as we pivoted to subscription and from strong growth in diversification and classic customer revenue. Variable costs were up by 59%, driven by the greater volume of bookings and a 17% increase in variable cost of booking. Variable cost of booking climbed from EUR 24.3 to EUR 28.5, reflecting higher acquisition cost to acquire Prime members and a rise in merchant costs. And merchant costs themselves are tied to high gross sales and international expansion. Overall, in the third quarter of fiscal '23 we saw the improving trends from the second quarter and significant improvements in profitability as more prime members renew their memberships. Cash marginal profit came in at EUR 115.5 million, an increase of 44% over the amount in fiscal '22. Cash EBITDA also improved substantially, reaching EUR 57.4 million in the 9 months, up 72% versus the same period last year.
David Corrales
executiveFixed costs rose by EUR 11.2 million, driven primarily by greater personnel expenses and external fees — both tied to hiring new employees — and that was offset by a EUR 1.6 million positive FX impact for the 9-month period. I'd like to remind everyone that we don't anticipate the rise in fixed costs, from EUR 63.3 million in fiscal '22 to EUR 100 million in fiscal '25, to be linear, since recruitment is front-end loaded so we can deliver on our business plan. As a reminder, altogether we plan to add 500 employees by March '25, with 60% of those having already been added in the past 12 months. Consequently, adjusted EBITDA was EUR 17.2 million from new in the 9 months of fiscal '22. And adjusted net income was EUR 25.8 million loss in the 9 months of fiscal '23. Moving now to Slide 16. I'll walk you through the cash flow statement. In the 9 months of fiscal '23, despite headwinds and normalization in the market, we ended the quarter with positive cash flow from operations of EUR 31.9 million -- sorry, EUR 31.9 million, mainly due to a working capital inflow of EUR 11.6 million.
David Corrales
executiveDuring the 9 months of '23, the inflow came in lower than it did across the same 9 months of '22. The reason is the bigger volume increase we experienced from March '21 through December '21, a stretch that came immediately after travel restrictions were lifted. From March '22 to December '22, volumes were steadier in nature. Our liquidity position has been handled well, which follows from a strong business model and active management. Throughout the entire pandemic, liquidity stayed more than sufficient and stable. By the end of December '22, the liquidity position stood at EUR 157 million. Across the 9 months of '23, we spent EUR 27 million of cash on investment, which is EUR 9 million above fiscal '22, since we are expanding our development capacity and, as a result, capitalizing more software developed. Cash used in financing came to EUR 33.1 million, versus EUR 16 million from financing activities the year before. That EUR 17 million swing in financing activities is tied to repayment of the revolver credit facility, at EUR 11 million, and of the government-sponsored loan, at EUR 3.8 million. The swing was offset by a EUR 22.7 million rise in bank overdrafts during the 9 months of fiscal '23, captured in the bank overdraft usage line of the cash flow statement.
David Corrales
executiveI'll now hand things back over to Dana so she can wrap us up.
Dana Dunne
executiveThank you, David. Over the following 5 slides, I'll attempt to sum up the reasons our company is attractive to investors. Kindly go to Slide 18. Reason one: eDO is distinctive, possessing enormous potential along with the capacity to monetize at that level. Evidence of this lies in the fact that we keep meeting rule 40, a benchmark metric used for judging companies. We remain standout performers and stand alone even when compared with our subscription peers, which are also high-growth and profitable businesses. Kindly go to Slide 19. Reason two: we hold pole position within an appealing market. Kindly go to Slide 20 of the presentation. Reason three: let me remind everyone that in travel, eDO ranks as a global flight leader outside China and is over 3x the size of the second player in Europe. Kindly go to Slide '21 of the presentation. Reason four: eDO has proven its capacity to win new prime customers even amid COVID waves and the recent geopolitical and macro backdrop. Moreover, this acquisition of new prime customers grows only as the travel market expands. Kindly go to Slide 22 of the presentation. Reason five: I want to stress once more that we believe, irrespective of the macroeconomic environment, our business model and track record put us in position to outperform the industry.
Dana Dunne
executiveIf you could go to Slide 23 in the presentation, we'll look at reason number six. Our position is strong, our financing is solid, and we're making good progress toward the FY'25 goals we set for ourselves — let me remind you what those are: first, more than 7.25 million prime members; second, prime ARPU of roughly EUR 80; and third, cash EBITDA above EUR 180 million. Taken as a whole, eDO is a business of far better quality, and that reflects our subscription model. It brings in loyal customers who keep coming back, which makes for a business that's more profitable and more predictable, with customer relationships that last. We're generating strong underlying profitability along with enormous room to grow. All of this will produce superior returns for shareholders and excellent service for customers, while at the same time transforming and revolutionizing the industry.
David de la Roz
executiveThanks, Dana. Now we'd like to move on to your questions. The questions submitted in writing through the webcast are the ones we'll be answering. We'll handle them in the order received, first come, first served, and we'll also try to group together questions that are similar in nature. If there isn't enough time to get to questions from the webcast, the Investor Relations team will ensure they get answered afterward. Also, we won't read the questions out loud, since I think that would waste everyone's time.
David de la Roz
executiveAlright, let's move on to the questions we've collected here. The first set comes from Franco Ruiz, an analyst at Exane BNP. His first question is: could you give us a sense of where basket size stands relative to last year and to pre-COVID? And is there a significant gap between the basket size of a Prime member and a non-Prime member? I'll take that one. Basket size in Q3 of fiscal '23 was EUR 367. A year ago it was EUR 307, so that's an improvement of EUR 60, but we're still roughly EUR 80 below where basket size sat pre-COVID for this same period, which was 442, okay? So there is progress versus a year ago. We remain below the pre-COVID basket size, and this is consistent with the remarks we've made over the past few quarters about the overall complexity of bookings being lower than the average complexity of the bookings we saw pre-COVID. On the second part of your question, Prime members' basket size is larger than that of non-Prime members, and that's driven by the fact that they generally purchase more products and services from us than the non-Prime customer does.
David de la Roz
executiveOn the second question — which I believe asks why ARPU fell in Q3 — I think I'll handle that one too. We addressed it in the prepared remarks, and I'm glad to go over it again. There's a mathematical effect at work in how ARPU evolves, since we're seeing strong growth in Prime members. Within ARPU, one component is driven by end-of-period numbers — namely the subscription fee — while another component is the revenue from individual bookings, which depends much more on average period numbers. Given this effect, when the gap between the average of period numbers and the end-of-period numbers is relatively wide, ARPU appears optically somewhat artificially inflated. So we flagged this over the last few quarters and said we expect ARPU to come down significantly. As the quarters have progressed in this Q3, we have lost Q2 of fiscal '22. Within the mix of Q2 of fiscal '22, there was a quarter that came right after the main pandemic restrictions were lifted.
David de la Roz
executiveAlso, there was, you could say, a notable rise in revenue for that specific period, which is sort of getting lost in the calculation and creates an effect that appears somewhat accelerated. The third question asks whether the rebound was anticipated in Q4 and what level of working capital, and therefore net debt, should be expected. That is something we don't provide guidance on for any quarter. Naturally, the high seasonality across the fourth quarter will produce an inflow of working capital — a meaningful one — and that will influence net debt as well. However, no specific figure will be given by us. And the fourth question — the last one — is whether you could break down, by year of subscription, our actual Prime members. I'm afraid that is another item we don't disclose. We provided it on a onetime basis during the last quarter, tied to a 1-year anniversary, but giving it on an ongoing basis is not something we plan to do. The second question on the list comes from Guilherme Sampaio at Caixa Bank. His first question asks whether you could offer some additional color on how our bookings are progressing from the year 2023.
David de la Roz
executiveAnd well, as you can see from the fact that they're on today's call, up to February 15 — so taking the first 6 weeks — bookings came in 31% higher than pre-COVID. The second question asks how sustainable we see the material market share gains eDreams achieved during the pandemic as corporate travel recovers. Well, I think I'll take that one as well. As corporate travel recovers, what happens is that you add more bookings and more volumes to the denominator, and it is for a segment of the market in which we don't participate. So looking at the whole travel market and then looking at our bookings, we do expect that, that calculation will progressively reduce. However, we see no reason why if we were able to book just the leisure travel market, why our market share would reduce, if anything, we think it will continue to increase because the value proposition of Prime has demonstrated on a consistent basis that it is a better value proposition for the consumers. The third set of question comes from Nizla Naizer, the analyst from Deutsche Bank. The first one is, how has the churn rates trended for Prime, has it improved with the return of travel.
David de la Roz
executiveDana, would you like to handle this one?
Dana Dunne
executiveOf course, David, happy to address that. Regarding your first question on churn rate — we don't disclose churn. That said, in the presentation from last November, we actually demonstrated that our churn rate had gotten better. In other words, it went down, just marginally, as time went on. And from that point onward, we keep observing it either holding steady or getting a bit better too.
David de la Roz
executiveNizla's second question is about the average number of bookings a Prime member makes. Dana, do you want to take that one?
Dana Dunne
executiveYes, of course. A Prime member typically generates roughly 3.2x the number of bookings compared with someone who isn't a Prime member. We've stopped revealing that figure each quarter, though that's approximately the level it sits at.
David de la Roz
executiveAlright. Nizla’s third question asks whether Prime is available in every market where eDreams operates now, and whether our Prime markets cover flights and hotels. It’s a 3-point question. Has competition gotten more intense? I’ll let you handle that.
Dana Dunne
executiveSure. First, some background for everyone. As a company, we serve 44 markets with what we call a non-Prime offering. Of those 44 countries, Prime is available in 9. We intend to expand it gradually in the years ahead into additional markets. Regarding 4 of those 9 Prime markets, the question of whether hotels are included alongside flights — yes, they are. In fact, across all 9 markets where Prime is offered, we provide it for flights, for hotels, for car rental or car hire, and in most of those markets for dynamic packages too. That will probably keep evolving going forward as well. The final piece was about competition — whether it has intensified. The answer is no. Speaking on a quarter-to-quarter basis since we last talked in November, it hasn't. The big Delta, the major shift on the competitive front, really came roughly 18 months back, maybe 24, 20, 16 months ago, somewhere around then, when essentially everyone in the travel industry began emerging from COVID and stopped concentrating on cutting costs and shuttering operations, shifting instead to rebuilding the business, so to speak.
Dana Dunne
executiveSo I'd say competition has been genuinely significant and intense from that point onward. And honestly, looking quarter to quarter, I don't see much shift in the competitive landscape overall.
David de la Roz
executiveThanks, Dana. Andrew Ross, the Barclays analyst, has the next batch of questions. The first one has already come up, so I won't use time on it. The second asks about expectations for cash margin and profit margins in the fourth fiscal quarter, given that Prime accelerated again in Q4 but on a bigger seasonal quarter. The first thing is to establish what the comparable figure for Q3 is, let's say. And it matters that we use the comparable figure, the one without the one-off effects in it. That comparable figure is 14.6% of cash EBITDA margins. And then we do expect an improvement on that, driven both by the Prime member base maturing further and by the fact that it is a bigger seasonal quarter. So from that standpoint it helps to somewhat offset the fixed costs. Although, remember that at the same time, we keep growing the fixed cost, because we keep increasing the employee base as guided in — for our 3-year plan. The next question is from Fehmi Naamane of ODDO. I won't repeat it, because it is a repeat question. Carlos Trevino, the analyst of Santander, has the next batch of questions.
David de la Roz
executiveThe first thing is that although you keep beating the market, with bookings growth far above where it stood before the pandemic, that outperformance is slowing down. Has anything shifted on the competitive side that is affecting this performance? I'll handle that one. From a competitive standpoint, performance really hasn't changed, and that's what Dana also said in response to Nizla's earlier question. What does add noise to the equation, though, is the shifts we are observing compared with pre-COVID, which is the days-to-departure point you raised. Let me give you an example. Take, for instance, January's bookings. On average, January's bookings have been made 4 to 6 days before departure. But when I check the same metric for January pre-COVID, bookings in that period were made on average 60 days before departure. What that means is that January used to contain a larger share of bookings that were booked further out. So people were booking further ahead than they do today. Those bookings aren't simply vanishing from the market; they just end up occurring in a different market, probably in another month, one that sits much closer to the departure date.
David de la Roz
executiveThe second thing I want to ask about is what's driving the sequential decline in fixed cost compared with 2Q. I think I'll handle that one too. The main factor is the favorable FX effect, which comes to EUR 2.1 million. Leaving that out, fixed cost would have come in at EUR 20.2 million rather than the EUR 18.1 million we reported before. So they're tracking the pattern we anticipated. And perhaps, since you raised this point, for everyone's benefit, let me spend a minute on what drives that one-off FX item. We have FX exposure, or bookings made in currencies other than the euro, during the days between when the customer books and when we actually collect the cash for that booking. Depending on the currencies and how distant they are, that window can range anywhere from 2 days to 4 days, all right? So if the euro depreciates over that 4-day stretch, there's an FX impact. On the other hand, if the euro appreciates across those 4 days, the effect goes the other way.
David de la Roz
executiveNow, generally speaking, in any single quarter this tends to be either somewhat positive or somewhat negative, but those effects get blended into the overall fixed cost figure. And if you cast your mind back a little, you'll recall that over roughly the last 12 months, the euro has depreciated against other currencies, as interest rates rose more in the U.S. and in other geographies where rates have been climbing, including Europe. That trend reversed somewhat toward the end of 2022, during November and December. And it happened rather abruptly. That's why, in the quarter, the impact came to EUR 2.1 million. I also offered another data point in the prepared remarks: if you look at the 9 months rather than the quarter, the positive effect was EUR 1.6 million. What that means is that across the first 2 quarters, it was negative at 0.5%. But to be precise, in the third quarter, it was positive growth of 2.1%. The next set of questions comes from Rakesh Rastogi of <<inaudible>> Wealth Advisers. The first one is, can you walk us through when operating cash flow will start to reflect improving profitability?
David de la Roz
executiveOkay, so operating cash flow will keep getting better, but you always have to view it over a 12-month period, or compare it with the same quarter a year earlier. And keep in mind that during the prior comparison period, certain quarters got a big boost from volume gains as things opened up after the super low volumes of COVID, when people were released from their homes. So you always need to consider it through that lens. But without question, you're going to triple down on operating cash flow. The second question is, what would the business and profitability look like right now if you had never launched Prime? Well, for that we'd need a bit of a crystal ball. It would be a very nice theoretical exercise. One thing I can guarantee you is that our business would not be as solid and as sustainable as it is today, because we wouldn't have a base of 4.2 million loyal and happy customers who pay a subscription fee and give us all of the bookings — that wouldn't happen, for sure, if we didn't have Prime at this point in time.
David de la Roz
executiveThe third thing people ask is why we wouldn’t provide granular data for the top 6 markets in the group, as in earlier quarters. Well, that level of detail is provided by us at the half-year mark. It’s included in H1, and we also provide it with full-year results. For quarterly results, what we offer is a limited financial review. So I’ll need to ask you to stay patient until the next quarter. Our next question comes from <<inaudible>>. Could you give some examples of business initiatives you have underway, such as new technology efforts or customer retention efforts? I believe you’d like Dana to take this one.
Dana Dunne
executiveSure. Thank you, David. I believe a lot of you are already familiar with who we are. Normally, we don't discuss or pre-announce these things. Rather, let me share some thoughts on what matters most to us. The first area involves Prime. With Prime, we see genuine opportunities across a multiplicity of dimensions. First among those dimensions is geographic reach and expansion. As we noted in response to Nizla's question, we offer a Prime product in 9 key countries. Yet broadly speaking, this is a business that operates in 44. So obviously, you can picture that expanding geographically would matter. The second dimension concerns product features and functionalities. There's an entire set of items we keep working on, keep enhancing, and keep broadening, both inside the existing portion of the business — how we handle that relationship with customers, how we encourage more repeat behavior, how we encourage more renewal there. And there are plenty of things we keep doing toward that. Beyond that, delivering an absolutely outstanding customer experience and product experience is truly important to us. So once more, we devote enormous amounts of time, teams, and focus to enhancing this, to enhancing particular product quality, features, functionalities, and also the overall end-to-end experience here.
Dana Dunne
executiveWe are genuinely putting a lot of effort into this, and we have been doing so for several years, all so that we can keep meaningfully enhancing how customers experience Prime. The second aspect involves the technology platform side of things. It becomes a little more, shall we say, technical or geeky. Yet beneath all of it, ultimately, lies the way we structure how we actually handle content and handle customer experiences from a content standpoint. All of that matters a great deal to us, and we keep investing along this dimension. That enables us to accomplish plenty of other things that numerous rivals are unable to do because of these significant dimensions. Since ultimately, our products depend on that context too. With that said, let me hand things back to you, David.
David de la Roz
executiveAlright. The following questions are from Paul Simenauer of BNP Paribas. Question one concerns the long-haul mix. As that mix grows, what happens to the working capital impact? The answer: the effect is positive. Long-haul tickets usually carry a higher airfare, so a bigger long-haul component means a larger basket size, and a larger basket size produces a greater working capital inflow. Question two: what useful rule of thumb exists for estimating quarterly deferred revenue increases? I'll handle that one too. What we generally tell analysts and investors — and many already do it this way — is that rather than modeling EBITDA and then adding deferred revenue on top, it's far more reliable to begin by modeling cash EBITDA on the cash EBITDA margin, which comes from the accompanying members joining the program: take the life number of members and the ARPU, then apply a margin to that. The reason is that deferred revenue tends to vary somewhat, depending on how much members use the program in any given quarter.
David de la Roz
executiveSo depending on how it's used, you'll see varying amounts of deferred revenue that then gets translated into actual revenue on the income statement. So my recommendation is to approach it the other way around. The third question has already been asked, so we won't read it. The fourth question asks where we expect the non-Prime portion of the business to level out, in terms of revenue margin and cash margin on a profit basis, as we progress toward our fiscal '25 goals. Well, let's take the non-Prime KPIs in our 3-year plan: what we have for fiscal '25 is EUR 46 million of marginal profit and EUR 296 million of revenue margin. We expect this part of the business to keep having, first, a declining rate within the overall revenue mix; and second, declining profitability as well. And the reason profitability declines is that within our non-Prime numbers, a good chunk come direct to us, and they repeat year after year, their family with us and our service, they prefer us over other competitors, and they come direct to us. However, our expectation is that this cluster of customers — the ones with higher profitability, because we don't incur a marketing cost — will eventually all become Prime members.
David de la Roz
executiveSo on the non-Prime portion of the business, the only customers we'll have left are ones we bring in through costly acquisition channels. Our next question comes from <<inaudible>>. As profitability gets better and you pay down a portion of debt, would you consider buying back shares, given where the share price is? Let's go through this step by step. Number one, we have to keep delivering the EBITDA as planned. Delivering that EBITDA, and along with it delivering on working capital as volumes rise, will give us improved cash generation. The first use of that cash has to be paying back the debt sitting on the balance sheet — debt of, let's say, a short-term nature — and that will happen through the government-sponsored loan and the remaining balance under the revolver credit facility, because <<inaudible>> isn't intended to be a permanent capital layer; it's intended to be something we draw, return, draw, return. Once there's excess cash beyond that, it will then be up to the Board to decide how to allocate it between further reductions of that debt — which would mean repurchasing portions of the loan — or repurchasing equity.
David de la Roz
executiveSo I think at that moment, the Board is going to look at where each of those two securities is priced right then, and they'll decide based on which option gives the company more value. Our next question is from <<inaudible>>, and it asks about working capital — payables appear to have tightened against gross bookings. Is that a timing issue or a seasonal one? It's seasonal? The December payable isn't really driven by the whole third quarter; it's driven specifically by the final 2 weeks of December, because remember, we collect the cash from customers. And typically, we hand that money to the airlines 2 weeks later. So what sits on the balance sheet at quarter end reflects just those last 2 weeks of December, which is a particularly slow stretch of the year, when people are much more focused on celebrating Christmas or getting ready for Christmas rather than booking at the last minute. That brings us to the end of the questions we have so far. So with that, we thank everyone for joining us in person and on the webcast.
David de la Roz
executiveAlso, before we wrap up this call, I want to let you know that our conference call to present the fourth quarter and full year 2023 results is scheduled for Thursday, the 25th of May. Until then, we would be glad to take your questions through our Investor Relations team or via the investor email address, investors@edreamsodigeo.com. I wish all of you a great day. Many thanks.
Dana Dunne
executiveThanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete eDreams ODIGEO S.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to eDreams ODIGEO S.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in eDreams ODIGEO S.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.